![Page 1: MIGRANT DEATHS IN SOUTH TEXAS · History of Migrant Deaths in South Texas South Texas has a long history of migrant deaths, corresponding to changes in U.S. immigration and labor](https://reader034.vdocuments.site/reader034/viewer/2022042916/5f554b7ff9302370d4404924/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
MAY 2020
MIGRANT DEATHS IN SOUTH TEXAS
STEPHANIE LEUTERT, SAM LEE, & VICTORIA ROSSI
![Page 2: MIGRANT DEATHS IN SOUTH TEXAS · History of Migrant Deaths in South Texas South Texas has a long history of migrant deaths, corresponding to changes in U.S. immigration and labor](https://reader034.vdocuments.site/reader034/viewer/2022042916/5f554b7ff9302370d4404924/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
1
TableofContents
ExecutiveSummary 2
MigrantDeathsinSouthTexas 3
HistoryofMigrantDeathsinSouthTexas 6
Methodology 8
DataLimitations 11
MigrantDeathCauses 12
MigrantDeathLocationsandDemographicsinSouthTexas 18
MigrantDeathProcessing 23
CostsofMigrantDeaths 31
RecommendationsandBestPractices 33
Appendix 37
Endnotes 44
![Page 3: MIGRANT DEATHS IN SOUTH TEXAS · History of Migrant Deaths in South Texas South Texas has a long history of migrant deaths, corresponding to changes in U.S. immigration and labor](https://reader034.vdocuments.site/reader034/viewer/2022042916/5f554b7ff9302370d4404924/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
2
ExecutiveSummaryFormorethanacentury,migrantshavediedinSouthTexaswhileattemptingtoentertheUnitedStates.ThedeathratehasebbedandflowedalongwithshiftsinU.S.immigrationandlaborpolicies,aslaborprogramscreatelegalpathwaysandmorerestrictiveborderenforcementpoliciespushtransitingmigrantsintoincreasinglyremoteareas.Yetthroughallthechanges,migrantdeathshaveneverceased.Overthelast22years,morethan3,253peoplehavelosttheirlivesattemptingtoentertheUnitedStatesinSouthTexas.Today,moremigrantsdieinSouthTexasthananywhereelseinthecountry.ThisreportbuildsonpreviousresearchrelatedtomigrantdeathsinSouthTexas.Itseekstoanswerthreequestions:1)WherearemigrantsdyinginSouthTexas?2)Whoaretheseindividuals?and3)Howdolocalagenciesdocumentandprocessthedeathsofpeoplewhocrossedtheborderwithoutauthorization?Toanswerthesequestions,theresearcherscreatedanoriginaldatasetcompiledfromrecordsreceivedthroughfieldvisitsandpublicinformationrequestsandaddedinadditionalmigrantdeathdatasetswhenpossible.Thereportalsoreliesoninterviewswithlocallawenforcement,justicesofthepeace,medicalexaminersandpathologists,forensicanthropologists,funeralhomes,consulates,andcivilsocietyorganizations,amongothers.Intotal,thereportcollected2,655casesofmigrantdeathsinSouthTexasfrom1990to2020andanadditional615casesofmigrantswhodrownedintheRioGrandebutwhosebodieswashedupontheMexicanshore.Thisdatabasedocumented12and30moremigrantdeathsthantheBorderPatrol’sofficialcountforfiscalyears2018and2019,respectively.Additionally,noneofthedrowningcaseswherethevictimendedupinMexicoareincludedintheBorderPatrol’snumbers.ThismeansthatBorderPatroldataalmostcertainlyunderstatesthetruescopeofmigrantdeathsinSouthTexas,especiallysincethehundredsofRioGrandedrowningdeathsareleftoutofthetotals.Thereportalsooutlinesdeceasedmigrants’causeofdeath,discoverylocations,anddemographics.Forthelasttwoyears,WebbCountyhasreportedthemostmigrantdeaths,butmigrantshavediedineverySouthTexascounty.Historically,thosedyingintheRioGrandeorTexasranchlandswereprimarilyMexicanmen.However,since2012,thenumberofCentralAmericansbothmigratinganddyingintheregionhasincreased,representingabouthalfofalldeathswherenationalitycouldbedetermined.Womenalsomadeupasignificantportionofthedead.In2013,womencomprisedalmostaquarterofallcaseswhereasexcouldbedetermined.County-levelofficials,whooftenworkinsomeofthepoorestareasinthestate,areresponsibleforprocessingmigrantdeathsandpayingforanyrelatedcosts.Arangeofactors,includingsheriffs’offices,justicesofthepeace,funeralhomes,medicalexaminers,forensiclabs,andconsulatesallplayaroleindocumentingthedeaths,requestingautopsiesandinvestigativetests,transportingthebodies,andsubmittingDNAsamples.Thisreportestimatesthatthesecostscanreachmorethan$13,100perdeceasedindividual,withcountiespayingroughly$2,000onaveragejusttoremovetheremainsfromthesceneandobtainanautopsy.Thisreportconcludeswithrecommendationsforstreamliningmigrantdeathprocessingthroughimprovedrecordkeeping,mandatedinvestigativetestingandDNAsamples,andincreasedstatefunding.
![Page 4: MIGRANT DEATHS IN SOUTH TEXAS · History of Migrant Deaths in South Texas South Texas has a long history of migrant deaths, corresponding to changes in U.S. immigration and labor](https://reader034.vdocuments.site/reader034/viewer/2022042916/5f554b7ff9302370d4404924/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
3
MigrantDeathsinSouthTexasInSouthTexas,theRioGrandeformstheborderwiththeMexicanstatesofTamaulipas,NuevoLeón,andCoahuila.Theriverslicesthroughwetlandsandsanddunes,rowsofpalmtreesandscragglymesquites.Theevolvingecosystemsmakeforadynamicandserenelandscape,buttheycanalsoprovedangerousandevendeadlyformigrantswhoswimtheriverorhiketheSouthTexasbackcountryinthehopesofenteringtheUnitedStatesundetected.Overthelast22years,theU.S.BorderPatrolhascounted3,253migrantdeathsinSouthTexas,definedinthisreportasthecountiesclosesttotheborderintheRioGrandeValley,Laredo,andDelRioBorderPatrolSectors.
Map1:CountiesCoveredintheReportbyBorderPatrolSectors
Source:U.S.BorderPatrol
ThesedeathsincludeindividualswhodrownedintheRioGrandeandthosewhodiedfromheatexhaustion,dehydration,orhypothermiaonTexasranches.However,thisnumberisundoubtedlyanundercount.First,somemigrantremainsmayneverbediscovered.Second,individualswhodrownintheRioGrandeandwhosebodieswashupontheMexicanriverbank—asopposedtotheUnitedStates’shore—arenotcountedinthesenumbers.Whilethird,localofficialsincertaincountiesmaynotalwayscallBorderPatroltoalertthemofamigrant’sdeath.
![Page 5: MIGRANT DEATHS IN SOUTH TEXAS · History of Migrant Deaths in South Texas South Texas has a long history of migrant deaths, corresponding to changes in U.S. immigration and labor](https://reader034.vdocuments.site/reader034/viewer/2022042916/5f554b7ff9302370d4404924/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
4
Graph1:BorderPatrol’sCountofMigrantDeathsinSouthTexasbyEnforcementSector(1998-2019)
Source:U.S.BorderPatrol
UnlikeotherareasoftheU.S.-Mexicoborder,suchasArizonaandCalifornia,migrantsinSouthTexasareoftenmovingthroughprivateland.a1Thishasseveralimportantimplicationsformigrantdeaths.First,civilsocietygroups—primarilytheSouthTexasHumanRightsCenter—mustnegotiatewithprivaterancherstowalkmigranttrails,leavewaterformigrants,orconductgridsearchesforhumanremains.Second,researchersstudyingthephenomenoncannotphysicallyaccessthelandwheremigrantsaredyingwithoutlocalgovernmentorrancherconnections.Third,mediaattentionisalsolimited,especiallysincemanyranchersprefernottopublicizethedeathsthatoccurontheirlandandmigrants'bodiesarewhiskedawaytolocalfuneralhomesortheWebbCountyMedicalExaminer’sOfficewithaslittlepublicityaspossible.ThesedifferenceshaveobscuredthescopeofmigrantdeathsinSouthTexas.MigrantdeathshavebeenbestdocumentedintheTucsonBorderPatrolSector.ThroughbookssuchasDevil’sHighway:ATrueStorybyLuisAlbertoUrreaandTheLandofOpenGravesbyJasondeLeón,thetragicstoriesofmigrantdeathsintheSonoranDeserthavebeensharedaroundtheworld.Whilehigh-profilegroupssuchasNoMoreDeaths,whichleaveswateralongmigrantroutes,havealsocontinuouslyraisedawarenessoftheissues.However,since2012,migrantdeathsinSouthTexashavesurpasseddeathsintheTucsonBorderPatrolSector.By2019,thenumberofdeathsinSouthTexaswasthreetimesmorethanintheArizonadesert.Yet,therehasbeenfarlessdocumentationoftheseindividuals’deaths.
aTexasis96percentprivateland.
![Page 6: MIGRANT DEATHS IN SOUTH TEXAS · History of Migrant Deaths in South Texas South Texas has a long history of migrant deaths, corresponding to changes in U.S. immigration and labor](https://reader034.vdocuments.site/reader034/viewer/2022042916/5f554b7ff9302370d4404924/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
5
Graph2:MigrantDeathsinSouthTexasandTucsonBorderPatrolSectors(1998-2019)
Source:U.S.BorderPatrol
ThisreportexpandsonpreviousresearchrelatedtomigrantdeathsinSouthTexastoincludemigrants’demographicinformationandtrendsinmigrantdeathsovertime.Usinganoriginaldataset,itaimstoidentifydemographicinformationaboutthemigrants,wherethedeathshaveoccurred,andhighlightdeathsthattheBorderPatroldoesnotcount.Additionally,thereportalsodetailsSouthTexas’county-levelstructuresforprocessingmigrantdeaths.ItexaminestherolesandresponsibilitiesfortheBorderPatrol,locallawenforcement,justicesofthepeace,medicalexaminersandpathologists,forensicanthropologists,funeralhomes,andconsulates.
![Page 7: MIGRANT DEATHS IN SOUTH TEXAS · History of Migrant Deaths in South Texas South Texas has a long history of migrant deaths, corresponding to changes in U.S. immigration and labor](https://reader034.vdocuments.site/reader034/viewer/2022042916/5f554b7ff9302370d4404924/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
6
HistoryofMigrantDeathsinSouthTexasSouthTexashasalonghistoryofmigrantdeaths,correspondingtochangesinU.S.immigrationandlaborpoliciesandborderenforcement.Overthepastcentury,changesinU.S.policyshapedthewaysthatMexicansandothermigrantsfromaroundtheworldenteredtheUnitedStatesandtransitedthroughSouthTexas.ThefirstrestrictionsonMexicanmigrationattheU.S.-Mexicoborderdatebackto1917,whentheU.S.governmentestablishedaliteracytestanda$8.00headtaxforMexicanlaborersenteringtheUnitedStates.Toavoidtheseregulations,MexicansenteringSouthTexastoworkonfarmsorrailroadsbegantowadeorswimacrosstheRioGrande,insteadofwalkingacrosstheinternationalbridges,exposingthemtotheriver’sswiftanddangerouscurrents.b2In1942,theU.S.governmentrespondedtoWorldWarIIlaborshortagesbyestablishingtheBraceroProgramandwelcomingMexicanlabortoU.S.agriculturalfields.LawmakersinitiallyexcludedTexasfromtheagreement,afterfarmownersrejectedtheprogramandlobbiedtoweakenitsprovisions.c3Yet,inthefollowingyears,hundredsofthousandsofMexicanscontinuedtocrosstheRioGrandewithoutdocumentstoworkonTexasfarms.In1952,Texasfarmownerssucceededinformalizingthisarrangement,gettinga“TexasProviso”writtenintotheImmigrationandNationalityAct(INA).ThisProvisoclaimedthat“employing”anillegalworkerwasnotthesameas“harboring”theworker.Thismeantthatfarmownerscouldknowinglyhireindividualswithoutdocumentsandavoidsanctions,butworkerswouldstillhavetosneakintothestatetoreachthefarms.Duringthisperiod,MexicanlaborerscontinuedtoenterintoSouthTexaswithoutdocumentsandattempttoevadetheBorderPatrol,oftenwithdeadlyconsequences.AJuly1949NewYorkTimesarticlenotedthatapproximatelyoneMexicandrownedintheRioGrandeeveryday.4Additionally,duringthelate1940sandearly1950s,theBorderPatrolsetuphighwaycheckpointslocated10to75milesintotheUnitedStates.5ThesecheckpointspushedMexicanlaborersofftheroadsandontoremotepaths,wheretheyfacedexposuretothearidlandscapeandextremetemperatures.Bythelate1950s,TexasbeganacceptingBraceroworkersinashiftthatlastedroughlyadecade.ThismeantthatsomelaborerscouldobtainlegalpaperstoentertheUnitedStatesandpassthroughofficialportsofentry.However,otherindividualscontinuedtoenterTexaswithoutdocumentsiftheycouldnotjointheBraceroProgramoriftheydidnotwanttoaccepttheprogram’slowwages.6TheBraceroProgramendedin1964,buthundredsofthousandsofMexicanscontinuedtocometotheUnitedStatesforseasonalagriculturalandranchingjobs.Onceagain,therewerenolegalpathwaystoworkintheUnitedStates,leadinglaborerstocrosstheriverandhikethroughranchlandstoreachtheirdestinations.7Inthelate1980sand1990s,U.S.policiesshiftedtheimmigrationlandscape.In1986,theImmigrationReformandControlAct(IRCA)legalized3millionimmigrantswhohadarrivedinthecountrypriortoJanuary1,1982.8ItalsoremovedtheTexasProvisoandincreasedBorderPatrolfunding.WhilesomeindividualsreceivedlegaldocumentsunderIRCA,otherswerenoteligibletoregularizetheirstatusandcontinuedtravelingbackandforthacrosstheborder.In1996,theU.S.CongresspassedtheIllegalImmigrationReformandImmigrantResponsibilityAct(IIRIRA),whichtookamorepunitiveapproachtounauthorizedimmigration.9Itincreasedthetypesofcrimesthatmadeanindividualeligiblefordeportation,added5,000BorderPatrolagentsoverthefollowingfiveyears,requiredadditionalborderfencing,andincreasedthecriminalpenaltiesforirregularentryandsmuggling.
bByoneaccount,75percentofMexicansbegantocomeillegallyaftertheheadtaximposition.cMexicanofficialsalsobalkedathavingtheirworkerssenttoTexas,giventhenotoriouslybadconditions.
