diet & bowel health - glnc.org.au · as stomach ulcers and gastritis. interestingly, prevention...
TRANSCRIPT
DigestiveandbowelhealthisanimportantpublichealthissueinAustralia.Wehaveanageingpopulationandincreasinglevelsofdigestivehealthproblems,includingcolorectalcancer(CRC),IrritableBowelSyndrome(IBS)andmalabsorptionandmalnutrition.
Colorectal Cancer
ColorectalcancerremainsthemostcommoncancerinAustraliawith30newpatientsdiagnosedeveryday.4outof5patientshavenorecognizableriskfactors.ProfTerryBolinstatedthatdietisimportantanditseemslikelythatfibreandparticularly,resistantstarchintake,influencethegenesisofCRC.HereferredtothelowincidenceofCRCinAfricaandAsiawherestarchintakeishigh.
To further its commitment to improving the digestive health of Australians, Bürgen® Rye initiated an Expert Roundtable discussion, held at CSIRO (Food Futures Centre), Sydney on 12 October 2011. The aim of the full day meeting was to assess the current advice and provide evidence-based, practical and realistic recommendations to assist Australians in managing their digestive and bowel health. The expert participants included:• Prof.TerryBolin,TheGutFoundation
• DrTonyBird,FoodFuturesNationalResearchFlagship,CSIROFoodandNutritionalSciences.
• MsKarenInge,Dietitian,APD&NutritionConsultant
• DrMichaelConlon,FoodFuturesNationalResearchFlagship,CSIROFoodandNutritionalSciences.
• DrTonyHelman,Chairman,NutritionAdvisoryGroup,RACGPandEditorinChief,ArborClinicalNutritionUpdates(Facilitator)
Figure 1: The association between starch intake (g/day) and colon cancer incidence1.
About Colorectal Cancer:
• Itkills12Australianseachday,80Australianseveryweek(morethan4,100perannum).Thisnationaldeathtollleadstheworld
• Bowelcanceristhemostcommoninternalcanceraffectingbothmenandwomen
• Ratesofthediseaseinyoungerpeoplehaveincreasedinthepast10years–67%increasein40-44yearagegroup2
• Almostasmanywomendieofbowelcancerasbreastcancer
• OnlyoneinfourAustraliansareawareofthedeadlyimpactofthedisease
• Awarenessisimportantasthediseaseispreventableandcurableifdetectedearly.
Expert Roundtable Report Diet & Bowel Health
Reference:(TheGutFoundationwww.gutfoundation.com/bowel_cancer_awareness_week)
Australia/USA
India/China
Bowel Health Issues in AustraliaProf Terry Bolin highlighted the most common internal cancer is colorectal cancer and that diet may well be an important factor in its genesis.
Recentevidencesuggeststhatdifferentfibresactthroughdifferentmechanismsandaremoreeffectiveincombinationthanindividuallyforpromotingbowelhealth3.
Combination of Fibres
Soluble fibre Insoluble fibre Resistant starch
Function Viscousfibresslowthetimeittakesforfoodtopassthroughthestomachandsmallintestineresultinginslowerabsorptionofnutrientsandlowercholesterollevels.
Exertsgreatestinfluenceonthelargebowel-helpstonormalizebowelfunction(shortenstransittime,helpsproducelargerandsofterstoolsandincreasesdefecationfrequency).
Starchesthatresistsmallintestinalbreakdownarefermentedbybacteriainthelargebowel,producingshortchainfattyacids(SCFA),whichareimportantforcolonichealth.
Sources Oats,barley,vegetables,lentils,beans(driedorcanned),nuts,seeds,Bürgen®Ryebreadandfruit.
Highfibrewheatbasedcereals,brownriceandpasta,millet,quinoa,bulgarwheat,wholemealandryebreads,Bürgen®Ryebread.
Legumes,wholegrains(e.grye),Bürgen®Ryebread,coldcookedpotatoes,riceandpastaandfirmbananas.
