![Page 1: Final Report ASSESSMENT · SafeTech Solutions is an EMS consulting firm with extensive expertise evaluating EMS organizations and assisting in the development of rural ambulance services](https://reader036.vdocuments.site/reader036/viewer/2022081613/5fb8596b1cbe0049666cd917/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
Contact: Aarron Reinert, Partner
29251 Potassium Street NW • Isanti, MN 55040 | Tel 651.248.4239
[email protected] • www.safetechsolutions.us
Final Report
ASSESSMENT OF
EMERGENCY MEDICAL SERVICES IN
SUBLETTE COUNTY, WYOMING
June 2016
![Page 2: Final Report ASSESSMENT · SafeTech Solutions is an EMS consulting firm with extensive expertise evaluating EMS organizations and assisting in the development of rural ambulance services](https://reader036.vdocuments.site/reader036/viewer/2022081613/5fb8596b1cbe0049666cd917/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
2
Table of Contents
ExecutiveSummary 3I. Introduction&AssessmentMethodology 6II. OverviewofSubletteCounty 7III. OverviewoftheEMSSysteminSubletteCounty 12IV. DescriptionofSubletteCountyEMS 16 V. KeyObservations 21 VI. Recommendations 32AppendixA:WhatisCommunityParamedicine?
![Page 3: Final Report ASSESSMENT · SafeTech Solutions is an EMS consulting firm with extensive expertise evaluating EMS organizations and assisting in the development of rural ambulance services](https://reader036.vdocuments.site/reader036/viewer/2022081613/5fb8596b1cbe0049666cd917/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
3
Executive Summary SafeTechSolutionsspentthreemonthsinthespringandsummerof2016studyingtheEMSsysteminSubletteCounty,Wyoming.Thisstudyfocusedonthelong‐termsustainabilityandreliabilityofSubletteCountyEMS.Thestudyincludedasitevisit;approximately20interviewswithkeystakeholders;extensiveresearchaboutSubletteCounty,theSubletteCountyRuralHealthCareDistrictanditsEMSsystem;thoroughanalysisofWyomingAmbulanceTripReportingSystemdata;andscrutinyofthefinancialandoperationaldataforSubletteCountyEMS.Basedonitsstudyandobservations,SafeTechSolutionsoffersthefollowingrecommendationstoSubletteCounty,SubletteCountyRuralHealthCareDistrict,andSubletteCountyEMS:1.CreateavisionandplanforEMSsuccessandsustainabilitythatincludesthefollowingelements:
Adescriptionofthelevel,quantityandqualityofEMSneeded,wantedandfundable. PrioritizationofEMSaboveotherlocalmedicalofferings. ApowerfulandreassuringstorytotellaboutEMS. Maximizationoftheuseofground‐basedEMS.
2.StrengthentheEMSorganizationalstructureandleadershipteamtosupportsustainabilityby:
ClarifyingtheEMSreportingstructureforEMSwithinthehealthcaredistrict. InvestingintheEMSleadershipteam’sknowledgeofEMSoperationsandfinance
andexposuretobestpractices. Ensuringtheleadershipteamiscommittedtotheorganizationanditsfuture.
3.Strengthenoperationalandfinancialefficiencybynarrowingthegapbetweenexpensesandrevenuesby:
Reducingthenumberofdeployedresourcestomatchanticipatedcallvolume. Developingandimplementinganewcallschedulethatreducesovertimeandissafe
andhumane. Raisingrevenuebyincreasingbillingrates,capturinglostrevenueandensuringall
patientsaretransportedtoahospital. Developingacapitalvehiclereplacementplan. Usingairmedicalresourcesefficiently.
4.Usedatatodrivedecisionsby:
Ensuringthatessentialdataisreliable,complete,andconsistentwithotherdatasources,suchasWATRS,billing,andthelocalcommunicationcenter.
Developingadashboardthatincludeskeyperformanceindicatorscriticalforsuccess.
Regularlymeasuringemployeeengagement.
![Page 4: Final Report ASSESSMENT · SafeTech Solutions is an EMS consulting firm with extensive expertise evaluating EMS organizations and assisting in the development of rural ambulance services](https://reader036.vdocuments.site/reader036/viewer/2022081613/5fb8596b1cbe0049666cd917/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
4
5.Continuetodevelophealthcareintegrationby:
ExploringwaystoexpandtheuseofEMSintonon‐911serviceswiththegoalofcreatingatrulyintegratedcaremodel.
Recommendationsarebasedonthefollowingkeyobservations.1.EMSisavitalandessentialelementofhealthcareandqualityoflifeinSubletteCounty.2.Asoperatingtoday,SubletteCountyEMSisnotsustainable.3.SubletteCountyEMSpossessesmanyelementsofaprogressiveandsustainableruralEMSsystem.
3A.BoththehealthcaredistrictandEMSdepartmenthavecapableleaders. 3B.TheEMSDirectorhasgoodbusinessandpeople‐managementskills. 3C.TheEMSsystemisimplementingdynamicdeploymentstrategies. 3D.TheEMSsystemprovidesahighlevelofqualityclinicalcare. 3E.EMSisadequatelyintegratedintothelocalhealthcaresystem. 3F.SubletteCountyEMShasaknowledgeableandcompetentbillingdepartment.
4.SubletteCountyEMSfacesmajorchallengesassociatedwiththelocaleconomyanditspositionwithinthehealthcaredistrict.
4A.SubletteCountyanticipatessharpreductionsintaxrevenues. 4B.EMSwillbeaffectedbychangeswithinthehealthcaredistrict. 4C.PerceptionsaboutthehealthcaredistrictmayhurtEMS. 4D.SubletteCountyEMSlacksaclearvisionandstrategicplan.
5.SubletteCountyEMSlacksclaritywithregardtoitsstructure,leadership,workforceanddatagathering.
5A.Thehealthcaredistrictreportingstructureneedsclarification. 5B.Departmentaljobdefinitionsandreportingstructureareweak. 5C.ThecurrentEMSleaderdoesnothavedeepoperationalandfinancialexperience
inEMS. 5D.EMSemployeeengagementisprecarious.
6.SubletteCountyEMSisnotoperatingefficientlynormaximizingitsrevenuefrompatientbilling,anditmayhavelittleornoincentivetodoso.
6A.Thecurrentschedulingsystemisnotefficient. 6B.TheEMSsystemhastoomanyresourcesforitscallvolume. 6C.Billingratesforpatienttransportsaretoolow. 6D.EMSislosingpotentialrevenuebytransportingpatientstodistrictclinics. 6E.EMSdoesnothaveacapitalreplacementplan. 6F.Thefrequentuseofairmedicalresourcesmaynotbeclinicallynecessaryor
operationallyefficient.
![Page 5: Final Report ASSESSMENT · SafeTech Solutions is an EMS consulting firm with extensive expertise evaluating EMS organizations and assisting in the development of rural ambulance services](https://reader036.vdocuments.site/reader036/viewer/2022081613/5fb8596b1cbe0049666cd917/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
5
6G.TheongoinghealthcaredistrictsubsidyoftheEMSservicemightserveasadisincentiveforimprovedorganizationalefficiencyandrevenuemaximization.
7.SubletteCountyEMSisfailingtodoanadequatejobofcollectingdataandanalyzinginformationaboutitsEMSsystem.
7A.SubletteCountyEMSdoesnothavebasiccalldata,andthedatathatitdoeshaveisatoddswithstate‐reporteddata.
7B.SubletteCountyEMSdoesnothavedefinedkeyperformanceindicators(KPIs). 7C.SubletteCountyhasnoformalorinformalprocessformeasuringEMSemployee
engagement. 7D.SubletteCountyhasnoformalmeasurementofEMScustomersatisfaction.
![Page 6: Final Report ASSESSMENT · SafeTech Solutions is an EMS consulting firm with extensive expertise evaluating EMS organizations and assisting in the development of rural ambulance services](https://reader036.vdocuments.site/reader036/viewer/2022081613/5fb8596b1cbe0049666cd917/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
6
I. Introduction & Assessment Methodology LikemanyruralcountiesinAmerica,SubletteCounty,Wyoming,facesgrowingchallengesinmeetingitsout‐of‐hospitalemergencymedicalcareneeds.TheawarenessofthesechallengesandthedesiretoovercomethemledSubletteCountyRuralHealthCareDistricttofileanapplicationwiththeWyomingOfficeofEMSandTraumaforgrantmoneytofundanassessmentofEMSinSubletteCounty.SafeTechSolutions,LLP,wascontractedtoconducttheassessment.SafeTechSolutionsisanEMSconsultingfirmwithextensiveexpertiseevaluatingEMSorganizationsandassistinginthedevelopmentofruralambulanceservicesandsystems.SafeTechSolutionshasworkedwithruralWyomingEMSagenciesthroughitsEMSLeadershipAcademyandinassessmentsinSweetwater,Fremont,CampbellandCarbonCounties.ThegoalsoftheSubletteCountyassessmentprojectareto:
Evaluatethesustainability,reliabilityandlong‐termsurvivabilityofEMSinthecounty,includingthecurrentstructureandoperationsofSubletteCountyEMS;
Validatesystemcomponentsthatareworkingwell;and Makerecommendationsforchangeandimprovement,asneeded.
Theassessmentfocusesonlocalneeds,currentoperations,systemdesignandavailablesupportingresourceswithaneyeonsustainability.Thescopeoftheassessmentislimitedandwasnotanauditofoperations,financesorclinicalperformance.Airmedicalserviceisnotpartoftheassessment.MethodologySafeTechSolutions’assessmentteamusedaprocessofinquiryandinvestigationthatcapitalizesonthefirm’sextensiveunderstandingofruralEMSsystems.Itsprincipalsgatheredquantitativeandqualitativedatathroughresearch,sitevisits,andinterviews.SafeTechSolutionsconsultantsvisitedSubletteCountytoreviewdocumentsanddata,conductinterviewsandassessoperations.Inadditiontoevaluatingtheambulanceorganization(organizationalstructure,leadershipandoperations),SafeTechSolutionspaidspecialattentiontothesocial,economic,demographic,culturalandpoliticalissuesinSubletteCounty,carefullyanalyzingdataandmakingrecommendationsbasedonindustrybestpractices,aswellaswhatispracticalanddoableinSubletteCounty.Thisreportsummarizesthefindings,keyobservationsandrecommendationsforEMSinSubletteCounty.