![Page 8: MIGRANT DEATHS IN SOUTH TEXAS · History of Migrant Deaths in South Texas South Texas has a long history of migrant deaths, corresponding to changes in U.S. immigration and labor](https://reader034.vdocuments.site/reader034/viewer/2022042916/5f554b7ff9302370d4404924/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
7
ThetougherapproachwenthandinhandwithanewseriesofBorderPatrolstrategies.InSeptember1993,theBorderPatrolbegan“OperationBlockade”inElPaso,withagentsstationedinlargenumbersontheRioGrande’sbanktocreateahumanwall.TheeffortsstoppedpeoplefromcrossingthroughElPaso’sdowntown,andtheBorderPatrolhailedtheoperationasasuccess.Asaresult,theBorderPatrolformalizedthisenforcementmethodinits1994SouthwestBorderStrategyandexpandeditacrosstheborder.10In1997,theBorderPatroladoptedthisapproachinSouthTexasin“OperationRioGrandeValley.”Alongtheborder,strategicallyplacedborderfencingincitydowntownsalsoreinforcedtheseoperations.YetwhiletheBorderPatrol’soperationsandfencingreducedthenumberofpeoplecrossingthroughU.S.bordercities,itledtoanewphenomenon:migrantsbegantocrossalongcityoutskirtsorinmoreremoteareas.Asthisenforcementshiftfunneledmigrantsintomoredesolateandruggedmigrationpaths,migrantdeathnumbersbegantotickupwards.In1999,researchersattheUniversityofHouston,theUniversidaddeMonterrey,andtheUniversityofCalifornia,LosAngelescountedmorethan1,600possiblemigrantfatalitiesalongtheborderbetween1993and1997.d11Theseresearchersnoticedanincreaseinthenumberofdeathsfromhyperthermia,hypothermia,anddehydrationasmigrantsbeganhikingthroughmoreremoteareas.Aroundthistime,MexicancrossersalsobegantostayintheUnitedStatesforlongerperiodsoftimeinordertoavoidre-crossingtheincreasinglydangerousandwell-monitoredborder.Inthelate1990s,theBorderPatrolstartedtocountthedeaths.In1998,theBorderPatrolbegantheBorderSafetyInitiative(BSI)tocollectinformationonmigrantdeaths,advertisethedangersassociatedwithcrossingtheborder,anderectrescuebeaconsintheTucsonSector.Soonafter,in2000,theBorderPatrolcreatedtheBorderSafetyInitiativeTrackingSystem(BSITS)asthemainrepositoryfordatacollectedonbordercrossingdeathsandrescues.e12Yeta2006GovernmentAccountabilityOffice(GAO)reportfoundinconsistenciesintheBorderPatrol’ssystemfortrackingandrecordingmigrantdeaths.13TheBorderPatrolhasalsotakenadditionalstepstoaddressmigrantdeaths.In1998,theBorderPatrolcreateditsSearch,Trauma,andRescueteam(BORSTAR)toassistinsearchandrescueoperations.Whilein2015,theBorderPatrolbeganitsMissingMigrantProgram,whichisanoutgrowthoftheBorderSafetyInitiative.Itprovidesthreetypesofassistance:1)BorderPatroldatabasesearchesformissingmigrants;2)searchandrescue;and3)remainsrecovery.TheMissingMigrantProgramalsoplacessignsinSpanishthroughoutSouthTexas’ranchlandandbeaconswithhigh-intensitybluelights.Yet,evenwiththeseefforts,hundredsofmigrantscontinuetodieinSouthTexaseachyearandofficialnumberscontinuetounderstatethefullscopeofmigrantdeaths.f14
dDuringthe1990s,anestimated50to75migrantsdiedinSouthTexaseachyear,accordingtoa2006GovernmentAccountabilityOffice(GAO)report.eTheBorderPatroldefinedamigrantdeathas:“Aborder-relateddeathisdefinedasasuspected,undocumentedmigrant:1)whileinfurtheranceofanillegalentry;2)withinadesignatedtargetzonewhetherornottheBorderPatrolwasdirectlyinvolved;and/or3)outsidethedesignatedtargetzonewhentheBorderPatrolhasdirectinvolvementwiththeincident.”fIn2018,CNNjournalistBobOrteganotedaBorderPatrolundercountofmorethan560migrantdeathsovertheprevious16years.
![Page 9: MIGRANT DEATHS IN SOUTH TEXAS · History of Migrant Deaths in South Texas South Texas has a long history of migrant deaths, corresponding to changes in U.S. immigration and labor](https://reader034.vdocuments.site/reader034/viewer/2022042916/5f554b7ff9302370d4404924/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
8
MethodologyThispaperusesamixedmethodologytoanswerthreebroadquestionsrelatedtomigrantdeathsinSouthTexas.Thefirstquestionlooksatcounty-leveladministrativeprocesses,asking:HowdolocalagenciesprocessanddocumentthedeathsofindividualswhoattemptedtoentertheUnitedStateswithoutauthorization?Theothertwoquestionsfocusonthedeathsthemselves,asking:WherearemigrantsdyinginSouthTexasandwhoaretheseindividuals?Theanswerstothesethreequestionsareintertwined,asunderstandingcounty-levelprocessesprovidesinsightsregardingthedataavailableforidentifyingdeathlocationsandthedeceased’sdemographicinformation.Toanswerthefirstquestion—regardinghowlocalagenciesprocessanddocumentmigrantdeaths—thereport’sresearchersreliedonTexasstatute,existingliterature,andsemi-structuredinterviews.Inparticular,theresearchersconductedinterviewswithsheriffs’officesin15counties,andinterviewswithjusticesofthepeace,citypolicedepartments,firedepartments,funeralhomes,medicalexaminers,andforensicanthropologists,amongothers.Theseinterviewsclarifiedeachcounty’sspecificprocessesforaddressingmigrantdeathswithintheirjurisdiction.Theyalsohelpedtoidentifyeachagency’sformofmigrantdeathdocumentation.Toanswerthisreport’ssecondandthirdquestionsondeathlocationsanddemographics,theresearcherscreatedanoriginaldataset.Theprimarydatasourcesweresheriffs’officeincidentreportsandjusticeofthepeaceinquestforms,whichwereobtainedthroughrecordsrequestsandsitevisits.gTheresearchersfiledpublicandjudicialrecordsrequestswithauthoritiesin19SouthTexascounties.hInresponsetotheserequests,officialsfromsevencountiesreturneddataofvaryingdetail.iTosupplementthisdata,researcherstraveledtonineSouthTexascountiestomeetwithlocalofficialsandreviewavailablefiles.jResearchersinputinformationfromthefilesintoaspreadsheetcontaining58variables,whichdocumentedthegeographiclocationofthehumanremains,thediscoveringparty,belongings,anddemographicinformation.Throughthesedatacollectionmethods,thereport’sresearchersdocumented1,696casesofmigrantdeathsinSouthTexasfrom1990to2020.SeeAppendixBfortherecords’sourcesandAppendixCforthenumbersofrecordsobtainedbycounty.Eventually,thisdatasetwaspareddownintoaspreadsheetwith21variablesandsupplementedwithotherdatasources.TheseadditionalsourcesincludedTexasVitalStatisticsdataforunidentifiedbodies(January1990toMarch2019),TexasTransnationalIntelligenceCenterdata(January2017toSeptember2019)fordeathslinkedtotransnationalcriminalgroups,Mexico’sMinistryofForeignRelationsdata(2000to2008and2004to2019)onMexicancitizenswhodiedwhileattemptingtoentertheUnitedStates,andtheInternationalOrganizationforMigration’s
gResearcherssoughtautopsyrecordsfrommedicalexaminers’officesandincidentreportnarrativesfromsheriffs’offices,bothofwhicharepublicrecordundertheTexasPublicInformationAct.Researchersalsosoughtjusticeofthepeaceinquestrecords,whichareopentothepublicpertheTexasRulesofJudicialAdministration.hResearchersrequestedrecordsfromauthoritiesinCameron,Dimmit,Duval,Edwards,Hidalgo,JimHogg,Kenedy,Kinney,Kleberg,LaSalle,Maverick,Starr,Uvalde,ValVerde,Webb,Willacy,Zapata,andZavalacounties.ResearchersdidnotsubmitapublicrecordsrequesttoBrooksCountybecausethesheriffhadalreadyprovidedresearcherswiththecountydata.iSheriffs’officesfromHidalgo,Kleberg,Starr,Webb,Cameron,LaSalle,andZapatacountiesprovidedrecordsthroughmailoremail.Formoreinformation,seeAppendixC.jResearchersreviewedfilesin-personinBrooks,Duval,Edwards,JimHogg,Kenedy,Kinney,Maverick,ValVerde,andUvaldecounties.TheonsetofCOVID-19inearlyMarch2020meantthattheresearcherscouldnotcompletetheirsitevisitstoofficialsinCameronCounty,DimmitCounty,MaverickCounty,andWebbCounty.
![Page 10: MIGRANT DEATHS IN SOUTH TEXAS · History of Migrant Deaths in South Texas South Texas has a long history of migrant deaths, corresponding to changes in U.S. immigration and labor](https://reader034.vdocuments.site/reader034/viewer/2022042916/5f554b7ff9302370d4404924/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
9
(IOM)MissingMigrantsProjectdata(2014to2020).kTheresearchersaddedthissupplementaldatatothecounty-leveldatasetonlyifitwasclearthatitdidnotduplicateanyexistingrecords.lWiththeseadditionalsources,thetotaldatasetincreasedto2,655migrantdeathscasesinSouthTexasfrom1990to2020.Whilethedatacollectedspanned30years,thefollowingsectionsofthisreportwillonlyexaminemigrantdeathsfrom2012to2019,givensporadicdataavailabilitybeforethistimeperiod.Fortheseeightyears,thedatasetincludes1,519migrantdeathsinSouthTexas.Thedatasetcontainsmorethan100casesforeachyearfrom16counties.mWhilethequalityofthedatavariedbysource,itwaspossibletodeterminethedecedent’scountyofdeathineverycase,thedecedent’ssexin59percentofthecases,theindividual’snationalityin40percentofthecases,andtheexactagein23percentofthecases.
Graph3:MigrantDeathsbyYearintheDataset(2012-2019)
Source:ReportDataset
However,thedatasetisincomplete.ItismissinginformationfromZavalaandWillacycountiesandhasincompleteinformationfromHidalgo,Starr,ValVerde,andLaSallecounties.Therearealsoadditionalreasonstosuspectthedataisincomplete,whicharedetailedinthefollowingsection.Yet,eventhisincompletedatasetcomprises93percentofthedeathsreportedbytheBorderPatrol
kTheTexasVitalStatisticsUnitdeclinedtoprovidemoredatafortheprojectbecausedeathcertificatesdonotcontaininformationaboutdecedent’slegalstatusintheUnitedStates.TheBorderPatrolprovidedonlyaggregatemigrantdeathcountsbysectorinresponsetoaFreedomofInformationActrequest.InitsJanuary2020response,theagencystateditdoesnotcollect“muchof”thedemographicinformationrequestedbyresearchers,includingnationality,becausemigrantsmaycarryfalseidentification.BorderPatrolalsostatedthatitdoesnotrecordtheGPSoraddresslocationofmigrantdeaths.lForrecordsthatlackedaspecificdate,theresearchersdidnotincludethesupplementaldataiftheyear,date,andcauseofdeathwerethesame.Thismethodologymayhaveresultedinanundercount.mEdwardsandWillacyCountydidnotreportanymigrantdeathsfortheseyears,norweretheyrecordedinanyotherdataset.ZavalaCountydidnotrespondtotherecordsrequest,butnomigrantdeathswererecordedinthecountyviaothersources.
![Page 11: MIGRANT DEATHS IN SOUTH TEXAS · History of Migrant Deaths in South Texas South Texas has a long history of migrant deaths, corresponding to changes in U.S. immigration and labor](https://reader034.vdocuments.site/reader034/viewer/2022042916/5f554b7ff9302370d4404924/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
10
initsDelRio,Laredo,andRioGrandeValleysectorsfortheseyears.nItalsorecords12and30moremigrantdeathsthantheBorderPatrolforfiscalyears2018and2019,respectively.
Graph4:ReportDatasetComparedtoBorderPatrolData(FiscalYears2012-2019)
WebbCountydatawasonlyreportedbycalendaryearandisincludedinitscorrespondingyear.
Source:ReportDatasetandBorderPatrolData
WhilethisreportfocusedonSouthTexas,theresearchersalsocreatedadatasetonmigrantdrowningdeathswhenbodieswashedupontheMexicansideoftheRioGrande.ThisdatasetincludedrecordsrequestsreceivedfromTamaulipas’PublicMinistry(ProcuraduríaGeneraldeTamaulipas);Coahuila’sPublicMinistry(FiscalíaGeneraldelEstadodeCoahuila);themunicipalgovernmentofReynosa,Tamaulipas;CivilProtection(ProtecciónCivil)inMatamoros,Tamaulipas;CivilProtectioninJiménez,Coahuila;andMexico’sMinistryofForeignRelations.Whennotduplicative,thedatasetwassupplementedwithcasesfromIOM’sMissingMigrantProject.Intotal,theresearcherscollected615casesofdrowningdeathsinMexico,with378casesfrom2012to2019.TheBorderPatroldoesnotcountthesedeathsinitsofficialnumbers.
nTheBorderPatrolreported1,647deathsduringtheseyears.
![Page 12: MIGRANT DEATHS IN SOUTH TEXAS · History of Migrant Deaths in South Texas South Texas has a long history of migrant deaths, corresponding to changes in U.S. immigration and labor](https://reader034.vdocuments.site/reader034/viewer/2022042916/5f554b7ff9302370d4404924/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
11
DataLimitationsThemostfundamentalchallengeforthisreport’sdatasetwasdeterminingwhofitintothetargetpopulation:unauthorizedmigrantsintransitthroughSouthTexas.Whilesomedeathsappearedtobeaclearfit,othersdidnot.Toensurethatnon-migrantswerenotincludedinthecount,theresearchersdesignedafour-prongedapproachtoansweringthisquestion:1)adecedenthadtobefoundalongknownmigrationroutes;2)theplaceofbirthandresidencywasnotintheUnitedStates;3)thedecedenthadtolackaU.S.socialsecuritynumberontheirdeathcertificate;and4)thedecedent’scauseofdeathhadtobeconsistentwithtransitmigrationanduncommonforindividualsnotintransit(suchasdehydration,heatstroke,orhypothermia).Forunidentifiedremains,theresearchersreliedmoreheavilyonmeetingthefirstandfourthcriteria.Indrawingthesedistinctions,itispossiblethatthisreport’sdatasetisanundercountofmigrantdeathsinSouthTexas.Forexample,thisreportdidnotincludeindividualsretrievedfromtheRioGrandewhosebodiesshowedsignsoffoulplay(e.g.gunshotwounds),giventhatorganizedcriminalgroupsmaythrowtheirvictims’bodiesintotheriver.However,itispossiblethatsomeoftheseindividualsmayhaveinfactbeeninthetargetpopulation,sincecriminalgroupsinMexicoalsovictimizemigrants.Additionally,thereportdoesnotincludeindividualswhodiedinhospitals,unlessthecasehadapolicereportstatingthatthedecedentwasamigrantintransitthroughSouthTexas.Thiswasbecauseitwasoftenimpossibletodetermineifthedeceasedwasintransitorsomeoneinthecommunitywithoutlegalstatus.Asecondfundamentalchallengewasobtainingthedeathrecordsfromcountyauthorities.Manysheriffs’officesandjusticesofthepeacefulfilledrecordsrequestsorpreparedrecordsforvisits.However,otherswereunwillingtofilltherequests.Theircitedreasonsgenerallystemmedfromtheamountofworkthatitwouldtaketopullsuspectedmigrantdeathrecordsfromthefiles.Somesheriffs’officerecordclerksalsostatedthattheircomputersoftwaresystemswouldnotallowthemtosearchfordigitalrecordswithouttheexactdateofanincidentorthenameofadecedent.oFinally,othersheriffs’officesandjusticesofthepeacealsoreportedthattheirfileswereinaccessibleinoff-sitestoragefacilities.However,evenwhentheresearcherswereabletoobtaintherecords,theirquantityandqualityvariedwidely.Eachcountyprovideddataforadifferentsetofyears,andsomecountieshadlargegapsintheirrecords.Somerecordsincludedcomprehensiveinformationwithdetailedreports,autopsyrecords,GPScoordinates,andphotosofthescene.Othersincludedonlythedateandcauseofdeath.Thisdisparityinavailabledatalimitedtheresearchers’abilitytodetermineexactlywhereindividualsweredyinginSouthTexas,theirdemographicinformation,andtrendsovertime.Duetothesechallenges,thereport'sdataisincompleteandunstandardizedacrosstimeandspace.Thefollowingsections’findingsshouldbeinterpretedinlightoftheselimitations.
oSomesheriffs’officesreportedhavinglostaccesstoearlierdigitalrecordsaftertransitioningtonewdatamanagementsystems,whichwereoftennecessaryadditionsinlightofnewstatecrimereportingrequirements.Privatecompaniesdigitallystoredtheseearlierfilesandwouldchargesheriffs’officestoaccesstheserecords—acosttheycouldnotafford.
