department of political science college of social...

160
Department of Political Science College of Social Science National Taiwan University master thesis 19922012 The Study of Cross-Strait Political Mutual Trust1992-2012 Chen An-Kuo Advisor: Chang Ya-Chung, Ph.D. 101 6 June, 2012

Upload: others

Post on 01-Jun-2020

6 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Department of Political Science College of Social Sciencentupoli.s3.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/finalP9532… · Department of Political Science College of Social Science

���������� ��

����

Department of Political Science

College of Social Science

National Taiwan University

master thesis

��� ������1992�2012��

The Study of Cross-Strait Political Mutual Trust�1992-2012�

���

Chen An-Kuo

� !"#$%& '�

Advisor: Chang Ya-Chung, Ph.D.

& ( ) � 101 � 6 *

June, 2012

Page 2: Department of Political Science College of Social Sciencentupoli.s3.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/finalP9532… · Department of Political Science College of Social Science

I

+,+,+,+,----

��� 1949������ �������������������� !"

#�$% 1987� 11& 2'()*+,-.#/01���*2345678�9� 1995

�: 2008��;�<=�>?@�AB�6CD��EF�GHI�JKLMNO���

PQB�RSTUVWX2008 � 5 & 20 '�YZ[\]�^_�`a�b[cd�e6

fg��hijklm�nopqbrstu�*vwxyz{|}�~�I�e6 16�

��������6��d�X2009�������`����b������PQ��

�2���ut��,��#k�e6�����Y��6 }��¡¢�£¤:¥7�

¦§¨©ª�«¬­®�¯�°±² ³��b´µJKe6¶·X¸����6J�¹

º»¼½¾x�¿ÀÁXk� 2012�YZ[\]Â^ÃÄ�ÅÆ3��=�Ç�ÈÉ6Ê

ËX

9Ì���¿ÍÎÏ��ÐÑÒÓÔ�XY��¹ÕÖ×ÃØÙ6��|}��#/

�Ú��bÛptÜe�bÝ¡Þ�_���´µe¹`ß�?Ìàáâ¹��PQãäå

Îfg6æçèéF�êëì¤í��b�î�¦eï�¶·6Çð¨ñò}·�óôz{

äxyõ#/�ª�´µ�¦ö÷=�6øùúwû��PQ�üõѬýþX¯u�I

������ò�í:�ï�}·6��­����� �,6����¹����

��3­��è��wx��6JK�¸�����2�¹­�X

û���£� !"b��JK#}$%6&'e�b()��JKñ#µ*!+e�b,�

��(-VPQ���ØÙ()û.0/e³01bK�2345e�b6Ä7`8e�b9

:2;`8e¨¦öPQ<=>?@A�B��0C����JKuD� ¤ÏEF�<¹

���ÚGC HI¹JÉ6sKX

PLMPLMPLMPLMNNNN��JK��JK��JK��JK����[cd�[cd�[cd�[cd�����K�2345K�2345K�2345K�2345����6Ä7`86Ä7`86Ä7`86Ä7`8����9:2;`89:2;`89:2;`89:2;`8

Page 3: Department of Political Science College of Social Sciencentupoli.s3.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/finalP9532… · Department of Political Science College of Social Science

II

....--------////----

O�PQ:R�STTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTI

UVTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTII

�£WòTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTIII

Z£WòTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTIV

X�Y Z=TTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTT1

X�[ GC�A�\6TTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTT1

Xc[] GC�^�_;TTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTT5

X-[] GC`a�b�TTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTT11

XcY £c&'TTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTT13

X�[ <=0/TTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTT13

Xc[] ��JKGC£cd/TTTTTTTTTTTTTTTT35

X-[] ��JK#}$%&'TTTTTTTTTTTTTTTT45

X-Y] ��JKÏev�fg@1992h1999 �BTTTTTTTTTT58

X�[] evi<TTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTT58

Xc[] fgjkTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTT70

X-[] lmTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTT85

XnY] ��JKÏoÇ�pA@2000h2012 �BTTTTTTTTTT88

X�[] oÇ"%TTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTT88

Xc[] pA:xTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTT101

X-[] lmTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTT104

XqY] ��JK()û.³uDEF0/TTTTTTTTTTTTT108

Page 4: Department of Political Science College of Social Sciencentupoli.s3.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/finalP9532… · Department of Political Science College of Social Science

III

X�[ ()û.0/TTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTT108

Xc[ uDEF0/TTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTT132

X�Y] m=TTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTT142

rs£cTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTT153

-

-

-

-

-

-

-

-

-

Page 5: Department of Political Science College of Social Sciencentupoli.s3.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/finalP9532… · Department of Political Science College of Social Science

IV

01.01.01.01.////----

tttt] ]] ]] ]] ] uuuu]]]]

t 2-1N$uvÛúw£*xØy�ztTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTT22

t 2-2N��{b23JKeÏñò|=}~@1992h2012�BTTTTT45

t 3-1Nm�����Ï 9u��4G:ØyWòTTTTTTTTTTT67

t 4-1N$ub��:�e��ztTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTT102

t 5-1N��¡¢78]�t@1992h2011�BTTTTTTTTTTTT113

t 5-2N98� 5& 1h2'b,-6����³��É�e,���TTT118

t 5-3N�j��j����TTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTT137

]]]]

] ]] ]] ]] ] uuuu]]]]

1-1NGC_; TTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTT10

4-1N������ TTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTT96

5-1N����JK`ò()û.0/_;TTTTTTTTTTTTT108

5-2N()���,�M#/���u]� TTTTTTTTTTTT111

5-3N#/���,ï�x(�u]� TTTTTTTTTTTTTT111

5-4N#/���,x(M�\��u]� TTTTTTTTTTTT112

5-5N#/���,¡l-�M���u]� TTTTTTTTTTT112

5-6N(),-�]���3�ÛptÜ6Í^TTTTTTTTTTT115

----

Page 6: Department of Political Science College of Social Sciencentupoli.s3.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/finalP9532… · Department of Political Science College of Social Science

1

234234234234---- 5�5�5�5�----

236236236236--------��789.:��789.:��789.:��789.:----

;;;;<<<<��78��78��78��78----

b²�tu��tu����Ee�Ì��(�������,ª�b ×����6

��PQe¡�îñò¢·¬�Ñ6í£��í�¤Ì¥¦§p6¨©X�$�6ª«x

Í�1949 � 10 &��¦#/¬­®¯�d°±�²2�ÃÄ�¦,±��³�´(�%

�õ_()�µ���M3¶i<6��Ü�X

� ·�x�I�$¡3¸¹ºº�´µ�»�*+²¼�¡¢½x�78lm¨"

%XǾ�01�#/¿À*+���,-PQ'Á45�«�¡ÞÃÔ� ��ÄÄ

ÅÆÇ����ÈÉq�Ç��Ê���6�D���9� 1995h1996�b(�ËÌT

Ae�1999 �ÍÎÏ�\] �b�¦=e�2002 ��ÐÑ�\]6b�V�¦=e�2005

�#/��bC�Ò¦Ó^e¨CD��Ô��EF6�ÕÖ×ä�Ç�3��PQ��

Ø�ÐÙÚ�­��6ÛɵuXÜt()�µÐ�ÉÝ;Þ�ßà�1á�¦�¨nâ

ãä��â7å�´µºº6Â�Ï�X2

æÌÏÜ�¶i=�x�0/ü�()�µç|�ÕÖ´µºº�ÑÖ�����2

66èÄ<=�é��#}�ù¦ö³ãä�ê��GC6ÇëX¯��bëì23nì

¤��JKe@í���´µ�ªBÏâîèïô ³�ðÙÌñ�Âò}·Ï��¯ñò

è­|âóX

90 �ôõ�(���ö/Æ�t#÷2;bK�2345e@Confidence Building

Measures�CBMsB6�ø�9¸¹ù�ÐÙúú�û�bè%ÚJ+�e�büýþ�)�

­��äxe6���C¯¨>�u�û?"�c ·�xI�b`²e��wÇ�JK

1 àf��ß�ºº6PL�?�� ��Ï`²y1974��_�àf�í¹>ß���6�� �Øá�������õs¯¹�Ù6à¦���û��&�� �¹¯ï���X2 UK Heo/Shale A. Horowitz�vConflict in Asia;Korea, China-Taiwan, and India-Pakistanx�(��¦§Ù����½�,¦ 97��� 7X

Page 7: Department of Political Science College of Social Sciencentupoli.s3.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/finalP9532… · Department of Political Science College of Social Science

2

fg��¬�X3

% 2008� 5&()cu�±� �YZ[Ý�{^��,¦X c^\]_���¥

7!"�ñ#b[cd�e�4*$lm#ò�n%ÃÄ���3àáµ&èéF�5I�P

Q�M36õ�ü6jkX9wx��PQ6�2°ÔÑ�îñ#6®'�(b��®´e

¶·XÃ)$�¡*�+��������,-®¤�.ë�b()�t3X-u�±� e

�b#/Xqô�÷�6���Ú/0e¨�üò^��6��1��¦���¿®�©

3 CBMs �()�ª�2? 1991 � 2 & 13 'î�3¶456t�I�â78l}�9ù:�Ü�XÍÎÏ\]? 1995� 4& 8'&�b�;�ei ���`a�í¹�d�ÝÔ<+=�(G1¸>�?�ëìm@:�Ü�X2000��ÐÑ�A\]_�(`a��Ñ¥ò23b´µJKA�e�B�C��? 2004¨��¦§DES�X2008�YZ[\]��_�pÆF⹦§�ÚÏ��G�? 2009��2010¨��¦§DES�X�#/�ª�1979��& 1'��d�#HP:bE()�ISeJÝ }��!"m�m@´µ�»Ü�X�iÌKLMl�b�¦�����]�e6�(ÚNX�_�/Æ�?�O,����¨

�÷�6���X.ëN1995� 1& 30'6b�;�eÆ`am@:�Ü��2004� 5& 17'��(P�¦(P6bq�QøGe� �b23´µJKA�e�2008 � 12 & 31 '�b���e�t_��d*2G1b��´µRSJKA�eTôb´µJKA�eX2010 �6¦§UVSJub´µRSJKA�ewM¯¦§�ÚX

�ëW�ª�()% 1996�õ�*2GCXR:}6bK�2345e��õ0/23(�´µJK645�âîèX4 b[cd�eY 1992 � 11 &#/6b��PQl:e�()6b�µ78fZ:e{Çð�:µ&èm��ëìtG§p�î�¦¨©6��¶·¬[Ã6bè%e�O\��t[6b�µ��]§p�î�¦

¨©e6d�X1992� 10& 28'¸ 30'��:�^_m���{�µ��µ&è@`aSG1Bm��ëìtb§p�î�¦¨©6¶·�î3/=X

�l6f���Ì��µ��7½�6B�¶·Ì�¦6ØÙµ&���q�î�¦¨©lmÇðX�µ

&èm���üòtG§p�î�¦¨©6f����â�­/=�î�¦6��c8�tb6��â�d

�lmX

�^_m����l: �3 5Ä£�tb��f:e)b¦]:e6m= �3 5Ä£�tb��f:$Ùú����`aSG1Ì�¦ØÙ6µ&�I�]�§p�î�¦6¨©�nt[3��¦Ó]�6f

g�9�£�tb�h���:ij[Ã��X�:�(m@i��f:ôtk� 3 3Ätb���nl_tbNb��µ��d�m>��¦Ó]�6"%��I�$]§p�î�¦6¨©�9�?�î�¦6

c8�í£èÑ­�Xno?��,=78'pq�¹rs���,²��?£S�a����tuÇ

ðXe°2}b1è%O\øG6��tb�î�¦¨©e��lôtt�¡Ì�um�6`òÃ��¨v�

f:62}�B�tbØyDE_?r�wkX

1992 � 11 & 16 '��l:r��x�f:t�Nb�¡uéFèm���y:ôt2}�ÚJzÇ6� ä�{1y|�:è%O\øG6��tb�î�¦¨©�n �3B�tbØy�¯�G�3�µ��

]§p�î�¦6¨©…|:d�}ñn²�y:62}…t|:~FO\tb6ò�xEy:��µ���§p�î�¦6¨©�m>��¦Ó6]�X9��µ��µ&èm���­�³�î�¦6��c8X

��������`aSG1@�¯�m�µ&B��tuÇð�eX�l6x_n��3�f:l_ H6

tb�hX12& 3'��f:&x�l��[Ãd�wt��}X¸��P?�î�¦¨©tb¶·6/=���ÃI�ÚJ²�@J­�íB6�kB�tbØy¹m�õE�k�X5 %Y\]�^_���¡" 7u6b��:�e�d7� 15�l}�1�d��®���±��±²���/ÛÉÁ�Z�LF���RS��Q�&LF�m�d*ía��°�d�d*�d�������^J

Ö����°²r���� �LF¨X¡¢x£N��,¦\]�¤¥X

Page 8: Department of Political Science College of Social Sciencentupoli.s3.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/finalP9532… · Department of Political Science College of Social Science

3

¹(���é%¦ä­��û.�()¸§Xû���tjkYZ[\]Â^ÃÄ�n

ÅÆåÎ��Ëa6¨Aä�ëì*2©�brs��tu�0ªI�JKe6X�«�

 ×�î­â¬6§ufg�­­yüX

®w�b�uDn ¤b����JKe�(�����6ñòè³�ë¯GC�6

��¨�°¹¼�GC�·\6õ��?¬�X

====<<<<��.:��.:��.:��.:----

YZ[\]¸±ö¡-u �Nbrstu�²æJK�z{|}�ÆvI�e6 16

�����t[¯���¶·6Í^y6õb23JK�z{|}���Ô��dvI�e

úÌ���`�­³´b6��J�¨©X>�|µâ�H£�b23@²æBJKe�Ì

��PQ�����26� �¥ò¶*X�£(·��¸ 20 �x@1992h2012 �B�

�JK6�2ܹº� M0/�nmLÚP£c�¦öPQ<=�� �» ×(��

1�6r��DX�¼=£½g[ÃÏB�GC\¾�¿bëÀN

@�B1991� 2&³ 12&�ÁÂôt��Ã��îlméF6bU�Äe�()�f�

#/�l¨�:�ÅÃ3���bJKA�eÆ�?Ç°�X1992 � 10 &b^_m�e

6"%(Ì�î23JK6î¹�¬[Ã6b[cd�e$Ù¸ÐÑb��ète�b�

�­te6éÈ÷=�9̯¹���� 40�_6X�îúÌlñò6��btle�bJ

Ke�úÌ���lm6fg�É«�8Xû��£� 1992��b[cd�eevI�J

K6i=�º¹GC����JK6$2���0C 20�x�¯ÊË6�2"%��û�

()�$�X

@cB��23JK6Ýð¶*@� B¹ìÌÍÎ`²û.Ïâ7èëì@ëb�

î�¦eÏ� �b~�¦Ó]�e\¾¨BÌ

@-Bb[cd�e6()X

@nBtjk|¦bÝ¡_�e@�bü¡­�eB6�ÚTD³,���(-VPQ

³()�#/ØÙû.����JK6()¹ìÌ

6 brstu�²æJK�z{|}�ÆvI�e16 �Ï|�¸±ö¡�t?YZ[Ý� 2008 � 5 &6\]{æÐÑ��� 9&²��­�Ý�³ 2009��A�¦¦,±`�ÏÒA:�X

Page 9: Department of Political Science College of Social Sciencentupoli.s3.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/finalP9532… · Department of Political Science College of Social Science

4

@qB�1bK�2345e6>?�0/23����JK6«Ó�A�X

@�B01¦öPQ<=Ïb@6BÄ7`8e@NeoÔFunctionalismB³b9:2;`

8e@Social ConstructivismB�0/����JKuD³ ¤EF���r¯ÏrD�2X

��âÕ\¾�¶·���PQ6�2��]BÑPLè()�õ%Ì�Ö�³ ¤

��JKéF�|µ¥¦º×6Ä¢��r¹�£¬g[:�ÃØÙ³2}Ïl9\6X

----

----

----

----

----

----

----

----

----

----

----

Page 10: Department of Political Science College of Social Sciencentupoli.s3.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/finalP9532… · Department of Political Science College of Social Science

5

2>2>2>2>6666--------��������?@?@?@?@9999ABABABAB----

;;;;<<<<��?@��?@��?@��?@----

�¼=£��01b$�GCeÚF�n�b£c�+e�b©u�+e³bÛÜGCe

º¹`òGC�^X

�����b�b�b�b$�GC$�GC$�GC$�GCeeeeÚFÚFÚFÚF

�9:Ýë6GC`Þ���ß�Ãàb¡*èe³bC`èe�¶`ß�îÏX�

b¡*èeGC�ª��á¶�µ��Çâ&ãä³�åæh¨���!"µu6�b�

ÑGµ*6�û_��n� ®w�¯<=^©Xõ�bC`èeGC�ª�©·�çè

uafg�2;éÆ�êë6<=é��ì)��íâ76�2X

�¼=£{1b¡*èe¹`ß6$�GCÚF�!"$�ë6î��ïgð>GC

"�¬��6µ*�����ñb¯®´6"%��õÇò¯�6û�PQ�n%óâ�

­�i÷¬ôõÏ��ö$�µu�é�¯÷��23�©@generalizationB��ø@lawBX

f?�£GC`aNb(���e6÷�è��êè�01b$�hm;e6GC3ùy

�3ùúL?û�Ú�ê6~��`ò�Ú6�ܹ@m;èb�B�wxâî6�Ú

�DÏGC�nâY�tÆ¥6m;èû.�Ù_�L?��@�£Y���()�#/B

ÏèØ�õ¹�Ú2}X{1�3ùGCÏ3��?ÕÖbüx`8e³b¥¦&ýÛÜ

�e6þ�X

û���GC��Ç��µu�¶·�x��ª�b�è6û.��¥rs¦ö¬2

36`��^��¦Ø¥BôtëA6ÚP=b¨��¹�£ØÙ�2}r)X

cccc����£c�+^£c�+^£c�+^£c�+^NNNN

�¼=£���6b£c�+^e ¹`òGC�^X£cÌYbBÑ$���6 S

£�¡¢�F®�tô9:6 S�æh����¯�ø��Ý �D���

�³è��6 S¡¢��æh��³��¬��6�5£����� ��ø��(�

¨�^Òää6èÄÑ$���6£���e�nb��]õÛÉ6W����n¿LaG

Page 11: Department of Political Science College of Social Sciencentupoli.s3.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/finalP9532… · Department of Political Science College of Social Science

6

6�^�3Ç"����t��ØÙwxeX7

£c6Äöâ�¹N@�B�u£c@(ö¡$"÷ŵ*�î¹A���6\�ñb

�G1¯���6u¹�ä�Ìw¡�t�Ñ�� <6l¨26¡¢�primary docu-

mentsBX@cB�u£c@±²Òäµ*¡"�GCÃ��6£��6 ¯6!q�=£�

��DE¨£cBX@-Bcu£c@dªè£cBX@nB-u£c@��1cu£cdª

6fg����u£c�î�]6~<n>�=b6£cBX

�¥�£c¿b6ò�`òÑ 6 �N@�Bôõ£c��ÛÉ�SªX@cB"¢��

=òl����X@-B��èìX@nB #$��º�ñ�X@qBú�G1]� tX

@�B­7%&£c�6É��FAî�6'(X

û���¼=£�!"èÄ)Ô�¢�Ã��*��S+�<��=£�DY,-�

¤E@í��¤¥B¨ÚP¡¢���~<��+�GCX� <¡¢6"%�ô.���

¦ö6£c���GC6/�� �XÜâ��t�£èY[°0#1G1£c¡¢6ô

õ��+�®w¨���ì��î2�è6�+GC��0/tî|¦³#/�Ú³¦ö

1����PQÏ()n �Bu1è6�Ú2}X

----����©u�+^©u�+^©u�+^©u�+^����ÛÜGC^ÛÜGC^ÛÜGC^ÛÜGC^

9:Ýë¤H�b©u�+e@level of analysisB6î���¦ö��¶·2*É��

0/�ð�b3�³45­�6�+©u�GH¬É�6tÆH:ÇòeX.ëbî�e�b¦

Óe³b¦öe¨ 3 î©u_;ó/¹ëW61Xû����GC��¤ð>b©u�+

^e0/()��JKÏ7@�ò�¨X

�¥��GC¤01bÛÜGC^e�¬H¡¢�îñb�8ò�nÍ�Ûܨ 4î

jk6 <�ÑGëäN@�BñbN¬òÛÜGC¦ÓÏ�*Ft¹6ñbX@cB8

òN�+è¦��*6�Ãû.���ǯ�2ª«X@-BnÍNâÛÜ6¡¢���

]¤6Íâ���ª�óÛÜy��ªâ����GC93X@nBÛÜNY�è¦6¡¢

:�C;GCÛÜ��<Hú5m=@(�=�auGC93BX

�£í¹��PQ�¯un­úúÔ�?()�#/6��Ï=�úÔ��#¦6J

7 >?@�>3@`��vGC�^�=£�Fx@(�NmA£¤�1999�B�� 139-140X

Page 12: Department of Political Science College of Social Sciencentupoli.s3.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/finalP9532… · Department of Political Science College of Social Science

7

�Ï=�û�0/b,���(-VPQe³��ÚJÏ=6J�PQ��GC��PQ�

��JK6}·��{ù¥ò6¶*X¬��GC�­�6�+©u�¡¢ñb�8

ò�ÛÜ��<<H�Å�âB6m=Xû���£ðÉ�¦ö=ÚPF¹��+�ÛÜ

¯r�Áª()�T^¯¡*�ì¹�GCÏ�Ú2} H=bÃ)X

====<<<<��AB��AB��AB��AB----

�Y[RÍÙ���¼=£����Y�Øy>bë_N

X�Y�¹�¼=£ÏbZ=eÙ��Q�GCÏ�A�\6�GC�^�_;�

`a�b�¨C�=b�qñ?¶·6 ��GC\¾Ï8�¨X�¼=£��{1b$

�GCeÚF�n�b£c�+e�b©u�+e³bÛÜGCe¨º¹`òGC�^X

XcY�D²bZ=e�*2�Mb�=eÙ��}~tbbK�2345e�b@6B

Ä7`8e�b9:2;`8e¨Øc�>?�ì¹_ÆGC�t H<=Ã)X�YqE

?@îª�Ä7è�u&è¡*6=b��F���ÚP#}6J��2��+0C¯¨

û�`ò\6�bG±wxHI��6A:eXñ�®�N@�B�b><=ßa@î�Ä7�

ð¡*�+ÃJ³÷�e�\6NÑ«úL@²¸B?���¹6é��n·�¡Ké�

��¬éL�x6>?��©01:��JKÏ2;�x�ïgû�<HI M6<ÇX

@cB�0/��ëA!ÓGCJKÏÚP£c�M��ö�Ûܯ��Ï �nº�èÓ

É��ìð)Ñ6ë¯Ã��du�£=bX@-B�É���+.a@ëN��JK#}

$%BèÄF¹6()�mL<=�ì¹�£²ÆY[ H=bÃ)X

X-Y�% 1991�b¦]#�eNO�P�wx��,¦���¦Ó]�¹9ç\¾

_�8õ 1992� 10&��f��l�:�^_�îµ&èlm�I�{b�î�¦e}·

¬Q�6�ÂRJ��[Ãb[cd�e³_xbn�µ&èl}6[ÃeX9�Y�´b

8 1991 ���i^��,¦\]ÍÎÏ`pä6b¦Ó]�PQ:e�"3v¦Ó]�#�x��v¦Ó]�#�x���Ñb()ST�¦�Ù��#/úÌ�¦6�Ù�e¡U6Ñ^X9 ÌY� 1993� 4& 27'¸ 4& 29'<=�>��,¦�ª6�µ78fZ:@(b�f:eBVµ¶WXY�����,d�¦�ª6�µ��PQl:@(b�l:eB:¶Z[c?6�\¬Õî6:�@]X

�uWZ:��X�uZW:�BXWZ:�úÌ�µ��% 1949���,¦��´(�x�J��î6r�Ã�^:_X¡"ÂÆ 3`4õlm�I�� 4& 29'�a7���`aS�al}���b�x*�cdeµfl}��:gh�:���l}��³WZ:�d�l}¨ 4�µ&èl}�õ��>�½i²6�jA��Æk��PQ6Çl��2�6õ¦ö9:m\X

Page 13: Department of Political Science College of Social Sciencentupoli.s3.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/finalP9532… · Department of Political Science College of Social Science

8

¯Øc�n>è�$�è£*�D÷��µ�Òb@ObB¡¢¨�ßa�£¯â¹b�

�JKeevPLϨ>X

²Æ=b% 1993h1999�<=��ÍÎÏÝ�`�ä���PQ$¡3b��4Gµ

*e�10b�Ynäo!áe�11bp� Ïîe�b(�ËÌTAe12�b�¦=e@÷�¦

�¦PQB13¨µ*¬°�6r�Cªq�Ïä�Y2;%r�s�6��JKªS3¾t

fg�n��#/�ª6��45³,¦6TA <�ÍÎÏÝ�6��EF¨ªD0/

¯�A�¨û�()X

XnY�2000h2008�=��ÐÑÝ�u^��,¦X ³X �^\]�,�±�

�@���Ô�bn­�vÑe14*2�:bÕ���e�b����e@�V�¦=B�15b�

10 b��4Gµ*e�Ì> 2000 � 7 & 24 '��6m�w�@X���<B¬��6X¯�b��4�#xÁe¹·6yªÜµ�>z{^_6|ëGCA�úÌ�i¹��}~6PL��á��Ob�?>¯�

���'�à 1�á�6£��t�n���i��4G4�i6áa�¿Xá��6ObY��1990�O�()\]�P`�`^�?@�¡>¯RÍ���i�¦#/�(éFl�P`�`^�����¯^_�

¬�4:_X¯�ܹñò6Ì�()���4�ôt��i^æ�Ó�s��_x�^��òæ6��s�

ö� 1991�:����ó�:ªyõ�?@úö� 1992�?^_��¦�l::¶Z[c:_X"¸� 1992� 8&��¦#/64�ôtÏ�à��ö�01�8:()�ª�ÍÎÏX11 1994� 3&�ÍÎÏ\]�\]�²�'���FÓ�Ynäo@��N����B6!á��_�b�¹()�6��e¹`·¶�3 6îáliXS£�Î? 1994� 5& 56'�vÉ'��xX12 1995� 6&���,¦ÍÎÏ\]á¶,¦p� #ë��b,Ϭ��¶�|�e¹·�tÐÑXÍÎÏ��Ã�³� 6¡¢M�,¦�#/�½�,¦£àÍÎÏá,�µ�t[ì-¤}�í¹,¦¥C,

�v-îgL`Dx6¨©�¾ñ¦§¯`²�nì-�=ÍÎÏ�p� #ë6Ð�X1995� 8& 23'�ÍÎÏr�ÔOrA��,¦Ju\]±AX�¦#/? 1995� 7& 21'¸ 1996� 3& 25'�d�î 7u-´gLFgШ��()á��ê�îËÌ�©��/f�ªf�î�÷ËÌ©�n�î�äï��å�

I? 3& 23'\]±A�«�¬��(6´µ¸>­®X,¦©? 1996� 3& 8'ÔO�3��¯g°��î()±�¸��n? 3 & 11 '%Õ�)��²�³��¯g°��½()�ê��3�:LX3 & 23'�\]#Am@y6&ä´�d´´µÐ¨9ùX13 �¦=��]÷��¦=�Y(�i= 1999 � 7 & 9 'äa��i��,¦\]ÍÎϲ��¦Ïøä(!ái��?()��¦ÏPQ6�î8òX(N1991��_µ¶Ï_��¦Ó��`ab�?(�·�Z�Y�r¸\]�¦:}Qúú¹()��A��nú�í���,d�¦6L^èX()��¦6PQ

i{¡Ìb¦Ó�¦Óe��b¸±Ì÷�6¦@stateB�¦@stateB6PQe�õ�b�L^����¹º��e��b��»��������e6b�î�¦eØÙPQy�¦i= 1999� 7& 25' 21i~��¦Ïø6Z¼ ½p[DS¾W¿+!áØy�õ£�Øy©�Î��¦6v�'¾WDxX14 ��,¦X ^\]�ÐÑ� 2000� 5& 20'{æ�À��t6P?()]�¶·6|=�Ì����PQ6ñò����i�ÐÑ�{æÐÑ�t�Nbüò�d«��(�¸���ra�^<ÏØ�­:Ô<

�3�­:I¿¦��­:���¦=M¶�­:��¿®tÜ6]�`¦�úÁÑÂΦ]#��¦]:

6¶·Xe15 ÌYí�()�#/­���¦Ó6`a�liÌ�3^PQÃÄÅ?XcÆ3^PQAÕi ��_?

2002� 8& 2'¹i^��,¦\]6�ÐÑ�'�±�Õî6¾W()�Ç:Xc [Æ�:���(�!"sÈ:}�|D�:�� �X

Page 14: Department of Political Science College of Social Sciencentupoli.s3.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/finalP9532… · Department of Political Science College of Social Science

9

���Ée¨÷�����JKÉSoÇX16�Y{ñ�?#/�,¦�ª6C��()6

��EFªD¨�+¯�A�¨û�()X

²Æ0/ 2008� 5&()cu�±� �YZ[Ý�{^��,¦X c^\]��

�¥7!"�ñ#b[cd�e�*$lm#ò�n%ÃÄ���3àáµ&èéF�I�

PQ�M36õ�ü6jk���JK*2ñ2XÙõ�Y��¹ÕÖ×ÃØÙ6��|

}�9:�Ê��#/�Ú��bÛptÜe�bÝ¡Þ�_���´µe¹`ßX9ÌbÝ

¡_�e�"�bü¡­�e6�Ú��wx6��JK���PQ6�����26Ö

ëìÌÌ�Y¬ËÌ6X�îñ�XXcîñ�©Ì 2008�¸���PQ$Ù ?À

Áñt6Ü��9ÌÐÑ��Ô��ëNtjk6b[cd�eÌ�×ÍÎÏ��JK6

åè�2X��êßû.�?����JK6 ¤BÑPLè6()�¤Ì�£bm=e

Ù�)�=aÏñòe)X

XqY���ªY[6<=0/nßa��{JK�ªÏJ�@uö�¹B¹=bf

g�GCb��JKuD� ¤ÏEFe�n��¹bg¯©ªeN�bK�2345e6

>?�@6BÄ7`8É�5M�`òqÐ?b23A�e�buDJKeXbgN©ªeN�

9:2;`8î�5M�`òqÐ?b ¤JKeX²ÆwMb,���(-VPQe@¦

Ó©uB6()û.0/�ìÉÑ�GCÏ=�³ØyX

X�Y�¹�¼=£Ïbm=eÙ��Ã)�¼=£�*êY[6G+³=b�\m�

®wuD³ ¤����JK6Ã�@m>�DB¨y�Y6Ì��?·� �����

��,wx�ëìº@b�ÙeÏÙ��<èAÒé�BÓ7��nÛÔ()�#/6��

JK��õ�r��PQ6���2@@@@�¼=£�¼=£�¼=£�¼=£GC_;ë GC_;ë GC_;ë GC_;ë 1-1BBBBX

16 b����Ée(�()í�õ�?í��V�í��¦�í�ãÕ�í�¾W6�Ä£��2_;X�

���É6 ����*2óYD$�Ö×�õ­Ì�ľØ�86$�GC�¯ë¯fg�±Ü¹��X

�ë¯WxÍ��Ñnw23�ëW¶<Ù46GCÏ��¬��*2 �_�óÚ�­±Ø�X

Page 15: Department of Political Science College of Social Sciencentupoli.s3.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/finalP9532… · Department of Political Science College of Social Science

10

----

----

----

��������������������������������������������������������

�����CD�����CD�����CD�����CD####�����CD�����CD�����CD�����CD####

�EFG<H3I&�J�KL<M>�EFG<H3I&�J�KL<M>

NO<��PQRSNO<��PQRS

H�TU�VWJ<H�TU�VWJ<

�X�YZ[L<��X�YZ[L<�

UB[L�\]9UB[L�\]9

^�<�����_^�<�����_

`a<����bc`a<����bc

defgdefg

�����hi�����hi�����hi�����hi####�����hi�����hi�����hi�����hi####

jklmnop<qrspt<�uvjklmnop<qrspt<�uv

wx8y<���wx8y<���

�����z{�����z{�����z{�����z{####�����z{�����z{�����z{�����z{####

|}~3&���3&�3�3�|}~3&���3&�3�3�

��<�T�����<�T���

������8������8������8������8####������8������8������8������8####

��M>NO<�����<��M>NO<�����<77�~9�~9

1515��c<��c<11�NO�NO

�������� ��������

19921992��������

19931993

��������

19991999��������

20002000

��������

20082008��������

20082008

��������

20122012��������

����������������

������9�������9�

���a���a

����#���� ¡^����#���� ¡^

11111-1:��AB1��AB1��AB1��AB1 ��������������������������������������������������������

�����CD�����CD�����CD�����CD####�����CD�����CD�����CD�����CD####

�EFG<H3I&�J�KL<M>�EFG<H3I&�J�KL<M>

NO<��PQRSNO<��PQRS

H�TU�VWJ<H�TU�VWJ<

�X�YZ[L<��X�YZ[L<�

UB[L�\]9UB[L�\]9

^�<�����_^�<�����_

`a<����bc`a<����bc

defgdefg

�����hi�����hi�����hi�����hi####�����hi�����hi�����hi�����hi####

jklmnop<qrspt<�uvjklmnop<qrspt<�uv

wx8y<���wx8y<���

�����z{�����z{�����z{�����z{####�����z{�����z{�����z{�����z{####

|}~3&���3&�3�3�|}~3&���3&�3�3�

��<�T�����<�T���

������8������8������8������8####������8������8������8������8####

��M>NO<�����<��M>NO<�����<77�~9�~9

1515��c<��c<11�NO�NO

�������� ��������

19921992��������

19931993

��������

19991999��������

20002000

��������

20082008��������

20082008

��������

20122012��������

����������������

������9�������9�

���a���a

����#���� ¡^����#���� ¡^

11111-1:��AB1��AB1��AB1��AB1

Page 16: Department of Political Science College of Social Sciencentupoli.s3.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/finalP9532… · Department of Political Science College of Social Science

11

2¢62¢62¢62¢6--------��������£¤9¥¦£¤9¥¦£¤9¥¦£¤9¥¦----

;;;;<<<<��£¤��£¤��£¤��£¤----

{�ª�xÍ�bJKe{ÌbÚJK^e�b��ÚKeX�tu©ªxÍ��J�

6I�Ï����6|îÌ�Ñ�?�ѧ?���6��ë��¡Ù�I�Ìâ�Ú

JØ<6�(âí¹I�Ï=Ô�JK��©ó­Ô�X�¥�ë�7ÛØ<:��6|

îÑ�?@¸±«§?B���âv�ÄJKW�¹bæçJKeyCÏ�ë�7Û

Ø<:��6|îѧ?���©v¡ÄJK®öÌbÜçJKeX�b³@�Y

X�[B�1992� 10&��f��l�:?^_{ÑP��£S�a}·6lm³¯_Æ

J��(¹�îb23JKe6î¹�¤¹��b��JKe6*ÝXû��¼=£ÏG

C�i=`a�Q� 1992 �¸¹ù�� 20 �6i=Ø��î��JK6GC�nÏ

��Nev@1992 �B�fg@1993h1999 �B�oÇ@2000h2008 �B³pA@2008h

2012�B¨ 4îjkX

�}·GC`a�ª�©��ë_N@�B��£`òËÌ?b��JKe�ª�n�

ÚP=b�GC³£cd/�ª�©��bK�2345e@b´µJKA�e�b´µ

RSJKA�eBÏÙ�`awMX@cB��¦ö�ÏbK�2345e�b@6BÄ7`8e�

b9:2;`8eÏØc�õ�n}~tbÚP£c�ëA=�¨�¹_ÆGC�t H

<=Ã)X@-B�b[cd�e­úÌ��23JK6$2��I���6��ØÙ��¸

¦öí£��ù3(������26ô�MXû�0/ 1992��6 20���b[c

d�e6Øc�()³wx�2¨�¹�£ñò6GC`ÞX@nB�{(���6��J

�õ|�GC��£¬cÞ6 20���()ØÙêá6��EF�ñ#ÚPµ*6�A�

ß೯���JK6()¨�n��#/�ª6��45³,¦6TA <¨�ªu5

0/X@qB�0/()��JKÏ¥Ù@,���(-VPQB³ØÙû.X@�B�0/

tî�Ú�?_Æ6����JK�26()Xn�bK�2345e�b@6BÄ7`8e

6É�³b9:2;`8e6î��xGC��JK6uD� ¤EFy¯\6�áSn

¤()�#/6��JK��õ�r��PQ6���2X

Page 17: Department of Political Science College of Social Sciencentupoli.s3.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/finalP9532… · Department of Political Science College of Social Science

12

====<<<<��¥¦��¥¦��¥¦��¥¦----

�b��ª��£â?ë�î�´æ¡¢�«^ãá�¦#/ÚPë¯����êØ

ÏëA!Ó"�ðÚÃQ�ÜÍÎbá�e�b¶äe¨ua���õ�ô~ÚPqF�=

���ÚÔ�³`*Ã�£*¨TôÏ�ì��ÅÉ~X�¥��#/Ù���?ÚP}

·6,���¡¢«^Ñq<H�j¹GCÏr)y�()�ª�©>?¡¢åæ�n«

�¨b�X

�¥�bK�2345e$�¦ö=Ô�ÑÚ�á6�1³uDh.�"¸�(��

�Ï=×Ã3�ç¬è�9Ì�uö�ÚP6!Sn­á��0/��JKÏ�ê¤�y

#Ù�6qFQ�t?<��ë¯G/:!·�=£¨�Ç����ª6 Mõ/éè6

GCóÑi#6�2÷=�ú���ê¯ëì6_õA×Ã3��6fgX

�£0/¥Ùû.���JK67@�ò�Ù��Q�,���(-VPQ¹`�n

ws1¯�첦Ó�¦ö��@íu^��B6()yõ�(���ë��÷%H¿í

,6$��m³��1�ä�¦öÏ=ój��7cÞSî6öÈh.��#/�|¦Ï

��JKGC�Ãs*X

Page 18: Department of Political Science College of Social Sciencentupoli.s3.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/finalP9532… · Department of Political Science College of Social Science

13

2>42>42>42>4---- �_�_�_�_fgfgfgfg----

��£GC����JK¬01Ï<=@A�B³£c�ª�Q�¦ö�6bK�2

345e@CBMsB�b@6BÄ7`8e³b9:2;`8e¹`�ð<=@A�BÏ>?Ø

c���ÚP�êØGCÃ�@!£�qFB�¸ 20�x��JK#}$%��0/uD�

¤��JK6EF�ì¹GC�t³�£_ÆY[ H=bfgX

236236236236--------^��a^��a^��a^��a----

;;;;<<<<�TU�VW�TU�VW�TU�VW�TU�VW----

bK�2345e���MÌ� 20 ¾� 70 �ô*2G1�9@îé��A�ïi

Ô�?¦ö��Ï��ëX�u¾W#g_¹b��´´Ñ�2�>Z�,�'�^�8

¨ 5¦? 1922� 2& 678Ïv�´´Ñ¶�x@Naval Armaments TreatyB� 1930�6bð

ñ�´:}e@London Naval ConferenceB�°Ì CBMs6B�ttyõ� 1962�bòàT

Ae@Cuban CrisisB_�,��Ï=¹3ÕÖ��6Ij�� 1963�[Ãl}�33bÂ

~e@hotlineBlBÑôtèX

>�bâ£�CBMs Ìð>IV�áV´µ786÷�RÍ��ó��<Ç�23K

^�ÕÖIj��³ó�ºº6â7è��õ[:m@:�Ü��7���l}6\6X

le�CBMs 6>?Ìú�´µ©ª�6uö¡*¬®wõx�õ_���ô�¥7ÃF

1ÚP>?�F^�nì¤����¥7�ª6q��1�ا��ºº6â7Xõ{

CBMsÏöÀ�Øc³¨ªD�î£c&'�<=0/X

ëA!Ó�? CBMs 6�2$%�C÷�ìi¹GCõ�èѯÉ�X�ßÌ�

1975�1986�vø ùfl9}�Sx@Helsinki Final ActB2{iõ�� 3jk=by17Ù

õ�¤Ñí¹¥¦�úge<º¹fg�n%�b¾ôe@generationBx��A�¯bK

�2345eÏ$��2��¹nî¾ô�X�ôÏ CBMs¹úgi<,���¦� 1972

17 �¾Å�v¦öPQN²>���xe*�@(�N��£¤µ�Ñb`��1998� 10& 1'B�� 8h11yûÉü�b��K�2345ý}e�vþàfZ:��x�XnäX�<@2003� 1&B�� 66h72X

Page 19: Department of Political Science College of Social Sciencentupoli.s3.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/finalP9532… · Department of Political Science College of Social Science

14

��ÏJ��¯·-î¾ô6��©��AÚ�y18h�cA$2�­��Ù¯=bØcn

«��X�äõ{ CBMsèjk@¾ôBÏ�2��bë_N

��������1955�1972����NNNN19

Xcu¾W#gGHXÕ��3ç#6ô�X­ú¡ÞªSo�TA�¦ö����

Iû,���#�>ì>�M�ô�ù�ç�¤��ØÙÃQX�b�#�`��e

@The North Atlantic Treaty Organization�NATOB20�b��`��e@Warsaw Pact�

Warsaw Treaty OrganizationB21�#õ�Ã3�úgiôr�*2X

1950� 5& 9'�^¦¥¶ �@Robert SchumannB ���^�¦d� 0���

����r�ùÏrHH�����<H�i��\<���@Konrad AdenauerBÎpX

1951 � 4 & 18 '�Û�i�8#�����������³^¦¨ 6 ¦�d�7�vX

Õ��d��¶�x@The European Coal and Steel Community�ECSCB�22� 1952� 7& 25

'�q�XÕrC«ð>¡Þ6~L*$��A�X

õÙ�ëA¬í£6X�ô CBMs�Q� 1955�,��?'Ø�:}��>,¦\]

���@Dwight D. EisenhowerB2}7�v*+`÷¶�x@Open Skies TreatyB¹$2��23¯� 1962�6bòàTAe�GS¾W�LM3å�ï�#gÏ���û�,��Ï=¹

18 �/��b��23´µK^45âîèÏ0/e�vd±¶·GCx�Xc;äXQ<@2002� 7&B��32X19 � 4î¾ô��ÏX�ô@úgi<By�jk��A�©X�jk¹Xcô���ö�X20 >,�Z�^��ü#�Û�i� Þ�8#���������!"�#$%¨¦? 1949 � 4 & 4 '78�Mb�#�`��e@The North Atlantic Treaty Organization�NATOBX1952h1982��ï&��'¯�����(%ú/Æ�M��X��23Ï\6��rsè)�¦f?,`�%>³^�¨¨©Û

