Transcript
Page 1: Ranging the GNSS Constellation - NASA...and Physical Geodesy • GNSS satellites are equipped with clocks of higher and higher stability. • As GNSS-derived satellite clock corrections

20th ILRS Workshop, Oct. 11, 2016

1

Institute for Astronomical

and Physical Geodesy

Institute for Astronomical

and Physical Geodesy

Ranging the GNSS Constellation

Urs Hugentobler

Technische Universität München, Germany

20th ILRS Workshop

Potsdam, October 11, 2016

Page 2: Ranging the GNSS Constellation - NASA...and Physical Geodesy • GNSS satellites are equipped with clocks of higher and higher stability. • As GNSS-derived satellite clock corrections

20th ILRS Workshop, Oct. 11, 2016

2

Institute for Astronomical

and Physical Geodesy

GPS SLR Residuals

Springer 2000

-6 cm

Page 3: Ranging the GNSS Constellation - NASA...and Physical Geodesy • GNSS satellites are equipped with clocks of higher and higher stability. • As GNSS-derived satellite clock corrections

20th ILRS Workshop, Oct. 11, 2016

• Earth albedo causes a radial GNSS orbit error of 1-2 cm

• Antenna thrust causes a radial orbit error at a level of 1 cm

Rodriguez et al., 2010

Influence of Earth Albedo

2 cm

3

Page 4: Ranging the GNSS Constellation - NASA...and Physical Geodesy • GNSS satellites are equipped with clocks of higher and higher stability. • As GNSS-derived satellite clock corrections

20th ILRS Workshop, Oct. 11, 2016

4

Institute for Astronomical

and Physical Geodesy

Improvements in Orbit Modeling and LRA Offsets

Urschl et al., 2007

Page 5: Ranging the GNSS Constellation - NASA...and Physical Geodesy • GNSS satellites are equipped with clocks of higher and higher stability. • As GNSS-derived satellite clock corrections

20th ILRS Workshop, Oct. 11, 2016

Flohrer et al., 2008

GPS SLR residuals in Sun-fixed reference frame, ROCK radiation pressure a

priori model.

SLR reveals significant systematic orbit errors

5

Page 6: Ranging the GNSS Constellation - NASA...and Physical Geodesy • GNSS satellites are equipped with clocks of higher and higher stability. • As GNSS-derived satellite clock corrections

20th ILRS Workshop, Oct. 11, 2016

6

Institute for Astronomical

and Physical Geodesy

SLR bias below 1 cm for IGS CODE reprocessed orbits

Current GPS SLR residuals

Page 7: Ranging the GNSS Constellation - NASA...and Physical Geodesy • GNSS satellites are equipped with clocks of higher and higher stability. • As GNSS-derived satellite clock corrections

20th ILRS Workshop, Oct. 11, 2016

7

Institute for Astronomical

and Physical Geodesy

What about new GNSS constellations?

Montenbruck et al. 2013

Montenbruck et al. 2013

Page 8: Ranging the GNSS Constellation - NASA...and Physical Geodesy • GNSS satellites are equipped with clocks of higher and higher stability. • As GNSS-derived satellite clock corrections

20th ILRS Workshop, Oct. 11, 2016

8

SLR Residuals of Galileo IOV Satellites

Institute for Astronomical

and Physical Geodesy

Montenbruck et al. 2015

Page 9: Ranging the GNSS Constellation - NASA...and Physical Geodesy • GNSS satellites are equipped with clocks of higher and higher stability. • As GNSS-derived satellite clock corrections

20th ILRS Workshop, Oct. 11, 2016

9

Institute for Astronomical

and Physical Geodesy

Cause: different shape of satellites

Page 10: Ranging the GNSS Constellation - NASA...and Physical Geodesy • GNSS satellites are equipped with clocks of higher and higher stability. • As GNSS-derived satellite clock corrections

20th ILRS Workshop, Oct. 11, 2016

10

Institute for Astronomical

and Physical Geodesy

Galileo SLR residuals

Page 11: Ranging the GNSS Constellation - NASA...and Physical Geodesy • GNSS satellites are equipped with clocks of higher and higher stability. • As GNSS-derived satellite clock corrections

