Download - Research Proposal d's
8/8/2019 Research Proposal d's
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/research-proposal-ds 1/29
[Type the document title] June 4, 2010
1
Contents:1. Introduction
1.1. Company background
1.2. Context
1.3. Strategic importance
1.4. Research objectives
2. Literature Review
2.1. International marketing strategy
2.2. Models
2.3. Conceptual Framework
3. Research Methodology
3.1. Research philosophies
3.1.1. Positivism
3.1.2. Interpretivism
3.1.3. Realism
3.2. Research approaches
3.3. Research strategies
3.4. Choices
3.5. Time horizons
3.6. Techniques and procedures
3.7. Triangulation, validity and reliability
4. Research design and limitations
8/8/2019 Research Proposal d's
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/research-proposal-ds 2/29
[Type the document title] June 4, 2010
2
5. Bibliography
International marketing strategy: expanding opportunities for Podravka on theUK market
1. Introduction
1.1. Company background
Podravka was founded in 1934 and with production of top-quality products of
recognizable brands today it is one of the leading companies of south-eastern,
middle and eastern Europe. It has three business segments: food, beverages and
pharmaceuticals. Their competitive advantage is high level of knowledge, especially
technological, constant innovation and investment in education, entrepreneurialism,
ambition, the winning spirit, team work and professionalism. Ha ving these attitudes
allows them to adjust successfully to the growing demands of the market, both
national and international. They find the loyalty of their customers to be their biggest
success. They are present in more than 40 countries throughout the world, withproduction plants in Croatia, the Czech Republic and Poland. The sales rates from
the international markets are 45% of the overall sales which shows the importance of
these markets for the company. Podravka¶s strategy on the European markets is
³realization of the leading position with the above -average growth rates´
(www.podravka.com).
They run business on the principles of sustainable growth and are continuously
increasing the company¶s value. They are concerned for t he environment
preservation therefore use less resources and make less waste. They are also
8/8/2019 Research Proposal d's
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/research-proposal-ds 3/29
[Type the document title] June 4, 2010
3
interested in progress of the society, community and their employees and offer them
support through their activities.
Podravka employs around 7000 people. They have recognised the creative,
enthusiastic and successful people are the key to their success , and therefore invest
in professional and personal development of their employees as well as funding
undergraduate and postgraduate stud y and offer internship program. Efficiency and
professionalism are rewarded. Podravka has its own management academy aiming
at ³development of long-term competitiveness and socially responsible engagement´
(www.podravka.com). They established a "prof. Zlata Bartl" Foundation and are
involved in supporting students, sponsorships and donation since they are interested
in the development of the entire society.
Podravka produces high quality, practical and safe products, adjusted to the national
cuisines, but with the specific local flavour. Podravka Brands are a result of long-time
tradition, knowledge and concern for the consumers' well -being. The products are
made from selected high quality raw material, using knowledge and modern
technological processes in order to preserve food nutrients. All products are labelled
in compliance with labelling regulations of Republic of Croatia, the European Union
as well as countries where company operates. Podravka has a management system
based on the following standards: ISO 9001 (Quality Management System), ISO
14001 (Environmental Management System), ISO 22 000 (Food Safety Management
System), OHSAS 18001 (Occupational Health & Safety Audit System), HACCP
(Hazard Analysis Critical Control Points) principles, as well as other standards and
regulations concerning the food industry and its markets (IFS - International Food
Standard, BRC - British Retail Consortium, NSF, Halal etc.). Business Quality
8/8/2019 Research Proposal d's
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/research-proposal-ds 4/29
[Type the document title] June 4, 2010
4
provides coordinated employee training in these areas at all level s. The systems are
regularly and permanently improving (www.podravka.com).
1.2. Context
Global and international companies find UK attractive for investment for various
reasons such as rapidly recovering economy, regulatory and legal system and the
return to growth. Podravka recognised that the UK has one of the fastest growing
food and drink markets in the world (UK Trade and investment, 2010). They have a
distributing partner in London and are present in the UK market with around 40
products in big chains such as ASDA, Tesco, Morrisons and a number of ethnic
shops. At the moment they are exporting and have no marketing activity in the UK.
