Download - Leadership in sport
1
A sport group is merely the collection of a number of
individuals and the leader is the most dominant individual
Richard FryerMSc Sport & Exercise Psychology
2012
2
What am I going to conclude?
There has been too much focus on ‘The Coach’as being ‘The Leader’ and this seems to be an
oversimplification of what happens in sports groups.
More emphasis needs to be placed on the group andsituational or contextual factors
Distributed leadership offers some useful ideasabout where research could be focused in the future
1
2
3
3
What is a group?
• A group comprises one or more people, involves interaction between people, demands an awareness of some form of common fate or goals, has a specific structure known to all members, and group norms.
– Hagger & Chatzisarantis (2005)
4
What is leadership?
• Some definitions are about leadership as a directive role i.e.– The behaviour of an individual while he is involved in
directing group activities (Hemphill, 1949)
• Others define leadership as a social process i.e.– Leadership is a process of social influence in which
one person is able to enlist the aid and support of others in the accomplishment of a common task (Chemers, 1997)
5
Is there a clear definition?
• Leadership as a concept has been researched and written about for generations.
• There still is no clear agreement or consensus about what it is or how to define ‘it’.
6
Some common ground…
• Leadership seems to be required when individuals and/or groups have goals to achieve.
• Leadership seems to be about assisting in the pursuit of these goals, particularly through decision-making.
• Leadership theory and group theory appear to be very closely related.
• Leadership is therefore still a relevant topic for the sporting domain.
7
What is it we want from individuals and/or groups in sport?
PERFORMANCE*OUTCOMES
* However this is defined e.g. winning, personal best
8
A conceptual framework for the study of sport groups
GroupStructure
GroupCohesion
GroupProcesses
MemberAttributes
GroupEnvironment
IndividualOutcomes
TeamOutcomes
Carron & Hausenblas (1998)
Leadership relatedfactors
L
L L
9
Team cohesion = better performance(or is that: better performance = team cohesion?)
10
Factors influencing cohesion
Personal
Team
Leadership
Environmental
Carron (1982)
11
The transformational leader
• Instils pride• Encourages members to go above and beyond• Promotes confidence in ability to achieve goals• Research mostly limited to individual followers rather
than teams – can create disproportional team conflict
InspirationalMotivation
IntellectualStimulation
IndividualisedConsideration
Bass & Avolio (1994)
IdealizedInfluence
12
Transformational leaders in sport(The ‘Supercoach’)
Jose Mourinho Wayne Bennett Vince Lombardi
Graham Henry Alex Ferguson Jurgen Grobler
Football RugbyLeague
AmericanFootball
RugbyUnion
FootballRowing
13
Multidimensional Model of Leadership (Chelladurai, 1990)
The MML proposes that group performance and member satisfaction are
dependent upon the congruency of required, preferred, and perceived
leader behaviours
REQUIREDBEHAVIOUR
OF SITUATION
COACHESPREFERREDBEHAVIOUR
COACHESPERCEIVEDBEHAVIOUR
Balanceof all 3
= satisfaction= performance
Antecedents
Characteristicsof the:
- Situation- Leader- Members ofthe group
14
Transformational leadership skills for coaches (Chelladurai, 2007)
• Creating a vision• Engaging in inspiring communication• Individualising communication• Knowing when to be demanding and directive
15
Is the role of the coach overstated?
16
Trapdoors and Honeymoons
Tottenham Hotspur FC1992 – 2008
17
Did this only happen at Spurs?
All Premier League Football Clubs1992 – 2008
18
Challenging the ‘single leader’ assumption
Leadership is asingle-handed,
heroic performancethat is the property
of the individual
Leadership issocially-constructedwith followers in a
context
Sinclair (2007)
19
Who is the leader?GB Rowing Example
Team DirectorDavid Tanner
AthleteGreg Searle
Men’s coachJurgen Grobler
Eight’s coachMark Banks Eight’s stroke
Dan RitchieEight’s coxPhelan Hill
20
Who is the leader?
Coach
AthleteLeadership
Manager
Captain
Many people providing leadershipwhen required. Not just one leader
21
Distributed Leadership
• Wide range of individuals and groups are brought into leadership (not just one coach).
• Leadership practice is though of as a product of the interactions of leaders, followers and situations
• This, therefore, is an interactive, rather than leader-based perspective
• Early days – little empirical evidence
Spillane (2005)
22
Is a sport group merely the collection of a number of individuals and the leader the most
dominant individual?
• The idea of there being a single leader of a sport group seems to be an oversimplification.
• The importance of the coach is perhaps overstated at the expense of contextual factors such as available resources.
• Leadership may be more helpfully thought of as being distributed across many individuals within a sport group.
It doesn’t appear so