detailed project report of par-tapi-narmada link project...

Detailed Project Report of Par-Tapi-Narmada link projectCHECK LIST

I General Data1 Name of the project Par-Tapi-Narmada link project2 Location:a State (s) Maharashtra and Gujaratb District (s) Nasik district of Maharashtra and

Valsad, Navsari, Dangs, Tapi,Surat, Bharuch, Narmada,Vadodara, Chhota Udepur andPanchmahal districts andSaurashtra region of Gujarat

c Taluka (s) Peint, Surgana, Dharampur,Vansda, Waghai, Songadh,Mandvi, Mangrol, Valiya,Zagadiya, Rajpipla, TilakwadaSankheda, Jetpur pavi, Nasvadi,Kavant, Bodeli,Chhota Udepur,Halol, Kalol, Ghoghamba andSaurashtra region

d Location of Head works Latitude (N) Longitude (E) (i) Jheri Dam 20o 22’ 25" 73o 25’ 51"(ii) (a) Paikhed Dam 20o 27’ 42" 73o 23’ 37" (b) Paikhed barrage 20o 27’ 11" 73o 22’ 30"(iii) (a) Chasmandva Dam 20o 37’ 02" 73o 22’ 36" (b) Chasmandva barrage 20o 36’ 05" 73o 18’ 50"(iv) Chikkar Dam 20o 42’ 00" 73o 30’ 50"(v) Dabdar Dam 20o 48’ 58" 73o 32’ 05"(vi) Kelwan Dam 20o 55’ 30 " 73o 32’ 00"

e Survey of India Topo-sheets 1:50,000 Scale

46 F/1246G / 2, 3, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 11, 1246H / 2, 3, 5, 6, 7, 9, 10

f Earthquake Zone number Seismic Zone - IIIg Complete address for

correspondence along with pinSuperintending Engineer,National Water Development

iv

code/e-mail Agency, 3rd Floor, Om PlazaBuilding, Dharampur Road,Abrama, Valsad, GujaratPIN- 396 002Tele-Fax No. 91-2632- 226067, E-mail: [email protected]

3 Category of the projecta Irrigation or Multipurpose Multipurpose b Storage or diversion Storage projectII Planning4 Has the Master plan for overall

development of the river basinbeen prepared and stages of basindevelopment discussed briefly?

Yes

5 Have the alternative proposalsbeen studied and their merits anddemerits discussed?

Yes

6 Does the scheme fit in the overalldevelopment of the river basin andits priority in the overalldevelopment of the basindiscussed?

Yes

7 Have the other Departmentsconcerned with the developmentbeen informed.

Yes

8 Is the present scheme proposed tobe executed in stages? If so, are itsvarious stages of execution anddevelopment discussed in thereport?

Yes, Discussed in chapter-10 ofVolume I-Main Report

9 Are the effects of the scheme onthe riparian rights & existingupstream and downstreamprojects, etc. discussed?

Yes, The requirement of water forall the existing, ongoing and futureprojects located in the up-stream aswell as down-stream of all theproposed projects has beenaccounted for while arriving at the

v

surplus quantity of water fortransfer to proposed Par-Tapi-Narmada link to drought pronearea of Saurashtra and Kutchregion of Gujarat State bysubstitution.

10 Has the provision for municipaland industrial water supply beenmade

Provision of Municipal andIndustrial water supply alongperiphery of Reservoirs and canalhas been made.

III InterState and InternationalAspects

11 Are there any International /InterState issues involved? If so,have these issues been identifiedand present status of agreement ortribunal decision indicatedspecially in respect of this project.

Par-Tapi-Narmada link project isan InterState project involvingMaharashtra and Gujarat States.

a Sharing of water Water availability study of theproject carried out during DPRpreparation has been accepted byboth the States. Issue of sharing ofwater and power between Gujaratand Maharashtra are underfinalization.

b Sharing of cost Based on the DPR specific MoUfor sharing of cost & benefitsincluding arrangements formanagement and control of waterwill be entered into amongst theStates of Maharashtra and Gujaratand Union Government. (ReferPara no.2 of tripartite MoU –Annexure -1.3 of Volume -II)

c Sharing of benefits (irrigation,flood control, power etc.)

vi

d Acceptance of the submergenceby the upstream State(s)

Submergence area of Jherireservoir is spread in Maharashtra,Paikhed reservoir is spread in bothGujarat and Maharashtra, andChasmandva reservoir is spread inboth Gujarat and Maharashtra.Submergence of proposed Chikkar,Dabdar and Kelwan reservoirs arespread in Gujarat. The location andsubmergence area of reservoirs isacceptable to both States.

e Acceptance by the upstreamState(s) of compensation of landcoming under submergence.

