Running head: MIGRATION FROM ZIMBABWE TO THE US AND NHRD 1
Exploring Migration from Zimbabwe to the United States and Implications for Zimbabwe’s
National Human Resource Development
Charlene Mutamba
Julia Storberg-Walker
North Carolina State University
Doctoral Submission
Keywords: national human resource development, migration, brain drain
Copyright © 2014 Charlene Mutamba & Julia Storberg-Walker
MIGRATION FROM ZIMBABWE TO THE US AND NHRD 2
Despite heavy investments in education by Zimbabwean policy makers, Zimbabwean
nationals continue to leave their home country for work or personal reasons. According to the
International Organization on Migration (2009) between 2000 and 2005, net migration rate was -
11.2. United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization (UNESCO) 2009
statistics show that Zimbabwe’s literacy rate of 91.4% is largely due to the increase in
investments in education made between 1980 and 2000. The investments in developing human
capital are not producing a return, however, to the country of Zimbabwe. For example, between
1990 and 2010, Zimbabwe, like other countries in the region, experienced and continues to
experience increases in the movement of workers out of the country (citation). This growing
concern is part of a phenomenon known as “brain drain” (Beine, Docquier & Rapoport, 2001).
Migration of highly trained individuals leaves many nations short of the skills necessary to
succeed in a global economy (El-Khawas, 2004).
Purpose Statement
The purpose of this exploratory study was to understand the work experiences of
migrants from Zimbabwe to the United States. Understanding these experiences is one strategy
towards identifying specific National Human Resource Development (NHRD) policies and
practices that may help to stem the brain drain. The case study was conducted by exploring the
career experiences of migrants from Zimbabwe working in the US.
Research Question
The research question guiding this study was: What are the work experiences of
Zimbabwe nationals in the United States?
MIGRATION FROM ZIMBABWE TO THE US AND NHRD 3
Context and Background
Since 1996, Zimbabwe has experienced an increase in outflow migration to countries
such as South Africa, New Zealand, the United Kingdom, and the US. Despite this increase in
migration, no other HRD scholars have focused on this aspect of NHRD. Some previous studies
on migration have been in developmental economics (El-Khawas, 2004; Liebig, 2003; Beine,
Docquier & Rapoport, 2008) while others broadly approached brain drain from Zimbabwe
(Tevera & Crush, 2003; Muchenje, 2003; Gwaradzimba & Shumba, 2010). Others scholars have
focused on human capital loss in the medical field (Pang, Lansang, & Haines, 2002; Troy,
Wyness, & McAuliffe, 2007; Hagopian, Thompson, Fordyce, Johnson, & Hart, 2004), but with a
focus on doctors only (Chikanda, 2006) and nurses only (Chikanda, 2005).
In addition, most research has focused on migration to European Union (EU) member
countries, Australia and New Zealand (Oberoi, & Lin, 2006).) Other studies conducted by the
WB focus on economic consequences of brain drain (Docquier, Lohest & Marfouk, 2007;
Bhargava, & Docquier, 2008). To date, no HRD scholars have researched migration from
Zimbabwe to the US and its impact on NHRD; hence, according to Merriam (2002), there is a
sense of urgency which this qualitative research fulfills.
This study is important because there is a need to understand how to help Zimbabwe keep
trained workers from migrating out of the country. NHRD scholars can help Zimbabwe policy
makers create structures and develop incentives to attract and retain high level skills and help
nations to both compete and collaborate within the global labor market. After understanding
more about the experiences of Zimbabwean migrants in the US, this paper will explore the
negative and positive implications of migration. Although the phenomenon of brain drain is not
new, the implications for Zimbabwe continue to be experienced.
MIGRATION FROM ZIMBABWE TO THE US AND NHRD 4
To begin this study, it is important to explore the following underlying definitions of
HRD and NHRD that were used in this study.
Human Resource Development (HRD)
To date there is no consensus on the definition of HRD; however, according to McLean
and McLean (2001), most definitions of HRD are focused on activities related to
learning/behavioral change, performance improvement and changing attitudes and organizational
culture. McLean and McLean’s (2001) definition of HRD encompasses the different contexts of
HRD in a global environment whereby:
Human resource development is any process or activity that, either initially or over the
long term, has the potential to develop adults’ work-based knowledge, expertise,
productivity and satisfaction, whether for personal or group/team gain, or for the benefit
of an organization, community, nation or, ultimately, the whole of humanity (p. 322).
