Download - Bad Faith Insurance Coverage
Copyright 2007. All rights reserved.
Bad Faith, Insurance Coverage & Current Issues
Impacting Insurance Defense
Presented byPatricia L. Dodge and Ronald L. Hicks, Jr.
Copyright 2007. All rights reserved.
Discussion Topics
I. Identifying Bad Faith Tort, C/A & Damages I. Identifying Bad Faith Tort, C/A & Damages
II. Negotiation & Settlement Techniques II. Negotiation & Settlement Techniques
III. Legislation Issues & Current Laws III. Legislation Issues & Current Laws
IV. Litigating an Insurance Claim IV. Litigating an Insurance Claim
V. Avoiding Bad Faith Claims V. Avoiding Bad Faith Claims
Copyright 2007. All rights reserved.
Bad Faith Tort, C/A & Damages
I. Identifying Bad Faith Tort, C/A & Damages I. Identifying Bad Faith Tort, C/A & Damages
Bad faith applies to both first party & UM/UIM insurance claims.
No different or heightened duty of good faith exists in the UM/UIM setting.
A. First Party & UM/UIM ClaimsA. First Party & UM/UIM Claims
Copyright 2007. All rights reserved.
Bad Faith Tort, C/A & Damages
Bad faith = “Any frivolous or unfounded refusal to pay proceeds of a policy.”
Bad faith includes failure to investigate the facts and failure to communicate with the insured
Found at 42 Pa.C.S.A. §8371; does not define “bad faith.”
1. PA Statutory Bad Faith Claim1. PA Statutory Bad Faith Claim
Copyright 2007. All rights reserved.
Bad Faith Tort, C/A & Damages
Bad faith does not mean fraudulent.
Bad faith = dishonest purpose; means breach of known duty through motive of self-interest or ill will.
Mere negligence or bad judgment is not bad faith.
Copyright 2007. All rights reserved.
Bad Faith Tort, C/A & Damages
§8371 does not apply to claim of wrongful refusal to renew insurance.
§8371 does not apply to claim for wrongful cancellation of insurance.
§8371 limited to wrongful denial of claim or refusal to pay benefits.
Copyright 2007. All rights reserved.
Bad Faith Tort, C/A & Damages
§8371 claim is not dependent upon resolution of underlying breach of contract claim.
§8371 claim can be successful if breach of contract claim fails for procedural reasons.
§8371 claim is separate, independent claim.
§8371 claim cannot be insured’s sole claim.
Copyright 2007. All rights reserved.
Bad Faith Tort, C/A & Damages
First element is governed by objective analysis; reliance not necessary.
Bad faith must be proven by clear and convincing evidence.
Two elements: Lacks reasonable basis for denying benefits & Knows or recklessly disregards lack of reasonable basis.
2. Elements PA Statutory Bad Faith2. Elements PA Statutory Bad Faith
§8371 applies throughout claim mgmt.
Copyright 2007. All rights reserved.
Bad Faith Tort, C/A & Damages
Hayes and Hollock cases are instructive on what courts find as constituting bad faith.
Bad faith includes asking for unnecessary amount of personal information before honoring claim.
§8371 encompasses a broad range of insurer conduct.
3. Types of Bad Faith Conduct3. Types of Bad Faith Conduct
Copyright 2007. All rights reserved.
Bad Faith Tort, C/A & Damages
Bad faith does not if denial is caused by insured’s own conduct.
Bad faith does not exist when reasonable basis to deny claim can be found, even if not relied upon at time of denial.
Copyright 2007. All rights reserved.
Bad Faith Tort, C/A & Damages
Discovery violations alone do not equate to bad faith.
Bad faith includes conduct during litigation if done with dishonest purpose.
Copyright 2007. All rights reserved.
Bad Faith Tort, C/A & Damages
“Insurer” means only an insurance company.
“Insurer” does not include agents, adjusters, contractors, self-insured entities or loss adjustment companies.
§8371 claim can be pursued only against an “insurer.”
4. Who Is An Insurer?4. Who Is An Insurer?
“Insurer” may be more than one insurance company.