![Page 7: Final Report ASSESSMENT · SafeTech Solutions is an EMS consulting firm with extensive expertise evaluating EMS organizations and assisting in the development of rural ambulance services](https://reader036.vdocuments.site/reader036/viewer/2022081613/5fb8596b1cbe0049666cd917/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
7
II. Overview of Sublette County SubletteCountycovers3.2millionacresinwesternWyoming.Of23countiesinthestate,SubletteCountyrankssixthingeographicalsize.TheWindRiverRangerunsnorthtosouthalongtheeasternportionoftheCounty,theGrosVentreWildernessliestothenorth,andtheWyomingRangerunsalongthewesternside.Thecentralportionofthecountyisavalleycomprisedofasagebrushsteppeeco‐region.Elevationrangesfrom6,280feetinthevalleyto13,400feetintheWindRiverRange.Thecountyhasmorethan1,300lakes.1Geographicallyisolatedfromrailroadsandpopulationcenters,SubletteCountyretaineditsfrontiercultureforfarlongerthanmanyareasofWyomingandtheWest.Itwasnotincorporateduntil1921,makingitthenewestcountyinthestate,andithasremainedoneoftheleastdenselypopulatedareasinthestatewellintothe20thcentury.Eventoday,80percentofSubletteCountylandispubliclyowned.SubletteCountyhasexperienceddramaticgrowthsince2000duetoenergydevelopment.Thecounty’spopulationincreasedfromfewerthanthan6,000residentsin2000tomorethan10,000residentsin2013.Populationgrowthsince2000(68percent)wasfourtimesthegrowthrateforWyoming(18percent)andsixtimesthegrowthratefortheU.S.(12percent).Mostoftheincreaseinpopulationoccurredfrom2002through2009whenpopulationincreasedatanaverageannualrateof7percentperyear.Since2009,thepopulationhasplateauedataround10,000residents,reflectingaslowdowninenergydevelopmentinthecounty.2SubletteCountyhasthreeincorporatedtowns:BigPiney,MarbletonandPinedale.SmallerunincorporatedcommunitiesincludeBondurant,Cora,BoulderandDaniel.Pinedaleisthecountyseat.3Nearly60percentofresidentsliveinruralpartsofthecounty.Theotherhalf 1Sublettewyo.com2ASubletteCountyProfile:SocioeconomicsbytheSubletteCountyBoardofCountyCommissioners,2015.3ibid
![Page 8: Final Report ASSESSMENT · SafeTech Solutions is an EMS consulting firm with extensive expertise evaluating EMS organizations and assisting in the development of rural ambulance services](https://reader036.vdocuments.site/reader036/viewer/2022081613/5fb8596b1cbe0049666cd917/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
8
liveinPinedale(25percent),Marbleton(12percent)andBigPiney(6percent).4Inadditiontoitspermanentresidents,SubletteCountyhoststransientworkerswhocometotheareaforemployment,primarilyintheoilandgasindustry.Asmanyas2,000non‐residentworkers(primarilymen)areinthecountyatanygiventime,dependingonthelevelofgasfieldactivity.5SeveralhighwayspassthroughSubletteCounty,includingUS191,whichrunsnorth‐souththroughPinedaleenroutetoGrandTetonsNationalPark,andUS189,whichtakestrafficthroughBigPiney,MarbletonandDaniel.Accordingtothecounty,trafficincreasedby60percentormorebetween1995and2005everywhereinSubletteCounty,exceptfortheRimonHighway189/191,whichwasupabout20percent.Bigtrucktrafficalsoshowedsignificantincreasesinandaroundallthetowns,aswellasonHighway351,andUS191betweenSandDrawandFarson.Notsurprisingly,trafficaccidentsalsoincreasedinSubletteCountyduringthistime.6
EconomySubletteCountyhasaboom‐busteconomydueinlargeparttoitsmineralresources,mostnotablytheJonahandPinedaleAnticlinenaturalgasfields.Themostrecentboombeganabout1999‐2000andfueledjobs,growthandinflationforabouteightyears.Itpumpedlargeamountsofmoneyintothelocaleconomythatallowedresidentstobuildnewschools
4Sublettewyo.com5ibid6ibid
Page 1 of 1
9/21/2009http://sublette-se.org/images/accidentws2.JPG
![Page 9: Final Report ASSESSMENT · SafeTech Solutions is an EMS consulting firm with extensive expertise evaluating EMS organizations and assisting in the development of rural ambulance services](https://reader036.vdocuments.site/reader036/viewer/2022081613/5fb8596b1cbe0049666cd917/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
9
andoutfitclassroomswithnewcomputers.7Itdrovetheconstructionofnewhomes,hotelsandrestaurants.Duringtheboom,wageswerehighandunemploymentwaslow.TheboompeakedinOctober2008withanall‐timehighof67naturalgasrigsinoperation.Lessthanayearlater,however,inMay2009,thenumberofdrillingrigsinthecountyhaddroppedto30.8Thesharpdecreasewascausedbya70percentdeclineinnaturalgaspricesbroughtonbyweakeneddemandinthefaceofaglobaleconomicdownturn.Thedeclineinnaturalgasproductionhascontinuedinrecentyears.BakerHughes,whichtracksrotaryrigsbystate,reportsthatasofApril2016,onlyninerigsareoperatingintheentirestateofWyoming,comparedwith25oneyearearlier.9People
SubletteCountyishometosome10,000permanentresidents,accordingtotheUSCensusBureau.Thisnumberrepresentsanincreaseof68percentinlessthanadecade,whichismorethanfourtimesthepopulationgrowthrateforthestateandsixtimesthegrowthratefortheUS.10Thereasonfortheincreaseislargelyattributabletothenaturalgasindustry.
Accordingtothecounty,thenumberofactivedrillingrigsinSubletteCountyhashadadirectandimmediateeffectontheworkforcepopulation.Atanygiventime,eachdrillingrigrequiresadirectworkforceofabout22people,thevastmajorityofwhomarenon‐residentsofthearea.Whentheweeklyrotationsoftheworkforcearetallied,about44differentindividualsarededicatedtoeachrig.Scoresofadditionalworkersarealsoneededtoprovidesupportandservicestotherigs.11Since2009,thecountypopulationplateauedataround10,000residents,reflectingaslowdowninenergydevelopmentinthecounty.12
Mostresidentsarewhite,employedandearnawageabovethestateaverage.The2015WyomingCountyProfilereportedmedianearningsforfull‐timemaleworkerstobe$67,390($38,517forfemales).Mostresidentsareemployedintheprivatesector,withthegas/oilandmining/quarryingindustriesaccountingforthehighestpercentageofemployeesinrecentyears.13Alongwiththeboomalsocamecrime.Thecountyreports,“SubletteCountyenjoyedamoderatetolowcrimerate,usuallybelowtheWyomingaverage.However,withtheadventofoilandgasdevelopment,crimeratesandarrestsmadewithinSubletteCountyhavesoared.”SubletteCountyhadthehighestcrimerateinthestatein2005,eclipsingthemetropolitancountiesofNatronaandLaramie.14
7TalkoftheNation,Feb.11,20138sublettewyo.com9BakerHughesmonthlyrigreportforApril201610SubletteCountyProfile:SocioeconomicsbytheSubletteCountyBoardofCountyCommissioners,August201511sublettewyo.com12ibid13SubletteCountyProfilebytheWyomingDepartmentofInformationandAdministration,2015.14Sublettewyo.com
![Page 10: Final Report ASSESSMENT · SafeTech Solutions is an EMS consulting firm with extensive expertise evaluating EMS organizations and assisting in the development of rural ambulance services](https://reader036.vdocuments.site/reader036/viewer/2022081613/5fb8596b1cbe0049666cd917/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
10
HealthcareinSubletteCountyUniversityofWisconsinPopulationHealthInstituteandtheRobertWoodJohnsonFoundationeachyearpublishhealthrankingsthatshedlightonthehealthandwellnessofresidentpopulationsbycountythroughouttheUnitedStates.TheannualCountyHealthRankingsmeasurevitalhealthfactors,includinghighschoolgraduationrates,obesity,smoking,unemployment,accesstohealthyfoods,thequalityofairandwater,income,andteenbirthsinnearlyeverycountyinAmerica.Expertscompiletherankingsusingcounty‐levelmeasuresfromavarietyofnationaldatasources.
The2015CountyHealthRankingsreportsuggeststhatthehealthofSubletteCountyresidentsisverygoodcomparedtotherestofthestate.Fewerthan15percentofadultresidentssmoke,comparedto20percentstatewide.Adultobesityis21percent,comparedto27percentstatewide.Preventivecaresuchasmammographyanddiabetesscreeningalsorankshigh.TheonlyfactorsinwhichSubletteCountyscoredpoorlyarealcohol‐impaireddrivingdeaths,longcommutesandpoorqualityofdrinkingwater.15SubletteCountyHealthcareResourcesSubletteCountyresidentsobtainbasicmedicalcareattwoareaclinics,oneinPinedaleandtheotherinBigPiney/Marbleton.BothareoverseenandoperatedbySubletteCountyRuralHealthCareDistrict,acountywideelectedboardoffivenon‐partisanmembers.ThehealthcaredistricttookoveroperationoftheMarbletonclinicinMay2005andthePinedaleclinicinJuly2006.Bothclinicshavebeenrebuiltinrecentyearsusingcountyfunds(Pinedalein2007,Marbletonin2009).Thereisnohospitalinthecounty;however,discussionsareongoingregardingconvertingthePinedaleclinictoaCriticalAccessHospital(CAH).ThisconversionwouldhaveanimpactonEMS.Out‐of‐CountyHealthcareResourcesPatientsthatrequiremoreacutecarethanthatwhichcanbeprovidedinSubletteCountyaretransportedbygroundorairambulancetoSt.John’sMedicalCenterinJackson(76miles);EasternIdahoRegionalMedicalCenter,aLevelIITraumaCenter(158miles);MemorialHospitalinRockSprings(103miles);SouthLincolnMedicalCenter,aCriticalAccessHospitalinKemmerer(56miles);andtothehospitalatUniversityofUtah,aLevelOneTraumaCenter,inSaltLakeCity(250miles). 15 CountyHealthRankings,2016
![Page 11: Final Report ASSESSMENT · SafeTech Solutions is an EMS consulting firm with extensive expertise evaluating EMS organizations and assisting in the development of rural ambulance services](https://reader036.vdocuments.site/reader036/viewer/2022081613/5fb8596b1cbe0049666cd917/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
11
FederallyDesignatedTraumaCentersinWyoming
![Page 12: Final Report ASSESSMENT · SafeTech Solutions is an EMS consulting firm with extensive expertise evaluating EMS organizations and assisting in the development of rural ambulance services](https://reader036.vdocuments.site/reader036/viewer/2022081613/5fb8596b1cbe0049666cd917/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
12
III. Overview of the EMS System in Sublette County EmergencymedicalcareinSubletteCountyincludesa911emergencymedicalcallsystem,emergencymedicaldispatch,firstresponse,groundambulance,airmedicaltransport,medicaloversightandqualityassurance.ThesystemworksthroughthecoordinatedeffortsofavarietyofagenciesthatincludesSubletteCountyRuralHealthCareDistrict,SubletteCountyEMS,SubletteCountySheriff'sofficeand911CommunicationsCenter,SubletteCountyUnifiedFire,WyomingHighwayPatrol,TipTopSearchandRescue,SubletteCountyEmergencyManagement,andavarietyofout‐of‐countyairmedicalservices.Althoughthecountyhastwomodernhealthcareclinicsthatoftenoperatelikestand‐aloneemergencyrooms,thereisnohospitalinSubletteCounty.ThenumberofrequestsforemergencymedicalresponseinSubletteCountyisunknown,ascountyEMSofficialsdisagreewiththewayinwhichdataisreportedtothestateEMSdataregistry(WATRS).16SafeTechSolutionsestimatestotalcallvolumeinSubletteCountytobeabout600annually,basedonareported491billablepatienttransportsin2015(transportstypicallyoccuron80percentofcalls).Requestsforserviceappeartobedownfrompreviousyears.Volumeinpastyearswasreportedlyashighas766(2011).2015EMSVolume(estimated) Groundambulanceresponses:589 Airmedicaltransports:unknown(noverifiabledatasourceavailable) Searchandrescuerequests:18‐24
Communications&DispatchCallsforout‐of‐hospitalemergencymedicalcarearereceivedbySubletteCountySheriff'sOffice911CommunicationsCenter.TheCommunicationsCenteranswersabout10,000callsperyear.Ofthese,fewerthan600requireEMSresponse.Thecenterismodernandup‐to‐date,withanewCADsystem,CRTradiosystem,andhasAVLmonitoringcapability.ThecenterisstaffedbydispatcherstrainedinEmergencyMedicalDispatchandpreparedtoprovidepre‐arrivalinstructions.EMSandtheCommunicationsCenterhaverecentlyaddedActive911capabilities.
