diabetes.pdf

13
2.32 Study protocol The effectiveness of text messages support for diabetes selfmanagement: protocol of the TEXT4DSM study in the democratic Republic of Congo, Cambodia and the Philippines Josefien van Olmen 1 2 * , Grace Marie Ku 1 3 , Maurits van Pelt 4 , Jean Clovis Kalobu 5 , Heang Hen 4 , Christian Darras 6 , Kristien Van Acker 7 , Balthazar Villaraza 3 , Francois Schellevis 8 and Guy Kegels 1 BMC Public Health 2013, 13:423 doi:10.1186/1471245813423 The electronic version of this article is the complete one and can be found online at: http://www.biomedcentral.com/14712458/13/423 Received: 21 February 2013 Accepted: 19 March 2013 Published: 1 May 2013 © 2013 van Olmen et al.; licensee BioMed Central Ltd. This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/2.0 ), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited. Corresponding author: Josefien van Olmen Department of Public Health, Institute of Tropical Medicine, Brussels, Antwerp, Belgium Department of General Practice & Elderly Care Medicine, EMGO Institute for Health and Care Research, VU University Medical Center, Amsterdam, The netherlands Veterans Memorial Medical Center, Quezon, Philippines MoPoTsyo, Phnom Penh, Cambodia Memisa, Kinshasa, DR Congo Memisa, Brussels, Belgium Diabetologist, working at Algemeen ziekenhuis Heilige Familie, Reet & Centre de Santé des Fagnes, Chimay, Belgium NIVEL (Netherlands Institute for Health Services Research), Utrecht, Netherlands & Department of General Practice and Elderly Care Medicine/EMGO Institute for Health and Care Research VU University Medical Center, Amsterdam, The Netherlands For all author emails, please log on . * [email protected] 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8

Upload: paul-allan-p-cenabre

Post on 08-Nov-2015

212 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

  • 4/17/2015 BMCPublicHealth|Fulltext|Theeffectivenessoftextmessagessupportfordiabetesselfmanagement:protocoloftheTEXT4DSMstudyinthedemocraticRepublicofCongo,CambodiaandthePhilippines

    http://www.biomedcentral.com/14712458/13/423 1/13

    2.32

    Studyprotocol

    Theeffectivenessoftextmessagessupportfordiabetesselfmanagement:protocoloftheTEXT4DSMstudyinthedemocraticRepublicofCongo,CambodiaandthePhilippinesJosefienvanOlmen12*,GraceMarieKu13,MauritsvanPelt4,JeanClovisKalobu5,HeangHen4,ChristianDarras6,KristienVanAcker7,BalthazarVillaraza3,FrancoisSchellevis8 andGuyKegels1

    BMCPublicHealth2013,13:423 doi:10.1186/1471245813423

    Theelectronicversionofthisarticleisthecompleteoneandcanbefoundonlineat:http://www.biomedcentral.com/14712458/13/423

    Received: 21February2013Accepted: 19March2013Published: 1May2013

    2013vanOlmenetal.licenseeBioMedCentralLtd.

    ThisisanOpenAccessarticledistributedunderthetermsoftheCreativeCommonsAttributionLicense(http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/2.0),whichpermitsunrestricteduse,distribution,andreproductioninanymedium,providedtheoriginalworkisproperlycited.

    Correspondingauthor:JosefienvanOlmen

    DepartmentofPublicHealth,InstituteofTropicalMedicine,Brussels,Antwerp,Belgium

    DepartmentofGeneralPractice&ElderlyCareMedicine,EMGOInstituteforHealthandCareResearch,VUUniversityMedicalCenter,Amsterdam,Thenetherlands

    VeteransMemorialMedicalCenter,Quezon,Philippines

    MoPoTsyo,PhnomPenh,Cambodia

    Memisa,Kinshasa,DRCongo

    Memisa,Brussels,Belgium

    Diabetologist,workingatAlgemeenziekenhuisHeiligeFamilie,Reet&CentredeSantdesFagnes,Chimay,Belgium

    NIVEL(NetherlandsInstituteforHealthServicesResearch),Utrecht,Netherlands&DepartmentofGeneralPracticeandElderlyCareMedicine/EMGOInstituteforHealthandCareResearchVUUniversityMedicalCenter,Amsterdam,TheNetherlands

    Forallauthoremails,pleaselogon.

    * [email protected]

    1

    2

    3

    4

    5

    6

    7

    8

  • 4/17/2015 BMCPublicHealth|Fulltext|Theeffectivenessoftextmessagessupportfordiabetesselfmanagement:protocoloftheTEXT4DSMstudyinthedemocraticRepublicofCongo,CambodiaandthePhilippines

    http://www.biomedcentral.com/14712458/13/423 2/13

    Abstract

    BackgroundPeoplewithdiabetesfinditdifficulttosustainadequateselfmanagementbehaviour.SelfManagementSupportstrategies,includingtheuseofmobiletechnology,haveshownpotentialbenefit.Thisstudyevaluatestheeffectivenessofamobilephonesupportinterventionontopofanexistingstrategyinthreecountries,DRCongo,CambodiaandthePhilippinestoimprovehealthoutcomes,accesstocareandenablementofpeoplewithdiabetes,with480peoplewithdiabetesineachcountrywhoarerandomisedtoeitherstandardsupportortotheintervention.

    Design/methodsThestudyconsistsofthreesubstudieswithasimilardesigninthreecountriestobeindependentlyimplementedandanalysed.ThedesignisatwoarmRandomisedControlledTrial,inwhichatotalof480adultswithdiabetesparticipatinginanexistingDSMEprogrammewillberandomlyallocatedtoeitherusualcareintheexistingprogrammeortousualcareplusamobilephoneselfmanagementsupportintervention.Participantsinbotharmscompleteassessmentsatbaseline,oneyearandtwoyearsafterinclusion.

