dietary and alcohol intake, smoking pattern, occupational risk, and family history in lung cancer...

2
loku.rhmu. 7okushmu Cuy 770 J Surg Oncol lYXY:ll.213-18. Wc diagnosed eight (8.9%) lung cancer patxnts in 90 workers cxposcdtochromatecompounds. Thedurationofcxposurc ranged from 8 to il years, with a mean value of 18 + X years. The hIstologIcal ciacslflcatlon was squamous-cell carcinoma m seven pauents and adcnocarcmoma in one patient. The sltc of origin of the primary tumors was located pcriphcrally in two (25%) and centrally m ‘ ilx (75%). All hut one of the?e patients undcrwcnt surgery. In three (37.5%) of thcsc patlcnis, lung cancer foci wcrc detecicd durmg the postoperative hollow up by sputum cytology and bronchoscopy. Two 01 these three patlcnts had multiccntrlc cancer foci: double primary early aquamous- ccl1 carcmoma m one and early squamous-ccl1 carcmoma + small-cell lung cancer m the other. In a high-risk group such as chromate workers, WC should cmphasx early dctcction of lung cancer by serial sputum cytology, chest x-rays. and bronchoscopy. Lung cancer patlen& wjrth chromate exposure should be treated with due regard to the posSLblli1) of synchronous or mctachl-onouscancer. Vegetable consumption and lung cancer risk: A population-based case-control study in Hawaii Lc Marchand L, Yoqhlrawa CN. Koloncl LN, Hankm JH, Goodman MT. Epidemoiogy Program. Cunr-er Rcseurch Cenw of Ilawaii. liniwrcir> ofllawzi~. //omluiu. /// YMl3. J Natl Cancer Inst lY8Y:81: I ISX- M. WC conducted a population-based study of diet and lung cancer among the multiethnic popularIon of Hawail in IYXi-lY85. We com- plctcdmtcrv~cwq for23Omenand I02 women wlthlungcancerand.597 men and 76X women conuols.frcquency-matched to the patients by age and xx. A quanutativc dietary history asscsscdthe usual mtakc of foods rich m vltamrn\ A and C and carotcnoids. A clear dose-dcpcndcnt ncgall\c association was dcmonstratcd bctaccn dietary bctz-carotcnc and lungcanccrrisk m both scxc\;. Aftcradjusting forsmokmgand other covaTIatcs, Ihc men m rhc lowc~tquxtileol he&carotcnc mtake hadan odds ratio 01 I .O (95% confidcncc interval. I I-3.2) compared to thox m the hlghc\t quartile of mtir. The corresponding odds ratio for women was 2.7 (Y5% confidcncc mtcrval, I .2-h. I). Noclcarassociatmn was lound for rctinol, vitamm C, folic acid. iron. dlctary fihcr,or frulls. All vcgctablcs, dark green vcgctablcs, crucifcrous vcgctablcs, and tomatoes showed stronger mvcrsc assocmtion\ wnh rl<k than beta- carotcnc. Tlu\ obscrvatlcm suggests that other const~tucnts of vegc- table\, such ah Iutc~n. lycopenc, and mdolc\. and other\. may also pro01 aFam\r lung cimcrr m humans. Comparative lung tumorigenicity of parent and mononitro-polynu- clear aromatic hydrocarbons in the RLU:Ha newborn moose assay Busby WF Jr, Stevens EK, Martin CN, Chow FL, Garner RC. P rogrom in Toxicology, Massachlcteus lnslilute of Technology. Cambridge, MA 02139. Toxic01 Appl Pharmacol 1989;99:555-63. A BLU:Ha newborn mouse lung adenoma bioassay was employed to compare the tumorigenicity of selected mononitroarenes and unsubsti- tuted parent compounds 6 months after imtial treatment. The presence of a nitro group had a variable effect upon compound potency in which tumorigenicity was increased, abolished, or unchanged. On the basis of rcsulu withequimolardoscs. thcpolencyofbenzo[a]pyrcnewasgreater than h-nitrobenzo[a]pyrene (Inactive), 6-niuochryscne was much greater than chrysenc (inactive), 3-niuofluoroanthene (active) wz equal to fluoranthcne (active), and I -nitropyrene (inactive) was equiva- lcnttopyrcne(inact~ve).Thepotcncy seriesamongthcmonomtroarenes was 6-nitrochrysenc >> 7.mtrofluoroanthrenc > 6.nmobcnzo[a]pyrene (mactlvc) = 1-nitropyrcnc (macdvc). Lung tumor mcidencc and multi- plictty were similar for both males and females. No consistenl pattcm wits ohserved for the occasional appearance of lymphoma or hepatrc