Economic Growth, Productivity, and Living Standards
Economic Growth, Productivity, and Living Standards
Principles of Macroeconomics
Dr. Gabriel X. Martinez
Ave Maria University
Chapter 20: Economic Growth, PrChapter 20: Economic Growth, Productivity, and Living Standardsoductivity, and Living Standards
22Copyright c 2004 by The McGraw-HillCompanies, Inc. All rights reserved.
Potential Output and the Long RunPotential Output and the Long Run
Potential output, as we know, is not Potential output, as we know, is not influenced by inflation.influenced by inflation.
An economy’s productive capacity is An economy’s productive capacity is determined bydetermined by– Human capital, Physical capital, Social capitalHuman capital, Physical capital, Social capital– Land and natural resourcesLand and natural resources– Technology, Management and entrepreneurshipTechnology, Management and entrepreneurship– Population, Social and legal environment.Population, Social and legal environment.
Chapter 20: Economic Growth, PrChapter 20: Economic Growth, Productivity, and Living Standardsoductivity, and Living Standards
33Copyright c 2004 by The McGraw-HillCompanies, Inc. All rights reserved.
IntroductionIntroduction
Why is economic growth good?Why is economic growth good?– More medicines:More medicines:
longer life expectancy and better healthlonger life expectancy and better health
– More schools and school materials:More schools and school materials: you know more, your friends know more.you know more, your friends know more.
– More economic stabilityMore economic stability No need to worry about feeding your family.No need to worry about feeding your family.
Chapter 20: Economic Growth, PrChapter 20: Economic Growth, Productivity, and Living Standardsoductivity, and Living Standards
44Copyright c 2004 by The McGraw-HillCompanies, Inc. All rights reserved.
IntroductionIntroduction
However…However…– More production may also mean that society More production may also mean that society
becomes obsessed with production and not with becomes obsessed with production and not with other good things in life.other good things in life.
– More production may come at the cost of social More production may come at the cost of social cohesion or the environment.cohesion or the environment.
Chapter 20: Economic Growth, PrChapter 20: Economic Growth, Productivity, and Living Standardsoductivity, and Living Standards
55Copyright c 2004 by The McGraw-HillCompanies, Inc. All rights reserved.
Real GDP per Person in Five Real GDP per Person in Five Industrialized Countries, 1870 - 2000Industrialized Countries, 1870 - 2000
Historical estimates are less precise: our accounting improved over time.Historical estimates are less precise: our accounting improved over time.Comparing economic output over a century cannot account for new Comparing economic output over a century cannot account for new goods and services; and we are not accounting for pollution, more stress, goods and services; and we are not accounting for pollution, more stress, etc.etc.
Chapter 20: Economic Growth, PrChapter 20: Economic Growth, Productivity, and Living Standardsoductivity, and Living Standards
77Copyright c 2004 by The McGraw-HillCompanies, Inc. All rights reserved.
Real GDP per Person In Selected Real GDP per Person In Selected Countries, 1870-2000 (in 1995 U.S. Dollars)Countries, 1870-2000 (in 1995 U.S. Dollars)
Country
Australia 5,626 7,385 9,561 18,033 24,708 1.1 1.9
Canada 2,447 5,791 9,362 20,899 26,604 1.8 2.1
France 2,249 4,401 6,049 17,801 22,447 1.8 2.6
Germany 1,205 2,320 5,005 18,014 23,247 2.3 3.1
Italy 2,248 3,167 4,042 13,331 21,930 1.8 3.4
Japan 963 1,825 2,216 16,899 24,772 2.5 4.8
United Kingdom 3,500 5,374 7,832 14,889 21,142 1.4 2.0
United States 2,843 6,745 11,921 22,480 32,629 1.9 2.0
Annual % change
1950-2000
Annual % change
1870-20001870 1913 1950 1979 2000
Observations•1870: Australia had the highest per capital real GDP and Japan the lowest•2000 real per capita GDP in Japan exceeded Australia•Note the difference in the growth rate of 1.1% for Australia and 2.5% for Japan
Chapter 20: Economic Growth, PrChapter 20: Economic Growth, Productivity, and Living Standardsoductivity, and Living Standards
88Copyright c 2004 by The McGraw-HillCompanies, Inc. All rights reserved.
Notice:Notice:– In 1870, Canada and the US had similar per In 1870, Canada and the US had similar per
capita GDPs.capita GDPs.– But the US grew slightly faster on average (1.9 But the US grew slightly faster on average (1.9
percent versus 1.8 percent per year).percent versus 1.8 percent per year).– Now the US is significantly richer than Canada.Now the US is significantly richer than Canada.
Why “Small” Differences in Growth Why “Small” Differences in Growth Rates MatterRates Matter
Chapter 20: Economic Growth, PrChapter 20: Economic Growth, Productivity, and Living Standardsoductivity, and Living Standards
1010Copyright c 2004 by The McGraw-HillCompanies, Inc. All rights reserved.
Why “Small” Differences in Growth Rates MatterWhy “Small” Differences in Growth Rates Matter
Year Initial GDPAdded GDP(3% growth
rate)Final GDP Initial GDP
Added GDP(3.5% growth
rate)
Final GDP
1 10,000 300 10,300 10,000 350 10,350
2 10,300 309 10,609 10,350 361 10,711
3 10,609 318 10,927 10,711 371 11,082
4 10,927 328 11,255 11,082 382 11,464
5 11,255 338 11,593 11,464 394 11,858
6 11,593 348 11,941 11,858 406 12,264
7 11,941 358 12,299 12,264 418 12,682
8 12,299 369 12,668 12,682 430 13,112
9 12,668 380 13,048 13,112 443 13,556
10 13,048 391 13,439 13,556 457 14,012
Chapter 20: Economic Growth, PrChapter 20: Economic Growth, Productivity, and Living Standardsoductivity, and Living Standards
1111Copyright c 2004 by The McGraw-HillCompanies, Inc. All rights reserved.
Growth rate (%) Value of $10,000 after 200 years
1.8 $354,450
2 $524,850
2.2 $776,570
Observations•A small sum compounded over long periods can greatly increase in value.•Small differences in growth rates have a very large impact on value.•If a country manages to grow merely 0.4 percentage points faster, it will be twice as rich in 200 years.
Why “Small” Differences in Growth Why “Small” Differences in Growth Rates MatterRates Matter
Chapter 20: Economic Growth, PrChapter 20: Economic Growth, Productivity, and Living Standardsoductivity, and Living Standards
1212Copyright c 2004 by The McGraw-HillCompanies, Inc. All rights reserved.
– The growth rate applies not only on the original The growth rate applies not only on the original GDP but on all previously accumulated growth.GDP but on all previously accumulated growth.
– Government policies that affect the long-term Government policies that affect the long-term growth rate by a small amount will have a major growth rate by a small amount will have a major economic impact.economic impact.
Why “Small” Differences in Growth Why “Small” Differences in Growth Rates MatterRates Matter
Chapter 20: Economic Growth, PrChapter 20: Economic Growth, Productivity, and Living Standardsoductivity, and Living Standards
1313Copyright c 2004 by The McGraw-HillCompanies, Inc. All rights reserved.
