development of a diabetes interview tool in spanish and english using a standardized...

1
Background Discussion Conclusion Students gained experience interviewing patients, understanding of diabetes mellitus type 2 assessment and sign/symptom prevalence. The findings of this study will be used to inform terminology development, refine the instrument for re-evaluation, and support future comparison of diabetes signs/symptoms internationally. Use of the Omaha System signs/symptoms items as a structured assessment interview data collection tool resulted in quantifiable data that are generated by equivalent standardized terms in Spanish and English. Further research is needed to create standardized care plans for problems identified in the assessment. Development of a Diabetes Interview Tool in Spanish and English Using a Standardized Nursing Terminology Karen A. Monsen, PhD, RN, FAANN 1,2 María de la Luz Bonilla Luis 3 , Ana María Pérez Garcés 3 Sebastiana del Rosario Gargantúa Aguila 3 , Elaine Darst, PhD, RN 1,2 , Kathleen E. Krichbaum, PhD, RN, FGSA, ANEF 1,2 1 University of Minnesota School of Nursing, Minneapolis, Minnesota, U.S.A 2 University of Minnesota Institute for Health Informatics, Minneapolis, Minnesota, U.S.A. 3 Benemerita Universidad Autonoma de Puebla, Facultad de Enfermeria, Puebla, Mexico 4 University of Minnesota Center for Spirituality and Healing, Minneapolis, Minnesota, U.S.A. Nursing scholars and administrators have long posited that data generated by computerized documentation in practice settings will be a useful tool for advancing knowledge of nursing intervention effectiveness. Standardized nursing classifications are nursing’s voice within the computerized electronic health record. Purpose Omaha System The Omaha System was selected for this international educational project in public health nursing and service learning because it exists in the public domain, is available in Spanish and English, and is a comprehensive, holistic assessment tool. The terms for signs/symptoms of Omaha System problems cane be used to structure data collection. The purpose of this study was to develop a diabetes interview data collection tool in Spanish and English for use by students from Canada, Mexico, and the United States participating in a public health nursing exchange program. Methods Public health nursing faculty with experience in diabetes assessment and standardized terminologies (KM and AMPG) selected Omaha System signs/symptoms related to diabetes to create an interview data collection tool in English and Spanish . The tool was reviewed by language and content experts, and was pilot tested by students and faculty for student interviews of diabetic patients in Canada, Mexico, and the United States. Results The Omaha System Partnership for Knowledge Discovery and Health Care Quality, Center for Nursing Informatics, University of Minnesota School of Nursing Acknowledgements HRSDC (Canada) - Human Resources and Skills Development PROMESAN (Mexico) - Program for Mobility in Higher Education FIPSE (USA) Fund for Improvement in Post Secondary Education UNIVERSITY OF MINNESOTA Elaine Darst, Karen Monsen, Kathie Krichbaum Alice F. Kuehn ST. LOUIS UNIVERSITY Cordie Reese Kris L'Ecuyer DALHOUSIE UNIVERSITY Barbara Downe-Wamboldt Andrea Chircop Debbie Sheppard-LeMoine Lucille Wittstock UNIVERSITY OF PRINCE EDWARD ISLAND Kim Robertson-Critchley Rosemary Herbert Donna Murnaghan BENEMÉRITA UNIVERSIDAD AUTÓNOMA DE PUEBLA MCE. María de la Luz Bonilla Luis MCE Ana María Pérez Garcés MCE Sebastiana del Rosario Gargantúa Aguila MCE María del Carmen Martínez Reyes Interview Quotes Students provided patient quotes from the interviews that validated the signs/symptoms selected on the interview data collection tool. For example: Believes harmful myths about treatment: “I am drinking this nutritional supplement to cure my diabetes” (sugar water solution) Conflicting spiritual beliefs: “I have prayed for a miracle so that I will not need treatment.” All selected signs/symptoms were present in the data from a preliminary sample of five patients from Mexico. An additional symptom was suggested by student interviews (“excessive thirst”). UNIVERSIDAD AUTÓNOMA DEL ESTADO DE MORELOS Orquídea Benitez Plascencia Alejandra Terrazas Meraz Abigail Fernandez Sanchez

Upload: buinhu

Post on 25-May-2018

214 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Background

Discussion

Conclusion

Students gained experience interviewing patients, understanding of diabetes mellitus type 2 assessment and sign/symptom prevalence. The findings of this study will be used to inform terminology development, refine the instrument for re-evaluation, and support future comparison of diabetes signs/symptoms internationally.