nodular hyperplasla in the \‘armus treatment groups. Long cancer risk, occupational exposure. and the debrisoquine metabolic phenotype Caporaso N, Hayes RFI. Doscmccl M ct al. Environmenml Epidemol- ogy Branch. Division of Cancer Eliology. rational Canrw Institute. Bethesda, MD 20892. Cancer Rcs 1989;49:3675-Y. The risk of lung cancer in smokers was exammed based on the debriscquine metabolic phenotype and on exposure to occupational lung carcinogens, specifically asbestos and polycyclic aromatic hydro- carbons. Extensive metabolizers of debnsoquine are at a 4-fold in- creased risk for lung cancer compared to poor metabolizers, after adjustment forage, sex, and smoking (,pack-years), when only cccupa- tonally uncxposcd subjects arc considcrcd. Increased risk related to the debrisoquinc metabolic phenotype was greatest for squamous and small cell histologlcs, and least for the adenocarcmoma subtype. Men with a history of exposure to occupational carcmogens had slgnifxantly mcreased nsk of lung cancer (relative risk = 2.8). after adjustment for age and smoking. Considering the combmcd cftect of the high nsk cxtensrvc mctaboli/cru debrisoquine mctabohc ,phenot)pe and likely occupational exposure to asbestos, the rclauvc cxccss rusk for lung cancer was I X-fold. Thus finding is conslstcnt wl’ lh a synergism m risk between theability to cxtcnslvcly mctaboll/edebrlscyurne and occupa- uonal exposure to lung carcinogens m male smokers. Debnsoqume phenotypmg has potential for idcntifymg carcmogen-exposed workers at high risk of lung cancer. Case-control study of lung cancer in Los Angeles County welders HullCJ,DoylcE,PetersJM,GxabrantDH, Bernstein I.,Prcstcm-Martin S. Division of Occupational Health, Depormeni of Preventive Medi- cine, University of Southern California School ofMedir-me, Los AnXe- le.<, CA 90033. Am J Ind Med 3989;16:303-12. A cze-control study of lung cancer m wtutc male welders was undertaken to investigate possible cnvironmentaJ and occupational causes of a 50% cxccss of lung cancer obscrvccl in this occupauonal group. The subjects were identified from a populauon-based cancer registry in Los Angeles County. A standardizd questionnaire was administered to either subjects or proxy informants of 90 lung cancer casesand ll6non-lung-cancercontrols. Significantly mcreasedrisksof lung cancer were associated with tobacco smokmg (odd5 ratio 7.6, p < .OOS) and shipyard weldmg with at least a IO-year latency since first exposure (odds ratio 1.7. p < .OS). Although thcrc WI’X elevated risks assoclatcd with somespcclfic wcldmg proccsses,nonc were statistically sigmficant. Control subjects wcrc more IIkcly to have had exposure to confined-space welding (odds ratio 0.6. 45% CI = (1.3~ 1.2), and this association was greatest where there had been at Ieaqt a 20.year latency s~ncefirstcxposurc(0.5.95~~ Cl -0.3-1.0). Wcconcludc thattheexcess of lung cancer in this welding population I< contr-[buted to by a higher frcqucncy of smoking and prohablc exposure to asbcstox m shipyards. Other factors may bc important, but probably hccausc oi lumtcd power and reliance on proxy informatmn, this study failed to detect other statistrcally significant rlbka. Dietary and alcohol intake, smoking pattern, axupational risk, and family history in lung cancer patients: Resoltv of a case-control study in males Pierce RJ, Kune GA. Kune S et al. I/nrvrrsuy q) iClrl/x-urne. L)epam ment of Surgery. lleldelherg Repammmn Ilospml l/t,ldrlberq, \‘rc. 3081. NW Cancer 1989;12:237-48. In a case-control study of 71 consccuuv~ new male cases of lung cancer and 71 male hospital control pancnts, prc,mus dietary and alcohol intake, smoking pattern. occupalmn. dusl exposure, and family history of lung cancer were invcstlgatcd. The cases and controls were stmilar in age, country of orlgm, arca of rcrldcnce, and marital status. Using a frcqucncy-based assessment of prcvtou? dlclan Intake. broad