As part of EIA study, R&Rpackage for PAPs has beenevolved keeping in view theprovisions of NationalRehabilitation and ResettlementPolicy- 2007 and the provisions ofLand Acquisition, Rehabilitationand Resettlement Bill – 2013.Provision for compensation of landcoming under submergence hasbeen made in R&R plan. ReferChapter–12, Volume I – MainReport.

f Settlement of oustees R&R package for PAPs has beenevolved keeping in view theprovisions of NationalRehabilitation and ResettlementPolicy- 2007 and the provisions ofLand Acquisition, Rehabilitationand Resettlement Bill – 2013.Refer Chapter–12, Volume I-MainReport.

IV Surveys

vii

12 Have the detailed topographicalsurveys been carried out for thefollowing items and mapsprepared as per prescribed scales?(a) River surveys Yes, Refer para 4.1.1 of Chapter 4

of Volume I-Main Report andPlates 4.1 to 4.17 of Volume VII-Drawings of Survey &Investigations

(b) Reservoir surveys Yes, Refer para 4.1.2 of Chapter 4of Volume I-Main Report andPlates 4.18 to 4.29 of Volume VII-Drawings Survey & Investigations

(c) Head-works surveys (dam,dykes, barrages, weirs, etc., andauxiliary components)

Yes, Refer para 4.1.3 of Chapter 4of Volume I-Main Report andPlates 4.30 to 4.38 of Volume VII-Drawings Survey & Investigations

(d) Plant and Colonies sites No, however Indicative map ofplant and colony layout is at Plate4.39 of Volume VII-DrawingsSurvey & Investigations

(e) Canals, Branch canals andwater distribution system

Yes, Refer para 4.1.5 and 4.1.8 ofChapter 4 of Volume-I of MainReport.

(f) Major canal structures Yes, Refer para 4.1.5 of Chapter 4of Volume-I of Main Report

(g) Power house, switch-yard,surge shafts, tailrace

Yes, Refer para 4.1.6 of Chapter 4of Volume-I of Main Report

(h) Tunnel(s), adits, penstocks,etc.

Yes, Refer para 4.1.7 of Chapter 4of Volume-I of Main Report

(i) Surveys(Detailed and sample)of areas of the command for OFDand drainage works

Yes, Refer para 4.1.8, 4.1.8.1 &4.1.8.2 of Chapter 4 of Volume I -Main Report, Plates 4.40 to 4.43 ofVolume VII-Drawings Survey &Investigations and Appendix 4.1 ofVolume-III.

(j) Soil surveys Yes, Refer para 4.2.6 of Chapter 4of Volume I-Main Report and Plate4.45 of Volume VII- Drawings

viii

Survey & Investigations(k) Surveys for soil conservation Yes, Refer para 4.1.9 of Chapter 4

of Volume I- Main Report(l) Any other surveysa)Archaeological,

Yes, Refer para 4.2.1 of Chapter 4of Volume I- Main Report andAnnexure 4.2.1 & 4.2.2 of Volume-II

b)Mineral survey Yes, Refer para 4.2.2 of Chapter 4of Volume I- Main Report andAnnexure 4.3 of Volume -II

c)Right of way survey Yes, Refer para 4.2.3 of Chapter 4of Volume I- Main Report

d)Communication survey Yes, Refer para 4.2.4 of Chapter 4of Volume I-Main Report and Plate4.44 of Volume-VII

V Geological Investigations13 Have the geological surveys for

the following items been carriedout and report on geology of thefollowing appended?

a Regional as whole Yes, Refer para 4.3.1 of Chapter 4 of Volume I - Main Report

b Reservoir( Local Geology) Yes, Refer para 4.3.2 of Chapter 4 of Volume I- Main Report

c Head works and energydissipation area

Yes, Refer para 4.3.3 of Chapter 4of Volume I-Main Report, Plate4.46 to 4.50 of Volume VII-Drawings, Survey & Investigationsand Appendix 4.2 of Volume-III.

d Power house and appurtenances Yes. The investigations at head works covers the areas of powerhouse

e Intake and regulators Yes. The investigations at head works covers the areas of Intake and regulators etc.

f Tunnel(s), Penstock hill, etc. Due to public hindrance,

ix

Investigation could not be carriedout at DPR stage. The same will becarried out at Pre constructionstage.

g Major canal structuresh Communication routes

VI Seismic Investigations14 Has the Seismicity of the region

been studied and co-efficient ofvertical/horizontal acceleration forthe various structures discussed?