The information about knowledge of the product or its existence in UK is passing by
word of mouth. From the author¶s own experience, Podravka products are not well
displayed therefore not visible nor easily found. Hence the interest of the author and
the question of the research: what would be the appropriate international marketing
strategy and what are the expanding opportunities for Podravka in the UK market?
The author is interested in Podravka¶s activities and success on the interna tional
markets, in this case in UK, because Podravka¶s main headquarters are situated in
the author¶s home town, and the company being a desirable employer offers good
career prospects. On the other hand, the question i s strategically important for
Podravka and they offered full support for doing this research since it will contribute
to making their decision on the strategy.
8/8/2019 Research Proposal d's
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/research-proposal-ds 5/29
[Type the document title] June 4, 2010
5
1.3. Strategic importance
The strategic intent is the direction in which the company goes to gain the long- term
strategic position (Morden, 2007). Podravka¶s intent is to be distinctive in terms of
understanding the customer needs, product brands and high quality products and
business processes. They are working towards their strategic goals such as
developing and innovating new products with added value, effective marketing
investments and further investment in employee development. Podravka has shown
interest in expanding their activities in UK in the nearby future, so the question of the
research is of strategic importance for the company since it may provide the
knowledge about the English market , identify the opportunities and help with
formulating the suitable strategy for expanding their activities on that market as well
as identify the resources needed, both product and human, to support these
activities.
1.4. Research Objectives:
The primary aim of the study is to identify the opportunities for Podravka to expand
its presence on the UK market. Objectives of the research include:
1. to identify expanding opportunities through market research and branding
2. economic viability of expanding strategy,
8/8/2019 Research Proposal d's
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/research-proposal-ds 6/29
[Type the document title] June 4, 2010
6
3. recommendations and choices available for international marketing strategy
2. Literature review
2.1. International marketing strategy
The companies operate in a complex and constantly changing technologic al and
competitive environment and in order to survive they need to adopt a dynamic,
flexible and cost effective international marketing strategy (Bradley, 2005).
³International marketing means ident ifying needs and wants of customers in different
markets and cultures, providing products, services, technologies and ideas to give
the firm a competitive marketing advantage, communicating information about these
products and services and distributing and exchanging them internationally through
one or a combination of foreign market entry modes (Bradley, 2005:3)´.
International companies must recognise the needs and demands of consumers in
many different markets, influenced by many different cultures and cope with existing
competition on each market they operate in. There are various opportunities and
competitive challenges in the open and integrated international markets for
companies looking for growth (Bradley, 2005) some of the challenges being high
investment cost, time, management team, restructuring, resource allocation,
coordination, human resources, diversity of cultures and market conditions. The
managers must be careful not to transfer successful strategies from domestic to
international market (Bradley, 2005). Business development strategy determines the
8/8/2019 Research Proposal d's
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/research-proposal-ds 7/29
[Type the document title] June 4, 2010
7
approach of the organisation to growth of business activity and it can be based on
alternative strategic choices such as cooperation, partnership, strategic alliances,
mergers, acquisitions, takeovers, franchising, licensing, direct investment,
divestment (entry modes). Partners are the most important in international markets.
There are two major schools of thought s in international marketing literature ;
standardisation and customisation concerning the issue of entering the new market
with the standardised product or contrary adjusting the existing products or
developing a new one for international market . Internationalisation literature mostly
favours standardisation because of the low costs, therefore competitive price, but it
is unlikely that markets are the same. Advantages of standardization are that people
who travel can find the same product with standard characteristics and quality which
contributes to company¶s reputation; the costs of production, research and
development, marketing, investment and trade barriers are reduced and quality
improved due to trained employees and technology. Disadvantages include the
product not being unique, therefore standardisation creates an opportuni ty for
competitors to enter the market with differentiated product to fit to the customer¶s
needs.
On the other hand, international marketing is defined as tailoring product or service,
communication, pricing and distribution for each market (McAuley, 2001 ) and
adaptation may be necessary to overcome certain trade barriers. Governments
recognise the relevance of international marketing which brings investment and
financial flow as well as new jobs, therefore open their economies to international
companies.
8/8/2019 Research Proposal d's
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/research-proposal-ds 8/29
[Type the document title] June 4, 2010
8
Ansoff¶s matrix is used to determine opportunities for business growth. It has two
dimensions; products and markets and four possible strategies: market penetration,
market development, product development, and diversification.
