devanāgari script” (देवनागरी लिपि) and the writing system of hindi...

28
1 भारत की भाषाएँ एवं देवनागरी लिपि ोफे सर महावीर सरन जैन म सन ् 1960 ईवी से रोमन लिपि की अिेा देवनागरी लिपि की मताओं एवं वैाननकता का िधर रहा ह । अंेजी के पववान की इस मायता का खडन करता रहा ह क हमै हदी सहहत समत भारतीय भाषाओं के लियंकन के लिए रोमन लिपि को वीकार कर िेना चाहहए। मने अतररारीय धराति िर पववान को उन कारण से अवगत कराया है जज नके कारण देवनागरी लिपि, रोमन लिपि की अिेा, हहदी सहत समत भारतीय भाषाओं को अधधक संगत और वैाननक ढंग से लिखने मै समथ है। उदाहरण के लिए, मने यरोि एवं अमेररका के पववान को इस तय से अवगत कराया क भारतीय भाषाओं मै युत होनेवािे महााण यंजन का उचारण इकाई ( unit) के ऱि मै होता है और इनको इकाई के ऱि मै लिखने के लिए रोमन लिपि मै वणथ ( Letters) नहीं ह। रोमन लिपि मै अिाण एवं महााण यंजन के लिए अिग अिग लिपि धचन नहीं ह। के वि हहदी मै ही नहीं अपितु तलमि को छोकर शेष सभी महविणथ भारतीय भाषाओं मै अिाण एवं महााण यंजन पवषम पवतरण ( Contrastive distribution) मै पवतररत ह अाथत इनका वनलमक ( Phonemic) महव है। इनको इकाई के ऱि मै लिखने की यवा देवनागरी मै है मगर यह यवा रोमन लिपि मै नहीं है। रोमन मइनको अिाण यंजन के बाद 'h ' लिपि धचन जोकर ही यत कया जा सकता है। मेरे इस तकथ का खडन अमेररका के भाषावैाननक चासथ एफ हॉकट ने करने की कोलशश की ता इस आधार िर अमे रकन भाषावैानक ने भारतीय भाषाओं को रोमन लिपि मै ही लिखने का तकथ दोहराया। मने अिने डी. लि. की उिाधध के लिए वीक त शोध-बंध मै अमेररकन भाषावैाननक हॉके ट वारा महााण यंजन को यंजन गुछ मानने के सुझाव एवं ताव का माण सहहत खंडन ककया। इस सबंध मै याान पवतार से पववेचन ककया जाएगा। मने हमेशा अिने अनेक अययन वारा यह िट कया क हहदी को (अधधकांश अय भारतीय भाषाओं को भी), देवनागरी लिपि ही संगत, क नत के नुऱि एवं वैानक ढंग से लिख सकने मै समथ है। इसके पविरीत, रोमन लिपि वारा इनको वैानक ढंग से लियंकत नहीं कया जा सकता। तसबंधधत कालशत क छ िेख के संदभथ ननन ह – हदी ः वऱि एवं वतथनी (कालशत मन, वषथ 2, अंक 2, हदिी, ि ठ 11-14, जुिाई, 1975) देवनागरी लिपि एवं हहदी की वतथनी: मताएँ, सीमाएँ, वैाननकता एवं समयाएँ, नागरी लिपि समे िन माररका, नागरी लिपि िररष, राजघाट, नई हदिी, ि 0 41-46 (अेि, 1977)।