Yes, Refer para 4.3.4 of Chapter 4of Volume I-Main Report andAppendix 4.3 of Volume-III.

15 Has the approval of the NationalCommittee for recommendingdesign of seismic co-efficient forRiver Valley Project (NCSDP)been obtained?

Yes, Refer para 4.3.4 of Chapter 4of Volume I-Main Report andAnnexure 4.4 of Volume-II.

16 Is there a possibility ofliquefaction of foundations? If sowhether liquefaction studies beencarried out?

No

VII Foundation Investigations17 Have the detailed foundation

investigations (including in-situtests and laboratory tests) for thefollowing structures been carriedout and detailed report(s)appended?

a Earth and rock filldam/barrage/weir.etc

Yes, Refer para 4.4 of Chapter 4 ofVolume I-Main Report Appendix4.4 to 4.9 of Volume-III ; Plates4.52 to 4.56 of Volume VIIDrawings Survey & Investigationsand Annexures 4.5 to 4.9 ofVolume-II

b Masonry/concrete dam/weir, etc. Yes, Refer para 4.4 of Chapter 4 ofVolume I-Main Report Appendix4.4 to 4.9 of Volume-III ; Plates

x

4.52 to 4.56 of Volume VIIDrawings Survey & Investigationsand Annexures 4.5 to 4.9 ofVolume-II

c Barrage(s)/Weir(s)//headregulator(s) etc

Yes. The Investigations at head works covers the areas of barrages and regulators

d Canal(s) & Canal Structures Due to public hindrance,Investigation could not be carriedout at DPR stage. The same will becarried out at Pre constructionstage.

e Power house(s), tunnel(s),transformer cavern(s), desiltingchamber(s), surge tank(s)/shaft(s), intake(s) canal structures,etc.

Yes. The Investigations at headworks covers the areas of powerhouses.

18 Are there any special featuresaffecting the designs?

No

VIII CONSTRUCTION MATERIALSURVEY

19 Have the surveys and laboratorytests for the followingconstruction materials beencarried out and report(s)appended?

a Soils for impervious, semi-pervious and pervious zones ofearth and rock-fill dam(s)

Yes, Refer para 4.5.1 of Chapter 4of Volume I- Main Report;Annexures 4.10.1 to 4.15.2 ofVolume-II; and Plates 4.58 to 4.63of Volume VII- Drawings Survey &Investigations

b Sand Yes, Refer para 4.5.2 of Chapter 4of Volume I-Main Report Appendix4.9 of Volume-III

c Rock and coarse aggregate Yes, Refer para 4.5.3 of Chapter 4

xi

of Volume I-Main ReportAppendix 4.9 of Volume-III

d Bricks and tiles Yes, Refer para 4.5.4 of Chapter 4of Volume I-Main Report

e Pozzolona Yes, Refer para 4.5.5 of Chapter 4of Volume I-Main Report

f Cement and lime stone Yes, Refer para 4.5.6 of Chapter 4of Volume I-Main Report

g Steel Yes, Refer para 4.5.7 of Chapter 4of Volume I-Main Report

h Any other Yes, Refer para 4.5.9 of Chapter 4of Volume I-Main Report

20 Have the sources for each of theabove material been identifiedand need etc. indicated?

Yes, Refer para 4.5.1 to 4.5.9 ofChapter 4 of Volume I-MainReport

21 Have the proposals forprocurement of scarce materialsbeen indicated?

Yes, Refer para 4.5.8 of Chapter 4of Volume I-Main Report

IX Hydrological and Meteorological Investigations22 (a)Have the hydrological and

meteorological investigations beencarried out and status of followingdata discussed in report?

i Rainfall Yes, Refer para 4.6.1 of Chapter4 of Volume I-Main Report

ii Temperature Yes, Refer para 4.6.5 of Chapter4 of Volume I-Main Report

iii Wind Speed Yes, Refer para 4.6.3 of Chapter4 of Volume I-Main Report

iv Gauge & Discharge Yes, Refer para 4.6.2 of Chapter4 of Volume I-Main Report

v Sediment Yes, Refer para 4.6.6 of Chapter4 of Volume I-Main Report

vi Water quality Yes, Refer para 4.6.7 of Chapter4 of Volume I-Main Report

vii Evaporation Yes, Refer para 4.6.8 of Chapter

xii

4 of Volume I-Main Report(b) Has the above data been collected& appended ?