16 ItisdifficulttoassessSubletteCountyEMS’scallvolumebecauseofhowdataiscollected.In2015WATRS(thestateEMSdatacollectionsystem)reports816totalcalls.SubletteCountyEMSbelievesthisnumberisunreliableduetosomeresponsesbeingenteredintoWATRSmultipletimes.Forexample,apatientwhoistransportedfromhometothehealthcareclinicandthenfromtheclinictoahospital,suchasinJackson,wouldbeenteredintoWATRStwice,butwouldonlyaccountforonebillabletransport.Themostreliabledataavailablewasthebillingdepartment’sdatafortotalbilledtransportsduringagivenperiod.SafeTechSolutionsincreasedthisnumberby20percenttoaccountforresponsesinwhichapatientwasnottransported(the20percentnon‐transportnumberiscommonacrossthenation).
![Page 13: Final Report ASSESSMENT · SafeTech Solutions is an EMS consulting firm with extensive expertise evaluating EMS organizations and assisting in the development of rural ambulance services](https://reader036.vdocuments.site/reader036/viewer/2022081613/5fb8596b1cbe0049666cd917/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
13
CallsforemergencymedicalassistancearetonedoutsimultaneouslytofirstrespondersandSubletteCountyEMS.TherearebaseradiosintwoEMSstations,locatedinBigPiney/MarbletonandPinedale.Respondersusein‐vehicleandhandheldradiosaswellascellphonestostayincontactduringcalls.Respondersreportmoderatelygoodreceptionthroughoutthecounty,butoccasionallyareinlocationswherethereisnoreception.SubletteCountyEMSisdispatchedviaradiosystemandpagers.ThesystemispartofWYOLINK,thestatewidedigitaltrunkedVHFP‐25compliantpublicsafetycommunicationssystemdesignedtocoordinateandintegratecommunicationsamongstate,localandfederalpublicsafetyagencies.Communicationtechnologybetweenthedispatchcenterandambulancecrewsappearssufficient,withnoproblemsreported.ThereisnodirectcosttoSubletteCountyEMSforthedispatchservice.Thedispatchandcommunicationsystemisfundedthroughacombinationof911surchargedollarsandresourcesfromthecountygeneralfund.FirstResponse&Co‐ResponseFirstresponseinSubletteCountyisprovidedbyavarietyofagencies,includingSubletteCountySheriff’sDepartment,WyomingStatePatrol,SubletteCountyUnifiedFire,andTipTopSearchandRescue.Sheriff’sdeputiesco‐respondwithSubletteCountyEMStoamajorityof911emergencymedicalcalls.SubletteCountyUnifiedFireDepartmentco‐respondswithEMSintheareasofBondurantandKendallValley.Somepart‐time,off‐dutyEMTsalsorespondasvolunteerfirstresponders.SubletteCountySheriff’sDepartmenthas55swornofficersandanadditional15employeeswhoprovidecountywidelawenforcement,operatethe911CommunicationsCenterandjail,andoverseethevolunteersearchandrescueprogram.SubletteCountyUnifiedFireisavolunteerdepartmentlocatedinsixfirestationsscatteredacrossSubletteCounty.Thedepartmentisaconsolidationofsixdepartmentsthatwerebroughttogetherin2014.Itisintheprocessofcreatingaunifieddepartmentandcultureundertheleadershipofafull‐timefirechiefandfull‐timeadministrativeassistant.Thedepartmenthasapproximately110volunteerfirefightersandanannualbudgetofapproximately$2.4million.Thedepartmentexpectssignificantbudgetreductionsin2017‐18becauseofalowertaxbaseinashrinkingeconomy.SubletteCounty’sremotetopographyoftenmakesitnecessaryfordispatchtosendsearch‐and‐rescueteamsonEMScalls.SearchandrescueisprovidedbyTipTopSearchandRescue,aPinedale‐basedvolunteer,non‐profitorganizationofapproximately40memberswhoreportthattheyrespondtooneortwocallspermonthyear‐round.TheorganizationoperatesunderSubletteCountySheriffDepartmentandreceivesfundingfromtheSubletteCountyCommission,StateofWyoming,andprivatedonations.Theorganizationrespondstohighanglerescues,waterrescues,icerescues,avalanches,missingandoverduepersons,medicalevacuationsandbodyrecoveries.
![Page 14: Final Report ASSESSMENT · SafeTech Solutions is an EMS consulting firm with extensive expertise evaluating EMS organizations and assisting in the development of rural ambulance services](https://reader036.vdocuments.site/reader036/viewer/2022081613/5fb8596b1cbe0049666cd917/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
14
Firstresponders,EMSrespondersandtheCommunicationCenterreporthavingrespectfulworkingrelationshipswitheachother.911Response&MedicalTransportEmergencymedicalresponseisprovidedbySubletteCountyEMS,anambulanceserviceownedandoperatedbySubletteCountyRuralHealthCareDistrict.ItwasformedinJanuary2006fromthemergeroftwocombinationEMSagencies:PinedaleEMSandBigPiney/MarbletonEMS.SubletteCountyEMSoperatesoutoftwoEMSstations,oneinBigPiney/MarbletonandtheotherinPinedale.InthePinedalestation,anALSunitisstaffed24/7,withtheavailabilityofasecondunitstaffedbytheDirectorandsupervisingparamedic.InBigPiney/Marbleton,anALSunitisstaffed24/7.Staffingismainlywithpaidemployees,withfourvolunteersoccasionallyfillinginwhenneededforbackup.Duringsummermonths,whentourisminthecountyisatitspeak,anadditionalambulanceisstaffedinPinedale.Whileambulancesarestationedabout35milesapart,SubletteCountyEMSusesadynamicdeploymentsystemtoensurethatambulancesarebestpositionedforrapidresponse.Forexample,whenbothambulancesinPinedaleareoncalls,theBigPiney/MarbletonambulancemovestoDaniel.WhenanambulancegoesoutonacallinBigPiney/Marbleton,thePinedaleambulancemovestoDaniel.Thissystemallowsforshorterresponsetimesoveralargeservicearea.SubletteCountyEMSreportsenroutetimeof2.2minutesandanaverageon‐scenetimeunder15minutes.Occasionally,anon‐transportingquickresponseunitstaffedbyaparamedicfromPinedaleisusedtorespondandbegintransportwhileawaitingambulanceresponse.EMSrespondersprovideanadvancedlevelofserviceandtransportpatientseithertothehealthcaredistrictclinicsinPinedaleorBigPiney/Marbletonortoout‐of‐countyhospitals.Out‐of‐countymutualaidisrarelyused,butisinplacefromsurroundingcountiesandavailableonanas‐neededbasis.BecauseofthelongdistancetothetraumacenterinSaltLakeCity(upto10hoursround‐trip),SubletteCountyEMSmaypassoffpatientstoGoldCrossambulancemid‐route,inwhatisknownasapatientintercept.Inadditionto911responseandtransport,SubletteCountyEMSparticipatesinavarietyofcommunityoutreachactivities,including:
FirstaidandCPRclasses; Standbysforfootballgames,rodeos,etc.; Servingfoodatlocalnursinghome(whileonduty); Deliveringfoodbags; Supportingcommunityevents,suchasbreastcancerwalk;and EmergencyMedicalResponderandEmergencyMedicalTechnicianBasiccourses.
Inaddition,becauseSubletteCountyEMSispartofthehealthcaredistrictandbecauseambulancestationsarelocatednexttohealthcaredistrictclinics,on‐dutyEMSpersonnel
![Page 15: Final Report ASSESSMENT · SafeTech Solutions is an EMS consulting firm with extensive expertise evaluating EMS organizations and assisting in the development of rural ambulance services](https://reader036.vdocuments.site/reader036/viewer/2022081613/5fb8596b1cbe0049666cd917/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
15
maybesummonedbytheCommunicationsCentertomeetpatientsattheclinicdoorsafterhours,opentheclinic,andbegintotriageandcareforpatientswhilewaitingforanurseandphysiciantorespond.AirMedicalServiceAvarietyofout‐of‐countyhelicopterflightservices(AirIdahoRescue,ClassicAirMedical,GuardianFlight,LifeFlightWyoming,LifeFlightNetwork)areavailablewhenthegroundambulancecreworclinicstaffrequeststhem.TherearenoairmedicalresourcesbasedinSubletteCounty,buthelicopterandfixedwingservicesareavailablefromIdahoFalls,LanderandotherlocationsinWyoming,ColoradoandUtah.AirambulancesarenotdispatchedthroughtheSherriff’sDepartment;rather,ambulancepersonnelcontactthemdirectlyusingcellphones.ThetotalnumberofairmedicaltransportsfromSubletteCountyeachyearisnotknown;however,ambulancepersonnelreportapproximately75airmedicaltransportsannuallyfromSubletteCountyhealthcareclinics.EMSEducationSubletteCountyEMSprovidesfirstaid,CPR,firstresponderandEMTtraining.Italsoprovidesongoingstafftrainingandcontinuingmedicaleducation.Therearenoparamedicprogramswithinthecounty.EMSSystemOversight&PlanningThereisnoformalEMSsystemoversightinSubletteCounty;however,anadvisorygroupcalledtheSubletteCountyEmergencyServicesGroupmeetsregularlytodiscussemergencyplanning,challenges,interoperability,bigeventplanning,needs,grantrequestsandagroupapproachtosolutions.Thegroupiscomprisedofthecountyemergencymanager,EMS,Sheriff’sDepartment,searchandrescue,HighwayPatrol,mayors,publichealth,industry/mining,andschools,withoccasionalrepresentationfromcitizens,theparkandforestservices,homelandsecurityandotherstakeholdersasneeded.
