development of novel non-immunoglobulin centyrin™-based ...p6 p5 p3 p1 p8 scfv1 scfv2 mock (a) (b)...

1
Development of Novel Non-Immunoglobulin Centyrin™-Based CARs Burton E. Barnett, Jenessa B. Smith, Xinxin Wang, David Hermanson, Yening Tan, Eric M. Ostertag, Devon J. Shedlock ABSTRACT INTRODUCTION CONCLUSIONS Chimeric-antigen receptor (CAR)-T cell immunotherapy is a promising type of cancer therapy and substantial progress has been made in developing adoptive T cell approaches for B cell malignancies. B cell maturation antigen (BCMA) is an attractive target for patients with multiple myeloma (MM) due to its high level of expression on tumor cells and restricted expression on normal tissues. In addition, BCMA is essential for cell growth and survival, and is therefore likely not susceptible to antigen escape. Traditionally, the antigen-binding domain of a CAR is a single chain variable fragment (scFv) comprised of heavy chain (HC) and light chain (LC) variable fragments joined by a flexible linker that has been derived from a non- human monoclonal Ab (mAb). However, there are a number of disadvantages to scFv-based CARs including the limited availability of scFv, their potential to elicit antibody responses, and their association with tonic signaling due, in part, to inherent instability and flexibility of the structure and the potential for both HC/LC domain swapping and multimer formation through framework region interactions. Thus, replacement with alternative binding technologies may improve CAR-T efficacy in the clinic. Centyrins™ are alternative scaffold molecules that bind protein targets with high affinity and specificity, similar to scFv molecules. However, unlike scFv, Centyrins™ are smaller, derived from human consensus tenascin FN3 domains and are predicted to have decreased immunogenicity. Additionally, a monomeric Centyrin™ in CAR format (“CARTyrin” molecule) is less likely to engage in domain swapping or interact with other Centyrins™ at the cell surface, thereby limiting the potential for the tonic signaling that drives the functional exhaustion of CAR T cells. Finally, as Centyrins™ are 1/3 the size of scFv molecules, they provide flexibility for the creation of multi-specificity CARs. Centyrins™ can be isolated against virtually any antigen through ex vivo panning of an extensive Centyrin™ library, yielding many distinct binders with a range of affinities and target epitopes. We tested a panel of 12 anti-BCMA (11 monomeric and one multimeric “P9”) Centyrins™ by linking them to a standard second-generation CAR scaffold. High quality mRNA of each CARTyrin construct was produced in order to rapidly screen CARTyrin cell surface expression and functionality in human pan T cells against BCMA + targets. We also constructed scFv-based CARs against CD19 and BCMA for comparison. CD3/CD28-stimulated T cells were electroporated (EP) with mRNA encoding each of the 12 anti-BCMA CARTyrins and, the following day, analyzed for surface expression of CARTyrin and their ability to degranulate against BCMA + tumor cells. All 12 CARTyrins were detected on the cell surface and the 11 monomeric CARTyrins imparted BCMA-specific killing capacity to T cells. Notably, in these assays, CARTyrins were functionally comparable to scFv-based CARs against BCMA or to CD19-specific scFv-based CARs in a parallel assay with CD19 + tumor cells. The 11 functional anti-BCMA CARTyrins were further characterized for functional avidity by determining their activity against a panel of target cells with titrated levels of surface BCMA expression. To create this panel, various amounts of high quality BCMA mRNA were electroporated into BCMA - K562 tumor cells. After 4 hours of co- culture with the panel of BCMA expressing cells, CARTyrin + T cell activity was measured as a function of CD107a expression. We observed a range of activities by each CARTyrin and show that this assay can be utilized to determine the minimal effective dose of BCMA needed to induce killing by CARTyrin + cells. Furthermore, we establish that certain BCMA-specific CARTyrins are responsive to target cells with extremely low levels of surface BCMA expression. The data shown in this poster are complemented by functional studies in vitro and in vivo that may be found in the posters listed below. These results confirm that Centyrins™ are viable replacements for scFv in the construction of functional CARs and establish their potential utility in generating novel BCMA-specific CAR molecules, as well as other novel targetable tumor antigens. Poseida Therapeutics, Inc. 4242 Campus Point Court, Suite 700 San Diego, CA, 92121 (CARTyrins) Targeting Human BCMA Signal Peptide Transmembrane Hinge Costimulatory Signaling Domain Centyrin™ Figure 1: Surface CARTyrin Expression in RNA-electroporated human T cells Surface expression of CARTyrin using a biotinylated BCMA-Fc protein and fluorescent streptavidin 24 hours post electroporation in primary human T cells. T cells were previously