![Page 13: MIGRANT DEATHS IN SOUTH TEXAS · History of Migrant Deaths in South Texas South Texas has a long history of migrant deaths, corresponding to changes in U.S. immigration and labor](https://reader034.vdocuments.site/reader034/viewer/2022042916/5f554b7ff9302370d4404924/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
12
MigrantDeathCausesMigrantsattemptingtoentertheUnitedStatesfacevariousrisksatdifferentpartsofthejourney.TheserisksincludeswimmingacrosstheRioGrande,exposuretoSouthTexastemperatures,suffocationrisksinsidevehicletrunksorcrowdedtrailers,andcarcrashesassmugglersattempttoevadetheBorderPatrolorlocallawenforcement.EachcountyhasauniqueriskprofileformigrantsenteringtheUnitedStates,dependingonthegeographicterrain,distancefromtheborder,andnearbyBorderPatrolcheckpoints.Similarly,eachunauthorizedmigrationmethodalsohasitsownriskprofile,includingforpeoplewalkingingroupsthroughthebrush,packingintovehicles,orattemptingtocrossintotheUnitedStates’interiorwithoutasmuggler.Drowning(UnitedStates).ToenterSouthTexasbetweenportsofentry,migrantsmustcrosstheRioGrande.TheRioGrande’sheadwatersbeginintheColoradoRockyMountains,buttheriverflowssouthfromthere,crossingNewMexicotoreachElPasoandthenformingtheU.S.-MexicobordertotheGulfofMexico.InitswindingpaththroughSouthTexas,theRioGrandepasseseightSouthTexascounties—ValVerde,Kinney,Maverick,Webb,Zapata,Starr,Hidalgo,andCameron—andborderstheMexicanstatesofCoahuila,NuevoLéon,andTamaulipas.Atsomepointstheriverisshallowenoughtoeasilywadeorwalkacross.Inotherareas,theriverrushesby,withundercurrentsmovingbelowthesurfaceatmorethan25milesanhour.Thelatterscenarioisfrequentlythecaseduringrainyseasonsorafterwaterisreleasedfromanearbydam.
Map2:SouthTexasBorderCountiesAlongtheRioGrande
Source:AuthorElaboration
![Page 14: MIGRANT DEATHS IN SOUTH TEXAS · History of Migrant Deaths in South Texas South Texas has a long history of migrant deaths, corresponding to changes in U.S. immigration and labor](https://reader034.vdocuments.site/reader034/viewer/2022042916/5f554b7ff9302370d4404924/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
13
Mexican-basedcriminalgroupssmuggledrugs,people,andothercontrabandintotheUnitedStatesacrosstheRioGrande.Thesegroupscontrolswathsoftheborder,especiallyintheareasfromMatamorostoPiedrasNegras.Inthesezones,migrantsmustobtainpermissiontocrosstheriverandpayarequiredfee.Thesmugglersgenerallymanagethispaymentlogisticsformigrantstheyareguiding,butmigrantstravelingwithoutguidesalsoneedtopay.Tocrosstheriver,peoplemaywadeorswimacrossorfloatoveroninnertubesorrafts.Aftercrossingtheriver,asylum-seekingmigrantswillseekouttheBorderPatroltorequesthumanitarianprotection.WhileindividualslookingtoevadetheBorderPatrolwillheadtonearbysafehousesbeforecontinuingtheirjourneys.CrossingtheRioGranderiverisdangerous,andthousandsofmen,women,andchildrenhavediedinitsdeceptivecurrents.Thisreport’sdatasetlists246drowningcasesfrom2012to2019,whichisanundercountsinceWebbandStarrcountydatadidnotlistmigrants’causeofdeathandCameroncountydatawasincomplete.Yet,fromtheavailabledata,138individualsdrownedinHidalgoCountyand72inMaverickCounty.TherewerelowernumbersofdrowningdeathsinCameronCounty,ZapataCounty,ValVerdeCounty,andKinneyCounty.Additionally,oneHonduranmandrownedwhilecrossingacreekinKlebergCountyafterheavyrainsraisedthewaterlevel.Drowning(Mexico).WhilethisreportfocusedondeathsinSouthTexas,severalofthedatasourcesdocumentedRioGrandedrowningdeathswherethebodieswashedupontheMexicanshore.pUsingthesedatasourcesandadditionalrecordsrequests,theresearchersdocumented378casesfrom2012to2019,whereanindividualdrownedintheriverbutdriftedintoMexicanterritory.ThesedeathsoccurredalongthelengthoftheTexas-Mexicoborder,withthelargestnumbersofbodiesrecoveredinReynosa(102),NuevoLaredo(96),Matamoros(55),andPiedrasNegras(38).
pThesedeathswereincludedintheIOMMissingMigrantdataandMexico’sMinistryForeignRelationsdata.
![Page 15: MIGRANT DEATHS IN SOUTH TEXAS · History of Migrant Deaths in South Texas South Texas has a long history of migrant deaths, corresponding to changes in U.S. immigration and labor](https://reader034.vdocuments.site/reader034/viewer/2022042916/5f554b7ff9302370d4404924/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
14
Map3:MigrantDrowningDeathsbyMexicanBorderCity(2012-2019)
Source:ReportDataset
NoneofthesecasesareincludedinBorderPatrolorU.S.county-leveldatasets.Instead,MexicanauthoritiesprocessthebodiesandMexicanstatepublicministrieskeepthetalliesoftheseindividuals.Thesedrowningdeathsincludesomeofthemosthigh-profilemigrantdeathcasesinrecentyears.InJune2019,forexample,thephotooftheSalvadoranfatheranddaughterandtheirintertwined,semi-submergedbodiesdrewoutrageandmourningaroundtheworld.Yet,sincetheirbodieswashedupontheMatamorosshoreoftheRioGrandeinsteadofacrosstheriverinBrownsville,Texas,thesetwoindividualsarenotincludedinanyU.S.datasetonmigrantdeaths.ExposuretotheElements.OncemigrantsenterU.S.territory,theyfaceadditionalrisks.ThisisespeciallythecaseformigrantslookingtocontinuebeyondtheBorderPatrol’s100-milejurisdiction,sincetheywillthenhavetopassBorderPatrolcheckpoints.Sincethe1950s,theBorderPatrolhassetupcheckpointsonnorth-boundhighwaysinTexas.BorderPatrolagentsstationedatthesecheckpointsaskpassengersiftheyareU.S.citizensandapprehendindividualswhoareattemptingtoentertheUnitedStates’interiorwithouttheappropriatemigratorydocuments.qCurrentlythereare13permanentBorderPatrolcheckpointsinSouthTexasinValVerde,Uvalde,Maverick,Dimmit,Webb,JimHogg,Brooks,Kenedy,andCameroncounties.
qFromOctober2018throughAugust2019,BorderPatrolagentsatcheckpointsinSouthTexasdetained5,801people.Thisnumbermayincludeindividualstravelingthroughthecheckpointswhoarenotmigrants
![Page 16: MIGRANT DEATHS IN SOUTH TEXAS · History of Migrant Deaths in South Texas South Texas has a long history of migrant deaths, corresponding to changes in U.S. immigration and labor](https://reader034.vdocuments.site/reader034/viewer/2022042916/5f554b7ff9302370d4404924/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
15
Map4:BorderPatrolCheckpointsinSouthTexas
Source:AuthorElaboration
MigrantsmustpassthesecheckpointsundetectedtoreachtheU.S.interior.Somemigrantsattempttopassthroughthecheckpointsincartrunksortrailers,orcircumventthecheckpointsinthesurroundingranchland.Inthislatterstrategy,acardropsoffaguideandagroupofmigrantsatapredeterminedpointbeforethehighwaycheckpoint.ThegroupthenhikesnorththroughtheTexasranchland,sometimesfollowingpipelinesorelectricitylinestoguidetheirway.Themigrantsbringbackpacksfulloffoodandcarrygallonsofwater.Oncethegroupreachesapredeterminedpointnorthofthecheckpoint—generallyafterseveraldays—carspulloverandpickthemup.ThegroupthendrivesnorthonmajorhighwaystoSanAntonioorHouston.Duringthisjourneymigrantsmaybeexposedtoextremetemperatures,causingbothhyperthermiaandhypothermia,ortheymayrunoutofwater.SomeindividualssetoutintotheTexassummerheatwithonlyagallonofwater,whichisbarelyenoughforoneday,letalonefortheentiretrip.Thismeansthattheymuststopandfilltheirjugswithwaterthattheyfindalongtheway.Iftheycannotobtainenoughwaterfromlivestockwatertanksorothersources,somemigrantscanbecomedehydratedanddie.Thereisalsothepotentialforexhaustion,injury,andcontactwithwildanimalssuchasrattlesnakes.Migrantswhobecomelostorseparatedfromtheirgrouprunanevenhigherriskofdeathorinjury.
intransit,includingundocumentedimmigrantslivingintheregionorpeoplewithexpiredimmigrationdocuments.
![Page 17: MIGRANT DEATHS IN SOUTH TEXAS · History of Migrant Deaths in South Texas South Texas has a long history of migrant deaths, corresponding to changes in U.S. immigration and labor](https://reader034.vdocuments.site/reader034/viewer/2022042916/5f554b7ff9302370d4404924/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
16
Variousfactorsmayworsenamigrant’sabilitytosurvivethisjourney.Onefactorisclothing.Manyindividualsprefertousedark-coloredshirts,sweaters,andjeanssincetheybelieveitallowsthemtobetteravoidBorderPatroldetection.However,thedarkcolorsalsoabsorbtheSouthTexassunandmaycontributetooverheating.Additionally,manymigrantswearclothingthatisillsuitedforlongwalksinroughterrain,includingstretchy,non-breathablepants,dressshoes,andflimsyboots.Asecondfactorthatcanworsenamigrant'sabilitytosurviveistheterrainitself.InBrooksCounty—whichhasreportedthemostmigrantdeathsinSouthTexasfrom2012to2019—thelandissandyandtheremayevenbesanddunesinthebrush.Thistypeofterrainismorechallengingforindividualswhoarewalkingfordaysandmayquicklyleadtoexhaustion.Bycomparison,othercountieshaveflatter,harderlandthatismoreconducivetolongtreks.VehicleDangers.Migrantsalsofacearangeofdangersassociatedwithbeingsmuggledinvehiclesorendingupintheirpath.First,individualswhoaresmuggledintheU.S.interiorwithintrailers,cartrunks,orothersmallspaces,facetheriskofsuffocationorintenseheatexposure,especiallyifthereisinsufficientventilationoriftheyareleftforlongperiodsoftime.InDecember2017,a24-year-oldmanfromMexicoattemptedtoentertheUnitedStates’interiorinatrailer.BeforearrivingattheFalfurriasBorderPatrolcheckpoint,heslippedintoasmallenclosedspaceunderthedriver’ssleepingcompartment.Whenthedriverandanotherpassengerwerepulledoutofthetruckforquestioning,themanremainedinthespace,ultimatelysuffocatingtodeath.Inthiscase,theBrooksCountySheriff’sOfficewastheactorresponsibleforremovingtheman’sbodyfromthecompartment.However,ifanindividualdiesinacartrunkwhilebeingsmugglednorth,thedrivermayleavethebodyalongsidetheroad.Vehicleaccidentsposeanadditionaldanger.WhenlawenforcementorBorderPatrolagentssuspectthatavehicleisengagedinsomeformofdrugorhumansmuggling,theywillfirstattempttopullthecarover.Ifthecardoesnotpulltothesideoftheroad,thesituationcanescalateintoahigh-speedchase,attimesthroughbackcountryranchland.Fleeingvehicleshavecrashedthroughfences,rolledintoditches,orflippedover,severelyhurtingorkillingthemigrantsinside.InDuvalCounty—northoftheFalfurriasBorderPatrolcheckpoint—membersofthelocalsheriff’sofficehaveengagedinseveralrecenthigh-speedchasesthatendedinmigrantfatalities.Migrantsmayalsobehitbyvehicles.ThisisespeciallytrueforindividualswhohikethroughranchlandtoavoidBorderPatrolcheckpointsandcrosshighwaysorroads.Thesemigrantsmaybewearingdarkclothes,travelingatnight,andrunningacrosshighwayswherecarsandtrucksaretravelingathighspeeds.InApril2016,a25-yearoldGuatemalanwomanattemptedtorunacrossHighway77inKenedyCountyandwasstruckbyatruck.Thedriverreportedthathesawthewomanatthelastminuteandtriedtoslowdown,butitwastoolate.TherearealsocasesofmigrantsbeinghitbyvehiclesinKlebergandDuvalcounties.AdditionalRisks.WithinmultipleSouthTexascounties,migrantswerealsokilledintrainaccidents.Inthesecases,theindividualsappearedtobefollowingthetraintracksasawayofguidingthemselvesnorthorattemptingtostowawaybetweenwagoncars.Itisalsopossiblethatinsomecasesmigrantsweresleepingonthetraintrackswhenthetrainapproached,inamisguidedbeliefthatitprotectsthemfromrattlesnakes.15Evenifthetrainconductorshadseentheindividualsonthetracks,itisunlikelythattheycouldhavestopped,giventhetimeneededtoslowaspeedingtrain.SeveralwomenalsoappearedtohavebeenmurderedastheytransitedthroughSouthTexas.Forexample,inDecember2013,huntersfounda31-year-oldwomanfromGuatemalainahuntingblindinBrooksCounty.Thewoman’sclothingwasindisarrayasifshehadbeensexuallyassaultedandtherewasabloodywoundonthebackofherheadwhereitappearedthatshehadbeenhitwithabluntobject.Anecdotesfromlocalofficialssuggestthatfemalemigrantsmaycommonlyface
![Page 18: MIGRANT DEATHS IN SOUTH TEXAS · History of Migrant Deaths in South Texas South Texas has a long history of migrant deaths, corresponding to changes in U.S. immigration and labor](https://reader034.vdocuments.site/reader034/viewer/2022042916/5f554b7ff9302370d4404924/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
17
harassmentorevenassaultandsexualviolenceduringtheirjourneythroughSouthTexas.However,thedatarevealedonlyafewinstanceswherethewomenappearedtohavebeenmurdered.
