document deliverers with so much on the web, do we need them ? bruce antelman information express...
TRANSCRIPT
Document Document DeliverersDeliverers
With so much on the Web, do we need them ?
Bruce AntelmanInformation [email protected]
Question
•Historically - large demand for Document Delivery - purchase of individual journal articles
•Now, with so much free on web - is there still a need ?
Answer - Yes
• As long as best authors publish in for fee publications - there will be a need to purchase articles - no library can subscribe to everything - copyright in digital world is stronger
• Document Delivery is more than just Fetching an item - every institution has special needs and requirements
• Someone has to do it - as long as there is work to do outsourcing may be less expensive
Changing Situation
•But.... the landscape is changing and the need for Document Delivery may transform
•Right now Doc Del is in the midst of change from paper based to online seamless delivery
PublishPublisherer
AuthorAuthor ReaderReader
LibraryLibrary(Bibliogra(Bibliogra
phic phic Databases)Databases)
Pre-Internet (Mediated)
Document Document DeliveryDelivery
Primary Secondary
Interlibrary LoanInterlibrary Loan
Free
Fee
PublishPublisherer
AuthorAuthor ReaderReaderLibraryLibrary
--Bibliographic Bibliographic DatabasesDatabases-Document Delivery-Document Delivery
Early Internet (Unmediated)
SecondaryPrimary
Interlibrary LoanInterlibrary Loan
Free
Fee
PublishPublisherer
AuthorAuthor ReaderReaderLibraryLibrary
Free
Fee
--Publisher Web Publisher Web Sites (all types Sites (all types of media)of media)
Today Primary Secondary
PublishPublisherer
AuthorAuthor ReaderReaderLibraryLibrary
Free
Fee
--Open Access Open Access TitlesTitles
-Institutional -Institutional DepositoriesDepositories
Today Primary Secondary
--Publisher Web Publisher Web Sites (all types Sites (all types of media)of media)
PublishPublisherer
AuthorAuthor ReaderReaderLibraryLibrary
Free
Fee
--Open Access Open Access TitlesTitles
-Institutional -Institutional DepositoriesDepositories
--For Fee For Fee Bibliographic Bibliographic DatabasesDatabases-Recommender -Recommender ServicesServices
Today Primary Secondary
--Publisher Web Publisher Web Sites (all types Sites (all types of media)of media)
PublishPublisherer
AuthorAuthor ReaderReaderLibraryLibrary
Free
Fee
--Open Access Open Access TitlesTitles
-Institutional -Institutional DepositoriesDepositories
--Free Bibliographic Free Bibliographic DatabasesDatabases-Web Page -Web Page Databases Databases (Google/Yahoo (Google/Yahoo etc.)etc.)-Specialized -Specialized Digital Resource Digital Resource DatabasesDatabases
--For Fee For Fee Bibliographic Bibliographic DatabasesDatabases-Recommender -Recommender ServicesServices
Today Primary Secondary
--Publisher Web Publisher Web Sites (all types Sites (all types of media)of media)
PublishPublisherer
AuthorAuthor ReaderReaderLibraryLibrary
Free
Fee
--Open Access Open Access TitlesTitles
-Institutional -Institutional DepositoriesDepositories
--Free Bibliographic Free Bibliographic DatabasesDatabases-Google/Yahoo etc.-Google/Yahoo etc.-Specialized -Specialized Digital Resource Digital Resource DatabasesDatabases
Author Author Web Web
SitesSites
--For Fee For Fee Bibliographic Bibliographic DatabasesDatabases-Recommender -Recommender ServicesServices
Today Primary Secondary
--Publisher Web Publisher Web Sites (all types Sites (all types of media)of media)
--Free Bibliographic Free Bibliographic DatabasesDatabases-Web Page -Web Page Databases Databases (Google/Yahoo (Google/Yahoo etc.)etc.)-Specialized -Specialized Digital Resource Digital Resource DatabasesDatabases
PublisherPublisherAuthorAuthor ReaderReaderLibraryLibrary
Free
Fee
--Open Access Open Access TitlesTitles
-Institutional -Institutional DepositoriesDepositories
--Free Bibliographic Free Bibliographic DatabasesDatabases-Google/Yahoo etc.-Google/Yahoo etc.-Specialized -Specialized Digital Resource Digital Resource DatabasesDatabases
Author Author Web Web
SitesSites
--For Fee For Fee Bibliographic Bibliographic DatabasesDatabases-Recommender -Recommender ServicesServices
Primary Secondary--Free Bibliographic Free Bibliographic DatabasesDatabases-Web Page -Web Page Databases Databases Google/Yahoo etc.Google/Yahoo etc.-Specialized -Specialized Digital Resource Digital Resource DatabasesDatabases
Where is Doc Del ?
--Publisher Web Publisher Web Sites (all types Sites (all types of media)of media)
--Free Bibliographic Free Bibliographic DatabasesDatabases-Web Page Databases -Web Page Databases (Google/Yahoo etc.)(Google/Yahoo etc.)-Specialized -Specialized Digital Resource Digital Resource DatabasesDatabases
Future of Document Delivery
•Gateways - integration into many resources
•Invisible Doc Del - seamless immediate delivery from all sources
•Beyond typical STM journals - to new media and even free media
•Customized solutions - with standardized processing
Pressures for Change
• Copyright fees for STM very high - ongoing tension between publishers, libraries and authors
• Newspapers and others starting to wean Internet Users from free
• Someone will always find a way to do it Faster and Cheaper - Google & Amazon selling book chapters could become ....
• Is an iTunes for STM just around the corner ?
Conclusion• As long as there are for fee publishers
there will be Document Delivery suppliers
• Document Delivery may become “invisible” back-ends to bibliographic databases and other services with a visible “front end” for hard to find items
• If the 100% of the STM world becomes free, Document Delivery may disappear, & new types of interfaces, from databases to referral systems & more will become subscription based - will a transactional side to these tools emerge ?
Document Document DeliverersDeliverers
With so much on the Web, do we need them ?
Bruce AntelmanInformation [email protected]謝謝
謝謝