    Glycosylatedhaemoglobinbloodpressure,height,weight,waistcircumferencewillbemeasured.Individualinterviewswillbeconductedtodeterminethepatientsassessmentofchronicillnesscare,degreeofselfenablement,andaccesstocarebeforeimplementationoftheintervention,atintermediatemomentsandattheendofthestudy.

    Analysesofquantitativedataincludingassessmentofdifferencesinchangesinoutcomesbetweentheinterventionandusualcaregroupwillbedone.Aprobabilityof

  • 4/17/2015 BMCPublicHealth|Fulltext|Theeffectivenessoftextmessagessupportfordiabetesselfmanagement:protocoloftheTEXT4DSMstudyinthedemocraticRepublicofCongo,CambodiaandthePhilippines

    http://www.biomedcentral.com/14712458/13/423 3/13

    servicesandvisits.Mobiletechnologycanbeparticularlybeneficialforthemanagementofachronicdiseaselikediabetes,forinstancebysupportingbehaviouralchangeandremindersfortakingmedicationandforappointmentswithcareproviders[911].Overall,theevidenceonthefeasibilityandadvantagesoftheuseofmobiletechnologyispositive,butmanystudiesaresmallandevidenceonitseffectivenessisnotveryrobust[1216].Despiteagrowingnumberofstudiesaboutmobilephoneapplicationsinlowincomecountries[17,18],weareawareofonlyonepublicationaboutafeasibilitystudyassessingtheuseofmobilephonesfordiabetessupportinsuchcontext.Thisstudyshowedthefeasibilityofmobilephoneuseforpeersupportandhealthmessaging.Theparticipantsreportedpositiveeffectsoftheintervention,forinstanceincreasedsocialsupportcoping,yettheirphysicalparametersdidnotimproveinthe6monthsfollowup[19].Theliteratureontheuseofmobiletechnologyforsupportingselfmanagementalsopointsouttheneedformoreprocessevaluationinordertobetterunderstandunderwhichconditionsandwhysuchinterventionswork.

    Thisstudywilladdressthesegaps,byevaluatingtheeffectivenessofamobilephoneDSMSinterventionontopofanexistingDSMEstrategyinDRCongo,CambodiaandthePhilippines,usingarandomisedcontrolleddesignwithafollowupof24months.Theprojectaimstoevaluatenotonlytheeffectivenessoftheinterventionineachcountry,butalsotoassesstheprocessesandcontextualfactorsthatinfluencetheimplementationofmobilephonetechnologyforsupportingselfmanagementinordertounderstandhowitworks,forwhom,underwhichcircumstances.

    Methods

    ObjectivesTheprimaryaimofthisstudyistoevaluatetheeffectivenessofamobilephoneDSMSinterventioninadditiontoanexistingDSMEstrategyinthreecountries,DemocraticRepublicofCongo(DRC),CambodiaandthePhilippines,toimprovehealthoutcomes(HemoglobinA1C(HbA1C)level,bloodpressure,BodyMassIndex(BMI),waistcircumferenceanddiabeticfootproblems),accesstocare(failuretoattendrate,perceivedqualityofcareandhealthcareexpenditure)andenablement(knowledge,selfmanagementandfeelingofcoping)ofpeoplewithdiabetesparticipatinginadiabetesselfmanagementeducationprogramme.Thesecondaryaimistoidentifybarriersandfacilitatingfactors,includingadditionalcostviaanincrementalcosteffectivenessanalysis,fortheimplementationofmobilephonetechnologyforsupportingselfmanagementinlowtomiddleincomecountries.

    StudydesignThestudyconsistsofthreesubstudieswithasimilardesigninthreelowtomiddleincomecountries,whichwillbeindependentlyimplementedandanalysed.ThedesignisatwoarmRandomisedControlledTrial(RCT),inwhichatotalof480adultswithdiabetes(type2or1)participatinginanexistingDSMEprogrammeineachcountry,willberandomlyallocatedtoeitherselfmanagementeducationasprovidedbytheexistingprogramme(usualcare)ortoselfmanagementeducationplusamobilephoneselfmanagementsupportintervention.Participantsinbotharmscompleteassessmentsatbaseline,oneyearandtwoyearsafterinclusion.

    EthicalapprovalMedicalethicalapprovalforthisstudywasobtainedfromtheInstitutionalReviewBoardoftheInstituteofTropicalMedicineAntwerp(11245776),theMedicalEthicsCommitteeoftheUniversitairZiekenhuisAntwerpen(B300201111924),theNationalEthicsCommitteeforHealthResearchinCambodia(207NECHR),theUniversityofKinshasaintheDemocraticRepublicofCongo(ESP/CE/050/11)andtheVeteransMemorialMedicalCentreinthePhilippines(VMMC2011012).

    StudycontextandpopulationThetargetpopulationconsistsofpersonswithdiabeteswhoarepresentlyparticipatinginexistingDSMEprogrammesintheDRC,CambodiaandthePhilippines.TheoverallprevalenceofdiabetesinDRCisestimatedbetween3.2%,inCambodiaat2.9%andinthePhilippinesat10.0%(IDF[20,21]).TheseexistingDSMEprogrammeshavebeendevelopedinreactiontotheirsurroundinghealthsystemanditswidersocial,culturalandeconomiccontext[22,23].Tosomeextent,thethreeDSMEprogrammescouldbeexplainedasexemplaryfortheircontext.