DrBirdhighlightedadietrichinarangeoffibrescanhelppreventandmanagecommonintestinalproblemslikeconstipation,haemorrhoidsanddiverticulardisease.Carefuluseofdietaryfibre(solubleorinsoluble,basedonthesymptoms),canalsohelptomanageirritablebowelsyndrome(IBS)andinflammatoryboweldisease4,5,6.
NHMRC Nutrient Reference Values for Dietary Fibre*
Men aged 19+ Women aged 19+
Adequate Intake (AI) 30g/day 25g/day
AIsincluderesistantstarch,thefirstglobalofficialrecommendation.TheAIwassetatthemediandietaryfibreintakeforthepopulation.
Suggested Dietary Targets (SDTs)
38g/day 28g/day
Levelsbasedonupperlevel90thcentileofintakeforreductionincoronaryheartdiseaserisk(notforCRC).
Upper limit Not set Not set
Noevidencethathighintakewouldproducesubstantialdeleteriouseffects.
The Australian Paradox: Comparatively High Fibre Intakes, High Rates of Colorectal Cancer
Dietaryfibrehasahighlevelofconsumerrecognitionanditsimportanceforgoodhealthiswellestablishedandaccepted7.AveragefibreintakesofadultsinAustraliaareformen~27g/dandforwomen~21g/d.Theselevelsarehighbyinternationalstandards-almosttwicethatoftheUS&UK.“OurdietaryfibreintakeisapproachingtheNHMRCtargetsandhasbeenatthislevelforthepasttwodecades.Paradoxically,bowelcancerratesremainstubbornlyhigh”,statedDrTonyBird.
Fibre intakes are too low, particularly resistant starch intakes
DrBirdisconcernedthatAustraliansarenotconsumingtherightamountandcombinationoffibre,particularlyresistantstarch.Recommendedresistantstarchintakesshouldbearound20gaday,whichisalmostfourtimesgreaterthanatypicalwesterndietcurrentlyprovides8.
Internationalcomparativestudiesshowstrongercorrelationsbetweenbowelcancerandstarch(andthusresistantstarch)intakethanwithdietaryfibre1.
Thestronginverseassociationbetweenstarchandbowelcancercorrespondswiththehypothesisthatfermentationofresistantstarchinthecolonisapotentialmechanismforbowelcancerpreventionviatheproductionofshortchainfattyacids,inparticularbutyrate.
“Although dietary fibre intakes seem to be reaching targets, more than 60% of the population, do not consume adequate amounts of fibre, particularly young women and food avoiders (those who avoid carbohydrates, gluten, wheat and other grains)”, –DrTonyBird.
(*NHMRC.NutrientReferenceValuesforAustraliaandNewZealand.Canberra:CommonwealthofAustralia,2006)
“CSIRO clinical trials have provided more than 40g of fibre per day, yet there were no significant differences in abdominal discomfort between the high fibre and the low fibre groups”, – DrTonyBird.
The role of dietary fibre in digestive healthDr Tony Bird highlighted the public health focus for fibre needs to evolve from general basic advice for people to ‘eat more fibre’ to a stronger emphasis on specifically consuming a diverse range of fibres for maintaining digestive health.
Wholegrainryeishighinfibreandcontainsadiverserangeoffibressuchasarabinoxylans,fructans,beta-glucanandresistantstarch.Manyofthesefibresarehighlyfermentableinthelargebowel,makingwholegrainryebeneficialforbowelhealth.
AnewstudybyCSIRO9addstothegrowingbodyofevidencethatryeisbeneficialforbowelhealth.Thestudywasacrossoverdesigninwhichtheeffectofconsuming4or5slicesdailyofeitherBürgen®Ryeorawhitebread(control)respectivelyforfourconsecutiveweekswascompared.
