Download - Aviation Economics
-
8/3/2019 Aviation Economics
1/23
Determinants of Market Share of Firms in
the Airlines Industry in the Domestic Sector
Project in Micro-Economics
Under Prof. H. Panda
Presented By:
Shanker Mohan (PGP27380)
ShiwangiSahu (PGP27381)
Shreeya Roy (PGP27382)ShreyaGarodia (PGP27383)
Soumo Deep Saha (PGP27384)
Subhrajit Chakraborty (PGP27385)
Sumit Singhal (PGP27386)
Suraj Shidaganal (PGP27387)
Sushant Singh (PGP27388)
-
8/3/2019 Aviation Economics
2/23
Introduction .................................................................................................................................................. 3
Major players in the Indian aviation industry ............................................................................................... 3
Kingfisher Airlines ..................................................................................................................................... 3
Jet Airways ................................................................................................................................................ 4
Market Structure and Implications ............................................................................................................... 6
Indian Aviation Market a differentiated Oligopoly .................................................................................... 6
Pricing Mechanisms ...................................................................................................................................... 7
Market Equilibrium through the Cournot Model ......................................................................................... 8
Factors determining market demand ........................................................................................................... 8
The Potential Market in India ................................................................................................................... 8
Elasticity of Demand ................................................................................................................................. 9
The Pricing Factor ................................................................................................................................... 10
How the prices are derived in a highly competitive market ............................................................... 10
Advertising .............................................................................................................................................. 13
In-flight Services ...................................................................................................................................... 16
Punctuality .............................................................................................................................................. 18
Market Demand and Supply (Charts).......................................................................................................... 21
CONCLUSION ............................................................................................................................................... 22
REFERENCES ................................................................................................................................................ 23
Table of Contents
-
8/3/2019 Aviation Economics
3/23
Introduction
India is one of the fastest growing aviation markets in the world. The Airport Authority of India (AAI)
manages a total of 127 airports in the country, which include 13 international airports, 7 custom airports,
80 domestic airports and 28 civil enclaves. There are over 450 airports and 1091 registered aircrafts in
the country. The genesis of civil aviation in India goes back to December 1912 when the first domestic airroute between Karachi and Delhi became operational. In the early fifties, all airlines operating in the
country were merged into either Indian Airlines or Air India. And, by virtue of the Air Corporations Act
1953, this monopoly continued for the next forty years.
The Directorate General of Civil Aviation(DGCA) controlled every aspect of aviation, including granting
flying licenses, pilots, certifying aircrafts for flight and issuing all rules and procedures governing Indian
airports and airspace. Finally, the Airports Authority of India (AAI) was assigned the responsibility of
managing all national and international airports and administering every aspect of air transport operation
through the Air Traffic Control.
In 1990s, aviation industry in India saw some important changes. The Air Corporations Act was abolished
to end the monopoly of the public sector and private airlines were reintroduced. With the liberalization ofthe Indian aviation sector, the industry has witnessed a transformation with the entry of the privately
owned full service airlines and low cost carriers. In 2006, the private carriers accounted for around 75%
share of the domestic aviation market. The sector has also seen a significant increase in the number of
domestic air travel passengers. Some of the factors that have resulted in higher demand for air transport
in India include the growing middle class and their purchasing power, low airfares offered by low cost
carriers like Air Deccan, the growth of the tourism industry in India, increasing outbound travel from India,
etc.
Increasing liberalization and deregulation has led to an increase in the number of private players. The
aviation industry comprises of three types of players:
Full cost carriers Low cost carriers (LCC)
Other start-up airlines
It is a phase of rapid growth in the industry with estimated growth of domestic passenger segment at 50%
per annum. This has led to intense price competition due to which full service carriers like Jet Airways, Air
India are giving discounts of up to 60-70% for certain routes to match the new entrants' ticket prices. The
customer has thus gained enormously as a result of liberalization of the sector.
Major players in the Indian aviation industry
Kingfisher Airlines
Kingfisher Airlines was a relatively late entrant to the airlines market and started its operation in May 2005
as a budget carrier in India. Within the first 6 months of its launch, KFA managed to take 6% of the
market share in domestic air travel. It has about 20% of the domestic market share currently. Key
strategies followed by Kingfisher to lead the air transport industry were:
-
8/3/2019 Aviation Economics
4/23
Launched Kingfisher Express to tap into Low Cost Carrier sector of domestic airlines
Provided best service through world class interiors, and in-flight entertainment systems
Came up with only one class to combine Business class experience into economy class fares.
This also helped in freeing up more space as compared to other low cost carriers
Increased comforts through more leg room and bigger seats.