�d�*]�Ö���ÏR���+��õ�§ Ö����6���RSn§ù�g6±,X21 ��Ã3_���g¹J6d°¦Ó­f��y1954� 11& 29'h12& 2'�-�Ý@MoscowB>�g�±��Õ��.%��r��ã�/0�.Y²ã�1 à²ã¨¦�ÕîbXÕ¦Órs³XÕ��

�RS:}eX 1955� 5& 11'�Õ�J���@WarsawBÕîXcu:}�:_78v;¦ ÎLFJÖ¶�x@�]¹��`��Warsaw PactBX�`�ÏØy`ò¹N��`�è¦+Ú:2�è¦�ÚJÎ3X22 1951� 4& 18'�>^¦����Û�i�������³8#�¨ 6¦?à4783vXÕ��d��¶�x@¨]và4¶�xBÃ3q�6bXÕ��d��e@European Coal and Steel Community�ECSCB�¶�? 1952� 7& 23'�qXe)¶�C��ÃQ¦â�­15wP6±²TH���6�°¡¢Xd��6Ã3���¦�Ø233�î%>8��7|6��d��ù�8è¦�Ù¢6�<²7�9�î:

¦Ó6d���õ¡úÌXÕX�îÑg;m;6��;ÃwxXÕ]L0��26�îPLèfgX23 1955� 7&�,�Z�^���'Ø�Õî6�^:}�����D�g �3*+`÷62}�(,�ÚJ£à���1<�A�=�´µ35�î÷�<���ÕÖ>?>?õ×Ã6øaX¡"á�6l��

®�,¦�@.��Ø6 25î¦Ó? 1992� 3& 24'�ø ùf7�3��¶�X�¬Ñ7�¦6}:/

Page 20: Department of Political Science College of Social Sciencentupoli.s3.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/finalP9532… · Department of Political Science College of Social Science

15

3ÕÖ��6IjõñA;B�?Ì� 1963�[Ãl}�33�¶±²C�6�[���

�fg��,��k? 1972�78vG±���¥µ*l}x@USÔSoviet Agreement on the

Prevention of Incident on the SeaB�24��l}ÃÄ6G±3,��Ï=ûIÇõ°�g|6

â7èXû���k$�úôí¹Ì CBMs�26DEX

cccc����1975�1986�Ï�Ï�Ï�Ïvvvvø ùfø ùfø ùfø ùfl9}�Sl9}�Sl9}�Sl9}�Sx@x@x@x@X�jkX�jkX�jkX�jkBNBNBNBN

bXÕRS�LF:}e@Conference on Security and Cooperation in Europe�CSCE��

äF]bXR:}eB;(�Ì�g6¥7�Ú`a�`òÌïgð>G*XÕ:}��Ç

ðêëN�¦¶·�b¸45¨ñ#}·X>?�:è¦3ù� "#�ÜÚz{X60�

ô��gí£����¦Óøa½ª�¥¦&ulm�ÑÇðâ7X1965� 1&��g

�H¥¦ÕîSXÕ¦Ó°â��6:}���rõ�RSX�q���H�±X¨d°

¦Ó*2æçD¥�IbXR:}eX1966� 7& 6'���`����lmPQ:�

�.Y²ãJ�O�5�÷@BucharestBÕî:}��:}�"�¢vXÕ���RSÔ

|x@Declaration on European Peace and SecurityB��Ô|í¹�¹3ì¤XÕ6RS¥¦

{Täâ45N

@�BÃ�f?}ñ�3�¦Ó`²��¨�­J�Ø�³��J�6��dÔ¨©�

Ö�¬ÑXK¦Ó=6uLPQX

@cBÇMtÔ´µgN�ü�´µøaX

@-B{T45�ÖÃXÕ��è6´µ�Ê@DetenteB�25®íTÜ´µf��%¥

¦��O´�ùG��´>�G±ï�ºº¨èÄ45X

@nB{T45�G�¦­7�±²�=²Ï��<Hï¸X

ÆP�_��¶�9?� 2002� 1& 1'*2�qX\�¶�67�¦¡[: 35îX¶�C��Qî7�¦Ñ²G1ÁÑ�¹2�è¸R6ËAËS¯�7�¦�÷��î÷�É�xôõ�¦´µ>16¡ÈX

@î^&6<�Aâ�¹�Ú�T(3Ñ�U¥0ÙV�³LÃWFX[@SARB¨ ¯<�¹Ñ����Y635�î<��ZTX)�¦�6^ì���ÉÃ<�^&_����<�¬<¡È�¶�7�¦Ø

d1X24 úgi<�,¦��g7� 1972�v���¥µ*l}x³ 1989�v,�§`TU´µ�¥µ*l�x@1989 U.S.-Soviet Prevention of Dangerous Military Incidents AgreementB��i,��óÌe)¡��l��23õ,´ä��[Ù��gþ±�[Ù�TAi6���[�8I�6´µPQ<H¿uX25 �Ê@détenteB�MQ^£��Y¦öøa½�6ü�@9ÐÙpÆ�»BX�¦öPQ�� 1967h1979�=�,¦��gÏ=úg½�ü�6i<]¹b�Êi<eX

Page 21: Department of Political Science College of Social Sciencentupoli.s3.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/finalP9532… · Department of Political Science College of Social Science

16

@qB�ítÔ\WÏ­â]��®�ìH^_`W@OderÔNeisse lineB�26�³��

=6VWX

@�B��í��6Ô�¹fg�ÉÃ�¦¶·6��ÇðX

@QBG*XÕ:}��:}�â��"rp��ìXÕRS6LFÔ|X

1969����`�¦Ó�.%�J�O[a�@BudapestB?uÕî��lmPQ:�

�_�" 1 ¢�SXÕ6�HS�2}NX��+=´µõ��3yXc���,¦�M

lmyX-�TÜ��ítܺ¹±���j6Ýð¶*yXn�ò�¬ÑXÕ¦ÓÕî

SXÕRS�LF:}X�� 10&���`�覥¶�ObØG*6:}� ���¨

©N

@�B�XÕ¦Ó=6PQ���rXÕRS�+=G1¸>"cX

@cB¹Ö�XÕ¦Ó=6��LF����¨¨©¹fg�,#¢d�¡Þ�Ýë

³ ¯6ghX

�¨©#��e��Ï_6bXR:}ef X��¦Ó�?���¬ �6���

e<Ì{Trû6��X9Ì� 1969� 12&�X�u�¯¬ �Ï2}º�3r�&��

��ÕîØÑ:}X��\<Og�@W. BrandtB­?§pbh �¨©e@The Hallstein

doctrineB�27õ�î±D6biL�Úe�ïgð>�±X¦Ó6�Ç�LF�[Ã�¦�

�]�6l9\6X70�ô��gvj�üÊË�Úk���¦Ó78��¶l�¯�®

íN

@�B? 1970� 8&�����g78v���¶�xX

@cB? 1970� 12&�����78v��ն�xX

@-B? 1971� 9&�,�@�Z�^¨¦m��#G78vn¦5�l�xX

@nB? 1972� 5&�,��gN¸Rb�X�<�jX

@qB? 1972� 10&�v±���f�¶lxX

26 �?�¦�Õ�VWX27 bh �¨©e@The Hallstein doctrineB�Q���\<���@Konrad AdenauerB¬ �X�`a��?g;d�¦@��BÌ��?�,n�6L^A;�o�¦���?�,d�¦@±�B27A���

�ϳ7X

Page 22: Department of Political Science College of Social Sciencentupoli.s3.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/finalP9532… · Department of Political Science College of Social Science

17

1972� 10&õ��g���X¦Ó¬Pp6bÚJ�qr´e}·@Mutual and Balance

Force Reduction Talk�MBFRB��2*�j���¦Ó¤r���gÕîbXR:}eX

:}� 1972 � 11 &õ�s�J�ø ùf�ÕîX�jkáVlm�³#G^6tÑ:

}�¯�r�¦Ód� 34¦X28

r�:}$i"u�d�� 3îjkXJÝ� 1973� 7& 3'h7'��ø ùfÕ

îX�jk¥¶:}�覥¶n�:}�7�l9�vS@Final RecommendationsBX�

� 9& 18'��'Ø�@GenevaBÕîXcjk¥¶:}X¡" 2�6m>�èr�¦�

ô?� 1975 � 3 & 30 'h8 & 1 '��ø ùfG*6X-jkè¦�ô�w:��r

�7�vø ùfl9}�Sx@Helsinki Final ActB�?ÌbXR:}er�Ã3Xl9}

�S6`òØy��äâ 4#Ù�N

@�BP?XÕRS¶·Nè¦78b�:¦Ó=ÚJPQY÷¨©e�vK�23

45x÷�©ªRS�r´£*x@Document on Conference Building Measures

and Certain Aspects of Security and DisarmamentBX

@cB¡Þ�Ýë� ¯�1��ê6LFN¯yz�?,2�:¦Ó=6¢d�2

�sâÏG±X

@-B�[³¯��êÏLFN®íÑ�Q²¼�M�Ó{6�Ë�6ý�£¤�Ö

×6LFX

@nB_Æ:}N¹Ñq@î}�SØy�nÉ�XÕRS�LF�2��¥Ãuö

�2� HbXR:}e¨ÚP��rsX

�vø ùfl9}�Sx�� CBMsJu�tX�ibXR:}e6ÃQ¦Î1

à²ã¥�®íXÕ¯� 33î¦Ó�,¦��ü#d 35¦�¡"�b 2�á67��j

$%�9?THd�X�}�S�=bbXÕRSeÙ��ø�3 CBMs6ÚPl�X`

ò6Øy�á�§ù�´µ��Ij¬×Ã6TU�WòëäN

28 ���@15¦BN,¦�Z¦�^¦�����ü#�8#��Û�i��������|}�!"� Þ��'¯�ï&�#$%X���@7¦BN@¦�±��Õ��/0�.Y²ã�.%��r��ãX�3¦@12¦BN~��Ö��~��ì¦�s���(%�� ��Y ��������ïÎ�������á�b�X

Page 23: Department of Political Science College of Social Sciencentupoli.s3.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/finalP9532… · Department of Political Science College of Social Science

18

@�Bñ#´µÐ¨ØÝ�£NÃQ¦����ÕîgLШi�r�\�'+:"

2� 5,000�i�¥¦!"rH¥7�[�?Ш� 21`E£X�ÎXÕ�¥

Ï���^ìÃQ¦Ï´µÐ¨�ê�o!¯�ÃQ¦�� 250 `��ØA�

]¥¦µÝ�DX

@cBÔOШØyNÔOÏØy�®íШ\6�">Cé�Äö@írÐÙ��

�B³Ð¨i=³��¨X

@-B��É�QNI��u�³J�@%>r1B6��ä�!"¥7�[���

����É�Qr�ñò´µÐ¨�É�Q�'�¶*³É�%�>��¦%

8X

@nB µ�Q78N�J�6fg��ð´µ�Q78�Já��ì��=6�Ç�

[ÃK^236\¾X

@qBÃQ¦f?ì¤��6K��â`� ��E´µ��Ï��X

ð}S�B�ñb7�¦¥¦{Tb`²�¨e�b­G1¸>e�b­]�\We�

b}ñ��É~e�b��Çð|Ýe�b­JØ�¦µ&e�b}ñ�²�f�%>e�

b}ñ�,�¨�%ð²e�b�2LFe³b@�6�î¦ö^8&e¨¨©���«

�2�:¦Ó=6PQ���XÕRS����³�ì¾W���RSX$Ùvø ùf

l9}�Sx78i�,���¦n­í��9bXR:}eÃÙ783vK�2345

x÷�RS�r´£*x@Document on ConfidenceÔBuilding Measures and Certain Aspects

of Securityand DisarmamentB�¹XÕ½�ã����RS6fgX

----����1986�1990�Ï�Ï�Ï�Ïvvvv��� ���� ���� ���� �:}£*:}£*:}£*:}£*x@x@x@x@XcXcXcXcjkjkjkjkBBBBNNNN

h�bXR:}e¬[Ã6d��ð}�ö¡Ú:bÑ«^ø�@e¨êßØ�X9

Ì:}G*¬°�6q��³_Æ:}¬[Ã6èÄð}��?_x6XÕ½�°�bØe

6®¤X.ëN¿u��6JKPQ����ê6���RS�Iñò6Ì��bXR:

}eÄ76C�2tä�¯:}{ù±��¦Óñò6��A�X��fg��_ÆÓ

Ñ��«6���Ã��tX

1983� 10& 25'��ø ùfÕîbXÕ��K^xRS2345³r´ØÑ:}e

Page 24: Department of Political Science College of Social Sciencentupoli.s3.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/finalP9532… · Department of Political Science College of Social Science

19

@Confidence and SecurityÔBuilding Measures and DisarmamentB�1984� 1& 15'?~�

J���� �@StockholmB?uÕî:}�� 1986� 9& 19'6bXR:}e��9

?78v��� �:}£*x@Document of the Stockholm ConferenceBX�£* CBMs

��«,#¹bK�xRS2345e@Confidence and Security Building Measures�

CSBMsB�S£d 104¶� 4î�*X£*��?´µî�ÑI¾Ø6C��õlñò6

Ì��´µî}·ë���¡Þ�1r¨}·wMC�`aX¯`òØyÑN

@�Bb�è45N

1.�ùG1¸>��¸>"cè)�¦X

2.:" 4����6´µÐ¨�¥¦?����£��©­H�îX

3.^ì´µî�r�Ù�:" 1� 3,000��/g� 3,000��¹�� 300��´A

200_��A�0?� 24`�Sª£:è¦X

@cBÉ�Qr�ШN8&��¬Ñ¯�r�XR:}6¦Ó�������É�

QrɬѴµ���ôE£¦¥¦� 21'Ø&;X

@-B´µÈ�7�NQ� 11 & 15 '��覥¦�¯�¦Ó7�ä��´µ��

'%t��¡È�D�®�Y�j©�ШÙ����\6�r�¦Ó�">

Cé�Äö�³Ð¨���Шi=¨�]�µÝ�£è)�¦X

@nBÈ��aN)�¦Ñ²�b¦Ó ¯�^e@national technical meansB�<Ù 

½�X[��¯���<Ù3Ñ�dÙè¦Ì���C�Xè)�¦Iâ!"

¥7�[RÍ��Q¸�¦��u��a�9Q�­H:" 3 u�Qu­H:

" 48li���ò��a¦6u'­H:" 2uX

@qBШ��>#�¸�b�X

XÕ��6�2È�ú¾�3,���ì=JKí£�û�� 80�ô�I�áu78

3öÈ CBMs6l��A�N

@�B� 1980�vG±���¥µ*l}x@USÔSoviet Agreement on the Prevention of

Incident on the SeaB6fg��783vTAè´µ�¥µ*l}xX�l}6

`ò\6��?ó��¦=��¸¹´µºº�¥�â7èX

Page 25: Department of Political Science College of Social Sciencentupoli.s3.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/finalP9532… · Department of Political Science College of Social Science

20

@cB? 1983�7�vgN¸RrG¶�x@Strategic Arms Reduction Treaty�STARTB

i�33bK�2345eéF�X

@-B� 1987�7823bó�ï�¬U��e@Nuclear Rick Reduction CentersB�$

Ù���n­BÑTA�<Ä7�9â ¬�¦=¸R��Ä7³ì¤¡È7

�X

v��� �:}£*x­úò�è)�¦´µ¡È6I�!G�ú줴µ��6

â�aèX1989� 11& 9'5�a /¡�úg�Ïm@�¦ö½�I�?XÕ6~LX

nnnn����1990�1999�Ï�Ï�Ï�ÏvvvvÛúw£*Ûúw£*Ûúw£*Ûúw£*x@x@x@x@X-jkX-jkX-jkX-jkBNBNBNBN

1990 � 9 & 12 '�>���Z�,�^��¨¦��-�Ý���¦]�¶·2*

bc�ne:}X1990� 10& 3'��]��bXR:}e��«� 1990� 11& 19 '

?à4Õî�ô�w:�:}�78v6XÕà4¶Yx@Charter of Paris for a New Eu-

ropeBX29

õ 1990� 11& 17'��¢�G*bXR:}eÏ¥¶©^:}�:_7�3vÛú

wK�xRS2345£*x@Vienna Document on Conference and Security Building Meas-

ures�CSBMsB�£*bC�èe�b¡È7�e³b£mèe¨45��«ì¤�¯�

`ò6Øy®íN

@�BÃQ¦¥¦?Q�6 12 & 15 '����{¯">�`ò¸R¹�]Ù���

³ä�:���Ï´µØ¤ÚJ7�¡ÈX%ÃQ¦â{¯�ÃQ¦¬ �6

´µ¡¢ò��aX

@cB33bººØ§��e@conflict preventive centerB����H�è6´µ���

 H�µ¦I��¯�r�¦NG*ø¥:}��î¦m§¨³lmLFA;X

@-BèÃQ¦�rH¥7�[Ï¥��J�Ï=23¡È¤�K¤E�<7©ª*

«�l�ÚP45X

@nBG*ÑP CBMs6�í:}@Annual Implementation Assessment MeetingB��/

29 1990� 11&�bXR:}e÷Å�w:�à4G*�¯l¹ñò6Ã�Ì 43¦7�3v6XÕà4¶YxXFì�bXÕ�¤��Ò6iô¡m@e�è¦_6PQb23���LF�}ñ6fg�eXF�B

�¬ÑXÕ¦Ó@®�,¦��ü#B[Ãd�6���r�ÔE3,����¦���XÕ��6o�X

Page 26: Department of Political Science College of Social Sciencentupoli.s3.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/finalP9532… · Department of Political Science College of Social Science

21

=\�³wxèÃQ¦¬l}ÑPbK�2345e@î�6ÚP}·X

@qBèÃQ¦6¡ ¦§ÃQ�´µY�Ã�ìJá³97²¼�*+÷´f�H

¯�ÃQ¦ôtrá¬uX

�qXÕ~L0�6'Áí�XR:}� 1990� 11& 17'��vÛúwK�xR

S2345£*x6)Ñ6fg��Cu78­�jk6vÛúw£*x@Vienna Docume-

ntB��ÅÌ 1992� 3&�1994� 11&�1999� 11&@$uÃ�³Øy��r�t 2-1BX

¯���$¡ 5�Ïu6/=_�� 1999� 11&�9?>bXR:}e6 54îr�¦Ï

¦Ó�J��'¯J�®��@IstanbulB��"vXÕRS¶Yx@Charter for European

SecurityB��³ñ6µ8vXÕ*]¸>¶�x@Conventional Armed Forces in EuropeB�v1999

�Ûúw£*x@Vienna Document 1999B¨�XÕRS}·ÚP6£*X

$ÙvXÕRS¶Yx$­B^øq��ïÌBÑ���@>£*XvXÕRS¶Yx

Øy�� 7#Ù��52k£�X¯��?ëìª�"cXÕRS6fg��¶Y�XqÙ

�� � 7�ÇðÏ[N

@�B�ì��N¹ì¤��lm"%��H3<µ:Ïä33bØÑPQ:e

@Preparatory CommitteeBX��PQ:*+9¬Ñr�¦%>r��:}{�

r���u5XbØÑPQ:e6/=}·�x%?<µ:�<µ:`�6P¯�

/=m�0D<µ:DEXbØÑPQ:e6Ä7�`òÌ�G°H3<µ:6

éFX

@cBu�î�N`ò\6�Ö����RS³É�r�¦��bXR:}eð}µ

�6uö��Xu�î�6²b�ؤ��>H3<µ:ð�X¯éF®í 

H�µ¦2}�¦m�Î3P<AÕ�lÖ23^ø���9:±��lÖl

mºº6��ÇðX

@-B²ªC�N²ªC�A�623�,¦2}�³�´µèØ6²ªC�Ù��

Ã3�¸¹6b!ÓlÖ�LF6²ªC�Ù�eX

@nBY���N¹7hª��u�î��²ªC��>bººØ§��eÁÂÑP

6´ÑéF���µfX¥òi�Y���6���QⲪ,a��³Ã)

Page 27: Department of Political Science College of Social Sciencentupoli.s3.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/finalP9532… · Department of Political Science College of Social Science

22

bLFRS#�e�¯�¦ö�rpghX

@qBµ��êî�Nµ��êî�¹XR�ººØ§ <"%�ñò6�1�¯

î�®íN¶·�µ¦6µ�î��µ��¸�Ö��2�36�^��¨X

@�BÛp��NRS¶Yج¹Ûp�����ÌÅÆ 1992�ø ùf�ô�w:

Ï_¬Ãàbú <e6��Xr�¦�?��}·�úì�bð�d/XR

��Ûp���ªº�6�Ü#6�Ü/éÐ6â7èeX�¥r�¦

������Ch/=�dµ¨©ä�XR�â�ð}�Ûp���ª»Ð

�÷è6î¯X

@QB�Ǽr^{N¶Y½¾r�¦�1�Ç�¼r^{xÇð��=6|ÝX�

�É?�£%? 1973 �7�ÏvXÕ����Çð|Ý`�x@Convention

European System of Peaceful Settlement of DisputesBX

0000 2-1####d�d�d�d�§§§§¨©ª�S¨©ª�S¨©ª�S¨©ª�S««««¬­3®0¬­3®0¬­3®0¬­3®0

¯ °°°° ±±±± ²²²²����³´�S³´�S³´�S³´�S���� [[[[ ,,,, ¬¬¬¬ ­­­­

1 9 9 0 �

11 * 1 7 µ

§¨©ª�T¶�·U�VW

�S«�Vienna Document on Conference and Security Building Measures¸CSBMs�

1.¹º»¼½¾¿RÀ7ÁÂÃľVWÅ2.�Æ��ÇÈÉÊËÌ<ÇÈ�EÍÎ<�ÏÐÑyÒÓ�ÔÅ

3.ÕÖ�×Ø c¸`aÙ�ºH�TU�VWJÚÛ�ܸÝÞÃÄÓßÅ

4.àÙ�áâ°ãäåæçÔèé¸Ò�êë9�cìÓ�Ô¸U�åæíçîïÅ

5.𨩪ã�HñòÐÏ&TJÅ

1 9 9 2 �

3 * 4 µ

§¨©ª�T¶�·U�VW

~ó�S«�Vienna Document of the Negotiation on Conference and Security Building Measures�

২©ª�T¶�·U�VW�S«ôõö÷ø#

1.ùúÙû�ÇÈ�E��Å2.XüÇÈ�EÍÎýþÖÊ�Å3.��ç�Å4.���Æ

1 9 9 4 �

11 * 2 8 µ

§1994� 11* 28µ¨©ª�T¶�·U�VW~ó�S«

�Vienna Document 11.28.1994 of the Negotiation on Conference and Security Building Measures�

§·�¿R�Ô��~ó�

S «� Global Exchange of Military Information�

1.Lç���û 9,000�<[ i� 250�<��i�� 500�<�� 250�y¿RÀ7¸����à 42��±ç��ÄÅ

2.��û 1� 3,000�:¿RÀ7 ���� !"#

���$û¸%&!�'ýð 21�¬()Å3.*� 12 * 15 µ+¸�ÆÒÓ¿R,-<[,ÇÈ�.¾Z¸ÉÊËÌ/Ï0ËÌÅ

4.ø1¿RÃÄ8¦¸2�1�33¿RÀ745/ÃÄ8¦Å�2�Ë̾:¿R67/ÃÄÅ�3�ì¿R¾8x9RS�ÃÄÅ

Page 28: Department of Political Science College of Social Sciencentupoli.s3.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/finalP9532… · Department of Political Science College of Social Science

23

�4��:¾¿;p</ÒÓ¿RÀ75.±û*����=¥¦#�1���û 1� 3,000�9 300�[ i�:¿RÀ

7¸>?� 6�Å�2���û 2� 5,000�9 400�[ i�:¿RÀ

7¸>?� 3�Å�3���û 4��9 900�[ i�:¿RÀ7¸>

?� 1�Å6.Ù±û�ì@�ABCD<Eë<FG#HIABã.¸`BÙ�J�KLM�Å

7.*�N O�PQcÅ

1 9 9 9 �

1 1 *

§RS�·T4«�Charter for European Security�

§RSêEÇ UVWX�

S «� Conventional Armed Forces in Europe�

§1999�¨©ª�S«�Vienna Document 1999�

HRS�·¶ÃÄ,-�·U

�VWJ

�Organization for Security and Cooperation in Europe Negotiation on Conference and Security Building Measures�

1.YZM�º[ì�¿R��ç�9\]¿R�$ûÅ2.^_9�`áâabcXdèéefÅ

����������������####ghighighighi<<<<jUk[ljUk[ljUk[ljUk[l §§§§��Óß9�TU�VW��Óß9�TU�VW��Óß9�TU�VW��Óß9�TU�VW«m«m«m«mnoLnoLnoLnoL ppppRS/%m�RS/%m�RS/%m�RS/%m�

T¶�·U�VW���T¶�·U�VW���T¶�·U�VW���T¶�·U�VW���q§q§q§q§^�9�r^�9�r^�9�r^�9�r«««« 2222s>s>s>s>t2t2t2t2¢¢¢¢uuuuÅÅÅÅ

õ�bK�2345e�8�ª��£ô.¦Ø¥ëA�!Ó� CBMs¬ �Ï�8�

~<Wbë_N

gNx¦öGC��@The Center for Strategic and International Studies�CSISBëA¿

À@Ralph A.CossaBÏ�8¹NHKvof9»of?f¸Áwx�<y�Fz��{|}¸

w�~�<Ï�F{��`�°:¿R9� >��<�JX30n��«´ò¯�ÇN@�B

�Ù�r�¦ÁÑLF6Ág�© CBMsj���X@cBë�>r�¦x23�ð¦ö�

6C`x6÷�© CBMsl¹ÑqX@-B¥¦6é�w¥7SÙ7�1?¯��ê�¦Ó

Ï=X@nB CBMsÌ�Ä�k�b�45�õ���X@qBCBMs¥¦Ñtu6�uö

30 ¿À@Ralph A.CossaB�þ±µ&!Ó�ö^ CSISGCQ³ä�=Â@Pacific ForumB`�X

Page 29: Department of Political Science College of Social Sciencentupoli.s3.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/finalP9532… · Department of Political Science College of Social Science

24

6³¨ÃG�6\¾X@�B����Ñ�]³C«��6ÚFÈ�ÌlÎ60F��X@QB

�àáÃÄ6.���"%òÛm�I¹ñòX

�H�@M. Susan PedersonB��0�@Stanley WeeksB��ëA¯�8¹NH�÷

ø�h×9�ÐB¾Q?¿R�1cø��¸w�����F�Ñ�Éi�:�9JX31�

¥úÑ/�Ä8Ï�N@�B/86 CBMs®íàá���¡Þ�1�63��¡Kúà�

RSÁѱ²PQy9Ì�~���=²����ê6K�³RS�â7:"ÅK÷�¹

Ö�K��RSõ3�645X@cBÄ86 CBMs©Ì�´µ�RS±²ÑPQyõ��

K�³RS6F¹X

1�÷@Jonathan AlfordB CBMs�8¹NHÝQ¿R�1h��:VWJX32

!"�¦§Ù¶ì�÷@John Jorgen HolstBÃ)XÕ� CBMs�ª6¡*�¯�8

¹NHø1y?��T^9�]öÒ��{:3�VW¸G[,ÄwJà÷ø¿RÀ7:�

ÐB¾¸Q¿RÀ7ì3Io¼:M£¸������y?:�1JÅ

,¦�Æ—�Ç���@The Henry L. Stimson CenterB`^0~È@Michael KreponBN

H��TU�VW�J3���¸QÒ���:�`�����°:�$ÓßFÐÏi�É

�¸�¯���¿RÀ7&:� ¾¸Q�`�°:�1cø�h�¸¡¢��°:£¤

¥¸¦�3��§>Zx/�`¬Í:�·d+ùJX33

¦ØëA�£%í¹NH��TU�VW��¨©ª«x�<y�Fz�¬w��~<

­�<{��`°�>��¾:ofF»ofVWÅ®��J¯°of~ó±²?:�²¸

F»of:�c¸��ì®�`¿RÀ7�Ô<¥¦¿RÀ7�³yVWm©��Jz�

Fy��ofF»of:Ädm223<>´�y�<Fz��·ºµ¸��J¿R¾8

:F»¿RG¶:¸·��°x���WJÅ34

31 LqvK��RS2345>=x@A Survey of Confidence and Security Building MeasuresB¨SX32 1�÷@Jonathan AlfordB�`òGCbK�2345eÚP}·�qÑvbK�2345eÏÄ7�b�x@The Usefulness and Limitations of CBMs�1981B¨SX33 0~È@Michael KreponB�¹,¦�Æ�Ç���@The Henry L. Stimson Center��?�ÉÊB�Ë`����ƹ� �èØ� òGC`Þ�?b¦ÓRSe}·�qÑv�êRSÏK�2345�Ìx@A Handbook of book of ConfidencehBuilding Measures for Regional Security�1998B¨SX34 ��#ë¥7ë��¥7¬Í�Î��,¦Ïг#ëÑÒ¨ ^ø¥7ë3Í����t^¦3��

#ë�¦�ãä�êGC¬Öi³(),`fZ:@î¶�¥7Ù¦cPQX¯ö^�ÐÑ��iôñò6

Page 30: Department of Political Science College of Social Sciencentupoli.s3.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/finalP9532… · Department of Political Science College of Social Science

25

¦ØëAÓ2�í¹NH��TU�VW�ß�w����`°:��¸ÝÞÒ��{¸

�ùú�h�Ô¸U���¸Þ%{�ñò9¸��åæF°æ¾:3�¹VWJÅ35

U�ÔÝ�í¹NH�¿R��8¦�J�º�`Fº»�`d¼¡¢��¸���$

Ó߸��½¶¾,-FÒ�°��¸�U�67îï<þ¾¿RÔ¿<À´Á¦×�

�{º?¸�ÃÄÅ9�·.Æ�ë±JÅ36

®w�bëA�!Ó6�Ç�|µâ�bK�2345e�8¿~®w¹�ä6B

��8N@�B�JKA��ß®����6��l��´µJKA��îÙ�X@cB�¯

le>?Ì�´µ©ª�6uö¡*¬®wHx�õ_����ô�¥7ÃF1ÚP>?

�F^�n�2¹Ø§¥7@preventive diplomacyB�³¯�6LFRSA�@cooperative

security mechanismsB��ì¤���¥7q��n§ùÁªºº6ÁDX@-B�¦Ó=1

xó�øa½�nÕÖg|ººTU6éBX@nB�­Ì±²1?Çð��6ºº��

3�õÌ23�Ä_;�1xÕÖ�ó�>?­���IǬ°�6ºº��3X@qB�

BÑb��´µ��6!G¤@transparencyBe�blÖè¦�Õ¯�?�î�uÔ��º�

��@"cBÏ��:OÑÁÑe)e¨Ä7X@�B�ÌÑP�?µu6í£�n��ê

µu�¡�¤(¡>ÚP45��^�Gè�Ö¨��´µ@��BF¹6� �\6�

�ÕÖ­¥ò6I:��3X@QB��¥�bK�2345e6b/8e�bÄ8eÉ��

ÅÌNb/8e6 CBMsâ�®�àá���¡Þ��1�6RÍ�¤(�?~�K�23

ÑÖ�°âs¹/8 CBMs 6�Ù¢XbÄ8e6 CBMs ©ÌY��´µ�RS±²Ú

P6�Kb��!G�e�bG±­K^e6ÚP45X

�bK�2345eØc�ª�¯BÑC��b��!G¤�³da45¨�ö��

Ì23JK6`òéBX¯ð>Ö�¦Ó=6C��JK³23¦Ó´µî�6é��C

×_ðÚ���� 2003�ô^ع¦ÓRS:}¦cPQ�!¶¹¦ö�ãäRS����j��d�,¦¥7�Ú�qFá¼ë¯=£¥�!SóÑv�d�j6<=�u&xX35 Ù�Ý #ë��ë3Ú^¸Öi�Õ���#ë¦öPQ�ÛA��GC�êN¦öPQ���PQ�

gNGC�TA <X36 b��gNë:e�S¶���,¦/´0ܱX¯ö? 2002��¡�\]�ÐÑi��¦§ÙP¯�@Ý��b´µJKA�e!hDE�n±²ªÞ�i6ßàGÙ¶X_ûÑ �b�V�¦=e`a�G

H�DE@Ï�áX

Page 31: Department of Political Science College of Social Sciencentupoli.s3.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/finalP9532… · Department of Political Science College of Social Science

26

©��ì¤�����´µ678�LFPQXèöK�23456Øy�ŹN

C�45@communication measuresBN�ѺºâD�øaPQ6¦ÓÏ=ÛpC�6

�[��TAxSiÑÖ?ÇÎøaXFú7ICø���01�ÛëÑ3�Ã�Älm

A�8è¦ã���@­äBn%�TA���ó��ÕÖXH�6A��ëbÂ~e

@hotlinesB�b�êC���e@regional communication centersB�37b�<lme@regularly

scheduled consultationsB¨X38

b�45@constraint measuresBN1xG覴���=rpûÄö��%�6!��

å¯Ì�VW�¸X>?��%�6Ù�0�òµÝµE���úb�3覴Ѻæ6

7>XëNb¸�ê@thin-out zones or limited force deployment zonesB�39µ��£6ò�

@pre-notification requirementsBX

!G¤45@transparency measuresBN¹è¦Ö�´µ7>���Ï`*è645XF

¹23K�"%6X�«�!G¤45÷Å�HñsXëNµ��£6ò��¡¢7�@data

exchangeB�40%fÉ�@voluntary observationsB¨X41

da45@verification measuresBN1�ôõ¡¢��íû¦�÷�¶��l�6@î

��XëN÷�d�@aerial inspectionsB�42�ª�����]@ground-base electronic sensoring

systemB�43u�d�@on-site inspectionsB¨X

37 7çÖºº¦Ó <TA�bXR:}eó233XÕC��RS���õ��é�úô�1��±��X38 .ë>,��vG±���¥µ*l}x@USÔSoviet Agreement on the Prevention of Incident on the SeaB¬236b,���´�:e��Ì1e��à�����àbè�³�bèÏ=6�^´Ã�<:}¨��7

 H±²´µ²¼6A:X¡K=Â78è�t[¯P�6µ�n �^ìâ76éêX39 b�B¸û÷����VW6´Ñ�Ù�6ö��'1Xëë�ã��¯â 1975�vÇÎøaÜ�l�x@Disengagement AgreementB6ìÙ¶l�233Åí 20`�6�´µ�@demilitarized zone�DMZB�I���6Ù��¸R��:b�X40 1991� 12& 9'�gL¦#:ð}23bgL¦*]¸RÎÒ��e@The United Nations Register of Conventional ArmsB{ÌáV6.aXè¦ôò� H`g0�¹���#OF¦©�]�FgËA�2�±¬A�gª�³ËÌ�ËÌ�]¨¸R6��ODEX1992��Ñ 83¦���ûÄ����&��:1993��Ѹ 90¦ �DEX41 v��� �K��RS23£*x@Stockholm Document on Confidence and Security Building MeasuresBC�:" 1� 7,000��ªÙ�� 5,000��î�÷óÙ�6Ш�õ�Ñ��É�Q68&X42 ë������`�ÃQ? 1988�v*+`÷¶�x@The Open Skies TreatyB�ÏC��>I�d�@îX43 â�d�û¦�¹Ñb�6@î���Ù�6ï�X�^;Þ6�ª�����]� 1975�vXcuð³ñ�¯âÇÎøaÜ�l�x@the second Egyptian-Israel Disengagement AgreementB� 1979�v�ð��l�x@the Treaty of Peace between Egypt and IsraelB�»ÐPLî¯X

Page 32: Department of Political Science College of Social Sciencentupoli.s3.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/finalP9532… · Department of Political Science College of Social Science

27

��1Ïjkè�ª��Ç���`^0~È CBMs<=¤º3 M6GC�Ã)

¯É���uö23K��6i<«Ó�ÌbººÕÖ45e@conflict avoidance measures�

CAMsBX¡Ä450ò6��¡�ܱ�û¹ºº�¡ÇÙ�è�6��:Ѭò§X

��Ï_Ó7uî��s�èI�6 CBMsX�� CBMs ô©ª{1�ÑÖ?¿®��

1�XbººÕÖ45e�bK�2345eâ�F¹óD��6çôX

0~È CBMs�¹ººÕÖ@Conflict AvoidanceB�K�23@Confidence-buildingB�

ì¤��@Strengthening the PeaceB¨-îjkX

ººÕÖjk6Øy®�N@�B^ì CBMs6�j�@î�0ò���f6ÎpX�

)­T³¦ÓRSk­GtѺºõ¤6� ä��3è�6���ô���îlf��

le«6C��²¼����?X�jk6bººÕÖ45e@CAMsB�¯\6�ÕÖ�3

6���,X¡>Lú6 CAMsâ�23�îf�6RS¤«��§ùº�µ*×ÃSª

ººX@cBCAMs6÷¯�ÕÖººè���I��­(ò6g|�³�ö�6��¬�

@unintended escalationB�.ë3{Â~�³´µÐ¨6µ��£óÑÖ?[áK\6X

(G�ÁÑ¥7PQ6¦Ó=úâ�{1X�H{T CAMs6iA�å�g|�¾ñ�3

6TUµ*Ï_XF7 H�kúï<@cooling-off periodB�Hè�'s�´Ñä�jk

6²¼X{T CAMsn�ïg3(2;�ÄÉ~6ÕÖºº�K�23Ï���«Ó�õ

��ép�Äú¹23fg6���F^X>?è�f�{T CAMs6<>�\6è­Ú

��¬�üò&u�ÝÕÖºº���?´Ñ�MXcjk6 CBMsX

K�23jk6Øy®�N@�BCBMs�f�\6�@îF^�]­�?��jk6

CAMsXJÝ��\¾�ª�CBMs6F^­úÌ�ÕÖº�6ºº�TA�õò��«

2;��6K^�K�X¯u��@�0òI#6��Îp�åèJ�Xû��X

�jk�2:XcjkÚ�÷jXCAMsÜSiè%d?�q�9 CBMs0òIá6��

�uD�Ó7��!G��TH��6øÇ�K^X�bººÕÖe"³:bK�23e

6"%��lBôtè6B��2̲�x%:¦�X-¦�¦ö�6¥¦´µÉ�A

u�¶·´µÐ¨X�¥���bººÕÖe:bK�23e6"%��+è��ï�6

PL}·ÁÑñ#:��©p�"%ܹù�X�H¦Ø6sâ�ñ#6gN¶·:�

Page 33: Department of Political Science College of Social Sciencentupoli.s3.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/finalP9532… · Department of Political Science College of Social Science

28

�×þñúâX�A®�¦Ø6��¡Þ���û#6C��>�¦Øñ#�s1¨y

_A.ë�2ï¸�´µgN¨¶·X@cB����Ç6¬Ui#i�0òæçõÑþ�

6�÷X.ëN��g\]üà¨��ð³�\]�[÷�à��\]ÝÈ@Collor de MelloB

�ö¹3�bººÕÖep¤ bK�23eõ�u¬UX�i CAMsâ� HRS¤«�

9Ìb÷j6ð³eÌ«^ÕÖ6X

ì¤��6jkØy®�Në�70ýÕÖg|6ñ#sân*2£m��¶��¦

Ó�÷�{H�kÆ�1 CBMs�ì¤��X�jk6\6�,#n ¤)Ô6LF��

nþâ7v×­7¬p6æç�2X

====<�<�<�<�XXXX����YZ[LYZ[LYZ[LYZ[L----

bÄ7`8e@FunctionalismB£õ? 19 ¾���20 ¾�e¦ö«��Ü�i<�É

î?X��cu¾W#g�_�z�¿À¦ö�����uØØc�v×�î��6¦ö

��X�*²@David MitranyBâ¹ÌbÄ7`8e6J�#}A�44�? 1943��*v�

îâ0F6����x@A Working Peace SystemB�¯�bÄ7èAÒeÉ?�(��î

¯`ÞØLF6�2:ÖÃ�¯F ¯`ÞÏLF�õÞb��@�BÜe@ramificationB

�2���îÙòØ6Ä7LF£?0ò��n°��¯FÙòú0òLF6���ë�

6Ä7���~¦ö���n7Ö�¾W��X

b6Ä7`8e@Neo-functionalismB£õ? 50 �ô�¸ 60 �ô��P���@Ernst

B.HaasB¹J6ëAµrÄ7`86+Jþ��45� �1¦Ó��6öÛ��ÇòXÕd

��tÔ_;³¯�2�nØí¯��«]L6â7�^Xb6Ä7`8e�Mitrany¬#

ÏbÄ7`8e­�Ï �?�A�?¡*è6<=�_A©¹�~�¾W��<(¤6

C`X

Mitranyí¹��Ï=6Ä7Â�PQâ�C�Üβ>��ê6ÚÃPQ��»*]

6¦WÉ?�23�îÚJÃÔ6¦ö9:�Ûp¾W6��X�í¹ð>¢d�Ý ³

9:��¨�ª6Ä7Â�PQ�ÛÜç6gN�®úI7§ùg|6å�X�i�!"

