![Page 1: The Development of Indirect Drive ICF and the Countdown to ... · The Development of Indirect Drive ICF and the Countdown to Ignition Experiments on the NIF Maxwell Prize Address](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022042118/5e9754adaececc41b46c0a34/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
The Development of Indirect Drive ICF and theCountdown to Ignition Experiments on the NIF
Maxwell Prize AddressAPS Division of Plasma Physics Meeting
November 15, 2007
John LindlNIF and Photon Science Directorate Chief Scientist
Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory
Work performed under the auspices of the U.S. Department of Energy byLawrence Livermore National Laboratory under Contract DE-AC52-07NA27344
![Page 2: The Development of Indirect Drive ICF and the Countdown to ... · The Development of Indirect Drive ICF and the Countdown to Ignition Experiments on the NIF Maxwell Prize Address](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022042118/5e9754adaececc41b46c0a34/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
The NIF ignition experiments will be the culminationof five decades of development which started withthe invention of the laser in 1960
• Ted Maiman demonstrated the first laser in 1960
• John Nuckolls 1972 Nature paper spelled out the essential requirementsfor high gain laser driven ICF
• Indirect drive experiments started at Livermore in the mid-1970’s• Dramatic advances in computations, lasers, diagnostics, and target
fabrication over the past 3 decades laid the groundwork for NIF and theNational Ignition Campaign (NIC)
• We are designing precision experimental campaigns for hohlraumenergetics, shock strengths and times, implosion velocity and ablatedmass, and symmetry, which will take 100-200 shots leading up to the firstignition attempts
• Targets near 1 MJ of laser energy have a credible chance for ignition inearly NIF operations
• The initial ignition experiments only scratch the surface of NIF’s potential
![Page 3: The Development of Indirect Drive ICF and the Countdown to ... · The Development of Indirect Drive ICF and the Countdown to Ignition Experiments on the NIF Maxwell Prize Address](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022042118/5e9754adaececc41b46c0a34/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
Inertial ConfinementFusion uses direct orindirect drive to coupledriver energy to the fuelcapsule
Spherical ablation withpulse shaping results in arocket-like implosion ofnear Fermi-degenerate fuel
Spherical collapse of theshell produces a centralhot spot surrounded bycold, dense main fuel
Indirect Drive
Hot spot(10 keV)
Cold, densemain fuel(200-1000 g/cm3)
Low-zAblator forEfficientabsorption
CryogenicFuel forEfficientcompression
There are two principal approaches to compression in Inertial Confinement Fusion
Direct Drive
DTgas
2.5 mm 0.1
mm
10mm
![Page 4: The Development of Indirect Drive ICF and the Countdown to ... · The Development of Indirect Drive ICF and the Countdown to Ignition Experiments on the NIF Maxwell Prize Address](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022042118/5e9754adaececc41b46c0a34/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
To illustrate the physics of ICF ignition, we compare aNIF capsule and a possible future high yield capsule
High yield capsule
NIF capsule
Radiation temperature = 300 eV 210 eVImplosion velocity = 4 x 107 cm/sec 3 x 107 cm/secCapsule absorbed energy = 0.15 MJ 2.0 MJCapsule yield ~ 15 MJ ~ 1000 MJ
CH + 0.25% Br + 5%O
DT solid (0.2 mg)
DT gas 0.3 mg/cc
1.11 mm
0.95
0.87
3.25mm
3.0
2.75
Be
DT solid(7.2 mg)
DT gas0.3 mg/cm3
![Page 5: The Development of Indirect Drive ICF and the Countdown to ... · The Development of Indirect Drive ICF and the Countdown to Ignition Experiments on the NIF Maxwell Prize Address](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022042118/5e9754adaececc41b46c0a34/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
Ignition is defined as the point at which α−particledeposition sustains the burn with no additionalinput of energy
0.2-MJNIF capsule(yield ~20 MJ)
2.0 MJcapsule (yield~1000 MJ)
Density and temperatureprofiles at ignition
ρr (g/cm2)
Ion
tem
pera
ture
(keV
)
12
8
4
0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1.0
Burn propagation after ignitiondepends only on fuel ρR
ρr (g/cm2)
Ion
tem
pera
ture
(keV
) 103
102
101
100
10-10 1 2 3
About 15 kJ of energy is coupled to the fuel for compression and ignition of the200 kJ NIF sized targetAt 1 MJ of yield, 200 kJ of α-particle energy is coupled to the fuel and it is well intothe ignition region - definition of ignition adopted by 1996 NRC review of NIFIn ITER with a Q=10, α-deposition is twice the external power needed to sustain theplasma
α-particlerange at10 keV
timeρ
Ti
102
103
101 Den
sity
(g/c
m3 )
![Page 6: The Development of Indirect Drive ICF and the Countdown to ... · The Development of Indirect Drive ICF and the Countdown to Ignition Experiments on the NIF Maxwell Prize Address](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022042118/5e9754adaececc41b46c0a34/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
• Over 3 decades of experiments on Nova, Omega and other facilitieshave provided an extensive data base to develop confidence in thenumerical codes
• Benchmarked numerical simulations with radiation-hydrodynamicscodes provide a first principles description of x-ray target performance(Laser-plasma interactions are treated separately with codes which arenow becoming predictive for NIF-relevant plasmas)
• “The Halite/Centurion experiments using nuclear explosives havedemonstrated excellent performance, putting to rest fundamentalquestions about the basic feasibility to achieve high gain” from 1990NRC review of ICF
Energy
Power
NIF Ignition
Nova, Omega
Halite/Centurion
Why do we believe that ignition will work on NIF?