    InDRC,thestudycontextisanestablishednetworkof60primarycarefirstlinecentresfordiabetescareinKinshasa,inwhichspecialisednurses,referredtoas

  • 4/17/2015 BMCPublicHealth|Fulltext|Theeffectivenessoftextmessagessupportfordiabetesselfmanagement:protocoloftheTEXT4DSMstudyinthedemocraticRepublicofCongo,CambodiaandthePhilippines

    http://www.biomedcentral.com/14712458/13/423 4/13

    Figure1.Context,studysitesandblockrandomisationoftheTEXTFORDSMstudy.

    educators,acttoimplementtheDSMEprogramme.Fivecentreshavebeenpurposivelyselectedtorecruitstudyparticipants.SimilartoothercountriesinSubSaharanAfrica,professionalcareforpeoplewithdiabetesisusuallyprovidedathealthservices[24,25].TheDSMEprogrammeinthePhilippinesisprovidedbyanumberofspeciallytrainedBarangayorcommunityhealthworkersand/ornursingaides/midwivesaseducatorsinQuezonCity(MetroManila),intheCityofBatac(IlocosNorteProvince)andinthemunicipalityofPagudpud(IlocosNorteProvince).HealthsystemsinAsiancountrieshavealongstandingtraditionofsuchcommunityhealthworkersinthedeliveryofprimarycare.TheDSMEprogrammeinCambodiaisfacilitatedthroughcommunitybasedpeereducatornetworks,whichbeganin2005asarelativelynewdevelopment.PeereducatorsareresponsiblefortheDSMEprogrammeforpatientswholiveintheirarea,supportedbyaheadquarterofficeinPhnomPenh.Ninepeereducatorshavebeenpurposivelyselectedfromoneurbannetworkand6ruralnetworksin2provinces(KampongSpeuprovince,Takeoprovince).

    BecauseofdifferencesintheexistingDSMEprogrammesineachcountry,thenumbersofdiabeticscaredforbyoneeducatoraredifferentinDRCongo,CambodiaandthePhilippines.Thepurposiveselectionofparticipatingcentresineachcountryisbaseduponcomparablepatientsize,qualityofDSMEprogramme,willingnessofDSMEprogrammestafftobepartofaresearchprojectandconveniencefactorssuchastraveldistance.Figure1showshowthedesignisimplementedineachcountry.

    SamplesizecalculationTheprimaryoutcomemeasureonwhichthesamplesizecalculationisbasedisthedifferenceintheproportionofdiabeticswithawellcontrolledHbA1C(definedasHbA1C

  • 4/17/2015 BMCPublicHealth|Fulltext|Theeffectivenessoftextmessagessupportfordiabetesselfmanagement:protocoloftheTEXT4DSMstudyinthedemocraticRepublicofCongo,CambodiaandthePhilippines

    http://www.biomedcentral.com/14712458/13/423 5/13

    theirexistingDSMEprogrammeuptothelevelofaminimumpackage.Thiscomprisesacoherentstoryexplainingdiabetesforpatientsandkeymessagesaboutninespecificdimensionsofdiseasemanagement:1)explanationofdiabetes2)healthyeating3)physicalactivity4)monitoring5)medications6)footcare7)tobaccoandalcoholcontrol8)patientheldrecordsand9)problemsolvingbyandempowermentofpatients[31,32].TheminimumpackagehasbeendefinedthroughaconsultationprocesswithpeoplefromtheexistingDSMEprojectsandwithdiabetologistsprovidingexpertadvice.Theminimumpackageislocallyvalidatedandfinetunedtothelocalcontextbyeachcountryteam,incollaborationwithlocalprojectstaff,healthcareprovidersandpatients.TherewillbeawrittencurriculumoftheDSMEprogrammeineachcountry.

    InterventionThecontentandprocessofDSMSisbasedupontheminimumDSMEpackageandonelementsofbehaviourtheory,aimingtoinfluencethemodifyingfactorsofbehaviour.DSMSmessagescan,forinstance,increaseknowledgeaboutcertainbehavioursandtheireffects,theycancreatenormativebeliefsandsocialpressureandtheycanprovideemotionalsupportandincreasetheperceptionofcontrolbypeoplewithdiabetes.MessagesforDSMSwillfollowtheninedimensionsofDSME,butwillbelocallydevelopedandvalidatedthroughconsultationswithDSMEstaffandpeoplewithdiabetes.Thelocalvalidationpertainstothelocalmeaningofhealthbehaviours(forinstancewhatisahealthydiet)butalsotolocallyrelevantmodifyingfactorsofbehaviour(constraintsfordoingphysicalexercise).Theparticipantsallocatedtotheinterventiongroupwillreceivearegularmobilephone.TheywillreceivestandardisedandindividualisedProjectInitiatedCommunication(ProjIC)throughShortMessagingServices(SMS),whichimpliesthemaximumlengthofmessagesbeing160characters.ThesoftwareFrontLineisusedtosendSMSinanconvenientway.Furthermore,peopleareencouragedtousethephonetocontactotherpeopleincludingfellowpatients,educatorsandproviderstoaskforadviceorprovideinformationwhenneeded,forinstancewhentheycannotcometoanappointment.Dependingonthearrangementswiththenationaltelephoneproviders,participantswillbeprovidedwithabudgetforcallsandmessages.ThisistermedPatientInitiatedCommunication(PatIC).

    Tocontrolforthepotentialeffectofprovidingparticipantswitharegularmobilephone,theparticipantsallocatedtotheusualcaregroupwillalsoreceiveamobilephonebutwillnotreceiveProjIC.TheywillhowevercontinuetoreceiveassistancefromtheireducatorsaccordingtotheDSMEprogramme.