Kingfisher Airlines low cost class on domestic routes is flown under the name of Kingfisher Red. It was
formerly owned by Air Deccan but after the merger with Kingfisher was renamed to Kingfisher Red.
Kingfisher Red operates flights to about 64 varied destinations across India. Important destinations
covered by the airline include Delhi, Jaipur, Mumbai, Bangalore, Srinagar, Ahmedabad, Ranchi, Kolkata,
Guwahati, Bhopal, Hyderabad, Goa, Chennai, Coimbatore, and Port Blair. Operating about 337 flights
daily, Kingfisher Red is gaining popularity owing to its scheduled flights; reach to important destinations,
and classy but cheap in-flight services. In spite of being a budget airline, Kingfisher Red ensures
customer satisfaction and comfort. Snacks and beverages are served aboard the airline as part of
affordable in-flight meal services. Reading materials are also available, which includes a special edition of
Cine Blitz published exclusively for the carrier and a fun-filled magazine from Disney.
The airlines strategy of cutting into the market share includes providing more services by increasing thenumber of routes covered. They intend to add single cabin aircrafts to the fleet in order to invest in a
lesser amount of initial fixed cost to enable more passengers converting to Kingfisher Red. As compared
to other services Kingfisher provides more in-flight services including the in-flight entertainment and free
meals.
Kingfishers strategies to balance the financial decrease caused by low cost services are as below:
Quick Turnaround: Aircrafts are utilized more often by not using the hangar for too long. This
helped reduce the capital and crew costs involved.
High Frequency: Routes which had the maximum number of demand were flown in higher
frequency. This helped in targeting the high demand in these areas as well as promoting loyalty
to Kingfisher brand. Lean Staffing: In order to keep costs down and ticket prices low, they followed a policy of
maintaining a low aircraft to employee ratio.
Reduced Expenses on Cabin crew: Inspections and cleaning stuff were kept minimal.
Utilization of aircrafts: The smaller models were maintained for the regional routes while the
airbuses were used for the routes with higher demand.
In all by cutting down rates on all domestic sectors, Kingfisher Red is a preferred and accepted option for
air travel because of their luxurious on-board facilities and their services on ground.
Jet Airways
Jet Airways is India's largest airline and the market leader in the domestic sector. It operates over 400flights daily to 67 destinations including 15 international destinations.The first private Indian carrier to fly
to international destinations, Jet Airways operates daily international flights to Kathmandu, Singapore,
Kuala Lumpur and London (Heathrow) among others.It has interline agreements with 126 international
airlines which allow passengers to use interline documents on Jet Airways for their travel.
Buyout of Air Sahara by Jet Airways: Jet Airways attempted to takeover Air Sahara on 19 January
2006, offering US$500 million in cash. Market reaction to the deal was mixed, with many analysts
-
8/3/2019 Aviation Economics
5/23
suggesting that Jet Airways was paying too much for Air Sahara. The Indian Civil Aviation Ministry gave
approval in principle, but the deal was eventually called off over disagreements over price and the
appointment of Jet chairman Naresh Goyal to the Air Sahara board. Following the failure of the deal, the
companies filed lawsuits seeking damages from each other.
A second, eventually successful attempt was made on 12 April 2007 with Jet Airways agreeing to
pay $340 million. The deal gave Jet a combined domestic market share of about 32%. On 16 April 2007Jet Airways announced that Air Sahara will be renamed as JetLite. The takeover was officially completed
on 20 April, when Jet Airways paid 400 crore.
In October 2008 Jet Airways and rival Kingfisher Airlines announced an alliance which primarily includes
an agreement on code-sharing on both domestic and international flights, joint fuel management to
reduce expenses, common ground handling, and joint utilization of crew and sharing of similar frequent
flier programs.
On 8 May 2009 Jet Airways launched its low-cost brand, JetKonnect. The decision to launch a new brand
instead of expanding the JetLite network was taken after considering the regulatory delays involved in
transferring aircraft from Jet Airways to JetLite, as the two have different operator codes. The brand was
launched on sectors that had 50% or less load factor with the aim of increasing it to 70% and above. Jetofficials said that the brand would cease to exist once the demand for the regular Jet Airways increases.
Consolidation of Indian Aviation Sector
Jet Airways takeover of Air Sahara and rebranding it as JetLite has resulted in the combined entity
having a domestic market share of approximately 32%, making it the largest airline group in the country.
The merger has resulted in potential cost and efficiency gains through network optimization, operational
rationalization and fleet simplification. It also provides the group with an opportunity to segment the
market more effectively, as well as access to pilots, engineers and valuable airport slots.
