disease emergence and resurgence: the wildlife-human connection

Prepared by the USGS National Wildlife Health Center in cooperation with the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service

Disease Emergence and Resurgence: The Wildlife-Human Connection

Circular 1285

U.S. Department of the Interior U.S. Geological Survey

Disease Emergence and Resurgence: The Wildlife-Human ConnectionBy Milton Friend With contributions from James W. Hurley, Pauline Nol, and Katherine Wesenberg

Prepared by the USGS National Wildlife Health Center in cooperation with the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service

Circular 1285

U.S. Department of the Interior U.S. Geological Survey

U.S. Department of the Interior Gale A. Norton, Secretary U.S. Geological Survey P. Patrick Leahy, Acting DirectorU.S. Geological Survey, Reston, Virginia: 2006Major funding support was provided by the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, Division of Federal Assistance, Administrative Grant No. AP95-017.For product and ordering information: World Wide Web: http://www.usgs.gov/pubprod Telephone: 1-888-ASK-USGS For more information on the USGS--the Federal source for science about the Earth, its natural and living resources, natural hazards, and the environment: World Wide Web: http://www.usgs.gov Telephone: 1-888-ASK-USGS For information about the USGS National Wildlife Health Center please visit http://www.nwhc.usgs.gov/

Any use of trade, product, or firm names is for descriptive purposes only and does not imply endorsement by the U.S. Government. Although this report is in the public domain, permission must be secured from the individual copyright owners to reproduce any copyrighted materials contained within this report. Suggested citation: Friend, Milton, 2006, Disease Emergence and Resurgence: The Wildlife-Human Connection: Reston, Va., U.S. Geological Survey, Circular 1285, 400 p. Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Friend, Milton Disease emergence and resurgence : the wildlife-human connection / by Milton Friend and others ; prepared by the USGS National Wildlife Health Center in cooperation with the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service. --1st ed. p. cm. -- (Circular ; 1285) Includes bibliographical references and index. 1. Zoonoses. 2. Wildlife diseases. 3. Animals as carriers of disease. 4. Communicable diseases--Transmission. 5. Emerging infectious diseases--Transmission. I. National Wildlife Health Center (U.S.) II. U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service. III. Title. IV. Series : U.S. Geological Survey Circular ; 1285. [DNLM: 1. Zoonoses. 2. Communicable Diseases, Emerging--transmission. 3. Disease Reservoirs--veterinary. 4. Bioterrorism. 5. Disease Outbreaks--prevention & control. WC 950 F911d 2005J RA639.F75 2005 614.43--dc22 ISBN 1-411-30664-3 2005027017

ForewordGiven the conspicuous role that diseases have played, and in many parts of the world continue to play, in human demography, it is surprising that ecologists have given so little attention to the way diseases may affect the distribution and abundance of other animals and plants. (May)1

In 2000, the Global Outbreak Alert and Response Network (GOARN) was organized as a global disease watchdog group to coordinate disease outbreak information and health crisis response. The World Health Organization (WHO) is the headquarters for this network.2 Understandably, the primary focus for WHO is human health. However, diseases such as the H5N1 avian influenza epizootic in Asian bird populations demonstrate the need for integrating knowledge about disease emergence in animals and in humans.3,4 Aside from human disease concerns, H5N1 avian influenza has major economic consequences for the poultry industry worldwide.5 Many other emerging diseases, such as severe acute respiratory syndrome (SARS), monkeypox, Ebola fever, and West Nile fever, also have an important wildlife component. Despite these wildlife associations, the true integration of the wildlife component in approaches towards disease emergence remains elusive. This separation between wildlife and other species interests is counterproductive because the emergence of zoonotic viruses and other pathogens maintained by wildlife reservoir hosts is poorly understood.6 This book is about the wildlife component of emerging diseases. It is intended to enhance the readers awareness of the role of wildlife in disease emergence. By doing so, perhaps a more holistic approach to disease prevention and control will emerge for the benefit of human, domestic animal, and free-ranging wildlife populations alike. The perspectives offered are influenced by more than four decades of my experiences as a wildlife disease practitioner. Although wildlife are victims to many of the same disease agents affecting humans and domestic animals, many aspects of disease in free-ranging wildlife require different approaches than those commonly applied to address disease in humans or domestic animals. Nevertheless, the broader community of disease investigators and health care professionals has largely pursued a separatist approach for human, domestic

animal, and wildlife rather than embracing the periodically proposed concept of one medicine.7 We especially need to embrace this concept as the human population increases because there will be more contact, direct and indirect, among humans, domestic animals, and wildlife. An Ecology for a Crowded Planet8 will be an even more pressing concern, and that includes increasing our understanding of disease ecology, especially that of the zoonoses.9Milton Friend

Literature Cited1. 2. 3. 4. 5. May, R.M., 1988, Conservation and disease: Conservation Biology, v. 2. p. 2830. Enserink, M., 2004, A global fire brigade response to disease outbreaks: Science, v. 303, p. 16051606. Ferguson, N.M., Fraser, C., Donnelly, C.A., Ghani, A.C., Anderson, R.M., 2004, Public health risk from the avian H5N1 influenza epidemic: Science, v. 304, p. 968969. Webby, R.J. and Webster, R.G., 2001, Emergence of influenza A viruses: The Royal Society, v. 356, p. 18171828. World Health Organization, 2004, Avian influenzafrequently asked questions, accessed August 16, 2004, at URL http://www.who.int/csr/disease/avian_influenza/avian_faqs/ en/. Childs, J.E., 2004, Zoonotic viruses of wildlife: hither from yon: Archives of Virology v.18, p. 111. Zinsstag, J., and Weiss, M.G., 2001, Livestock and human health: Science, v. 294, p. 477. Palmer, M., Bernhardt, E., Chornesky, E., Collins, S., Dobson, A., Duke, C., Gold, B., Jacobson, R., Kingsland, S., Kranz, R., Mappin, M., Martinez, M.L., Micheli, F., Morse, J., Pace, M., Pascual, M., Palumbi, S., Reichman, O.J., Simons, A., Townsend, A., and Turner, M., 2004, Ecology for a crowded planet, Science, v. 304, p. 12511252. Marano, N., and Pappaioanou, M., 2004, Historical, new and reemerging links between human and animal health: Emerging Infectious Diseases, v. 10, p. 20652066.

6. 7. 8.

9.

iii

iv

AcknowledgmentsThis publication is the culmination of a fulfilling career far beyond anything I had envisioned. Contributions to my professional development by family and mentors deserve special recognition along with contributions by others because they have provided the foundation for me to undertake such a project. The encouragement, support, and sacrifices by my parents, Leo and Fannie, resulted in my transition from a laborer into the intriguing world of science. My wife, Jacki, enriches my life, provides the love, encouragement, and support that allowed me to experience a career that seems more like a wonderful fairy tale rather than reality. Three of my many mentors also deserve special mention. Professor J. Franklin Witter (Animal Pathology, University of Maine), kindled my interests in diseases of wildlife and started me down the path that I would eventually follow. Dr. Donald J. Dean (Director, Division of Laboratories and Research, New York State Department of Health), introduced me to the challenges of zoonotic disease and encouraged my pursuit of advanced training. Professor Daniel O. Trainer, Jr. (University of Wisconsin) provided a highly stimulating advanced education and learning experience and greatly contributed to my professional development. Collectively, their friendship, guidance, and technical expertise enhanced my knowledge base, technical capabilities, perspectives, and vision. Their patience, understanding, and other traits made them excel as role models and I am forever grateful to have worked with and learned from these outstanding individuals. I also am sincerely grateful to the many individuals who have contributed to the completion of this project through their time, efforts, and thoughtful comments. Ms. Danielle Lohaus and Ms. Melissa Lund typed the draft manuscripts, making countless adjustments to the drafts, organized some of the tables, and assisted in many other ways. A smile was always part of their efforts despite often trying conditions and frequent requests for rapid completion of material. Dr. Margaret Fleischli meticulously checked the numerous citations within the chapters and organized them into numerical lists, compiled the draft lists of scientific names and the glossary of technical terms, and drafted several of the Appendices. Her contributions were invaluable. Ms. Karen Cunningham and Ms. Kathryn Cleary provided searches and tabulations of information from the National Wildlife Health Center (NWHC) databases that were used in various graphics and tables. Ms. Kathy Wesenberg and Ms. Christine Marsh provided invaluable library support though searches and document acquisition that provide the foundation for much of the information presented in this publication. Ms. Carol Williams provided endless photocopy services needed for project operations and assisted with the library support efforts in other ways. Ms. Barbara Littlewood indexed the manual. Ms. Frances J. Bergmann, Ms. Jennifer Rodriguez, and Ms. Rosemary Stenback provided cartography and illustration support, and Ms. Kelly Conrad provided data and information search support. Many NWHC scientific staff and others also deserve special recognition: Dr. David E. Green for his contributions on infectious diseases of amphibians; Dr. Rebecca Cole for her counsel on parasitic diseases; Drs. Kathy Converse, Grace McLaughlin, Joshua Dein, and Rex Sohn for data and counsel involving wildlife mortality events and agency wildlife disease programs; Mr. Doug Docherty for assistance with the taxonomy of viruses; Dr. Frank Panek of the USGS Leetown Science Center for his information on emerging fish diseases; and Drs. Louis N. Locke (retired), David Blehert, Kathy Converse, Kimberly Miller, Bryan Richards, Mr. Bob Dusek, and Mr. Paul Gertler of the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service also deserve special recognition for their laborious manuscript reviews and helpful comments. I am also greatly appreciative of the support, manuscript reviews, other assistance, and great patience and forbearance afforded me in the completion of this project by Dr. Leslie Dierauf, Director of the NWHC, and Deputy Director, Ms. Christine Bunck. I apologize for any omissions in acknowledgment of individual contributions that may have been made by others over the extended period of time required for project completion.Milton Friend

vii

viii

PrefaceScientists need to think beyond traditional disease research and consider the possible roles played by climate change, air travel, and the growth of cities (Dr. FranoisXavier Meslin, World Health Organization)

