document resume - eric · document resume ed 050 350 ac 010 343 author boren, h. e., jr. title the...

90
DOCUMENT RESUME ED 050 350 AC 010 343 AUTHOR Boren, H. E., Jr. TITLE The Pilot Training Study: A User's Guide to the Advanced Pilot Computer Cost Model (APT). INSTITUTION Rand Corp., Sa7Aa Monica, Calif. SPURS AGENCY Department of the Air Force, Washington, D.C. EEPORT NO RM-6087-PR PUB DATE Dec 69 NOTE 89p. ECUS PRICE DESCRIPTORS IDENTIFIERS ABSTRACT EDRS Price MF-$0.65 HC-$3.29 *Computer Programs, *Cost Effectiveness, *Educational Programs, *Flight Training, Guides, *Models *Advanced Pilot Training, APT, Project. RAND This Memorandum describes a computer program for calculaUng, except for facilities, the required resources and related costs of formal advanced pilot traininq courses. Facilities are assumed to be inherited and hence are treated as sunk costs. The program is based on a previously presented methodology. The first three sections of this Memorandum deal with a general description of the program and its operations. Specific operating instructions are given in Section IV. In conjunction with Section IV, appendices are presented showing a listing of all program variables used in the calculations, detailed flow charts of the program, and a source listing (FORTRAN-IV (IBM 360/365) ] of the program. Program outputs are discussed in Section V. For related documents see AC 010 340-342 and AC 010 344-347. (Author/CK)

Upload: others

Post on 15-Aug-2020

1 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: DOCUMENT RESUME - ERIC · DOCUMENT RESUME ED 050 350 AC 010 343 AUTHOR Boren, H. E., Jr. TITLE The Pilot Training Study: A User's Guide to the Advanced Pilot Computer Cost Model (APT)

DOCUMENT RESUME

ED 050 350 AC 010 343

AUTHOR Boren, H. E., Jr.TITLE The Pilot Training Study: A User's Guide to the

Advanced Pilot Computer Cost Model (APT).INSTITUTION Rand Corp., Sa7Aa Monica, Calif.SPURS AGENCY Department of the Air Force, Washington, D.C.EEPORT NO RM-6087-PRPUB DATE Dec 69NOTE 89p.

ECUS PRICEDESCRIPTORS

IDENTIFIERS

ABSTRACT

EDRS Price MF-$0.65 HC-$3.29*Computer Programs, *Cost Effectiveness,*Educational Programs, *Flight Training, Guides,*Models*Advanced Pilot Training, APT, Project. RAND

This Memorandum describes a computer program forcalculaUng, except for facilities, the required resources andrelated costs of formal advanced pilot traininq courses. Facilitiesare assumed to be inherited and hence are treated as sunk costs. Theprogram is based on a previously presented methodology. The firstthree sections of this Memorandum deal with a general description ofthe program and its operations. Specific operating instructions aregiven in Section IV. In conjunction with Section IV, appendices arepresented showing a listing of all program variables used in thecalculations, detailed flow charts of the program, and a sourcelisting (FORTRAN-IV (IBM 360/365) ] of the program. Program outputsare discussed in Section V. For related documents see AC 010 340-342and AC 010 344-347. (Author/CK)

Page 2: DOCUMENT RESUME - ERIC · DOCUMENT RESUME ED 050 350 AC 010 343 AUTHOR Boren, H. E., Jr. TITLE The Pilot Training Study: A User's Guide to the Advanced Pilot Computer Cost Model (APT)

S CEPARTMESIT OF HEALTHEDUCATION & LVELFtPEOFFICE OF EOUCA)ION

THIS DOCUMENT HAS BEEN REPRODUCED EXACTLY AS RECEIVED FROMTEE PERSON Of ORGANIZATION °RIGiNAtiNG IT POINTS OF VIEW OR GRINIONS STATED 00 NOT NECESSARILYREPRESENT OFF IDAL OFF ICE OF EDUCATION POSITION OR POLICY

SCOPE OF INTEREST NOTICE

The ERIC Fecfhy het awgnedtele document 10, p o..,essmgto nIn our judgement, 11,1 documentis also of Interest to the clew As9-houses noted to the right, I ndeetog should teed thew spec.'Points of view.

DECEMBER 1989

THE PILOT TRAINING STUDY:A User's Guide to the Advanced

.=

Pilot Training Computer Cost Model (APT)J . E. Boren, Jr.

1'I (It. .4".1.33' 4 ,

ebik4/10410 ktaAss oat. outs ns stsialluncs: WILI11112D.Vtw . ,

44PeffiVifiti*R.14.1Mr;

Page 3: DOCUMENT RESUME - ERIC · DOCUMENT RESUME ED 050 350 AC 010 343 AUTHOR Boren, H. E., Jr. TITLE The Pilot Training Study: A User's Guide to the Advanced Pilot Computer Cost Model (APT)

MEMORANDUMRM-6087-PRDECEMBER 1969

THE PILOT TRAINING STUDY:A User's Guide to the Advanced

Pilot Training Computer Cost Model (APT)H. E. Boren, Jr.

This research is supported by the United `.7,tatcs Mr Force under Project RAND Contract I'o. F41620-67C0015munitored by the Directorate of Operational Requirementsand Development Plane, Deputy Chief of Staff, Research and Devekpment, Ilq USAF.Views or conclusions contained in this study should not be interpreted as representingthe official opinion or policy of the United States Air Force.

DISTRIBUTION STATEMENTThis docurt.iit has been approved for public release and sale; its distribution is unlimited.

2

IPSCI 11.11.11 it. ,a11,1

Page 4: DOCUMENT RESUME - ERIC · DOCUMENT RESUME ED 050 350 AC 010 343 AUTHOR Boren, H. E., Jr. TITLE The Pilot Training Study: A User's Guide to the Advanced Pilot Computer Cost Model (APT)

This study is presented as a competent treatment of the subject, worthy of pub-lication. The Rand Corporation vouches for the quality of tht research, withoutri-cessarily endorsing the opinions and conclusions of the authors.

Published by The RAND Corporation

Page 5: DOCUMENT RESUME - ERIC · DOCUMENT RESUME ED 050 350 AC 010 343 AUTHOR Boren, H. E., Jr. TITLE The Pilot Training Study: A User's Guide to the Advanced Pilot Computer Cost Model (APT)

PREFACE

In April 1967, the Office of the Assistant Secretary of Defense

(Manpower and Reserve Affairs) forme' a Pilot Advisory Committee to

study "Pilots as a National Resource." The Committee consisted of the

Assistant Secretary and a represantative of each of the three Services.

Staff members from Rand were invited to attend the early meetings of

the Committee. The outgrowth was that the Air Force member requested

Rand to accept responsibility for examining the Air Force pilot train-

ing process. The objecti!te of the Eand Pilot Training Study was to

develop a series of comv:.er models for use in estimating the resources

required to Produce pilots and the costs of training them. Further,

the models were to be designed for sensitivity analyses and long-range

planning.

For the convenience of readers whose interesto may not extend to

all aspects of the pilot training process, the results of the study

are presented in eight volumes, as follows:

VolumeI RM-6080-FR The Pilot Training Study: Personnel Flow and the

PILOT Model, by W. E. Moor

II RM-6081-PR The Pilot Training Study: A User's Guide to thePILOT Computer Model, by Lois Littleton.

III RM-6082-PR The Pilot Training Study: Pre-commiasioningTraining, by J. W. Cook.

IV RM-6083-PR The Pilot Training Study: A Cost-EstimatingModel for Undergraduate Pilot Training, byS. L. Allison.

V RM-6084-PR The Pilot Training Study: A User's Guide to theUndergraduate Pilot Training Computer Cost Model,by Lois Littleton.

VI RM-6085-PR The Pilot Training Study: Advanced Pilot Train-ing, by P. J. Kennedy.

VII RM-6086-PR The Pilot Trainirg Study: A Coat-EstimatingModel for Advanced Pilot Training, by L. E.Knollmeyer.

VIII RM-6087-PR The Pilot Training Study: A User's Guide to theAdvanced Pilot Training Computer Cost Model (APT),by H. E. Boren, Jr.

4

Page 6: DOCUMENT RESUME - ERIC · DOCUMENT RESUME ED 050 350 AC 010 343 AUTHOR Boren, H. E., Jr. TITLE The Pilot Training Study: A User's Guide to the Advanced Pilot Computer Cost Model (APT)

iv-

TW.s Memorandum, Volume VIII of the series, describes the computer

program for the Advanced Pilot Training Cost Model(APT )p which is de-

signed to be ,sscid for estimating the resources and costs required to

train pilots in formal advanced courses [Combat Crew Training Schools

(CCTS), Replacement Training Unite (RTU), or Transport Training Units

(TTU)]. This model is not designed to cover the types of advanced fly-

ing training sch as proficiency flying, upgrading training, special

weapons training, and training for miscellaneous types of aircraft for

which no formal school exists. These types of advanced training are

accomplished in less formal programs after the pilot is initially qual-

ified to fly the particular aircraft involved.

The procedures described in this Memorandum may be followed with-

out reference to the other Memorandums in the series. However, for an

understanding of the purposes for which the cost model was constructed,

the user will find it useful to read Volumes VI and VII which describe

the advanced pilot training (APT) program. It is further suggested

that the user read Volume I for an understanding of the part that APT

plays in the total process of training USAF pilots.

In this Memorandum, the term APT refers to the Advanced PilotTraining Computer Cost Model (program).

Page 7: DOCUMENT RESUME - ERIC · DOCUMENT RESUME ED 050 350 AC 010 343 AUTHOR Boren, H. E., Jr. TITLE The Pilot Training Study: A User's Guide to the Advanced Pilot Computer Cost Model (APT)

-V-

SUMMARY

This Memorandum describes a compute: program (APT) for calculating,

except for facilities, the required resources and related costs of for-

mal advanced pilot training courses. Facilities are assumed to be in-

herited and hence are treated as sunk costs. Tha program is based on

the methodology presented in RAND Memorandum RM-6086-PR cited in the

Preface.

The first three sections of this Memorandum deal with s general

description of the program and its operations. Specific operatio.g in-

structions are given in Section IV. In conjunction with Section IV,

appAndices are presented showing a listing of all program variables

used in the calculations, detailed flow charts of the program, and a

source listing [FORTRAN-IV (IBM 360/65)] of the program. Program out-

puts are discussed in Section V.

Page 8: DOCUMENT RESUME - ERIC · DOCUMENT RESUME ED 050 350 AC 010 343 AUTHOR Boren, H. E., Jr. TITLE The Pilot Training Study: A User's Guide to the Advanced Pilot Computer Cost Model (APT)

-vii-

CONTENTS

PREFACE iii

SUMMARY

SectionINTRODUCTION

II. GENERAL DESCRIPTION 3

Operation 3

Options 4

III. PROGRAM CONSIDERATIONSFlow of Operations 8

IV. INPUT PROCEDURES 12

General Description 12

Input Data Cards 12

Variable-Listing Selection Designators 17

End-of-Data Designators 18

Data Card Arrangement 19

V. PROGRAM OUTPUTS 24

AppendixA. LISTING OF APT COMPUTER PROGRAM VARIABLES 39

B. FLOW CHARTS OF APT COMPUTER PROGRAM 49

C. LISTING OF FORTRAN-IV (IBM 360(65) APT COMPUTER PROGRAM 69

7

Page 9: DOCUMENT RESUME - ERIC · DOCUMENT RESUME ED 050 350 AC 010 343 AUTHOR Boren, H. E., Jr. TITLE The Pilot Training Study: A User's Guide to the Advanced Pilot Computer Cost Model (APT)

FIGURES

1.

2.

3.

4.

5.

6.

7.

Flow of Operations

Example of Input Keypunch Form

Sample Data Card

Run 1 Sample Output (Weapon System A):Printout, 1967

F/n 1 Sample Output (Weapon System A):

Run 1 Sample Output (Weapon System A):1967, F(00I)-F(053)

Run 1 Sample Output (Weapon System A):

Standard

Common Dump, 1967 .

Variable Listing,

Variable Listing,

9

15

16

25

26

27

1967, F(054)-F(106) 28

8. Run 1 Sample Output Weapon System A): Variable Listing,1967, F(10!)-F(159) 29

9. Run 1 Sample Output (Weapon System A): VariableListing, 1967, F(160)-F(212) 30

10. Run 1 Sample Output (Weapon System A): VariableListing, 1967, F(213)-F(265) 31

11. Run 1 Sample Output (Weapon System A): VariableListing, 1967, F(266)-F(310) 32

12. Run 1 Sample Output (Weapon System A): StandardPrintout, 1968-1969 33

13. Run 1 Sample Output (Weapon System 11): StandardPrintout, 1967-1969 34

14. Run 1 Sample Output (Weapon System C): StandardPrintout, 1967-1969 35

15. Run 2 Sample Output (Weapon System D): StandardPrintout, 1967-1968 36

16. Run 2 Sample Output (Weapon System E): StandardPrintout, 1967-1969 37

17. Sample Output: End -of -Data Statement 38

a

Page 10: DOCUMENT RESUME - ERIC · DOCUMENT RESUME ED 050 350 AC 010 343 AUTHOR Boren, H. E., Jr. TITLE The Pilot Training Study: A User's Guide to the Advanced Pilot Computer Cost Model (APT)

I. INTRODUCTION

The APT computer program computes the required resources and at-

tendant costs for Advanced Pilot Training, given such basic inputs

syllabus requirements and numbers of students entering APT from duty

assignments involving similar aircraft, from duty assiEnments involving

dissimilar aircraft, from desk jobs, and from undergraduate pilot train-

ing (UPT). All required facilities (the physical plants) are assumed

to be inherited and are treated as sunk costs. Hence, the calculation;

do not include any facility construction costs.

Long and short courses are available in this program for each air-

craft system. The long course is for students from dissimilar aircraft,

from UPT, and from desk jobs, for whom more extensive training is re-

quired. The short course is for students from similar types of aircraft.

For any aircraft system, the program deals with as many as five cate-

gOries of equipment, namely, three types of training aircraft, simulators,

and trainers.

The information presented in this Memorandum is supplementary to

that presented in RM-6086-PR. That publication describes in detail the

methodology employed in the APT model. Since the APT program was de-

veloped to reflect explicitly that methodology, a detailed line-by-line

description of the program is not considered to be necessary. Instead,

this Memorandum deals with a general description of the computer pro-

gram (Section II), program considerations (Section III), input proce-

dures (Section IV), and program outputs (Section V).

The APT computer program is written completely in FORTRAN-IV for

use on the RAND IBM 360/65 computer system and is totally self-contained.

Except for the standard input/output devices, it does not require any

auxiliary tapes or disks and does not use any auxiliary programs. As

a result, it should be adaptable to other computer systems.

See Preface.

Page 11: DOCUMENT RESUME - ERIC · DOCUMENT RESUME ED 050 350 AC 010 343 AUTHOR Boren, H. E., Jr. TITLE The Pilot Training Study: A User's Guide to the Advanced Pilot Computer Cost Model (APT)

-2-

A listing of all variables used iii the program calculations is

given in Appendix A. Detailed flow charts showing each step of the

program are present in Appendix B. Finally, the FORTRAN-IV source

program is listed in Appendix C.

10

Page 12: DOCUMENT RESUME - ERIC · DOCUMENT RESUME ED 050 350 AC 010 343 AUTHOR Boren, H. E., Jr. TITLE The Pilot Training Study: A User's Guide to the Advanced Pilot Computer Cost Model (APT)

-3-

II. GENERAL DESCRIPTION

OPERATION

The APT computer program is structured so that a single sees:

on the computer will process as many runs as desired, or as time per-

mits. Each run consists of one or more weapon systems for one or more

years of operation. The program prints the results by weapon system

for one year at a time. A run may comprise as many weapon systems and

yeare as the user desires or, again, as time permits. A major feature

of the APT program is that, within a run, once a complete set of inputs

is entered for the first year of the first weapon system, only changes

in those ....puts need to be entered for succeeding years and for succeed-

ing weapon systems. Hence, the program is highly suited to sensitivity

analyses in which one may wish to determine the effect of input variations.

One pass is made through the program for each year of each weapon

system. Thus, if a run were to consist of 10 weapon systems and 15

years for each weapon system, 150 passes would be made through the pro-

gram for that run. Each pass requires approximately 0.25 second (360/65

central processing unit time), depending on some of the options exer-

cised by the user. For each pass, the relevant resources and costs are

calculated and printed in prescribed formats. In addition, two optional

printouts are provided for printing the values of the variables used

in the program.

Because of the repetitive nature of many of the calculations, one

subscripted variable (ti) ie used for all program variables so that such

-alculations are made with only one set of equations with variable -

eubecripted parameters. Thus, through use of DO-loops in the program,

the machine goes through mach calculations as many times as required,

using the one set of equations and each time increasing, in prescribed

increments, the appropriate parameter subscripts. This Approach re-

duces the size of the program, in terns of both the FORTRAN instructions

and the Common Block listing of the variables.

Page 13: DOCUMENT RESUME - ERIC · DOCUMENT RESUME ED 050 350 AC 010 343 AUTHOR Boren, H. E., Jr. TITLE The Pilot Training Study: A User's Guide to the Advanced Pilot Computer Cost Model (APT)

-4-

OPTIONS

The F variable used in the program is dimensioned 310, which al-

lows for both the input and output data. An optional printout is pro-

vided for listing the F array in tabular form. This listing is labelled

"Common Dump." It includes the value of each F variable and the cor-

responding subscript. Such a listing may be exceedingly useful in the

analysis of various runs since much of the data--particularly numbers

generated in the form of intermediate calculations--do not appear on

the output pages. With the aid of the Common Dump and the variable

listing (Appendix A), which also lists the subscript (called address)

of each F variable, the user can find the value for any subscript so

listed--hence any input or output variable. The Common Dump is actu-

ally a permanent record of the values of ;.11 of the F variables for any

pass through the program.

An alternative method is provided for printing out values of the

F variables used in the program, in which the address, name, and value

of the variable are listed on one line. This option has the advantage

of providing complete information to the user concerning the F vari-

ables he selects to be listed. Another advantage is that the user may

select only the variables he desires to be listed. A disadvantage is

that more pages of output may be required, depending on tae number of

variables listed. For example, if all 310 variables are listed, six

pages are requires' compared with only one page for the Common Dump

listing of all variables. Also this option requires that all 310 cards

containing the F'- variable' listing must be entered as input data.

As stated previously, this model applies only to pilots who are

trained in formal Advanced Pilot Training Schools. The pilots for whom

this model is not applicable may be grouped into two categories: those

who are not trained formally in advanced pilot schools and those who

are _rained, as required, in small numbers. A substantial number of

aircraft types is involved in this group of pilots for which either

12.

Page 14: DOCUMENT RESUME - ERIC · DOCUMENT RESUME ED 050 350 AC 010 343 AUTHOR Boren, H. E., Jr. TITLE The Pilot Training Study: A User's Guide to the Advanced Pilot Computer Cost Model (APT)

-5-

valid cost data are not available or use of the model is not practical.

However, the percentage of such aircraft is relatively small (approxi-

mately 7 percent of the total aircraft inventory }.

If, for a single computer run, the user wishes to account for all

pilots trained, including those whose costs are not computad in this

model, he may do so by applying the zero-output designator to this lat-

ter group of pilots. Then, the costs and resources required will be

printed for all weapon systems except those for which the zero - output

designator is used. For each of those, the only output is the number

or graduates.

An option is provided the analyst for calculating the number of

simulator maintenance and operating personnel. This value may be cal-

culated either as a function of the number of simulators required or

as a function of the total number of student simulator hours charged

to pilot training. This is done automatically in the program by using

the magnitude of the input variable relating to the number of simulator

operating and maintenance personnel authorized. If this value is equal

to, or greater than, 1.0, it is treated as an authorized number per

simulator. If the value is less than 1.0, it is treated as an author-

ized number per simulator hour. Hence, depending on its magnitude,

this input variable is multiplied by either the number of simulators

required or the number of student simulator hours charged to pilot train-

ing to give the number of simulator maintenance and operating personnel.

Finally, an option is provided for setting all input F variables

to zero. Normally, for eacl: run the values of these variables are re-

tained from pass to pass so that, as sta',:ed previously, the user only

has to enter changes in tLe inputs. Howtver, there may be occasions

for the user to zero all inp variables so that he can start a new pass

with all variables set to zero. This may occur when many years or many

weapon systems, or both, have been run, and the user finds it difficult

to keep track of the current values of some of the input variables.

Initially, all F variables--input and output--are set tc zero; then,

at the start of succeeditg passes through the program, most of the out

put variables are set to zero.

Page 15: DOCUMENT RESUME - ERIC · DOCUMENT RESUME ED 050 350 AC 010 343 AUTHOR Boren, H. E., Jr. TITLE The Pilot Training Study: A User's Guide to the Advanced Pilot Computer Cost Model (APT)

-6-

A summary of the designators used to exercise the various program

options is given in Table 1.

14

Page 16: DOCUMENT RESUME - ERIC · DOCUMENT RESUME ED 050 350 AC 010 343 AUTHOR Boren, H. E., Jr. TITLE The Pilot Training Study: A User's Guide to the Advanced Pilot Computer Cost Model (APT)

-7-

Table 1

PROGRAM OPTIONS

Desi nator

Dump printout

Zero-output

Clear

Weapon systemvariable-listing

Variable-listingread (Constantinput data)

Simulator operatingand maintenancepersonnel authorized

Variable Descri tion

F(117) O. --Do not print Common Dump

1.0- -Print Common Dump

F(118) 0. --Do not omit all calculationsexcept number of graduates

1.0 - -Omit all calculations exceptnumber of graduates

F(119) O. --Do not zero all inpat variables

1.0Zero all input variables afterprintout

F(120) 0. --Variablc addresses, names, andvalues not to be listed

F(141)

7(071)

1.0Variable addresses, names, andvalues to be listed for thispals through program. F(120)is then set to zero.

O. --Addresses and napes of allvariables not to be read

1.0 -- Addresses and names of all

variables to be read once

z1.0--Per simulator required

<1.0- -Per simulator hour

15

Page 17: DOCUMENT RESUME - ERIC · DOCUMENT RESUME ED 050 350 AC 010 343 AUTHOR Boren, H. E., Jr. TITLE The Pilot Training Study: A User's Guide to the Advanced Pilot Computer Cost Model (APT)

-8-

III. PROGRAM CONSIDERATIONS

FLOW OF OPERATIONS

Figure 1 is a flow chart showing the general flow of operations

through the program. These operations are described in this section.

Initially, all input F variables in Common are set to zero. Sev-

eral other internal indexes are also initialized (for example, page

number). Next, a title card is read which contains the general title

for the enAre run. The constant input data [F(121)...F(141)], ex-

cluding F(135), are then entered. These values are referred to as con-

stant input data because they are usually constant for a run or runs

and do not vary with weapon system or veer. However, if the need

arises, any of them may be treated as a weapon system input and entered

as such for any pass through the program. Next, the title and rage

number are printed on a new page.

If, for at least one of the passes through the program, the user

will require a listing of the aderesses, names, and values of the vari-

ables, he must enter a 1.0 for the "read" designator in the constant

input data [F(lA1) = 1.0]. If this is done, the machine then reads in

the complete listing of OA of the program variables (310 cards) so

that the addresses and names are stored as alphanumeric information

for subsequent printouts. This listing is read in only once. On the

other hand, if this designator is not entered with a value of 1.0 in

the constant input data, the variable listing of 310 cards must not be

entered. Next, the current equipment inventories are set to zero. For

subsequent years of the same weapon system, these values are not set

to zero but are updated by adding to them the equipment to be procured

and, in the case of aircraft, subtracting the attrition aircraft. They

are reset to zero for each new weapon system. All calculations pertain-

ing to equipment resources, inzluding costs, are always performed through-

out the program in order of aircraft types 1, 2, and 3 (as applicable);

simulators; and trainers.

After the equipment inventories are se' to zero and other initial-

ization is completed, the weapon system number and name are read on a

161111......-

Page 18: DOCUMENT RESUME - ERIC · DOCUMENT RESUME ED 050 350 AC 010 343 AUTHOR Boren, H. E., Jr. TITLE The Pilot Training Study: A User's Guide to the Advanced Pilot Computer Cost Model (APT)

SET ALL INPUT FVARIABLES EQ ZERO.

(OTHER INITIAL17_ATIONh

READ TITLEFOR RUN

I(READ CONSTANT)

INPUT DATAF(121)...F(141) j

i(PRINT TITLE ANDPAGE NUMBER ON

NEW PAGE

VARIABLELISTING BEEN READ

PREVIOUSLY?

No

Yes

(READ LISTING OFADDRESSES AND NAMES

OF ALL F VARIABLESF (001) ...F (31C)

LSET CURRENT EQUIPMENTINVENTORIES TO ZERO ".