Copyright 2007. All rights reserved.
Bad Faith Tort, C/A & Damages
§8371 applies equally to third party claims.
Third party cannot bring a §8371 claim absent assignment.
B. Third Party ClaimsB. Third Party Claims
Judgment creditor can bring a §8371 claim if permitted by policy.
Copyright 2007. All rights reserved.
Bad Faith Tort, C/A & Damages
1. Negligence/Fraud Claims
2. Breach of Contract Claims
C. Related Causes of ActionC. Related Causes of Action
3. UTPCPL Claims
Copyright 2007. All rights reserved.
Bad Faith Tort, C/A & Damages
Other
DistressInterest
Punitive
Fees
Figuring Out Damages
D. What to Consider When:
Copyright 2007. All rights reserved.
Bad Faith Tort, C/A & Damages
Physical injury required in order to recover emotional distress damages.
Restatement (Second) of Damages §353 permits recovery without bodily injury, but limited situations – not yet adopted in PA
Emotional distress damages are not available under §8371, but can be recovered for breach of contract for insurer’s bad faith.
1. Emotional Distress1. Emotional Distress
Copyright 2007. All rights reserved.
Bad Faith Tort, C/A & Damages
Interest at 6% legal rate awarded as a matter of right in breach of contract actions.
Interest at prime plus 3% awarded at court’s discretion in §8371 actions.
Recovery of prejudgment interest depends on nature of bad faith claim.
2. Interest2. Interest
Interest awarded at court’s discretion in UTPCPL actions.
Copyright 2007. All rights reserved.
Bad Faith Tort, C/A & Damages
Punitive damages are recoverable in §8371 actions at court’s discretion upon bad faith finding.
Punitive damages not recoverable in breach of contract actions for insurer’s bad faith.
3. Punitive Damages3. Punitive Damages
Punitive damages are recoverable in UTPCPL actions at court’s discretion.
Copyright 2007. All rights reserved.
Bad Faith Tort, C/A & Damages
Reasonableness must exist b/n amount and deterrence, tortuous act, plaintiff’s actual harm and defendant’s wealth.
Punitive damages have no proportional relationship to compensatory damages.
Copyright 2007. All rights reserved.
Bad Faith Tort, C/A & Damages
Ratio of punitive damages to actual harm – generally only single-digit ratio will pass muster.
Degree of reprehensibility of tortuous conduct
3. Punitive Damages – Campbell/Gore3. Punitive Damages – Campbell/Gore
Difference b/n punitive damages and civil penalties authorized in comparable cases.
Copyright 2007. All rights reserved.
Bad Faith Tort, C/A & Damages
Attorney’s fees cannot be recovered for breach of contract absent insurer’s bad faith.
Attorney’s fees are awarded at court’s discretion in §8371 actions.
PA follows the “American Rule.”
4. Attorney’s Fees and Expenses4. Attorney’s Fees and Expenses
Attorney’s fees are awarded at court’s discretion in UTPCPL actions.
Copyright 2007. All rights reserved.
Bad Faith Tort, C/A & Damages
No reported case on recovery of “Diagnostic v. Treatment” damages for insurer’s bad faith.
5. Other Damages5. Other Damages
Copyright 2007. All rights reserved.
Bad Faith Tort, C/A & Damages
I. Identifying Bad Faith Tort, C/A & Damages I. Identifying Bad Faith Tort, C/A & Damages
Question & Answer Session
Copyright 2007. All rights reserved.
Negotiation & Settlement
II. Negotiation & Settlement TechniquesII. Negotiation & Settlement Techniques
1. Investigation of Liability & Damages
2. Available Insurance Coverage
A. Appraisal of Insurance ClaimsA. Appraisal of Insurance Claims
3. Other Relevant Issues
Copyright 2007. All rights reserved.
Negotiation & Settlement
II. Negotiation & Settlement TechniquesII. Negotiation & Settlement Techniques
1. Joinder/Consolidation
2. Involvement of Neutral
B. Negotiation StrategiesB. Negotiation Strategies
Copyright 2007. All rights reserved.