44 David Mitrany@1888Ô1975B�Z¦@.Y²ãB$�³��<=ëAX45 Ernst B. Haas@1924h2003B��K#ë50Ò��¦öPQëq�Öi�1969h73�=¹��¦öPQGC¬`^��,¦�X¹q�¦ö��ëÓ�6Ä7`8v2�X

Page 34: Department of Political Science College of Social Sciencentupoli.s3.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/finalP9532… · Department of Political Science College of Social Science

29

Ä7Â�PQúâ�¿®Z¢�6p���Y³P5X­�©u6lm�J�­9pï

3,-6�@\¾�¤ Há�6��¾´X>��6q��Æpï:Pp¦ö=èÄ�

¦6LFPQXõð>õ�²>�Kp®Ã¹AÒáU��¦ö���R�6A:%Ù

��XMitrany6��'(`òa �b��e@Doctrine of RamificationB6É��X�í

¹ûî!��ê6LF:ÖÃ��î!��ê6LF�{ë��>���U­³6,#�

l9ú:�M��µ&6`aX�í¹��6¦ö9:«^¡>7�[Ã�ï7ð>�ù

³é�6LF[ÃXJÝ9Mû�A;÷�6²>�8F���¦6ðÚÄ7����°

6éB��õ�K¡£�ë��x6A;{:H:66²>X¡Ä½Ù6Ä7ð>��â

�­³6,#�l_¡KÄ7Ùò6LF:�Ã�ÄÄ7è6J�¤«�GHè,�¦

Ó6�3î�7>Ú�G�Xõ%�¡>ûK�¦�³:¦Ó��>?Ü­�Ä�6

¦Wò�Ï�b��CõÜ7¹�,���Xõ��,�H�Ä7è6A;�â�H:�

µ�,�¦Ó¬­7H:60òi��µ(:¨x�¦Ó6�@pï:�Ä7è�6

q��ë�Ñ�?¦ö~LX

Ùõ�P�Aí¹ Mitrany ÇÙä"?ÈÉX���Ä7LF6"%����ºº

³í£ �Ì­7ÕÖ6�9+ÃQ¦Ï=�t�ºº�øa��â7�q���Æi

"?ø46Â�PQ­9­7Ü�g|�Cõ��ºº6A:X46P?¦Ó�@�â�pï

6Í^�P�Aí¹ò� ¯©ª6Ä7LF[:pï�öq��Æ6\6�u�Ìi÷

j�õ\�úÁÑ^ìuaâ�Îpb¦öA;Ñ7>Tô¦Óù�,q�6�ÆeX47

Ùõ�bÄ7`8eC���¦ÓJÚâ�����Ê­R61�ä��¦ö��62

;X¯¬°�6C`èF1�%ѯ���%�7�Lcu¾W#g_�v3è�!æ6

¦ö�@ëgL¦è¬��B�³i<XÕd��Ã3ÏtÆ�õ�qd��ÏÐ��

bÄ7`8eH�9:ë³uaGC��µr³�2�̹b6Ä7`8eX

b6Ä7`8e%bÄ7`8eQ��2õx�õb6Ä7`8e�bÄ7`8el

#6 Å�?�?~L6�>@momentumB9M­�6ÇòXb6Ä7`8eAí¹~L

�ê>¡Þ�Ý û.ð��õÌ��>J�6m��õ�~L6"%��¬°�6¶·�

46 80�ôZ¦�^¦�d����Ú�6��(¹GÇ.aX47 � 1992� 6&�|}`,¦�C�P�Y��0¶�6m���â6a�@6pïµu�n­ydX

Page 35: Department of Political Science College of Social Sciencentupoli.s3.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/finalP9532… · Department of Political Science College of Social Science

30

¥¦>èÃQ¦6Z���� ¯Ã�³èÄ������6��xÇðX�µ�~

L"%�7�<T��¸±G�­��¦�G�µ�?~L6�f�°�PL6(

)>X�|Ï�b6Ä7`8e6ñ���+��>?~L"%�¬»Ð6î¯X¯u�b6

Ä7`8eì�~L6\6�?[Ã�îBÑ��èØ:¦ÓA;��îSÙ6XÕg;�

õbÄ7`8e6~L>?È�ü7[Ã�î�ê6Ä7è�LX

____<<<<�UB[L�UB[L�UB[L�UB[L----

¦öPQGC�ê��X��G1b2;`8e�MA¹ Nicholas Onuf�48*2? 80

�ô�<�>Pj<=¨��<=�`8<=6����ñ6ds¦öPQ<=����

?%=¬ØX`ab<?e@IdeasB�bm;eÏ=6ÚJ()PQ�ì�C©�����

£¤6ñòèXb2;`8e0/�ö��@Human ConsciousnessB³¯�¦öPQ6î¯�

�³¦Óí���6�Ã�õ�`8<=¬P56²>��Xb2;`8eÌÄ­�6

ø��t[��?¦öPQ`8<=6­ä�÷ÅÌ��^=�@MethodologyB���=

@OntologyB�í�=@EpistemologyB��%�f�<=6¶·�®�5�A�m;6P

Q�]�¶·�¦Ó�¶·�¦ö��¶·�¦ö��6p�¶·�g|���¶·�

�¸B�6>?�ëuD�¦Ó�¡¢���²>�`²���¨���î39:ë�

8�6ñ6Çò�b2;`8e()3¦öPQ<=6�2�n��êØv3�tu`8�

%>`8nâ6�ë�`X

�ë����Bôtè6ëA¹ Alexander Wendt�49¯?qFvSocial Theory of In-

ternational Politicsx@¦ö��69:<=BSª´b3�6b2;`8e<=�> C�

`86<è`8��`86C'`8X�ܯ�ëAIG��ÑG�b2;`8e6òzN

��¦ÓÌ��6`òî¹A�«��Ü�̦Ó×Ã6yc�¦ö��6m;��lñ

48 Nicholas OnufQ? 1989�ÏqFvWorld of Our Making Rules and Rule in Social Theory and International Relationsx� �X49 Alexander Wendt Wendt? 1999 ��*6vSocial Theory of International Politicsx �S�Ñ�]�É~ �3�6¦öPQ2;`8<=���ú�33��¦öPQ<=�6ñò��Xå¯Wendt  �1�>ë<=@quantum mechanics theoryBF¹¯ï�6=��¯011���<=F¹¯2;`86£�=`a�·�aGÝëu�=6É��ú{Ìâ�7Ýë�GC�aG<?�����Ãõ�í�³î�6F1X

Wendt 61���<=�û?2;`8ØÙ6£�=|=��Ýëu�=6£�=3ù6�3­�6P���õ �1���<=F¹&��� E�âA­�6's¾W��X

Page 36: Department of Political Science College of Social Sciencentupoli.s3.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/finalP9532… · Department of Political Science College of Social Science

31

ò6ÌbdÑ£�e�(É?6�K�ÌÚJ`�è6�õ��Ø>16�Ky-�9:P

Q;2bí���e�õutí���mL6ÚF`òÑ 3ÄN�"`²u�6Юy

�"���6LFy�"¦öm>®b�=6í�e¹bõ�6í�eX>�òzG�Y�

b2;`8e6ï�É��{̦ö���¦öPQGC6`ò�+��@î�AB̦

Ó�¦�¦Ï=6ÚJ`�èõ�¦Ó�;Ã3¦ö��yÚJ`�6¦ö���ð�

3¦Ó6í���yû��¦Ó�¦ö��ÌÚJ2;õÃ6XWendt 6b2;`8e

m;�â�ôF���8¹bdÑ£�e�b£¤eX¡î1���dÑ£�2;î¹�

6bí�e�b�eX¥�6¦ö��mLØ�6É?m;�­9â���q¦Ó6î

¹�õ%â�¿®��ئÓ6í���³f?í�õ�Ã6¦Ó�X

b2;`8eúí¹�lÎ6��­Ìx%�²ä6ì��@�ú­Ì£%�³Ã

��¤õx69:¨�C`�õÌx%è`�ÚJÏ=6JK�õ�í��ë�¡ÄJK

�õ�í�7Û�Ã�{:�è¦Ï=×{�Ä� 6d����°��­�g|�kÇ

ð��|Ý6d��bRSd��eú{23õxXõb2;`8e��bC`e�b£¤e�

bí�e�bdÑ£�e�buDe6>?�ÑGëäN

bC`e6>?N2;`8¬Y]6bC`e�?�Ä9:���®�C©�¾´�

^ø�¨!�¨"¨XnbC`e�8¹bî¹�d�pÑ6ú�î¹6d�Ø<XF

Ì�Äõ�pÑ6d�É?eXb2;`8eÚ�ñsC©�C`6�Ã�F1�í¹¦ö

C`Ñq9:�c@Social ContentB�õ%�3?²>�OÏ¥�nF¹¦Óí���6

fgX¯í¹N2;õ°��x9:C`�­ú()�C�q¦ö���¦Óî¹A6B

�î¹���#ÝAÒ³ut�¥�Ú\¾6éB�õ%â�çÖî¹�<Ç�$Ìñ

ò6�Ñ��6���)�6C`ä�ëì01L^�k�<T¦Ó�X

b£¤e6>?Nb£¤eQY�ö÷����÷�i÷�¬�ÃÏ����@í�

�����Ø��B�ÏB�tk³d1��XWendt61 3Ħö«��£¤��ÅÌN

hO�@Thomas HobbesB��0@John] LockeB�p�@Immanuel KantBX«��Ü�â7

°�´µ7|�²>�q�g|Xn`a«��Ü�JÉ©u�Ñ 3 Äm;N:��7|

Page 37: Department of Political Science College of Social Sciencentupoli.s3.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/finalP9532… · Department of Political Science College of Social Science

32

���È XWendtûõ{TMartin Wight 50�Z¦ë�6É��51� 3Äm;@£¤B

]¹hO���0�p�m;XWendt í¹��BÑd1É?6õ�í�23_�¦Óâ

�:S%Ö÷è�ÚJ=;%õ��K^������ÚFÇðºº�õ­Ì�ê¸>�

�õut�0m;Dp�m;p®X

bí�e6>?Nbí�e6>?x%9:�<ë�Yûî¹�¬BÑ6îè��Æ

Ï�Å���ÆÌ!"�b�Ae6PQõ�ÃX�ßâ��Nî�í�@Personal IdentityBN

`òÌ�<ëP�6�ê�Y%|62;�%|F¹�3î�6%|���23%|í�y

õ�í�@Collective IdentityBN`òÌ9:ëP�6�ê�í¹¬Ñí�°Ì2;õÃX

0/{¡?9:Ï�6%|��AÏ=6J�PQ�>J�PQ�t��6 �õ2;%

|6í�Xtô9:Ô�qèÄ­�6õ�í��.ëN`²í����í��,�í��

��í��¦Óí���¸?¦öí�¨Xb2;`8e¬'s6Ì�?¦ÓÌ�x%�î

õ�í�Ì­�6`²¦Ó7�Ã�îõ�í�&̯ëAí¹¡ÞJ��d�6¥Ù:

��d�6ØÙ:�¨¨�ÖG¦�¦Ï=°�õ�í��f�²�¦öC`�b�¦Ó

î¹XWendt�~�í�@Corporate IdentityB�9:í�@Social IdentityBÑG9:õ�

í�@Societal Collective IdentityB6�Ã"%�ú{Ìî�Að>õ�î��m;�«

@ContextsB��]"%³ÚNu&6 3 ÄA�Ø�v×%|��õ��õ�Ã9:õ

�í�X

bdÑ£�e6>?NbdÑ£�eYî¹���î÷�1���d�BÑ6ÚJ`

50 Robert James Martin Wight@1913 – 1972B�¹ 20¾�¦öPQ�ê�Z¦ë�6£�ëA�¯qFÑNvPower Politicsx@1946 revised and expanded edition 1978B�'Why is there no International Theory?(@first published in the journal International Relations in 1960 and republished in the edited collection Diplomatic Investi-gations in 1966BX51 Z¦ë�¬Y�6Ì�î¦öPQGC9��¯õ£Ñ�ÄÑ^X¯��í¹Z¦ë�£%?bðñ�¡

ë3e@London School of Economics and Political Science, F] LSEB�`ò<>�?àáZ¦ë�6ëAëCharles Manning�Martin Wight�Hedley Bull�Michael Donelan�Robert Purnell6ë¯�£�)�bðñ�¡ë3e@Jones 1981, 1-2 ; Finnemore 1996, 17BX��í¹Z¦ë�ãf? 1959�¬�Ã6b­â*¦ö��PQ:e@British Committee on the Theory of International PoliticsBXZ¦ë�6f�Øc`òa �¦ö9:}·Ï��õ¦ö9:k�¦ö��@international systemB³¾W9:@world societyB¡�î>?ÚPgX¹3´G¦ö9:6'(�Z¦ë���¦öPQGC6 3î*]@three traditionsB�(tu`8@realismB�<è`8@rationalismB�ÀØ`8@revolutionismBq�x��/=X�¥��?¦ö9:6�Ø�÷ÅÌP?d+C`�C©³��6â7`a�Z¦ë�ØÙÑá�`8@pluralismB��m`8@solidarismB�Ä­�6É�X¸?Z¦ë�6f��^=@methodologyB�©®�3�£`8@humanismB�~�`8@holismBX

Page 38: Department of Political Science College of Social Sciencentupoli.s3.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/finalP9532… · Department of Political Science College of Social Science

33

�Ï<Ç�<g��ûî9:1��d��+£��2;î¹�6¡¢��XbRS÷�e

@security dilemmaB69:m;�52(Ì�ÄdÑ£��õRS9�¤Ì�Ä9:m;��

RS9��dÑ£�¾x��6ÚJK^�$Ô��ºº�n#Ó�ÚKâ1����

ÇðX

buDe6>?N9:m;�Ã�Ô��Ìî¹�9:uD6m�Xî¹�Ï=6J

��×Ã39:m;X¡ÄJ�Ì9:m;�Ã�Ô�6f�¶*�ë�î¹�9:uD

��®¤�{:()É?6®¤�¦ö��69:m;¤:�Ï¿®X

�¥�b2;`8e�?b¦Ó`²e³b¦Ó�e68òÑ�Ä6ÇòXí¹¦

Ó�`²6Ô��2;3�î¦ÓÏ=â�J�69:1��ú{̦ÓJ�6¦ö9:X

û��ÚJ�í`²Ì2;¦Ó�¡6�îñò�.Xb2;`8e6ëA­úP5¦�

¦Ï=6ÚJ�í�I`a¦Ó`²ÌÄ9:2;�F�s�¦Ó�`²=62;PQX

õ`²W�3¦Ó�¦ö9:69:í��¦ÓÁÑ`²ú{ÁÑ@¦ÓB9:��r�

ÚJ�í6¦ö9:X{¦Ó�õ|�b2;`8eí¹¦ÓÌ>�µ��6¦ö9:

@®�¦ö�B¬9:¤6��²�66C`���³��6í£�nð>¦ö9:

�<HûK÷�µ�X²>��ÄüÌ�kõ­Ì\6�¦Ó¥¦ð�G1¡K�k6\

6X¦Ó�Ì�¦öC`���6�]ä¬W��n<Ç�$ÌÎ6%ú�6¦Ó�X]

���b2;`8e6÷èâ�6,ëÀN

X��¾WÌ5�A�ÛÉ1��2;6¾WNJÝ�Ûɵu�¡6�8ÌÑb6�

üÑ!"5�A6uD��Ó7<H�8y¯u�9:Ìâ�2;6�9:û¹�6J��

uDH�°���3�û�¾WÌb|µ×{6¾We�)Ì|µ×{6¾W�Å$b|

µúâ�¿®FeX

Xc�5�A�m;Ï=ÌJ;6�vÑ#Ýè6¶·N5�A�m;ÌÚJÃÔ6

~���AvÑ�Ø�6Ý_�õ%5�A�¡úÌ�î~�>?�è5�AÏ=úÌÚ

52bRS÷�eN�`�=<gGî¹�BÑ��6ÚJ>��GFµ\Ì���6�A�� F�l-6í

��Ü������´Ñ�����¥�:"c�m�{ÌbRS÷�eX����ªxÑ�bRSd��e

©ÌSÙ­�6m;�î¹�6dÑ£�GFµÑq��6ÚJK^�FµÏ=Ô��ºº�9ÌFµ�

ÚKâ��"��ÚFM�Çð�m�{ÌRSd��X

Page 39: Department of Political Science College of Social Sciencentupoli.s3.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/finalP9532… · Department of Political Science College of Social Science

34

ÃÔ�ÚJ()6PQ�èîî�Ú�?¯�î�õÔ��.ë�./��Ìm;èû.�

`��./Ì5�A�vÑ`��./�ú{vÑ./��3�vÑ^ì���¯���

Ì«^Ô�6���Ï=úÌ�U6[<Xm;Ì�Ä¡£���6�L�m;�5�A

=Ì�ÄÚJ;Ã6PQXm;)Ì5�AuD��6m��úÌ��6��³p����

G5�A6î�ùâ7�n��¯î���i�úÌlñò6�5�A6î�k­³°

�66m;X

X-�É?6>1Ìû#6N2;`86É?ÌdÑÉ?�ú{Ì£¤�0�ÌC©X

��ÄÉ?ùdÑÉ?6iÛ�F6>1{Ìû#6Xå¯��ÄÉ?ô×1á6¦ö

9:ÃQ²�Ïi�Fµ{ù3¦ö9:6µuXdÑÉ?­úâ�¿®9:µu�°

â�v×669:µuXõ%�É?­ÌY÷î�6E~ �°BÑ2;Ä7�â�2;

î¹6¡¢��õ��î¹�6��¡{É?s¹¦öPQ�6Jòû.X

----

----

----

----

----

----

----

----

Page 40: Department of Political Science College of Social Sciencentupoli.s3.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/finalP9532… · Department of Political Science College of Social Science

35

2>62>62>62>6--------�������������������_`a���_`a���_`a���_`a----

% 90�ôõ�(���/Æ�t#÷2;b��JKe�bK�2345e@�]b´

µJKA�e�b´µRSJKA�eBÏ�ø��iÏ=�?b��JKe6GC��

w�X53õ�¦ö�� CBMs ÚPA�01?��JKÏ��û��£ð>ô.��

q�ëA!Ó{b����JKe�bK�2345eÏÚP6GCqF@!S�=£�

<�³!2D÷B¨�ì��3¸��êÏ5¡=b�n·�4+�Ûܯ=�X

�êØÏ-á=b�â�®w¹N�Çðï�|}@`²¶·B¹23��JKÏÝ

ð%¥ò¶*A�ë(#���aã�Öiy`aÛ�b�î�¦e5_Ì;%����

JK6f6A�ë7ò#ë()GC38¦ 3¶Xõ�Ü9D´µJK6 CBMsGCÙ

��Ñ`aâ>áVRSA��gL¦��êì²�MÖÃA�ë�(g±`���ìÝ

�y�z{|}É�@�:;uò��T`ò�Bn �ÚPC�45A�ë<#g

N¬=G>¬¶³ûÉü¨ëAy°Ñ��ãä�ê CBMs6uaGC��®w�úLã

Õ��6é�A�ë(#����?GÖiXÑP=b¶�ë_N

(#���6aã�Öi?'=�µ��23JK(�£�Y�Nbë���­7Û�

ï�¶·�THd����­yd23�r6JKXe54¯`òÏÉ�³=�ëäNX��

bJKe¥¦ef?b�Çe�@7 M�Ç�@723JK6EFTJKÌ9:�ÊJ�

6fg�IÌ��PQ7�rH¤6PLXXc�úg<=�¹�$±�X¦Óf�7�

vø ùfl9}�Sx¡¢ôtq23JK6£*Ì�Ìû¹�g����H:3�

X�?¯`²���6�í�û�Óf���X¦Ó�î CBMsXF��Ñ�>?±�X

�?ï�¶·¡Ñ3d��ÓÑJKA�6°�XX-�,¦�?ãäRSѯ%=6

C���Ûp����î�xÍ�,¦$ÙA���23b´µJKA�e�9¯gN�

�?Ûp(����§ù^ì����ª¿®tÜX,¦\�°­:f�Í:�î�b�

53 �()¬ 6b´µJKA�e�öÈ?�½,�¬23ÏbK�2345e@CBMsB�¦ö=�¯ØcÑ��d�Xõ#/Ã�% 2004�*2¨úG1b´µJKA�e�M�9���`�� 2008� 12& 31'6���@���B�ï¿Ã3b´µRSJKA�e�¸¹ù#/Ã��¯ØcnwG��8X54 �?v�¦�=&�x�\X�n-<@2009� 11&�BX

Page 41: Department of Political Science College of Social Sciencentupoli.s3.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/finalP9532… · Department of Political Science College of Social Science

36

î�¦e¹¨©�ra­�Ò~î�¦¹\¾6��l��ú­:²��îâ7¦³,(

´B6b´µJKA�eXXn�2009� 4& 22'�YZ[\]�H,¦��kÆ�îv(

)PQ^xX�°Ñ���23b´µJKA�e\�¹i°iynt��,¦kÆ���

(´B��(,PQ�HñòX5& 9'�YZ[?G��b´µJKA�et�NHÇI

c�mÈ¥¸É/��9t�Ó߸ÊË[,:¿.J��ðt�¸��ÊË»¼ÌÍJm

iGÇ���YZ[6t�â�Í��\�,¦°Áѹ��l��b´µJKA�e*

CDXXq��?��xÑ�b�î�¦e¨©Ìï��f�3ù�ÁÑ¡�����JK

A�Ì«^236X��6=b�±i¨Ã�(¥¦�b�î�¦¨©e�23����

J�X55ë���­7Û�ï�¶·�THd��n­yd23�r6JKX

X����,¦% 1971�õ��3�¦ö�6r�è�9ÌFÎ÷°Ì��î¶�±

�`�Ô�q�9��¡Ä­fª���,¦µuÔ�6=b93()����ç#â�

EE6÷=T��=b6F��úÌl�­¨Ã6���{Ìb��,¦:OÌ"$eX�

��¦,±��í� ��Ä7ÛGè�HwÍÎÏÝ�6=b�â�8���â�I�

6=bIJXXQ�()ë¯W���66÷ä*2GCëìb23K�45e¶·�9

Ì\Ì� ¯�%�¶·�q��ÉSÁÑK¼:ï��¡U6'ÛüÌv¾Wè¦b2

3K�45e6Øy����L�M�õÁÑ ­'s¶·6�ØX¥¦'s6Ì�|µ

ò~�6Ì�î�r�â¶âu6JK�°Ì�î¹3 <\�â76ºº�õ236J

KÌÃaÖi6É���AÓÌ�r6JK�_Aü̹3è%�6²fÏ�XX;�

ÁÑ%K{ÁÑJKT��$ÙÑÜá6%K�9Ì°ÌÁѲ���,¦ÐÙÔ�6

%KX���¶·������v(���¨6N�ÍOXX[����0ò%K�(�

0òѧpb�î�¦e�Ó76÷�¦�26%K���0òÑ!"b���¨e�Iy

dãD]�6%KX��ë�7Ûñ#%K�JK%Ùâ�Ð:PÃXX ����õ|�

²�(�¹�îb¶�±�`�e�ü̲�µu6tÜõ�9Ìâ�QOÜÎ(�6�

���Û6EEX

55 Âg����â�� 2005� 4&�tÑPb…m@��:�Ü��[Ã��l��…23´µJKA�e6øG�¯¨û�?��í¹Âģpb�î�¦eA�¬����ï�¶·�Ñd�X

Page 42: Department of Political Science College of Social Sciencentupoli.s3.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/finalP9532… · Department of Political Science College of Social Science

37

#/7ò#ë()GC33¶8¦ Öi �b¦ÓR�<=eN8Öiv¦ö9:

ÛF> 200îS�6bR�¦Óe;Ã6b¦ö½�eXèbR�¦ÓeTÑ÷�6���

�,�����ÅÌ¡îR�6Øï�`��RªXèb¦ÓR�e¥¦rp���`²

É~è��ÕÖûR�®�õ�t*U"¸V�W[�×æö½�6�Ê­RX¬¹6

�»��@��²B{Ì�q?b¦ÓR�e6r�©�îG�Ø�<��¥r�¬�R

�­�ò§6`²î¹X�¦Ì¦ö½���îñò6¦ÓR���UÌ>����,�

���`²;Ã6�î~�X�¾W�X#á'¦ÓR�6RªüÑ�ÄY¯ôt¡î¦

Ó­���¦¡�¦ÓR�6tª\�Ì>U�fI¯;Ã6�û¹b~î�¦e>?ä

Ô� 2 î7|¦Óôt²6�²�Fµ�Å�­�6÷=�ùLôtq¡îR��I��

õu�b���ªe6PQXh� 2 ZbRªe¬�q6ªæ#l[��ï�è%6÷

=\îGq�Ø�<��¥r�6Ä7Xü­">?:�PQ6èØów¿®�cAÏ=

6PQ��Ì�Äb­��eÜ�X

û��8Öií¹b�ì��JKe{ÌI��)Ñ6JKfg��kÆ,#���

��`²��è6í£7õ�]í�²�b�î�¦�Ø 2 î7|�¦ôt²6�² �

nÔe6tuX�i��Ú�{TJÖ�J�6î���ì���,6�gm�Ø0d

��6���¹l9Çð�����ã�I��S6��_;X����JK6ì¤�Î

3áSf�6¨©èd�¥�úÑ�I��B�6��J��rp��¹u6���n�

ÃJÚ�z�ÕÖ¹j��6��î¹C`X

���JK6@î�ª�8Öií¹�¬¹6b����JKe�{Ì�µ��I�

���O\�Sª�î¹]í6���2t�d�Û������î�¦6^ø���t

uÏ�?�23õÚJ®y�K^6��PQXõb�ì��JKe{ÌI��)Ñ6J

Kfg��kÆ,#�����`²��è6í£7õ�]í�²�b�î�¦�Ø 2 î

7|�¦ôt²6�² �nÔe6tuX�i��Ú�{TJÖ�J�6î���ì�

��,6�gm�Ø0d��6���¹l9Çð����23õI��S6��_

;X����JK6ì¤Ì�îC�²æ6"%�¥¦�jk[Ã\¾X

8¦ í¹����JKÏ[Ã�â���äqî«ÓNX����I�§pb[c

Page 43: Department of Political Science College of Social Sciencentupoli.s3.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/finalP9532… · Department of Political Science College of Social Science

38

d�e�Û��î�¦5_�Ì;%����JK6f6�¡Ìlf�6��JKXXc�

��I���í���î�¦6fg����«]ín²�b��`²����² �n

Ôe6tu�nt�f�d�Û�¡���ؽ6Ú���è��Ã����JK60î

5_XX-���I��Û�(�����ؽ��è6fg�����,6ò��d�

m>�l#b��^Î()�b����,78LF6èÄ�¹sâ�����JKؤ

ùì#6���°>XXn���I�>ßBß6b�²��e�ãDª�ª6bd�

�<e�n�ú�6��d1�¦�¥`²�����JK¥¤Ã¦ö9:6��>1X

Xq���I��¡Þ���d;�9:�£¤���L6fg����¨�,`6�

��l9[Ã����PQé�69çRÍX

8Öií¹�;2����6��PQ�¥¦23d�6��fg�ú{Ìò23l

f�6��JKX����JK6ì¤�G��PQ¸±�t�ä-î�ª6æ箤N

X����I�787½6©^#_ ¬�78`a��«,#X���:jk���m

�����©±²��6�[úr�23�X���±7½H�¤�¦d�±�»���

©^ÃQpq7½�()¯��±�#/�ª6J���Xrû����PQ6­��è

û.r�G±�âØ<è��Xr���786î¹`�'á�¤�����©^`²

>Ùò��±��9���ém�W¨�A;�j©���çç�M��787½

#èÏ����è©^6C��xÁÑë�`4"���,-��uu��H:3Î �

����PQ6ØcI�åÄáaX

Xc���I���Ø¥åèJ�6ؽr��ÃX���¦öùLKL]¨�f�

�­?�t�îõè7|6�¹�I�û�ÕÖ3#16­¥ò6ØbX#/�ªIá�

'sëìÇð(),-r�¦ö��6ò��()�ªú­?Fc�«Ä6F\6��º

dX��¦#/6Îpä�()�ª6 �ÙòÁÂ��É�Q¡¢Ju��b¾ e#

:@WHABX()�ªú¿®����6g#:}<=w? hò��MgL¦XI�

�¦öùL �dÔ�ÚJ�'6�¹SxS�MX���Ï=���d�������

^JÖ�ªTH66�2¨��ÌJ�J�6åèJ�ttX

X-����,�d�PQ��«ì¤X�qb-�e6f�ut���è�ª6

Page 44: Department of Political Science College of Social Sciencentupoli.s3.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/finalP9532… · Department of Political Science College of Social Science

39

787½Ã�r�äó���786ÚF����t66®¤XI� �3��âÑ�?

787½6�Ú���,=78LFI��óX��á�x�ª�¦öZ�TA���¡

ÞÚJTe��µ��ùS¾W¡ÞlRS6�lÑ�>6�êX­úë�����,

Ï=6��ú��«45�b;;Ðfe<=�#/�IliD()í�3��#/úÃ

¹f�l#6¥3x£����I�JÚÎ3�ÚJP��Ç�����26ì#>1�

���,6��I�45X

f?�bbR�<=e���I�6��PQÌb��`²����² �nÔe6

��Ü�XX��«=()�ªÌ�f���Ê��²���\�6¦ö��tu���

¦#/�ª�X#á'ùLôtq�¦�÷ÅÌH:gL¦6�í�¡U6µu�ëg

�XXc�«=#/�ªëì��()�()�ª¬§p6b��,¦��e��K÷�

6ùLµu�ÃÙîGqbôt�¦e6��Ä7��Ø�<��¥r�q�()��6

�,X

�¦ö6ùL�I�kÆ�ßBß6��è%§p=�ôt�¦6��`aX­"�

>?��I�6��PQó«d�6G£C©��@�däq¬U�­��èX¹3ó�

����ºº6¬U� ¬`²>Ùò6LF©^���I�¥¦f?µuÔ�6��P

Q�m>[Ã()�ª �6brstu�23JK�z{|}�dvI�e�#/�ª

 �6b23JK�z{|}���Ô��dvI�e6d�X

��Ï=��JK6 ¤�­ú�Ñ�?�©Ï=I�456��J�����,Ï

=23�787½�J�LFfgÏ�6ÚJ3Ç�K^I�ñòX¶<��Ïä�t6

�¦��£¤#�]ä6��£¤��] ��G������6Çð®HI�í,�÷

jX¹��I�¥¦h²Ö���787½6«sâ¤�8�,Ñd�6i=�÷=hL

Òi�d��×66�¦��£¤#�]Xë�����©Ï=6JKÓÑâ7H:�,

Ï=6íâ�Îp���=6��JKÓÑâ7TÏ­þ�1Ï­jX

����JK6ì¤�Î3áSf�6¨©èd�¥�úÑ�I��B�6��J�

�rp��¹u6���n�ÃJÚ�z�ÕÖ¹j��6��î¹C`XAlmondí¹N

HÎÏ�Ð�°6Ñ:Ò±¸3? Â�ðÙI>�:ÓÔº��� <�±Õ:�Ö¸

Page 45: Department of Political Science College of Social Sciencentupoli.s3.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/finalP9532… · Department of Political Science College of Social Science

40

×3? ©Â�ðÙÓÔ�°Z��L� ���/~ó&Z�ØÙÚÛ:�ªe×JX56

¹����I�°�p��äqîB�6¶·NX������JK6ì¤0òÑ�

�âÑ�«�6C©�A��d��]¨xÎÏXXc�����JK6줭7�û�

��O�³��l}��I���u�B�6��î¹�X����Ú��{Ìtt¹,

#���,6787½�þ>ÖÃ��¡Þ�£¤��Q7½6«sâ¤XX-��b�

�����e6d�fg��æç����u���¦ör��ê�6J�Õ4�ÚJk

p�ÚJ}ñXXn��23b´µJKA�e�ª���tÑ6��JK×�ÎpI�

�îe«623b´µJKA�e6 ¯©^6m���q��JK6ì¤�â�Ú��

 ¬´µJKA��j6©^XXq�����JK6ì¤0òI�456C�l��I

�`²>APÏ=ëì�î�O²¼6¶·¡â��îuØè6/=X

b23JKÌ�î��6"%�C«æ²6"%eX��ì����JK6"%��

I��òÑI#6l��ÚJ3Ç�®yè�6�����5mûn�6�îhè6º�

µ*�³<è6C����X��I��9M��I#÷=6�i�ú93%=I#6÷

=X

�(g±`���ìÝ�?'��´µJKA�6o�u—ÁÑJ�{ÁÑJK�Á

ÑJK{ÁÑRS(�£�í¹NHÜÝ�&��ÞÝßÕº��:[@¸¦J���°

Þì8U��¿R��8¦�¸�d��TU�VW�:È¥×àåæ� ~ó:È¥

×�:Ḻð���â/�)%ã¸æ&×äåJÅ57�乯=�NX��´µJK4

5­Ì\6õÌ�k��\���6t¹õ|�23b´µJKA�eHû#/Ý �b�

�¨©eõj�º»�9Ì��½§ù´µººÃÄh.6d�÷Ø�â�º¹��2;

´µJK6rsXØy®�N�áVRSA�F¹C�6�[ygL¦��êì¦6Îp

��My@-Bºº¦Óf�Ù��ÉS²� CBMsyººI�g>>¹��ûN¦Îpõ

w�ôµu>6ç�­�]y{��é��Ý� CBMsq���¡PQøa�ü_�?

�î���r´�jyi±��45��H:K�23èÄ45á�pä��|}��

56 G. A. Almond�¦ö��ëA�qÑvÛÜ��ëN���"%��Úx¨!SX57 �?v6¾��Æ=Âx�Xc�<@2004� 6& 30'BX

Page 46: Department of Political Science College of Social Sciencentupoli.s3.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/finalP9532… · Department of Political Science College of Social Science

41

yduîAÝq�X

Xc�{ CBMsõ|����µd�Ýë�ë¯GC��â�BÑáñÄ7XJÝ�

78Ä7�ª�â�ð>ë¯78��Ö����Ç��Ã�r�6C��[X¯u�K

�45e«2;Ä7�ª�â�!"ë¯G/6��{K�456e«�2� �23è

���d�G/qËd��®w�âîèÜ�6���G±K�45u5Ï_6râû.X

X-�Ù�Ô�è�!Gè6K�45�ëÔ�­ÝG1¸>��t¦§UVS��

��¬§p6`²¶·n«±²()�ú­�³^ø8&XXn�CBMs ­b?¦ÓÏ=

6µ&�â�Õ*��Ì�¹¦�¦PQ6|}X�|Ï���Ï=6 CBMs�$Ù23

��îI�sþJK%�H­�S6fgÏ��9\�õ|�����ÐÑ¥òðÖ?´

µJK45��teH[6��PQ�ó���øa�ÕÖ´µIj�÷�­¥ò6´µ

ººXXq�\���PQ�sþ��JKäÈjº»�û� CBMs¤«^Ñ3(è�2�

9fgè6K�45ïâ�u�£¤78��v��G��uî6â7èX

ûÉüÝ�'��K�2345ý}(6`ò=�¹N58X����PQ6�2ë�!

" CBMsF¹9ù:�Ü�6ØÑè£m}·�wiz{�xÕb�î�¦e¶·�23

ÑqC��[XXc�ü�#/�b��¨©e6¼¤�§p�� CBMs�Î()�3|

=�´Ñ7�6���ÕÖûIÇ�Ijõå�­¥ò6ººX

<#gN¬=G>¬¶�Ó2�Ý�¬`�Ïv��PQ�K�2345xY�N59X

�����6$��2ßà�������6_;�!"23RS���786á��[�

�ÇXÕ�ãä�� CBMs6¡*��2�F¹|¦ CBMs63ù�uD¡*�ÚN01

6rs�n�� CBMsâîÚF6C��[:����l}l9\¾XXc�{��6$

��2"%��*]RS���PQ�(�g|�,¦���Ú�³#/6´µgN'Û�

F¹ CBMsGC6ßàfg��+ CBMs6>?�¡*�kõ=b¦ö���(�RS6

()��� CBMs6��³âî6ÚFX

58 �?vþàfZ:��x�XnäX�<@2003� 1&B�� 65h91X59 =G>�Ó2�`��v��PQ�K�2345x@(�N�3 S`��, 94� 9&BX

Page 47: Department of Political Science College of Social Sciencentupoli.s3.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/finalP9532… · Department of Political Science College of Social Science

42

�?GÖi�yz�Ý�6'K�2345�ãäRS(�£�¯`ò�=bNbd

s\� CBMs�ãä��6���ÚPA��ãä�� CBMsA��26¶·�/= CBMs

�ãä���¥7©ªÏ�16â7èXe¨�ªX60

���ê�¦ö³��PQëA!Ó6=b�â�®w�N

@�B�aã�Öi�8¦ Öi°���b[cd�e¹��JK66fg�Ì��l

f�6��JKX

@cB�aã�Öií¹��í�³��JK¶·��0�b���te�b��-¶e³

bd��exº¹ ¤�­â¬6A��õ­úÌò2;��¡Þ�9:7

86b��9�e�bÄ7èLFeõX¯=bIJ¾~�4�n�tîY��

Ô���bop�Ý¡_����Ýd_j�³�Ý¥_ü�e¨Y÷¨©Ïä�¯@

îj�Ú�Ü�X

@-B�8¦ Öi6b¦ÓR�<=e��H����ò²�b��`²����²

�nÔe6tu�¯�nÒíÑb�¦��e6_;X9Ì>?��­²�b��

,¦e�^<�ÐÙÔ�6µu�û��í�¶·��üyà()�%=��6í

��9Ì()ú¥¦ý{?#/¬ôt6¦Ó�,�í�Xf?��\��¦Ó�

,�����ª6í���¡ÑqËÒ�³Ò6���û�±²��A|�6�

�ì�2;�b6¦Óe6í��Ìij¹()�,²�6�¡ú̹�$(),

-�b�¦��e\Ñ�[ 70}��6Û~­tA�6e�¨ûX

@nB�8¦ Öiú :�����d�µ&LF�n­¥ßI�¬�à6���¦^

<��X�|Ï�ú{Ì��¦��²6_;ä��î��µ&d��<6é�X

�ÄÉ�ö�?bÄ7�6ñ2í�e�Ì¡>Ä7è6LF��C�����6�

Ç�õ��ÚJ=6í�XF�A|�2;í�ÚF­�6Ì�Fí¹�±èñ�

í�6��î`�@ëN]�_6�¦B:�qÄ7è6LFõ%Ù�t�¨Ñ6

`�@ëN��B:%��Ü�X9Ì�Ä7èLF2;66í���¡úѯ<

=6÷�XÑ�í¹bJ�e6��n«^ó�¦Ó=6|Ý�Ä7èLFCõÑ

60 �?v¶·�GCx�X-;äX�<@, 88� 6&B�� 1h21X

Page 48: Department of Political Science College of Social Sciencentupoli.s3.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/finalP9532… · Department of Political Science College of Social Science

43

â7G�¦=6}·��¤X�g|¹.�¯Ãûiá���Ä7��Ä7LF�

n­×�Ü�g|XÄ7LFSÙ:줭�ÃQ¦6d���23J�J�6

PQX9Ì�"%�úÑâ7�t�ºº�øa��Ñâ7���Cõ6õg|X

@qB���� CBMs6£cd/Ù��¯Øy³C�Ù�n«���õPL趷�?

*$�j@C��l}B6bï�e}·@� �¶*B�ú{Ì��6b`²eí

£¶·X

@�B�% 1996��_�()ë¯W���66÷ä*2GCëì23K�45϶·�

9Ì¡KGC#�õ���î�ªNJÝÌ �èÄ23JK6�hX®�N@�B

Ô�è45�.ë��Ô�����Çð¶·y@cBC�è45�.ë23Â~¨

TA <A�y@-B!G¤45�.ë`OUVS�´µÐ¨��£���¡¢7

��É�Ш¨y@nBb�è45�.ëb�´Ñ�'1y@qB�aè45�.