stimulated with anti-CD3/CD28 mAb-coated beads, allowed to rest, and thawed O/N prior to electroporation with 10ug CARTyrin mRNA. a) CARTyrin expression (y-axis). CARTyrin+ frequency (b) and mean fluorescence intensity (c). BCMA-specific CAR molecules (“scFv 1” and “scFv 2”) were included as positive controls. All CARTyrins tested were expressed on the surface of primary human T cells All BCMA-specific CARTyrins (except F9 comprised of multimeric Centyrin™) exhibited specific effector function against BCMA+ tumor cells, demonstrating comparable functionality to BCMA scFv-based CARs BCMA-specific CARTyrins exhibit high functional avidity and a titratable dose response against BCMA antigen, demonstrating a range of potency down to picogram amounts of BCMA Testing RNA CARs is an effective screening platform for identification of lead CAR candidates The potency exhibited by Centyrin™-based CARTyrins combined with their advantages in size, immunogenicity, flexibility, and lack of tonic signaling suggest they may provide an excellent alternative to scFv based CARs Figure 3: Electroporation with lower levels of CARTyrin mRNA permit greater functional distinction between CARTyrin candidates (a) Surface expression of in T cells 24 hours post electroporation with either 10 ug or 5ug of CARTyrin mRNA. (b) Expression of CD107a (y-axis) and CD8 (x-axis) in live (7AAD-), CD3+ T cells 4 hours post co-culture with tumor cells at an effector to target ratio of 1:4. Each bar represents one CARTyrin molecules, in order of P5, P12, P8, P2, P11. Assays were performed 24hrs post electroporation. Figure 4: Comparative analyses of BCMA-specific CARTyrins against BCMA+ tumor cells (a) Surface expression of CARTyrin in T cells electroporated with 5ug of CARTyrin mRNA. (b) Frequency of CD107a+ in live, CD3+, CD8+ T cells 4 hours post co-culture with tumor cells at an effector to target ratio of 1:4. Assays were performed 24hrs post electroporation. Error bars represent 3 independent experiments. Centyrin™ is a registered trademark of Janssen Pharmaceuticals, Inc. Poseida has licensed certain rights to the Centyrin™ technology platform from Janssen Pharmaceuticals, Inc. for use in autologous T cell therapeutics (a) (b) K5 62 H92 9 U266 %CD107a+ K562 H929 U266 %CD107a+ (a) (b) Figure 2: T cells electroporated with BCMA CARTyrins demonstrate specific activity against BCMA+ tumor cells (a) Expression of CD107a (x-axis) in live (7AAD-), CD3+ T cells 4 hours post co-culture with tumor cells at an effector to target ratio of 1:4. Frequencies of CD107a+ cells is shown on the plots. (b) Bar graphs represent CD107a+ frequency of CD8+ T cells. Assays were performed 24 hours post electroporation with BCMA-specific CARTyrins. (c) BCMA expression via flow cytometry in the indicated tumor cells. A CD19-specific scFv CAR (“CD19”) was included as a positive control for its activity against Nalm6 cells. P7 P1 2 P9 P11 P1 0 P2 P 4 P6 P5 P3 P1 P8 BC M A sc Fv 1 BCMA scFv 2 CD19 s cFv P7 P12 P9 P 1 1 P10 P2 P4 P6 P5 P3 P1 P8 BCMA s c Fv 1 BCMA scFv 2 CD 1 9 s c Fv P7 P1 2 P9 P11 P1 0 P2 P4 P6 P5 P3 P1 P8 BC M A sc Fv 1 BCMA scFv 2 C D19 s cFv (a) (b) (c) P7 P12 P9 P1 1 P 10 P 2 P4 P6 P5 P 3 P 1 P8 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100 P7 P 12 P 9 P11 P10 P2 P4 P6 P 5 P3 P1 P8 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100 P 7 P 12 P 9 P11 P10 P 2 P 4 P 6 P 5 P3 P 1 P 8 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100 (a) (b) Figure 5: BCMA-specific CARTyrins function against picogram amounts of BCMA (a) Expression of CD107a (y-axis) in CD8+ T cells (pre-gated on live (7AAD-), CD3+) 4 hours post co-culture with K562 tumor cells electroporated with the indicated amount of BCMA mRNA (x-axis). Effector to target ratio of 1:4. (b) Expression of BCMA on BCMA-electroporated K562 cells. Mean fluorescence intensity (MFI) of BCMA expression is quantified on the y-axis. Assays were performed 24 hours post electroporation with BCMA-specific CARTyrins. L.O.D., limit of detection. 0.001 0.01 0.1 1 10 100 0 20 40 60 80 BCMA mRNA (ug) P7 P12 P9 P11 P10 P2 P4 P6 P5 P3 P1 P8 scFv1 scFv2 Mock (a) (b) I. PiggyBac™-Produced CAR-T Cells Exhibit Stem-Cell Memory Phenotype Session 703 Poster I II. A Novel Bcma-Specific, Centyrin™-Based CAR-T Product for the Treatment of Multiple Myeloma Session 653 Poster I CD107a P1 P2 P3 P4 P5 P6 P7 P8 P9 P10 P11 P12 scFv 1 scFv 2 CD19 Mock CD107a P1 P2 P3 P4 P5 P6 P7 P8 P9 P10 P11 P12 scFv 1 scFv 2 CD19 Mock CD107a P1 P2 P3 P4 P5 P6 P7 P8 P9 P10 P11 P12 scFv 1 scFv 2 CD19 Mock CARTyrin P5 P4 P3 P6 P12 P9 P1 P11 P8 P10 P7 P2 scFv 1 scFv 2 Mock P 1 2 P 11 P7 P2 P4 P8 P3 P6 P10 P 1 P5 P9 s c F v1 s c Fv 2 no mRNA P1 2 P11 P7 P 2 P4 P8 P 3 P6 P 10 P 1 P5 P9 s c F v 1 s c Fv2 n o m RNA %CAR+ METHODS & RESULTS scFv Centyrin™ Size: ~250 aa ~90 aa Components: Heavy & Light Chain Variable Regions, Flexible Linker Fibronectin type III domain Derived: Mouse/RodentAbs Human Stability: Not as stable as original IgG format Stable