Upload: prof-mahavir-saran-jain

Post on 21-Nov-2015

170 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

DESCRIPTION

The document deals the “Devanāgari Script” (देवनागरी लिपि) and the writing system of Hindi language (हिन्दी वर्तनी). This script is also used in writing other languages such as Sanskrit, Marathi, and Nepali etc. The script is written from left to right. There are no special forms for capital letters as are in Roman script. As a rule, each simple consonant character or letter represents a syllabic form, means each written consonant has an inherent short “a” (अ). In other words, each written consonant letter represents a consonant followed by the vowel “a”. In a case, when a consonant is to be pronounced without any vowel, then consonant letter is marked by a sign called “halant” (हलन्त). In Hindi, in certain positions, the inherent “a” is not pronounced. To denote, other vowels, special signs are attached to the consonant character or letter. These signs are called “matrās” (मात्राएँ). Every matra has its rule for attachment to the consonant or consonant double or consonant cluster. Devanāgari script has ligatures characters for consonant clusters also. Hindi stops (including “affricates”) and nasal consonants are arranged in five series (classes’ वर्ग) according to the place of articulation. These are: (1) Velars (now soft palate) (K-series कवर्ग) (2) Palatals (Ch-series चवर्ग) (3) Retroflex (now- post-alveolar) (T-series टवर्ग) (4) Dentals (t-series तवर्ग) (5) Bilabials (p-series पवर्ग). Devnāgari Script has two special signs: (1) Anunāsik (अनुनासिकता का चिह्न ँ) – This sign denotes the nasalization of a vowel. Nasalization in Hindi is a supra-segmental phoneme. (2) Anuswāra (अनुस्वार ं). This sign is not a specific sound. It represents many nasal consonants as-well-as nasalization of vowels in certain positions. It means, in certain positions, it represents the value of “Anunāsik” also. When preceding a Hindi stops series, the anuswāra sign, if used, represent the nasal consonant of the series, to which the stop belongs. In velar series, represent velar nasal consonant (ङ्). In palatal series, represent palatal nasal consonant (ञ्). In retroflex series, represent retroflex nasal consonant (ण्). In dental series, represent retroflex nasal consonant (न्). In bilabials, represent bilabial nasal consonant (म्). In other words, aanuswāra represents the “Pancmakshr” (पंचमाक्षर) or nasal consonant of the above mentioned series. Writing with anuswāra in such positions has been optional. It is also used preceding some other consonants such as “y”(य) , “r”(र) , “l”(ल), “s”(स) , “sh”(श), “h”(ह) . Some other facts of script and sounds and /or phonemes of Hindi have been also discussed.

TRANSCRIPT

  • 1

    1960 , , , (unit) (Letters) (Contrastive distribution) (Phonemic) 'h' . . - ( ), , ,

    ( , 2, 2, , 11-14, , 1975)

    : , , , , , , , 0 41-46 (, 1977)

  • 2

    1984 1988 - 1992 , 2001 , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

    1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. ( ) 9. 10. 11. 12.

    12

    / ()

  • 3

    -, (, , , , , , , , ) - [, , . ] , , , //, // // - // // / / (, ) / / (, )

    / / (, , ) / / (, )

    / / ( , ) / / ()

    // // / / () / / (, )

    / / () / / ()

    / / () / / ()

    // // / / ( , , , ) / / ( , )

    / / ( ), (), () / / (), () ( )

    / / ( )

    / / (), ()

  • 4

    1. : - , ( ), 6, 30, 10-22, (, 1991))

    2. : - , Linguistics and Linguistics, studies in Honor of Ramesh Chandra Mehrotra, Indian Scholar Publications, Raipur, pp. 311-326

    (1994))

    3. : , (- ) 21 30, , , , (2007))

    4. (, 06 , 2010)

    5. http://www.rachanakar.org/2010/07/2.html

    6.- , 3, 17, , , 34 43 (, 2014)

    : (1)

    () ( )

  • 5

    '' - '' '' ( + = ) ( ) '' "" + =

    + =

    + =

    + =

    + =

    + =

    + =

    + =

    + =

    + =

    + =

    '' , '' , -

    () ,-,

    () /

    ( ) , ,

  • 6

    () ,

    , , , (2) ( ), , , , , , , - i (3) '' '' '' '' '' , '' , , '' '' , '' '' , '', '' ('+' = '') (4) '' '' '', '', '', '', '', '', ( ) (non-contrastive distribution) , (Phonemic system) (Phonemes) '', '', , '' '' ( , 60- 75, . . - ),

  • 7

    , , 1974) - - '' '' - - '' '' , '' '' (5) (6) -

    / , / , / , / / , / , / , / , / /, / , /

    (6) / -

    / , / , / / , / , / / , / , / / , / , / / , / , / / , / , / / , / , / / , / , / / , / , / / , / , /

    (7) (Contrastive distribution) (Phonemes)