Because of the increasing human population worldwide, and the greater number of people traveling globally, infectious diseases are spreading more rapidly than in previous decades. Nevertheless, any outbreak, whether zoonotic or another infectious disease, is a local event. Recently, a reporter contacted the National Wildlife Health Center (NWHC) and asked us to predict the next five deadliest diseases that could affect the nation. His urgent request asked us to provide him with every bit of information possible, so he could inform the public about how best to get ready for the next epidemic, be it in wildlife, domestic animals, or people. This is not the first time people or agencies inside or outside the federal government have asked scientists at the NWHC to predict what disease will next rear its ugly head. What will be the next disease du jour? What do you see in your crystal ball? Even though many scientists worldwide are investigating emerging and resurging diseases, no one is able to predict the future, at least not at this time in the fields of wildlife and/or zoonotic diseases. We cannot yet say that on this date, in that location, at this time, disease X will break out in a particular species and from a specific source. Nevertheless, on several occasions NWHC scientists in the field have identified environmental situations prone to disease emergence prior to disease eruptions occurring in wildlife. They have also developed models of environmental factors associated with avian botulism.1 Ecological investigations of diseases by NWHC scientists and others are enhancing our ability to read the landscape relative to disease risks. The time is coming soon though, when we will be ableat the very leastto forecast the next occurrence, perhaps based on climate change predictions, or changes in habitat, or other environmental or ecosystem factors. For example, the altitudinal spread of avian malaria and avian pox in Hawaiian forest birds is a possible outcome of increasing global temperatures.2 Enhanced understanding of the ecology of diseases of wildlife has direct importance for combating many infectious diseases of humans. According to Dr. Mark Woolhouse from the University of Edinburgh (Scotland), humans are plagued by 1,709 known pathogens, 832 of which are zoonotic (49 percent). Of the156 of these diseases that are considered emerging, 114 are zoonotic (73 percent).3 On

the list of high-priority agents of concern for bioterrorism activities from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC), nearly 80 percent are zoonoses (CDC A and B lists). Therefore, the wildlife-human-domestic animal connections are nearly impossible to ignore when investigating wildlife disease. Emerging diseases can be novel or exotic, with either expanded geographic range, emerging in species not previously considered susceptible or spreading in novel ways and to unusual locales and communities. For example, the National Center for Infectious Diseases states Many emerging or reemerging diseases are acquired from animals or are transmitted by arthropods. Environmental changes can affect the incidence of these diseases by altering the habitats of disease vectors.4 Who are the players, and what are their roles in infectious, emerging, and resurging diseases? The short answer is everyone and everything. The long answer is those scientists who study/investigate wildlife, domestic animal, and vector-borne public health and disease, those with interests in conservation, environmental and ecosystem health, and those who believe that public education, politics, and science-based policy are essential components of any process or program related to public health and safety. For truly novel diseases, like SARS and Hendra virus infection, preventing establishment in new geographic areas and host populations should be a primary focus. Triage in each and every outbreak involves these steps: 1. Determine whether or not an outbreak is occurring; 2. Assess the risk level (high, medium, low) of that disease being caused by a zoonotic or other infectious agent; 3. Determine whether exposure to that disease agent will lead to catastrophic losses/impacts and/or mortality/morbidity; 4. Gather data on incidence and exposure routes and rates; 5. Understand prevalence of the particular disease outbreak agent;

v

6. Implement a consistent contingency response to prevent, control, treat and/or manage the risk of contracting that disease; and, 7. Ensure that science-based decisionmaking and policy development take place. Due to the complex nature of information needed to address each of these steps, I believe the future of wildlife disease investigation and study, especially of zoonoses, lies in collaborative and coordinated efforts, undertaken by multiand inter-disciplinary teams of highly motivated individuals, to promote and spread the word of scientific discovery. May this publication make a difference in all you do and motivate you to participate in studies involving the wildlife-humandomestic animal connections related to zoonotic and other infectious diseases.Leslie A. Dierauf, V.M.D. Director, National Wildlife Health Center Madison, WI

Literature Cited1. Rocke, T.E., and Samuel, M.D., 1999, Water and sediment characteristics associated with avian botulism outbreaks in wetlands: Journal of Wildlife Management, v. 63, p. 12491260 Benning, T.L., LaPointe, D., Atkinson, C.T., and Vitousek, P.M., 2002, Interactions of climate change with biological invasions and land use in the Hawaiian Islandsmodeling the fate of endemic birds using a geographic information system: Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, v. 99, p. 1424614249. Enserink, M., 2000, Malaysian researchers trace Nipah virus outbreak to bats: Science, v. 289, p. 518519. Centers for Disease Control, 1998, National Center for Infectious Diseases: Preventing emerging infectious diseasesa strategy for the 21st Century, accessed December 2, 2004 at URL http://www.cdc.gov/ncidod/emergplan/.

2.

3. 4.

vi

BiographiesMilton Friend is an emeritus biologist at the U.S. Geological Surveys National Wildlife Health Center (NWHC) in Madison, Wisconsin. He developed the concept document for the Center and served as the director from its inception in 1975 until 1998. In 1999, he accepted an appointment by the Secretary of the Interior to develop and oversee a science program for the restoration of Californias Salton Sea. He served as chief scientist for that program until early 2002, and then returned to the NWHC to work on this publication. Previous employment includes research on environmental contaminants for the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, serving as the wildlife disease specialist for the New York Department of Environmental Conservation, and positions with the Vermont and the Massachusetts Departments of Fish and Game. He received a B.S. in wildlife conservation from the University of Maine (forestry minor), M.S. in wildlife management from the University of Massachusetts (epidemiology minor), and joint Ph.Ds (veterinary science and wildlife ecology) from the University of Wisconsin (epidemiology minor) where he is an adjunct professor of Animal Health and Biomedical Sciences. His teaching at the University of Wisconsin is focused on diseases of wildlife. Among his numerous publications are the Field Guide to Wildlife Diseases published in 1987 and a greatly expanded and updated 1999 revision co-authored with J.C. Franson, Field Manual of Wildlife Disease, General Field Procedures and Diseases of Birds. Dr. James W. Hurley is a family practice physician in Madison, Wisconsin. He received a B.S. in Zoology from the University of WisconsinMadison in 1965 and an M.D. degree from Tulane University in New Orleans in 1969. He completed his internship and residency in California (UC San Diego and UC Davis). For many years, Jim lived in California, where he practiced at the Truckee-Tahoe Medical Clinic in California. His appreciation of the outdoors, wilderness medicine, and domestic and foreign travel shapes his perspectives on zoonotic and infectious diseases. In working to help the public and other physicians become more aware of appropriate precautions, he believes that awareness leads to prevention.

Pauline Nol is a research scientist at the U.S. Department of Agricultures National Wildlife Research Center in Fort Collins, Colorado, developing vaccines against brucellosis and bovine tuberculosis in wild ungulates. From 1999 to 2003, she worked at the U.S. Geological Surveys National Wildlife Health Center as a graduate student and a post-doctoral researcher, studying avian botulism in fish-eating birds and sylvatic plague in black-footed ferrets and black-tailed prairie dogs. She received a B.S. in Zoology and a D.V.M. from the University of Florida, and an M.S. in Veterinary Science at the University of Wisconsin.

ix

Katherine Wesenberg is the librarian at the U.S. Geological Surveys National Wildlife Health Center. Previous to 1992, when she began at NWHC, she was the librarian for Anaquest Corporation, a pharmaceutical firm. In 1995, she produced a literature review concerning the investigation of avian mortality in the Playa Lakes region of New Mexico. In 1997, she authored a chapter titled The Effects of Pollutants on Wildlife in Information Sources in Environmental Protection (Bowker Saur, 1997). Between 1999 and the present, initiatives involving West Nile virus (WNV) and Chronic Wasting Disease (CWD) have been her major focus. She received her M.S. in Library Science and Information Studies from the University of Wisconsin.