Upload: votram

Post on 30-Dec-2016

216 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

loku.rhmu. 7okushmu Cuy 770 J Surg Oncol lYXY:ll.213-18. Wc diagnosed eight (8.9%) lung cancer patxnts in 90 workers

cxposcdtochromatecompounds. Thedurationofcxposurc ranged from 8 to il years, with a mean value of 18 + X years. The hIstologIcal ciacslflcatlon was squamous-cell carcinoma m seven pauents and adcnocarcmoma in one patient. The sltc of origin of the primary tumors was located pcriphcrally in two (25%) and centrally m ‘ilx (75%). All hut one of the?e patients undcrwcnt surgery. In three (37.5%) of thcsc patlcnis, lung cancer foci wcrc detecicd durmg the postoperative hollow up by sputum cytology and bronchoscopy. Two 01 these three patlcnts had multiccntrlc cancer foci: double primary early aquamous- ccl1 carcmoma m one and early squamous-ccl1 carcmoma + small-cell lung cancer m the other. In a high-risk group such as chromate workers, WC should cmphasx early dctcction of lung cancer by serial sputum cytology, chest x-rays. and bronchoscopy. Lung cancer patlen& wjrth chromate exposure should be treated with due regard to the posSLblli1) of synchronous or mctachl-onous cancer.

Vegetable consumption and lung cancer risk: A population-based case-control study in Hawaii Lc Marchand L, Yoqhlrawa CN. Koloncl LN, Hankm JH, Goodman MT. Epidemoiogy Program. Cunr-er Rcseurch Cenw of Ilawaii. liniwrcir> ofllawzi~. //omluiu. /// YMl3. J Natl Cancer Inst lY8Y:81: I ISX- M.

WC conducted a population-based study of diet and lung cancer among the multiethnic popularIon of Hawail in IYXi-lY85. We com- plctcdmtcrv~cwq for23Omenand I02 women wlthlungcancerand.597 men and 76X women conuols.frcquency-matched to the patients by age and xx. A quanutativc dietary history asscsscd the usual mtakc of foods rich m vltamrn\ A and C and carotcnoids. A clear dose-dcpcndcnt ncgall\c association was dcmonstratcd bctaccn dietary bctz-carotcnc and lungcanccrrisk m both scxc\;. Aftcradjusting forsmokmgand other covaTIatcs, Ihc men m rhc lowc~tquxtileol he&carotcnc mtake hadan odds ratio 01 I .O (95% confidcncc interval. I I-3.2) compared to thox m the hlghc\t quartile of mtir. The corresponding odds ratio for women was 2.7 (Y5% confidcncc mtcrval, I .2-h. I). Noclcarassociatmn was lound for rctinol, vitamm C, folic acid. iron. dlctary fihcr,or frulls. All vcgctablcs, dark green vcgctablcs, crucifcrous vcgctablcs, and tomatoes showed stronger mvcrsc assocmtion\ wnh rl<k than beta- carotcnc. Tlu\ obscrvatlcm suggests that other const~tucnts of vegc- table\, such ah Iutc~n. lycopenc, and mdolc\. and other\. may also

pro01 aFam\r lung cimcrr m humans.

Comparative lung tumorigenicity of parent and mononitro-polynu- clear aromatic hydrocarbons in the RLU:Ha newborn moose assay Busby WF Jr, Stevens EK, Martin CN, Chow FL, Garner RC. P rogrom in Toxicology, Massachlcteus lnslilute of Technology. Cambridge, MA 02139. Toxic01 Appl Pharmacol 1989;99:555-63.

A BLU:Ha newborn mouse lung adenoma bioassay was employed to compare the tumorigenicity of selected mononitroarenes and unsubsti- tuted parent compounds 6 months after imtial treatment. The presence of a nitro group had a variable effect upon compound potency in which tumorigenicity was increased, abolished, or unchanged. On the basis of rcsulu withequimolardoscs. thcpolencyofbenzo[a]pyrcnewasgreater than h-nitrobenzo[a]pyrene (Inactive), 6-niuochryscne was much greater than chrysenc (inactive), 3-niuofluoroanthene (active) wz equal to fluoranthcne (active), and I -nitropyrene (inactive) was equiva- lcnttopyrcne(inact~ve).Thepotcncy seriesamongthcmonomtroarenes was 6-nitrochrysenc >> 7.mtrofluoroanthrenc > 6.nmobcnzo[a]pyrene (mactlvc) = 1 -nitropyrcnc (macdvc). Lung tumor mcidencc and multi- plictty were similar for both males and females. No consistenl pattcm wits ohserved for the occasional appearance of lymphoma or hepatrc nodular hyperplasla in the \‘armus treatment groups.