I(READ WEAPON SYS IFNI

NUMBER AND NAMEON SEPARATE CARD

1SET OUTPUT F VARIABLES

TO ZERO EXCEPT CURRENTEQUIPMENT INVENTORIESAND VARIOUS PERSONNEL

CHANGES

9-

1...CALL SUBROUTINE RE) ,D(READS WEAPON SYSTEM INPUT

DATA) F(002)...F(120), F11351,F(142)...F(145), F(217)...F(219)

CALL SUBROUTINE EQUIP(CALCULATES NUMBER OF

GRADUATES, AVERAGE NUMBEROF STUDENTS PER ',EAR, STUDENTLOAD, TRAINING HOURS, AND

EQUIPMENT REQUIREMENTS.ALSO UPDATES EQUIPMENT

INVENTORIES.)

CALL SUBROUTINE PERSCALCIAATES PERSONNEL

REQUIREMENTS.)

CALL SUBROUTINE INCO(CALCULATES INVESTMENT

COSTS.)

CALL SUBROUTINE OPCO(CALCULATES OPERATING

COSTS AND TOTALS.)

'CALL SUBROUTINE OUTPUT(PRINTS OUTPUT.)

End

of run

End of all 'Jr's

( PRINT TERMINATIONSTATEMENT ON

NEW PAGE(ALAL DATA PROCESSED)

F,ALI. EXIT

Fig. 1--Flow of operations

1'7

Page 19: DOCUMENT RESUME - ERIC · DOCUMENT RESUME ED 050 350 AC 010 343 AUTHOR Boren, H. E., Jr. TITLE The Pilot Training Study: A User's Guide to the Advanced Pilot Computer Cost Model (APT)

-10-

separate card. At this point all of the output variables are set to

zero except for the current equipment inventories and various personnel

changes. The remaining major operations involve calling the subroutines

to perform their specified tasks. First, subroutine READ is called to

read in the weapon system input data [F(002...F(120), F(135), F(142)...

F(145), F(217)...F(219)). Subroutine EQUIP is then called to calcu-

late the various training hours and equipment requirements. Also, the

number of graduates, the average number of students per year, and the

average student loads are calculated in this subroutine since they arc'

required for subsequent calculations in the same subroutine. Equipment

inventories are then updated in subroutine EQUIP.

Subroutine PERS is called next to determine all of the personnel

requirements including the incremental changes from year to year, re-

quired for certain calculations. All of the instructor, maintenance,

administrative, and support personnel are determined in this subroutine,

These people are further categorized into rated officers, non-rated

caicers, airmen, and civilians.

Following the personnel calculations, subroutine IfC0 Is called

to determine the investment costs charged to pilot training. In like

manner, subroutine OPCO is called to determine the operating costs am,

also the various total costs required for the output summary. All costs

are calculated in thousands of dollars except for the operating cost

per graduate, which is in dollars. Finally, subroutine OUTPUT is called

to print the results in prescribed formats.

Depending on the end-of-data designator and whether all data have

been processed, tie path then returns to some earlier portion of the

MAIN routine and coonences the ne\.: pass through the program. If one

year of a weapon system is completed with more years to follow, the

path returns to the point at which all of the output variables are set

to zero. If the last year of a weapon system has teen completed with

*Inittally, all weapon system input variables were intended to be

F(001)...F(120), constant inputs to be F(121...F(145), and all outputvariables to be F(151...F(300). [F(146)...F(149) are internal indices.]However, as modifications were required, it was necessary to add someinput variables with indexes out of order. This in no way affects theoperation of entering the data, as will be seen subsequently.

18

Page 20: DOCUMENT RESUME - ERIC · DOCUMENT RESUME ED 050 350 AC 010 343 AUTHOR Boren, H. E., Jr. TITLE The Pilot Training Study: A User's Guide to the Advanced Pilot Computer Cost Model (APT)

more weapon systems to follow for that run, the path returns to the

point at which the current equipment inventories are set to zero. If

the run is completed (with more runs to follow) so that all weapon sys-

tems have been processed, all of the weapon system inputs are set to

zero (in subroutine OUTPUT), and the path returns to an initialization

point (A in Fig. 1) just: before the point where the main title is read

for the run. Finally, if all data have been processed for all runs,

a termination statement Is printed on a ne,.7 page, and CALL EXIT is exe-

cuted by the program ending the job at that point.

19

Page 21: DOCUMENT RESUME - ERIC · DOCUMENT RESUME ED 050 350 AC 010 343 AUTHOR Boren, H. E., Jr. TITLE The Pilot Training Study: A User's Guide to the Advanced Pilot Computer Cost Model (APT)

-12-

IV. INPUT PROCEDURES

GENERAL DESCRIPTION*

Many different sets of data may be entered into the computer, each

set representing one year of a weapon system. Thus, there must be as

many sets of input data as the product of weapon systems and years.

The end of each s. is signalled by an end -of -data designator. This

designator is required for identifying whether the set of data consti-

tutes the end of a year, a weapon system, a run, or all runs. After

each set of data is read, all of the computations are performed on that

set and the results are printed, before the text set of data is read

by the machine.

As was stated previously, the F-variable ..array used in the prograr

is dimensioned 310. The subscripts of F are referrer; to as addresses

of F. Since F is the first array listed in Common, addresses rep-

resent the relative locations of the subscripted F variables in Common.**

Thus, F(001) represents the first F variable in Common, F(010) the

tenth, and F(310) the 310th in Common. (Preceding zeros for the ad-

dresses have no meaning; they are used merely for convenience so that

all addresses can be represented by three-digit numbers.)

Basically, the input procedures are structure° so that the address

of F is entered together with the value of the subscripted F as a pair.

The machine then stores the value in the relative location in Common

equal to the address. For example, if an address of 80 is entered with

a value of 0.9, the program performs the following operation:

F(080) = 0.9.

INPUT DATA CARDS

The basic set of data represents one year of a weapon system. The

first card of the first year of a set of weapon system data must always

*A specific summary on input data cards and their arrangement for

one or more runs is given at the end of this section under Data CardArrangement.

The F array is listed in Appendix A.

9n

Page 22: DOCUMENT RESUME - ERIC · DOCUMENT RESUME ED 050 350 AC 010 343 AUTHOR Boren, H. E., Jr. TITLE The Pilot Training Study: A User's Guide to the Advanced Pilot Computer Cost Model (APT)

-13-

be a title card. This card contains only the number and name of the

weapon system under consideration. Columns 1-2 are reserved for the

optional entry of the weapon system number (integer value). The wea-

pon system title is read in cols. 5-44 as alphanumeric information,

and the remaining porcione of the card are not used. The weapon sys-

tem number is stored as F(001) but 4.3 not used currently in the pro-

gram or printed in the output. After development of the program, it

was found that the weapon system number could be entered just as easily

as alphanumeric information in the title portion and printed out as

part of the title. However, it is Caere as F(001) if the user wishes

to modify the program to make use of it. Hence, there is no require-

ment to enter a number in cols. 1-2 of this card.

The cards following the weapon system title card contain the in-

put data for one or more years of the weapon system. In entering the

numerical data, eight pairs of F addresses and the corresponding F val-

ues may be entered on one card. The address of each variable is en-

tered as an integer in specified columns immediately preceding those

allotted to the corresponding variable value. These specified columns,

or fields, for the addresses are three columns wide and start in any

column ending in "1." Thus, cols. 1-3, 11-13, 21-23, 31-33, 41-43,

51-53, 61-63, and 71-73 are allotted for the addresses. The correspond-

ing fields for the F values (real numbers) are six columns wide and

start in any column ending in 4. Therefore, cols. 4-9, 14-19, 24-29,

34-39, 44-49, 54-59, 64-69, and 74-79 are reserved for the corresponding

F values. The implied decimal point location in each "variable" field

is between the third and fourth columns of those fields--for example,

between cols. 6 and 7 or 16 and 17, etc. Of course, a punched decimal

point will override the implied decimal point location.

Because the address of any variable is entered with the value of

the variable as a pair, the pairs may be entered in any order of address.

However, the address and the value of the variable must always be kept

together as a set. Pairs of blank fields (for example, cols. 1-3,

4-9) are not processed in the program. On the other hand, if addresses

are entered that are less than zero, or zero with a non-zero value for

the variable, or greater than 145 (except for 217, 218, and 219, which

21'

Page 23: DOCUMENT RESUME - ERIC · DOCUMENT RESUME ED 050 350 AC 010 343 AUTHOR Boren, H. E., Jr. TITLE The Pilot Training Study: A User's Guide to the Advanced Pilot Computer Cost Model (APT)

-14-

are the aircraft recurring investment cost factors), an error message

is printed, and the run is terminated at that point. Negative or zero

numbers are not legitimate numbers for addresses, and an address greater

than 145 (except for the three addresses noted above) means that an out-

put variable is being entered.

Figure 2 shows an input keypunch form that may be used to enter

data for this program. Each field contains an address and data (value)

pair. The vertical dashed lines are the implied decimal point loca-

tions. Thus, in the data field, three digits are allowed on each side

of the decimal point for the F value, which are usually sufficient for

most of the data. This is true because cost data must be entered in

thousands of dollars except where noted by a dollar sign in the list-

ing of Appendix A (see address 101, for example). Inputs noted by a

dollar sign are entered in dollars. However, as was stated previously,

those data values requiring more digits may be entered by simply key-

punching the decimal points to override the implied decimal point loca-

tions. The cross-hatched columns (10, 20, 30, etc.) are not used, ex-

cept tc separate the fields.

A total of 148 inputs is listed in Appendix A [F(001)...F(145),

F(217)...F(219)]. However, F(001) is not used as an input, and the

20 constant inputs [F(121)...F(141) excluding F(135)] are only entered

once. Therefore, 127 is the maximum number of weapon system inputs

that ould ever be required for one pass through the program (usually

for the initial, or base case, set of data). Since eight inputs can

be entered on a card, a total of 127 divided by 8 or 16 data cards

would be requited, or 17 incl'iding the weapon system title card.

Since all inputs are set to zero initially, they will remain zero

until a value is entered. Note, however, that for subsequent passes,

if inputs are not entered, their previous values will be retained from

year to year or from weapon system to weapon system. Therefore, if

one does not want the alue of an input to be retained for the next

pass, one must enter a new value or a zero for the input.

An example of nn input data card is shown in Fig. 3. Here, vari-

ables with addresses 098 thcough 105 ore entered. Variable with address

098 has a value of 900; variable with address 099 has a value of 80;

variable with address 100 has a value of 0.05, and so on.

99

Page 24: DOCUMENT RESUME - ERIC · DOCUMENT RESUME ED 050 350 AC 010 343 AUTHOR Boren, H. E., Jr. TITLE The Pilot Training Study: A User's Guide to the Advanced Pilot Computer Cost Model (APT)

Fie

ld1

ifF

ield

2F

ield

3'.V

.Fie

ld4:

4,,F

iOd5

oFie

ld6k

Dat

a.Z

1Add

r

gt

Dat

a."

,'?.A

ddr

:-/-

Fie

ld 7

!N-

Fie

ld8

1D

ata

-1:'i

= it:12

11E

1RM

Dat

a-;

''I'A

ddr

Dat

a4A

ddr

Dat

aP

Add

rD

ata

.i:N

Adc

itii_

__D

oto

iAdd

riii

ii122

2254

678

9012

3456

7890

1234

52

2222

2333

3333

333

4444

4444

4479

1901

2345

6789

0123

455

5555

5555

6666

6666

4677

7777

7777

956

7890

1234

5678

9012

3456

7890

MO

M=

MM

AM

It, Z.

M11

=11

=11

11.M

inM

IME

IINIM

MIM

IIIIIM

MIII

MIII

=M

B Yr

,t ;??

.

ME

M=

EIM

IMM

=11

1111

.1.g

illM

MM

E11

.111

11=

=M

IER

INIII

IMM

IIIIII

IIIIM

IIEM

IIIIII

MM

..-'.

.,

,-

IMM

INIM

ER

=M

ar

.... g

;.,t.

INIM

EIM

MII

IIIIIM

IIME

ME

NE

=,

.4

INIM

MO

OM

MIII

IIMIN

Mill

EM

Illm

imill

ig.1

11.1

111=

IIIM

EM

IIIIII

IIIIII

IIIIB

IN11

1111

1EIIM

EN

NIN

ER

EI

MI

W -.'

-

,

4- N; '''

,r.

''''

M=

IIIIII

IIIM

MIN

IIIM

MI

.:,-.

:6

rilim

mt=

IMM

IDM

In'-:

.,.. ,,, p,- ....

, , ,, .

MIN

ISIM

INII

MII

MM

iII

IIM

MIN

OM

MII

III1

111/

NN

W

III

III

,

ME

MM

INII

IMII

IME

111

MII

MIN

IEN

IIII

IIIM

IN=

1111

1111

11=

1

MM

IMM

IME

MIM

MIM

MI

.

12 3

4567

e 90

1 23

4567

89

012

34

5678

90)2

3456

7890

123

456

7890

Fig. 2--Example of input keypunch form

Page 25: DOCUMENT RESUME - ERIC · DOCUMENT RESUME ED 050 350 AC 010 343 AUTHOR Boren, H. E., Jr. TITLE The Pilot Training Study: A User's Guide to the Advanced Pilot Computer Cost Model (APT)

098900 099 80 100 05 101100 108424 103 0 104 0 105325

1000110100100011001001101010000100110000110000010001001101000110010000010000000012l 111 r l 1 11 11 12 11 11aN" NIl2lnanamaltma7171>2 11H1 `71111137Y114UN(SYrtonumliuuss uSIHll pilll UHp411flllilllrlr711ISJliia/r

1111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111i111111111111111111

2222222i2222222222221222222222272222222222121222227222i2222222722222222222122M

313313333333333333333:3333333333333M333333333333331333333333313333333331333333

44444444444444444441444144444444444444444441414444444414444444144444444444444444

5555555555555555555555555551S555M55555955555555$5555555555S5555555555515 15555

66iii6iiii566656166M6666661iiiiii6i66iiiiiiii611666166566616166166961E6666F6C6

177111771711111111171711171111111171111/1711711/111/11111/111/7177171/7/311111i7

(1110111111911111118111118111811611111111011111111111111111111118011111118191111

911199319311191111119111M111111995$11199111931191111199991919999359999991119991/1414/111tUunUnito111321n111214n1:1111MX11411A:L3M23110M.:OLICUUtSUMWOS..AUWA141111URAUPWOnnn;104n4WJaM

mualip

Fig. 3--Sample data card

el A

Page 26: DOCUMENT RESUME - ERIC · DOCUMENT RESUME ED 050 350 AC 010 343 AUTHOR Boren, H. E., Jr. TITLE The Pilot Training Study: A User's Guide to the Advanced Pilot Computer Cost Model (APT)

-17-

VARIABLE-LISTING SELECTION DESIGNATORS

Variable-listing selection designators are used to designate which

variable addresses, names, and values are to be listed when this option

of listing the F variables is used. Unless all variables are to be

listed (described in lie next paragraph), four input cards are used

each time some of the variables are to be listed. If the column num-

bers on these four cards are thought of as running continuously from

card to card, ona has 1...80 columns on the first card, 81...160 on

the second, 161...240 on the third, and 241...320 on the fourth card.

In the program the first 31U columns of these four cards are treated

as corresponding to the 310 F variables in Common, and a numeral 1

punched in any of those columns will cause the variable with address

corresponding to that column to be listed. For example, is punched

in cols. 5, 80, and 172 will cause F(005), F(080), and F(172) to be

listed.

If all variables are to be listed, only one card is required. A

numeral 9 in column 1 will result in a printout of all F variables.

This eliminates the necessity of punching is in alp 310 columns.

The selection designator cards are always entered immediately af-

ter the set of weapon system data for which the variables are to be

listed. In the set of weapon system data preceding the selection desig-

nator card(s), the variable F(120) must be entered as 1.0. This causes

the selection desigrator cards to be read. OtheIvise, F(120) is left

at zero, and the selection designators are not entered. It should be

noted that contrary to the general rule for input variables, the value

of F(120) is always set to zero for the start of the next pass through

the program--that is, a value of 1.0 for F;,120) is not retained fog

the next pass through the program. Therefore, when selection designa-

tors are to be read for a set of data, F(120) must be entered as 1.0

in the set of data to which the selection designators aptly. This was

done so that the listing of variables in this form would require: a pos-

itive action by the user. Also, this prevents the inadvertent carry-

over of 1.0 for F(120) to the next year for which the user does not

want the variables listed in this way and thus has not entered the se-

lection designator cards.

9r-

Page 27: DOCUMENT RESUME - ERIC · DOCUMENT RESUME ED 050 350 AC 010 343 AUTHOR Boren, H. E., Jr. TITLE The Pilot Training Study: A User's Guide to the Advanced Pilot Computer Cost Model (APT)

-13-

END-OF-DATA DESIGNATORS

There are four designators used to end the reading of a set of

data for one year of a weapon system. They are three-digit sixes, sev-

ens, eights, or nines (66, 777, 888, 999) and are entered in any of

the address fields following the last data value entered. Once this

designator is entered, the remaining fields of the card must be blank.

A new set of input data must always start on a new card. The designa-

tor 666 indicates that one year of input data is completed with more

years to follow for the same weapon system. Hence, the next card con-

tains only numerical data beginning for the next year. A 777 indicates

the end of all years for a wiapon system with more weapon systems to

follow. Thus, the next card must be a title card for a new weapon

system set of data. An 888 indicates the end of a run--tl.at is, the

end of data for all years and for all weapon systems of a run--but

that another run is to follow. Therefore, the next card must be a

title card for a new run. The cards to follow would then be the same

as those for the first run. If a new run is initiated, all weapon sys-

tem input data are set to zero. The constant input data are retained,

however.

For ti-e second and subsequent runs, were is a provision for read-

ing in the constant input data again. If there are no changes in these

values from the previous run, one card must be entered containing the

end-of-data designator 666 in any of the address fields (for example,

c..)1s. 1-3). Then, the previous constant input values will be retained.

Finally, a 999 designator indicates that the very last set of data

has been entered. After this set is processed, the machine prints a

termination statement on a new page Icating that this is the end of

the final run; hence all data have been processed. At that point CALL

EXIT is executed, and the job 13 terminated. It is important to note

that unless the end-of-data designators are entered properly in the

address fields, the mechine will continue to read data until no more

data are available, thus causing premature termination of the job.

Since the processing of pairs of blank fields is omitted in the read-

ing of input data, the end-of-data designator may be entered in

21

Page 28: DOCUMENT RESUME - ERIC · DOCUMENT RESUME ED 050 350 AC 010 343 AUTHOR Boren, H. E., Jr. TITLE The Pilot Training Study: A User's Guide to the Advanced Pilot Computer Cost Model (APT)

-19-

cols. 1-3 on a separate card immediately following the set of data to

which it applies. In some situations, this permits easier manipulation

of a set of data.

DATA CARD ARRANGEMENT

Table 2 summarizes the types of input cards used fur the APT pro-

gram. In conjunction kith Table 2, Table 3 is presented to show the

arrangement of input data cards for two hypothetical runs. Run 1 con-

sists of weapon systems A, B, and C, each to be operated for three

years. Run 2 consists of weapon systems D and E to be operated for

two and three years, respectively. A code index of the cards is given

in Tables 2 and 3 to allow the user to cross reference the cards in

the two tables.

For the runs shown in Table 3, the variable listing read desig-

nator F(141) must be entered as 1.0 in the constant input data since

the variable listing is to be read next for later printout. Then, in

the first year data set of weapon system A, the variable listing print

designator F(120) must be entered as 1.0. This causes the machine to

read the selection designators next for printing the F-var4able listing.

Also F(117) is entered as 1.0 in that same first year data of weapon

system A since the Common Dump is to be printed as well as the variable

listing.

Finally, Table 4 is presented to summarize the address and data

field locations on the data cards.

27

Page 29: DOCUMENT RESUME - ERIC · DOCUMENT RESUME ED 050 350 AC 010 343 AUTHOR Boren, H. E., Jr. TITLE The Pilot Training Study: A User's Guide to the Advanced Pilot Computer Cost Model (APT)

Table 2

SUMMARY OF INPUT CARDS

Code(see Table 3)

1

2

3

4

5

Type of Card

Title of Run

Constant Input Data

Variable Listing(310 cards);optional)

Weapon System Title

Data for One Yearof Weapon System

Remarks

First card of data deck for eachrun. Contains title of run incols 1-80 (alphanumeric informa-tion).

Consists of constant input dataF(121).. F(141) less F(135). End-

of-data designator for this set ofdata is 666(last entry ill anyaddress field), For second orsubsequent runs, at least onecard with a 666 designator mustbe entered here. If only onesuch card is entered, previousconstant input data are retainedfor the new run.

If F(141) = 1.0 in constantInput data, the F-variablelisting of 31C c.rds is enteredhere, This listing is enteredonly once regardless of numberof runs made. Each card of thislisting contains the address(cols 1-3) and name (cols 7-72)of the F variable. If F(141) =0.0 in the constant input data,this listing is not entered.

First card of first year of wea-pon system data. Contains titleof weapon system in cols. 5-44.No data are entered on this card.(Cols. 1-2 were originally reservedfor weapon system number, a numbernot currently required.)

Contains data for one year of aweapon system. End-of-data desig-nator 666 is used in address fieldat end of this set of data ifmore years of same weapon systemare to follow. A 777 designator

28

Page 30: DOCUMENT RESUME - ERIC · DOCUMENT RESUME ED 050 350 AC 010 343 AUTHOR Boren, H. E., Jr. TITLE The Pilot Training Study: A User's Guide to the Advanced Pilot Computer Cost Model (APT)

-21-

Table : (continued)

Code(see Table 3) i Type of Card Remarks

6 Variable-ListingS3lection Desis-natort1 or 4 cards)

(optional)

is used if this is last year ofweapon system with more weaponsystems to follow in this run.An 888 designator is used if thisis last year of last weapon sys-tem of this rui, with more runsto follow, A 999 designator isused if this is last set of data oflast run. Job is then terminatedafter this data set is processed,

Used to designate which variablesare to be listed. Always usedimmediately after set of data forwhich variables are to be listed,In that set of data F(120) = 1.0.If all variables are to be listed,a 9 is entered in col. 1 of aseparate card entered here.Otherwise, four cards are usedwith a 1 entered in column num-bers corresponding to addressesof variables to be listed. Ije

four cards may be thought of ascontaining cols 1...80, 81...160,161...240, and 241...320, the first

310 of which correspond to theF addresses.

Page 31: DOCUMENT RESUME - ERIC · DOCUMENT RESUME ED 050 350 AC 010 343 AUTHOR Boren, H. E., Jr. TITLE The Pilot Training Study: A User's Guide to the Advanced Pilot Computer Cost Model (APT)

-22-

Table 3

DATA CARD ARRANGEMENT FOR TWO RUNS

Code(see Table 2)

1

2

3

4

5

6

5

5

4

5

5

5

4

5

5

5

1

2

4

5

5

4

5

5

5

Type of CardsEnd-of-DataDesignator

Run 1 title card

Constant input data [F(141)=1.0] 666

F-variable listing (310 cards)

Weapon system A title card

Year 1 data [F(117)=1.0, F(120)=1.0] 666

Variable listing selectiondesignators (1. or 4 cards)a

Year 2 data 666

Year 3 data 777

Weapon system B title card

Year 1 data 666

Year 2 data 666

Year 3 data 771

Weapon system C title card

Year 1 data 666

Year 2 data 666

Year 3 data 888

Run 2 title card

Constant input data (at least one card) 666

Weapon system D title card

Year 1 data 666

Year 2 data 777

Weapon system E title card

Year 1 data 666

Year 2 data 666

Year 3 data 999

aFor this example whose outptits are discussed indipction V, only onedesignator card was used since all 310 F variables WIre listed.

30

Page 32: DOCUMENT RESUME - ERIC · DOCUMENT RESUME ED 050 350 AC 010 343 AUTHOR Boren, H. E., Jr. TITLE The Pilot Training Study: A User's Guide to the Advanced Pilot Computer Cost Model (APT)

-23-

Table 4

SUMMARY OF ADDRESS AND DATA FIELD LOCATIONS

Address FieldaLocation (cols)

(integer)

Corresponding DataField Location (cola)

(real number)

Implied Decimal PointLocation for Data Field

(between colsi

1-3 4-9 6-7

11-13 14-19 16-17

21-23 24-29 26-27

31-33 34-39 36-37

41-43 44-49 46-47

51-53 54-59 56-57

6i-63 64-69 66-67

71-73 74-79 76-77

&Address fields are also used for end-of-data designators (666,

777, 888, or 999). The end-of-data designator is always the lastentry of each year (set) of weapon system data.

31

Page 33: DOCUMENT RESUME - ERIC · DOCUMENT RESUME ED 050 350 AC 010 343 AUTHOR Boren, H. E., Jr. TITLE The Pilot Training Study: A User's Guide to the Advanced Pilot Computer Cost Model (APT)

-24-

V. PROGRAM OUTPUTS

Examples of outputs generated by the program are depicted in Figs.