![Page 7: The Development of Indirect Drive ICF and the Countdown to ... · The Development of Indirect Drive ICF and the Countdown to Ignition Experiments on the NIF Maxwell Prize Address](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022042118/5e9754adaececc41b46c0a34/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
The first laser was demonstrated by TheodoreMaiman in Malibu, CA, in May 1960
![Page 8: The Development of Indirect Drive ICF and the Countdown to ... · The Development of Indirect Drive ICF and the Countdown to Ignition Experiments on the NIF Maxwell Prize Address](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022042118/5e9754adaececc41b46c0a34/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
John Nuckolls and John Emmett were central tothe development of the LLNL ICF Program
John Emmett,who came toLLNL in 1972was the drivingforce behind thedevelopment ofthe LLNL laserprogram
John Nuckolls’vision of smallthermonuclearexplosions, laidout in his seminal1972 Naturepaper, providedthe motivation foran aggressive ICFProgram
Disk Amplifier Prototype from the mid 1970’s
![Page 9: The Development of Indirect Drive ICF and the Countdown to ... · The Development of Indirect Drive ICF and the Countdown to Ignition Experiments on the NIF Maxwell Prize Address](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022042118/5e9754adaececc41b46c0a34/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
Would you hire these people?
Laser Programs1978 ManpowerBook
George Zimmerman
John Lindl
Mike Campbell
![Page 10: The Development of Indirect Drive ICF and the Countdown to ... · The Development of Indirect Drive ICF and the Countdown to Ignition Experiments on the NIF Maxwell Prize Address](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022042118/5e9754adaececc41b46c0a34/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
Ed Moses did not come to Livermore until the 1980’sbut he would have fit right in during the 1970’s
Laser Programs1978 ManpowerBook
George Zimmerman
John Lindl
Mike Campbell
Ed Moses
![Page 11: The Development of Indirect Drive ICF and the Countdown to ... · The Development of Indirect Drive ICF and the Countdown to Ignition Experiments on the NIF Maxwell Prize Address](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022042118/5e9754adaececc41b46c0a34/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
• 1970’s: Radiation driven target designs provided a path forward for high gainICF with relaxed laser beam quality and hydrodynamic instability comparedto direct drive
• 1976: first laser driven indirect drive experiment in 1976 on the Cyclops laser
The first steps leading to indirect drive ignitionwith lasers took place in the mid 1970’s
—Cyclops was developed as a prototype beamline for Shiva
![Page 12: The Development of Indirect Drive ICF and the Countdown to ... · The Development of Indirect Drive ICF and the Countdown to Ignition Experiments on the NIF Maxwell Prize Address](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022042118/5e9754adaececc41b46c0a34/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
The 20 beam 10 kJ 1.06 µm Shiva laser was amajor step forward in the scale and complexity ofhigh energy laser systems
Shiva target areaShiva laser bay
![Page 13: The Development of Indirect Drive ICF and the Countdown to ... · The Development of Indirect Drive ICF and the Countdown to Ignition Experiments on the NIF Maxwell Prize Address](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022042118/5e9754adaececc41b46c0a34/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
1979-1981: Shiva and Argus experiments show limits to radiationtemperature from LPI and a path to TR>200 eV using frequency convertedlight (2ω and 3ω)
Experiments on the Argus and Shiva lasersprovided key results on achievable hohlraumtemperatures
Hot electron fractions approached50% in 1ω hohlraums on Shiva
Shorter laser wavelengths candramatically reduce hot electronsfor a given laser energy into ahohlraum
08-00-0594-2502.pub
100
10–1
10–2
10–3
10–4
fR = 1.0 –!tc IL dt/Etotal
2 " 10–4 2 " 10–3 2 " 10–2
2 " 6
2 " 32 " 2
2 " 1
3 " 6
4 " 6
Cairn hohlraum scale size(scale 1 = 500-µm
diam " 800 µm long)
Incident energy (kJ)
3 " 3
3 " 1.5
2 " 10–1 1
1% at Tr = 130 eV30-50% at Tr ~160-170 eV
Flue
nce
(keV
/keV
) 1012
1010
108
Energy (keV)
Hot ElectronFraction
![Page 14: The Development of Indirect Drive ICF and the Countdown to ... · The Development of Indirect Drive ICF and the Countdown to Ignition Experiments on the NIF Maxwell Prize Address](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022042118/5e9754adaececc41b46c0a34/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
With Nova, the ICF program brought together advancesin laser performance, precision diagnostics, andadvanced modeling tools needed to establish therequirements for Ignition.