    TheeducatorsarenotinvolvedintheinitiationofDSMSrelatedcommunication.However,alleducatorswillbeprovidedwitharegularmobilephonesothattheycanbereachedbypatients.Theywillreceiveamodestmonthlyallowancetocompensatethemfortheadditionalworkandcoststhattheywillhavebecauseoftheintervention:receivingmorecalls/SMSfrompatientstakingnecessaryactionupontheseandbeinginvolvedinthedatacollectionforphysicalexaminationandbloodsampling.TheywillcontinuetoprovideDSMEtotheirpatientsirrespectiveoftheirallocationtooneofthetrialarms.

    ThestudyprojectmanagerineachcountryisthecentralpersoninprovidingProjICtothepeopleintheDSME+DSMSgroup.He/shewillbeprovidedwithasmartphonewithinstructionsandtrainingonhowtouseit.He/shewillenterpatientrelateddataintoadatabasethatisdevelopedandmanagedatnationallevelandsendoutProjICtopatientsthatbelongtotheDSME+DSMSgroupinthedifferentparticipatingcentres/fieldsites.Hewillsupportandgivefeedbacktoeducatorswhennecessaryandcoordinateresearchdatacollectionatsitelevel.

    DatacollectionFromeachparticipant,wewillcollectdatalinkedtoeachoftheresearchquestionsandobjectives.ThevariablesarelistedinTable1includingtheinstrumentsusedandthewaystocollectthesedata.Thesevariableswillbecollectedforallparticipantsatbaseline,oneyearandtwoyearsafterinclusionbytrainedresearchstaffwhowillinterviewparticipantsguidedbywrittenquestionnaires,andwhowillperformphysicalexaminationandcollectbloodsamples.

    Table1.Listofvariables,measuringinstrumentsanddatasources

    Thepatientquestionnaire(Additionalfile1)includesseveralscalesthatmeasuredimensionsofchroniccare:theneeds&servicesscale,attitudescaleandcontrolscalewhichareallsubscalesfromtheDiabetesCareProfile(DCP)[34]thepatientenablementscore[35]andthePatientAssessmentofChronicIllnessCare(PACICScore)[39].Thesescaleshavebeenvalidatedinheterogeneouspopulationsinclinicalandcommunitysettingsinwesterncountries[34,33].Thepatientenablementscorehasbeenvalidatedinalowincomecountry[40].Thequestionnairewasdevelopedforastudyinvolvingpersonswithdiabetesinthe

  • 4/17/2015 BMCPublicHealth|Fulltext|Theeffectivenessoftextmessagessupportfordiabetesselfmanagement:protocoloftheTEXT4DSMstudyinthedemocraticRepublicofCongo,CambodiaandthePhilippines

    http://www.biomedcentral.com/14712458/13/423 6/13

    Philippines.Resultsofthatstudyareyettobepublished.Thequestionnaireswillbetranslatedintolocallanguagesandpretestedinallcountries.Wewillalsocollectthefollowingpersonalanddiabetes(care)relatedvariables:age,sex,education,diabeteshistory(yearofdiagnosis,hospitaladmissions,treatment,hypertension)andphysicalaccesstocare(distancetocareproviders).Fortheprocessanalysis,wewillassessthenumberofSMSsenttoeachparticipantintheinterventiongroupandthenumberofphonecalls/SMSthatparticipantsofbothgroupsmadetotheeducator.

    Additionalfile1.Webannex1.PatientQuestionnaire.Format:DOCSize:443KBDownloadfileThisfilecanbeviewedwith:MicrosoftWordViewer

    Foreachcountry,wecollectanumberofcontextualcharacteristicsfromprimaryandsecondarysources.Theseare:prevalenceofdiabetes,mobilephonepenetration,literacyrate,detailsabouttheexistingDSMEprogramme(numberofpatientspereducator,componentsofDSMEstrategies,frequencyofcontactbetweenpatientsandeducator,etc.),presenceofpatientorganisationsandknowledgeandprofessionalhabitsofdiabetescareproviders(throughselfadministeredquestionnairesenttodiabetescareprovidersintheenvironment).

    DatawillbeelectronicallyenteredandcleanedthroughEpiInfo,usingadoubleentryprocedure.

    DataanalysesAnalysesofquantitativedataincludingassessmentofdifferencesinchangesinprimaryandsecondaryoutcomesbetweentheinterventionandusualcaregroupwillbedonemakinguseofStataversion11.Aprobabilityof

  • 4/17/2015 BMCPublicHealth|Fulltext|Theeffectivenessoftextmessagessupportfordiabetesselfmanagement:protocoloftheTEXT4DSMstudyinthedemocraticRepublicofCongo,CambodiaandthePhilippines

    http://www.biomedcentral.com/14712458/13/423 7/13

    MulticountryanalysisAftertheanalysisoftheeffectivenessoftheinterventionineachcountry,wewillperformamulticountryanalysis.Wewillanalyseifanystatisticallysignificantdifferencesintheprimaryandsecondaryendpointscanbedetectedbetweenthethreecountries.Wewillusearealisticapproachtolookforfactorsexplaininganyidentifieddifferencesbetweencountries,explaininghowtheactualinterventionledtotheobservedresultsandwhytheresultsdiffer(ornot)betweencountries[4143].Projectdocuments,projectreportsfromthefieldsitesandobservationreportswillbecollected.Indepthinterviewswillbecarriedoutwithprojectmanagersanddiabeteseducatorsandfocusgroupdiscussionswithpatientsfrombothgroupswillbecarriedout.Triangulationofdatawillbedonebycomparingtheresultsfromthesesources.TheinterviewrecordingswillbetranscribedverbatimandenteredinNVivo.Qualitativedataanalysiswillbecarriedoutusingtheprogrammetheoryastheanalyticalframework[44,45].