Use of the Omaha System signs/symptoms items as a structured assessment interview data collection tool resulted in quantifiable data that are generated by equivalent standardized terms in Spanish and English. Further research is needed to create standardized care plans for problems identified in the assessment.

Development of a Diabetes Interview Tool in Spanish and English

Using a Standardized Nursing Terminology Karen A. Monsen, PhD, RN, FAANN1,2 María de la Luz Bonilla Luis3, Ana María Pérez Garcés3 Sebastiana del Rosario Gargantúa Aguila3, Elaine Darst, PhD, RN1,2, Kathleen E. Krichbaum, PhD, RN, FGSA, ANEF 1,2

1University of Minnesota School of Nursing, Minneapolis, Minnesota, U.S.A 2University of Minnesota Institute for Health Informatics, Minneapolis, Minnesota, U.S.A. 3Benemerita Universidad Autonoma de Puebla, Facultad de Enfermeria, Puebla, Mexico 4University of Minnesota Center for Spirituality and Healing, Minneapolis, Minnesota, U.S.A.

Nursing scholars and administrators have long posited that data generated by computerized documentation in practice settings will be a useful tool for advancing knowledge of nursing intervention effectiveness. Standardized nursing classifications are nursing’s voice within the computerized electronic health record.

Purpose

Omaha System

The Omaha System was selected for this international educational project in public health nursing and service learning because it exists in the public domain, is available in Spanish and English, and is a comprehensive, holistic assessment tool. The terms for signs/symptoms of Omaha System problems cane be used to structure data collection.

The purpose of this study was to develop a diabetes interview data collection tool in Spanish and English for use by students from Canada, Mexico, and the United States participating in a public health nursing exchange program.

Methods

Public health nursing faculty with experience in diabetes assessment and standardized terminologies (KM and AMPG) selected Omaha System signs/symptoms related to diabetes to create an interview data collection tool in English and Spanish . The tool was reviewed by language and content experts, and was pilot tested by students and faculty for student interviews of diabetic patients in Canada, Mexico, and the United States.

Results

The Omaha System Partnership for Knowledge Discovery and Health Care Quality, Center for Nursing Informatics, University of Minnesota School of Nursing

Acknowledgements

HRSDC (Canada) - Human Resources and Skills Development

PROMESAN (Mexico) - Program for Mobility in Higher Education

FIPSE (USA) – Fund for Improvement in Post Secondary

Education UNIVERSITY OF MINNESOTA Elaine Darst, Karen Monsen, Kathie Krichbaum Alice F. Kuehn

ST. LOUIS UNIVERSITY Cordie Reese Kris L'Ecuyer

DALHOUSIE UNIVERSITY Barbara Downe-Wamboldt Andrea Chircop Debbie Sheppard-LeMoine Lucille Wittstock

UNIVERSITY OF PRINCE EDWARD ISLAND Kim Robertson-Critchley Rosemary Herbert Donna Murnaghan

BENEMÉRITA UNIVERSIDAD AUTÓNOMA DE PUEBLA MCE. María de la Luz Bonilla Luis MCE Ana María Pérez Garcés MCE Sebastiana del Rosario Gargantúa Aguila MCE María del Carmen Martínez Reyes

Interview Quotes

Students provided patient quotes from the interviews that validated the signs/symptoms selected on the interview data collection tool. For example:

• Believes harmful myths about treatment: “I am drinking this nutritional supplement to cure my diabetes” (sugar water solution)

• Conflicting spiritual beliefs: “I have prayed for a miracle so that I will not need treatment.”

All selected signs/symptoms were present in the data from a preliminary sample of five patients from Mexico. An additional symptom was suggested by student interviews (“excessive thirst”).

UNIVERSIDAD AUTÓNOMA DEL ESTADO DE MORELOS Orquídea Benitez Plascencia Alejandra Terrazas Meraz Abigail Fernandez Sanchez