![Page 16: Final Report ASSESSMENT · SafeTech Solutions is an EMS consulting firm with extensive expertise evaluating EMS organizations and assisting in the development of rural ambulance services](https://reader036.vdocuments.site/reader036/viewer/2022081613/5fb8596b1cbe0049666cd917/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
16
IV. Description of Sublette County EMS OrganizationalOwnership&StructureSubletteCountyEMSisadepartmentofSubletteCountyRuralHealthCareDistrict,acountytaxingdistrict.SubletteCountyRuralHealthCareDistrictwasestablishedin1987followingthedissolutionoftheSubletteCountyMemorialHospitalDistrict.ThedistrictisoverseenbyaBoardofTrusteeswhoareelectedbycountyresidents.Thetrusteeshireahealthcareadministratorwhoservesaschiefexecutiveandoverseestheoperationsoftheservicesprovidedbythedistrict.Servicesincludetheoperationoftwoclinicswithmedicalstaffs,nursingservices,radiologyservices,laboratoryservicesandemergencymedicalservices.Thedistrictoperatesindependentlyofcountyandmunicipalgovernment,butusespropertyandbuildingsownedbythecounty.Theclinicisunabletomakeimprovementstothesebuildingswithoutconsentofcountycommissioners.EMSfunctionsasadepartmentofthehealthcaredistrict.Thedirectoroftheambulanceserviceishiredbythehealthcareadministratorandreportstotheadministrator.ThecurrentorganizationalchartshowstheEMSdirectorreportingdirectlytotheEMSmedicaldirector,however,inpractice,theEMSdirectorreportstotheadministratoronoperationalandfinancialissuesandtotheEMSmedicaldirectoronclinicalissues.TheEMSdirectorhasanassistantwhofunctionsintheroleofasupervisingparamedic.
![Page 17: Final Report ASSESSMENT · SafeTech Solutions is an EMS consulting firm with extensive expertise evaluating EMS organizations and assisting in the development of rural ambulance services](https://reader036.vdocuments.site/reader036/viewer/2022081613/5fb8596b1cbe0049666cd917/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
17
WorkforceSubletteCountyEMSemploys17full‐timeand9part‐timepersonnel.Allareactive.Fourofthepart‐timestaffareunpaidvolunteers–remnantsofatimewhenallemployeesdonatedtheirtime.Theagespanoftheworkforceisbetween25and61,withanaverageageof38.Fivefieldpersonnelareparamedics,15areAEMTs,and6areEMSbasics.EmployeesarehiredandevaluatedbytheEMSdirector.EMSstaffwork48hoursonand96hoursoff.Thereisconsiderableschedulingflexibility,andemployeesareabletoschedulesignificantstretchesoftimeoff.Whenoff‐duty,someofthestaffmakethemselvesavailabletobecalledinforback‐up.Employeeshaveapayandbenefitpackagethroughthehealthcaredistrictthatincludeshealthanddentalinsurance.Currenthourlypayratesare:
EMT‐Basic:$10.50 Intermediate/AdvancedEMT:$12.20 Paramedic:$15.60
Onthesurface,theseratesappearlowcomparedtonationalaveragesforEMSorganizationsofsimilarsizeservingruralcommunities.However,actualtake‐homepayissignificantlyhigherduetoscheduledandunscheduledovertime.Scheduledovertimecanaddseveralmoredollarsperhour.Anaccurateevaluationofcompensationincludesanevaluationofannualcompensationdividedbyhoursworked.Facilities,Vehicles&EquipmentSubletteCountyEMSoperatesoutoftwospaciousEMSstationsthatareownedbySubletteCountyandrentedtothehealthcaredistrictforthecostofupkeep(approximately$100,000peryear).Bothfacilitiesaremodernandcomfortable,withlargevehiclebays,officespace,ampletrainingrooms,dayroomswithkitchensandlivingareas,andsleeprooms.FourvehiclesaregaragedinPinedale,threeinBigPiney/Marbleton.Ambulancesavailablefor911responseinclude:
Unit15,firstoutinPinedale:2012FordF‐450madebyOsagewith48,789miles,StrykerPowerliftcot,ZollX‐seriesMonitorwiththeabilitytotransmit12leadECG,LucasDevice,ePCR,modernequipment,ingoodorder,andwellmaintained;
Unit129,secondoutinPinedale:2007FordF‐450madebyLifelinewith121,894miles,StrykerPowerliftcot,ZollX‐seriesMonitorwiththeabilitytotransmit12leadECG,ePCR,modernequipment,ingoodorder,andwellmaintained;
UnitMS14,thirdoutinPinedale:2001FordF‐350madebyLifelinewith139,000miles,StrykerPowerliftcot,ZollE‐seriesMonitor,ePCR,equipmentingoodorder,andwellmaintained;
![Page 18: Final Report ASSESSMENT · SafeTech Solutions is an EMS consulting firm with extensive expertise evaluating EMS organizations and assisting in the development of rural ambulance services](https://reader036.vdocuments.site/reader036/viewer/2022081613/5fb8596b1cbe0049666cd917/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
18
UnitEMS1,EchoUnit(AdvancedLifeSupportRapidResponseVehicle)inPinedale:2012ChevyTahoewith39,00miles,ZollX‐seriesMonitorwiththeabilitytotransmit12leadECG,LucasDevice,Autovent,Minimedpump,ALSsupplies,Kingvision,ePCR,modernequipment,ingoodorder,andwellmaintained;
UnitMS140,firstoutinMarbleton:2012Dodge4500madebyOsagewith49,000miles,StrykerPowerliftcot,ZollX‐seriesMonitorwiththeabilitytotransmit12leadECG,LucasDevice,ePCR,modernequipment,ingoodorder,andwellmaintained;
UnitMS256,secondoutinMarbleton:2008FordF‐450madebyLifelinewith70,000miles,StrykerPowerliftcot,ZollX‐seriesMonitorwiththeabilitytotransmit12leadECG,ePCR,modernequipment,ingoodorder,andwellmaintained;and
UnitMS141,thirdoutinMarbleton:2005FordF‐350madebyOsagewith101,000miles,StrykerPowerliftcot,ZollE‐seriesMonitor,ePCR,Equipmentingoodorder,andwellmaintained.
Allmedicalequipmentisuptodateandappropriateforthelevelofcareprovidedandthedemandsoftheservicearea.MedicalOversight&QualityAssuranceSubletteCountyEMShasprogressivepatientcareprotocols,internalqualityassuranceandengagedmedicaldirection.Afull‐timeparamedicactsastheQA/QIofficerandreviewsallrunreports.Patientcarereportsoncomplicatedand/orhighacuitycallsareforwardedtothemedicaldirectorforreview.Providerdocumentationiscontinuouslyevaluatedandsupportedwithproviderfeedbackandtraining.Thedepartmentparticipatesinregularcasereviewswithitsmedicaldirectorandclinictraumacoordinator.PatientcarereportdataisconsistentsubmittedtoWATRS.TheSubletteCountyMedicalDirectorisresponsibleforensuringfieldprovidershaveappropriatepatientcareprotocols,areclinicallycompetent,andadequatelysupportedwithclinicalcasereviews,continuingeducationandskillmaintenance.HekeepsupwithclinicaldevelopmentsandseekstoensureSubletteCountyEMSisdeliveringbestpractices.Hisinvolvementintheclinic’semergencyservicesallowsfrequentinteractionwithfieldcrews.Finance&FundingSubletteCountyEMSisfundedthroughbillingforpatientcare,taxrevenuereceivedbySubletteCountyRuralHealthCareDistrict,andlabordonatedbyvolunteers.SubletteCountyRuralHealthCareDistrictisfundedthroughbillingforpatientservicesandataxof2millsthatisleviedeachyearbythecounty.HealthcarefundsalsoaresecuredbytheRuralHealthFoundation(RHF),a501(c)(3)nonprofitcorporation.ItiscloselyaffiliatedwiththeSubletteCountyRuralHealthCareDistrictbutisseparatelygoverned
![Page 19: Final Report ASSESSMENT · SafeTech Solutions is an EMS consulting firm with extensive expertise evaluating EMS organizations and assisting in the development of rural ambulance services](https://reader036.vdocuments.site/reader036/viewer/2022081613/5fb8596b1cbe0049666cd917/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
19
andmanaged.FundsraisedbytheRHFareusedforprojectsthatimprovehealthcarethroughoutthecounty.DonationsmadetotheRHFaretaxdeductibleasallowableundercurrentIRStaxcodes.Aspartofhealthcaredistrict,SubletteCountyEMShasadepartmentalbudgetandtracksEMS‐specificrevenuesandexpenses.In2015,itreportedtotalrevenuesof$513,654receivedfrompatientbilling.Duringthesametimeperiod,itreportedtotalexpensesof$1.9million,resultinginanetlossof$1.4million.Thebillingprocessincludesthefollowingsteps:Patientcarereports(PCR)arereadandcodedbythebillingdepartment;anyquestionsaboutthePCRsarereturnedtoEMSstaffforclarificationsandcorrections;aclaimiselectronicallysubmittedthroughaclearinghouse,whenallowed.ExplanationofBenefits(EOBs)arereturnedinthesamemanner.Statementsaresenttopatientsevery28days.Paymentplansforunpaidbillsareaccepted.Internalcollectionprocessesareenacted,andwhenapplicable,anoutsidecollectionagencyused.Billingratescomparewithnationalaveragesasfollows:
BillingLevels
SubletteCountyEMS
RatesNationalAverages
Non‐emergencytransportation(WC) $25 $17Mileage $22/mile $30ALSnon‐emergency $662
ALSemergency $1,048 $2,500‐$3,500BLSnon‐emergency $551
BLSemergency $882 $1,000‐$2,000ALS2emergency $1,517 $3,000‐$4,000ALStreatmentwithnotransport $200 ALStreatmentwithnotransport $100
AmbulanceStandby $50/hour $200BLS/$400ALS
A0434SpecializedCriticalTransport NoUse $3,500‐$4,500
![Page 20: Final Report ASSESSMENT · SafeTech Solutions is an EMS consulting firm with extensive expertise evaluating EMS organizations and assisting in the development of rural ambulance services](https://reader036.vdocuments.site/reader036/viewer/2022081613/5fb8596b1cbe0049666cd917/html5/thumbnails/20.jpg)
20
Totalbillabletransportsbyyearareasfollows:
TotalBillableTransports,byTypeofTransportYear‐to‐Year17
2011 2012 2013 2014 2015
Total Ambulance Responses (estimated) 766 658 580 582 589
Total Billed Ambulance Transports 638 548 483 485 491
A0426, ALS 1 non‐emergency 2 1 1 96 173
A0427, ALS 1 emergency 422 342 255 182 154
A0428, BLS non‐emergency 20 6 10 92 67
A0429, BLS emergency 151 170 195 94 66
A0433, ALS 2 43 29 22 21 31
A0998, Response and Treatment, No transport 12 30
Ambulance Standbys 27.5 48.3 32.2 39.5
Ambulanceresponsesversusbilledambulancetransportsbyyearareasfollows:
17 Accuratelyassessingvolumeremainsproblematic.SeesectiononEMScallvolumeabove.
0
100
200
300
400
500
600
700
800
2011 2012 2013 2014 2015
Total Ambulance Responses(estimated)
Total Billed AmbulanceTransports
![Page 21: Final Report ASSESSMENT · SafeTech Solutions is an EMS consulting firm with extensive expertise evaluating EMS organizations and assisting in the development of rural ambulance services](https://reader036.vdocuments.site/reader036/viewer/2022081613/5fb8596b1cbe0049666cd917/html5/thumbnails/21.jpg)
21
IV. Key Observations 1.EMSisavitalandessentialelementofhealthcareandqualityoflifeinSubletteCounty.Geography,climate,distancestomedicalresources,highlevelsoftrauma,andlimitedresourcescombinetomakeEMSavitalserviceinSubletteCounty.Informantsviewtheavailabilityofambulancetransporttodefinitivemedicalcareasveryimportanttotheirsenseofsecurityandwell‐being.Intheabsenceofalocalhospitalandreadilyaccessibleadvancedmedicalspecialties,informantsdeemlocalEMSresourcesasessentialtolifeandsafetyissues.SomeinformantsreportviewingEMSasthemostessentialpartofthelocalhealthcaresystem.2.Asoperatingtoday,SubletteCountyEMSisnotsustainable.ThecurrentoperatingbudgetandoperationalstrategiesforSubletteCountyEMSappeartobebasedonfinancialandoperationalassumptionsmadeduringalocaleconomicboom.AnticipateddeclinesintaxrevenuesandotherfinancialdemandsonthehealthcaredistrictsuggestthatSubletteCountyEMSisnotsustainableasoperatingtoday.Thecurrentgapbetweenoperatingexpensesandtransportrevenuesforcesthedepartmenttorelyona$1.4millionsubsidythatislikelytonotbeavailableinthenearfuture.Withoutreducingexpensesorincreasingrevenues,thecurrentEMSoperationsarenotsustainable.