Negotiation & Settlement
Question & Answer Session
II. Negotiation & Settlement TechniquesII. Negotiation & Settlement Techniques
Copyright 2007. All rights reserved.
Legislation & Current Laws
III. Legislation Issues & Current Laws III. Legislation Issues & Current Laws
Objections can attack both the procedure and substance of the subpoena.
Failure to raise objections before or at the time of compliance may constitute waiver.
Copyright 2007. All rights reserved.
Legislation & Current Laws
Question & Answer Session
III. Legislation Issues & Current Laws III. Legislation Issues & Current Laws
Copyright 2007. All rights reserved.
Litigating An Insurance Claim
IV. Litigating An Insurance Claim IV. Litigating An Insurance Claim
PA state civil procedure rules mandate use of a timely motion for protective order.
Federal civil procedure rules permit not only a timely motion for protective order, but also written objections to document requests w/n 14 days of service or before compliance if less than 14 days.
Burden of proof is on you.
Copyright 2007. All rights reserved.
Litigating An Insurance Claim
Question & Answer Session
IV. Litigating An Insurance Claim IV. Litigating An Insurance Claim
Copyright 2007. All rights reserved.
Avoiding Bad Faith Claims
V. Avoiding Bad Faith Claims V. Avoiding Bad Faith Claims
A valid subpoena cannot be ignored.
Failure to comply with a subpoena may result in a contempt proceedings.
Contempt of a subpoena is generally punished by way of fine.
Copyright 2007. All rights reserved.
Avoiding Bad Faith Claims
Question & Answer Session
V. Avoiding Bad Faith Claims V. Avoiding Bad Faith Claims
Copyright 2007. All rights reserved.
Bad Faith, Insurance Coverage & Current Issues
Impacting Insurance Defense
Presented byPatricia L. Dodge and Ronald L. Hicks, Jr.
Copyright 2007. All rights reserved.
Learn About The Lawsuit
OpposingCounsel
Caption IssuingAttorney
Orders& Rules
Target
Information
What you need is:
Copyright 2007. All rights reserved.
Assess Risks
ResponseCosts
Relationship Costs
Party Costs
Other Lawsuits
Appearance Fees
Attorneys’ Fees
Copying Costs
Public Disclosure
Owens v. QVC (EDPA)
NMH v. Ashcroft (7th)
“Fishing Expedition”
MGM Studios v. Groskter (D.Del.)
Threat not proper obj.
Self-incrimination
Other privileges
Party’s private information
3rd PartyInformation
Trade Secrets
Copyright 2007. All rights reserved.
Procedural Defects
Fees &Mileage
PersonalService
100 MileRule
Issuing Signature Beyond Close
of Discovery
Who May Serve
Copyright 2007. All rights reserved.
Relevancy
Relevancy
Pertains toClaim or Defense
AdmissibilityUnimportant
Not Privileged
ReasonablyCalculated
Copyright 2007. All rights reserved.
Undue Burden
OtherMeans
UntimelyService Health
Issues
ExcessiveCosts
Overly Broad
Examples
What you need is:
Copyright 2007. All rights reserved.
Possession, Custody or Control
Actual possession or legal right to obtain documents on demand.
“Practical ability” to demand = ability to enforce compliance with demand.
“Possession, custody or control” is coextensive with other discovery rules.
Copyright 2007. All rights reserved.
Unreasonable Response Time
Unreasonable response time is a matter of the court’s discretion.
“Fails to allow reasonable time for compliance” is a stated grounds to quash under Fed.R.Civ.Proc. 45(c)(3)(A).
Copyright 2007. All rights reserved.
Trade Secrets
It is rare that a federal or state court subpoena is quashed on the basis of trade secret or confidential information.
Fed.R.Civ.Proc. 45(c)(3)(B)(i) authorizes the quashing of a subpoena to prevent disclosure of trade secrets and confidential information. The rule is not absolute.
Copyright 2007. All rights reserved.
Privileges
QualityReview
Tax Preparer
Accountant
Attorney-Client & Work Product Sarbanes-Oxley
Investigation
Self-Critical Analysis