Wilson (2012) defines HRD as, “the processes for increasing the cognitive, affective and
behavioral capacities of all people and organizations in a society” (p.9). These definitions of
HRD have been expanded as the field of HRD is explored in different contexts.
National Human Resource Development (NHRD)
In the past, NHRD was defined around vocational education and training and
occasionally by country level manpower planning and human capital development (Wilson,
2012). NHRD was evaluated using macro indicators, such as: the Human Development Index
(HDI), analytic reports and academic articles. Now, according to Wilson (2012), sources of
NHRD include: personal learning, universities, colleges and schools, informal learning, work
based learning, voluntary and community groups, health education, employment training and
continuing education. Ardchvili, Zavyalova and Minina (2012) describe NHRD as encompassing
MIGRATION FROM ZIMBABWE TO THE US AND NHRD 5
education and training issues, which include: basic education, industrial training, productivity
and equity in labor forces and workplaces, creation of comparable labor market data, lifelong
learning and management development.
The concept of NHRD has expanded from the definition of HRD. According to Swanson
and Holton (2001), there is a need for HRD in developing nations to address the challenges of
developing their human resources as a national asset and source of sustainable development and
competitiveness. In addressing these concerns, McLean, Bartlett and Cho (2003) add education,
health, safety, and other factors to their definition of NHRD thereby further expanding the scope
of HRD beyond the organization. They believe that issues of national policy require a broader
scope.
In the 2004 special issue of Advances in Human Resource Development, several authors
tackled the concept of NHRD from diverse lenses. Lutta-Mukhebi (2004) approaches NHRD
from the understanding that Kenya’s national HRD is synonymous with education to eradicate
“ignorance, disease, and poverty” (p. 327). Johnson, Bartlett, Cunningham, Lynham, and Von
Der Marwitz (2010) define NHRD through their experience in South Africa, specifically within
the context of the impact of HIV on national human resources. The use of context specific
definitions of NHRD provides a basis for a clearer understanding of the impact of migration on
Zimbabwe specifically.
In addition, Lynham and Cunningham (2004) define NHRD as, “A process or processes
of organized capability and competence based learning experiences undertaken within a
specified period of time to bring about individual and organizational growth and performance
improvement, and to enhance national economic, cultural and social development” (p.319).
There are currently five emerging models for NHRD according to Cho and McLean (2004): (a)
MIGRATION FROM ZIMBABWE TO THE US AND NHRD 6
centralized NHRD, (b) transitional NHRD, (c) government initiated NHRD, (d) decentralized/
free market NHRD and (e) small nation NHRD. Zimbabwe may not fit entirely in one category
or the other but would fall between government initiated and transitional NHRD.
The varying contexts of NHRD have created a need for different definitions. Hasler,
Thompson and Schuler (2006) describe NHRD in Brazil as a systematic development of human
skills, capabilities and knowledge for the purpose of performance improvement in the
organization, community and nation. Zimbabwe’s NHRD utilizes some of the components of
NHRD in general; however, there are country specific aspects of NHRD that must be considered
as well.
A broader definition of NHRD is championed by McLean (2006 as cited in Tynaliev
(2009) as,
An undertaking at the top level of government and throughout the country’s society that
coordinates all activities related to human development (HD) to create greater efficiency,
effectiveness, competitiveness, satisfaction, productivity, knowledge, spirituality and
well-being of its residents. It includes education, health, safety, training, economic
development, culture, science and technology and factors influencing HD (p.3).
In addition, Metcalfe and Rees (2005) define NHRD as, “the development of a national
policy of skills development and is normally devised by governmental administration
departments. HRD initiatives can be regionally oriented within a nation state or incorporate
partnerships with other governments” (p. 457). These broader definitions of NHRD focus on
governmental policy and other aspects of human development that contribute to the general well
being of the worker.
MIGRATION FROM ZIMBABWE TO THE US AND NHRD 7
Literature Review
There are several theories about the movement of people but this study will draw on
theories of migration that explain NHRD issues that affect Zimbabwe. This section will cover
human capital theory, family migration theory, network migration theory, migrant self-selection,
and new economics of migration as they inform NHRD policy and practice. The use of these
theories is to understand how the participant experiences, as understood through the data
analysis, are either confirming or contradicting the expected outcomes the theories suggest. Due
to space limitations, only a brief overview of the relevant theories is presented in this paper.