From 1984 to 1999, the 10 beam, 30 kJ, 0.35 µm Novalaser was the central facility for indirect drive ICF
![Page 15: The Development of Indirect Drive ICF and the Countdown to ... · The Development of Indirect Drive ICF and the Countdown to Ignition Experiments on the NIF Maxwell Prize Address](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022042118/5e9754adaececc41b46c0a34/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
00
1 2Total energy (MJ)
200
400
Pow
er (T
W)
plasmainstabilities
hydroinstability
symmetryHigh volRfinal
Rolarge
large R/DR
High Pr, Tr, ILHohlraum physics acceptable below about 300 eV
Plasma physics issues constrain the hohlraumtemperature and hydrodynamic instabilitiesestablish the minimum required temperature
“Bird’s beak” plot from 1990
NIF designcapabilities
Hydrodynamicinstabilitiesdetermine theminimumtemperaturerequirement
![Page 16: The Development of Indirect Drive ICF and the Countdown to ... · The Development of Indirect Drive ICF and the Countdown to Ignition Experiments on the NIF Maxwell Prize Address](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022042118/5e9754adaececc41b46c0a34/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
• 1985-1990: Nova experiments demonstrated key target physics requirementsfor laser driven high gain (pulse shaping, symmetry control, Rayleigh-Taylorstabilization by radiation ablation, TR>200 eV with 3ω light
• 1990: 300 eV hohlraum temperature demonstrated on Nova led to a reducedscale ignition facility from the 5-10 MJ LMF to the 1-2 MJ NIF asrecommended by the 1990 NRC review of ICF
• 1990’s Demonstration of precision control of laser driven hohlraums asrequired for ignition (Nova Technical Contract from 1990 and 1996 NRCreviews of ICF)
Experiments on the Nova laser demonstratedkey target physics results needed for ignition
Scaling of peak drive temperature300
250
200
150150 200 250 300
Experimental peak Tr (eV)
Lasn
ex p
eak
Tr (e
V)
Hohlraum Length (µm)
![Page 17: The Development of Indirect Drive ICF and the Countdown to ... · The Development of Indirect Drive ICF and the Countdown to Ignition Experiments on the NIF Maxwell Prize Address](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022042118/5e9754adaececc41b46c0a34/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
Advanced diagnostics have been central tomeasuring the phenomena critical tounderstanding NIF
1.6 ns
1.9 ns
2.2 ns
2.5 ns
time
time
Sequence of x-ray backlitimages of imploding capsuleGated MCP x-ray imager
Pinholes MCP +film pack
Gatingelectronics
1 m
MCP gated imagers were operated between 100 eVand 10 keV with 5-50 µm, 30 -300 ps resolution
300µm
![Page 18: The Development of Indirect Drive ICF and the Countdown to ... · The Development of Indirect Drive ICF and the Countdown to Ignition Experiments on the NIF Maxwell Prize Address](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022042118/5e9754adaececc41b46c0a34/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
Face-on: Streaked
08-00-0593-1818B
The measured growth of ablative hydrodynamicinstabilities in ICF agrees with numerical models
3-D 2-DTime (ns)
Growth of Harmonics vs time
![Page 19: The Development of Indirect Drive ICF and the Countdown to ... · The Development of Indirect Drive ICF and the Countdown to Ignition Experiments on the NIF Maxwell Prize Address](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022042118/5e9754adaececc41b46c0a34/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
Interactionbeam
L=2 mm and longerCH gas fill
produces uniformne/ncr=6%
3w TransmittedBeam Diagnostic
Full-ApertureBackscatter Station
(FABS)
Near Backscatter Imager(NBI)
0
1
2
3
4
0 500 1000
Time (ps)
Elec
tron
Tem
pera
ture
(keV
)
Te
Ti
Plasma temperatures measured with Thomsonscattering agree well with simulations
0
0.05
0.1
0.15
-1.5 -1 -0.5 0 0.5 1 1.5
Interaction Beam Path (mm)
n e/n
cr
A uniform 6%ncr plateau is produced between0.5 and 1.0 ns
Froula et al., Phys. Plasmas 13(5) (2006)
t=0.5 ns
t=1.0 ns
Recently, we have been able to produce well characterizedNIF-like plasmas on the Omega laser
![Page 20: The Development of Indirect Drive ICF and the Countdown to ... · The Development of Indirect Drive ICF and the Countdown to Ignition Experiments on the NIF Maxwell Prize Address](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022042118/5e9754adaececc41b46c0a34/html5/thumbnails/20.jpg)
Calculations of these Omega experiments provideevidence of a significant step towards meeting the
grand-challenge of predictive modeling of LPI with pf3d
• PS instantly reduces the contrast, suppressing theamplification from intense speckles
•The pF3D calculations took about 1 million CPU hours
DataNO PS
DataPS
pF3d PS:
D. Froula et al. to be published
pF3d no PS:
Beam power (GW)
SBS(
%)
CPP
150 µm
CPP+PS
Best Focus
Divol TI1-5ThursdayFroula NO6-13Wednesday
![Page 21: The Development of Indirect Drive ICF and the Countdown to ... · The Development of Indirect Drive ICF and the Countdown to Ignition Experiments on the NIF Maxwell Prize Address](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022042118/5e9754adaececc41b46c0a34/html5/thumbnails/21.jpg)
The scale of ignition experiments isdetermined by the limits to compression
200
100
10
1
0.2
Compression (X liquid density)102 103 104 105
50050
5
0.5
Capsuleenergy (KJ)
NIF
Relaxed pressure and
stability requirements
Ther
mon
ucle
ar e
nerg
yCa
psul
e ab
sorb
ed e
nerg
y
Capsule Energy Gain Plotted vs Compression • Pressure is limited toP(Max)~100 Mbar by LaserPlasma Interaction (LPI)effects
• Given the pressure limits,hydrodynamic instabilitieslimit implosion velocities to
!