ë÷�d��u�d�¨X¯uÌì�bÝd_je�bÝF_qe�bÝ¥a_��e

¨«Ó6±�è�(`a��â��F�6��*2�!"ÚJK^6²æ�C�

?x <lï�6b�î�¦e¶·Xõ¡U6'ÛüÌv¾Wè¦ CBMs6Øy

����L�M�õÁÑ ­'s¶·6�ØXF��Ñ�¡>É�±�X6¡*�

Qûï�¶·@`²B¡Ñ3d��õ_ÓÑJKA�6°�X

@QB�|�¬ �6b´µJKA�eÌöÈ�½,��¬236bK�2345e�

̦Ó�¦Ó��¨��¬236yõ#/�ª¬ �6b´µRSJKA�e¯

8òÇÙѬ­��#/´µÝë3±GCQ.3öG�Y�NH�¿R��8¦�

ß�9��°:3��ªVW¸%�¿R�·��8¦�Jæç��èé�ê±ë

:èé��J��¹#/�ªC�^ìâ7(©��,¦`²�c6bK�2345e

�bJKA�e6��=bX�¥¤ÑÙ�#/ëAGUY���A�NH>ìà�

�°¸%�à�í�&â>Zîï��3I&��:ô�ABÄ[ðJ<H��â

ìN�¨ñ¡I&�:�`�·<[@/Gò�¡:ô�LJ<Hó�ô�ݱd

�,¬­J<H��¿R��Ä�¿R�·��8¦�J���°:R¸2¢�>Z

õöJÅ>��#/�ª6Ã��ëA!Ó6Ñ^�â��t¯�Ù�épbz{|

Page 49: Department of Political Science College of Social Sciencentupoli.s3.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/finalP9532… · Department of Political Science College of Social Science

44

}e�b>gL¦��êì²�MÖÃe�bCBMs­b¦Ó=µ&�â�Õ*��

î�¦�6|}e¨É�ÏëA !�#X

Page 50: Department of Political Science College of Social Sciencentupoli.s3.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/finalP9532… · Department of Political Science College of Social Science

45

2¢62¢62¢62¢6---- ����bcdefg����bcdefg����bcdefg����bcdefg----

ÑP���b23JKe}·�6#}�01�ª�â�³ 90�ô�%�GC¬è_�

$¡3 1993� 4&ÍÎÏ�tb�¹()�6��e�1993� 9&*2���MgL¦�

1994 �b�î�¦e���¤�1995�96 �(�ËÌTA�\]±A�1999 �ÍÎÏ6

b�¦=e�2002 ��ÐÑ6b�V�¦=e�³ 2005 �#/�"bC�Ò¦Ó^e¨

CD��EF6º�_�pÆ�Ê�±: 2008� 5&()cu�±� _���PQ*2

Çl�23JK��Ókñ�ÀÁX �ä}~tâI�{ÚP}·6ñò�ÚèÔ���

�¨�ì�0/¯�Ï®¤��c@�r�t 2h2BX

0000 2�2####��÷��÷��÷��÷HHHHU���U���U���U���JJJJ��,ã�ø¡��,ã�ø¡��,ã�ø¡��,ã�ø¡����1992�2012��������

¯ °¯ °¯ °¯ °

É 0 � �É 0 � �É 0 � �É 0 � �

����¯ªù¯ªù¯ªù¯ªù����FFFF

x úx úx úx ú <<<< � S� S� S� S

¬ ­¬ ­¬ ­¬ ­ . û. û. û. û

1 9 9 2 �10 * 28 µ�

12 * 3 µ

uô<u��

10* 28ü30µ�àýþ¸÷u���R¾�þÂ�Qw�{~&2«0�ßÕH3I&�[ðJ

:<�Þ a�#

uô0�#Hàu���N�� ���`E3:

�e&¸y?Ü�ßÕH3I&�J:[𸦺

ð3I&�:KL¸��Ùì>�Uc�wÙ�

��h:?f0�3I&�[ð�JÅ

11* 16µu� �uô0�#HàÇ��ľ{~&¸��0UcàÒ��{:+ù�¸Áw

�����h:?f0�H3I&�[

ðJG&h�¼u����ßÕ3I&�:[

ðÊZ����æ&�:Uc�^Ê�

Ä�0�:,�����u���âßÕ3I

&�:[ð¸� ���`:E3Ŧàu���

R¾{~&¸>É/3I&�:� KLÅ��

��¸º��þÂ�Qw�FG#{~R�ø�

��{��JÅ���öuô:0�?�Å

12* 3µ¸uôf�u�¸ºë±NO�0� cÅ

!�¸ÓðH3I&�[ðJ0�<�:a�¸�

Ò±y?Ò�æ&��>���:�"�#0�¬

­d�²%�3"$Å

ýþ�M>NO�

Page 51: Department of Political Science College of Social Sciencentupoli.s3.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/finalP9532… · Department of Political Science College of Social Science

46

1 9 9 3 �4 * 27 µ�

4 * 29 µ

%&'�uô

(R)�<*ïK

�u�)�

�³Î�c#3<��þÂ�QwÁÂ�cm><

��+,�SÁ5<Y-R.�cm¢<��67

~¦×�cm/<%*~N��cÅ

Xø0�23�%*

~�61

1 9 9 3 �8 * 31 µ

H��1J<H�

�X21þ

3J

6ÃÉ0§��<�9&�E345�«�ì&<Ï<

@<k<6<µ<7y 7 ��89�� 62[,:�

í;h¸��<��ê¸G<�à=�&��>�

â:�Ö9[$Å

1 9 9 4 �7 * 5 µ

>?þ¾�âáÍ�>�r45�§�u��Óß;h

�« N� 8�@�É Å63

1 9 9 5 �1 * 30 µ

AB)��`[

C�

HHHHAD�AD�AD�AD�JJJJ64

ùEN u���ÄÅE3~ómy?�F÷�G

���ºH½Þ ~ómIJ��G ��pÅX�K

1 9 9 5 �4 * 8 µ

qrs�LE�

HHHHqM�qM�qM�qM�JJJJ

à��� :��öN�&�E3m���~ßÕ

�ÄÅ?f{�3O�Pm,�y?N�QRof

~ó�G�ºH½:±S×mÊìÓxú'¹º�

G�ºH½Þ ��MTÅ

�E2>U?û

1 9 9 6 �6 * 26 µ

AB)�� [C�

����àH3I&�[ðJ�of�G�ºH½¸

Þ ~ó�cźG � <�IJ��G �

�VWXY��>p<Å

ð6Z[æ&p<

1 9 9 7 �8 * 8 µ

å\]�>? [

?�

&N~� º���H¸_�>? û`�H�

�øö�>yð&�J:�80�H3I&�[

ðJ Ê?:�æ&Å

1 9 9 8 �4 *

a�)� ��

)�

d}b¿R�ó¸��~U�¿R��¦×¸�Æ

¿RÀ7Ô¿¸�c¿RÀ7�h�¸ë���Ä

ÅÅ

61 X�uWZ:�Ì�µ��% 1949���,¦��¿´()�x�J��î6r�Ã�^:_�¹��@��½i²6�jA��ÆkI�PQ6Çl��2X62 SSÎ�|³m=¥��¹ 5#Ù�N@1B()Ì�¦­â��6�Ù�y@2B()¶·6>xy@3B�¦��Çð()¶·6f���y@4B()�µ��PQ6�2³¯ú>y@5B¦öµ&��³()6BX�rsNhttp://www.people.com.cn63 SSÎ�|³m=¥��¹ 3#Ù�N@1B(����Ò��6e£��Øy@2B(���PQ6�2y@3B()(���PQ6Ø¥1�û.X�rsNhttp://www.mac.gov.tw/ct.asp?xItem=68283&CtNode=5836&mp=464 �O,� 1995��[�«�t 8�`a�ò�ÌN@1B§p�î�¦6¨©Ìut��]�6fg�� y§ðC�(�|=�î���b�Ò��e�bjkè�î�¦e¨Ñ^ú§ðC�X@2B�?()�¥¦�2,=¡Þ£¤PQ�­p�}�9Ì�C���b�î�¦e�b���(e¹\66b,#¦ö�Ô

÷=e��X@3B�î����]��j��j"%�â�H���è±����Ñôtè��r�y��î�¦� ä��$¶·�â��yI�âÝ{b��î�¦6¨©ä�r�m@��:�Ü�e�î�jX

@4Bm>ut��]�y�¦�­��¦��9­��+=G1¸>X@5B`a­������()�J���¡ÞLFy��{Tuö«Ó�ªut±²b-�eX@6B��òd�k������£¤6#�*]X@7Bd�}ñ()�I6������ÓF`6fgX��()è±��èW���#/7����ú��rÉá¶X@8B��()�½6�÷��ú�¡¢:#/á¶�#/úf�²�()�ª6���½()yâ�dm¦Ì�úâ�Ý{ûK¶·7����{ÌÚJããÍÍ�úÌÑ6y­0òFÖ^ì¦öùLy

\­7b��­Ú½xeX

Page 52: Department of Political Science College of Social Sciencentupoli.s3.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/finalP9532… · Department of Political Science College of Social Science

47

1 9 9 8 �7 * 22 µ qrs�LE�

ùEH)[E3JX=�¸d��à� &���

ôõö¸�{³Î��ÄÅ��Å�E

1 9 9 8 �1 0 *

14ü18 µ

%&'�uô

(R)�<*ïK

�u�)�

ë±#3<ø1ºµ¸Ý±ef¦×�{~g8m

><ÝÞ�Ùhi�û,Ô�pm¢<÷��j

�I�klÒ��mÜ^m/<*ïKF�ðVW

¯8��p<y 4�NOÅ

öu<no�2>�%

*~�

1 9 9 9 �1 * 18 µ

pàq�&N¿

?rsåi��

û�

á�¹º��H¿R��8¦JþÖ�E#�

�~tuÞ �G�ºHê~ó¸à�~ó&¸y

?�{cã�¿Rvb¸F ��¿R��:M

e<¬­<¯°9¿ wäy�ÔÅ

xV

1 9 9 9 �4 * 6 µ

*ïK�u�

)�

º��¿R��ùEy@#�dà3�:US�¸

zÝJ3I&� H¿;WÝ���pJm��E¸

{áÅ|¯;?}�~¸����Ã�¿;¸�¯

:¿;¸��J�Ï:�¿¸zÝJ�¿¸d��

>Z�p�

æ&H%S��Jp<

1 9 9 9 �5 * 9 µ

)Þ�

H��+|�c�J2��#��9&�~��·

?úºµ¸���O�Ò¼{9¯���ÃĸU

�ÄÅAB¸�uë±y?)u:��9ÄÅÅ

2 0 0 0 �6 *

�v� ��)�

1�Ê?:�àÒ���ôõö¸�7����<

· ºµ¸���noZì��f~¸dÝQ��

¿R�h�¸}b�ó��% i�¸^���

·ºµ9��¸U���H¿R��8¦J N��

u��ÄÅÅ

�ÏÍ��

2 0 0 0 �1 2 *

����LE�

��Óß:��J23,¸�ø19�>:

¯�Óß�¸d}b��� º¿R�Ô>�,

:�{Ä�¸��ì�,U�H¿R��8¦JÅ

æ�EC���·

�a�����

2 0 0 2 ������`[

C�

HHHH3&3&3&3&X¢ X¢ X¢ X¢ JJJJ

É0#¡¢ö£ì3I&�¸�>Ä���¤3I

&�¸&�:[@ÄGò>­�¥m��àH3&J

ôõö¦¯§ä¨©� �c¸tªef��ºµ

Ä~ó¸�á�ùcH3&J+ù�:H¢I��

~J�¨©of�G���ºH½<«Ã��XY:

�í���À7¬°<��� ­ú<��Å

2 0 0 3 �11 * 20 µ

®Ï��>?

[?�

��Ó߯7½¶�·9ÄŸ>q°�>Õ±¿

R²³¸´µ��Óß:�$¸ª«¿R?�â>

Jì¶{���<�:?�¸{���<�:·�

£ì3I¸÷Jºµ9ÄÅ{�Å

) 92�¸?ûc�¹

2 0 0 4 �2 * 3 µ ����LE�

ùEHÄÅ���7AB��JBº¸[$��y

?�\�0¼»noÄ�n¸�T�»¿R½m�

¯1�:�[7!"�>�\�03¼½{���

7�{:?f¸�¾¿H3I[ð</�c�JÞ

 of~óÅ

Page 53: Department of Political Science College of Social Sciencentupoli.s3.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/finalP9532… · Department of Political Science College of Social Science

48

2 0 0 4 �5 * 17 µ

&N&À���

Ä1þ3<�

���R1þ

3HÁ3��hJ65

É0#ef��ºµ9~ó¸Åy�{¸of�G

�ºH½mU�H¿R��8¦J N�Bµ��Ó

ßÄÅ��ÉÊ:ÂAÅ

2 0 0 4 �10 * 10 µ ����LE�

����HM>ýþ~Jdôõ¸���u¿R

²³:H½¸)Ãð~of�G�ºH½¸���

{~óU���H¿R��8¦J �Ä`a��¿

.�r¸N��cHu� dÅðJ ëd�u��

ÄÅ:�#ÃÆÅ

�Ç~µ

2 0 0 5 �3 * 4 µ

�����`[

C�

HHHH�/��/��/��/�JJJJ

3<ßÕH3I&�[ðJ§>7Èm

><�ÂÄÅE3:� §>ÉÊm

¢<ËÌÍq°ð���):?¹§>ÎÏm

/<óº�ôÀ7§>7ÈÅ

É0º��Ä�r

65 2004� 5& 17'�#/��ÐÑÂ^\]6{æ�«��tbq�QøGe��ªY�b��PQ��¾te�n%±�()¥Cbn­�ÁÑe���PQ�:TUVWXøG� �3bqîX­e3ùNb|

µ§pb�î�¦¨©e63ùX­tl�|T���j6m>X­+=��()�Id������26

@�X­¿®�§ð� ¦�`²���É~6�?X­�����(��X­y�eX��X��øG��

tt�¯�(�Ú6f�¨©Nbjk������j��¨lm�r�m@:�Ü��23´µJKA��

d�v×��PQ�����265_eX��¤¹#/Ã�J� ³b´µJKA�e�MX

Page 54: Department of Political Science College of Social Sciencentupoli.s3.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/finalP9532… · Department of Political Science College of Social Science

49

2 0 0 5 �4 * 29 µ�

5 * 2 µ

ai��)�[

C�

HHHH��ÄÅÉÊ��ÄÅÉÊ��ÄÅÉÊ��ÄÅÉÊ

N�:ÐN�:ÐN�:ÐN�:ÐJJJJX2X2X2X2

þ�þ�þ�þ�66

9���L��N�É0#ÝÞof�G���º

H½¸ë±ÄÅ��¸UB��ÓßÄÅ��ÉÊ

:AB¸¨©U�H¿R��8¦J }b��¿R

ñòÅ

àó�Ñ@ç�¯Ò¸����~Þ åÓ���

Ƹ²?ÝÞÄÅ<U�¿R�·8¦y3 :y

@¸q°�âklÅ.�����~óof$�¸

3Ôì¼H¿R��8¦J ���)±ÓT:¿R

�·<�¸÷�VW{�Å

p<�>�ÄÅ�Õ�

2 0 0 5 �5 * 12 µ

Ö~×�Ø)�

[C�

�7�G���ºH½¸ÝÞU���ÄÅABm

��~ç��{~óof�G�ºH½¸�uë±

ÄÅ�cmU���H¿R��8¦J N�¨ñ�

uÄÅ9�·¸�Ã��ÓßÄÅ��ÉÊÅ

������~

2 0 0 6 �2 *

8ü1 8 µ

kÏM��nÙ

)�

2² 2008��)�Ø�¸^9�>�{��ÄÅ��:AB¸Þ%U���H¿R��8¦JÅ

RS�Õ

2 0 0 7 �3 * 13 µ

����LE�

~°��<t�9&�Nî�u:ÄÅ<�·9�

�¸��áI%m­½:ÚÛ9ÞÄ>&ª«:

²³9îïÅ

æ�t�iܶ�í�

�&T)«ÝÞ

2 0 0 7 �10 * 15 µ

�����`[

C�

ùE#Hà�3I&�[ð�:ôõö¸�{of�

G���ºH½¸ë±ÄÅ�c¸BU��ÓßÄ

ÅÉÊÂA¸ÖD��ÓßÄÅÉÊXß J�r

��Å

&�Nà�2s��·

��0�:� �Ä

��

2 0 0 8 �3 * 23 µ

kÏM�LEW

·��

tu�7³ÎH��ÄÅ�cJmq°ZáÄ�>à

��N�ÙÖ<¿R��ÄÅ��/��:�íÉ

ʬ°y 3? c�Þ Äź~ÅLEW·���

2 0 0 8 �3 * 26 µ

�����`[

C����àHM>NOJ:ôõöef���{ ¾�¾q��vb

2 0 0 8 �4 * 12 µ

a�)�^LE

W·��

:�>�`[C���êëHo���¸ÖD��¸

§ä�c¸N�yâJ: 168?¹Å 'ã�ä

2 0 0 8 �4 * 29 µ

�����`[

C�

�HN�� ¸U���¸§ä�c¸NDyâJ

: 16 8åãf~a�)¸1���~K¿ 2005 ��N��N�ɾ:H��ÄÅÉÊN�:ÐJø

1���ûæ�įç��yÙG¶��Ãĸ�

àHM>NOJ:ôõötªef���{~óÅ

2/�a�ai��

66 2005� 4& 29'��d�»\SÒ����i^�¦¦,±`�Âgd��O3b�����2d�fàe�P*��PQ���26½6#×�òd�Ö�q�ª6éFN@1BÖ�hªjk���j�d����,�+y@2BÖ�9ù:�Ü��[Ã��l}y@3BÖ���¡ÞSª78�23��¡ÞLFA�y@4BÖ�lm(),-P�6r�¦ö��6¶·y@5B23±�±�<C���X�rsNhttp://www.hellotw.com/zt1/ztfl/jlzt/wbx_dlx/WBX_XWZL/2008 05/ t20080527_359001.htm

Page 55: Department of Political Science College of Social Sciencentupoli.s3.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/finalP9532… · Department of Political Science College of Social Science

50

2 0 0 8 �5 * 20 µ kÏM�LE�

^è±àHM>NOJ:ôõö¸tªef�{¸

�éÕ'ã�ä&ùE:Ho���¸ÖD��m

§ä�c¸N�yâJ16 åã¸��N�êë:Åì�Å

LE÷ù�;

2 0 0 8 �10 * 18 µ kÏM�LE�

1�9�>U�H¿R��8¦JF��ÄÅ��

í쯰0m23,ÞàîÄU���ôõÅ

æ&Hï׶·�RJ

ð��2008�2/u�p<

2 0 0 8 �10 * 28 µ

�ñÈ��ÏÍ

)�

à��Ä{&¸U���H¿R��8¦J��ë

��ÃÄÅ:.Ƹ¦�e&¸�ZJF¯ç<�

� ¸W�ò¿R:�eÅ

ó#Áp

2 0 0 8 �12 * 31 µ

�����`[

C�

HHHH�M��M��M��M�JJJJ67

off~kÏM:y@¸�dH����V¯÷¿

R<�Þ æô��¸�aU��¿R�·��8

¦�<�J �ò�õ���¸à�3I&�[ð�

:ôõö¸�{of�G���ºH½¸ë±ÄÅ

�c¸BU��ÓßÄÅÉÊ:ÂAÅ

ö]§����÷�«

É030��¹µ

2 0 0 9 �1 *

�øh�{É¿

�ù¸�ÏÍÉ

�

��V¯÷R<�Þ æô��¸�aHU�¿R

��8¦J<�¸ìêðy?¡ú¿R�·g`Å68

2 0 0 9 �4 * 22 µ kÏM�LE�

��t��âè±û ��Óß@#·;#��U

�H¿R��8¦J.+d¯·ª¸��q°9&

��>üFÜ^¯çc��Fý¯çÓßo¼��m

�0�¸t�è±þ�º�¿�¸ºt�Óß»¼

�,Å

àLEâ9t�r�8

BH�íiÜ��&TJ

�CSIS��Ôab

2 0 0 9 �4 *

q¨3�&N�

�1Éã��

��·�à� <¿R? :��9��¸2²>

{�¸F�{�?>�¸ì�Z±d��Ó߸

�!­Û��ÓßÉʸºÇ©��>Z }mW

�,:Jy?U���¸d{�<�k�NO<D

µUSmºð��U�H¿R��8¦J<� HÇ

J��°:R�J >:G#�`õömÊÖ�{:

VW¯8,HUS�.:�êJÅ69

2 0 0 9 �5 *

kÏM�LE�

9µ0��Xø0ó#�#_Zà 2012 �aª¸>��ô/��� c�:�{Ŧ 11µ�&�����0�#H>���»3�,ëJÅ

æ&ó#op

2 0 0 9 �5 * 20 µ kÏM�LE�

��Óß:��¸Ê�? ~�°��·#�)�

�¸�FJ°�3���¸>�dÇI<�Ç3�

��ë��m2²��,Ä�>Þ ÄÅ�c~

ó¸FJH¿R��8¦JVW¸�>��,F�

�º�vwm.+Õ±ý��Éà¯çc�öÅ

÷ù���í��

2 0 0 9 �7 * 2 µ kÏM�LE�

��U�H¿R��8¦J3R H~�븦¯8

·í�JÅ70 p<��k

67 6�`a¹Nb���î�¦�����JKy��¡ÞLF�Ö�d��2y����£¤��ì��¢¾y�ì�Q½x�,#èW78yÛ�¦Ó`²�lm�¥µ&ym@:�Ü��[Ã��l}Xe68 %>iD�2009� 1& 21'�Xn*X69 gLD�2009� 4& 30'�A15*X70 Q�� 2009� 7& 1'�%>iD��Nb#/¦(P`^��2}*+�µ�~�hª23´µRSJKA�e¬µÏ&�X

Page 56: Department of Political Science College of Social Sciencentupoli.s3.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/finalP9532… · Department of Political Science College of Social Science

51

2 0 0 9 �8 * 1 µ kÏM�LE�

H>��9��� J F³Î¯ç��àä�

,m��Á*öª��¸��Óß��Î� HÇ·

£JÖ�Jm��u��ZJ�Ii1@ñò�å

:ÖP¸���`â��ÊË�{��:�$�

m£ìW��ìVW:Ç /Ï0Z ¸ÊË!

ì�T9&N�ÉÅ

æ&t�" X28B

H#'�Jop

2 0 0 9 �8 * 8 µ

$%&�>?

[?�

��ÓßÎ�¸2'oJ�?:d�8(¸~Õ±

íç<ºµ�/�{¸t�Õ±�mÊ�Á)��

:ÏC¿.¸^cìê�7��Óß��ÉÊÅ

�t�*cû+,-

2 0 1 0 �1 * 28 µ

õ�&�u�

¼^)�

�N��Ä��y?¸àóºH�ôJ<ßÕHM>

NOJ:N�� ôõö÷Þ��¸Ò±.¾�7m

åæy:H¢çJ?���¸��¯çÓßø/0

:o¼�<¦×�Ä8¦�m��Ù¢�æMe>

12�¸M,>1ùå¸���:ß oàÒ±Å

2 0 1 0 �8 * 11 µ

q%v�u�

^)3 �

)�

���±�ZáwÃÄÂ�º4¸æ�[�Jy?

ì��:ôõű5��ôõ¸÷J 2008���y?N�¨ñ:óºH�ôJ<ßÕHM>NOJ:�

ôõÅ

àH��ÄÅD6�äJ

7

2 0 1 0 �9 * 24 µ &()�LEâ

¹º�>G �8`9H��º�vw¸X^��J

:~µ�f~#�dÇJ3��:Ä@¸�º�

>? ��uÄÅ9½¶�·::×;E� �

�¸0�<���Å�1�¸�Ó"�âà&(

)�T@:AB�¸¨Õ��H>E<>ô<>ÇJ

:�H¸�àHM>NOJ:ôõö¸éÕH��

�d[¸º�)ìêJ:[ð¸�7���êNÛ

:ÉÊÅ

X2=

2 0 1 0 �10 * 19 µ kÏM�LE�

�â�XéÕHF¯��J<HF>��J/HF�

�?Jy[ðÅ���7�íG�c|îÄU��

�ôõ¸@2�{ ECFA 9N�ABCDÓÔy¸âJH�TU�VWJ �â��^��EFÄU�

����Å

æ�H2010�u�GE(�HI !pÔJ

2 0 1 1 �1 * 12 µ ��1

óºH�ôJ<ßÕHM>NOJJ��y?U��

��:�,+ùÄôõ¸J�¼Ç3+ùÄô

õ¸��Óß:Î�ÄÉÊ^Ú|~¼�q°y

?Zkl­d�{ijÎ�������cDµì

ê:US

@ ��

2 0 1 1 �1 * 19 µ

pK���1[

ª�

��y?~W#3<LM� ôõÅÇIôõ¸W

�,:÷JN�óºH�ôJ ��ÄßÕHM>N

OJm><ÃÕo�?:ÅW+÷J,Õ±�7��

ÓßÄÅÉÊÅy?~d�è±÷Þ��<��N

O¸.¾�7<Ò:% m¢<Z�ÉʬK¸¨

©����ÃÄ:ÙIG¶¸:9��? N��

¸$����¯çÃÄÂA�c:Ù��±c

e¸�7����!P��ÃÄ:8¦�¸Þ3Ä

2���Ù¢�)Ò�æ�Å

à2011�23uH��ÓßJQR É0�d

HLMôõ ÃÕ?

: Z�¬KJo�

Page 57: Department of Political Science College of Social Sciencentupoli.s3.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/finalP9532… · Department of Political Science College of Social Science

52

2 0 1 1 �1 * 28 µ kÏM�LE�

u���âþ�£ì3I&�¸¦�L>�Å2008�W·LE�¸:º�ùEo���<NDyâ:

^]¸%&��>©Å.efºHM>NOJ:�

�¸��à�� 6 * 11 µN 23�HA�Jef&1¼ 10�:���{¸Q?��ÓßÞöX:¯�Å©1�¸ÊËJà&()�T@:AB�¸

ßÕ¨ÕH>E<>ô<>ÇJ:�u�H¸àHM

>NO<3&Ù0J:NO�¸éÕH���d[<

º�)ìêJ�/Hºy<��<�SJ:[ð¸

ÖÊ9&��>:���7Å

ECH ���>?û

J±�20��ÇK

2 0 1 1 �1 * 30 µ

TÇn�·��

�[C�

Ù­ÙÍ�,UV&À:,�W�ë�'�:º�

�ĸ>1LMÄø1��ÓßÉÊ:� <¯ç<

��Ä)�ôõÅ�0�¸è±UVHF>��J<

HF¯��J<H¿XYÞJ:ô�Zé¸�ÞÙ�

�ÄÅàHóº�ôJ<ßÕHM>NOJ:� ô

õö÷Þ����¸ÃÕ.¾�7Å

2011�º��Äc

2 0 1 1 �3 * 1 µ

pK���1[

ª�

q°��Ù¢Aµcz«Ã�Xè[<#��­ü

:��Å\¸à��°Ò±·?ú<zh�<8

¦�:��,߸d��)°��ùú��Ä�]

:¦×ÃÆÅ�0�¸q°����'�Zá^�

�?:ÄEÞ3Ä� #3J����,cø_

`¸ab­¶Ä¢c¸ab�\Ä�OÒ½Å>J

��,cø�ö¸z,��� ¸c,d�� Å

¢J��,cøÕ�Å

H2>Uu��ä�

JÉã

2 0 1 1 �3 * 8 µ kÏM�LE�

��Óß:ÉÊ~�JHF¯��J<HF��?J<

HF>��J ¿XYÞÅ� :<�¸.+�íì

�eÜ^�,ÅÊË[$à&()�T@��¸¨

Õ��u�H>E<>ô<>ÇJ�H¸�HM>

NO<3&Ù0J��7��Óß:ÄÅÉʸÇ

©JÊ˺ìÓ��� 3I}�~:�ÖÅ

æ&Ï�H+f �J

op

2 0 1 1 �3 * 25 µ

pK���1[

ª�

��Óßà3©Wô�<�öÒ±NO¸ë±3

ÅÇ©NONì 3 �¸áF¸y?â󺪫Òf:�ô¸©÷Jóº�Ñ�ò¸¨ñ�u��¸

�¨ñ&()g¡#æ�:êëÅG�¸#�H3

I&�J:HM>NOJźðH3I&�J:KL¸

y?��Ü>� H¦����� ¸ÇJ�M>N

O�:�h±àJÅW�¸kl<�<�>°1:

Þ ���{��¸iÊÙ�G¶:�êÃÄÅ

9�)�j�L�0

Ô

2 0 1 1 �5 * 10 µ

����&N&

ÀL���

��y?,ßÕ#�H3I&�[ðJ:HM>N

OJ è±ß�óºH�ôJ�ÑÀ7màN��

ôõöU���¸Þ%��� ¸ÊÖ.¾�7m

�¯¸,� �Þ����!P��¸��Äø1

��j¢���¸÷1&(��Ä&()g��¸

�è±ÃÆ��ôh)*Nk����Ãı²Å

�&��)�Ûl[

Cjmn

Page 58: Department of Political Science College of Social Sciencentupoli.s3.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/finalP9532… · Department of Political Science College of Social Science

53

2 0 1 1 �5 * 11 µ ��1

u��äN1:Òf^¼½�¸N1:¯°M�à

*� 6 *:2>I�M¸duO�¸1�HM>NOJJ��U�� ��<ÖÊ�{~ó:�,ô

õ¸ }F��Ç3ôõ¸���{<��ÄÅÉ

Ê^Ú|~¼m¹º¡C,-o���RS¸q°

��? Záp�qr­ys��_ø¡C�¯

tu�L:<�¸©0�¸¡C,- �Ü!"&

(�nC�Î��$ûXY_ø¼¡¢C��¸

ÇJ�>? ;É:��Å

X2ɾ

2 0 1 1 �5 * 30 µ kÏM�LE�

à&()�T@AB�¸��Óß�>J�9�Ó

߸%J3�èé:Ó߸ÊËÚ@©>þ��

>:[@¸¦JÊË>~©>���>Wßà�

>춠Q @:R�¸vH�>þ�¸�>��J

Jº���HW�:{;¸©Jo���<§ä�

c<ÝÞÄÅW�:?@¸%��Óß»��:Þ

ʸ©ÂhH�>þ�[@<�>�� @J:�

�¸�ì¶Ü^lPwQÈ¥:��ÓßÅ

ECH2011�¡¢�í@�%m½¶cJ

ÖxyÞ

2 0 1 1 �7 * 11 µ

$%&�>?û

[?�

�â�7�>�r¸�HM>NO¸3&Ù0JÄ

def��¦×��{:ôõ H3&÷J&()

�¸íì2>�{;JÅ�1�¸��Øo:Ä{>

~�ફ� +ùÅ.+�>º�¹º¾:¿R

ÍÎÞÝ�à¸�>~[7ÁÂ�#:Ä@¸��

Ç©��Óß&>�,:ÆÛ¸��!ZU��·

:��¸Þ%^:3IØoÄ{:ÄÅ�peace with reconciliation�Xz¢Å

9xV( :{~

2 0 1 1 �8 * 23 µ uô

2008� 5* 26µ¸�É�u�¸0�Hu°�Ê�à�M>NO�:ôõö¸tªef¦×�

�{ÅJ

u� 5* 29µf�¸0ëHÊ�������¸tuà�M>NO�ôõöef�67æ�

9�{~óÅJ

°���¸���ÊÖ: 6�~¸³Î: 15��c¸âJ�M>NOdôõÅ)Þ�®[C��

M>NO¸|}ôõ¸>ì�ì�c:Ø ~�

<�¸��:�{©>�ZÅ

X2=

2 0 1 1 �8 * 28 µ

pK���1[

ª�

��ÓßÄÅÉÊ:RI�àJ3{���÷N�

� �U¼:��¸Ç{��:ôõ÷JßÕHM

>NOJ ÷JóºH�ôJÅàÇIôõö¸y?

*³Î3��c¸÷Jd��øv¼3hX�¸|

%QÇ{��:YZb�bzÅ2²ì�[$��

��:ôõ¸¦�¯��u��Ã��!è±øv

ö :�h¸�J>O�í:Å�2Ç�:º@3

ÔØ:���W¸ �ñB��Óß:ÄÅÉ

ʸ �îï���÷ècJ���÷:OXê

ëÅ�>? >Z��Å

ECH2011�� �Ã

�aJ

2 0 1 1 �10 * 17 µ kÏM�LE�

û`à�� 10 �¬�c9�>�³H��ÄÅ�cJÅ

H�+s� ��:ÐJ

�¹��

Page 59: Department of Political Science College of Social Sciencentupoli.s3.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/finalP9532… · Department of Political Science College of Social Science

54

2 0 1 1 �12 * 9 µ >?

1992� 10*¸��àýþ~¯¸°ð�>? ùEH3I&�J� ¾c�¸Ê?UcÙ���

�h?f0ëÅ!ð��h:¬­¸Ê?ßæç

1992� 8* 1µq+LErsF�[Õ:�E?ûc/G�c�H3I&�J:KL¸G&ù�

Hu����ßÕ�3I&���[ð¸¦y?±

���KLì±>�Å&NWß�d�3I&��

�d�&(�)NÄ��¸Ê?ð�d�3I

&��~� 1912 �±��'�&()�JÅ�>u���à 1992 � 11 *ºðÊ?ùEH��?fÙ�0ëJ0�HZ����æ&J ©÷J

��ºH3&JKLì>�:��¸y?Ù��

�?f0�>��ָǩ÷JH3I&�¸Ù�

0�J:NOÅ

 ���>?û0�¸�âºHM>NOJ:�

Ö¸�¾çW��â:�r¸©÷JK¿&()�

:T@AB �3g����Å1992�W¯ÜÚHM>NOJ�tu¸¦���|ë±H3&Ù0J:

NOÅÊË[$:H3&JWÝJ&()�ÅHM>

NOJ:��÷JH§ä�c<��{J ©J�

���ef¦×��{:�,¾çÅ

X2=

2 0 1 2 �1 * 1 µ

����&NL

���

àX:3��¸,ßÕHÄÅE3<3��¦J:

?¹¸àHM>NOJ:ôõöè±�7��Óß

ÄÅÉÊÅ

·���X�Kµ

2 0 1 2 �1 * 1 µ

pK���1[

ª�

'�^Þ3Ä����¯Ã�ĸ� �Þ��

�ÐÄ��>�°�~óÅ�¯¸àßÕHM>

NOJôõöè±�Þ�{~¸áF,2u³Î

H��ÃñÄÝÞ��JÅ�1� HM>NOJ:

�hJ��� ¸�ßÕ3I&���¸�y?�

��� Å��y?~à�ôõöÞ3Äd��

<÷Þ��¸|%d��Óß:)���ÉÊù

úcß�:ÃÆÅ

2012�2>uH��ÓßJQRÉ0HèæÖ

� ò�X�Jo�

2 0 1 2 �1 * 4 µ

$%&�>?û

[?�

�âßÕà&()�T@:AB�¸¨ÕH>E<

>ô<>ÇJ:�u�HméÕH���d[¸º

�)ìêJ:[ð¸�HM>NO<3&Ù0Jd

ôõ¸�7¦×��{¸ÊË[$H3&J÷J&

()�ÅHM>NOJ÷JH§ä�c<��{J

�#{�á���à����ö(�:<�Å��

�â|°��:�OÒ½��¸ÉÊ�N��{<

N�d���){�<�Å�0�¸¯� 3 �z�:��¸ÄÅ|±d��W�þV=Å��~è±

éÕÒ���<o���<§ä�c<NDyâ:

��¸����)��9êëdüF¸Õ±��¦

×��{:ìX�ĸ{���Ù���9�)@

ë<�¸÷Þy?�{<QR��¸îÄUB��

�êNÛ�z¸d�u��ÄÅ���M:ô�Å

����>? ~�� º&()�:�à¸�

X���

Page 60: Department of Political Science College of Social Sciencentupoli.s3.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/finalP9532… · Department of Political Science College of Social Science

55

�àÙIG¶¸¨©�í�yÒ���<��º

s¸!ZîÄ�k��¸N�ÖD��Óß:�±

ÉÊÅ

2 0 1 2 �1 * 14 µ

���1Éã

��

÷��·N�²0�¸��ÓßÄÅÉÊJ3Uo

�:ïé¸?�_����÷:�ÕÅ:�è±à

óºH�ôJ<ßÕHM>NOJ:N�ôõö¸9

��Ù¢��� ¸þ+ �¸èæÖ�¸Þ3Ä

ÖD��ÓßÄÅÉÊ:Xß ¸N� ð&(

)g:¡�f¢Å

2 0 1 2 �2 * 1 µ kÏM�LE�

��Óß9Ê�íÓß:Î�Ò£Ò±¸îYÒ±

H.¾¿�J�virtuous cycle� Ç©ÞÊ«Ã�â3 :^]¸�à&()�T@�¸¨Õ��u�H>

E<>ô<>ÇJ:�H¸�àHM>NO<3&

Ù0J:ÂA�îÄë±Å

æ�Ht�à��J

R[C¤-¥

2 0 1 2 �2 * 9 µ

¦k§�>?

^[?�

��*3I�c³Î:�e¸âJ���â8¦º

8¦¸��¨ûº¨û º<�Å*3I�cUB

E��Å�Å\¸÷©ªk«3�¸*3Ic�â

J3Ik«¸k«cz¬?c�¸���°UB:

Å�Óß^ìc�:ôõ HÇ÷J_L:ÄÅ:\

]JÅ

@ ��

2 0 1 2 �2 * 29 µ ��1

­J®±��ÓßÄÅÉÊ:��Ù¢��¸¨©

)Þ�ôh��¸IJ#Ë�VWXY��>¸÷

Þ���{Å

X2ɾ

2 0 1 2 �3 * 22 µ

jmn��)�

Ûl[C�

���à�7��Óß:¾ç¸J��­½9�>

­½�)ÓßU@¸ÇJ�H3��½J:\]Ä

d@^ôõ¸Ü^��R:Í�J>?¸%»

��͸ǯ�;h��>JH�9�ÓßJ %J

HèéÓßJÅ

j������

2 0 1 2 �5 * 20 µ kÏM�LE�

20 ����:T@�ú¸÷JH3I&()�¸�I­½JÅ

LE÷ù�;

����������������####���� ¡^���� ¡^���� ¡^���� ¡^----

¡>�tÉ���JK#}$%â��t���{bJKe�ªÏJ��Q� 1992�

6�:^_µ&èlmP*�×@[cd�B��Ã�b�î�¦�è%tbe¨©�I

�ÚJ²�@J­�íB6B�tb¹m��1995�6b�;�eò�b���je�b�

��÷�JáeÏÈ�_�$¡�ÂR()�ª6CD��EF�#/���è�Já�

lm�b(�ËÌTAeµ*��y²Æ|��,¦62}ä�*2 �323b´µJ

KA�e@´µØµ��B6#}�næçGC¯_;�ØyXõ#/©�¸ 1999�eÓ

>´��Æ@��ïB³�l:@Z[cB��bm@:�Ü�e�b´µJKA�e�

b´µ78e¨}·rª&���_ÍÎÏÝ�6b�¦=eÎù�Ü% 1999ä;�*2

Page 61: Department of Political Science College of Social Sciencentupoli.s3.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/finalP9532… · Department of Political Science College of Social Science

56

¸ 2002�=�kÞtb|Â�úe6à¹�±¸���6b��6-�e�t_Ókñ�

õ�çu�6ïg���9Ì�(ô�ÐÑÝ�6b�V�¦=e�\�ä�Ï_«=Ñ

��ëì6#>½��n�­����*6b¦§DESe��­³��b2;()´µ

RSJK¦cA�e¨}·�9Ì#/¡vÑí��ÍO��}·�Cõ� 2004��Ð

ÑÂ^\]6{æ�«��tbq�QøGeY�Nb��PQ��¾t�±�()¥C

�n­�ÁÑ����PQ�:TUVWe��i6��JK?�uLMNOX2005�

_��dpõ�Âg��Ã�¨�K±�÷�2*23JK6¦ml}�±¸ 2008�()

cu�±� ���PQÓkÑD��26�>X9�ik�t66¶·�Å{ÌYZ[

��pDbÝ¡_�e@�bü¡­�eB6�Ú�DX

Ã�b6¡¢��+m�ë_N

{���bK�2345e6��xÍ�$Ù�<�¦#/6�� ?Ú�ô�6Ü

��9Ì�¸�x6&�ïúpÆ��X|µâ��Ç�¦#/Ã����23b´µJ

KA�e63ù³Ð®���*26 ¡(ù�:_x� 1999h2009�;�=�Ѭ¹

6B�«ÓC��rª&�¨��â�Í:#/�ª´Ñt��õ¡KÐ�ú�L¯�

¢f��ÝTHb�î�¦ed�_?C«�MG/�l�6%�Xn� 2009� 7&�Y

Z[\]`*t�Nb��º�9iA°Á:e_�I���}·6C��J�Ñó£

6Á�X

�O,iô³���i<�°§pb�î�¦¨©eÌ��b23JKe6� �û

�â��=�b ;#e�_«=¤���¯f��è­:¿®X

ª���PQ®¤�#/*2¥�01b�î�¦�Ø¥ÑÅeÚN�.ë��?(

),-6Ô*�Á¦è��(),-­?`ab�î�¦{Ì���,d�¦e�ð�|

T(),�X9�¦ö��ÃÙì§`a���,d�¦Ì�¦n�L^��XÙ~��

�]�69ç\¾uØ�nw¿®�ú�ÚN�Ñq­�6®¤õX

$Ù#/l9\¾­®�9¯��«:�6b]�e�~¹�«ã6uD��X�

«ã6ÚNÌX�«ÜÎIÇ��Î:��23JKyXc«ÓÌ23_;�C«]�X

!"b£¤�¦¨¡Þ�¦¨���¦e���6"%�â�Ý��b�î�¦e¨©ä

Page 62: Department of Political Science College of Social Sciencentupoli.s3.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/finalP9532… · Department of Political Science College of Social Science

57

r�m@��:�Ü��O��Ï£¤í��¡ÞJ�%�I� ¤����Ç�jÉÃ

_��õ[Ã]�\¾X�q#/¦Ó��6©õ�¦ö()>6'��Ç��¯@��

%K��(�Ú��ÁÌè�¥�XÜ#/ÐÙÌ�NC�b(�e�§pb[cd�e

¹fg�{TbÝd_je�bÝ¡_�e�bà���e6����Ã��bS���

á©u�A�¤e678ؽ��[Ãb��Ô�e��õbË�¤�e6\¾X

Ú�?#/�½�|�tjk6�Ú��©¹NÛpb­]�­��­¸e³bJ­

�í`²�J­�í�²e6(�tÜ��b[cd����ète¹fg�opb�(

)¹`���,Ñ�e6¨©�{TbÝ¡_�e�bÝ¥_üe�bÝd_je6���

����¤lm��ª«JKX

2008�()cu�±� _���PQÓ>���/0põÞtD��2Ï�X9�

iYZ[\]6���ÚkC�p¹bÝ¡_�e@�bü¡­�eB6�Ú�D�GH

��623JK6��é%ÁüX

�����6JK#}$%�Ç��bK�2345e@�b´µJKA�eB�b2

3JKe¨}·6/=$¡ 20�3�Fúù3���J��gg�O6¡��MX9

Ì�u�tu�����¬:CD��EF�­>�FïÌb®�¯�e°wxëìÌó

Om>X

Page 63: Department of Political Science College of Social Sciencentupoli.s3.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/finalP9532… · Department of Political Science College of Social Science

58

2¢42¢42¢42¢4]]]] �����CD9hi�����CD9hi�����CD9hi�����CD9hi----

����1992�1999��������

236236236236--------CD¯uCD¯uCD¯uCD¯u----

��JK62;2? 90 �ô�¯�6PLS¹ 1992 ��:b^_m�e_¬[Ã6

b[cd�e�9Ï�(�Ã3b¦Ó]�PQ:e@�äF]Nb¦]:eB�/P:��f

:�NOv¦]#�x��"P?b�î�¦e6c8¨�4É~6Ý<´ÑéF�k��

��ªò�3Ú�6u��9G±±õ«6��J�lméFH�Ѭ�2X�äõ{v

;��JKñ#µ*���ëbÏX

;;;;<<<<§§§§�EFG�EFG�EFG�EFG««««9999HHHH3I&�3I&�3I&�3I&�JJJJKLKLKLKL----

�����v�v�v�v¦]#�¦]#�¦]#�¦]#�xxxx

1980�ô_<��q¦ö½������6�2��¦¦,±�gNAÒ��b²R

()eTôbÁk#/e�ûõ�ÛpbS¦L^èepDæç�ub�(L^èeX�b²

RgNeKL6�Ì�¦¦,±�²66����¤³�����PQ6ñ6��X� 1991

� 5&: 1992� 7&�Âùv�Q³ºi<Si¶lx�NOv¦Ó]�#�x@�äF]N

v¦]#�xB�v���,PQ¶.x��ñ6;2#/�Ú�����PQtÜ��X

1990 � 10 & 7 '�ÍÎÏ�\]�õÉK�±³9:èW���?\]�Ã3b¦

]:e�nñ´�i��ëW' �Z@®��Zµ���µ��¶·¨�K��B�^

GCPQXûb¦]:eyw3¯��K±³9:��@®��i�´¹¦]:PQõô

*α+6,�±��p¸¹B�¬�BÑ��%�6ôtè�`K>X

1991 � 3 & 5 '�v¦]#�x¡"b¦]:e³�¦¦,±±ØA�6G/�n/

ék�èW���?¡\]R���_$¡ 6 º�9?ï�nr�`O��i�\]��

S¶6�8x�î�3r�P<X1991 � 3 & 14 '�<Hî�33:�"�ù#/�

Page 64: Department of Political Science College of Social Sciencentupoli.s3.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/finalP9532… · Department of Political Science College of Social Science

59

Ú6Y÷¨©X71b¦]#�eS£ 824��£�]ÑÚ�Ìè��¦Ó]�¹\¾�3�

¸%@78J�B��%@JKLFB�þ%@lm]�B¨ 3jkXv¦]#�x{�ù

|¦BÑjkè³ôtè6d�£*X

cccc����bbbb��������eeeec8c8c8c8

1992� 8& 1'�b¦]:e�"P?b�î�¦e6c8��ÎÏ�i��|»b�

î�¦e¶·i(�63ù�¡�d�£*­³ô61�ú¹�ß,-¬­¼X¯�lñ

ò6ÌX��N(Hu����ßÕ�3I&���[ð¸¦y?���KLì±>�¸

&NWß�d�3I&���&(�)NÄ�¸^�E3���^±dG°�:3I�è

c �½�ÅÊ?ð�d�3I&��~� ±²±³ �±��'�&()�¸G[@/ð¡I

&�¸.+� @¸ðì/ð�´+k¸��Md&��3Í�¸¦�>'d&��3Í

�JÅ72

----�����8��8��8��8�Ä7Ä7Ä7Ä7

v¦]#�xQ�wx�¦6]�¬3�ÏgNf X�i¹|¦#/�Ú6l�Y

÷¨©����PQ �3�B�8�$�è6's÷=X¯ò�ëäN@�B\¾Nb�

¦å�e�23,`�%>�]Ä6�¦X@cB� N§pb�î�¦e3ù�Û�()

RS�+X@-B¨©N���<è��¨�J�X@nB�%N�¹ 3 îjk�®�N¸

%@78J�Bjk��%@JKLFBjk�³þ%@lm]�BjkX@qB]���

�PQ6��N����������u�X

v¦]#�x�"_�¯É�­ú½�3��#/µ&6f �úù _��2;