Yes,

X Hydrology23 Is the hydrology dealt with in details

in a separate volume? Have the briefdetails been included in this report?

Yes, Refer Chapter–5, VolumeI-Main Report and AppendixNo. 5.1 of volume IV.

24 Have an index map and bar chartshowing location of various hydro-metric, climatic and rainfall stationsexisting/ongoing/planned waterresources projects and the dataavailability at those stations beenattached?

Yes, Refer Chapter-5 of VolumeI-Main Report

25 Have required detail note aboutproject specific hydro-meteorologicaldata observatories been attached.


26 Have required detail in case ofHimalayan rivers, if project beingplanned in upper reaches, the satelliteimageries of project catchmentespecially one during snowmeltperiod(March-may) and one duringmonsoon(June-September) periodbeen attached?

Not Applicable

27 Are details notes about quality,consistency, processing and gapfilling of the data included

Yes, Refer Chapter-5 of Volume I-Main Report

28 Have hydrological studies beencarried out for the following:

a To establish the availability of waterfor the benefits envisaged.

Yes, Refer Chapter-5 of VolumeI-Main Report and Appendix-5.1 of Volume – IV.

b To determine design flood for thevarious structures (Spillway, weir,

Yes, Refer Chapter-5 of VolumeI-Main Report and Appendix –

xiii

barrage, etc.) 5.3 and 5.4 of Volume – IV.c Sediments storage Yesd Design flood for diversion during

constructionYes

e Tail water rating curve Yes, Refer Chapter – 5 of Volume I-Main Report

f Evaporation rates fromreservoirs/concerned area

Yes

g Command area rainfall Yes29 Has the Ground Water Potential

(existing use and additionalavailability) been indicated ?

Yes

30 Have the studies regarding reservoirsedimentation been carried out andrevised Elevation-Area Capacitycurves been used in the simulationstudies? (Working Table)?

Yes, Refer Chapter-5 of VolumeI-Main Report and Appendix –5.2 of Volume IV

31 Have the ecological requirements ofwater such as low flow augmentationand water quality control etc. andwater requirement for domestic,industrial use and power generation(thermal, hydel, nuclear) beenconsidered and included in theProject Report and incorporated inthe simulation studies?

Yes

32 Have the details of the simulationstudies (Working Table) andconclusions arrived from the variousalternatives explaining the factors andassumptions been included anddiscussed?

Yes, Refer Chapter-5 of VolumeI-Main Report Appendix – 5.5of Volume – IV.

33 Have the number of failures fordifference aspects been indicated?

Yes, Refer Chapter-5 of Volume- I

34 Have the likely desirable andundesirable changes in the hydrologic


xiv

regime due to the project beenbrought out in the report?

35 Is the criteria adopted for selection ofthe construction diversion flooddiscussed?

Yes

36 Has the basis for determining thestorage capacity been discussed?

Yes

37 Have integrated working tables (formore than one reservoir in thesystem) been prepared?

Yes

38 Has carry over storage beenprepared? If so, whether studies formost economic carry over storagebeen done?

No

39 Have the flood routing studies beencarried out?

Yes. Refer Chapter-6 of VolumeI-Main Report

40 Have the back water studies beencarried out?

Yes. Refer Chapter-5 of VolumeI-Main Report

XI Land acquisition and resettlement of oustees41 Have the type and quantum of land

proposed to be acquired in thesubmergence area project area, areacoming under canal and distributionsystem, area required forrehabilitation of the oustees beendetailed?

Yes, Refer Chapter- 12 of Volume I-Main Report

42 Is the basis for provision for landacquisition indicated?


43 Have the rehabilitation measures,amenities and facilities to be providedto the project affected persons beendiscussed and whether theirprovisions included in the report? Arethese in accordance State’spolicy/project specific policy/draftnational policy for rehabilitation and


xv

resettlement 44 Are the basis of land acquisition of

the submerged area upon FRL/MWLetc. discussed?


XII Design45 Does the State have established a

Central Design Organisation andState level multidisciplinaryAdivisory Committee and whether itscomposition has been indicated in thereport

A design of various componentsof the project has been carriedout by Central Watercommission (CWC).

46 Has the selection of final location ofthe head works and appurtenances, inpreference to the other sitesinvestigated, been discussed?

Yes

47 Have the layout of the project viz.,location of head works, workshop,sheds, offices, colonies, etc. beenfinalized and discussed?

