Joint Information Systems Committee
Stephen BaileyRecords Manager, JISC
Is there more to ERM than an EDRMS?
Joint Information Systems Committee 31/03/2006 | Supporting education and research | Slide 2Joint Information Systems Committee Supporting education and research
Selecting an ERM System Is there more to ERM than an ERMS?
Joint Information Systems Committee
Is there more to ERM than an ERMS?
Lancaster University, 10th May 2006 Steve BaileyRecords & Information ManagerJISC Executive
02/12/2005 | Supporting education and research | Slide 3
Joint Information Systems Committee 31/03/2006 | Supporting education and research | Slide 4
YES
The end
Joint Information Systems Committee 31/03/2006 | Supporting education and research | Slide 5
A bit more detail…
‘Selecting an Electronic Records Management System’
The assumption being:
– You are already sure it is the right technology for your institution to solve your most pressing RM issues
– The only decision is which to choose…
Time for a sanity check
– As an ‘Enterprise Content Mgt System’ this represents one of the biggest IT projects your institution will ever embark upon
– Implementation costs of several £100K
– Ongoing costs of several £10K per annum
– Will dominate your working day forever more
– Will change the way every member of staff works
Worth asking vendors and yourself an awkward question or two first…
Joint Information Systems Committee 31/03/2006 | Supporting education and research | Slide 6
Some (awkward?) questions
What are your motivations for wanting an EDRM?
What is the scope of the project going to be?
How do your users feel about it?
Have you considered the true costs, and will you ever achieve an ROI?
Have you considered alternative approaches?
Joint Information Systems Committee 31/03/2006 | Supporting education and research | Slide 7
But first…
Aristotle (384 – 322 BC) Copernicus (1473-1543)
Joint Information Systems Committee 31/03/2006 | Supporting education and research | Slide 8
Motivations
Straw poll
We are going to implement an EDRM because…
Senior management have identified the need for one
Our IT strategy has identified the need for one
Administrative staff have identified the need for one
Academic staff have identified the need for one
It will solve our most pressing information/records management issues
A consultant/vendor has said we need one
Everyone else seems to want one / be getting one
Joint Information Systems Committee 31/03/2006 | Supporting education and research | Slide 9
Motivations
At all times consider the institutional perspective
– If done properly an EDRM should impact on every function, every user and every system in the institution
– This is not just a professional tool to help you perform your role with a local impact only
– If that is all you want, you are buying a sledgehammer to crack a nut
What are your institution’s real information management priorities?
– Strategic goals, operating plans, vision statements, minutes of SMT
– Will an EDRM really make a contribution to achieving any of them?
“ah, but its my role as Records Manager to tell them this is a priority”
– Yes, but see above…
Joint Information Systems Committee 31/03/2006 | Supporting education and research | Slide 10
Scope
Straw poll
How many of your institutions are planning or implementing…
an institutional repository?
a new web content management system?
a new intranet or other collaborative tool?
a new student records system?
a new finance system?
How many of you…
Have no way of knowing
Joint Information Systems Committee 31/03/2006 | Supporting education and research | Slide 11
Scope
If this is to be a truly enterprise-wide ERMS
– Have you consulted widely enough with all relevant system owners/project teams?
– Are you clear on how your EDRM is going to integrate with these systems?
• Technically
• Functionally
• Politically
– If not, what is to stop your EDRM system becoming yet another silo of information and worse still, one with no organisational support or clear business purpose?
Joint Information Systems Committee 31/03/2006 | Supporting education and research | Slide 12
Scope
What about integration with your line of business applications?
– “too difficult” - “too expensive”
– “Maybe in phase 2” - “We don’t have anything to do with them”
– “But they don’t contain records” - “I don’t think we have any”
LoB applications are the lifeblood of your institution
They often contain mission-critical information and records
Little/no consideration is often paid to their information mgt functionality
Huge duplication of data & inconsistency of management controls
Ask your Head of finance which he would rather save in a fire: his finance system, or the network drive
Ignore them at your peril…
Joint Information Systems Committee 31/03/2006 | Supporting education and research | Slide 13
Scope & Users
Okay, lets stick to documents and records for now…
Average of 4000+ staff per institution
Are you going to roll out to all 4000+?
– Licence costs, training, support, quality control, upgrades, coronary, suicide…
Or are you only going to rollout to selected staff e.g. local and central admin staff?
– Much more manageable… but what happens to the rest
Your Enterprise Content Management System is now only managing a small percentage of the information created by an even smaller number of users
– But at considerable cost…
What about all those promises of organisation-wide retrieval & management of assets your project was founded on?
Joint Information Systems Committee 31/03/2006 | Supporting education and research | Slide 14
Users
Okay, lets assume you are eventually going to roll it out to everyone
Straw poll
Which of these best sums up your experience of working with academics on records management or compliance issues?
Always keen to be involved, adopt new ways of working and comply with new procedures
It’s a real struggle, but eventually they fall into line & do what’s required
It’s a nightmare. They are not at all interested, ignore what we say and carry on regardless
Why should they view an ERMS any differently?
Joint Information Systems Committee 31/03/2006 | Supporting education and research | Slide 15
Costs and resources
I’ll leave you to find out the facts and figures of licences etc etc
Lets take a look at hidden resource implications
– Who is going to keep doing the ‘day job’ whilst you are involved with this?
– This is a project without end
• who is going to continue to maintain it?
• What impact will continued licence costs have on your budgets?
– What guarantees do you have of access to additional internal resources
• IT staff
• Departmental co-ordinators etc
Joint Information Systems Committee 31/03/2006 | Supporting education and research | Slide 16
Alternatives
Not suggesting any are the answer, just that they should be considered:
‘Traditional’ records management software
– Management of physical (& electronic) assets + record centre operations
Workflow software
– Focus on improving the processes which create information & records
Open standard’s based ‘glue’ to co-ordinate & manage LoB applications
– A key focus of the JISC e-administration agenda
MS Office 2007
– “the next version of the Office system (will be) a tool to help companies solve their records management problems” – MS Blog April 06
Joint Information Systems Committee 31/03/2006 | Supporting education and research | Slide 17
So where does this leave us?
Forget the technology and think carefully about your requirements
– As a records manager
– As an institution
Consult as widely as possible – with an open mind
Think carefully about the scope of your proposed system – particularly from the institutional perspective
– Do you need an enterprise wide system?
– Can you realistically achieve & maintain an enterprise wide system?
If not, where does that leave you?
– Be clear about what your objectives are & think carefully about how you will demonstrate success and ROI
– Are there more proportionate alternatives you could/should consider?
If in doubt, go see an institution who has achieved it already
– And draw your own conclusions if you can’t find one…
Joint Information Systems Committee 31/03/2006 | Supporting education and research | Slide 18
Thank You
Steve [email protected]
Joint Information Systems Committee
A one-day event for Higher Education10th May 2006
The Conference Centre, Lancaster University
Selecting an Electronic Records Management System