Vimp
< 4"107cm/sec
and this limits themaximum compression
• Symmetry and pulseshaping must beaccurately controlled toapproach the maximumcompression
![Page 22: The Development of Indirect Drive ICF and the Countdown to ... · The Development of Indirect Drive ICF and the Countdown to Ignition Experiments on the NIF Maxwell Prize Address](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022042118/5e9754adaececc41b46c0a34/html5/thumbnails/22.jpg)
![Page 23: The Development of Indirect Drive ICF and the Countdown to ... · The Development of Indirect Drive ICF and the Countdown to Ignition Experiments on the NIF Maxwell Prize Address](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022042118/5e9754adaececc41b46c0a34/html5/thumbnails/23.jpg)
NIF will provide a qualitative advance in ICF capabilitywith >50X more energy and far greater precision andflexibilty than any previous high energy laser facility
![Page 24: The Development of Indirect Drive ICF and the Countdown to ... · The Development of Indirect Drive ICF and the Countdown to Ignition Experiments on the NIF Maxwell Prize Address](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022042118/5e9754adaececc41b46c0a34/html5/thumbnails/24.jpg)
Cluster 4 Cluster 2 Cluster 1
End view of NIFCluster 3
Upper quad
Lower quad
Bundle
Cluster 1Cluster 4
Cluster 3Cluster 2
Top view of targetchamber (upper quads)
NIF is a 192 beam laser organized into “clusters”,“bundles” and “quads”
![Page 25: The Development of Indirect Drive ICF and the Countdown to ... · The Development of Indirect Drive ICF and the Countdown to Ignition Experiments on the NIF Maxwell Prize Address](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022042118/5e9754adaececc41b46c0a34/html5/thumbnails/25.jpg)
The NIF Project is over 94% complete and 15 of the 241 µm laser bundles (120 beams) have beenperformance qualified
![Page 26: The Development of Indirect Drive ICF and the Countdown to ... · The Development of Indirect Drive ICF and the Countdown to Ignition Experiments on the NIF Maxwell Prize Address](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022042118/5e9754adaececc41b46c0a34/html5/thumbnails/26.jpg)
(single beam)
![Page 27: The Development of Indirect Drive ICF and the Countdown to ... · The Development of Indirect Drive ICF and the Countdown to Ignition Experiments on the NIF Maxwell Prize Address](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022042118/5e9754adaececc41b46c0a34/html5/thumbnails/27.jpg)
![Page 28: The Development of Indirect Drive ICF and the Countdown to ... · The Development of Indirect Drive ICF and the Countdown to Ignition Experiments on the NIF Maxwell Prize Address](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022042118/5e9754adaececc41b46c0a34/html5/thumbnails/28.jpg)
Hohlraum Wall: – U or U0.75Au0.25
Laser Beams(24 quads through eachLEH arranged toilluminate two rings onthe hohlraum wall)
Laser Entrance Hole(LEH) with window
Hohlraum Fill – He0,8H0.2 at 0.9 mg/cm3
10.8mm
Capsule fill tube
Graded-doped BeCapsule (CH andDiamond are alternates)
Solid DTfuel layer
The NIF point design has a graded-doped, berylliumcapsule in a hohlraum driven at 285 eV
Cryo-coolingRing
Aluminum assembly sleeve
°°°
°
![Page 29: The Development of Indirect Drive ICF and the Countdown to ... · The Development of Indirect Drive ICF and the Countdown to Ignition Experiments on the NIF Maxwell Prize Address](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022042118/5e9754adaececc41b46c0a34/html5/thumbnails/29.jpg)
Precision target fabrication and assemblytechniques being developed for the NIF meetthe ignition target requirements
![Page 30: The Development of Indirect Drive ICF and the Countdown to ... · The Development of Indirect Drive ICF and the Countdown to Ignition Experiments on the NIF Maxwell Prize Address](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022042118/5e9754adaececc41b46c0a34/html5/thumbnails/30.jpg)
![Page 31: The Development of Indirect Drive ICF and the Countdown to ... · The Development of Indirect Drive ICF and the Countdown to Ignition Experiments on the NIF Maxwell Prize Address](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022042118/5e9754adaececc41b46c0a34/html5/thumbnails/31.jpg)
Nikroo YO5-4Friday
![Page 32: The Development of Indirect Drive ICF and the Countdown to ... · The Development of Indirect Drive ICF and the Countdown to Ignition Experiments on the NIF Maxwell Prize Address](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022042118/5e9754adaececc41b46c0a34/html5/thumbnails/32.jpg)
Forsman YO5-3Friday
![Page 33: The Development of Indirect Drive ICF and the Countdown to ... · The Development of Indirect Drive ICF and the Countdown to Ignition Experiments on the NIF Maxwell Prize Address](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022042118/5e9754adaececc41b46c0a34/html5/thumbnails/33.jpg)
Initialoperations
TR(eV)
225
250270
300
Max allowed hot spotdegradation fraction
ε = 0.2 0.3 0.4
Experimentallower limit
for 1%scatter
Tanglineartheory10%
scattering
Ignition point design optimization must balanceLPI effects, laser performance impacts, andcapsule robustness
![Page 34: The Development of Indirect Drive ICF and the Countdown to ... · The Development of Indirect Drive ICF and the Countdown to Ignition Experiments on the NIF Maxwell Prize Address](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022042118/5e9754adaececc41b46c0a34/html5/thumbnails/34.jpg)
Ignition point design optimization must balanceLPI effects, laser performance impacts, andcapsule robustness
DesignOptimum forinitial ignitionexperiments
SSD and Polarization smoothingto be incorporated on NIFraises this threshold
Initialoperations
TR(eV)
225
250
270300
Max allowed hot spotdegradation fraction
ε = 0.2 0.3 0.4
Experimentallower limit
for 1%scatter
Tanglineartheory10%
scattering
285 eVPoint
design