![Page 19: MIGRANT DEATHS IN SOUTH TEXAS · History of Migrant Deaths in South Texas South Texas has a long history of migrant deaths, corresponding to changes in U.S. immigration and labor](https://reader034.vdocuments.site/reader034/viewer/2022042916/5f554b7ff9302370d4404924/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
18
MigrantDeathLocationsandDemographicsinSouthTexasFrom2012to2019,migrantsdiedinalmosteverySouthTexascounty.Duringthistimeperiod,roughlyhalfofthedeathsoccurredincountiesdirectlyalongtheU.S.-Mexicoborder;theotherhalftookplaceininteriorcounties.However,thereisatrendtowardtheborderbecomingtheriskierarea.From2012to2016,therewereanequalnumberofdeathsinborderandinteriorcounties.Butoverthepastfouryears,thenumberofdeathsalongtheTexas-Mexicobordersteadilyroseasapercentoftotalnumbers.In2019,61percentofmigrantdeathsinSouthTexasoccurredinabordercounty.
Map5:TotalMigrantDeathsbySouthTexasCounty(2012-2019)
Source:ReportDataset
Duringthetimeperiodcoveredinthisreport,BrooksCountyreportedthemostdeaths.BrooksCountyhasaBorderPatrolcheckpointabout70milesnorthfromtheborderonHighway281andhasbecomethemostnotoriouscountyformigrantdeathsinSouthTexas.Inmediastoriesovertheyears,Brookshasbeencalledthe“DeathValleyformigrants”and“thekillingfields.”16However,
![Page 20: MIGRANT DEATHS IN SOUTH TEXAS · History of Migrant Deaths in South Texas South Texas has a long history of migrant deaths, corresponding to changes in U.S. immigration and labor](https://reader034.vdocuments.site/reader034/viewer/2022042916/5f554b7ff9302370d4404924/html5/thumbnails/20.jpg)
19
Map5showsoveralldeathtotalsfor2012to2019,andBrooksCountyisnolongerthecountywiththemostmigrantdeathsintheregion.In2018,WebbCountysurpassedBrooksCounty,andisnowthemostdangerousplaceinSouthTexasformigrantsenteringtheUnitedStates.
Graph5:MigrantDeathsinBrooksCountyandWebbCounty(2012-2019)
Source:ReportDataset
InWebbCounty,therisingnumberofmigrantdeathsappearstocorrespondtoshiftingmigrationroutesforsingleadults.InotherSouthTexasbordercounties,suchasneighboringMaverickCountytherewereanincreasingnumberofmigrantdeathsasfamiliesattemptedtocrosstheRioGrandetoseekasylum.However,theBorderPatrol’sLaredoSector—whichincludesWebbCounty—hascontinuouslyrecordedlownumbersoffamilyapprehensions.ThismeansthatitismorelikelythatsingleadultsdiedinWebbCountywhileattemptingtoevadetheBorderPatrol.Nationality.Inthe1990sandmid2000s,Mexicancitizensmadeupthevastmajorityofbordercrossersandsubsequentlythemajorityofmigrantdeaths.TheseMexicancitizenswerepartofacentury-oldmigrationpattern,wherebyMexicannationalswouldentertheUnitedStatesforseasonalagriculturalandranchingworkandthentravelbacktotheirhomesinMexico.From2004to2012,theMexicangovernment’sdataonitscitizens’deathsalongtheU.S.-MexicobordermirrorstheU.S.BorderPatrol’soverallmigrantdeathdata.
![Page 21: MIGRANT DEATHS IN SOUTH TEXAS · History of Migrant Deaths in South Texas South Texas has a long history of migrant deaths, corresponding to changes in U.S. immigration and labor](https://reader034.vdocuments.site/reader034/viewer/2022042916/5f554b7ff9302370d4404924/html5/thumbnails/21.jpg)
20
Graph6:SRE’sMexicanDeathsComparedtoTotalCBPDeaths(2004-2019)
Source:Mexico’sMinistryofForeignRelationsandU.S.CustomsandBorderProtection
Fromthelate2000sonward,however,anincreasingnumberofCentralAmericansandindividualsfromothercountriesbegancrossingtheRioGrandeandtraversingSouthTexas’backtrails.In2012,thenumberofnon-Mexicanapprehensionsbegantorise,andthisnumberwasalsoreflectedinmigrantdeathdata.From2012to2019,non-MexicansgenerallymadeupmorethanhalfofmigrantdeathsinSouthTexas.Intotal,306Salvadorans,Guatemalans,andHonduransdiedintheregionduringthistimeperiod,comparedto273Mexicans.rThedatasetalsoreporteddeathsofpeoplefromEcuador,Nicaragua,Colombia,theDominicanRepublic,Brazil,Belize,CostaRica,andPeru.
Graph7:MigrantDeathsinSouthTexasbyNationality(2012-2019)
Source:ReportDataset
rThisinformationondeceasedmigrants’nationalitiescomesprimarilyfromtwosources.Thefirstsourcearetheidentificationcardsthatindividualshadintheirpossessionwhentheypassedaway.ThesecondsourcearedeathcertificatesaddedtofilesafteranindividualwasidentifiedthroughDNAtestingorothermeans.Thisreporttriednottouseidentificationcardsasthesoleidentifier,sincesomeindividualsmayusefalseMexicanidentificationcardsinordertomovesafelythroughMexico.
![Page 22: MIGRANT DEATHS IN SOUTH TEXAS · History of Migrant Deaths in South Texas South Texas has a long history of migrant deaths, corresponding to changes in U.S. immigration and labor](https://reader034.vdocuments.site/reader034/viewer/2022042916/5f554b7ff9302370d4404924/html5/thumbnails/22.jpg)
21
Thedeceasedmigrantscamefromvariouscitiesandtownswithintheircountries.TheMexicanswhodiedwhileattemptingtoentertheUnitedStatescamefrom24differentstates.ThemostindividualshailedfromMichoacán(16cases),followedbyMexicoState(12cases),andthentheborderstatesofTamaulipasandCoahuila(8caseseach).InGuatemalaandHonduras,themigrantsalsocamefromawiderangeofdepartmentsaroundthecountry.OnlyinElSalvadordidthelargestnumbersofpeoplecomefromjustafewbigcities:SanSalvador(16cases)andSanMiguel(8cases).Sex.WhilethestereotypesofmigrantscrossingtheRioGrandeorhikingthroughTexasranchlandgenerallyfocusonmen,womenalsomakeupasignificantportionofbordercrossersandbordercrossingdeaths.Withinthedataset,morethanhalfofmigrantdeathscases(59percent)identifiedtheindividual’ssex.sFrom2012to2014,thepercentofwomenamongthedeadhititspeak,consistentlymakinguparound20percentofthetotal.However,after2014,thesenumbersdecreasedtobetween9and17percent.In2019,femalesmadeup16percentofmigrantdeathsalongtheborder.
Graph8:MigrantDeathsinSouthTexasbySex(2012-2019)
Source:ReportDataset
Migrantnationalitytrendsvariedbysex.From2012to2019,45percentofidentifiedmenwereMexican,19percentwereSalvadoran,18.5percentwereGuatemalan,and12percentwereHonduran.Amongwomen,thesetrendsdifferedslightly.Mexicanwomenalsomadeupthehighestamountoffemalemigrantdeathswith37percentofthetotal.Yet,Salvadoranwomenaccountedfor30percentofidentifiedindividuals.Guatemalanwomenmadeup17percentofthedeathsandHonduranwomenmadeup10percent.Age.From2012to2019,theaverageageofdeceasedindividualsinSouthTexasconsistentlyhoveredaround30yearsold.Therewaslittledifferenceintheaverageagesofdeceasedmenandwomen,oramongnationalities.
sSometimestheindividual’ssexwasnotabletobeascertained,especiallywhentheonlyrecoveredremainswereunidentifiablebones.
![Page 23: MIGRANT DEATHS IN SOUTH TEXAS · History of Migrant Deaths in South Texas South Texas has a long history of migrant deaths, corresponding to changes in U.S. immigration and labor](https://reader034.vdocuments.site/reader034/viewer/2022042916/5f554b7ff9302370d4404924/html5/thumbnails/23.jpg)
22
Graph9:AverageAgeofDeceasedMigrantsinSouthTexas(2012-2019)
Source:ReportDataset
However,therewasawiderangeinages,particularlyforindividualswhodrownedwhileattemptingtocrosstheRioGrande.From2012to2019,thedatasetincluded17casesofminorswhodrowned.Thisincludedaten-month-oldbabywhowasseparatedfromhisfamilynearPiedrasNegrasastheycrossedtheRioGrande.Additionally,inSeptember2019,aHonduranmotherandher21-month-oldsondrownedwhileattemptingtocrosstheRioGrandeinValVerdeCounty.ThefamilyhadsoughtasylumintheUnitedStatesandbeenreturnedtoMexicoaspartoftheMigrantProtectionProtocols(MPP).Afterareportofapossibledrowning,theBorderPatrolfoundthemotherandson’sbodiesfloatingintheriver.
![Page 24: MIGRANT DEATHS IN SOUTH TEXAS · History of Migrant Deaths in South Texas South Texas has a long history of migrant deaths, corresponding to changes in U.S. immigration and labor](https://reader034.vdocuments.site/reader034/viewer/2022042916/5f554b7ff9302370d4404924/html5/thumbnails/24.jpg)
23
MigrantDeathProcessingInSouthTexas,arangeofactorsprocessmigrantdeaths,includingfederal,state,county,andnon-governmentalentities.TheirresponsibilitiesareoutlinedinfederalandTexasstatelaw,withstatuteguidingtheactionsthateachactorissupposedtotake.However,withinthe19countiesthatthisreportcovered,thesepracticeswerenotalwaysstandardized.Thefollowingsectionwilloutlinevariousentities’legalresponsibilitiesinmigrantdeathprocessing,includingwhatthisroleissupposedtolooklikeandwherecountiesmaydivergeintheirpractices.
Graphic1:MigrantDeathProcessinginSouthTexas
Source:AuthorElaboration
BorderPatrol.TheU.S.BorderPatrolisthefederalagencytaskedwithapprehendingmigrantswithintheborderregionandisfrequentlytherespondingagencyformigrantsindistress.Theseagentsoftendiscoverdeceasedmigrantsastheytrackindividualsandgroupsthroughranchlandorflyoverremoteareasinhelicopters.IncountieswithhighlevelsofmigrationandinteractionwithBorderPatrolagents,localsmaydirectlycalltheBorderPatrolwhentheydiscoverhumanremains.Between2012and2019,theBorderPatrollocatedonethirdofthe417casesinthedatasetthatrecordedthediscoveringparty.However,whiletheBorderPatrolisthefederalagencycharged
![Page 25: MIGRANT DEATHS IN SOUTH TEXAS · History of Migrant Deaths in South Texas South Texas has a long history of migrant deaths, corresponding to changes in U.S. immigration and labor](https://reader034.vdocuments.site/reader034/viewer/2022042916/5f554b7ff9302370d4404924/html5/thumbnails/25.jpg)
24
withaddressingunauthorizedmigrationintheborderregions,Texas’countiesareresponsibleforprocessingmigrantdeaths.WhenBorderPatrolagentslocatehumanremains,theycontactthecorrespondingsheriff’soffice.Whilethisstepismandatory,therelationshipbetweentheBorderPatrolandsheriffs’officesmayvarybycounty,dependingonthecounty’slocation,thefrequencyofmigrantdeaths,thesheriff’soffice’spersonnelnumbers,andpersonalrelationships.Forexample,inBrooksCounty,thesheriff’sofficeroutes9-11callsfrommigrantsindistresstotheBorderPatrol,giventhattheagencyhasmoreresourcesandpersonneltorespond.However,thereisnostandardprocedureforcooperationandsomesheriffs’officesincountieswithlownumbersofmigrantdeathsrarelycollaboratewiththeBorderPatrol.BorderPatrolagentsrecordmigrantdeathsintheBorderSafetyInitiativeTrackingSystem,whichincludesinformationonmigrantdeathlocationandthedeceased’sdemographics.17Thisdatabaseisusedtoanalyzetrendsinmigrantdeathsandtoallocatebudgetingforthecomingyear.Ifagentscandetermineadecedent’snationality,theBorderPatrolmayalsocontacttherelevantconsularoffice.However,theBorderPatroldoesnotappeartobecollectingdetailedinformationonlocationordemographics.AccordingtoaJanuary30,2020FreedomofInformationActresponseregardingdeceasedmigrants’nationality,sex,andage,thechiefoftheFOIAAppeals,Policy,andLitigationbranchwrote:“theUSBP[U.S.BorderPatrol]reportedthatitsimplydoesnotcollectmuchofthedatathatyourequested.”Additionally,itnotedthat“theagencydoesnotcollectGPSdataorotheraddressinformationaboutthedeceasedmigrantsitencounters.”Sheriff’s’Office.InSouthTexas,sheriffs’officesplayacentralroleinprocessinganddocumentingmigrantdeaths.Outsideofmunicipalities—incorporatedsettlementsthatincludecities,towns,andvillages—lawenforcementauthorityfallstocountysheriffs.ForthesprawlingcountiesthatcharacterizeSouthTexas,thismakesforalargejurisdiction.Sheriffs’officesmustrespondtoreportsofthediscoveryofhumanremainswithintheirterritory.Whensheriffs’officesarealertedtothediscoveryofmigrantremains,whetherbytheBorderPatrolorlocalresidents,theytypicallysendonetofourdeputiestophotographanddocumenttheremains,justastheywouldacrimescene.Thesheriff’sofficeisresponsiblefornotifyingothercountyofficialstotraveltothesceneofthedeath.Theseincludeajusticeofthepeacetoaidinthedeathinvestigationandafuneralhometoremovetheremainsfromthescene.InWebbCounty,thesheriff’sofficecontactstheWebbCounty’sMedicalExaminer’sOfficetoremovetheremains.Atthesceneofthedeath,asheriff’sofficeinvestigatorordeputygathersanddocumentsevidence.Thisprocessmayincludeinterviewingtheindividualthatdiscoveredthebody,takingphotosoftheremains,andsearchingthesurroundingarea.Somesheriffs’officesmayrequesttheassistanceofTexasGameWardens,TexasRangers,orlocalfiredepartmentstohelpretrievedrownedbodieswithsearchandrescueboats.Oncebackinthestation,thesheriff’sofficepersonnelcompleteanincidentreport,whichgenerallycontainsstandardinformationsuchasnames,date,andlocation,aswellasanarrativeoftherelevantfacts.MoredetailedincidentreportsincludeGPScoordinatesofthebody’slocationandtranscriptsofdispatchcalls.Onlythreeofthe15sheriffs’officesinterviewedforthisreport—BrooksCounty,KenedyCounty,andHidalgoCounty—proactivelygroupfilesrelatingtodeceasedmigrantsandseparatethemfromotherrecords.BrooksCountyorganizesthefilesinbindersbyyear,whileKenedyCountykeepstheminfilingcabinetsinchronologicalorder.HidalgoCounty’sresponsetoapublicrecordrequestalsoindicatesthatittracksmigrantdeathselectronically.Incontrast,sheriffs’officestaffinothercountiesmayoccasionallynoteadecedent’ssuspectedorconfirmedmigrationstatusinanincidentreportbutlackastandardizedmethodfortrackingthesecases.