20th ILRS Workshop, Oct. 11, 2016

11

Institute for Astronomical

and Physical Geodesy

old and new model… Inga

Galileo SLR residuals

Page 12: Ranging the GNSS Constellation - NASA...and Physical Geodesy • GNSS satellites are equipped with clocks of higher and higher stability. • As GNSS-derived satellite clock corrections

20th ILRS Workshop, Oct. 11, 2016

12

Institute for Astronomical

and Physical Geodesy

New ECOM2 radiation pressure model

IGS MGEX project: http://mgex.igs.org/analysis/slrres.php

Galileo SLR residuals

Classical ECOM radiation pressure model

Page 13: Ranging the GNSS Constellation - NASA...and Physical Geodesy • GNSS satellites are equipped with clocks of higher and higher stability. • As GNSS-derived satellite clock corrections

20th ILRS Workshop, Oct. 11, 2016

13

Institute for Astronomical

and Physical Geodesy

• SLR ranging to GPS and GLONASS has a long history. Independent orbit

validation helped to improve orbit models.

• Radiation pressure modelling crucially depends on details of satellite

structure and surface properties.

• SLR to satellites of the new GNSS constellations and satellites on new orbit

types thus plays an essential role for calibrating such models.

• For GEO the determination of satellite longitude with GNSS tracking data is

highly susceptible to biases. SLR can play an important role.

• For IRNSS satellites currently SLR are the only public tracking data allowing

the determination of precise orbits.

Conclusions 1

Page 14: Ranging the GNSS Constellation - NASA...and Physical Geodesy • GNSS satellites are equipped with clocks of higher and higher stability. • As GNSS-derived satellite clock corrections

20th ILRS Workshop, Oct. 11, 2016

14

Monitoring of Satellite Clock Behaviour

Institute for Astronomical

and Physical Geodesy

Page 15: Ranging the GNSS Constellation - NASA...and Physical Geodesy • GNSS satellites are equipped with clocks of higher and higher stability. • As GNSS-derived satellite clock corrections

20th ILRS Workshop, Oct. 11, 2016

15

Institute for Astronomical

and Physical Geodesy

Gravitational Redshift

E11

a = 29‘600 km

e = 0.00002

i = 55.4°

E14/18

a = 27980 km

e = 0.15725

i = 50.0°

Page 16: Ranging the GNSS Constellation - NASA...and Physical Geodesy • GNSS satellites are equipped with clocks of higher and higher stability. • As GNSS-derived satellite clock corrections

20th ILRS Workshop, Oct. 11, 2016

16

Institute for Astronomical

and Physical Geodesy

• SLR as tool for high precision time synchronization of stable GNSS clocks

combining Laser one-way with two-way, similar to ELT concept.

• Convince ESA for Galileo.

Laser Time Transfer to Galileo

ESA

Page 17: Ranging the GNSS Constellation - NASA...and Physical Geodesy • GNSS satellites are equipped with clocks of higher and higher stability. • As GNSS-derived satellite clock corrections

20th ILRS Workshop, Oct. 11, 2016

17

Institute for Astronomical

and Physical Geodesy

• GNSS satellites are equipped with clocks of higher and higher stability.

• As GNSS-derived satellite clock corrections are highly correlated with radial

orbit errors.

• SLR thus plays an important role to separate temperature-induced

variations of the apparent satellite clocks from orbit errors and to

characterize the physical behavior of the clocks.

• This is also crucial for improving the determination of the gravitational

redshift parameter α beyond Gravity Probe A using the clocks onboard the

two Galileo satellites misplaced to eccentric orbits (Delva et al., 2015).

• It is time that SLR time synchronization of GNSS clocks plays a more

important role.

Conclusions 2

Page 18: Ranging the GNSS Constellation - NASA...and Physical Geodesy • GNSS satellites are equipped with clocks of higher and higher stability. • As GNSS-derived satellite clock corrections

20th ILRS Workshop, Oct. 11, 2016

Institute for Astronomical

and Physical Geodesy 18 18

GPS GLONASS Galileo BeiDou

GNSS is expanding

• Soon more than 100 satellites in the sky

• All equipped with SLR reflectors (GPS beginning with Block III SV-9)

Page 19: Ranging the GNSS Constellation - NASA...and Physical Geodesy • GNSS satellites are equipped with clocks of higher and higher stability. • As GNSS-derived satellite clock corrections

20th ILRS Workshop, Oct. 11, 2016

19

Institute for Astronomical

and Physical Geodesy

• GNSS constellation is expanding, and in future all satellites will be equipped

with SLR reflectors.