JK6���nÖÃ��6��¤lmXB�õ|�v¦]#�x��6Ä7ÑN@�Bù

l()ÉK�#/�Úí£6 !�ÑÖq˦Ød�Nv¦]#�xQ�����è£*�

71 v¦]#�x?,¦ 80� 2& 23'�>b¦]:eX-u:}�"y_?,¦ 80� 3& 14'¾î�3Xccc-u:}�"X72b¦]:e? 1992� 8& 1 '�X;u:}�"P?b�î�¦e6c8�S£d 3¶�ÎX�¶@r�Ø£B¥�·¹NXc¶�,¦ 38�@1949�Bõ��¦ ?wi�ÒÏÜ��>�î��u�����µ����¹ÛÉϵu�^ì��]�Ï`a� ­7¿s��µuÏÔ�XX-¶���,¦��¹�,

�Ï�2�¦ÓÏÄì��,Ï�+�8�b¦Ó]�#�e�æç�Td��*2]�«Ày Á#/�

½�¤7uµ�Ì��&u6��Â=Ã��d�LF�¹23%>,`]Ä6�î�¦õÃc���>1X

Page 65: Department of Political Science College of Social Sciencentupoli.s3.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/finalP9532… · Department of Political Science College of Social Science

60

BÆkè�8nÑÛp��(�tÜ6Ä7����cX@cBÑ�?��*2ûÄ%�6

JK�ó��d6���ÕÖ6�g|N§�nÄǯb��wx6\¾YD]�eÏ

ñ��â[ÃÕgq��nÑ��«6A:��*��¼½����PQÏ üåB�8X

@-BPŧpb�î�¦e�����6��]��ÑÖ����¤lm6�îN> 1992

� 8& 1'��"6ÑPb�î�¦e6c8�? 1992� 11&���µ&èlm���

ç#F1�nÖÃ3 1993 � 4 &6X�ubWZ:�e��³ _6����èlm�Ì

����78�jklm6Ã)X@nB�bv×èéÈe6�^�|Tb�lµ#e6x

�÷=Nó�#/�(�Ï���nÆÎ6�ÞØ]�|}6TA�*$3()�,�¯

×�Õg6K�X@qBF¹���jkl��é�~Lè�#/éF6f �´)Nv¦

]#�x�i̹��,¦#/�Ú6bl�Y÷¨©eX¯ �Ç� 4¨©� 3jkÖÃ

]�XâÚ'()#Ý�#/���)Û���,¦6}¾�k¹��ãäJ�J�fgX

õb¦]:e¬�"6b�î�¦e6c8Ù��©� 1992� 10& 28'¸ 30'�

�f��l�:�b^_m�e����3Sò�È6Ä7�±²ÖÃ3I�lm6ù�

[Ã�nC�Ф¹_x#Ó¬­£6b[cd�eX

�lm6�ä�#/{b�î�¦e¶·6í£¹N@�B��]§pb�î�¦e¨

©X@cB��]m>��¦Ó]�X@-B��6µ&èm���­�³b�î�¦e6

��c8X

õ|�6í£©Ì@Ã)v¦]#�xBNb��µ��d�m>��¦Ó]�6"%��

I�$]§p��î�¦�6¨©�9�?��î�¦�6c8�í£èÑ­��2}�1

è%O\øG6��tb�î�¦¨©�eX¸��P?b�î�¦e ©tb¶·6/=�

��ÃI�ÚJ²�@J­�íB6�kB�tbØy¹m�õE�k�X¿��b¦]:e

¬PÅ6b�î�¦e6c8�¯Ä1â®w¹N@�BqË3�i()ØÙ�b�î�¦e

¶·6d�X@cBÎÏ��|»b�î�¦e¶·i63ùX@-B? 1992 � 11 &��

�µ&èlm���ç#F1�b[cd�eÏb�î�¦�è%tbe>�O�X

====<H<H<H<HM>NOM>NOM>NOM>NOJJJJ----

Page 66: Department of Political Science College of Social Sciencentupoli.s3.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/finalP9532… · Department of Political Science College of Social Science

61

��������1992��:��:��:��:bbbb^_^_^_^_m�m�m�m�eeee"%"%"%"%73

1992��û���,=78�Ápq�ÑP��£S*a³d�����¶·�ÉO

ÇðX�f:? 1992� 3&�ôt.����l:J�lm��_�:¡'�x�C��

ð�? 1992� 10& 28'�^_lmÑP��£S�aÏl}X74

@�B��lmÊ�b��¨©eN

��Ï��>?#/ ���l}0�b�î�¦¨©e¹� �ò��l}£�

�MÚP£�X�l:n � 5 Ä�h�Ø�]�Ñb��£S�aÌ�¦ØÙ6µ&e

�b��]§p�î�¦Ï¨©e6£�X75�?�l: �6 5Ä�h�()�ª«^²

��9ú�í:ë�­{b�î�¦¨©e�� <��Ë«^º»¼½���=àáÉ

OÇð6¶·¤kÆÅÌXû��>b¦]:e�b�î�¦e6c8ØFÇò�F¹

|����m�i6f�3ùX?Ì� 1992� 8& 1'��"3bP?��î�¦�6c

8eX

@cBI� � <b��e¶·�hN

��#/¬ Ï 5 ��h�()�ªC;GC�>/P: � 5 Ä���h�i²�

f:?:��Í� �X76�f:n/P:i²6 5Ät[�h�µr¹ 3Ä�n</P

:���¡ 3 Ät[�hÌN1.�?�¦Ð ?wi�ÒÏÜ����µ��d�m>�

�¦Ó]�6"%��>?��,=78'pq�¹rs���,²��?£S�a

73 �?¦�fZ:¤¥�¦R@+B090-001�@2001� 9& 6'BX74 �u:�6r��]¹Nb���£S*a�³�b�x*�Xcu:�eyI�ôt¹à�Î@�f:^

øý& ¶B³�¸@�l:¦cÙ¸`^B��Ý�ylm`·¹b��£S�ae³b��b�Kx�

cdeeÚPµfX75 #/�ª6 5î�h¹N@1B�µ��£SG1¶·Ì�¦6ØÙµ&X@2B�µ��£SG1¶·Ì�¦6µ&X@3B�µ��£SG1¶·Ì�¦6µ&Xs�:�µ��Ô�­���@�¦ÓówÉÃ]�B6tu�¡öµ&ѯ÷�è��"�l:��¦`aQl:��f:6�¨lm�M�tuÇÏX@4B��µ��d�m>��¦Ó]�6"%��I�]§p�î�¦Ï¨©����`aSG1@�¯�m�µ

&B��tuÇÏX@5B�µ��PQl:��¦`aQl:��µ78fZ:Ã�µ��]§p�î�¦Ï¨©6d���"�¨lm�tuÇÏ�µ��£SG1¶·X76 |�e~6 5��h¹N@1BI��qb�î�¦��î�¨��u�e6¨©X@2BI��qb���î,`�%>�]Ä�]�6�¦���µ&�Ì�¦�6µ&e6¨©X@3Bo?�µ��¶< ?�ÒÜ�����d�m>��¦Ó]�6"%��I�Ðí¹¥¦{£S�a@�¯�m�µ�B��tuÇ

ðX@4BI��qb¹���î��,`]�6�¦6¨©eX@5BI��qb������,`]�e6¨©X

Page 67: Department of Political Science College of Social Sciencentupoli.s3.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/finalP9532… · Department of Political Science College of Social Science

62

�tu��ÇðX2.�µ��£S�aÌ���¦�=6µ&X3.��µ��d�m>��

¦Ó]�6"%��I�$]§pb�î�¦e6¨©�9�?�î�¦6c8�í£è

Ñ­�Xno?��,=78'pq�¹rs���,²��?£S�a����t

uÇðX

1992� 10& 28'�I�>�f:��l:ôt�^_2*m�X�:m"%��I

�Ã� �t[�h�C;˺X()�ªi²�f:�b�î�¦e¶·�bè%O\

tb��eÇðX�l:ôt�� }wt²����ùm�X�f:ôt�û¸ 11& 5

'���l:ôt«kÆmÏ�f_���_Ñ(X

@-B�f:�x�l:`aè%O\øGt�N

�f:n? 11 & 3 '�O6ýºt�Nb�l:��u^_m������î�¦¨

©��?§p��Ѭtb��:¡kH`�AP����O\øG��è%t[�â�

²�X¸?O\øG6B�Øy�|�e)v¦Ó]�#�x³�¦Ó]�PQ:��

� 8& 1'�?��î�¦�c8¬Fð}���t[eX

Ì'��f:n�bØy�x�l:X�'��l:�;�f:�t�}ñn²�

�f:Ï2}X77

@nB�l:r�&xt�}�N

�_��l:? 11& 16'r��x�f:t�Nb��^_m�����f:ôt2

}�{1�:è%O\øG6��tb�î�¦6¨©�n �B�tbØy�¯�G�

t[3��]§p�î�¦6¨©T11& 3'y:xxr��£|:t�kH()�ª

6����O\øG6���è%t[X|:d�}ñn²�y:62}Tt|:~F

O\tb6ò�xEy:��µ���§p�î�¦6¨©�m>��¦Ó6]�X9�

�µ��µ&èm���­�³�î�¦6��c8X��������`aSG1@�

¯�m�µ&B��tuÇðX�e

@qB[Ãd�_$�bWZ:�eN

77 1992� 11& 3'�f:r��x�£�l:�ÑP�ª��b�O\øG��è%t[eX�'��l:²<�f:xx�3­>�l:Òã�¸�S¶�£�f:��Ó�S¶b|:d�}ñn²�y:62}eX

Page 68: Department of Political Science College of Social Sciencentupoli.s3.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/finalP9532… · Department of Political Science College of Social Science

63

11& 16'xx_��f:ów&x��l:(? 11& 30'?�xx�ïgi'ut

bZW:_e�n2}? 12 &�´�îØÑè£m�12 &ä´utbZW:_eXe)�

�6"%�â�H£ 1992 �6���:m�6m�Ì��ñòbd�e�®�äâ 3 �N

1.�b�î�¦e¨©�()�ªí¹Ìb�î�¦�è%tbe�#/�ª©í¹Ìb�

�µ��µ&èm���­�³�î�¦6��c8e�789�iúnwG�C�b��è

te�ûÏ*2'_6WZ:�Xû�âÑ�¹��=6��ñò6bd�e�bJK6*

ÝeX2.()�ªtb6Øy®��f:X-h�v¦]#�x³b�î�¦e6c8X�

���d�ªt�í£X3.�l:ú�b�î�¦e³b��¦Ó]�e6¨©ä� �

�µ6tbØyX

��(¹ 1992��:^_m�Ïßà�"%X�u:�6ÃÄ�¾�q���3'

�xJu6��tl�I¹ _��JK62;P*3�×X

cccc�����M6p��M6p��M6p��M6p�NNNN����bbbb����è%�O\tb�î�¦����è%�O\tb�î�¦����è%�O\tb�î�¦����è%�O\tb�î�¦eeee::::bbbb[cd�[cd�[cd�[cd�eeee

��b6 1992� 11& 3'¸ 16'�:6x½x���â��tb�î�¦�è%t

be6 2� 8�6�vÑ�t"yõ% 1992��:b^_m�em@: 1995� 7&*2

��b(�ËÌTAe6e<�()6Ô�`òQ�b����è%�O\tb�î�¦e

xñb�u:�6º»X79±¸ 1995� 8&�Ó>i^�f:ÕS¶6ÌÖ�Ý�J�G

1b�î�¦�è%tbexôt 1992 �b^_m�e6bd�e�¡ú{Ì_x�ß�

¬í£6b[cd�e6B�ØcX80

¸? 1999� 2& 1'õ²^/P:`P6�õÝ��©�Å� 1999� 5& 27'�9

& 11'³ 2000� 4& 28'�`*�t3 3u���Øy] ³3b�����î�¦�

6Øc[Ã�è%tb�6�d��ey¯�I�Hb��[cd���Myw¦�,�d

-±6��î�¦�3ùeX%�õ_�b�î�¦�è%tbe6b[cd�e¬M�?

78 �£Ï]¹b��­te¨©X79 �ÍÎÏ�\]? 1995� 6&eá¶,¦p� #ë_��� 6& 16'�l:xx���:Ï=6lm���iõ#/�l:�bè%�O\øG��t[�î�¦¨©e6d�°�3®¤X80 �f:�S¶ÌÖ�Nb#/�ª×` ���µ�:�m����î�¦�è%tb���ÐÙú1�

+¡ôt�l:7&:�:d��©¡î�¹ÌÎ6X�?()6�D�1995� 8& 8'X

Page 69: Department of Political Science College of Social Sciencentupoli.s3.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/finalP9532… · Department of Political Science College of Social Science

64

ÇØ�X81

#/�ª©�­uÏ_@2000� 7&³ 2001� 4&B�>i^�l::¶6Z[cÝ

�³¦(P�|�aÙ¨Ý���¬ �6b[cd�eÑG�6&��×a��ib[

cd�e�M­Ì()��ª�Ú�f6�(�Ñ^X82

¸?>b����è%�O\tb�î�¦e@1992� 11&�_B�b�î�¦�è%

tbe@1995 �B:b[cd�e@2000 �B¨�M6ÛÜ®¤��õû? 2000 ���¦

¦,±���²�,�±J�ù��,¦6@�±Xû¹,�±�d°±��b�î�

¦eØ¥s�X?Ì�i^/P:`P6�õÝ�� }G1b[cd�e¡î�M�ô

b��ètey<>¹Nb¦,±ò���èt��d°±ò�����,�±üò�èt�X

¬��{1�[cd��x>� 1992 �?b^_m�ei6~î�¹�m�eX¯1�{

Ì�b[cd�exxÕb��e¡îs�6�MX�õÝ�ö¹£t�Nbû¹Ó���

�à�ïg7v×ûîéÈ>?�8��7���î�¦�¶·�ÇÄ���ö� 2000�

4&è�`æ<�«�v×�[cd��¡�î6�M�� Õ*��î�¦�¡ 4î��

ncÞ��è±6`aeX83

----����������������bbbb[cd�[cd�[cd�[cd�eeee6í£6í£6í£6í£NbNbNbNb����eeee����bbbb����eeee

���:� 1992 �ª�b�î�¦e6¶·i�¯uª�6ÌNb#/`a()Ì�

��,d�¦6�Ù��9()©í¹e)��,¦¶^���,¦ÓÌ�¦n�L^�

81 /P:`P�õNb��=6¶·`òÑ�ö��Ì��趷���ÌuØ趷�#/�ªë��±

ò�|����î�¦�¨��è6¶·�ÝÞ­¨�­ú¶·�­É���PQú­d¿uX"�¡*Ç

�������î�¦�6Øc[Ã�è%tb�6d��Ó7ù�ÖÃX�uWZ:�X�?gLD�1999� 5& 27'X/P:`P�õNb��î�¦�è%tb�Ì���:6d�����ÚJ}ñy��î�¦Ìwx6��

û���Ñ~�]�6fgy9]�Ìwx�­Ìt�X�?�¦iD�1999� 9& 11'X/P:`P�õ? 2000� 4& 28'��<�#ëÕP6¦öë¯G/:��M��H�b[cd�e�

Myw¦�,�d-±6b�î�¦e3ùX�?gLD�2000� 4& 29'X82 �l::¶Z[cNbjk�:²¼��6PL�Ì()�ªG���­���¦=�����: 1992�[Ã6è%�O\��tb��µ��]§p�î�¦�6d��¡U�:6µ�{ÎP�²¼��{âY

�*$eX�?�¦iD�2000� 7& 14'X2001� 4& 27'�¦(P�|�aÙ¨Nb�[cd��Ì�îÛÉÔ��­úr� 1992�^_m�6�

l��f:�µ��í��f:Vµ¶WXY��ú�íTeX83 �õ��R¦`��'�õ�N��î�¦�è%tb�d�6�8�Ãc(�vb�î�¦�è%tbed

�6�uxµ8q*�@(�N¦Ó�ÚGCfZ:�,¦ 95� 9&B�X VII�X

Page 70: Department of Political Science College of Social Sciencentupoli.s3.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/finalP9532… · Department of Political Science College of Social Science

65

�e¡î��X_x(��b¦]:e�b�î�¦e6c8F�øG_�ÑPb�î�

¦e¶·�nw?ù���:lmÏsâ�ûõÖà 1993� 4&�6�\Õî6X�u

bWZ:�e³bn�µ&èl}eÏ[Ã��¹PLÏ�X

�i�:��7ÛÚJ²�6ñ�¹N���ª63ù�¨©®� 3�N@�B§pb�

î�¦¨©ey@cBm>��¦Ó6]�y@-BÑP��µ&èlm��b�î�¦e6

���c{Tb��­te��X(��ª63ù�¨©���f:X-î�h�ÑHi

¨Ã�ú®� 3 ��(@�B���¦]�y@cB§p�î�¦¨©y@-B�?�î�

¦¨©6���c{TO\è%tb3ùX

�Aº�ÛÜâ��t���Ú����?b§p�î�¦¨©e�b��¦Ó]

�e�­����?��í¹�µ&èlm����î�¦6���cb­te�(��ª

©í¹���b��e���c�â�bèteXõ�i��7Ûª�%b­C�eÑPbO

\è%tb��î�¦�e6 }�Qû(�t�Nbe)v¦Ó]�#�x��¦]:�

�?��î�¦c8�¬Fð}��t[e�(Ì�b§p�î�¦¨©e³bm>��¦

Ó]�e 2îñò� Ïä�I�Óf�8¡î� 1949�����Ï_{Ô�6��|

}�� 1992�6 11&��:3�îI�â�²�@�b­C�e��bÙ�²�eB6bd

�e��¹PLÏcX

��ÏPLÌÖÃd�b�e6Ù��õb�e6Ù�©�?���tGb��­te

3ùúb?��µ&èm���|Ï�¯nÁÑÑG���wxâ76��èm�Ì�¤

ú1b��­te¨©X­"����63ùÍx�wx��6��èm��ÑPb�î

�¦¨©e�¦Ó]�¶·�â7­:²�bè%tbe63ùXrë���¬Ñ6�ü

Ñb��µ��µ&èm���­�³��î�¦�6��c8e��¹PLÏ-X

nnnn�����8�Ä7�8�Ä7�8�Ä7�8�Ä7

�_Æ6�2����f:Vµ¶6WXYÝ�öÑNb�[cd��nÁÑ consensus

@d�B�ë�ò¶���í¹Ñ consent@���]àB� accord@Ú��ÇBeX84�¦ö

PQ6>?xÍ�1992 �6�:"%�m��Ì�î23JK6î¹Xb[cd�e¯u

84 v�»'Dx�2002� 9& 19'X

Page 71: Department of Political Science College of Social Sciencentupoli.s3.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/finalP9532… · Department of Political Science College of Social Science

66

{Ì 1992 ���23JK6ØyXb[cd�eµu�úÌ�µ��²¼�¬[Ã6l

ñòbd�e�Ì��lm³JK6fgX��¬Ñ¡7�6l}��³r�m�6l}�

âÑ�ûb[cd�eõ<HutX9 1995� 6&ÍÎÏ\].,p� #ëá¶Ï_�

#/�l:í¹()�ªß�b�î�¦¨©e��b�î�¦�è%tbeº3,#Çò�

õ*26bù3 1992 �6bd�e6Øy�³¸ 2000�,�±��@�����ªIS

t�í3b[cd�eX

____<<<<��PQRS��PQRS��PQRS��PQRS----

��������ßà¡"ßà¡"ßà¡"ßà¡"

2000� 7 &O�(�6vm���x���i� 1992� 10&6�:^_m���

��(=Ñ3b­¹�£e6C��[�85Å{Ì% 1990� 12&¸ 1992� 8&=�¸±

9u64G:@�r�t 3h1B�ÑP��ëbëÀN

()�ª64GQ>ÍÎÏ�\]6ÕS�?@³i^�s��¡<6��su^�

��ÓßQàn r�X#/�ª©Ý_Ѧ(P`^�'�@1991� 6&�B³�á¦

@1991 � 7 &_B�¦,±ÀØPQ:@,ÀB¸`�â¤ã��l::¶Z[c��»

P`ä`^öåU¨�{�}~6Ì^_6¦ë#æá��X

e)vm���x6!·³ 2001��*6vÍÎÏ@�Euäx6P��Î3�b6

9 u¥���4G°S"�=�@á��B�¥±²ª:3 18 u�i=¸ 1994 � 3 &¹

ù�4:��©®�3^_�(�����ç�³èò¨�X

�¡ 27u64:��I�¼³6}· �/é�®�b��¡Þ÷�e�bLF���

�ã�e�b()�M¾¢�]e�b����e³b���6�\LP¦ö�0e¨¡Þè�

µ&趷y9`ò6��°ÌËÌ�I�j6��è}·��ë�D���ªÇòÍ6

��<?@ë��\]±A��(�6ò�B�¦]:�/P:��f:_;³v¦]#�x

Øy�n#}78��l}¨Xõ���ª©ö }Nb±�±�je�b]�¶·e�b�;

�Øye¨X

õ¯�l6�p�6Ù��Q�ö!"��[��ÍÎÏá,�E£#/ÚPC��

85 �3PéêGö? 1995�P�ÚPµ*�9Ú�½�í_­33ÏX

Page 72: Department of Political Science College of Social Sciencentupoli.s3.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/finalP9532… · Department of Political Science College of Social Science

67

�<THzÇ�9È�nwëqybp� Ïîe_�I��ù:ªX

0000 3µµµµ1 {I��¶·�{I��¶·�{I��¶·�{I��¶·� 9���PQ¬­+,���PQ¬­+,���PQ¬­+,���PQ¬­+,

¯°¯°¯°¯°---- ­�­�­�­�---- PQPQPQPQ---- [�[�[�[�---- ±²±²±²±²----

± ² ² ¸ �-

±³*¹±µ-ý þ-

º»¼-

½¾Ù-

¿Àk-

T'Á-

� HX�7ûÂïuJ<�-

� º�ùcH��¯�è½J-

á� -

± ² ² ± �-

³ * ±Ä µ-ý þ-

º»¼-

½¾Ù-

õÅÈ-

ÆjÇ-

¿Àk-

T'Á-

� ±~HX�7ûÂïuJ�ÒÓc�-

ùE³´H��ÄÅ

�cJ-

± ² ² ± �-

¹ * ³² µ-ý þ-

º»¼-

½¾Ù-

¿Àk-

-

� y?ºðHX�7ûÂïuJ�f~-

� ³´H��ÄÅ�cJ<�-

³ H��ÄÅ�cJ

�ùcÈß-

± ² ² ± �-

É * ±É µ-ý þ-

º»¼-

½¾Ù-

õÅÈ-

-

� �>êëf~��HX�7ûÂï

uJ�HM�J~µ-

� d&N&À:of=�-

-

± ² ² ± �-

Ä *-n o-

õÅÈ-

¿ÊË-

p�-

� a�ÃÄABuö0Í<�-

ë±NO-

Page 73: Department of Political Science College of Social Sciencentupoli.s3.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/finalP9532… · Department of Political Science College of Social Science

68

¯°¯°¯°¯°---- ­�­�­�­�---- PQPQPQPQ---- [�[�[�[�---- ±²±²±²±²----

± ² ² ± �-

±±*±Éµ-ý þ-

½¾Ù-

õÅÈ-

pß)-

-

� ��øö¡�,-<�-

��ºötu[7

ÎÄ�QwH�´+kÓÏ

½J�-

± ² ² ± �-

±³ * ³ µ-ý þ-

º»¼-

½¾Ù-

ÆjÇ-

�ÐØ-

� Ñ.X3ÒP- -

± ² ² ³ �-

É * ±É µ-ý þ-

º»¼-

½¾Ù-

õÅÈ-

ÆjÇ-

*ïK-

�ÐØ-

� º�� HÄÅNç

�{E3Uc�J

�°y?Óf-

Ô�á�H%*~J-

± ² ² ³ �-

Õ *-� n- �ÐØ- � Ppqrs- -

����������������####½¼½¼½¼½¼ §§§§x9�Öx9�Öx9�Öx9�Öüüüü|����|����|����|����3�3�3�3�3�3�3�3�«««« ×××× ±³±³±³±³ÅÅÅÅ

cccc�����8�Ä7�8�Ä7�8�Ä7�8�Ä7

��64G7½��i���36��PQ��ä�°�3�K�8�Ä7X®�N

@�Bi�ÍÎÏY{^\]-wi=�#/�ª(`�2*²¼�Ç����©�Í6

<Oi��õ)�,¦m�¦#GÍìG6vÍìG&ãäx@James Lilleys MemoirBÒ��

ÍÎÏúP¯¯D�O,ra��­:ÔO()�3X��çÑÖ?���ÍÏK^X@cB

()�ª64GQ>Í�~�÷�Gj¯�6±��©�ÚP6ðÚ�¡È�r�6A:

�ÑbXû����[¹±'�ðÚ�"¸Ì��ZôX@-BÍÎÏ{^®2�É�ð

Page 74: Department of Political Science College of Social Sciencentupoli.s3.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/finalP9532… · Department of Political Science College of Social Science

69

>æç�T³*vè6F¹�xáS¯��²>³��Xõ#/�ªûb`Ròµ*eÚ

¦ö�ru�¤�i'()b��jí��©Ñ���]�#���©ÑÖ?¯¦ö

�Æ6¿uXûÏ����Ñ×Û6îûð�ì¤C�LFX@nB4G:�°|3n �

6��õ|� H�î���06A:X�f��l�:³4G:Ï�G�ï�¶�[n

î����6ÚJ�Ç�C��˺*ð3�¶b/Fe����23e«JK6éF�Ã

cç#Xn,�­×6Ù��?NÚÜ?#/�ªb¤ÁÂÚP�&�(>¤.:eÏ�

�¤6EF�()6çç±'�r����ðÚõ|�d8?î���¤�ñò?¦Ó~

��6�¹��X

----

----

----

----

----

----

----

----

----

----

Page 75: Department of Political Science College of Social Sciencentupoli.s3.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/finalP9532… · Department of Political Science College of Social Science

70

2>2>2>2>6666--------hiÓ"hiÓ"hiÓ"hiÓ"----

¡"3�� 90�ôe<6�ÂRJ�³I�b��Ô�e@b§p�î�¦¨©e�b�

�¦Ó]�e³b��ète�b��­teB6m>_���JK*2óô�9Ì��¿

ÈÉ�ü6ÊË��¤Ñ®'�t�6�6��JK$¡3õ&<�ú*2´Ñ²�fgX

;;;;<<<<jklmØopjklmØopjklmØopjklmØop----

��������ßà¡"ßà¡"ßà¡"ßà¡"

1994 � 4 &�ÍÎÏ�\]�\]�²�'���FÓ�Ynäo6!á�86�ª_

6X���ÌNb�YÝ��|Ñiá�(ö÷Ñe��_¶�3 6 îáliX!áS£·

¹N'�¹()�6��(�? 1994� 5& 5'��?'�vÉ'��xX

á�É�WòëäN@�B�'�ag|�ÍøY�8()X¯�¹b­òúù�()

Cr̤¥Ï�eX@cB()�#/Ì­�6�����,¦��Ìû#/Øg�Jõx

()��¦d°±v()®¹���,d�¦6�ú�b¡Ìûü6ýþ°eX@-Bb�¦e

¡îMíÈ­¨X@nB()¥¦Ì()�6�¡Ìf�6É?X@qB#/��,�`8�

��,�ú®�36\�����òX¯í¹ë���(23#��,��#���¦�

©ãÕ{�3X@�Bt�Ç�Ö×��3�¦,lëÖ×\òá�K()$��()�<�

�³%=6e¨¨¢%X"�hÌÖK#/6µ�Ì��6Ö×X@QBb�½�j()²

>6�SÙÌ¥x�²e�b(G̦,±�úÌ¥x�²�üÌx]�()�6�î±ù

3eX@;Bb���³�,_�ÑHX\õ|Ï�¡��3eXb�(::;àá()

�6cc;µ*�v�ð³Òx{Ì�îm=eX

cccc������C���C���C���C�

�����3­6õ#/6ì-C���?ÍÎÏ��Ynäo6��Øy��Pj

í¹NbÍ6���­rû6tU3�6C,�'(����³���¦��¦£¤��

86 �Ynäo@1923� 8&h1996� 2&B¨������¯Ý��¹bþ­³�Y´ÏäoeÏ�X��$�lÑý��"¸ú�"�AlÑ��¯F���¡H�ú2�<è6$�ÉxR�`É6��<è6

�����û�úô]¹b�����e6$�lÑX�Ynäo��6F�«'�õ%% 1960�Ï_�B���H��¯ôtF¹ 1966�6#`lÑv�Y¬­äx�S�Qî���BÝG ­6îè��Æ@`îN���YBX

Page 76: Department of Political Science College of Social Sciencentupoli.s3.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/finalP9532… · Department of Political Science College of Social Science

71

¦�,6° ��õ�ú��C�3��'��'���'�£¤6Â�� Î1u��

6�5|î�'(��6eO�þ�¡¼���eX

� 6& 14'*2ÂÆ 5`����ª!"ëA�^_v£�Dx�6�9v�g��x�

v�,'Dx!£¨��±²����=²Y�6��P�ÍÎÏ6#/�Ú<?�b�(e

'(XJÝ���ÍÎÏ��Ynäo6��¹bû�ü=e�n!",=GCA;()G

C:��ëA���+ÍÎÏ6�����?>v�,'Dx@�¥*B�¥D÷X�:ë

AY��()�÷�#�¬¹b()�6��e�nv��6e£YD#/�Y¦,±¹b¥

x�²e�Ø�b�¦e6>?�"¸`Ùt��#/6����]�`aÌbûü6ýe

¨¨�¡K=� �[���X87

�Ï�6�9��»�s�ú�iP�Í6b�ÕÏze³|=X886�9D÷Y��

��<=Íáuø|()b0�`²¦Ó�µ¥7e�b�MgL¦63ù­:0_e�"¸

�?»O#�#/Ìb��eX89£Yí¹ÍÎϬ¹b��,¦�()eÌb�î�¦e

<=�n]()`ò�²A��îbÌè¥7e:b�9¥7e�� �bjkè�î�¦e

:bâ²�á���µ��Iñ�íe�Ú�Ç��r�Db(�eÏEX90

^_v£�Dx�'µ�ÍÎÏ6�(��|î(9=�úY��ÍÎÏ��Ynä

o6��`· �G��{Ì� �í�¦6Ô���í()Ì�¦6�Ù��n�õ�

��%{�ò¾�()�,�ð³X>?ÍÎÏÌ()6l�u²A��¡Ä���ë�

$��ëë��êu5�b¯m��()Ìfjè6eXÎ�Ï¥�v�,'DxúpÆ�

ÍÎÏ�î��6�-���YÂ�ß¹3b�î�¦e6(^X

6& 16'�#/l��÷��O,Ju1%:��s�(m¦¡�¹Xe)^_vG

DxD÷��O,��s�/±�Q­�ÄÇ�(¡��6P��1�å�X>?­u�

6b�Þ�µ*e��_�91()�#/Áª����Xû�����uµ*�#/�©6

87 v�,'Dx�1994� 6& 13'X88 ÍÎÏ�\]? 1994� 5& 3'h16'�á ;�2*b�ÕÏze��îr�á¶3²�b����#4��á�³��Þ�¨ 4¦�:_3 20áî¦Ó6�J�`ò�÷�X89 Q÷û? 1994� 3& 31'��#/��ú�Þ����õ()zî�¬ !6ÉÁ�Ú��"�æ�����QS'ô#�6b�Þ�µ*eX90 6�9�£�1994� 6& 14'X91 �r�$ 80X

Page 77: Department of Political Science College of Social Sciencentupoli.s3.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/finalP9532… · Department of Political Science College of Social Science

72

�ÚÌNb�%=�&-��ÍÎÏ6��Ø�|=��i�()��¡Þ'���ø�(

¡ÞéFeX���µ&èlm�ª��l::¶Z[c��WXY��l:���f:�

(Öh²ÕîXcubWZ:�e³bÌy:�eyn2}Xquµ&èlm�bÌy:�e

�uÕîX¡Þ�ª�©>¦(P`^�á¦��l:Z[c�yÙÑ�.è�s�(¡

�¹X92

�¥�¦&3()µ&P`�¸`^Ò)éNH|qrsÄjklmØìÓ���ß:

~µ¬­¸��yEqrsº��Óß:½×¸G�J�>ºE3¸qrs;E¼ØT

µÅJ<H�>Wß|h�¼{qrs:¬TØ�¸¦û`[p���ÄÙ�Ï=¸��Ê

>ºqrsÄW��ú¸è±�$¸�Ã�3�¬°JÅ����ivgLDxúY��#

/_�(���#¨©­®6�¹ä��()�bi='e�b¡Þ'eX���©

Ç�l��­¥q�Ml���Çð()¶·X�i��b¡Þ'e�ì�()6¡Þg

h�9­¥?*<Ø�qX

----����()ØÙC�()ØÙC�()ØÙC�()ØÙC�

()ØÙú�t�ÍÎÏCÌ6ø+Xi^¦,±¸`�Í�,��H:�t��±

عì3�¶ä�b¦,±Ì¥x�²e¹`·D,-5ÙÌ�Ñ#H��Óß�Ä:<

t~�?Ù�Úxúã˸Û����u�Ü:�J���@¸wÇ�:<��<)*�J

H�ï�)�Jt��:Ý�J�0-:`Pà$�����,¦0.´�l:�:�ú

��ÍÎÏXà$�ÑNHqLE*+p<¯±():��¬­ ��ô�:Þ��ß|¯

}�~¼¸JA��)��t¸àØ )Þ��ôébJÅ93

¦,±��P`��`�/01���P`��:}�úY��¾(:�,�±d�

 ×(�ÊË�G(�ø�23�ÍÎÏ'�²�¾(:ôt�¨?Ì�Ľ¾�¡Ìk

�Ynäo!á_���«âD(�X¥7Ù¶4k©t�²���`²=¨Ñ^�«�

Ì+=b�î�¦e�¡U�x¨?Ì��,¦69m�Ì��%5X94�i6± �6(

��¶rA�6±p�úì-��ÍÎÏb��F¹��±`��Ñ63ùeX6±pÑ�

92 ^_vGDx�1994 � 6& 18'X93 vgLDx�1994� 6& 30'X94 vgLDx�1994� 7& 20'X

Page 78: Department of Political Science College of Social Sciencentupoli.s3.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/finalP9532… · Department of Political Science College of Social Science

73

��î��,¦@�±`��¦Ó�J�Ñ�¡U6��Ó�rÌb()�6��eX

ª�èW6Ø�ø+�ÍÎÏ�²�v,�DxÒA�á¶iì�NHÊËì�E<

��EFG� Û�á��ô��<�JÊË,à«�ü½�E3�ÊËJ,à�°)[

��:E3Å&()��àÇ��¸���<)âÇȸâJdZ��Ü: ã¸ì

ã!�~E3¸E3>JÎNà�3ä}¼JÅ�¥�ÍÎÏúY�NH}z�º��d

�}eå ��d���:æç�Ç µ¸G�J¹����¸�à��,U�3I���

:�`¸Ö�,�ëÅ9��Òà¸�����%�z¼¸��ì�zµ>蹸±�ý

,U��°)[:� ���:���ì� ¸ì_9¸¦JíìÉã@�ű5���

�@� J�à)� 34 �+¸���)|�&�)�E ¸ÇJ¬E ���Åo�d2

�¸!,��)�,��éXÖ� ,�ò�¸Ï±±ì���Õ:��źð&�:�

L¸ì©��dJ&���¸Jê)g¸�FJê��:�븦2²JÇ�¸Xø02

«�&�:£¤3åàϸì¯ì£J&[:3Í�JÅ95

----����()�+()�+()�+()�+

�#/�ª���b�O,s�(m¦¡�¹:2}hªÕîXcubWZ:�e�¯

� Ú�GÇ�Î3ïgð����<¤ÚPµ*�()6õ6­å��q�¥�¤�

�14õ6J��:��¤ÇI�6�m�b¸��6!�@�¸±­òþ�BX

���ª���i<ÍÎÏ6|îúdä3|}X9�iÍ�(��¡#²�j�

�`8�7Ñ­ä����P��9­×¹8�û�¯�?6t[úI¹±²õ­9

:���b()`���e�¨Ãt[��Ø��r6(^X�?���ÍÎÏ�±Ñ�Ä

IJ�ë�vÍÎÏë�6Ö;x�S�¬ÑNHºð&�3�,3��3�í! J<Hì

¯ì��îB3�<²³3�<ïó3�¸2²>Ç�ë¸&�÷}�Z,E3©ðñ:

òóJ<Hàï&�:¯ì¸3�,ô}:õï¸Ý�òºö;¸3¼÷����~øùÁ

ÂÇ�:yú@J}�,:JÅ

9Ì��"'()�6��(!á�f������ÍÎÏÑ366��y@ë�d

9Ý3()GC¬¬¶<=Ù¬ÑNH�>åhºqrs|ìû:¾y@��dqüE3

95 vgLDx�1994� 9& 13'X

Page 79: Department of Political Science College of Social Sciencentupoli.s3.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/finalP9532… · Department of Political Science College of Social Science

74

ý�ýÃJÅ96¿É�b|=H£����ª�?()�ªÌ�:§pb�î�¦¨©ed

ä3­K^����JK(«M�î¾t6i<X

====<<<<qrspt9�uvwx8qrspt9�uvwx8qrspt9�uvwx8qrspt9�uvwx8----

��������ßà¡"ßà¡"ßà¡"ßà¡"

1995� 5&�´�,¦r�-�3�Å 97�� 0�³ 396�� 0�6­/èÛ'�

«�}�"b��ÍÎÏ���¡¢&¯�p� #ëá¶eð}hX5& 22'�,¦¦

&3r�ÔO��ï�Í6.,7aX

¯u�bp� Ïîe6Ãûâ~�: 1994� 5&�ÍÎÏÝ��îb�ÕÏze�"

�>"?i6b@Aµ*eX97�µ*®Ã��,¦%=#B6÷�~�GH�D`auO

()6,¦¦:IÌ­�±�6/D()�9?ù¿�Ê\]ÍÎ×�2}�Zô��

Í6á,6`ò¨ûÏ�X

�_Í�,¦i= 6 & 7 '�aC[�DE�9 '�p� #ë6bX���e�t

·¹b,Ϭ��¶�|�e6ÐÑX�ÐØyÞt()6,`<?�¡Þ�2�nt�

()�¦ö9:»Ð��6î¯X¯� 17 u ³b��,¦�()e�nì�b|µ:

þS>D�­â76µ&fg�eXÍѦ_�ÒA:�ì��á¶,¦ÌD¦ö9:*[

()�ø��¹F×b�î�¦eX

���½�,¦£àÍÎÏá,�µ�t[ì-¤}�í¹,¦¥Cv-îgL`Dx

6¨©�98¾ñ¦§�¦`²�nì-�=ÍÎÏ�p� #ë6Ð��#/¦Ó`��O

96 vgLDx�1994� 6& 9'X97 ÍÎÏô��>"?"�i�¹3t[�,¦6¤}�¡GHI�JK�AL�²��x��6,¦�(

l:<µ`�UÈMX¡N�Ùëq�O�ÍÎÏó<Hb��á,eO¬�¬Á�M�á¶p� #ëX98 v-îgL`Dx®�3v��`Dx�v�,27`Dx�v�,{Çð,¦D(�B¸R¶·6`Ex

@F]v;�Q`DxBX¡-î`DÌ#/�,¦�úgi<*$���PQrH¤6ñòfg�¯�ÑP

()¶·6Ù��,¦��ø]¯���ÚÌf?b�î�¦¨©e��,v-îgL`Dx�v()PQ^x

¬�86Xv��`DxÌ 1972� 2& 28'�,¦\]²0��#/\<�Px?��7��S�Ìv���,d�¦�,�§L-¦gL`Dx7�X¡îgL`D6÷ÅÏ �?�I�nÁÑxÕè%6���

£*�´G3��­�6É��Ù_t�I�f�}ñ��63ù��_?´bI�[Ã6d�Xv�,27

`DxS]v���,d�¦�,�§L-¦P?23¥7PQ6gL`Dx�? 1979� 1& 1'r��q�ÔO���,d�¦�,¦23r�6#G^¥7PQX,¦��`D�Ju�íb���,d�¦��Ì

�¦6n�L^��e�9rû�()6�Ã�½xXv;�Q`DxS]v�,{Çð,¦D(�B¸R¶

·6`Ex�? 1982� 8& 17'7��,¦��`D�{�(B¸¶·º�3G�6���lñòØy¹N

Page 80: Department of Political Science College of Social Sciencentupoli.s3.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/finalP9532… · Department of Political Science College of Social Science

75

,ItGb,¦l9ò¹¯HIð���ô�eX99

¯_�#/Ô�*2��â6PÍ£Y�̹b£2e�100�? 1995 � 7 & 21 '¸

1996 � 3 & 25 '�d�î 7 u-´gLFgШ��()á��ê�îËÌ�©��g

ª�î�÷ËÌ©��³�äï��å¨�ÂR´µÐ¨î�X� 7 & 21 'h26 '¡k

<=�d´�QRS�� 65�T��îËÌ�©�d�©3 6U���Ì[ËÌX8& 15

'�25 '�©�îËÌ��VuÌ©�ШXI? 1996 � 3 &�����,¦ÕîJu

r�¸\]±A�¬��(6´µ¸>­®6ì��?�@î3ËÌ�©��fW��Å

¸��© 4 U���Ì[ËÌ��³ 2 u±áö���6�/÷gL´µÐ¨X,¦©?

