Introducing Trans-Domain Proposals pilot procedure
Christer Halen Senior Administrator of Science OperationsMafalda Quintas and Giuseppe Lugano
Science Officers
IGLO - Brussels, 13 March 2013
2
Submission to a COST Domain - timeline (ex: n° proposals in collection 2012-1)
MONTH 1 MONTH 2 MONTH 3 MONTH 4 MONTH 5 MONTH 6 MONTH 7 MONTH 8
Collection of Preliminary Proposals (612)
Eligibility check & Domain allocation (593)
Domain Committee assessment (116)
deadline Full Proposal (115)
External experts assessment (77)
Domain Committee Hearings (final list)
Approval CSOJAF
Preparation of Full Proposal
Preparation of MoU
3
Overview COST Open Call for Proposals
Trans-Domain Proposals (TDP)
Introducing TDP Pilot Motivations and Key Features Process and Calendar Proposal Registration, Submission and Evaluation
4
COST Open Call Bottom-up implementation of new COST Actions
No pre-set topics and priorities Trans-nationality, transparency, fairness, equality of treatment
Submission of proposals on a continuous basis Two collection dates / year (March and September) Announced in the Official Journal of the European Union
Science and Technology-Driven Evaluation Process Peer-review: at least three evaluators per proposal Domain Committees in charge of evaluation and quality control,
supported by Science Officers ~ 7% success rate
Motivations for a Pilot TDP Evaluation Procedure
Need to better respond to the needs of growing trans-disciplinary research communities
Lighter and faster evaluation procedure so as to give quick answer to proposers
Opportunity to allow COST to adapt and contribute to ERA goals
Preparing integrated procedures for proposal evaluation, Action monitoring and impact assessment
7
8
TDP Pilot Key Features 1. Revised evaluation criteria and proposal template, enabling
clearer description, evaluation and implementation of Action objectives, added value of networking, and COST activities through which such objectives will be pursued
2. Shortened evaluation process (time gain: ~1,5 months) replacing the current two-proposal scheme with a one-proposal scheme (10-15 pages)
3. Efficient expert selection and allocation through newly developed Expertise Grid and Expert Database
4. Clearer description of the process through detailed Guidelines for Proposers and Evaluators
9
TDP Pilot Proposal Template
More concise proposal without loss of meaningful information, easier for both proposers and evaluators
TDP Pilot Proposal TemplateA. Scientific and Technological Challenge
B. Added Value of Networking
C. Milestones and Deliverables – Contents and Timeframes
D. Action Structure and Participation
(Optional) References
Total length: ~ 10 – 15 pages
10
New Challenges: Expert Identification
Proposal Registration (Deadline 29.3)
Mandatory step not part of the evaluation itself, used for a timely selection of experts
The Proposal is registered via e-COST to improve interaction and user-friendliness
What is registered: Proposal Title, Acronym Initial idea: short abstract (up to 250 words) Areas of Expertise Needed for Evaluation: from a pre-
defined multi-layered list of expertise areas
11
COST Experts Database – Newly Developed Used for a timely identification of relevant experts
Algorithm matching areas of expertise required by the proposal and
experts with relevant expertise
Used in all steps of the evaluation procedure
As of 15/02/2013: ~ 6000 registered experts (89% from COST Countries)
All COST Countries represented
Gender balance: 63% male, 37% female experts
Early Stage Researchers (PhD+ 8 years): 25%
Additional effort needed in covering all Research Areas
New Challenges: Expert Identification
12
Proposal Evaluation 1st step “Challenge Selection”:
External experts evaluate remotely the scientific and technological soundness and timeliness for which networking provides a clear added benefit to address the challenge
2nd step “Implementation Plan”: DC Members and DC Experts evaluate remotely the coherence and
feasibility of the implementation plan supporting COST mission and criteria TDP Panel prepares consensus reports at a dedicated meeting
TDP Panel Hearings: TDP Panel and DC Chairs evaluate leadership potential, motivation and
drive, organisational and communication skills of the invited proposers
13
Proposal Evaluation CriteriaType ID TitleSection A A.1 Features of the ChallengeCriterion 1 A.1.1 State of the ArtCriterion 2 A.1.2 Relevance and TimelinessCriterion 3 A.1.3 Challenge FeasibilitySection A A.2 Type of ImpactCriterion 4 A.2.1 Risk LevelCriterion 5 A.2.2 Scientific versus Societal ImpactCriterion 6 A.2.3 TimeframeSection B B Added Value of NetworkingCriterion 7 B.1 In Relation to the ChallengeCriterion 8 B.2 In Relation to Existing EffortsSection C C Suitability for COSTCriterion 9 C.1 AnonymityCriterion 10 C.2 Scope for COST ActionsCriterion 11 C.3 Action Structure SuitabilityCriterion 12 C.4 Feasibility of ActivitiesSection D D Foreseen ParticipationCriterion 13 D.1 Network of ProposersCriterion 14 D.2 Plans to Involve Relevant Participants
COST enables break-through scientific developments leading to new concepts and products and thereby contributes to strengthen Europe’s research and innovation capacities.
COST is a unique means for European researchers to jointly develop their own ideas and new initiatives across all scientific disciplines through trans-European networking of nationally funded research activities.
14
TDP Pilot - timeline Submissions to Trans-Domain Proposals
MONTH 1 MONTH 2 MONTH 3 MONTH 4 MONTH 5 MONTH 6 MONTH 7 MONTH 8
March 29th closing of
registrations
June 14th Collection
Step 1 - Challenge selection:External experts evaluation
Step 2 - Implementation Plan: TDP Panel
Approval CSOJAF
Preparation of Proposal
Preparation of MoU
TDP Panel Hearings (final list)
15
New e-COST Tools: Proposal Registration(Deadline 29.3)
16
New e-COST Tools: Proposal Submission(Collection Date: 14.6)
17
Proposer 1 University of Berne
Dr. Proposer 1 (University of Berne)
Invitation tool allows proposers to interact and COST to monitor the growth of the network of proposers
New e-COST Tools: Network of Proposers
At least 5 Proposers (1 Main Proposer, 4 Secondary Proposers) affiliated with legal entities based in at least 5 different COST Member Countries or Cooperating State
18
New e-COST Tools: Evaluation
19
Practicalities• Proposal Registration
• Proposal Submission
• COST Experts database
Deadline: March 29th at 5pm Mandatory – registration after this date: proposal will only be
evaluated next Collection Date (OC2013-2)
Deadline: June 14th at 5pm
Always Open: Disseminate the opportunity to researchers in your country
20
For Further Information TDP page http://www.cost.eu/domains_actions/TDP
Open Call Guidelines for TDP Pilothttp://www.cost.eu/download/TDPguidelines
e-COST (creation of user profile, proposal registration and submission)https://e-services.cost.eu
COST Experts pagehttp://www.cost.eu/participate/experts
21
For Further Information TDP Science Officers
We are available to support researchers in your country with any question regarding the TDP Pilot:
• Dr Giuseppe Lugano Tel. +32 (0) 2 533 3822 [email protected]
• Dr Mafalda Quintas Tel. +32 (0) 2 533 3834 [email protected]
www.cost.euDr. Mafalda QuintasScience OfficerCOST OfficeAvenue Louise 1491050 Brussels, BelgiumT: +32 (0)2 533 3822F: +32 (0)2 533 [email protected]
Thank you!