1
Announcements: Tuesday
Breakout—review for the final Office hours next week:
Tuesday 1:30-3 Wednesday 10-11:30, 3-5
Thursday 2-4Exam is on Friday 10-12, various rooms that
I will post on Oncourse
2
Announcements: Thursday
Office hours next week:
Tuesday 1:30-3 Wednesday 10-11:30, 3-5
Thursday 2-4
Exam is on Friday 10-12, various rooms that you were told in section and that I will post on Oncourse
3
G302, Week 14 Managing Controversial Issues
4
Calgene
The aim: to genetically modify crops: insert genes to improve a crop in some way. $90 million was spent 1980-92.
5
Calgene’s Products The FLAVR SAVR tomato, which
would not rot on the vine and so could be naturally ripened
Herbicide-resistant cotton Improved canola oil for detergents,
shampoo, margarine, and auto lubricants
Which of these would have the most political trouble?
6
What you will learn today
How should you deal with activists and the press?
7
The Life Cycle of an Issue
Development Felt need, Dissatisfaction
Politicization Public discussion, Intellectual leadership, Mobilization Triggering event
Legislation
Implementation
Your Ability to Influence Shrinksover Time...
8
Heading off the Issue
1. Crisis Audits: identify a list of potential problems
2. Fix the problem before the pressure starts.
3. Admit responsibility
4. Co-opt the opposition
9
Admit Responsibility Cut your losses Best done early---before pressure--- not late Limit the story’s lifetime
Maybe even if you’re not mainly to blame— like out-of-court settlements, or no-questions-asked returns
Like the “big bath” in accounting
10
Co-opting the Opposition
Figure out their personal objectives
Get their approval by compensating them
“Substitutes” in the interest-group analysis chart
The “Danegeld” problem
11
The Politics of Mass Opinion
Concentrated
Dispersed
Concentrated
Interest group politics
Entrepreneurial politics
Dispersed
Client politics
Majoritarian politics
Policy Benefits
PolicyCosts
Mass opinion is mobilized in entrepreneurial and majoritarian politics.
12
Entrepreneurial Politics Political entrepreneurs are expert at
using the media to mobilize interest groups
Does your business have that expertise? Sensationalism sells the story!!! Many people forgive someone who lies
for the public interest People don’t forgive businesses that lie
13
Greenpeace and Shell Should the Brent Spar be dumped
deep in the sea? Greenpeace’s situation: a drop in
contributions Greenpeace estimate: 5,000 tons
of oil sludge. Shell: 100 tons.
14
Greenpeace’s spokesman:
“Joe Six-Pack won’t understand your technical details. All he knows is that if he dumps his can in a lake, he gets fined. So he can’t understand how Shell can do this.”
15
Imagine you are a reporter…
Reporters must operate with tight deadlines Reporters are not experts. They rely on experts:
Government sources: The FDA, the ITC Think tanks like the Heritage Foundation and the
Brookings Institution Academics: Wisconsin and Oxford Industry sources paint, railroads, U.S. Steel
Which experts have the greatest incentives to be readily available? Are they biased? Can they be trusted?
16
How to “Spin” the Press: Give Them What They Need Provide information. Give them a name and phone number of
someone to call for a quote or a fact. Always be trustworthy. Correct mistaken
statements instantly. Write the story for them! Give them
something as a starting point. Create “think tank” response (Accuracy in
Media, Center for Media and Public Affairs, the Media Institute, etc.)
Enlist a politician to push your position
17
Coca-Cola Children in Belgium started
becoming nauseous after drinking Coca-Cola
Was it Coke’s fault? Even the Coke managers in Europe and the USA didn’t know
18
What strategy should Coca-Cola have used?
(a) Lobby the EC regulators(b) Co-opt the opposition(c) Start advertising to influence
public opinion(d) Admit potential responsibility(e) Wait two weeks to get the facts
correct, then use one of the options above1. Did the sign-in sheet get around?
2. If you answered a question, bring up anotecard for me.
19
PR Mistake 1: Not Using Your PR Department
20
PR Mistake 2: Not Telling Your PR Department
21
PR Mistake 3: Listening to Overcautious Lawyers
Why do you think your company’s legal staff might give you bad advice when they suggest you say nothing to the public about the crisis?
22
PR Mistake 4: Putting Off the Pain
23
Calgene’s Tomato Strategy Marketing channels Lobbying regulators Lobbying politicians Educating the media FDA approval
24
The Unhappy Ending Calgene’s political strategy was highly successful. It
did get FDA approval. Calgene’s business strategy didn’t do so well.
Consumers didn’t find it worth paying a 200% price premium for the tomato.
Calgene sold out to Monsanto. The moral: Even with the best political strategy, a
company needs a good product produced at a low cost.
25
Business Lessons Identify issues before they are
publicized. Head off problems using self-
correction or co-opting. Keep good relations with the
press and government. Make their jobs easier.
26
Evaluations: Tuesday: 4960, G302
Thursday morning: 4944, G302
Thursday evening: 4954. G302