Why Nations Become Rich: The Crucial Why Nations Become Rich: The Crucial Role of Average Labor ProductivityRole of Average Labor Productivity
QuestionQuestion– What determines a nation’s economic growth What determines a nation’s economic growth
rate?rate?– Some definitions:Some definitions:
YY = real GDP = real GDP NN = number of employed workers = number of employed workers POPPOP = total population = total population
Chapter 20: Economic Growth, PrChapter 20: Economic Growth, Productivity, and Living Standardsoductivity, and Living Standards
1414Copyright c 2004 by The McGraw-HillCompanies, Inc. All rights reserved.
Why Nations Become Rich: The Crucial Why Nations Become Rich: The Crucial Role of Average Labor ProductivityRole of Average Labor Productivity
Real GDP Per PersonReal GDP Per Person
POP
Nx
N
Y
POP
Y
ObservationsReal output/person depends on:
How much each worker can produce.The percent of the population that is working.
GDPper
capita=
# of employedpopulationx
averagelabor
productivity
Chapter 20: Economic Growth, PrChapter 20: Economic Growth, Productivity, and Living Standardsoductivity, and Living Standards
1515Copyright c 2004 by The McGraw-HillCompanies, Inc. All rights reserved.
Why Nations Become Rich: The Crucial Why Nations Become Rich: The Crucial Role of Average Labor ProductivityRole of Average Labor Productivity
N/POPN/POP– Increases in female labor force participation contribute Increases in female labor force participation contribute
to increasing GDP per capita.to increasing GDP per capita.– Immigration may contribute to increasing N/POP Immigration may contribute to increasing N/POP
because immigrants are often of working age.because immigrants are often of working age.– The massive retirement of baby-boomers reduces the The massive retirement of baby-boomers reduces the
percentage of population employed and GDP per capita.percentage of population employed and GDP per capita.
POP
Nx
N
Y
POP
Y
Chapter 20: Economic Growth, PrChapter 20: Economic Growth, Productivity, and Living Standardsoductivity, and Living Standards
1616Copyright c 2004 by The McGraw-HillCompanies, Inc. All rights reserved.
Why Nations Become Rich: The Crucial Why Nations Become Rich: The Crucial Role of Average Labor ProductivityRole of Average Labor Productivity
Y/NY/N– In the long run, increases in output per person In the long run, increases in output per person
arise primarily from increases in average labor arise primarily from increases in average labor productivity (Y/N).productivity (Y/N).
POP
Nx
N
Y
POP
Y
The Determinants of Average The Determinants of Average Labor ProductivityLabor Productivity
Chapter 20: Economic Growth, PrChapter 20: Economic Growth, Productivity, and Living Standardsoductivity, and Living Standards
1818Copyright c 2004 by The McGraw-HillCompanies, Inc. All rights reserved.
The Determinants of Average Labor The Determinants of Average Labor ProductivityProductivity
Human CapitalHuman Capital
Social CapitalSocial Capital
Physical CapitalPhysical Capital
Land and Natural ResourcesLand and Natural Resources
Chapter 20: Economic Growth, PrChapter 20: Economic Growth, Productivity, and Living Standardsoductivity, and Living Standards
1919Copyright c 2004 by The McGraw-HillCompanies, Inc. All rights reserved.
The Determinants of Average Labor The Determinants of Average Labor ProductivityProductivity
TechnologyTechnology
PopulationPopulation
Management and EntrepreneurshipManagement and Entrepreneurship
Social and Legal EnvironmentSocial and Legal Environment
Chapter 20: Economic Growth, PrChapter 20: Economic Growth, Productivity, and Living Standardsoductivity, and Living Standards
2020Copyright c 2004 by The McGraw-HillCompanies, Inc. All rights reserved.
Human CapitalHuman Capital– The talents, education, training, and skills of The talents, education, training, and skills of
workers.workers. Remember that physical capital is “produced and Remember that physical capital is “produced and
durable goods that are used to produce other goods.”durable goods that are used to produce other goods.” Education (or training) is like capital because it is Education (or training) is like capital because it is
“produced”, it is durable, and it helps us produce “produced”, it is durable, and it helps us produce more goods than we would have produced without more goods than we would have produced without education.education.
The Determinants of Average The Determinants of Average Labor ProductivityLabor Productivity
Chapter 20: Economic Growth, PrChapter 20: Economic Growth, Productivity, and Living Standardsoductivity, and Living Standards
2121Copyright c 2004 by The McGraw-HillCompanies, Inc. All rights reserved.
ExampleExample– James and Kate draw graphs in MS Word.James and Kate draw graphs in MS Word.
James (a novice) draws 1 graph/hr or 40 James (a novice) draws 1 graph/hr or 40 graphs/week.graphs/week.
Kate (has taken many economics courses) draws Kate (has taken many economics courses) draws 30/hr or 1200/week.30/hr or 1200/week.
Average labor productivity/week = (40+1200)/2 = Average labor productivity/week = (40+1200)/2 = 620/week620/weekor 1240/80 hrs = 15.5 graphs/hr.or 1240/80 hrs = 15.5 graphs/hr.
Kate (with training) is more productive than James.Kate (with training) is more productive than James.
The Determinants of Average The Determinants of Average Labor ProductivityLabor Productivity
Chapter 20: Economic Growth, PrChapter 20: Economic Growth, Productivity, and Living Standardsoductivity, and Living Standards
2222Copyright c 2004 by The McGraw-HillCompanies, Inc. All rights reserved.
ExampleExample– South Korea and Nicaragua since WWIISouth Korea and Nicaragua since WWII– Both are a tiny countries close to economic Both are a tiny countries close to economic
giants.giants.– Korean culture (emphasizes order and learning) Korean culture (emphasizes order and learning)
encouraged economic growth much more than encouraged economic growth much more than Nicaragua’s.Nicaragua’s.
– Now Korea is in the “club for rich countries”, the Now Korea is in the “club for rich countries”, the OECD. OECD.
The Determinants of Average The Determinants of Average Labor ProductivityLabor Productivity
Chapter 20: Economic Growth, PrChapter 20: Economic Growth, Productivity, and Living Standardsoductivity, and Living Standards
2323Copyright c 2004 by The McGraw-HillCompanies, Inc. All rights reserved.
Social CapitalSocial Capital– Social capital is important because all Social capital is important because all
production processes require many people production processes require many people working together.working together. Without trust, contracts fail and ideas don’t get Without trust, contracts fail and ideas don’t get
developed.developed.
– Social Capital is the habitual way of doing Social Capital is the habitual way of doing things that guides people in how they approach things that guides people in how they approach production and economic life.production and economic life. Trust, conventions, agreed expectations.Trust, conventions, agreed expectations.
The Determinants of Average The Determinants of Average Labor ProductivityLabor Productivity
Chapter 20: Economic Growth, PrChapter 20: Economic Growth, Productivity, and Living Standardsoductivity, and Living Standards
2424Copyright c 2004 by The McGraw-HillCompanies, Inc. All rights reserved.
Physical CapitalPhysical Capital– Worker productivity depends not only on their Worker productivity depends not only on their
skills (human capital) but on the tools (physical skills (human capital) but on the tools (physical capital) they have to work with.capital) they have to work with.