The Centre for Asia Pacific Aviation last year predicted that consolidation of the Indian airline industry is
necessary and inevitable as a second (but not final) phase of domestic Indian airline evolution. The
financial realities of the sector are becoming more visible, as it struggles in the absence of pricing power.In the financial year ended 31-Mar-07, Indian carriers have posted combined losses of USD400-500
million. Air Deccan alone posted a loss of USD53 million for the quarter ended 31-Mar-07, on revenue of
USD108 million a net margin of -49%.
The ultimate outcome of the merger has been to usher in more consolidation down the line (Kingfisher
Airways taking over Deccan Airlines), which resulted in restoring some market discipline as market power
shifts to fewer stronger players. This is certainly a strategy which Jet will have considered.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Indian_rupee_sign -
8/3/2019 Aviation Economics
6/23
Market share of various operators
Market Structure and Implications
The aviation industry in India, especially with regard to passenger airlines, follows a strictly oligopoly-type
structure with the characteristics.
1. An industry dominated by a small number of large firms (see market shares, above)
2. Firms sell either identical or differentiated products (the only differentiation here being in service
quality and frills offered), and
3. The industry has significant barriers to entry (which holds true both with respect to regulations
and huge capital investment required)
One sees the following characteristics with respect to the Indian passenger airlines market
Few number of firms contributing to majority of the market share Products are differentiated in terms of service quality and offerings
MR=MC
p>MC
Entry Barriers
Firm is a price-setter
Long run profit >= 0
Strategy dependent on individual rival firms behaviour
Indian Aviation Market a
differentiated Oligopoly
Each seller in an imperfectly competitive market faces
a negatively sloped demand curve for his product,
permitting him some control of the price of his product.
In an oligopoly, a few firms produce the same product,
while in monopolistic competition, many firms produce
-
8/3/2019 Aviation Economics
7/23
differentiatedbut similar products. In a differentiated oligopoly, a few firms produce products different
enough for each firm to have its own downward sloping demand curve. As with a perfectly competitive
firm or a monopoly, the differentiated oligopoly firm produces at a profit maximizing level of output where
marginal cost equals marginal revenue. The firm finds the price it will charge customers at the profit
maximizing level of output (Qm) from the demand curve, and sets price to P m. As we can see, the firm is
earning economic profits since price exceeds average total cost at the profit maximizing level of output.
Pricing Mechanisms
Price and quantity are determined by
the interaction of demand and supply in
the market. However, given the large
number of buyers, firms can decide
prices at which they will sell tickets. In
fact, in the airlines sector, firms go in for
third degree price discrimination and
segment the market, charging a higher
price to the market with a relatively
inelastic demand (such as fares
between business and economy class
travelers, or between emergency travel
and leisure travel by providing apex fares). The low cost airlines follow this different pricing strategy.
Customers booking early with carriers such as Air Deccan will normally find much lower prices if they are
prepared to commit themselves to a flight by booking early, on the justification that consumers demand
for a particular flight becomes more inelastic the nearer to the time of the service.
The term revenue management is commonly used to describe most aspects of airlines pricing andseat-inventory control decisions; but in reality, revenue managers primarily practice seat-inventory control.
Formally, revenue management describes a process of setting fares for each route (origin and destination
pair) and each set of restrictions (nonstop, time-of-day, day-of-week, refundable, advance purchase, first
class or coach, and Saturday-night stay over) and limiting the number of seats available at each fare. In
the language of economics, revenue management increases airlines profits in three ways
Implements peak-load pricing.
Implements third-degree price discrimination. That is, fare restrictions screen customers and
segment them by their sensitivity to price and potentially by their demand uncertainty. For
instance, Indian Airlines apex fares (for booking one week or three weeks in advance).
Implements an inventory control system for coping with uncertain demand.
Limited Entry
Virgin Group founder Richard Branson once famously said: "The safest way to become a millionaire is to
start as a billionaire and invest in the airline industry."
-
8/3/2019 Aviation Economics
8/23
The mortality rate in the airline business is very high. That's equally true for any low-cost airline model. It
requires adequate staying power to buy aircraft and take losses in the initial years. Experts say it takes
nearly $60 million-70 million (Rs 270 crore-315 crore) to float a full-service airline.Entry costs are not
recoverable and incumbents have the ability to respond quickly to entry of a new competitor. Capacity
constraints, absence of freedoms to compete on a route, investment constraints, and restrictions on
codesharing can all be important barriers to entry.
Market Equilibrium through the Cournot Model
The Cournot model assumes that each firm takes the
output of the other firm as given. If Indian Airlines
output is assumed to stay the same, Jet will maximize
profits by setting MR=MC. The result is shown. In the
Cournot framework the equilibrium is at the intersection
of the two reaction functions. These are just the profit-
maximizing conditions rearranged.