    CosteffectivenessanalysisInaddition,wewillconductanincrementalcosteffectivenessanalysis(CEA)comparingtheDSMSstrategyinadditiontotheexistingDSMEstrategywiththeDSMEstrategyonly.Theevaluationwilltakethesocietalviewpointtakingintoaccountbothpatientandprogrammecosts.Costsincurredbypatientsconsistofdirectmedical(e.g.costforconsultation,medicationandthecostforurgentcareandhospitalisation),directnonmedical(costforusingmobilephoneforPatIC,travelcost,foodcost,costrelatedtoexercise)andindirectcosts.Indirectcostsincludethevalueoftimespentbyparticipantsvisitingeducatorsandotherhealthcareprovidersandthelossofproductivityduetoillness.Programmecostsincludethecostfordevelopmentandmanagementoftheinterventionandthecostfortelecommunication.Informationaboutpatientdirectandindirectcostswillbecollectedbyatrainedfieldresearcherwithapatientquestionnaire(seesectionondatacollection).ThevalueoftimelosseswillbeestimatedfromsecondarysourcestakingtheGDPofthethreecountriesintoaccount.Theinformationonprogrammecostswillbecollectedprospectivelybykeepingadetailedaccountofallexpendituresattheprogrammelevel.ProgrammeeffectivenesswillbeexpressedintermsofthepercentageincreaseofpeoplewithdiabeteswithacontrolledHbA1Clevel[46,47].

    Discussion

    ThecentralhypothesisthatwillbetestedinthisstudyisthatamobilephoneDSMSinterventionontopofanexistingDSMEprogrammewillimproveclinicaloutcomesforpeoplewithdiabetes,measuredbytheirHbA1Clevel.Thewiderangeofsecondaryvariableswillyieldinformationonintermediaryoutcomesandonotheroutcomeswhicharealsoveryrelevantfortheorganisationofsupport.

    Althoughtheinterventionitselfisrelativelysimple,itseffectsarerealisedthroughcomplexprocesses,likethebehaviour(change)ofpeoplewithdiabetes.Theeffectoftheinterventionwillpartlydependonfactorsrelatedtotheprocessitself(forinstance,thelevelofinteractionandpersonalisationofmessages),butalsoontheprofileofpeoplewithdiabetes(forinstancetheirattitudetowardstheirdiabetesandtheirfamiliaritywithmobilephones)andonthecontext[48,49].

    Themulticountryanalysiswillaimtounderstandanydifferencesintheeffectsoftheinterventionandtheroleofthecontext,forinstancethedesignoftheexistingDSMEprogramme,knowledgeandprofessionalhabitsofdiabetescareproviders.

    Themajorlimitationofourdesignwithindividualrandomisationatthelevelofthepatientisthatwithineachparticipatingcentre,therewillbepatientsintheDSMEonlygroupandintheDSME+DSMSgroup.PatientscanbeincontactwitheachotherandthismightcausesomecontaminationbetweenDSMEonlyandDSME+DSMSpatients,resultinginasubestimationofeffect.TheindividualtargetingofthemessagesandthecentralmanagementoftheDSMSinterventionwithoutinterferenceoftheeducatorsshouldminimisethiscontamination.Anothermethodologicalweaknessisthelackoflocalvalidationofthescaleswithinthequestionnaire,whichfellbeyondthescopeofourstudy.Pretestingandlocalfinetuningwillpartlyaddressthisissue.Sincewewillusethesamequestionnaire3timesalongthecourseofthestudy,weexpectthatfamiliaritywiththeinstrumentswillgrowovertime.

    Thegrowingnumbersofpatientswithchroniclifelongconditions,suchasdiabetesandhypertension,putsanimmenseburdenonhealthsystemsandpopulations[50].Scarcityofresourcesandthelackofqualityandcontinuityofhealthcareresulttohighexpenditureandverypoorhealthoutcomes.Theinterventiontestedaddressestheproblemthatthegreaterpartofdiabetesmanagementtakesplacewithoutexternalsupportandthatmanychallenges,unforeseenproblemsand

  • 4/17/2015 BMCPublicHealth|Fulltext|Theeffectivenessoftextmessagessupportfordiabetesselfmanagement:protocoloftheTEXT4DSMstudyinthedemocraticRepublicofCongo,CambodiaandthePhilippines

    http://www.biomedcentral.com/14712458/13/423 8/13

    1. FunnellM:Peerbasedbehaviouralstrategiestoimprovechronicdiseaseselfmanagementandclinicaloutcomes:evidence,logistics,evaluationconsiderationsandneedsforfutureresearch.Familypractice,27Suppl2010,1(June2009):i17i22.PublisherFullText

    2. ShigakiC,KruseR,MehrD,SheldonK,BinG,MooreC,LemasterJ:Motivationanddiabetesselfmanagement.

    questionsmostofthetimeoccurattheinbetweenmomentsofthescheduledcontactswiththesupportsystem,likehealthcareprovidersandeducators.Theprojectexploitstheavailabilityofwidelyaccessibleequipmentandcommunicationtechnologytonarrowthegapbetweenthesupportsystemandpeoplewithdiabetes.Inthisway,itaddressestheneedofpeoplewithdiabetestocombinetheirlifelongconditionwiththeirotherneedsandrolesinlifeandtocontributetotheirempowerment[51,52].ItwillbeinterestingtoevaluatetheimpactofthiscomplementaryDSMSstrategyontheworkloadoftheeducatorsandhealthprovides,animportantissueforfurtherscalingupingeneralservices(WHO[53]).Thestudyaddressesgapsinknowledgeandexperienceonutilizationofmobilephonetechnologytosupportpeoplewithdiabetesindevelopingcountries.Resultswillprovideinformationtodecisionmakersregardingconditionsofimplementationindevelopingcountriesandpossibleexpectedresults.