TwentyhealthyhumanscompletedthestudyandtherewasnodifferenceinabdominaldiscomfortwhenconsumingthewhitebreadorBürgen®Ryebread,whichwasselfreportedusingagastrointestinalqualityoflifeindex.Bürgen®Ryeelicitedanumberofchangesconsideredbeneficialtobowelhealth:• increasedfaecalbulkandlowered
faecalpHcomparedtowhitebread• significantlyincreasedlevelsof
acetate,butyrateandtotalSCFA• significantlyincreasedfaecal
concentrationsandexcretionofammonia(toxin)
• significantlyincreasednumbersofFaecalibacteriumprausnitziiandRuminococcusbromii,whicharepotentiallybeneficialbacteriaandmayfacilitatebutyrateproduction.
ThisstudysupportspreviousresearchconductedbyCSIROshowingthattheconsumptionofryefoods(includingBürgen®Ryebread)improvedmarkersofbowelandmetabolichealthinoverweightmiddle-agedmen10.
The role of gut microbiota in maintaining gastrointestinal health – current understanding and challenges
DrConlondiscussedthisevolvingareaofnutritionscience.Thegutmicrobiotafermentcarbohydratesandproteinsthatreachthelargebowelandcancontributetothebenefitsobtainedfromconsumptionofwholegrains.Dietaryfibrescanincreasemicrobialgrowthandmassinthelargebowel(contributingtofaecalbulking),dilutepotentiallytoxicproductssuchasammonia,phenolsandhydrogensulphidethatcanresultfromproteinfermentationandreducetheirimpactonguttissues.Also,fibreswhicharefermentedbythebacteriainthelargebowelleadtotheproductionofshortchainfattyacids(SCFA),primarilyacetate,butyrateandpropionate,whichhavemultiplebeneficialeffectsoncolonictissuesandlowerluminalpH,providinganenvironmentmoreconducivetogrowthofbeneficialbacteria.
Bread Type in CSIRO Research Project
Resistant Starch g/100g
Total Dietary Fibre g/100g
Bürgen®Rye
4.7 8.4
Sunblest®White
0.9 3.7
Benefits of Rye:
• Highfibrewholegrainandcontainsadiverserangeoffibres• Improvesbowelfunction• Effectivestoolbulkingagent
• Increasesbutyrateproduction• Promotesfaecalexcretionofpotentialtoxins(foregammonia)• ReducesfaecalpH
“There are about 10 times as many bacteria in the large bowel as cells in our body”
Beneficial bacteria
DrConlonrevealed“thereislimitedknowledgeaboutthebacteriathatliveinthelargebowelyetwedoknowthereareapproximately10timesasmanybacteriainthelargebowelascellsinourbodyandweallhaveourowndistinctgut
microbiota”.Inclinicalstudies,improvedgastrointestinalhealthmaynottranslatetoobviouschangesinthegutmicrobiota.“Specific,possiblysmall,changesmaygoundetected,”hestated.
Are dietary fibres prebiotics?
AcurrentdefinitionofaprebioticsetbytheInternationalScientificAssociationforProbioticsandPrebioticsisa“selectivelyfermentedingredientthatresultsinspecificchangesinthecompositionand/oractivityofthegastrointestinalmicrobiota,thusconferringbenefit(s)uponhosthealth”.IntherecentstudybyCSIRO,Bürgen®Ryebreadincreasednumbersofpotentiallyhelpfulbacteriathatfacilitatecarbohydratefermentationandbutyrateproduction(e.gR.bromiiandF.prausnitzii)butdidnotincreaselactobacilliandbifidobacteria.DrConlonbelievesthatafocusonlactobacilliandbifidobacteriaindefiningaprebioticislikelytobetoonarrowandpossiblyirrelevanttoadulthealth. The challenge – there is a current limited understanding of gut microbiota (types and activities) that limit our ability to determine which microorganisms should be used as markers of bowel or digestive health.
Large Bowel Microbiology:• Anaerobicenvironment• Mostmicrobes:
− Difficulttoculture− Uncharacterised
• Microbesfacilitatefermentationofcolonicsubstratesandareintegraltocolorectalhealth
(NB:Numbersareapproximateandcanvary)
1010
102-3
105-8
1012
Gastrointestinal Tract Microbiology
Rye & Gastrointestinal HealthDr Michael Conlon presented the results of a recent CSIRO study which examined the bowel health benefits of consuming Bürgen® Rye Bread and revealed the implications of a narrow definition for prebiotics.