The revenue of both a competitive firm and of a
monopolist depends only on the firm's own output: for a
competitive firm we assume that the firm's output does
not affect the price, and for a monopolist there are no
other firms in the market. For a duopolistic, however,
revenue depends on both its own output and the other
firm's output.
We conclude that the firms' outputs and the price are different in Cournot-Nash equilibrium than they are
in a competitive equilibrium. As the demand curve slopes down, price exceeds marginal cost, so that, as
for a monopoly, the total output produced by the firms is less than the competitive output. An implicationis that, as for a monopoly, the Nash equilibrium outcome in a Cournot duopoly is not Pareto efficient.
Factors determining market demand
The Potential Market in India
While formulating the national strategy one must remember a few aspects of Indian Passenger Aviation
Market -
India is a large potential market for corporate and luxury travellers.
India is also a low fare market.
India also has largely blocked but significant markets in the north in China.
Unlike other major travel hubs in the region, India is an original market both for originating as well
as turnaround traffic.
India is also a potential transit hub in more than one direction.
In Aviation circles India has become Asia's hot growth market and in the words of SIA CEO it is, along
with China, one of the two "locomotives" for growth in the continent. Thus to enter in to an open skies
agreement when India has nothing more to offer than land for airports and the so called cheap blue
-
8/3/2019 Aviation Economics
9/23
and white collar labor will tantamount to accepting a second class economic citizenship in the comity
of nations.
The demand drivers of the airline industry:
Ticket prices
Passenger income levels
Access to and suitability of other modes of transportation
Frequency of services
Safety
Random factors such as terror threat
The supply drivers of the aviation industry
Behaviour of competition
Government regulation
Cost of resources (fuel, labour, maintenance, technology)
SWOT Analysis:
Strengths:
1. Creation of new airports, revamp of older ones and modernization of major International airports
2. Low fares due to immense competition
3. Large number of Low cost Carriers in the market and their increasing share
4. Growing Tourism market in India
5. Airlines flying to new destinations
Weaknesses:
1. Shortage of trained personnel including Pilots and trainers
2. High Operational Costs for the Airlines
3. Security threat from anti social elements and terrorists
4. Infrastructural constraints and lack of proper infrastructure at many airports
Opportunities:
1. Civil aviation passenger growth at 20% is one of the highest in the world
2. Anticipation of doubling the number of passengers in the next decade
3. High disposable income for the first time flyers and Indian Middle Class in general
4. Under penetrated markets; huge potential for expansion
5. Growth in Tourism
Threats:
1. Low Profit margins and high operational costs
2. Over regulated market with a lot of intervention from the Government
3. Shortfall in infrastructure with high time for construction and revamp activities
Elasticity of Demand
The airline industry is an extremely unstable industry because it is highly dependent upon current market
conditions. Events such as inflation, terrorist attacks, and the price of oil have greatly influenced the
-
8/3/2019 Aviation Economics
10/23
demand for airline tickets throughout the years. Competition consistently affects the price of airline tickets
because it gives the customer other options. Substitutes that are existence is traveling by train, car, or
avoiding travel whenever possible. Customers have resorted to all named substitutes during turbulent
times in our economy. The elasticity of demand is greatly affected by the customer's purpose for travel.
Airline customers typically fly for business or pleasure. With the wave of technology, a large percentage
of business travel has been eliminated to conserve spending.
The Pricing Factor
The following factors affect pricing decisions in the aviation industry:
Survival: Airlines plagued with over-capacity, intense competition, or changing consumer wants
pursue survival strategies.
Maximum current profit: Many Airlines try to set a price that maximizes their current profits and
delivers a high return on investment.
Maximum market share: In this, Airlines believe in higher passenger volume that will lead to
lower costs per passenger and higher long-run profits and hence maximize their market share.
Product-Quality Leadership: Many firms pursue the ambition to be product-quality leader.
Traditional ways of setting prices:The legacy carriers have long had an exotic, almost incomprehensible
pricing system. However, these days, with the Internet allowing travelers to shop for the cheapest tickets
easily, and low-cost airlines offering uncomplicated set prices, traditional carriers have to follow suit or risk
losing more and more passengers.Ticket prices are also determined by prices of fuel which consists of
75% of the operational costs of an airline.
Dynamic Pricing
JetLite tries to sell maximum number of tickets through dynamic pricing. The tickets are priced according
to the availability and demand of tickets. In airline industry, the marginal cost of flying an additional
customer is very low. Thus, JetLite tries to maximize its revenue by selling the maximum number of
tickets possible. It earns its revenues not only from the sale of tickets but also from the sale of food itemsand any other service for which it charges over and above the price of the ticket.