3& 8'ÔO�3��¯g°�?()±��êXY�n? 3& 11'%Õ�)��²�³

��¯g°��½()�¸�êX3 & 23 '�()\]#Am@�6 &ä´�d´?�Z

�î-îÎ/Ш_�b¸®em@X

cccc������C���C���C���C�

�,¦��ÍÎÏ6á,_�i^#/¦&3¸\<Ú¥7Ù¶4¯[3(G�,¦

m��#G\q]��ªt[ì-¤}X101�i#/¥7Ùú{,¦��ÔO£àÍÎÏ

�b��á¶e�tøG�YÂ,¦¥Cv-îgL`Dx¨©�F×b�î�¦e

¦§b�¦`²e�øGt��d�,¦PQû�/0X

^_v#`Dxú�9�&-P�NHt���qrspt¸Jþó&t§¢I6Ãþ

b,¦��øG�F­��@î��¶<D()�B¸R6�Ú�FD()�B6¸R�è7�'1�­

:"�,27_¸B�H�6Ð��F´ÑC«G±F�()6¸R�B�n¡"�ki=÷�l_6ÇðeX99 vgLDx�1995� 6& 10'X100 X�Õ£2Ì� 1995�6 7�8&�XcÕ©Ì� 1995� 12&*2¸ 1996� 3&��,¦\]±Am@_Ó�ùX101 4¯[D\q]¤}iY�Nbo?ÍÎÏ6¡¢�­����$�8���á,��Ì�î¾ñ6��

¶·��¿®­3,¦7y�Îp()�½F×��î�¦������(�6µueX4¯[ñ,�#/§ð

C���¦BÑ¥7PQ6^ì¦Ó�()�2Ã�PQ��î^ìBÃ�èØ67½X�Ñ�^ì� F

×b�î�¦e�b���(e6î��X�­7²���¡î¨©¶·����63ùG�%§�­ïX,

¦��­'�d6¾r7��§ðC��ÔOð�£àÍÎÏá,�¾ñ¥C�,v-îgL`Dx�¦§b�

¦`²e���»-�¦6��]�#�X�Y��()¶·Ì()�,PQ�26`òsâ��,27

Ì�,¦{()¶·F�G���Óut6X,¦��ß�%=6���{T»-�,PQ6î��_�

̾ñ6X�i4¯[ôt���½D,¦ ��ñò��ò,�bí�s�£àÍÎÏá,6_��3(

ÝrHIeX�nÑ�b#/�D^s�,PQ�9½�6�2�G¯­H­F�ì-C��¯Â^�SÙ

>,��ueX

Page 81: Department of Political Science College of Social Sciencentupoli.s3.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/finalP9532… · Department of Political Science College of Social Science

76

�«<îï&tÓß:S�RS¸Jº&�[@:S�hiÅ2«ºs��<�¸3åJ`

B&tÓß��0¸»���¸t�Lì��3©�¸>:�y�&�:E3¸�?�Ë

­���<�:{�ÅìÓ&�[@<Gò�¡Ä��E3:��[ð<�ö¸�>:�

Ö>쪫7ÈÅqrstLöJ�Í�XYECt����ù��ùÓ¸�8

Já�ù����JÅ9��òÍÎÏb^_e��lm6$��%�`a$�A¬���

��PQ�2�­ò¬iôè8õ�X6�9÷Åp�v#`Dx¡¼9��t�áÓ^

_DbP�,¦F^­��6�9n6bv^_²Dx�vmDx6�=�],¦��6F

^�¡�»3�,27_ <()¶·6!.�ß=27i6��X102

5& 25'�#/ �m@÷´�[QcX¸6á,î%�nTܦ&3¦&PQÍy

ݳ÷´ôt�á,î%�Å_�,ï7¦m¨X�¥¦§Ù¶�d� 6 &á,Ï

�á,���ú��µ*�2õôTÜ��Dk,¦����ÍÎÏ6á,X�_�#/

¥7Ù�|��et�NHq°t�Â��qrsptËÌ� û &t§¢I6Ãþ�«

[ðJ<Ht�à��<�ö9�>b0bø>1ÁÂVWù��t�Óß� ���qr

spt¸S�îï�&�:[@� _t? QÒ ¸3�� ¸3O�²�·~°t?þ

�JÅö^,¦mfg#G³m^_\�µ6Í£út�NH°ðt��â��Î��:q

rsp<t� +æ�ù���É0�; ÇQ?t�9�>:Óß��� ±²Õ²��M

/���RS���:W��JÅ

h����ÍÎÏá,�µD,¦ ��-¤}�9 5 & 27 'h29 '�ÌÖ��y

ÙÑÐë<�(�ÕîXcubWZ:�eX�uØÑè£m�yÙÑ$�(�út[3

C�ÍÎÏá,63ù�9�:6£mnw�:()X

b�ge���·¹b()�½¥ß��î�¦�¨©Õae��£YP�()�½

ß�b�î�¦e¨©X£YÑ�§pb�î�¦e°ÌF×b�î�¦e�ÌPQ:()

�Ú�Ø0¸Pñò¶·�úÌPQ:�¦]�°Ì¶<��6#Ì#�¶·X�¦��

³�,�¡�¨©¶·�ð­:íÈ��^ì�Ò���M�¾h��X¸�x�()

�½�b�î�¦e6¶·�C«/0�±¸`Ù�¦ö�F×b�î�¦e�9��PQ

102 6�9�£�1995� 5& 23'X

Page 82: Department of Political Science College of Social Sciencentupoli.s3.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/finalP9532… · Department of Political Science College of Social Science

77

�2�i¦��]�F×I#6sâ��H®�()�I�Ø6S��¦�6ñs�µ

�X()¶·±²PQ:ãä���¸¾W6�������2�¾j()�½Ri���

5u&:b�î�¦e63ù�x�³i�î�µ�����j�¡ÓÌ&u�Çð��

PQ���]�¶·6n�âîP^Xb�¦��]�Ö�:e<µÍÓk©í¹�ÍÎÏ

�p� #ëÐ����¯a�H� �áu :b��,¦�()e�� v����Ü

�S�¤�?u¤X�¥�#/9Ý3��묬¶Ó#ZP�ÍÎÏ\]6b`²�,e

<?�ÍÎÏ� �1¡î ^xt�()bØ�,`¤e� ¬()6b¦ö�ÆeX103^

_v£�Dx9=�b,¦���Þhle¹·�YÂ,¦£àÍÎÏá,�¥C�,v-

îgL`Dx¨©�¾ñ()�,PQ�,¦£àÍÎÏá,¾ñ¦§�,PQ³()ã

ä����XYÂ,¦r���Ûbmnõ«£�eoõ«pe�bqrr�2��¦�

12s�¦�,s¹:��{�¦,�õ­'eX104

ø²q 6 & 16 '�#/¦&3(P�|��tøGY�NH��Wß»uÁÂ:3�

¹À7¸¨©qrspt¸S���¼��Óß��¸È���ÓßÉʸ­�&�E3¸

2>�H%*~J/GÐ.¾½{|>ZU[ËÌN  Ç�·J��? 3�µ±:JÅ

105�¥��dkÆD,� �ì-¤}�tÂ,¦ÁÑ��b�î�¦¨©e��iG&m

,#GÍ[uX

6& 30'��O,�:�v¦¦Ó`�m�0i�Ju`�{bÍÎÏá,e�µ`

*�t��X�O,ÑNH��<�JÓß�&�[@ÄE3:È¥µ�Å'��6¸ÊÉ

0ÓðÝÞ��E3: 8 �y@Ä[$¸ò�0ë¼ÊËà�3I&��+ù�{���

<�:�TÄÙ�¸¦J��WßßÕ ��r¸­���ÄÅE3ÅW»t��â��

qrs�t�Þ �Í�p<� h.$�­´µ��I&��<�3&3�� S�îï&

�[@¸©îï&tÓß:ôõ¸ÊË^±WÝ­,ÄE1�ó~JÅ

�_�d´� 1995 � 7 &h1996 � 3 &=���()�î3�ÂR6ËÌ�©³´

Ð�¡Ìd´% 1958��x��()¬�îÏlì-6´µî��õ¯\6�(Ìïg�

103 vgLDx�1995� 6& 13'X104 ^_v£�Dx�1995 � 6& 12'X105 #/�»()P`��¦&3()µ&P`��v�¦()¶·x�@��N[Õ S�*9�1998� 9&B�� 113h114X

Page 83: Department of Political Science College of Social Sciencentupoli.s3.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/finalP9532… · Department of Political Science College of Social Science

78

��Fx§ù()ãD�ÒX�i#/¥7Ù�|�æ+���±l:}i(t�NHº

ð��¿R��¸ÇJ�dqrs�Ü´µ�3&3��/��I&��±µ±:JÅ106

----����,¦6TA <,¦6TA <,¦6TA <,¦6TA <107

¿�Ê\]� 1993 � 1 &� 43}6A�M`Uw�¯��fgÜ��k��D (

6,¦¦:r�-�3]� 1994 � 11 &>d�±M`�j�9G¿�Ê���¦:�Ô

���²��¨­>ä���3ÍÎÏ6p� ÏîX

9Ì_x���ª6ì-C�³µ*6�2�8��#x���û�,¦{T3äâ

6�F�u5TA <N@�BUw�¦&3d�GC�nîb�¾´��ÕÖöÈ6�¹

���Å{ÌN(��©ÃQ.,ü7f?b��<>e@privateB�b¾Ø��r�èØe

@unofficialB�bîh@��hB��e@case by caseB�³b�Ñ6e@rareBX@cB��d

´ 1995 � 7�8 &=6ËÌ�©�Ш�Î3��6ÑMHÊË>�dÇ�:��ìmð

½¶:ÄÅ�·J¥�¦&3ãäuy.�@Winston LordB¤ÑNH>�ÊË��©>º

��F��ÇSR�JX¯C�Ïú<�È��t[�?(��½bF×z{e6­|X

@-B¿�ʹ3R}��nµE()���\]��4x6����¦&y0��

á�� 1995� 8&r�~Òbãä¡ÞLF:}e@APECBi�1�794¯[?p79

�O,X4x��¿�ÊJ�raN,¦­Îpb�î�¦e�b���(e�­Îpb(

)�3e�­Îpb()�MgL¦e@F]Nb6-­eBye)v4¯[&ãäx�¿�Ê

°���O,á¶���nt��Hïg�#/23�¨��PQX@nB1995� 11&Ï

_�()�ªr�´Ñ�î��,¦X�ur�¸\]AÕ���ð��îXcÕ6£2

¸®�¯CéÛ��Õ°#X,¦{Tاè¥745���ª��#/¥7ٸٶ8

��á,����ª?��()6¦R:�S¶��i��¢�4:���r(����

³��6C��[���ÕÖIjX@qB1996 � 3 &��?d´´Ð6�FSxS#�

ºÎd´Ñ6����3�î�¯g°��.(���#�6¸>��gN®ú6F1X

nnnn����()�+()�+()�+()�+

106 v�,'Dx�1995� 6& 18'X107 �õ�vTUVWh��¦=:�V�¦x�@(�N`äþ��*`�B�2003� 12& 30'�� 38h51X

Page 84: Department of Political Science College of Social Sciencentupoli.s3.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/finalP9532… · Department of Political Science College of Social Science

79

�? 1995³ 1996�6(�TA�ëA��í¹NH�3����:��¸Jì3ÉÊ

:�e¸G&¨�ìÃ�<»�9 �bJÅ108�uºº6þû"¸â~�:úgm@�,

¦�~���Ú�`Ròµ*¨¨�õb�Þ�µ*e�b�Ynäo6!áe¨��Ñ�

ÕÖ×6q�X¸û©Ñ(�6&u¥7�ñÑgL¦0���³,¦¦:Îp()6Ú

Pð}�õÍÎÏ,¦Ïîü­"ÌI�PQ¬p6÷�~X109

�#/�ª��±�x�h����?ÍÎÏb]�e6ð�ÑØ��9�ÍÎÏ

�¦ö�æç��b&u¥7e���br�gL¦e0���Ø��(��>6�26

F¹�f��úù? �¾hP��nwÑ^ìuö6´µî�Xû���Í6bp�

Ïîe_�f?b*«ÏÈ�e�b¬F¬¹eß[õ�6�¹ä���9?ÍÎÏ�

è���n� 1995�ä;�*2Õî�ÂR6´µÐ¨³ËÌ�©�6�(�TAX

�i���63ùxÍ�û¹��,¦�()d���`8î��¹3ò�ùb�î

�¦e�b���(e6�Òî¹�¬���¥¦�(����{T¾r3ùX���#

/S¦()GC:<µ�����2GC��¸GCQù�í¹NH®:åæ¼�Jt��

�qrs��Í�tL�pt¸�>? ��dqrsý�í���ö��Óß�/t�

A�����¦V&�: �ÆRÅ2_­!��è±"ü�3I&��:[ð¸��<

� ��í�¸��Óß©��d��`Óß� Ç^S�7È�>:&�E3�r¸�

!#/&(�)NÄ���:ôõ¸aÓ�É�z)g­½:7$Å��¸�>? >

%�X�w 1949��� 30�¬Ü^u�x8:ef¸ß�­0hu���Ó߸�8ö

ÞJ&�¬�¸>­�� Nɸc>���ô &�ÉÊJÅ

ÍÎÏá,µ*­ú6�#/bCÍe³bC,e6ø+�ú8��Ø�()�b�

î�¦e�Ú6¶·�/0�Ñ�ñ6¿®�b�î�¦e68ò�¡ú�»3���b�

î�¦�è%tbe6]¨X#/­?{Tö�b�î�¦e��c8¶·bwiz{e

63ù�¡úGH����ji¬Õ�6`²¶·���ôò��b�î�¦e¨©u�

�/=}·��tX�i�#/�ª¿ª9ùlm�[�A�Ïä�úGHtÑ�6Xc

108 ���v�d6�(ðÚ���PQ�2x�@(�N¬­=Â�*9�2000� 3&B�� 157X109 �á��'�[[qñ�[[�(�TAN������(�ÏðÚ�Id/(�v�,PQ!·GCN1995ñ1997ë¯G/:x�@(�N�»GC3�1997� 6&B�� 2h10X

Page 85: Department of Political Science College of Social Sciencentupoli.s3.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/finalP9532… · Department of Political Science College of Social Science

80

ubWZ:�eûõwiTÜ���PQ¾ñ/0���JK��X

�,¦�ª�Î3b6-­eGÇD#/â�Ï¥�>?¿�Ê��v()�å¯Ì

ÍÎÏs¹bz{F×Ae�û��­9|�ÃQá,�:�bb4�¾´e6b��Â"

�#Px(á¶6,¦ëA�¦:}Q�Ö<úÓÙG±�"¸,¦Ô��()6ÁªD

÷ú*2�t@ë01Ê��`��,`P¨BX

¿L���ÍÎÏ6p� Ïî�Î3¯î�²æ3�()ÞØ6��øg³Á1¥�

¯�ë,¦D#/6â��b�î�¦�è%tbe6éÈ÷=Ü����JK�ò¨�°

â¤Ì()�¦ö÷=³��PQ�6ñ#¦�X

____<<<<����������������èé:�9�Óßèé:�9�Óßèé:�9�Óßèé:�9�Óß����

��������µ*¡"³ßàµ*¡"³ßàµ*¡"³ßàµ*¡"³ßà

1999� 7& 9'�a 11i�i^��,¦\]6ÍÎÏÝ�²��¦Ïø@Deutshe

WelleBä(!á�110¯`ò6 ¶ÌNb�n�uöâî6�ÔO()�3��­ô#á

'()�,²�6��¦���Ï=�Ì�ÑË�6�hÌeÍÎÏ&wNH&()�|

1912 �U���¸3åâJ[@ô�:�`¸�à 1991 �:'T�¸|^��Óß�ú

à�èé:�9�Óß� 111±��íìò=¾��ô�:�,Jů�?()�#/PQ

68ò¹NH1991 �'T��¸|^�`Gò£¤¥�ð�<´<+<k¸o<^LE9

�cû©ß°��­½·E¸�þ�&(�)NÄ�:Ã@¾Å��Ä�>:Óߪ÷

|¯J��`9�`� F!¢J�èé:�(state)9�(state)�:Ó߸%»�3Ã@�â<

3(Ã�â� F�3&À�â<3­?�â�:�3I&��¬ÍÓßJÅ�k!á?�

¦i= 1999� 7& 25' 21i�>�¦Ïø6Z¼ ½p[DS¾W¿+�õ£�Øy©

�Î��¦6v�'¾WDxX

��ÔE�=3��,¦% 1991� 5& 1'Âù�Q�ºi<�x6#/�Úfg�

ñ6233�î�ÚfgXºë¯x6�¦=ÔE3(ññ�º�3,���(-VPQ�

­9��3#/�ú¼�3,¦X

110 !áQ>�¦Ïø\r Dieter Weirich��¦ÏøãÕÙ`^ Gunter Knabe��¦ÏøÒA Simone de Manso�î@>i^î�36ý½½¶%2���BX111 Z�¹Nspecial state-to-state relationship.

Page 86: Department of Political Science College of Social Sciencentupoli.s3.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/finalP9532… · Department of Political Science College of Social Science

81

&'�i6¦ö1�³��PQN(�ËÌTAÒã�6y#/��­?�:�g6

}�_��¥�Ú6ñ�ï½b-áe@±á��á�á�By^_ù�&®#/�è

ò� 1999�O&®y1998� 8&,¦\]¿�Ê���b`*e�t,¦6b6-­e

�Úy112#/�,�Z�^�'�@¨¦6b��PQeú2;ÉÃy����GÇ�

()­��å¯Ì��D��â�6��I�(��Â�ÃÃñ6­>X

�()ØÙ�ª�ÍÎÏ!"�?6µ¶�²>I�õ�X�#/�Ú��¦,±Ø

6#/éFY÷l�i=�Ôu��b¦]:e*:6u'ú�G�ðÚ²>C�õ�?Í

³¯±'×��å¯Ìi^¦R:¦cPQ6a�å��Z£Xû��¡Ki÷¶*³Í

6\]^<(Æä6�¹Ïä�¯�Éð23�¶bÍÎÏE~e�x�366¦Ó��

���PQ=bX113

b�¦=e{�ë�ܹä�> 1998� 8&Ã36¦R:bì¤��,¦`²¦Ó�

�l�e@Gõ�N�Z£y'¶Na�å��¥���¶·B¡" 9î&õ�GCõ°��

¯ò�¹N@�Bb()eÌ�î`²�3¦Ó�F6��±Î�b��,¦e�õb��,

¦�()e6`²��²@�ú�²B]­³?#/��,���úú³?(·ZYX@cB

û��l�í¹b()­Ì�¦6�Ù�e�()�#/Ì�î­Ú/�6¦Ó���PQ

­ÌØ�¶·�õ̦öPQ�ú1¦ö^�¦öC`�¯l9�WÌI�ÚJ�í��

¹b��,¦e³b���,d�¦eX@-B�ì²�b��,¦�()e6Ñ^�9í

¹% 1991 �*2µ¶_�{�®Ãb��,¦()e�F�^ø�Ø�¨�bXcd

�e�b6d�ey�b�¦e�b��,¦e�b���,d�¦e�vÑPQ�t�lα

²]�b()eX@nBlÎe�­ò?�b]�e�ë�ò��ü7�b]�e@unificationB�

õ­Ìb?]�e@reunificationB�lÎ1b]Le�b~Le¨�M�h1vFÇòè

�XNØÙ`²¦Ó=6PQX@qBb()­Ì�¦6�Ù�eQ�f?b()��w�

=eX114@�Bbw­tbe1992�6b�î�¦�è%tbed���1b78����

112 i� 1995� 8 &�ÍÎÏbp� Ïîe_�¿�ʹ3R}��nµE()���\]��4x6���J�raN,¦­Îpb�î�¦e�b���(e�­Îpb()�3e�­Îpb()�MgL¦e

6b6-­e�ÚXn��u­�6Ì��u¿�ÊÌb`*eÔE��()6­>��X113 �õ�vTUVWh��¦=:�V�¦x�@(�N`äþ��*`�B�2003� 12& 30'�� 77X114 b()��w�=eÌ>,¦��gi< ��P?()Ì���,d�¦6�îú�A��,¦6�î

Page 87: Department of Political Science College of Social Sciencentupoli.s3.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/finalP9532… · Department of Political Science College of Social Science

82

z{|}ex8òb[cd�ey륦º�©u6tb�â1,�±6'()�Úð}£(

xtbNb()Ì`²�36¦Ó�F6�����,¦eX115

cccc���������6C������6C������6C������6C�

�¦=�t_���6C�²õì§��,¦5�¥7­>��()ÐÌ£2¸®y

õ,¦6C�©Ì%L3��� �X

JÝ�#/6X�¢øG� 7& 11'��»(P�¦(P�|�6�8�!"6�9

�t���PjÍÎÏH)·G�Ñ&�Gò[@¸ý���ÑE�:� �8J<HSo

*���Ñ ¸��+,-k¸ÉÊ.� dJX7 & 12 '�Z[c�tbïgWÝ�

§¨e6��yõ���iúu�,¦Ì�¹�¦=ß_�r6`÷>1�å¯Ì¯má

�b�#GYÚ,¦I¡�Ø�Ï��â(õ£X

,¦�ª�>�(l: ¶a¢£? 7& 13'¤�ÍÎÏ��ªØ��¦=Ì�¡

9�¶^³¿®�Ú�²q¦&3áuñ,,¦6b�î�¦�Úe³ñÖ�����n

%��« :b6-­eX�i�¦:Ù��©�t3­����@�6,`±}QáC�

b�¦=e�õd�±©átÎp��D (6,¦¦:Ï�Ò�I� 3(� �6÷jX

����6짳�µÝwôE£õ��­|6���â>¥¦|��Q.,ÑG���

¦§ÙéFl�á(��³ÅüÔO´B¨µ*ê£X

7& 16'*2�TA*2¬^���­�ò+.î´ÐÈ��^_Ô�I#¼_D÷

b' �d´�g��S�ge�b�dºªº§?|_O�¸e�b�i´Ñ2¨|ûl

Þe¨yõ�id´gApp���)]����¦=�t_6 3 wØ�¯��6pu[

:¯·u�IÑ 2 uS"�µ�~���gAnö�ª�¸!��»Ëî�©ÑIj�º

º�¼(�X

ú¤�A�î`²¦Ó��­7��6|='(X#/�()Ã�6r�3ù�ÌC�b()��w�=e�

9ÌàáÎp()�36��{A��Í �í¹ 1945�Xcu¾W#gm@Ï_'�üÌøG+=�()6`²�9nwG�t�()`²pï9��,¦���GH()�¦ö�6��°wÉS��X115 v()�Úð}£xÌ,�±? 1999� 5& 8'G*6X;ÆXcuS¦±Qôt#:@Sô:B��"6£*�ñb(�tÜ�P��±<?yÌ,�±`�6��,¦�� <��¶·l�¨©Xv()�Ú

ð}£xÔ]�()bµu�eù�î`²�36,`¦Ó�b¯`²�êú³?(·ZY�¯��ÞS�

�³�L¦ö^C�Ï���L²ÐêeX()bSÙÃ\�¶^]¹��,¦�9����,d�¦J­/

��)Ì$�µu�úÌtuÜ�ey�(,�±�í���,¦Ì�îL^%�36�²�õ­?Ìb¥x

�²eXv()�Úð}£x a�b^ìÑP�3tÜ6I�e�¥¦¡>()S�a,�`,¦���ð�X

Page 88: Department of Political Science College of Social Sciencentupoli.s3.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/finalP9532… · Department of Political Science College of Social Science

83

��nò�3d´? 8 &e�©3b±¬- ��eÕöÌ[ËÌ6È��6õ3

,¦6��P5�?Ì,¦TA <6©ub��7& 18'�¿�ÊJÝ!"Â~D�

O,raNb,¦6�î�¦�Ú­®e�20'�¦&yXOÒ÷ÔO�Å�Q�½���

(��îª�ªC��3ÇX116õ_@21 'B�%¿�Ê\]�ó�®�¦§Ù¶�¦&

3�|�¨��Å�­�î�Ô�,¦ïg(�|Ý������Çð6�¢3ù�=²

ï���6¸>2�ú�Ѭ[�X117

8 & 1 '���,¦/P:�t·¹b�¨����I�e6Ѫ��H����&

:b�î�¦�è%tbe6d��ì�b�¦=ez��3��=6�¨���õè�

�Ú­®�)Ù�Ú­®�%Ù­Ô�¬¹6bµ¶�µ^�µ¿¦]#�e6¶·X9

&�´�gL¦\&PQ:/=��,¦M:h�,¦ôt»`�6�|C��¡Ì 1993

�|¦���MgL¦î��x�,¦X�u­1b«]eõ1bC�ext[3ù�¯

�b�¦=eµ*�¬­()Ï�"¹GÇX

1999 � 9 & 21 '�()��b[c�#��e�f�®ñXb�¦=e>Ì<�3�

�³,���(-VPQÏ����6��TA�`����¯,è��×X

----����()�+()�+()�+()�+

#/� 2000� 2&��t3v�î�¦6¨©�()¶·xUVS�¡Ìk 1993�

8 &6v()¶·��¦6]�xÏ_�118Xc¼��()¶·6�ÚUVSy¯�Ñ 2

k£�6�°\�X�kÌNHqrs|¯±d���Ñ :L�0¸J��u���ß

È��¸J&tÓßÉÊ/F�¸©J%m­½ÄÅ9��:01´µ�Jů�u�C

��#/�½�Í6:s���¡[:��X

��kÌNH2²E���¬�êEtL|&��¥E�:��Rϸ2²E���2

116 ,¦¦R:ãäµ&¡ `^ͱë�ãäÖy/�²�½��y,¦�(l:<µ`�³´�.(�X117 ¿�ÊJ� �b-îεe6Ñ^��Źbí£�î�¦e�b<g����e�b��Çð��eX118 1993� 8& 31'¬`O6v()¶·��¦6]�xUVS�Ì#/X�u6�(UVS�FÌ"��(�Ú3ù6\mX`ò3ù¹N@1B()Ì�¦­â��6�Ù¢X@2B()¶·6�ÃÌ¥¦>1�M6m�X@3B#/Ìôt�¦6n�L^���ѲîG¦Ó`²X@4B��î�¦6� ä�()bñÑgL¦eÌ�Än �Ò¦Ó`²6î¹X@5B§pC�F×b(�e�b���(e�b�î�¦e6`aX@6BÇð()¶·6f�3ùÌ��]���¦��X@7B�¦]�_�()ù÷Åî���+Ñ��6%�²X

Page 89: Department of Political Science College of Social Sciencentupoli.s3.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/finalP9532… · Department of Political Science College of Social Science

84

3��¸2²��WßÚ¥u­45ç�~óÄÅ{���E3<�¸&��â£Z¬e

ÁÂ3O�Z:1ÝVW¸¨©QwÇ ¸�¨ñ&�:[@ÄGò�¡¸�±&�:E

3�IJÅ¡b-îë�eôÇâ¹b�d1¸-¶*e�õ¯�bX-îë�eÒí3i

=6>?�¡Ì"��w��6ܹ�Ç�3���Í6¶·Ó��­K^�¡Ñ3¥

òi­_¸'6¥���¯�()"cϾñ%�­|âó�() þX

9Ìû¹�uUVS66`O�!�()X ^\]#Aú¹­: 1 î&6i=��

��d\<º»f¾Ñ"cO¼6½��GH#/l­f�Í:6m��t�`a(�6

,�±��@����6��JKkƪS¾¾s*X

Page 90: Department of Political Science College of Social Sciencentupoli.s3.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/finalP9532… · Department of Political Science College of Social Science

85

2¢62¢62¢62¢6--------á�á�á�á�----

7É 1992h1999�6��J��I�PQ�úg'Û6�¤põãD78*+�>?

()�ªÝ<éFd�Éu�­=��Ú�D@¦]#���î�¦c8B�Ì��é

@¦]:�/P:��f:B¨�ª]G�:����7� 1992�b^_m�e_TH�

#/2;JK6fghb[cd�eXn_Æ'&L���}·�`�6��EF�­9w

7<H�½¬bØ<e6Ãq�CõB()�µ�Dg|�TUÏVWXCÉ#/�¯

���PQóM7½e<jk�C�©¿;Z@ëÃ3�l:�u^lmU�Ä6ðÚ�

Ü�f:À3 10 î&B�õ%Î3b��4Ge�[Q>¯�õÏ¥�¯·#Ù�}·6

`�²Ì>(��j���ú7ô�û�õX�ä{�jkñ#µ*�26B�ñò÷

Ø�®w�+ëÀX

1992h1999�=���,¦\]ÍÎÏ6gNf N1993�õ�ÍÎÏ���b�M

gL¦e���*2­³f���6�¡y90�ô���áu£2¸®6m�GHÍÃÄ

�Á×�()ô�­6�����õ¡î����rÌ()b|�`8elåÂ6ÃÄX

1994��Íb�î�¦e���¤�^ø¤��î�¦­?Ì��,¦�õÌî$��

£¤��<�ÅW�6>?X1191999 ���b�¦=e�ÍiÆÜ��b()`�èe�

]º¹¦�2;6����6b()`�èeE~ ÌÝqË()ØÙ6b|�`8e�?

C«�b|�`8e"³:b¦�`8e�(23�?()�6¦ÓX�AÒ3�¶>b1

®:Ø®e6ÚN�¯¦�`82;E~ ¹N��,¦¨��,¦:()¨��,¦�

()¨��,¦Ì()¨()���,¦¨()�()¨()Ì()d�¦X�6¡�Ä

¦�2;f �GH��JKÇ��PQ/0�¹()¾x3ç��TUX

��2;��JK6fgb[cd�eN#/�ª�b[cd�e6í£¹NX���

�]§pb�î�¦e¨©yXc���]m>��¦Ó]�yX-���6µ&èm�

��­�³b�î�¦e6��c8X|�6í£Ì@Ã)¦]#�BNHàu���N�

119 1994� 7&�b/P:e`OJÙ#/�ÚUVSv(���PQÑGSx�$Ù����PQ��¹b�î�¦�����e�9Ìì�b�î�¦ÌY$����<��£¤��ÅW�6�¦e�¡{�"é

�3b�î�¦e^<Øc�GÏo¤X

Page 91: Department of Political Science College of Social Sciencentupoli.s3.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/finalP9532… · Department of Political Science College of Social Science

86

� ���`E3:�e&¸y?Ü�ßÕ�3I&��:[𸦺ð3I&�:KL¸

��Ùì>�¸Uc�wÙ���h:?f0�3I&�[ð�JÅû���b[cd�e

��#/Ìb��­te�|�©Ìb��èteXܬ¹6b��èteúÌb[cd�e

6 1/6õXõ��f:Vµ¶6WXYÝ�¤ÑNH�M>NO��íì 6789:89;9�NO�

2²,<#¸#�dì 6789:8<�þ�<=��F >667?@�Ò��{�JXÜ�r6b[c

d�eØc�¯uvÑbète�õÌ���§pb�î�¦¨©e6b��e�bJKeX

9Ì­â�í6�¸ 20�x�b[cd�e������2��ÚP���b[cd�e

¨?ÈÉ3����JK�åèJ�6fgX�£í¹r�¨£Ï[���?&: 1992�

JK6fg�(b§p�î�¦¨©e�ÊÎ 1994��_6èÄHI�Ç�ë�Ó7kÆ

¤��678�JKX

�S 5î�\@1990� 12&h1994� 3&B6b��4G:eN�°|3 40�6�

�õ|�b4G:e H�î���06A:XI��1¡î�ä�[ú�u�÷�}·��

2;3��6JK�õ_n�`*�[��7>�f��l�:2*�j@ëNË�3W

Z:����A�6�\¨B�120ë��G�ï�¶�[nî����6ÚJ�Ç�C��

˺*ð3�¶b/Fe����ÜÎ������Ç�23e«JK6éF�Ì"#X

­"�t�6i÷&\xÍ��ÍÎÏÝ�6`÷ä����?@¨�¹4G�9C­Ì

¹3m���LFµf�õÌ�î���F���ª�0�d�()�Ú6O~����

ªÌ�ÎR}��ó�#/:����¯��t�X9(óë���£í¹��i64G

:���JK62;��Ðѯrª6�8�Ãc6X

90�ô�,¦���J��¬»Ð6î¯N,¦ö¡ 3u�M(�ººÏ��¯ <

6��©s�¹�¯í£õѬ­��1995�ÍÎÏá,¬6�6TA�>?��()

��¹bz{F×Ae�¬��#/6ì-C�{T°ñ<�6���"¸�4D�� �

b6-­e6raX1996� 3&�()ÕîX�u\]¸\]±A���6´Ðî�ô�

�Çâ¹`�fÍ�?Ì���¯g°�®úX1999 �(��tb�¦=e���"��

120 4G�[Î3bWZ:�eÏ¥����©lñò6C�Ã��{Ìb�;�e�bÍ�¶e6 �X�

i�O,ïg723%=���PQ6$����õÍÎÏ©ïgÖG�d+=�(�¸��áu�äC�

_�è%�t3ñòÔ��¡úÌ��PQ6l�wX

Page 92: Department of Political Science College of Social Sciencentupoli.s3.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/finalP9532… · Department of Political Science College of Social Science

87

E���ªR}������ª�(�5­�­8µ�,#�m>ºÎ�q¼r�¦§�

�A6î¯Xõ()úd�aG3�,��¡�#Ï=�Î�Ñb�Ï�Ð�Ðe67>y

9¯m��Î3î��÷�±��ÞØTH3���Ï¥��¥©b�#3��D��

â�6>[�î�e�b� 3���()�½6����]�6¥��eXÑ°Ññ�H�

Ï=�­|%GXõ�bJKe�ª�>?(��?��}·bºæe�GH(�,Ï=6

JK¬¹«áX

��6ô�û�N«=Ìb�YnäÒ!áe�bÍÎÏ6�p� Ïî�e�b�¦=e

¨|=�î��]Ì>(���ºæ���ô�²NXõ¯�¢6F^(Ìb£2¸®eX

Î�Ï¥���°�í:�>?,¦6¿L¦>"?ì#����PQ�­7¿N�ú­

7rª�¤�Üõ#/�2��Äb:S()Çð()¶·e6ÚN�121���Ñ�¯�

(�Ú­�()�õ�,¦¹���üò��,¦�()%Ù{`Xû��e)¡î'

Û���#_�~�,éF��¿�Ê�ó6èî�Ùò�>��ì�îgh�Î3¿�

�@¿�Ê��O,Báu:ªÏ¥�Ù:J¶³´�úpqJá�õ,¦ú �È�!

"¡KJá78�ó�:����JKX9Ú�?�,éF6ÃÄ�����()6��

���«ü¿�1996 �b(�ËÌTAe�ËÌ6�©³´Ð�GHÍÎÏ�:" 54}6

A��A3��,¦X�uS,±A\]y1999�6b�¦=e��_����ªÈ�°

vÑ� 4 ����(£2¸®¬�:6Cq��ë:Ö��¡�u6C-A�9??¡�

��×Ã,�±�ÐÑ6��X����JKfg�I�Ó?tu6CDEFÏä�(

«DoÇÏÚX

121 �õ�vTUVWh��¦=:�V�¦x�@(�N`äþ��*`�B�2003� 12& 30'�� 52h53X

Page 93: Department of Political Science College of Social Sciencentupoli.s3.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/finalP9532… · Department of Political Science College of Social Science

88

2/42/42/42/4]]]] �����z{9�8�����z{9�8�����z{9�8�����z{9�8----

����2000�2012��������

236236236236--------z{�ez{�ez{�ez{�e----

2000��,�±6�ÐÑÝ��¦,±�Ò�ÍÎÏ\]6b�¦=eïÖ³#/6

£2¸®Ï��� 39.3%6A���A3��,¦X ^\]X122ÍÎÏ@�i<Ñ�f

g6��JK��`a()�36,�±��_�Ø0I�áÔX

;;;;<<<<]]]]||||HHHH}~3&}~3&}~3&}~3&JJJJ����HHHH��3&��3&��3&��3&J�J�J�J�3�3��3�3��3�3��3�3������----

��������ßà¡"ßà¡"ßà¡"ßà¡"

2000 � 3 & 18 '�()6\]AÕm�P)�À��ÐÑ�t�¼�L#á'�<

O6�A�|�±�f��#/�îS���23è6C�����n�I��÷�6J

át���X123�¼��3(�:¦Ø¥èW6Õ�Xõ��6C� �R·�Î3ñ,

b�î�¦¨©e�C�(�`a¥�úì�Hº��XG �¸ÊË �AGã¸�G �

º#^ý��Óß�:«?B.�sJXB`_��O,`�ú�t���u�&�Ñ6�

�X124��½���i¤Ìwi��3äxX

)i^/P:`P�õÝ�6&ã�2000 � 4 & 14 'äa��ÐÑ�\]�A�¡

¢�½/P:¤ánÖTFDX:��� 1992�6b�î�¦�è%tbe6d��t�

öÖ"­�6Ñ^�ïg7<H��«6¡¢XÃ�õ6Gj��iÑ�b�î�¦�è

122 �õ�vTUVWh��¦=:�V�¦x�@(�N`äþ��*`�B�2003� 12& 30'�� 76�87X123 ¯S£ñ�>¹Nb(�6������ÌI��,d�6<OXwx�|µf��l#6u��ð��

�îS��6C����X��r¦ÓRS��,�6� Ïä�|µf�{��±²����m�¦¡�

��l��´µJKA�¨è�}·�îlmX|µú@×����O,Ý��º»fÝ�³Z[cÝ�7

1x()á¶X1Ñ�Ø�Ùúf��{æÏ���½�¦#/�î�Ç�C�ÏzX|µÚKI�6�÷

�]7¹��PQwx6åè�2�jþ���ÚÊ�óD�u��Ç�æçLF�?u���6?u\¾eX124 �O,t�Nb()��AÕ¡m@3�|µ"�Ñ�t�ÐÙí¹�()­�¤�²�|µ���x

#/�y�i�|µúâ�:()�eX

Page 94: Department of Political Science College of Social Sciencentupoli.s3.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/finalP9532… · Department of Political Science College of Social Science

89

%tbe6d�°��¶X125

û��,�±�������õ� 4& 28'Õî6�ù¦öG/:�� ��î66

�MNb1992 �d�e�b[cd�e�F¹#/6b�î�¦e�¦,±6b��ète

�,�±6bèteÏd�®¹X�Ü#6éÈè�8H>ºù�3I&��:���æ

�>�ù®J<H~���C¯)Þ�X�â:ý,J<H2���WD�<W1�:<�÷

��Eà3�JÅ1269Ì��2} �_�,�±C�ú<yõ#/�ª�©� Û & ÜÝ '

@6�9B�Þ & ßà '@�l:¸:¶Òã�B�ÜÜ & Üá '@¦(P¸`^��ïB¨�

�Ô����U�Ä�����µ&`���¨ù��C^�ø���G1b[cd�e

�MX127­"�#/¬��6Ì�b��¨©eu 6b[cd�e�¡ú̯ö1¸6

´©X-

�¥�Ñ���@�X����b��,¦e¦�n G1�9u'±3iá�¦]:

�*�¦]#��1�°ÑàáBÑñò$��86�?['�ëb�c-%>'e�bQ

Q¤ge�b;c-Vge�b()Ák[e�bî¶�?'e¨�B��«ø«�6�"XÜ

â�Í��Ñ����_­úbÕ���e�I*2�uö6î��¤��,¦6$�³Ø

cX

,�±e@��$Ù�ÐÑ�u�6�A�|³bn­�vÑe6{æÐÑ�a3�

�PQ�128#/�ªú�ÚNè6bÖ¯|�ɯîeû�X9Ì�>�¢`a()�3

6,�±`��#/�¯��Ï ��i��JK%�Ï��Ìâ�(�6X

,�±��6/P:`PQ^1ÍÎÏi<b�¦=e òõâ�Ï�6�Z£ã��

¯<?�f�3ù�b�¦=e6=b�¨Ãt[yõ_Ñ��ÄÄ6�F�êë�Ø

�Ù¸\]? 5 & 28 ' �b()��w�=e�/P:¸`P�G�Ô]Nb92 �c:

125 �õ�vTUVWh��¦=:�V�¦x�@(�N`äþ��*`�B�2003� 12& 30'�� 129X126 ibid�� 132X127 ibid�� 134X128 2000 � 5 & 20 '��ÐÑ���,¦X ^\]{æÐÑ�t�Nbüò�d«��(�¸���ra�^<ÏØ�­:ÔO�3�­:I¿¦��­:���¦=M¶�­:��¿®tÜ6]�`¦�úÁÑ

ÂÎv¦]#�x�b¦]:e6¶·eXbn­�ÁÑeúì-}�:,¦���,¦6PQX�ÐÑ\]

^ØáuD,¦��rabn­�ÁÑe6�ÚÁÑ¿®�õ,¦�ª©t�Nbäå�6ran%:¾0�

�OFe@appreciates Chen's pledge and takes it very seriouslyBX

Page 95: Department of Political Science College of Social Sciencentupoli.s3.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/finalP9532… · Department of Political Science College of Social Science

90

�����üÑ|}�vÑd��e��f:�S¶à�ÎÑNb92�vÑd��üÑ�èÑ

è�6d��e�6 & 27 '��ÐÑ?\]�D,¦ãÕfZ:áæ :f�²� 1992 �

6b��èted�_����ôä��Z£b`*§¨e¨�GUÇ�Ñ����6�

��Úôb�¦=e6¥ç�¡�¤×a¯%@�e2�(ð�è=b��ète�� b�

�e>?X

2001� 1&�,¦�±� �d�±6lOïM`Uw��߯��6f�<?®

ö¹b6r�`8e@neo-conservatismB��µì��¦`8�ñs,`%>��²�C�

d°`8�`aĦì"�næçJØ�`÷¦öµ&yb6r�`8e�b%>`8e6

�Å�?é=ê�'(��br�`8e6­��?Íë�u¯¡63¦��Xå¯��

AÕ<=�d�±67A�#{ì�b#/έ7�()G1¸>yÑP()¶·6�Ú�

¥¦{T����Çð�õ%¥¦¹()�,¬��eXû��{¯f�<?³�ÚÉõ|�

���Ï��%Ù?()Ñ�Xk�� 2001� 4& 1'���3��,6bá�dAeµ

*�129�ª3I�PQ6õ¤��()õ|��µ*Ìb`äìäx6À�eX,¦6��

61(|=��F�I93Ñ��-#6½í³K�X

2002� 8& 3'��ÐÑ�sÈ6���D�±�Õî�:6b¾W()�ÇgL:e

ÔENH��J3I[@ô�:�`��Fº�&��3�3�� ,��~I�ÙG

­��ÄHI�`¸,�ØZûþ)�J�@:�,¾ÄeO¾JX130

¡¼�º�­�µ_ô�yÌbèºÐ�e��AÌÑ��Ø� 6(^�uö��

¯Øy{Ì����tÜt[lG�6í£�úÌ�`÷Ïä6#/�Úlf�6�DX

Ñ6b()¥õxe�b()òã%=6Ee¨1¼�131¤�b�V�¦e�³b`¦3^e

¨î��Ïï�9?!�Ñ��{ÌòãDb()uØ�3eÏEX

129 ��? 2001� 4& 1'��_,¦�´ EPh3�<�A�á�¦�@î<�^&�Ç+´�´�÷"�� 2 _ðh8�g°A�î¶s�ñòX¯� 1 _ðh8A��áÞ±á 70T@110`�B�÷�,A��Kd�ðh8 AóÉ�ËîQ��çô_ä�­G�_ô#/ÔO���õ,A©�ó�áÞõÐAùX#/YÂ,¦<�AÜ�dDðh8 A�n�ÁÑ�£�àâ6�¹äó�?�¦��Xõe),¦Ñ^�EPh3AÌô��6ðh8A¬d��nô��_ðh8¾:AùX��,I�{µ*Â^¼p­ä�IЮÃ�ù¥7TAX¡"��î>�l9�,¦�t�kíȯV6b[öe��¦ò+A�Q�7°ËAE9X130 �(¹b�V�¦=e�k]b;-��eX131 :� 2000� 5& 20'��ÐÑ\]{æÐѳv�¦iDx�91� 7& 22'�X-*yvgLDx�91� 7& 31'�\*X

Page 96: Department of Political Science College of Social Sciencentupoli.s3.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/finalP9532… · Department of Political Science College of Social Science