![Page 35: The Development of Indirect Drive ICF and the Countdown to ... · The Development of Indirect Drive ICF and the Countdown to Ignition Experiments on the NIF Maxwell Prize Address](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022042118/5e9754adaececc41b46c0a34/html5/thumbnails/35.jpg)
Laser beam propagationin the hohlraum
X-ray generationand symmetryof the radiationflux onto thecapsule
Hydrodynamicinstabilities asthe ignitioncapsule implodes
Detailed calculations of NIF ignition targets present anumber of computational grand challenge problems
°°°
°
![Page 36: The Development of Indirect Drive ICF and the Countdown to ... · The Development of Indirect Drive ICF and the Countdown to Ignition Experiments on the NIF Maxwell Prize Address](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022042118/5e9754adaececc41b46c0a34/html5/thumbnails/36.jpg)
•Integrated hohlraum and capsule calculations - low spatial frequency perturbations (l=8 or less) — Hohlraum radiation flux asymmetry — Pointing errors — Power Imbalance — Capsule misplacement in the hohlraum
— Hohlraum misalignment in the chamber— Missing beams or other off normal operation— Holes in the hohlraum or other inherently 3D structure
• Capsule only calculations - intermediate to high spatialfrequency perturbations (l=10 to 1000) — DT ice roughness — Ablator roughness — Ablator microstructure• Single Beam - Very high spatial frequency perturbations — laser wavelength and laser frequency scale features in the
incident beam and in laser plasma interaction in the hohlraum
The Advanced Simulation Capability (ASC)computers are essential for a wide variety of 3Deffects which impact NIF ignition targets
![Page 37: The Development of Indirect Drive ICF and the Countdown to ... · The Development of Indirect Drive ICF and the Countdown to Ignition Experiments on the NIF Maxwell Prize Address](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022042118/5e9754adaececc41b46c0a34/html5/thumbnails/37.jpg)
Resolving laser wavelength scale phenomena inthe propagation of a laser beam in an ignition scaleplasma is a grand challenge problem.
9.2mm
°°°
°
letterbox” simulationscapture the essentialphysics for “near 2D”situations, like a NIFhohlraum, “
A letterbox run for 10’sof picoseconds using thecode pF3D requires 8Terabytes of memory and~ 2.5M cpu-hours on the8000 processor Atlasmachine or ~ 15M cpu-hours on 32,000processors of the128,000 processor BG/Lmachine
HinkelTI1-4 Thursday
![Page 38: The Development of Indirect Drive ICF and the Countdown to ... · The Development of Indirect Drive ICF and the Countdown to Ignition Experiments on the NIF Maxwell Prize Address](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022042118/5e9754adaececc41b46c0a34/html5/thumbnails/38.jpg)
Optimized 2D symmetry calculations meet the pointdesign requirements
Be capsule fuel region at ignition
80µ
The imploded fuel coreshows very little residualangular variation from theNIF multi-cone geometry Callahan
UO3-1 Friday
![Page 39: The Development of Indirect Drive ICF and the Countdown to ... · The Development of Indirect Drive ICF and the Countdown to Ignition Experiments on the NIF Maxwell Prize Address](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022042118/5e9754adaececc41b46c0a34/html5/thumbnails/39.jpg)
Calculations with Hydra of the 300 eV point designshow very little intrinsic 3D azimuthal asymmetry
Cross section perpendicular to the
hohlraum axis at ignition
80µ
A 3D hohlraum calculationcapable of resolving l=8radiation asymmetry requiresabout 0.2M CPU hours
3D calculations to assessthe effects of powerimbalance, pointing errors,capsule placement errors, etcare in progress
Jones YO6-8Friday
![Page 40: The Development of Indirect Drive ICF and the Countdown to ... · The Development of Indirect Drive ICF and the Countdown to Ignition Experiments on the NIF Maxwell Prize Address](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022042118/5e9754adaececc41b46c0a34/html5/thumbnails/40.jpg)
The ignition point design capsule is subject tohydrodynamic instability over a wide range ofspatial scales
Outer surface of the Be ablator -up to about mode 120 during theacceleration process
Inner surface of the DT fuel - up toabout mode 30 during decelerationto ignition conditions
Interface between Be and DT - upto about mode 1000 duringacceleration
ignition point design capsule
![Page 41: The Development of Indirect Drive ICF and the Countdown to ... · The Development of Indirect Drive ICF and the Countdown to Ignition Experiments on the NIF Maxwell Prize Address](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022042118/5e9754adaececc41b46c0a34/html5/thumbnails/41.jpg)
Detailed 3D effects of capsule surface roughnessare evaluated using HYDRA calculations
• 3D radiation asymmetry isobtained from integratedhohlraum simulations
• Nominal “at spec” capsulefabrication perturbationsare applied on the DT iceand the ablator
Ignition Time140 ps BeforeIgnition Time
Ablator/DTinterface
Hohlraumaxis
Stagnationshock
400 g/cc density isosurface (different scale)
60 g/cc density isosurface
A full sphere coveringmodes 1-30 or an octantcovering modes 4-120 requires about 170 millionzones and ~ 4 million cpuhours on 4000 processors ofthe 10,000 processor 100TFLOP purple machine
![Page 42: The Development of Indirect Drive ICF and the Countdown to ... · The Development of Indirect Drive ICF and the Countdown to Ignition Experiments on the NIF Maxwell Prize Address](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022042118/5e9754adaececc41b46c0a34/html5/thumbnails/42.jpg)
Hydrodynamic instabilities at the capsule ablator-fuelinterface are a particularly challenging problem
Calculationsresolve instabilitygrowth in 3D, up tomode 1000, at theBe/DT interface
Benchmarkcalculations for a4.5-9 degree wedgeusing the HYDRACode require 44-176 million zonesand 1-4 million CPUhours on 1000-4000processors on the10,000 processor,100 TFLOP purpleMachine Hammel PO6-3
Wednesday