![Page 26: MIGRANT DEATHS IN SOUTH TEXAS · History of Migrant Deaths in South Texas South Texas has a long history of migrant deaths, corresponding to changes in U.S. immigration and labor](https://reader034.vdocuments.site/reader034/viewer/2022042916/5f554b7ff9302370d4404924/html5/thumbnails/26.jpg)
25
CountyJusticeofthePeace.Justicesofthepeaceareelectedjudgesthatholdvariousdutieswithinacounty,suchaspresidingoversmallclaimscourts,conductingmarriageceremonies,andcarryingoutinquests.18Theyarenotrequiredtohaveamedicalbackgroundormedicalknowledge,andmayhaveanotherfull-timejobwhileservingintheposition.Thejusticeofthepeace’sinquestisaninvestigationintothecauseandcircumstancesofadeathinordertodetermineifanunlawfulactwascommitted.19Inthecaseofmigrantdeaths,Texasstatutemandatesaninquest.tWhencalledtothesceneofadeath,thejusticeofthepeaceplaysseveralroles.First,heorsherecordsthetimeofdeathtobelistedonthedeathcertificate.Thisissometimesinterpretedas“pronouncingthepersondead,”butjusticesofthepeacedonotperformthisrole.Instead,theynotethetimeofdeath.20Second,justicesofthepeacemustdecidewhethertoorderafullorpartialautopsyfromaforensicpathologisttodeterminethenatureofthedeath.21However,ifthejusticeofthepeacebelievesthatthecauseandmannerofdeathareevidentbeyondareasonabledoubt—asmaybethecasewithmigrantdrownings—heorshehasthediscretiontoforegoanautopsyandsendthebodydirectlytoafuneralhome.Thecountycommissionerscourtpaysfortheautopsy,whichcanrangefromroughly$1,200to$3,000,dependingonthecomplexityofthecaseandthestateofabody’sdecomposition.22ForcountiesinSouthTexas,financialconsiderationsmayserveasdeterrencetoorderinganautopsy.23Ifthedeceasedindividualisunidentified,thejusticeofthepeacemaytakeadditionalsteps.Ifthereisnomeansofmakingapositiveidentification,orifofficialsdoubttheauthenticityofanidentificationtheyfindatthescene,thejusticeofthepeacehasthediscretiontoorderlaboratorytestsfromaforensicpathologisttohelpdeterminethedeceasedperson’sidentity.24Forcasesinwhichthebodyhasfullydecomposedandonlyskeletalremainsareavailable,thejusticeofthepeacemayseekthehelpofaforensiclab.25Texaslawrequiresthatjusticesofthepeacekeepdetailedrecordsoftheinqueststheyconduct.26AccordingtotheTexasCodeofCriminalProcedure,theinquestrecord“mustincludeareportoftheevents,proceedings,findings,andconclusionsoftheinquest.Therecordmustalsoincludeanyautopsypreparedinthecaseandallotherpapersofthecase.Allpapersoftheinquestrecordmustbemarkedwiththecasenumberandbeclearlyindexedandbemaintainedintheofficeofthejusticeofthepeaceandbemadeavailabletotheappropriateofficialsuponrequest.”27Thepublichastherighttoinspecttheserecords.28FuneralHomes.Funeralhomesprovidesupporttocountyofficialsinprocessingmigrantremains.Funeralhomesareprivatelyoperated,for-profitcompaniesthatcompeteforthecounties’business,eitherthroughanopenbidprocessthatawardsacontracttothecheapestproviderorbymeansofalternatingamongvariousfuneralhomes.Whilemorepopulouscountiesusethebidorrotationsystems,smallercountiesinSouthTexasmayrelyononefuneralhometoservicetheentirecounty
tAccordingtotheTexasCodeofCriminalProcedure§49.04,thereare8instancesinwhichjusticesofthepeacearerequiredtocarryoutinquests,4ofwhichapplytothecircumstancesinwhichmigrantsarecommonlydiscovered:
(2)thepersondiesanunnaturaldeathfromacauseotherthanlegalexecution;(3)thebodyorabodypartofapersonisfound,andthecauseorcircumstancesofdeathareunknown,includinginstancesinwhichthepersonisunidentified;(4)thecircumstancesofthedeathindicatethatthedeathmayhavebeencausedbyunlawfulmeans;(6)thepersondieswithouthavingbeenattendedbyaphysician.
![Page 27: MIGRANT DEATHS IN SOUTH TEXAS · History of Migrant Deaths in South Texas South Texas has a long history of migrant deaths, corresponding to changes in U.S. immigration and labor](https://reader034.vdocuments.site/reader034/viewer/2022042916/5f554b7ff9302370d4404924/html5/thumbnails/27.jpg)
26
orevenmultiplecounties.Thefuneralhome’sinitialroleistoremovethebodyfromthesceneandtransportittoitsnextdestination.uThemigrantremains’nextdestinationdependsonwhetherajusticeofthepeacedecidestoorderanautopsyoradditionaltests.Ifthisisthecase,funeralhomestafftransporttheremainstoamedicalexaminer’sofficeoraforensicanthropologist.However,ifthedecedentisidentifiedandthecauseandmannerofdeathhavebeenestablished,justicesofthepeacemaysendtheremainsdirectlytothefuneralhome.Inthesecases,funeralhomestaffworkwithconsularauthorities—andinsomecasesthedeceased’sfamilydirectly—tofacilitaterepatriationofthebody,skeletalremains,orcremationashes,dependingonthefamily’swishes.Ifthedecedentisunidentified,butthejusticeofthepeaceoptsnottoorderanautopsyorlaboratorytests,theremainsalsogotothefuneralhome.Texaslawrequiresthatthestaffthenstorethebodyinrefrigerationforatleasttendaysbeforeburyingit.29Funeralhomesdonothavethelegalauthoritytoidentifybodies.vInstead,somefuneralhomespostdeathnoticesinlocalpaperstonotifythepublicoftheperson’spassingandtohelplocatetheperson’sfamily.30Ifnobodyclaimsthebodyduringthetendayperiod,thefuneralhomearrangesforanindigentburial,whichischargedtothecountycommissioner.31Incountiesthatdonothaveindigentcemeteries,funeralhomesmaynegotiatewithprivatelyownedcemeteriesforburiallots.Somefuneralhomesreportthatthetotalcostoftheburialmayexceedwhatthecountypaysthem.w32Thereareconflictingstatutesregardingcremationofunidentifiedremains.TheTexasCodeofCriminalProcedureexplicitlystatesthatitisillegaltocremateunidentifiedbodies.Thecodestatesthat“Ifthebodyofadeceasedpersonisunidentified,apersonmaynotcremateordirectthecremationofthebodyunderthisarticle.”33However,intheabsenceofnextofkinorlegalexecutors,theTexasHealth&SafetyCodegrantsjusticesofthepeacetherighttocontroldispositionofthebody,includingtherighttocremate.34TheTexasHealth&HumanSafetycodealsopermitscrematoriumstoacceptunidentifiedremainsifcommissionerscourtsorothercountyofficials—namelyjusticesofthepeace—authorizethecremation.35Afteranautopsyorlaboratorytests,thefuneralhomemayalsotransporttheremainsbacktoitsfacilitytoprepareforrepatriationorburial.However,thisisnotthecasewiththeWebbCountyMedicalExaminer’sOffice,whereremainsdonotreturntothecountyofdiscovery.Instead,themedicalexaminersendsidentifiedremainsthatwillberepatriatedtotheSouthTexasMortuary&CremationServicesfuneralhomeinWebbCounty.RemainsthatarenotidentifiedareburiedinacemeteryinWebbCounty.MedicalExaminers.Medicalexaminersarephysiciansthathavetraininginforensicpathologyandtoxicology,andworktodeterminecausesofdeathbycarryingoutpost-mortemexaminationsoncorpses.Texasstatuterequiresthatcountieswithmorethan2millionresidentsappointamedicalexaminer,whileothercountiesmaydosovoluntarilybasedonneedandresources.36Ofthe254countiesinTexas,only12employmedicalexaminers.x37Inthose12counties,justicesofthepeacerelinquishtheirinquestdutiestothemedicalexaminers.38
uInWebbCounty,theOfficeoftheMedicalExaminerremovesthebodyfromthescene.vUnderTexaslaw,onlymedicalexaminers,justicesofthepeace,orothermedicallegalauthoritiessuchasdeathinvestigatorsmayidentifyabody.wTexaslawrequiresboththefuneralhomeandthejusticeofthepeacetokeeparecordoftheburial.xCountieswithmedicalexaminersincludeBexar,Collin,Dallas,Ector,ElPaso,Galveston,Harris,Lubbock,Nueces,Tarrant,Travis,andWebb.
![Page 28: MIGRANT DEATHS IN SOUTH TEXAS · History of Migrant Deaths in South Texas South Texas has a long history of migrant deaths, corresponding to changes in U.S. immigration and labor](https://reader034.vdocuments.site/reader034/viewer/2022042916/5f554b7ff9302370d4404924/html5/thumbnails/28.jpg)
27
Ofthe19countiesincludedinthisreport,onlyWebbCountyhasestablisheditsownmedicalexaminer’soffice,which,inadditiontoWebbCounty,alsoservestenofthesurroundingcounties.yThismakestheWebbCountyMedicalExaminer’sOfficeanimportantentityforprocessingmigrantdeathsinSouthTexas.Othercountiesintheregionuseprivatepathologistsorsendtheirbodiestoamedicalexaminerinanothercounty,suchasNuecesorBexar.Insomecases,thisrequiresthefuneralhometotransportthebodyupto390milesround-trip.
Table1:MedicalExaminerbyCountyforIdentifiedorUnidentifiedSuspectedMigrants
County EntityPerformingAutopsyandLaboratoryTestsonBodies
DistancefromCountytoMedicalExaminer
Brooks WebbCountyMedicalExaminer 90miles
Cameron ValleyBaptistMedicalCenter 26miles
Dimmit WebbCountyMedicalExaminer 84miles
Duval WebbCountyMedicalExaminer 55miles
Edwards CentralTexasAutopsy 195miles
Hidalgo ValleyForensics 10miles
JimHogg WebbCountyMedicalExaminer 55miles
Kenedy NuecesCountyMedicalExaminer 60miles
Kinney BexarCountyMedicalExaminer 125miles
Kleberg NuecesMedicalExaminer 42miles
LaSalle WebbCountyMedicalExaminer 70miles
MaverickWebbCountyMedicalExaminer
BexarCountyMedicalExaminer
127miles
148miles
Starr WebbCountyMedicalExaminer 92miles
Uvalde BexarCountyMedicalExaminer 82miles
ValVerde WebbCountyMedicalExaminer 182miles
Webb WebbCountyMedicalExaminer --
Willacy ValleyForensics 39miles
Zapata WebbCountyMedicalExaminer 52miles
ZavalaWebbCountyMedicalExaminer
BexarCountyMedicalExaminer
95miles
120miles
Source:Interviewswithcountyofficials
yTheWebbCountyMedicalExaminer’sOfficeservesBrooks,Dimmit,Duval,Frio,JimHogg,LaSalle,Maverick,Starr,Webb,Zapata,andZavalacounties.
