do judges deserve huge salaries ?

8/18/2019 Do Judges DESERVE huge Salaries ?

1/41

S .O .S e - Clarion Of Dalit - Weekly Newspaper On Web

Working For The Rights & Sur i al Of The Oppresse!

"!itor# N$%$R$ $.'.R( )O*.+, issue.+ ( ( . ,/,0/ ,+

Salary of Chief Justice of India Rupees 100000 per month & salary of supreme court judge Rupees 90000 per month plus 5star heritage bungalo ! 5 star air " train tra#el ! 5 star health care facility ! etc all at ta$ payers e$pense

Salary of Member of Parliament Rupees 130000 per month + grand allowances 5 star heritagebungalow , 5 star air train tra!el , 5 star health care facility , etc all at ta" payers e"pense

Can1el 2uge Salaries 3 4 ST$R perks to Supre5e Court & 2igh Court u!ges

To3

2.".2onourable 6resi!ent of 7n!ia3

Rashtrapathi 8hawan 3

New Delhi.

https://sites.google.com/site/sosevoiceforjustice/shame-shame-mps-mlas/m_parliament.jpg?attredirects=0https://sites.google.com/site/eclarionofdalit/hang-rapist-corrupt-judges/1.png?attredirects=0https://sites.google.com/site/sosevoiceforjustice/reduce-salaries-of-judges/aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa.jpg?attredirects=0


2/41

9our ":1ellen1y 3

We are seeing raise in 1ri5inali;ation of politi1s 3 entry of people with 1ri5inal ba1kgroun!s into 1ourt halls 3 Chairs of 2onourable u!ges 3 parlia5ent . We are seeing 5e!ia reports of 7llegal 3 inappropriate a1tions of


3/41

We are seeing raise in 1ri5inali;ation of politi1s 3 entry of people with 1ri5inal ba1kgroun!s into halls of parlia5ent 3 legislati e asse5blies. )ohra1o55ittee has offi1ially a1knowle!ge! 1ri5inali;ation of politi1s. Till !ate there is no a1tion plan fro5 1entral & state go ern5ents to 1urb this5ena1e. $ppropriate legal a1tions are not taken against guilty '6s '*$s. This is bringing !isrepute to whole politi1al 1lass in1lu!ing the honest &sin1ere ones.

When far5ers are 1o55itting sui1i!e unable to bear 1rop loss 3 1hil!ren are barely sur i ing on a single pie1e 5eal a !ay 3 1hil!ren !ying !ue tostar ation 3 5alnutrition 3 et1 3 our '6s 3 '*$s 1ann=t li e 4 star lifestyle at our e:pense 3 ta: payer=s e:pense.

2ereby 3 we re>uest you #

+. To re


4/41

7ne of the favors enjo#ed b# Judges for favoring criminal ne>us of ruling politicians , tacitl# aiding the crimes ofruling government is the discretionar# allotment of sites to judges b# the government$

I don’t know whether se retariat sta! of "#I o$ e % D&RP' ( DP' o$ ials are forwardin) *+ appeals for usti e , e-*ails to +ou or not. The+ will be held a ountable for their lapses if an+. This noti e is a)ainst the repeated failure of onstitutional duties % indire t

ollusion with ri*inals b+ pre ious "HIE/ #0STI"Es 1/ INDI&. Noti e is ser ed a)ainst the* , to the o$ e of "#I , N1T personall+a)ainst +ou. &t the indi idual le el I do whole heartedl+ respe t Honourable #usti e Shri T S Thakur .

Please refer two *+ appeals for usti e throu)h D&RP' 2

D3'3&(E(4567(55484

DEP1#(E(4567(559:8

In india de*o ra + is a far e , freedo* a *ira)e. the *ost basi freedo* RI'HT T1 IN/1R;&TI1N % Euer . thesepeople want ,wish *e to see dead , wish to see H0;&N RI'HTS ?&T"H losed . so that, a oi e a)ainst in usti es is silen ed fore er ,the ri*es of =$=$I$Ps losed , buried fore er.

To *+ nu*erous appeals , HR?’s appeals to +ou ,+ou ha e not +et replied. It learl+ shows that +ou are least bothered about the li esof people or usti e to the* .it pro es that +ou are hell bent to prote t the ri*inals at an+ ost. +ou are ust pressurisin) the poli e toen>uire *e ,to take *+ state*ent, to repeatedl+ all *e to poli e station all with a iew to silen e *e.all of +ou en o+ @le)al i**unit+pri ile)esA ,wh+ don’t +ou ha e )i en powers to the poli e ( in esti)atin) o$ er to su**on all of +ou for en>uir+ or else wh+ don’t allof +ou are not appearin) before the poli e oluntaril+ for en>uir+ at the least wh+ don’t all of +ou are not sendin) +our state*entabout the ase to the poli e either throu)h le)al ounsel or throu)h post +ou are aidin) ri*inals ,b+ den+in) *e ob oppurtunities in

R.B.I "0RREN"C N1TE PRESS *+sore , it+ i il ourt ,ban)alore , disti t ourt , *+sore ,et % b+ ille)all+ losin) *+ newspaper.there is a )ross, total *is*at h between +our a tions and +our oath of o$ e. this a*ounts to publi heatin) % *oral turpitude on+our part.

6.+ou are *akin) onte*pt of the er+ au)ust o$ e +ou hold.4.+ou are *akin) onte*pt of the onstitution of india.7.+ou are *akin) onte*pt of iti ens of india.

.+ou are sponsorin) % aidin) terroris* % or)ani ed ri*e.F.+ou are iolatin) the funda*ental % hu*an ri)hts of the iti ens of india and of nei)hbourin) ountries.9.+ou are iolatin) % *akin) onte*pt of the 0.N H0;&N RI'HTS "H&RTER to whi h india is a si)nator+.:.+ou are obstru tin) *e fro* perfor*in) *+ funda*ental duties as a iti en of india.

G. &s a result of +our )ross ne)li)en e of onstitutional duties +ou ha e aused *e da*a)es ( losses to the tune of R0PEES T?1"R1RE 1N3C.

Read full ase details at

https ((sites.)oo)le. o*(site(e larionofdalit( hief- usti e-terror-links

+ou are hereb+ alled upon to Pa+ da*a)es to *e and SH1?-"&0SE within 75 da+s , wh+ +ou ann’t be le)all+ prose uted for theabo e *entioned ri*es .

If i a* repeatedl+ alled to poli e station or else where for the sake of in esti)ations , the losses i do in urr as a result like loss of wa)es, transportation , ob , et *ust be borne b+ the )o ern*ent. pre oiusl+ the poli e ( IB personnel repeatedl+ alled *e the o*plainant

su!erer of in usti esJ to poli e station for >uestionin) , but ne er alled the )uilt+ ulprits e en on e to poli e station for >uestionin) ,as the ulprits are hi)h % *i)ht+ . this t+pe of one sided >uestionin) *ust not be done b+ poli e or in esti)atin) a)en ies . if an+thin)untoward happens to *e or to *+ fa*il+ *e*bers like loss of ob , *eetin) with hit % run a idents , loss of li es , et , the

urisdi tional poli e to)ether with abo e *entioned a ussed publi ser ants , "hief #usti e of India % #urisdi tional Distri t ;a)istratewill be responsible for it. E en if ri*inal ne=us le els fake har)es , poli e Kle fake ases a)ainst *e or *+ dependents to silen e *e ,this o*plaint is % will be e!e ti e.

if an+thin) untoward happens to *e or *+ dependents , the )o ern*ent of india is liable to pa+ Rs. T?1 rore as o*pensation tosur i ors of *+ fa*il+. if *+ whole fa*il+ is eli*inated b+ the ri*inal ne=us ,then that o*pensation *one+ *ust be donated toIndian &r*+ ?elfare /und. afterwards , the *one+ *ust be re o ered b+ '1I as land arrears fro* the salar+ , pension , propert+ , et of )uilt+ ud)es , poli e o$ ials , publi ser ants % "onstitutional fu tionaries. Thankin) +ou. #ai Hind , Lande ;atara*.

Date 54.57.4569MMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMM...+our’s sin erel+,Pla e ;+sore , IndiaMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMM.Na)ara a ; R

1# P$% & '($ a 'riminal )

'ase of *ence eating the crops ) uard himself stealing ) ccountability of (udges a M-S.

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA ORIGINAL JURISDICTION

http://v.v.i.ps/http://v.v.i.ps/http://v.v.i.ps/https://sites.google.com/site/eclarionofdalit/chief-justice-terror-linkshttp://v.v.i.ps/http://v.v.i.ps/https://sites.google.com/site/eclarionofdalit/chief-justice-terror-links


5/41

CRIMINAL WRIT PETITION NO. OF 2015

IN THE MATTER OF

NAGARAJA . M.R ,

edito , SOS e C!" io# o$ D"!it % SOS e &oi'e $o J()ti'e ,

* LIG 2 , No + 1 , HUDCO Fi )t St"-e , L" /i "#t"#"-" ,

He "! , M )o e 3 5+001+ , 4" #"t" " St"te

.....Petitio#e

&e )()

Ho#o( " !e C ie$ J()ti'e o$ I#di" % Ot e )

....Re)6o#de#t)

PETITION UNDER ARTICLE 12 to ARTICLE 75 % ARTICLE 51A OF THE CONSTITUTION OF INDIA FOR ISSUANCE OF A WRIT IN THE NATURE OF

MANDAMUS UNDER ARTICLE 72 % ARTICLE 22 OF THE CONSTITUTION OF INDIA.

To ,

Ho#8 !e T e C ie$ J()ti'e o$ I#di" "#d Hi) Lo d) i68) Co/6"#io#

J()ti'e) o$ t e S(6 e/e Co( t o$ I#di". T e H(/ !e 6etitio# o$ t e Petitio#e " o9e #"/ed.

MOST RESPECTFULL: SHOWETH ;

1. F"'t) o$ t e '")e;

/ur whole hearted respects to honest few in udiciary , parliament public ser!ice# /ur salutes to them , due to honest efforts of those few noblepersons only at least democracy is sur!i!ing in $ndia#

A . ("!! e)6o#)i !eto (6 o!d 'o#)tit(tio# . O#! Peo6!e , CitiBe#) o$ I#di" " e )(6 e/e No J(d-e) , No Mi#i)te ) , et' " e )(6 e/e. J(d-e) , /i#i)te ) , 6 e)ide#t et' " e "!! 6( !i')e 9"#t) 'o#)tit(tio#"!! /"#d"ted to SER&E t e 6( !i' , NOT to /")te o9e t e/. E9e# "$te e" ) o$ i#de6e#de#'e t e)e ?(d-e) , /i#i)te ) "9e #ot'o/e o(t o$ 'o!o#i"! "#-o9e i#)te"d e'o/e =o )e t e"ti#- -e#e "! 6( !i' ") t ei )e 9"#t).

C . E9e i#)tit(tio# i# i#di" i) di e't! o i#di e't! "''o(#t" !e to 6eo6!e , o=e9e ?(di'i" "!o#e i) #ot t "#)6" e#t #ot -i9i#- "''o(#t) o$ it@) "'tio#) to6eo6!e.

D . J(d-e) e#?o 5 )t" 6" % 6e ) , /" i#- /e "t t e 'o)t o$ 6eo6!e@) /o#e , 6( !i' e ' e>(e , (t " e #ot -i9i#- "''o(#t) o$ t ei "'tio#) to 6eo6!e , #ott "#)6" e#t to t e 6( !i' e e. T e " e #ot e9e# o#o( i#- RTI "66!i'"tio#) )ee i#- i#$o /"tio# " o(t "'tio#) o$ ?(d-e) , e'"()e 'o (6t ?(d-e) =i!! e '"(- t

ed "#ded.

E . J(d-e) " e #ot )(6e (/"#) #o )(6e "i#) #o $ o/ /oo# o /" ) , t e " e o di#" /o t"!) $ o/ t e )o'iet " o(#d () "#d ?()t !i e () '"6" !e o$ doi#--ood =o ") =e!! $"!!i#- 6 e to (/"# !( e) !i e i e , 'o (6tio# , $"9o iti)/ , et'.

F. J(d-e) t i# t e " e )o!e '()todi"#) o$ 'o#)tit(tio# o$ i#di" , i# $"'t e9e 'itiBe# o$ i#di" i) " '()todi"# o$ 'o#)tit(tio# o$ i#di".

G . 'ollegium of udges is nothing but a coterie , a M *$ proof & unfit corrupt persons li2e dina2aran , another udge in!ol!ed in mysore roost resortse" scandal being selected by S'$ collegium promoted to the ape" court# $t is ust the tip of iceberg , behind the udicial !eil of secrecy manycorrupt udges are hiding# ereby , $ challenge onourable supreme court of india that sub ect to conditions $ will bring to boo2 corrupt udges whoare hiding behind the !eil# re you ready )


6/41

H . W e# 'o/6" ed to )o/e 'o (6t ?(d-e) = o " e #ot i#- (t ' i/i#"!) , " d "i# , 6" ")ite) o# o( 6( !i' e ' e>(e , )o'iet , t e ' i!d =o e ) = o " e " d=o i#- e" #i#- !e)) t "# (6ee) 72 " d" " e $" ette , - e"t (/"# ei#-).

I . O$'o( )e = e# t e 'o( t ide#ti$ie) t "t i#te#tio#) o$ "# "'t o$ 6" !i"/e#t ") (#'o#)tit(tio#"! , it ") t e i- t to )t i e it do=# to (6 o!d t e )(6 e/"' o$'o#)tit(tio#. NJAC A't 6"))ed 6" !i"/e#t =") i# $"'t $i!!i#- " !e-"! 9"''(/ " o(t "''o(#t" i!it % )e!e'tio# o$ ?(d-e) "#d i# t( # )t e#-t e#i#- t e 'o#)tit(tio#o$ i#di". (t )t i i#- do=# NJAC A't o$ -o9e #/e#t o$ i#di" , )(6 e/e 'o( t o$ i#di" i) =e" e#i#- 'o#)tit(tio# o$ i#di" , /" i#- 'o#te/6t o$ 6" !i"/e#t ,'o#)tit(tio# % "!! I#di"# 'itiBe#). I$ "t "!! )(6 e/e 'o( t =") e"!! )i#'e e it 'o(!d "9e )(--e)ted /o e "!te #"ti9e) $o t "#)6" e#t , "''o(#t" !e ?(di'i" =it"66 o6 i"te t "#)6" e#t 6 o9i)io#) $o -(" di#- ?(di'i"! i#de6e#de#'e.

J . W e# -o9e #/e#t o$ i#di" 6"))ed (#'o#)tit(tio#"! "'t) !i e !"#d "'>(i)itio# i!! , )6e'i"! )t"t() to 4") /i , "-"i#)t (#i$o / 'i9i! 'ode 6 o/oted (#e>("!di$$e i#- 'i9i! !"=) $o 9" io() e!i-io# 6eo6!e "#d o6"! -") 9i'ti/) "'t , #('!e" e#e - "'t , et' , did it #ot d"=# o# )(6 e/e 'o( t o$ i#di" t "t it i) t e )o!e'()todi"# o$ 'o#)tit(tio# t e# = #ot SCI )t i e do=# t o)e (#'o#)tit(tio#"! 6" !i"/e#t" "'t)

4 . $t is the duty of Supreme 'ourt of $ndia to Protect , uard the constitutional rights of e!ery $ndian citi4ens # Since 5 years $ am appealing to S'$about issues concerning public welfare , national security , etc and as a result suffering in ustices , my constitutional rights , human rights arerepeatedly !iolated but S'$ is mum e!en when repeated appeals were made to it# Parado"ically , after these appeals for ustice , $ ha!e suffered morein ustices , attempts on my life were made , physically assaulted , li!elihood obs were denied , news publication closed , press accreditationdenied , recei!ed threatening calls , blan2 calls, e!en to date rough elements follow us , rough elements scout near home at mid night# 6oes notthese indicate some ties between rough elements S'$ (udges )

L . E9e#t o(- t e i#$o /"tio# i) e"di! "9"i!" !e =it SCI , i#$o /"tio# =") de#ied 'iti#- (#"9"i!" i!it . I$ "t "!! i#$o /"tio# i) #ot t (! "9"i!" !e , = did#@t t eCPIO TRANSFER ti "66!i'"tio# to 'o#'e #ed de6" t/e#t) o$ SCI , Mi#i)t o$ L"= , J()ti'e , Re)6e'ti9e Hi- Co( t) , et'.