– Tools.Tools.– Buildings.Buildings.– Factories.Factories.– Machines.Machines.– Software.Software.
The Determinants of Average The Determinants of Average Labor ProductivityLabor Productivity
Chapter 20: Economic Growth, PrChapter 20: Economic Growth, Productivity, and Living Standardsoductivity, and Living Standards
2525Copyright c 2004 by The McGraw-HillCompanies, Inc. All rights reserved.
ExampleExample– James gets better software.James gets better software.
Microsoft produces a new kind of graphing utility for Microsoft produces a new kind of graphing utility for WordWord
An untrained student using the new software can An untrained student using the new software can draw 20 graphs/hour.draw 20 graphs/hour.
James uses the new software and Kate graphs with James uses the new software and Kate graphs with the old software.the old software.
The Determinants of Average The Determinants of Average Labor ProductivityLabor Productivity
Chapter 20: Economic Growth, PrChapter 20: Economic Growth, Productivity, and Living Standardsoductivity, and Living Standards
2626Copyright c 2004 by The McGraw-HillCompanies, Inc. All rights reserved.
ExampleExample– James gets better software James gets better software (AMU buys 1 license).(AMU buys 1 license).
James’s weekly output (40 hrs x 20) = 800 graphs.James’s weekly output (40 hrs x 20) = 800 graphs. Kate’s weekly output (40 hrs x 30) = 1200 graphs.Kate’s weekly output (40 hrs x 30) = 1200 graphs.
Total output = 2,000 graphs/weekTotal output = 2,000 graphs/week or average labor productivity = 1,000 graphs/week or average labor productivity = 1,000 graphs/week or 2,000/80 hrs. = 25 graphs/hr.or 2,000/80 hrs. = 25 graphs/hr.
– James’s use of the new software increases average James’s use of the new software increases average productivity 62 percent.productivity 62 percent.
The Determinants of Average The Determinants of Average Labor ProductivityLabor Productivity
Chapter 20: Economic Growth, PrChapter 20: Economic Growth, Productivity, and Living Standardsoductivity, and Living Standards
2727Copyright c 2004 by The McGraw-HillCompanies, Inc. All rights reserved.
– James and Kate get better softwareJames and Kate get better software(AMU buys 2 licenses).(AMU buys 2 licenses). Kate’s hourly productivity increases to 50 graphs/hr.Kate’s hourly productivity increases to 50 graphs/hr. James’s weekly output (40 hrs x 20) = 800 graphs.James’s weekly output (40 hrs x 20) = 800 graphs. Kate’s weekly output (40 hrs x 50) = 2000 graphs.Kate’s weekly output (40 hrs x 50) = 2000 graphs.
Total output = 2,800 graphs/weekTotal output = 2,800 graphs/week or average labor productivity = 1,400 graphs/weekor average labor productivity = 1,400 graphs/week or 2,800/80 hrs. = 35 graphs/hr.or 2,800/80 hrs. = 35 graphs/hr.
– James’s and Kate’s use of the new software increases James’s and Kate’s use of the new software increases average productivity 40 percent.average productivity 40 percent.
The Determinants of Average The Determinants of Average Labor ProductivityLabor Productivity
Chapter 20: Economic Growth, PrChapter 20: Economic Growth, Productivity, and Living Standardsoductivity, and Living Standards
2828Copyright c 2004 by The McGraw-HillCompanies, Inc. All rights reserved.
Capital, Output, and Productivity Capital, Output, and Productivity in the Computer Clusterin the Computer Cluster
(1) Number of licencse (capital)
0 1240 80 15.5
1 2,000 80 25
2 2,800 80 35
3 2,800 80 35
(2) Total number of
graphs drawn each week (output)
(3) Total hours worked per
week
(4) Graphs drawn per
hour worked (productivity)
Observations• For a given number of workers, adding capital will generally increase output and average labor productivity.
• The more capital that is already in place, the smaller the benefits of adding extra capital.
Chapter 20: Economic Growth, PrChapter 20: Economic Growth, Productivity, and Living Standardsoductivity, and Living Standards
2929Copyright c 2004 by The McGraw-HillCompanies, Inc. All rights reserved.
Diminishing Returns to CapitalDiminishing Returns to Capital– If the amount of labor and other inputs If the amount of labor and other inputs
employed is held constant, then the greater the employed is held constant, then the greater the amount of capital already in use, the less an amount of capital already in use, the less an additional unit of capital adds to production.additional unit of capital adds to production.
The Determinants of Average The Determinants of Average Labor ProductivityLabor Productivity
Chapter 20: Economic Growth, PrChapter 20: Economic Growth, Productivity, and Living Standardsoductivity, and Living Standards
3030Copyright c 2004 by The McGraw-HillCompanies, Inc. All rights reserved.
The Determinants of Average The Determinants of Average Labor ProductivityLabor ProductivityO
utpu
t
Amount of Capital
More capital adds more output.
But each unit of extra capital adds less extra output.
Chapter 20: Economic Growth, PrChapter 20: Economic Growth, Productivity, and Living Standardsoductivity, and Living Standards
3131Copyright c 2004 by The McGraw-HillCompanies, Inc. All rights reserved.
Physical CapitalPhysical Capital– Public policy designed to stimulate growth Public policy designed to stimulate growth
should consider that:should consider that: Increasing the amount of capital available to the Increasing the amount of capital available to the
workforce will tend to increase output and average workforce will tend to increase output and average labor productivity.labor productivity.
The degree to which productivity can be increased by The degree to which productivity can be increased by an expanding stock of capital is limited.an expanding stock of capital is limited.
The Determinants of Average The Determinants of Average Labor ProductivityLabor Productivity
Chapter 20: Economic Growth, PrChapter 20: Economic Growth, Productivity, and Living Standardsoductivity, and Living Standards
3232Copyright c 2004 by The McGraw-HillCompanies, Inc. All rights reserved.
Average Labor Productivity and Capital Average Labor Productivity and Capital per Worker in 15 Countries, 1990per Worker in 15 Countries, 1990
Using Econometrics: Statistical theory applied to economics helps us find relations between variables.
For example, it can help us explain the approximate effect more Real Capital per Worker on Real GDP per worker…
… and to explain why the US has more per-worker GDP (and Germany less per-worker GDP) than just the level of capital would predict.
Chapter 20: Economic Growth, PrChapter 20: Economic Growth, Productivity, and Living Standardsoductivity, and Living Standards
3333Copyright c 2004 by The McGraw-HillCompanies, Inc. All rights reserved.
Land and Other Natural ResourcesLand and Other Natural Resources– Generally, an abundance of natural resources Generally, an abundance of natural resources
increases the productivity of workers.increases the productivity of workers.– Sometimes, abundance of natural resources is Sometimes, abundance of natural resources is
not necessary or useful:not necessary or useful: A country might get “lazy” because everything comes A country might get “lazy” because everything comes
out of the land.out of the land. Resources can be obtained throughResources can be obtained through
international markets.international markets.
The Determinants of Average The Determinants of Average Labor ProductivityLabor Productivity
Chapter 20: Economic Growth, PrChapter 20: Economic Growth, Productivity, and Living Standardsoductivity, and Living Standards
3434Copyright c 2004 by The McGraw-HillCompanies, Inc. All rights reserved.