Upload: others

Post on 09-May-2020

1 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Development of Novel Non-Immunoglobulin Centyrin™-Based ...P6 P5 P3 P1 P8 scFv1 scFv2 Mock (a) (b) I.PiggyBac™-Produced CAR-TCellsExhibitStem-CellMemoryPhenotype Session703PosterI

Development of Novel Non-Immunoglobulin Centyrin™-Based CARs

Burton E. Barnett, Jenessa B. Smith, Xinxin Wang, David Hermanson, Yening Tan, Eric M. Ostertag, Devon J. Shedlock

ABSTRACT

INTRODUCTION

CONCLUSIONS

Chimeric-antigen receptor (CAR)-T cell immunotherapy is a promising type of cancer therapyand substantial progress has been made in developing adoptive T cell approaches for B cellmalignancies. B cell maturation antigen (BCMA) is an attractive target for patients withmultiple myeloma (MM) due to its high level of expression on tumor cells and restrictedexpression on normal tissues. In addition, BCMA is essential for cell growth and survival, andis therefore likely not susceptible to antigen escape. Traditionally, the antigen-binding domainof a CAR is a single chain variable fragment (scFv) comprised of heavy chain (HC) and lightchain (LC) variable fragments joined by a flexible linker that has been derived from a non-human monoclonal Ab (mAb). However, there are a number of disadvantages to scFv-basedCARs including the limited availability of scFv, their potential to elicit antibody responses, andtheir association with tonic signaling due, in part, to inherent instability and flexibility of thestructure and the potential for both HC/LC domain swapping and multimer formation throughframework region interactions. Thus, replacement with alternative binding technologies mayimprove CAR-T efficacy in the clinic.

Centyrins™ are alternative scaffold molecules that bind protein targets with high affinity andspecificity, similar to scFv molecules. However, unlike scFv, Centyrins™ are smaller, derivedfrom human consensus tenascin FN3 domains and are predicted to have decreasedimmunogenicity. Additionally, a monomeric Centyrin™ in CAR format (“CARTyrin” molecule) isless likely to engage in domain swapping or interact with other Centyrins™ at the cell surface,thereby limiting the potential for the tonic signaling that drives the functional exhaustion ofCAR T cells. Finally, as Centyrins™ are 1/3 the size of scFv molecules, they provide flexibilityfor the creation of multi-specificity CARs. Centyrins™ can be isolated against virtually anyantigen through ex vivo panning of an extensive Centyrin™ library, yielding many distinctbinders with a range of affinities and target epitopes.