How the prices are derived in a highly competitive market
Consider the cost function of an airline (total cost versus passengers carried between two points). There
is a small increase in cost for each additional passenger and a big discontinuous increase when an
additional plane has to be put into service. An incorrect interpretation of the marginal cost-pricing rule
would suggest that for economic efficiency the passengers should be charged the negligible cost of
carrying one more passenger on a partially filled plane or the enormous cost of putting another plane into
service. The correct interpretation of the marginal cost pricing principle is that for economic efficiency the
passengers should be charged the average cost per passenger of another planeload of passengers.
We can divide the costs of flying into three parts-
Internal factors
External factors
Government policies
Airlines use a formula of combining their yield and inventory costs to determine ticket prices. While it is
imperative to focus on the idea of being profitable, the focus is to maximize the cost of the flight revenue.
-
8/3/2019 Aviation Economics
11/23
One huge factor that encourages an increase in the cost of tickets relates to a customer ordering a ticket
close to the departing date, define this as a risk factor because they need to make up for all unsold seats.
A high percentage of the revenue is dedicated to overhead costs such as fuel and labor. When a ticket
price is higher with one airline than the other, the customer interprets this as being an excessive cost. The
demand is greatly affected by the external market conditions that are in existences such as taxes; by law
it is legal to add taxes to airline tickets since they are considered a luxury good.
Impacts of external costs
In many cases external costs can affect the lifespan of many airlines. The airlines are dependent on
customers to buy their tickets in order to survive the external cost of fuel, labor, and advertising. The
external costs are set depending on the current condition of the market. According to FRBSF Economic
Letter (2002), over the last 20 years airlines such as PanAm, Texas Air, and TWA have gone out of
business. Externalities such as tragedies (in some cases crashes) as well as over-head costs left these
airlines in turmoil. Two notable airlines United and Delta went bankrupt, but they managed to climb out by
making changes. Delta and United escaped bankruptcy by cutting back on employee pay, pension plans,
and in-flight meal service. The rate of transaction affects the livelihood of current employees, retirees,
customers, and each individual airline.
Effect of negative and positive externalities
Many airlines fail to survive when negative externalities strike the airline industry directly. Positive
externalities allow people to take future changes for granted and unrealistic expectations are developed.
The elasticity of demand is determined by competition, which would be other sources of transportation
such as cars, buses, boats, and trains. The current market conditions affect the overall demand for airline
tickets and the base-price per ticket. Vulnerabilities that are existent in the airline industry are not realized
until a tragedy takes place.
Entry of new carriers and effect on market share
Even casual observers of the airline industry are familiar with the significant consumer benefits that can
result when an upstart airline enters a market -- fares drop and capacity and frequencies increase,
sometimes dramatically. It is not unusual for a deep fare cut to double the demand for airline service on a
city pair. This not only confirms that competition is good for consumers, but also demonstrates that actual
competition enhances consumer welfare far more than the threat of potential entry.
It is not surprising that incumbent carriers respond to new entry. The combination of low fares and
increased demand may prompt an Incumbent to increase its own service. If it matches the entrant's fares
across the board, Incumbent may increase its capacity to handle profitable new traffic generated by the
lower fares; and if Incumbent only lowers fares selectively, Upstart may grow, perhaps eventually building
a competing hub and spoke network of its own. Either way, the consumer is better off. This is the essence
of the competitive process.
In some cases, Upstart's lower operating costs and high load factors allow it to survive and even prosper;
in other cases, too many passengers decide that the new lower fares offered by Incumbent, combined
with other amenities such as better schedules, frequent flier programs, passenger lounges and in-flight
service, are a better value than Upstart offers. The higher frequencies and network efficiencies of
Incumbent sometimes more than counterbalance the lower operating costs of Upstart; Upstart fails to
-
8/3/2019 Aviation Economics
12/23
maintain profitability and must exit. After Upstart's exit, Incumbent's fares and service offerings quickly
move back toward pre-entry levels, much to the chagrin of passengers.
The claims of predation that we find most credible involve not only price cuts, but also significant capacity
expansion by incumbents. Our starting presumption is that Incumbent's pre-entry schedules are optimal
for efficiently operating its network. And if the existing network is optimal, the added cost of carrying an
additional passenger on the existing network can be quite small.
Entry by Incumbent into a route it was not currently serving would seldom be a normal competitive
response to a rival. If the route were not profitable for Incumbent before Upstart entered, why would it be
profitable afterwards? On the other hand, expansion of capacity by Incumbent on a route it already serves
might be a normal response if the new entrant forced prices down enough to greatly increase demand.
It is quite evident that the low cost airlines have gained in terms of market share which substantiates the
above analysis.