M . Doe) #ot 'o( t "d/i#i)t" "ti9e o$$i'e 6o)e)) SER&ICE REECORDS o$ e"' e/6!o ee i#'!(di#- ?(d-e). I$ #ot o# = "t ")i) t e -i9e 6 o/otio#) ,t "#)$e ) , )"!" , et' to ?(d-e) T e 6e )o# = o 6o)e)) SR '"# -i9e i#$o /"tio# " o(t -(i!t ?(d-e). W CPIO #ot ") i#- t "t 6e )o# to ) " e i#$o /"tio#

N . I$ " 'o//o#/"# i) "!!e-ed o$ " 6ett ' i/e e i) i//edi"te! " e)ted , 6(t e i#d " ). Po!i'e )6e#d t o()"#d) o$ (6ee) $o i#9e)ti-"tio# to 6 o)e'(te t "t6ett ' i/i#"!. J(d-e) )6e#d o( ) to e" t "t '")e % 6 e6" e ?(d-e/e#t) (##i#- i#to te#) o$ 6"-e) )o/eti/e) e9e# o9e % " o9e t o()"#d 6"-e). Fi#e .W e# t e 9e )"/e 6o!i'e % ?(d-e t e/)e!9e) 'o//itt - "9e ' i/e) det i/e#t"! to #"tio#"! )e'( it , i#te- it , et' , #o " e)t) , #o 6 o)e'(tio# o#! 'o9e (6 ,WH: A e J(d-e) % Po!i'e " o9e L"= I) J(d-e@) MAFIA "t 6!"

O . T e "'tio# o$ CPIO SCI "/o(#t) to 'o9e (6 o$ ?(d-e) % t ei ' i/e). T e e , CPIO i) "!)o 'o//itti#- " ' i/e. Wit e)6e't to 6 e9io() RTI A66e"!) "!)oCPIO % RTI Fi )t A66e!!"te A(t o it SCI "9e e6e"ted! 'o//itted ' i/e) 'o9e i#- (6 ?(d-e) % t ei ' i/e). i!!io#) o$ i#di"#) " e " e! )()t"i#i#- o# ")i#-!e 6ie'e /e"! " d" , =e !o=e /idd!e '!")) 6eo6!e toi!i#- " d to e" # " $e= (#d ed) o$ (6ee) (t )ti!! 6" i#- t" . I) it #ot ) "/e to t e/ ) "/e toJUDGE) t "t t e d "= 6" % 6e ) "/o(#ti#- to !" ) o$ (6ee) $ o/ o( /o#e , $ o/ t" e) 6"id () )ti!! #ot do t ei 'o#)tit(tio#"! d(tie) 6 o6e ! .

P . 7hen a (udge imself 'ommits 'rime , 7hen a P/%$'8 imself robs , Murders 9#

T e 6( !i' )e 9"#t) % t e -o9e #/e#t /()t e o!e /ode!) i# !"= " idi#- "'t) , $o ot e ) to e/(!"te % $o!!o=. i$ " )t(de#t /" e) " /i)t" e it i) e '()" !e % '"#e 'o e'ted t e te"' e . i$ t e te"' e i/)e!$ /" e) " /i)t" e , "!! i) )t(de#t) =i!! do t e )"/e /i)t" e. i$ " t ie$ )te"!) , e '"# e '"(- t , !e-"!!

6(#i) ed % e$o /ed . i$ " 6o!i'e i/)e!$ 'o//it) ' i/e , /"# t ie9e) -o )'ot $ ee (#de i) 6"t o#"-e. e9e# i$ " 6o!i'e , 6( !i' )e 9"#t 'o//it) " ' i/e , e '"#e !e-"!! 6 o)e'(ted % ?()ti'e '"# e )o(- t t e "-- ie9ed.

?()t t i# , i$ " ?(d-e i/)e!$ t "t too "6e 'o( t o$ t e !"#d it)e!$ 'o//it) ' i/e 9io!"tio#) o$ RTI A't , 'o#)tit(tio#"! i- t) % (/"# i- t) o$ 6( !i' "#d o )t ('t)t e 6( !i' $ o/ 6e $o /i#- t ei 'o#)tit(tio#"! $(#d"/e#t"! d(tie) , = "t "66e#)

it -i9e) " oo)te do)e to t e i' % /i- t , t o)e i# 6o=e , ' i/i#"!) i# 6( !i' )e 9i'e to 'o//it /o e ' i/e). t "t i) e "'t! = "t i) "66e#i#- i# i#di". t eed('"ted 6( !i' /()t "i)e to t e o''")io# % 6e"'e$(!! , de/o' "ti'"!! /()t o66o)e t i) ' i/i#"!iB"tio# o$ ?(di'i" , 6( !i' )e 9i'e. t e# "!o#e , =e '"# (i!d "RAM RAJ:A OF MAHATMA GANDHI8S DREAM.

I "9e ) o=# i# t e $o!!o=i#- "tt"' /e#t o= ?()ti'e i) o(- t , 6( ' ")ed , /"#i6(!"ted i# INDIA =it "'t("! '")e). J()t )ee t e e'e#t e "/6!e) o$)(6 e/e 'o( t ?(d-e) i#9o!9ed i# )e ("! "))"(!t '")e % ROOST Re)o t M )o e Se )'"#d"! i#9o!9i#- ?(d-e) , i$ "# o di#" $e!!o= "d 'o//itted t e)"/e ' i/e) e =o(!d "9e ee# "(!ed o9e t e 'o"! $i e. J()t t" e "#ot e e'e#t e "/6!e o$ P i)o#e Mo9ie "'to )"#?" d(tt , TADA 6 o9i)io#) =e e

di!(ted t e ?(d-e to $"9o( i/ "#d #o= e i) -etti#- 6" o!e =ee "$te =ee = i!e t e o di#" 'o#9i't) #e9e -et " )i#-!e 6" o!e t o(- t t ei )e#te#'e. W "t i!!i"#t J(d-e) , = "t i!!i"#t 6o!i'e )i ?i.

2. (e)tio# ) o$ L"=;

A e J(d-e) " o9e L"= % '"# -o )'ot $ ee C"# ?(d-e) ' e"t , "6e , )=i#d!e ot e ) "#d -o )'ot $ ee =it o(t !e-"! 6 o)e'(tio# W -(i!t CJI) =e e #ot!e-"!! 6 o)e'(ted i# " $"i % t "#)6" e#t /"##e

7. G o(#d);

Re>(e)t) $o e>(it" !e ?()ti'e , $ ee e 6 e))io# % 6 ote'tio# to !i$e % !i e t . T "#)6" e#' , "''o(#t" i!it i# )e!e'tio# % $(#'tio#i#- o$ J(d-e).

. A9e /e#t;

GI&E WHAT ACTION HAS EEN TA4EN AGAINST THE GUILT: JUDGES MENTIONED IN THE ELOW MENTIONED WE SITES % FOLLOWING ARTICLES.

We )"!(te o#e)t $e= i# 6( !i' )e 9i'e , J(di'i" , 6o!i'e , 6" !i"/e#t % )t"te !e-i)!"ti9e "))e/ !ie). o( = o!e e" ted e)6e't) to t e/. HERE : , I DOHUM L: RE UEST :OU TO GI&E ME WRITTEN STATEMENTS ANSWERS TO THE FOLLOWING UESTIONS 3 WHICH IN ITSELF ie "#)=e ) ARE THEINFORMATION SOUGHT : ME. HERE WITH I AM SEE4ING NOT THE OPINIONS A OUT SOME H:POTHETICAL ISSUES , UT :OUR OFFICIAL STAND ,LEGAL STAND ON ISSUES WHICH ARE OF FRE UENT OCCURRENCE WHICH ARE &IOLATING PEOPLE@S FUNDAMENTAL RIGHTS % HUMAN RIGHTS.WE DO HA&E HIGHEST RESPECTS FOR JUDICIAR: % ALL PU LIC INSTITUTIONS , THIS IS AN APPEAL FOR TRUTH , INFORMATION SO THAT TO

APPREHEND CORRUPT FEW IN PU LIC SER&ICE, WHO ARE AIDING % A ETTING TERRORISM , UNDERWORLD % CRIMINALS. I HA&E SHOWN IN


7/41

DETAIL WITH LI&E , ACTUAL CASES , EKAMPLES , HOW INDIAN LEGAL S:STEM IS MANIPULATED : CRIMINALS WITHIN JUDICIAR: , POLICE ,PROSECUTION , ETC. READ DETAILS AT ;

H"!$ o$ $o /e CJI) Co (6t ;

tt6); )ite).-oo-!e.'o/ )ite )o)e9oi'e$o ?()ti'e "!$ o$ $o /e '?i) 'o (6t ,

tt6); )ite).-oo-!e.'o/ )ite e'!" io#o$d"!it = ee!i#- de"!i#- ?(d-e) 6o!i'e ,

At o'itie) o# Wo/e# JUDGES

tt6); )ite).-oo-!e.'o/ )ite e'!" io#o$d"!it "t o'itie) ?(d-e)

A 3 o$ M"#i6(!"tio# o$ I#di"# Le-"! S )te/

tt6; ===.)' i d.'o/ do' 1 +5+520 A o$ M"#i6(!"tio# o$ I#di" Le-"! S )te/ ,

tt6; ===.)' i d.'o/ do' 1+7 5 5 1 C ie$ J()ti'e o$ I#di" A C i/i#"! ,

J()ti'e S"t ")i9"/ A e o( DEAF DUM % LIND

tt6); )ite).-oo-!e.'o/ )ite e'!" io#o$d"!it ?()ti'e )"t ")i9"/ " e o( de"$ d(/ !i#d ,

R"?i9 G"#d i A))"))i#"tio# Co9e (6

tt6); )ite).-oo-!e.'o/ )ite )o)e9oi'e$o ?()ti'e "?i9 -"#d i "))"))i#"tio# 'o9e (6 ,

SHAME SHAME MP) % MLA)

tt6); )ite).-oo-!e.'o/ )ite )o)e9oi'e$o ?()ti'e ) "/e ) "/e /6) /!") ,

JUDGE) o o e ) o$ J()ti'e

tt6); )ite).-oo-!e.'o/ )ite )o)e9oi'e$o ?()ti'e ?(d-e) o o e ) o$ ?()ti'e ,

RTI % L"#d Go!/""!

tt6); )ite).-oo-!e.'o/ )ite )o)e9oi'e$o ?()ti'e ti !"#d -o!/""! i# " #"t" " ,

tt6); )ite).-oo-!e.'o/ )ite )o)e9oi'e$o ?()ti'e !"#d - " e ) i# / ( d " ,

tt6); )ite).-oo-!e.'o/ )ite )o)e9oi'e$o ?()ti'e ?(d-e) 'o9e (6 !"#d )'"/) ,

W NOT 7 d de- ee To t( e o$ Co (6t Do'to ) , Po!i'e % J(d-e)

tt6; e '!" io#o$d"!it. !o-)6ot.i# 2015 10 = #ot 7 d de- ee to t( e o$ do'to ). t/!*!i# ) ,

tt6); )ite).-oo-!e.'o/ )ite )o)e9oi'e$o ?()ti'e 7 d de- ee to t( e do'to ) 6o!i'e ,

He e , =e do e>(e)t CPIO O O Ho#o( " !e C ie$ J()ti'e o$ I#di" , S(6 e/e Co( t o$ I#di" , Ne= De! i to "#)=e t e $o!!o=i#- >(e)tio#) i# 6( !i' i#te e)t , $o)"$e-(" di#- #"tio#"! )e'( it , N"tio#"! (#it % i#te- it % to !e-"!! "66 e e#d "#ti #"tio#"!) , ' i/i#"!) =it i# t e ?(di'i" % 6o!i'e. J(d-e) " e #ot )(6e io

(/"# ei#-) , )o/e o$ t e/ "9e e9e# e'"/e ?(d-e) t o(- de9io() /e"#) ot e t "# /e it , i#te- it . J(d-e) " e 6( !i' )e 9"#t) d "=i#- )"!" % 6e )$ o/ 6( !i' e ' e>(e "#d "''o(#t" !e to 6( !i' ") "# ot e 'o//o# /"# i).

We )"!(te o( $ eedo/ $i- te ) , /i!it" 6e )o##e! % /" t ) $o "!! t e )"' i$i'e) /"de t e/. Let () (i!d " )t o#- , Se'(!" , De/o' "ti' I#di" -etti#- id o$$

$e= 'o (6t e!e/e#t) , "#ti #"tio#"!) , t "ito ) "/o#- 6( !i' )e 9"#t) , "/o#- ?(di'i" % "/o#- 6o!i'e = o " e - e"te t e"t to I#di"@) (#it % i#te- it t "#P" i)t"#i te o i)t) o ' i#e)e /i!it" .

I#$o /"tio# i#6(t $o /) 6" t o$ 6 o'e)) o$ o#e@) e 6 e))io#. O#e@) e 6 e))io# i# "# $o /) 3 = itte# , o "! , et' e'o/e) i#$o /"tio# i#6(t to t e o66o)ite 6e )o# ,i# t( # e e 6 e))e) i) e6! . I#$o /"tio# % E 6 e))io# " e i#)e6" " !e 6" t) % $o / !i$e!i#e o$ " de/o' "' . T "t i) t e e")o# , Ri- t to E 6 e))io# i) t e ")i'$(#d"/e#t"! i- t ") =e!! ") (/"# i- t o$ e9e I#di"# 'itiBe#. W e# " 6e )o#@) i- t to e 6 e))io# i) 9io!"ted , i) ot e i- t) to e>("!it , ?()ti'e , et' "!)o " e9io!"ted. S(66 e))io# o$ I#$o /"tio# "/o(#t) to '( i#- o$ E 6 e))io#.

I# " de/o' "' , 6eo6!e "9e " i- t to #o= o= t e 6( !i' )e 9"#t) " e $(#'tio#i#-. Ho=e9e ti!! d"te 6( !i' )e 9"#t) " e idi#- e i#d t e 9ei! o$ O$$i'i"!)Se' et) A't = i' i) o$ iti) 9i#t"-e ' e"ted iti) to )(66 e)) #"ti9e i#di"#) . t i) 'o9e (6 6( !i' )e 9"#t) " e idi#- t ei o=# 'o (6tio# , ' i/e) ,/i)/"#"-e/e#t , $"i!( e) , et'. e9e# RTI A't i) #ot ei#- $o!!o=ed i#toto 6( !i' )e 9"#t). Ho=e9e t e e'e#t de! i i- 'o( t (!i#- "$$i /i#- t "t CJI i) (#deRTI 6( 9ie= % o(#d to "#)=e RTI e>(e)t , i) #ote=o t .

O( 6 e9io() RTI e>(e)t to CJI , (#io# o/e )e' et" o$ GOI, P e)ide#t o$ I#di" , DG % IGP o$ GO4 "#d ot e ) =e e #ot o#o ed. T e i#$o /"tio# I )o(- t =e e"#)=e ) to t e $o!!o=i#- >(e)tio#) /e#tio#ed i# t e e!o= /e#tio#ed =e )ite) . t e >(e)tio#) 'o#'e #ed t e 6")t , 6 e)e#t 'o#ti#(i#- i#?()ti'e) /eted o(t to/i!!io#) o$ I#di"# 'itiBe#) , d(e to = o#- i!!e-"! =o 6 "'ti'e) o$ I#di"# ?(d-e) , 6o!i'e % 6( !i' )e 9"#t) . T e i#$o /"tio# =e )o(- t =o(!d e 6o)e t e t "ito ) ,"#ti #"tio#"!) , ' i/i#"!) i# 6( !i' )e 9i'e. T e i#$o /"tio# =e " e )ee i#- " e #o de$e#)e )e' et) , #o #"tio#"! )e' et). T e t (t $(! i#$o /"tio# e 6o)e) t e "#ti#"tio#"!) , t "ito ) i# t e 6( !i' )e 9i'e % )t e#-t e#) o( #"tio#"! )e'( it , #"tio#"! (#it % i#te- it .