![Page 43: The Development of Indirect Drive ICF and the Countdown to ... · The Development of Indirect Drive ICF and the Countdown to Ignition Experiments on the NIF Maxwell Prize Address](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022042118/5e9754adaececc41b46c0a34/html5/thumbnails/43.jpg)
The point design capsule of copper doped Bedriven at 285 eV has been specified in detail
(Cu doped Be shell for 285eV, 1.3 MJ)
Parameter Be(285) "current best calc"
Absorbed energy (kJ) 203Laser energy (kJ)(includes ~8% backscatter)
1300
Coupling efficiency 0.156
Yield (MJ) 19.9Fuel velocity (107 cm/sec) 3.68Peak rhoR (g/cm2) 1.85Adiabat (P/PFD at 1000g/cc) 1.46Fuel mass (mg) 0.238Ablator mass (mg) 4.54Ablator mass remaining (mg) 0.212Fuel kinetic energy (kJ) 16.1
![Page 44: The Development of Indirect Drive ICF and the Countdown to ... · The Development of Indirect Drive ICF and the Countdown to Ignition Experiments on the NIF Maxwell Prize Address](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022042118/5e9754adaececc41b46c0a34/html5/thumbnails/44.jpg)
A CH capsule at 300eV and 1.3 MJ is the principalalternate to Be at 285 eV
•Post-processed hohlraumsimulations at 300 eVindicate LPI equivalent to orbetter than Be at 285eV•Amorphous material withno crystal structure issues•Large data base from Novaand Omega•Less efficient ablator but at1.3 MJ (&300eV), this targetlooks attractively robust.More work in progress.•Transparency makes cryolayer easier to characterizebut low thermal conductivitymakes layer formation in thehohlraum more challenging
1110 µm
10151000
965955
875
YieldEabs
Implosion velocityFuel mass
Ablator mass
CH(300)17.6 MJ150 kJ3.85 x 107
cm/s 0.21 mg2.3 mg
![Page 45: The Development of Indirect Drive ICF and the Countdown to ... · The Development of Indirect Drive ICF and the Countdown to Ignition Experiments on the NIF Maxwell Prize Address](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022042118/5e9754adaececc41b46c0a34/html5/thumbnails/45.jpg)
We are also evaluating a nanocrystalline diamondablator option at 270 eV and 1.3 MJ
YieldEabs
Implosion velocityFuel mass
Ablator mass
24.7 MJ260 kJ3.58 x 107 cm/s0.27 mg5.26 mg
Diamond(270)
3.51 g/cc75 µmthickDT 61 µmthick
1.3 MJ, 270eV design
• Higher density: diamond absorbsenergy at larger radius. Equivalentto 10 - 20% more laser energy.
• Ablator surface is very smooth.Can tolerate 20x the measuredsurface roughness.
• LPI analysis indicates 270 eVdiamond hohlraum has less riskthan Be hohlraum at 285eV
• Complex material propertiesduring pulse shaping: Stays solidafter 1st shock, melts with 2ndshock (Be melts with 1st)
1300
Ho TI1-3 Thursday
![Page 46: The Development of Indirect Drive ICF and the Countdown to ... · The Development of Indirect Drive ICF and the Countdown to Ignition Experiments on the NIF Maxwell Prize Address](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022042118/5e9754adaececc41b46c0a34/html5/thumbnails/46.jpg)
Assessment of ignition targets utilizes computercalculations, coupled to planned precision targetphysics campaigns
Our key question is not “How well can the codes predict theignition target a-priori?”, but instead “Will the uncertainties and
variability that remain after our tuning programs be acceptable?”This is a key focus of our preparations for ignition experiments
• We are designing experimental campaigns for hohlraum energetics, shockstrengths and times, implosion velocity and ablated mass, and symmetry,which will take 100-200 shots leading up to the first ignition attempts
• Most physics uncertainties will be normalized out with these “optimization”experiments (Residual physics uncertainties for these items are set by howaccurately we can do the experiments - the point design specs includeestimates for the achievable accuracy)
• Specifications on target fabrication and laser performance are set to achievethe required precision and reproducibility.
• Uncertainty in some physics issues such as DT thermal conduction andalpha particle deposition in Fermi degenerate DT will remain after theseexperiments
![Page 47: The Development of Indirect Drive ICF and the Countdown to ... · The Development of Indirect Drive ICF and the Countdown to Ignition Experiments on the NIF Maxwell Prize Address](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022042118/5e9754adaececc41b46c0a34/html5/thumbnails/47.jpg)
Drive temperature Trad(Target scale, energy and focal spot size)96 beams
Demonstrate symmetry, shock timing andablation rate techniques at NIF scale96 beams
Point design symmetry, shocktiming, and ablation rate
Commission 96more beams
Hohlraum coupling with 192 beams forbaseline target scale, energy & Trad
192
beam
s
Ignition campaign
Integratedphysicsexperiments
The National Ignition Campaign is focused onpreparing for the first ignition experiments in 2010
![Page 48: The Development of Indirect Drive ICF and the Countdown to ... · The Development of Indirect Drive ICF and the Countdown to Ignition Experiments on the NIF Maxwell Prize Address](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022042118/5e9754adaececc41b46c0a34/html5/thumbnails/48.jpg)
The 23.5º and 30ºbeams heat the waist ofthe hohlraum The 50º beams and 44º
beams heat the hohlraumnear the LaserEntrance hole
The 96 beam campaign will utilize the 30º and 50ºbeams to emulate the ignition target
°°°
°
![Page 49: The Development of Indirect Drive ICF and the Countdown to ... · The Development of Indirect Drive ICF and the Countdown to Ignition Experiments on the NIF Maxwell Prize Address](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022042118/5e9754adaececc41b46c0a34/html5/thumbnails/49.jpg)
The 96 beam emulators are scaled to preservehohlraum energy density and per beam intensity
300 eV1 MJ,192beams)
Rcap = 1 mm
Rhohl=2.55 mm
RLEH=1.275 mm
Rcap = 0.7 mm
Rhohl=1.785 mm
RLEH=1.275 mm
cm
cm
96-beamEmulatorat 70%scale
We use full-sizephase plates,so the LEH isnot scaled.