3.SubletteCountyEMSpossessesmanyelementsofaprogressiveandsustainableruralEMSsystem.Creatingasustainable,highquality,ruralEMSsystemintoday’smarketdemandsleadership,vision,operationalandfinancialefficiency,communitysupportandprogressivemedicaldirection.SubletteCountyEMShasmanyoftheseelementsinplace.3A.BoththehealthcaredistrictandEMSdepartmenthavecapableleaders.Theexecutive
$0.00
$500,000.00
$1,000,000.00
$1,500,000.00
$2,000,000.00
$2,500,000.00
$3,000,000.00
$3,500,000.00
2013 2014 2015
Expenses Vs. Patient Billing Revenue
Total Expenses
Total Revenues
![Page 22: Final Report ASSESSMENT · SafeTech Solutions is an EMS consulting firm with extensive expertise evaluating EMS organizations and assisting in the development of rural ambulance services](https://reader036.vdocuments.site/reader036/viewer/2022081613/5fb8596b1cbe0049666cd917/html5/thumbnails/22.jpg)
22
leadershipoftheSubletteCountyRuralHealthCareDistricthasdemonstratedclearleadershipinseekingoutthisassessment,endeavoringtounderstandruralout‐of‐hospitalemergencymedicalservices,developinganappropriateplaceforEMSindistrictplanning,andchoosingaqualifiedEMSdirectorwhoinspirespeopletofollowhim.3B.TheEMSDirectorhasgoodbusinessandpeople‐managementskills.TheEMSDirectorhasasubstantivebackgroundinbusinessdevelopmentandpeople‐managementandiscreatingaculturethatemployeesvalue.Heiscurrentlymanagingasignificantbudgetcontractionbyfindingefficiencies,isopen‐minded,andconstantlyseekingwaystoimprovethesystem.Employeesdescribehimas“oneofthebestthingsthathashappenedtoSubletteCountyEMS.”3C.TheEMSsystemisimplementingdynamicdeploymentstrategies.SubletteCountyEMSmovesitsambulancestostrategicstaginglocationswhenresourcesaredepleted.Thissystemofdynamicdeploymentrequiresmonitoringthesystem’sstatusandproactivelymovingresources(sometimestothediscomfortofemployees).Dynamicdeploymentisabestpracticestrategythatmovesambulanceassetswithinageographicareatoprovidethebestpossibleresponsetimeswhileminimizingfixedcosts.Suchforward‐thinkingandpracticeisrareinruralEMSsystems.3D.TheEMSsystemprovidesahighlevelofqualityclinicalcare.TheclinicalcareprovidedbySubletteCountyEMSmatchesbestpracticesinruralareasaroundthenationandisclearlyanorganizationalpriority.Theserviceprovidesadvancedlevelcareandisappropriatelystaffed.TheMedicalDirectorisappropriatelyqualified,preparedandengagedandisalwaysseekingwaystoensurethatSubletteCountyEMSisontheleadingedgeindeliveringhigh‐quality,ruralemergencymedicalcare.Informantswiththecommunity,clinicandreceivinghospitalsreportnoconcernsaboutclinicalcareprovidedbySubletteCountyEMS.
3E.EMSisadequatelyintegratedintothelocalhealthcaresystem.TensionbetweenEMSandclinical/hospitalstaffoftenoccurswhenEMSispartofahospitalorhealthcaredistrict.ThistensionoftenisduetodifferencesbetweenhowEMSoperatescomparedtoclinicsandhospitals.IssuesthatcreatetensionareEMScrews’downtimebetweencalls,theprovisionofuniforms,andanexpectationthatEMScrewsbeusedtosupplementclinicorhospitalstaff.ThereisasurprisingabsenceofthesetensionsinSubletteCounty.TheclinicstaffclearlyembracestheEMSdepartmentandtheuniquenessofhowEMSoperates.ThedistricthassucceededinintegratingEMSinwaysthatstrengthenbothEMSandthedistrict.EMSiscalledupontoassistwithpatientcareinamannerthatstrengthensEMSclinicalskillsanddeepenstherelationshipbetweenEMSandclinicpersonnel.EMScrewsprovideavitalandcost‐savingafter‐hourfunctionofopeningtheclinicforpatients,beginningpatientcareandsummoningnursing/medicalstaff.TheintegrationdescribedabovepavesthewayforfurtherintegrationusingCommunityParamedicineandMobileIntegratedHealthcare.(SeeAppendixA).
![Page 23: Final Report ASSESSMENT · SafeTech Solutions is an EMS consulting firm with extensive expertise evaluating EMS organizations and assisting in the development of rural ambulance services](https://reader036.vdocuments.site/reader036/viewer/2022081613/5fb8596b1cbe0049666cd917/html5/thumbnails/23.jpg)
23
3F.SubletteCountyEMShasaknowledgeableandcompetentbillingdepartment.WhenevaluatinganEMSagency’sbillingcapacity,SafeTechSolutionsconsidersthebillingstaff’stechnicalknowledgeofEMS‐specificbilling,theuseandunderstandingofkeyreimbursementperformancemeasures,thetimeavailabletomanageEMSclaims,andwhetherEMSreimbursementisseenasaprioritycomparedtootherclaimswithintheorganizations.SubletteCountyEMSbillingstaffisknowledgeableaboutEMSbilling,includingareassuchasHCPCcodes,originanddestinationmodifiers,andtheneedtobillMedicareforadenialpriortobillingabeneficiaryforanon‐coveredservice.Thebillingstaffisabletoquicklyandeasilyprovidedataonkeybillingperformancemeasures,suchasA/Rdays,A/R,payermix,andbillablecallsbyoriginanddestination.Itisunlikelythatoutsourcingbillingwouldbringadditionalrevenuesintothesystem.Outsourcingcouldcomplicatefinancialmanagement;impedethewayinwhichbillingpracticesworkwithintheorganizationalmission,vision,andvalues;andhindercustomerservice.4.SubletteCountyEMSfacesmajorchallengesassociatedwiththelocaleconomy,aswellaswithitspositionwithinthehealthcaredistrictanditslackofaclearvisionandstrategicplan.MajorchallengesfacingSubletteCountyEMSarethelocaleconomy,howEMSispositionedwithinSubletteCountyRuralHealthCareDistrict,andtheabsenceofaclearvisionandstrategicplanforEMS.Specifically,thesechallengesare:4A.SubletteCountyanticipatessharpreductionsintaxrevenues.Duringthepastdecade,SubletteCountyEMShasoperatedwithoutmuchconcernaboutoperationalcosts.Thelocaleconomyprovidedampleresourcesthroughtherevenuescollectedbythehealthcaredistrictthat,inturn,subsidizedtheEMSsystemtothetuneofmorethan$1millionannually.18Asignificantdownturninthelocalmineralextraction‐basedeconomyisthreateningtheresourcesavailabletosubsidizeEMSoperations.
InformantsfromSubletteCountyandthehealthcaredistrictreportedanexpectationofsignificantdeclinesinrevenuesin2016andbeyond.EffectiveMay21,2016,thehealthcaredistrictbeganinitiativesto“rightsize”healthcareservicesprovidedinSubletteCounty.Theseinitiativescomeontheheelsofananticipated$3.5millionreductionoftaxrevenuethiscomingbudgetyear.Itisalsoanticipatedthatthedistrictwillfaceanadditional$1.75millionreductionforthe2017budget.
Reductionsinexpendituresincludeadjustmentstoemployeebenefits,positioneliminationperattrition,paywageadjustmentsperattritionandchangesofpurchasinggroupfor 18 Asubsidyistherevenuesneededtomakeupthedifferencebetweenoperationalcostsandwhatiscollectedfrombillingforservices.
![Page 24: Final Report ASSESSMENT · SafeTech Solutions is an EMS consulting firm with extensive expertise evaluating EMS organizations and assisting in the development of rural ambulance services](https://reader036.vdocuments.site/reader036/viewer/2022081613/5fb8596b1cbe0049666cd917/html5/thumbnails/24.jpg)
24
suppliesandequipment.SaturdayclinichoursattheBigPiney/MarbletonandPinedaleClinicsweresuspendedindefinitely.