Source: Adopted from Ansoff (1965)
Knowledge of the market, product and customers is important source of
differentiation and it means focusing on elements of customers¶ buying decision
process (Bradley, 2005).
Brands are the key sources of product-market differentiation. A prerequisite to
establishing an effective product -market position is developing local knowledge of
what the enterprise is all about. Establish ing the presence is expensive and there
may be barriers as strong culture, loyalty, distribution systems, price, tax etc.
(Morden, 2007). The promotion strategy of the company should include the branding
strategy and identification of the communicating with target groups of customers.
Strategic marketing plan consists of defining corporate mission statement, value,
economic environment, business eco-system, competitors, customers, product
positioning, pricing strategy, distribution, promotion, speed and timing (Tvede and
Ohnemus, 2001). Cultural dimension influences marketing activities and there can
8/8/2019 Research Proposal d's
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/research-proposal-ds 9/29
[Type the document title] June 4, 2010
9
be national and corporate culture. The internationalisation literature suggests that
retailers will go for expansion into culturally close countries. Sensitivity to cultural
needs of the market is essential and the starting poi nt is understanding the customer
(McAuley, 2001). The most powerful way the companies respond to the trends in
international markets is the growth of brands (Bradley, 2005), brand being a product
hard to copy.
Food is bound with local culture and has low e conomies of scale and it is difficult to
establish global food brands. Global or at least international menu is emerging, but it
is difficult to predict the dynamic of change ± how quickly convergence will happen
and what the effect it will have on markete rs. There are also patterns of consumption
of food and trends to be considered (McAuley, 2001) and existing local brands may
be a barrier. Country of origin and the brand name are of great importance (Randall,
2000, McAuley, 2001).
Company's functional capabilities (marketing and operations) and diversification
strategies (product/service and international diversification) as well as efficient
integration of resources impact its financial performance (Nath et al, 2010).
Marketing capability and market driven strategies are the key to high financial
performance of the company as well as narrow portfolio of products and
concentration on divers international markets (Nath et al, 2010).
2.2. Models
SWOT is an acronym for Strengths, Weaknesses, Opportunities, and Threats. The
SWOT analysis is useful tool for strategy formulation by analysing internal and
external factors of the organisation. It generates strategic options (Johnson and
Scholes, 2006), but disadvantage is that analyses is compared to competitors and
8/8/2019 Research Proposal d's
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/research-proposal-ds 10/29
[Type the document title] June 4, 2010
10
two sides lead to opposite directions. Analysis of e xternal factors which cannot be
controlled is concerning industry or market, similar to Porter¶s five forces, or political,
economical, social, cultural, technical and legal factors which are elements of
PESTLE analysis.
Porter¶s five forces
Source: (Porter 2004)
Porter¶s five forces is model used to analyse the attractiveness of the industry. It
consists of five competitive forces: the threat of new entrants (how easy or difficult is
it for new entrants to start to compete, barriers such as licence to operate, safety
rules, a significant advantage, high costs, distribution channels, switching costs for
customers, product differentiation and brand loyalty, high capital and investment
requirements), the threat of substitutes (how easy can the product be substituted,
cheaper, how acceptable they are and their cost and propensity of customers), the
bargaining power of buyers (position and concentration of buyers, the impact on their
8/8/2019 Research Proposal d's
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/research-proposal-ds 11/29
[Type the document title] June 4, 2010
11
product, quality, the existence of substitutes, switching costs, information ), the
bargaining power of suppliers (position and concentration of sellers and potential
suppliers, monopoly, significance of the product, the volume of sales) and the rivalry
among the existing firms (competition, dominance or equality in strength/size,
concentration of existing firms, the maturity of the industry, the positioning of the
product and the product life cycle ) (Robson, 1997). It is frequently used tool but the
criticised that it was developed for analysing stable environment and based on the
idea of industry competition, therefore it may not be suitable for today¶s dynamic
environment, but can be used as a starting point and supplemented by other models.