• How to observe GNSS satellites with SLR to derive precise orbits?

• Covariance analysis with simulated SLR observations from

– 1, 6, and 17 SLR stations,

– three sets of normal points, at 30° elevation rising, culmination if

elevation above 60°, and at 30° elevation setting,

– or one set of normal points per station at high elevation,

– of full 24-satellite Galileo constellation.

• Good weather situation, observations of stations uncoordinated.

Simple Simulation

Page 20: Ranging the GNSS Constellation - NASA...and Physical Geodesy • GNSS satellites are equipped with clocks of higher and higher stability. • As GNSS-derived satellite clock corrections

20th ILRS Workshop, Oct. 11, 2016

20

Simulation: 1 SLR Station

Institute for Astronomical

and Physical Geodesy

Page 21: Ranging the GNSS Constellation - NASA...and Physical Geodesy • GNSS satellites are equipped with clocks of higher and higher stability. • As GNSS-derived satellite clock corrections

20th ILRS Workshop, Oct. 11, 2016

21

Institute for Astronomical

and Physical Geodesy

Simulation: 6 SLR Station

Page 22: Ranging the GNSS Constellation - NASA...and Physical Geodesy • GNSS satellites are equipped with clocks of higher and higher stability. • As GNSS-derived satellite clock corrections

20th ILRS Workshop, Oct. 11, 2016

22

Institute for Astronomical

and Physical Geodesy

Simulation: 17 SLR Station

Page 23: Ranging the GNSS Constellation - NASA...and Physical Geodesy • GNSS satellites are equipped with clocks of higher and higher stability. • As GNSS-derived satellite clock corrections

20th ILRS Workshop, Oct. 11, 2016

23

Range of E01 for one SLR Station

Institute for Astronomical

and Physical Geodesy

Page 24: Ranging the GNSS Constellation - NASA...and Physical Geodesy • GNSS satellites are equipped with clocks of higher and higher stability. • As GNSS-derived satellite clock corrections

20th ILRS Workshop, Oct. 11, 2016

24

Institute for Astronomical

and Physical Geodesy

Ranges of all Galileo Satellites for one SLR Station

Page 25: Ranging the GNSS Constellation - NASA...and Physical Geodesy • GNSS satellites are equipped with clocks of higher and higher stability. • As GNSS-derived satellite clock corrections

20th ILRS Workshop, Oct. 11, 2016

25

Simulated SLR Observations: E=30°, Culmination

Institute for Astronomical

and Physical Geodesy

Page 26: Ranging the GNSS Constellation - NASA...and Physical Geodesy • GNSS satellites are equipped with clocks of higher and higher stability. • As GNSS-derived satellite clock corrections

20th ILRS Workshop, Oct. 11, 2016

26

Institute for Astronomical

and Physical Geodesy

Simulated SLR Observations: E=30°, Culmination

Page 27: Ranging the GNSS Constellation - NASA...and Physical Geodesy • GNSS satellites are equipped with clocks of higher and higher stability. • As GNSS-derived satellite clock corrections

20th ILRS Workshop, Oct. 11, 2016

27

Simulated SLR Observations: 1 Station, 1 Day

Institute for Astronomical

and Physical Geodesy

1 sta 1 day

Page 28: Ranging the GNSS Constellation - NASA...and Physical Geodesy • GNSS satellites are equipped with clocks of higher and higher stability. • As GNSS-derived satellite clock corrections

20th ILRS Workshop, Oct. 11, 2016

28

Institute for Astronomical

and Physical Geodesy

1 sta 1 day

Simulated SLR Observations: 1 Station, 1 Day

Page 29: Ranging the GNSS Constellation - NASA...and Physical Geodesy • GNSS satellites are equipped with clocks of higher and higher stability. • As GNSS-derived satellite clock corrections

20th ILRS Workshop, Oct. 11, 2016

29

Institute for Astronomical

and Physical Geodesy

1 sta 1 day

Simulated SLR Observations: 1 Station, 1 Day

Page 30: Ranging the GNSS Constellation - NASA...and Physical Geodesy • GNSS satellites are equipped with clocks of higher and higher stability. • As GNSS-derived satellite clock corrections