91

¯�A¹ìÌe) 2002� 8& 26'��6,¦vm���x4+Y��>?(gp

pD(�f�Ö8��Î�ÍÎÏ�Ñ÷äéCN`6Á���8��r�6�ÐÑ­_

¦äøp�ïgð�ì-Ô�f����Z���¦Ø��7|�H��nð� �,�

± 12&i����¶6AÕø�X�U6É�ú�t�v� ù'Dx6�+D÷��£

�Y��Ñ6ì§4M���¦Ø��7 ù�X�Ñ��û¹Å­úâ�méCú �

S> ×�O����¶AÕ�6ø���iâ iÙ�(:x\]#AX

2002� 8& 30'��ÐÑðqÒA[�Ô�ÚË6A:�`*Çòb�V�¦e�b`

¦�5e`a6ßàX¯�lñò6Ñ 3�XX��b�V�¦e6`a ��Ìû���

 �-��±�Ìb�î¦Ó6ØÙ6µ&e�Ñí¹�F¹��,¦\]�ò§ù()û

õôû¤�VW¤XXc�,�±v(�±#xÌ~�23�î66`²�3d�¦�`

a7>()a,AÒ�ð��¬�¡Ìb()`¦eX9Ìv()�Úð}£x�©Ìí¹

Ã\�()tÜõ|�Ì��,¦�+ò()�3�����,d�¦]��©Ì� ò

b¿®tÜe�¬�¥¦òbS,`¦eXX-�()òã%=6E�¬��5�>�,ð

��­Ì\]�@�±`�â�ð�X

cccc����()ØÙC�()ØÙC�()ØÙC�()ØÙC�

b�V�¦e`a��t��K6¦�1�±9M�-6C��Áª6��ÌâØ<

6X9Ì�{�µ6��ØyxÑú6�C�3()9:��îºÙõx6�Ú¿®õ÷

Ñ6�¥�Ó��¦,±`�Âg6Í^ÌN()`ò¡Þ�òÑR���61��

­�pï\¾�ü�iϲ�+�r×ö·�­9Ì�÷«7õ�°¾xf§X¬

¹6f§�Âg6�yÌbv 2,300��IRS�(���Æb��õeX¸?1,±`�

�Ã�©Ì���ÐÑ6b�V�¦e`a�¾ñ¥ß\]{æÐÑ�S¾W�S,6Ô

��÷ÅÌbn­�ÁÑe6`aÉS»-á',-ò���ÛptÜ6`8,���Ã

�í¹�()�26���8��2;Éu6,`���­Ì()ñ6�Db�32¦e�

��ù¥¦��ñ#ô�ïk«^ØÙm�6«¹g|X132

õémèWúÑÚ�Ó�6C�XJýõ�Vµ¶5X�í¹�iáÌòÐ:PÃ�

132 v�¦iDx91� 8& 4'�X-*yvgLDx91� 8& 5'�Xc*X

Page 97: Department of Political Science College of Social Sciencentupoli.s3.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/finalP9532… · Department of Political Science College of Social Science

92

wx#�¦:ÌëìЮ°­¨Ã�9Ì�V�¦i̵uÁÑ¥ò÷���x×í

¥ò6øa�¸±�¯þáÌïgrptÜX�l��l:<µ¶¢��©ÑN�ÐÑ:

ë����Ì�g��6ÚN�­"«={TìÄÚN�()���}·�6_��°Ì

Tð?¡ÞX133

{�9:èW®�Ô����îÜÁª6î�xC�b�V�¦e`aÏi�()6

,�ït[3­�6É�X�ë��b�V�¦e`a�gLD,�Ñ 47%AÃ�TVBS

,�úÑ 54%í�X�?b`¦ð�()�Úe62}�©ÑI�6Û.âD?Îp�A

�~�ÅÌNgLD6 59%³ TVBS6 62%X­"úÑÓ��i�t�ë�¦iD6,�

{Ñ�[ 64%6,-Ó�()6¡Þûõ�v�60%6,-í¹�ÐÑ6b�V�¦e`

aº�9:,�Xõ%(óÕî`¦�úÑ 44%6�áA­Îp()�3I¿¦��¡Ú

Ü?Îp6 29.7%¹��TVBS 6,�úÑÚ�6m��{Ì 50%­:AÃ�õAÃ�3

AüÑ 36%X134

9Ì�,�6ãDn­����,-��ÚÉSÎp6�uèXû¹tuÎ÷ÐÙÔ

��¬�Ó�°Ìtt«�X�ÐÑ6b�V�¦eÔ�Y��Ú¬6X�'ç�óä�

284 ��(ñ 1.02 îXç���Ó':" 450 Ó�8 #öçSª���ùb[��

µ*e�xl#çfX135

----������6��6��6��6C�C�C�C�NNNN

)vgLDx��»9�m���ÒA6D÷�,¦Ã�le6C�#�¹Nbµ�n

­£�e�b,¦¦&3ñ,¯���î�¦��Ún«¿®eX1369Ì�,=6C�© �

±~�ë��q��ÆbgNx¦öGC��e@CSISB6���@Jane SkanderupB137ÑN

b[�x��j[�AÕÑPÌey138v¢�iDxY�Nb¡Ì�\]{^�xl²¸Î

p()�36�u��eX

133 v�¦iDx91� 8& 5'�X-*X134 vgLDx�91� 8& 5'�Xc*yv�¦iDx�91� 8& 5'�Xn*³ 91� 8& 6'�Xc*X135 v�¦iDx�,¦ 91� 8& 6'�Xq*X136 vgLDx�91� 8& 6'�\*X137 ���i^ CSISbä�=Âe6���`^@>"?BX138 v�¦iDx�91� 8& 4'�X-*X

Page 98: Department of Political Science College of Social Sciencentupoli.s3.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/finalP9532… · Department of Political Science College of Social Science

93

©_,¦ÃQ6r����!���µ6� ��¥�­äX2002� 8& 7'�Uw

¦ÓRS:}�|�}sY0�D¥+ÒAÕî6FD:�t[Nb|µÌ��î�¦��

Ú�õ%­Îp()�3eyn%áu±�b�ÐÑeþ��w��^ìb\De�bÝ�e

6]¹��t[,¦µ�wôE£Ï­ä�nð�%¨X2002� 8& 8'�,¦¸¦&y

1�Ï��÷��½,¦Çòb�V�¦e`a6(�/P:`P�Z£:_i�÷Åï

g(�_�ºñò�ÚøGÏ�7�,�£mXní¹�()0òD�êØ6¦Ó�ì

ÑG(����Úw®X139�Z£�¢�����Å:_3�ÆëA�¦:}Q�³ñò

ÃQ�/=:¿u(�,I�C�6â7èXõlñò6�Ì�Z£D,�ì�Nb()n

ÁÑò�3eX140õ_�vgLDx6b,¦ 1�­B�¡ ÃQ6���Øy¹NHt�q

°ý���:�D¢~µ��d3I|¯�G:RS¸©Zæ&��? :{;¸¦Þ0

h>q°KL��ò×É�¸��t<��°�MN�wQ:Óß�JX141

û����ª�,¦²�3�ÐÑ6µ_Çò�142���ª�,¦ræç´Ñ2®µ

f�ú­f�¡*µ��á¬ÝÞ�>ÌüÇ3(�,Ï=øaPQXõ��³i�b�

î�¦3ùe�b­Îp()�3e6t��§¨3��6���ÓGH¡ù�x:6��

ù�Ù#Õ6µ*l_H����ùX

nnnn������6C���6C���6C���6C�

{ë��ÍÎÏ� 1999� 7& �b�¦=e6C��U�����ÐÑ¡�ÑVú

Ì&��-�b£2eB�âÑÌ���ú�Â1��X�BÑÃ�¯a�nC��d�»

É�6�,'D�6�9Ñ�=Q³��£Y�tXõ#/�(ëA�úçç�£�Õî

���t[��ÐÑb�V�¦e`a6Pj�­"�¡úâ�ÑÌ#/�(��Ñb(

�e|=�tib�Ä.î6&�eõX

¯��2002 � 8 & 7 '�v�,'Dx�t6�9�=Q£Y'TU6fÍÔ��Ð

Ñ�Ò|=(¹ôtÏFX¯ñ�Ñc��ÌY��ÐÑ�ÍÎÏ�U�Ì�î��PQ

139 vgLDx�91� 8& 10'�Xn*X140 v�¦iDx�91� 8& 10'�Xn*X141 vgLDx�91� 9& 12'�X c*X142 2002� 8& 7'�}sY0Nb()`*ì��ÐÑ6��­Ì��()�3��µë�Çò�|µú{ÚK�µ¬º6ÇòeX��¼ÊÇH«^X

Page 99: Department of Political Science College of Social Sciencentupoli.s3.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/finalP9532… · Department of Political Science College of Social Science

94

�¦ö9:6bz{F×Ae���ÌY�Ðѽ���b�V�¦e�!"`,¦�ut

b(�e�©Ìbn ¿®tÜ�úv()��¦�����()�Dg|eX�¥�>

b�¦9:Ýë3()GC¬eà¾�¬¶¬�t�·¹'�¢�S§p(�3ù6»Ç

SÔ�()/P:;&Q'Ѫ(6 6,000 �¶£��B�1X¯�`ò6=��Ìí�

�ÐÑ6(�<?�±ÁÑ®�üÌ��3|Má®6¥VXõH#:zÏJd¼Ê���

ô�ÇI>Ï:.ÆÅ��¼���:�zÏ�9�>Ï� ©÷��y�ÇYp>?;

OqP¹:����:QR¼eÅà£uö�!�3#/Sª��ÐÑK^»°6káX¦

(P�|�ÍÛ���ÒA:ÔâµÝ´ÑÎ6øGº�ÑNH���HS���3�3

�� Z�Âh#±04:�/>3íì�£>�JÛD��)*¸TD�íU�:@.�

Ë���Vg)�¸HS��ô� ýl¢=WM��ôYI�:1�1øX_����

)¸&���:J��¯ç¸&�îï:J���÷:OXêë¸J^���:Y�JÅ

9Ì�b£2e$Ù&-�b¸®e©w�ë 1995 �ÍÎÏá,�1996 �()\]±

A³ 1999�ÍÎÏ�tb�¦=eix6�-XIl���6Ñ^ó�t� 2002� 9&�

4¯[Xs�2i6���h����ÐÑ6b�Ò<=e ����9Ìï���� 

:H[$klÉÊ��æ�9��¸����¢çJ��¯çÉÊ:�íý,J6Í^�

ú ³H>îÉ����êÊËâ^¨ñ���÷:Ã@@ë9�ØËÌØ ���÷�

�Ãñ@/G�WMðJÅ¡ÇÙì��(ó�ÐÑ6b�V�¦e aô�è¹b(�e�

9Ì��6¡¢�78­���J�Xû����ÇÙ«���6¼½¾:,=786

©u�X���Ñ���3ù(G��ÐÑb�V�¦e`apÆ��Ï_�Ð:§pb�

���PQ­():��¡¢PQe�AÑ¢Qb��PQ���78e�* <6¨©X

�O,�b �#e��DE�÷Å :NH��åæçZ<ç[<ç{J���÷:N�

êë±à¸�·~�ÁÂ�í:Ä\¸kl�Þ¸ÖD��¯çÃÄ:Xß JÅ143û�>

��4��6=��â�����78­:�:()X

#/�Ñ6b�V�¦eÔ�_�r�m@3bÖ¯|�ɯîe6jk�vÑ��

��¹b���(�eX9Ì�f?"� 1995�96�³ 1999���6Ö����,¦�L

143 v�¦iDx�91� 11& 9'�Xc*X

Page 100: Department of Political Science College of Social Sciencentupoli.s3.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/finalP9532… · Department of Political Science College of Social Science

95

<O6`*t������µ*�{1�"�­�U6�ܹ£�6�ky(óëÌ�9

�����JK��¸�[»�oÇ6�«X

qqqq����������������JKJKJKJK6()6()6()6()

�Ñ�����:è�b�V�¦e}·�_¡ki<�â�É�:��ª�(��

�6­��¯®¤Ï¨û�â>�äBîªD�+X

JÝ�2000� 7& 13'�4¯[:�()6ýWÁÂ�á¶�i� ��î6É��

(b§p���9â�­/=Øce�b��Øcú­Ì��(�e�Ç����b�î�¦e

¶·�º�38«�Ã466Ç�,�±��ü0,G§pb�î�¦e(â�­0tb

¯ØcX8& 24'�4��á�:�gLD�á¶�i�¯Ñ^I¹B��Å{Ì��b6

-�eNH¡¢ö£ì3I&�¸�>Ä���¤ð3I&�¸&�:[@ÄGò�¡>­

�¥JX9& 5'�¦(P�|�aÙ¨r�ôtÃ��º�b6-�e6tbX¯=bÏ

Ìè��Ú�~ϲª�Ç����������6K�X

¯u�#/¡ÞpƲªÃ¶�2001�6¡Þö~Ì 7.3%�2002�Ì 8%y�¥¢

d\�� 2001�Ì 5,097s,��Ü 2000��� 250s,��2002�I,�¸ 6,207s

,��¹¾WX��y¥m.#/¦¡�2001�¹ 468s,��2002� ¬¹ 527s,��

:S,¦�ù¾WX�y¥�ÔOú> 2001�6 2,121s,���u���¸ 2,864s

,��¤¹¾WJ����:S()Dx6�¹�6¥�ÔO 1,200 s,�ÏûXë�¡

Þu>�IG¯%KääX

�¥���,�Ú�ª�f��ÅÆlOï��_6b��¾§e�b��Ô�e6F

^�ú{ÌÑ��I�����@ë�²¶·B­ì�����â�LFÏ @ëC�î

�Bh1LFX,¦�b[��µ*e_�I�¡>�©�÷�6pq:ª�x����

6�Ç�JK�¡î�ü6#¦PQ�¤¹��� <��}·����3�<©ª³u

Ø©ª�6Ö>X

�?(��ª6��|î­?�çëX6���Î3Ç�¯ÒT 1996�1999�6Ö

���(�ÚI�«���Ñ��6í�I� ­Ï¥��£í¹�����Ñ���è

Ï_�­?��ÐÑÔÑK��<O�õ{1b:S()Çð()¶·e@�,�(BÚ

Page 101: Department of Political Science College of Social Sciencentupoli.s3.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/finalP9532… · Department of Political Science College of Social Science

96

N6Ú�'Û�:S,�±����ïg?() 2,300 ��,X*2�­�6�Æ��Ú

x|T�2;����ĩu6JKX

====<H<H<H<H�T��T��T��T�JJJJ��������----

��������ßàÑGßàÑGßàÑGßàÑG

1995 �e��Ù�()£¤�ë¯W���Ã6bÖÝS()¤gNe�¹��$�

ÖÝS()¤æç0FX�i6�r�Ý�Ú^Ö×Ù'¶X��()6$�Ö׶<�

x��¦¹`��H­ä�ïg$�Ö×7mLtu��0ò�(�23()¦Ó,�í

�6fg�ñ6Çò$���Tô��¦$�£¤¹ï���6,�`8X1995� 1&�

�r��vgLDx��t'$�Ö×òëìý�(�£� �¯�v6b���<=eX

�í¹Há���o·e:d�]eãË~|����À­½:d���·^<·�<·

¡¢:d�¸|��<»�:d���_�<Ã_:d�¸G¯¬£`�öýáýOX¸

a�b�,�±)%îY2�JÅ1997 � 8 &v�ôx,-*ð3b$�Ö×�$���

!Je�n�Î>�¬��6'�î6�É6Ø�(�£��£?u:b3b���<=e

6�õ��í¹��$�ÖÝSØy��þ �1¡��6<Ç�?þ ��ê6$�£

��û���?6Ö"6�����àq()¨�¦¨¾W6ù��F@�rs 4h1BX

1111 ccccüüüü±-±-±-±-�T�����1�T�����1�T�����1�T�����1----

����������������####���� ¡^���� ¡^���� ¡^���� ¡^----

Page 102: Department of Political Science College of Social Sciencentupoli.s3.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/finalP9532… · Department of Political Science College of Social Science

97

�r�¬ñb6���$�¢%_;¹NH23dJeò��fÙFn<&<6<º<

g­½� 2>dJ����F�higºju� 2¢dJ&��¸2/dJ%S�¸2

ÁdJ¡¢�JÅ¡Ä���$�¢%�Ö×jk�K�NHá�&��id�!P:�T

Éà23d¸á�å�id23<>d¸�&d2><¢d¸å&d2><¢</d¸�

�d2¢</<ÁdJÅ

b���<=e6$���IJ�­Ì*]$�ë�i=6>þ³¸�õÌ�<÷=

�6b>¸³þe�(Ì�()Ç���()�¹���D¥,a6$�XF�»3*]$

�ë��i=þ¸F¹$�Öë6é��¯l#6v6©Ìv()���¦�ÉS��

*x�­?�?�î$���ÏØ�õÌè%���Ô�Xb���<=eÌÉSÑÅ?�

ß6$�í��^=�BÑÝGb��¦¤e��âDX¯ª«IJÌ���<63ù�

5_x�$��v()+�±ã�¾W6î��õ­Ì+���,�$��26î�xS

�()$�X�%=ú±|­!�ÑN b���e6uØbüÑ���Å{Ìí�()eX

1996 � 10 &��r��¦3��´��t���$�ÝÖÝS�RPQ:n1^

`^X��b���<=e¹Y÷�â~3��$�¢%##��¢%##()�ÉS

��¦�����x���ÃÌ�Y[63�¹N()��£¤�±á㣤"��²�

�@��±ß�`�B³G�iô�9:�¡Þ@#��$B���PQ�£¤�@Ö×�

£¤�,¯B�%ã��%Ù���X

b���<=e³#÷µ86b��$�¢%##e}�3�ëW³Ö×W�õ��

kÑbí�()eÖÝS*2�M�ù�?Ì��3()�«�.6#=|Xm���¬

 �6��$�¢#wôÖ×Ù{wX

2004���ÐÑÝ��b�&�Ìe6�­äÂ^ÃÄX144n^Ø�r�u^Ö×Ù

¶_�(01Ö×î�6²>�¡£�*2�îb��¦¤eî��®íN#'()�^

Î3[b3B �Ïu6lë¾¼bºîëërr6�¦�eyî£9¬Ñ��ØBÑb�

144 2004� 3& 19'�|TÂ^6,�±+\]�ÐÑ�¸\]Ø�Ù�(áÊù¤��13i 45���*�µ*X>?�i�-r�++,�û#6-�:Þ3*ø�.��/012�3�tùX\]�¸\]�

_ô4½�µ��� 5.8 `�¥6û,�3�5Xe)µ_µ����6�d*3 2 *�¯� 1 &�ÌG"7�8¬9:_��Ø�Ù;Þ�� 1&©<"�ÐÑ=ÙX�µ*�? 2004���,¦\]#AÑqÚ�#6()��u'Õî6#A¦���*�m�Ì��Ø<��¦�,�±ÛA�H~�� ú¹ 0.228%X

Page 103: Department of Political Science College of Social Sciencentupoli.s3.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/finalP9532… · Department of Political Science College of Social Science

98

¦e�]��c6ë��ò�br�e@(v��Øb�¦e2 �üìByGõS¦���

¶:}�Ô]b*.:}e­B¦ö^6�@>�145í�b()��w�=e�n¯âM

��$�ÖÝS�Hæ�/=y? �b����Ée�¹¦��l$�Ö×63�_;¨X

F��Ñ��r�@îb��¦¤e6Ö×��Ú�\6�G()�,6í���®¤�

G()�,�?�¦6í��Á��X

cccc����Øy�+Øy�+Øy�+Øy�+

b����Ée`a>b!�e%¸õþ�Ö÷�GCÑP$���<�9:�£è

�ª6£�X�Ç��()��¦�ãÕõ¾W��b�<e6þ¸xð�Öë6Ý_u

��ÛñX>¸õþ6É��Öë�SÙѯ��6���Ùõb����Ée�Çò(

)6"�@$�Bi�ïѯb��õ%¯nw¡ëW¶<Ù4ÏGC�Ü �_óÚ�

"­±ëA6Ø�X�$���«=���G��¨ô�')��¸��,¦i<�()

�#/³¾W6f�PQ�]j�ÑÌ�Äb���e6PQX

��]�i<�()ô�<�çþ6��¦Ó¬*�Xõ_G�TH`÷²�ã33

()9:��#�¹`�6fgX�i()��ÐṨa,�#�ï,9:e3��

h¨Ç�¯����¦#/Ï=£¤ghϧìÞ¹­|6µuX¨ô()��()$�

�¬>i=l¶�úl«`�è6÷�X¯�¡£¤è�ªf����¦#/¹���õ

�i¾Ñ6ï,9:àá÷è�¯9:f��#¤�õ�¨a,¤�b?øæ¤e�t�3

£¤�6T@õ��<�6þ¸�ÓÌð�()£¤6f�ØcÏPLX')6()��

?'�6A,����#�9:6`�è��i�<�Üþ6'�Tô#/x`÷()

6ãDX��,¦i<6()��#/�<=����uö�ïBX6PQ�GH()�

°�¦Óí�6C�X�i�þ��R�Ý6,¦���¡�´�Ý �£¤6Î3��

Ý���G¯Ã¹()()lñò6¦ÓX��«=^ì�i<�()�#/�¸¾W6

f�PQ�)­7F��1�<6þ¸xÑG�¬�b����Éeu�«^�rtt(

145 1943 � 11 & 23h26 '�D�rPQ¶�.��\]³E� JÚ¨��,�Z 3 ¦�ô?ð³*.G*:}�n? 12& 1'�t3b*.Ô|e�`òØy¹N@1B'�«¶*¦óX@2B®°±� 4ú�()�·�M�¦X@3B7°�Þ�Þ�Æ�ÞM�gX@4BÉÝ�3X@5B¨Ý>'�?ä�ϯ��ÞS7>,¦¯�X

Page 104: Department of Political Science College of Social Sciencentupoli.s3.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/finalP9532… · Department of Political Science College of Social Science

99

)6"�@$�BX

��<!�¹`ß6b����Ée�Çò()6`�èi¬�:°�¾ñ6¶·�

¯PL�?�ö6`��í����`òÌ�£¤û.¬`÷�õ��<û.X¦�í�

¶·��Ø�Ì�Ä£¤¶·y�ö�q£G6Ð��Ó:Ñ:Sl��Ï�6í�X®

�|µ`¬¹�<��()6í���ì·­Ì�Ä£¤tÆÌû�£¤�6!�¯u

Û�<�6!�IñòHáX()+ò>¸õþ�23%=6`���³¾WÉ�`ß�

Ì£¤�õ­Ì�<X

�<�()�?øæl¸�|µ6£¤�Fï�þX'��()¸ô��ÇÙÛ?ø

æ³FRñò�õ�<��þ6,¦úÛ¸�GH6±áã�|µñòHáXõ#/¯u

`òÌ�Ä£¤>?�:3tô�Ó��3,�¦Ó6�cX()6#�]�#/"x�

��£¤Ì()SÑ£¤Ïfg�úÌl#6`�'X�"��#á'()�6£¤í�

�#/è�n«c�X¡U6µu�í��u�«^��<!�����6��ì¹ÇòX

----����()()()()

,�±�$�Ö×�S>5³�#/6PQX�b(��Éeº¹Ö×�Ú6fg�

?!"Ö×�Úxì¤b�3�ÉeXÎ3,¤'��()6A,¡*�s'��() 50

�¹b'�eõ�b')e�n�b����Ée¡U6Ö×��Y÷ä�()6[��¢

@¦l�¦�B¢%���¢#���t3ÝÖ()��?Ö�¦��l_©Ì¾W�6

÷��I�6é�X ()�6Øy®�3�îÙ���îÌ������î©Ì� 16 ¾

�A,¦Ó¡N()*2ëb�� ñJ�Ù()Ú:A,¦ÓKL6$��õûÄ�8

��¯uÒÙvb�¦eús¹ÌKL()6�îbA,¦ÓeXõ 2007� 1& 31'�,

�±���î�3¶MNO����()�9�%P6�Möt���@MNOBÎp�

r����$�ÖÝS=µ6�Úð�y�í¹�ò23()`�è6��É�{ò�=

#�¦�m�b��eQ��¬¹6b¶^��e{­Ì�Ä�()¹`�6��Éy=

µ6*��$�ÖÝS6|}�Ç�í�()`��í��¦`���Ä��ÉÌ«^�

Çõd�X

��6�ÇrÌ3,�±��6Ø�(^�b����Éeôt3�Ä66%|���

Page 105: Department of Political Science College of Social Sciencentupoli.s3.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/finalP9532… · Department of Political Science College of Social Science

100

�X�|Ï�¡f��Ì�Ä%|�¦�í�66`a��ûK�@÷������B�

:�Ä��@ëN��<�>¸õþ��3%=6`���B�n)�2*�56ë¨�í

£��i�¡Ä6`aC�3¡K�%�¯`�è¶<�­06�<60òXµu��ü

ò¡Ä�<0òÔ��èÄ�()`�����6É�óiydH:¡K�6í�X��

<6�Bx�3()6`�è�ü̯�6�Ä���õ%Ì�ÄRÍlF�yd6��X

b����Ée)­7ÑG$��()�()�`�èí,õᮤ6Ü��ú­7

ÑG$��()�#/³¾W6�rPQX�Ä�Éü7ôt�ô()Ù����?"�

Ü�6­ä��³23�Ä66`�è�¾WÉ6� X¡Ä� SÙâ�<Ç�ïÐÙ

¥¦�$�µu���­â1`É6(gTôuöܹX^ìî����ë��IÇ$�

6Ü�ä�î�ÊÇ%=6"��¯¬2366í��6`�6`a�ú9�t¾ñ6

¶·X

,�±���b(��Ée¹fg��õ�b�V�¦e�b()Ì`²�36¦Óe�

b�Ú%ðe¹`ò=b�s()�32¦¹l����S°6\¾�í¹�#/��¹

Ô�6µu�ë�ò¿®¥¦�"S��,6`¦%ðX�´µRS�Ú�æçÃ�,�

'��¡Þ�ïgh1G±�#/6Ã���$�£¤�� 5³��¦6PQXõ��

\�ÔÑ�Ä�É��ÌbØg�Ée��Ìb]��ÉeXbØg�Ée¬�Ã6=b�F

��Ñ�(b­�í��,¦��6r�èe�n�b���,d�¦ÌôtS�¦6n�

L^��ext[X�¡Ä=bä�¥ÙÌ�¦ö¥7�TU��,¦��Ô�6µu�

�´µRS�­�()Xb]��Ée6=b©Ìb��]�e�b�¦��e��Ú�Ù{

â�®�b|T()�,e6¡Þ�Ú��ì��786£¤9:�Ú�9Ì]�_6(

)�láüÌî��%�6÷�î��X

��6bØg�Ée�b]��Ée�,�±6b(��ÉeVVù3�î�36�

É�ú�Ã3�36=b�%Ù÷�ÚJºº6�Ú�ÚJK^6»�X

Page 106: Department of Political Science College of Social Sciencentupoli.s3.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/finalP9532… · Department of Political Science College of Social Science

101

2>2>2>2>6666--------�8���8���8���8��----

2000h2008���ÐÑ��@�6 8����,�±ÁÑK¼¶^�6`²¶·�9

Ì����¡¢�£¤�ãM3�¶�#/5�6[EXú{ÌÑ�,�±�tu1�­

£à6��ä�ÁÑ�¶^©uº�b��e6Õ��9Ì­³�×Y>�b��=be�

b���ÉeÏ��b�V�¦e³b����Ée¹¯ôtXk� 2005 � 3 &�#/�

�bC�Ò¦Ó^e�146�¡C��9G����Ï=6JKÉSoÇX��,¦6cu�

±� �¦,±6YZ[Ý��H3\]#A�ñ#b[cd�e�����JK�oÇ6

ÂW�ñ6¥õ�´Ñ�²pA6:xX

2008 � 3 & 22 '��¦¦,±\]�¸\]rA�YZ[�û�¶� 765 �·�<

H­/è6���ù��,¦X c^\]�¸\]���Ï=C��tÛÜ6®¤X

2008� 4&����Xnu:�¦,±�Ë`�Âgi�( �b23JK�z{|}�

��Ô��dvI�e6 16�Ï|y���i�û�¶��bXãÕ=Âei�ú¾x

3YZ[ �6brstu�*vwx�z{|}�~�I�e6 16 ���X2009 �6

bXãÕ=Âe©ÌbÃ4:eX4kp[YZ[6b�YdÞ�ÚJkp� ¤LF�

*vwxe16�Ï|�ÃÓZ©�bª�wx�Â=�.�45LF���n�e16�¨

©&�X�ubXãÕ=Âe¾x3��²¼6¨A�GÏù��*2LF6��î

��X�u²¼�4 îb16 �eÏ|�JÑñ��7õ�¯ï�Øy{Ì��òb23J

Ke�òb���2eX

Y��@�_�¯#/6�ÚÑÅ?���Ï�¤�°|���¿�²¼�lm�*

+¹��J�6fg�[>*2��=78½x�8�wx�#/lm�j6`òµ&�

}·�C«Ü�3"� ·�x6��¼½X

��ü6#1�ä����:� 2008� 5&Ï_jk��¤lm��Õî 7ub��

146 2005 � 3 & 14 '�#/X ÆS¦�,ôt#:X-u:}�"3bC�Ò¦Ó^e��`{¡���`�7�n3(M�u5X�^`òØy̽¾��kÆ78LF�9�iúJuG� �3� 3Ä�¹ä�¦#/âG1�����[:¦Ó]�X¡ 3Ä�¹Ìb()��¦�Ò�õue�b��â7÷�()��¦�Ò6ñ#µ®e³b��]�6â7èÉSÇ�eX¥WÌ�õ�� 3#¶*�6l_���(b��]�6â7èÉSÇ�e�¡ôí¹Ì��â�ô�H¥�Çò6¶*X

Page 107: Department of Political Science College of Social Sciencentupoli.s3.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/finalP9532… · Department of Political Science College of Social Science

102

:�e�d7� 15 �l}n[à 1 �d��Ã\]ÙX¡Kl}@d�B¹��678±

�23G�6C`@$ub��:�e���r�t 4h1BX

0000 4üüüü1####d�d�d�d�HHHHA�~A�~A�~A�~JJJJ±²±²±²±²3®03®03®03®0

¯ °°°° ~tu~tu~tu~tu<<<<­�­�­�­� ±±±± ²²²²2 0 0 8 �

6 * 1 2 µ23�A�~�no�

§u���¨8~ö,«

§u���Óð�>k)l��Õm�c«

2 0 0 8 �

1 1 * 4 µ2>�A�~��n�

§u���¬��c«

§u���u��c«

§u���Z��c«

§u���no�·�c«

2 0 0 9 �

4 * 2 6 µ2¢�A�~�ºo�

§u���N�ABpq/j@�m�c«

§u���+fÃÄ�c«

§u���¬�YZ�c«

§>�����NO«

2 0 0 9 �

1 2 * 2 2 µ 2/�A�~��&�

§u���rào`s`tÃÄ�c«

§u���ÆÅËã`t�ÂÃÄ�c«

§u���uvvûwÃÄ�c«

2 0 1 0 �

6 * 2 9 µ2Á�A�~��Ç�

§u���¯çÃÄAB�c«�ECFA�§u���rx"à@ÃñÃÄ�c«

2 0 1 0 �

1 2 * 2 0 µ 2M�A�~��n� §u���yzC�ÃÄ�c«

2 0 1 1 �

11 * 2 0 µ 2��A�~��{� §u���|H�·ÃÄ�c«

����������������####>?>?>?>?

YZ[���ñ#b[cd�e���ñ2��JK�GI�PQü�X¾��()

6¦ö÷=úI^/�ëN��,¦ÃÄr�3¾W �#:@WHAB�ù��{_l

�@GPAB6�QyZ¦�� ��¢����ü#�XN�Yx�㨦Ó@��Bú

Úk9M()�,Ö7aO¬X147õ78v�µ��¡ÞLF_;l}x@ECFAB�IG(

)�¥¡¢ó�3�#«X148

147 |¦�,­1µÝ,�7aóâ��½6¦Ó@��B[ 114 î�ÜY\] 97 � 5 &�^��� 61îX148 b�µ��¡ÞLF_;l}e�ØyÑN�|�5Y�16¶¶£X��|�(âG�I�����q¾W¢d�@WTOBf�¨©�s1I�6¡Þ¶*�C«G±�ÜÎ��=6¢d�¦¡sâ�v×`�6¢d�¦¡1�XI�LF`aN�í��s1I�6¡Þ¶*�{T45�ì�µ��6¡Þ78�

LF�nâÕwM��¡Þl}6LF`a�®�C«G±�ÜÎI�Ï=uØá'`�¢d6P6��P

Page 108: Department of Political Science College of Social Sciencentupoli.s3.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/finalP9532… · Department of Political Science College of Social Science

103

���,=78JáÙ��2011�#/�,M�()\'� 172�·�u�ÚÜ 2008

�6 30� 2,000·�u��¶_�:" 5�X¯�x(6ö���ÉÁ{��¨ 80%y

!�78�m&��uÏ�¨ 15%�¡�ö�Þt#_�öy¸?#/���,û��

ab�1�PQx({û��û¨9:78A¨ 5%�Þt��p�6�2Á�X�9ma

,�x(��<�û�î�­G¨h*'�]ÞC�äóÁ�X��#786Ã\ýÐX

&' 20�x��f:³�l:� 1993� 4&?6�\JuÕîWZ:��*$�:

��¤6lm�[�Ùõ 1995 �ûbp� Ïîe��:lm�³�1999 ��b�¦=e

 ���:r�6gh�[ú�ùX�:r�6C�6é���[�±¸ 2008�Y\]�

^���PQÇl�ÓÑk�6ÀÁXõ��ú�u� 2008� 5' 20'Ï_�$�3�

�â6�:�j�!"l}�23��78±��&uÇðcP¦Ó�6��¡¢�£

¤�9:78¬Q�6¶·�n¹��åèJ���2ã�fgX¡ÄÇ3���TH�

�JK6fgÏ_�wx6êáâ7èX

6sâyC«G±�ÜÎI�Ï=cÞ-áÙò6ý&¢db�è45y H¦¡r��Ö�ID¦¡yÖ

�¢d¦¡ó/¤�°�78�LFX¢d�¦¡N@1B`òÌ��wx¬0òkÆ��6`�¢dl}�ý&¢dl}�¦¡l}¨�8�lm6`a�`òµ���³G8?l}�q_ 6î&Ø2*lm�nhªÉÃX@2B�`�¢dÙ��`òC�_Æ6lm�cÞ6`�`a�°��ö�lm*2³m@<b�¨°�C©�¢ddÞC©¨µ�X@3B�ý&¢dÙ��`òC�_Æ6lmÏ�D��C«G±�ÜÎI�Ï=cÞ-áÙò6ý&¢db�è45�kÆ,2ý&¢d6/�� ����I��ý&¢d�ê

6LFX@4B�¦¡Ù��hª23¦¡r�A��n ¬¦¡6ó�è�^C!G�XG8¡ÞLF�ê�®�9­b?���°²r��¢dó/¤��P�Z����m&�°�LF� ¬�l��7|>¨�

ê³��I�¡¢��J3Pµ X¸?B�LFØy������?l}�q_�?>I�C�lmB

���³ØyXi<�eN¹�ªut��¡Þl}6\¾�I����Ù�`��ý&�Åu5i<�e�

(GI����¡Þl}�q_�hª+ÑÙ�`�óÖ6�ý&�*+�Xõ¹ó�i<�e�\�I

�°�â76º��l}��iC�i<�eó6�ý&�*+6ÚPKÄ45�.ëSi¢ddÞC©@ë

CâI��q45�§ 45B��³Si¨°�C©�ý& HA�8¨X¹�u ECFAl}6ÚPKÄRÍ�Øy®íN@1B.¥¶lNC�I�â�{T�Ûp� WTO C©Ú��6.¥45��Û��,6ep³���6RS��ÌÛ�¦Óñò6RS�X.ë�¹Û�¦�6ep�HSi�ù­RS��6�

O¨45X@2B|ÝÇðA�NI��­�?�l}�q_ 6î&Ø{23ú�6|ÝÇð%�2*£m�nhª[Ãl}��Çð^ìP?�l}Çò�u5�ú16|ÝX��Ï��>I�!"lmÇð��>

b��¡ÞLFPQ:e�ú�����ÇðX@3BA;RÍNI�Ã3b��¡ÞLFPQ:e�Á <��l}ÚP6µf�®�Éù�u�l}\¾¬¥06£m�¶·n�í�l}6@î�Çð^ìP?

�l}Çò�u5�ú16|ݨX@4B�*³_Æl}NC� 5��*@®�N`�¢di<�e°�³ó6RÍ�Si¨°�C©�I�§ 45�ý&¢di<�eÙò³*+45�Siý& HA�8B�

³e)�l}7�6_Æl}�;Ã�l}6�Ù�X@5Bµr��qN`òC���¡Þl}Øyâ�¡>I���_µr��³¹G¯�q�I��ÉÃÚP%���£��¨C�X@6B9ù¶lN��9ù�l}��Sª�£���XI���9ù�£��Ï'õ 30'Ø*2lmXëlmw7[Ã���©�l}%�£����9ù�£Ï'õ 180'9ùX

Page 109: Department of Political Science College of Social Sciencentupoli.s3.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/finalP9532… · Department of Political Science College of Social Science

104

2¢62¢62¢62¢6--------á�á�á�á�----

7É 2000h2008��ÐÑ��i<6��J��I�PQÐÅÆÍÎÏ@�6°|�

�¤'ÛX��K��Ï=¡H6õ|}6�·��ëb��¨©e�b[cd�e6É

����()ØÙÛÜs�6�·�ëb|Ì()�úÌ�¦�e��()b¦Ó��e6

Í^��³b�V�¦e`a�Ñ���±*2i6§�O¼:©_6fpÇò�°��

_C�Ñ^i�â��t¯�ø{TxÕ�gh6F^�ûõ8�6#/�Údä3b­

��èe�béÈèeXC¯¨û�Ã���]<=x�+�Qû¹�6�ÚiM�®�Î

p�0�6û.�â7Ìx%?èÄ­�i÷1�ä6°�@ëbAÕs1eT¨B�v�

µ <��Äí,õ%qj6J�'s"%���Ù{:Ñ­�6i�m�X

û��|µâ�É�:�Î�Y�bb()�¦��V�¦e�b`¦�¶e�br� e�

b����Ée¨`a��ÚÏ¥�óÑêë 2004 �6§kè`¦�2006 �O*2�Ñ

? �()�3�b�()�8�MgL¦e�brH¦Óð}£e�n{TbMg`¦�\

]#Ae¨���F��iò�è^ë�6br�e0��,³¦ µ�³¥¨­�

UÕ6b�Fe�ô��í�Ì���b���(�e�Ò���IG��PQl��m�

³Õ¯òAddë_X

2006 � 12 & 1 '�Ñ�(�æP�¾W()�#:ôti�ª��äá���ô

t�½�b()¦e6O�X12& 5'�Ñt�òb�()�8�MgL¦e��ÑNHº

ðÊ�øö6Ã�:?f¸2²Õ±�&()�<&()�à��<FJ&()�����

:tLøö6Ã�¸^}ö3I&��0@��¸Ê˧º>�3I&��0@ �3I

&��÷Î&(�)NÄ���0¸¦J&(�)NÄ�íì@ê�0��¸©íì@ê

�0 ³~¹¸¸����)JÅ

2007 � 1 &�b�r¦öAùe¿�b()no¦öAùe�²Æ¦ µ�b�

���e¿�¹b()��e���¿�¹b()¦ö×�ç¢Ñb`�e��p¿�¹b(

)�p`�ç¢Ñb`�e��õm¥ �èq�6E�SªI¿¨X

2007� 6&�,�± �6b�()�8�MgL¦eS¦è`,¦�h�ôb`¦

R}PQ:e�ð�7 &e,�±Dî�3b�fPQ:e ��fh�7 & 12 'î�3

Page 110: Department of Political Science College of Social Sciencentupoli.s3.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/finalP9532… · Department of Political Science College of Social Science

105

�f:FÃbOI¨ ���f�`,¦� hí�L?C�eð}Xõµu��f:Ã

^ü7OI¨ ��9�f:ïr%í�¡î`¦hÃ3�GÇ¥^sæX

2007� 8&��xgL¦�S¶tf£,��()�8�MgL¦�Ú0&¦X�<

_�Ñ?��xgL¦�S¶tf£�R<:��`��Áã�ì�gL¦�S «²u

A6:QM:h�ò�gL¦�S ñ6s� <|¦,��()�8�MgL¦�hX

2007 � 9 & 10 '�Ñ�\]�!"sÈ���(¼��'�#�Õî6¾W()�

Ç:gL:X- nÆ�:�t��ì�b{Ì()ò�3�()òr��()ò�¶�

()ò�MgL¦�()òù�î6õ�36rH¦ÓeX

2007� 9& 30'�,�±�"vrH¦Óð}£x�ð}£� :bi'ÉÃ()r

����6¶^��ú�iAÕî`,¦���lÇ()¹`²�3¦ÓeX

õÑ������Ú6C;�IB�C��N�b[cd�e�ª��ÐÑ 2000�Ý

Ì�íb[cd�e�_xï �b[c��ey2001�3PAÕïkÑb[cd�eÌÜ

���,¦��v()y2004�©kI¿¹b[c^_fge ô�Ùõ±¸¯w^��

�=6��fg³C��[Ð��³Ü�X�bn­�ÁÑe�ª�2000�Ñ6{æÐÑN

b£,&NÚ�º�7Ǹ��ÃÂàªu�¬¸>=¾ô�¸>cÎ�,¸>�

7���öT¸>�7ÎÏ�H:Eôþ�¸©íì��§�EFG«9H�EJ:

<�JXÙõ��p\�:3AÕùL3­�½()br��¶e�H6(���ÎpX2003

�OÑNH_J&Nè±2¿#�/>3íì�Ø:>�à¼J�9 2005 � 2 &k�1,±

`��Ã�ñ,bn­�ÁÑe6d�X2006�e�Ñk%Éb�ÁÑe��� �bÂ

]e`a�n� 2006� 2& 28'7�`£�r�ÂÎ@ùBb¦]:e�v¦]#�x�

¡,¦P5�¿1Z£bceasee�г�£b9ùey�¥E�,�Ìbwi�ùe��Ø

D(),-ïÔ]ÑÌbÂÎe�#x�ª�^�¾ñ()(�,JKX149

��Ñ�� �6��`a��F�]Ú:#/�½³,¦Ïì-PjX.ë�,¦

¦&3��b¦ µ�¿�e�µ�>�|�}sY0@Sean McCormackB �&�NHÊ

Ë>�Õ��Wß±Á ì�Zx? ÎÏ���HF�:ô�: �VW¸@2¸t�

149 � 2006� 2& 27'äa��ÐÑG*b¦ÓRS:}e�:}m@_ÔONb9ù¦Ó]�PQ:0F�9ùv¦Ó]�#�xú1eX

Page 111: Department of Political Science College of Social Sciencentupoli.s3.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/finalP9532… · Department of Political Science College of Social Science

106

>�Õ��Wßî°��#ÎtJXÜ>#/³,¦6C�â£�Ñ��i<6��EF³

=b�¯¬×Ã6m�ÌGÇ��¾ñ6G¦��"¸Ì(�,Ï=JK�����¡Þ�

¥7¨è�ª]­�?()wx�2X

õ� 2008� 3& 22'���,¦X c^\]�¸\]AÕm�P)_����Ç

6��3(Çt��¸\]�A�û�¶�b��d��ùfZ:eVµ¶Ï¡¢.#/

r�bXãÕ=Âe�n�#/¦Ó`����:ª� }��±�>��®A*2�h

ª*+#/ÉÁÛx(�Ö���¡¢rH¤�jk��lmA�¨ 4 �ò�Xkë�¦

¦,±`�ÓyÅ.#/á¶�¯GØ(¹b��®A±�e�b�:k�eÚPµ��#

/�O��ØFC�y/P:i²�f:��l:�î��è�µ&6:��lmX¡K

È�Ç�6Ì��Ï=6q��ø4¡¢�³��C�6PQX

¶u�x�(�Ï=6�����Ìãä��RS���6ñòû.�¯¨û�?(

)� ãä���WgN6z¢�{X��(��õÕË��(��ãä��6�V¦Ó�

êë'���¢�è�,"¸Ì±áã¦ÓXû��r(�6��©Ã¹ãä�ê�lñ

ò6}·Ï�Xõ�Mãäµ&" 6,�'¨¦¤�±l�õ·6 <(�ÚP6}·�

Ë^ì���Ú�I¼�(�TAXY���^�x�æç�#/lm�����õC

�ïÎ(���Ï=6­K^��¶[ ·�Ïu6��¼½�õá'¦Ó¤����ü

6��½�Ã:z{�ní¹��϶6�Ç�uÑÖ?ãä�ê6RS���X

��ÈÉ��«6��fà6Ëa��|µú­â¿sò�R·6��ª���6�

2�­7��Ï��¡¢C��«6àÆs¹l9ù()Ñ�6m��I­7¿s

º�?|ªOäèÄH¿Ým6��}·�â7Ò��KS�()RS�ãä�ê��6

()û.Xû¹��PQ�q¡¢½x6J������j��}·Ï¡¢PQb,}e

¸����PQX+|µwi+äÈÉ6É��¿�tu`8ì�¦ÓRStuª6's

é��7�:P?b¡¢,}¸��e�b����Юe6ß_ÐÑàáO¤Ç6j·�

ÒÓXX���()ª�6¦öPQ½�xÍ�����PQ6«�Ì�º�,���

(-VPQÌ��}·�³(�,Ï=6´B�³,��Ï=¤:¤ 6ÛÜ®¤�Xc�

\�¹ù�Y�����Ï=¬[Ã6l}#�ù?¡Þ�µ&è6�j��}·�ów

Page 112: Department of Political Science College of Social Sciencentupoli.s3.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/finalP9532… · Department of Political Science College of Social Science

107

¼³�jèØ6��è�·�êë¥7÷¶�¦ö�6r��"¸/=����l�X

û��t�7THÚ�ÈÉ6�2�n��µ&èØ6}·�2¸û�jk_�C�ª

SIj <6��èï�}·�¡Ì��=j�ÕÖ6j·yÆiÎÏ����JK6

b[cd�eÌ�°Í�#^Ì�H/=�ú�³i~���266=b��¡û�X

°Ñiñò6���Ì�()6$�Ö×�ª�|µ��¨Ã�&:��,�6�É�

õ­Ì�Ó�()��¦$��é�X����h²µrtÑÖÝS6�É=b��t

Ñ6ÖÝSfg��­ò?��b()�e�b�¦�e�õ]�b�¦�e]ÏX�Öë

ù���ÝÖb()�e_Öb�¦�e��~¹ÝÖ¨Ý6b�¦�e�?Öb()�e�

�°¨r�6$�S���Xn¨Ýb�¦�e6b�ô�¦¼e@( 1949 ��_6�

¦�B�����,¦6���2�õ­üÌú��#/6�2õX¸? 1949 �_��

,¦�()69:�¡Þ�ª$��©â�+�¨Ñ6b()�e��iX��÷r�,

�±��¹S>5³�#/6PQ�õ�$�Ö×�¬{16"��kX

Page 113: Department of Political Science College of Social Sciencentupoli.s3.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/finalP9532… · Department of Political Science College of Social Science

108

2Á42Á42Á42Á4]]]] ��������/��é}�a��������/��é}�a��������/��é}�a��������/��é}�a----

�Y��bY[��{JK�ªÏJ�@uö�¹B¹=bfg�0/()��J

KÏè�û.@íb,���(-VPQeB³uDEFXn�bK�2345e�b6Ä7

`8eÉ�5M�`òqÐ?buDJKe��b9:2;`8eî�5M�`òqÐ?b

¤JKe�ìÉÑ�GCÏ=�³ØyX

236236236236]]]] �����a�����a�����a�����a----

�[0/()�#/���()b����JKe6`òû.�n��«Ã¯°�m

���¹r�Áª@bÑ�e�bѦeI���JKB�Å{tÆñb��+Ø�¥ÙÃ

û�Gù�É~6GC5_@ë 5h1B�õ�,¦Ï()Ù��©��0/X

----

��

��J

K()

û.