Yes

48 Has the layout of the various majorcomponents of the head works beendiscussed in the light of site feature,geology, and foundationcharacteristics, etc.

Yes

49 Have the detailed designs beenprepared for the followingcomponents and got vetted by CDO?

Civil designs of variouscomponents of the project havebeen carried out by CentralWater Commission.

a Earth or rock fill dam, masonry orconcrete dam, spillway, barrage, weir,etc. and appurtenances.

Yes

b Energy dissipation arrangements,training wells, etc.

Yes

c Openings through dam-galleries,head regulators, penstocks, otheroutlets, sluices, etc.

Yes

xvi

d Regulators Yese Canal and water conductor system Yesf Canal structures Yesg Pump house , intake structures Yesh Power house, tunnels, surge shaft Yesi Instrumentation Yesj Power evacuation arrangement Yes, Power evacuation studies

carried out by Tehri HydroDevelopment Corporation IndiaLimited (THDCIL)

k Design of Hydro Mechanicalequipments

Yes. E&M studies carried outby Tehri Hydro DevelopmentCorporation India Limited(THDCIL)

50 Have the salient features of the abovecomponents and the assumptionsmade in the design of abovecomponents of the project beenindicated and basis of assumptiondiscussed?

Yes

51 Have any model studies been carriedout for location of the dam, spillwayand other appurtenances checking thedesign profile of the spillway, energydissipation arrangements, location ofoutlets/ regulators, etc?

Model studies will be conductedat construction stage.

52 Has the final alignment of canal(s)and branch canal(s) been discussed inthe light of various alignmentsstudied?

Yes

a. Does the canal design provide formeeting requirements of rushirrigation?

Yes

b. Have any intermediate storages andtail tanks been considered to reducethe canal capacities?

No.

xvii

53 Are the canals and distribution systembeing lined and if so what is theminimum capacity of the channelproposed to be lined?

Only main canal to be lined

54 Is the location of canal structures onmain and branch canals fixed afterdetailed surveys of the finalalignments?

Yes

55 Are the regulation arrangements ofthe off-taking channel both near andaway from the cross regulatorsdiscussed?

Yes

56 Are sufficient escapes includingterminal escapes provided on themain/branch canaldistributaries/minors?

Yes

57 Have the basis for adopting waterway for the cross drainage worksbeen discussed?

Yes

58 Have the proposals for rating thecanal section by providing standingwave flumes, rating of the falls, broadcrested weirs. V-notches etc. beendiscussed for the canal anddistribution system?

No

59 Have any model studies for majorcanal structure(s) been carried out andif so, are the results discussed andincorporated in the design?

No

XIII Irrigation and Command AreaDevelopment

60 Have the conveyance and fieldirrigation efficiencies for paddy andupland crops during Kharif, rabi, etc.been indicated, discussed and

Yes

xviii

justified?61 Have the 10-daily/monthly Crop

water requirements at the canal headbeen worked out?

Yes, Monthly crop water requirement worked out.

62 Are there any proposals forintroducing Warabandi and if so havethese proposals been discussed in thereport and sample calculations for atypical distributory / minor / sub-minor furnished?

The water distribution system of Government of Gujarat will be followed.

63 Has the present position of irrigationin the command through existingcanals, tanks, lift schemes, wells, etc.been brought out in the report?

Yes

64 Are the particulars of all irrigationprojects (including minor schemes)existing/proposed in the commandbeen indicated?

Yes

65 Are there potential areas, whereground water is available? If so, hasthe quantity & quality of the groundwater been indicated?

Yes, Refer to Annexure – 9.25of Volume - II.

66 Has the quantum of available groundwater been assessed and plan for itsconjunctive use with surface waterbeen prepared and incorporated in thereport?

Yes, Refer to Annexure – 9.25of Volume - II.

67 Have the semi-detailed soil surveysbeen carried out for the entirecommand? If not the extent of areasurveyed may be indicated.

Yes

68 Have soil and land irrigabilityclassifications brought out in thereport?

Yes

69 Is the method used for determiningthe crop water requirements

Yes

xix

discussed?70 Has the pre-project cropping pattern

and the proposed cropping patternalong with justification beenfurnished?

Yes

71 Has the proposed cropping patternbeen certified by Centre/StateAgricultural Authorities giving theStatement of having considered thesoil characteristics and landirrigability characteristics of thecommand area in deciding thepercentage of the command areafalling under respective crops assuggested in DPR.

Yes

72 Whether drinking water needs of thepopulation projected for the 25-30years after construction of the projecton enroute and that in the commandof the project considered.