John M. Evans is the graphics subunit chief and senior illustrator with USGS, Denver, Colorado. After attending Eastern New Mexico University, John served four years as a Navy Lithographer/Artist (19681972). John has worked in publications design, created artwork for textbooks, and has provided illustrations and design support to numerous agencies. While working as a supervisory visual information specialist with the Bureau of Reclamation (19791981), John received an Award of Excellence from the Society for Technical Communication for his scientific field guide illustrations. From 1981 to 1989, John developed course artwork and graphic design for the Office of Personnel Management. His work has appeared in many USGS publications including the National Ground Water Atlas, National Water Summary, and a State Department presentation for the Middle East Peace Process. He has also produced artwork for the Colorado Division of Wildlife, National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration, and for numerous college geology textbooks. Elizabeth Ciganovich is a technical editor with the U.S. Geological Survey, Water Resources Discipline, in Madison, Wisconsin. She served on the editorial and design teams for U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service wetland status publications and for the USGS technical report templates, the Field Manual of Wildlife Diseases, General Field Procedures and Diseases of Birds, the National Water Summary series, and the National Ground Water Atlas. She has a degree in journalism from the University of Wisconsin and is a member of the Association of Earth Science Editors.

Gail Moede Rogall is a technical editor and information specialist with the U.S. Geological Surveys National Wildlife Health Center. She has worked at the NWHC since December 1999. Previously, she worked as a technical editor for the USGS Water Resources Discipline in Wisconsin and Massachusetts. Gail received her B.S. in Landscape Architecture and her M.S. in Life Sciences Communication from the University of Wisconsin.

x

ContentsForeword ...........................................................................................................................................................................................................ii Preface ..............................................................................................................................................................................................................v Acknowledgments .........................................................................................................................................................................................vii Biographies ......................................................................................................................................................................................................ix Introduction.......................................................................................................................................................................................................1 Chapter 1. Why This Book? ...........................................................................................................................................................................3 by Milton Friend Chapter 2. Disease Emergence and Resurgence ...................................................................................................................................19 by Milton Friend Chapter 3. The Wildlife Factor ..................................................................................................................................................................127 by Milton Friend Chapter 4. Zoonoses and Travel ...............................................................................................................................................................191 by James W. Hurley and Milton Friend Chapter 5. Is This Safe to Eat? ..................................................................................................................................................................207 by Pauline Nol and Milton Friend Chapter 6. Biowarfare, Bioterrorism, and Animal Diseases as Weapons ........................................................................................231 by Milton Friend Chapter 7. How to Find and Access Published Information on Emerging Infectious Diseases ....................................................273 by Katherine Wesenberg and Milton Friend Conclusion.....................................................................................................................................................................................................301 Glossary .........................................................................................................................................................................................................305 Appendixes Appendix A. Some Emerging and Resurging Pathogens Causing Disease in Fauna and the Geographic Areas Most Affected..............................................................................................................................................................................315 Appendix B. Common and Scientific Names of Animals and Plants in Text ...............................................................................334 Appendix C. Agents That Require Specific Government Approval for Scientific Investigations Within the USA........................................................................................................................................................................................347 Appendix D. Pathogens of Focus for Biowarfare and Bioterrorist Activity.................................................................................348 Index...............................................................................................................................................................................................................357

xi

xii

IntroductionThescourgeofepidemicdiseaseretainsanimportantplaceinthehistoryofhumanity. (Kohn)

Humans have been affected by and have contributed to the eruption and spread of disease since antiquity.13 This connectivity is such that disease in the Americas was one of the five Seeds of Change addressed by the National Museum of Natural Historys commemoration of the Columbus Quincentenary. As for the other Seeds of Change, diseases sent ripples around the globe, affecting the people as well as the flora and fauna of both the New World and the Old.4 During recent decades, these ripples have become waves that are likely to intensify, swelled by human population growth, civil strife, and other factors. Similar to the Columbus voyages of discovery, disease emergence involves the processes of encounter and exchange resulting in both deliberate and accidental introductions.4 Biowarfare was the primary purpose for past deliberate disease introductions in the Americas (e.g., smallpox during the French and Indian Wars). Bioterrorism is the primary focus for current introductions (e.g., post-9/11 anthrax letters).5 Ecosystem alteration is a human hallmark with direct and indirect consequences for disease,612 especially for zoonoses. Large-scale landscape alteration will continue to occur due to human population growth and technological advancement.13,14 These transformations not only enhance the processes of encounter and exchange between organisms as a factor for disease emergence, but they also can greatly accelerate evolutionary changes, especially in disease organisms.11 Clearly, disease continues as an important seed of change sowed by human actions that result in the emergence of new global challenges for society. The context for this book focuses on providing an understanding that disease emergence and spread often are outcomes of human actions, rather than the result of events for which society has no control.Milton Friend

3. 4. 5. 6.

7. 8. 9.

10. 11. 12.

13. 14.

Verano, J.W., and Ubelaker, D.H., eds., 1992, Disease and demography in the Americas: Washington, D.C., Smithsonian Institution Press, 294 p. Viola, H.J., 1992, Foreword, in Verano, J.W., and Ubelaker, D.H., eds., Disease and demography in the Americas: Washington, D.C., Smithsonian Institution Press, p. ixx. Morens, D.M., Folkers, G.K., and Fauci, A.S., 2004, The challenge of emerging and re-emerging infectious diseases, Nature, v. 430, p. 242249. Epstein, P., ed., 1998, Marine ecosystems: emerging diseases as indicators of change: Year of the Ocean special report on health of the oceans from Labrador to Venezuela: Boston, Mass., Harvard Medical and the Global Environment, 85 p. Fayer, R., 2000, Presidential address: Journal of Parasitology, v. 86, p. 11731181. Friend, M., McLean, R.G., and Dein, F.J., 2001, Disease emergence in birds: challenges for the twenty-first century: The Auk, v. 118, p. 290303. Levins, R., Awerbuch, T., Brinkmann, U., Eckardt, I., Epstein, P., Makhoul, N., Albuquerque de Possas, C., Puccia, C., Spielman, A., and Wilson, M.E., 1994, The emergence of new disease: lessons learned from the emergence of new disease and the resurgence of old ones may help us prepare for future epidemics: American Scientist, v. 82, p. 5260. McMichael, A.J., 2001, Human frontiers, environments, and disease: past patterns, uncertain futures: Cambridge, UK, Cambridge University Press, 413 p. Palumbi, S.R., 2001, Humans as the worlds greatest evolutionary force: Science, v. 293, p. 17861790. Patz, J.A., Epstein, P.R., Burke, T.A., and Balbus, J.M., 1996, Global climate change and emerging infectious diseases: Journal of the American Medical Association, v. 275, p. 217223. Vitousek, P.M., Mooney, H.A., Lubchenco, J., and Melillo, J.M., 1997, Human domination of Earths ecosystems: Science, v. 277, p. 494499. Ayensu, E.D., Van R. Claasen, Collins, M., Dearing, A., Fresco, L., Gadgil, M., and Gitay, H., 1999, International ecosystem assessment: Science, v. 286, p. 685686.

LiteratureCited1. 2. Kohn, G.C., ed., 1995, Encyclopedia of plague and pestilence: New York, N.Y., Facts on File, Inc., 408 p. McNeill, W.H., 1976, Plagues and peoples: Garden City, N.Y., Anchor Press, 369 p.

Introduction

DiseaseEmergenceandResurgence:TheWildlifeHumanConnection

Chapter 1

Why This Book?...diseases entrenched in natural foci are old in nature and new only in relation to the time and conditions of their appearance in man and still more new when one considers the time at which the physician learned to diagnose correctly.(Pollitzer)1

Photo by Milton Friend

ContentsOverview....................................................................................................................................5 Background ...............................................................................................................................7 Disease Ecology ........................................................................................................................7 Box 11 Infectious Disease Publications: Past and Present ................................................9 This Book in Perspective .........................................................................................................11 Box 12 Human Activities and Zoonoses ..........................................................................12 Literature Cited ........................................................................................................................17

Bolded words within the text indicate terms that are defined in the Glossary.