He e , i do e>(e)t t e o#o( " !e )(6 e/e 'o( t o$ i#di" , $o " S(6 e/e Co( t /o#ito ed C I E#>(i i#to t i) = o!e i))(e ") " #"t" " 6o!i'e " e e!6!e)) ,t e do#8t "9e !e-"! 6o=e ) to 6 o)e'(te i- % /i- t , 'o#)tit(tio#"! $(#'tio#" ie). T e "9e #ot e9e# e#>(i ed t e -(i!t &&IP) e9e# o#'e o=e9e U#de6 e))( e $ o/ i- e (6) t e e6e"ted! '"!!ed /e t e 'o/6!"i#"#t to 6o!i'e )t"tio# too )t"te/e#t) $ o/ /e "!! $o '!o)i#- t e $i!e).

https://sites.google.com/site/sosevoiceforjustice/half-of-former-cjis-corrupthttps://sites.google.com/site/eclarionofdalit/wheeling-dealing-judges-policehttps://sites.google.com/site/eclarionofdalit/atrocities-by-judgeshttps://sites.google.com/site/eclarionofdalit/atrocities-by-judgeshttp://www.scribd.com/doc/187575206/A-Z-of-Manipulation-of-India-Legal-Systemhttp://www.scribd.com/doc/173854541/Chief-Justice-of-India-A-Criminalhttps://sites.google.com/site/eclarionofdalit/justice-sathasivam---are-you-deaf-dumb-blindhttps://sites.google.com/site/eclarionofdalit/justice-sathasivam---are-you-deaf-dumb-blindhttps://sites.google.com/site/sosevoiceforjustice/rajiv-gandhi-assassination-cover-uphttps://sites.google.com/site/sosevoiceforjustice/rajiv-gandhi-assassination-cover-uphttps://sites.google.com/site/sosevoiceforjustice/shame-shame-mps-mlashttps://sites.google.com/site/sosevoiceforjustice/shame-shame-mps-mlashttps://sites.google.com/site/sosevoiceforjustice/judges-or-brokers-of-justicehttps://sites.google.com/site/sosevoiceforjustice/rti-land-golmaal-in-karnatakahttps://sites.google.com/site/sosevoiceforjustice/land-grabbers-in-m-u-d-ahttps://sites.google.com/site/sosevoiceforjustice/land-grabbers-in-m-u-d-ahttps://sites.google.com/site/sosevoiceforjustice/judges-cover-up-land-scamshttps://sites.google.com/site/sosevoiceforjustice/judges-cover-up-land-scamshttp://e-clarionofdalit.blogspot.in/2015/10/why-not-3rd-degree-torture-of-doctors.html#linkshttp://e-clarionofdalit.blogspot.in/2015/10/why-not-3rd-degree-torture-of-doctors.html#linkshttps://sites.google.com/site/sosevoiceforjustice/3rd-degree-torture-by-doctors-policehttps://sites.google.com/site/sosevoiceforjustice/half-of-former-cjis-corrupthttps://sites.google.com/site/eclarionofdalit/wheeling-dealing-judges-policehttps://sites.google.com/site/eclarionofdalit/atrocities-by-judgeshttp://www.scribd.com/doc/187575206/A-Z-of-Manipulation-of-India-Legal-Systemhttp://www.scribd.com/doc/173854541/Chief-Justice-of-India-A-Criminalhttps://sites.google.com/site/eclarionofdalit/justice-sathasivam---are-you-deaf-dumb-blindhttps://sites.google.com/site/sosevoiceforjustice/rajiv-gandhi-assassination-cover-uphttps://sites.google.com/site/sosevoiceforjustice/shame-shame-mps-mlashttps://sites.google.com/site/sosevoiceforjustice/judges-or-brokers-of-justicehttps://sites.google.com/site/sosevoiceforjustice/rti-land-golmaal-in-karnatakahttps://sites.google.com/site/sosevoiceforjustice/land-grabbers-in-m-u-d-ahttps://sites.google.com/site/sosevoiceforjustice/judges-cover-up-land-scamshttp://e-clarionofdalit.blogspot.in/2015/10/why-not-3rd-degree-torture-of-doctors.html#linkshttps://sites.google.com/site/sosevoiceforjustice/3rd-degree-torture-by-doctors-police


8/41

He e , I do e>(e)t t e o#o " !e )(6 e/e 'o( t o$ I#di" to 'o#)ide t i) ") " PIL $o ; = it o$ M"#d"/() "#d to i))(e i#)t ('tio#) to t e 'o#'e #ed 6( !i')e 9"#t) i# t e $o!!o=i#- '")e) to 6e $o / t ei d(tie) % to "#)=e t e >(e)tio#).

T e Petitio#e ") )e#t /"# !ette ) "66e"!) 6etitio#) to )(6 e/e 'o( t o$ i#di" % ot e 'o( t) t o(- e /"i! , DARPG =e )ite % t o(- e-(!" /"i!e>(e)ti#- t e/ to 'o#)ide t o)e ") PIL). (t #o#e o$ t e/ =e e "d/itted , e9e# "' #o=!ed-e/e#t $o e'ei6t) =e e #ot -i9e#. See Ho= d(t 'o#)'io() ,o(

?(d-e) " e % )ee o= o( ?(d-e) " e )e#)iti9e to=" d) !i$e , !i e t o$ 'itiBe#) , 'o//o#/e# % )ee o= '" e!e)) o( ?(d-e) " e to=" d) "#ti #"tio#"! ' i/e) ,' i/e) =o t ' o e) o$ (6ee).

T "t t e 6 e)e#t 6etitio#e ") #ot $i!ed "# ot e 6etitio# = i' " e "d/itted 'o( t) i# "# Hi- Co( t o t e S(6 e/e Co( t o$ I#di" o# t e )( ?e't /"tte o$t e 6 e)e#t 6etitio#.

PRA:ER;

I# t e " o9e 6 e/i)e), it i) 6 " ed t "t t i) Ho#8 !e Co( t /" e 6!e")ed;

i He e , I do e>(e)t t e o#o " !e )(6 e/e 'o( t o$ I#di" to 'o#)ide t i) ") " PIL $o ; = it o$ M"#d"/() "#d to i))(e i#)t ('tio#) to t e 'o#'e #ed 6( !i')e 9"#t) i# t e $o!!o=i#- '")e) to 6e $o / t ei d(tie) % to "#)=e t e >(e)tio#).

ii He e , I do e>(e)t t e o#o( !e )(6 e/e 'o( t o$ i#di" to /" e 6( !i' "!! t e 6 o'eedi#-) o$ )(6 e/e 'o( t 'o!!e-i(/) "#d 'o e)6o#de#'e et=ee#

SCI , P e)ide#t@) o$$i'e % -o9e #/e#t o$ i#di" e-" di#- )e!e'tio# o$ ?(d-e). To /" e 6( !i' "!! t e e!i-i i!it ' ite i" $o!!o=ed $o )e!e'tio# o$ ?(d-e) "#d = o $i!!ed= "t ' ite i" , = o did#@t $i!! = i' ' ite i" "#d t e $i#"! "# i#-.

iii He e , I do e>(e)t t e o#o( !e )(6 e/e 'o( t o$ i#di" to (6 o!d t e 'o#)tit(tio# o$ i#di" "#d to 6 ote't t e 'o#)tit(tio#"! i- t) o$ "!! I#di"# 'itiBe#)i#'!(di#- /i#e.

i9 He e , I do e>(e)t t e o#o( !e )(6 e/e 'o( t o$ i#di" to (6 o!d t e 'o#)tit(tio# o$ i#di" , to 6 ote't t e 'o#)tit(tio#"! i- t) , (/"# i- t) o$ "!! I#di"#'itiBe#) i#'!(di#- /i#e "#d to e#" !e , $"'i!it"te "!! I#di"# 'itiBe#) to 6e $o / t ei F(#d"/e#t"! D(tie) ") 6e 'o#)tit(tio#.

9 to 6")) )(' ot e o de ) "#d $( t e o de ) ") /" e dee/ed #e'e))" o# t e $"'t) "#d i# t e 'i '(/)t"#'e) o$ t e '")e.

Re"d ; tt6); )ite).-oo-!e.'o/ )ite )o)e9oi'e$o ?()ti'e 6i! = it o$ /"#d"/() 1 ,

FOR WHICH ACT OF 4INDNESS, THE PETITIONER SHALL E DUT: OUND, E&ER PRA:.

D"te ; 2 t O'to e 2015 Fi!ed ; N"-" "?".M.R.

P!"'e ; M )( ( I#di" Petitio#e i# 6e )o#

# P$% : 7hy ;/. 3 rd degree .orture , 6eath Sentence to 'orrupt (udges , Police 6octors



IN THE MATTER OF

NAGARAJA . M.R

edito SOS e C!" io# o$ D"!it % SOS e &oi'e $o J()ti'e* LIG 2 , No + 1 ,, HUDCO Fi )t St"-e , L" /i "#t"#"-" ,He "! , M )o e 3 5+001+ , 4" #"t" " St"te.....Petitio#e

&e )()

Ho#o( " !e C ie$ J()ti'e o$ I#di" , S(6 e/e Co( t o$ I#di" % Ot e )

....Re)6o#de#t)

PETITION UNDER ARTICLE 12 to ARTICLE 75 % ARTICLE 51A OF THE CONSTITUTION OF INDIA FOR ISSUANCE OF A WRIT IN THE NATUREOF MANDAMUS UNDER ARTICLE 72 % ARTICLE 22 OF THE CONSTITUTION OF INDIA.

To ,Ho#8 !e T e C ie$ J()ti'e o$ I#di" "#d Hi) Lo d) i68) Co/6"#io#J()ti'e) o$ t e S(6 e/e Co( t o$ I#di".

https://sites.google.com/site/sosevoiceforjustice/pil---writ-of-mandamus-1https://sites.google.com/site/sosevoiceforjustice/pil---writ-of-mandamus-1


9/41

T e H(/ !e 6etitio# o$ t e Petitio#e " o9e #"/ed.


1. F"'t) o$ t e '")e;(it" !e ?()ti'e (#de 'o#)tit(tio# o$ i#di" ") i#di" i) "!)o " )i-#"to o$UN H(/"# Ri- t) C " te .

A!! H(/"# ei#-) " e -(" "#teed =it (/"# i- t) o$ !i$e , !i e t , e"!t , )"$et , e>(it" !e ?()ti'e 9i t(e o$ t ei i t it)e!$ i e)6e'ti9e o$ "#'o#)tit(tio#"! odie) o )t"t(to odie).

Re>(e)t) $o e>(it" !e ?()ti'e , P o)e'(tio# o$ 'o (6t 6( !i' )e 9"#t) , 'o (6t do'to ) , 'o (6t ?(d-e) , 'o (6t 6o!i'e. Re>(e)t $o )(6 e/e 'o( t o de ) todo'to ) , ?(d-e) % 6o!i'e to 6e $o / t ei d(tie) 6 o6e ! .

. A9e /e#t;


PRA:ER;I# t e " o9e 6 e/i)e), it i) 6 " ed t "t t i) Ho#8 !e Co( t /" e 6!e")ed;

" . He e , I do e>(e)t t e o#o " !e )(6 e/e 'o( t o$ I#di" to 'o#)ide t i) ") " PIL $o ; = it o$ M"#d"/() "#d to i))(e i#)t ('tio#) to t e 'o#'e #ed 6( !i')e 9"#t) i# t e $o!!o=i#- '")e) to 6e $o / t ei d(tie) % to "#)=e t e >(e)tio#).

. to 6")) )(' ot e o de ) "#d $( t e o de ) ") /" e dee/ed #e'e))" o# t e $"'t) "#d i# t e 'i '(/)t"#'e) o$ t e '")e.

'. to 'o#)tit(te i/6" ti"! )t"t(to i#9e)ti-"tio# 'o//ittee 'o/6 i)i#- NGO) , 6 e)) , 6o!i'e % ?(di'i" "t t"!( !e9e!) to i#9e)ti-"te '")e) o$ 7 d de- ee to t( e !"= e#$o 'e/e#t "-e#'ie) . E))e#ti"!! t e)e 'o//ittee) /()t i#'!(de " /e/ e $ o/ 9i'ti/@) )ide d( i#- i#9e)ti-"tio# % 6 o)e'(tio#. T e )t"te -o9e #/e#t

/()t e" t e 'o)t o$ it@) $(#'tio#i#- i#'!(di#- t "#)6o t"tio# , $ood , e/(#e "tio# "t "'t("! "te.

d. I# t e '")e) o$ 7 d de- ee to t( e , $" e e#'o(#te ) , t e e /()t e 6 o9i)io# $o 2 #d , 7 d /edi'"! e "/i#"tio# , /edi'"! o6i#io# do'to ) "66oi#ted i#9e)ti-"tio# 'o//ittee.

e. = e# -o9e #/e#t do'to ) " e '"(- t -i9i#- $"!)e 6o)t /o te/ e6o t) , $"!)e /edi'"! o6i#io#) t e /()t e di)/i))ed $ o/ )e 9i'e "#d !e-"!! 6 o)e'(ted$o " etti#- to t( e , "tte/6t to /( de o /( de ") t e '")e /" e.

$. = e# 6o!i'e , ?"i! )t"$$ o !"= e#$o 'i#- 6e )o##e! " e '"(- t $o 6 )i'"!! % /e#t"!! to t( i#- " (/"# ei#- , "# (#de t i"! o 'o#9i't t e /()t edi)/i))ed $ o/ )e 9i'e "#d !e-"!! 6 o)e'(ted $o " etti#- to t( e , "tte/6t to /( de o /( de ") t e '")e /" e.

-. = e# " ?(d-e i) '"(- t $o -i9i#- i")ed ?(di'i"! o de =it o(t e "/i#i#- t e 9e "'it o$ e9ide#'e) , )t"te/e#t) , e6o t) -i9e# 6o!i'e , !"= e#$o 'e/e#t6e )o##e! , do'to ) , = e# " ?(d-e ")e) i) ?(di'i"! o de ) o# $o 'ed 'o#$e))io#) t" e# $ o/ (#de t i"!) , 'o#9i't) 7 d de- ee to t( e /et od) , t o)e ?(d-e) /()t e di)/i))ed $ o/ )e 9i'e "#d !e-"!! 6 o)e'(ted $o " etti#- to t( e , "tte/6t to /( de o /( de ") t e '")e /" e.


10/41

. = e# " ?(d-e $"i!) to 6 ote't !i$e , e"!t , )"$et o$ " 6 i)o#e , = et e (#de t i"! o 'o#9i't , t o)e ?(d-e) /()t e di)/i))ed $ o/ )e 9i'e "#d !e-"!!6 o)e'(ted $o " etti#- to t( e , "tte/6t to /( de o /( de ") t e '")e /" e.

I . ") 7 d de- ee to t( e , $" e e#'o(#te ) " e 6 e /edit"ted , 'o!d !ooded /( de ) , ei#o() ' i/e) , t e " e " e)t o$ " e '")e) "#d ?(d-e) , 6o!i'e , !"=e#$o 'e/e#t o$$i'i"!) , do'to ) " etti#- , e e'(ti#- 7 dde- ee to t( e , $" e e#'o(#te ) /()t e "#-ed ti!! de"t . T e " e =o )e t "# 4ASA .

?. t e )t"te -o9e #/e#t /()t -i9e -o9e #/e#t ?o to o#e $ o/ 9i'ti/@) $"/i! "#d /()t 6" 'o/6e#)"tio# "t "'t("! !i9i#- 'o)t !e9e!) to t "t $"/i! .

. t e -o9e #/e#t /()t e'o9e t "t 'o/6e#)"tio# 'o)t $ o/ )"!" , 6e#)io# , 6 o6e tie) o$ -(i!t ?(d-e) , 6o!i'e , et' ") !"#d " e" ).

!. to !e-"!! 6 o)e'(te (#de /( de ' " -e) STF 6o!i'e , $o e)t o$$i'i"!) = o =e e e)6o#)i !e $o 7 d de- ee to t( e , e#'o(#te de"t ) o$ t i "!) i# MM Hi!!) ,4" #"t" " d( i#- o6e "tio# #" 9ee "66"#.

/. to !e-"!! 6 o)e'(te (#de /( de ' " -e) ?(d-e) = o $"i!ed to 6 ote't t e !i9e) o$ (#de t i"!) , 'o#9i't) i# o6e "tio# #" 9ee "66"#.

#. to !e-"!! 6 o)e'(te (#de /( de ' " -e) -o9e #/e#t do'to ) = o -"9e $"!)e 6o)t /o te/ e6o t) , $"!)e /edi'"! o6i#io#) " o(t $" e e#'o(#te ) ,7 d de- ee to t( e o$ t i "!) i# o6e "tio# #" 9ee "66"#.

o . to 6")) )(' ot e o de ) "#d $( t e o de ) ") /" e dee/ed #e'e))" o# t e $"'t) "#d i# t e 'i '(/)t"#'e) o$ t e '")e.


D"ted ; 10t

De'e/ e 2015 .FILED :; NAGARAJA.M.R.