TechnologyTechnology– Technology isTechnology is
the the body of knowledge available to a civilization – body of knowledge available to a civilization – skills, scientific methods and materials – for skills, scientific methods and materials – for making goods and supplying services.making goods and supplying services.
The Determinants of Average The Determinants of Average Labor ProductivityLabor Productivity
Chapter 20: Economic Growth, PrChapter 20: Economic Growth, Productivity, and Living Standardsoductivity, and Living Standards
3535Copyright c 2004 by The McGraw-HillCompanies, Inc. All rights reserved.
TechnologyTechnology
New technologies are the single most New technologies are the single most important source of productivity important source of productivity improvement.improvement.
– A new technology will expand the productivity in A new technology will expand the productivity in many sectors by stimulating greater many sectors by stimulating greater specialization.specialization.
The Determinants of Average The Determinants of Average Labor ProductivityLabor Productivity
Chapter 20: Economic Growth, PrChapter 20: Economic Growth, Productivity, and Living Standardsoductivity, and Living Standards
3636Copyright c 2004 by The McGraw-HillCompanies, Inc. All rights reserved.
PopulationPopulation– Some economists have argued that an Some economists have argued that an
important factor in technological development is important factor in technological development is population growth.population growth. More population implies a greater demand for goods, More population implies a greater demand for goods,
and therefore a demand for new technologies.and therefore a demand for new technologies. Moreover, more population increases opportunities Moreover, more population increases opportunities
for scientific and social cooperation.for scientific and social cooperation. This means that natural resourcesThis means that natural resources
won’t get exhausted.won’t get exhausted.
The Determinants of Average The Determinants of Average Labor ProductivityLabor Productivity
Chapter 20: Economic Growth, PrChapter 20: Economic Growth, Productivity, and Living Standardsoductivity, and Living Standards
3737Copyright c 2004 by The McGraw-HillCompanies, Inc. All rights reserved.
The Determinants of Average The Determinants of Average Labor ProductivityLabor Productivity
A more highly populated country gives more opportunities for scientific interaction.
Comparing technological development over a billion years, economist Michael Kremer of Harvard (1993) found that
Higher Initial Population and Population Growth Higher Technological Development
Chapter 20: Economic Growth, PrChapter 20: Economic Growth, Productivity, and Living Standardsoductivity, and Living Standards
3838Copyright c 2004 by The McGraw-HillCompanies, Inc. All rights reserved.
Entrepreneurship and ManagementEntrepreneurship and Management– Entrepreneurship is the ability to get things done.Entrepreneurship is the ability to get things done.
It’s having creativity and visionIt’s having creativity and vision It also involves a talent for translating that vision into reality.It also involves a talent for translating that vision into reality. Factors influencing entrepreneurshipFactors influencing entrepreneurship
– Social CustomsSocial Customs
– TaxationTaxation
– RegulationRegulation
– Management:Management: Influence productivity by implementing more efficient methods Influence productivity by implementing more efficient methods
of production.of production.
The Determinants of Average The Determinants of Average Labor ProductivityLabor Productivity
Chapter 20: Economic Growth, PrChapter 20: Economic Growth, Productivity, and Living Standardsoductivity, and Living Standards
3939Copyright c 2004 by The McGraw-HillCompanies, Inc. All rights reserved.
Economic Growth:Economic Growth: what does it cost us? what does it cost us?
There is no such thing as a free lunchThere is no such thing as a free lunch– To increase the stock of physical or human capital, we To increase the stock of physical or human capital, we
must divert resources that could otherwise be used to must divert resources that could otherwise be used to increase the supply of consumer goods.increase the supply of consumer goods. More machines or industrial software means less butter and More machines or industrial software means less butter and
fewer sports cars.fewer sports cars. More education to earn a higher income tomorrow means less More education to earn a higher income tomorrow means less
time to earn a high income today.time to earn a high income today.
Chapter 20: Economic Growth, PrChapter 20: Economic Growth, Productivity, and Living Standardsoductivity, and Living Standards
4040Copyright c 2004 by The McGraw-HillCompanies, Inc. All rights reserved.
Economic Growth:Economic Growth: what does it cost us? what does it cost us?
There is no such thing as a free lunchThere is no such thing as a free lunch– Research and Development of new Research and Development of new
technologies involves sacrifice of current goods.technologies involves sacrifice of current goods.– Many countries have achieved a high standard Many countries have achieved a high standard
of living through allowing great income of living through allowing great income inequalities in the past.inequalities in the past.
Chapter 20: Economic Growth, PrChapter 20: Economic Growth, Productivity, and Living Standardsoductivity, and Living Standards
4343Copyright c 2004 by The McGraw-HillCompanies, Inc. All rights reserved.
The Role of Government in Fostering The Role of Government in Fostering ProductivityProductivity– Establish:Establish:
Well-defined property rightsWell-defined property rights Maintain Maintain political stabilitypolitical stability Promote Promote free and open exchange of ideasfree and open exchange of ideas
The Determinants of Average The Determinants of Average Labor ProductivityLabor Productivity
Chapter 20: Economic Growth, PrChapter 20: Economic Growth, Productivity, and Living Standardsoductivity, and Living Standards
4444Copyright c 2004 by The McGraw-HillCompanies, Inc. All rights reserved.
Economic NaturalistEconomic Naturalist– Why did communism fail?Why did communism fail?
Output per person in the Soviet Union was probably Output per person in the Soviet Union was probably less than one-seventh the U.S. rateless than one-seventh the U.S. rate
The Soviet Union had:The Soviet Union had:– Human capital.Human capital.– Physical capital.Physical capital.– Natural resources.Natural resources.– Technology.Technology.
The Determinants of Average The Determinants of Average Labor ProductivityLabor Productivity
Chapter 20: Economic Growth, PrChapter 20: Economic Growth, Productivity, and Living Standardsoductivity, and Living Standards
4545Copyright c 2004 by The McGraw-HillCompanies, Inc. All rights reserved.
Economic NaturalistEconomic Naturalist– Why did communism fail?Why did communism fail?
There was an absence of:There was an absence of:– Private property rights.Private property rights.– Free markets.Free markets.– Political stability.Political stability.– Modern legal framework.Modern legal framework.
The Determinants of Average The Determinants of Average Labor ProductivityLabor Productivity
Policies for Economic GrowthPolicies for Economic Growth
Chapter 20: Economic Growth, PrChapter 20: Economic Growth, Productivity, and Living Standardsoductivity, and Living Standards
4747Copyright c 2004 by The McGraw-HillCompanies, Inc. All rights reserved.
Promoting Economic GrowthPromoting Economic Growth
Promoting GrowthPromoting Growth– Promote saving and investmentPromote saving and investment
Physical capitalPhysical capital Human CapitalHuman Capital
– Support research and developmentSupport research and development– Improve the legal and political frameworkImprove the legal and political framework
Chapter 20: Economic Growth, PrChapter 20: Economic Growth, Productivity, and Living Standardsoductivity, and Living Standards
4848Copyright c 2004 by The McGraw-HillCompanies, Inc. All rights reserved.