PESTLE analysis provides a framework of six key areas for investigating and
analysing the external macro-environment that influence an organisation (Cadle et
al, 2010): political, economical, socio-cultural, technological, legal, environmen tal
factors. These factors are not controllable and may be considered as threats or
opportunities. This is useful tool for analysing a country and i s normally used in
creation of international strategy.
Marketing mix
Marketing Mix 4P's model was proposed by McCarthy in 1960. It is a widely used
tool for assessing the controllable variables in the environment, identifying the
customer needs, adjusting the product and establishing the brand image. It helps
with formulating a marketing strategy and maximize the performa nce of the
organisation. It is a combination of four elements: product, price, place and
promotion. Booms and Bitner extended the model to 7P¶s adding people, process
and physical evidence which help to gain knowledge about the environment.
8/8/2019 Research Proposal d's
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/research-proposal-ds 12/29
[Type the document title] June 4, 2010
12
Source: BBC Business studies: The marketing mix
2.3. Conceptual framework
The elements of models presented will be used for development of conceptual
framework because of the advantages they have, although know how, management
and marketing skills, speed and timing, culture, demand for and product familiarity
are some of the important factors identified in literature review , yet not covered in the
models. However, these factors may be assessed by analysing the strengths and
weaknesses of the company.
8/8/2019 Research Proposal d's
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/research-proposal-ds 13/29
[Type th e doc u en t tit e] June 4, 2010
13
Marketingmix
SWOT
Porter'sfive forces
PESTLE
ti f i i t ti l
ti t t , ii i ilit
8/8/2019 Research Proposal d's
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/research-proposal-ds 14/29
[Type the document title] June 4, 2010
14
The conceptual framework shows that previously described factors of Porter¶s five
forces, PESTLE, SWOT and Marketing mix will be analysed in the research. Porter¶s
five, Pestle and opportunities and threats followed by marketing mix are helpful for
market research, while strength and weaknesses asses internal factors of the
company. Marketing mix will also help with decisions on the branding strategy. All
together, the analysis will help to choose between standardisation and diversification
and appropriate mode of entry. This leads to and help with assessing the objectives
of the research stated in the introduction.
8/8/2019 Research Proposal d's
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/research-proposal-ds 16/29
[Type the document title] June 4, 2010
16
Source: Saunders et al (2007): The research µonion¶
This chapter will analyse various elements shown in the diagram and choose the
most appropriate ones for research design framework and answering the question of
the research.
8/8/2019 Research Proposal d's
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/research-proposal-ds 17/29
[Type the document title] June 4, 2010
17
3.1. Research philosophies
Three major ways of thinking in research philosophy are ontology, epistemology and
axiology.
Ontology is understanding of what is (theories of being and becoming) , and is
concerned with the nature of reality. The two aspects of ontology are objectivism and
subjectivism (Saunders et al, 2007).
O bjectivism
Social entities are external and exist independent of consciousness or experience
and research is finding objective, provable and repeatable facts. Positivism and to
some extent realism are closely related to this perspective (Gray, 2009).
S ubjectivism
The social phenomena are created from perceptions of the actor and it is a
continuous process of interaction and revision (Saunders et al, 2007). Reality exists,
but the nature of reality is determined by individual consciousness. It is necessary to
look at the details to understand the reality and it is often associated with social
constructionism.
C onstructionism
The meaning of the things is constructed or created by the experience and
interaction with realities. Interpretivism and to some extent realis m are related to this
perspective (Gray,2009). People will have different interpretations which affect their
interactions with the world.
8/8/2019 Research Proposal d's
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/research-proposal-ds 18/29
[Type the document title] June 4, 2010
18
Axi ology studies judgements about value (Saunders et al, 2007) and is concerned
with the role of the researcher¶s values in the research process.
Ep is temology is understanding of the meaning and acceptance of the knowledge,
and concerned with acceptable knowledge in the field. It is determined by what the
researcher thinks is important for the study; facts or opinions an d attitudes, hence
the positivist or interpretivist as well as the realist perspective.
There are three dominant views in business research on research philosophy, and
these are: positivism (objectivism), interpretivism (constructivism) and realism. The
terminology for research philosophy is inconsistent or sometimes contradictory
(Gray, 2009). Gray (2009) discusses the theoretical perspectives which are
positivism and interpretivism, realism being part of the later one. Saunders et al
(2007) discuss three philosophies: positivism, realism and interpretivism. Collis and
Hussey (2003) discuss positivism and phenomenology. Easterby -Smith et al (2008)
discuss positivism, relativism and social constructionism.