Long cancer risk, occupational exposure. and the debrisoquine metabolic phenotype Caporaso N, Hayes RFI. Doscmccl M ct al. Environmenml Epidemol- ogy Branch. Division of Cancer Eliology. rational Canrw Institute. Bethesda, MD 20892. Cancer Rcs 1989;49:3675-Y.

The risk of lung cancer in smokers was exammed based on the debriscquine metabolic phenotype and on exposure to occupational lung carcinogens, specifically asbestos and polycyclic aromatic hydro- carbons. Extensive metabolizers of debnsoquine are at a 4-fold in- creased risk for lung cancer compared to poor metabolizers, after adjustment forage, sex, and smoking (,pack-years), when only cccupa- tonally uncxposcd subjects arc considcrcd. Increased risk related to the debrisoquinc metabolic phenotype was greatest for squamous and small cell histologlcs, and least for the adenocarcmoma subtype. Men with a history of exposure to occupational carcmogens had slgnifxantly mcreased nsk of lung cancer (relative risk = 2.8). after adjustment for age and smoking. Considering the combmcd cftect of the high nsk cxtensrvc mctaboli/cru debrisoquine mctabohc ,phenot)pe and likely occupational exposure to asbestos, the rclauvc cxccss rusk for lung cancer was I X-fold. Thus finding is conslstcnt wl’lh a synergism m risk between theability to cxtcnslvcly mctaboll/edebrlscyurne and occupa- uonal exposure to lung carcinogens m male smokers. Debnsoqume phenotypmg has potential for idcntifymg carcmogen-exposed workers at high risk of lung cancer.

Case-control study of lung cancer in Los Angeles County welders HullCJ,DoylcE,PetersJM,GxabrantDH, Bernstein I.,Prcstcm-Martin S. Division of Occupational Health, Depormeni of Preventive Medi- cine, University of Southern California School ofMedir-me, Los AnXe- le.<, CA 90033. Am J Ind Med 3989;16:303-12.

A cze-control study of lung cancer m wtutc male welders was undertaken to investigate possible cnvironmentaJ and occupational causes of a 50% cxccss of lung cancer obscrvccl in this occupauonal group. The subjects were identified from a populauon-based cancer registry in Los Angeles County. A standardizd questionnaire was administered to either subjects or proxy informants of 90 lung cancer casesand ll6non-lung-cancercontrols. Significantly mcreasedrisksof lung cancer were associated with tobacco smokmg (odd5 ratio 7.6, p < .OOS) and shipyard weldmg with at least a IO-year latency since first exposure (odds ratio 1.7. p < .OS). Although thcrc WI’X elevated risks assoclatcd with somespcclfic wcldmg proccsses,nonc were statistically sigmficant. Control subjects wcrc more IIkcly to have had exposure to confined-space welding (odds ratio 0.6. 45% CI = (1.3~ 1.2), and this association was greatest where there had been at Ieaqt a 20.year latency s~ncefirstcxposurc(0.5.95~~ Cl -0.3-1.0). Wcconcludc thattheexcess of lung cancer in this welding population I< contr-[buted to by a higher frcqucncy of smoking and prohablc exposure to asbcstox m shipyards. Other factors may bc important, but probably hccausc oi lumtcd power and reliance on proxy informatmn, this study failed to detect other statistrcally significant rlbka.

Dietary and alcohol intake, smoking pattern, axupational risk, and family history in lung cancer patients: Resoltv of a case-control study in males Pierce RJ, Kune GA. Kune S et al. I/nrvrrsuy q) iClrl/x-urne. L)epam ment of Surgery. lleldelherg Repammmn Ilospml l/t,ldrlberq, \‘rc. 3081. NW Cancer 1989;12:237-48.