4B.EMSwillbeaffectedbychangeswithinthehealthcaredistrict.Aspartofitsefforttoincreaseservicesandrevenue,SubletteCountyhealthcaredistricthasbeenaggressivelyseekingCriticalAccessHospital(CAH)designationforitsPinedaleclinic.CAHdesignationhasthepotentialtogreatlyenhancebillingrevenuethroughcost‐basedreimbursementforcurrentservices,aswellaspermitadditionalservicessuchasin‐patientcare,swingbedcareandobservationcare.ThischangeofdesignationcouldhavebothpositiveandnegativeimplicationsforEMS.Currently,about30percentofpatienttransferstoout‐of‐countyemergencydepartmentswouldbeeligibleforcareataCAH,meaningpatientswouldnotbetransferred,andasaresult,transferrevenuewoulddiminish.However,CAHstatusalsohasthepotentialtoincreaseEMSrevenuebecauseambulancetransportstotheCAHwouldbecomeeligibleforreimbursement(whereastransportstotheclinicarenot).AmbulanceservicesthatarepartofaCAHthatmeetthe35‐milerulealsoareeligibleforcost‐basedreimbursement,unlikethemajorityofambulanceserviceswhicharereimbursedunderaMedicareFeeschedule.Thehealthcaredistrictiscurrentlyawaitinga“greenlight”fromcountycommissionerstomakerequiredphysicalchangestotheclinicstructurestomeethospitallifesafetycodesandregulations.WhetherCAHdesignationwillbesuccessfulisunknown.Acrossthenation,manyCAHsfacesignificantsustainabilityissues.Informantsareconcernedthatdistricttime,attention,focusandresourceswillbeneededtomakeaSubletteCountyCAHsuccessfulandmaydivertimportantresourcesfromEMS.Asoneinformantsaid,“Ifthathospitalfails,we’llstillneedEMS.”4C.PerceptionsaboutthehealthcaredistrictmayhurtEMS.SomeinformantsreportedhavinglittleconfidenceinthehealthcaredistrictBoardofTrusteesbeingabletoadapttodeclinesintaxrevenues.Someinformantsbelievethatthedistricthasoverbuilt,growntoolarge,andisunwillingtoreduceservicestomatchdecliningrevenues.Theseperceptionsmayhaveanimpactonthelong‐termviewofEMSinSubletteCountyandtheresourcesthatitneedstocontinuetoprovideahighlevelofqualityservice.4D.SubletteCountyEMSlacksaclearvisionandstrategicplan.Localresidents,ambulancepersonnelanddistrictleadersareeasilyabletoarticulatetheday‐to‐daybenefitsofhavingahighlevelofqualityEMSinSubletteCounty.CommunityinformantsspokepassionatelyabouttheimportanceofEMSasameanstoaccessthehealthcaresystem.However,bothinformantsandEMSstaffalsoexpressedconcernaboutthefuturebecauseEMSlacksaclearvisionandstrategicplan.Asresourcesbecomescarce,findingandkeepingtherightpersonnelbecomesmoredifficult,leadersareforcedtomakedifficultdecisions,andthereisuncertaintyaboutwhatwillguideplanninganddecision‐making.Havingaclearlydefinedandeasilyunderstoodvisionandplanforthefutureprovidesleaderswithapowerfulstorywhenfightingforresources.
![Page 25: Final Report ASSESSMENT · SafeTech Solutions is an EMS consulting firm with extensive expertise evaluating EMS organizations and assisting in the development of rural ambulance services](https://reader036.vdocuments.site/reader036/viewer/2022081613/5fb8596b1cbe0049666cd917/html5/thumbnails/25.jpg)
25
5.SubletteCountyEMSlacksclaritywithregarditsstructure,leadership,workforce,anddatagathering.5A.Thehealthcaredistrictreportingstructureneedsclarification.ThecurrentorganizationalchartshowstheEMSdirectorreportingdirectlytotheEMSmedicaldirector.Inpractice,informantsdescribetheEMSdirectorasreportingtothehealthcaredistrictadministratorforoperationalandfinancialissuesandtotheEMSmedicaldirectorforclinicalissues.Organizationalchartsprovideclearlinesofauthorityandresponsibilities.Theycreatestructurestosupportefficiencies,synergiesandcollaborations.Operations(theambulancedepartmentleader)andclinicalcare(themedicaldirector)mustworkcloselyandhavesharedresponsibilitieswithintheambulancedepartment.However,attimes,theyhaveconflictingresponsibilities,suchasmeetingbudgetresponsibilitiesversusnewclinicalinitiatives.5B.Departmentaljobdefinitionsandreportingstructureareweak.SubletteCountyEMShasaninformalstructurethatidentifiesanambulancedirector,assistantdirector,supervisors,employeeswithassignedareasorresponsibilities(suchasQAorvehiclemaintenance),andclinicalstaff.Jobdescriptionsandkeyperformanceindicatorsforeachjobarenotup‐to‐date,nordotheyaccuratelyreflectcurrentperformance.Formalizingtitles,positions,jobdescriptionsandreportingstructureprovidesclarityandensuresallemployeeshavetheappropriateresponsibilityandempowermenttobesuccessfulwithintheirpositions.5C.ThecurrentEMSleaderdoesnothavedeepoperationalandfinancialexperienceinEMS.Whilewellliked,thecurrentEMSleaderlacksexperienceintheEMSindustry.InformantswithinandoutsideoftheorganizationreportthatthecurrentEMSdirectorisanexcellentchoicetoleadtheorganization.Heisrespectedandcreditedwithbringingafun,friendly,team‐likeculturetotheorganization.SafeTechSolutionsagrees;however,whilehehasgreatbusinessandpeople‐managementskills,heandthedepartmentcouldbenefitfromadeepeningofhisexposuretoandknowledgeofEMSleadershipandmanagementconceptsspecifictoEMSorganizations.ThisincludesEMSleadership,matchingcallvolumewithresources,schedulinginalow‐volumeagency,longtransports,matchingorganizationalresourcestoadecreasingcallvolume,andEMSemployeeengagement.5D.EMSemployeeengagementisprecarious.Whileemployeesgenerallyreportbeingcommittedtotheorganizationandpleasedwithitscurrentleadership,employeeengagementatSubletteCountyEMSnonethelessseemstenuous.Thisconclusionisrelatedtothemannerinwhichcut‐backswerehandledpriortotheleadershipofthecurrentEMSdirector,concernsaboutannualearnings,concernsaboutthelocaleconomyandthefinancialhealthofthehealthcaredistrict,perceptionsthatEMSisnotapriorityforthedistrict,concernsthatannualincomewillbereducedastheEMSdepartmentlimitsovertime,andconcernsthatthecurrentleaderwillnotstay.Employeeengagementisawayoftalkingaboutemployees’enthusiasm,commitment,
![Page 26: Final Report ASSESSMENT · SafeTech Solutions is an EMS consulting firm with extensive expertise evaluating EMS organizations and assisting in the development of rural ambulance services](https://reader036.vdocuments.site/reader036/viewer/2022081613/5fb8596b1cbe0049666cd917/html5/thumbnails/26.jpg)
26
loyaltyandwillingnesstodomorethanrequiredtoadvancetheorganizationalmission.Employeeengagementiskeytoorganizationalsuccess.Engagementisconnectedtoefficiency,safety,customerservice,patientcareandlong‐termsuccess.Currently,SubletteCountyEMShasnoformalmeansofmeasuringemployeeengagement.6.SubletteCountyEMSisnotoperatingefficientlynormaximizingitsrevenuefrompatientbilling,anditmayhavelittleornoincentivetodoso.6A.Thecurrentschedulingsystemisnotefficient.Thecurrentcallscheduleof48hourson/96hoursoffisdemandingonfieldpersonnelandresultsin2,496hoursofovertimeperfull‐timeemployeeperyear.Thismodelisfinanciallyunsustainableandexposestheorganizationtolargelegalrisks,suchaswageandhourcomplaintsandlitigation,andtheriskofmedicalerrors,vehiclecrashes,andlowemployeemoraleandengagement.ThecallscheduleusedbySubletteCountyEMSjeopardizestheorganization’slong‐termsurvivabilitybycreating96hoursofovertimeperweek.Inatwo‐weekpayperiod,thetypicalfull‐timeemployeeworks48hoursofstraighttimeand96hoursoftime‐and‐a‐half.Thissystemisusingthe8and80rule,inwhichovertimeispaidforanyhoursovereightinagivenday.With96hoursofovertimeperpayperiod,anemployeereceives2,496hoursofovertimeeveryyear.Thissystemresultsinemployeesreceivingmoreinovertimepaythantheydoinstraighttime(1,248hoursofstraighttime,2,496hoursofovertimepay)andanannualwageof$77,875peryearforastartingparamedic.Payrollcostswillgrowexponentiallyduetothescheduledovertime.Thelogicalresultisunsustainablegrowthinsalarydollars.
AnticipatedWageIncreasesOvertheNextFiveYears
UndertheCurrentOvertimeSystem19
19 Thecalculationusesstartingparamedicpayandassumesatotalyearlyincreaseincompensationof3percent.
1248
2496
Straight Time vs. Over Time
Straight Time
Over Time
![Page 27: Final Report ASSESSMENT · SafeTech Solutions is an EMS consulting firm with extensive expertise evaluating EMS organizations and assisting in the development of rural ambulance services](https://reader036.vdocuments.site/reader036/viewer/2022081613/5fb8596b1cbe0049666cd917/html5/thumbnails/27.jpg)
27
2016 2017 2018 2019 2020
Straight Time $19,468.80 $20,052.86 $20,654.45 $21,274.08 $21,912.31
Over Time $58,406.40 $60,158.59 $61,963.35 $63,822.25 $65,736.92
Annual Comp $77,875.20 $80,211.46 $82,617.80 $85,096.33 $87,649.22
Anothersignificantconcernisthepossibleeffectthat48hoursofon‐dutytimecouldhaveonemployees,suchastheriskoffatigueresultinginmedicalerrors,motorvehicleaccidents,lowengagement,poormorale,andpoorphysicalhealth.Nationally,mostorganizationsareeliminating24‐hourshiftsduetooverwhelmingresearchlinkingshiftlengthwithmedicalerrors,vehicleaccidentsandpooremployeehealth.6B.TheEMSsystemhastoomanyresourcesforitscallvolume.Thecurrentunitdeploymentmodelofthree24‐hourambulancecrewsondutyperday(fourduringsummerhours)plusasupervisorwithaccesstoanEchounitdoesnotmatchthecallvolumeoffewerthantwocallsaday.Themostreliabledataforunderstandingthecurrentcallvolumecomesfromthebillingdepartment,whichsuggeststhatSubletteCountyEMSrespondstoanestimated589callsperyear.20Thisaveragesto1.7callsaday.Becauseofalackofdata,someassumptionsneedtobemadetocalculateneededresources.Forexample,let’ssayonecallperdayresultsinapatientbeingtransportedtoalocalclinic,andthattransporttakesonehourfromstarttofinish.Asecondcallresultsinanout‐of‐countytransportthattakesatotalofsixhours.Theresultwouldsuggestthatambulancesareengagedanaverageofsevenhoursperday.Basedonthisassumption,aswellasavailabledata,itisreasonabletoassumethattwo24‐hourambulancecrewscouldeasilyprovidecoveragetoSubletteCounty,withaminimaldelayinresponsetimesoroccurrenceswhentheunitsareunavailable.21Incontrast,SubletteCountyEMScurrentlystaffsthreeambulances24hoursaday,andfourinthesummermonths.Thisstaffingmodel,coupledwiththeamountofovertimethatresultsfromit,ispartlyresponsiblefor$1.9millioninexpenses(muchofwhichgoestolabor),anda$1.4millionannualshortfall.6C.Billingratesforpatienttransportsaretoolow.SubletteCountyEMSmaybelosingrevenuebybillingatratesthatarelessthanthecostofprovidingservice.Acrudewaytocalculatetargetbillingratesistodividetotalexpensesbytotalbillabletransports.Withexpensesof$1.9millionand491billabletransports,eachcallwouldneedtoreturn$3,853tothesystemtocovertheexpenseofprovidingtheservice. 20 Thisiscalculatedbyadding20percentor99responsestothereported491billablecallsin2015.A20percentno‐transportrateiscommonforU.S.EMSservices. 21 AtypicalEMSgoalistostaffforcoverageof80percentofthecallvolume.Itwouldbefinanciallyunsustainabletostafffor100percentofcallvolume(i.e.alwayshavinganambulancewaitingforthepotentialofacall).