Disease Emergence and Resurgence: The WildlifeHuman Connection

Chapter 1

Why This Book?OverviewThe appearance and diagnosis in humans of various infectious diseases is a dynamic situation involving new diseases that continue to arise and challenge humankind, along with fluctuating levels of established diseases. Some of the agents causing these diseases originate in humans and others in animals. As a group, the zoonoses (diseases transmissible between animals and humans) are of special concern because of the close associations people have with domesticated species and free-ranging wildlife. In many areas of the world, those associations with wildlife have become greater during recent years, especially as the increasing human population results in wildlife and people sharing more of the same space (Fig. 1.1). In addition, the popularity of outdoor recreation and ecotourism results in millions of humans entering wild places (Fig. 1.2). During 2001, 39 percent of the USA population 16 years old and older participated in activities related to fish and wildlife. These activities generated 1.1 percent of the Nations gross domestic product ($110 billion).2 Because of these factors, zoonoses are the dominant type of infectious disease in the current era of disease emergence and reemergence, a situation that is likely to continue for the foreseeable future (see Chapter 2). Not only can humans contract diseases from wildlife (Fig. 1.3), but humans can introduce diseases that jeopardize wildlife.3,4 Wildlife populations that become infected by pathogens typically considered to cause human disease may then become enzootic foci for those infections. Recent infection of African wildlife with the human strain of tuberculosis (Mycobacterium tuberculosis) has been attributed to the expansion of ecotourism and is but one example

Figure 1.1 Urban and suburban environments are important habitats for some wildlife. The potential for transfer of zoonotic diseases amplifies the need to actively manage the health of wildlife populations within human environments.

of disease introduced into wildlife populations associated with human encroachment into remote areas.47 Three basic factors can minimize the potential for diseases present in nature, such as AIDS, from becoming established as new diseases of humans, and can help to protect humans from long established zoonoses, such as rabies: 1) knowing the natural history of animal diseases transmitted to humans, 2) raising public awareness about the diseases they may encounter, and 3) implementing sound practices and public policy to address those diseases. Minimizing the introduction

286 million

209 million

767 million

National Parks

National Forests

State Parks

Figure 1.2 Outdoor recreational visitor use associated with USA parks and forests in 2000 (data from T. Jordan, National Park Service; L. Warren, National Forest Service; D.D. McLean, Indiana State University).

Why This Book?

Photos by Milton Friend


Hydatid disease

Ornithosis

Trichinosis

Toxic tissue secretons

Leptospirosis

Plague

Mycobacterium infections

West Nile fever

Salmonellosis

Bovine tuberculosis Figure 1.3

Baylisascariasis

Erysipeloid

Examples of diseases potentially acquired from various wildlife species groups.


Crow photo courtesy USGS; all others by Milton Friend

of typically human infections into wildlife populations is complicated because less is known about disease transmission from humans to free-ranging wildlife. A better understanding of the dynamics involved is essential for identifying mechanisms for limiting wildlife exposures to those infections.4 In addition to human illness and death, zoonoses are a threat to the sustainability of wildlife populations and impose heavy economic, social, and institutional costs.

increasing number of wake-up calls in response to human ignorance and arrogance towards disease processes.10 HIV infection is a well-known consequence of human behavior and conveys lessons relative to how human/wildlife interactions, in combination with human mobility and behavior, can result in the establishment of new disease foci.11 Therefore, it is prudent to consider diseases of wildlife from a global perspective rather than from just a local, regional, or even national perspective (Box 12).

BackgroundAnother Emerging Diseases Publication Many published works have addressed emerging diseases; however, these publications often are directed towards scientific audiences within the human and animal health fields (Box 11). Nondisease specialists and the general public are also in need of information about these diseases, thus this book is directed towards them. In contrast to the previous Field Manual of Wildlife Diseases,8 also developed by the National Wildlife Health Center, this publication does not address the pathology, ecology, and control for specific diseases. Instead, the focus is on concepts associated with disease emergence in wildlife, the general importance of wildlife as sentinels for disease emergence, and the importance of wildlife as sources for zoonotic disease. Forthcoming publications will provide in-depth coverage for many of the diseases identified here. The extensive literature citations in this publication expand the information base for disease specialists and others by providing scientific literature sources about specific diseases and associated subject areas. Noninfectious diseases and the full spectrum of infectious diseases are not addressed here. Compared with general knowledge about diseases transmitted to humans by domestic animals, the public knows less about acquiring diseases from wildlife populations, especially diseases associated with the changing pattern of wildlife/human interactions. Because of this lack of knowledge, response to zoonoses transmitted by wildlife is often crisis-oriented rather than based on preventive strategies. Our intent is to enhance the basic understanding about disease ecology and disease transmission from wildlife to humans, especially those who are more at risk because of their contact with wildlife (Fig. 1.4). We also highlight the human role in disease emergence in wildlife. Disease Emergence in a Changing World Many factors associated with disease emergence and resurgence (see Chapter 2), such as human-induced landscape and seascape changes, worldwide travel, urbanization, changing environmental conditions, and changes in human behavior, provide new opportunities for microbes and parasites to infect humans, animals, and arthopod vectors of disease. Evolutionary processes favor the disease agents9 and are providing an

Disease EcologyBy examining the history of long-standing diseases and how their ecology has changed in response to changes in environmental conditions and human behavior, we can understand more about current and future disease risks. For example, the history of rabies, a long-standing zoonosis, is lost in antiquity. The first recorded presence for this disease is from the days of the Asclepiadae, 124 40 BC .12 Despite this extended history, with few exceptions, the disease is no less a worldwide problem than it was centuries ago.13 In part, the stature of rabies as a dreaded disease has been maintained by its diverse ecology. Rabies transmitted to humans by nonvampire bats has provided new dimensions for this disease within North America since the early 1950s.14 However, rabies virus in a nonvampire bat was first identified in 1916 in a Brazilian fruit-eating bat. Since then, rabies in nonvampire bats has also been documented in Europe and Asia in addition to South and North America.15 Several different strains of rabies associated with specific wildlife species have been recognized, leading to a greater understanding of rabies ecology. The ecology of arthropod-vectored disease, such as West Nile fever and dengue fever, can be even more complex than that of rabies. Humans can become infected and contract the same zoonoses through multiple routes (Fig. 1.5). Therefore, to prevent exposure to pathogens, it is important to know the different routes of exposure (Table 1.1) and to be aware of other factors, such as the environmental persistence of the causative agents. For example, animal hides with hair have been the source of human cases of anthrax from curios purchased by tourists.16 Fish and wildlife law-enforcement personnel involved with port-of-entry inspections and other activities may encounter animal hides and other materials imported illegally. Safeguards against the transport of pathogens from the country of origin have been compromised in those situations and the law-enforcement personnel must quickly evaluate potential risks and deal with the situation without compromising their health or that of others. Important factors to consider are knowledge of the types of disease agents that might be encountered in animal hides and products made from them, the countries that pose substantial risks from those diseases, and routes for human exposure (e.g., aerosol vs. contact).

Why This Book?

Figure 1. Enhanced contact with animals and animal components associated with some types of work-related and recreational activities results in increased potential for exposure to zoonotic diseases. Recognition of inherent risks provides a basis for actions to minimize risks that may exist.


Postmortem photo by James Runningen; cave photo by William Zarwell; other photos by Milton Friend

Infectious Disease Publications: Past and Present

Box 11

Keeping up with the continual publication of new scientific literature can be a challenge. An unfortunate result of focusing primarily on the newest literature is that the historic literature is often forgotten. Consequently, insights that might spring from reexamining past perspectives along with present knowledge do not emerge. Also, for some, the historic literature may hold greater interest than current literature because of the richness of concepts, discovery, and insights of early investigators prior to the development of current technologies and expanded knowledge of specific diseases.

Before modern theories and technology were highly developed, publications on diseases were rich in descriptive detail of the observations being made at the gross level and the conclusions being drawn from those observations. The general wisdom and powers of deduction displayed, despite the technical limitations of those times, are impressive (see quote from Hippocrates on page 11).

Descriptive epidemiology provides a foundation for many correlations and hypotheses that have been converted to important scientific discovery with the advent and application of enhanced technology and scientific methods. A classic example of descriptive epidemiology leading to disease control is John Snows quantitative investigation of cholera in London during 1854, many years prior to the 1883 identification of the causative agent. He determined that the mortality rates in houses supplied by a specific water company were between eight and nine times greater than those in homes supplied by another water company, and also were much greater than in the remainder of London. Those findings, along with his investigation of the Broad Street Pump cholera epidemic, resulted in his inference of the existence of a cholera poison transmitted by polluted water, and led to legislation mandating that all of the water companies in London filter their water by 1857.18 Numerous other diseases have been described as distinct clinical entities and the primary sources for human infection correctly identified prior to the isolation and identification of the causative agents.

The historic accounts of disease are also an important part of the history of human civilization because the two are so intimately intertwined (see Chapter 2). For example, it has been suggested that domestic pigs brought to the New World in 1539 by the Spanish explorer Hernando de Soto were the source of epidemic disease that decimated Native American populations in the Mississippi Valley following disease transfer from the pigs to wildlife.19 Historic publications on epizootics affecting wildlife that involve zoonoses often provide a wealth of information about animal populations, habitat conditions, environmental changes, and human activities during the time period of the publication. The descriptive naturalist approach by some of the field biologists conducting those investigations provides an enhanced vision of the field conditions associated with the specific disease events.