4-17. The particular data shown are used only to illustrate the types

of outputs obtained from the program. The outputs represent the sys-

tems listed in Table 3. In this example, both the Common Dump and vari-

able listing are printed for the first year of weapon ,ystem A. Such

listings are always printed on separate pages. Otherwise, the lines

of output remain together for each weapon system.

Each value listed in the weapon system output is rounded to the

nearest whole number except for the numbers of aircraft and simulators

required (see, for example, Fig. 4). Values for these items are printed

to two decimal places. As explained previously and noted on the out-

put pages, all costs shown in the weapon system output are in thousands

of dollars except for the operating cost per graduate, which is in

dollars.

As an example of the use of the Common Dump "-sting, suppose that

one is interested in obtaining the value of the instructor flying hours

per student for all aircraft types in the long course. On the fifth

page of Appendix A the address of this variable is listed as 171, and

in the Common Dwmp(Fig. 5) its value is seen to be 42.5. Similarly,

the value of the total ground school classroom hours (address 184) is

listed as 406.496. These values are also obtained, of course, from

the variable listing, Fig. 9.

Finally, it should be noted that the page numbers start with 1 at

the beginning of each run. This is seen in Figs. 4 and 15. Otherwise,

the pages are numbered consecutively within a run.

Figures 4-17 represent demonstration runs. Neither the inputsnor the outputs of those runs are intended to be used for any otherpurposes. If any results from the APT program are to be used for of-ficial purposes, the inputs should be obtained from official sources.

Page 34: DOCUMENT RESUME - ERIC · DOCUMENT RESUME ED 050 350 AC 010 343 AUTHOR Boren, H. E., Jr. TITLE The Pilot Training Study: A User's Guide to the Advanced Pilot Computer Cost Model (APT)

AWAKED PaOr TRAINING COST MODEL TEST RUN NO. 1

PAGE

1

WEAPON SYSTEM A

(ALL OUTPUT COSTS EXCEPT OPERATING COST PER GRAGuAYE AAE IN TmOuSANDS OF DOLLARS.)

NO.

NO.

NO.

OPER

OPER

AVG

PERM

TYPE 1

TYPE 2

TYPE S

NO.

FLYING

OTHER

TOTAL

PLUS

COST PER

WO.

STUD.

PARTY

ACFT

ACE).

ACFT

SIMS

INV

HOUR

OPER

OPER

INY

GRAD

YEAR

GRAD

LOAD

PERS

REQ

RIO

RED

1E0

COST

COST

PAY

COST

COST

COST

(SI

1967

396

107

1206

27.09

0.0

2.0

1.72

011761

2763

2553

26477

26477

66261

Fig. 4 - -Run 1 sample output (weapon systemA): standard printout, 1967

Page 35: DOCUMENT RESUME - ERIC · DOCUMENT RESUME ED 050 350 AC 010 343 AUTHOR Boren, H. E., Jr. TITLE The Pilot Training Study: A User's Guide to the Advanced Pilot Computer Cost Model (APT)

wFAPON 595TEP.

PAG7

2

lurpul .:)5T5 EXCEPT oPFAA7Y4G CIST PER sAA0uATE ARE 14 Y4105.1415 9F 101147,5.1

CONMON DUMP

12

34

56

89

10

ADDRESSES

1.000

1.000

200.000

40.000

60.000

100.000

14.000

14.000

0.990

0.990

1-

10

103.000

0.0

0.0

101.000

0.0

0.0

27.000

27.000

188.000

188.000

11

20

2.100

0.0

0.0

0.0

0.0

425.030

2.000

600.000

0.0

600.000

0.0

300.000

85.000

300.000

0.0

2.000

0.0

16.000

B5.000

16.000

21-

::

6.000

6.000

0.700

C.700

1.100

0.0

0.050

0.0

0.0

0.460

41-

50

0.0

0.0

3120.000

2800.000

740.000

0.0

0.0

30.000

0.0

0.0

51-

60

3.000

2.000

2.000

0.125

3.000

0.100

8.000

0.050

0.0

0.0

6 -

70

0.012

2.004

5.000

0.140

0.0

0.550

1.000

0.0

0.100

0.900

71-

80

0.500

0.060

0.500

0.710

0.240

0.750

0.140

20.000

0.020

6500.000

0.960

0.0

0.200

0.0

0.800

900.000

0.210

80.000

0.750

0.050

81-

1:g

100.000

650.000

0.0

0.0

371.000

0.0

0.0

167.000

0.0

0.0

101- 110

10.000

10.000

500.000

8.000

0.0

0.0

1.000

0.0

0-0

1.000

111- 120

5987.000

100.000

500.000

800.000

1000.000

400.000

10543.000

16000.000

13500.000

4800.000

121- 130

Z6763.000

25.000

407.000

810.000

0.700

15.000

250.000

150.000

446.000

140

.:6

1.000

0.0

0.0

0.0

2.000

2.000

1.000

1.000

1.000

1967.000

141- 150

400.000

200.000

200.000

198.000

198.000

396.000

199.000

199.000

53.577

51.577

151- 160

107.154

10248.492

0.0

0.0

10248.492

0.0

0.0

20496.984

0.0

0.0

161- :70

I

42.500

42.500

8457.492

8457.492

16914.98.

2686.498

2886.498

5372.996

1193.999

1193.999

171- 140

143

2)87.999

2338.249

2338.249

4676.496

1634.774

1636.774

3273.548

701.475

701.475

1402.949

181- 190

as

1024.849

0.0

0.0

21521.832

0.0

0.0

9900.039

0.0

0.0

29.763

191- 200

,

0.0

0.0

3.000

2.000

29.084

0.0

0.0

1.722

0.918

0.0

201- 210

0.0

0.0

0.0

0.0

0.0

0.0

0.039

0.0

0.0

3761.097

211- 220

39.800

8.955

3.980

10.912

4.676

68.323

10.540

13.715

8.000

100.579

221- 230

495.002

0.0

0.0

495.002

45.133

4.000

49.133

644.714

95.260

847.127

231- 240

65.920

1313.047

1205.893

148.363

936.384

1084.746

121.146

126.456

21.907

0.0

247- 250

0.0

0.0

0.0

0.0

0.0

0.0

0.0

0.0

0.0

0.0

251- 260

0.0

0.0

0.0

0.0

0.0

0.0

0.0

0.0

0.0

0.0

261- 270

0.0

0.0

6435.023

3672.914

1653.306

11761.238

1.990

1.990

1129.722

2023.291

271- 200

295.741

4494.641

6813.672

7943.391

819.313

8762.703

200.000

30.147

534.410

1063.567

281- 290

9.644

4.000

0.0

19.696

37.091

140.458

537.828

5951.117

26477.059

66861.250

291- 300

26477.059

0-237

0.0

0.0

3372.299

0.0

0.0

3372.299

0.0

0.0

301- 310

Fig. 5--Run 1 sample output (weapon system A): Common Dump. 1967

Page 36: DOCUMENT RESUME - ERIC · DOCUMENT RESUME ED 050 350 AC 010 343 AUTHOR Boren, H. E., Jr. TITLE The Pilot Training Study: A User's Guide to the Advanced Pilot Computer Cost Model (APT)

1 2

WEAPON SYSTEM A

(ALL OUTPUT COSTS EXCEPT OPERATING COST PER GRADUATE ARE IN TPUUSANOS OF

WEAPON SYSTEM NUMBER

YEAR NUMBER (1.. 2.. 3.. .

..

ETC.)

PAGE

DOLLARS.) 1.00000

1.00000

3

1ENTERING STUDENTS PROP SIMILAR AIRCRAFT

200.00000

4ENTERING STUDENTS FROM OISSImILAR AIRCRAFT

40.00000

5ENTERING STUDENTS FROM DESK JOBS

60.00000

6ENTERING STUDENTS FROM uNCIERGRA0uATE PILOT TRAINING (UPI)

100.000CC

7LENGTH OF LONG COURSE (WEEKS)

0.0000G

8LENGTH OF SHORT COURSE (WEEKS)

14.00000

9FRACTION OF ENTERING STUDENTS WHO GRADUATE - -LCNG COURSE

C.53000

10

FRACTION OF ENTERING STUDENTS WHO GRADUATE- -SHORT COURSE

0.99000

It

HOURS EACH STuDENT On:WIRED TO FLY- -TYPE 1 AIRCRAFT, LONG COURSE

103.00000

12

HOURS UCH STUDENT REQUIRED TO FLY-TYPE 2 AIRCRAFT. LONG COURSE

0.0

13

HOURS EACH STUDENT REQUIRED TO FLY--TYPE 7 AIRCRAFT, LONG COURSE

0.0

14

/OURS EACH STUDENT REQUIRED TO FLY-TYPE 1, SHORT COURSE

101.00000

15

FOURS EACH STUDENT RECKHRED TC FLY- -TYPE 2. SHORT COURSE

0.0

16

NOIAS EACH STUDENT REQUIRED TO FLY - -TYPE 3. SHORT COURSE

0.0

17

SIMULATOR HOURS REQUIRED PER STUDENT- -LCNG COURSE

27.00000

la

SIMULATOR HOURS REQUIRED PER STUDENT-SHORT COURSE

27.CCCOC

19

POURS 5/WENT REOuTRED TO ATTEND GROUND SCHOOL (GSI-LONG COURSE

1.88.00090

20

HOURS STUDENT REO.,,,IREO TO ATTEND OROUNO SCHOOL (CSI-SHORT COURSE

Ingo:Imo

21

AVERAGE NO. STUDENT PILOTS ON STUCENT CREW--TYPE 1. LONG COURSE

2.000CC

22

AVERAGE NO. STUDENT PILOTS ON STUCENT CREW - -TYPE 2. LCNG COURSE

0.0

23

AVERAGE NO. STUDENT PILOTS ON STUDENT CREW - -TYPE 3. LONG COURSE

C. C

24

AVERAGE NO. STUDENT PILOTS ON STUDENT CREW- -TYPE 1. SHORT COURSE

2.0000C

25

AVERAGE nn. STUDENT PILOTS ON STUDENT CREW- -TYPE 2. SHORT COURSE

0.0

IV76

AVERAGE NO. STUOENT PILOTS ON STUDENT CREW- -TYPE 3, SHORT COURSE

C.C.

,j

77

HOURS INSTRUCTOR FLIES WITH EACH STUOENT--TYPE I. LONG COURSE

85.CCCOC

28

HoURS INSTRUCTOR FLIES WITH EACH STUCENT- -TYPE 2, LONG COURSE

0.0

?9

OURS INSTRUCTOR FLIES WITH EACH STUDENT- -TYPE 3. LONG COURSE

C. C

30

HOURS INSTRUCTOR FLIES WITH EACH STUDENT - -TYPE 1. SHORT COURSE

135.CCCCC

31

POURS INSTRUCTOR FLIES WITH EACH STUDENT-TYPE 2. SHORT COURSE

0.0

32

HOURS tmsTRucToR FLIES WITH EACH STUDENT- -TYPE 3, SHORT COURSE

C.0

33

MAXIMUM HOURS PER YEAR INSTRUCTOR FLIES WITH STUDENTS

425.0000C

34

MAXIMUM SIMULATOR HOURS PER YEAR INSTRUCTOR SUPERVISES

500.CCOOC

35

MAXIMUM TRAINER HOURS PER YEAR INSTRUCTOR SUPERVISES

600.00000

36

MAXIMUM GS HOURS PER YEAR CCTS INSTRUCTOR TEACHES

3CO.CCCOC

37

MAXIMUM OS HOURS -ER YEAR FTO INSTRUCTOR TEACHES

300.00000

38

AVG NO_ STUDENT PILOTS ON SIMULATOR AT ONE TIME

2. C0000

39

AVG NO. sTLIDENT PILOTS IN CS CLASSROOM AT ONE TIME- -LONG COURSE

16. CC000

40

AVG NO. STuDENT PILOTS IN GS CLASSROOM AT ONE TIFF-SHORT COURSE

16.COOCC

41

TRAINER HOURS REWIRED PER STUDENT - -LONG COURSE

5.00000

42

TRAINER HOURS REQUIRED PER STUDENT -SHORT COURSE

6.00000

43

FRACTION OF GS HOURS TAUGHT BY CCTS INSTRUCTORS-LONG COURSE

0.70000

44

FRACTION OF GS HOURS TAUGHT BY COTS INSTRUCTORS-SHORT COURSE

0.70000

45

AIRCRAFT ATTRITION PER /00000 FLYING MOORS- -TYPE

11.10000

46

AIRCRAFT ATTRITION PER 100000 FLYING HOURS-TYPE 7 (SEE 1441

C.0

47

OTHER FH CHARGED TO CREW TRNG (FRACT. sTUD.4SEP. INST. FH)- -TYPE

0. C5C00

48

OTHER FH CHARGED TC CREW TRAINING (FRACTICN STUDENT FHI-TyPE 2

C.0

49

OTHER Fm CHARGED TO CREW TRAINING (FRACTION STUDENT FH)--TYPE 3

C.0

50

FRACTION DE TOTAL FH CP COST ALLOCATED TC PILOT TRAINING- -TYPE 1

0.46C CO

51

FRACTION OF TOTAL FH CR COST ALLOCATED TO PILCT TRAINING- -TYPE 2

0.0

52

FRACTION OF TOTAL Fm OR COST ALLOCATED TO P)LCT TRAINING- -TYPE 3

0.0

53

TRAINING HOURS AVAILABLE PER YEAR ON ONE SIMULATOR

3120. CCCCC

Fig. 6--Run I sample output (weapon system A):

Variable listing, 1967, F(001)-F(053)

Page 37: DOCUMENT RESUME - ERIC · DOCUMENT RESUME ED 050 350 AC 010 343 AUTHOR Boren, H. E., Jr. TITLE The Pilot Training Study: A User's Guide to the Advanced Pilot Computer Cost Model (APT)

7)

54

5556

57

WEAPON SYSTEP A

(ALL OUTPUT COSTS EXCEPT OPERATING COST PER GRADUATE

ARE IN THOUSANDS OF

TRAINING POURS AVAILABLE PER YEAR ON ONE TRAINER

AVAILABLE FLYING HOURS PER YEAR - -TYPE 1

AVAILABLE FLYING HOURS PER YEAR --TYPE 2

AVAILABLE FLYING HOURS PER YEAR --TYPE 3

PAGE

4

OOLLARS.1

2600.00000

740. C0000

C.0

0.0

58

AIRCRAFT AVAILABLE AT BEGINNING OF FIRST YEAR--TYPE I

30. CCOOC

59

AIRCRAFT AVAILABLE AT BEGINNING OF FIRST YEAR-TYPE 2

0.0

60

AIRCRAFT AVAILABLE AY BEGINNING OF FIRST YEAR-TYPE

30.0

61

SIMULATORS AVAILABLE AT BEGINNING OF FIRST YEAR

3.10000

62

TRAINERS AVAILABLE AT BEGINNING OF FIRST YEAR

2.COOCC

63

FIXED NUMBER OF IhSTRUCIOR-SUPERVADMIN-SONLEVEL

2. CCCCC

64

VARIABLE NUMBER OF INSTRUCUIR-SuPERVPROMIN

(PER IAST.1--,SOON LEVEL

0.125CC

65

FIAEO NUMBER OF ACADEMIC- PROGRAM SUPERVISORS-SOU/CRON

LEVEL

3.CCCOC

66

VARIABLE NO. ACAO-PROD SUPERV, PER STUD. IN STUO.

1080 - -SOON LEVEL

0.10000

67

6(1

TOTAL STAN) -AR }EVALUATION PERSONNEL REQUIRED

AIRCRAFT MAINTENANCE PERSONNEL ROCUIREO PER 'rLYING

HOUR -TYPF I

B.CCCCC

0.05000

69 70

AIRCRAFT MAINTENANCE PERSONNEL REQUIRED PER FLYING HOUR--TYPE 2

AIRCRAFT MAINTENANCE PERSONNEL REQUIRED PER FLYING

POUR-TYPE 3

o.c

o.c

71

SINULATOR OPEP.MTC PERS AUTHORIZEC PER SIMULATOROR PER 51N HOUR

o.c1200

72

TRAINER OPER.PTC PERS AUTHORIZED PER VRAINEM

2.00000

73

FIXED NUMBER OF AOMINISTRATIVE PERSONNEL --WING

LEVEL

S. CCCCC

74

VARIABLE NO. AOMIN PERS-WING LEVEL (PER OPER4PTC

PERSONNEL)

0.14000

75

FIXED NUMBER OF SUPPORT PERSONNEL

C.0

76

VARIABLE NC. SUPPORT PERS (PER TOTAL STUOENT

LOAO.OPER.mICAOMIN)

0.55000

77

FRACTION OF GS Ot'IS INSTRUCTORS WHO ARE OFFICERS

1.00000

75

FRACTICN Of

G5 CJ.IS INSTRUCTORS WHO ARE AIRMEN

0.0

79

FRACTION OF 05 FIO INSTRUCTORS MHO ARE OFFICERS

0.10000

go

FRACTION OF GS FED INSTRUCTORS MHO ARE AIRPEN

C. SCCOC

81

FRACTION OF INSTRuCTORSUPERVACMIN (SOON LEVEL) WHO

ARE OFFICERS

0.50000

82

FRACTION OF INSTRUCTOR-SUPERV.A0MIN (SOON LEVEL) )00 MAE

AIRMEN

0.5000C

83

FRACTION OF ACAD-PROGRM SUPERVRAOM(N (SOON LEVEL) WHOARE OFFICERS

0.24000

84

FRACTION OF ACAD-PROGRP SUPERVAROPIN (SOON LEVEL) WHO

ARE AIRMEN

0.74000

85

FRACTION Of AIRCRAFT mfc PERSONNEL WHC ARE OFFICERS

0. C2000

86

FRACTION OF AIRCRAFT NYC PERSONNEL WHO ARE AIRMEN

0. 56000

87

FRACTION OF SIMULATOR AND TRAINER MTCPOPER PERS WNO

ARE OFFICERS

0.2CCCC

se

FRACTION OF SIMULATOR AND TRAINER RTC/OPER PERS

WHO ARE AIRMEN

C.8COOC

89

FRACTION OF AMR PERSONNEL (WING LEVEL) WHC ARE OFFICERS

0.21000

90

FRACTION OF AOMIN PERSONNEL (WING LEVEL) WHO ARE

AIRMEN

0.75000

91

FRACTION OF SUFrORT PERSONNEL WHO ARE OFFICERS

0.06000

92

FRACTION OF SUPPORT PERSONNEL WHO ARE AIRMEN

C.71C0C

93

FRACTION OF OFFICERS 1040 ARF RATED

0.75000

94

MIN INCREASE IN STUOENT LOAO REFORE 1.1. TANG

EOUIP.F!-PARES JUSTIF.

2 C. C0000

95

1.1. COST PEA AIRCRAFT- -TYPE 1

6500.00000

96

1.1. COST PER AIRCRAFT- -TYPE 2

0.0

97

(.1. COST PER AIRCRAFT--TYPE

0.0

98

I.I. COST PER SIMULATOR

900.00000

99

I.!. COST PER TRAINER

80.COPOO

100

FRACTION OF I.I. SIFULATOP COST FOR SIMULATOR SPARES

COST

C.05000

101

1.1. COST FOR TANG EQUIP+SPARE$ PER INCREASE IN STUDENT

LOAD (S)

100.CCCOC

102

OPERATING COST PER FLYING HOUR FOR DEPOT P.0 - -TYPE 1 (A)

650.00000

103

OPERATING COST PER FLYING HOUR FOR DEPOT MTE-TYPE 2

14)

0.0

104

OPERATING COST PER FLYING HOUR FOR OEPOT MTC-TYPE 3 IA)

0.0

105

OPERATING COST PER FLYING HOUR FCR POL--TYPE 1

(SI

371.00000

106

OPERATING COST PER FLYING HOUR FOR POL- -TYPE Z (s)

0.0

Fig. 7--Run 1 sample output (weapou system

A):

Varfable lis,fing, 1967, F(054)-F(106)

Page 38: DOCUMENT RESUME - ERIC · DOCUMENT RESUME ED 050 350 AC 010 343 AUTHOR Boren, H. E., Jr. TITLE The Pilot Training Study: A User's Guide to the Advanced Pilot Computer Cost Model (APT)

WEAPON SYsTER A

(ALL OUTPUT COSTS EXCEPT OPERATING CCST PFR GRA0UATF ARE IN TFOUSANOS PF

RAGE

OCLLARS.I

5

IOT

OPERATING COST PER FLYING HOUR FOR POL--TYPE 1 (SI

0.0

IC)

OPFRATINn COST PER FLYING HOUR FOR MATERIAL- -TYPE

I(SI

167.000O,

109

OPERATING COST PEP FLYING HOUR FCR MATERIAL-TYPE 2

01.1

0.0

110

OPERATING COST PER FLYIN0 HOUR En. MATERIAL- -TYPE 3 ("I

P.0

III

112

OPERATING COST PER STUDENT FOP muNITICNS--LoNG COURSE (I)

OPERATING CCST PER STUOFNT FOR MUNITIONS - -SHORT MIME (SI

IC.,CCPL

10.00000

113

114

OPERATING COST PER STUOENT FOR AVERAGE TOY/PCS (SI

OPERATING COST PER Sly PER YR FOP SIm mTC--NATERIAL. SERVICES

5°=2

IIS

OPERATING COST PER YEAR FOR TARGET RENTAL

0.0

116

R ANO 0 COST

0.6

117

OUMP PRINTOUT OESIGNATOR (0./1.--(10 NCT /OC PRINT CUPP!

I.COOOO

IIR

ZERO-OUTPUT DESIGNATOR (0./1.--00 NOT/00 ZERC OUTPUT EXCEPT GRACSI

0.0

119

CLEAR DESIGNATOR (0./1.--00 NOT /DO 7FRO OUT ALL . VARIABLES

0.0

120

WEAPON SYSTEM VARIABLE-LISTING PRINT OESIGNATOR

I.00000

121

BEGINNING YEAR (E.G., 196"E)

1967.00000

122

MIN INCREASt t4 PERM PARTY BEFORE 1.1. EOUTP.SuPPLIES JuSTIFIEO

100.0000C

121

1.1. COST FOR BASE SUPPORT FOuIPPSPAR.S 0FR PEE* PARTY INCREASE(S1

500.00OOC

124

LI. COST FOR BASE SGPPLY INVENTORY PER PERM PARTY INCREASE (SI

80C.CCCOO

125

176

1.1. COST FCR PERM - PARTY- INCREASE TRAINING OfF BASE (SI

1.1. COST FOR VERN-PARTY-INCREASE TRAVEL Is)

1!).170.0(C)

127

OPER. COST PER YEAR FOR AVG PAY OF STUOENI Is)

11543.COOCC

CA,

12R

179

OPER. CCST PER YEAR FOR AVG PAY PE PERM PARTY lATE0 OFFICER (SI

OPER. COST PER YEAR fOR AVG PAY OF REPM PARTY NONRATED OFFICER (s)

16000.00000

13500.COOCC

e

wN1

130

CPER. COST PER YEAR FOR AVG PAY OF PERM PARTY AIRMAN (SI

4SMC.0C000

h.1

131

OPFR. COST PI R YEAR FOR AVG PAY Or CIVILIAN 114

A763.00000

,C)

137

OPER. CnST P

YEAR FOR AvG TOY OF PERM PARTY (S)

25.00000

'

133

OPER. COST PER YEAR FOP SERVICES--AVG PER PEPSCN CN BASE (S)

407.COCOC

1'4

OPER. COST PAR TEAR FOR SuRPLIESPEOVIP PFR PERSON UN PASE IS)

Sle 20000

1'5

FRACTION OF SIMULATOR HOURS OR COSTS ALLOCATE° TO PACT TRAINING

..7000C

116

OPER. COST PER YEAR FOR SUPPORT ACFT--AVG PEP. PERSON ON BASE IS)

15.00000

137

OPER. COST PER YEAR FOP ;FERN F:ATY OFFICER 'RAINING OFF SASE IS)

25C.COCOC

134

OPER. COST PER 4..:AR FOR PEON PARTY AIRFARE( TRAINING OFF IMF "%)

150.0000C

119

CPO,. COST PER YEAR FCR AVERAGE PCS PE, PERM PARTY PERSON (SI

446.CO0PO

140

FRACTION OF 1.1. A1RCPAET CO5T FOR AIRCRAFT SPARES COST

0.15000

141

VARIABLE - LISTING READ DESIGNATOR (0./1.--OC ACT/TIC REDO VARIABLES)

1.CCCOC

142

INSTRUCTOR LEAO/TOw FLYING HOURS PER STUDENT--TY1- I. LONG CCURSE

0.0

*,1

INSTRUCTOR LEAO/TCM FLYING HOURS PTE STUDENT - -TYPE 1. SHORT COURSE

0.0

144

AIRCRAFT AF.RITION PER 100010 FLYING hnuRS--TYPE 3 ISEF 045. 0481

C.0

145

146

OPER. COST PER YEAR FCR TRAINER RTC PER TsNR--RATERIAL, SERVICES

PAGE NUMBER

2.(CCCC

2.COCCE

147

YEAR COUNTFC

I.CCOOC

14R

END-OE-OATA DESIGNATOR

1.00000

'49

PASS COUNTER

1.00000

153

CURRENT YEAR

1967.COCPC

I51

TOTAL ENTERING STUDENTS

400.000OC

152

TOTAL ENTERING STUDENTS - -LONG COURSE

2CO.0000C

153

TOTAL ENTERING STUDENTS-SHORT CCURSE

2OC.00000

154

TOTAL GRADUATES-LONG COURSE

197.9559E

155

TOTAL GRADUATES - -SHORT COURSE

197.91998

156

TOTAL GR4OUATFS

395.SSS76

157

AVERAGE NUMBER Pc STUDENTS PER YEAR-LONG COURSE

11%3::::::

154

AVERAGE NUMBER OF ,'UOENTS PFR ',TAR-Sur.* CFURSE

159

AVERAGE STUOENT LOAD FOR LONG COURSE

53.57E89

Pig. 8--Run 1 sample output (weapon system A):

Variable listing, 1967, F(107)-F(159)

Page 39: DOCUMENT RESUME - ERIC · DOCUMENT RESUME ED 050 350 AC 010 343 AUTHOR Boren, H. E., Jr. TITLE The Pilot Training Study: A User's Guide to the Advanced Pilot Computer Cost Model (APT)

WEAPON SYSTEM

(ALL Output COSTS EXCEPT OPERATING COST PER GRADUATE ARE IN TmOUSANOS OF

PArE

DOLLARS./

160

AVERAGE STUOENT LOAD FOR Smnmi COURSE

53.57689

161

TOTAL AVERAGE STUDENT LOAD

1C7.1537e

162

TOTAL STUDENT FLYING HOURS -TV4F I. 1,NG COURSE

10248.45219

163

TOTAL STUDENT FLYING HOURS-TYPE 2. LONG CCURSE

C.0

164

ToTAL 4IWENT FLYING HOURS- -TYPE 1. LONG COURSE

C.0

16S

rYAL STUDENT FLYING HOURS- -TYPE 1. S"ORY COURSE

10240.49219

166

TOTAL STUDENT FLYING HOURS- -TYPE 2. SHORT COURSE

0.0

167

TOTAL STUDENT FLYING HOURS- -TYPE 1. SHCRT CCUPSE

C.0

168

TOTAL STUDENT FLYING HOURS- -TYPE 1

70496.90418

169

TOTAL STUDENT FLYING HOURS-TYPE .7

0.0

170

_STUDENT FLYING HOURS-TYPE 3

C.0

171

INSTRUCTOR FN PER STUDENT- -ALL AIRCRAFT TYPES. LONG COURSE

47.50000

172

INSTRUCTOR gm PER STUDENT-ALL AIRCRAFT TYPES. SHORT COURSE

42.5C00E

173

TOTAL HOURS INSTRUCTOR FLIES WITH STUDENTS- -LONG COURSE.