![Page 28: Final Report ASSESSMENT · SafeTech Solutions is an EMS consulting firm with extensive expertise evaluating EMS organizations and assisting in the development of rural ambulance services](https://reader036.vdocuments.site/reader036/viewer/2022081613/5fb8596b1cbe0049666cd917/html5/thumbnails/28.jpg)
28
Incontrast,SubletteCountyEMSreceives,onaverage,$913percall,resultinginalossof$2,940.95percall,basedoncurrentexpenses.Raisingratesclosertonationalaverages(seechartonPage17)couldoffsetasmuchas50percentofthecurrentexpenses.Forexample,let’ssayrateswereraisedtoananaveragechargeof$3,335pertransport.Atthecurrentrateofreturn(45percent),eachtransportwouldresultin$1,500.75,foratotalofroughly$740,000annually.TheEMSsystemmightfindadditionalrevenuebytakingall192patientscurrentlybeingtransportedbyairmedicalservicesandshiftingthemtogroundambulance,whichcouldaddanadditional$288,144totherevenue,foratotalof$1,028,000annuallyorapproximatelyone‐halfofthecurrentexpenses.ItisunlikelythatSubletteCountyEMScouldraiseitsrateshighenoughtobreakeven;however,withcostcontainmentandincreasedrevenues,itcoulddramaticallyreducetheamountofneededsubsidy.6D.EMSislosingpotentialrevenuebytransportingpatientstodistrictclinics.WhenSubletteCountyEMStransportspatientstodistrictclinicsratherthantohospitals,andthepatientsaretreatedattheclinicsandnottransferredtohospitals,SubletteCountyEMScannotcollectforitsservices.TheCentersforMedicareandMedicaidServices(CMS)doesnotallowambulanceservicestobillMedicareforambulancetransportstoalternatedestinations,suchasclinicsandphysicians’offices.Theexactnumberofpatientstransportedtoclinicseachyearisnotknown;however,SafeTechSolutionsbelievesthatitrepresentssomepotentiallostrevenue.AnambulanceservicemaybillMedicarepatients(usingtheuniqueclaimcodeA0888non‐coveredservice)fortransportstoaclinicorphysician’sofficeonceanofficialdenialofpaymentisreceivedfromMedicare;however,thereisnoindicationthatthispracticebeingdone.UseofA0888,oftenreferredtoas“billingforadenial,”wouldprovideanindicationofhowoftenthissituationoccurs.6E.EMSdoesnothaveacapitalreplacementplan.Havingadetailedcapitalreplacementplanguidesadepartmentinplanningfortheuseoflimitedcapitalfunds.Withoutalong‐termplan,resourcesoftenareallocatedtothecrisisoftheday,ordepartmentsarepittedagainsteachother,whichresultsintensionandturmoilwithintheorganization.6F.Thefrequentuseofairmedicalresourcesmaynotbeclinicallynecessaryoroperationallyefficient.SubletteCountyEMScurrentlydoesnottracktheuseofairmedicalresourcesinthecounty,nordoesithaveanairmedical‐specificprotocoltoguidefieldandclinicpersonnelintheuseofairmedicaltransport.Theuseofairmedicalresourcescanbedifficultandcomplex.Whendistancesaregreatandapatientappearsacute,airmedicaltransportappearstobeareasonablechoice.However,costs,risksandlossofgroundtransportrevenueareimportantfactorsintheairmedicalequation.AnairmedicalhelicopterbillinWyomingtodayisroughly$65,000andcouldhavea20percentco‐paytothepatientofroughly$13,000.Airmedicalresourcesareoftenoverused.22Bydeveloping
22 http://www.theatlantic.com/health/archive/2016/01/air‐ambulance‐helicopter‐cost/425061/
![Page 29: Final Report ASSESSMENT · SafeTech Solutions is an EMS consulting firm with extensive expertise evaluating EMS organizations and assisting in the development of rural ambulance services](https://reader036.vdocuments.site/reader036/viewer/2022081613/5fb8596b1cbe0049666cd917/html5/thumbnails/29.jpg)
29
guidelinesforappropriateuseandarigorouspost‐usereviewprocess,SubletteCountycanensurethatairmedicaltransportiswarranted,andthecostandrisksjustified.6G.TheongoinghealthcaredistrictsubsidyoftheEMSservicemightserveasadisincentiveforimprovedorganizationalefficiencyandrevenuemaximization.TheexpensestooperateSubletteCountyEMStodayfarexceeditsrevenues.ThepolicybythehealthcaredistricttooffsetEMSlossesusingdistrictfundsmaybeadisincentivetotheEMSsystemtoraiseitsbillingrates,takeonmorepatienttransfers,andmakeotherchangesnecessarytoachieveabalancedbudget.Withoutasignificantsubsidyfromthedistrict,SubletteCountyEMSwouldberequiredtomakesignificantadjustmentstoitsexpensesandrevenuestoremainfinanciallyviable.Whileitisnotuncommonforruralambulanceserviceswithalargegeographiccoverageareaandalowcallvolumetobesubsidized,asubsidythatconsistentlymakesupforashortfallwithoutdemandingconcomitantresponsibilitymaycreateanenvironmentinwhichattentiontofiscalresponsibilityisoverlooked.7.SubletteCountyisfailingtodoanadequatejobofcollectingdataandanalyzinginformationaboutitsEMSsystem.SubletteCountyEMSlacksreliabledataandinformationneededforanalysisandimprovement.BasicdataandespeciallyhistoricaldataaresomeofthemostimportanttoolsanEMSleadercanhave.Databecomesevenmoreimportantwhenmanagingaruralorganizationwithalargeanddiverseserviceareaandlowcallvolume.7A.SubletteCountyEMSdoesnothavebasiccalldata,andthedatathatitdoeshaveisatoddswithstate‐reporteddata.SubletteCountyEMSneedsreliableanddependabledatasourcesthatitcanminetoconductanalysesofkeyperformanceindicators,suchascalldata,peakvolumeperiods,financialperformance,medicationandequipmentutilization,etc.BasedonSafeTechSolutions’multipleattemptstoobtainreliablecalldata,theonlysourceofreliableinformationappearstobethebillingsystem.TherealsoisadiscrepancybetweendatareportedtothestateEMSdatabase(WATRS)andtheorganization’srunvolumedata(Seegraphiconpage30),resultinginaninabilitytoproperlyuseretrospectivedatatodrivestrategicdecision‐making.Calldata,suchascallsbytimeofdayanddayofweek,helpmanagerstoknowwhentodeployresources.Ascallvolumegrowsordeclines,datainformsdecisionsaboutwhentoaddresourcesorwhentotakeresourcesoutofthesystem.
![Page 30: Final Report ASSESSMENT · SafeTech Solutions is an EMS consulting firm with extensive expertise evaluating EMS organizations and assisting in the development of rural ambulance services](https://reader036.vdocuments.site/reader036/viewer/2022081613/5fb8596b1cbe0049666cd917/html5/thumbnails/30.jpg)
30
DataDiscrepancies
2011 2012 2013 2014 2015
WATRS Data for Total Responses 1117 976 994 859 799
Ambulance Responses (estimated from billing data) 766 658 580 582 589
Total Billed Ambulance Transports 638 548 483 485 491
7B.SubletteCountyEMSdoesnothavedefinedkeyperformanceindicators(KPIs).KPIsaremeasurablevaluesthatdemonstrateshoweffectivelyanEMSsystemisperforminginkeyobjectives.EMSorganizationsuseKPIstoevaluatetheirsuccessatreachingtargetsandmakingneededchange.7C.SubletteCountyhasnoformalorinformalprocessformeasuringEMSemployeeengagement.Employeeengagementisakeyindicatoroforganizationalperformance.Engagedemployeesdriveorganizationalsuccess.Disengagedemployeesmaydragdownothersandimpactoperationalperformance,patientcarequality,customerserviceandrecruitmentandretention(especiallyinatimeofworkforceshortages).A2013HarvardBusinessReviewAnalyticServicesreportofmorethan550executivesfoundthat71percentofexecutivesrankemployeeengagementasveryimportantinachievingsuccess.23Acrossthenation,someofthebestEMSorganizationsarefindingthatprioritizingandmeasuringemployeeengagementisaperformancemeasurethathasabigimpactonall
23 TheImpactofEmployeeEngagementonPerformance,2013,HarvardBusinessSchoolPublishing.
0
200
400
600
800
1000
1200
2011 2012 2013 2014 2015
WATRS Data for TotalResponses
Total Ambulance Responses(estimated from billing data)
![Page 31: Final Report ASSESSMENT · SafeTech Solutions is an EMS consulting firm with extensive expertise evaluating EMS organizations and assisting in the development of rural ambulance services](https://reader036.vdocuments.site/reader036/viewer/2022081613/5fb8596b1cbe0049666cd917/html5/thumbnails/31.jpg)
31
others.Engagementisformallymeasuredusingengagementsurveysandinformallymeasuredbypreparingleadersandsupervisorstoprioritizeengagementandrecognizeitspresenceorabsence.7D.SubletteCountyhasnoformalmeasurementofEMScustomersatisfaction.WhileSubletteCountyHealthCareDistrictdoestrackcustomersatisfactionthroughsurveys,itscustomersatisfactiondataisnotspecifictoindividualdepartments.ThegeneralityofthedatamakesitdifficulttounderstandthesuccessesandareasforgrowthintheEMSdepartment.EMSmaybeapatient’sfirstexperienceorthelastexperiencewithahealthcaresystem.Theseimpressionsoftencolortheentirepatientexperience.UnderstandingmorespecificallyhowEMSismodelingtheactionsandbehaviorsoftheorganizationwouldprovideactionablegoalsandobjectivesforthedepartment.
![Page 32: Final Report ASSESSMENT · SafeTech Solutions is an EMS consulting firm with extensive expertise evaluating EMS organizations and assisting in the development of rural ambulance services](https://reader036.vdocuments.site/reader036/viewer/2022081613/5fb8596b1cbe0049666cd917/html5/thumbnails/32.jpg)
32
V. Recommendations1.CreateavisionandplanforEMSsuccessandsustainability.Avisionisavisualizationanddescriptionofthefuturethatguidesplanninganddecision‐making.Theprocessofcreatingavisionassistsanorganizationinthinkingthroughwhereitisgoingandwhatspecificallyisneededtogetthere.AsthehealthcaredistrictpursuesCAHdesignationforitsclinic,itshouldalsocreateavisionforsustaininghighqualityEMSinthecounty.WhileaCAHwillexpandlocalmedicalcareandprovideadvantagesforpatientstabilizationandlocalmitigationofminormedicalemergencies,SubletteCountywillalwaysbereliantuponemergencymedicaltransportationtohigherlevelsofcare.AvisionforthefutureofEMSinSubletteCountyshouldincludethefollowingelements: Adescriptionofthelevel,quantityandqualityofservicesneeded,wantedand
fundable.Thevisionshouldreflectalevel,quantityandqualityofEMSserviceappropriateforalargeruralregionwithlimitedmedicalresources,longresponseandtransporttimes,andlimitationsofclimate,weatheranddistancetovariousmedicalspecialties.ThelevelofcareenvisionedwilllikelybeAdvancedLifeSupportwithsomecriticalcareandcommunityparamediccomponents.ThequantityofEMSresourcesshouldappropriatelyfitanticipatedcallvolume,andqualityshouldbeassessedandguidedbybestpractices.