20th ILRS Workshop, Oct. 11, 2016

30

Institute for Astronomical

and Physical Geodesy

1 sta 1 day

Simulated SLR Observations: 1 Station, 1 Day

Page 31: Ranging the GNSS Constellation - NASA...and Physical Geodesy • GNSS satellites are equipped with clocks of higher and higher stability. • As GNSS-derived satellite clock corrections

20th ILRS Workshop, Oct. 11, 2016

31

Institute for Astronomical

and Physical Geodesy

1 sta 3 day

Simulated SLR Observations: 1 Station, 3 Days

Page 32: Ranging the GNSS Constellation - NASA...and Physical Geodesy • GNSS satellites are equipped with clocks of higher and higher stability. • As GNSS-derived satellite clock corrections

20th ILRS Workshop, Oct. 11, 2016

32

Institute for Astronomical

and Physical Geodesy

6 sta 1 day

Simulated SLR Observations: 6 Stations, 1 Day

Page 33: Ranging the GNSS Constellation - NASA...and Physical Geodesy • GNSS satellites are equipped with clocks of higher and higher stability. • As GNSS-derived satellite clock corrections

20th ILRS Workshop, Oct. 11, 2016

33

Institute for Astronomical

and Physical Geodesy

6 sta 3 day

Simulated SLR Observations: 6 Stations, 3 Days

Page 34: Ranging the GNSS Constellation - NASA...and Physical Geodesy • GNSS satellites are equipped with clocks of higher and higher stability. • As GNSS-derived satellite clock corrections

20th ILRS Workshop, Oct. 11, 2016

34

Institute for Astronomical

and Physical Geodesy

17 sta 1 day

Simulated SLR Observations: 17 Stations, 1 Day

Page 35: Ranging the GNSS Constellation - NASA...and Physical Geodesy • GNSS satellites are equipped with clocks of higher and higher stability. • As GNSS-derived satellite clock corrections

20th ILRS Workshop, Oct. 11, 2016

35

Institute for Astronomical

and Physical Geodesy

17 sta 3 day

Simulated SLR Observations: 17 Stations, 3 Days

Page 36: Ranging the GNSS Constellation - NASA...and Physical Geodesy • GNSS satellites are equipped with clocks of higher and higher stability. • As GNSS-derived satellite clock corrections

20th ILRS Workshop, Oct. 11, 2016

36

Institute for Astronomical

and Physical Geodesy

Formal Orbit Errors: 1 Station, 1 Day

Page 37: Ranging the GNSS Constellation - NASA...and Physical Geodesy • GNSS satellites are equipped with clocks of higher and higher stability. • As GNSS-derived satellite clock corrections

20th ILRS Workshop, Oct. 11, 2016

37

Institute for Astronomical

and Physical Geodesy

Formal Orbit Errors: 1 Station, 3 Days

Page 38: Ranging the GNSS Constellation - NASA...and Physical Geodesy • GNSS satellites are equipped with clocks of higher and higher stability. • As GNSS-derived satellite clock corrections

20th ILRS Workshop, Oct. 11, 2016

38

Institute for Astronomical

and Physical Geodesy

Formal Orbit Errors: 6 Stations, 1 Day

Page 39: Ranging the GNSS Constellation - NASA...and Physical Geodesy • GNSS satellites are equipped with clocks of higher and higher stability. • As GNSS-derived satellite clock corrections

20th ILRS Workshop, Oct. 11, 2016

39

Institute for Astronomical

and Physical Geodesy

Formal Orbit Errors: 6 Stations, 3 Day

Page 40: Ranging the GNSS Constellation - NASA...and Physical Geodesy • GNSS satellites are equipped with clocks of higher and higher stability. • As GNSS-derived satellite clock corrections

20th ILRS Workshop, Oct. 11, 2016

40

Institute for Astronomical

and Physical Geodesy

Formal Orbit Errors: 6 Stations, 1 Day, Culminations

Page 41: Ranging the GNSS Constellation - NASA...and Physical Geodesy • GNSS satellites are equipped with clocks of higher and higher stability. • As GNSS-derived satellite clock corrections

20th ILRS Workshop, Oct. 11, 2016

41

Institute for Astronomical

and Physical Geodesy

Formal Orbit Errors: 6 Stations, 3 Days, Culminations

Page 42: Ranging the GNSS Constellation - NASA...and Physical Geodesy • GNSS satellites are equipped with clocks of higher and higher stability. • As GNSS-derived satellite clock corrections