Yes

73 Are the areas and percentages of theCCA that will be irrigated duringkharif, rabi, two seasonal, summerand perennial been indicated?

Yes

74 Is justification furnished for irrigatingperennials and summer crops fromthe reservoir?

Yes

75 Have the monthly reservoir operationstudies been carried out at least for 20years and summary on annual basisattached?

Yes

76 Have the number of blocks selectedfor detailed surveys for On FarmDevelopment (OFD) works includingdrainage and total area covered by

Yes, Sample command areasurveys have been carried out inen-route command areaincluding OFD work.

xx

such blocks been indicated?77 Have the arrangements for financing

the OFD works and proposals if any,for strengthening the same beendiscussed?

No

78 Have the agencies responsible forexecution of the OFD works beenidentified and simultaneous planningof execution of OFD works alongwith engineering works discussed?

Not Applicable

79 Has the year-wise phasing ofirrigation development as a result ofthe project been discussed?

No

80 Is the existing communication systemtelephone, wireless, and roads withincommand area sufficient to meet therequirement after full development ofirrigation? If not, have the newproposals been planned anddiscussed?

Yes, However, suitableprovisions have been kept in theestimate for future demand also.

81 Is the adequacy of the marketingcentres in the Command Area andnew proposals to meet therequirements after full developmentof irrigation been discussed?

Yes

82 Is there any stabilisation of existingirrigation proposed?

Yes

XIV Flood Control and Drainage83 Have the various flood control

components of the multipurposeproject been indicated?

Not Applicable

84 Have the damage areas in pre-project& post project situations beenidentified and flood intensitiesworked out at each of the damage

Not Applicable

xxi

centre(s) which gets affected?85 Have the following flood aspects

been discussed?a Flood cushion in the reservoir Not Applicableb Maximum moderated flood out flows

over the spillway etc. and itsfrequency

Yes

c Existing and proposed safe carryingcapacities of the channel below thedam after construction of floodembankment, channel improvement,river diversion, etc.

Yes

d Synchronized moderated peak floodsdue to release(s) from the Damupstream and uninterested catchmentupto the damage centers

Yes

e Average annual expenditure incurredon flood relief works

Not Applicable

f Area and population affected/likely tobe affected before/after the project

Not Applicable

g Estimated saving in annual loss oflife, property, cattle, crops, etc.(evaluated in terms of money) due toflood control.

Not Applicable

86 Have the following drainage aspectsof command area been discussed?

a Existing Surface and sub-surfacedrainage network and problems of thedrainage congestion, water logging,alkalinity/salinity if any.

Yes

b Studies on sub soil water table (pre-monsoon, post-monsoon etc.)

Yes

c Maximum intensity of 1,2 & 3 dayrainfall

Yes

d Deficiencies in farm drains Yese Deficiencies in existing natural drains Yes

xxii

f Proposal for improvement of drainage/ water logging/alkalinity/salinity ofthe area along with justificationthereof.

Not Applicable

g Identification of the area in Commandwhich will get benefited due toexecution of drainage network andbenefits thereof in terms of relieffrom crop damage, increased yields,etc.

Not Applicable

XV Navigation Not applicable87 Is the present scheme for remodeling

of the existing facilities and /orextension of the navigable reach orestablishing new navigable reach?

88 Is the existing inland transport systembeing fully utilized? If not, have thebottlenecks in its full utilization beenidentified and discussed?

89 Have the surveys for goods andpassenger traffic been carried out anddiscussed?

90 Is the extent of modification requiredin the existing system discussed andjustified?

91 Do design for the canal sections andstructures take into account theNavigation requirements?

92 Have the proposals to develop thenew scheme and phases ofdevelopment in the different reachesbeen discussed?

93 If the area is being served by inlandwater transport, have the followingbeen discussed:

a The existing toll rates and registrationfees, for the crafts(size wise)

xxiii

b Proposals for revision of tollage ratesand fees, if any

c Concurrence of the competentauthorities for revision of rates andfees.

d Proposal to subsidies the tariff,tollage, craft registration fee,passenger fare, etc. to attract traffic.

94 Has the State Inland Water Authoritybeen consulted while finalizing thescheme and its view point discussed?

95 Has economic justification andviability of the Navigation componentof the multipurpose project beendiscussed?

XVI Power96 Have the following points been

discussed?a Availability of the power generating

capacity in the State as well as in theregion from different sources

Yes, Refer Chapter 8 of VolumeI-Main Report

b Total energy available and peakingcapacity of the system in the State aswell as in the region from differentsources.


c Integrated operation of the systemand present status of utilisation in theState as well as in the region.


d Surpluses and shortfalls in the systemin the State as well as in the region.


e Future plans of power developmentfrom different sources in theState/region.