PrioritizationofEMSaboveotherlocalmedicalofferings.BecauseofEMS’svitaltransportationroletoadvancedlevelsofcare,itisessentialthatEMShavepriorityinhealthcarespendinginSubletteCounty.ThevisionshouldtakeintoconsiderationtheopportunitiesandrisksofCAHdesignation,whichcouldprovideadditionalresourcestoEMS,suchastheabilitytobillwhenpatientsarebroughttotheCAH,aswellascost‐basedreimbursementforEMS.ButCAHdesignationalsocouldbecomealiabilityforEMSbybecomingthetoppriorityincommandingdistrictresources,suchastime,attentionandmoney,inboththeshort‐termandlong‐term.EMSmustremainapriorityregardlessofCAHdesignation.
ApowerfulandreassuringstorytotellaboutEMS.AvisionthatensuresEMSwillbeprioritizedindistrictplanningmayassistleadershipintellingareassuringstoryabouttheuseoflocalfinancialresources.
Maximizationoftheuseofground‐basedEMS.Inenvisioningthefuture,itisimperativethatEMSisappropriatelyusednotonlyfor911responseandtransportbutalsoforinterfacilitytransfersaswellintheemergingroleofintegratingwithandextendingaccesstohealthcarethroughcommunityparamedicine.
![Page 33: Final Report ASSESSMENT · SafeTech Solutions is an EMS consulting firm with extensive expertise evaluating EMS organizations and assisting in the development of rural ambulance services](https://reader036.vdocuments.site/reader036/viewer/2022081613/5fb8596b1cbe0049666cd917/html5/thumbnails/33.jpg)
33
2.StrengthentheEMSorganizationalstructureandleadershipteamtosupportsustainability.HavingastrongorganizationalstructureintheEMSdepartmentwillcontributetolong‐termsustainabilityandisvitaltoorganizationalperformance.SubletteCountyEMSshouldtakethefollowingactions: ClarifytheEMSreportingstructureforEMSwithinthehealthcaredistrict.Boththe
EMSdirectorandtheEMSmedicaldirectorshouldreportdirectlytothehealthcareadministrator,withdottedlinereportingbetweentheEMSdirectorandtheEMSmedicaldirector.Thisstructurecreatesanadvantageousseparationbetweenclinicalcarereportingandoperationalandfinancialreporting.
Clearlydefinetheroles,responsibilitiesandperformanceindicatorsoftheEMSleadership/managementteam.Identifytheneededteamstructureandroles(suchasdirector,assistantdirector/manager,qualitycoordinator,supervisors,trainingcoordinator,etc.).Rolesandtitlesshouldhaveclearjobdescriptionsandperformanceindicatorsthatareunderstoodbyallandusedtoguideperformance.
InvestintheEMSleadershipteam’sknowledgeofEMSoperationsandfinanceandexposuretobestpractices.SubletteCountyEMSwillbenefitfromEMSleadershiptrainingandeducation,exposuretoothersystems,andcontinuouslearningaboutbestpracticesandinnovation.LeadershipshouldbeencouragedtoattendEMSleadershipeducation,conferencesandseminars.
Ensuretheleadershipteamiscommittedtotheorganizationanditsfuture.
3.Strengthenoperationalandfinancialefficiencybynarrowingthegapbetweenexpensesandrevenues.Efficientuseofhuman,financialandmaterialresourcesiskeytolong‐termsustainability.SubletteCountyEMScouldcutitscurrentlossesinhalf,andpossiblymovethedepartmenttobreak‐evenstatusbytakingthefollowingactions: Reducethenumberofdeployedresourcestomatchanticipatedcallvolume.Basedon
bestavailabledata,SubletteCountyEMShastoomanystaffedambulancesondutyperdayandshouldreduceresourcestotwo24‐hourtransportingambulancesperday.UnitutilizationshouldbestudiedtoconsidertheadditionofanEchounittoaugmentresponsecapability.
Developandimplementanewcallschedulethatreducesovertimeandissafeandhumane.Thecurrent48on/96offscheduleshouldbemodifiedtoonethatislesstaxingonfieldpersonnelandresultsinlessovertime.SafeTechSolutionsrecommendsa36‐hourworkweekforfieldstaff.Theschedulewouldconsistofthree12‐hourshifts.Twoofthe12‐hourshiftscouldbeputtogetherforamaximumof24hoursonduty,withatleast12hoursoffbetweenshifts.Thischangemay
![Page 34: Final Report ASSESSMENT · SafeTech Solutions is an EMS consulting firm with extensive expertise evaluating EMS organizations and assisting in the development of rural ambulance services](https://reader036.vdocuments.site/reader036/viewer/2022081613/5fb8596b1cbe0049666cd917/html5/thumbnails/34.jpg)
34
requirethehiringofadditionalfieldpersonnelandwillresultinadditionalshort‐termexpenses(hiring,uniforms),butissaferinthelong‐term.Inaddition,itwillresultinlessovertime,whichwillreduceexpenses.Eliminatingscheduledovertimeshouldbeagoal,andunscheduledovertimeshouldbenomorethan10percentoftotalwages.
Raiserevenuebyincreasingbillingrates,capturinglostrevenueandensuringallpatientsaretransportedtoahospital.
Developacapitalvehiclereplacementplan.Developaschedulewithcostsforallcapitalpurchasesoverthenext10years.Usethisscheduleasamaptoplanfinanciallyandoperationallytoensurethattheorganizationhasthemostup‐to‐datephysicalassetsandfinancestopayforthoseassets.
Useairmedicalresourcesefficiently.Airmedicaluseshouldbeguidedbyclinicalandoperationalneedsanddeterminedbyastandardprotocol.Createanairmedicalprotocolbystudyingcurrentairmedicaluseanddeterminingwhetheruseismedicallynecessaryandappropriate.DeterminewhetherSubletteCountyEMSislosingrevenuebyover‐useofairmedicalresourcesversuslong‐distancegroundtransports.
4.Usedatatodrivedecisions.Thecollectionandappropriateuseofdataisessentialtoefficientsystemoperations.Decision‐makingshouldbeguidedbyreliabledataandinformation.Specifically,SubletteCountyEMSshould: Ensurethatessentialdataisreliable,complete,andconsistentwithotherdatasources,
suchasWATRSandthelocalcommunicationcenter.TheWATRSsystemprovidesmanypre‐definedandcustomreportstoanalyzesystemperformance.EnsuringthedatasubmittedtoWATRSis100percentreliableshouldbeapriority.
Developadashboardthatincludeskeyperformanceindicatorscriticalforsuccess.A
dashboardisaquickwayofmonitoringsystemperformance.ForSubletteCountyEMS,adashboardmayinclude:
o Systemstatus(howoftendeployedresourcesarebeingusedandhowoften,whenthesystemislowonresourcesandresponsetime);
o Schedulingandovertime(consistencyofscheduletolimitovertimetopredeterminedlevel);
o Clinicalquality(protocolcompliance);o Financialperformance(expenses,revenues,collectionrates)’o Airmedicaluse;ando Customersatisfaction.
Regularlymeasureemployeeengagement.Employeeengagementiskeytoensuring
thattheorganizationhasaculturethatemployeesloveandtowhichtheyare
![Page 35: Final Report ASSESSMENT · SafeTech Solutions is an EMS consulting firm with extensive expertise evaluating EMS organizations and assisting in the development of rural ambulance services](https://reader036.vdocuments.site/reader036/viewer/2022081613/5fb8596b1cbe0049666cd917/html5/thumbnails/35.jpg)
35
attracted.Engagementshouldbemeasuredthroughannualsurveysandregularconversationswithemployeesconcerningkeyengagementissues.
5.Continuetodevelophealthcareintegration
ThedistrictshouldcontinuetointegrateEMSintoitshealthcareofferings,andexploreexpandingitsuseofEMSintonon‐911serviceswiththegoalofcreatingatrulyintegratedcaremodel(seeAppendixA).
![Page 36: Final Report ASSESSMENT · SafeTech Solutions is an EMS consulting firm with extensive expertise evaluating EMS organizations and assisting in the development of rural ambulance services](https://reader036.vdocuments.site/reader036/viewer/2022081613/5fb8596b1cbe0049666cd917/html5/thumbnails/36.jpg)
36
Appendix A WhatisCommunityParamedicine?CommunityParamedicsorMobileIntegratedHealthcare(MIH)istheprovisionofhealthcareusingpatient‐centered,mobileresourcesintheout‐of‐hospitalenvironment.Itmayinclude,butisnotlimitedto,servicessuchasprovidingtelephoneadviceto9‐1‐1callersinsteadofresourcedispatch;providingcommunityparamedicinecare,chronicdiseasemanagement,preventivecareorpost‐dischargefollow‐upvisits;ortransportorreferraltoabroadspectrumofappropriatecare,notlimitedtohospitalemergencydepartments.KeycomponentsofMIHprogramsinclude:• Fullyintegrated–avitalcomponentoftheexistinghealthcaresystem,withefficient
bidirectionalsharingofpatienthealthinformation.• Collaborative–predicatedonmeetingadefinedneedinalocalcommunityarticulatedby
localstakeholdersandsupportedbyformalcommunityhealthneedsassessments.• Supplemental–enhancingexistinghealthcaresystemsorresources,andfillingthe
resourcegapswithinthelocalcommunity.• Datadriven–datacollectedandanalyzedtodevelopevidence‐basedperformance
measures,researchandbenchmarkingopportunities.• Patient‐centered–incorporatingaholisticapproachfocusedontheimprovementof
patientoutcomes.• Recognizedasthemultidisciplinarypracticeofmedicine–overseenbyengaged
physiciansandotherpractitionersinvolvedintheMIHprogram,aswellasthepatient’sprimarycarenetwork/patient‐centeredmedicalhome,usingtelemedicinetechnologywhenappropriateandfeasible.
• Teambased–integratingmultipleproviders,bothclinicalandnon‐clinical,inmeetingtheholisticneedsofpatientswhoareeitherenrolledinorreferredtoMIHprograms.
• Educationallyappropriate–includingmorespecializededucationofcommunityparamedicineandotherMIHproviders,withtheapprovalofregulatorsorlocalstakeholders.
• ConsistentwiththeInstituteforHealthcareImprovement'sIHITripleAimphilosophyofimprovingthepatientexperienceofcare;improvingthehealthofpopulations;andreducingthepercapitacostofhealthcare.
• Financiallysustainable–includingproactivediscussionandfinancialplanningwithfederalpayers,healthsystems,AccountableCareOrganizations,managedcareorganizations,PhysicianHospitalOrganizations,legislatures,andotherstakeholderstoestablishMIHprogramsandcomponentservicesasanelementoftheoverall(IHI)TripleAimapproach.
Legallycompliant–throughstrong,legislatedenablementofMIHcomponentservicesandprogramsatthefederal,stateandlocallevels.