Untapped opportunities
Under penetrated Market :Total Passenger Traffic only 50 million as on 31st Dec 2005 amounting
to only 0.05 trips per annum as compared to developed Nations like United States have 2.02 trips
per annum
High Level of potential demand with growth in Indian economy Untapped Air Cargo Market
Air Cargo has not yet been fully taped in the Indian markets and is expected that in the coming
years large no of players would have dedicated fleets.
Break up of costs for any airline The following pie charts shows us the breakup of the costs faced by
any airline under particular heads like food, advertising & promotion, labor, etc. As can be seen from this
the highest cost faced by the airlines comes due to labor. Advertising and Promotion has only a small
percentage of 1.6% of the total expenses.
Indian Aviation industry is cyclical. Brands must be structured in such a manner so that they can
withstand the lean period and this cyclical nature. Maintaining core values are important.
-
8/3/2019 Aviation Economics
13/23
AdvertisingAdvertisement for the Indian Aviation Sector is done across various mediums. Television is not used that
frequently for the promotion in this industry but there are some exceptional advertisements that come up
in this space, the latest being the hot meals ad for Spice Jet on the TV. Primarily the ads are sent
across in the form of mailers or shown as part of space bought on the web pages. The promotions are
generally to bring out the new features being introduced by the airlines, new routes being introduced,promotional fares, new routes being operated, etc. Some of the advertisements have been included
below
This Air India promo was done to attract the customers to the low air fares on a particular International
Route. Indian customers are some of the most price conscious passengers in this world and promotionfor low fares attracts the customers a lot more than other features.
Similar to the Air India advertisement about low fare on International route, the above advertisement from
Spice Jet pulled in a lot of customers. This pricing strategy was specifically followed by Spice Jet when it
entered the market. It offered 9000 seats for 99 INR for the first 99 days. The result is obvious with
SpiceJet being one of the leaders in the LCC (Low Cost Carrier) category in the present scenario. The
focus on the fares is quite evident for the airlines in the LCC category, as this segment has been trying to
position itself as an alternative for people presently travelling in the Indian Railways AC segment. By
trying to focus on the fares Spice Jet did itself a world of good.
The advertisements are also based on the point of differences that the airline has when compared to the
rest of the industry. Specifically these ads are brought out as comparative study and try to show theairline in a higher category than its peers. One such advertisement by Spice Jet follows.
-
8/3/2019 Aviation Economics
14/23
The advertisements can also be based on the special deals/ packages offered to certain category of
passengers. Spice jet often promotes the free air tickets that it offers from time to time. Air Deccan
(previous avatar of Kingfisher Red) promoted its fares of Re.1, which was successful to generate huge
volumes for the airlines. Spice Jet has corporate deals and also has concessional fare strategy for
students. Jet Airways had a similar promotion for a student which has been given in the followingadvertisement.
For the Full Service category the ads are positioned on the service features and the added benefits. The
above ad from Jet Airways tries to show it in a different light from the competitors focusing on the fact that
what the others are going to do in future it is implementing it presently.
-
8/3/2019 Aviation Economics
15/23
Kingfisher used the following ad when it was about to introduce the Airbus A380 fleet in the country. This
not only brought to the notice of the customer that Kingfisher was the only player in India to use the new
jumbo jet but also attracted them to try it out as it was part of a contest.
Finally some advertisements can take a direct dig at the competition and bring out some hilarious results
as shown below.
-
8/3/2019 Aviation Economics
16/23
The airlines to boost their sales have also come out with some other promotional strategies. LCCs
generally have these promotional sales of merchandise as a part of in flight service (Indigo sells these
merchandise tagging them as lowest priced in the air). Airlines are also having tie ups with banking
institutions to issue co-branded credit cards, which offer added benefits to the customer in the terms of
ticket purchase and entertainment expense. Additionally there can be cash back options that can be
linked with these cards. Airlines also have frequent flyer numbers for their most frequently flying clients
and offer flying miles which can be redeemed when a certain number of flights/miles have been flown by
the client. All this is part of the advertisement and promotional strategy of any airline to increase sales
and market share in the long and short run of the business.
In-flight ServicesA crucial factor which governs the choice of one flight over another is the value a passenger gets for his
money. For two companies offering the same route using the same airplane the distinguishing factor
becomes the in-flight services involved. Since all these are included in the cost of flight, customers see
these services as added features for which they are paying for. Thus they consider the effective cost of
the actual flight to be relatively cheaper. Thus a twofold method of capturing the market is seen with more
comfort associated with cheaper effective prices. Full service airlines provide their passenger with many
attendant services like hot meals, frequent flyer programs, spacious legroom etc. While low cost carriersdo not provide all these facilities and work with the minimum number of air hostesses on the flight.
Removing business class, storage space for the meals and limited seat pitch (maximum inclination of the
seat) makes space for additional seats which can increase the seat capacity of the plane by 20%. All the
same the increasing competition in the airlines industry has caused operators to add their flight services
so as to attract the passengers to choose one service over the other.