P!"'e ; M )( ( , I#di" .PETITIONER IN PERSON

3# P$%


11/41

1. F"'t) o$ t e '")e;

". I#e>("!it i# )o'iet , (#?()t !"=) , (#?()t e#$o 'e/e#t o$ !"= i) " eedi#- - o(#d $o $ ()t "ted o(t ) , ' i/i#"! e!e/e#t) , #" "!ite) , te o i)t).&e)ted $o ei-# % do/e)ti' i#te e)t) /"#i6(!"te t e)e i#e>("!itie) i# )o'iet to "d9"#'e t ei 9e)ted )e!$i) i#te e)t) ()i#- t e)e $ ()t "ted ,di)i!!()io#ed o(t ) ") 6"=#) i# t ei 6o=e -"/e.

. Po!i'e % ot e !"= e#$o 'e/e#t "-e#'ie) ()e 7 d de- ee to t( e "-"i#)t 6eo6!e )()6e'ted o$ 6ett ' i/e) , = e e") t e do#@t ()e 7 d de- eeto t( e "-"i#)t t ei o=# 'o (6t 'o!!e"-(e) , J(d-e) = o "id (#de =o !d do#) , i- ' i/i#"!) e" #i#- i e /o#e to t e t(#e o$ Mi!!io#) o$ do!!" ). I#/"# '")e) o$ Po!i'e 'o (6tio# , ?(di'i"! 'o (6tio# e9e# !e-"! 6 o)e'(tio# i) #ot "t "!! do#e.

'. W o!e MUSLIM 'o//(#it i) 6"i#ted ") " te o % )()6e'ted =o !d o9e . T e do#@t e")i! -et ?o ) , e#ted o()e) , !o"#) , et' e9e od)()6e't) t e/. I$ o( -o #(/ e ) t e e " e /"# C i)ti"# te o i)t) i# )6"i# , Ni'" "-(" , '( " , I e!"#d , et' "#d /o)t i/6o t"#t! /")te /i#d) o$ te o i)/ , 6eo6!e = o )o=ed t e )eed) o$ te o i)/ i# Midd!e E")t , A)i" , e!)e = e e " e "!! CHRISTIANS. Doe) t "t /e"# "!! C i)ti"#) " e

te o i)t). T (e /o)t o$ t e te o i)t) 'o/e $ o/ /()!i/ 'o//(#it , o=e9e t e e " e "!)o 'o//o# $o! !i e () i# t e /()!i/ 'o//(#it = o e" #$o " o#e)t , )i/6!e !i9i#-. T e e " e -ood 6eo6!e i# "!! 'o//(#itie) ") t e e " e "d 6eo6!e.

d. C i/e i) " ' i/e , = et e i- o )/"!!. T e e i) di)' i/i#"tio# i# 'e!! "!!ot/e#t , !" o( o( ) , 6 o9i)io# o$ $ood , 9i)ito ) $"'i!it et=ee# o di#""''()ed % i' "''()ed 6e )o#) , o di#" ' i/i#"!) "#d i' ' i/i#"!) =it i# ?"i!.

e. T e 6o!i'e % P e)idi#- J(d-e i# t e '")e " e e)6o#)i !e $o e"!t , )"$et o$ 6e )o#) ot i# t ei '()tod ") =e!! ") )"$et o$ =it#e))e) o(t)ide.M"# 6e )o#) " e )( ?e'ted to 7 d de- ee to t( e = i!e i# '()tod , )o/e 6eo6!e "9e died i# !o' (6 "#d =it#e))e) =e e t e"te#ed , /( de edo(t)ide , (t t e e)6e'ti9e 6o!i'e , ?(d-e) " e #ot !e-"!! 6 o)e'(ted $o /( de ' " -e).

$. T e )()6e't) = o =e e "'>(itted o$ ' " -e) (#de "#ti te o !"=) % ot e ' i/i#"! ' " -e) , = o =e#t t o(- e!! , = o)e $"/i! )($$e ed , " e #ot6"id "# 'o/6e#)"tio# $o = o#-$(! dete#tio# 'o( t) o$ !"= #o t e 6o!i'e = o =e e e)6o#)i !e $o = o#- dete#tio# " e !e-"!! 6 o)e'(ted $o!e9e!i#- $"!)e ' " -e).

-. US P e)ide#t) "#d US -o9e #/e#t i# !e"-(e =it US ")ed MNC) )(''e))i9e! 6o ed it@) #o)e i# t e "$$"i ) o$ ot e )o9e ei-# #"tio#) , ' e"tedi$t i# t e 6e"'e$(! 'o(#t ie) , )o=ed t e )eed) o$ te o i)/ , "ided % )(66o ted te o i)t) i# "!! e)6e't). US i) " e" t!e)) (t' e , (t #o= 6 e"' i#-

#o# 9io!e#'e , 6e"'e to t e =o !d.. US -o9e #/e#t "!=" ) 6 "'ti'e) do( !e )t"#d" d) t" e $o i#)t"#'e i#d()t i"! "''ide#t do#e P oi! o$$ US 'o")t , US Go9e #/e#t e t "'ted

'o/6e#)"tio# to t e /" i/(/ e te#t. W e e ") US ")ed MNC U#io# '" ide #o= DOW C e/i'"!) did /"# )!"(- te i# i#di" "t o6"! , )ti!! US-o9e #/e#t i) #ot o de i#- t e -(i!t 'o/6"# to 6" 'o/6e#)"tio#.

i. USA = i' i) " (-e! i#d()t i"!iBed #"tio# =it 6o6(!"tio# e#?o i#- o6(!e#t !i$e )t !e ") '"()ed /o e d"/"-e to t e e#9i o#/e#t e)(!ti#- i#'!i/"te ' "#-e. A) t e =o )t de)t o e o$ e'o!o- , US -o9e #/e#t i) o(#d i) o(#d to 6" /o e $o t e e6"i o$ e#9i o#/e#t. Ho=e9e US-o9e #/e#t i) $o 'i#- ot e "' =" d 'o(#t ie) to ) " e it@) o=# ( de#.

2. (e)tio# ) o$ L"=;

A e P e)ide#t) o$ U#ited St"te) o$ A/e i'" " o9e L"= A e US 6o!i'e , ?(d-e) , ot e 6( !i' )e 9"#t) " o9e !"=

W "t Le-"! Ri- t) P e)ide# o$ USA , US Mi!it" , US Po!i'e % US J(d-e) "9e to )(''e))i9e! 9io!"te t e (/"# i- t) o$ 'itiBe#) o$ ot e 'o(#t ie)ot =it i# USA % o(t)ide.

o= /(' US e)o( 'e) =e e )6e#t $ o/ US TREASUR: , to $i#"#'e te o i)t o(t$it) , /i!it" ?(#t") i# ot e )o9e ei-# #"tio#)

i) #ot A! >(ed" , T"!i "# ' e"tio#) o$ USA

did Se6te/ e 11 WTC "tt"' t (! "66e#ed i?"' ed "i 6!"#e o =") it 6!"##ed US "(t o itie) )eett6; ===.#ei(.ed( Q" ?"/e)) ///. t/*M"i#

i) "'i"! 6 o$i!i#- , 6 o$i!i#- " 6" ti'(!" 'o//(#it % )()6e'ti#- "!! t e /()!i/) ") te o )()6e't) , i- t

i$ it i) i- t , t e ' e"to ) o$ )(' te o i)t o(t$it) 3 6")t 6 e)ide#t) o$ USA 3 = o =e e C i)ti"#) /" e) it !o-i'"! to "))(/e = o!e o$ o( C i)ti"#'o//(#it ") te o )()6e't

i) #ot ()e o$ 7 d de- ee to t( e o# "!! t 6e o$ )()6e't) i# US 6 i)o#) % i# t e 6 i)o#) o$ US "!!ied 'o(#t ie) "t t e e e)t o$ US "(t o itie) , i- t i) it#ot 9io!"tio# o$ (/"# i- t) % US !"=)

did US $i#d "# =e"6o#) o$ /")) de)t ('tio# i# I "> , = i' =") t e /"i# e")o# $o US "tt"' i#- I ">

= #ot US "(t o itie) ()e )'ie#ti$i' i#te o-"tio# te' #i>(e) !i e 6o! - "6 , !ie dete'to te)t) i#)te"d o$ i# (/"# 7 d de- ee to t( e o# te o)()6e't) % )()6e't) i# ot e ' i/i#"! '")e)

= "t !e-"! i- t o( P e)ide#t o$ USA "9e , to i!!e-"!! )6e#d i!!io#) o$ o( do!!" ) o# i# (/"# , i!!e-"! "'t) o$ te o i)/ , /i!it" 'o(6 , ' e"tio# ,"idi#- % " etti#- o$ te o i)t) , et' , i# ot e )o9e ei-# #"tio#) = i!e =e " e )($$e i#- $ o/ !o)) o$ ?o ) ,!o)) o$ o/e d(e to #"t( "! '"!"/itie) , et'

I#)6ite o$ e6e"ted "66e"!) $o ?()ti'e JUDGES o$ SUPREME COURT o$ USA " e /(/ "#d #ot t" i#- "'tio# "-"i#)t te o 6 e)ide#t). I) it e'"()et e o=e t ei e!e9"tio# to t e i- e)t ?(di'i"! 6o)t to t e US 6 e)ide#t o i) it " )( 9i9"! "'t

C ( , Fo(#d"tio# o$ "!! e!i-io#) i) (/"#it , i#d#e)) % (#i9e )"! ot e ood. It i) t e 6 e"' e ) = o /i) e6 e)e#t it. Te o i)/ ' e"ted , "ided ," etted "# od i) i# (/"# % = o#- . Te o i)/ i) ' e"tio# o$ 6o=e (#- , )e!$i) 6eo6!e % t e /()t e !e-"!! 6(#i) ed .

He e , =e "66e"! to t e o#o " !e )(6 e/e 'o( t o$ USA to !e-"!! 6 o)e'(te P e9io() PRESIDENTS OF USA i# t e !")t de'"de) , $o ' i/e) o$te o , ") 6e t e 6 e)e#t US "#ti te o !"=).

http://www.neiu.edu/~ayjamess/hmmm.htm#Mainhttp://www.neiu.edu/~ayjamess/hmmm.htm#Main


12/41

7. G o(#d);

Re>(e)t) $o e>(it" !e ?()ti'e , $ ee e 6 e))io# % 6 ote'tio# to !i$e % !i e t o$ "!! A/e i'"# 'itiBe#) ") 6e ILL o$ RIGHTS. T "#)6" e#' ,"''o(#t" i!it i# $(#'tio#i#- o$ US P e)ide#t , US 6o!i'e % US J(di'i" .

. A9e /e#t;

GI&E WHAT ACTION HAS EEN TA4EN AGAINST THE GUILT: US P e)ide#t) US JUDGES , US POLICE , US PU LIC SER&ANTS e)6o#)i !e $o TERROR C i/e) 'o//itted i# USA % O(t)ide USA =it )(66o t $ o/ US -o9e #/e#t.

PRA:ER;


He e , I do e>(e)t t e o#o " !e )(6 e/e 'o( t o$ USA to 'o#)ide t i) ") " PU LIC INTEREST LITIGATION $o ; = it o$ M"#d"/() "#d to i))(ei#)t ('tio#) to t e 'o#'e #ed 6( !i' )e 9"#t) i# t e $o!!o=i#- '")e) to 6e $o / t ei d(tie) % to "#)=e t e >(e)tio#).

He e , I do e>(e)t t e o#o( " !e )(6 e/e 'o( t o$ USA to (6 o!d t e 'o#)tit(tio# o$ USA "#d to 6 ote't t e 'o#)tit(tio#"! i- t) o$ "!! A/e i'"#'itiBe#).

He e , I do e>(e)t t e o#o( " !e )(6 e/e 'o( t o$ USA to !e-"!! 6 o)e'(te 6") 6 e)ide#t) o$ USA "#d I#'(/ e#t P e)ide#t o$ Go9e #/e#t o$U#ited St"te) o$ A/e i'" $o Te o C i/e) , to t( e o$ i##o'e#t) i# G("#t"#"/o , e#ditio#) , et'.

He e , I do e>(e)t t e o#o( " !e )(6 e/e 'o( t o$ USA to i#iti"te !e-"! 6 o)e'(tio# o$ 6o!i'e , !"= e#$o 'e/e#t o$$i'i"!) , ?(d-e) e)6o#)i !e $o 7 d

de- ee to t( e o$ i##o'e#t) , !o' (6 de"t ) , $" e e#'o(#te ) "#d to 6" 'o/6e#)"tio# to 9i'ti/) "#d to e'o9e /o#e $ o/ 6e )o#"! 6 o6e tie) o$t o)e -(i!t 6o!i'e , ?(d-e).

He e , I do e>(e)t t e o#o( " !e )(6 e/e 'o( t o$ USA to o de t e ?"i! "(t o itie) to )to6 '!"))i$i'"tio# o$ 6 i)o#e ) "#d to )to6 di)' i/i#"tio# o$6 i)o#e ).

He e , I do e>(e)t t e o#o( " !e )(6 e/e 'o( t o$ USA to o de 6o!i'e % 6 e)idi#- ?(d-e o$ " '")e to e#)( e 6 ote'tio# o$ !i$e o$ "''()ed ,=it#e))e) i# t e '")e , 'o/6!"i#"#t o$ t e '")e.

He e , I do e>(e)t t e o#o( " !e )(6 e/e 'o( t o$ USA to o de DOW C e/i'"!) to 6" $(!! 'o/6e#)"tio# to 9i'ti/) o$ o6"! G") T "-ed i#I#di" "#d i#iti"te ' i/i#"! 6 o)e'(tio# o$ e)6o#)i !e 'o/6"# e e'(ti9e).

He e , I do e>(e)t t e o#o( " !e )(6 e/e 'o( t o$ USA to o de -o9e #/e#t o$ USA to 6" to=" d) t e d"/"-e) it ") do#e to t e e#9i o#/e#t.

He e , I do e>(e)t t e o#o( " !e )(6 e/e 'o( t o$ USA to o de -o9e #/e#t o$ USA to )6e#d t" 6" e @) /o#e o# $ood )"$et , e"!t '" e , ?o !e))#e)) o$ A/e i'"# 'itiBe#) t "# o# )6o#)o i#- te o i)/ i# ot e 'o(#t ie).

to 6")) )(' ot e o de ) "#d $( t e o de ) ") /" e dee/ed #e'e))" o# t e $"'t) "#d i# t e 'i '(/)t"#'e) o$ t e '")e.


D"te ; 71)t J"#(" 201 Fi!ed ; N"-" "?".M.R.


># P$% & $ndia , Pa2istan , -S sponsoring .8RR/R$SM

6ouble spea2 of o!ernment



IN THE MATTER OF

NAGARAJA . M.R ,



He "! , M )o e 3 5+001+ , 4" #"t" " St"te

.....Petitio#e


13/41

&e )()

H.E.Ho#o( " !e P e)ide#t o$ I#di" % Ot e )

....Re)6o#de#t)

PETITION UNDER ARTICLE 12 to ARTICLE 75 % ARTICLE 51A OF THE CONSTITUTION OF INDIA FOR ISSUANCE OF A WRIT IN THE NATUREOF


To ,




1. F"'t) o$ t e '")e;

O( = o!e e" ted e)6e't) to o#e)t $e= i# ?(di'i" , 6" !i"/e#t % 6( !i' )e 9i'e. O( )"!(te) to t e/ , d(e to o#e)t e$$o t) o$ t o)e $e= #o !e6e )o#) o#! , "t !e")t de/o' "' i) )( 9i9i#- i# I#di".

A . ("!! e#tit!ed to ?()ti'e , e>("!!e)6o#)i !e to (6 o!d 'o#)tit(tio# . O#! Peo6!e , CitiBe#) o$ I#di" " e )(6 e/e No J(d-e) , No Mi#i)te ) , No Po!i'e , No Mi!it" , et' " e )(6 e/e.

J(d-e) , /i#i)te ) , 6 e)ide#t , Po!i'e , Mi!it" et' " e "!! 6( !i' )e 9"#t) 'o#)tit(tio#"!! /"#d"ted to SER&E t e 6( !i' , NOT to /")te o9e t e/.E9e# "$te e" ) o$ i#de6e#de#'e t e)e 6o!i'e , ?(d-e) , /i#i)te ) "9e #ot 'o/e o(t o$ 'o!o#i"! "#-o9e i#)te"d e'o/e =o )e t e"ti#- -e#e "!6( !i' ") t ei )e 9"#t).

C. I#e>("!it i# )o'iet , (#?()t !"=) , (#?()t e#$o 'e/e#t o$ !"= i) " eedi#- - o(#d $o $ ()t "ted o(t ) , ' i/i#"! e!e/e#t) , #" "!ite) , te o i)t).&e)ted $o ei-# % do/e)ti' i#te e)t) /"#i6(!"te t e)e i#e>("!itie) i# )o'iet to "d9"#'e t ei 9e)ted )e!$i) i#te e)t) ()i#- t e)e $ ()t "ted ,di)i!!()io#ed o(t ) ") 6"=#) i# t ei 6o=e -"/e.