Promoting Economic GrowthPromoting Economic Growth Capital is important for the growth process.Capital is important for the growth process. The U.S. has used tax incentives to The U.S. has used tax incentives to
increase saving.increase saving.– Social Security and IRAs are forms of Social Security and IRAs are forms of
encouragement.encouragement.
Respect for private property is necessary Respect for private property is necessary to encourage people to accumulate capital to encourage people to accumulate capital for long-run benefits.for long-run benefits.
Chapter 20: Economic Growth, PrChapter 20: Economic Growth, Productivity, and Living Standardsoductivity, and Living Standards
5050Copyright c 2004 by The McGraw-HillCompanies, Inc. All rights reserved.
Promoting Economic GrowthPromoting Economic Growth
Greater educational level and skills of the Greater educational level and skills of the workforce workforce higher labor productivity. higher labor productivity.– Accumulation of Human Capital.Accumulation of Human Capital.– Education also is an important source of Social Education also is an important source of Social
Capital.Capital.
Chapter 20: Economic Growth, PrChapter 20: Economic Growth, Productivity, and Living Standardsoductivity, and Living Standards
5151Copyright c 2004 by The McGraw-HillCompanies, Inc. All rights reserved.
Promoting Economic GrowthPromoting Economic Growth
Create Institutions That Encourage Create Institutions That Encourage Technological InnovationTechnological Innovation– PatentsPatents
Patents allow innovators to charge high prices Patents allow innovators to charge high prices profits are the incentive for innovation.profits are the incentive for innovation.
Patents also Patents also fewer positive externalities to fewer positive externalities to technology.technology.
– Protecting property rightsProtecting property rights Innovators need incentives to innovate: enjoying the Innovators need incentives to innovate: enjoying the
fruits of their labors.fruits of their labors.
Chapter 20: Economic Growth, PrChapter 20: Economic Growth, Productivity, and Living Standardsoductivity, and Living Standards
5353Copyright c 2004 by The McGraw-HillCompanies, Inc. All rights reserved.
Promoting Economic GrowthPromoting Economic Growth
The State may need to provide funding for The State may need to provide funding for basic research basic research
Technology’s “common knowledge” aspect Technology’s “common knowledge” aspect little incentive to do basic research (for little incentive to do basic research (for individuals).individuals).– ““Free riders” take advantage of others’ work.Free riders” take advantage of others’ work. Technology is a public good.Technology is a public good.
U.S. government finances 60 percent of the basic U.S. government finances 60 percent of the basic research in the country.research in the country.
Chapter 20: Economic Growth, PrChapter 20: Economic Growth, Productivity, and Living Standardsoductivity, and Living Standards
5555Copyright c 2004 by The McGraw-HillCompanies, Inc. All rights reserved.
Promoting Economic GrowthPromoting Economic Growth The Poorest Countries: A Special Case?The Poorest Countries: A Special Case?
– Improve the legal and political frameworkImprove the legal and political framework Corrupt legal systems create uncertainty about Corrupt legal systems create uncertainty about
property rightsproperty rights Taxation and regulation discourages Taxation and regulation discourages
entrepreneurshipentrepreneurship Markets are not allowed to functionMarkets are not allowed to function Lack of political stability discourages foreign Lack of political stability discourages foreign
investment and makes foreign aid less effective.investment and makes foreign aid less effective.
– ECO 320 studies Development Economics.ECO 320 studies Development Economics.
Limits to Economic GrowthLimits to Economic Growth
Chapter 20: Economic Growth, PrChapter 20: Economic Growth, Productivity, and Living Standardsoductivity, and Living Standards
5757Copyright c 2004 by The McGraw-HillCompanies, Inc. All rights reserved.
Limits to Economic GrowthLimits to Economic Growth
Can a country grow forever without Can a country grow forever without depleting its natural resources and depleting its natural resources and damaging the environment?damaging the environment?– The historical experience in many countries that The historical experience in many countries that
have grown rich is that the environment does have grown rich is that the environment does suffer substantially.suffer substantially.
– Evidently, non-renewable resources can be Evidently, non-renewable resources can be depleted. depleted.
Chapter 20: Economic Growth, PrChapter 20: Economic Growth, Productivity, and Living Standardsoductivity, and Living Standards
5858Copyright c 2004 by The McGraw-HillCompanies, Inc. All rights reserved.
Limits to Economic GrowthLimits to Economic Growth The mistake of this way of thinking is that it The mistake of this way of thinking is that it
assumes that “more GDP” means “more of assumes that “more GDP” means “more of the same stuff”.the same stuff”.
In fact, much of the economic growth we In fact, much of the economic growth we see is see is different different stuff, often stuff that is stuff, often stuff that is environmentally sounder.environmentally sounder.– Richer countries tend to demand “greener” Richer countries tend to demand “greener”
technologies – and are able to afford them.technologies – and are able to afford them.
Chapter 20: Economic Growth, PrChapter 20: Economic Growth, Productivity, and Living Standardsoductivity, and Living Standards
5959Copyright c 2004 by The McGraw-HillCompanies, Inc. All rights reserved.
Limits to Economic GrowthLimits to Economic Growth Another problem with the “limits to growth” idea is Another problem with the “limits to growth” idea is
that it assumes that technology is constant.that it assumes that technology is constant.– In fact, technology changes frequently.In fact, technology changes frequently.– Technological advances often follow periods of scarcity.Technological advances often follow periods of scarcity.– For example, when oil became scarce in the 1970s, For example, when oil became scarce in the 1970s,
firms and consumers reacted by demanding machines firms and consumers reacted by demanding machines that used less oil.that used less oil.
– The price of oil fell dramatically The price of oil fell dramatically over timeover time..– Today, industrialized nations use ½ the oil they used to Today, industrialized nations use ½ the oil they used to
per unit of GDP.per unit of GDP.
Chapter 20: Economic Growth, PrChapter 20: Economic Growth, Productivity, and Living Standardsoductivity, and Living Standards
6060Copyright c 2004 by The McGraw-HillCompanies, Inc. All rights reserved.
Limits to Economic GrowthLimits to Economic Growth
OPEC Oil Embargo
Iranian Revolution
First Gulf War
Second Gulf War
Price of Oil in 2005 US$
Chapter 20: Economic Growth, PrChapter 20: Economic Growth, Productivity, and Living Standardsoductivity, and Living Standards
6161Copyright c 2004 by The McGraw-HillCompanies, Inc. All rights reserved.
Limits to GrowthLimits to Growth
Unlike technology, environmental quality Unlike technology, environmental quality cannot be bought and sold, but is protected cannot be bought and sold, but is protected only by government policy.only by government policy.– Government policy can be misdirected, too late, Government policy can be misdirected, too late,
or simply ineffective.or simply ineffective.– Do we tell the Brazilians to stop eating so we Do we tell the Brazilians to stop eating so we
can protect the rain forest?can protect the rain forest?
Chapter 20: Economic Growth, PrChapter 20: Economic Growth, Productivity, and Living Standardsoductivity, and Living Standards
6262Copyright c 2004 by The McGraw-HillCompanies, Inc. All rights reserved.