3.1.1. Positivism
Positivism is scientific, rather than philosophical, deals with facts, not values. It
argues that reality is what is observable, and can be measured through objective
methods. The findings are replicable, quantifiable, statistical and can be generalised.
On the other hand, they are limited beca use they do not discover the meaning of the
data. It is based on empirical experience and believe s that reality is what can be
proven because the world operates within laws and can be measured by empirical
study (Gray, 2009). It is often related to natural sciences such as physics, where
results can be measured and generalised. This approach ignores the subjective
8/8/2019 Research Proposal d's
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/research-proposal-ds 19/29
[Type the document title] June 4, 2010
19
state of an individual and sees the researcher as independent (Collis and Hussey,
2003).
3.1.2. Interpretivism (Social Constructionism)
Interpretivism includes symbolic interactionism, phenomenology, realism,
hermeneutics and naturalistic inquiry (Gray, 2009). This approach is based on rich
data therefore gives better insight into social processes. It recognises the complexity
of the reality. It is more suitable for business research since it is context specific. It is
the opposite perspective to positivism and is concerned with subjective aspects of
human behaviour, focusing on the meaning rather tha n measurement and was
developed as a result of criticism of positivism (Collis and Hussey, 2003) . However,
the data collection and analysis is long and difficult and findings are less reliable.
Contrasts of positivismand socialconstructionism
Positivism Socialconstructionism
The observer must be independent is part of what is beingobserved
Human interests should be irrelevant are the main drivers of scienceExplanations must demonstrate
causalityaim to increasegeneral understandingof the situation
Research progressesthrough
hypotheses anddeductions
gathering rich datafrom which ideas areinduced
Concepts need to be defined sothat they can bemeasured
should incorporatestakeholder perspectives
Units of analysis statistical probability may include thecomplexity of µwhole¶situations
Generalisation through statistical probability theoretical abstractionSampling requires large numbers
selectedrandomly
small numbers of cases chosen for specific reasons
Source: Adapted from Easterby-Smith et al (2008)
8/8/2019 Research Proposal d's
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/research-proposal-ds 20/29
[Type the document title] June 4, 2010
20
3.1.3. Realism
Realism accepts values of all data sources, enables generalisation, but requires
large samples (Easterby-Smith et al, 2008). The external reality is out there
independent of the observer and can be analyse d, but there are phenomena that
cannot be observed. Truth is relative. It is similar to positivism by scientific approach
to development of knowledge. There are two types of realism, direct and critical.
Direct explains that what you see is what you get, and what we experience is true;
and critical that what we experience is just senses and some things are merely
illusions or representation of the real (Saunders et al, 2007). The critical realism
acknowledges change and importance of multi -level study therefore it is much more
suitable for business and management re search. Esterby-Smith et al (2008) state
that realism is more about identifying what the reality is rather than discovering it.
Saunders et al (2007) state that business and management research is often a
mixture between positivist and interpretivist, ref lecting the realism approach.
Critical realism, having the characteristics of both positivism and interpretivism, is
identified as the best option to assess the research question stated in the
introduction.
3.2. Research approaches
Research approaches can be deductive or inductive. Deductive is proposing start
with working theory, design a research methodology, collect, analyse data and
agree/disagree with the original starting theory. It collects quantitative data and it is
closer to positivist perspective and does not have the alternative explanations nor
takes into the account that humans do not answer mechanist ically to certain
circumstances. It is testing the theoretical proposition by the research strategy
8/8/2019 Research Proposal d's
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/research-proposal-ds 21/29
[Type the document title] June 4, 2010
21
design to test it (Saunders et al, 2007). It is highly structured and sees researcher as
independent.
Inductive approach proposes start with an idea related to an aspect of a business
organisation, accumulate data, and theory testing in the end. Inductive approach
comes from social sciences. It gives the idea of what is really going on, that is the
nature of the problem. It collects qualitative data, recognises the researcher as a part
of the research process, but doesn¶t need to generalise the findings.