  • 8

    'h' ' + ' (consonant cluster) '' '+' Sanskrit and certain modern languages such as Hindustani, are often said to have four types of

    stops : voiceless and voiced, intersecting un-aspirated and aspirated. But in both named cases the aspiration (be it voiceless or voiced) is rather patently simply the phoneme /h/ which recurs

    elsewhere: this leaves just a two-way manner contrast. (C. F. Hockett A Manual of Phonology, P. 107 (1955))

    - (pattern congruity) , 1955 , " + (+) + (+) (phonemic level) (phonemes) - (Phonotactics) (consonant clusters) " 1961 20 (, , , , , , , , , ) Hindi and many other languages of India are generally said to have four series of stops: voiceless un- -aspirate, voiceless aspirate, voiced un-aspirate, and voiced aspirate. Of course, it is obviously possible to reduce these to two series,

    each of which can occur in clusters with a following /h/. Linguists have disagreed as to which analysis is preferable. --- --- --- Of course, if the number of phonemes is reduced by treating some as clusters, the differences which exist between languages are not removed. They are

    merely transformed from differences in the inventory of phonemes into differences in the inventory of clusters. There is little practical difference between saying that Hindi contrasts with English in having four rather two series of stops and saying that Hindi differs from English

  • 9

    in having clusters of stops plus /h/. - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -In English, there are numerous

    differences in distribution between stops and affricates. This is not true for Hindi. The two

    phonetic sound-types pattern alike in many respects. It is, therefore, useful to consider affricates not as a class apart, but only as a phonetically different type of stop. - - The result is a symmetrical pattern of twenty stop phonemes (in Hindi).

    (H. A. Gleason, Jr., An Introduction to DESCRIPTIVE LINGUISTICS (Revised Edition) pp. 332- 335, New York, 1961)

    , (1. + 2. ) (- ) (phonetic level) , (, , , , , , , , , ) + '' '' '' '' . . [], [],[],[ ] - - (, , , , , , , , , ) [], [],[],[ ] +, +, +, + ( , 34- 38, . . - ), , , 1974) ( , 50- 51, . . - ), , , 1974) +

    [] [] [] [] [] [ ]

  • 10

    [] [] [] [] [] [ ] [] [ ] [] [ ]

    ( ) , / -

    / , / , / / , / , /

    / , / , / , / , / , / , /

    / , / , / , / , / , /

    / , / , / , / , / , /

    / , / , / , / , / , /

    / , / , / , / , / , / , / , / , / , / , /

    / , / , / , / , / , / , /

    / , / , / , / , / , /

    / , / , / , / , / , /

    / , / , / , / , / , / , / , /

  • 11

    , /

    (8) -

    / , / / , / , / / , / / , /

    ( ) , , , , - "Tal" ( ) (9) ( ) [], (-) [], [] [] (10) [], [] [] (11) [] [ ]

    (12) (phonemic)

    , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

  • 12

    , , , , , ,

    ( , 81- 89, . . - ), , , 1974) ( ) ( ) ( ) ( ) , , , ( ) ( ) ( , , , , ) , , , , , , -

    , = , = , = , = , =

  • 13

    [ ] (Phonemic system)

    (I.P.A.)

    , , , , ( ) , (sounds) (phonemes) , (phonemic system)

  • 14

    (Phonetics)

    ()

    (I.P.A.) ,

    - ()

    http://www.rachanakar.org/2014/11/blog-post_80.html#ixzz3KHZP8sub

    (Phonemes) , Phoneme Spelling Frequency in Terms of Popularity in US English Text

    The popularity of words in text needs to be considered for phonetic or phonics representation. See the phoneme spelling frequencies for the top 5k words of US English.

    https://www.screenr.com/V0ZNClick the expand box at lower right. Note ...

    Screenr - tzurinskas: Summary of spellings of the 40 US English phonemes by text

    frequency,see... screenr.com

    '' '' '', '', '', '',

    '', '', ( )

    (non-contrastive distribution) ,

    (Phonemic system) (Phonemes)

    - -

  • 15

    (

    , 19- 22, . .

    - ), , , 1974) (, , )

    (phonemic)

    (phoneme) (allophones)

    /

    ( ,

    09- 30 60-75, . . - ), , , 1974)

    (Speech sounds)

    ,

    ,

    ,

  • 16

    26

    (uppercase or capital letters)

    A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z

    ( lowercase or small letters)

    a b c d e f g h i j k l m n o p q r s t u v w x y z

    1.