Digestivehealthisadominanthealthissueinconsumers’mindsnowandinthefuture.Today’sconcernsareabout‘feelinggood’anddealingwithflatulence,bloating,indigestionandconstipationcomparedtofutureconcerns,whicharefocusedaroundmoreseriousconditionssuchasstomachulcersandgastritis.Interestingly,preventionofbowelcancerisnota‘topofmind’healthissue.
Consumersrecognisethatdietisakeyplayerindigestivehealthandhaveahighwillingnesstotreatwithfood.Generally,consumersprefertoeattheirwaytohealthbyincreasingtheirintakeofhealthyfoodsratherthaneatinglessofthefoodsthattheylikethatmaynotbeashealthy.(ADANutritionandyoutrends2011)
“Consumers know ‘fibre keeps you regular’ but have limited awareness of the types of fibre and the health benefits”.
Socialresearchhasfoundconsumersswitchoffwithwordssuchas‘bowel’and‘constipation’preferringpositivemessageslike‘helpstokeepyourdigestivesystemhealthy’or‘helpskeepyouregular’.
Karenrecommendedweget‘backtobasics’andhelpconsumersunderstandwhatis‘normal’.Inarecentradiointerviewondigestivehealth,KarenpointedoutthedownloadoftheBristolstoolchartontheradiostationswebsitereceivedmorehitsthananyothernewsfeatured.
Thisclearlyindicatespeopleareafterthistypeofinformationbuttooembarrassedtoask–weneedtomakethisreadilyavailable.
TheBristolStoolChartclassifiestheformofhumanstoolsintosevencategories.Types1and2indicateconstipation,with4and5beingthe“idealstools”,and6–7tendingtowardsdiarrhoea12.
Type 2
Type 1
Type 3
Type 4
Type 5
Type 6
Type 7
Separate hard lumps, like nuts(hard to pass)
Sausage-shaped but lumpy
Like a sausage but with cracks on the surface
Like a sausage or snake, smooth and soft
Soft blobs with clear-cut edges
Fluffy pieces with ragged edges, a mushy stool
Watery, no solid pieces.Entirely Liquid
Bristol Stool Chart
Consumer InsightsKaren Inge encouraged health professionals to look outside clinical guidelines when educating Australians on bowel and digestive issues. ‘Beating the bloat’ is the hot button in digestive wellbeing but is talking about it sexy?
Recommendations: Key Issues
ThePaneldiscussionfocusedoncurrentknowledgeonfibreandbowelhealthandthepracticalimplicationsoftheroundtablepresentations.
General Recommendations• Target high risk consumers:
− RestrictiveEaters–particularlythoseonlowcarborhighproteindiets
− FoodAvoiders–thoseonGlutenFreeorWheat-FreeDiets(self-prescribedandmedicallydiagnosed)
− OlderAustralians
− PeoplewithCoeliacDisease
− Breakfastskippers
• Address misconceptions and misunderstandings:
− Educateoncombinationoffibres,recommendedlevelsandrichsources–withafocusonincreasingintakesofresistantstarchandwholegrains
− Wheatandglutenavoiders–educateontheimportanceoffibreinmaintainingbowelhealth
− Normalgutandbowelfunction–BristolStoolChart(indicates7typesofstoolswithType4and5beingmostoptimal).Thiscouldbeausefulcommunicationtooltoeducatepeopleonnormalbowelhealthandtoassistinassessingthetypeoffibreintakeimportantforimprovingbowelhabits(suchas,howtogetfroma1toa4).
− Thereisaneedforevidence-basedinformationandpracticaltipsonthecombinationoffibresinmanagingdigestiveandbowelhealth.ThesecommunicationmaterialswouldbeusefulresourcesforDietitians,GPs,PracticeNursesandGastroenterologistsandeasilyaccessibleonline.
Health Professional Recommendations
• Informhealthprofessionalson‘newnews’relatedtocombinationofdietaryfibresforbowelhealthandtheneedtofocusonincreasingresistantstarchintake.