8487.49719

174

TOTAL HOURS INSTRUCTOR FLIES WITH STUDENTS- -SHORT COURSE

8457.49219

175

TOTAL HOURS INSTRUCTOR PLIES WITH STUDENTS

16914.6848A

176

TOTAL STUDENT SIMULATOR HOURS- -LONG CCURSE

2686.49005

177

TOTAL STUDENT SIPULATCR HOURS- -SNORT COURSE

2686.49805

178

TOTAL STUDENT SIRULATOR HOURS

5177.9960s

179

TOTAL STUDENT TRAINER HOURS - -LONG COURSE

1191.99977

180

TOTAL STUDENT TRAINER HOURS-SmCRT COURSE

11

191

TOTAT STUDENT TRAINER HOURS

21rY.1=

182

TOTAL GROUND-SCHOCL CLASSROOM HOURS-LCSG CCURSE

2118.24854

193

TOTAL GROUND - SCHOOL CLASSROOM HOURS -SHORT COURSE

2118.24854

194

TOTAL GROUND-SCHOOL CLASSRCCR HOURS

4676.44605

IRS

TOTAL GS GLASSFoCm HOURS TAUGHT BY CCTS INSTRUCTORS-LONG COURSE

1636.77193

Co.,

186

TOTAL GS CLASSROOM HOURS TAUGHT BY COTS INSTRuCTCRS-SHORT COURSE

1616.77191

187

TOTAL GS CLASSROCH HOURS TAUGHT By CCTS INSTRUCTORS

32',-.54795

OD

188

TOTAL GS CLASSROOM HCURS TAUGHT BY FTn INSTRUCTORS- -LONG COURSE

701.47461

199

TOTAL GS CLASSROOM HOURS TAUGHT BY FTD INSTRUCTORS- -SHORT COURSE

7O1.47461

190

TOTAL GS CLASSROCR HOURS TAUGHT BY Fro INSTRUCTORS

1402.94972

191

OTHER FLYING HOURS - -TYPE I

1074.E4912

192

OTHER FLYING HOURS - -TYPE 7

C.0

193

OTHER FLYING HOURS- -TYPE 3

C.0

194

TOTAL FLYING HOURS - -TVPt 1

21571.83203

195

TOTAL FLYING HOURS --TYPE 2

0.0

196

TOTAL FLYING HOURS- -TYPE 3

0.0

197

FLYING HORS CHARGED TO PILOT TRAINING-TYPE

_8000.C3SCA

198

PLYING HOURS CHARGED TO PILOT TrA16 NG-TYRE 2

0.0

199

PLYING HOURS CHARGE? TO Pl'nT tRAI4ING-TYPE 3

0.0

290

CURRENT INVENTORY - -TYPE 1

28.76126

201

CURRENT INVENTORY- -TYPE 2

0.0

202

CURRENT INVENTORY-TYPE 3

0.0

203

CURRENT INVENTORY-SIMULATORS

3.00000

204

CURRENT INVENTORY-TRAINERS

20

205

AIRCRAFT REOUTRED- -TYPE

12..=

206

AIRCRAFT REQUIRED- -TYPE 7

C.e

217

AIRCRAFT REQUIRED- -TYPE 3

C.0

208

SIMULATORS REQUIRED

1.72711

209

TRAINERS REQUIRED

0.91846

210

AIRCRAFT TO BE PROCURED- -TYPE 1

0.0

211

AIRCRAFT TO BE PRO6uRED-TYPE 2

C.0

212

AIRCRAFT TO BE PR0CoREO-TYPE 3

0.0

Fig. 9--Run 1 sample output (weapon system A):

Variable listing, 196/, F(1G0)-F(212)

6

Page 40: DOCUMENT RESUME - ERIC · DOCUMENT RESUME ED 050 350 AC 010 343 AUTHOR Boren, H. E., Jr. TITLE The Pilot Training Study: A User's Guide to the Advanced Pilot Computer Cost Model (APT)

713

/14

215

716

WEAPON sysyEm A

(ALL OUTPUT COSTS EXCEPT CPERATiNG COST PER GRADUATE ARE IN THOU56NOS OF

SIMULATORS TO BE PROCURED

TRAINERS TO SE PROCURED

TOTAL INSTRuCTCA LEAD /TOW FLYING //MRS-TYPE 1. LCNG COURSE

TV-AL INSTRUCTOR LEAD /TOW FLYING HOURS-TYPE 1. SHORT COURSE

PAGE

OOLLAR5.$ 0.0

0.0

0.0

C.0

217

RECURRING INVESTMENT COST FACTOR-TYPE I (WEAPON SYSTEM I, 'LIT)

0.03878

218

RECURRING INVESTMENT COST FACTOR - -TYPE 2

( wEAPCN SYSTEM INPUT)

C.0

219

RECURRING INVESTMENT COST FACTOP-TYPE 3 WEAPON SYSTEM INPUT)

C.0

220

SIMULATOR HOURS CHARGEO TO PILOT TRAINING

3761.05717

221

222

TOTAL FLYING INSTRUCTORS REQUIRED

TOTAL SIMULATOR INSTRUCTORS REQUIRED

3n.75556

223

724

TOTAL TRAINER INSTRUCTORS REQUIRED

TOTAL GROUNO-:CHOOL COTS INSTRUCTORS REQUIRED

3.secoc

1:::::::

225

TOTAL GROUND- SCHOOL ETD INSTRUCTORS REQUIRED

4.67650

226

TOTAL INSTRUCTORS REQUIRED

68.37324

277

TOTAL. INSTRUCTOR SUPERVISORS AND AOMIN PERS REOVIR8p_som LEVEL

IC.54041

228

TOTAL ACAD-PROGRAM SUPERVISORS AND AOMIN PERS PECUIRED-SODN LEVEL

13.71537

229

TOTAL STANDARD-EVALUATION PERSONNEL REQUIRED

8.CCOOC

231)

TOTAL NONSTJOENT OPERATIONS PERSONNEL

231

TOTAL AIRCRAFT MAINTENANCE PERSCWNEL-TYPE 1

IZZINM

232

TOTAL AIRCRAFT mA1NTENANCE PERSONNEL-TYPE 2

0.0

233

TOTAL AIRCRAFT MAINTENANCE PERSONNEL-TYPE 3

(5 7.C171

Cm,

734

TOTAL AIRCRAFT MAINTENANCE PERSONNEL

49

235

TOTAL SIMULATOR MAINTENANCE AND OPERATING PERSONNEL

45.:3315

CID

236

TOTAL TRAINER MAINTENANCE ANO OPERATING PERSONNE

4.00000

237

TOTAL SIMULATOR AND TRAINER MAINTENANCE ANO OPERATING PERSONNEL

49.133/5

238

TOTAL OPERATIONS AND MAINTENANCE PERSONNEL

644.7136/

239

240

TOTAL ADMINISTRATIVE I.ERSONNEL (WING LEVEL)

TOTAL STUDENT LOAD

OPERATION

FITC

ADMINISTRATIVE PERSONNEL

895.47.2590S

17695

241

TOTAL SUPPORT PERSONNEL

465.51968

242

TOTAL PERSONNEL CHARGED TO PILOT TRAINING. INCLUDOG STUDENTS

1313.04663

243

TOTAL PERMANENT PARTY PERSONNEL

1205.85282

244

TOTAL PERMANENT PAR TV OFFICERS

148.36266

745

TOTAL PERMANENT PARTY AIRMEN

936.38379

246

TOTAL PERMANENT PARTY MILFTARY PERSONNEL

1084.74634

247

TOTAL CIVILIANS

121.i4648

248

TOTAL PERMANENT PARTY RATED OFFICERS

126.45577

249

TOTAL PERMANENT PAYTY NONRATED OFFICERS

21.SC694

250

CHANGE IN STUOENT LOAD

0.0

251

CHANGE IN TOTAL PERSONNEL. INCLUDING STUDENTS

0.0

252

CHANGE IN TOTAL PERMANENT PARTY PERSONNEL

0.0

253

CHANGE IN TOTAL PERMANENT PARTY MILITARY PERSCNNEL

c.0

254

CHANGE IN PERM_ PARTY LESS CHANGE DUE TO ALLOC. FPACTION vAkIJ.TION

0.0

755

AOJUSTMENT TO FLIP_ EFFECT ON 1.1. COST OF CHANGE IN ALLOC. FRACT.

0.0

256

CUMULATIVE CHANGE IN STUDENT LOAD UNTIL THRESWG&D IS REACHED

0.0

257

CUMULATIVE CHANGE IN ADJ. PERM PARTY UNTIL THRESHOLO IS REACHEO

0.0

258

1.1. COST OF AIRCRAFT TO BE PROCURED-TYPE 1

0.0

259

1.1. COST OF AIRCRAFT TO BE PROCURED -TY'- 2

0.0

260

1.1. COST OF AIRCRAFT TO 5F PROCURED-TY.

30.0

261

1.1. COST OF SIMULATORS rn RE PROCUREC

0.0

262

S.I. COST OF TRAINERS TO BE PROCURED

0.0

263

I.I. COST OF AIRCRAFT SPARES-TYPE I

0.0

264

1.1. COST OF AIRCRAFT SPARES-TYPE 2

0.0

265

1.1. COST OF AIRCRAFT SPARES-77PE 3

0.0

Fig. 10--Run 1 sample output (weapon system A):

Variable listing, 1967, F(213)-F(265)

7

Page 41: DOCUMENT RESUME - ERIC · DOCUMENT RESUME ED 050 350 AC 010 343 AUTHOR Boren, H. E., Jr. TITLE The Pilot Training Study: A User's Guide to the Advanced Pilot Computer Cost Model (APT)

a:.

266

267

268

269

270

WEAPON SYSTEM A

(ALL OUTPUT COSTS EXCEPT OPERATING COST PER GRADUATE ARE IN THOUSANDS OF

1.1. COST OF SIMULATOR SPARES

I.I. COST Of TRAINING ECUIP AN1 SPARES 70R STUDENT LOAD INCREASE

1.1. COST OF BASE SUPPORT EQUIPSPARES FOR PERM PARTY INCREASE

I.,. COST OF SUPPLIES FOR PERMANENT PART., INCREASE

I.I. COST OF TRAINING FCR PERMANENT PARTY INCREASE

RAGE

R

90LAARS.1

0.0

0.0

0.0

0-C

0.0

271

1.1. COST OF TRAVEL FOR PERMANENT PARTY INCREASE (PCS)

C.0

272

TOTAL INCREASE IN I.I. COST

0.0

273

OPERATING COST OF DEPOT MAINTENANCE

6435. C2344

274

OPERATING COST OF POL

3672.91357

275

CPERATING COST OF MATERIAL

1651.30566

276

OPERATING COST OF TOTAL FLYING HOURS

11761.23878

277

OPERATING COST OF MUNITIONS-LONG COURSE

1.99000

278

OPERATING COST OF MUNITIONS-SHORT COURSE

1.99000

279

OPERATING COST OF STUDENT PAY

1129.72168

280

OPERATING COST Of RATED OFFICER PAY

2023.29077

281

OPERATING COST OF NONRATrU OFFICER PAY

295.74341

282

OPERATING. COST OF AIRMEN PAY

4494.64063

251

OPERATING COST OF TOTAL PERMANENT PART', MILITARY PAY

6813.67188

254

OPERATING vIsT OF TOTAL MILITARY PAY. INCLUDING STUDENTS

7943.39063

285

OPERATING COST OF CIVILIAN PAY

819.31348

286

OPERATING COST Of TOTAL PAY -- MILITARY PLUS CIVILIANS

8762-70111

287

OPERATING COST OF STUDENT TOY/PCS

199.99998

288

OPERATING COST OF ALL PERMANENT PARTY PERSONNEL TOT

30.14731

289

OPERATING COST OF SERVICES

534.40967

291'

OPERATING COST OF SUPPLIES ANO EQUIPMENT

1061.56689

291

OPERATING COST OF SIMULATOR WIC. MATERIAL. AND SERVICES

9.64384

292

OPERATING COST OF TRAINER RTC. MATERIAL. AND SERVICES

4-00000

291

OPERATING COST OF TARGET RENTAL

0.0

294

OPERATING COST OF SUPPORT AIRCRAFT

19.29559

295

OPERATING COST OF OFFICERS TRAINING

37.C9C65

296

OPERATING COST OF AIRMEN TRAINING

140-45755

297

OPIPSTING COST OF PERMANENT CHANGE OF STATION

537.87813

298

TOTAL OTHER OPERATING COST. INCLUCING RECURRING INVESTMENT

5953.11719

299

TOTAL OPERATING COST. INCLUDING RECUPRING INVESTMENT

26477. C5 eS9

3(.0

OPERATING COST PER GRADUATE (I

66861-25090

3:1

TOTAL SYSTEM COST (INVESTMENT

OPERATING). EXCLUDING R AND

C20477. C5856

301

AIRCRAFT LOST TO ATTRITION --TYPE 1

0.21674

303

AIRCRAFT LOST TO ATTRITION- -TYPE 2

0.0

104

AIRCRAFT LOST TO ATTRITION--TYPE 3

0-0

10S

RECURRING INVESTMENT COST (OPERATING COST)--TYPE 1

3172.29912

306

RECURRING INVESTMENT COST (OPERATING COST)--TYPE 7

0.0

307

RECURRING INVESTMENT COST (OPERATING COSTI- -TYPE

0.0

ma

TOTAL AIRCRAFT RECURRING INVESTMENT COST (OPERATING COST)

3372.29932

309

NOT USED

0.0

37....

NOT USE.)

0.0

Fig. 11--Run -

Sample output (weapon system A):

Variable listing, 1967, F(266)-F(310)

Page 42: DOCUMENT RESUME - ERIC · DOCUMENT RESUME ED 050 350 AC 010 343 AUTHOR Boren, H. E., Jr. TITLE The Pilot Training Study: A User's Guide to the Advanced Pilot Computer Cost Model (APT)

WEAPON SYSTEM

(ALL OUTPUT COSTS EXCEPT OPERATING COST PER GRADUATE ARE IN THOUSANDS OF

OOLLARS.)

PAGE

9

NO.

NO.

NC.

OPER

OPER

AVG

PERM

TYPE

ITYPE

2TYPE 3

NO.

FLYING

OTHER

TOTAL

PLUS

COST PER

NO.

STUD.

PARTY

ACFT

ACFT

ACE!'

SIMS

INV

HOUR

OPER

OPER

INV

GRAD

YEAR

GRAO

LOAO

PEAS

REO

REO

RED

RED

COST

COST

PAY

COST

COST

COST

IS/

1448

356

96

1089

26.18

0.0

0.0

1.55

010585

7919

5365

23870

23870

66975

1969

436

118

1323

A1.99

0.0

0.0

1.89

9770

12937

9606

6541

29084

38855

66769

R AND 0 COST

.0

Fig. 12--Run 1 sample output (weapon system A): standard printout, 1968-1969

Page 43: DOCUMENT RESUME - ERIC · DOCUMENT RESUME ED 050 350 AC 010 343 AUTHOR Boren, H. E., Jr. TITLE The Pilot Training Study: A User's Guide to the Advanced Pilot Computer Cost Model (APT)

WEAPON SYSTEM 8

PAGE 10

(ALL OUTPUT COSTS EXCEPT OPERATING COST PER GRADUATE ARE IN THOUSANDS OF OOLLARS.

NO.

NO.

NO.

OPER

OPER

AVG

PERM

TYPE 1

TYPE 2

TYPE 3

NO.

FLYING

OTNER

TOTAL

PLUS

COST PER

NO.

STUD.

PARTY

ACFT

ACE!

ACFT

SINS

INV

HOUR

OPER

OPER

INV

GRAD

YEAR

GRAD

LOAD

PERS

REO

REO

REQ

REO

COST

COST

PAY

COST

COST

COST

(1)

1947

297

69

601

18.61

0.0

0.0

1.15

03426

4667

2536

10679

10629

35787

1668

267

62

544

16.75

0.0

0.0

1.03

0301.

4228

2289

9600

9600

35915

1969

327

76

657

20.47

0.0

0.0

1.26

159

37')

5106

2783

11657

11816

35682

R AND 0 COST

0

Fig. 13--Run 1 sample output (weapon system B): standard printout, 1967-1969

Page 44: DOCUMENT RESUME - ERIC · DOCUMENT RESUME ED 050 350 AC 010 343 AUTHOR Boren, H. E., Jr. TITLE The Pilot Training Study: A User's Guide to the Advanced Pilot Computer Cost Model (APT)

HEAPON SYSTEM C

PAGE 11

TALL OUTPUT COSTSEXCEPT OPERATING

COST

GRADUATE ARE IN

THOUSANDS OF 001.1.AR5.1

NO.

NO.

NO.

OPER

OPER

AVG

PERM

TYPE 1

TWE 7

TYPE 3

NO.

ELTING

OTHER

TOTAL

PLUS

COST PER

NO.

STUD.

PARTY

ACF7

ACr7

ACFT

SINS

INV

HOUR

OPO

OPER

INV

GRAD

YEAR

GRAD

LOAO

9885

RED

RE0

RIO

REC

COST

COST

pay

COST

COST

COST

1St

1967

177

88

3111

90.61.

I.t8

2.39

1.38

021425

19059

13275

56268

54268

306359

1468

160

79

2807

81.65

1 -.

2.61

1.24

019306

17207

12419

48932

58032

306552

1969

198

96

3416

99.52

1.27

3.18

1.52

45214

23544

2093D

15131

59605

104819

306201

R ARO 0 COST

-0

14--Run 1 sample

output (weaponsystem C):

standard printout,

1967-1969

Page 45: DOCUMENT RESUME - ERIC · DOCUMENT RESUME ED 050 350 AC 010 343 AUTHOR Boren, H. E., Jr. TITLE The Pilot Training Study: A User's Guide to the Advanced Pilot Computer Cost Model (APT)

ADVANCED PILOT TRAINING COST MODEL TEST RUN NO. 2

PAGE

1

WEAPON SYSTEM 0

(ALL OUTPUT COSTS EXCEPT OPERATING COST PER GRADUATE ARE IN THOUSANDS OF DOLLARS.>

ND.

NO.

NO.

OPER

OPER

AVG

PE1M

TYPE 1

TYPE 2

TYPE 3

NO.

FLYING

OTHER

TOTAL

PLUS

COST PER

NO.

STUD.

PARTY

ACFT

ACFT

ACFT

SIMS

INV

HOW(

CPER

OPER

INV

GR913

YEAR

GRAD

LOAD

PERS

RED

RED

PtQ

RED

COST

COST

PAY

COST

COST

COST

181

1967

396

107

2233

29.08

0.0

0.0

1.72

425501.,

14420

41805

51792

51792

130789

1168

356

96

2013

26.18

0.0

0.0

1.55

023011

13011

10632

46654

46654

130902

R AND 0 COST

0

Fig. 15--Run 2 sample output (weapon system D): standard printout, 1967-1968

Page 46: DOCUMENT RESUME - ERIC · DOCUMENT RESUME ED 050 350 AC 010 343 AUTHOR Boren, H. E., Jr. TITLE The Pilot Training Study: A User's Guide to the Advanced Pilot Computer Cost Model (APT)

WEAPON SYSTEM E

(ALL OUTPUT COSTS EXCEPT OPERATING COST PER GRADUATE ARE IN THOUSANDS OF DOLLARS.)

PAGE

2

NO.

NO.

NO.

OPER

OPER

AVG

PERM

TYPE 1

TYPE 2

TYPE 3

NO.

FLYING

OTHER

TOTAL

PLUS

COST PER

NO.

STUD.

PARTY

ACFT

ACFT

ACFT

SINS

INY

HOUR

OPER

OPER

INV

GRAD

YEAR

GRAD

LOAD

PERS

REO

REO

REO

REO

COST

COST

PAY

COST

COST

COST

IS)

1947

1968

1949

297

267

127

69

62 76

911

825

1001

18.61

16.75

20.47

0.0

0.0

0.0

0.0

0.0

0.0

1.15

1.03

1.26

0 0247

6229

5606

6852

6389

5778

7000

4086

3684

4488

.

16704

15068

18340

16704

15068

18587

56242

56371

56137

R ANO D COST

0

Fig. 16--Run 2 sample output (weapon system E):

standard printout, 1967-1969

Page 47: DOCUMENT RESUME - ERIC · DOCUMENT RESUME ED 050 350 AC 010 343 AUTHOR Boren, H. E., Jr. TITLE The Pilot Training Study: A User's Guide to the Advanced Pilot Computer Cost Model (APT)

END OF FINAL RUN -- ALL OATA NAVE BEEN PROCESSED.

Fig. 17--Sample output: end-of-datastatement

Page 48: DOCUMENT RESUME - ERIC · DOCUMENT RESUME ED 050 350 AC 010 343 AUTHOR Boren, H. E., Jr. TITLE The Pilot Training Study: A User's Guide to the Advanced Pilot Computer Cost Model (APT)

-39-

Appendix A

LISTING OF APT COMPUTER PROGRAM VARIABLES

4 7, .