Yes, Refer Chapter 8 ofVolume-I

f Fitment of the scheme in planning ofpower development of theState/region


xxiv

g Energy generated from the project,firm power; seasonal power and totalpower


h Proposal for transmission linesconnecting to the existing system/grid


i Project cost per kwh installed and perkwh generated at bus bar ascompared to the different hydro-electric, thermal generation and gasprojects and different sources in theState as well as in the region to justifythe power component of the project.


XVII Construction Programme and Plantand Manpower Planning

97 Are the major components of workproposed to be done departmentallyor through contractor

Through contractor

98 Have the various alternativeconstruction programme been studiedand proper justification furnished forthe final programme adopted?

Yes

99 Has the proposed constructionprogramme been prepared andsynchronized for timely completionof each of the major component ofwork including Command AreaDevelopment?

Yes

100 Have the year wise quantities of thefollowing materials of constructionbeen worked out for variouscomponents of the project:

a Excavation separately in – soft andhard strata

Yes

b Earthwork in filling-impervious,semi-pervious and pervious

Yes

c Rockfill- for dam, toe, riprap, etc. Yes

xxv

d Stone for masonry Yese Coarse aggregate for concrete Yesf Sand – for filter, masonry/ concrete Yesg Gravel – for filter Yesh Steel of various sizes and type Yesi Cement- normal, quick/slow setting

with or without pozzolana, specialtypes

Yes

j Lime –surkhi - pozzolana Yesk Scarce material – special steel Yesl Other material – fuel, electricity,

explosive, etc.Yes

101 Have the year wise quantities to beexecuted by machine/labour for eachof the major component been workedout for each of the above material

Yes

102 Have the labour intensive items of thevarious major components of theproject been identified and thequantities of such items worked out?

Yes

103 Have PERT chart or CPM diagramsfor construction programme ofvarious components been made andincluded in report? Has organizationset up and frequency for projectmonitoring been indicated in theReport.

Yes

XVIII Foreign Exchange104 Have the details of the plant and

machinery, spares, instruments andscarce materials to be importedworked out?

Most of the requirements ofplants and machinery, spares,equipments / instruments, etcproposed to be procured wouldbe met indigenously.

105 Has the phasing of imports andsource(s) of imports been discusseditem wise?

Not Applicable

xxvi

106 Are the imports to be affected underforeign grants/credits or internalresources of the country?

Not Applicable

107 Is the scheme covered under Statesector or Central sector

State sector

XIX Financial Resources108 Has the concurrence of the State

Finance Department been obtained?Based on the DPR theconcerned Department ofGovernments of Maharashtraand Gujarat will obtain theconcurrence of their respectiveFinance Departments

109 Is the scheme included in the Fiveyear/Annual plan? If not, what is thepresent position regarding itsinclusion in the plan?

To be included by Government of India

110 Whether the scheme has already beenstarted? If so, is the present stage ofconstruction indicated?

Yet to be started

111 Have the year wise requirement offunds been indicated?

Yes, Refer Chapter-10 of Volume I-Main Report

112 Is the scheme covered or proposed tobe covered under any foreignassistance/aid agreement?

No

XX Estimate113 Is the separate volume of estimate

attached as appendix?Yes, Refer Appendix Volume –VI (A) - Cost estimate.

113 Is the year to which the rates adoptedin the estimate relate to indicated?

Yes, Refer Chapter 13 ofVolume I-Main Report

115 Have the analysis of rates for variousmajor items of work for the majorcomponents of the project beenfurnished and with basis of analysisdescribed?

Yes, References to analysis ofrates furnished in AppendixVolume – VI (B).

116 Are the provisions for the followingitems made on the basis of sample

xxvii

survey and sub-estimates:a Distributaries, minor and sub-minors Yesb Water courses Yesc Drainage Yesd CAD works Yes

XXI Revenues117 Are the basis for the following

sources of revenues furnished?a Betterment levy and proposal for its

recoveryNot Applicable

b Irrigation cess Not Applicablec Flood protection cess Not Applicabled Crop wise water rates No revenue from crop wise

water rates considered.e Sale of water for village/ city/

industrial/power /water supplyThe rates considered asprevailing in Gujarat.