D. I =i!! !i)t e!o= 9" io() t 6e) o$ i#e>(itie) e i)ti#- i# 6 e)e#t d" i#di" e9e# "$te #e" ! e" ) o$ i#de6e#de#'e.

E. Peo6!e o$ J"//( % 4") /i , No t E")te # )t"te) o$ I#di" " e -o9e #ed di$$e e#t )et o$ !"=) t "# t e e)t o$ i#di".

F. T e e " e di$$e e#t )et o$ 6 o6e t !"=) , )(''e))io# !"=) , /" i"-e !"=) , et' $o 6eo6!e o$ di$$e e#t e!i-io#).

G. J(d-e) 'o//itti#- ' i/e) "-"i#)t =o/e# , i#d(!-i#- i# 'o (6tio#, et' '"# #ot e !e-"!! 6 o)e'(ted % 6(#i) ed.

H. E9e# "$te e" ) o$ i#de6e#de#'e , )ti!! d"!it) , t i "! 6eo6!e " e )($$e i#- % "' =" d.

I. Po!i'e % ot e !"= e#$o 'e/e#t "-e#'ie) ()e 7 d de- ee to t( e "-"i#)t 6eo6!e )()6e'ted o$ 6ett ' i/e) , = e e") t e do#@t ()e 7 d de- eeto t( e "-"i#)t t ei o=# 'o (6t 'o!!e"-(e) , J(d-e) = o "id (#de =o !d do#) , i- ' i/i#"!) e" #i#- i e /o#e to t e t(#e o$ !" ) , ' o e) o$

(6ee). I# /"# '")e) o$ Po!i'e 'o (6tio# , ?(di'i"! 'o (6tio# e9e# !e-"! 6 o)e'(tio# i) #ot "t "!! do#e.

J. W o!e MUSLIM 'o//(#it i) 6"i#ted ") " te o % )()6e'ted =o !d o9e . T e do#@t e")i! -et ?o ) , e#ted o()e) , !o"#) , et' e9e od)()6e't) t e/. T (e /o)t o$ t e te o i)t) 'o/e $ o/ /()!i/ 'o//(#it , o=e9e t e e " e "!)o 'o//o# $o! !i e () i# t e /()!i/ 'o//(#it = o

e" # $o " o#e)t , )i/6!e !i9i#-. T e e " e -ood 6eo6!e i# "!! 'o//(#itie) ") t e e " e "d 6eo6!e.

4. A#ti Te o L"=) !i e TADA , AFSPA , et' " e ()ed =it i/6(#it =it o(t e")o#i#- e9e# o# o!d 6eo6!e , ' i!d e# "#d = oe9e >(e)tio#) t e 6o!i'e ,/i!it" $o t ei "'tio#). Ide"!! t e)e !"=) ) o(!d 'o9e t o)e "idi#- te o i)t) , "#ti #"tio#"!). Ho=e9e 'e t"i# 'e!e itie) , 6o!i'e o$$i'i"!) t e/)e!9e)= o o #o =it te o i)t) , (#de =o !d "#d "id t ei te o "'ti9itie) " e #ot 'o9e ed t e)e te o !"=).

L. Co#)tit(tio# o$ I#di" ") #ot "(t o iBed , -i9e# 6o=e ) to "# od to ()e 7 d de- ee to t( e "-"i#)t )()6e't) , it i) i!!e-"! % i# (/"#. Po!i'e)e!e'ti9e! ()e 7 d de- ee to t( e "-"i#)t )()6e't) , i##o'e#t) $ o/ 6oo , o di#" "' - o(#d) to e t "'t $"!)e 'o#$e))io#). W e e") t e do#@t ()e7 d de- ee to t( e "-"i#)t e"! ti/e , i- ti/e i' % i#$!(e#ti"! ' i/i#"!) i#)te"d t e -et /"# $"'i!itie) i# t e ?"i!.

M. C i/e i) " ' i/e , = et e i- o )/"!!. T e e i) di)' i/i#"tio# i# 'e!! "!!ot/e#t , !" o( o( ) , 6 o9i)io# o$ $ood , 9i)ito ) $"'i!it et=ee# o di#""''()ed % i' "''()ed 6e )o#) , o di#" ' i/i#"!) "#d i' ' i/i#"!) =it i# ?"i!.

N. T e 6o!i'e % P e)idi#- J(d-e i# t e '")e " e e)6o#)i !e $o e"!t , )"$et o$ 6e )o#) ot i# t ei '()tod ") =e!! ") )"$et o$ =it#e))e) o(t)ide.M"# 6e )o#) " e )( ?e'ted to 7 d de- ee to t( e = i!e i# '()tod , )o/e 6eo6!e "9e died i# !o' (6 "#d =it#e))e) =e e t e"te#ed , /( de edo(t)ide , (t t e e)6e'ti9e 6o!i'e , ?(d-e) " e #ot !e-"!! 6 o)e'(ted $o /( de ' " -e).

O. T e )()6e't) = o =e e "'>(itted o$ ' " -e) (#de "#ti te o !"=) % ot e ' i/i#"! ' " -e) , = o =e#t t o(- e!! , = o)e $"/i! )($$e ed , " e#ot 6"id "# 'o/6e#)"tio# $o = o#-$(! dete#tio# 'o( t) o$ !"= #o t e 6o!i'e = o =e e e)6o#)i !e $o = o#- dete#tio# " e !e-"!! 6 o)e'(ted $o

!e9e!i#- $"!)e ' " -e).


14/41

P. T i "! 6eo6!e = o " e i# " it"#t) o$ $o e)t , = o " e !i9i#- i# " /o# =it e'o!o- , 6 ote'ti#- $o e)t) )i#'e 'e#t( ie) " e e9i'ted "(t o itie) i#t e #"/e o$ 6 ote'ti#- $o e)t). S"/e "(t o itie) -i9e 9")t t "'t) o$ $o e)t !"#d o# 6!"tte to i- /(!ti#"tio#"! 'o 6o "tio#) , = o i# t( # de)t oe'o!o- , e#9i o#/e#t.

. D"!it) , "' =" d '!")) 6eo6!e = e# 'o#)t ('t )/"!! te/6o " (t/e#t) o# -o9e #/e#t !"#d , t o)e (t/e#t) " e i//edi"te! "Bed do=# , d"!it)e9i'ted 6o!i'e , "(t o itie). W e# i' ' oo ) i!!e-"!! e#' o"' 9")t t "'t) o$ -o9e #/e#t !"#d) , !" e) , '"#"!) , (i!d (-e to=#) i6) , ()i#e))'o/6!e e) e" #i#- ' o e) o$ (6ee) , #o "'tio# to "Be do=# i!!e-"! (i!di#-) , e9i't e#' o"' e ) i) t" e# 6o!i'e , "(t o itie). S"d! , -o9e #/e#t i)i# 6 o'e)) o$ e#"'ti#- !"=) to !e-"!iBe t o)e i!!e-"! )t ('t( e) e!o#-i#- to i' ' oo ).

R. Go9e #/e#t o$ i#di" to $ i- t t e 6 o =" o$ '(##i#- , 'o=" d e te #"! e#e/ie) i) i#d(!-i#- i# t e )"/e 'o=" d! t"'ti') o$ "idi#- % " etti#-te o i)/ , t e =" i!!i#- /"# i##o'e#t 'i9i!i"#). I#)te"d GOI /()t -i9e " e$itti#- /i!it" e6! to e#e/ .

S. GOI i) e)6o#)i !e $o ' e"tio# , $(#di#- , t "i#i#- o$ SALWA JUDUM , to 'o(#te #" "!i)/ i# i#di". GOI i) e)6o#)i !e $o ' e"tio# , $(#di#- ,t "i#i#- o$ 'o(#te te o i)t o(t $it) i# #o t e")t i#di" , ?"//( 4") /i , P" i)t"# "#d e)6o#)i !e $o ' e"tio# , $(#di#- , t "i#i#- o$ LTTE , T"/i!te o i)t o(t$it) i# ) i!"# ". GOI 6o ed it@) #o)e i# t e i#te #"! "$$"i ) o$ e")t P" i)t"# = i' !ed to ' e"tio# o$ )e6" "te #"tio# "#-!"de) . A!! t e)e !edto !o)) o$ t o()"#d) o$ i##o'e#t !i9e) , GOI did#@t ot e to 'o/6e#)"te t e/.

T. I# i#di" , =e "9e /"# (#"tte#ded do/e)ti' 6 o !e/) , "!$ o$ o( 6o6(!"tio# i) " e! )()t"i#i#- o# " )i#-!e 6ie'e /e"! " d" . GOI i#)te"d o$6 o6e ! ()i#- t e 6 e'io() t" 6" e @) /o#e to )o!9e do/e)ti' 6 o !e/) , )>("#de i#- t e/ o# $(#di#- te o o(t$it). No !e-"! 6 o)e'(tio# o$ GOIMi#i)te ) e)6o#)i !e $o t e)e te o "'t) t" e# ti!! d"te.

U. A'tio#) =e e t" e# =it i/6(#it "-"i#)t )i te o i)t) (t i# t e )"/e =" "'tio#) =e e #ot t" e# "-"i#)t t o)e e)6o#)i !e $o )i /"))"' e i#de! i , e!)e = e e.

&. A'tio#) =e e t" e# =it i/6(#it "-"i#)t te o i)t) e)6o#)i !e $o ( #i#- o$ S" " /"ti e 6 e)) t "i# =e e t" e# , (t i# t e )"/e =" "'tio#) =e e#ot t" e# "-"i#)t t o)e e)6o#)i !e $o God " iot) i# G(?" "t .

W. A'tio#) =e e t" e# =it i/6(#it "-"i#)t te o i)t) e)6o#)i !e $o o/ " o/ !")t) =e e t" e# , (t i# t e )"/e =" "'tio#) =e e #ot t" e#

"-"i#)t t o)e e)6o#)i !e $o o/ " iot) "$te =" d).K. M"# i#d()t i"!i)t) " e 'o#t i (ti#- /o#e to ' i/i#"!) , (t #o "'tio# GOI to )to6 it t" e# ti!! d"te.

:. Go9e #/e#t o$ P" i)t"# , ' i#" " e "idi#- te o i)t) , )e6" "ti)t) , M"oi)t) i# i#di". Go9e #/e#t o$ USA i) "!)o i#di e't! "idi#- te o i)t) ,)e6" "ti)t) , M"oi)t) i# i#di" t o(- P" i)t"#.

. W oe9e "i)e) i) 9oi'e "-"i#)t t e i!!e-"!itie) o$ "(t o itie) " e )i!e#'ed i# /"# =" ) "(t o itie). He =i!! e $itted i# $" e '")e) , i) !i9e!i ood)#"t' ed "=" , 'o( t) =it =ei d i#te 6 et"tio#) o$ !"= =i!! 6(#i) i/ , )!"6 'o#te/6t ' " -e) o# i/ )e#di#- i/ to ?"i!. I$ e i) )6i!!i#- o(t /o eTRUTH e =i!! e #e(t "!iBed , /( de ed i#te!!i-e#'e "-e#'ie) =it t e "id o$ ' i/i#"!). M"# = i)t!e !o=e ) , RTI A'ti9i)t) , Jo( #"!i)t) , H(/"#Ri- t) A'ti9i)t) , C ()"de ) "9e died / )te io()! t i) =" . No 'o/6e#)"tio# to 9i'ti/) , #o !e-"! 6 o)e'(tio# o$ "(t o itie) e)6o#)i !e $o it ti!!d"te.

2. (e)tio# ) o$ L"=;

A e "!! I#di"# 'itiBe#) e"!! e>("! A e 6o!i'e , ?(d-e) , /i#i)te ) " o9e !"=

7. G o(#d);

Re>(e)t) $o e>(it" !e ?()ti'e , $ ee e 6 e))io# % 6 ote'tio# to !i$e % !i e t . T "#)6" e#' , "''o(#t" i!it i# $(#'tio#i#- o$ 6o!i'e % J(di'i" .

. A9e /e#t;

GI&E WHAT ACTION HAS EEN TA4EN AGAINST THE GUILT: JUDGES , POLICE , PU LIC SER&ANTS e)6o#)i !e $o " o9e /e#tio#edi#?()ti'e).

PRA:ER;


i He e , I do e>(e)t t e o#o " !e )(6 e/e 'o( t o$ I#di" to 'o#)ide t i) ") " PIL $o ; = it o$ M"#d"/() "#d to i))(e i#)t ('tio#) to t e'o#'e #ed 6( !i' )e 9"#t) i# t e $o!!o=i#- '")e) to 6e $o / t ei d(tie) % to "#)=e t e >(e)tio#).

ii He e , I do e>(e)t t e o#o( " !e )(6 e/e 'o( t o$ i#di" to e#$o 'e (#i$o / 'i9i! 'ode $o "!! I#di"# 'itiBe#).

iii He e , I do e>(e)t t e o#o( " !e )(6 e/e 'o( t o$ i#di" to (6 o!d t e 'o#)tit(tio# o$ i#di" "#d to 6 ote't t e 'o#)tit(tio#"! i- t) o$ "!! I#di"#'itiBe#) i#'!(di#- /i#e.

i9 He e , I do e>(e)t t e o#o( " !e )(6 e/e 'o( t o$ i#di" to (6 o!d t e 'o#)tit(tio# o$ i#di" , to 6 ote't t e 'o#)tit(tio#"! i- t) , (/"# i- t) o$"!! I#di"# 'itiBe#) i#'!(di#- /i#e "#d to e#" !e , $"'i!it"te "!! I#di"# 'itiBe#) to 6e $o / t ei F(#d"/e#t"! D(tie) ") 6e 'o#)tit(tio#.

9 He e , I do e>(e)t t e o#o( " !e )(6 e/e 'o( t o$ i#di" to "##(! !e-"! i//(#it 6 i9i!e-e) -i9e# to ?(d-e) o$ i#di" "#d /" e t e ?(d-e)"''o(#t" !e $o "!! t ei "'tio#).

9i He e , I do e>(e)t t e o#o( " !e )(6 e/e 'o( t o$ i#di" to "##(! A ti'!e 7+0 o$ o( 'o#)tit(tio# -i9i#- )6e'i"! )t"t() to ?"//( 4") /i )t"te"#d "!)o "##(! !"=) -i9i#- )6e'i"! )t"t() to #o t e")te # )t"te) o$ i#di".

9ii He e , I do e>(e)t t e o#o( " !e )(6 e/e 'o( t o$ i#di" to i#iti"te !e-"! 6 o)e'(tio# o$ 6o!i'e , !"= e#$o 'e/e#t o$$i'i"!) , ?(d-e) e)6o#)i !e$o 7 d de- ee to t( e o$ i##o'e#t) , !o' (6 de"t ) , $" e e#'o(#te ) "#d to 6" 'o/6e#)"tio# to 9i'ti/) "#d to e'o9e /o#e $ o/ 6e )o#"!6 o6e tie) o$ t o)e -(i!t 6o!i'e , ?(d-e).

9iii He e , I do e>(e)t t e o#o( " !e )(6 e/e 'o( t o$ i#di" to o de t e ?"i! "(t o itie) to )to6 '!"))i$i'"tio# o$ 6 i)o#e ) "#d to )to6di)' i/i#"tio# o$ 6 i)o#e ).

i He e , I do e>(e)t t e o#o( " !e )(6 e/e 'o( t o$ i#di" to o de 6o!i'e % 6 e)idi#- ?(d-e o$ " '")e to e#)( e 6 ote'tio# o$ !i$e o$ "''()ed ,=it#e))e) i# t e '")e , 'o/6!"i#"#t o$ t e '")e.