Page 49: DOCUMENT RESUME - ERIC · DOCUMENT RESUME ED 050 350 AC 010 343 AUTHOR Boren, H. E., Jr. TITLE The Pilot Training Study: A User's Guide to the Advanced Pilot Computer Cost Model (APT)

-40-

APT COMPUTER PROGRAM VARIABLES*

INPUT LISTING

WEAPON SYSTEM INPUTS

001 WEAPON SYSTEM NUMBER002 YEAR NUMBER (1., 2., 3., . ETC.)003 ENTERING STUDENTS FROM SIMILAR AIRCRAFT004 ENTERING STUDENTS FROM DISSIMILAR AIRCRAFT005 ENTERING STUDENTS FROM DESK JOBS006 ENTERING STUDENTS FROM UNDERGRADUATE PILOT TRAINING IUPT)007 LENGTH OF LONG COURSE (WEEKS)008 LENGTH OF SHORT COURSE WEEKS/009 FRACTION OF ENTERING STUDENTS WHO GRADUATE--LONG COURSE010 FRACTION OF ENTERING STUDENTS WHO GRADUATESHORT COURSE011 HOURS EACH STUDENT REQUIRED TO FLY--TYPE 1 AIRCRAFT, LONG COURSE012 HOURS EACH STUDENT REQUIRED TO FLY- -TYPE 2 AIRCRAFT, LONG COURSE013 HOURS EACH STUDENT REQUIRED TO FLY- -TYPE 3 AIRCRAFT, LONG COURSE014 HOURS EACH STUDENT REQUIRED TO FLY -TYPE 1, SHORT COURSE015 HOURS EACH STUDENT REQUIRED TO FLT'- -TYPE 2, SHORT COURSE016 HOURS EACH STUDENT REQUIRED TO FLY--TYPE 3, SHORT COURSE017 SIMULATOR HOURS REQUIRED PER STUDENT--LONG COURSE018 SIMULATOR HOURS REQUIRED PER STUDENT--SHORT COURSE019 HOURS STUDENT REQUIRED TO ATTEND GROUND SCHOOL IGS)--LONG COURSE020 HOURS STUDENT REQUIRED TO ATTEND GROUND SCHOOL (GS) -- SHORT COURSE021 AVERAGE NO. STUDENT PILOTS ON STUDENT CREW--TYPE LONG COURSE022 AVERAGE NO. STUDENT PILCTS ON STUDENT CREW--TYPE 2, LONG COURSE023 AVERAGE NO. STUDENT PILCTS ON STUDENT CREW-TYPE 3, LONG COURSE024 AVERAGE NO. STUDENT PILOTS ON STUDENT CREW--TYPE 1, SHORT COURSE025 AVERAGE NO. STUDENT PILCTS ON STUOENT CREW--TYPE 2, SHORT COURSE026 AVERAGE NO. STUDENT PILOTS ON STUDENT CREW--TYPE 3r SHORT COURSE027 HOURS INSTRUCTOR FLIES WITH EACH STUDENT-TYPE 1, LONG COURSE028 HOURS INSTRUCTOR FLIES WITH EACH STUDENT--TYPE 2, LONG COURSE029 HOURS INSTRUCTOR FLIES WITH EACH STUDENT--TYPE 3, LUNG COURSE030 HOURS INSTRUCTOR FLIES WITH EACH STUDENT--TYPE 1, SHORT COURSE031 HOURS INSTRUCTOR FLIES MITE EACH STUDENT- -TYPE 2, SHORT COURSE032 HOURS INSTRUCTOR FLIES WITH EACH STUDENT--TYPE 3, SHORT COURSE033 MAXIMUM HOURS PER YEAR INSTRUCTOR FLIES WITH STUDENTSP34 MAXIMUM SIMULATOR HOURS PER YEAR INSTRUCTOR SUPERVISES035 MAXIMUM TRAINER HOURS PER YEAR INSTRUCTOR SUPERVISES036 MAXIMUM GS HOURS PER YEAR CCTS INSTRUCTOR TEACHES037 MAXIMUM GS HOURS PER YEAR FTD INSTRUCTOR TEACHES038 AVG NO. STUDENT PILOTS CN SIMULATOR AT ONE TIME039 AVG NO. STUDENT PILOTS IN GS CLASSROOM AT ONE T'ME--LONG COURSECAO AVG NO. STUDENT PILOTS IN GS CLASSROOM AT ONE LIME- -SHORT COURSE

-..041 TRAINER HOURS REQUIRED PER STUDENT--LONG COURSE042 TRAINER HOURS REQUIRED PER STUDENT--SHORT COURSE043 FRACTION OF GS HOURS TAUGHT BY CCTS INSTRUCTORS--LONG COURSE044 FRACTION OF GS HOURS TAUGHT BY CCTS INSTRUCTORS--SHORT COURSE

* SEE ABBREVIATIONS LISTING ON LAST PAGE OF THIS APPENDIX.

48,

Page 50: DOCUMENT RESUME - ERIC · DOCUMENT RESUME ED 050 350 AC 010 343 AUTHOR Boren, H. E., Jr. TITLE The Pilot Training Study: A User's Guide to the Advanced Pilot Computer Cost Model (APT)

-41-

045 AIRCRAFT ATTRITION PER 100000 FLYING HOURS--TYPE 1046 AIRCRAFT ATTRITION PER 100000 FLYING HOURS--TYPE 2 (SEE 1441047 OTHER FH CHARGED TO CREW, TRNG (FRACT. STUD.+SEP. INST. FH)--TYPE 104B OTHER FH CHARGED TO CREW TRAINING (FRACTION STUDENT FH)--TYPE 2049 OTHER FH CHARGED TO CREW TRAINING (FRACTION STUDENT FH)--TYPE 3050 FRACTION OF TOTAL FH OR COST ALLOCATED TO PILOT TRAINING--TYPE 1051 FRACTION OF TOTAL FH OR COST ALLOCATED TO PILOT TRAINING--TYPE 2053 TRAINING HOURS AVAILABLE PER YEAR ON ONE SIMULATOR054 TRAINING HOURS AVAILABLE PEP. YEAR ON ONE TRAINER052 FRACTION OF TOTAL FH OR COST ALLOCATED TO PILOT TRAINING- -TYPE 3055 AVAILABLE FLYING HOURS PER YEAR--TYPE 1056 AVAILABLE FLYING HOURS PER YEAR--TYPE 2057 AVAILABLE FLYING HOURS PER YEAR--TYPE 3058 AIRCRAFT AVAILABLE AT BEGINNING OF FIRST YEAR--TYPE 1059 AIRCRAFT AVAILABLE AT BEGINNING OF FIRST YEAR--TYPE 2661 SIMULATORS AVAILABLE AT BEGINNING OF FIRST YEAR060 AIRCRAFT AVAILABLE AT BEGINNING OF FIRST YEAR--TYPE 3062 TRAINERS AVAILABLE AT BEGINNING OF FIRST YEAR063 FIXED NUMBER OF INSTRUCTOR-SUPERV+ADMIN-SQDN LEVEL064 VARIABLE NUMBER OF INSTRUCTOR-SUPERV*ADMIN (PER INST.)--SQDN LEVEL065 FIXED NUMBER OF ACAOEMIC-PROGRAM SUPERVISORS--SQUADRON LEVEL066 VARIABLE NO. ACAD-PROG SUPERV, PER STUD. IN STUD. LOAD -SQDN LEVEL067 TOTAL STANDARD-EVALUATICN PERSONNEL REQUIRED068 AIRCRAFT MAINTENANCE PERSONNEL REQUIRED PER FLYING E'-RJR-TYPE 1

069 AIRCRAFT MAINTENANCE PERSONNEL REQUIRED PER FLYING HOUR - -TYPE 2070 AIRCRAFT MAINTENANCF PERSONNEL REQUIRED PER FLYING HOUR--TYPE 3071 SIMULATOR OPER+MTC PERS AUTHORIZED PER SIKULATOR OR PER SIM HOUR072 TRAINER OPER+MTC PERS AUTHORIZED PER TRAINER073 FIXED NUMBER OF ADMINISTRATIVE PERSONNEL--WING LEVEL074 VARIABLE NO. ADMIN PERS- -WING LEVEL IPER OPER+MTC PERSONNEL)075 FIXED NUMBER OF SUPPORT PERSONNEL076 VARIABLE NO. SUPPORT PERS (PER TOTAL STUDENT LOAD+OPER+MTC+ADMIN)077 FRACTION OF GS CCTS INSTRUCTORS WHO ARE OFFICERS078 FRACTION OF GS CCTS INSTRUCTORS WHO ARE AIRMEN079 FRACTION OF GS FTD INSTRUCTORS WHO ARE OFFICERS080 FRACTION OF GS FTD INSTRUCTORS WHO ARE AIRMEN081 FRACTION OF INSTRUCTOR SUPERV+ADMIN (SQDN LEVEL) WHO ARE OFFICERS082 FRACTION OF INSTRUCTOR-SUPERV+ADMIN (SQDN LEVEL) WHO ARE AIRMEN083 FRACTION OF ACRD-PROGRM SUPERV+ADMIN (SQDN LEVEL) WHO ARE OFFICERS084 FRACTION OF ACAD-PROGRM SUPERV+ADMIN (SOON LEVEL) WHO ARE AIRMEN085 FRACTION OF AIRCRAFT MTC PERSONNEL WHO ARE OFFICERS086 FRACTION OF AIRCRAFT MTC PERSONNEL WHO ARE AIRMEN087 FRACTION OF SIMULATOR AND TRAINER MTC +OPER PERS WHO ARE OFFICERS088 FRACTION OF SIMULATOR AND TRAINER MTC+OPER PERS WHO ARE AIRMEN .

089 FRACTION OF ADMIN PERSONNEL (WING LEVEL) WHO ARE OFFICERS090 FRACTION OF ADMIN PERSONNEL (WING LEVEL) WHO ARE AIRMEN091 FRACTION OF SUPPORT PERSONNEL WHO ARE OFFICERS092 FRACTION OF SUPPORT PERSONNEL WHO ARE AIRMEN093 FRACTION OF OFFICERS WHO ARE RATED094 MIN INCREASE IN STUDENT LOAD BEFORE I.I. TRNG EQUIP+SPARES JUSTIF.095* 1.1. COST PER AIRCRAFT --TYPE 1096 I.I. COST PER AIRCRAFT--TYPE 2

* ALL COSTS (INPUT AND OUTPUT) ARE IN THOUSANDS OF DOLLARS EXCEPT THOSEDENOTED BY 1$1.

49

Page 51: DOCUMENT RESUME - ERIC · DOCUMENT RESUME ED 050 350 AC 010 343 AUTHOR Boren, H. E., Jr. TITLE The Pilot Training Study: A User's Guide to the Advanced Pilot Computer Cost Model (APT)

-42-

097 I.I. COST PER AIRCRAFT--TYPE 3098 I.I. COST PER SIMULATOR099 I.I. COST PER TRAINER100 FRACTION OF 1.I. SIMULATOR COST FOR SIMULATOR SPARES COST101 1.1. COST FOR TRNG EQUIP+SPARES PEP INCREASE IN STUDENT LOAD (S)102 OPERATING COST PER FLYING HOUR FOR DEPOT MTC--TYPE 1 (S)103 OPERATING COST PER FLYING HOUR FOR DEPOT MTC- -TYPE 2 (S)104 OPERATING COST PER FLYING HOUR FOR DEPOT MTC--TYPE 3 IS)105 OPERATING COST PER FLYING HOUR FOR POD- -TYPE 1 (S)106 OPERATING COST PER FLYING HOUR FOR POL--TYPE 2 (S)107 OPERATING COST PER FLYING HOUR FOR POD- -TYPE 3 (S)108 OPERATING COST PER FLYING HOUR FOR MATERIAL- -TYPE 1 IS)109 OPERATING COST PER FLYING HOUR FOR MATERIAL--TYPE 2 Is)110 OPERATING COST PER FLYING HOUR FOR MATERIAL--TYPE 3 IS)111 OPERATING COST PER STUDENT FOR MUNITIONS- -LONG COURSE ($1112 OPERATING COST PER STUDENT FOR MUNITIONS- -SHORT COURSE ($)113 OPERATING COST PER STUDENT FOR AVERAGE TOY/PCS IS)114 OPERATING COST PER SIM PER YR FOR SIM MTC--MATERIAL, SERVICES115 OPERATING COST PER YEAR FOR TARGET RENTAL116 R AND 0 COST117 DUMP PRINTOUT DESIGNATOR (0./1.--DO NOT/DO PRINT DUMP)118 ZERO-OUTPUT DESIGNATOR (0./1.--DO NOT/00 ZERO OUTPUT EXCEPT GRADS)119 CLEAR DESIGNATOR (0./1.--DO NOT/DO ZERO OUT ALL F VARIABLES120 WEAPON SYSTEM VARIABLE-LISTING PRINT DESIGNATOR

CONSTANT INPUTS

121 BEGINNING YEAR tE.G., 1969)122 MIN INCREASE IN PERM PARTY BEFORE I.1. EQUIP+SUPPLIES JUSTIFIED123 I.I. COST FOR BASE SUPPORT EQUIP+SPARES PER PERM PARTY INCREASEISI124 I.I. COST FOR BASE SUPPLY INVENTORY PER PERM PARTY INCREASE IS)125 1.1. COST FOR PERM-PARTY-INCREASE TRAINING OFF BASE IS)126 1.1. COST FOR PERM-PARTY-INCREASE TRAVEL IS)127 OPER. COST PER YEAR FOR AVG PAY OF STUDENT (S)128 OPER. COST PER YEAR FOR AVG PAY OF PERM PARTY RATED OFFICER IS)129 OPER. COST PER YEAR FOR AVG PAY OF PERM PARTY NONRATED OFFICER IS/130 00ER. COST PER YEAR FOR AVG PAY OF PERM PARTY AIRMAN IS)131 OPER. COST PER YEAR FOR AVG PAY OF CIVILIAN IS)132 OPER. COST PER YEAR FOR AVG TDY OF PERM PARTY (S)133 OPER. COST PER YEAR FOR SERVICES--AVG PER PERSON ON BASE (S)134 OPER. COST PER YEAR FOR SUPPLIES+EQUIP PER PERSON ON BASE IS)135* FRACTION OF SIMULATOR HOURS OR COSTS ALLOCATED TO PILOT TRAINING136 OPER. COST PER YEAR FOR SUPPORT ACTT- -AVG PER PERSOt! ON BASE IS)137 OPER. COST PER YEAR FOR PERM PARTY OFFICER TRAINING OFF BASE (SI138 OPER. COST PER YEAR FOR PERM PARTY AIRMAN TRAINING OFF BASE (S)139 OPER. COST PER YEAR FOR AVERAGE PCS PER PERM PARTY PERSON (S)140 FRACTION OF I.I. AIRCRAFT COST FOR AIRCRAFT SPARES COST141 VARIABLE-LISTING READ DESIGNATOR 10./1.-00 NOT/DO READ VARIABLES)142* INSTRUCTOR LEAD/TOW FLYING HOURS PER STUDENT--TYPE 1, LONG COURSE143* INSTR:CTOR LEAD/TOW FLYING HOURS PER STUDENT--TYPE 1, SHORT C0,2RSE144* AIRCRAFT ATTRITION PER 100000 FLYING HOURS--TYPE 3 (SEE 045, 046)145* OPER. COST PER YEAR FOR TRAINER MTC PER TRNR--MATERIAL SERVICES

* WEAPON SYSTEM INPUT. SEE ALSO ADDRESSES 217, 218, AND 219.

rn

Page 52: DOCUMENT RESUME - ERIC · DOCUMENT RESUME ED 050 350 AC 010 343 AUTHOR Boren, H. E., Jr. TITLE The Pilot Training Study: A User's Guide to the Advanced Pilot Computer Cost Model (APT)

-43-

CUTPUT LISTING

INTERNAL COUNTERS

146 PAGE NUMBER147 YEAR COUNTER148 END -OF -DATA DESIGNATOR149 PASS COUNTER

CURRENT YEAR PLUS STUDENT AND GRADUATE TOTALS

150 CURRENT YEAR151 TOTAL ENTERING STUDENTS152 TOTAL ENTERING STUDENTS - -LONG COURSE153 TOTAL ENTERING STUDENTS - -SHORT COURSE154 TOTAL GRADUATES- -LONG CCURSE155 TOTAL GRADUATES- -SHORT COURSE156 TOTAL. GRADUATES157 AVERAGE NUMBER OF STUDENTS PER YEAR - -LONG COURSEL58 AVERAGE NUMBER OF STUDENTS PER YEAR- -SHORT COURSEL59 AVERAGE STUDENT LOAD FOR LONG COURSE160 AVERAGE STUDENT LOAD FOR SHORT COURSE161 TOTAL AVERAGE STUDENT LOAD

TRAINING HOURS

162 TOTAL STUD NT FLYING HOURS- -TYPE 1, LONG COURSE163 TOTAL STUDENT FLYING HOURS- -TYPE 2, LONG COURSE164 TOTAL STUDENT FLYING HOURS- -TYPE 3, LONG COURSE165 TOTAL STUDENT FLYING HOURS- -TYPE 1, SHORT COURSE166 TOTAL STUDENT FLYING HOURS- -TYPE 2, SHORT COURSE167 TOTAL STUDENT FLYING HOURS- -TYPE 3, SHORT COURSE168 TOTAL STUDENT FLYING HOURS- -TYPE 1169 TOTAL STUDENT FLYING HOURS- -TYPE 2170 TOTAL STUDENT FLYING HOURS- -TYPE 3171 INSTRUCTOR FH PER STUDENT- -ALL AIRCRAFT TYPES, LONG COURSE172 INSTRUCTOR FH PER STUDENT --ALL AIRCRAFT TYPES, SHORT COURSE173 TOTAL HOURS INSTRUCTOR FLIES WITH STUDENTS- -LONG COURSE174 TOTAL HOURS INSTRUCTOR FLIES WITH STUDENTS- -SHORT COURSE175 TOTAL HOURS INSTRUCTOR FLIES WITH STUDENTS176 TOTAL STUDENT SIMULATOR HOURS- -LONG COURSE177 TOTAL STUDENT SIMULATOR HOURS- -SHORT COURSE178 TOTAL STUDENT SIMULATOR HOURS179 TOTAL STUDENT TRAINER HOURS- -LONG COURSE180 TOTAL STUDENT TRAINER HCURS- -SHORT COURSE181 TOTAL STUDENT TRAINER HCURS182 TOTAL GROUND- SCHOOL CLASSROOM HOURS --LONG COURSE183 TOTAL GROUND - SCHOOL CLASSROOM HOURSSHORT COURSE184 TOTAL GROUND - SCHOOL CLASSROOM HOURS185 TOTAL GS CLASSROOM HOURS TAUGHT BY CCTS INSTRUCTORS- -LONG COURSE186 IOTAL GS CLASSROOM HOURS TAUGHT BY CCTS INSTRUCTORS - -SHORT COURSE187 TOTAL GS CLASSROOM HOURS TAUGHT BY CCTS INSTRUCTORS188 TOTAL GS CLASSROOM HOURS TAUGHT BY FTD INSTRUCTORS - -LONG COURSE

5i

Page 53: DOCUMENT RESUME - ERIC · DOCUMENT RESUME ED 050 350 AC 010 343 AUTHOR Boren, H. E., Jr. TITLE The Pilot Training Study: A User's Guide to the Advanced Pilot Computer Cost Model (APT)

-44-

189 TOTAL GS CLASSROOM HOURS TAUGHT BY ETD INSTRUCTORS--SHORT COURSE190 TOTAL GS CLASSROOM HOURS TAUGHT BY ETD INSTRUCTORS191 OTHER FLYING HOURS--TYPE 1192 OTHER FLYING HOURS--TYPE 21°3 OTHER FLYING HOURS--TYPE 3194 TOTAL FLYING HOURS-TYPE I195 TOTAL FLYING HOURS.--TYPE 2196 TOTAL FLYING HOURS--TYPE 3197 FLYING HOURS CHARGED TO PILOT TRAINING - -TYPE 1198 FLYING HOURS CHARGED TO PILOT (RAINLNG--TYPE 2199 FLYING HOURS CHARGED TO PILOT TRAINING - -TYPE 3

EQUIPMENT REQUIREMENTS

200 CURRENT INVENTORY--TYPE 1201 CURRENT INVENTORY--TYPE 2202 CURRENT INVENTORY- -TYPE 3203 CURRENT INVENTORY--SIMULATORS204 CURRENT INVENTORY--TRAINERS205 AIRCRAFT REQUIRED--TYPE 1

206 AIRCRAFT REQUIRED - -TYPE 2207 AIRCRAFT REQUIRED-TYPE 3208 SIMULATORS REQUIRED209 TRAINERS REQUIRED210 AIRCRAFT TO BE PROCURED- -TYPE 1

211 AIRCRAFT TO BE PROCURED- -TYPE 221,2 AIRCRAFT TO BE PROCURED- -TYPE 3213 SIMULATORS TO BE PROCURED214 TRAINERS TO BE PROCURED215 TOTAL INSTRUCTOR LEAD/TOW FLYING HOURS--TYPE 1, LONG COURSE216 TOTAL INSTRUCTOR LEAD/TOW FLYING HOURS--TYPL 1, SHORT COURSE217 RECURRING INVESTMENT COST FACTOR--TYPE 1 !WEAPON SYSTEM INPUT)21B RECURRING INVESTMENT COST FACTOR- -TYPE 2 (WEAPON SYSTEM INPUT)219 RECURRING INVESTMENT COST FACTOR--TYPE 3 (WEAPON SYSTEM INPUT)220 SIMULATOR HOURS CHARGED TO PILOT TRAINING

PERSONNEL REQUIREMENTS

221 TOTAL FLYING INSTRUCTORS REQUIRED222 TOTAL SIMULATOR INSTRUCTORS REQUIRED223 TOTAL TRAINER INSTRUCTORS REQUIRED224 TOTAL GROUND- SCHOOL CCTS INSTRUCTORS REQUIRED225 TOTAL GROUND - SCHOOL FTD INSTRUCTORS REQUIRED226 TOTAL INSTRUCTORS REQUIRED227 TOTAL INSTRUCTOR SUPERVISORS ANN ADMIN PERS REQUIRED--SODN LEVEL228 TOTAL ACAD-PROGRAM SUPERVISORt; AND ADMIN PERS REQUIRED-SOON LEVEL229 TOTAL STANDARD-EVALUATICN PERSONNEL REQUIRED230 TOTAL NONSTUDENT OPERATIONS PERSONNEL231 TOTAL AIRCRAFT MAINTENANCE PERSONNEL- -TYPE I232 rum. AIRCRAFT MAINTENANCE PERSONNEL --TYPE 2213 TOTAL AIRCRAFT MAINTENANCE PERSONNEL--TYPE 3234 TOTAL AIRCRAFT MAINTENANCE PERSONNEL235 TOTAL SIMULATOR MAINTENANCE AND OPERATING PERSONNEL236 TOTAL TRAINER MAINTENANCE AND OPERATING PERSONNEL

Page 54: DOCUMENT RESUME - ERIC · DOCUMENT RESUME ED 050 350 AC 010 343 AUTHOR Boren, H. E., Jr. TITLE The Pilot Training Study: A User's Guide to the Advanced Pilot Computer Cost Model (APT)

-45-

237 TOTAL SIMULATOR AND TRAINER MAINTENANCE AND OPERATING PERSONNEL238 TOTAL OPERATIONS AND MAINTENANCE PERSONNEL239 TOTAL ADMINISTRATIVE PERSONNEL (WING LEVEL)240 TOTAL STUDENT LOAD + OPERATIONS + MTC + ADMINISTRATIVE PERSONNEL241 TOTAL SUPPORT PERSONNEL242 TOTAL PERSONNEL CHARGED TO PILOT TRAINING, INCLUDING STUDENTS243 TOTAL PERMANENT PARTY PERSONNEL244 TOTAL PERMANENT PARTY OFFICERS245 TOTAL PERMANENT PARTY AIRMEN246 TOTAL PERMANENT PARTY MILITARY PERSONNEL247 TOTAL CIVILIANS248 TOTAL PERMANENT PARTY RATED OFFICERS249 TOTAL PERMANENT PARTY NCNRATED OFFICERS250 CHANGE IN STUOENT LOAD251 CHANGE IN TOTAL PERSONNEL, INCLUDING STUDENTS252 CHANGE IN TOTAL PERMANENT PARTY PERSONNEL253 CHANGE IN TOTAL PERMANENT PARTY MILITARY PERSONNEL254 CHANGE IN PERM. PARTY LESS CHANGE DUE TO ALLOC. FRACTION VARIATION255 ADJUSTMENT TO ELIM. EFFECT ON I.I. COST OF CHANGE IN ALLOC. FRACT.256 CUMULATIVE CHANGE IN STUDENT LOAD UNTIL THRESHOLD IS REACHEO257 CUMULATIVE CHANGE IN ADJ. PERM PARTY UNTIL THRESHOLD IS REACHEO

INITIAL INVESTMENT COSTS (THOUSANDS OF DOLLARS)

258 1.1. COS( OF AIRCRAFT TC BE PROCURED--TYPE 1259 1.1. COST OF AIRCRAFT TC BE PROCURED--TYPE 2260 1.1. COST OF AIRCRAFT TO BE PROCURED - -TYPE 3261 1.1. COST OF SIMULATORS TO BE PROCURED262 I.I. COST OF TRAINERS TC BE PROCURED263 1.1. COST OF AIRCRAFT SPARES--TYPE 1

264 1.I. COST OF AIRCRAFT SPARES--TYPE 2265 1.1. COST OF AIRCRAFT SPARES--TYPE 3266 I.I. COST OF SIMULATOR SPARES267 I.I. COST OF TRAINING EQUIP AND SPARES FOR STUDENT LOAD INCREASE268 I.I. COST OF BASE SUPPORT EQUIP+SPARES FOR PERM PARTY INCREASE269 1.1. COST OF SUPPLIES FCR PERMANENT PARTY INCREASE270 1.1. COST OF TRAINING FCR PERMANENT PARTY INCREASE271 1.1. COST OF TRAVEL FOR PERMANENT PARTY INCREASE (PCS)272 TOTAL INCREASE IN 1.1. COST