Human Capital Theory
The human capital theory is used to explain how education or training raises the
productivity of workers by imparting useful knowledge and skills, hence raising workers’ future
income by increasing their lifetime earnings (Becker, 1964). The theory is used to justify the
assertion that increase in education and training of the workforce will result in economic growth.
In this study the human capital theory will be used to show how Zimbabweans who have
acquired more education and training but leave the country can affect its future economic
growth. The research questions in this study can be answered by also using the definition of
human capital provided by Fitz-Enz (2000 as cited in Nafukho, Hairston & Brooks, 2004) in
which,
Human capital encompasses the traits one brings to the job: intelligence, fulfilling work
energy, a generally positive attitude, reliability and commitment. One’s ability to learn: aptitude,
imagination, creativity and what is often called ‘street smarts’ savvy (how to get things done) (p.
548).
In a study on brain drain in Zimbabwe, 29% of the respondents listed career advancement
as the main reason for their departure (Chetsanga et al, 1998). This means that almost a third of
MIGRATION FROM ZIMBABWE TO THE US AND NHRD 8
those who migrated felt their education and training was being underutilized in Zimbabwe. In a
study conducted by the Scientific and Industrial Research and Development Center, most of the
respondents who left Zimbabwe held bachelor’s or polytechnic degrees, 20 percent of those who
left held masters degrees, while five percent held Ph.D. degrees (Chetsanga et al., 1998).
Sjastaad’s (1962) human capital theory" of migration is used to explain the movement of
people as an investment activity. The government of Zimbabwe may therefore influence the
migration decision by improving the overall attractiveness of their country as a place to live, as
locations with a high standard of living are likely to have strong advantages in the competition
for highly skilled labor (Liebig, 2003).
By focusing on the migration decision of the individual, the human capital theory
acknowledges the importance of subjective factors that have been largely neglected in the
literature. Sometimes migrants are attracted by high-standard training, research and educational
facilities in the new country because they are important in developing human capital (Liebig,
2003). As education and training increases human capital, the future host country’s ability to provide
easier access may be an important factor in migration.
In understanding the importance of human capital to NHRD, Paprock (2006) says,
Human capital focuses on the economic behavior of individuals, especially the way their
accumulation of knowledge and skills enables them to increase their productivity and
their earnings and in so doing, to increase the productivity and wealth of the societies
they live in. (p. 17).
Family Migration Theory
Family migration theory expands the traditional model of migration by making the
assumption that the family, rather than the individual, makes the decision to move to another
MIGRATION FROM ZIMBABWE TO THE US AND NHRD 9
country. This approach has been developed by Mincer (1978). He used the concept of family ties
to explain migration propensities of families, concluding that family ties deter migration,
especially when the family must consider a working spouse. In the study by the Scientific and
Industrial Research Center in Zimbabwe, 13.8% of the respondents indicated they migrated because
of marriage (Chetsanga et al, 1998).
When the family is the decision-making unit, the income of each family member is
included in making a decision to migrate. If both spouses are motivated by job opportunities,
there could then be a tendency to migrate to large, diversified labor markets that offer good
employment prospectives for women (Mincer, 1978). Therefore migration becomes a family
decision and not just a single career decision. This is important when applied to NHRD as
governments and decision makers must incorporate the needs of the family in creating workforce
policy.
New Economics of Migration
Proponents of the new theories of migration believe wage difference and individual decision
making are too simplistic in explaining the movement of people. Migration is to be analyzed as a
decision dependent on various factors, such as family decisions. As a result, the unit of analysis in
the new economics of migration is the family and household and not the individual migrant
(Massey et al., 1993 as cited in Melisovich, 2009).
Secondly, migration does not aim at maximizing income, but rather at diversifying risk.
Families send some of their members abroad to diversify income risk, a strategy that is
particularly important in less developed countries where no insurance markets or retirement
plans exist. In understanding the migration of Zimbabwe nationals to the US it is important that
those involved in NHRD place some emphasis on how the family as a unit is affected by
MIGRATION FROM ZIMBABWE TO THE US AND NHRD 10
government policy.
Network Migration Theory
Network migration theory involves kinship, friendship, community and ethnic ties.