In a case-control study of 71 consccuuv~ new male cases of lung cancer and 71 male hospital control pancnts, prc,mus dietary and alcohol intake, smoking pattern. occupalmn. dusl exposure, and family history of lung cancer were invcstlgatcd. The cases and controls were stmilar in age, country of orlgm, arca of rcrldcnce, and marital status. Using a frcqucncy-based assessment of prcvtou? dlclan Intake. broad

food groups were similar for cases and controls. Cases had a signifi- cantly lowerintakcoffish thancontrolsdid(oddsratio=0.5,confidence Interval = 0.2-I .O. p = 0.05). A protective effect for fish consumption in lungcanccrhasnotbwnprev~ouslyrcported.Thcdietary intakeoffoods contaming retmol and 3.carotcnc and the intake of alcohol were not sigmficandy different between cases and controls. For cases, smoking duration was longer and the hmc since cessation for exsmokers was shoncr, cigarette pack years were longer, and the number of cigarettes smoked per day was greater. The factors of occupation, dust exposure, and famdy history of cancer (mcludmg lung cancer) were similarly disulbutcd bctwcen cases and controls.

Study of lung cancer histologic types, occupation, and smoking in Missouri Hoar Zahm S, Brownson RC, Chang JC. Davis JR. Occupaliona[ Sfudw Section. Enwnnmen~al Epprdrmmlogy Branch, National Can- rer /n.wute, Rockulle, MD 2ORY2. Am J Ind Med lY89;15:565-78.

A case-control study of lung cancer was conducted to evaluate the relauonshlp bctwccn lung cancer htslologic types and occupation, adjusted for smokmg. A total of 4,431 whnc malt cases and 11,326 cancer controls, dlagnoscd bclwccn I980 and 1985, were identified through the MIssour Cancer Rcglstry. For all histologic types com- bmcd, cxccss risk walr ohxxvcd among many a prlori suspected hrgh- risk occupauons. Lung cancer wa\ clcvatcd among men employed a~ msulxors (odds ratio [OR] = 6.0: Y5? confidcncc mterval [Cl] = 0.7, 137.X),carpcntcrs(OR= 1.3: 95% Cl = I .O,l.7),pamtcrs,plastcrcrs,and wallpaper hangers (OR = 7.0; 95% Cl = 1.2,3.3), structural metal workers (OR = 1.9; YS% Cl = 0.6,6.0), mechanics and rcparrers (OR = 1.3; 95% Cl = l.O,l.7), motor vehicle drivers (OR = 1.5; 95% CI = 1.2,l.X). pohce and flrcflghtcrs (OR = 1.6; 95% Cl = l.l,2,3),andfood scrwcc pcrsonncl (OR = I .8; 95% CI = I .0,3.S). A deficit of lung cancer was observed among farmers (OR = 0.9; 95% Cl = 0.7.1.0). Adenocx- cmoma of the lung was clcvatcd among carpcntcrs (OR = 1.6; 95% CI = l.O,?.S)andcabinctandfurn~~urcmakcrs(OR=2.O;Y5~Cl=O.4,8.~), which 1h mtcrcstmg bccausc ofthc prcvwuh reports ofcxccs~ adcnocar- cmoma of the nasal cavny assocwcd \rlth wood dust exposure. Aden- ocarcmoma, were alho clwatcd among plumbers (OR = 2.0; 95% CI = 1.0,3.X)andprmtcrs(OR = 1.X: Y5% Cl =0.7,4.2). Elcctrlc~answereat shghdy lncrcascdriskforadenocarcinoma(OR = 1.5:95%C1=0.7,2.8) and ‘other’ or mixed ccl1 t)pc< of lung cancer (OR = 1.5; 95% CI = 0.8.2.9) but atdwreawd risk for small cell (OR = 0.8; 95% Cl = 0.3,2.0) and squamous cell (OR = 0.8; 953 CI = 0.4,l.h) tumors. Among welders, adcnocarcinoma (OR = 1.7: YS% CI = 0.7.3.x) and squamous cell (OR = I .7: 95% CI = 0.9,3.3) cancer, wcrc elcvatcd, but small cell and ‘other’ lung cancers hcrc not. Dc\pltc the IimItatIons of the Cancer Rcgl\try data, some mtcrcslmg a\wclations ucrc obscrvcd that merit further study, panlcularl) the a\wc1atIon bstwecn lung adenocar- clnoma and occupatmnal cxposurc to wood And wood dust.

Lung cancer in women and type of dwelling in relation to radon exposure Svensson C, Pershagen G, Klommck J. Dep~tmeni ofCanr:rrEpidemi- #logy, Karolinska Institute. S-104 01 Stockholm. Cancer Res lYXY;49:1861-5.