20th ILRS Workshop, Oct. 11, 2016

42

Institute for Astronomical

and Physical Geodesy

Formal Orbit Errors: 17 Stations, 1 Day

Page 43: Ranging the GNSS Constellation - NASA...and Physical Geodesy • GNSS satellites are equipped with clocks of higher and higher stability. • As GNSS-derived satellite clock corrections

20th ILRS Workshop, Oct. 11, 2016

43

Institute for Astronomical

and Physical Geodesy

Formal Orbit Errors: 17 Stations, 3 Days

Page 44: Ranging the GNSS Constellation - NASA...and Physical Geodesy • GNSS satellites are equipped with clocks of higher and higher stability. • As GNSS-derived satellite clock corrections

20th ILRS Workshop, Oct. 11, 2016

44

Institute for Astronomical

and Physical Geodesy

• Simple simulations demonstrate the capability of precise orbit determination

for GNSS satellites using a limited number of observations per station.

• Coordination of the observations between the stations is crucial to make

economic use of the observing system.

• Eventually SLR observations should not only be used for orbit validation but

combined with GNSS observations for determining precise orbits.

Conclusions 3

Page 45: Ranging the GNSS Constellation - NASA...and Physical Geodesy • GNSS satellites are equipped with clocks of higher and higher stability. • As GNSS-derived satellite clock corrections

20th ILRS Workshop, Oct. 11, 2016

45

Institute for Astronomical

and Physical Geodesy

Space Geodetic Techniques

SLR

GNSS

DORIS

VLBI

Page 46: Ranging the GNSS Constellation - NASA...and Physical Geodesy • GNSS satellites are equipped with clocks of higher and higher stability. • As GNSS-derived satellite clock corrections

20th ILRS Workshop, Oct. 11, 2016

46

Institute for Astronomical

and Physical Geodesy

Space Geodetic Techniques

SLR

GNSS

DORIS

VLBI

Page 47: Ranging the GNSS Constellation - NASA...and Physical Geodesy • GNSS satellites are equipped with clocks of higher and higher stability. • As GNSS-derived satellite clock corrections

20th ILRS Workshop, Oct. 11, 2016

47

Institute for Astronomical

and Physical Geodesy

Space Geodetic Techniques

SLR

GNSS

DORIS

VLBI

Page 48: Ranging the GNSS Constellation - NASA...and Physical Geodesy • GNSS satellites are equipped with clocks of higher and higher stability. • As GNSS-derived satellite clock corrections

20th ILRS Workshop, Oct. 11, 2016

48

Institute for Astronomical

and Physical Geodesy

• SLR plays an important role since decades for validating GNSS derived

satellite orbits.

• For new GNSS constellations and new orbit types SLR proves to be

essential to calibrate new radiation pressure models.

• SLR allows to separate orbit- and temperature-induced variations of stable

onboard GNSS clocks.

• Eventually the role of SLR becomes even more important by contributing to

precise orbit determination of GNSS satellites.

• Coordination of the observation schedule between stations is crucial to

optimize the benefit-to-cost ratio.

• Integration of GNSS and SLR observations for precise product generation

has to be forced in the context of GGOS.

Conclusions

Page 49: Ranging the GNSS Constellation - NASA...and Physical Geodesy • GNSS satellites are equipped with clocks of higher and higher stability. • As GNSS-derived satellite clock corrections

20th ILRS Workshop, Oct. 11, 2016

49

Institute for Astronomical

and Physical Geodesy

• For validation and calibration of radiation pressure models?

– one satellite block for a range of Sun-beta angles, i.e., one satellite

block per orbital plane

– good coverage along the orbit

• For determination of gravitational redshift parameter using Galileo E14/E18:

– good coverage of orbits of both satellites (as long as clock running on

H-maser)

• For BeiDou GEO satellites:

– coverage of all satellites

• For contributing to precise orbit products combined with GNSS

– coverage of full constellation

– coordination of observation schedule among SLR stations

How to track GNSS?

Page 50: Ranging the GNSS Constellation - NASA...and Physical Geodesy • GNSS satellites are equipped with clocks of higher and higher stability. • As GNSS-derived satellite clock corrections

20th ILRS Workshop, Oct. 11, 2016

Many thanks for

your attention!


Top Related