Current knowledge about infectious diseases is essential for combatting these diseases. Nevertheless, there will always be value in taking the time to dust off historic accounts of disease to appreciate the contributions made, and perhaps, to gain some new insights from the wisdom of past investigators. Chapter 7 (How to Find and Access Published Information on Emerging Infectious Diseases) provides guidance for access to historic and current information on emerging infectious diseases.

Why This Book?

Consumption of infected wild game

Contaminated mouth parts and claws of companion animals

Contact with infected wildlife

Arthropod bites

Aerosols from contaminated environments

Contact with contaminated water

Laboratory-acquired infections

Ingestion of contaminated water

Figure 1. Principal routes of human exposure to infectious agents. (Mouse and tick photos courtesy of the Centers for Disease Control; microscope photo by James Runningen; other photos by Milton Friend.)

10


Although zoonoses are diseases transmitted between result in those diseases becoming important zoonoses. animals and humans, humans are not essential for the mainDisease Emergence and Resurgence (Chapter 2) discusses the tenance of most zoonotic disease agents. In many instances, current state of emerging and reemerging diseases of wildlife the disease is not transmissible from human to human nor and humans. The Wildlife Factor (Chapter 3) discusses the do human cases of the disease result in the transfer of the changing patterns of wildlifehuman interactions and how disease to other species. In those situations, humans are a those changes affect the potential for disease emergence dead-end host, regardless of whether disease culminates and resurgence. Zoonoses and Travel (Chapter 4) provides in death. Nevertheless, humans greatly influence the estabinformation to expand awareness about zoonoses that may be lishment, maintenance, and occurrence of many zoonoses encountered during travel and useful information for interactand other diseases. Serious consequences can arise from ing with the medical community. Is This Safe to Eat? (Chapter instances where significant human diseases are introduced 5) provides general commentary on the consumption of fish into wildlife populations, which then serve as reservoirs for and game and addresses some of the questions commonly human infections. This dimension of disease emergence has asked of wildlife disease specialists. Biowarfare, Bioterrorreceived little attention. ism, and Animal Diseases as Bioweapons (Chapter 6) focuses Regardless of the disease, three basic factors are involved on the concepts, concerns, and potential for utilizing wildlife for disease to occur. Environmental conditions must be such as vehicles for the introduction and transmission of infectious that the disease agent can exist in a viable state; hosts must disease. How to Find and Access Published Information on be susceptible to that agent; and the host and agent must Emerging Infectious Diseases (Chapter 7) provides insights have sufficient interaction for disease to occur (Fig. 1.6). and guidance for negotiating the information maze of scienEnvironmental conditions are often the driving force that tific literature and staying current with advances in knowlcause host-agent relations that result in disease. edge. Following the chapters, supplemental information The basic disease cycle of host, agent, and environment ranging from a glossary of terms, scientific names of species, has many permutations. These differences are primarily and other useful data are included. Literature citations provide associated with how various types of infectious disease sources for further exploration. In some instances, historical agents (Table 1.2) are maintained in nature and transmitted or other interests are the basis for the citation. Collectively, to susceptible hosts (Fig. 1.6). Understanding these processes the contents of this book provide a wealth of information in can help minimize the potential for exposure to the pathogens a format that should be highly readable and informative for that cause infectious disease. This aspect of landscape ecolindividuals with different levels of interest and knowledge in ogy is not a new concept. zoonoses and other infectious diseases of wildlife. Many people move freely and rapidly between cities, nations, and continents in which we are a stranger. Also, Milton Friend our love for nature frequently takes us into environs that are even less familiar. Familiarity with disease risks before we visit a place can help guard against the diseases that may Centuries ago, Hippocrates, in his treatise On Airs, Waters, and Places, c. 400 be present in those places. For example, B.C., noted the linkage between environmental conditions and disease prevention multiple reports of outbreaks of acute and control in humans. schistosomiasis have been documented When one comes into a city in which he is a stranger, he ought to consider since 1975 among European and Ameriits situation, how it lies as to the winds and the rising of the sun; for its influence can tourists returning from various is not the same whether it lies to the north or to the south, to the rising or to the setting sun. These things one ought to consider most attentively, and concerning African countries. 17 In addition, a the waters which the inhabitants use, whether they be marshy and soft, or hard and greater understanding of the potential running from rocky elevations, and then if saltish and unfit for cooking; and the that humans, companion animals, and ground whether it be naked and deficient in water, or wooded and well-watered, agricultural activities have for introducand whether it lies in a hollow, confined situation, or is elevated and cold.... From ing disease into wildlife populations can these things he must proceed to investigate everything else. For if one knows all these things well, or at least the greater part of them, he cannot miss knowing, help in minimizing the establishment of when he comes into a strange city, either the diseases peculiar to the place, or those diseases.

This Book in PerspectiveThis book provides a foundation for why diseases of wildlife deserve greater attention and how lack of attention can in some instances

the particular nature of the common diseases, so that he will not be in doubt as to the treatment of the diseases, or commit mistakes, as is likely to be the case provided one had not previously considered these matters. And in particular, as the season and the year advance, he can tell what epidemic disease will attack the city, either in the summer or the winter, and what each individual will be in danger of experiencing from the change of regimen.

Why This Book?

11

Box 12

Human Activities and Zoonoses

Humans interact with wildlife in many ways including cultural and subsistence use by native peoples, recreation, economic pursuits, and as a result of employment activities. Too often, the potential for disease transfer is either not considered or inadequately addressed (see Chapter 2). Increased consideration of disease can reduce human risks and still provide for the continued enjoyment and traditional uses of wildlife.

EcotourismIncreasing numbers of people visit exotic places and enter into habitat that may expose them to microbes and parasites not present in their home environment. Physical contact with wildlife often is not required because arthropod vectors, contact with contaminated waters, or cultural food habits may be the primary means for disease transmission. For example, about one-third of 26 members of a whitewater rafting expedition in Costa Rica contracted leptospirosis from the river water during their expedition.20 Another example involves a cluster of African trypanosomiasis (sleeping sickness) in travelers to Tanzanian National Parks. Those cases are thought to represent a change in the local epidemiology of this disease.21 Travelers can minimize their potential exposure to disease agents by learning about the status of significant diseases and taking appropriate precautions.

Companion AnimalsAn estimated 68 million dogs and 73 million cats are kept as pets in the USA.22 While outdoors, the dog or cat may encounter and consume wildlife such as small rodents that are either diseased or carriers of disease agents that cause zoonoses. They may also encounter ticks and other arthropods infected with disease agents. Many people also have wildlife as companion animals. Several cases of rabies resulting in substantial numbers of human exposures within the USA have been associated with pet skunks.23 Salmonellosis has often been contracted from pet turtles, and Easter ducklings and chicks24,25 and during recent years unusual Salmonella serotypes (strains) have been isolated from people having direct or indirect contact with lizards, snakes, or turtles.26 Ornithosis (chlamydia) outbreaks originating from pet shops27 and human cases associated with birds kept in the home28 are other examples of zoonoses acquired from companion animals.

Wildlife RehabilitationThe strong bonds that exist between many people and wildlife have resulted in increasing involvement in efforts to save and rehabilitate injured and diseased wildlife, such as the cleaning of wildlife coated with spilled oil. In many instances, the individuals involved are not specialists in animal disease, and the clinical signs in the affected animals are too general to identify the presence of serious zoonoses. Also, the facilities where the animals are cared for, and theAll photographs by Milton Friend

12


management of animals within them, are rarely adequate to minimize the potential for disease transmission among animals or between the animal patients and humans. For example, an attempt to assist a sick wild baby rabbit resulted in tularemia affecting an eye (Parinauds oculoglandular syndrome) of the individual attempting to provide assistance.29 As more wildlife rehabilitators become aware of particular zoonoses and gain more knowledge about species that are likely to harbor disease agents, they will be able to better judge risks involved with individual animals brought into the rehabilitation facility (chlamydiosis and West Nile fever are two avian diseases of increasing importance). To reduce risks from disease, training for individuals and certifying wildlife rehabilitation facilities is essential.

Wildlife HarvestsMany people hunt, trap, and fish;these activities result in humans having direct contact with a broad spectrum of wildlife. Nevertheless, those involved in the harvest of wildlife may have little knowledge of what disease agents may be harbored by the species they are pursuing or how humans become infected by those agents. Trichinosis infections of individuals consuming wild game meat30,31 and a recent case of Escherichia coli O157:H7 from deer meat32 are examples of diseases generally associated with livestock. Unlike domestic animals, there are no health inspections for wildlife harvested for personal consumption. Timely, objective information on wildlife diseases should be fully integrated within the framework for licensing, methods for take, and promotion of these activities. However, to better inform the public about disease risks, more wildlife-disease surveillance is needed.