Deductive and inductive approaches are not mutually exclusive therefore it is
advisable to combine the two in the same work (Saunders et al, 2007), therefore a
combination of the inductive and deductive approach will be used for this r esearch.
3.3. Research strategies
Research strategies include experiment, survey, case study, action research,
grounded theory, ethnography and archival research.
Case study explores a situations, subjects and issues in the real context, where
relationships may be uncertain and they are usually deductive (Myers, 2009/10).
Types of case studies are single and multiple case design. The limitations of case
study are that it will only have the internal val idity therefore cannot be generalised,
reliability and replicability are questionable (Bryman and Bell, 2007) and they are
context-specific. A single case study will be used for this research because it is
based on a single company within a specific context.
Case study is usually associated with qualitative research, but both qualitative and
quantitative methods are used (Easterby-Smith, 2008).
8/8/2019 Research Proposal d's
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/research-proposal-ds 22/29
[Type the document title] June 4, 2010
22
Quantitative research is scientific, presented by numbers in tables and graphs, has
precise research design, hypotheses, definite sample and is related to positivist
approach. The advantages are that it is reliable and credible, can be measured and
easily analysed, is objective and well organised. Disadvantages are that the quality
of data depends on the methods used to collect the data and they can be
manipulated, there can be too much data, lack of interpretation, low validity. It is
most appropriate to positivist and deductive approach (Bryman and Bell, 2007;
Saunders et al, 2007).
Qualititive research deals with meaning, people understanding and behaviour. The
data is produced by researcher¶s interpretation. Advantages are that data are based
on reality, rich, in depth, detailed and focused, it acknowledges the possibility o f
contradiction and has tolerance of ambiguity. Disadvantages are that sample is
usually small therefore the data may not be representative, interpretation depends
on the researcher and may be subjective, findings are more experimental,
explanations may be oversimplified. It has high validity but low reliability and is most
appropriate to interpretivist and inductive approach (Bryman and Bell, 2007;
Saunders et al, 2007).
3.4. Choices
Choices include mono method, multi method and mixed methods. Mono-method is
using one method for the research; multi-methods is using of more than one data
collection and data analysis to answer the research question (Saunders et al, 2007).
Mixed methods as the third research paradigm is practical synthesis based on
qualitative and quantitative research and is likely to provide superior research
findings. (Burke Johnson et al, 2007). Mixing methods enables triangulation (Gray,
8/8/2019 Research Proposal d's
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/research-proposal-ds 23/29
[Type the document title] June 4, 2010
23
2009, Saunders et al, 2007) and ensures higher reliability and validity. Different
methods can be used for different purposes. They may be related to realist approach
and case study since they require various sources of data and that is the reason the
mixed methods will be used for this research and provide both qualitative and
quantitative results necessary for assessing the research objectives.
3.5. Time horizons
The research can be cross-sectional which takes place at one short period of time or
longitudinal which takes place over a longer period of time and requires two or more
points of measurements while resources and time are limited.
This research will be cross-sectional looking at a problem at one point in time. It is
usually short time, doesn¶t have large sample and therefore it is not representative.
The advantage of longitudinal study is that it can identify changes over time and is
more reliable.
3.6. Techniques and procedures
Techniques and procedures include data collection and data analyses. Data can be
collected through questionnaires, interviews, observations, sampling, documents,
journals, video recordings, secondary data and unobtrusive measures. There are two
types of primary data collection method; qualitative and quantitative (Hair et al,
2007).
Quantitative data is based on meanings derived from numbers, results are numerical
and standardised and analysis is shown in diagrams and statistics and is usually
gathered through questionnaires, observations and surveys. Qualitative data
8/8/2019 Research Proposal d's
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/research-proposal-ds 24/29
[Type the document title] June 4, 2010
24
meaning is expressed through words, results need to be classified in categories and
analysed by conceptualisation (Saunders et al, 2007).
I nterviews collect qualitative, reliable and valid data by asking questions about
opinions and feeling about the issue. They may depend on the order people are
interviewed, time consuming, have issues with recording and transcription but lead to
discovery and insight on the subject (Saunders et al, 2007) , in-depth and clear
answers. Interviews and questionnaires are associated with both positivist and
interpretivist approaches (Collis and Hussey, 2003). Interviews can be structured,
semi structured and non-directive, focus and informal.