Limits to GrowthLimits to Growth Another problem is “human ecology.”Another problem is “human ecology.” Economic growth tends to become its own Economic growth tends to become its own
end.end.– Societies give up traditions, customs, social Societies give up traditions, customs, social
ties;ties;– Religion loses its value and gets squashed by Religion loses its value and gets squashed by
advertising, by laws, or it’s forced away from the advertising, by laws, or it’s forced away from the public sphere.public sphere.
– Loss of a sense of community and human Loss of a sense of community and human dignity in the workplace;dignity in the workplace;
Chapter 20: Economic Growth, PrChapter 20: Economic Growth, Productivity, and Living Standardsoductivity, and Living Standards
6363Copyright c 2004 by The McGraw-HillCompanies, Inc. All rights reserved.
Limits to GrowthLimits to Growth
– A devaluation of the family, which becomes just A devaluation of the family, which becomes just a convenient social arrangement or an a convenient social arrangement or an economic tool or hindrance;economic tool or hindrance;
– ConsumerismConsumerism: possession and comfort as the : possession and comfort as the end of life. Drugs are an extreme example.end of life. Drugs are an extreme example. ““a style of life which is presumed to be better when it a style of life which is presumed to be better when it
is directed towards "having" rather than "being", and is directed towards "having" rather than "being", and which wants to have more, not in order to be more which wants to have more, not in order to be more but in order to spend life in enjoyment as an end in but in order to spend life in enjoyment as an end in itself ” (Centesimus Annus, 36)itself ” (Centesimus Annus, 36)
Chapter 20: Economic Growth, PrChapter 20: Economic Growth, Productivity, and Living Standardsoductivity, and Living Standards
6464Copyright c 2004 by The McGraw-HillCompanies, Inc. All rights reserved.
Limits to GrowthLimits to Growth
The solution is neither to shrug one’s The solution is neither to shrug one’s shoulders and deny the problemshoulders and deny the problem– ( “if they choose it, who am I to say anything?”)( “if they choose it, who am I to say anything?”)
Nor to stop economic growthNor to stop economic growth– (“stop the world, I want to get off”)(“stop the world, I want to get off”)
Rather, remember Growth is an important Rather, remember Growth is an important means to achieve an end.means to achieve an end.– Societies need to remain sane about what the Societies need to remain sane about what the
end of human life is.end of human life is.
Theories of Economic GrowthTheories of Economic Growth
Chapter 20: Economic Growth, PrChapter 20: Economic Growth, Productivity, and Living Standardsoductivity, and Living Standards
6666Copyright c 2004 by The McGraw-HillCompanies, Inc. All rights reserved.
The Production Function and The Production Function and Theories of GrowthTheories of Growth
The The production functionproduction functionshows the relationship between the quantity of shows the relationship between the quantity of inputs used in production and the quantity of inputs used in production and the quantity of output resulting from production.output resulting from production.
InputsInputs OutputsOutputs
11 1010
22 1818
33 2424
44 2828
Chapter 20: Economic Growth, PrChapter 20: Economic Growth, Productivity, and Living Standardsoductivity, and Living Standards
6767Copyright c 2004 by The McGraw-HillCompanies, Inc. All rights reserved.
The Production Function and The Production Function and Theories of GrowthTheories of Growth
The production function for growth has land, The production function for growth has land, labor, and capital as factors of production.labor, and capital as factors of production.
Output = A• Output = A• ff(Labor, Land, Capital)(Labor, Land, Capital)
– ““AA” is an adjustment factor that captures the ” is an adjustment factor that captures the effect of technology.effect of technology.
Chapter 20: Economic Growth, PrChapter 20: Economic Growth, Productivity, and Living Standardsoductivity, and Living Standards
6868Copyright c 2004 by The McGraw-HillCompanies, Inc. All rights reserved.
Describing Production FunctionsDescribing Production Functions
Remember: what happens when more of Remember: what happens when more of one input is added one input is added withoutwithout increasing any increasing any other inputs?other inputs?
The The law of diminishing returns law of diminishing returns states that states that increasing one output, increasing one output, keeping all others keeping all others constantconstant, will lead to smaller and smaller , will lead to smaller and smaller gains in output.gains in output.
Theories of Economic GrowthTheories of Economic Growth
The Classical Growth ModelThe Classical Growth Model
Chapter 20: Economic Growth, PrChapter 20: Economic Growth, Productivity, and Living Standardsoductivity, and Living Standards
7070Copyright c 2004 by The McGraw-HillCompanies, Inc. All rights reserved.
The Classical Growth ModelThe Classical Growth Model The The Classical growth modelClassical growth model focuses on focuses on
the interaction between land and labor.the interaction between land and labor.
It also stresses the role of capital It also stresses the role of capital accumulation in the growth process.accumulation in the growth process.– This capital accumulation is exogenous This capital accumulation is exogenous
(generated outside of the model).(generated outside of the model).– The more capital an economy has, the faster it The more capital an economy has, the faster it
will grow.will grow.
Chapter 20: Economic Growth, PrChapter 20: Economic Growth, Productivity, and Living Standardsoductivity, and Living Standards
7171Copyright c 2004 by The McGraw-HillCompanies, Inc. All rights reserved.
The Classical Growth ModelThe Classical Growth Model
The Classical growth model focused onThe Classical growth model focused onhow diminishing returns to labor placed how diminishing returns to labor placed limitations on growthlimitations on growth..– It’s typically associated with the work of Thomas It’s typically associated with the work of Thomas
Malthus.Malthus. Land was assumed to be relatively fixed.Land was assumed to be relatively fixed.
– Therefore, additional workers were less and Therefore, additional workers were less and less productive: output per capita would fall as less productive: output per capita would fall as population grew.population grew.
Chapter 20: Economic Growth, PrChapter 20: Economic Growth, Productivity, and Living Standardsoductivity, and Living Standards
7272Copyright c 2004 by The McGraw-HillCompanies, Inc. All rights reserved.
The Classical Growth ModelThe Classical Growth Model
Chapter 20: Economic Growth, PrChapter 20: Economic Growth, Productivity, and Living Standardsoductivity, and Living Standards
7373Copyright c 2004 by The McGraw-HillCompanies, Inc. All rights reserved.
Diminishing Returns of Diminishing Returns of LaborLabor
Output per person
Labor
Production function
Q1
Q2
L1 L*
Chapter 20: Economic Growth, PrChapter 20: Economic Growth, Productivity, and Living Standardsoductivity, and Living Standards
7474Copyright c 2004 by The McGraw-HillCompanies, Inc. All rights reserved.
Focus on Diminishing Marginal Focus on Diminishing Marginal Productivity of Productivity of LaborLabor
As output per person declines, at some As output per person declines, at some point available output is no longer sufficient point available output is no longer sufficient to feed the population.to feed the population.
This belief is called the This belief is called the iron law of wagesiron law of wages.. The long run was called the The long run was called the stationary stationary
statestate..
Chapter 20: Economic Growth, PrChapter 20: Economic Growth, Productivity, and Living Standardsoductivity, and Living Standards
7575Copyright c 2004 by The McGraw-HillCompanies, Inc. All rights reserved.