OPERATING COSTS AND TOTAL SYSTEM COST ITHOUSANOS OF DOLLARS)

273 OPERATING COST OF OEPOT MAINTENANCE274 OPERATING COST OF POL275 OPERATING COST OF MATERIAL276 OPERATING COST OF TOTAL FLYING HOURS277 OPERATING COST OF MUNITIONS--LONG COURSE27£ OPERATING COST OF MUNITIONS - -SHORT COURSE279 OPERATING COST OF STUDENT PAY280 OPERATING COST OF RATED OiFICER PAY281 OPERATING COST OF NONRATEO OFFICER PAY282 OPERATING COST OF AIRMEN PAY283 OPERATING COST OF TOTAL PERMANENT PARTY ;ILITARY PAY284 OPERATING COST OF TOTAL MILITARY PAY, INCLUDING STUDENTS

13

Page 55: DOCUMENT RESUME - ERIC · DOCUMENT RESUME ED 050 350 AC 010 343 AUTHOR Boren, H. E., Jr. TITLE The Pilot Training Study: A User's Guide to the Advanced Pilot Computer Cost Model (APT)

-46-

285 OPERATING COST OF CIVILIAN PAY286 OPERATING COST OF TOTAL PAY -- MILITARY PLUS CIVILIANS287 OPERATING COST OF STUDENT TOY/PO288 OPERATING COST (IF ALL PERMANENT PARTY PERSONNEL TOY289 OPERATING COST OF SERVICES290 OPERATP.G COST OF SUPPLIES AND EQUIPMENT291 OPERATING COST OF SIMULATOR MTC, MATERIAL, AND SERVICES292 OPERATING COST Oi TRAINER MTC, MATERIAL, ANO SERVICES293 OPERATING COST OF TARGET RENTAL294 OPERATING COST OF SUPPORT AIRCRAFT295 OPERATING COST OF OFFICERS TRAINING296 OPERATING COST OF AIRMEN TRAINING297 01"-.RATING COST OF PERMANENT CHANGE OF STATION298 TOTAL OTHER OPERATING GCS'', INCLUDING RECURRING INVESTMENT299 TOTAL OPERATING COST, INCLUDING RECURRING INVESTMENT300 OPERATING COST PER GRADUATE (S)301 TOTAL SYSTEM COST (INVESTMENT + OPERATING), EXCLUDING R AND 0302 AIRCRAFT LOST TO ATTRITION- -TYPE I303 AIRCRAFT LOST TO ATTRITION-TYPE 2304 AIRCRAFT LOST TO ATTRITION-TiPE 3305 RECURRING INVESTMENT COST (OPERATING COST(- -TYPE I

306 RECURRING INVESTMENT COST (OPERATING COST(- -TYPE 2307 RECURRING INVESTMENT COST (OPERATING COST)--TYPE 3308 TOTAL AIRCRAFT RECURRING INVESTMENT COST (OPERATING COST)309 NOT USED310 NOT USED

54

Page 56: DOCUMENT RESUME - ERIC · DOCUMENT RESUME ED 050 350 AC 010 343 AUTHOR Boren, H. E., Jr. TITLE The Pilot Training Study: A User's Guide to the Advanced Pilot Computer Cost Model (APT)

-47-

ABBREVIATIONS LISTING

ACAD ACADEMICACFT AIRCRAFTADMIN ADMINISTRATIVEADJ. ADJUSTEDALLOC. ALLOCATIONAVG AVERAGECCTS COMBAT CREW TRAINING SCHOOLIS)ELIM. ELIMINATEEQUIP EQUIPMENTFH FLYING HOURIS)FRACT. FRACTIONFTD FIELD TRAINING DETACHMENTGS GROUND SCHCOLINST. INSTRUCTOR(SI

INITIAL INVESTMENTJUSTIF. JUSTIFIEDMIN MINIMUMMTC MAINTENANCENO. NUMBEROPER. OPERATINGPCS PERMANENT CHANGE OF STATIONPERM PERMANENTPERS PERSONNELPOL PETROLEUM-OIL-LUBRICANTSPROG PROGRAMR AND 0 RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENTSEP. SEPARATESIM SIMULATOR(SIWON SQUADRONSTUD. STUDENTIS)SUPERV SUPERVISORIS)TOY TEMPORARY DUTYTRNG TRAININGTRNR TRAINERIS)UPT UNDERGRADUATE PILOT TRAINING

55

Page 57: DOCUMENT RESUME - ERIC · DOCUMENT RESUME ED 050 350 AC 010 343 AUTHOR Boren, H. E., Jr. TITLE The Pilot Training Study: A User's Guide to the Advanced Pilot Computer Cost Model (APT)

-49-

Appendix 13

FLOW CHARTS OF APT COMPUTER PROGRAM

56

Page 58: DOCUMENT RESUME - ERIC · DOCUMENT RESUME ED 050 350 AC 010 343 AUTHOR Boren, H. E., Jr. TITLE The Pilot Training Study: A User's Guide to the Advanced Pilot Computer Cost Model (APT)

START

1 =1

CLEAR ALL INPUTVARIABLES IN COMMON

F (t) = D.

SET RECURRING INVESTMENTCOST FACTOKS TO ZERO.

F (217) = 0.F(218) =0.F (219) = 0.

SET VARIABLE LISTINGREAD INDEX TO ZERO.

101 =0

1 +=1j

SET VARIABLE-LISTINGSELECTION

DESIGNATORS TO ZERO.ID (1) = 0.

MM.

SET PAGE NUMBER TO I.!PAGE = I

SET PASS COUNTER TO

(149 ) 0.

REAP TITLE CARD FOR RUN)( WTITLE . = 1,20)

50

K = 1

If both the Faddress andValue are Zero,510;:: to the nextpair of fields,

PRINT ERROR

MESSAGE,INCLUDINGVALUE OF I.

CALL EXITSET 1 EQUAL TO FADDRESS READ IN.

1 =I1(K)

STORE F1(K) VALUEAS (1).(I), Fl (K)

K=K 1 Yes

READ EIGHT PAIRS OF FADDRESSES (SUBSCRIPTS)AND F VALUES AS 11 I K )

AND Fl (K).(11 (K), II IKI, K' LB)

Reod

constantirp rf

(octal.E (121 ) ...Fless F(135).

Note

0

IEND

(I) Circled numbers ore continuation points forwordin the progroo. Circled letfers ore continual ;onpOIMISLoavoo,:11 in the prorarn.

(2) Multiplication signs me represented Ely cnterrsLs ('I.(3) All symbols ore in FORTRAN notation. forA

clori ficorion, scene dixislons ore shown osfor i.orros, 'other than All.

MAIN ROUTINE

57".

Page 59: DOCUMENT RESUME - ERIC · DOCUMENT RESUME ED 050 350 AC 010 343 AUTHOR Boren, H. E., Jr. TITLE The Pilot Training Study: A User's Guide to the Advanced Pilot Computer Cost Model (APT)

-51-

0PRINT TITLE AND PAGENUMBER ON NEW PAGE.

(TITLE(!), I= , 20), PAGE

SET PAGE NUMBER TO 2F (1461 2.

Check vorloble-listingrecd indicator..

0

Yes

READ IN ADDRESSES ANDNAMES OF ALL F

VARIABLES IN COMMON1, (NAMES (I, ), J = 1, 17)

3M?

Yes

SET VARIABLE LISTINGREAD INDEX TO I .

ID? = I

203

[ SET ZERO-OUTPUTDESIGNATOR TO ZERO.

F 0181 =O.

SET YEAR COUNTERTO ZERO.

F(147) s

(READ WEAPON SYSTEMNUMBER AND NAME

\.1W, (NAME (1), I= 1,10)

STORE VALUE OF WEAPONSYSTEM NUMBER AS F(001).

F (001

i) = IW

O151

SET ALL OUTPUT F VARIABLESIN COMMON TO ZERO.(EXCEPT EQUIPMENT

INVENTORIES)F(1). 0.

STORE VALUES OF AIRCRAFTRECURRING INVESTMENTCOST FACTORS (INPUTS)

TEMPI = F (217)TEMP2 = F (218)TEMP3 = F (219)

F(700)... F(204)

SET CURRENT EQUIPMENTore equipmentinventoi1es.

1 = 205

INVENTORIES TO ZERO.F (1) = 0.

1 < 204?Yes.

I '1

MAIN ROUTINE (CONTINUED)

58

Page 60: DOCUMENT RESUME - ERIC · DOCUMENT RESUME ED 050 350 AC 010 343 AUTHOR Boren, H. E., Jr. TITLE The Pilot Training Study: A User's Guide to the Advanced Pilot Computer Cost Model (APT)

-52-

RESTORE VALUES OF AIRCRAFTRECURRING IN"iSTMENT

COST FACTORSF (217) = TEMPIF (218) = TEMP 2F(219)= TEMP3

SET VARIAB E-LISTINGPRINT DESIGNATOR

TO ZERO.F(120) =0.

STEP YEAR COUNTER BY I i.F (147) = F (147) + I .

Pon countercourts marker ---o / posses mode STEP PASS COUNTER BY 1.through F (149) = F (149) + I.progror forone run.

CALL SUBROUTINE READ(READS INPUT DATA BY

WEAPON SYSTEM)

CALL SUBROUTINE EQUIP(CALCULATES TRAININGHOURS AND EQUIPMENT

REQUIREMENTS)

Checktero-outputdesignator.

Yes

No

CALL SUBROUTINE PERS(DETERMINES PERSONNEL

REQUIREMENTS)

CALL SUBROUTINE I NCO(CALCULATES INVESTMENT

COSTS)

CALL SUBROUTINE 0".<0(CALCULATES OPERATING

COSTS)

CALL OUTPUT(PRINTS OUTPUT'

FIX END-OF-DATADESIGNATOR

IND F ( 48) + 0.5

PRINT TERMINATIONSTATEMENT IF ALL DATAHAVE BEEN PROCESSED.

CALL EXIT

MAIN ROUTINE (CONTINUED)

59

Page 61: DOCUMENT RESUME - ERIC · DOCUMENT RESUME ED 050 350 AC 010 343 AUTHOR Boren, H. E., Jr. TITLE The Pilot Training Study: A User's Guide to the Advanced Pilot Computer Cost Model (APT)

START

SET INDEX 1 TO ZERO,1 =0

READ EIGH I PAIRS OF FADDRESSES (SUBSCPIPTS) 1AND F VALUES AS 1 1 ( K )

AND F (K ).(WEAPON SYSTEM INPUT DATA1 (11 (K), fl (K), K = 1,8)

K =1

II both the Faddress and

Yes F value arezero, skip tothe next poirof fields.

SET 1 EQUAL TO FADDRESS READ IN.

1.11(K)

STORE Fl (K) VALUEAS (1)?

F (I) = Fl (K)

[th4-11 Yes

-53-

PRINT ERROR

MESSAGE,INCLUDINGVALUE OF 1.

CALL EXIT

END

II (K) /666AND

II (K)/ 777AND

II (K )/889AND

11 (K1/999?

No

CURRENT YEAR (BEGINNINGYEAR r YEAR NUMBER - 1.0)

F (150)- F (i21) F (002) - 1.0

END-OF-DATA DESIGNATORF (148)- (II (K) 500)/100

Checkvariable-listingdesignator.

Yes

READ FIRST 80 VARIABLE-LISTINSELECTION DESIGNATORS,

SHOWING WHICH F-VARIABLENAMES AND VALUES ARE TO

BE LISTED.\,... (0--DO NOT UST; 1 --LIST))

(ID (n, I =1,80)

(AIL F-variablenames and valuesare to be listedlater in Sub-routine Output)

SET ALL VARIABLE-LISTINGSELECTION DESIGNATORS TO 1.

ID (I) = I

(READ REMAININ G 230 \VARIABLE- LISTING

SELECTION DESIGNATORS(ID (0, I = 81,310) ,

SUBROUTINE READ

rn :)'

Page 62: DOCUMENT RESUME - ERIC · DOCUMENT RESUME ED 050 350 AC 010 343 AUTHOR Boren, H. E., Jr. TITLE The Pilot Training Study: A User's Guide to the Advanced Pilot Computer Cost Model (APT)

START

TOTAL NUM,BE OF ENTERINGSTUDENTS

F (151)- F (0031+ F 004 )F (005)- F (006)

NUMBER 0 ENTERINGSTUDENTS IN LONG

COURSE

F(1.52)- F(I.T1)- F(003)

NUMBER OF ENTERINGSTUDENTS IN SHORT

COURSE

F (153) F (003)

[

0F(I.153)=FH.8). F(1+151)]

NUMBER OF GRADL14.TES

I1=1 Long courseI =1 -- Short course

Yes F(118)=1.0?

0

Cheer ..ro-output.designator.

AVERAGE NUMBER OFSTUDENTS PER FEAR

F (1+ 156)- 0.5 (F (1+151)-T ES 153))

AVERAGE STUDENT LOADS

F(I. 158) F(1+ 156)F(1+ e)52.0

-54-

Yes

LE (I + 170) 0.

J 1

K -3.1-J

T(K17) 0.?

0

--Ai.craft types1,2,3,respectively

CFeckdivisors

STUDENT FLYING HOURS

158)F(K. F(/ . 156) F(K 7)F(K . 17)

INSTRUCTOR FLYING HOURS PERSTUDENT

F(I. 170)=F(1+170)F( K 2')F[K 17)

LNUMBER OF HOURS INSTRUCTORFLIES WITH STUDENTS

F(1+172)4(1+ 1561FEI- 1701

TOTAL INSTRUCTOR FLYINGHOURS IN LEAD'TOW AIRCRAFT

TYP I

F(I 114)--F(I IS6)F(1. 1411

SUBROUTINE EQUIP

61

Page 63: DOCUMENT RESUME - ERIC · DOCUMENT RESUME ED 050 350 AC 010 343 AUTHOR Boren, H. E., Jr. TITLE The Pilot Training Study: A User's Guide to the Advanced Pilot Computer Cost Model (APT)

Chrcl. ..."-TFdl visor

rSTUDENT TRAIN : :725

1

l.F i 178)- F(I.1.):CiT(I 401

-55-

STUDENT SIMULATOR HOURS

F(I 175) F(I 56)F(116)F(038)

res

1

Checkdivisor

TOTAL NUMBER OF GROUND-SCHOOL CLASSROOM HOURS

F)).181' FO 1561'F0181F(I- 38)

NUMBER OF GROUND-SCHOOLCLASSROOM HOURS TAUGHT

BY CCTS INSTRUCTORSF(1.184) F(I+181)(F(I. 42)

NUMBER OF GROUND - SCHOOLCLASSROOM HOURS TAUGHT

BY FID INSTRUCTORSF(1187)F(1.181)-F(1184)

I

TOTAL NUMBER OF GRADUATESF (156)- F ( 54). F 055)

Check:era-oupuldesignator

'TOTAL AVERAGE STUDENT WADIF (161) F (159). F(163)

TOTAL STUDENT FLYING HOURSF(116/) P,,1 161 1 Fl 164

I, 2, 3 --Aircraftypes 1, 2, 3,respecvey

i I --Hours :ns,L.:.rorflies with sluden1s. TOTAL HOURS

I": 4 --.ETuclent s F(1.174) F1I. 1721- F(l 173)hours.

1=7 --Student hoiner hours1 ID-- Ground-school (GS)

classroom hours.1=13-- GS classroom hours

taught by CCTSins),Oors.

16 -- GS classroom hours/ought by ETDinstructors.

RETURN

END I

SET lo)VF NTORIES OF AIRCRAFTTYPES, SIMULATORS, AND

TRAINERS INITIALLY TO HOSEFOR BEr INNING Y7^.R.F(1 1991 FIT . V)

I 5?

CONSTANT MULTIPLIERDF 10, (-5)

SUBROUTINE EQUIP (CONTINUED)

62

Page 64: DOCUMENT RESUME - ERIC · DOCUMENT RESUME ED 050 350 AC 010 343 AUTHOR Boren, H. E., Jr. TITLE The Pilot Training Study: A User's Guide to the Advanced Pilot Computer Cost Model (APT)

SET AIRCRAFT ATTRITIONTERM TO ZERO.

ATFR = 0.

Yes

I = 1-3 -- Aircrafttypes I - 3

I = 4-- SimulatorsI = 5-- Trainers

-56-

OTHER FLY NG HOURSF(1. 190)- F(1 46)F (1 + 181)

Yes

--F.1 F(1+

TOTAL FLY NG HOURS193)= F(I 167). F(I 190)

ADJUST OTHER FLYINGHOURS FOR AIRCRAFT TYPE1 TO INCLUDE LEAD/TOW

AIRCRAFT HOURS.F(191 )=F(047)(168).

F(215) F(216))

0

Yes

ADJUST TOTAL FLYINGHOURS FOR AIRCRAFT TYPE

I TO INCLUDE LEAD /TOWAIRCRAFT HOURS.

F(1941. F(1941. F(115)*F ( 216

FLYING HOURS CHARGEDTO PILOT RAINING

f (I. 196)r F (I 49) F (I 193)

NUMBER OF AIRCRAFTREQUIRED

F(1+2041:4(10 193VF(1.54)

Che.:kdiy'sor

Ye!

NUMBER OF TYPE 3AIRCRAFT TO BEPROCURED FOR

AT;RITIONF(304)=F(144)

F(198)09

NUMBER OFSIM16 4TORS

REQUIREDF I 208) = F

F (053)

...1 TRAINERSOF

No INERS REQUIREDF (109) = F (181 V

F (054)

NUMBER OF TYPE I TYPE 2

AIRCP.AFT TO BE PROCUREDFOR ATTRITION

F(1301), F(I44)F(I193) DF

STORE VALUE OF F (I 301)AS ATTR

ATTR = F (I+ DOI)

STORE VALUE Qt F (304)AS ATTR

ATTR- F(304)....

L

TOTAL NUMBER OF AIRCRAFT,SIMULATORS, AND TRAINERS TOREPROCUREO, INCLUDING ATTRITION

NI+ 209) = F(I.104)-F)1+1991ATTR

SUBROUTINE EQUIP (CONTINUED)

r 3

F(E 209).0

If number to beProcured is lessthan zero, setnumber to zero.

Page 65: DOCUMENT RESUME - ERIC · DOCUMENT RESUME ED 050 350 AC 010 343 AUTHOR Boren, H. E., Jr. TITLE The Pilot Training Study: A User's Guide to the Advanced Pilot Computer Cost Model (APT)

-57-

CURRENT EQUIPMENTINVENTORY199 F(1+199)'

F(1+209)- ATTR

1 1 1

SIMULATOR HOURS CHARGEDTO PILOT TRAINING

F (220) = F (178) F (135)

IRETURN

ENDI

SUBROUTINE EQUIP (CONTINUED)

114

Page 66: DOCUMENT RESUME - ERIC · DOCUMENT RESUME ED 050 350 AC 010 343 AUTHOR Boren, H. E., Jr. TITLE The Pilot Training Study: A User's Guide to the Advanced Pilot Computer Cost Model (APT)

Checkdivisors

START

-58-

o FLYING INSTRUCTORSF(221)= F (175)/F (033)

SIMULATOR INSTRUCTORSF(222)= F (178)/F (034)

o TRAINER INSTRUCTORSF (223) =- F (181)/F (035)

TOTAL INSTRUCTORS REQUIREDF ( 226) = F (221 ). F (2221

F (223) + F (224) -F(225)

GROUND-SCHOOL CCTSINSTRUCTORS

F 1224) = F (187)4(036)

INSTRUCTOR SUPERVISORSAND ADMIN. PERSONNEL

(SQUADRON LEVEL )F ( 227) = F (063) F COO)

F (226)

GROUND-SCHOOL FTDINSTRUCTORS

F (225)= F (190)/F (037)

SUBROUTINE PERS

65

ACADEMIC PROGRAMSUPERVISOR AND ADMIN.PERSONNEL SQUADRON

LEV L)F (228)=F (065)4 F (066) 1

F(161)

STANDARD- VALUATIONPERSONNEL

F(229) F(067)

TOTAL NONSTUDENTOPERATIONS PERSONNEL

F (230), F (226) F (227).F (228) F (229)

I= I

MAINTENANCE PERSONNELFOR AIRCRAFT TYPES I, 2, 63

F (1 ' 230) = F (I + 62).F (I. 95)

TOTAL AIRCRAFTMAINTENANCE PERSONNELI (2311 =F (231) 4 F (232)

F (233)

Page 67: DOCUMENT RESUME - ERIC · DOCUMENT RESUME ED 050 350 AC 010 343 AUTHOR Boren, H. E., Jr. TITLE The Pilot Training Study: A User's Guide to the Advanced Pilot Computer Cost Model (APT)

SIMULATOR MAINTENANCE& OPERATING PERSONNEL

(FUNCTION OF SIMULATORSREQUIRED)

F (235) f (071) F (208) F (135)

66-59-

SIMULATOR MAINTENANCE

Yes& OPERATING PERSONNEL(FUNCTION OF STUDENT

SIMULATOR HOURS IF (235) F (07)) F (220)

TRAINER MAINTENANCE &OPERATING PERSONNEL

F(236) F (072) F (204)

SIMULATOR AND TRAINERMAINTENANCE AND

OPERATING PERSONNELF (237) = F (235) F(236)

TOTAL OPERATIONS ANDMAINTENANCE PERSONNEL

F(238) F(230). F(234). F(237)

TOTAL ADMINISTRATIVEPERSONNEL (WING LEVEL)

F(239) -F(073). F(074)F(238)

TOTAL STUDENT LOADOPERATIONS & MAINTENANCE

IDMINISTRAIIVE PERSONNE1F(240) ,-F(161) F(238)F(239)

TOTAL S1EPPORT PERSONNELF(24I )- F(075)0 F(076) F(240

TO'1AL PERSONNEL CHARGEDTO PILOT TRAINING,

)NCLUDING STUDENTSF (:42) F (240) + F (241)

TOTAL PERMANENT-PARTYPERSONNEL

F (243) F (242)- F (161)

RATED IN TRUCTORSTEMP F (22 ) 4 F (222) +

F (223) + F ( 229)

LTOTAL PERMANENT-PARTY

OFFICERS

F(244) =TEMP + F (077) F (224) +F(079). F(225)+ F(081)F(227)4 F(083) F(228)4F(085) F(234)+ F(08 ?).F(237) +F(089). F(239)+F(091) F(241)

TOTAL AIRMENF(245)- F(078) F(224). F(080)

F(225)4F(082) F(227).F(084). F(228). F(086)f(2341.F(088). F(237).F(090). F(239). F(092)F(241 )

TOTAL PERMANENT-PARTYMILITARY PERSONNEL

F (246). F (244) 4 F (245)

TOTAL CIVILIANSF (247) F (243) F (244)

TOTAL PERMANENT-PARTYRATED OFFICERS

F (243) = F (093) F (744)4 TEMP (1.0-F (093))

SUBROUTINE ARS (CONTINUED)

Page 68: DOCUMENT RESUME - ERIC · DOCUMENT RESUME ED 050 350 AC 010 343 AUTHOR Boren, H. E., Jr. TITLE The Pilot Training Study: A User's Guide to the Advanced Pilot Computer Cost Model (APT)

TOTAL NONRATED OFFICERSF (249)= F(244)- F (248)

ALLOCATION CONSTANTSC.(1.0+ F(074) .(1.0 F(076))D=0.

Checkyearcounter

STUDENT LOAD CHANGEF(250)=F(161)- T(4)

TOTAL PERSONNEL CHANGE,INCLUDING STUDENTSF (251 )= F (242)- T(5)

CHANGE IN TO AL PERMANENT-PARTY PE SONNEL

F (252) = F 243) - T (6)

CHANGE IN TOTAL PERMANENT-PARTY MILITARY PERSONNEL

F(253). F(246)- T(7)

1 =I 1

CONSTANT USED INSUBSEQUENT CALCULATIONSD = D+ ((F (1+49) -T (Int

F (1.67) F {I+ 193))

-60-

D= D4 (F (135)-T(8))F (178)

F(071)

D= D+(F ( 35)-T(8))F(208) F(071)

FACTOR TO ELIMINATE EFFECTON E.I. COST OF CHANGE IN

ALLOCATION FRACTIONF(255). C D

rPERMANENT PAR Y CHANGE LESSCHANGE DUE TO VARIATION 1N

ALLOCATION FRACTIONF(254). F (252)- F(255)

STORE F (050), F(0 1), F (052), F(161),F(242), F (243),F (246), ond F (135

TM= F(050)T (2) = F (051)T (3). F (052)T (4) = F (161)T (5). F (242)

(6). F (243)T (7)= (246)T (8) = (133)

RETURN I

ENG

SUBROUTINE PERS (CONTINUED)

67

Page 69: DOCUMENT RESUME - ERIC · DOCUMENT RESUME ED 050 350 AC 010 343 AUTHOR Boren, H. E., Jr. TITLE The Pilot Training Study: A User's Guide to the Advanced Pilot Computer Cost Model (APT)

START

1-77-1

COST A'RCRAFT. TRAINERS ANDSIMULATORS TO BE PROCURED.