Migration networks are considered a kind of social capital, defined as a form of capital that exists
in the relations between people (Coleman, 1988). For Zimbabwe nationals network links lower
the costs associated with migration.
Migration networks lower the cost of migrating by providing the migrant with
information about: the potential host country and its labor market and earnings opportunities,
provide assistance during the settlement process, in times of financial trouble and are important as
information asymmetries, e.g. to obtain entry and work permits (Faist, 1997). For example, 75
percent of PhD degree holders from Zimbabwe now living in a different country decided to migrate
because they found jobs through personal connections (Chetsanga et al., 1998).
According to Tevara and Crush (2003), networks abroad generally tended to influence the
consideration given to leaving Zimbabwe. Generally, the respondents with networks in the chosen
destination had the greatest likelihood of leaving the country. About 70 percent of those who have
considered migration know of at least one migrant in the desired country of destination (Tevara at
al., 2003). In general, network migration lowers the risk to Zimbabweans moving to a different
country.
Migrant Self-Selection
The migration of workers from Zimbabwe to the US may be explained through migration
self selection. Self-selection theory provides hypotheses about the relative attractiveness of
prospective host countries for certain classes of migrants - beyond traditional unemployment and
wage differences.
MIGRATION FROM ZIMBABWE TO THE US AND NHRD 11
Positively self-selected migrants are those who enjoy above-average earnings in the
source and in the host country. Positive self-selection results in a greater migration propensity of
highly skilled workers. Chiswick (1999, 2000),who based his argument on a human capital
model, believes that migrants tend to be positively self-selected due to the presence of out-of-
pocket costs to migration. These direct migration costs have lower opportunity costs for the
highly skilled that tend to have more disposable income and will be likely to recoup the cost of
moving.
Neo-classical Macroeconomic Migration Theory
Wang and Holton (2005), describe neoclassical economics as the study of the allocation
of scarce resources among alternative ends. The application of this theory helps to explain the
net difference in expected wages which contributes to most to the decision by skilled workers to
migrate. By applying this theory, one assumes that flows will completely end in the absence of
wage and unemployment rate differentials, as only employment opportunities induce migration.
If this theory is applied in this context we see that high skilled workers from Zimbabwe who are
living and working in the US were mostly driven by the increase in wages. By using this theory
several factors are explained in the aggregate demand for and supply of potential labor migrants.
These include the size and growth of the population and the active work force, unemployment
rates, (net) wages and the working time (Liebig, 2003).
Theoretical Framework
The purpose of this study can be analyzed through the family migration theory, network
migration theory and human capital theory.
MIGRATION FROM ZIMBABWE TO THE US AND NHRD 12
Method
A qualitative case study approach was used to analyze the experiences of migrants who
moved to the US. This study included a purposively chosen sample of migrants who left
Zimbabwe to live in the US.
Semi-structured interviews in English were conducted in the fall of 2013 with two
participants. Interviews were conducted individually face to face in order to record nonverbal
cues. Each interview lasted about one hour. The interviews were analyzed to answer the research
questions using open and a priori coding from information obtained in the literature.
The decision to use a case study is based on the review of literature and research methods
used to study this phenomenon. Yin (2009) says, “case study research involves the study of a
case within a real life contemporary context or setting. According to Creswell, “ Case study
research is a qualitative approach in which the investigator explores a real life, contemporary
bounded system (a case) or multiple bounded systems (cases) over time through detailed, in-
depth data collection involving multiple sources of information and reports” (p. 97).
Migration
Human Capital Theory
Network Migration
Theory Family
Migration Theory
MIGRATION FROM ZIMBABWE TO THE US AND NHRD 13
This case study follows Merriam’s (1998) recommendation that case study methodology
be used when the researcher attempts to get an understanding of an issue or a phenomenon from
the perspective of those involved in the situation. Using quantitative methods would have
impeded my ability to analyze the individual career experiences of migrants and to allow their
voices to be heard by policy makers who affect NHRD. Participants were protected by member
checking by allowing the participants to read the transcript to ensure their views are accurately
represented.
Participant Selection
According to Merriam’s (2002) standard for good qualitative research the participants
were purposively recruited. These participants were provided with the informed consent form
and a copy of the Institutional Review Board (IRB) application and approval documents.
Participants then scheduled at a date and place of their choosing. Participants were labeled Jane
and John.