Focus on Diminishing Marginal Focus on Diminishing Marginal Productivity of Productivity of LaborLabor
Thomas Malthus, in his essay “On Thomas Malthus, in his essay “On Population” (c. 1800) argued that the great Population” (c. 1800) argued that the great majority of the population would always majority of the population would always live at the subsistence level.live at the subsistence level.– If wages rose above subsistence, people If wages rose above subsistence, people
would multiply like roaches.would multiply like roaches.– As population rose and output/worker fell, As population rose and output/worker fell,
“war, famine, and pest” would bring population “war, famine, and pest” would bring population back to subsistence.back to subsistence.
Chapter 20: Economic Growth, PrChapter 20: Economic Growth, Productivity, and Living Standardsoductivity, and Living Standards
7676Copyright c 2004 by The McGraw-HillCompanies, Inc. All rights reserved.
Diminishing Returns of Diminishing Returns of LaborLabor and and Population GrowthPopulation Growth
Output
Labor
Subsistence level of output per worker
Production function
L*
Q1
Q2
L1
Surplus of food
Shortage of food
Chapter 20: Economic Growth, PrChapter 20: Economic Growth, Productivity, and Living Standardsoductivity, and Living Standards
7777Copyright c 2004 by The McGraw-HillCompanies, Inc. All rights reserved.
Malthus versus the Industrial Malthus versus the Industrial RevolutionRevolution
These predictions turn out to be wrong.These predictions turn out to be wrong.– Malthus could not foresee the Industrial Malthus could not foresee the Industrial
Revolution.Revolution.– Dramatic changes in the world’s capacity to Dramatic changes in the world’s capacity to
produce expand the boundaries of life.produce expand the boundaries of life.
Increases in capitalIncreases in capital returns to the extra returns to the extra unit of unit of laborlabor does not decline, even with does not decline, even with fixed fixed landland supplies. supplies.
Chapter 20: Economic Growth, PrChapter 20: Economic Growth, Productivity, and Living Standardsoductivity, and Living Standards
7878Copyright c 2004 by The McGraw-HillCompanies, Inc. All rights reserved.
The Classical Growth ModelThe Classical Growth Model
Chapter 20: Economic Growth, PrChapter 20: Economic Growth, Productivity, and Living Standardsoductivity, and Living Standards
7979Copyright c 2004 by The McGraw-HillCompanies, Inc. All rights reserved.
The Classical Growth ModelThe Classical Growth Model
Classical economists (such as J.S. Mill or A. Classical economists (such as J.S. Mill or A. Marshall 1850 - 1900) focused their analysis, and Marshall 1850 - 1900) focused their analysis, and their policy advice, on how to increase investment:their policy advice, on how to increase investment:
– Policies, therefore should encourage saving and Policies, therefore should encourage saving and investment.investment.
– Countries that save more, invest more and grow faster.Countries that save more, invest more and grow faster.
savings savings investment investment
capital accumulation capital accumulation growth growth
Theories of Economic GrowthTheories of Economic Growth
The Neo-Classical Growth ModelThe Neo-Classical Growth Model
Chapter 20: Economic Growth, PrChapter 20: Economic Growth, Productivity, and Living Standardsoductivity, and Living Standards
8181Copyright c 2004 by The McGraw-HillCompanies, Inc. All rights reserved.
Neo-Classical Theory of Neo-Classical Theory of Economic GrowthEconomic Growth
The Classical School realized that capital The Classical School realized that capital was important.was important.– But it did not have a theory of how capital is But it did not have a theory of how capital is
accumulated.accumulated. This gave rise to the This gave rise to the Neo-Classical Theory Neo-Classical Theory
of Economic Growthof Economic Growth– Robert Solow (in the 1950s – 1960s)Robert Solow (in the 1950s – 1960s)– The level of Capital/Worker is explained The level of Capital/Worker is explained
endogenouslyendogenously to grow to a steady level. to grow to a steady level.
Chapter 20: Economic Growth, PrChapter 20: Economic Growth, Productivity, and Living Standardsoductivity, and Living Standards
8282Copyright c 2004 by The McGraw-HillCompanies, Inc. All rights reserved.
Neo-Classical Theory of Neo-Classical Theory of Economic GrowthEconomic Growth
The idea is that:The idea is that:– If Capital is highly productive If Capital is highly productive workers can save workers can save
a lot a lot savings become capital savings become capital capital / worker capital / worker increases.increases. What happens to returns to the extra unit of capital as What happens to returns to the extra unit of capital as
capital / worker increases?capital / worker increases?
Chapter 20: Economic Growth, PrChapter 20: Economic Growth, Productivity, and Living Standardsoductivity, and Living Standards
8383Copyright c 2004 by The McGraw-HillCompanies, Inc. All rights reserved.
Neo-Classical Theory of Neo-Classical Theory of Economic GrowthEconomic Growth
The idea is that:The idea is that:– If Capital is not very productive If Capital is not very productive workers don’t workers don’t
save much save much capital accumulation slows down capital accumulation slows down capital / worker decreases.capital / worker decreases. What happens to returns to the extra unit of capital as What happens to returns to the extra unit of capital as
capital / worker decreases?capital / worker decreases?
Chapter 20: Economic Growth, PrChapter 20: Economic Growth, Productivity, and Living Standardsoductivity, and Living Standards
8484Copyright c 2004 by The McGraw-HillCompanies, Inc. All rights reserved.
Neo-Classical Theory of Neo-Classical Theory of Economic GrowthEconomic Growth
The focus turns to the diminishing returns to The focus turns to the diminishing returns to capital:capital:
If capital / worker increases If capital / worker increases capital grows faster than labor capital grows faster than labor
extra unit of capital is less productiveextra unit of capital is less productive
As each worker uses more machines, each As each worker uses more machines, each additional machine turns out to be less additional machine turns out to be less productive.productive.
Chapter 20: Economic Growth, PrChapter 20: Economic Growth, Productivity, and Living Standardsoductivity, and Living Standards
8585Copyright c 2004 by The McGraw-HillCompanies, Inc. All rights reserved.
Neo-Classical Theory of Economic Neo-Classical Theory of Economic GrowthGrowth
Chapter 20: Economic Growth, PrChapter 20: Economic Growth, Productivity, and Living Standardsoductivity, and Living Standards
8686Copyright c 2004 by The McGraw-HillCompanies, Inc. All rights reserved.
Diminishing Returns of Diminishing Returns of CapitalCapital
Capital / Worker tomorrow
Capital / Worker today
Capital accumulation per
worker
Chapter 20: Economic Growth, PrChapter 20: Economic Growth, Productivity, and Living Standardsoductivity, and Living Standards
8787Copyright c 2004 by The McGraw-HillCompanies, Inc. All rights reserved.
Diminishing Marginal Productivity Diminishing Marginal Productivity of Capitalof Capital
If capital / worker increases If capital / worker increases capital grows faster than labor capital grows faster than labor
extra unit of capital is less productive extra unit of capital is less productive slower capital / worker growth slower capital / worker growth
capital / worker growth comes to a steady capital / worker growth comes to a steady levellevel
capital / worker income stops risingcapital / worker income stops rising
Chapter 20: Economic Growth, PrChapter 20: Economic Growth, Productivity, and Living Standardsoductivity, and Living Standards
8888Copyright c 2004 by The McGraw-HillCompanies, Inc. All rights reserved.
