Addressing the Skills GapBy
Prof. Ali El Hajj
American University of Beirut
May 2017
Content
• Background
• Digital Skills: Issues and Challenges
• Addressing the Skill Gaps
• Recommendations
2
Background
• Skills Gap
• Digital Divide
• Digital and Experts Skills
3
Introducing the Skill Gap
• A Skill Gap is the difference between the skills needed for a job or task and the skills possessed by the available workforce.
• Digital Government requires Digital skills at different levels.
• “Digital” is more than just technology, websites, internet –it requires operating models, designed around users and data.
• Digital skills are often cited as lacking or in shortage.4
Levels of Digital Skills
• Basic Digital Literacy Skills: Needed by every citizen to carry out basic IT functions like using social media, making internet searches, etc.
• General Digital Skills for the Workforce: Include skills needed to use IT applications such as processing information, e-commerce, etc.
• Professional Digital Skills: Include skills needed by IT professionals to work in the IT sector such as the development of new digital technologies, and new products and services.
5
The Citizens Case: Digital Divide
E-government services face barriers due to digital divide among citizens. This divide has two elements:
• Access Divide:
• Access to the Internet: prerequisite for e-government use.
• Age and education: main predictors of technology access.
• Skill Divide:
• Technical competence: skills to operate hardware and software tools.
• Information literacy: effectively locate, evaluate, use and communicate information from different resources.
6
Digital Skills for Digital Government
• Experts with knowledge of public sector requirements.
• IT experts within the public and/or private sector for
evolving the new IT system.
• Capacities within the public sector (Ministry) to manage the
new IT system.
• IT skills among clerical staff in the public sector.
• Basic IT skills among users of digital government services.
Users include citizens, public and private sectors.7
Examples of Experts Skills
• Data Scientists and Statisticians: provide needed expertise
to analyze and predict data and to drive strategic decisions.
• Database Administrators: ensure that data is collected,
stored securely and used in compliant manner.
• Big Data Analysts: capabilities needed to turn collected
data into business intelligence.
• Business Intelligence Analysts: provide data mining,
cleansing and reporting skills to support business decisions
and yield quantifiable return on investments.8
Examples of Expert Skills (Continued)
• Computer Systems Analysts: needed to design systems
and processes that combine technology expertise with the
organization’s business strategies.
• IT Architects: manage the security architecture and ensure
compliance with rules and regulations.
• Digital transformation combines people, processes and
technology, in addition to change management skills that
will enable having a truly digital organization
9
Digital Skills:
Issues and Challenges
• Challenges
• Digital Skills Survey
• Public Sector
10
Challenges of Digital Skills
• IT experts require high salaries, and governments
cannot compete with the private sector.
• The shortage and brain drain of digital skills is a
critical issue.
• There is a digital skills gap across industries that
aggravates the government’s situation.
• There is a need to better invest in digital skills.
11
Digital Skills Survey:
Leadership
Digital Skills Survey by Government Digital Leaders, National Audit Office, UK:
• There are not many Digital and Technology (DaT) leaders in place.
• Most of those in place have not been long in post.
• A significant proportion have good private sector experience, but do not have public sector experience.
• There is reasonable penetration on boards, less at main board.
• DaT is typically a small proportion of overall workforce.12
Digital Skills Survey:
Skills Gap
• Estimates of the gap show shortfalls across all areas.
• Most organizations need to improve capacity and capability in key technical areas.
• Effectiveness of approaches to developing capability – learning from colleagues preferred to formal training.
• Use of consultants expected to decline in the next 5 years –with more use of partnering.
13
Digital Skills Survey:
Barriers and Challenges
• Financial position and budgets, career paths and competing
priorities have the largest negative impacts on developing
existing staff.
• Market conditions, pay and recruiting processes have the
largest negative impacts on recruitment and retention.
• Procurement processes have the largest negative impact on
obtaining external resources.
• Funding and pay seen as biggest challenges to developing
capability and capacity.14
Digital Skills Survey:
Key Findings
• Most initiatives by the strategic center of government are regarded as helpful or very helpful.
• A greater role for the center is envisaged in coordinating and facilitating as well as supporting skills development.
• Central guidance is mostly considered to be relevant and mostly adhered to.
15
Public Sector Challenges
• E-Government services should be accessible to all citizens
regardless of age or digital skills level.
• Resistance to change of long serving employees who are
used to paper-based processes.
• Transformation is a gradual process because changing
work processes takes time and should be done right.
• Working with trusted partners who have sector expertise
will help build the digital skills needed for successful
transformation.16
Addressing the Skill Gap
• Training Staff
• Role of Higher Education
• Digital Talent Management
17
Training Senior Staff for e-
government
• Training for Individual Level Skills.
• Training in e-Government Management Knowledge.
• Training in e-Government Management Skills.
• Developing Leadership Quality for Managing ICT and e-government.