    , , , , , ,

    2. -

    , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

    3. - , , , , , i, , , , ,

    ,

    ,

    ,

    "put" "but" "but"

  • 17

    1.

    2.

    3.

    1.

    Abandon, Adduct, Adobe A

    Abolition, Add, Adamant A Air, Aim, Ailment, Album A Alter, Already, Almost A Charm, Charge, Charter a

    2.

    ()

    bill, fit, silk, silt, sin , , , ,

    i

    symbol, sympathy , y because, become, before , , e varieties ie minute u women o three ee

    ()

  • 18

    keen, keep, kite, king , , , k cat, case, cash, come , , , c qualify, queen , q duck, luck, suck , , ck chemist, school , ch

    3.

    Psychic, Psychology , P Knife, know , k talk l often t

    (phonemic system) ,

    . Some appreciation of the difficulties is necessary, since otherwise even simply stated

    phonemic groupings will be misunderstood. We can, however, leave the subject of problems

    and method by outlining some of misconceptions and inconsistencies which are apt to plague,

    not the serious analyst, but the beginning student. The most disastrous type of misconception

    is to allow phonemic classification to be influenced by spelling, with which it has little to do and

    which it often contradicts.

    (Archibald A. Hill: Introduction to Linguistic Structures from sound to sentence in English, P. 56,

    New York, 1958)

    , 28 , 2014 English is an uncommonly tricky language to spell. Every rule seems to have an exception and

    homophones (for example rough and ruff) abound. English has a complicated history,

    influenced structurally by many other languages and keen on borrowing words from yet more.

  • 19

    As a result, it is very tolerant of illogical spellings (receipt anybody?). It is also spoken with a

    large variety of accents, so it would be difficult to come up with a good English phonemic

    orthography (where a system of signs corresponds exactly to sounds).

    http://www.theguardian.com/education/2014/oct/28/-sp-spelling-language-learning-english

    '

    '

    ( )

    ' '

    , ,

    , , 2010

    ,

    ,

    '

    '

    , 2

    , 2014 ' '

    ' '

    , , - ( (ISCCI))

  • 20

    (Unicode)

    - ,

    ,

    -

    , , , ,

    Centre for Development of Advanced Computing (-) , - -2000, , (-) -, , (, , ), , ,

  • 21

    (alphabetic writing) (syllabic writing) 50 60 (syllabic writing) , '' - '' '' ( + = ) ( ) '' "" , , , , , /

    ( /

    V / VC , , , , , CV , , , / CCV , , , CVC , , , , / CCVC , , , ,

  • 22

    ( , 175- 188, . . - ), , , 1974)

    '' 22 -

    3.1.2.5 , , , , , , (SPECIMENS) (The specimen given in Fig. 3 are only as a guide to illustrate the principles established in 3 and 4) , , , ( ) , , "+++++" =

    , ,

  • 23

    ,

    (syllabic writing) ,

    ''

    70 ()

    ()

    ( , , , , )

    , , , , , ,

    ()

    ()

    '' , ,

    [ , , ] [] , . '' '' '' '' [ , , ] [] [ , , ] []

  • 24

    , [ , , ] [] [ , , ] []

    (1) [ , , ] [ , , ] () [ ] , , , , , , , () [ ] , ,

    (2) , 25 3.6.1.2, 3.6.1.3, 3.6.1.4 3.6.1.2 () 3.6.1.3 3.6.1.4 (-)

    -

    31 3.1.4.3 /

    32 3.1.5.2

    (

    )

  • 25

    21 ,

    ,

    ,

    (1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8)

    (9)

    ,

    ,

    ,

    - - ,

    ; ,

    ,

    ,

    , , , .

    ,

    ,

  • 26

    ,

    ()

    -

    , , , ,

    -,

    1.

    (phonetic writing)

    2. (Unicode) (grapheme)

    16

    32

    16 65536 32 4294967296

    (speech to text)

    ,

    (grapheme)

    (phonemes) (phonemes)

  • 27

    (phonemic

    system) ,

    (phonemic system)

    ,

    (phonemic system) ,

    ,

    -

    (phonemic system) (speech sounds)

    , ,

    ,

    -----------------------------------------------------------------------------

    ( , )

    123, , 203001

    [email protected]

  • 28