![Page 29: MIGRANT DEATHS IN SOUTH TEXAS · History of Migrant Deaths in South Texas South Texas has a long history of migrant deaths, corresponding to changes in U.S. immigration and labor](https://reader034.vdocuments.site/reader034/viewer/2022042916/5f554b7ff9302370d4404924/html5/thumbnails/29.jpg)
28
Throughautopsiesandlaboratorytests,medicalexaminerscanhelpincreasethechancesofpositivelyidentifyingdeceasedmigrants.Themedicalexaminer’sprocessincludestakingfingerprints,recordingdentalrecords,notinguniquetattoos,andtakingx-raysinsearchofidentifyingfractures.ThisdataischeckedagainstCBP’sbiometricsdatabase.39IfmigrantshavepreviouslyenteredtheUnitedStatesandbeenincontactwithU.S.officials,theirbiometricinformationwillcreateamatch.SomemedicalexaminersandpathologistsalsouploadinformationtotheNationalMissingandUnidentifiedPersonsSystem(NamUs),whichishousedattheUniversityofNorthTexas’CenterforHumanIdentification(UNTCHI)andfundedbytheNationalInstituteofJustice(NIJ)attheU.S.DepartmentofJustice.NamUsoperatesasacentralizedclearinghousethatfamiliesandotherorganizationscanaccesstohelplocatetheirlovedones.DatabasesinNamUsincludeinformationregardingtheremains’geographiclocation,photographsofpersonalbelongingsfoundatthescene,demographicinformation,andotherdetailsthatmayaidinidentifyingthedecedent.40Whenthereisanewentry,NamUsautomaticallycross-checksitwiththeexistingentriestoseeifthereisapotentialmatch.However,notallmedicalexaminersandjusticesofthepeaceuseNamUs,andthereisnolawrequiringthemtodoso.Iftheindividualisnotidentifiedthroughlaboratorytests,themedicalexaminermayelecttotakeaDNAsamplefromthebody.Forsomemedicalexaminers,takingDNAfromanunidentifiedbodyisstandardoperatingprocedure.Forexample,theWebbCountyMedicalExaminertakesDNAsamplesfromalmosteverydecedentthatpassesthroughtheoffice,exceptthosewhohavealreadybeenidentifiedthroughothermeanssuchasfingerprints.41Asanaddedprecaution,theWebbCountyMedicalExamineralsotakesDNAfromremainsthatwerediscoveredwithidentification.Bycomparison,othermedicalexaminersmaynotalwayshavesuchrigorouspractices.Instead,theymayviewtheirprimaryresponsibilityasdeterminingthecauseandmannerofdeathandnotperformingidentityinvestigations.ForensicLabs.Medicalexaminersmayseektheassistanceofspecializedlabs,whereforensicanthropologistsandDNAanalystscarryoutmorein-depthtests.Iftheremainshavefullyskeletonized,thejusticeofthepeacemaychoosetosendthemdirectlytoaforensiclab.ForcountiesinSouthTexas,therearethreeforensicactorsthatassistwithprocessingofmigrantremains:theUNTCHI,theArgentineForensicAnthropologyTeam(EquipoArgentinodeAntropologíaForense,EAAF),andtheForensicAnthropologyCenteratTexasStateUniversity(FACTS).InadditiontohousingNamUs,theUNTCHIprovidesfreeforensicanthropologyservicesandisoneofthefewU.S.laboratoriesthatisaccreditedtouploadDNAsamplestotheCombinedDNAIndexSystem(CODIS).42CODISisaseriesofdatabasesfundedandmanagedbytheFederalBureauofInvestigation(FBI),whichcontainsDNAfrommissingandunidentifiedpeopleandcriminalinvestigations.Otherforensiclabswithinthestate—suchasFACTS—sendtheirDNAsamplestotheUNTCHItouploadintoCODIS.TheprocessingtimesforDNAanalysisandprofilematchesaretypicallysixtoeightmonths.CODIShasstrictrulesforitsDNAsamples.Toincludearelative’sDNAreferencesample,thefamilymembermustsignaconsentformandprovidethesampleinthepresenceofalawenforcementofficerorapprovedcriminaljusticeagencyrepresentative,suchasamedicalexaminerorconsularofficer.CODISpolicystatesthatDNAinitsmissingandunidentifiedpersonsdatabaseisnevercomparedagainstitscriminaldatabaseandthatpeoplecanaskfortheirprofilestoberemovedfromthedatabaseafterthesystemmakesamatch.43However,somefamiliesarestilluncomfortablewithCODIS’rules.Tomitigatethisanxietyandincreaseparticipation,theUNTCHI
![Page 30: MIGRANT DEATHS IN SOUTH TEXAS · History of Migrant Deaths in South Texas South Texas has a long history of migrant deaths, corresponding to changes in U.S. immigration and labor](https://reader034.vdocuments.site/reader034/viewer/2022042916/5f554b7ff9302370d4404924/html5/thumbnails/30.jpg)
29
hascollaboratedwithcountyandcityofficialstohosteventsthatallowfamilymemberstoprovidereferencesamplesinmoretrustedenvironments.TheEAAFalsomanagesadatabaseonunidentifiedandmissingmigrants.TheorganizationworkstocollectDNAfamilyreferencesamplesinmigrantsendingcommunitiesinHonduras,ElSalvador,theMexicanstatesofChiapasandOaxaca,and,since2009,alongtheU.S.-Mexicoborder.44TheEAAFusesBodeCellmarkForensics,aprivateforensiclabinVirginia,toprocessandanalyzeitssamples.UnliketheUNTCHIwhichreceivesfederalfundingandprovidesitsservicesfreeofcharge,BodeCellmarkForensicschargesforitstesting,makingitcost-prohibitiveforsomefamilies.zAlthoughtheEAAFpossessesDNAreferencesamplesfromthefamiliesofmissingmigrantsandCODIShousesDNAprofilesonunidentifiedhumanremains,U.S.policyrestrictionshavenotallowedforcross-referencingbetweenthetwodatabases,despiteyearsofnegotiations.45Forensicexpertshavesuggestedthatcross-referencingbetweentheEAAF’sdatabaseandCODIScouldresultinhundreds,ifnotthousands,ofpositiveidentifications.46Someorganizations,suchasFACTSatTexasStateUniversityandthePimaCountyMedicalExaminerinTucson,Arizona,haveutilizedbothdatabasestoincreasetheprobabilityofmakingapositiveidentification.ToaddressthedividebetweentheEAAF’sdatabaseandCODIS,theUNTCHIrecentlycreatedtheHumanitarianDNAIdentificationDatabase,whichusesCODISsoftware.ThedatabaseincludesalloftheUNTCHI’spreviousCODISentries,whichaccountforoverhalfofCODIS’totalentries.Insteadofsplittingthesamples,theUNTCHIisabletoduplicatetheDNAprofile,whichallowsittostreamlinecosts.ToencourageparticipationintheHumanitarianDNAIdentificationDatabase,theUNTCHIhasloosenedsomeoftherestrictionspertainingtolawenforcement’spresenceforfamilymembersprovidingDNAreferencesamples.Thedatabaseisstillinitsearlystagesand,ifitprovessuccessful,theUNTCHIhopestoincludeCODISentriesfrompartnersinCaliforniaandArizona.FACTSatTexasStateUniversityprovidesforensicanthropologyservicestothreecountiesinTexas:Brewster,Brooks,andJeffDavis.ItreliesontheUNTCHIforDNAanalysisunlessithasanidentificationhypothesis,inwhichcaseitsendstheDNAsampletoBodeCellmarkForensicsforentryintotheEAAF’sdatabase.FACTSalsocarriesoutexhumationsofunmarkedgravesalongthebordertoassistinidentifyingmigrantremains.ForeignConsulates.Consularofficesassistinidentifyingandrepatriatingdeceasedmigrantsandoftenfacilitateinformationexchangesamongfamilymembers,medicalexaminers,lawenforcementofficers,andfuneralhomes.Familiesofmissingmigrantsmayfeelmorecomfortableworkingwiththeirgovernment’sofficialsratherthancommunicatingdirectlywithU.S.authorities.Thismeansthatinsearchandrescuesituations,consularstaffmaychannelusefulinformationfromfamilymemberstotheBorderPatrol,suchasamigrant’slocation.WhileconsularstaffmayalsohelpobtainaDNAreferencesamplefromafamilymembertomakeanidentification.Consularauthoritiesmayalsoassistinrepatriatingtheircitizens’remainsonceadecedentisidentified.Somecountriesofferfinancialassistancetohelpoffsetthecostsofdeathcertificateprocessing,embalmingorcremation,andrepatriation,eitherbylandorbyair.Familiesgenerallypayforanyremainingrepatriationcosts,whichcandifferbyfuneralhomeanddestinationcountry.
zInMay2020,theUNTCHIreportedthatitcosts$885toprocessafamilyDNAreferencesampleand$1,492foranunidentifiedhumanremainsDNAsample.ThisestimateincludesautosomalSTR,Y-STR,andmitochondrialDNAoneachsample,andlabor.FundingfromtheStateofTexascoverstheseexpensesforin-statecaseswhiletheNationalInstituteofJusticeprovidesfundingforothers.
![Page 31: MIGRANT DEATHS IN SOUTH TEXAS · History of Migrant Deaths in South Texas South Texas has a long history of migrant deaths, corresponding to changes in U.S. immigration and labor](https://reader034.vdocuments.site/reader034/viewer/2022042916/5f554b7ff9302370d4404924/html5/thumbnails/31.jpg)
30
Currently,Mexico’sgovernment,throughitsnetworkofconsulates,offersuptoUS$1,550perdeceasedMexicannationaltocoverrepatriationcosts.ThisassistanceisalsoofferedforMexicanmigrantswhodiewhileattemptingtoentertheUnitedStates.aaAtthesametime,thecostofacremationandrepatriationis$1,095attheSouthTexasMortuaryinWebbCounty,whileembalmingandrepatriationcanrunmuchhigherdependingonthefinaldestination.bbThismismatchbetweenavailablesupportandthefuneralhomepricesmeansthatMexicanfinancialsupportonlycoversthefullcostofacremationandnotanembalming.IfMexicanfamiliesprefertorepatriatetheembalmedremainsforburial,theywillhavetocovertheremainingbalance.Somefamiliesmaychoosetopaythisadditionalmoney,sincetheyopposecremationonreligiousgroundsorwishtoviewtheremains.
aaIn2016,Mexico’sconsularserviceswereabletoprovide$3,500perperson.In2017,thisamountchangedto$1,850andin2018itdroppedto$1,550.bbInMexico,thereisnorepatriationcostforcremation,sincetheashescanbereturnedtoMexicoforfreeinadiplomaticpouch.
![Page 32: MIGRANT DEATHS IN SOUTH TEXAS · History of Migrant Deaths in South Texas South Texas has a long history of migrant deaths, corresponding to changes in U.S. immigration and labor](https://reader034.vdocuments.site/reader034/viewer/2022042916/5f554b7ff9302370d4404924/html5/thumbnails/32.jpg)
31
CostsofMigrantDeathsBordercrossingdeathsalsocreatecostsforSouthTexascounties,whicharesomeofthemostimpoverishedintheUnitedStates.Thesecostsmaybedirect,throughautopsiesorburials,orlessdirect,throughloststafftimeanddivertedresources.Yettheyaddupandcanmakeitdifficultforunder-resourcedagenciestofollowbestpracticeswhenrespondingtomigrantdeaths.Overwhelmeddepartmentsmaykeeppoorrecords,avoidorderingautopsies,andotherwisecutcornerstostaywithincountybudgets.BrooksCountyistheclearestexampleofthesecosts’effects.From2009to2013,morethan350peoplediedinthecounty,creatingabillofmorethan$628,000.Tosavecosts,BrookscountyofficialsoftenchosenottoorderautopsiesorDNAtestingfordeceasedmigrants,andthelocalcemeteryburiedthebodiesinunmarkedgraveswithoutrecordingtheburiallocations.47Thesemigrantsoftenhadlittlechanceofbeingidentifiedandrepatriatedtotheircountries.In2013,however,thesechancesincreasedslightly,whenforensicanthropologistsbeganexhumingtheremainsinthecountycemetery.48Sincereceivingstatefundingassistancein2013,BrooksCountynowroutinelyordersautopsiesandkeepssomeofthemostdetailedmigrantdeathrecordsintheregion.Overall,whentracedfromdiscoverytoburial,thedeathofasinglemigrantcostsacountyaminimumof$1,100.Thistotalassumesthatcountyofficialsdonotrequestanautopsy,paynothingforaburialplot,andusenospecializedequipmenttoretrieveadrownedindividual.However,whenfactoringintheseandothercosts,asinglemigrantdeathcouldcostacountyupwardsof$13,100.Table2outlinesthecostsforeachstateandlocalentityinvolvedinprocessingmigrantdeaths.International,federal,andstateauthorities,alongwithuniversitiesandcivilsocietyorganizations,alsofacecostsassociatedwithprocessingandidentifyingmigrantremains.49TheMexicanconsulateoffersbothfinancialandlogisticalassistancetofamilieswithmissingrelativesandstate-fundeduniversitiesmayexhumedecedentsatnochargetotheirfamilies.ccTheBorderPatroldoesnottrackcostsrelatedtosearchandrescueoperationsordeceasedmigrants.50
ccSeeAppendixFforabreakdownofMexicanconsulatesfinancialandpersonnelcostsrelatedtomigrantdeaths.
![Page 33: MIGRANT DEATHS IN SOUTH TEXAS · History of Migrant Deaths in South Texas South Texas has a long history of migrant deaths, corresponding to changes in U.S. immigration and labor](https://reader034.vdocuments.site/reader034/viewer/2022042916/5f554b7ff9302370d4404924/html5/thumbnails/33.jpg)
32
Table2:StateandCountyCostsAssociatedwithBorderCrossingDeaths(PerDecedent)
Service InvolvedActors CostBreakdown ApproximateCost PaidBy
Respondtoandinvestigatescene
Sheriff’soffice Personneltime(3to5hours,1to4staff),equipment,gas
$130to$41051 County,statedd
Retrievedrownedbody Sheriff’soffice,occasionallyfiredepartments,gamewardens,orTexasRangers
Personneltime(3to5hours),searchandrescueequipment,gas
$240to$75052 County,stateee
Documentincident,collaboratewithexternalagencies
Sheriff’soffice Personneltime(3hours)
$40 County
Declaretimeofdeath,collectincidentinformation
Justiceofthepeace,medicalexaminer(WebbCounty)
Personneltime(1.5to3hours),gas
$55to$16053 County
Documentincident Justiceofthepeace Personneltime(1to3hours)
$40to$8054 County
Decedenttransportation,storage,casket,indigentburialservice
Privatefuneralhome,cemetery
$800to$1,30055
County,privatefuneralhome
Autopsy Medicalexaminerorprivatepathologist
$1,250to$3,00056
County
Microscopicslides Medicalexaminer $20perslide57 County
Decedentstorage Medicalexaminerorprivatepathologist
$50to$100/day,or$375flatrateff58
County
Burialplot Publicorprivatecemetery,privatefuneralhome
Nocost(donation)to$5,000gg59
County,privatefuneralhome
Exhumationfromburialplot
Decedent’sfamily,NGOs,universityanthropologydepartments,funeralhome,cemetery
$2,000 Decedent’sfamily,NGOs,state,hhfuneralhome
ddBrooksCountyhasreceivedstatefundingthroughtheOfficeoftheTexasGovernor’seGrantprogram.eeFiredepartments,gamewardens,andTexasRangerstypicallybecomeinvolvedonlywhensheriff’sofficeslackthespecializedequipmentortrainingnecessarytoretrieveabody.ffTheBexarCountyMedicalExaminercharges$50to$100aday,andtheWebbCountyMedicalExaminerchargesaflatfeeof$375.ggIntheabsenceofindigentcemeteries,funeralhomescontactprivatecemeteriesandnegotiateburialplotrates.Funeralhomespayanycostsnotcoveredbycounties.hhTheTexasstategovernmentprovidesfundingforpublicuniversityforensicanthropologydepartments.