• EncouragetheuseoftheBristolStoolChartasamarkerofgoodbowelhealthandtomonitordietarychanges(e.g.movingfroma‘1or2’toa‘4or5’)
• Detailedandinformativemessagesaddressingkeyissuesfor‘atriskgroups’,andgastrointestinaldiseasesarerequiredforconsumersandpatients.
• Advisepatientstomakegradualchangestotheirdietaryfibreintakeandtodrinkenoughwater.Forexample,graduallyoveraweekchangetoahighfibrebreakfastcerealandtheninweek2,changetoawholegrainbreadlikeRyebread.
• Practicalconsumer-friendlyguidelinesonhowtomeetrecommendedfibreintakesfromavarietyofsourcesneedtobedeveloped.
Research recommendations
• Specificguidelinesonthemixoffibresforpreventivehealtharerequired.
• CurrentconsumptiondataonfibreintakesincludingresistantstarchisrequiredforAustralianadults.
• Up-to-datefoodcompositiondatabaseincludingthetypesoffibreinfoodsisrequired.
• Officialdietaryfibreandresistantstarchrecommendationsneedtobereviewedasthecurrentadequateintakes(25-30g/day)reflectthecurrentlowintakesofresistantstarchintheAustralianpopulation.Recommendationsforspecifictargetgroupsmaybenecessary,e.g.byage,lifestage,gender,pre-andpost-menopauseandrace.
• Exploreimplicationsoffoodavoidanceandfaddietsonfibreintakesandbowelhealth.
• Moreresearchtoconfirmnon-invasivebiomarkersofbowelhealth-whichtypeoffibreorbacteriaisimportantformaintainingbowelhealth.
• Isthereanupperintakelimitoffibreisolatesthatcouldbeproblematic?Moreinformationonwithinandbetweenindividualresponsestodietaryfibres.
Recommendations
Key messages
• Combinationsofdietaryfibreareessentialforbowelhealth-therearethreemajortypesoffibreanditisimportanttoconsumealltypesoffibrefromawidevarietyoffoods.
• Internationalcomparativestudiesshowstrongercorrelationsbetweenbowelcancerandresistantstarchintakethanwithdietaryfibre.
• Australianfibreintakeshavebeenincreasingoverthelasttwentyyears,yetcolorectalcancerratesremainstubbornlyhigh.
• Atleast60%ofAustraliansarenotgettingenoughfibreandthemajorityarenotgettingenoughdiversityinfibreintake,especiallyresistantstarch.
• MedianvaluesarenotappropriateasabasisforAdequateIntake(AI)recommendationswherethepopulationconsumeslowlevelsofresistantstarchandhasahighincidenceofchronicdisease.ReliablecontemporaryfibreintakedataarerequiredandofficialAIrecommendationsneedtobereviewed(aspercurrentreviewofNRV’s).
• Ryeisahighfibrewholegrainandcontainsadiverserangeoffibres,includingresistantstarch.RecentresearchconductedbyCSIROonBürgen®Ryebreadaddstothegrowingbodyofevidencethatryeisbeneficialforbowelanddigestivehealth.
• Thereisacurrentlimitedunderstandingofgutmicrobiota,thereforeresearchoutcomesshouldbefocusedonimprovedbowelfunctionasopposedtoanincreaseinspecificbacteria(bifidobacteriaandlactobacilli).
• Consumersneedtobebetterinformedaboutdigestiveandbowelhealth.Misconceptionsaboutgrainfoodsneedtobeaddressedandcommunicationsneedtobetargetedto‘atrisk’groups(e.g.dieters,foodavoiders(gluten-freeorwheat-free)andolderAustralians).
• Consumersneedtoknowwhat’snormalintermsofbowelfunctionandwhattoaimfore.g.a‘4’onBristolStoolChart.
• ‘Notallfibreiscreatedequal’.Healthprofessionalsneedtoaddresscurrentmisconceptionsaboutfibre-richgrainfoodsinthedietastheyareessentialforprovidingtheoptimalcombinationoffibresfordigestiveandbowelhealth.