118 Have these rates been compared withthe existing rates at the other projectsin the State region?

Yes, Existing rates of the Stategovernment have been adopted.

119 In case the rates are being enhanced,has the concurrence of the concerneddepartment(s) been obtained?

As per prevailing adopted system.

120 Have the organizational set up for thecollection of revenue been indicated?

No, existing system ofGovernment of Gujarat will beutilized

XXII B-C Ratio121 Are the allocated costs for the

following components of themultipurpose project worked out andbasis therein furnished?(a) Irrigation Yes(b) Power Yes(c) Flood Control Not Applicable(d) Navigation Not Applicable(e) Water supply Yes(f) Any other Not Applicable

122 Have the various departments of the Based on the DPR the issue of

xxviii

State/Centre agreed to the sharing ofthe above allocated cost?

sharing of cost by State Govts.of Maharashtra and Gujarat willbe decided. (Refer Para No. 2 oftripartite MoU – Annexure -1.3of Volume - II).

123 Have the crop wise benefits beenworked out for irrigated and unirrigated crops being grown beforeproject in consultation with theagriculture department and Statementfurnished?

Yes

124 Have the crop wise benefits beenworked out for proposed croppingpattern after the introduction ofirrigation in consultation with theagriculture department and Statementfurnished?

Yes

125 Is the B.C. ratio of Irrigation Projectsacceptable or otherwise justified?

Yes

126 Is the B.C. ratio for Flood ControlProjects acceptable or otherwisejustified?

Not Applicable

127 Have the financial and economicreturn Statements been furnishedkeeping in view the phasing ofdevelopment?

Yes

128 Are the benefits other than thoseconsidered in the B.C. ratio andfinancial return Statement beenidentified?

Yes

129 Is the benefit from Gallper land, ifproposed, based on lease ratesadmissible and Statement fromconcerned Central /State authoritiesfurnished?

Not Applicable

xxix

130 Are the benefits from fisheries,horticulture, if proposed, based onlease rates admissible and Statementfrom concerned Central/Stateauthorities furnished.

Yes

XXIII Ecological aspect131 (a) Is the area likely to have any of

the following environmental andecological problems due to the alteredsurface water pattern? If yes whetherpreventive measures have beendiscussed?

i Excessive sedimentation of thereservoir and the upper reaches of theriver and its tributaries tailing intoreservoir

No

ii Water logging, salinity/alkalinity Noiii Quality of surface and ground water Noiv Groundwater recharge No, However, groundwater

table will improve in the down-stream areas of the proposedreservoirs.

v Health hazard-water borne diseases,industrial pollution, etc.

No

vi Submergence of important mineralsdeposits

No

vii Submergence ofmonuments/archeological sites

No

viii Fish culture and aquatic life Yes, the same will be improvedconsiderably due to the creationof six reservoirs.

ix Plant life (flora) Nox Wild Life Noxi Migratory birds No, same will be improvedxii National Park and sanctuaries Noxiii Seismicity due to filling of reservoir No

xxx

xiv Likely change in the regime of theriver

No

xv Any other No(b) Have the environmental and forestclearance from MoE&F beenobtained? If not what is statusthereof?

The Ministry vide letter No.J-12011/55/2008-IA.I, dated 8th

June 2009 accorded clearancefor pre-construction activities atthe proposed site as per theprovisions of EIA Notification-2006 alongwith the TORs forpreparation of EIA report. Finalclearance will be obtained aftercompletion of DPR.

XXIV Colonies and Buildings132 Has the planning of the

colony/building been done keeping inview the ultimate use for optimumutilization of the investment?

Yes

133 Has an estimate of the extent ofhigher cost involved been made anddetails discussed?

Yes

134 Are the permanent buildings beingconstructed required for maintenanceof the project only?

Yes

135 Can the buildings other than requiredfor maintenance of the project beingconstructed be put to some other useafter the completion of the project bythe department or any other agencies?

Yes

136 Have the interested agencies beenconsulted in planning of the buildingsto suit their requirements later on?

Not yet

137 Have the proposals for disposal oftemporary buildings been discussed?

Yes

XXV Public participation andCooperation

xxxi

138 Are the possibilities of these beendiscussed in:(a) Planning Yes(b) Construction No(c) Improved agricultural practices Yes

139 Have public debates about utility ofprojects been held and the responsethereof outlined in the Report?

Not yet

XXVI Soil Conservation140 Is the need for soil conservation

measures in the catchment of theproject discussed?

Yes

xxxii

detailed project report of par-tapi-narmada link project...

Documents