I F (1 2571 F(1, 94) F11+ 209)

Yes

1=1-3-- Aircrafttypes 1-3

1.1-- Simulators1= 5 Trainels

68.

-61-

AIRCRAFT PROCUREMENT COSTALLOCATED TO PILOT TRAININGF11.257 }- F(1257) F(1, 45, )

COST OF AIRCRAFT SPARESFII-I-262) F(110) F(1.257)

N 5?

No

<IVULA TOR PROCUREMENTCOSI ALLOCATED TO

PILO 7 TRAININGF12611 F ( 2611 F1135)

COST OF SIMULATOR SPARESF ( 766) F (100) F (261)

F(147)>1.0?

0

SI = O.

52 0.

Yes

CUMULATIVE CHANGE INS'UDENI LOAD UNTILTHRESHOLD IS REACHED

SI = SI F(254))

SUBROUTIN8' 'NCO

CUMULATIVE CHANGE IN ADJPERMANENT PARTY UNTIL

THRESHOLD IS REACHED:2 S2 F ( 254)

SET F VARIABLE TO SIF (256) Si

Is SI

underthresholdvalue?

SET F VARIABLE TO 52F (257 ) S2

SI < F (0941?

No

Yes

COST OF TRAINING EQUIPMF!iTAND SPARES FOR SiUDENT

LOAD INCREASE. IF JUSTIEI:CBY THE INCREASE.

F (267) F (101 ) SI 0.001

Is 52 underthreshold vorue ?

Yes

= O.

52 c F (1221?

No

COST OF BASE SUPPORT EQUIPMENTAND SPARES FOR PERMANENTPARTY INCREASE IF JUSTIFIED

L Y THE INCREASE.F ( 268) F (123) S2 0.001

LCOST OF SUPPLIES FOR

I-ERMANENT PARTY 'INCREASEIF JUSTIEIEDDY THE INCREASE

(2691= F(1241 52 0 001

I 52

COST OF TRAINING FORPERMANENT PARTY INCREASE

F (270) F (125) F '251) 0.001

Page 70: DOCUMENT RESUME - ERIC · DOCUMENT RESUME ED 050 350 AC 010 343 AUTHOR Boren, H. E., Jr. TITLE The Pilot Training Study: A User's Guide to the Advanced Pilot Computer Cost Model (APT)

- 62-

COST OF TRAVEL (PCS) FORPERMANTNT PARTY INCREASEF(271),F(126)F(254)

0.001

I =258

Ye

Ye

F( 270) = 01

IF F(270) or F(271)is less /hoe zero, serirs yoke ro zero.

IF(2711 =0.

LFTOTAL INCREASE IN

INVESTM NT COST(272)=F 272). F(I)

Yes

LIRETURN

rEND

I= I I

SUEROUTINE INCO (CONTINUED)

69;

Page 71: DOCUMENT RESUME - ERIC · DOCUMENT RESUME ED 050 350 AC 010 343 AUTHOR Boren, H. E., Jr. TITLE The Pilot Training Study: A User's Guide to the Advanced Pilot Computer Cost Model (APT)

63-

START

DEPOT MAINTENANCE COSTF(273) r (F(102)F(197).F(103)

F(1.98)* F(1C4)F(199)).0.001

POL COSTF(274 ) _ (F(I01)-F(197).F(106)

F( 198). F( 107) F(199)I0.001

MATERIAL COSTF(275)- (F(1081- F(127)- F(109).

F(19814 F(110) F(149)10.001

TOTAL FLYING-HOUR COSTF (276)- F(273) F(274)+ F (275)

'MUNITIONS COS --LONG COURSEIF 12771= F(111 F (1.57) 0.001

MUNITIONS COS -- SHORT COURSEF(278)- F (112 F (158) 0.001

STUDENT PAYF (279 ) F (127) F (181) 0.001

RAFED 0 FICER PAYF ()28) F (248) 0.001

NONRATED OFFICER PAYF (281 ) = F (129 ) F (249 ) 0.001

AIRMEN PAYF (282)- F (130) F1245)- 0.001

I TOTAL PERMANENT-PARTYMILITARY PAY

F (283)- F (280) F(281)+ F (282 )

TOTAL MILITARY PAY,INCLUDING STUDENTS

F (284). F (279). F(283)

CIVILIAN PAYF (285) F (131) F(247) 0.001

TOTAL PAY -MILITARYPLUS CIVILIANS

F(286).. F(284)+ F (285)

1STUDENT TDY/PCS

F(287)= F (113) F (151) 0.001

AIL PERMANENT-PARTYPERSONNEL TDY

F(288), F (132) F (243) 0,001

:ERVICES COSTF (2E9) = F (1331 F (242) 0.001

OTHER SUPPLIES AND EQUIPMENTCOST

r(290)= F (1341 F(242) . 0.001

SIMULATOR MAINTENANCE,MATERIAL, AND SERVICES COST

1(291),f (114)F(208)F(135)

TRAINER MAINTENANCE,MATERIAL, AND SERVICES COST

F (292):. F (14S). F(204)

I[-TARGET RENTAL COSF-1

F ( 293) F (115)

SUBROUTINE OPCO

7O

Page 72: DOCUMENT RESUME - ERIC · DOCUMENT RESUME ED 050 350 AC 010 343 AUTHOR Boren, H. E., Jr. TITLE The Pilot Training Study: A User's Guide to the Advanced Pilot Computer Cost Model (APT)

-64-

SUPPORT-AIRCRAFT COSTF(294)= F(136) F(242) 0.0'1

OFFICERS TRAINING COSTF (295) = F (137) F (244) 0.031

AIRMEN TRAINING COSTF (296) = F (138) F (245) 0,031

PERMANENT CHANGE OF STATION COSTF (297)=F (139) F (243). 0.031

RECURRING INV STMENt COSTS...AiRCRAFT TYPES 1, 2, 83

F (30`1 = F (205) F (095) F (217) F (050)F (3061 = F (206) F (096) F (218) F (051;F (307) F (207)* F (097) F (219 ) F (052)

TOTAL AIRCRAFT RECURRINGINVESTMENT COST

F (308) = F (305) + F (306) + F (307)

[ TOTAL OTHER OPERATING COSTF (298) = F (277) 4 F (278) + F (287) + F (288)*

F (289) + F (290)4 F (291)4 F(292)+F(293)+ F (294)* F (295)4 F (296)+F (297) + F (308)

TOTAL OPERATING COST INCLUDINGRECURRING INVESTMENT

F (299)= F (276) + (286)4 h (298)

CheckJIvisof

F(156)=0.2

Yes

N OPERATING COST PER GRADUATE ($)F (300/ F (299) 1000./F (156)

TOTAL SYSTEM COST, EXCLUDII.G RD TEF (301). F (272) + F(299)

RETURN

1END1

SU3ROUTINE OPCO (CONTINUED)

71

Page 73: DOCUMENT RESUME - ERIC · DOCUMENT RESUME ED 050 350 AC 010 343 AUTHOR Boren, H. E., Jr. TITLE The Pilot Training Study: A User's Guide to the Advanced Pilot Computer Cost Model (APT)

ISTART

LFXFAG NUMBER

AGE = F 1451 0.5

Ye Checkyearnumber

Checkpass

counterF(149 =1.0?

Yes

(PRINT WEAPON SYSTEMNAME ON SAME PAGE,(NAME (I), 1= 1, 10)

rCPRINT SUBHEADINGS

)..*'

i3..

I INITIALIZE LINE COUNT. ILINES = 10

- 65-

PRINT WEAPON SYSTEM \NAME AND PAGE

NUMBER ON NEW PAGE,(NAME (1), I= 1, 10)

PAGE

STEP PAGENUMBER BY 1.

IPAGE = PAGE 4. I

FIX DATA 10 BE PRINTED.11 (1) F (150) 0.511(21= F (15.5) 0.511(3). F (161)* 0.511 (4) F (243) 0.511(5) = F (2n)

= 276) 0.511(7) F(2861+ 0.511 (8) = F (298) 0.581 ei F (299) 0.511 (10). F (301) 0.511 011= F (300) 0.511(12)=F (It6) 0.5

L.

YesLINES < 58?

a

Checkline

count

PRINT WEAPON SYSTEMNAME AND PAGE NUMBER

ON NEW PAGE.NAME (0,1=1,10), IPAGE

STEP PAGE NUMBER BY I.IPAGE = PAGE I

PRINT SUBHEADINGS )

L_INITIALIZE LINE COUNT.

LINES = 10

Checkvero-outputdesignator

(PRINT ONLY vEARa NUMBER AND

TOTAL NUMBEROF GRADUATES11(11,It(2)

PRINT ONE LINE OFOUTPUT DATA.

(II (J), ) =1,4),(F (1), J = 203, 2081,OS (J), = 5, 11)

SUBROUTINE OUTPUT

72

STEP LINE COUNT BY I.LINES . EINES I

Page 74: DOCUMENT RESUME - ERIC · DOCUMENT RESUME ED 050 350 AC 010 343 AUTHOR Boren, H. E., Jr. TITLE The Pilot Training Study: A User's Guide to the Advanced Pilot Computer Cost Model (APT)

Check common-dump printoutdesignator

F (117) = 0.?

0

-66-

Yes

r17RINIT WEAPON SYSTEMNAME AND PAGE NUMBER

ON NEW PAGE.\(NAME (1), 1 = 1,10), (PAGE

STEP PAGE NUMBER BY IIPAGE = :PAGE s 1

PRINT SUBHEADINGS

1 l

= 9 I

CPRINT ONE LINE OF F-

VARIABLE VALUES AND RANGEOF ADDRESSES (SUBSCRIPTS)

(F(K),K =1, 1),1, 1

1.1.10 --'` I < 310?

0

Check vorioblelisting printdeionolor

F (120)= O.?

0

Y

PRINT WEAPON SYSTEM N1,

{NAME

AND PAGE NUMBERON NEW PAGE.

i NAME (1), I = 1, 10), IPAGE/

STEP PAGE NUMBER BY 1(PAGE = (PAGE , I

PRINT TWO LINESOF SPACE

FS: T ITEM COUNT TO ZERO.ITEMS = 0.

Yes

1 1=

0

OCheck variable-listing selectiondesivorors

PRINT ADDRESS (SUBSCRIPT) OF FVARIABLE, NAME OF F VARIABLE,

AND VALUE OF F VARIABLE.1, (NAMES (1, J), J= 1,17), F (I)

STEP ITEM COUNT BY 1.ITEMS = TEMS = 1

SUBROUTINE OUTPUT (CONTINUED)

73

Page 75: DOCUMENT RESUME - ERIC · DOCUMENT RESUME ED 050 350 AC 010 343 AUTHOR Boren, H. E., Jr. TITLE The Pilot Training Study: A User's Guide to the Advanced Pilot Computer Cost Model (APT)

-67-

Checkitemcount

YesITEMS < 531

No

PRINT WEAPON SYSTEMNAME AND PAGE NUMBER

ON NEW PAGE.(NAME (1), .1= I ,10), !PAGE

STEP PAGE NUMBER BY 1.PAGE = 'PAGE 1

PRINT TWO LINES )OF SPACE

RESET ITEM COUNTER TO ZERO.ITEMS = 0

PotINT R AND 0COST.

11(12)

1

SET LINE 4C504.MT

LINES = 45(..._

PRINT WEAPON SYSTEMNAME AND PAGE NUMBER

ON NEW PAGE.(NAME (I), I = I. 10), IPAGE

PRINT SUBHEADINGS

{ STEP PAGE NUMBER 111Y 1.PAGE PAGE I

SET LINE COUNTTO ID.

LINES = 10

Check end-of-daroindicoroz

Yes

Yes

0

Checklinecount

( PRINT WEAPON SYSTEM NNAME AND PAGE NUMBER

ON NEW PAGE.NAME (I), 1 = I , 10), WAGE)

ISTEP PAGE NUMBER BY 1 .:PAGE = !PAGE 4 I

PRINT R AND D COST.1I(12)

-1.-1 SET F VARIABLE EQUAL0 PAGE NUMBER.IF (146) = IPAGE

CheckvorialB1e-listingprintdesignator

SET ALL VARIABLE-LISTINGSELECTION DESIGNATIONS

TO ZERO.10 (I). 0

SUBROUTINE OUTPUT (CONTINUED)

74

Page 76: DOCUMENT RESUME - ERIC · DOCUMENT RESUME ED 050 350 AC 010 343 AUTHOR Boren, H. E., Jr. TITLE The Pilot Training Study: A User's Guide to the Advanced Pilot Computer Cost Model (APT)

Checkcleardesignoros

-68-

(119) = 0. andF(148)/33

0

Yes

I1 -1

1r-

SET ALL INPUT FVARIABLES TO ZERO.

F W. O.

Se remaininginput vortabletto zero.

1= 14?

F(i) 0

RETURN

END

Yes1 = 1 !

F(1+ 75)-0.

F (135) = O.

I(145) =0.]

RETURN

TEND

1 =1* I

SUBROUTINE OUTPUT (CONTINUED)

Page 77: DOCUMENT RESUME - ERIC · DOCUMENT RESUME ED 050 350 AC 010 343 AUTHOR Boren, H. E., Jr. TITLE The Pilot Training Study: A User's Guide to the Advanced Pilot Computer Cost Model (APT)

-69-

Appendix C

LISTING OF FORTRAN-IV (IBM 360/65) APTCOMPUTER PROGRAM

76

Page 78: DOCUMENT RESUME - ERIC · DOCUMENT RESUME ED 050 350 AC 010 343 AUTHOR Boren, H. E., Jr. TITLE The Pilot Training Study: A User's Guide to the Advanced Pilot Computer Cost Model (APT)

-70-

COMMON F(310), T1TLE(20), NAME(10),. ID(310), NAMES(310,17)DLMENSION F1(8), 11(8)

CC MAIN ROUTINE OF APT COMPUTER PROGRAM THAT DETERMINES COSTS OFC STUDENTS IN ADVANCED PILOT TRAINING SCHOOL (COTS)C

SET ALL INPUT VARIABLES IN COMMON TO ZERO.10 DO 20 1 a It 150

F(1) O.20 CONTINUE

F(217) a O.F(218) = O.F(219) a O.ID1 = 0SET VARIABLE-LISTING SELECTION DESIGNATORS TO ZERO.DO 25 I a 1, 310ID(11 = 0

25 CONTINUESET PAGE NUMBER TO 1.

30 IPAGE 1.

C SET PASS COUNTER TO ZERO.F4149) a O.

C READ TITLE CARO.READ ;5, 40) (TITLE(1), 1 a 1, 20)

40 FORMAT (20A4)1 0

C READ CONSTANT INPUTS.50 READ (5, 60) (11(K), Fl(K)u K 1, 8)60 FORMAT (8(13, F6.3, 1X))

PO 70 K = 1, 8IF (11(K) .EQ. 666) GO TO 80IF M(K) .EQ. 0 .AND1 F1(K) .EQ. 0.) GO TO 70IF (11(K) .GT. 216 .AND. 11(K) .LT. 220) GO TO 65IF (11(K) .LE. 0 .0R. MM. .GT. 145) GO TO 140

65 1 I1(K)F(11 a F1(K)

70 CONTINUEGO TO 50

C PRINT TITLE AND PAGE NUMBER ON NEW PAGE80 WRITE (6, 90) (TITLE(I), 1 = 1, 20), IPAGE90 FORMAT (1H1/ 10X, 20A4, 26X, 5HPAGE 12)

C SET PAGE NUMBER TO 2.F(1461 a 2.0IF (1D1 .EQ. 1 .OR. F1141) .EQ. 0.) GO TO 100

C READ IN ADDRESSES AND NAMES DF ALL F VARIABLES IF ('1141) = 1.0.92 READ (5, 94) 1, (NAMES(10.1)0 J 2 1, 17)94 FORMAT (13, 3X, 17A4)

IF (I .NE/ 310) GO TO 92101 a 1

C SET CURRENT EQUIPMENT INVENTORIES TO ZERO.100 DO 105 1 200, 204

F(I) a O.105 CONTINUE

C SET ZERO- OUTPUT DESIGNATOR TO ZERO.F11181 0.SET YEAR COUNTER TO ZERO.

77

Page 79: DOCUMENT RESUME - ERIC · DOCUMENT RESUME ED 050 350 AC 010 343 AUTHOR Boren, H. E., Jr. TITLE The Pilot Training Study: A User's Guide to the Advanced Pilot Computer Cost Model (APT)

-71-

F(1471 = O.READ WEAPONSYSTEM CARDREAD (5, 110) 1W, (NAME([),, I = 1, 10)

*10 FORMAT (12, 2X, 1044)FI0011 = 1W

C SET ALL OUTPUT VARIABLES IN COMMON TO ZERO EXCEPT EQUIPMENTC INVENTORIES AND AIRCRAFT RECURRING. INVESTMENT COST FACTORS.

120 00 130 I = 151, 199F(I) = O.

130 CONTINUEC STORE VALUES OF AIRCRAFT RECURRING INVESTMENT COST FACTORS.

TEMPI = F(2171TEMP2 = F(218)TEMP3 = F4219)00 132 I is 205, 310F(1) = O.

132 CONTINUEC RESTORE VALUES OF AIRCRAFT RECURRING INVESTMENT COST FACTORS.

F(217) = TEMPIF1218) = TEMP2F1219) = TEMP3

C SET VARIABLE LISTING PRINT DESIGNATOR TO ZERO.F(120) = O.

C STEP YEAR COUNTER BY I.F(1471 = F(147) + 1.0

C STEP PASS COUNTER BY 1.F(1491 = F(149) + 1.0

C READ WEAPON SYSTEM INPUTS.CALL READ

C CALCULATE TRAINING HOURS AND EQUIPMENT REQUIREMENTS.CALL EQUIPIF IF(118) .EQ. 1.01 GO TO 135

C CALCULATE PERSONNEL REQUIREMENTS.CALL PERS

C CALCULATE INVESTMENT COSTS.CALL INCO

C CALCULATE OPERATING COSTS.CALL OPCO

C PRINT RESULTS.135 CALL OUTPUT

IND = F(148) 4.. 0.5

GO TO (120, 100, 30, 1601, INDC PRINT ERROR MESSAGE

140 WRITE (6, 1501150 FORMAT (1H0/ 10X, llOHAN ADDRESS FOR ONE OF THE INPUT CONSTANT

C FACTORS HAS NOT BEEN ENTERED PROPERLY. THE LAST CORRECT, ADDRESSCHAS , 13, 1H. / 10X, 29HTHIS JOB HAS BEEN TERMINATED. )

CALL EXITC PRINT ENDOF RUN STATEMENT

160 WRITE (6, 170)170 FORMAT (1H1/ 10X0 49HENO FINAL RUN -- ALL DATA HAVE BEEN

C PROCESSED.)CALL EXITEND

78

Page 80: DOCUMENT RESUME - ERIC · DOCUMENT RESUME ED 050 350 AC 010 343 AUTHOR Boren, H. E., Jr. TITLE The Pilot Training Study: A User's Guide to the Advanced Pilot Computer Cost Model (APT)

72

SUBROUTINE READCOMMON F(310), TITLE(20), NAME(10).. 10(310), N&MES(310,17)DIMENSION F1(8), 1118)

C SUBROUTINE FOR READING WEAPON SYSTEM INPUT DATAC

10 I g 0C READ WEAPON SYSTEM INPUT DATA

20 READ 15, 30) (11(K), FILM, K = 1, 81

30 FORMAT (8(13, F6.3, IX))DO 40 K = 1, 8IF (MK) .GT. 665) GO TO 50IF (11(K) .EQ. 0 .AND. F1(K1 .EQ. 0.) SO TO 40IF (11(K) .GT. 216 .AND. I1(K) .LT. 220) GO TO 35IF (MK) .LE. 0 .OR. 11(K) .GT. 1451 GO TO 60

35 I = I1(K)F(I) = FI(K)

40 CONTINUEGO TO 20

50 IF (111K) .NE. 666 .AND. MK) .NE. 777 .AND. MK) .NE. 888 .AND.C 111K) .NE. 999) GO TO 60

C CURRENT YEAR (BEGINNING YEAR + YEAR NUMBER 1.0)F(1501 = F(121) + F(002) 1,0

C ENDOFDATA DESIGNATO1C F11481 = 1.0 -- END OF ONE YEAR'S DATA FOR ONE WEAPON SYSTEMC (11(K) = 6661C F(148) = 2.0 -- END OF FINAL YEAR'S DATA FOR ONE WEAPON SYS1EIC (I1(K) = 777)C F(148) = 3.0 -- END OF FINAL YEAR'S DATA FOR FINAL WEAPON SYSTEM.C GO TO NEW RUN.C 1I1(K) = 888)C F(148) = 4.0 -- END OF ALL RUNS

(11(K) = 999)F(148) = (11(K) 500)/100IF (Fi1201 .EQ. 0.) RETURNREAD (5, 55) (Mi)t I s 1, 80)IF (10111 .EQ. 9) GO TO 80READ (5, 55) (10111, 1 = 81. 1601READ 15, 55) (IO(13, I = 161, 240)READ (5, 55) (10(I), I = 241, 305)

55 FORMAT (80111RETURNWRITE ERROR MESSAGE

60 WRITE (6, 70) I

70 FORMAT (1H0/10)(0 tO7HAN ADDRESS FOR A WEAPON SYSTEM INPUT IARIABLEC HAS NOT BEEN ENTERED PROPERLY. THE LAST CORRECT ADDRESS WAS .13.C 1H. / 10)(1 29HTHIS JOB HAS BEEN TERMINATED. )

CALL EXITSET ALL VARIABLELISTING SELECTION DESIGNATORS TO I.

80 DO 90 1 a 1, 310IO(I) a

90 CONTINUERETURNEND

79 .

Page 81: DOCUMENT RESUME - ERIC · DOCUMENT RESUME ED 050 350 AC 010 343 AUTHOR Boren, H. E., Jr. TITLE The Pilot Training Study: A User's Guide to the Advanced Pilot Computer Cost Model (APT)

-73-

SUBROUTINE EQUIPCOMMON F(310), TITLE(201, NAME(10), 10(3101, NAMES(310017)

C SUBROUTINE FOR DETERMINING TRAlNiNG HOURS AND EQUIPMENTC REQUIREMENTSCC TOTAL NUMBER, OF ENTERING STUDENTS

10 Ft151) = F(003) + F(004) + F(0051 + F(006)C NUMBER OF ENTERING STUDENTS IN LONG COURSE

F(152) = F(151) - F(003)NUMBER OF ENTERING STUDENTS IN SHORT COURSEF(153) = F(003)DO 30 I = 1, 2

C I = 1 -- LONG COURSE, I = 2 -- SHORT COURSEC NUMBER OF GRADUATES

F(1 +153) F(I+8) * F(I+151)IF (F(118) .EQ. 1.0) GO TO 30

C AVERAGE NUMBER OF STUDENTS PER YEARFII+1561 a 0.5 * IF(I+151) + F(I+1531)

C AVERAGE STUDENT LOADSF(I+158) g F(1+156) * F(116) / 52.0FII+1701 O.DO 20 J = 1, 3

K a 3 * I + JIF (F(K+171 .EQ. 0.1 GO TO 20

C STUDENT FLYING HOURS FOR AIRCRAFT TYPES 1, 2, AND 3FIK+1581 g F11+156) * F(K+7) / F(K+17)

C INSTRUCTOR FLYING HOURS PER STUDENTF41+170) a Ft1.+170) + IF(K+231 / FIK+1711

2a CONTINUENUMBER OF HOURS INSTRUCTOR FLIES WITH STUDENTSFII+1721 F(I+156) * F(I+170)

C TOTAL INSTRUCTOR FLYING HOURS IN LEAD/TOW AIRCRAFT TYPE 1

Flt+2141 FII+156) * FII+141)C STUDENT SIMULATOR HOURS

IF IF10383 .NE. 0.) FII+1751 = F(I +156) * F(I+161 / F(038)C STUDENT TRAINER HOURS

F(I +1781 = FI10156) * F(I+40)C NUMBER OF GROUND - SCHOOL CLASSROOM HOURS

IF (FII +38) .NE. 0.) FII+181) = FII+156) * F11+18) / F41+38)C NUMBER OF GROUND-SCHOOL CLASSROOM HOURS TAUGHT BY CCTS INSTRUCTORS

F1I+1841 FII+181) * F(I+42)C NUMBER OF GROUND- SCHOOL CLASSROOM HOURS TAUGHT BY ETD INSTRUCTORS

F(1+1871 F(1+1811 F(I+184)30 CONTINUE

C TOTAL NUMBER OF GRADUATESFI156) a F(154) + F(1551IF IF(118) .EQ. 1.0) RETURN

C TOTAL AVERAGE STUDENT LOADF1161) a FI159) + F1160)

C TOTAL STUDENT FLYING HOURS -- AIRCRAFT TYPES 1, 2. AND 3DO 40 I a 1, 3

F41+1671 a F(I+1611 + F(I+164140 CONTINUE

C TOTALS -- HOURS INSTRUCTOR FLIES WITi STU)ENTS, SIJDEVT SIMJLATOR

Page 82: DOCUMENT RESUME - ERIC · DOCUMENT RESUME ED 050 350 AC 010 343 AUTHOR Boren, H. E., Jr. TITLE The Pilot Training Study: A User's Guide to the Advanced Pilot Computer Cost Model (APT)

-74-

C HOURS, STUDENT TRAINER HOURS, GS CLASSROOM HOURS, GS CLASSR)OMC HOURS TAUGHT BY CCTS, AND GS CLASSROOM HOURS TAU3IT BY FTD

DO 50 1 = 1, 16, 3F([ +1741 = F(I+172) + F(I+173)

50 CONTINUEC SET INVENTORIES OF AP.CRAFT TYPES, SIMULATORS, AN TRAINERSC INITIALLY TO THOSE Ff1R BEGINNING YEAR.

IF (F(147) .GT. 1.0) GO TO 70DO 60 I = 1, 5

FII+1991 A FII+57160 CONTINUE

OF = 10.**(-5)70 OD 90 I = 1,

I a 1-3 -- AIRCRAFT TYPES 1 -3, I = 4 -- SIMULATORS, I = 5 --C TRAINERSC SE i AIRCRAFT ATTRITION TERM INITIALLY TO ZERO.