![Page 34: MIGRANT DEATHS IN SOUTH TEXAS · History of Migrant Deaths in South Texas South Texas has a long history of migrant deaths, corresponding to changes in U.S. immigration and labor](https://reader034.vdocuments.site/reader034/viewer/2022042916/5f554b7ff9302370d4404924/html5/thumbnails/34.jpg)
33
RecommendationsandBestPracticesWhilethisreportandthefollowingrecommendationsfocusonmigrantdeathprocessing,themostimportantpolicieswillalwaysbetheeffortsaimedatpreventingthesedeaths.HighnumbersofmigrantdeathsinSouthTexasandalongtheborderrepresentfailuresinU.S.immigrationandlaborpolicy,giventhemismatchofsupplyanddemandforlegalpathways.Thismeansthatwhilestreamliningpost-mortemprocessingiscriticaltoidentifyingremainsandkeepingarecordofdeaths,thesetasksshouldnotreplacenorprecedeanystepstoreducethenumbersofpeopledyingintheRioGrandeandTexasranchlands.Thereisalsononeedtostartpolicydiscussionsfromscratch.Twoyearsago,membersofCongressfromTexasintroducedthebipartisanMissingPersonsandUnidentifiedRemainsActof2018totheU.S.HouseofRepresentativesandSenate.60TheproposedlegislationwouldhavesupportedTexascountiesandnon-governmentactorsbyauthorizingfederalgrantsforprocessingmigrantremains,requiringthatfamilyDNAreferencesbeusedonlyforidentifyingmissingpersons,constructing170additionalrescuebeacons,andmandatingvariousgovernmentreportsonmigrantdeaths.Passingthisbillwouldrepresentastepforwardformigrants,theirfamilies,andbordercommunities.However,ithasnevermovedforward.Beyondfederallegislation,therearealsosmallerscalechangesthatcouldhaveanimportanteffectonmigrantdeathprocessing.Thesestepsinclude1)standardizingandincreasingtransparencyonmigrantdeathrecordkeeping;2)ensuringthatallremainspassthroughTexas’outlinedidentificationprocedures;and3)increasingstatefundingfortheseefforts.WhiletheprimarygoalshouldbereducingandeliminatingmigrantdeathsinSouthTexas,takingthefollowingstepswouldhelpstreamlinemigrantdeathprocessing,ensurethatalldeceasedmigrantsaretreatedequallyregardlessofwheretheydieandassistwiththeindividual’seventualidentificationandrepatriation.1.StandardizeRecordKeepingWhenamigrantdiesinSouthTexas,variousactorsareresponsiblefordocumentingthedeath,includingtheBorderPatrol,thecountysheriff’soffice,ajusticeofthepeace,afuneralhome,andpotentiallyamedicalexaminer.Whilethisinformationisfundamentalforidentifyingremains,pursuinginvestigations,andforunderstandingthescopeofmigrantdeathsinSouthTexas,deficienciesintheseagencies’datacollectionprocessescanlimittheseactivities.BorderPatrol.Formorethantwodecades,theBorderPatrolhasbeenresponsibleforcreatingandmanagingacentralizeddatabaseonmigrantdeathsalongtheU.S.-Mexicoborder.However,itisunclearwhatinformationtheBorderPatrolcollectsregardingmigrantdeathsortheirmethodsfordatacollection.Theagencyhasalsofacedmultipleaccusationsthatitdoesnotaccountforallmigrantdeaths.61Inlinewiththesecritiques,thisreportdocumentedmoredeathsinSouthTexasthantheBorderPatrolforfiscalyears2018and2019.ThisalsodoesnotincludethehundredsofRioGrandedrowningdeathswherethebodieswashedintoMexicanterritoryandwerenevercountedinBorderPatrolnumbers.ThesefindingssuggestthatthereisaneedfortheBorderPatroltoprioritizemigrantdeathinformationcollection,outlineagreementswithcountyofficials,andcollectandpublishmoredetaileddata.
● CreateDataSharingAgreementswithTexasSheriffs’Offices.TheBorderPatrolshouldcreatewrittenagreementswithTexassheriffs’officestodetailmigrantdeathinformationsharingpractices.Theseagreementsshouldincludeapubliclyavailable,standardizedmethodologyforidentifyingmigrantdeathsinthecounty,alongwiththestepsthatthe
![Page 35: MIGRANT DEATHS IN SOUTH TEXAS · History of Migrant Deaths in South Texas South Texas has a long history of migrant deaths, corresponding to changes in U.S. immigration and labor](https://reader034.vdocuments.site/reader034/viewer/2022042916/5f554b7ff9302370d4404924/html5/thumbnails/35.jpg)
34
BorderPatrolandcountyofficialsshouldtaketosharethisinformation.Thiscouldincludeprovidingasecured,electronicformforsheriffs’officestofilloutwhentheydiscovermigrantremainsandBorderPatrolagentsarenotpresent.ThesestepswouldallowtheBorderPatroltohavegreaterdemographicinformationondeceasedindividuals.
● Cross-BorderMigrantDeathDataCollection.ThenumbersofdeceasedmigrantsintheBorderPatrol’sdatabaseshouldnotdependontheRioGrande’scurrents.Instead,theBorderPatrolshouldformanagreementwithMexico’sNationalMigrationInstitute(InstitutoNacionaldeMigración,INM)todocumentdrowningdeathsintheRioGrande.WhileINMisnottheagencyinchargeofdocumentingthesedeathsinMexico,itshouldforgeagreementswiththestate-levelagenciestoreceivetheinformation.TheBorderPatrolshouldpublishthisinformationwithitscurrentnumbersofmigrantdeathsbysector.
Sheriffs’Offices.Sheriffs’officesoftengatherthemostdetailedinformationaboutdeceasedmigrantsthroughcrimeorincidentreports.However,onlythreesheriffs’officesinthesurveyedSouthTexascountieshavesystemsinplacetotrackmigrantdeathrecords.Thesesystemsaresimpleandeffective:theBrooksCountySheriff'sOfficestoresmigrantdeathrecordsinbinders.TheKennedyCountySheriff’sOfficenotesthetopouterportionofcasefilesandstorestheminaseparatefilingcabinetshelf.WhileHidalgoCountyappearstohaveanelectronicsystemfortrackingmigrantdeaths.Afterreceivingapublicrecordsrequest,theDuvalCountySheriff'sOfficecreatedanewelectronicsearchcodetotrackmigrantdeathsinitsdatabase.
● Standardizeincidentreportinformation.AcrossSouthTexas,sheriffs’officesdonothaveastandardizedincidentreport.Instead,sheriffs’officesoftenusevarioustemplatesthatchangeovertime.Sheriffs’officesshouldencouragedeputiestostandardizetheirincidentreportsinlinewithbestpractices.Forexample,incidentreportsshouldalwaysattempttoincludeGPScoordinatesforthebodylocation,thediscoveringparty,arecordoftheindividual’sclothingandbelongings,anyavailabledemographicinformation,andclearphotosofthesceneandbelongings.
● Improvetrackingsystemsforelectronicandpaperfiles.Sheriffs’officesshouldcreateinternalsystemsfortrackingbordercrossingdeathsinboththeirelectronicandpaperfiles.Theseimprovementswouldfacilitateeffortstoidentifydeceasedmigrantsandassistcountyofficialswithbudgetingpurposesandwhenapplyingfortargetedgrants.
● IncreasetheUseofNamUs.Sheriffs’officesshoulduploadprofilesofunidentifiedremainstotheNamUsdatabase.Giventhatsheriffs’officepersonnelaretheindividualsdocumentingthesceneandtheindividuals’belongings,theyarewellpositionedtouploadthisinformationintothedatabase.
JusticesofthePeace.Texasstatuterequiresthatjusticesofthepeacekeeptheirinquestrecords.Thelanguagestatesthattherecordsmustincludeareportof“theevents,proceedings,findings,andconclusionsoftheinquest.”62Thereportmustalsocontainacopyoftheautopsyreport,ifperformed,andanyotherpertinentpapers.Despitetheseguidelines,notallinquestreportscontaintherequiredinformation.
● StandardizeInquestFormInformation.Justicesofthepeaceshoulduseastandardizedinquestformtoimproverecordkeeping.Currently,eachcountyhasadifferentsystemforrecordinginquests,andinsomecounties,thesystemmayvaryamongjusticesofthepeace.Justicesofthepeacemayevencreatetheirowninquestreportformuponenteringoffice.CreatingastandardizedformwouldimprovecompliancewithTexasstatuteandstreamlinerecordinspections.
![Page 36: MIGRANT DEATHS IN SOUTH TEXAS · History of Migrant Deaths in South Texas South Texas has a long history of migrant deaths, corresponding to changes in U.S. immigration and labor](https://reader034.vdocuments.site/reader034/viewer/2022042916/5f554b7ff9302370d4404924/html5/thumbnails/36.jpg)
35
2.EnsureAllRemainsPassThroughOfficialBodyIdentificationProcessesSouthTexas’county-levelofficials—includingjusticesofthepeace,medicalexaminers,andfuneralhomes—areresponsibleforprocessingmigrantremainsandensuringthattheycanalleventuallybeidentified.TheseofficialsmayfollowTexasstatute,butthereareareasfordiscretionwithinthisstatute.Whilediscretioncanbuildflexibilityintothelaw,itmayalsohindermigrants’identification.JusticesofthePeace.Justicesofthepeacehavetheauthoritytoorderinvestigativeandlaboratoryteststohelpdetermineadeceasedperson’sidentity.63Thesetestsdifferfromautopsiesandincludetakingfingerprints,recordingdentalrecords,notinguniquetattoos,andtakingx-raysinsearchofidentifyingfractures.Whilethesetestsincreasethelikelihoodofidentifyinganindividual,Texasstatuteprovidesjusticesofthepeacewiththediscretiontoforegothem.64
● MandateInvestigativeandLaboratoryTestsforUnidentifiedRemains.LawmakersshouldamendtheTexasCodeofCriminalProceduretorequirejusticesofthepeacetosendunidentifiedbodiestoaforensicpathologistandunidentifiedskeletalremainstoaforensicanthropologistforinvestigativeandlaboratorytests.Thesetestsshouldbemandatedregardlessofwhetheranautopsyisnecessarytodeterminethenatureandcauseofdeath.
MedicalExaminers/Pathologists.Forensicpathologists—eitherintheirrolesasappointedmedicalexaminersorasprivatecontractors—areoftenresponsiblefortakingaDNAsampleandsendingittoalabforanalysis.DNAanalysismayhelptoidentifyremainswhenotherexaminationsproveinadequate.WhilesomepathologistshavemadeDNAcollectionastandardpractice,itisnotrequired.Instead,TexasstatuteonlynotesthatajusticeofthepeacecanrequestaphysiciancollectaDNAsampleforforensicanalysisandinclusioninCODIS.
● MandateDNATestingforUnidentifiedRemains.LawmakersshouldamendArticle63.056(a)oftheTexasCodeofCriminalProceduretoremovethejusticeofthepeace’sdiscretionaryauthority,andtorequirepathologiststotakeDNAsamplesfromallunidentifiedbodies.Incaseswheretheremainshaveskeletonized,thenewlanguageshouldalsoallowjusticesofthepeacetosubmitthebonesdirectlytotheUNTCHIinlieuofsendingthemtoapathologist.
FuneralHomes.Statelawsareunclear,ifnotcontradictory,oncounties’authoritytocremateunidentifiedremains.TheTexasCodeofCriminalProcedurestatesthat“apersonmaynotcremateordirectthecremation”ofunidentifiedremains.65However,theTexasHealth&HumanSafetycodepermitsthecremationofunidentifiedindividuals’remainswhenauthorizedbyacountycourt.66Thisdiscrepancyshouldbeaddressedtoavoidthecremationofanyunidentifiedindividuals.
● ProhibitCremationsofUnidentifiedRemains.TheTexasHealth&HumanSafetycodeshouldbeamendedtoremovecountyofficials’discretiontocremateunidentifiedremainsandensureitisnotinconflictwiththeTexasCodeofCriminalProcedure.Thiswouldpreservethepossibilityoffutureidentification,evenifpathologistsdidnotfirstcollectbiologicalreferencesamples.Itwouldalsograntmatchedfamiliestheabilitytoviewtheirrelatives’remainstoprovidecertaintyandclosure.67Additionally,religioustraditionsorculturalpracticesmayalsoopposecremation.
![Page 37: MIGRANT DEATHS IN SOUTH TEXAS · History of Migrant Deaths in South Texas South Texas has a long history of migrant deaths, corresponding to changes in U.S. immigration and labor](https://reader034.vdocuments.site/reader034/viewer/2022042916/5f554b7ff9302370d4404924/html5/thumbnails/37.jpg)
36
3.SupportIncreasedFundingforCountiesMostofthecostsofprocessingmigrantdeathsfalltoSouthTexascounties.Someofthesecountiesareamongthestate’smostimpoverished,andthesecostscanputastrainoncountybudgets.AccordingtotheSmallAreaIncomeandPovertyEstimates(SAIPE)ProgramCensusdatafor2018,thepooresteightcountiesinTexaswereamongthosecoveredinthisreport.Intotal,13ofthisreport’s19countiesreportedmorethan25percentpovertyrates.68Migrantdeathprocessingcostscanreachthousandsofdollarsperindividualandcountyofficialsmaynothavetheresourcesorpersonneltoadheretobestpractices.OfficeoftheTexasGovernor.TheOfficeoftheTexasGovernorcanprovidetargetedfundingsupporttocountiesthroughitseGrantprogram.Previously,theOfficeoftheTexasGovernorhasprovidedsupporttotheBrooksCountySheriff'sOfficethroughtheeGrantprogramtohelpcovercostsassociatedwithprocessingmigrantdeaths.
● ProvideeGrantsforCountieswithMigrantDeaths.TheOfficeoftheGovernorshouldopenadditionaleGrantopportunitiesforSouthTexascountieswithhighmigrantdeathnumbers.Thesegrantsshouldtargetsheriffs’officesandjusticesofthepeace.Thefundingcouldbeprovidedasareimbursementforcostsorcouldbeearmarkedforspecificactivitiesinthefuture,suchaspersonnelhours,autopsies,andlaboratorytests.Theycouldalsocoverthecostofhiringadditionalstafforworkingovertimetodigitizeorscanrecordsandmodernizethesecounties’recordsystems.Overall,stategrantswouldprovideSouthTexascountieswithanincentivetoimprovetheirpracticesandhelpreducethefinancialstrainofprocessingmigrantdeaths.