Data Collection
Multiple sources of data were explored to help inform this study and in adherence to the
standard by Yin (2003) that findings and conclusions will be more convincing if several sources
of information are used. Semi-structured interviews were useful in allowing me the flexibility to
probe for clarity or for the participants to elaborate on how their experiences answer the research
questions.
Data Analysis
Data analysis was conducted through different phases. First, upon completion of
interviews, the recording and interview notes were transcribed into a word document and then
analyzed through open coding. According to Creswell (2013), “open coding is coding the data
MIGRATION FROM ZIMBABWE TO THE US AND NHRD 14
for its major categories of information” and categories are, “units of information composed of
events, happenings and instances” (p.86). The third stage comprised using a priori codes derived
from literature related to the theoretical framework to analyze emerging themes.
Participants
Jane received additional education in the US in accounting and management and
currently works in business and finance. John received a PhD degree in chemistry. The
participant currently works in scientific research.
Results
From the interview analysis many categories emerged during open coding which were
narrowed into five categories. Initial open coding revealed 45 codes. These were eventually
narrowed to nine categories: family, economy, education in Zimbabwe, career opportunities in
Zimbabwe and the US, infrastructure in Zimbabwe, human rights, foreign investment, rule of
law and politics.
A priori codes
. The a priori codes from migration literature included: career and education (wages,
poor working and career conditions, educational systems, career opportunities) (Tevara & Crush,
2003), local infrastructure and resources, local politics and governance (Chetsanga, 1998),
economy (local and foreign investment) (Wang and Holton, 2005) and family (Mincer, 1978) as
other issues that participants felt where important to understanding the impact of migration on
NHRD.
Career and Education
The most expressed reasons for migration was career and educational opportunities.
Participants discussed poor career and education opportunities both in Zimbabwe and the US, the
MIGRATION FROM ZIMBABWE TO THE US AND NHRD 15
education systems and how wages affected their career experiences. This confirms one of the
main reasons why workers with more human capital are more likely to migrate as described in
the human capital theory of migration proposed by Sjastaad (1962). The findings on career and
education can be grouped into poor career opportunities, educational opportunities and wage
issues.
Poor career opportunities. However, the career opportunities in the US ‘do not always
meet the migrants’ expectations. Jane experienced challenges early in her career as the
opportunities were not as many as she had perceived while in Zimbabwe. Jane perceives that she
would have had better career prospects in Zimbabwe because her peers with the same level of
education and experience have better career opportunities. In addition, Jane echoes that even
though career opportunities were the number one reason for migrating, her peer network in
Zimbabwe has achieved more.
Educational Opportunities. Based on her experiences Jane discusses how the choice to
study something business related without specific certification requirements has impeded her
career. John describes how the experience of migration influenced his career choice which
would be beneficial in understanding how workers with more human capital affect NHRD. He
says,
When migrant Zimbabweans came here I think the thing that ended up influencing their
career decisions more than what they wanted to do was what was available to them and
by that I mean if there was a University offering scholarships in let’s say Biology then
Zimbabweans who would have wanted to do Actuary Science for example would have
taken the Biology because of the resources being offered.
John believes,
MIGRATION FROM ZIMBABWE TO THE US AND NHRD 16
…..one, investment in primary, secondary and tertiary education. If the government says
we are going to invest in our people and in our infrastructure and actually start doing
that…. you need investment in human resources more than anything else.
Wages. Even though wages are somewhat important according to the literature (Dovlo,
2003, Jane was the only one who discussed how it would influence her decision to return. She
believes if workers continue to be paid in US dollars it would create stability in the labor market.
In addition she believes the Zimbabwe government must encourage multinationals to invest and
create more jobs that would give workers more choice in the labor market.
Economic Issues
Economic issues are often listed as an important reason for migration. Jane remembered
that when leaving Zimbabwe the economy was beginning to deteriorate and most of her family
that left around that time also left for economic reasons. One of the issues that affects the
economy is direct foreign investment. Both participants believed this was crucial to NHRD. John
offered some recommendations that may be relevant to NHRD policy makers,
I would also want to see private public interaction where academic institutions actually
send their students into private enterprise. But the private entities do not exist because the
government does not enable an environment in which they could exist. Set up an
environment that is conducive for private enterprise research and development and even
foreign biotech companies to come into the country. The locals are in no position to start
these biotech companies and foreigners to come in with local partnerships and that
becomes private and the government themselves invest and you have interaction between
private and public and that makes sense.