In-flight services can be broadly classified into three:
1. Generic services
2. In-flight catering
3. In-flight entertainment
Generic Services
Airline industry is more than just a transportation service. Unlike other normal modes such as trains and
buses, customers tend to attach a lot of the importance on services rendered to them by the service
provider. This does not just limit to the services provided within the flight. It begins right from ease of
booking a ticket till the customer checks out of the airport. Smoothness of check-in process, efficiency
and accuracy of baggage handover, personal services provided at the airport all play an important role in
enhancing these services. Understanding the need to woo customers as early as possible, many airline
services have offered pick-up shuttles from locations to the airport for their customers. Online check -in
services are also offered to passengers so that they can reduce the delay spent on domestic travel. Since
most of these services are accounted as fixed costs, the fare charged to passengers can be distributed
and minimized. All these enhance the flying experience offered to the customers by low cost airlines.
In-Flight Catering
In-flight meals are the meals provided to on board customers prepared by the Airlines catering services.
The quantity and type of meal provided depends largely on the airline service, the time of the day and the
flight route. Recognizing that the time involved for domestic travel is less, most flight operators have
managed cost effectiveness by offering only optional meals which can be bought on the flight. In-flight
meals used to be provided to all customers for most airline services but considering the increasingly
-
8/3/2019 Aviation Economics
17/23
competitive slashing of prices, operators have reduced the number of flights which actually provide in-
flight meals for free. Passengers can now choose from a variety of items given in a menu on the flight.
These are generally priced at a premium and do not form a part of the actual ticket. The cost of using
domestic airlines to fly between cities has thus decreased.
In-flight Entertainment
Another in-flight service provided to attract customers is the entertainments provided on-board. These
include gift packets to passengers, on-board movie or radio services etc. Certain services provide
television screens attached to the seats which air a certain number of channels which the passenger can
individually choose. Kingfisher airlines provide portable earphones to all its passengers so that they can
enjoy this service. It leads the way to in-flight entertainment among Indian domestic airlines. At the same
time other services such as Indigo maintain the low cost by providing no in-flight entertainment.
The different levels of services as perceived by a customer are shown through a scale as represented
below:
In-flight services of some major operators are as below:
Air India Express and Indian Airlines: Despite being a low-cost airline, Air India Express offers in-flight
services like free standardized meals and limited on-board entertainment facilities. Indian Airlines offers a
wide variety in its in-flight meal menus, with a multi-cuisine approach to cater to the predilections of the
range of passengers.
GoAir: GoAir offers travel in two classes, namely Economy Class and Business Class. Passengers
travelling in Business Class are served meals on-board, while Economy Class travelers can purchase
meals on-board. Mineral water is served complimentary to passengers travelling in both classes.
Indigo:To keep fares always affordable, Indio has designed a clean, comfortable and reliable airline
without costly frills that put upward pressure on fares. Indigo offers an assortment of vegetarian/non-
vegetarian sandwiches, flavored cashew nuts, cookies, soft drinks and juices for sale onboard. Drinking
water is provided free of charge on all its flights to all customers. Food can also be carried on board, and
the allowed food items include: cold snacks, non-alcoholic drinks, snack bars and biscuits.
Jet Airways: JetScreen is Jet Airways' award-wining in-flight Entertainment system. JetScreen offers a
virtual feast of entertainment for passengers with options like movies, latest music albums, award-winning
TV shows and games. Jet airways offer the in-flight magazine JetWings with an in-flight shopping
catalogue called JetBoutique.
Kingfisher: The airline offers several unique services to its customers. These include: personal valet at
the airport to assist in baggage handling and boarding, exclusive lounges with private space,
-
8/3/2019 Aviation Economics
18/23
accompanied with refreshments and music at the airport, audio and video on-demand, with extra-wide
personalized screens in the aircraft, sleeper seats with extendable footrests, and three-course gourmet
cuisine.
Punctuality
The first factor that a consumer experiences when he goes in a flight is the on-time performance of the
airlines he has chosen. Punctuality is one of the major competitive factors between airlines as it directly
affects consumer preferences. The main objective of using a domestic flight instead of a train in India is to
save time. People generally take flights for urgent work like seminars, meetings, etc. And if a flight gets
late, it upsets the whole agenda of the travellers. Punctuality depends on the following factors
Network planning and control
Aircraft availability
Ground operations and departure process
Affect of Unscheduled Maintenance on Punctuality
Any lag in these processes might lead to a considerable delay in the flight schedule. These processes
should be efficient and systematic so that these may not affect the quality of service of the airlines. The
other dimension to punctuality is the cancellation of flights, many reasons are involved
Technical Operational
Commercial
Weather
-
8/3/2019 Aviation Economics
19/23
Cancellation rates of the major domestic operators
Reasons for cancellation in domestic airlines
Delay costs and punctuality trade-offs
There are two major trade-offs involved in acknowledging costs of punctuality-
Punctuality vs. Turnover and yield
Punctuality vs. cost and equipment utilization
Punctuality vs. Turnover and yield
Poor operational performance in maintaining traffic at peak hours, short connecting times and tight
scheduling may result in loss in revenue maximization in the long run.