![Page 38: MIGRANT DEATHS IN SOUTH TEXAS · History of Migrant Deaths in South Texas South Texas has a long history of migrant deaths, corresponding to changes in U.S. immigration and labor](https://reader034.vdocuments.site/reader034/viewer/2022042916/5f554b7ff9302370d4404924/html5/thumbnails/38.jpg)
37
AppendixAppendixA:
Table3:SouthTexasCountiesByBorderPatrolEnforcementSector
RioGrandeValleySector LaredoSector DelRioSector
BrooksCounty JimHoggCounty DimmitCounty
CameronCounty LaSalleCounty EdwardsCounty
HidalgoCounty WebbCounty KinneyCounty
KenedyCounty DuvalCounty MaverickCounty
KlebergCounty ZapataCounty UvaldeCounty
StarrCounty ValVerdeCounty
WillacyCounty ZavalaCounty
![Page 39: MIGRANT DEATHS IN SOUTH TEXAS · History of Migrant Deaths in South Texas South Texas has a long history of migrant deaths, corresponding to changes in U.S. immigration and labor](https://reader034.vdocuments.site/reader034/viewer/2022042916/5f554b7ff9302370d4404924/html5/thumbnails/39.jpg)
38
AppendixB:
Table4:RecordsObtainedbySource(2012-2019) 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
BrooksCountySheriff'sOffice 130 87 61 48 61 52 50 15
CameronCountySheriff'sOffice 1
DimmitCountySheriff'sOffice 4 4 2 4 4 1 4
DuvalCountySheriff'sOffice 12 2 7 1 2 1 2 7
HidalgoCountySheriff'sOffice 21 29 30 16 28 18 34 16
IOMData 3 13 18 24 25
JimHoggCountySheriff'sOffice 4 4 1 3 5
KenedyCountySheriff'sOffice 4 12 13 9 23 10 13 9
KinneyCountyJusticeofthePeace 3 2 1 3 1
KlebergCountySheriff'sOffice 2 2 1 2
LaSalleCountySheriff'sOffice 1 1 1
MaverickCountyJusticeofthePeace1 2 1 1 1 5
MaverickCountyJusticeofthePeace2 8 5 6 3 6 5 2
MaverickCountyJusticeofthePeace3-2 8 4 2 1 1 12
MaverickCountyJusticeofthePeace3.1 1 1 1 2 1 1 2
MaverickCountyJusticeofthePeace4 2 1 1 1 2
MaverickCountySheriff'sOffice 1 6 5 2 3
StarrCountySheriff'sOffice 9 4 3 1 9 9
TexasVitalStatistics 4 4 4 3 1 1 3
TexasTransnationalIntelligenceCenter 23
ValVerdeCountyJusticeofthePeace4 3 1 2 3
ValVerdeJusticeofthePeace1 1 1
WebbCountyMedicalExaminer 31 36 39 41 42 48 55 59
ZapataCountySheriff'sOffice 2 3 1
Total 236 194 180 140 197 181 197 194
![Page 40: MIGRANT DEATHS IN SOUTH TEXAS · History of Migrant Deaths in South Texas South Texas has a long history of migrant deaths, corresponding to changes in U.S. immigration and labor](https://reader034.vdocuments.site/reader034/viewer/2022042916/5f554b7ff9302370d4404924/html5/thumbnails/40.jpg)
39
AppendixC:
Table5:RecordsObtainedbyCounty(2012-2019)
2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 Total
Brooks 130 87 61 48 61 52 50 46 535
Cameron 2 2 2 4 3 2 3 1 19
Dimmit 4 4 2 4 4 1 7 26
Duval 12 2 7 1 2 1 3 7 35
Edwards 0
Hidalgo 22 31 32 17 29 21 38 17 207
JimHogg 5 4 3 6 5 23
Kenedy 4 12 13 9 23 11 15 9 96
Kinney 3 2 1 3 1 1 11
Kleberg 2 2 1 1 1 1 2 10
LaSalle 1 1 2 2 1 7
Maverick 13 13 9 11 18 17 16 32 129
Starr 9 4 3 1 10 9 2 2 40
Uvalde 1 1
ValVerde 4 1 1 2 4 6 18
Webb 31 36 39 41 42 48 55 59 351
Willacy 0
Zavala 0
Zapata 2 3 1 4 1 11
Total 236 194 180 140 197 182 197 193 1519
![Page 41: MIGRANT DEATHS IN SOUTH TEXAS · History of Migrant Deaths in South Texas South Texas has a long history of migrant deaths, corresponding to changes in U.S. immigration and labor](https://reader034.vdocuments.site/reader034/viewer/2022042916/5f554b7ff9302370d4404924/html5/thumbnails/41.jpg)
40
AppendixD:
Table6:DeathsbyNationality(2012-2019)
2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 Total
Belize 1 1
Brazil 1 1 1 3
Colombia 1 2 3
CostaRica 1 1
DominicanRepublic 1 1 1 3
Ecuador 1 1 2 1 1 1 2 9
ElSalvador 22 19 21 14 14 11 10 6 117
Guatemala 9 18 21 7 21 12 21 3 112
Honduras 12 14 7 2 8 6 14 14 77
Mexico 44 39 35 28 44 27 25 31 273
Nicaragua 1 1 2 1 1 1 7
Peru 1 1
Unknown 146 99 91 85 108 124 123 136 912
Total 236 194 180 140 197 182 197 193 1519
![Page 42: MIGRANT DEATHS IN SOUTH TEXAS · History of Migrant Deaths in South Texas South Texas has a long history of migrant deaths, corresponding to changes in U.S. immigration and labor](https://reader034.vdocuments.site/reader034/viewer/2022042916/5f554b7ff9302370d4404924/html5/thumbnails/42.jpg)
41
AppendixE:
Table7:FemaleDeathsbyCounty(2012-2019)
2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 Total
Brooks 23 21 19 4 5 6 5 5 88
Cameron 1 1 1 3
Dimmit 0
Duval 1 1 1 3
Edwards 0
Hidalgo 1 3 1 2 5 1 2 15
JimHogg 1 1 2 4
Kenedy 2 1 2 5 3 1 14
Kinney 0
Kleberg 1 1
LaSalle 0
Maverick 3 2 2 7
Starr 1 1 1 1 2 2 8
Uvalde 0
ValVerde 2 2
Webb 0
Willacy 0
Zavala 0
Zapata 0
Total 31 30 23 8 14 16 9 14 145
![Page 43: MIGRANT DEATHS IN SOUTH TEXAS · History of Migrant Deaths in South Texas South Texas has a long history of migrant deaths, corresponding to changes in U.S. immigration and labor](https://reader034.vdocuments.site/reader034/viewer/2022042916/5f554b7ff9302370d4404924/html5/thumbnails/43.jpg)
42
Table8:MaleDeathsbyCounty(2012-2019) 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 Total
Brooks 74 48 30 26 43 26 31 10 288
Cameron 1 1 2 3 3 2 1 13
Dimmit 1 4 5
Duval 6 2 4 2 1 6 21
Edwards 0
Hidalgo 19 28 31 17 26 16 34 15 186
JimHogg 3 2 3 2 10
Kenedy 2 8 11 5 16 10 10 5 67
Kinney 3 2 1 3 1 1 11
Kleberg 1 1 1 1 4
LaSalle 1 1 1 3
Maverick 7 10 7 9 15 13 8 25 94
Starr 7 3 1 8 5 1 2 27
Uvalde 1 1
ValVerde 3 1 1 1 2 4 12
Webb 0
Willacy 0
Zavala 0
Zapata 2 3 1 1 7
Total 125 103 92 64 116 79 94 76 749
![Page 44: MIGRANT DEATHS IN SOUTH TEXAS · History of Migrant Deaths in South Texas South Texas has a long history of migrant deaths, corresponding to changes in U.S. immigration and labor](https://reader034.vdocuments.site/reader034/viewer/2022042916/5f554b7ff9302370d4404924/html5/thumbnails/44.jpg)
43
AppendixF:Table9:MexicanGovernmentCostsAssociatedwithBorderCrossingDeaths(PerDecedent)
Service InvolvedActors CostBreakdown Approximate
Cost PaidBy
Consularmissingpersonsassistance
Foreignconsulate
Personneltime:Communicationwithfamilies,BorderPatrol,andMedicalexaminer;openingmissingpersonscase;DNAsamplingcoordination(4hours)ii69
$60jj70 Foreigngovernment
CremationConsulate,privatefuneralhomes,county
$1,095
Foreigngovernment,decedent’sfamily
Repatriationofremains
Consulate;Transportationagencies(e.g.airlinesortruckingcompany);privatefuneralhomes
Airorlandtransport,personneltime(10hours),equipment
$135to$4,63571
Foreigngovernment(Mexicangovernmentcoversupto$1,550perdecedent),decedent’sfamilykk72
iiThishourlybreakdownprovidesanestimateoftimespentfillingoutformsandcommunicatingwithfamilies,amongotheractivities.ThisreflectstheMexicangovernment’scostsandmaynotreflectthepracticesofotherforeigngovernments.jjThisreflectstheMexicangovernment’scostestimatesandmaynotreflectthepoliciesofotherforeigngovernments.kkAlthoughsomeCentralAmericancountrieshavealsosetupfundstoassistfamilieswithrepatriationcosts,reportssuggestthatfewfamiliesreceivethisassistance.InElSalvador,forexample,familiesreportedthatpublicofficialsvisitedtheirhomestodetermineiftheywerefinanciallyabletoshoulderrepatriationcosts.Accordingtothefamilies,theseofficialssuggestedtheyselltheircarsorgethomemortgagestopayforthereturnoftheirrelative’sremains.
![Page 45: MIGRANT DEATHS IN SOUTH TEXAS · History of Migrant Deaths in South Texas South Texas has a long history of migrant deaths, corresponding to changes in U.S. immigration and labor](https://reader034.vdocuments.site/reader034/viewer/2022042916/5f554b7ff9302370d4404924/html5/thumbnails/45.jpg)
44
Endnotes
1M.KatherineSpradley,NicholasP.Herrmann,CourtneySieger&ChloeP.McDaneld,“IdentifyingmigrantremainsinSouthTexas:policyandpractice,”ForensicSciencesResearch,4:1,October29,2018.2DavidSpener,ClandestineCrossing:MigrantsandCoyotesontheTexas-MexicoBorder(Ithaca,CornellUniversityPress,2009).3Ibid.4“MexicanInfluxReported,”NewYorkTimes,July23,1949,https://timesmachine.nytimes.com/timesmachine/1949/07/24/84274923.html?pageNumber=7.5AlbertSteinberg,“Humane‘Villains’:TheU.S.BorderPatrolhaltsillegalmigrantsbythemillion--butwithallpossiblekindness,”NewYorkTimes,October8,1950,https://timesmachine.nytimes.com/timesmachine/1950/10/08/86467378.pdf.6 Spener,2009. 7 Ibid. 8U.S.Congress,House,ImmigrationReformandControlActof1986,99thCongress,https://www.congress.gov/bill/99th-congress/senate-bill/1200.9U.S.Congress,House,IllegalImmigrationReformandImmigrantResponsibilityActof1996,104thCongress,2dSession,https://www.congress.gov/104/crpt/hrpt828/CRPT-104hrpt828.pdf.10“BorderControl:RevisedStrategyisShowingSomePositiveResults,”U.S.GovernmentAccountingOffice,December1994,https://www.gao.gov/archive/1995/gg9530.pdf.11“IllegalImmigration:Border-CrossingDeathsHaveDoubledSince1995;BorderPatrol’sEffortstoPreventDeathsHaveNotBeenFullyEvaluated,”GovernmentAccountabilityOffice,August2006,https://www.gao.gov/new.items/d06770.pdf;KarlEschbach,JacquelineHagan,NestorRodriguez,RubénHernándezLéon,StanleyBailey,“DeathattheBorder,”TheInternationalMigrationReview,Vol33,No2,1989,430-454.12“SearchandRescueEffortsforFY2016,”U.S.DepartmentofHomelandSecurity,May23,2017,https://www.dhs.gov/sites/default/files/publications/CBP%20-%20Search%20and%20Rescue%20Efforts%20for%202016.pdf;GovernmentAccountabilityOffice,2006,p.11.13GovernmentAccountabilityOffice,2006.14BobOrtega,“BorderPatrolfailedtocounthundredsofmigrantdeathsonUSsoil,”CNN,May15,2018,https://www.cnn.com/2018/05/14/us/border-patrol-migrant-death-count-invs/index.html.15 Interview,KinneyCountySheriff. 16“Texas’BrooksCountyis‘DeathValley’formigrants,”NBCNews,July9,2014,https://www.nbcnews.com/storyline/immigration-border-crisis/texas-brooks-county-death-valley-migrants-n152121.17 U.S.DepartmentofHomelandSecurity,2017. 18DavidB.Brooks,“GuidetoTexasLawsforCountyOfficials,”TexasAssociationofCounties,2018.19TexasCodeofCriminalProcedure§49.01(2).20JusticesofthePeaceandConstablesAssociationofTexas,“Inquests,”TexasJusticeCourtTrainingCenter,2018,p.1. 21TexasCodeofCriminalProcedure§49.10(c);TexasCodeofCriminalProcedure§49.10(i).22 TexasCodeofCriminalProcedure§49.10(g)&(h). 23Ortega,2018.24TexasCodeofCriminalProcedure§49.10(k),(l)&(n).25 Ibid(n). 26TexasCodeofCriminalProcedure§49.15(a).27Ibid.28TexasGovernmentCode§27.004(a).29TexasHealth&SafetyCode§711.002(a-1);TexasAdministrativeCode,Title25,Part1§181.4. 30Interview,SunsetMemorialFuneralHome.31 TexasHealth&SafetyCode§694.002(a). 32 TexasHealth&SafetyCode§193.009;TexasCodeofCriminalProcedure§49.25,Sec.10b.
![Page 46: MIGRANT DEATHS IN SOUTH TEXAS · History of Migrant Deaths in South Texas South Texas has a long history of migrant deaths, corresponding to changes in U.S. immigration and labor](https://reader034.vdocuments.site/reader034/viewer/2022042916/5f554b7ff9302370d4404924/html5/thumbnails/46.jpg)
45
33 TexasCodeofCriminalProcedure§49.09(e). 34Ibid;TexasHealth&SafetyCode§711.002(a);TexasHealth&SafetyCode§716.101. 35 TexasHealth&SafetyCode§716.101.36TexasCodeofCriminalProcedure§49.25,Sec.1.37TexasJusticeCourtTrainingCenter,2018.38TexasCodeofCriminalProcedure§49.25,Sec.1239 RudyMaya,“WebbCountyMedicalExaminerexplainsbodytransferprocess,”KGNS,June21,2019,https://www.kgns.tv/content/news/Webb-County-Medical-Examiner-explains-body-transfer-process-511632931.html.40Spradleyetal.,2018.41Ortega,2018.42Spradleyetal.,2018. 43 Ibid;Ortega,2018. 44 Spradleyetal.,2018. 45 Ibid. 46 Ibid. 47 Ibid. 48 Ibid. 49 U.S.DepartmentofHomelandSecurity,2017. 50 Ibid. 51Interviews,sheriffs’offices.52Interview,EaglePassFireDepartmentchief.53Interview,ValVerdeCountyjusticeofthepeace.54 Ibid.55InterviewSunsetMemorialFuneralHomedirector;BudgetprovidedbytheBrooksCountySheriff’sOffice.56 Inquestrecordreviews;BudgetprovidedbytheBrooksCountySheriff’sOffice;FeeschedulepostedontheBexarCountyMedicalExaminer’sOfficewebsite. 57FeeschedulepostedontheBexarCountyMedicalExaminer’sOfficewebsite;Interview,WebbCountypublicinformationoffice.58Interview,BexarCountyMedicalExaminer;BudgetprovidedbytheBrooksCountySheriff’sOffice.59Interview,SunsetMemorialFuneralHomedirector.60MissingPersonsandUnidentifiedRemainsActof2018,U.S.HouseofRepresentatives,115thCongress,2ndSession,https://www.congress.gov/bill/115th-congress/house-bill/7218/text.61 GovernmentAccountabilityOffice,2006;Ortega,2018. 62 TexasCodeofCriminalProcedure§49.15(a). 63TexasCodeofCriminalProcedure§49.10(l)&(m).64Ibid.(k).65 TexasCodeofCriminalProcedure§49.09(e). 66TexasHealth&SafetyCode§716.101.67Spradleyetal.,2018.;Boss,Pauline.“AmbiguousLossintheFamiliesoftheMissing,”Lancet,vol.360,no.9350,December2002.68“SmallAreaIncomeandPovertyEstimatesProgram,”U.S.CensusBureau,2018,accessedMay12,2020,https://www.census.gov/programs-surveys/saipe.html.69 Interview,formerMexicanconsularofficial.70Ibid.71 Ibid.72 “EmptyPromises:GapsinElSalvador’sLegalFrameworkAddressingMigrantDisappearances,”BostonUniversitySchoolofLaw’sInternationalHumanRightsClinic,Medium,July1,2019,https://medium.com/@BUSLAHR/empty-promises-gaps-in-el-salvadors-legal-framework-addressing-migrant-disappearances-555efba06e0b.