Meezan YP8-38Friday
We test various TRADignition designs bychanging only thelaser pulse-shape.
![Page 50: The Development of Indirect Drive ICF and the Countdown to ... · The Development of Indirect Drive ICF and the Countdown to Ignition Experiments on the NIF Maxwell Prize Address](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022042118/5e9754adaececc41b46c0a34/html5/thumbnails/50.jpg)
The 96-beam scaled experiments closely matchthe ignition plasma conditions.
96-beam
Ignition(scaled)
96-beam
Ignition(scaled)
ne/nc (max = 0.3) at peak power
![Page 51: The Development of Indirect Drive ICF and the Countdown to ... · The Development of Indirect Drive ICF and the Countdown to Ignition Experiments on the NIF Maxwell Prize Address](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022042118/5e9754adaececc41b46c0a34/html5/thumbnails/51.jpg)
“Keyhole” targets to meet the shock timingrequirements are one of the optimization targetswhich precede ignition experiments
°°°
°
Surrogate Capsule andPedestal support
Visarline ofsight
Robey YO6-15 FridayBoehly CO5-8 Monday
![Page 52: The Development of Indirect Drive ICF and the Countdown to ... · The Development of Indirect Drive ICF and the Countdown to Ignition Experiments on the NIF Maxwell Prize Address](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022042118/5e9754adaececc41b46c0a34/html5/thumbnails/52.jpg)
Accurate pulse shaping is a key to “1D”capsule performance
VISAR measures shockFront doppler shift
Cold D2
1st shock
3rd
2nd
Hohlraum
interfaceVISAR Image of
3-shocks
• Jump in fringe shift gives shock arrival
• Fringe position gives shock velocity
Pulse shape for Be at 1.3 MJand 285 eV
NIF’s pulse shaping system wasdesigned specifically to meet theserequirements
Timing of first3 shocks fromvisar (50 ps)
Timing of 4th rise fromshock collision opticalemission (100ps)
![Page 53: The Development of Indirect Drive ICF and the Countdown to ... · The Development of Indirect Drive ICF and the Countdown to Ignition Experiments on the NIF Maxwell Prize Address](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022042118/5e9754adaececc41b46c0a34/html5/thumbnails/53.jpg)
Hohlraum drivesymmetry includingeffects of LPI and laservariability for longwavelength 3Dperformance
Pulse shaping andcapsule parametersfor “1D” performance
We are doing multivariable sensitivity studies toassess the margin and robustness of ignitiontarget designs
°°°
°
Hydrodynamicinstability forshorter wavelength3D performance
Salmonson TI1-2Thursday
![Page 54: The Development of Indirect Drive ICF and the Countdown to ... · The Development of Indirect Drive ICF and the Countdown to Ignition Experiments on the NIF Maxwell Prize Address](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022042118/5e9754adaececc41b46c0a34/html5/thumbnails/54.jpg)
We have identified 34 pulse shaping and capsuleparameters that impact 1Dcapsule performance
Time
Radi
atio
nTe
mpe
ratu
re
Shock Timing ParametersShock Levels (4)Shock Times (4)Steepness of Final Rise (1)
Capsule ParametersLayer Thickness (7)Material Composition (8)Impurity Concentration (10)
Dens
ity
Radius
![Page 55: The Development of Indirect Drive ICF and the Countdown to ... · The Development of Indirect Drive ICF and the Countdown to Ignition Experiments on the NIF Maxwell Prize Address](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022042118/5e9754adaececc41b46c0a34/html5/thumbnails/55.jpg)
In order to vary all parameters simultaneously, weincorporate a distribution for each
Top-Hat distribution
0 1-1x spec
Normal distribution
0 1-1x spec
prob
abilit
y
For complex physical processessuch as shock timing and levels
that will likely vary normally.
For fabrication specs such ascapsule dimensions that can be
measured and rejected.