MIGRATION FROM ZIMBABWE TO THE US AND NHRD 17
Political and governance issues
As cited in migration literature (Dovlo, 2003) politics was an important factor in
migration and NHRD. Jane would return to Zimbabwe if,
The government can start by creating a political atmosphere that isn’t the way that things
were in the early 2000s. The biggest thing is the rampant corruption, the greed, and
lawlessness that exist. People don’t respect contracts; don’t respect rules because how do
you create a level playing field.
John adds, “Other things like a government that respects human rights, that respects
intellectual development that wants to see itself do better.” John offers a concrete suggestion
based on how countries like China and India have dealt with migration as a national policy issues
and says,
So what the government would have to do is look at their institutions because they now
actually have quite a few institutions and say we want to build our chemistry department
so here is this grant money for the next 10 years. Here is an updated lab that we have
equipped to the best of our ability so please come back and we will give you this
guaranteed tenured position at the University of Zimbabwe of the National University of
Science and Technology. Come, teach our kids, you are going to be tenured for the next
years and come and do research. That’s what the governments of China and India are
doing. Most of them want to stay here but the government of India says if you come we
will give you an academic position and not only just an academic position we are going
to give you money for graduate students in your lab and post-doctoral students in your
lab so it’s almost an economic or financial incentive for you to come back.
Local infrastructure
MIGRATION FROM ZIMBABWE TO THE US AND NHRD 18
Another important theme to explore is local infrastructure and resources that affects
migration. Jane believes a more stable economy, better infrastructure like reliable water and
electricity, quality road network, functional supply chain for retail store and well-funded schools
have also contributed to the decision to migrate. Most migrants are concerned with how
infrastructure would affect their quality of life and their career in general.
Family and Other Issues
Other issues that participants discussed were family consideration in migrating and the
decision to return to Zimbabwe. John mentions that his decision to return to Zimbabwe will be
affected by his spouse as described in family migration theory.
Conclusion
The purpose of this study was fulfilled through a qualitative design. The analysis of data
revealed the following categories that help to answer the research question: career and education,
local infrastructure and resources, local politics and governance, economics and other issues.
Participant’s responses confirm migration theories that explain the movement
Statistics from the Migration Policy Institute show that traditionally migrants from sub-
Saharan Africa have more years of schooling than Americans. The two participants used in this
study confirm this assertion as they both have 18 or more years of schooling which increases
their human capital substantially which greatly affects their decision to return to Zimbabwe.
The literature reviewed and the findings from this research are persuasive enough to
recommend a closer examination of the effect of migration on NHRD in Zimbabwe and other
countries in sub-Saharan Africa. This study found that overall the career experiences of migrants
from Zimbabwe to the US show that more education improved their career opportunities but also
made them less likely to return to Zimbabwe. The participants are generally concerned about bad
MIGRATION FROM ZIMBABWE TO THE US AND NHRD 19
governance and infrastructure, educational and career opportunities and the economy in general
in Zimbabwe.
Based on these findings, the study suggests that migration from Zimbabwe to the US
negatively impacts NHRD in Zimbabwe. This conclusion is consistent with the conclusions of
previous work by Chetsanga (1998) which points out that movement of highly skilled individuals
must be approached by the Zimbabwe government as a human resource policy issue.
Implications
This is a challenge to other HRD researchers to explore the impact of migration on
NHRD, international human resource development (IHRD) and global human resource
development (GHRD). It is important for researchers to explore the links between migration and
HRD in an increasingly global world where migration is more common. Understanding the
impact of the movement of workers across borders could also expand HRD’s scope within the
context of a knowledge economy.
The call to expand the definition of NHRD by McLean (2004) necessitates that HRD
researchers explore the interconnected global labor market and how movement of skilled
workers affects the specific national and overall global economy.
More theories and research on NHRD are important because developed countries must
continue to adequately prepare their citizens for the global labor market by increasing funding
and opportunities for workers to train for new skills. Reports indicate that current workers will
have to change eight to ten jobs in their lifetime and that half the skills workers possess will
become obsolete in a few years (Global Education and skills Forum, 2013). With the rapid
changes in the global economic and labor market it is important for nations to decide whether
MIGRATION FROM ZIMBABWE TO THE US AND NHRD 20
their NHRD will be based on free market economics or allow government involvement in skills
development.