We tested a panel of 12 anti-BCMA (11 monomeric and one multimeric “P9”) Centyrins™ bylinking them to a standard second-generation CAR scaffold. High quality mRNA of eachCARTyrin construct was produced in order to rapidly screen CARTyrin cell surface expressionand functionality in human pan T cells against BCMA+ targets. We also constructed scFv-basedCARs against CD19 and BCMA for comparison. CD3/CD28-stimulated T cells wereelectroporated (EP) with mRNA encoding each of the 12 anti-BCMA CARTyrins and, thefollowing day, analyzed for surface expression of CARTyrin and their ability to degranulateagainst BCMA+ tumor cells.

All 12 CARTyrins were detected on the cell surface and the 11 monomeric CARTyrins impartedBCMA-specific killing capacity to T cells. Notably, in these assays, CARTyrins were functionallycomparable to scFv-based CARs against BCMA or to CD19-specific scFv-based CARs in aparallel assay with CD19+ tumor cells. The 11 functional anti-BCMA CARTyrins were furthercharacterized for functional avidity by determining their activity against a panel of target cellswith titrated levels of surface BCMA expression. To create this panel, various amounts of highquality BCMA mRNA were electroporated into BCMA- K562 tumor cells. After 4 hours of co-culture with the panel of BCMA expressing cells, CARTyrin+ T cell activity was measured as afunction of CD107a expression. We observed a range of activities by each CARTyrin and showthat this assay can be utilized to determine the minimal effective dose of BCMA needed toinduce killing by CARTyrin+ cells. Furthermore, we establish that certain BCMA-specificCARTyrins are responsive to target cells with extremely low levels of surface BCMAexpression. The data shown in this poster are complemented by functional studies in vitroand in vivo that may be found in the posters listed below. These results confirm thatCentyrins™ are viable replacements for scFv in the construction of functional CARs andestablish their potential utility in generating novel BCMA-specific CAR molecules, as well asother novel targetable tumor antigens.

Poseida Therapeutics, Inc. 4242 Campus Point Court, Suite 700 San Diego, CA, 92121

(CARTyrins) Targeting Human BCMA

Signal PeptideTransmembrane

Hinge Costimulatory Signaling DomainCentyrin™

Figure 1: Surface CARTyrin Expression in RNA-electroporated human T cellsSurface expression of CARTyrin using a biotinylated BCMA-Fc protein and fluorescent streptavidin24 hours post electroporation in primary human T cells. T cells were previously stimulated withanti-CD3/CD28 mAb-coated beads, allowed to rest, and thawed O/N prior to electroporation with10ug CARTyrin mRNA. a) CARTyrin expression (y-axis). CARTyrin+ frequency (b) and meanfluorescence intensity (c). BCMA-specific CAR molecules (“scFv 1” and “scFv 2”) were included aspositive controls.

• All CARTyrins tested were expressed on the surface of primary human T cells• All BCMA-specific CARTyrins (except F9 comprised of multimeric Centyrin™) exhibited specific

effector function against BCMA+ tumor cells, demonstrating comparable functionality toBCMA scFv-based CARs

• BCMA-specific CARTyrins exhibit high functional avidity and a titratable dose response againstBCMA antigen, demonstrating a range of potency down to picogram amounts of BCMA

• Testing RNA CARs is an effective screening platform for identification of lead CAR candidates• The potency exhibited by Centyrin™-based CARTyrins combined with their advantages in size,

immunogenicity, flexibility, and lack of tonic signaling suggest they may provide an excellentalternative to scFv based CARs

Figure 3: Electroporation with lower levels of CARTyrin mRNA permit greater functional distinctionbetween CARTyrin candidates(a) Surface expression of in T cells 24 hours post electroporation with either 10 ug or 5ug of CARTyrin mRNA. (b) Expression of CD107a(y-axis) and CD8 (x-axis) in live (7AAD-), CD3+ T cells 4 hours post co-culture with tumor cells at an effector to target ratio of 1:4. Each barrepresents one CARTyrin molecules, in order of P5, P12, P8, P2, P11. Assays were performed 24hrs post electroporation.

Figure 4: Comparative analyses of BCMA-specific CARTyrins against BCMA+ tumor cells(a) Surface expression of CARTyrin in T cells electroporated with 5ug of CARTyrin mRNA. (b) Frequency of CD107a+ inlive, CD3+, CD8+ T cells 4 hours post co-culture with tumor cells at an effector to target ratio of 1:4. Assays wereperformed 24hrs post electroporation. Error bars represent 3 independent experiments.