These examples are not reasons for avoiding the activities noted. Instead, they indicate the need for greater awareness of zoonotic diseases so that people can minimize their potential risks. For example, because of the potential contact with bats, since the 1960s it has been recommended that cavers receive rabies vaccination. Nevertheless, a recent survey of cavers indicated a general under-appreciation of the risk for rabies from bat bites.35 Similarly, recent fatal cases of yellow fever in unvaccinated travelers to the Amazon also reflect under-appreciation of the risks involved from this disease.36,37

Why This Book?

Trapping photo courtesy of the Centers for Disease Control; all others by Milton Friend

OtherNumerous other human activities have the potential to result in exposure to zoonoses. For example, 9 members of a 34-person humanitarian group from Oregon that traveled to Swaziland to participate in a construction project returned to the USA with African tick-bite fever.33 Similar humanitarian activities in Mexico have resulted in church group members from Pennsylvania and from Washington State returning with cases of the fungal disease coccidioidomycosis.34 People have commonly acquired Lyme disease from ticks while hiking, and have become infected with hantavirus from exposure to contaminated environments while camping.

13

A

ENVIRONMENT

HOST

AGENT

B

ENVIRONMENT

HOST

AGENT

Figure 1. (A) Primary factors involved in the occurrence of disease: susceptible hosts; agents capable of causing disease; environmental conditions that facilitate the presence of disease agents; (B) Environmental conditions facilitate host-agent interactions in a manner that results in disease.

1


Illustration by Jennifer Rodriguez and Frances J. Bergmann

Table 1.1

Routes for human exposure to infectious disease agents harbored by wildlife. General circumstances (examples) Diseased animal has agent present in saliva and inoculates human through a bite wound (rabies). Healthy animal commonly has agent present in mouth and transfers the agent through a bite wound (pasteurellosis). Healthy animal has contaminated mouthparts from recent feeding on diseased animal and transfers the agent through a bite wound (tularemia). Individual harvesting, processing, or handling wildlife with bare hands, contact with infectious agents present within animal tissues, organs, and fluids, and in some instances on contaminated body surfaces (tuberculosis). Contaminated hands may also transfer agent to eyes (tularemia). Swimming or otherwise immersing bare body parts in waterbodies contaminated by infectious agents able to survive within those environments. Entry of the pathogen is through small abrasions in the skin, conjunctiva of the eye, or by invasion of infectious parasites (swimmers itch). Contact with soil and other components of the terrestial environment that have been contaminated with infectious agents by rodent feces and urine (hantavirus).

Route of exposure Animal bite

Direct contact

Indirect contact

Arthropod bite

Arthropods that either become infected and harbor those infectious agents or have contaminated body parts and fluids as a result of recent feeding on an infected host transmit the disease agent when feeding on humans (West Nile fever). Individuals investigating various aspects of infectious diseases in confined areas (scientists and other laboratory workers), workers processing animals and crop harvests in production facilities, and individuals cleaning animal facilities have become infected by a variety of infectious agents present in the animals, their body discharges, or by water contaminated at other locations. The infectious agents become airborne in water sprays and by other means, are inhaled, and establish infection with the human host. In some instances, entry may occur through the conjunctiva of the eye (Newcastle disease). Contaminated hides used for curios for the tourist trade and hides processed for the leather industry and other purposes have been a source for human infections. The infectious agents become airborne during handling and are inhaled (anthrax). Fungal spores present in soil and in bird and bat guano become airborne when soil is disturbed. Human exposure to the fungal pathogens results from inhalation (histoplasmosis). Healthy-looking infected wildlife (including fish) are harvested and consumed without being cooked long enough or at a sufficiently high temperature to kill disease agents present (trichinosis). In some instances, the wildlife (especially fish) is consumed raw (anisakiasis).

Aerosol

Ingestion

Why This Book?

1

Table 1.2 Types of infectious disease agents causing zoonoses. Agent type (examples) Virus Rabies (RNA virus); herpesvirus infections (DNA viruses) Characteristics Organisms usually too small to be seen by light microscopy Use the functions of living host cells of other species to replicate Able to reproduce with genetic continuity and the possibility of mutation Virus particle, or virion, primarily consists of either a DNA or an RNA (nucleic acid) core enclosed within a protein shell or capsid Unicellular organisms, other than blue-green alga, visible by light microscopy; reproduction is commonly by cell division Typically, the bacterial cell is contained within a cell wall Rickettsia Rocky Mountain spotted fever Chlamydia Chlamydiosis (ornithosis, psittacosis) A specialized type of bacteria that typically occurs within the cytoplasm of cells or within the gut of insects that transmit these organisms to vertebrates, including humans

Bacteria Salmonellosis

Another specialized type of bacteria that is classified as a separate group Reproduction is only within the cytoplasm of vertebrate host cells Reproduction is by a unique, complex developmental cycle involving attachment and penetration of the host cell by infectious elementary bodies, which undergo further transformations before developing into additional elementary bodies that are released when the dead cell is ruptured as part of the reproductive process Do not have a cell wall

Fungi imperfecti Histoplasmosis

Heterogeneous group of fungi with a body not differentiated into discretely recognized components for reproduction and other functions; some develop into two forms depending on the conditions for their growth (dimorphic); budding is a common form of growth Systemic mycoses are the group most commonly involved in zoonoses of concern and are generally pulmonary in origin

Protozoa Toxoplasmosis

Animal-like unicellular organisms that range in size from submicroscopic to macroscopic Approximately 10,000 of the 35,000 species within this group are parasitic Reproduction typically involves asexual and sexual stages

Metazoan parasites Hydatid disease (echinococcosis)

Multicellular parasitic organisms with a body composed of cells differentiated into tissues and organs; usually with a digestive cavity lined with specialized cells Generally macroscopic, but some are microscopic Life cycles often involve different host species for each of the developmental stages of the parasite; a mixture of invertebrate and vertebrate intermediate (developmental) hosts is common for completion of the life cycle

Prions Mad cow disease

An aberrant form of the normal cellular prion protein; causes neurodegenerative disease An emerging disease issue about which too little is known to clearly understand the processes involved in transmission or zoonotic status

1


Literature Cited1. 2. 3. 4. Pollitzer, R., 1967, History and incidence of tularemia in the Soviet Union, a review: New York, Fordham University, Institute of Contemporary Russian Studies, 366 p. United States Fish and Wildlife Service, 2002, National survey of fishing, hunting, and wildlife-associated recreation: state overview, issued June 2002, 32 p. Ferber, D., 2000, Human diseases threaten great apes: Science, v. 289, p. 12771278. Alexander, K.A., Pleydell, E., Williams, M.C., Lane, E.P., Nyange, J.F.C., and Michel, A.L., 2002, Mycobacterium tuberculosis: an emerging disease of freeranging wildlife: Emerging Infectious Disease, v. 8, p. 598601. Ferrer, M., and Hiraldo, F., 1995, Human-associated staphylococcal infection in Spanish imperial eagles: Journal of Wildlife Diseases, v. 31, p. 534536. Gardner, H., Kerry, K., Riddle, M., Brouwer, S., and Gleeson, L., 1997, Poultry virus infection in Antarctic penguins: Nature, v. 387, p. 245. Anderson, I., 1998, With people come plagues: New Scientist, v. 159, p. 4. Friend, M., and Franson, J.C., eds., 1999, Field manual of wildlife diseasesgeneral field procedures and diseases of birds: U.S. Geological Survey, Information and Technology Report 1999-001, 426 p. Lederberg, J., 1997, Infectious disease as an evolutionary paradigm: Emerging Infectious Diseases, v. 3, p. 417423. Lederberg, J., 2000, Infectious history: Science, v. 288, p. 287293. Hahn, B.H., Shaw, G.M., De Cock, K.M., and Sharp, P.M., 2000, AIDS as a zoonosis: scientific and public health implications: Science, v. 287, p. 607614. Steele, J.H., 1975, History of rabies, Baer, G.M., ed., The natural history of rabies, v. 1: New York, Academic Press, Inc., p. 129. Baer, G.M., 1975, Preface, in Baer, G.M., ed., The natural history of rabies: New York, Academic Press, Inc., v. 1, p. xiiixiv. Venters, H.D., Hoffert, W.R., Scatterday, J.E., and Hardy, A.V., 1954, Rabies in bats in Florida: American Journal of Public Health, v. 44, p. 182185. Constantine, D.G., 1971, Bat rabies: current knowledge and future research, in Nagano, Y., and Davenport, F.M., eds., Rabies: Baltimore, Md., University Park Press, p. 253265. Whitford, H.W., 1979, Anthrax, in Steele, J.H., and others, eds., CRC handbook series in zoonoses, Section A, bacterial, rickettsial and mycotic diseases v. 1: Boca Raton, Fla., CRC Press, p. 3166. Centers for Disease Control, 1990, Acute schistosomiasis in U.S. travelers returning from Africa: Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report, v. 39, p. 141142, 147148. Lilienfeld, A.M., and Lilienfeld, D.E., 1980, Foundations of epidemiology (2nd ed.): New York, Oxford University Press, 375 p. Mann, C.C., 2002, 1491: The Atlantic Monthly, v. 289, p. 4153. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, 1997, Outbreak of leptospirosis among white-water raftersCosta 21.