-
8/3/2019 Aviation Economics
20/23
Punctuality vs. cost and equipment utilization
One of the most obvious and easy measures to increase punctuality is to remove bottlenecks and add
capacity (e.g. the number of aircraft, longer block times, and more ground staff and equipment). Without a
solid quantitative business case, based on analyzing potential savings from avoided delay costs, it is
unlikely that a controller will support such ideas, especially as most of the savings are variable while the
capacity increase builds up fixed costs.
REPORT FROM DGCA
Performance of the various operators as per DGCA report
Reasons for delay as given by DGCA
Few years back, the government of India had announced plans for allowing domestic airlines to expand
their international operations to more destinations. For past few months, there have been positive
developments in air transport volumes. International passenger load factors rebounded by 0.8 percentage
points to75.8%. Freight volumes improved by 1.2% and passenger volumes were up by 1.8%. These
-
8/3/2019 Aviation Economics
21/23
might help to alleviate some of the pressure on profits from continued high fuel prices. But there are risks
associated with political unrest in the Middle East and the European currency crisis. Such happenings in
foreign countries affect the earnings of airlines in India, thereby affecting their market share in the
industry.
The International Air Transport Association announced traffic results for May 2011 which showed an 8%
increase in international traffic and a 4.8% increase in domestic traffic for a consolidated increase of 6.8%in passenger traffic over May 2010. This is 4% higher than the beginning of the year. Freight traffic
showed a drop of 4% against the post-recession peak of the re-stocking cycle in May 2010. However,
recent months show a renewed upward trend with freight volumes 2% higher than the start of the year.
Market Demand and Supply (Charts)
-
8/3/2019 Aviation Economics
22/23
CONCLUSION
The purpose of this project was to study the domestic market for operators in the Indian aviation industry
and understand the factors that drive their market share. The market share is dependent on many factors
such as the ticket pricing considering the income level of passengers, frequency of service and
accessibility/ suitability over other modes of transport as well as the brand of the product. But afterstudying all these factors, the underlying influence seems to be only one the airline operators main
focus area being not only in providing transportation but also varied in-flight services which is the
differentiating aspect for the experience that a customer takes back for the service that each operator
provides.
In the Indian airlines industry, Kingfisher and Indigo are the market leaders holding 20% of the market
each. Following close behind is Jet airways with 18.5%. The key differentiating factor for Kingfisher is the
type of services provided (for e.g., live TV) as well as the brand image that they have created (so that the
common man associates flying with Kingfisher airlines). For Indigo, the key factors have been the
punctuality and frequency of service. Indigo is a favorite, mostly, among corporate customers as it values
their time through completely non existent delays. The market share that Kingfisher enjoys has fairly
remained constant over a period of time and it has been on a rise for Indigo. However, for Jet Airways this
share has been on a slight decline. Jet airways had been one of the first players in this industry because
of which it holds a high market share. But with the introduction of more LCC operators in the market, it
has been losing its share. Similarly, Indian Airlines has also been losing out on its market share because
of high ticket prices and relatively lower value delivery. Jet Lite maintains a relatively smaller but constant
share of 7.6% whereas it has been on the rise for Spice Jet and Go Air.
The domestic sector is growing at a rapid pace and is expected to increase over the next 20 years at 12-
14% rate. The players are primarily targeting to acquire a major share of this market in order to remain
dominant in long term and that is a reason in spite of being oligopolistic in nature some airlines have
registered losses over the last few years.
-
8/3/2019 Aviation Economics
23/23
REFERENCES
1. Competitive Strategy for Low Cost Airlines - Hongwei Jiang RMIT University, Australia
2. Aspirations, Enterprise Strategy and Sustenance of a Start-up in a Competitive
Environment:
3. A Study of Developments in Air DeccanM. R. Dixit, Sunil Sharma and Amit Karna
4. Airports and airlines sector focus article
5. www.livemint.com
6. www.theindusview.com
7. http://www.centreforaviation.com
8. www.airfleets.net
9. http://www.indiainternalflights.com/
10. Low-fare Airlines, (2004, July 8).Economist.com.
11. Official websites of major domestic airline operators.