Download - Darren slides
Pleasedrawadragonfly
Doesnega0vityhavearoleinlearning?
• HowdoIknowthatI
ThisisCordulegaster boltonii
Evidence
• Checkimagesdescrip0ontocheckthosethatmatched
• Descrip0onsmatchedtogiveastandardmodelofcomparison‐Linneaus
• Checkedspeciesdistribu0onmaps‐foundlocally• CheckedTemporalinforma0on‐right0meofyear• Checkedtwodifferentwebsites‐thatwerereliable
• Iwrotedownacarefulobserva0on
ThisisCordulegaster boltonii‐ or is it
EvidenceAGAINST
• It’sabluryphotograph• Myinterac0onwithitwasatfirstdistracted• Myinterac0onwasbrief• Nopicture(noteven)mineshowsthegoldenreflec0onthatIsaw‐Iseeinmymemory
• Thedistribu0onmapplacedtheSppmorenorthinthecity
• Thespecifichabitatrequirementsegheathlanddon’tmatch.
Judgment
folk‐theory of mindformostpeopleisthatknowledgeasanimmutable,transmissableen0tywithintrinsic
truth.
weshouldlookbeyondthesimplis0cexplicit/tacitordeclara0ve/proceduralduali0esofknowledgewhichtypifyourdiscourse,andincludethesesixknowledgecategories:statable,implicit,episodic,
impressionis0c,skillandregula0ve,eachimportant.
Mezirowpositsthatalllearningischangebutnotallchangeis
transforma0on
Known
UnKnown
Confident
Unaware
Uncertain
Howmightenquiryhelpcanourcollec0vetheoryofmind?
Howmightenquiryhelp?
Assessmenttask
Theegghasmanyproblemstodealwith‐Survivalegnotbeingeaten
Thischangesover0me.Sofortheinstarstagesits
havingenoughfood
Undergoecdysisupto15instars
Successfuldeterminedby
“nega0vefeedback”onthesystem
Metamorphosis‐Emergebecome
public
Ourwalkthrewupamul0tudeofissues
Werefinedour
problemaswelearned
Notjustonce
Successassessmentcriteria
Presen0nglearning
ourchange
(Too?)O_entheonlyvisible
part
Theegghasmanyproblemstodealwith‐Survivalegnotbeingeaten
Thischangesover0me.Sofortheinstarstagesits
havingenoughfood
Undergoecdysisupto15instars
Successfuldeterminedby
“nega0vefeedback”onthesystem
Metamorphosis‐Emergebecome
public
NOTDRIVENBY
AQUESTION
WantsVS
Needs
Notmo0va0on/engagement
led
AllsuccessfulDragonfliesgothroughsamecyclewedidn’t
Butthisstartsmethinkingabout
popula0onstudies
Andheindidualandsocialaspectsoflearning
Since1980,34of37Bri0shspeciesofdragonflyhaveexpandedtheirrangenorthwardsbyanaverageof74km
Why?
Climate
Pollu0on
symbio0c
Compe0tors
What’stheuseofmodelsinassis0ngdevelopingunderstanding?
• NottakingthingsPrima Facie • DiscrepenciesmayleadyoutoCHANGEDunderstanding
• Modelsencourageposi0veandnega0vethinking?