![Page 56: The Development of Indirect Drive ICF and the Countdown to ... · The Development of Indirect Drive ICF and the Countdown to Ignition Experiments on the NIF Maxwell Prize Address](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022042118/5e9754adaececc41b46c0a34/html5/thumbnails/56.jpg)
We use ensembles of simulations to estimate theprobability of ignition
Yield(MJ)
Be at 1.3MJ and 285 eV
95% have yield > 2 MJ
Results of 10,000 runs varying all 341D parameters randomly within theirrespective distributions
![Page 57: The Development of Indirect Drive ICF and the Countdown to ... · The Development of Indirect Drive ICF and the Countdown to Ignition Experiments on the NIF Maxwell Prize Address](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022042118/5e9754adaececc41b46c0a34/html5/thumbnails/57.jpg)
Statistical ensembles of 2D simulations includeperturbations on all capsule surfaces
•All 1D parameters (dimensions,compositions, densities, drive parameters)sampled statistically•Roughness for all 2D surfaces set “at spec,”phases varied randomly
Be layer roughness
100.0
10.0
1.0Sqrt
(Pow
er) =
rms
roug
hnes
s (n
m)
1.0 2.0 5.0 10.0 20.0Modes
![Page 58: The Development of Indirect Drive ICF and the Countdown to ... · The Development of Indirect Drive ICF and the Countdown to Ignition Experiments on the NIF Maxwell Prize Address](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022042118/5e9754adaececc41b46c0a34/html5/thumbnails/58.jpg)
2D calculations provide an assessment of theimpact of non-spherical effects
~85% above 1 MJ
~2/3 above 12 MJ
Results of 360 2D simulations (A statistical sample of 60 1Dcapsules with 6 random number seeds in 2D for each 1D point)
![Page 59: The Development of Indirect Drive ICF and the Countdown to ... · The Development of Indirect Drive ICF and the Countdown to Ignition Experiments on the NIF Maxwell Prize Address](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022042118/5e9754adaececc41b46c0a34/html5/thumbnails/59.jpg)
The 285 eV point design has a credible chancefor ignition in early NIF operations….
Energy Margin = Target Energy divided bythe minimum energy required for ignition
Gain
Energy Margin M
!
G
!
G +"RMS
!
G "#RMS
Point design capsule hasa margin of 4.8 with all 1Dparameters nominal andno 3D effects
5
10
Ignition achieved fortargets with Margin >1
00.5 1 2 3 4 5
Median V,entropy3D at specMargin 1.5
15
1D2D
Haan BP8-34 MondayClark TI1-1 Thursday
![Page 60: The Development of Indirect Drive ICF and the Countdown to ... · The Development of Indirect Drive ICF and the Countdown to Ignition Experiments on the NIF Maxwell Prize Address](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022042118/5e9754adaececc41b46c0a34/html5/thumbnails/60.jpg)
Ultimately, yields well in excess of 100 MJ maybe possible on NIF
Expected NIF performance at 2ωwith optimized conversioncrystals and lenses
Potential NIF performance at 2ω based on stored 1ω energy
Expected NIFperformance at 3ω
Tr(eV)
Yields versus laser energy for NIF geometry hohlraums
Band isuncertainty in
hohlraumperformance
2010-2011experiments
200 eV
210 eV
225 eV
250 eV
270 eV
300 eV
Laser energy (MJ)
Yiel
d (M
J)
![Page 61: The Development of Indirect Drive ICF and the Countdown to ... · The Development of Indirect Drive ICF and the Countdown to Ignition Experiments on the NIF Maxwell Prize Address](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022042118/5e9754adaececc41b46c0a34/html5/thumbnails/61.jpg)
Double shell indirect drive targets are apossible alternate for ignition
05-00-0696-1321
• Non-cryogenic
• Low radiationtemperature relaxesLPI effects
• Fabrication to controlmix is a majorchallenge
•Inherently limited torelatively low gainbecause most of thecompressed mass isinert
Low-z ablator(e.g. Be or CH)
High-z shell(e.g. Au/Cu)
Graded densitymaterial to controlhydro instabilityduring collision(e.g variable densityCu foam)
DT fuel
![Page 62: The Development of Indirect Drive ICF and the Countdown to ... · The Development of Indirect Drive ICF and the Countdown to Ignition Experiments on the NIF Maxwell Prize Address](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022042118/5e9754adaececc41b46c0a34/html5/thumbnails/62.jpg)
NIF can explore direct drive or fast ignitionas alternate approaches to ignition
05-00-0696-1321
• Separate compression and ignition• Potentially highest gain• Short pulse physics is major issue
Fast IgnitionPolar Direct Drive
• Direct Drive in the Indirect Drive Geometry• Higher coupling efficiency than indirect drive• Beam smoothing and implosion symmetry are major challenges
![Page 63: The Development of Indirect Drive ICF and the Countdown to ... · The Development of Indirect Drive ICF and the Countdown to Ignition Experiments on the NIF Maxwell Prize Address](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022042118/5e9754adaececc41b46c0a34/html5/thumbnails/63.jpg)
The NIF ignition experiments will be the culminationof five decades of development which started withthe invention of the laser in 1960
• Dramatic advances in computations, lasers, diagnostics, and targetfabrication over the past 3 decades have laid the groundwork for NIF andthe National Ignition Campaign (NIC)
• Experiments for hohlraum energetics, shock strengths and times,implosion velocity and ablated mass, and symmetry, will normalize outmost remaining physics uncertainties
• Targets near 1 MJ of laser energy have a credible chance for ignition inearly NIF operations …..when the required precision of targetexperiments, laser performance, and target fabrication is achieved
• The initial ignition experiments only scratch the surface of NIF’s potential
Ignition is a grand challenge undertaking. It is likely to take a fewyears to achieve the required level of precision and understandingof the physics and technology needed for success.
![Page 64: The Development of Indirect Drive ICF and the Countdown to ... · The Development of Indirect Drive ICF and the Countdown to Ignition Experiments on the NIF Maxwell Prize Address](https://reader033.vdocuments.site/reader033/viewer/2022042118/5e9754adaececc41b46c0a34/html5/thumbnails/64.jpg)