    Abbreviations

    DSMS:DiabetesselfmanagementsupportDSME:Diabetesselfmanagementeducation

    Competinginterests

    KristienVanAckerhasafunctionintheDiabetesFootProgrammeofIDF.

    Noneoftheauthorshasanyfinancialcompetinginterest.

    Authorscontributions

    JVOiscoordinatinginvestigatorofthestudyanddraftedthefirstversionofthistext.JVO,GMK,MVP,JCK,HH,CD,BV,GKhavebeenallinvolvedinthedesignoftheproject,thewritingoftheprotocolanditsimplementation.GMKdesignedthepatientquestionnaire.FSandKVAhaveprovidedspecialistadviceaboutdiabetesandmethodology.Allauthorshavecontributedtothemanuscriptbyprovidingcontentrelatedfeedbackandimprovementsondraftversions.Allauthorsreadandapprovedthefinalmanuscript.

    Acknowledgements

    ThisprojectissupportedbyaBRIDGESGrantfromtheInternatiDiabetesFederation.BRIDGES,anInternationalDiabetesFederationproject,issupportedbyaneducationalgrantfromLillyDiabetes.

    WearegratefulforthesupportofLimbanazoKapinduladuringthepreparationofthesoftwarefortheintervention.WethankWimVanDamme,BartCriel,ChristianaNoestlingerfortheirsupporttotheconceptualdevelopmentofthestudy.WethankDominiqueDubourg,VeerleVanLerbergheandJorisMentenfortheirsupporttothedataanalysisplanofthisprotocolandpaper.

    References

  • 4/17/2015 BMCPublicHealth|Fulltext|Theeffectivenessoftextmessagessupportfordiabetesselfmanagement:protocoloftheTEXT4DSMstudyinthedemocraticRepublicofCongo,CambodiaandthePhilippines

    http://www.biomedcentral.com/14712458/13/423 9/13

    ChronicIlln2010,6(17459206(Electronic)):202214.PubMedAbstract|PublisherFullText

    3. vanOlmenJ,KuG,BermejoR,KegelsG,HermannK,VanDammeW:TheGrowingCaseloadofChronicLifeLongConditionsCallsforaMovetowardsFullSelfManagementinLowIncomeCountries.GlobHeal2011,7(1):38.BioMedCentralFullText

    4. ColemanK,AustinBT,BrachC,WagnerEH:EvidenceontheChronicCareModelinthenewmillennium.HealthAff2009,28(1):7585.PublisherFullText

    5. FunnellM,NwankwoR,GillardM,AndersonR,TangT:Implementinganempowermentbaseddiabetesselfmanagementeducationprogram.DiabetesEduc2005,31(1):53.556,61PubMedAbstract|PublisherFullText

    6. GaryTL,GenkingerJM,GuallarE,PeyrotM,BrancatiFL:Metaanalysisofrandomizededucationalandbehavioralinterventionsintype2diabetes.DiabetesEduc2003,29(3):488501.PubMedAbstract|PublisherFullText

    7. GlazierRH,BajcarJ,KennieNR,WillsonK:Asystematicreviewofinterventionstoimprovediabetescareinsociallydisadvantagedpopulations.DiabetesCare2006,29(7):16751688.PubMedAbstract|PublisherFullText

    8. LorigK,SobelD,StewartA,BrownBJr,BanduraA,RitterP,GonzalezV:Evidencesuggestingthatachronicdiseaseselfmanagementprogramcanimprovehealthstatuswhilereducinghospitalization:arandomizedtrial.MedicalCare1999,37(00257079(Print):514.PubMedAbstract|PublisherFullText

    9. KrishnaS,BorenSA,BalasEA:Healthcareviacellphones:asystematicreview.TelemedicineandeHealth2009,15(3):231240.Retrievedfromhttp://www.liebertonline.com/doi/abs/10.1089/tmj.2008.0099 webcitePubMedAbstract|PublisherFullText

    10. LesterRT,RitvoP,MillsEJ,KaririA,KaranjaS,ChungMH,JackW:EffectsofamobilephoneshortmessageserviceonantiretroviraltreatmentadherenceinKenya(WelTelKenya1):arandomisedtrial.Lancet2010,376(9755):18381845.PubMedAbstract|PublisherFullText

    11. TriefP,SandbergJ,IzquierdoR,MorinP,SheaS,BrittainR,FeldhousenE:Diabetesmanagementassistedbytelemedicine:patientperspectives.TelemedicineandeHealth2008,14(15563669(Electronic)):647655.PubMedAbstract|PublisherFullText

    12. ColeLewisH,KershawT:Textmessagingasatoolforbehaviorchangeindiseasepreventionandmanagement.EpidemiolRev2010,32(1):5669.PubMedAbstract|PublisherFullText|PubMedCentralFullText

    13. HoltzB,LaucknerC:Diabetesmanagementviamobilephones:asystematicreview.Telemedicinejournalandehealth:theofficialjournaloftheAmericanTelemedicineAssociation2012,18(3):175184.PublisherFullText

    14. SheaS,WeinstockR,TeresiJ,PalmasW,StarrenJ,CiminoJ,LaiA,10675027(Print):Arandomizedtrialcomparingtelemedicinecasemanagementwithusualcareinolder,ethnicallydiverse,medicallyunderservedpatientswithdiabetesmellitus:5yearresultsoftheIDEATelstudy.JAmMedInformAssoc2009,16:446456.PubMedAbstract|PublisherFullText|PubMedCentralFullText