He e , I do e>(e)t t e o#o( " !e )(6 e/e 'o( t o$ i#di" to o de GOI % )t"te -o9e #/e#t) to -i9e e)e 9"tio# , ot e $"'i!itie) to d"!it) ,


15/41

"' =" d '!")) 6eo6!e i# t( #. T e# $"'i!itie) =i!! e "9"i!" !e to =ide )e'tio# o$ d"!it) i#)te"d o$ " ' e"/ , "$$!(e#t d"!it $"/i! e6e"ted! -etti#-e#e$it) $o -e#e "tio#) , = i!e (#d ed) o$ d"!it $"/i!ie) do#@t -et e#e$it e9e# o#'e i# t ei !i$e ti/e.

i He e , I do e>(e)t t e o#o( !e )(6 e/e 'o( t o$ i#di" to o de GOI % )t"te -o9e #/e#t) to 6 ote't t e $o e)t i- t) o$ t i "!) o9e t e $o e)tt e d=e!! i#. To !e-"!! 6 o)e'(te i!!e-"! e#' o"' e ) o$ $o e)t , i' ' oo ).

ii He e , I do e>(e)t t e o#o( " !e )(6 e/e 'o( t o$ i#di" to "##(! t e !"#d "'t) e#"'ted 9" io() )t"te -o9e #/e#t) = i' -oe) o# to!e-"!iBe i!!e-"! e#' o"' /e#t o$ -o9e #/e#t !"#d) , !" e) , '"#"!) , et' i' ' oo ). To !e-"!! 6 o)e'(te t e i!!e-"! e#' o"' e ) , i' ' oo ).

He e , I do e>(e)t t e o#o( " !e )(6 e/e 'o( t o$ i#di" to !e-"!! 6 o)e'(te /i#i)te ) , 6( !i' )e 9"#t) o$ GOI % )t"te -o9e #/e#t) = o "ided," etted te o i)/ , = o ' e"ted SALWA JUDUM , = o "ided t"/i! te o o(t$it) i# ) i!"# " , = o ' e"ted 'o(#te te o o(t$it) i# NEFA , J%4 ,P" i)t"# , = o "ided "#-!"de) i )e6" "ti)t). To 6" 'o/6e#)"tio# to 9i'ti/) o$ t o)e te o i)/ "#d to e'o9e /o#e $ o/ 6 o6e tie) o$ -(i!t/i#i)te ) , -(i!t 6( !i' )e 9"#t).

i He e , I do e>(e)t t e o#o( !e )(6 e/e 'o( t o$ i#di" to o de GOI % )t"te -o9e #/e#t) to t" e i/6" ti"! "'tio# "-"i#)t "!! t e ' i/i#"!)e)6o#)i !e $o te o "'t) , iot) , o/ !")t) i e)6e'ti9e o$ = i' 6" t t e e!o#- to o = i' 'o//(#it t e e!o#- to o i$ e i) " 'e!e it o

o di#" 6e )o#.

ii He e , I do e>(e)t t e o#o( !e )(6 e/e 'o( t o$ i#di" to o de GOI to -i9e " e$itti#- /i!it" e6! to e#e/ie) , ' () t e i#t (de ) , te o)i)t), #" "!ite) (t #ot to i#d(!-e i# 'o=" d! 6 o =" = i' i!!) i##o'e#t 'i9i!i"#).

iii He e , I do e>(e)t t e o#o( !e )(6 e/e 'o( t o$ i#di" to o de GOI % )t"te -o9e #/e#t) to 6" 'o/6e#)"tio# to 9i'ti/) = o =e e = o#-!det"i#ed , ?"i!ed 6o!i'e , "(t o itie) (#de "#ti te o !"=) , ' i/i#"! !"=). To e'o9e /o#e $ o/ 6 o6e tie) , )"!" , 6e#)io# o$ -(i!t 6o!i'e %

?(d-e).

i9 He e , I do e>(e)t t e o#o( !e )(6 e/e 'o( t o$ i#di" to o de R I , GOI % )t"te -o9e #/e#t) to i-o o()! /o#ito t "#)"'tio#) o$'o//e 'i"! $i /) , i#d()t ie) $o !"' /o#e t "#)"'tio#) "#d to ee6 " t" o# "(dito ) , 'o/6"# )e' et" ie) = o "id t o)e ' i/i#"!). To /" e6( !i' det"i!) o$ -(i!t i#d()t i"!i)t) , to !e-"!! 6 o)e'(te t e/ "#d to e'o9e /o#e )i6 o#ed o$$ $ o/ t e/.

9 He e , I do e>(e)t t e o#o( !e )(6 e/e 'o( t o$ i#di" to 6")) )(' ot e o de ) "#d $( t e o de ) ") /" e dee/ed #e'e))" o# t e$"'t) "#d i# t e 'i '(/)t"#'e) o$ t e '")e to e/o9e i#e>("!itie) 6 e9"i!i#- i# o( !"= , i# !"= e#$o 'e/e#t % i# o( )o'iet ") /e#tio#ed " o9e. = i' , '"()e) o$ o i-i# $o #" "!i)/ , te o i)/ '"# e e ")ed.

9i He e , I do e>(e)t t e o#o( !e )(6 e/e 'o( t o$ i#di" to de'!" e P" i)t"# , ' i#" % USA ") te o )t"te) "#d o de GOI to de"! "''o di#-!=it t o)e #"tio#) "#d to /" e "# "66e"! to UNITED NATIONS , INTERNATIONAL COURT OF JUSTICE to t" e "'tio# "-"i#)t P" i)t"# , ' i#" %USA $o t ei te o ' i/e) i# i#di".

9ii to 6")) )(' ot e o de ) "#d $( t e o de ) ") /" e dee/ed #e'e))" o# t e $"'t) "#d i# t e 'i '(/)t"#'e) o$ t e '")e.


D"te ; 27 d J"#(" 201 Fi!ed ; N"-" "?".M.R.


5# P$% : Mercy 6eath Plea to onourable 'hief (ustice of $ndia



IN THE MATTER OF

NAGARAJA . M.R


&e )()

Ho#o( " !e C ie$ J()ti'e o$ I#di" , S(6 e/e Co( t o$ I#di" % Ot e )

....Re)6o#de#t)

PETITION UNDER ARTICLE 12 to ARTICLE 75 % ARTICLE 51A OF THE CONSTITUTION OF INDIA FOR ISSUANCE OF A WRIT IN THE NATUREOF MANDAMUS UNDER ARTICLE 72 % ARTICLE 22 OF THE CONSTITUTION OF INDIA.

To ,Ho#8 !e T e C ie$ J()ti'e o$ I#di" "#d Hi) Lo d) i68) Co/6"#io#J()ti'e) o$ t e S(6 e/e Co( t o$ I#di". T e H(/ !e 6etitio# o$ t ePetitio#e " o9e #"/ed.


1. F"'t) o$ t e '")e;


16/41

6o=e "#d =i!! e !o)t i# 6o!iti'"! )>(" !e) . A d" =o(!d 'o/e = e# e9e# "i % ="te =i!! e t" ed.< Si Wi#)to# /"de t i) )t"te/e#t i# t e Ho()e o$Co//o#) ?()t e$o e t e i#de6e#de#'e o$ I#di" % P" i)t"#. S"d! , t e $o e=" #i#- o$ L"te Wi#)to# C ( ' i!! ") ee# 6 o9ed i- t )o/e o$ o(' i/i#"! , 'o (6t 6( !i' )e 9"#t).

2. A) " e)(!t o$ $i- ti#- $o 6( !i' '"()e) , 6( !i' -ood I "9e i#di9id("!! )($$e ed #(/e o() i#?()ti'e) "#d )ti!! )($$e i#- i#?()ti'e). M #e=)6"6e6( !i'"tio# =") i!!e-"!! '!o)ed do=# , / =e #e=) 6"6e #ot -i9e# =it 6 e)) "'' editio# , / ?o o66( t(#itie) i# R I Note 6 e)) , PES E#-i#ee i#-'o!!e-e , NIE E#-i#ee i#- 'o!!e-e , M )o e di)t i't 'o( t , et' )#"t' ed "=" i!!e-"!! , I =") e"te# (6 , "tte/6t) o# / !i$e =e e /"de e9e# "$te

i#-i#- t e"t) to / !i$e =e e o(- t to #oti'e o$ )(6 e/e 'o( t o$ i#di". See o= d(t d(t 'o#)'io() o( )(6 e/e 'o( t ?(d-e) " e "!! t e)e)($$e i#-) $o 6( !i' '"()e) I "9e "i)ed % to )i!e#'e /e.

2. (e)tio# ) o$ L"=;

A e 6o!i'e % J(d-e) " o9e !"= C"# J(d-e) % Po!i'e Co/itt ' i/e) , -o )'ot $ ee C"# J(d-e) % Po!i'e i#te#tio#"!! #e-!e't to "id ' i/i#"!) t ei

d(tie) , = i!e ) "/e!e))! d "=i#- te#) o$ t o()"#d) o$ (6ee) /o#t ! )"!" % 6e ) o# ti/e =it o(t $"i! $ o/ 6( !i' e ' e>(e .

7. G o(#d);Re>(e)t) $o e>(it" !e ?()ti'e , P o)e'(tio# o$ 'o (6t 6( !i' )e 9"#t) , 'o (6t ?(d-e) , 'o (6t 6o!i'e. Re>(e)t $o )(6 e/e 'o( t o de ) to ?(d-e) %6o!i'e to 6e $o / t ei d(tie) 6 o6e ! .

. A9e /e#t;

He e , I do e>(e)t t e o#o " !e )(6 e/e 'o( t o$ I#di" to 'o#)ide t i) ") " PIL $o ; = it o$ M"#d"/() "#d to i))(e i#)t ('tio#) to t e 'o#'e #ed6( !i' )e 9"#t) i# t e $o!!o=i#- '")e) to 6e $o / t ei d(tie) % to "#)=e t e >(e)tio#).

Re"d t e "'t("! '")e det"i!) "t $o!!o=i#- =e 6"-e) i#9o!9i#- ?(d-e) % 6o!i'e i# ' i/e). T e ' i/i#"! #et=o , 'o (6tio# #et =o , MAFIA o$ J(d-e)% Po!i'e i) )t o#- , = e#e9e o#e o$ t ei /e/ e ) i) "''())ed , ot e ) = ite =") , ( t e '")e i# t e #"/e o$ i#9e)ti-"tio#. T "#)6" e#t ,i/6" ti"! i#9e)ti-"tio# ") i# t e '")e o$ 'o//o# /"# i) #ot "t "!! do#e.

We e)6e't t e o#e)t $e= i# ?(di'i" , 6o!i'e % 6( !i' )e 9i'e. T o)e o#e)t $e= " e "!)o e'o/i#- 6" tie) to ' i/e e'o/i#- )i!e#t , #ot doi#-t ei d(tie) , #ot " e)ti#- t ei 'o (6t 'o!!e"-(e). T ei t e " e 'o9e i#- (6 ' i/e % "idi#- ' i/i#"!) to 'o//it /o e ' i/e).

D(e to t e)e t 6e o$ 'o (6t ?(d-e) % 'o (6t 6o!i'e i##o'e#t), 'o//o#e ) !"#d i# ?"i!) "#d )o/e " e e9e# "#-ed $o ' i/e) #ot 'o//ited t e/ ,= i!e t e i' ' oo ) o"/ $ ee.

T e 'o (6t ?(d-e) % 'o (6t 6o!i'e " e ) "/e!e)) 6eo6!e , 6" ")ite) i# o( )o'iet . T e t" e te#) o$ t o()"#d) o$ (6ee) /o#t ! )"!" % 6e )$ o/ o( /o#e , t" 6" e @) /o#e "#d )ti!! do#@t do t ei d(tie) 6 o6e ! . T e ?(d-e) -i9e )e /o#) , ?(d-e/e#t) (##i#- i#to (#d ed) o$ 6"-e)= e# t ei o=# $o! i) i# t e do' , '"(- t $o ' i/e) t e i#te#tio#"!! $"!! )i!e#t. T e 6o!i'e ()e $i!t !"#-("-e , ()e 7 d de- ee to t( e "-"i#)t'o//o#e ) , i##o'e#t) = e# t ei o=# $o! i) i# t e do' , '"(- t $o ' i/e) , d"'oit t e do#@t ()e $i!t !"#-("-e #o t e ()e 7 d de- ee to t( e .E9e# i# $it '")e) = e e "!!e-ed J(d-e) % Po!i'e '"# e -i9e# de"t )e#te#'e , t e " e )6" ed , =

P!e")e do#@t )e#d 6o!i'e "-"i# to / o/e #eit e e$e / '")e to 6o!i'e. T e do#@t "9e 6 "'ti'"! 6o=e ) to i#>(i e i- % /i- t ?(d-e). T e =i!!'o/e to / o/e , '"!! /e to 6o!i'e )t"tio# , =i!! t" e " )t"te/e#t $ o/ /e % =i!! '!o)e t e $i!e )e#di#- it to e"d >(" te ). T i) ") "66e#ed6 e9io()! #(/ e o$ ti/e). I$ o( " e o#e)t i# i#te#t , P!e")e 'o#)tit(te "# i/6" ti"! , t "#)6" e#t e/6o=e ed I#>(i 'o//ittee to de"! t i) '")e.

T e ?(d-e) , 6o!i'e % 6( !i' )e 9"#t) i#te#tio#"!! de!" t" i#- "'tio# i# '")e) "#d =it o!d -i9i#- i#$o /"tio# i# ti/e , )o t "t e9ide#'e) " e ( ied i#ti/e , -et) de)t o ed "#d ti/e !"6)e o''( ) e)(!ti#- i# t e '")e e'o/i#- ti/e " ed. So/e o$ PIL) )( /itted () " e 20 e" ) o!d 'o#'e #i#-#"tio#"! )e'( it "#d I =") "!)o e!i-i !e $o $ ee !e-"! "id "t t e ti/e o$ "66!i'"tio# )ti!! t e ?(d-e) % 6o!i'e did#@t t" e "66 o6 i"te "'tio# o=e9e t e) "/e!e))! too t o()"#d) o$ (6ee) )"!" , 6e ) $ o/ o( /o#e . Ti!! d"te #o ?()ti'e i# )i- t i#)te"d /o e i#?()ti'e) /eted o(t to /e ") " e)(!t o$ t i) ' ()"de. THESE INCAPA LE JUDGES % POLICE ARE UNFIT FOR THE POSITIONS THE: OCCUP: , IF THE: CANN@T PRO&IDE JUSTICE

ATLEAST GI&E ME MERC: DEATH.

I ,NAGARAJA.M.R. e e do de'!" e t "t i#$o /"tio# -i9e# " o9e " e t (e to t e e)t o$ / #o=!ed-e % e!ie$. I$ i "/ e6e"ted! '"!!ed to 6o!i'e)t"tio# o e!)e = e e $o t e )" e o$ i#9e)ti-"tio#) , t e !o))e) i do i#'( ") " e)(!t !i e !o)) o$ ="-e) , t "#)6o t"tio# , ?o , et' /()t e o #e t e-o9e #/e#t. 6 e9oi()! t e 6o!i'e I 6e )o##e! e6e"ted! '"!!ed /e t e 'o/6!"i#"#t )($$e e o$ i#?()ti'e) to 6o!i'e )t"tio# $o >(e)tio#i#- , (t#e9e '"!!ed t e -(i!t '(!6 it) , i' ' oo ) , ' i/i#"!) e9e# o#'e to 6o!i'e )t"tio# $o >(e)tio#i#- , ") t e '(!6 it) " e i- % /i- t . t i) t 6e o$ o#e)ided >(e)tio#i#- /()t #ot e do#e 6o!i'e o i#9e)ti-"ti#- "-e#'ie) . i$ "# t i#- (#to=" d "66e#) to /e o to / $"/i! /e/ e ) !i e !o)) o$ ?o ,/eeti#- =it it % (# "''ide#t) , !o)) o$ !i9e) , de"t d(e to i/6 o6e /edi'"! '" e , et' , t e ?( i)di'tio#"! 6o!i'e to-et e =it " o9e /e#tio#ed"''())ed 6( !i' )e 9"#t) =i!! e e)6o#)i !e $o it. E9e# i$ ' i/i#"! #e () !e9e!) $" e ' " -e) , 6o!i'e $i!e $" e '")e) "-"i#)t /e o / de6e#de#t) to)i!e#'e /e , t i) 'o/6!"i#t i) % =i!! e e$$e'ti9e.

I$ I o / $"/i! /e/ e ) o / de6e#de#t) " e de#ied o( $(#d"/e#t"! i- t) , (/"# i- t) , de#ied 6 o6e /edi'"! '" e $o o( )e!9e) , I$ "# t i#-(#to=" d "66e#) to /e o to / de6e#de#t) o to / $"/i! /e/ e ) I# )(' '")e C ie$ J()ti'e o$ I#di" to-et e =it t e ?( i)di'tio#"! e9e#(e %6o!i'e o$$i'i"!) =i!! e e)6o#)i !e $o it , i# )(' '")e t e -o9e #/e#t o$ i#di" i) !i" !e to 6" R). TWO ' o e ") 'o/6e#)"tio# to )( 9i9o ) o$ / $"/i! .i$ / = o!e $"/i! i) e!i/i#"ted t e ' i/i#"! #e () ,t e# t "t 'o/6e#)"tio# /o#e /()t e do#"ted to I#di"# A / We!$" e F(#d. A$te =" d) , t e/o#e /()t e e'o9e ed GOI ") !"#d " e" ) $ o/ t e )"!" , 6e#)io# , 6 o6e t , et' o$ -(i!t 6o!i'e o$$i'i"!) , J(d-e) , 6( !i' )e 9"#t) %Co#)tit(tio#"! $('tio#" ie).