It is imperative for more theory and research on how underdeveloped countries can create
NHRD policy and strategy that will allow them to compete economically. According to the WB
(2012) investments in human resources on a national scale beginning with basic education,
vocational education, higher education and skills training in order to compete and collaborate
globally. Most economies of underdeveloped countries are focused on agriculture. However,
these nations must diversify their labor market by providing skills training in various industries.
NHRD in underdeveloped countries must incorporate education, health and safety as described
by McLean, Bartlett and Cho (2003). Combining education, health and safety will strengthen the
workforce holistically.
In addition, the HRD literature on sub-Saharan Africa is scarce and on Zimbabwe is
almost non-existent. It is important for more scholars to explore NHRD in sub-Saharan Africa as
globalization causes policy and practice to be intertwined with each problem going beyond the
boundaries of one nation.
Understanding migration from Zimbabwe to the US informs economic and social policy.
Study findings suggest national policy makers in Zimbabwe would benefit from strategies that
would attract workers with high skills whether they are Zimbabwe nationals or other migrants. In
this global economy it is important for Zimbabwe to consider attracting workers beyond its
traditional citizenry. In order for this to occur, the Zimbabwe government must openly welcome
back workers who possess a lot of human capital, improve governance by tackling corruption,
greed and lawlessness, promote entrepreneurship and a business environment that welcomes
MIGRATION FROM ZIMBABWE TO THE US AND NHRD 21
foreign investment. Other local issues they must address include infrastructure which is
sometimes not directly associated with HRD but creates the environment in which HRD thrives.
Implications for practice include the need for NHRD policy to address how migration can
benefit a sub-Saharan African country like Zimbabwe and others in the region affected by loss of
human capital. In addition there is a concerted effort to lure high skilled workers who possess a
significant amount of human capital back to sub-Saharan Africa in general. This is driven by the
need to attract and retain high skilled workers by helping countries to compete and collaborate in
the global labor market.
MIGRATION FROM ZIMBABWE TO THE US AND NHRD 22
Reference List
Becker, G. S. (1993). Human capital: A theoretical and empirical analysis with special reference
to education. Chicago, IL: University Of Chicago Press.
Beine, M., Docquier, F., & Rapoport, H. (2001). Brain drain and economic growth: Theory and
evidence. Journal of Development Economics, 64(1), 275-289.
Bhargava, A., & Docquier, F. (2008). HIV pandemic, medical brain drain and economic
development in sub-Saharan Africa. The World Bank Economic Review, 22(2), 345-366.
Capps, R., McCabe, K., & Fix, M. (2011,). New streams: Black African migration to the United
States. Retrieved from Migration Policy Institute website:
www.migrationpolicy.org/pubs/AfricanMigrationUS.pdf
Chikanda, A. (2006). Skilled health professionals’ migration and its impact on health delivery in
Zimbabwe. Journal of Ethnic and Migration Studies, 32(04), 667-680.
Chiswick, B. R. (1999). Are immigrants favorably self-selected?. The American Economic
Review, 89(2), 181-185.
Cohn, Elchanan, and Terry G. Geske. The Economics of Education. New York, NY: Pergammon
Press, 1990. Print.
Coleman, J. S. (1988). Social capital in the creation of human capital. American journal of
sociology, S95-S120.
Creswell, J. W. (2013). Qualitative inquiry and research design: Choosing among five
approaches. Sage. Thousand Oaks.
Docquier, F., Lohest, O., & Marfouk, A. (2007). Brain drain in developing countries. The World
Bank Economic Review, 21(2), 193-218. doi:10.1093/wber/lhm008
El-Khawas, M. A. (2004). Brain drain: Putting Africa between a rock and a hard place.
Mediterranean Quarterly, 15(4), 37-56.
MIGRATION FROM ZIMBABWE TO THE US AND NHRD 23
Fitz-Enz, J. (2000). The roi of human capital: measuring the economic value of employee
performance. Amacom.
Gwaradzimba, E., & Shumba, A. (2010). The nature, extent and impact of the brain drain in
Zimbabwe and South Africa. Acta Acad, 42(1), 209-241.