Diminishing Returns of Diminishing Returns of CapitalCapital and Population Growthand Population Growth
Capital / Worker tomorrow
Capital / Worker today
Population growth x Capital / Worker
Capital accumulation
per worker
Q1
Q2
K/LPoor K/L*
Surplus of Capital
K/LRich
Chapter 20: Economic Growth, PrChapter 20: Economic Growth, Productivity, and Living Standardsoductivity, and Living Standards
8989Copyright c 2004 by The McGraw-HillCompanies, Inc. All rights reserved.
Neo-Classical Theory of Neo-Classical Theory of Economic GrowthEconomic Growth
– Diminishing returns to capital be stronger for richer Diminishing returns to capital be stronger for richer nations than for poor ones.nations than for poor ones.
– Poor countries with little capital should grow faster than Poor countries with little capital should grow faster than countries with lots of capital.countries with lots of capital.
Eventually per capita incomes among nations Eventually per capita incomes among nations would would convergeconverge..
This has not happened because of differences in This has not happened because of differences in hhuman capitaluman capital and and technological progresstechnological progress..
If skills and technology increase faster in a rich country than in a If skills and technology increase faster in a rich country than in a poor one, incomes will not converge.poor one, incomes will not converge.
Chapter 20: Economic Growth, PrChapter 20: Economic Growth, Productivity, and Living Standardsoductivity, and Living Standards
9090Copyright c 2004 by The McGraw-HillCompanies, Inc. All rights reserved.
Technology, Human Capital, and Technology, Human Capital, and GrowthGrowth
Population growth x Capital / Worker
Q1
Q2
K/L1 K/L2
Capital / Worker tomorrow
Capital / Worker today
Capital accumulation
per worker
Better Technology increases productivity
Chapter 20: Economic Growth, PrChapter 20: Economic Growth, Productivity, and Living Standardsoductivity, and Living Standards
9191Copyright c 2004 by The McGraw-HillCompanies, Inc. All rights reserved.
Technology, Human Capital, and Technology, Human Capital, and GrowthGrowth
Chapter 20: Economic Growth, PrChapter 20: Economic Growth, Productivity, and Living Standardsoductivity, and Living Standards
9292Copyright c 2004 by The McGraw-HillCompanies, Inc. All rights reserved.
Sources of Real U.S. GDP Sources of Real U.S. GDP Growth, 1928-2000Growth, 1928-2000
Human capital (13%)Physical capital (19%)
Technology (35%)Labor (33%)
Theories of Economic GrowthTheories of Economic Growth
New Growth TheoryNew Growth Theory
Chapter 20: Economic Growth, PrChapter 20: Economic Growth, Productivity, and Living Standardsoductivity, and Living Standards
9494Copyright c 2004 by The McGraw-HillCompanies, Inc. All rights reserved.
New Growth TheoryNew Growth Theory
Neo-Classical growth theory realized that Neo-Classical growth theory realized that Technology and Human Capital were Technology and Human Capital were important for economic growth.important for economic growth.– But it did not have a theory of how technology But it did not have a theory of how technology
and human capital were accumulated.and human capital were accumulated.
This gave rise to This gave rise to New Growth TheoryNew Growth Theory– NGT explains technology NGT explains technology endogenously.endogenously.
Chapter 20: Economic Growth, PrChapter 20: Economic Growth, Productivity, and Living Standardsoductivity, and Living Standards
9595Copyright c 2004 by The McGraw-HillCompanies, Inc. All rights reserved.
New Growth TheoryNew Growth Theory
New growth theoryNew growth theory emphasizes the role of emphasizes the role of technology rather than capital in the growth technology rather than capital in the growth process.process.
Technology is the result of investment in Technology is the result of investment in creating technology (research and creating technology (research and development).development).– Technology is more complicated than capital Technology is more complicated than capital
because of externalities and learning-by-doing.because of externalities and learning-by-doing.
Chapter 20: Economic Growth, PrChapter 20: Economic Growth, Productivity, and Living Standardsoductivity, and Living Standards
9696Copyright c 2004 by The McGraw-HillCompanies, Inc. All rights reserved.
New Growth theory distinguishes between New Growth theory distinguishes between investment in capital and investment in investment in capital and investment in technology.technology.– Some technological breakthroughs may Some technological breakthroughs may
happen with little investment.happen with little investment.– Large amounts of investment are not a Large amounts of investment are not a
guarantee of finding good ideas.guarantee of finding good ideas.
New Growth TheoryNew Growth Theory
Chapter 20: Economic Growth, PrChapter 20: Economic Growth, Productivity, and Living Standardsoductivity, and Living Standards
9797Copyright c 2004 by The McGraw-HillCompanies, Inc. All rights reserved.
Increases in technology often have Increases in technology often have enormous positive spillover effects.enormous positive spillover effects.– Technological advances in one sector of the Technological advances in one sector of the
economy lead to advances in completely economy lead to advances in completely different sectors.different sectors.
– For example, military research in computers For example, military research in computers led to the mainframe, the personal computer, led to the mainframe, the personal computer, the internet, etc…the internet, etc…
New Growth TheoryNew Growth Theory
Chapter 20: Economic Growth, PrChapter 20: Economic Growth, Productivity, and Living Standardsoductivity, and Living Standards
9898Copyright c 2004 by The McGraw-HillCompanies, Inc. All rights reserved.
Learning by doingLearning by doing – improving the – improving the methods of production through experience.methods of production through experience.– Learning by doing increases the productivity of Learning by doing increases the productivity of
workers.workers.– This counteracts the law of diminishing marginal This counteracts the law of diminishing marginal
productivity.productivity.
New Growth TheoryNew Growth Theory
Chapter 20: Economic Growth, PrChapter 20: Economic Growth, Productivity, and Living Standardsoductivity, and Living Standards
9999Copyright c 2004 by The McGraw-HillCompanies, Inc. All rights reserved.
Network ExternalitiesNetwork Externalities NetworksNetworks
– The use of a good by one individual makes The use of a good by one individual makes that technology more valuable to other people.that technology more valuable to other people.
Switching from a technology Switching from a technology exhibiting network externalities exhibiting network externalities to a superior technology is to a superior technology is expensive and sometimes expensive and sometimes nearly impossible.nearly impossible.This is a reason why This is a reason why technology is subject to technology is subject to uncertainty but also a source of uncertainty but also a source of great benefits.great benefits.
Chapter 20: Economic Growth, PrChapter 20: Economic Growth, Productivity, and Living Standardsoductivity, and Living Standards
100100Copyright c 2004 by The McGraw-HillCompanies, Inc. All rights reserved.
Policy ConsequencesPolicy Consequences
The Classical school is right in part.The Classical school is right in part.– More natural resources per person (and better More natural resources per person (and better
use thereof) will increase standards of living.use thereof) will increase standards of living. The NeoClassical school is right in partThe NeoClassical school is right in part
– More savings and capital encourage growth, but More savings and capital encourage growth, but up to a point.up to a point.
– Technology is key.Technology is key. New Growth theory is right in partNew Growth theory is right in part
– Property rights and networks are key to Property rights and networks are key to technological development.technological development.