T e Petitio#e ") )e#t /"# !ette ) "66e"!) 6etitio#) to )(6 e/e 'o( t o$ i#di" % ot e 'o( t) t o(- e /"i! , DARPG =e )ite % t o(- e-(!"/"i! e>(e)ti#- t e/ to 'o#)ide t o)e ") PIL). (t #o#e o$t e/ =e e "d/itted , e9e# "' #o=!ed-e/e#t $o e'ei6t) =e e #ot -i9e#. See Ho= d(t'o#)'io() ,o( ?(d-e) " e % )ee o= o( ?(d-e) " e )e#)iti9e to=" d) !i$e , !i e t o$ 'itiBe#) , 'o//o#/e# % )ee o='" e!e)) o( ?(d-e) " e to=" d)"#ti #"tio#"! ' i/e) , ' i/e) =o t ' o e) o$ (6ee). T "t t e 6 e)e#t 6etitio#e ") #ot $i!ed "# ot e 6etitio# = i' " e "d/itted 'o( t) i# "#Hi- Co( t o t e S(6 e/e Co( t o$ I#di" o# t e )( ?e't /"tte o$ t e 6 e)e#t 6etitio#.


" . He e , I do e>(e)t t e o#o " !e )(6 e/e 'o( t o$ I#di" to 'o#)ide t i) ") " PIL $o ; = it o$ M"#d"/() "#d to i))(e i#)t ('tio#) to t e'o#'e #ed 6( !i' )e 9"#t) i# t e $o!!o=i#- '")e) to 6e $o / t ei d(tie) % to "#)=e t e >(e)tio#).


'. To !e-"!! 6 o)e'(te t e 6( !i' )e 9"#t) = o " e e)6o#)i !e $o #ot -i9i#- 6 e)) "'' edit"tio# to / =e #e=) 6"6e ) , / )e!$ ") " ?o( #"!i)t "#de)6o#)i !e $o '!o)( e o$ / #e=) 6"6e ).

d. To !e-"!! 6 o)e'(te "(t o itie) o$ M ) RPG C" !e) Ltd , = o de#ied ?o o66o t(#itie) to /e (#de t e e e)t o$ ' i/i#"!) e)6o#)i !e $o !"te PMR"?i9 G"#d i "))"))i#"tio# '")e.

e. To !e-"!! 6 o)e'(te "(t o itie) o$ M ) PES Co!!e-e o$ E#-i#ee i#- , = o de#ied ?o o66o t(#itie) to /e (#de t e e e)t o$ ' i/i#"!) e)6o#)i !e$o !"te PM R"?i9 G"#d i "))"))i#"tio# '")e.


17/41

$. To !e-"!! 6 o)e'(te "(t o itie) o$ M ) N"tio#"! I#)tit(te o$ E#-i#ee i#- , = o de#ied ?o o66o t(#itie) to /e (#de t e e e)t o$ ' i/i#"!)e)6o#)i !e $o !"te PM R"?i9 G"#d i "))"))i#"tio# '")e.

-. To !e-"!! 6 o)e'(te "(t o itie) o$ M ) Re)e 9e "# Note N(d "# P9t Ltd , = o de#ied ?o o66o t(#itie) to /e (#de t e e e)t o$ ' i/i#"!)e)6o#)i !e $o !"te PM R"?i9 G"#d i "))"))i#"tio# '")e.

. To !e-"!! 6 o)e'(te "(t o itie) o$ M )o e Di)t i't Co( t) % "#-"!o e Di)t i't Co( t) , = o de#ied ?o o66o t(#itie) to /e (#de t e e e)t o$' i/i#"!) e)6o#)i !e $o !"te PM R"?i9 G"#d i "))"))i#"tio# '")e.

i. To !e-"!! 6 o)e'(te 6e )o#) e)6o#)i !e $o "tte/6t) o# / !i$e.

?. to !e-"!! 6 o)e'(te ?(d-e) , 6o!i'e % C I o$$i'i"!) e)6o#)i !e $o 'o9e (6 o$ !"te PM R"?i9 G"#d i "))"))i#"tio# '")e.

4 . To 6 o9ide 6 ote'tio# to !i$e , !i e t , !i9e!i ood , ?o ) o$ /e , / $"/i! /e/ e ) % de6e#d"#t).

!. To eo6e# , ei#9e)ti-"te "))"))i#"tio# '")e o$ L"te PM R"?i9 G"#d i.

/. To !e-"!! 6 o)e'(te "(t o itie) o$ )(6 e/e 'o( t o$ i#di" $o #ot "#)=e i#- ) o= '"()e #oti'e i))(ed to t e/ "#d o de t e/ to "#)=e t e ) o='"()e #oti'e ") =e!! ") RTI >(e)tio#) -i9e# to t e/ t e 6etitio#e .

#. To 'o#d('t "# i/6" ti"! , t "#)6" e#t )(6 e/e 'o( t /o#ito ed e#>(i i#to '")e) /e#tio#ed /e.

o. To "d/it "!! PIL) $i!ed /e i# !" -e 6( !i' i#te e)t.

6. To i#iti"te ' i/i#"! 6 o)e'(tio# o$ 6( !i' )e 9"#t) , 6o!i'e % ?(d-e) = o " e t i#- to 'o9e (6 ' i/e "#d ' i/i#"!) de# i#- /e i#$o /"tio# , #ott" i#- "'tio# o# o( "66e"!) , PIL).

>. To "=" d /e " 'o/6e#)"tio# o$ RUPEES TWO CRORES to=" d) t e !o))e) I "9e )($$e ed "#d i#?()ti'e) I "/ )ti!! -oi#- t o(- $o $i- ti#- $o6( !i' '"()e).

. To e'o9e 'o/6e#)"tio# "/o(#t ") !"#d " e" ) $ o/ -(i!t 6o!i'e , -(i!t ?(d-e) % -(i!t 6( !i' )e 9"#t) i#di9id("!! .

). To 6e /it /e to =o i# t e i#9e)ti-"tio# te"/ , to "))i)t t e/ i# i#9e)ti-"tio# )( ?e't to 'o#ditio#) .

t . to 6")) )(' ot e o de ) "#d $( t e o de ) ") /" e dee/ed #e'e))" o# t e $"'t) "#d i# t e 'i '(/)t"#'e) o$ t e '")e.

(. . 8S8 $;' P (" !e) . A d" =o(!d 'o/e = e# e9e# "i % ="te =i!! e t" ed.< Si Wi#)to# /"de t i) )t"te/e#t i# t e Ho()e o$ Co//o#)


18/41

?()t e$o e t e i#de6e#de#'e o$ I#di" % P" i)t"#. S"d! , t e $o e=" #i#- o$ L"te Wi#)to# C ( ' i!! ") ee# 6 o9ed i- t )o/e o$ o( ' i/i#"! , 'o (6t 6( !i')e 9"#t).

2. A) " e)(!t o$ $i- ti#- $o 6( !i' '"()e) , 6( !i' -ood I "9e i#di9id("!! )($$e ed #(/e o() i#?()ti'e) "#d )ti!! )($$e i#- i#?()ti'e). M #e=)6"6e 6( !i'"tio#=") i!!e-"!! '!o)ed do=# , / =e #e=) 6"6e #ot -i9e# =it 6 e)) "'' editio# , / ?o o66( t(#itie) i# R I Note 6 e)) , PES E#-i#ee i#- 'o!!e-e , NIEE#-i#ee i#- 'o!!e-e , M )o e di)t i't 'o( t , et' )#"t' ed "=" i!!e-"!! , I =") e"te# (6 , "tte/6t) o# / !i$e =e e /"de e9e# "$te i#-i#- t e"t) to / !i$e=e e o(- t to #oti'e o$ )(6 e/e 'o( t o$ i#di". See o= d(t d(t 'o#)'io() o( )(6 e/e 'o( t ?(d-e) " e "!! t e)e )($$e i#-) $o 6( !i' '"()e) I "9e "i)ed% to )i!e#'e /e.

2. (e)tio# ) o$ L"=;

A e 6o!i'e % J(d-e) " o9e !"= C"# J(d-e) % Po!i'e Co/itt ' i/e) , -o )'ot $ ee

7. G o(#d);Re>(e)t) $o e>(it" !e ?()ti'e , P o)e'(tio# o$ 'o (6t 6( !i' )e 9"#t) , 'o (6t ?(d-e) , 'o (6t 6o!i'e.

. A9e /e#t;


T e Petitio#e ") )e#t /"# !ette ) "66e"!) 6etitio#) to )(6 e/e 'o( t o$ i#di" % ot e 'o( t) t o(- e /"i! , DARPG =e )ite % t o(- e-(!" /"i!e>(e)ti#- t e/ to 'o#)ide t o)e ") PIL). (t #o#e o$t e/ =e e "d/itted , e9e# "' #o=!ed-e/e#t $o e'ei6t) =e e #ot -i9e#. See Ho= d(t 'o#)'io() ,o(

?(d-e) " e % )ee o= o( ?(d-e) " e )e#)iti9e to=" d) !i$e , !i e t o$ 'itiBe#) , 'o//o#/e# % )ee o='" e!e)) o( ?(d-e) " e to=" d) "#ti #"tio#"! ' i/e) ,' i/e) =o t ' o e) o$ (6ee). T "t t e 6 e)e#t 6etitio#e ") #ot $i!ed "# ot e 6etitio# = i' " e "d/itted 'o( t) i# "# Hi- Co( t o t e S(6 e/e Co( t o$I#di" o# t e )( ?e't /"tte o$ t e 6 e)e#t 6etitio#.


" . He e , I do e>(e)t t e o#o " !e )(6 e/e 'o( t o$ I#di" to 'o#)ide t i) ") " PIL $o ; = it o$ M"#d"/() "#d to i))(e i#)t ('tio#) to t e 'o#'e #ed 6( !i')e 9"#t) i# t e $o!!o=i#- '")e) to 6e $o / t ei d(tie) % to "#)=e t e >(e)tio#).


'. To !e-"!! 6 o)e'(te t e 6( !i' )e 9"#t) = o " e e)6o#)i !e $o #ot -i9i#- 6 e)) "'' edit"tio# to / =e #e=) 6"6e ) , / )e!$ ") " ?o( #"!i)t "#d e)6o#)i !e$o '!o)( e o$ / #e=) 6"6e ).

d. To !e-"!! 6 o)e'(te "(t o itie) o$ M ) RPG C" !e) Ltd , = o de#ied ?o o66o t(#itie) to /e (#de t e e e)t o$ ' i/i#"!) e)6o#)i !e $o !"te PM R"?i9 G"#d i"))"))i#"tio# '")e.

e. To !e-"!! 6 o)e'(te "(t o itie) o$ M ) PES Co!!e-e o$ E#-i#ee i#- , = o de#ied ?o o66o t(#itie) to /e (#de t e e e)t o$ ' i/i#"!) e)6o#)i !e $o !"te PMR"?i9 G"#d i "))"))i#"tio# '")e.

$. To !e-"!! 6 o)e'(te "(t o itie) o$ M ) N"tio#"! I#)tit(te o$ E#-i#ee i#- , = o de#ied ?o o66o t(#itie) to /e (#de t e e e)t o$ ' i/i#"!) e)6o#)i !e $o !"te PMR"?i9 G"#d i "))"))i#"tio# '")e.

-. To !e-"!! 6 o)e'(te "(t o itie) o$ M ) Re)e 9e "# Note M(d "# P9t Ltd , = o de#ied ?o o66o t(#itie) to /e (#de t e e e)t o$ ' i/i#"!) e)6o#)i !e $o !"tePM R"?i9 G"#d i "))"))i#"tio# '")e.

. To !e-"!! 6 o)e'(te "(t o itie) o$ M )o e Di)t i't Co( t) % "#-"!o e Di)t i't Co( t) , = o de#ied ?o o66o t(#itie) to /e (#de t e e e)t o$ ' i/i#"!)e)6o#)i !e $o !"te PM R"?i9 G"#d i "))"))i#"tio# '")e.

i. To !e-"!! 6 o)e'(te 6e )o#) e)6o#)i !e $o "tte/6t) o# / !i$e.

?. to !e-"!! 6 o)e'(te ?(d-e) , 6o!i'e % C I o$$i'i"!) e)6o#)i !e $o 'o9e (6 o$ !"te PM R"?i9 G"#d i "))"))i#"tio# '")e.

4 . To 6 o9ide 6 ote'tio# to !i$e , !i e t , !i9e!i ood , ?o ) o$ /e , / $"/i! /e/ e ) % de6e#d"#t).

!. To eo6e# , ei#9e)ti-"te "))"))i#"tio# '")e o$ L"te PM R"?i9 G"#d i.

/. To !e-"!! 6 o)e'(te "(t o itie) o$ )(6 e/e 'o( t o$ i#di" $o #ot "#)=e i#- ) o= '"()e #oti'e i))(ed to t e/ "#d o de t e/ to "#)=e t e ) o= '"()e #oti'e") =e!! ") RTI >(e)tio#) -i9e# to t e/ t e 6etitio#e .

#. To 'o#d('t "# i/6" ti"! , t "#)6" e#t )(6 e/e 'o( t /o#ito ed e#>(i i#to '")e) /e#tio#ed /e.

o. To "d/it "!! PIL) $i!ed /e i# !" -e 6( !i' i#te e)t.

6. To i#iti"te ' i/i#"! 6 o)e'(tio# o$ 6( !i' )e 9"#t) , 6o!i'e % ?(d-e) = o " e t i#- to 'o9e (6 ' i/e "#d ' i/i#"!) de# i#- /e i#$o /"tio# , #ot t" i#-"'tio# o# o( "66e"!) , PIL).

>. To "=" d /e " 'o/6e#)"tio# o$ RUPEES TWO CRORES to=" d) t e !o))e) I "9e )($$e ed "#d i#?()ti'e) I "/ )ti!! -oi#- t o(- $o $i- ti#- $o 6( !i''"()e).

. To e'o9e 'o/6e#)"tio# "/o(#t ") !"#d " e" ) $ o/ -(i!t 6o!i'e , -(i!t ?(d-e) % -(i!t 6( !i' )e 9"#t) i#di9id("!! .

). To 6e /it /e to =o i# t e i#9e)ti-"tio# te"/ , to "))i)t t e/ i# i#9e)ti-"tio# )( ?e't to 'o#ditio#) .

t . to 6")) )(' ot e o de ) "#d $( t e o de ) ") /" e dee/ed #e'e))" o# t e $"'t) "#d i# t e 'i '(/)t"#'e) o$ t e '")e.


D"ted ; 27 d J(! 2015 .FILED :; NAGARAJA.M.R.

P!"'e ; M )( ( , I#di" .PETITIONER IN PERSON


19/41

B# 67* E *egal 6rose1ution of %o ern5ent offi1ials 3 6ubli1 Ser ants in ol e! in Relian1e S1a5s



IN THE MATTER OF

NAGARAJA . M.R ,



He "! , M )o e 3 5+001+ , 4" #"t" " St"te

.....Petitio#e

&e )()

Ho#o( " !e C" i#et Se' et" , PMO , Go9e #/e#t o$ I#di" % Ot e )

....Re)6o#de#t)



To ,




1. F"'t) o$ t e '")e;


A .


20/41

T "t t e 6 e)e#t 6etitio#e ") #ot $i!ed "# ot e 6etitio# = i' " e "d/itted 'o( t) i# "# Hi- Co( t o t e S(6 e/e Co( t o$ I#di" o# t e )( ?e't /"tte o$t e 6 e)e#t 6etitio#.

PRA:ER;



ii He e , I do e>(e)t t e o#o( !e )(6 e/e 'o( t o$ i#di" to !e-"!! 6 o)e'(te -(i!t o$$i'i"!) /e#tio#ed i# t e " o9e )"id e6o t.

iii He e , I do e>(e)t t e o#o( !e )(6 e/e 'o( t o$ i#di" to (6 o!d t e 'o#)tit(tio# o$ i#di" , to 6 ote't #"t( "! e)o( 'e) "#d to 6 ote't t e 'o#)tit(tio#"!i- t) o$ "!! I#di"# 'itiBe#) i#'!(di#- /i#e.

i9 He e , I do e>(e)t t e o#o( !e )(6 e/e 'o( t o$ i#di" to i//edi"te! ee6 "!! -o9e #/e#t o$$i'i"!) /e#tio#ed i# t e " o9e )"id e6o t (#de )()6e#)io#$ o/ )e 9i'e % to t" e #e'e))" )te6) to 6 ote't "!! t 6e o$ e9ide#'e).