ATTR = O.IF .GT. 3) GO TO 80

C OTHER FLYING HOURSF(I+190) = F(I+46) * F(I+167)ADJUST OTHER FLYING HOURS FOR AIRCRAFT TYPE 1 TO INCLUDE LEAD /T04AIRCRAFT FLYING HOURS.IF (I .F4. 1) F(191) = F1047) * (F11681 + F(215) + FI215))

C TOTAL FL'.ING HOURSF(I+193) = F(I+1671 + F(I+1901

C ADJUST TOTAL FLYING HOURS FOR AIRCRAFT TYPE I. TO INCLJDE LEA'/TOWC AIRCRAFT FLYING HOURS.

IF (I .EQ. 1) F1194) = F(194) + F(215) + F(216)C FLYING HOURS CHARGED TO PILOT TRA14147

F(I+196) = F11+491 * F11+193)NUMBER OF AIRCRAFT REQUIREDIF (FII+54) s.N2. 0.) F(I+204) = FI1+193) / F(1 +54)GO TO 172,. 74, 76), I

C NUMBER OF SIMULATORS REQUIRED72 IF (F(053) .NE. 0.) F(208) = F1178) / F(053)

C NUMBER OF TRAINERS REQUIREDIF IF(054) .NE. 0.) F(209) * FI181) / FI054)

C NUMBER OF TYPE 1, TYPE 2 AIRCRAFT TO BE PROCURED FOR ATTRITION74 F(I+301) F(I+44) * F(1+193) * OF

ATTR 2 F11+301)GO TO 80

C NUMBER OF TYPE 3 AIRCRAFT TO BE PROCURED FOR ATTRITION76 F(3041 = F(144) * F(196) * OF

ATTR = F(304)TOTAL NUMBER OF AIRCRAFT, SIMULATORS, AND TRAINERS TO BE PROCURED

80 FI1+2091 s F(I +204) - F(I+1991 + ATTRC IF NUMBER TO BE PROCURED IS LESS T-IAN ZERO, SET NUMBER TO ZERO.

IF IFII+209) 0.) F(I+209) = O.C CURRENT INVENTORY OF AIRCRAFT TYPES, SIMULATORS, 44) TRAINERS

F11+199) F1I+1991 + F(1 +2091 ATTR90 CONTINUE

SIMULATOR HOURS CHARGED TO PILOT TRAININGFIA201 a F(17B) * F(135)RETURNEND

81

Page 83: DOCUMENT RESUME - ERIC · DOCUMENT RESUME ED 050 350 AC 010 343 AUTHOR Boren, H. E., Jr. TITLE The Pilot Training Study: A User's Guide to the Advanced Pilot Computer Cost Model (APT)

-75-

SUBROUTINE PERSCOMMON F(310), TITLE(20), NAME1101. 10(3101, N44ES(310.171DIMENSION t(8)

C SUBROUTINE FOR DETERMINING PERSONNEL REQUIREMENTSCC NUMBER OF FLYING INSTRUCTORS REQUIRED

IF (F(033) .NE. DO F(221) = F(175) / F(033)NUMBER OF SIMULATOR INSTRUCTORS REQUIREDIF (F(034) .NE. 0.1 F(2221 = F(L781 / F(034)

C NUMBER OF TRAINER INSTRUCTORS REQUIREDIF (F(035) .NE. 0.) F(223) = F11811 / F(0351

C NUMBER OF GROUND-SCHOOL CCTS INSTRUCTORS REQUIREDIF (F(036) .NE. 0.1 F(221,1 = F11871 / F(0361

C NUMBER OF GROUND-SCHOOL FTD INSTRUCTORS REQUIREDIF IFI0371 .NE. DO F(225) = F(1901 / F(037)

C TOTAL INSTRUCTORS REQUIREDF12261 = FI2211 + F(222) + F(223) + F(2240 + F(225)NUMBER OF INSTRUCTOR SUPERVISORS AND ADMINISTRATIVE PERSONNEL

C REQUIRED (SQUADRON LEVEL)F(227) = F(0631 + F(064) * F(226)

C NUMBER OF ACADEMIC-PROGRAM SUPERVISORS AND ADMINISTRATIVEC PERSONNEL REQUIRED (SQUADRON LEVEL,

F(228) = F10651 + F1066) * F(161)NUMBER OF STANDARD-EVALUATION PERSONNEL REQUIREDF(229) = F(067I

C TOTAL NONSTUDENT OPERATIONS PERSONNELF(230) = F(226) + F(227) + F1228) + F(229)

C NUMBER OF MAINTENANCE PERSONNEL FOR AIRCRAFT TYPES 1, 2, AND 3DO 20 I = L, 3

F(I +230) F(/+671 * FII+196/20 CONTINUE

C TOTAL AIRCRAFT MAINTENANCE PERSONNELF12341 = F(2311 + F(2321 + F12331

C NUMBER OF SIMULATOR MAINTENANCE AND OPERATING PERSONNEL (FUNCTIONC OF NUMBER OF SIMULATORS REQUIRED)

F(2351 = F(0711 * F(208) * F1135)C NUMBER OF SIMULATOR MAINTENANCE AND OPERATING PERSONNEL (FUNCTIONC OF SIMULATOR HOURS CHARGED TO PILOT TRAINING)

IF IF(D71) .LT. 1.01 F(235) F(071) * F(220)C NUMBER OF TRAINER MAINTENANCE AND OPERATING PERSONNEL

F(236) = F10721 * F(204)C TOTAL SIMULATOR AND TRAINER MAINTENANCE AND OPERATING PERSONNEL

F(2371 = F(235) + F42361C OPERATIONS AND MAINTENANCE PERSONNEL

F12381 = F1230) + F(234) + F12371ADMINISTRATIVE PERSONNEL (0114G LEVEL)FI239I = F(0731 + F(074) * F(2381

C TOTAL STUDENT LOAD + OPERATIONS + MAINTENANCE PERSONNEL +C ADMINISTRATIVE PERSONNEL

FI2401 = F1161) + F(238) + F12391TOTAL SUPPORT PERSONNELF(2411 * F(075) + F(076) * F(2401

C TOTAL PERSONNEL CHARGEABLE TO PILOT MINING, INCLUDING STUDENTSF1242) m F1240) + F1241)

529

Page 84: DOCUMENT RESUME - ERIC · DOCUMENT RESUME ED 050 350 AC 010 343 AUTHOR Boren, H. E., Jr. TITLE The Pilot Training Study: A User's Guide to the Advanced Pilot Computer Cost Model (APT)

-76-

C TOTAL PERMANENT PARTY PERSONNELF1243) = F1242) - F(L61)

C RATED INSTRUCTDRS (TEMPORARY VALUE)TEMP = F(221) + F(222) F(223) * F(229)

C TOTAL PERMANENT PARTY OFFICERSF(244) = TEMP + F(077) * FI2241 + F(0791 * F(225) +

F(081) * F(2271 + F(063) * F(228) + F(085) * F(234) +F40871 * F(237) + F1089) * F(239) + F(09L) * F1241)

C TOTAL PERMANENT PARTY AIRMENF(245) F(078) * F1224) + F1080) * F(225) + F(082) * F(227) +

C F(084) * FI228) + F1086) * F(234) + F(088) * F(2371 +

F(090) * F(239) + F40921 * F(241)TOTAL PERMANENT PARTY MILITARY PERSONNELF(246) = F(244) + F(245)

C TOTAL CIVILIANSF(247) = F(243) - F(246)

C TOTAL PERMANENT PARTY RATED OFFICERSF(248) = F(093) * F(244) + TEMP * (1.0 - F(093)I

C TOTAL PERMANENT PARTY NONRATE) OFFICERSF1249) = F(244) - F(248)C = (1.0 + F(074)) * (1.0 + F(076))D = O.IF (F(I47) .EQ. 1.0) GO TO 40

C STUDENT LOAD CHANGEF(250) = F(1611) T(4)

C TOTAL PERSONNEL CHANGE, INCLUDING STUDENTSF1251) = F(242) - T(5)CHANGE IN TOTAL PERMANENT PARTY PERSONNELF(2521 = F(243) - T(6)

C CHANGE IN TOTAL PERMANENT PARTY MILITARY PERSONNELF(253) = F(246) - T(7)00 30 I = 1, 3

0 a 0 + ((F(I+491 - T(1)) * F(I+67) * F(I+173))30 CONTINUE

IF (F107111. .LT. 1.) 0 = 0 + (F(135) T(8)) * F(I78) * F(071)IF (F(071) .GE. I.) D = D + (F(135) - T(8)) * F(208) * F(071)

C ADJUSTMENT TO ELIMINATE EFFECT ON INVESTMENT COST OF CHANGES INC ALLOCATION FRACTIONS

40 F(255) = C * 0PERMANENT PARTY CHANGE LESS :MANGE OUE TO VARIATIONS IN ALLOCATIONFRACTIONS

F12541 = F(252) - F(255)C STORE F10501, F(051), F(052), F(161), F(242), F12431, F(246),

AND F(1135).T(1) s F(050}T(2) = F105I)T(3) = F1052)T(4) = F(l61)T(5) = F(242)T(6) a F(243)T(7) = F(246)T(8) = FIL35)RETURNEND

83

Page 85: DOCUMENT RESUME - ERIC · DOCUMENT RESUME ED 050 350 AC 010 343 AUTHOR Boren, H. E., Jr. TITLE The Pilot Training Study: A User's Guide to the Advanced Pilot Computer Cost Model (APT)

-77-

CC

C

SUBROUTINE INCOCOMMON F(310), TITLE(20), NAME(101, 13(310), NAMES(313,171

SUBROUTINE FOR DETERMINING INVESTMENT COSTS

10 DO 20 1 = I, 5

C COST OF AIRCRAFT, TRAIWAS, AND SIMULATORS TO BE PROCJREDF(I+257) = F(I+94) * F(I+2091IF (I .GT. 3) GO T3 20

C ALLOCATE AIRCRAFT PROCUkP,TAT COST TO PILOT TRAINING.F(1+2571 = F(I+257) * F(1. -9)

C COST OF AIRCRAFT SPARESF(1+2621 = F1140) * F(I+257)

20 CONTINUEC ALLOCATE SIMULATOR PROCUREMENT COST TO PILOT TRAINING.

F(261) = F(261) * F(1351C COST OF SIMULATOR SPARES

F1266) = F(100) * F(261)[F (F1147) .GT. 1.0) GO TO 30SI = O.S2 = O.

30 Si = SI + F(250)52 = 52 + F(254)F(256) = SIF(257) = 52IF (S1 .LT. F(094)) GO TO 40

C COST OF TRAINING EQUIPMENT AND SPARES FOR STUDENT LOAD INCREASEC WHEN JUSTIFIED BY THE INCREASE

F(267) = F(101) * SI * 0.001Si = O.

40 IF (S2 .LT. F(1221) GO TO 50C COST OF BASE SUPPORT MIPMENT AND SPARES FOR PERMANENT PARTYC INCREASE WHEN JUSTIFIED BY THE INCREASE

F126131 = F(123) * 52 * 0.001C COST OF SUPPLIES FOR PERMANENT PARTY 14C1E4SE WHEN JUSTIFIED dYC THE INCREASE

F(269) = F(124) * S2 * 0.001S2 = 0.

C COST OF TRAINING FOR PERMANENT PARTY INCREASE50 F(270) = F(1251 * F(254) * 0.001

C COST OF TRAVEL (PCS) FOR PERMANENT PARTY INCREAStF(271) = F(I26) * F(254) * 0.001IF (F(270) .LT. 0.) F(270) m O.IF IF(271) .LT. 0.1 F(271) = O.

C TOTAL INCREASE IN INVESTMENT COST00 60 I a 258, 271F(272) = FI2721 + F(I)

60 CONTINUERETURNEND

84

Page 86: DOCUMENT RESUME - ERIC · DOCUMENT RESUME ED 050 350 AC 010 343 AUTHOR Boren, H. E., Jr. TITLE The Pilot Training Study: A User's Guide to the Advanced Pilot Computer Cost Model (APT)

-78-

SUBROUTINE OPCOCOMMON Ff310), TITLE(20), NAMEIIO), 10(310), NAMES(31D,17)

C

C SUBROUTINE FOR CALCULATING OPERATMJ COSTSC

C DEPOT MAINTENANCE COST10 F(273) %F(102)*F(197) + F(103)*F(198) + F(1041*F(14911 * o.clat

C POL COSTF1274) = (F1105)*F(197) + F(106)*F(196) + F(107)*F(1431) * D.DD1

C MATERIAL COSTF1275) = (F(108)*F1197) + F(109)*F(198) + F(110)*F(19911 * D.D)1

C TOTAL FLYING-HOUR COSTF1276) = F(273) + F(274) + F(275)MUNITIONS COST -- LONG COURSEF(277) s F(111) * F(157) * 0.001

C MUNITIONS COST -- SHORT COURSEFf278) = F(112) * F(I58) * 0.001

C PAY -- STUDENTSF(279) = F(127) * F(161) * 0.001

C PAY -- RATED OFFICERSF(2801 = F(128) * F1248) * 0.001

C PAY -- NONRATED OFFICERSF1281) = F1129) * FI249) * 0.001

C PAY -- AIRMENF(282) = F(130) * F(245) * 0.001

C PAY -- TOTAL PERMANENT PARTY MILITARYF(283) = F(280) + F(281) + F(2821

C PAY -- TOTAL MILITARY, INCLUDING STUDENTSF(284) = F1279) + F(283)PAY CIVILIANSF(285) = F(131) * F(247) * 0.001

C TOTAL PAY -- MILITARY PLUS CIVILIANSF12861 = F(284) + FI285)TDY/PCS STUDENTSF(287) a F(113) * F(151) * 0.001

C TOY ALL PERMANENT PARTY PERSONNELF(288} s F(132) * F(2431 * 0.001

C SERVICES COSTF(289) = F(133) * F(2421 * 0.001

C OTHER SUPPLIES AND EQUIPMENT COSTSF(290) s F(134) * F(242) * 0.001

C SIMULATOR MAINTENANCE, MATERIAL, AND SERVICES COSTF(291) = F(114) * F(208) * F(I35)TRAINER MAINTENANCE, MATERIAL, AND SERVICESF(2921 Ff1451 * F(204)

C TARGET RENTALF(293) a F(115)

C SUPPORT AIR;RAFT COSTF(294) a F(136) * F(242) * 0.001

C OFFICERS TRAINING COSTF(2951 F(I37) * F(2441 * 0.001

C AIRMEN TRAINING COSTF(296) = F(1381 * F(245) * 0.001

C PERMANENT CHANGE OF STATIONF(2971 a F(119) * F(243) * 0.001

Page 87: DOCUMENT RESUME - ERIC · DOCUMENT RESUME ED 050 350 AC 010 343 AUTHOR Boren, H. E., Jr. TITLE The Pilot Training Study: A User's Guide to the Advanced Pilot Computer Cost Model (APT)

-79-

C RECURRING INVESTMENT COSTS -- AIRCRAFT TYPES 1, 21 3

F13051 = F(205) * F10951 * F(217) * F(050)F1306) = F1206) * FI096) * FI2181 * F(051)F(307) = FI2071 F(097) * F(219) * FI0521

C TOTAL AIRCRAFT RECURRING INVESTMENT COIF(309) = F(305) + FI3061 + F(307)

C TOTAL OTHER OPERATING COSTF(298) = F(277) + FI2781 + F(287) + F(2881 + F(.)89) f FI2901

C FI2911 + F(292) + F(293) + FI2941 + FI2951 + F(296) f

C F(297) + F130e)C TOTAL OPERATING COST, INCLUDING RECURRING INVESTMENT

FI2991 = F(276) + F(2861 + F(298)C OPERATING COST PER GRADUATE IS)

IF IF(I56) .NE. 0.1 FI3001 = F(299) * 1000. / F(1551C TOTAL SYSTEM COST, EXCLUDING R AND D

F1301) = F1272) + FI2991RETURNEND

86

Page 88: DOCUMENT RESUME - ERIC · DOCUMENT RESUME ED 050 350 AC 010 343 AUTHOR Boren, H. E., Jr. TITLE The Pilot Training Study: A User's Guide to the Advanced Pilot Computer Cost Model (APT)

-80-

SUBROUTINE OUTPUTCOMMON F(3101, TITLE(201, NAME(101, ID(3101 NAMES(313,17)UIMENS)ON 11112)

C

C SUBROUTINE FOR PRINTINa OUTPUTC

C FIX PAGE NUMBER.10 PAGE = F(146) + 0.5

C PRINT WEAPON SYSTEM HEADING FOR FIRST YEAR.IF (F(147) .GT. 1.0) GO TO 60IF tF(149) .EQ. 1.0) GO TO 30WRITE (6, 701 (NAME(!), I = 1, 10), !PAGE

C STEP PAGE NUMBER BY 1.!PAGE (PAGE + 1

GO TO 4530 WRITE (6, 40) (NAME(!), I = It 10)40 FORMAT (1H / 52X, 1044 29X, 821(4LL OUTPUT :OSTS EX:EPT

C OPERATING COST PEI GRADUATE ARE IN TiOUSAN)S OF DOLLARS.) / I

C PRINT SUBHEADINGS.45 WRITE (6, 50)50 FORMAT (1H / 37X, 313H40.t 6X), 50X, 214X, 4HOPER) / 21X, 3HAY3,C 4X, 4HPERM, 4X, 6HTYPE 1, 3X, 6HTYPE 2, 3X, 6HTYPE 3, 4X, 3HN3.,C 14X, 6HFLYING 13X 5HOTHER 4Xt 5HTOTAL, 4Xt 4HPLUS 2X,C 8HCOST PER / 12X, 3HNO.t 5X, 5HSTUD., 3X, 5HPARTY, 4X,C 3(4HACFTI 5X) t 4HSIMSt 5X, 3HINV, 6)(11 4HH3URt 14X, 2(4HOPER, 5X) tC 3HINtit 5X, 4HGRAD / 1Xo 4HYEAR, 6X, 4HGRAD, 5X, 4HL3AD, 4X,C 4HPERS 5X, 4(3HREQ, 6X1t 2I4HCOST, 5X), 1X, 3HPAY,C 315X, 4HCOST), 4X, 3H($1 )

C INITIALIZE LINE COUNT.LINES = 10IF (F11491 .EQ. 1.0) LINES = L2FIX DATA TO BE PRINTED.

60 11(11 = F(1501 + 0.511112) = F(156) + 0.511(3) it F(1611 + 0.511(41 = F(243) + 0.511.151 = F1272) + 0.511.(6) = F(276) + 0.511171 a F(2861 + 0.51118) F(298) + 0.5I1.191 = F(299) + 0.5IMO) = F(3011 + 0.5HIM FI300) + 0.5111121 = F(116) + 0.5IF 1LINES .LT. 581 GO TO 90

C PRINT HEADINGS AND PAGE NUMBER ON NEW PAaE.WRITE (6, 701 11AME(11, I a lo 10), (PAGE

70 FORMAT 11H1/ 52X, 1044, 27K, 5APAGE 12129X,82HIALL OUTPUT :OMCEXCEPT OPERATING COST PER GRADUATE AIE 14 TiOUSAN)S 3: DOLLARS.)/)

C STEP PAGE NUMBER BY 1.1PAGE g !PAGE I 1

80 WRITE 16, 50)C SET LINE COUNT TO 10.

LINES g 10C PRINT ALL DATA.

R7

Page 89: DOCUMENT RESUME - ERIC · DOCUMENT RESUME ED 050 350 AC 010 343 AUTHOR Boren, H. E., Jr. TITLE The Pilot Training Study: A User's Guide to the Advanced Pilot Computer Cost Model (APT)

-81-

90 IF (F(118) .EQ. 0.) WRITE (6, 100)C (F(JM. J = 205, 208), (11(J), J =

([1(J), J = 11 ft),

5, 11)IF (1-118) .EQ. 1.0) WRITE (6, 1001 I1(1), 11(2)

C

100 FORMAT (IX. 14, IX, 3118, IX), 4(F8.2, IX), 6118. IX). (8)STEP LINE COUNT BY 1.LINES = LINES + 1

IF (F(117) .EQ. 0.1 GO TO 150

C

WRITE (6, 70) (NAME([), I = 1, 10),STEP PAGE NUMBER BY I.

IPAGE

[PAGE = IPAGE + 1

WRITE (6. 110)110 FORMAT (1H0/// 58X, IIHCOMMON DUMP

C 1H3, 11X, 1H4p IIX. 1145, 11X, 1H6,C 10X, 2H10, 6X, 9HADDRESSES //)

/// 8X, [HI, 11X. 112, 11{,11X, 1H7, 11X, 1H8, 11X1 119,

C PRINT COMMON DUMP.DO 130 I = I. 310. 10

= 1 + 9

120WRITE (6, 1201 (FM. < = I, J), 1,

FORMAT (IX. 10(F11.3. IX), 2X, 14, I4)

130 CONTINUE150 IF (F1120) .EQ. 0.) GO TO 180

WRITE (6, 70) (NAME(I), I = I. 10),STEP PAGE NUMBER BY I.

IPAGE

IPAGE = IPAGE 1

WRITE 16, 155)155 FORMAT (1H 1)

ITEMS = 0C PRINT ADDRESS, NAME, AND VALUE OF EACH F V4IIABLE SO DESIGNATE).

DO 170 1 = 1, 310IF (10(1) .NE. 1) GO TO 170WRITE (6, 160) Ip (NAMES(I,J). J = 1, 17), FM

C160 FORMAT (20X, 13, 3X, 17A4, 7X, F15.5)

STEP ITEM COUNT BY 1.ITEMS = ITEMS + I

IF (ITEMS .LT. 53) GO TO 170WRITE (6, 70) INAME(.111 J = ip 101. (PAGE

C STEP PAGE NUMBER BY 1.IPAGE 2 IPAGE + 1

WRITE (6, 155)C RESET ITEM COUNT TO ZERO.

ITEMS = 0170 CONTINUE180 IF (F(117) + F11201 .EQ. 0.1 GO TO 200

IF (F(148) .EQ. 1.0) GO TO 190WRITE (6, 220) 11(12)

C SET LINE COUNT TO 45LINES 2 45GO TO 2'..0

190 WRITE (6, 70) (NAME([), 1 = 1, 10i,WRITE (6, 501

IPAGE

C STEP PAGE NUMBER BY 1.IPAGE IPAGE + 1

C SET LINE COUNT c0 10.LINES = 10GO TO 230

200 IF IF(148) .EQ. 1.01 GO TO 230

88

Page 90: DOCUMENT RESUME - ERIC · DOCUMENT RESUME ED 050 350 AC 010 343 AUTHOR Boren, H. E., Jr. TITLE The Pilot Training Study: A User's Guide to the Advanced Pilot Computer Cost Model (APT)

-82-

IF (LINES .LT. 561 GO TO 210

CWRITE 16, 70) INAME(I),STEP PAGE NUMBER BY 1.

I = 1, 101, IPAGE

IPAGE = IPAGE + 1

210 WRITE (6, 2201 II(12)220 FORMAT (1H0/ 10X, 17HR AND D COST = [B)

C FLOAT PAGE NUMBER.230 F(146) = [PAGE

IF (F(1201 .EQ. 0.1 GO TO 250OD 240 I = 1, 31010111 = 0

240 CONTINUE250 IF iF(119) .EQ. O. .AND. F(148) .NE. 3.) RETURN

CLEAR ALL WEAPON SYSTEM INPUT VARIABLES 14 COMMON.00 260 I = 1, 120FIIJ = O.

260 CONTINUEDO 270 I = 142, 144F(I) = O.F(1+75) = O.

270 CONTINUEF(1351 = O.1-11451 = O.RETURNEND

1.1! C: r ousc

JUL 1 1971

on Aduit Education

89