Questionnaires are most widely used technique for data collection. It is a list of
questions, but it is very important how it is designed. Open ended questions are
recommended for gathering qualit ative data. Problems are also the respond rate or
careless responses to the questions, but they are efficient because they tak e less
time and offer anonymity to participants.
S econdary data is data collected from another researcher, and although highly
appreciated, valuable efficient and of high quality, they may be gathered for a
different purpose, old and not important or applicable for the specific context under
study.
The three techniques presented, interviews, questionnaires and secondary data
sources are chosen for the research and will enable triangulation.
Data analysis may be quantitative (statistics) or qualitative which includes choice of
analytical approach (Myers, 2009/10).
8/8/2019 Research Proposal d's
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/research-proposal-ds 25/29
[Type the document title] June 4, 2010
25
3.7. Triangulation, validity and reliability
Esterby-Smith et al (2008) define triangulation as the collection of data from different
sources or in different times. Triangulation helps to balance the potential strength s
and weaknesses of each method, reduces subjectivity and is accurate. It has a
positivist frame by showing single reality (Grey, 2009). Still, it includes both
quantitative and qualitative data to form sequential picture. Using interviews,
questionnaires and secondary data for this research will enable the triangulation
balancing their advantages and disadvantages, reducing subjectivity and increasing
validity and reliability. Validity is concerned whether the data as well as the methods
used to obtain the data are accurate and honest. Reliability is concerned with
consistency or repeatability of the measures used in the research. The threats to
reliability may be subject and/or observer error and/or bias (Saunders et al 2007).
4. Research design and l imitations
The design of this research will be following:
Philosophy chosen is critical realism, approach will be mainly inductive, but with
elements of deductive, therefore a combination of both, strategy chosen is single
case study, choices will be mixed methods, time will be cross-sectional, techniques
and procedures for data collection will be questionnaires, interviews and secondary
data which will enable the triangulation. The research design is chosen after
analysing the characteristics of various elements and , more important, the
relationships between them. This design seems appropriat e for assessing and
providing the answers to the research question and research objectives.
8/8/2019 Research Proposal d's
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/research-proposal-ds 26/29
[Type the document title] June 4, 2010
26
Limitations of the study may be the samples chosen to be interviewed and fill in the
questionnaires, sample size, composition, representativeness, access to key
respondents, threats to validity and reliability, managers may have their own agenda,
understanding the issue may be limited, people¶s views and how they interpret the
world around them, objectivity (will the research provide an accurate and fair picture
and conclusions?) and credibility (is there evidence and detail of how the data is
produced?). Results may be suggestive rather than conclusive.
In addition, in this particular case, the company under study has problems with
corruption among the top management and the chief executive. ³Last October police
arrested six top company executives, including the current and former chief
executives, suspecting they had been using company funds to buy its own shares,
aiming to take over the company´ (Reuters, 2010). The investigation about this has
wider meaning since stopping corruption is needed for progress of author¶s country
to enter the European Union. This is important since it may become a barrier to
collecting data inside the company. Also, the company may n eed to postpone or
even recede the expansion activity due to problems with compan y funds (if proven
they exist) and interest in the research as well as providing the necessary data may
reduce or disappear.
The language will probably not represent a limitat ion because all managers are
required to know and use English in performing their business duties, although it
may be uncomfortable to talk in a foreign language while the researcher and
themselves come from the same country and speak the same native language, and
they even may refuse to do so. Also, the language nuances and phrases and
expressions may be misinterpreted.
8/8/2019 Research Proposal d's
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/research-proposal-ds 27/29
[Type the document title] June 4, 2010
27
Outside the company, Randall (2000) identified a number of problems with market
research such as understanding and predicting customer¶s behaviour, decisions and
reactions; identifying the group of customers and their cultural believes . Furthermore,
the research technique may force the answer, therefore it may not represent the
reality. Market research tends to be reactive, may not turn out useful, since it may
get the same answers. The results may look impressive and the researcher may
believe in them, but not completely understand them. It is recommended to research
what can be measured reliably. There is also a cost associated with market
research.
Various limitations can come from the research design itself since it is chosen by the
researcher and depends on the researcher¶s ontological , epistemological and
axiological views.