D"te ; 2 t No9e/ e 2015 Fi!ed ; N"-" "?".M.R.

P!"'e ; M )( ( I#di" ..Petitio#e i# 6e )o#

C# 67* E *egal 6rose1ution of offi1ials in ol e! in 8ellary 'ining S1a5



IN THE MATTER OF

NAGARAJA . M.R ,



He "! , M )o e 3 5+001+ , 4" #"t" " St"te

.....Petitio#e

&e )()

Ho#o( " !e C ie$ Se' et" , Go9e #/e#t o$ 4" #"t" " % Ot e )

....Re)6o#de#t)



To ,


21/41




1. F"'t) o$ t e '")e;


A . (e)t t e o#o( !e )(6 e/e 'o( t o$ i#di" to (6 o!d t e 'o#)tit(tio# o$ i#di" , to 6 ote't #"t( "! e)o( 'e) "#d to 6 ote't t e 'o#)tit(tio#"!i- t) o$ "!! I#di"# 'itiBe#) i#'!(di#- /i#e.

i9 He e , I do e>(e)t t e o#o( !e )(6 e/e 'o( t o$ i#di" to i//edi"te! ee6 "!! -o9e #/e#t o$$i'i"!) /e#tio#ed i# t e " o9e )"id e6o t (#de )()6e#)io#

$ o/ )e 9i'e % to t" e #e'e))" )te6) to 6 ote't "!! t 6e o$ e9ide#'e).



D"te ; 0 t No9e/ e 2015 Fi!ed ; N"-" "?".M.R.



22/41

D# P$% & ("!! e)6o#)i !eto (6 o!d 'o#)tit(tio# . O#! Peo6!e , CitiBe#) o$ I#di" " e )(6 e/e No J(d-e) , No Mi#i)te ) , et' " e )(6 e/e. J(d-e) , /i#i)te ) , 6 e)ide#t et' " e "!! 6( !i')e 9"#t) 'o#)tit(tio#"!! /"#d"ted to SER&E t e 6( !i' , NOT to /")te o9e t e/. E9e# "$te e" ) o$ i#de6e#de#'e t e)e ?(d-e) , /i#i)te ) "9e #ot'o/e o(t o$ 'o!o#i"! "#-o9e i#)te"d e'o/e =o )e t e"ti#- -e#e "! 6( !i' ") t ei )e 9"#t).

C . U#io# '" ide 6!"#t UCIL =") (#)"$e "#d i#d(!-ed i# (#)"$e =o 6 "'ti'e) , /"i#te#"#'e =") i#"de>("te.

D . E9e# " !o'"! ?o( #"!i)t t o(- " #e=) 6( !i'"tio# 6( !i'! o(- t to #oti'e o$ "(t o itie) 'o#'e #ed 6e i!) o$ o6"! -") 6!"#t , e" ) e$o e t e o6"! -")!e" , i#d()t i"! "''ide#t o''( ed . He $o e=" #ed.

E . I#)6ite o$ $o e=" #i#- M"d " P "de) I#d()t ie) , F"'to ie) I#)6e'to "te de6" t/e#t) $"i!ed to t" e "de>("te )te6) , "!!o=ed t e UCIL 6!"#t to (#(#i#te (6ted.

F . I#)6ite o$ $o =" #i#- M"d " P "de) )t"te 6o!!(tio# 'o#t o! o" d $"i!ed to t" e "de>("te )te6) , "!!o=ed t e UCIL 6!"#t to (# (#i#te (6ted.

G . M"d " P "de) )t"te -o9e #/e#t )ide )ide =it UCIL /"#"-e/e#t i) e>("!! e)6o#)i !e $o t e o6"! -") !e" '")e. It $"i!ed to do it@) )t"t(tod(tie) "#d to 6 e9e#t di)")te i# ti/e.

H . E9e# "$te t e di)")te too 6!"'e , M"d " P "de) )t"te -o9e #/e#t "#d Go9e #/e#t o$ I#di" i#)te"d o$ !e-"!! 6 o)e'(ti#- M .W" e# A#de )o# He"d o$ UCIL = o =") i# '()tod , i!!e-"!! , "Be#! e!6ed i/ to (# "=" $ o/ !"=.

I . E9e# "$te t e di)")te too 6!"'e , M"d " P "de) )t"te -o9e #/e#t $"i!ed to !e-"!! " e)t "#d 6 o)e'(te (#io# '" ide to6 e e'(ti9e).

J . U#io# C" ide USA e"d >(" te ) ="#ted !(' "ti9e I#di"# /" et , ' e"6 I#di"# e)o( 'e) , ' e"6 I#di"# !" o , !" I#di"# !"=) (t did#@t "9e t e de'e#'to e)6e't I#di"# !"=).

4 . Go9e #/e#t o$ I#di" , Go9e #/e#t o$ M"d " P "de) $"i!ed to )ee e t "ditio# o$ M . W" e# A#de )o# "#d ot e to6 U#io# C" ide e e'(ti9e) $ o/ USA.T e $"i!ed to -et i- t 'o)t % 'o/6e#)"tio# $ o/ US Co 6o "te -i"#t % US -o9e #/e#t.

L . T e -o9e #/e#t o$ USA "#d S(6 e/e Co( t o$ USA i) 6 "'ti'i#- do( !e )t"#d" d) , ?()t )ee t e e "/6!e o$ P oi! )6i!!"-e i# USA te ito " U4 ")ed'o 6o "te -i"#t. T e -o9e #/e#t o$ USA % S(6 e/e Co( t o$ USA e t "'ted (-e 'o)t % 'o/6e#)"tio# $ o/ U4 ")ed iti) Pet o!e(/ , $o A/e i'"# 'itiBe#))($$e i#- d(e to t e oi! )6i!!"-e. T e " o-"#t Go9e #/e#t o$ USA % S(6 e/e Co( t o$ USA ) "/e!e))! 6e 'ei9e) !i9e) o$ A/e i'"#) 6 e'io() "#d ot e ) ")' e"6. O( )6i#e!e)) I#di"# -o9e #/e#t , )(6 e/e 'o( t o$ i#di" o=) , o= to=) e$o e t e/.

M . T e -o9e #/e#t o$ I#di" % Go9e #/e#t o$ M"d " P "de) = o " e t e/)e!9e) '(!6 it) "!o#-=it UCIL to 'o9e (6 t ei o=# ' i/e) , to $"9o US/(!ti#"tio#"! e#"'ted " #e= !"= '( t"i!i#- t e !e-"! i- t) o$ o6"! -") 9i'ti/) , I#di"# 'itiBe#).

N . S "/e!e))! S(6 e/e Co( t o$ I#di" , =e#t " )te6 $( t e T e# C ie$ J()ti'e o$ I#di" J()ti'e A /"di % i) e#' 'o!!e"-(e) di!(ted t e 6e#"! ' " -e) o$6 o)e'(tio#.

O . Ti!! d"te #eit e U#io# C" ide #o DOW = o too o9e t e /"#"-e/e#t o$ U#io# C" ide ") 6"id i- t 'o)t % 'o/6e#)"tio# #o t e "9e '" ed " o(tt e '!e"# (6 o$ o6"! -") di)")te )ite ti!! d"te e9e# "$te de'"de).

P . W e# Go9e #/e#t o$ USA % S(6 e/e Co( t o$ USA doe) #ot e)6e't I#di"# L"=) , I#di"# 'itiBe#) = ) o(!d A/e i'"# CitiBe#) , A/e i'"# Co 6o "tio#) , A/e i'"# I#te e)t) i# I#di"# te ito ) o(!d e 6 ote'ted


23/41

2. (e)tio# ) o$ L"=;

A e M(!ti #"tio#"! Co 6o "tio#) % it@) to6 e e'(ti9e) " o9e !"= I) t e "'t) o$ o( /i#i)te ) , ?(d-e) i# "idi#- " ' i/i#"! , $(-iti9e to (# "=" $ o/ !"= ?()t , !e-"!

7. G o(#d);

Re>(e)t) $o e>(it" !e ?()ti'e , !e-"! 6 o)e'(tio# o$ -(i!t (#de ARTICLE 21 , ARTICLE 1 3 1 , ARTICLE 21 , )ee i#- J()ti'e , 'o/6e#)"tio# "#d $oi))("#'e o$ WRIT o$ MANDAMUS UNDER ARTICLE 72 % ARTICLE 22 OF THE CONSTITUTION OF INDIA.

. A9e /e#t;

Gi9e = "t "'tio# ") ee# t" e# "-"i#)t '(!6 it) i#9o!9ed i# o6"! -") !e" '")e ti!! d"te.

PRA:ER;



ii He e , I do e>(e)t t e o#o( " !e )(6 e/e 'o( t o$ i#di" to !e-"!! 6 o)e'(te M"d " P "de) )t"te -o9e #/e#t i#d()t de6" t/e#t , $"'to ie) )"$et %

I#)6e'to "te de6" t/e#t "#d MP Po!!(tio# Co#t o! o" d o$$i'i"!) $o ' i/i#"! #e-!i-e#'e o$ d(tie).

iii He e , I do e>(e)t t e o#o( " !e )(6 e/e 'o( t o$ i#di" to !e-"!! 6 o)e'(te t e MP )t"te -o9e #/e#t % I#di"# -o9e #/e#t /i#i)te ) "#d o$$i'i"!) = oe!6ed $(-iti9e M . W" e# A#de )o# to (# "=" $ o/ I#di"# !"=.

i9 He e , I do e>(e)t t e o#o( " !e )(6 e/e 'o( t o$ i#di" to !e-"!! 6 o)e'(te t e MP )t"te -o9e #/e#t % I#di"# -o9e #/e#t /i#i)te ) "#d o$$i'i"!) = o$"i!ed to )ee e t "ditio# o$ M . A#de )o# "#d ot e UC to6 e e'(ti9e) $ o/ USA.

9 He e , I do e>(e)t t e o#o( " !e )(6 e/e 'o( t o$ i#di" to !e-"!! 6 o)e'(te t e MP )t"te -o9e #/e#t % I#di"# -o9e #/e#t /i#i)te ) "#d o$$i'i"!) = o$"i!ed to e t "'t "66 o6 i"te 'o/6e#)"tio# , 'o)t) $ o/ U#io# C" ide o $ o/ DOW o $ o/ 'o(#te -(" "#to Go9e #/e#t o$ USA ti!! d"te.

9i He e , I do e>(e)t t e o#o( " !e )(6 e/e 'o( t o$ i#di" to de'!" e 9oid , "##(! t e o6"! G") &i'ti/) A't "#d e!"ted e#"'t/e#t) , -o9e #/e#to de ) 6"))ed ot Go9e #/e#t o$ I#di" "#d Go9e #/e#t o$ M"d " P "de) = i' '( t"i!) t e 'o#)tit(tio#"! i- t) o$ o6"! -") !e" 9i'ti/).

9ii He e , I do e>(e)t t e o#o( " !e )(6 e/e 'o( t o$ i#di" to !e-"!! 6 o)e'(te $o /e ' ie$ ?()ti'e o$ i#di" M . A /"di % i) e#' 'o!!e"-(e) = o di!(tedt e 6 o)e'(tio# ' " -e) "-"i#)t (#io# '" ide "#d it@) to6 e e'(ti9e).

9iii He e , I do e>(e)t t e o#o( " !e )(6 e/e 'o( t o$ i#di" to o de DOW C e/i'"!) to 6" t e "66 o6 i"te 'o)t % 'o/6e#)"tio# to=" d) o6"! -")!e" di)")te .

i He e , I do e>(e)t t e o#o( " !e )(6 e/e 'o( t o$ i#di" to o de Go9e #/e#t o$ USA , S(6 e/e Co( t o$ USA to e)6e't I#di"# L"= i$ t e ="#te'i6 o'"! e)6e't. To o de -o9e #/e#t o$ USA % S(6 e/e Co( t o$ USA to e t "dite $o /e to6 e e'(ti9e) o$ U#io# C" ide to I#di" , to e#)( e "66 o6 i"te

6" /e#t o$ 'o)t , 'o/6e#)"tio# i# t e )"id '")e ") -o9e #/e#t o$ USA "66e#) to e " 'o(#te -(" "#to .

To de'!" e P e)ide#t o$ USA % C ie$ J()ti'e o$ USA ") ' i/i#"!) $o t ei do( !e )t"#d" d) , $o "idi#- 6e 6et "to ) o$ /"# )!"(- te "t o6"! .

I To o de $o C I i#9e)ti-"tio# i#to "))et) o$ M .A /"di , /i#i)te ) , -o9e #/e#t o$$i'i"!) = o e!6ed (#io# '" ide % it@) e e'(ti9e).


D"te ; 0+ t No9e/ e 2015 Fi!ed ; N"-" "?".M.R.

P!"'e ; M )( ( I#di" ..Petitio#e i# 6e )o#

10# P$% : %and Mafia and (udges



IN THE MATTER OF

NAGARAJA . M.R


&e )()

Ho#o( " !e C ie$ Se' et" , Go9e #/e#t o$ 4" #"t" " % Ot e )


24/41

....Re)6o#de#t)

PETITION UNDER ARTICLE 12 to ARTICLE 75 % ARTICLE 51A OF THE CONSTITUTION OF INDIA FOR ISSUANCE OF A WRIT IN THE NATURE OFMANDAMUS UNDER ARTICLE 72 % ARTICLE 22 OF THE CONSTITUTION OF INDIA.

To ,Ho#8 !e T e C ie$ J()ti'e o$ I#di" "#d Hi) Lo d) i68) Co/6"#io#J()ti'e) o$ t e S(6 e/e Co( t o$ I#di". T e H(/ !e 6etitio# o$ t ePetitio#e " o9e #"/ed.

MOST RESPECTFULL: SHOWETH ;1. F"'t) o$ t e '")e;(e)t t e o#o " !e )(6 e/e 'o( t o$ I#di" to 'o#)ide t i) ") " PIL $o ; = it o$ M"#d"/() "#d to i))(e i#)t ('tio#) to t e 'o#'e #ed 6( !i')e 9"#t) i# t e $o!!o=i#- '")e) to 6e $o / t ei d(tie) % to "#)=e t e >(e)tio#).

T e Petitio#e ") )e#t /"# !ette ) "66e"!) 6etitio#) to )(6 e/e 'o( t o$ i#di" % ot e 'o( t) t o(- e /"i! , DARPG =e )ite % t o(- e-(!" /"i!e>(e)ti#- t e/ to 'o#)ide t o)e ") PIL). (t #o#e o$t e/ =e e "d/itted , e9e# "' #o=!ed-e/e#t $o e'ei6t) =e e #ot -i9e#. See Ho= d(t 'o#)'io() ,o(

?(d-e) " e % )ee o= o( ?(d-e) " e )e#)iti9e to=" d) !i$e , !i e t o$ 'itiBe#) , 'o//o#/e# % )ee o='" e!e)) o( ?(d-e) " e to=" d) "#ti #"tio#"! ' i/e) ,' i/e) =o t ' o e) o$ (6ee). T "t t e 6 e)e#t 6etitio#e ") #ot $i!ed "# ot e 6etitio# = i' " e "d/itted 'o( t) i# "# Hi- Co( t o t e S(6 e/e Co( t o$I#di" o# t e )( ?e't /"tte o$ t e 6 e)e#t 6etitio#.


" . He e , I do e>(e)t t e o#o " !e )(6 e/e 'o( t o$ I#di" to 'o#)ide t i) ") " PIL $o ; = it o$ M"#d"/() "#d to i))(e i#)t ('tio#) to t e 'o#'e #ed 6( !i')e 9"#t) , Go9e #/e#t o$ 4" #"t" " "(t o itie) i# t e $o!!o=i#- '")e) to 6e $o / t ei d(tie) % to "#)=e t e >(e)tio#).


https://sites.google.com/site/sosevoiceforjustice/rti-first-appeal---muda-bda-kiadbhttps://sites.google.com/site/sosevoiceforjustice/rti-first-appeal---muda-bda-kiadb


25/41

FOR WHICH ACT OF 4INDNESS, THE PETITIONER SHALL E DUT: OUND, E&ER

do judges deserve huge salaries ?

Documents