  • 4/17/2015 BMCPublicHealth|Fulltext|Theeffectivenessoftextmessagessupportfordiabetesselfmanagement:protocoloftheTEXT4DSMstudyinthedemocraticRepublicofCongo,CambodiaandthePhilippines

    http://www.biomedcentral.com/14712458/13/423 10/13

    15. TomlinsonM,RotheramBorusMJ,SwartzL,TsaiAC:ScalingUpmHealth:WhereIstheEvidence?PLoSMed2007,10(2):e1001382.

    16. FreeC,PhillipsG,GalliL,WatsonL,FelixL,EdwardsP,PatelV,HainesV:TheEffectivenessofMobileHealthTechnologyBasedHealthBehaviourChangeorDiseaseManagementInterventionsforHealthCareConsumers:ASystematicReview.PLoSMed2013,10(1):e1001362.PubMedAbstract|PublisherFullText|PubMedCentralFullText

    17. KahnBJG,YangJS,KahnJS:MobileHealthNeedsAndOpportunitiesInDevelopingCountries.HealthAff2010,2(2):254260.PublisherFullText

    18. MahmudN,RodriguezJ,NesbitJ:Atextmessagebasedinterventiontobridgethehealthcarecommunicationgapintheruraldevelopingworld.Technologyandhealthcare:officialjournaloftheEuropeanSocietyforEngineeringandMedicine2010,18(2):137144.PublisherFullText

    19. RotheramBorusMJ,TomlinsonM,GwegweM,ComuladaWS,KaufmanN,KeimM:Diabetesbuddies:peersupportthroughamobilephonebuddysystem.DiabetesEduc2012,38(3):357365.PubMedAbstract|PublisherFullText

    20. InternationalDiabetesFederation:DiabetesAtlas.RetrievedFebruary6,2013.2011.http://www.idf.org/diabetesatlas/ webcite

    21. OumS,PrakP,KhuonE,MeyV,AimS,BounchanY,CinS:PrevalenceofNonCommunicableDiseaseRiskFactorsinCambodia.StepsSurveyCountryReport.PnomPenh:UniversityofHealthSciences&MinistryofHealth2010.

    22. FisherEB,EarpJA,MamanS,ZolotorA:Crossculturalandinternationaladaptationofpeersupportfordiabetesmanagement.FamPract2010,27(Suppl1):i6i16.PubMedAbstract|PublisherFullText

    23. VanDammeW,KegelsG:Healthsystemstrengtheningandscalingupantiretroviraltherapy:theneedforcontextspecificdeliverymodels:commentonSchneideretal.ReprodHealthMatters2006,14(27):2426.PubMedAbstract|PublisherFullText

    24. DeGraftAikinsA,BoyntonP,AtangaLL:DevelopingeffectivechronicdiseaseinterventionsinAfrica:insightsfromGhanaandCameroon.GlobHeal2010,6:6.BioMedCentralFullText

    25. WatkinsP,AlemuS:DeliveryofdiabetescareinruralEthiopia:anexperiencefromGondar.EthiopMedJ2003,41(00141755(Print)):917.PubMedAbstract

    26. Diabetes.Co.UKTheGlobalDiabetesCommunity:HbA1cUnitsConverterDCCTtoIFCC.UK:Diabetes.Co2012.RetrievedNovember26,2012,fromhttp://www.diabetes.co.uk/hba1cunitsconverter.html webcite

    27. ShojaniaKG,RanjiSR,McDonaldKM,GrimshawJ,SundaramV,RushakoffRJ,OwensDK:Effectsofqualityimprovementstrategiesfortype2diabetesonglycemiccontrol:ametaregressionanalysis.JAMA2006,296(4):427440.PubMedAbstract|PublisherFullText

  • 4/17/2015 BMCPublicHealth|Fulltext|Theeffectivenessoftextmessagessupportfordiabetesselfmanagement:protocoloftheTEXT4DSMstudyinthedemocraticRepublicofCongo,CambodiaandthePhilippines

    http://www.biomedcentral.com/14712458/13/423 11/13

    28. MbanyaJCN,MotalaAA,SobngwiE,AssahFK,EnoruST:DiabetesinsubSaharanAfrica.Lancet2010,375(9733):22542266.PubMedAbstract|PublisherFullText

    29. RamachandranA,MaRCW,SnehalathaC:DiabetesinAsia.Lancet2010,375(9712):408418.PubMedAbstract|PublisherFullText

    30. HeX,WharradHJ:DiabetesknowledgeandglycemiccontrolamongChinesepeoplewithtype2diabetes.IntNursRev2007,54(3):280287.PubMedAbstract|PublisherFullText

    31. AmericanAssociationofDiabetesEducators:SevenSelfCareBehaviours.AADE.RetrievedSeptember21,2012,fromhttp://www.diabeteseducator.org/ProfessionalResources/AADE7 webcite

    32. FunnellM,BrownT,ChildsB,HaasL:Nationalstandardsfordiabetesselfmanagementeducation.Diabetes2009.,33PublisherFullText

    33. GlasgowR,WagnerE,SchaeferJ,MahoneyL,ReidR,GreeneS:DevelopmentandvalidationofthePatientAssessmentofChronicIllnessCare(PACIC).Medicalcare2005,43(5):43644.Retrievedfromhttp://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/15838407 webcitePubMedAbstract|PublisherFullText

    34. FitzgeraldJT,DavisWK,ConnellC,HessGE,FunnellM,HissRG:DevelopmentandValidationoftheDiabetesCareProfile.EvalHealthProf1996,19(2):208230.PubMedAbstract|PublisherFullText