Centyrin™ is a registered trademark of Janssen Pharmaceuticals, Inc. Poseida has licensed certain rights to the

Centyrin™ technology platform from Janssen Pharmaceuticals, Inc. for use in autologous T cell therapeutics

(a) (b)

K562

H92

9

U26

6

%C

D10

7a

+

K56

2

H92

9

U26

6

%C

D1

07

a+

(a) (b)

Figure 2: T cells electroporated with BCMA CARTyrins demonstratespecific activity against BCMA+ tumor cells(a) Expression of CD107a (x-axis) in live (7AAD-), CD3+ T cells 4 hours post co-culturewith tumor cells at an effector to target ratio of 1:4. Frequencies of CD107a+ cells isshown on the plots. (b) Bar graphs represent CD107a+ frequency of CD8+ T cells.Assays were performed 24 hours post electroporation with BCMA-specific CARTyrins.(c) BCMA expression via flow cytometry in the indicated tumor cells. A CD19-specificscFv CAR (“CD19”) was included as a positive control for its activity against Nalm6 cells.

P7P12 P9

P11P10 P2 P4 P6 P5 P3 P1 P8

BCM

A scFv

1

BCM

A scF

v 2

CD19

scF

v

P7P12 P9

P11P10 P2 P4 P6 P5 P3 P1 P8

BCM

A s

cFv

1

BCM

A s

cFv 2

CD19

scF

v

P7P12 P9

P11P10 P2 P4 P6 P5 P3 P1 P8

BCM

A s

cFv 1

BCM

A s

cFv 2

CD19

scF

v

(a) (b)

(c)

P7P12 P9

P11P10 P2 P4 P6 P5 P3 P1 P8

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

90

100

P7P12 P9

P11 P10 P2 P4 P6 P5 P3 P1 P8

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

90

100

P7P12 P9

P11 P10 P2 P4 P6 P5 P3 P1 P8

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

90

100

(a)

(b)

Figure 5: BCMA-specific CARTyrins functionagainst picogram amounts of BCMA(a) Expression of CD107a (y-axis) in CD8+ T cells (pre-gated onlive (7AAD-), CD3+) 4 hours post co-culture with K562 tumorcells electroporated with the indicated amount of BCMA mRNA(x-axis). Effector to target ratio of 1:4. (b) Expression of BCMAon BCMA-electroporated K562 cells. Mean fluorescenceintensity (MFI) of BCMA expression is quantified on the y-axis.Assays were performed 24 hours post electroporation withBCMA-specific CARTyrins. L.O.D., limit of detection.

0.001 0.01 0.1 1 10 1000

20

40

60

80

BCMA mRNA (ug)

P7

P12

P9

P11

P10

P2

P4

P6

P5

P3

P1

P8

scFv1

scFv2

Mock

(a)

(b)

I. PiggyBac™-Produced CAR-T Cells Exhibit Stem-Cell Memory Phenotype Session 703 Poster III. A Novel Bcma-Specific, Centyrin™-Based CAR-T Product for the Treatment of MultipleMyeloma Session 653 Poster I

CD107a

P1 P2 P3 P4 P5 P6 P7 P8

P9 P10 P11 P12 scFv 1 scFv 2 CD19 Mock

CD107a

P1 P2 P3 P4 P5 P6 P7 P8

P9 P10 P11 P12 scFv 1 scFv 2 CD19 Mock

CD107a

P1 P2 P3 P4 P5 P6 P7 P8

P9 P10 P11 P12 scFv 1 scFv 2 CD19 Mock

CARTyrin

P5 P4 P3 P6 P12 P9 P1

P11P8 P10 P7 P2 scFv 1 scFv 2 Mock

P12

P11 P7 P2 P4 P8 P3 P6

P10 P1 P5 P9

scFv1

scFv2

no mRNA

P12P11 P7 P2 P4 P8 P3 P6

P10 P1 P5 P9

scFv1

scFv2

no mRNA

%C

AR

+

METHODS & RESULTS

scFv Centyrin™

Size: ~250 aa ~90 aa

Components: Heavy & Light ChainVariable Regions,

Flexible Linker

Fibronectin type III domain

Derived: Mouse/RodentAbs Human

Stability: Not as stable as original IgG format

Stable