22.

23.

5. 6. 7. 8.

24.

25.

26.

27.

9. 10. 11. 12. 13. 14. 15. 16.

28.

29.

30.

31.

32.

33.

17. 18. 19. 20.

34.

35.

Rica, 1996: Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report, v. 46, p. 577579. Jelinek, T., Bisoffi, Z., Bonazzi, L., van Thiel, P., Bronner, V., de Frey, A., Gundersen, S.G., McWhinney, P., and Ripamonti, D., 2002. Cluster of African trypanosomiasis in travelers to Tanzanian national parks: Emerging Infectious Diseases, v. 8, p. 634635. American Pet Products Manufacturers Association, 2001, 2001/2002 APPMA National pet owners survey: Greenwich, Conn., American Pet Products Manufacturers Association, 293 p. Diesch, S.L., 1982, Reported human injuries or health threats attributed to wild or exotic animals kept as pets (19711981): Journal of the American Veterinary Medical Association, v. 180, p. 382383. Centers for Disease Control, 1984, Pet turtle-associated salmonellosisPuerto Rico: Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report, v. 33, p. 141142. Centers for Disease Control, 1992, Salmonella hadar associated with pet ducklingsConnecticut, Maryland, and Pennsylvania, 1991: Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report, v. 41, p. 185187. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, 1995, Reptileassociated salmonellosisselected states, 19941995: Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report, v. 44, p. 347350. Morrison, W.M., Hutchison, R.B., Thomason, J., Harrington, J.H., and Herd, G.W. 1991, An outbreak of psittacosis: Journal of Infection, v. 22, p. 7175. Longbottom, D., and Coulter, L.J., 2003, Animal chlamydioses and zoonotic implications: Journal of Comparative Pathology, v. 128, p. 217244. Thompson, S., Omphroy, L., and Oetting, T., 2001, Parinauds oculoglandular syndrome attributable to an encounter with a wild rabbit: American Journal of Ophthalmology, v. 131, p. 283284. Dupouy-Camet, J., 1999, Is human trichinellosis an emerging zoonosis in the European community?: Helminthologia, v. 36, p. 201204. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, 1996, Outbreak of trichinellosis associated with eating cougar jerkyIdaho, 1995: Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report, v. 45, p. 205206. Rabatsky-Ehr, T., Dingman, D., Marcus, R., Howard, R., Kinney, A., and Mshar, P., 2002, Deer meat as the source for a sporadic case of Escherichia coli O157:H7 infection, Connecticut: Emerging Infectious Diseases, v. 8, p. 525527. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, 1998, African tick-bite fever among international travelersOregon, 1998: Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report, v. 47, p. 950952. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, 2000, Coccidioidomycosis in travelers returning from MexicoPennsylvania, 2000: Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report, v. 49, p. 10041006. Gibbons, R.V., Holman, R.C., Mosberg, S.R., and Rupprecht, C.E., 2002, Knowledge of bat rabies and human exposure among United States cavers: Emerging Infectious Diseases, v. 8, p. 532534.

Why This Book?

1

36. 37.

Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, 2000, Fatal yellow fever in a traveler returning from Venezuela, 1999: Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report, v. 49, p. 303305. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, 2002, Fatal yellow fever in a traveler returning from Amazonas, Brazil, 2002: Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report, v. 51, p. 324325.

1


Chapter 2

Disease Emergence and ResurgenceIngenuity, knowledge, and organization alter but cannot cancel humanitys vulnerability to invasion by parasitic forms of life. Infectious disease which antedated the emergence of humankind will last as long as humanity itself, and will surely remain, as it has been hitherto, one of the fundamental parameters and determinants of human history. (McNeill)1


ContentsConcepts .................................................................................................................................21 Box 21 Infectious Disease: A Continuum of New Challenges and Opportunities.............22 Perspectives ............................................................................................................................26 Box 22 Humans and Disease: From Despair to Optimism and a Return to Reality .........28 Box 23 Social Impacts of Emerging Infectious Disease ...................................................32 Box 24 Wildllife and Zoonoses: Different Roles for Different Diseases ............................36 Disease Emergence in Wildlife ................................................................................................38 Box 25 Cholera and the Marine Environment ..................................................................40 Box 26 Emerging Disease and Coral Reefs .....................................................................42 Box 27 Biotoxins and Disease Emergence ......................................................................48 Box 28 Disease Emergence and Resurgence in Shellfish ...............................................52 Box 29 Marine Mammals and Zoonoses..........................................................................57 Box 210 Infectious Disease and the Southern Sea Otter .................................................60 Emerging Foodborne Diseases ...............................................................................................84 Disease Emergence and Companion Animals ........................................................................93 Factors Contributing to Disease Emergence ...........................................................................97 Literature Cited ......................................................................................................................108

Bolded words within the text indicate terms that are defined in the Glossary.

20


Chapter 2

Disease Emergence and ResurgenceA profusion of emerging diseases has affected humans since the early 1980s, and pathogens of animal origin or products of animal origin cause many of these.2 Some of these diseases had not been established previously, such as AIDS, and others are a resurgence of diseases thought to have been controlled, such as tuberculosis in developed nations. This change in the status of diseases affecting humans has resulted in emerging infections becoming a focus for national and global attention (Box 21). Emerging and reemerging diseases have generally been defined as infectious diseases of humans whose occurrence during the past two decades has substantially increased or threatens to increase in the near future relative to populations affected, geographic distribution, or magnitude of impacts.35 This concept has been expanded to also include other species and noninfectious diseases.68 Disease emergence and reemergence are affecting a wide variety of species on a global scale. An overview of the scope of this problem is provided to increase awareness of the role of wildlife in the ecology of emerging/reemerging diseases and to explore some of the primary factors involved. live hosts in a manner that generally involves multiplication of the organism within the host as a prerequisite for an outcome of disease. Noninfectious diseases such as botulism, other diseases involving natural (i.e., algal, fungal, etc.) and synthetic toxins (i.e., pesticides) that may be acquired from the consumption of food items and allergic responses are, in general, not addressed here. However, diseases caused by biotoxins (natural toxins) are noted for circumstances of special concern. For wildlife, noninfectious diseases of microbiological origin have been a prominent component of disease emergence and reemergence. For example, type C avian botulism, Clostridium botulinum, is a food poisoning of wild birds and occasionally some other species (humans are resistant to type C toxin but not to most other types of botulinum toxin). This disease has evolved from being a problem in Western North America to becoming the greatest known cause of disease affecting free-ranging waterbirds throughout the world. Avian botulism was essentially limited to areas west of the Mississippi River prior to 1940 (Fig. 2.1),13 and prior to 1960, had very limited occurrence outside of North America (Fig. 2.2). In addition to greatly expanding its geographic distribution within the USA since the mid-1970s (Fig. 2.1), unique epizootics have appeared since the mid-1990s at the Salton Sea in southern California. The type C botulism outbreaks in white pelicans and brown pelicans at the Salton Sea are the largest die-offs of pelicans ever reported from any cause and the first to be associated with fish.14 The occurrence of epizootics of type E botulism during 2000 and 2002 in Lake Erie of the North American Great Lakes system also is of significance because humans are highly susceptible to type E toxin.15 An estimated 8,000 birds died during the summer outbreak of 2000, and more than 25,000 during the 2002 epizootic. Ring-billed gull, red-breasted merganser, common loon, and long-tailed duck were the primary species affected.16 These epizootics are the largest mortalities recorded for birds due to type E botulism. The first wild bird epizootic from this toxin was in 1963 and involved extensive mortality of gulls and common loons in Lake Michigan, another of the Great Lakes, where periodic outbreaks have persisted.17,18 Little is known about the ecology of type E botulism in nature. Fish are susceptible to type E toxin and they may be the source of the toxin killing some fish-eating birds. Human cases of type E botulism acquired from commercial smoked fish from the Great Lakes resulted in changes in regulations governing the commercial preparation of smoked fish.19,20 However, recreational fishermen sometimes smoke the fish

ConceptsWhat is Disease? For general purposes, disease is broadly defined as any departure from health9 resulting in bodily dysfunctions. Impairments to health caused by conditions such as arthritis, major depression, reproductive sterility, dementia, and Parkinsons disease are common, in addition to clinical illness from infections, such as influenza and death due to cancers and cardiac failure. For wildlife, disease primarily impairs populations by reducing offspring (e.g., brucellosis) or by reducing the probability for survival of individuals (e.g., plague). If enough individuals are affected, the collective effects can reduce the sustainability of the population.8 Recent appearances of chytridiomycosis in amphibian populations have raised great concern about the sustainability of affected populations, especially those already in threatened and endangered status.1012 Disease Agents Disease can result from exposure to a variety of infectious agents and also can be an outcome from other factors (Table 2.1). Infectious disease has been the human health focus for disease emergence and reemergence and is the primary orientation here. That is, the focus is on organisms that invade

Disease Emergence and Resurgence

21

Box 21

Infectious Disease: A Continuum of New Challenges and OpportunitiesInfectious disease is one of the few genuine adventures left in the world (Zinsser).291

Time has vividly etched how infectious disease has influenced human life as evidenced by cultural mores, religious beliefs, the demography of peoples, the outcomes of wars and colonization attempts, economic status, and lifeexpectancy.1,289291,337 Thus, there is a foundation of selfinterest involving personal health and economic well being in the current resurgence by the developed nations of the world to increase efforts for addressing infectious disease after decades of neglect. In addition, bioterrorism has become an increasing concern due to world change initiated by the infamous events of September 11, 2001, and by the anthrax-contaminated letters sent in the months that followed. As a result, previous reductions in resources for infectious disease programs are being restored28 and enhanced.