Panel Discussion: Getting the focus back on fibre and bowel health – what needs to be done?All participating experts agreed on the need to clear up the current confusion about diet and bowel health and communicate positive evidence-based messages about the beneficial role of fibre-rich grain foods and the combination of fibres needed for bowel health.
References:1.CassidyA,BinghamSA,CummingsJH.Starchintakeandcolorectalcancerrisk–aninternationalcomparison.BrJCancer199469:937-942.2.DavisDM,MarcetJE,FrattiniJC,etal.IsIttimetolowertherecommendedscreeningageforcolorectalcancer?JournalAmericanCollegeofSurgery.2011;213:352-362.3.BirdAR,VuaranM,CrittendenR,HayakawaT,PlaynMJ,BrownILandToppingDL.Comparativeeffectsofahigh-amylosestarchandafructooligosaccharideonfecalbifidobacterianumbersandshort-chainfattyacidsinpigsfedBifidobacteriumanimalis.DigestiveDiseasesandSciences.2009;54:947-954.4.AndersonJW,BairdP,DavisJrRH,FerreriS,KnudtsonM,KoraymA,WatersVandWilliamsCL.Healthbenefitsofdietaryfiber.NutritionReviews.2009;67(4):188–205.5.PositionoftheAmericanDieteticAssociation:HealthImplicationsofDietaryFiber.JAmDietAssoc.2008;108:1716-17316.TheGutFoundation(Australia).Dietaryfibreandhealth,2005.PreparedbyTerryBolin,AlistairCowen,MelvynKorman,RosemaryStanton.7.MohrP,QuinnS,MorellM,ToppingD.EngagementwithdietaryfibreandreceptivenesstoresistantstarchinAustralia.PublicHealthNutrition2010;13:1915-19228.BaghurstPA,BaghurstKI,RecordSJ.Dietaryfibre,non-starchpolysaccharidesandresistantstarch-areview.FoodAust.1996;48(Suppl):S3-S35.9.ConlonM&BirdAR.StudyonthePrebioticPotentialofBürgen®Rye.2011:CSIROReport.10.McIntoshetal.Whole-grainryeandwheatfoodsandmarkersofbowelhealthinoverweightmiddle-agedmen.AmJClinNutr2003;77:967-974.11.Abelletal.PhylotypesrelatedtoRuminococcusbromiiareabundantinthelargebowelofhumansandincreaseinresponsetoadiethighinresistantstarch.FEMSMicrobiolEcol.2008;66:505-515.12.LewisSJ,HeatonKW.Stoolformscaleasausefulguidetointestinaltransittime.Scand.J.Gastroenterol.1997;32(9):920–4
®GoGrainsHealth&Nutrition.Trademarkusedunderlicense.Allrightsreserved.January2012
Food Serving Size Resistant Starch (g)
Oatmeal 1cup,cooked 0.5g1
Barley,pearl ¾cup,cooked 2.8g1
Bürgen®RyeBread 2slices,100g 4.7g2
Pasta,cold(insalad) 1cup 1.4g1
Lentils ¾cup,cooked 5.0g1
Potato,cold(insalad) 1-2”diameter 1.0g1
Navybeans ½cup,cooked 3.8g1
Foods with Moderate to High Resistant Starch Content - Aim for 20g resistant starch per day for bowel health
References:1MurphyM,EnvironInternationalCorporation.BirkettA.BarndtR.PreliminaryestimatesofresistantstarchintheUnitedStates,2006.2ConlonM&BirdT.StudyonthePrebioticPotentialofBürgen®Rye.2011:inpress)
For patient resources and facts sheets visit visit www.burgen.com.au/healthcareprofessional
Bürgen®iscommittedtoprovidinghealthprofessionalsandallAustralianswithspeciallydevelopedinformation,publicationsandresourcestokeepyouup-to-dateontheroleofBürgen®breadinhealthandwellbeing.
Australia’s leading independent voice for grains and legumes in health and nutrition
®