Hagopian, A., Thompson, M. J., Fordyce, M., Johnson, K. E., & Hart, L. G. (2004). The
migration of physicians from sub-Saharan Africa to the United States of America:
measures of the African brain drain. Human resources for health, 2(1), 17.
Johnson, M. H., Bartlett, K. R., Cunningham, P., Lynham, S. A., & Von Der Marwitz, J. (2010).
A necessary dialogue: A South African case study exploring the role of national HRD in
HIV/AIDS non-governmental organizations. Human Resource Development
International, 13(2), 165-183. doi:10.1080/13678861003703708
Liebig, T. (2003). Migration theory from a supply side perspective. Research Institute for L
Abour Economics and Labour Law, 92. Retrieved from
http://www.unisg.ch/~/~/media/Internet/Content/Dateien/InstituteUndCenters/FAA/Publi
kationen/Diskussionspapiere/2003/dp92.ashx
Lutta-Mukhebi, M. C. (2004). National human resource development policy in Kenya. Advances
in Developing Human Resources, 6(3), 326-333. doi:10.1177/1523422304266081
Lynham, S. A., & Cunningham, P. W. (2004). Human resource development: The South African
case. Advances in Developing Human Resources, 6(3), 315-325. doi:
10.1177/1523422304266079
McLean, G. N., & McLean, L. (2001). If we can't define HRD in one country, how can we
define it in an international context?. Human Resource Development International, 4(3),
313-326
MIGRATION FROM ZIMBABWE TO THE US AND NHRD 24
McLean, G. N., Kuo, M. C., Budhwani, N. N., Yamnill, S., & Virakul, B. (2012). Capacity
building for societal development : Case studies in human resource development.
Advances in Developing Human Resources, 14(3), 251-263.
doi:10.1177/1523422312446147
Melisovich, U. T. (2009). Labor migration from post-soviet Kyrgyzstan to Russia and its
developmental impact in the context of national human resource development. (Order No.
3358653, University of Minnesota). ProQuest Dissertations and Theses, , 179. Retrieved
from http://search.proquest.com/docview/219949926?accountid=12725. (219949926).
Merriam, S. B. (2002). Assessing and evaluating qualitative research. Qualitative research in
practice: Examples for discussion and analysis, 18-33.
Metcalfe, B. D., & Rees, C. J. (2005). Theorizing advances in international human resource
development. Human Resource Development International, 8(4), 449-465.
doi:10.1080/13678860500354601
Mincer, J., & Polachek, S. (1978). An exchange: The theory of human capital and the earnings of
women: Women's earnings reexamined. The Journal of Human Resources, 13(1), 118-
134.
Muchenje, T. B. (2003). An analysis of the cause and effect of the brain drain in Zimbabwe.
Harare: Scientific and Industrial Research and Development Centre.
Nafukho, F. M., Hairston, N., & Brooks, K. (2004). Human capital theory: implications for
human resource development. Human Resource Development International, 7(4), 545-
551.
MIGRATION FROM ZIMBABWE TO THE US AND NHRD 25
Paprock, K. E. (2006). National human resource development in transitioning societies in the
developing world: Introductory overview. Advances in developing human resources,
8(1), 12-27.
Schultz, Theodore W. Economic Value of Education. New York, NY: Columbia University
Press, 1963. Print.
Sjaastad, L. A. (1962). The costs and returns of human migration. The journal of political
economy, 70(5), 80-93.
Swanson, R. A., & Holton, E. F. (2009). Foundations of human resource development. San
Francisco CA: Berrett-Koehler Publishers.
Tevera, D. S., & Crush, J. (2003). The new brain drain from Zimbabwe. Southern African
Migration Project, 29. Retrieved from www.equinetafrica.org/bibl/docs/TEVrights.pdf
Troy, P. H., Wyness, L. A., & McAuliffe, E. (2007). Nurses experiences of recruitment and
migration from developing countries: A phenomenological approach. Human Resources
for Health, 5(15). doi:10.1186/1478-4491-5-15
Wang, G. G., & Holton, E. F. (2005). Neoclassical and institutional economics as foundations for
human resource development theory. Human Resource Development Review, 4(1), 86-
108.
Wilson, J. P. (2012). International human resource development: Learning, education and
training for individuals and organizations. Philadelphia PA: Kogan Page Limited.
Yin, R. K. (2009). Case study research: Design and methods (Vol. 5). Sage.