International collaboration, as in the 2003 onset of severe acute respiratory syndrome (SARS),338 is essential for minimizing the potential impacts from emerging disease because pathogens are often hidden hitchhikers associated with commerce and human travel. Proactive rather than reactive efforts are needed to meet the challenges posed by: those ferocious little fellow creatures, which lurk in the dark corners and stalk us in the bodies of rats, mice, and all kinds of domestic animals [and wildlife]; which fly and crawl with the insects, and waylay us in our food and drink and even in our love (Zinsser).291 These challenges are eternal because of the great adaptive capabilities of those ferocious little fellow creatures22 and new opportunities continually provided to them by the periodic folly of human behavior and actions. A recent editorial spoof, New World Pathogen Strategy Disclosed,339 exploits pathogen adaptability and human frailties by taking the reader into a mythical convention of pathogens in which they are discussing the topic Our Infective Future: The New Agenda. The keynote speaker, a contemporary prion, in addition to giving plaudits to HIV, the tuberculosis bacillus, and to the viruses Ebola, Hanta, Lassa, and Marburg for gains they have made, notes that: Homo [sapien] is remarkably hospitable to us And they are recklessly changing the climate, releasing many of us from our historical geographic costraints Although they themselves deny that there is such a thing as a free lunch, we know better. There is a free lunch, and it is them.

People grieve by the NAMES Project AIDS Memorial Quilt Our globally interactive society results in the need for a global perspective in combating infectious disease because: It is not possible to adequately protect the health of our nation without addressing infectious disease problems that occur elsewhere in the world. Left unchecked, todays emerging disease can become the endemic disease of tomorrow (CDC).255

1530

1683

Disease and Discovery

22


pr op os op ed e Sm in ve al lp nt ox ed va An cc tis in ep at io tic n m G er et ho m ds th eo D ry ip of ht he di se ria as Vi an e ru tit va se ox lid s in at di ed sc Pe ov ni er ci llin ed di Vi sc ru ov se er s ed gr ow St re n pt in om ce ll yc cu St in ru ltu di ct re sc ur ov e er of Pr ed D io N ns A di di sc sc PC ov ov er er of R ed ed te D c N h (s A n cr ol ap og ie H y ) ae fo ge m rd no op et ec m hi e lu tio se s i n qu nfl en ue ce nz d ae ro sc

er m

th

M ic

G

eo r

y

1796

1848

1876

1890

1892

Photo courtesy of the Centers for Disease Control

1929

1931

1943

1953

1982

1988 1995 (adapted from Lederberg)22

Illustration by John M. Evans

Internatio nal Socie ty Infectioof us Agents

CWD Prion

BSE Prion

HIV Esq.

Mr. SARS

Human actions have always created new opportunities for pathogens, while disease emergence continues to provide new opportunities for humans to gain a better understanding of the ecological, behavioral, and social conditions that result in disease. The need to aggressively apply this knowledge is facilitated by a more informed public and collaboration among agencies, governments, and scientists that spans disciplines and political boundaries. Numerous scientific conferences, workshops, other regional, national, and international meetings, and other actions are focusing on emerging infectious disease. Notable actions include: 1995The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) of the United States Department of Health and Human Services, Public Health Service initiates publication of Emerging Infectious Diseases, a scientific journal for tracking and analyzing disease trends. 1996The White House issues a Presidential Decision Directive on Emerging Infectious Diseases, which establishes a national policy and implementation actions to address the threat of emerging infectious disease by improving domestic and international surveillance, prevention, and response measures.340

1998CDC issues an emerging disease strategy document, Preventing Emerging Infectious Diseases: A Strategy for the 21st Century. 341 2002CDC issues a mission-oriented document addressing approaches for the improvement of global capacity for disease surveillance and outbreak response, Protecting the Nations Health in an Era of Globalization: CDCs Global Infectious Disease Strategy. 342 Numerous global health Web sites focusing on emerging diseases are developed as well as numerous regional and disease-specific surveillance networks (see CDC Appendices A and E).342 The actions noted are but the tip of the proverbial iceberg of current response to emerging infectious disease. Major investments are also being made in the development of high level biosecurity facilities where studies can be carried out on the most hazardous pathogens. Advances being made have been greatly assisted by the reporting from all aspects of the news media including newspapers and weekly news magazines to television news shows and documentaries, and by the Hollywood spotlight that has made millions of people aware of emerging infections [e.g., The Philadelphia Story (AIDS) and Outbreak (Ebola)]. Therefore, it is fitting that the author of the book, The Coming Plague: Newly Emerging Diseases in a World Out of Balance343 earned a Pulitzer Prize for journalism.

Disease Emergence and Resurgence

23

Australia, Myxoma Virus, and the European Rabbit Myxomatosis in Australia is a classic example of host-pathogen adaptation for the benefit of both parties.26 Highly virulent strains of myxoma virus were introduced into European rabbit populations in an attempt to rid Australia of this introduced species. The biological control program depended upon mosquitoes to vector the disease and spread it among the rabbit population. After several failed introduction attempts, the virus established an epizootic foothold, causing a case-fatality rate of over 99 percent during the summer of 1952.27 However, instead of dying out during the winter as expected, some virus survived and established enzootic foci for the disease. Those foci produced mutant strains of virus with reduced virulence, as evidenced by longer survival times for infected rabbits (weeks rather than days). Because of the longer survival times, the probability for mosquitoes to acquire and transmit the attenuated virus strains was far greater than that for the highly virulent strains. Within 3 years, this selective process resulted in the attenuated mutant viruses (70-percent to 90-percent case-fatality rate) becoming the predominant strains of myxoma virus in Australia.27,28

Drawing by Erinn Dornaus

In addition to virus mutations, genetic selection for survival was also occurring within the rabbit population. Within 7 years, the susceptibility of the rabbits to the original virulent virus when tested in the laboratory had fallen from 90 percent to 25 percent. Thus, attenuation of the myxoma virus and genetic selection for resistance to myxoma virus by the rabbit population has resulted in host-pathogen adaptation that prevents the virus from killing all of the hosts that sustain its presence. While some rabbits still die in Australia from myxomatosis, many survive infection to produce young. The European rabbit remains a pest species in Australia, but populations are at levels considerably reduced from those that existed prior to the establishment of myxomatosis.2629 A biological postscript is currently being written to the myxomatosis story. Rabbit hemorrhagic disease virus escaped from experimental studies on an offshore island, reached mainland Australia in October 1995, and rapidly spread. Rabbit hemorrhagic disease (RHD) has decreased long-term average numbers of rabbits by 85 percent in some arid areas. In the coastal areas, the numbers of rabbits were reduced by 73 percent in the first year, but gradually recovered to only 12 percent below pre-RHD numbers in the third year.30 As for myxomatosis, biological adjustments are occurring, although, now as a three-party interaction of RHD, myxomatosis, and rabbits. The appearance of RHD has changed seasonal patterns of rabbit recruitment, rabbit abundance, and myxomatosis activity. RHD generally has a severe impact on rabbit populations through the breeding season, but compensatory recruitment after RHD activity declines allows rabbit numbers to recover somewhat. Because of the loss of susceptible rabbit hosts, the seasonal peak in myxomatosis activity is slightly delayed. RHD is outcompeting myxomatosis because it kills most rabbits (2 days for viremia) before they become infective for myxomatosis (810 days for viremia).30 The final outcome from this competition remains to be learned.

they catch. Public education has been helpful in informing the public of proper temperature and time required at that temperature to destroy toxins that may be present. It is likely that the recent bird mortalities on Lake Erie are an indicator of environmental changes that are resulting in increased levels of type E botulinum toxin within the foo

disease emergence and resurgence: the wildlife-human connection

Documents

wildlife diseases

wildlife service circular

milton disease emergence

geological survey circular

disease outbreak information

disease outbreaks

disease reservoirs

carriers of disease