18
Training for Individual Level Skills
• MS Office (Word, Excel, PowerPoint, …)
• Internet (Browsing, download and save
documents, fill a form and upload
documents, website development, …)
• Smart devices, mobile phones, …
19
Training in e-Government
Management Knowledge
• This is the essential knowledge of e-government
management in organizational level
• Concept of e-government
• Networked government
• MIS and data based decision making
• Managing intranet and web portal
• Business process reengineering
• Knowledge in ICT project management
20
Training Need in e-Government
Management Skill
• Training needs in the below skills:
• Skills in using MIS and database in decision making
• Using e-Procurement for procuring goods and services for the organization
• Working in an automated office
• Re-engineering business process in own organization due to ICT introduction
• Providing e-Service for the citizen
• Using and providing interactive intranet for the clients of the organization
• Managing ICT projects
21
Developing Leadership Quality for
Managing ICT and e-government
• Skills and knowledge in transparency
• Knowledge in managing ICT and change
management
• Managerial skills in business process re-
engineering
22
Advancing Digital Literacy in
Education: Issues and Challenges
• Student Orientation: There is a lack of awareness of career
opportunities within the digital sector.
• There is no enough support for students with their decision-
making around career and skills development.
• Even though digital skills development is integrated in school
curricula, the digital skills level is variable and inconsistent.
• While IT is used in schools, we need to ensure that it is
effectively used in teaching and learning.
23
Advancing Digital Literacy in
Education: Teaching and Learning
• Change the curricula to address cognitive, social, and behavioral as well as technical and critical thinking skills.
• Digitization of the learning process by using smart boards and tablets and having blended or online courses/programs.
• Transition of learning content to the cloud.
• Focus on students as producers and makers, not only knowledge consumers.
• Launch digital literacy programs targeted to specific groups such as the elderly and underprivileged.
24
Advancing Digital Literacy Across
Higher Education:
Collaborations and Partnerships
• Collaboration between the private sector and schools/universities to shape the digital curricula and become part of the advisory boards.
• Business partnerships with companies to ensure that the digital curriculum is aligned with market demand and available job vacancies.
• Develop Smart Collaborations: Governments, Campuses, and Organizations must collaborate together in different projects, from information-sharing initiatives to developing joint IT projects.
• The supply of needed digital skills is mainly through education and training delivered by education institutions.
25
Digital Talent:
Attracting, Building and Retaining
• Government must have a suitable working environment to attract global experts and high-skilled IT professionals.
• Companies need to attract and build digital capabilities in-house. Work with an external vendor to build the solution, operate with adjustments, and then transfer capabilities for the owner to run independently.
• Adjust policies to encourage digital talent to join local firms. For example, modifying the visa policy could help lower the barrier to attracting talent.
• Assessing digital skills of applicants/employees is challenging.26
Digital Talent:
Management
Companies should develop a 360-degree talent management
approach from attraction, onboarding, and training to retention.
• At the attraction level, companies should have a compelling vision.
• At the onboarding and training level, invest in continuous learning
and professional development for employees.
• At the retention level, use predictive analytics to identify the
employees who are most likely to leave.
• A digital talent platform must be properly set.
27
Recommendations
28
Recommendations to
Education Sector
The education sector should develop and adapt their offers
to meet the changing needs of the digital economy.
• Coordinate with stakeholders to ensure that the offered educational
courses/programs meet the demand for digital skills.
• Build digital skills capacity with industry-relevance: Computing-related
degrees should equip people with skills needed to be effective workers.
• Motivate and inspire young people to consider digital careers.
• Implement programs to continually update the digital skills of their staff.
• Support teachers to deliver the new computing curriculum and develop
their teaching approaches in line with developing educational technology. 29
Recommendations to
Government
Government should provide leadership, coordination, and key resources in establishing the conditions for digital skills development.
• Ensure that digital skills are learned pervasively at all stages of education and training.
• Focus education policy on skills of strategic importance to the nation.
• The government should work with the industry to understand which digital skills are of particular strategic importance to the nation.
30
Recommendations to
Employers
Employers take ownership of digital skills development
• Collaborate at a national level. Employers should collaborate, through
networks and partnerships, to develop approaches to raising digital skills levels.
• Lead on setting standards. Employers should set the minimum standards that
individuals are expected to acquire through education and training.
• Build the skills of their own employees. Employers should ensure existing
staff have the training to keep their digital skills updated, and develop active
recruitment and development strategies to maximize digital skills of their workforce.
• Foster lifelong learning. Employers should help embed a culture which
recognizes and builds on the talents of their employees, actively supporting their
learning through a wide range of learning approaches. 31
Recommendations on
CollaborationLocal and regional governments and organizations should address the digital skills needs of their local areas:
• Collaborate: Local partnerships and networks (Universities and employers) should work together to determine the skills needs, so that education and training provision is better matched to demand. Government must encourage these partnerships to share best practice and knowledge of successful programs and training schemes.
• Inform: Universities and Employers should ensure that relevant and focused information is made available about digital skills training and education provision.
32
References
• Digital Skills for the UK Economy, ECORYS UK, Jan 2016
• Digital Literacy, An NMC Horizon Project Strategic Brief, Oct. 2016
• Digital Middle East: Transforming the region into a leading digital economy, Digital
McKinsey, Oct. 2016
• Digital Transformation Skills for Government and How Public Sector Organizations can
acquire them, Microsoft.
• The digital skills gap in government, Survey Findings, National Audit Office (UK),
December 2015
• Training Curriculum on E-Government: An Empirical Study on Senior Civil Servants of
Bangladesh, Md. Zohurul Islam, Md. Abdul Mannan, International Journal of Advances in
Management and Economics, 2014
33