    35. HowieJGR,HeaneyD,MaxwellM:Quality,corevaluesandthegeneralpracticeconsultation:issuesofdefinition,measurementanddelivery.FamPract2004,21(4):458468.PubMedAbstract|PublisherFullText

    36. FitzgeraldJT,AndersonRM,GruppenLD,DavisWK,AmanLC,JacoberSJ,GrunbergerG:ThereliabilityoftheDiabetesCareProfileforAfricanAmericans.EvalHealthProf1998,21(1):5265.Retrievedfromhttp://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/10183339 webcitePubMedAbstract|PublisherFullText

    37. GarciaAA,VillagomezET,BrownSA,KouzekananiK,HanisCL:TheStarrCountydiabeteseducationstudy.DiabetesCare2001,24(1):16.Retrievedfromhttp://care.diabetesjournals.org/content/24/1/16.short webcitePubMedAbstract|PublisherFullText

    38. FitzgeraldJT,FunnellMM,HessGE,BarrPA,AndersonRM,HissRG,DavisWK:Thereliabilityandvalidityofabriefdiabetesknowledgetest.DiabetesCare1998,21(5):70610.Retrievedfromhttp://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/9589228 webcitePubMedAbstract|PublisherFullText

  • 4/17/2015 BMCPublicHealth|Fulltext|Theeffectivenessoftextmessagessupportfordiabetesselfmanagement:protocoloftheTEXT4DSMstudyinthedemocraticRepublicofCongo,CambodiaandthePhilippines

    http://www.biomedcentral.com/14712458/13/423 12/13

    39. GlasgowRE,WhitesidesH,NelsonCC,KingDK:UseofthePatientAssessmentofChronicIllnessCare(PACIC)withdiabeticpatients.DiabetesCare2005,28(11):2655.Retrievedfromhttp://care.diabetesjournals.org/content/28/11/2655.short webcitePubMedAbstract|PublisherFullText

    40. VanEygenL,VanLerbergheV,BlaiseP,WoelkG,CrielB:ThechallengeofmeasuringqualityofcareathealthcentrelevelinAfrica:TheexampleofTsholotshohealthdistrictinMatabeleland.IntJHealthPlannManage2007,22(1):6389.PubMedAbstract|PublisherFullText

    41. MarchalB,DedzoM,KegelsG:ArealistevaluationofthemanagementofawellperformingregionalhospitalinGhana.BMCHealthServRes2010,10:24.PubMedAbstract|BioMedCentralFullText|PubMedCentralFullText

    42. PawsonR,TilleyN:RealistEvaluation.Changes.London:SAGEPublications1997.

    43. RiddeV,RobertE,GuichardA,BlaiseP,vanOlmenJ:LapprocheRealistlpreuvedureldelvaluationdesprogrammes.Revue2012,26(3):114.

    44. ByngR:UsingRealisticEvaluationtoEvaluateaPracticelevelInterventiontoImprovePrimaryHealthcareforPatientswithLongtermMentalIllness.Evaluation2005,11(1):6993.PublisherFullText

    45. YinRK:EnhancingtheQualityofCaseStudiesinHealthServicesResearch.HealthServRes1999,34(5):12091224.PubMedAbstract|PubMedCentralFullText

    46. CreeseA,ParkerD:Costanalysisinprimaryhealthcare.Geneva:WorldHealthOrganisation1994.

    47. DrummondM,OBrienB,StoddartG,TorranceG:MethodsfortheEconomicEvaluationofHealthCareProgrammes.Oxford:OxfordUniversityPress1997.

    48. FjeldsoeBS,MarshallAL,MillerYD:Behaviorchangeinterventionsdeliveredbymobiletelephoneshortmessageservice.AmJPrevMed2009,36(2):16573.PubMedAbstract|PublisherFullText

    49. RyanP,LauverD:Theefficacyoftailoredinterventions.JNursScholarsh2002,34(15276546(Print)):331337.Retrievedfromhttp://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/j.15475069.2002.00331.x/full webcitePubMedAbstract|PublisherFullText

    50. AbegundeDO,MathersCD,AdamT,OrtegonM,StrongK:Theburdenandcostsofchronicdiseasesinlowincomeandmiddleincomecountries.Lancet2007,370(9603):192938.PubMedAbstract|PublisherFullText

    51. IrP,MenC,LucasH,MeessenB,DecosterK,BloomG,VanDammeW:SelfreportedseriousillnessesinruralCambodia:acrosssectionalsurvey.PLoSOne2010,5(6):e10930.PubMedAbstract|PublisherFullText|PubMedCentralFullText

    52. vanOlmenJ,CrielB,DevadasanN,PariyoG,DeVosP,VanDammeW:PrimaryHealthCareinthe21stcentury:primarycareprovidersandpeoplesempowerment.TropMedIntHealth2010,00(00):15.PublisherFullText

  • 4/17/2015 BMCPublicHealth|Fulltext|Theeffectivenessoftextmessagessupportfordiabetesselfmanagement:protocoloftheTEXT4DSMstudyinthedemocraticRepublicofCongo,CambodiaandthePhilippines

    http://www.biomedcentral.com/14712458/13/423 13/13

    53. WorldHealthOrganization:PreventionandControlofNoncommunicableDiseases:Guidelinesforprimaryhealthcareinlowresourcesettings.Geneva2012.

    SignuptoreceivenewarticlealertsfromBMCPublicHealth Signup

    Prepublicationhistory

    Theprepublicationhistoryforthispapercanbeaccessedhere:

    http://www.biomedcentral.com/14712458/13/423/prepub