A case-control study based on mtcrwcws with 210 incident fcmalc lung cancer patrents, 209 age-matched population controls, and I91 hospital controls was carried out in Stockholm county, Swcdcn. Radon measurements made in a sample of 303 dwellings, in which the study subjects had lived, showed that dwellings with ground contact had an avcragc concentration of approximately 160 Bqm 3, twrcc the avcragc conccnuatton of other dwellings. A cumulated radon cxposurc index was calculated for each subject based on dala from the intcrvicws and thcmcasurcmcnts.Forthc totalgroupoflungcanccrarclatlvcr~sk(RR), adjusted for smokmg, age, and degree of urbanwation, of I .X (95% confidence mtcrval: 1.2-2.9) and 1.7 (0.9-3.3) assoclatcd wnh ‘mtcrmc-

diatc’ and ‘high’ exposure to radon was found. There was also a significant trend to a positive dose-response relationship (P(trend) = 0.03). For small ccl] cancer the corresponding figures for RRs wcrc I .9 (0.64.5) and 4.7 (1.5-14.2), respectively (P(trcnd) = 0.01). There seemed to be a positive interaction between randon cxposurc and smoking in relation to lung cancer. The findings indicate that domestic radon may bc of importance for the induction of lung cancer, particularly for some histological types.

Amosite mesothelioma in a cohort of asbestos workers Ribak J, Seidman H, Selikoff IJ. Environmental Research Laboratory, Mount Sinai School ofMedicine, New York, NY. Stand J Work Environ Health 1989;15:10&10.

A cohort of 280 asbestos workers with a short duration of cxposurc to amositc between 1941 and 1945 was followed. These men were alive five years afier starting work and were observed until 1988. Seventeen cases of malignant mesothelioma (eight pleural, nine peritoneal) were found. The mean age at the onset of exposure was 33 years for men with pleural mesothelioma and 30 years of those with peritoneal mesotheli- oma. Chest pain was the main symptom in pleural mesothelioma and abdominal pain in peritoneal mesothelioma. Open lung biopsy was the most useful diagnostic approach for pleural mesothelioma, whereas for pcritoncal mesothclioma it was exploratory laparotomy. Pleural pa- tients died of pulmonary insufficxncy, and peritoneal patients of wastmg and Inanition. In both groups the death certificate diagnosis was less accurate than the climcal diagnosis at death. The mean survival was 12.5 months from first symptom to death for the pleural group and 5.4 months for the perrtoneal group.

Time trends in occupational risks of long cancer among Swedish men from 1961-1979 Carstensen J.M. Pershagen G. Eklund G. Department of Oncology, Uni- versity Ilospital, S-581-85 Linkopmg. Am J Ind Med 1989;15:441-8.

Using data from the Swedish Cancer-Enwronmeni Register, time trends in the standardized Incidence ratio (SIR) for lung cancer 1961- 1979 were studrcd in different occupations. After adjustments for differences in the SIR with respect to year of birth, only the decreasing trends for blacksmiths and members of the armed forces as well as increasing trends for foundry workers and constructron machine opera- tors were significant (p < 0.05). For bakers and pastry cooks, there was a significant interaction between year of birth and observation period in relation to SIR. Data on smoking habits, obtained from a sample of the population, did not stem to explain the trends.

Risk estimates for lung tomours from inhaled 2’pPu0,, 2’8Pu02, and “9Po(N0,), in beagle dogs Dagle GE, Park JF, Gilbert ES, Weller RE. Pacific Northwest Labora- tory, Richland, WA 99352.. Radiat Prot Dosim 1989;26: 173-6.

Lung cancer risks arc bemg studied m beagle dogs given smgle exposures to aerosols of L39P~0,, 238Pu0,, or 239P~(N0,),. A major objective of these studies is to examine the risk of lung cancer relative tothespecificactivityofthcradionuclidc,rateofdoscaccumulationdue to diffcrcnccs in solubilities of the radionuclides, and the presence of competing risk from extrapulmonary lesions. Dose-response relation- slups were studled for the three groups of dogs, with analysts specifi- cally designed to evaluate differences in response. Based on estimated cumulative dose to the lung, risks were found to differ sigmficantly among the radionuclidcs; they were highest for 239P~(N0,), and lowest forz3*Pu0,.Amodc1 in which therisk wasassumcd to beapurcquadratic function of dose fitted the data much better than a pure lmcar model. Currently,allthrccgroupsofdogscanbecomparcdonlytolOyearsaftcr exposure. Howcvcr, it is apparent that the average cumulative dose to the lung may not be an adequate predictor of lung cancer risk for different isotopic and physicochemical forms of plutonium.