Note: word count approximately 4887.
8/8/2019 Research Proposal d's
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/research-proposal-ds 28/29
[Type the document title] June 4, 2010
28
5. Bibliography
Ansoff, H.I. (1965) C orporate strategy . US: McGraw-Hill Inc.
BBC Business Studies: The marketing mix. [Online]. Available from: <http://www.bbc.co.uk/schools/gcsebitesize/business/marketing/marketingmixrev1.sht
ml> [Accessed 10 May 2010].
Bradley, F. (2005) I nternational marketing strategy. 5 th edition. PrenticeHall/Financial Times. Essex: Pearson Education Limited.
Bryman, A. and Bell, E. (2007). Business Research Methods. 2nd Edition.Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Burke Johnson, R., Onwuegbuzie, A.J. and Turner, L.A. (2007) Toward a definitionof mixed methods research. Journal of Mixed Methods Research , 1(2) pp.112-133.
Cadle, J., Paul, D. and Turner, P. (2010) Business Analysis Techniques: 72 Essential Tools for S uccess . Swindon: British Informatics Society Limited.
Collis, J. And Hussey, R. (2003) Business Research ± a practical guide for undergraduate and postgraduate students . 2 nd edition. Palgrave Macmillian.
Easterby-Smith, M., Thorpe, R. and Jackson, P.R. (2008) Management research . 3 rd edition. London: SAGE.
Gray, D.E. (2009) Doing Research in the real world . 2 nd edition. London: SAGE.
Hair, J.F., Money, A.H., Samouel, P. and Page, M. (2007) Research methods for business . Chichester: Wiley & Sons Ltd.
Johnson, G. and Scholes, K. (2006) Exploring C orporate S trategy, Text and C ases, 7th Edition, FT/Prentice Hall, Harlow.
Lynch, R. (2006) C orporate S trategy , 4th edition, Prentice Hall, FT .
McAuley, A. (2001) I nternational Marketing : C onsuming Globally, Thinking Locally .Chichester, West Sussex, New York: John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.
Morden, T. (2007) Principles of S trategic Management , 3rd edition, Hampshire: Ashgate Publishing Limited.
Myers, J. (2009/10) Research Methods Module Handouts. The University of Bolton.
Nath, P., Nachiappan, S. and Ramanathan, R. (2010) The impact of marketingcapability, operations capability and diversification strategy on performance: Aresource-based view. I ndustrial marketing management, 39(2) pp. 317-329.
Podravka: About the company. [Online]. Available from: <http://www.podravka.com/company/about-the-company> [Accessed 10 May 2010].
8/8/2019 Research Proposal d's
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/research-proposal-ds 29/29
[Type the document title] June 4, 2010
Porter, M.E., (2004) Competitive Advantage: Creating and Sustaining Superior Performance. New York: Free Press.
Randall, G. (2000) Branding : A Practical Guide to Planning Your S trategy . 2 nd edition. London; Dover, N.H. Kogan Page.
Reuters (2010) C roatia's Podravka Q1 profit up, sales inch down . [Online]. Availablefrom: < http://in.reuters.com/article/idINLDE63T1D720100430> [Accessed 13 May2010].
Robson, W. (1997) S trategic Management and I nformation S ystems . 2 nd edition.London: Pitman Publishing.
Saunders, M., Lewis, P. and Thornhill, A. (2007) Research Methods for BusinessS tudents. 4 th edition. Harlow: Pearson Education. Prentice Hall/Financial Times.
Theodosiou, M. And Leonidou, L.C. (2003) Standardization versus adaptation of international marketing strategy: an integrative assessment of the empiricalresearch. I nternational Business Review , 12 (2) pp.141-171.
Tvede, L. and Ohnemus, P. (2001) Marketing strategies for the new economy .Chichester: John Wiley and Sons, LTD.
UK Trade and Investment (2010) O verseas firms flock to UK [Online]. Available from:< http://www.ukinvest.gov.uk/United-Kingdom/110454/en-AU.html > [Accessed 3June 2010].
UK Trade and Investment (2010) UK food and drink sector opportunities [Online]. Available from: < http://www.ukinvest.gov.uk/Food-&-Drink/en-GB-list.html>
[Accessed 16 May 2010].