�)�

ª

#/�

ª

()û

.

Áª

()û

.

()û

.

Áª

()û

.

ñ#

b[c

d�e

��,

=78

«

,ë`

86t

t

b|Ì

�¦�e

í�'

Á��

Ìè6

b�î

�¦e

=b

¡ÞÃ

,�`

86t

t

��è

´>

Ù�

1111 5�1----��� ����� ����� ����� ��[,[,[,[,----

�����aAB�����aAB�����aAB�����aAB----

����������������####���� ¡^���� ¡^���� ¡^���� ¡^----

Page 114: Department of Political Science College of Social Sciencentupoli.s3.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/finalP9532… · Department of Political Science College of Social Science

109

;;;;<<<<��? ��? ��? ��? ----

��������rª()û.rª()û.rª()û.rª()û.

@�B�bñ#�[cd��e�ªN

Ã�£ÏÉ��GC�1992�6b^_m�e_6b[cd�e̹��2;��J

KÏ$2��õ�¡" 1994h2008��;�Ï=��J��ÂR6bõèà1e_�150÷

���JKoÇX³¸ 2008� 5&�()cu�±� �Y������b[cd�ef

g����H�*$3#786iôXn��¿�üø��úÑ[�Ó�6ܹX

#/�ªáb[cd�e6Øc�8¹bè%�O\��tb��µ��]§p�

î�¦¨©�6d�e�()�ª©íTb[cd�e6í8Ìb�î�¦�è%tbeX

9ÌYZ[���_�b��ète4î�ú�t3�¤6��X����u^/P:`P

*2�Y���b�î�¦¨©e¶·��t3éÈ6tb��XÚÜ(��ª� 1992�

¬ ³6 3 �¨©Nb§p�î�¦¨©���¦Ó]����ète��ª�A 6@x

@±X�?��PQ63ù�ú� 1992�6 3�¨©p¤�b��,¦�¶^_;ä��

�[cd����­]�­��­¸��Ú¹fge6£�tbÏX�¥�b��,¦Ìî

`²�36¦Óe¨tb��¡H�t�Y�¦,±��6ÃQO��Ú�6�b�î�¦

¨©e�b��¦Ó]�e¨£�©ç±�t�Y��6O\Ô��Sª£�Ï�X�?Y

õ|�Ì�í¹b��,¦¶^_;e¡ 8 î�¡â�cÞb�î�¦¨©e�b��

¦Ó]�e�9Ì¡U6tbüÌ�Äb^<�ÁÑHIe6Ñ^õ����6î�xÍ�

ÕÖ ³ûK£�úÒ�3��è6s1�õ¯¬°�6��9:¤m�©Ìb�î�¦

¨©e�b��¦Ó]�e�()C�ù�î��­r�6�MX� 1992�6b��è

te=b���î�¦ÌY��,¦�Ã)¶^�v¦]#�x�`²cÞS�¦�9Ì

150 � 6bõèà1eÌYN1994�6b�Þ�®he��Ynäo!áy1995�6bp� Ïîe@�:lm�ùBy1995h1996�b(�ËÌTAe@�uËÌ�©�´ÐBy1999�6b�¦=e@�:r�gh�[�³By2000 �Ñ��@����b[cd�e2002 �6b�V�¦=e�b`¦�5ey2003 �*26èÄbr�e0�@��¦¤B�`¦�¶y2004�6b§kè`¦ey2005� 3& 14'#/�"bC�Ò¦Ó^ey2006�6b�()�8�MgL¦e�r�ÂÎ@ùBb¦]:e�v¦]#�xy2007�,�±�"vrH¦Óð}£xy2008�6bMg`¦�\]#Ae¨T³��JK6ñ#µ*X

Page 115: Department of Political Science College of Social Sciencentupoli.s3.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/finalP9532… · Department of Political Science College of Social Science

110

2008��_�¦,±$ÙÐÌ1b[cd�e¡î�M�9Ìbè%tbe�6b%|t

be6ØyÌ­?Ìb§p�î�¦¨©e�b��¦Ó]�e�õÌb��,¦Ìî`²

�36¦Óe�b­]@­�]B�­�@­(�BeX

9Ì�Y�¯Ñ^úº3Û��JÝÌ� 2010���£E��$ÙÐÙ°ÁÑ¿®b(

)�Ú> 2,300��ð�e6`a�9Ì¡�3�î¨Ã6� �(�b��,¦¶^e

6_;äX¯uÌvgLDx� 1& 12'69=��'��PQ6wx>b��,¦¶^e

%�ð�(¹·���Y6Ñ^�ì�b��PQ6wx>���,¦¶^�6%�ð�eX

?A�Y�6��:�Y��_��AP1¼��ø]b��e�b#/e�­]b�¦eX

vgLDx? 2& 17'?�'��6ÇN�î��õ­�Ò6X->?�¦(ÎpY6Ñ

^�n����Ì¡îbX->?�¦e6�Ù��û�­â]��¹b�¦e�¹Y\]

6Ñ^ H<=Ã)X

���JKõ|�¡Ì�îr�6�D�<>ÌNX��YZ[�b#/er���

�HñòXF̤Ç��b�=PQe�nÉDjkûÄ��²�b�3e�`²�b­�

Òe6X�«X�r�*2�|µÓÑâ7C���ÝmjÇ6��¶·<ù��©ë

1995h2008�;��ß�?þ8���b()��¦e¡U6�¦=�Ï]���¯m�

ü:88I�PQõ¤�õ­:Ñ^ìrª�26â7XXc�Y��f�¨ÃÔ���

b��,¦¶^e6_;ä <��PQ�Ìr�6�DXû¹\�6b��,¦¶^e

{Ìb��¶^e�§p�b��,¦¶^e6_;ä <��PQ�{Ì����JK6

raX�¹¬���£bñ#�[cd��e�s¹��2;��JKÏçñò6rDû

.¨>X

@cB,=78«N

90�ôe<���PQ6�ü�GǾ���b,=Âe6tÆ�I�¡Þ�£Ö�

z�¨è©ª6J��78���%#�Þt�¬6Á��%$¡ 20·�³áu�����

´µPQøaõwÑ#_�¿®X 5h2 ¸ 5h5�Q��,-�.��78�01�

z�]�')Ê~ �â�¨ÃÉ�:�¨Á�X

Page 116: Department of Political Science College of Social Sciencentupoli.s3.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/finalP9532… · Department of Political Science College of Social Science

111

1111 ����üüüü³-³-³-³-��������­½�)Þö�>­½��EË1­½�)Þö�>­½��EË1­½�)Þö�>­½��EË1­½�)Þö�>­½��EË1----

����������������####>?>?>?>?----

1111 5�2----�����­½�)Þö�>­½��EË1�­½�)Þö�>­½��EË1�­½�)Þö�>­½��EË1�­½�)Þö�>­½��EË1----

����������������####>?>?>?>?----

Qb��ìd 101� 1�2*=ç��dÙ�×·��EË=ç�

����������������####>?>?>?>?----

1111 5�3----�>�>�>�>­½�)­½�)­½�)­½�)|���|���|���|�����EË��EË��EË��EË1111������������<<<<�!�!�!�!<<<<¯ç��¶¯ç��¶¯ç��¶¯ç��¶

�¥y�¥y�¥y�¥y����----

Qb��ìd 101� 1�2*=ç��dÙ�×·��EË=ç�

Page 117: Department of Political Science College of Social Sciencentupoli.s3.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/finalP9532… · Department of Political Science College of Social Science

112

1111 5�4----�>�>�>�>­½�)­½�)­½�)­½�)��özL��özL��özL��özLË��Ë��Ë��Ë��EË1EË1EË1EË1----

����������������####>?>?>?>?----

Qb��ìd 101� 1�2*=ç��dÙ�×·��EË=ç�

1111 5�5 �>�>�>�>­½�)­½�)­½�)­½�)¯á¢çöEz¯á¢çöEz¯á¢çöEz¯á¢çöEz��EË��EË��EË��EË1111----

����������������####>?>?>?>?----

Qb��ìd 101� 1�2*=ç��dÙ�×·��EË=ç�

Page 118: Department of Political Science College of Social Sciencentupoli.s3.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/finalP9532… · Department of Political Science College of Social Science

113

õ�¡¢78�ª���¢d% 1993�õ²ª���B�Q��_����'���

¸ 2011�¹ù�|¦�#/��6¢d\�¨|�¥¢d\�6 22.8}�Ü 1992� 

¬3 3�Ïá�(m�#/6¦¡Z�� 20�=I��3 53�Ïû@:�t 5h1BX

0000 5�1 ��¯���EË0��¯���EË0��¯���EË0��¯���EË0����1992üüüü2011�������� +�xú+�xú+�xú+�xú#�#�#�#���������t�t�t�t�

�×Ê�º�>­½�

>L�+����

Ê�º�>­½E

L�+����

|��{

l�>­½

��S=

�{

l�>­½

��+�

1992� 116.67 �7.6��

105.48 �12.9�� 264 2.47

1993� 150.97 �9.3��

139.93 �16.4�� 1,262 11.4

1994� 178.81 �10��

160.23 �17.2�� 934 9.62

1995� 225.25 �10.5��

194.34 �17.4�� 490 10.93

1996� 237.87 �10.9��

207.27 �17.9�� 383 12.29

1997� 263.71 �11.1��

224.55 �18.4�� 728 16.15

1998� 239.51 �11.1��

198.41 �17.9�� 641 15.19

1999� 258.35 �11.1��

213.13 �17.5�� 488 12.53

2000� 312.39 �10.67��

250.01 �16.46�� 840 26.07

2001� 278.5 �13.45��

219.5 �20.27�� 1,186 27.8

2002� 373.9 �15.89��

294.5 �23.3�� 1,490 38.58

2003� 463.2 �17.70��

353.6 �25.43�� 1,837 45.95

2004� 616.4 �18.72��

449.6 �26.83�� 2,004 69.4

2005� 763.7 �20.04��

562.8 �28.36�� 1,297 60.1

2006� 881.2 �20.7��

633.3 �28.3�� 1,090 76.4

2007� 1,023 �22��

742.8 �30.1�� 996 99.7

2008� 1,054 �21.2��

739.8 �28.9�� 482 98.4

2009� 865.9 �22.9��

620.9 �30.5�� 249 60.6

2010� 1,207.8 �23��

848.3 �30.9�� 518 122.3

Page 119: Department of Political Science College of Social Sciencentupoli.s3.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/finalP9532… · Department of Political Science College of Social Science

114

2011� 1,347.1 �22.8��

911 �29.6�� 575 131

����������������####���� ¡^���� ¡^���� ¡^���� ¡^����>?>?>?>?����----

���:� 2008� 5&Ï_jk��¤lm��Õî 7ub��:�e�d7� 15�

l}n[à 1 �d�X¡Kl}@d�BI¹��678±�23G�6C`�¹��7

8 ×3åÎ61�X

¿L�b6tƳ]�')6Þt�Ç�¡K¡Þ£¤678�Î#Ù�C�3,=

6�u���0ò�õ%��71()6`a³%� �ÑbX��¡¢£¤786#«

���������Ç�b¸I�!�ÌÚ�%ÙõÑq6�«ü�����½ÍÎÏ�

�ÐÑ�è¹b���(�e_��ïg?�,�ò�(),-23��Ä©u6JKX

cccc����Áª()û.Áª()û.Áª()û.Áª()û.

@�B,ë`86tt

()��p��2¸�,-â�!",`AÕ��èÛA�Ï=�îÛÜAÒ�õ

A�ú¡Ã¹3@�6L^èfgX{��õ|�()����Dq��,`p�¡

BÆ�X¡Ä���6,`��u�,,`²��ªÑ��6�«�8�Ùõ�()6�

�p�útt�3ì-6,ë`8¯aX

õ¯��,ë��()lû�ld����õ_�úl­Í3(�çÑâ7÷���

�ðÉ��¯6�-"?���PQ�X����ð>,ë�6��¼|��õ,-�#

/��:�6�<����PQ6 <��^ì�¤��TI�d�6`a�{ô�¹Ì

D#/�Î�ë¹�d�E�Xõ^ìSÌ���SÌ7lǬ¹()`²��,}¾6

`a�©ôs¹��r��¬D«:�­yfgX

1995��ÍÎÏ�\]6bp� Ïîe�6���SªCÌ�¿ª�³bWZ:�e�

n�|�î£2¸®X¯�¡úÌ�,�`8@�¤â],ë`8B�D#/�,F���

í¹()¡ß��¦]�6l#��X9()�&�#/6"ci�ú*2��Zè6

�Ð��õ,-�?#/6C������G��I� ?���a6ÊË��X

2000�\]#A��ÐÑ�H3AÕX¯_fõ3b�V�¦e�b`¦�5e }·X

Page 120: Department of Political Science College of Social Sciencentupoli.s3.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/finalP9532… · Department of Political Science College of Social Science

115

2003� 7& 25'�Ñ�²��,¦m��#GÍìGit��2004�\]AgÌ�ù

b�V�¦ vs.�î�¦e6�ðXðÙ�b����e3�¹u�#A`ßX¯u��

,�6®DxÍ�H¨Ã�()Î#Ù�6,-Ì`a��bÛptÜe6�9����

fAb�V�¦e�Ì­��j,-6�Z�ð>�()b`�èe�360��ººè6

}·³�#/C�6���mLù�T�£�áSf�t6�^Ï�@(),-�]��

�3�ÛptÜ6Í^��r� 5h6BX

1111 5�6 ��������)*ºE3)*ºE3)*ºE3)*ºE3<<<<ô�F¨Õ�H:y@ô�F¨Õ�H:y@ô�F¨Õ�H:y@ô�F¨Õ�H:y@----

����������������####>?>?>?>?----

Page 121: Department of Political Science College of Social Sciencentupoli.s3.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/finalP9532… · Department of Political Science College of Social Science

116

b`¦e6}·úÌë���M WHO �{Ì(),-6d��âÌ`�AÃÙD,

-��Nb���V�¦�6_;ä�M WHO `¦e��¨F¹­úÌ��±²,`�ä

×�,�Óº`6��6`,¦��Ib�V�¦ebM�Ì���PQ���6,ë

EFX2004� 3&6\]#AÏ��`¦^6�"�³�\]#A�`Õîb§kè`¦e

6ÔO�151{Ì�ı²��éÆb�,e6,ë`8��?()6¶�,`��³��

PQ×Ã-#"cX

µu��|µü0©FÉ�óâ�t�b,ëe¡îÑ^�t�èÄ­���3ù6=

bÏ�X��ª�7|�±Ï=­³�b,ë`8e7ÚYW��¹3/ÎA,<HÎp�

­_ ��K­L<�j�ut6�����9�iï)­�·>�¾�%=ÓÌ�r�

b¥��,¡�Ve�7Û�Ö�*[�ôtb�,6ø�e6��>1X

,ë�6"���r�G,`7A£¤�ؤX,`AÕ̹3A>�7�F�­*

A,ú2�<��ÛÉ6'sXÙõ�()6,ë�6"�r�ï×{3bAÕ�me6

ÛÉ�àX>?¨X#á'6��,-£¤©u²��7AA¹3<TA�¥¦T|,-�

¡{÷�¯×����7A£Ô6Ø�jÖ�"õä�ì��Ã��õ¿sú26É��

õ�Ú�%��¿s35�<?�î�7>X�¡ÄbAÕ�me¬S��«=7AA°

ÌA,)ô¡Ä��¬�Á�iydº��<è6ð�X152

?�Ñ��¹.�¯�bïne���PQ6}·��­'«^âÃ6tu�­1,

`lm6P^õÕP�^6`¦�ÉSÌ�Ä,ë�6�F�Ð�Ì�Ä7A�6@��

^X@�Ïe�¹��#/6u�&��`*��bn­�ÁÑeX9k#>�îb���

(�eE~�Gb(�e|îB��³3]�|}6�¼²X_¹�� 2004�6Â^�`

*�íbn­�ÁÑe6����áSb(�f�Ö8�e6�£X¡Äbu®eVVÌ

,ë�6��¹�T²>6A:`8ttX

,ë`8�,3()9:ØÙ6�3X,ë`86çÝ�,¤6âD�G,ë`8A

��3bS��,e�bS��-ed��?ôt6¥�XÙõ��tu6àá�¹ä�#

151 ��§kè`¦¬Ã)6Ì`¦^X Q¶X��6C�Nb�¦ÓÚ�¥>"c��¦Ó`²Ñ¿®Ï

��\]H¡î�33:Ïð}�{¦ÓRSµ��7�`,¦�eX152 �f��v%>,`6<Ex@(�Ng¡�*9�2001B�� 45h46�� 242h243X

Page 122: Department of Political Science College of Social Sciencentupoli.s3.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/finalP9532… · Department of Political Science College of Social Science

117

-d��f6����ij[ÃXõ,ë`8ì�%=�ø��?]��¥Ù«s±'�

6�?�¯m�Ì×Ã�±'�6¿N�ì���õ]�±'�6���÷�bá'�6

��eX,ë`8»-3,`��b^�e�b�qe6f6X,ë`86çÝ,`6'(

,-s¹L^è6n�x£�¹»-tÔ6���*3�óÏòX�,ë`86mÂä�

^ì���^ø)��3q>X�����1,-6Îp<T­�^ø�����6²>X

()6�±í�kÞt�GÇ6�ê¤âD��Ù��,-Îpéfú �±A{

á�õ��áÙ��,-Î3éC�±A{áX��q�-67|��ê`86Ä�èÑ

3��6ÃÄXõ���AÕÏ���-6AÕ7|kyd��()9:)Ñ6��C�X

��qéfú �éCú 6b]�Ï|e�bú+ººe«^ù���LX¡U��"�

6��r�F1ä�()9:ØÙ6�3�Z�#�9:6�Ê���ú�:¾ñ"cX

,ë�6mÂI±²"c��PQ6��X23��åÎ6(���PQÌ���,

6e���¬�X,ë�6��r�ï×Ã3��PQ6�Ê�G±3JK��,3øaX

�()���,ë�mÂHH�(��>�'(mLX¡­âÕÖ�ò§��PQ6�ÊX

(G��i�f?0ò�ú:ðÖàáµ*xfõ��|ÝX¡)C�3b(�e�>­

³��Fxb�ø��úC�3,ë`80ò�Ô?b��e�bººeX

@cBb|Ì�¦�eí�6'Á��

î�3Gs:�b,-6����³��É�e¹`·�Q��î¬u,�X? 96h

98���Ñ���\]#A�³YZ[\]@�6 3����b()�e�b�¦�e6

í�Y¾��Ûܯ,�m��%í¹Ìb()�e6Û.NÑõ§�9�:" 6 Ã�Ã

�Ì 63}�67}³ 64.6}X%íÌb�¦�e6Û.©ÞtC�äó�Ã�Ì 96 � 15.4

}�97�ó¸ 13.6}�98�©?ó¸ 11.5}X98� 5& 27'`O6,�@5& 1h2'�

�B�ÃÄá¶3 1,113�Ã��y� 95}6K�дä�éUI �rÁ 3}�Ø�¯�

í�%=Ì()��¹í�%=Ì�¦�6 5.6 ��í�Ì%=()�úÌ�¦�@�A

�ÌB6Û.¹ 18.1}@:�t 5h2BX

2009� 12&�v`ä,-x6,�')ú�Hú'�62}�áAí¹%=Ìb()�e�

%íb)Ì()�úÌ�¦�e6Ñ 22}�%íÌb�¦�e6ú 8}y¯��18 : 29

Page 123: Department of Political Science College of Social Sciencentupoli.s3.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/finalP9532… · Department of Political Science College of Social Science

118

�6�°��í¹%=Ì()�I�[ 75}�¹�ö��66�Xv`ä,-x��©6

bbãä��GCfZ:eVµ¶6��6ÇâÑ��½AÒbÌ�¦�úÌ()�e6

Û~l��}�6Ì���£¤6í���#,�Å�?Ð6���ë�¦�ßÆ��

�:b�¦e�ôt6{Ìb���,d�¦e�û�Iì¤3()��¡¿��6í��X

£¤#ë����¦#/¬¬¶ y�� ���#ë� 2008� 8& 22h24'¬º

6,��Ç�$Ù9:6�3ª­iì�ºº�¹ú±iá�9í�%=Ì()�6Û.

�[ 48.4}@í�%=Ì�¦�6Û.üÑ 4}B�b¡Û,�±@� 8 �6^ì�îi<

�°òxH�eX���«Y��_x��[îA±�H�¤�/Ûx(ÉÁ¨d��#

/¦Ó`�����i�t¬¹6b���eX9 TVBS¬º6,�Ç��¦�í�� t

ÆCõI¾ñX')Ç���b­ �)Ì()�úÌ�¦�e6� ä�í�%=Ìb(

)�e6�[ 72}�í�%=Ìb�¦�e6©Ñ 16}X�b)Ì()�úÌ�¦�e6

� ä�b()�e¹ 49}�b�¦�e¹ 3}�í¹%=b)Ì()�úÌ�¦�e6©

¹ 44}X153

0000 5�2  ���û)� ���û)� ���û)� ���û)� 98���� 5**** 1�2µµµµHHHH)*:� ½×/g���)*:� ½×/g���)*:� ½×/g���)*:� ½×/g���JJJJ)��Á)��Á)��Á)��Á

2222 15����----

à��à��à��à��¸ì��d�ÜJì��d�ÜJì��d�ÜJì��d�ÜJHHHH������������JJJJ ©ì��d�ÜJ©ì��d�ÜJ©ì��d�ÜJ©ì��d�ÜJHHHH&��&��&��&��JÅJÅJÅJÅ"<��d�ÜJ"<��d�ÜJ"<��d�ÜJ"<��d�ÜJHHHH������������J�J�J�J�·J·J·J·J

HHHH&��&��&��&��J����J����J����J����-

��� &�� ���J Úh�ó~ LË

64.6 11.5 18.1 5.8 100.0 ����������������#### ���û ���û ���û ���û----

õ�Û 1998 � 6 &�Í�\]@�i<@b�¦=e ��Bî�3/P:ÑP,-

�%|í�6Í^�Ñ 37.2}6,-í¹%=b)Ì()�úÌ�¦�e�Ñ 30.5}6,-

í¹%=Ìb()�e�Ñ 19}6,-í¹%=Ìb�¦�eX]�'�Ç�(),-í�

%=Ìb�¦�e6Û.�u�C�äó�Xå¯Ì��¡" ·�x6���¤�b�

�¦¤eEF_@ëbr�e0��b����Ée6$�ÖרB�¯í�Û.IÌ#_

��X$Ù 2008�Y���������ü��9Ы^¡pë�Á�X<=�����

153 vgLDx�2011� 3& 9'X

Page 124: Department of Political Science College of Social Sciencentupoli.s3.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/finalP9532… · Department of Political Science College of Social Science

119

��2ÊËì-i�()ØÙ6¦�í��]�|}��:C�G±�9e),�¡¢Ç

��m�ïÚCXb¹�$��PQSxSÎ�,�'�SxS Ìe y�ì��b¡K

')E�|µ�(),-�%=6��ÁD¨î�­���PQëì¿®��«^()Ø

�6�=Xe60h70}Ã6,-í¹�:lmÑçÖ�9h�ë��nÁÑ¿®(),-

�Hb|Ì()�e6(^X

tjkë�tÆ��í��xÑ�¡t���PQ=¡r��Mb��,�Ø6�=

PQe�(),-Ñ:"@�²¸B�;Û.6�t[�b÷Ì÷�|Ì|e6�=PQí

�X�f�ë�b�=PQeÏä6��J��Ìj�23JK6X

====<<<<�>? �>? �>? �>? ----

��������rª()û.rª()û.rª()û.rª()û.

@�BÌè6b�î�¦e=b

��% 1949����x�I��%{r]��»�s��¹¹º����²Xå¯�

#/�ª�% 1982� 1&�Ml� �b�¦��ey1541992� 3&b^_m�e���

�¬ �6 5��hy1998� 10&�WZXcuª:@:_Bi���D(� �6b�

î�¦e86�ÑG¨�155]Ì�b���,d�¦e¹`�6b�î�¦¨©eX

9Ì��6b�î�¦ef�ú�i=³��6�2õѬ¿®��~�ë 2000� 7

& 13'�4¯[:�()6ýWÁÂ�á¶�i� ��î6É��(b§p���9â

�­/=Øce�b��Øcú­Ì��(�e�Ç����b�î�¦e¶·�º�38«�

Ã466Ç�(�ü0,G§pb�î�¦e(â�­0tb¯ØcX8& 24'�4��

á�:�gLD�á¶�i�¯Ñ^I¹B��Å{Ì��b6-�eNH¡¢ö£ì3I

&�¸�>Ä���¤ð3I&�¸&�:[@ÄGò�¡>­�¥JX9& 5'�¦(P

154 1982� 1&�Ml�`�t�Nb��î¦Ó��Ä������Ìâ�£à6��µ­ò»-#/6���|µú­ò»-�Åî��eX%�b�¦��e6>?r�Ã�X¯�(Ì�¦Óut]�_�()âF¹

÷Åî���+Ñ��6%�²�nârû´�e�b()tî9:�¡Þ��­®�����­®��¥¦

6¡Þ�£¤PQ­®X���°�¢£������¬Ñ²�L^k�²�¥¦¦¡­�]�eX155 � 86�6S£¹Nb¾W�üÑ�î�¦�()Ì�¦6�Ù��\�ów]��I��d�m>���î�¦6¨©ä��¨lm�d}]�y�î¦Ó6`²���Ì­â��6�()6��������î

�¦6� ä�î/=eX

Page 125: Department of Political Science College of Social Sciencentupoli.s3.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/finalP9532… · Department of Political Science College of Social Science

120

�|�aÙ¨r�ôtÃ��º�b6-�e6tbX

�d¥¶yÓ¤ú� 2002� 9& 13'?gL¦#:�ß»=:��`*Ô����

½ÜBÌè6b��6-k=e� B�Øy��Å{�yÓ¤�gL¦#:�t��Ï��

�Uu^"m¥�Q�¥­¦ö9:1�6�#/�l:H&¸:¶yÙÑ�� 2001� 9

& 1 'á¶�Z�i�D��¦9 �3�î>?�Å{Ìb��Ï=�ò<¤��,¦

³���,d�¦6����eXe)yÙÑÝ�6Ñ^��î��6.�{̬¹6b[

cd�e�I��ÁÑÑ�¡b�î�¦eÌ��,¦°Ì���,d�¦X

¯u��#/�l::¶Z[c�¡Ub��6Çe6Ñ^Û4¯[°i ���Ù

IÌ�yÓ¤6��Ï�X1997 � 1 & 15 '�,¦���Ƨò:}��Z¡#¨ 

�NH3I&�z>J3���:&�¸©>J��&(�)NÄ�� %JAB)±ùE

:�3I&�[ð�JX11& 16'���²�à$�~�6ôt�i�ĮÃ�Ñ�NH3

I&��>yð�&(�)NÄ�� ©>yð�&()�� %J���÷N��µE3

:&�ű53I&�¸~J3IÊ�E3:&�¸N��:E3:&�JÅ

«=ÌZ6b��6Çe�46b��6-�e�yÙÑ6b¦�<¤=e�yÓ¤6

b��Ñ^Ø¥��=e�f��;Ã����r�Zô�h6�(�Úf��nµr3

îÏÑ�6b()Ì�¦6�Ù�eÏÑ^� �²¸(�"�b()�#/�Ì�¦�

Ù�e63ùX�¥���Hp�6ÌN�#/Ã� ³b#/�()���î�¦ei�

nÁÑÉS�íb�µ���ów]�e6µuXõ\���]�OF¬¹6¡îb�î

�¦e��ÙÌ°wÉS]�X�Ì�Z[cO�b���Id�)×]�6�¦e�úÌ

�yÙÑO�bÁÑÑ�Ì��,¦����,d�¦eXû����b�î�¦¨©e�

��b#/�()���¦e�b��ów]�e6Ìè¶lÏ_��(�"�ò�b�

¨��e�³b�í��µue�ÑB�&�X

Ü�I�3ùC�B¸�%����Ѭ&�i��2;��6��JKõ|��r

ªÏ()X

@cBpÆ6¡Þö

#/%� 1979�¿À*+�x�¡Þ{�˲6ª��2�¯�$$¡Bu¦�Ø¥

Page 126: Department of Political Science College of Social Sciencentupoli.s3.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/finalP9532… · Department of Political Science College of Social Science

121

�¡��6ñ#º��ë 1989 �6b`Ròµ*e�1997�6bãÕZ�¬�e�2008 �

6b¾WZ�¬�e¨�9B�Q�29Ûp�]�[��'6¡Þö~�¯¦Ø�°

©�@GDPB¡:"'���{¾WXc��tÑöª��¤�� 10�Ø~",¦6

â7èi�Xõ��«ìC¡ 30 �6¡Þö~�1980h1990 �6�]¡Þö~�¹

8.6}�1990h2000 �6�]¡Þö~�¹ 10}�2000h2010 �6�]¡Þö~�¹

9.7}����i¾Wè¦�]¡Þö~°­: 4}�õ%��î:" 13s�O6ª#¡

Þ�õ|�òÛpë��д6ö%i=¶[ 30����jH6Ã{X

û��#/º¹�î¾W¡Þ#¦�+7�¦Ø¡ÞÛp��I¾Ø6ò��n�¦

ö�Áõ�Á6Â^�­9�¯¡Þ¶þ6�2ѬÖ��SR¡Þ6¶<�2ú�¨

ñòX�¨¡Þ#¦6ؽ�u>�¥�G����­±K��õ¡ÄËaúÑ�?��

���J��2�%K�Ìè�G¯�(�ÚI�«�X

°Ñ�îÑY6É��Å{Ì(m�?#/�¡Þö~6ÃcX80�ô�(m¡

//ÆÆ!"èÄ����[:#/b��¦¡e�1989 �b`Ròµ*e��Ï_�à

ᥡççO��wü.#/¦¡X�i�üÑ(mÐÙ�«_k:#/¦¡X�µ�^

_�M ¬�Ù_?­�±®��*6i=Ø{*2��°X156)í�(m¸±ç

/± ¬�±®�¾v×:"¯�6{�A:�³¾x:" 194 s,�6¦¡Z�X1979

��/±6�]¬HüÑ­: 100,��:3 2009� ¬6�]¬H¡:" 1� 2,000

,��ö:" 120��õ ¬{Ì(m¦¡6#� Xõe)¡ÞÙ¦R:6¡¢Ç��

(m.�¥è¦@��B±²¦¡6Ûñ���¦#/>(m¦¡��6 6 Ã�¨?(m

v¦¡ñ�õ��#/��Â���`��öáu`*t��(m�#/¡Þ�2Ãci

#X#/ 2009 � 6 &O¥�ÔO�[ 2.13 á,���{SRX��õ(mÃc6Û.�

[ 1�4@¯�(m¦¡ 3,000s,��$�(m�#/6�:� 2,000s,���BX¡K

�Ì�')�±²â�í¤�x6X

#/©õѯ`Ûɶ*6KL�Ìi�GÙ�úÑ#/Ø�6¶*KLX9ë�Ñ

(m�#/¡Þö��2Ñ­â¯56ñ#Ãc6��u­¹"X{�É�õ|�(m

156 ¬¹b-x�de{ÌY(m�/±�¾�î6bx¢�ée�bxU�ée�bx*¹Ke�bde¢de

6�Ä��¢d���¡U6¢dé�¹/±v×3ç#6éFA:��MX

Page 127: Department of Political Science College of Social Sciencentupoli.s3.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/finalP9532… · Department of Political Science College of Social Science

122

6¡Þq�â,}:��6��©ª�¯�?��JK62;����¤Ñ�cX

cccc����Áª()û.Áª()û.Áª()û.Áª()û.

@�B,�`86tt

1978�O�#/�q¿À*+ ¤�260ò���¦ö�6 ÎPQ�­H­æç

%¡¦MSR¾W���Xõ�²�¡�`8�Ø°p6�i�«âÕÖ6òª���

�Ïõx6'(��������É�¡rÌ��lu�6b��Юe6�RXܯó

�1,�`8��¦`8xÁ×#/�,6õ�í��b|Ae�b�AeÁ×Ã�î

�3ª�ð>�õ�,6í��<�õGH�²����Ø6�i�ÐÌ��Äb23B

��¦÷¯�69:`8eÉ����õ­��%¡6¦Ó�,�"¸Ì�²°����

�õqË#/�,�%¡¡¢6õ�í��q�X

#/Ã�� 90�ôÏ_//ÆÆ�2�¦`8Ö×6uØ�8��?û�¡Þ�6¿

À*+_��áS¯�²L^fgX>�õä��2�ÄbÃ�,�`8e@�]b¦Ó,

�`8e�state nationalismB�÷ÅÌ�O,��²Ï_�!"�¦`8Ö×6u5���

âÔ�=b�6E��,�`8¿¿Ã¹#/£�¢�6�Ä`÷è�¼�b¡Þ�2��

����¦Ó]�eóù�÷��áS�²L^è6`ò=bXõ¡"ÖÝS�*¿Ô

�6�]Ô*�>Ã�,�`8E76�D�Øy�%��*2pM#-6��X#/,

=� 1990�ô�õ3�C��@å¯Ì,¦B6b#-,�`8e@popular nationalismB�

Ì�Ä>äõ�@bottom-upB62;é�X�AÌ>�õä@top-downB6�IJ>0F�

Ì>#/Z¬Á×�x6,�`8�áÌP?"�ÅK��<=�Ô�5_6=by_

AïÌ�Ä>äõ�6,�`8�Ìx%?/#�,6¬��6�Z>1X

¡�Ä,�`86'sIJ�BÑBî÷�N��ØPQ��!"¡�Ä,�`8�

�¦`86���â�qË�,6í��n%ð>ì�b�¦÷¯e�â�±����B

*x��õGH��6���������­:�ï�²ÏfgX��¥PQ��!"

,�`8�â�줦Ó`²6îG7>�r�è�nGHb�¦�e6>1H��m�

�õX�]�¶·���,�`8��6Ëaä�GH���6\�()¶·Ì�ÄbØ

�¶·e�Ì¥�¬­H^�{±6�¡ÇÙ�¯ <ØÙ6]�¶· �Ñ�X

Page 128: Department of Political Science College of Social Sciencentupoli.s3.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/finalP9532… · Department of Political Science College of Social Science

123

Ù#/�EF,�`8Ïö�¯Cªq�ú��²t�JÝÌ×Ã3±���36ì

¤�õ°�3öÈv�¦â�Ñ­x¡ö²��¾Ñì-�¦¯a�b��£¤#S=e

6qF�=b�t�157¡��¯uÌì¤3±���"¸ãÕL¦Ï=6C��×Ã3­

R�>?XuÏ̼¤6�����#/"¢EF,�`86m��GH,�`8ù¯

ØÙl�6Y÷¨©�^쨩°­7�ÏC¼�Ì�çyd¹Ñ���¬�F�àáµ

&Hô«b�#õ6��¤³ººX

Ü��(�Ú��­�̧pb�î�¦¨©e�ì�()Ì�¦­â��6�Ù��

�Ì 1979�6bE()�ISe�1995� 1&6b�;�e¨�¬Ññò6øG�£*�

)Ç���é6,����£¤í��¡KÑMÎ3òt[���6\¾¥�`òúÌß

_Ñç,�`86�Z���Xû¹��,�`8��¦`8%L01�"�EF�Ü

,�`8F¹��PQ�2"%�â7÷�g|6��º�û.­7°d�¿³s��

i�()ú0ò÷Å3Ç:#/,-�?()6�¢÷�,����Î�­:°d8()

8´³�#/6µ¾X¡¢÷�6�s�6�¶�+�,�`86#�äÚ:��è6�

��¥GH��JKþ��3(RSTUÜ�X

@cB��è6´>Ù�

Ã),¦¦§Ù� 2012� 5& 18'`Ol66#/´>DEY��Ç+´ÐlÝ

�6¸RÙ��()��6´�@á�´�BX�÷ÌÙ��ª�2004 �6DEYÇ+´

�(ËÌÙ�¹ 500 U�2005��¸ 650h730 U�2006 ��¸ 710h790U�2007 ��

¸ 900U�2008��¸ 990h1,070U�ÔE»��2009��¸ 1,050h1,150U�õ¸ 2011

� 10&¹ù�Ç+´Ù� 1,000h1,200U*%Ì[ËÌ�(����õ%ì�¡KËÌ

b�©%�´��Ì��ñ�ª�Ñ ¬eXëÇ|¦R��6�¡�¤�+XYË̤

M�©\�Ç+´�(ËÌÙ�'\I���� 1,500Uh1,800UÏ=XDEì���Ç

+´Ð��2´µ7>8��â�úù(��®ú,¦¨¥>�M(�ºº�n�¥òi

157 v�¦â�Ñ­húg_iô6�����·ÒxÌ��¾- 1990�ô�¦#/,�`8�Z¬Ã6S+�F]v�¦â�Ñ­x�FAT�ì�alÕ�¸V�ò¨�¨��1996�>��émgL�*9�*XH63S¾W 100áÓ6ýÔ�6Pp�D÷�ÃT��l¹���6�¦qF�Ý_ô�à 8Ä£�XFú6õ3�¦Ã��,=6��PpXS��úg_�,PQ�,�`86É�6õ3#/=��?�Sè

�6��­�X

Page 129: Department of Political Science College of Social Sciencentupoli.s3.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/finalP9532… · Department of Political Science College of Social Science

124

�¸>Çð()]�¶·XDEí¹�(�´>�qpÆD#/â��+��«dsl¸

¡B�,¦¦§Ù¬`O6�¦´>DE��Y�Ç+´6´>���2���´Ñb]

�e�C��q�nÉD�#/Ñ��2X¯��+�#/+¸>�( {ûæg�Ç

+´$þ Sªè6�îÎ/Fg67>�9¡��÷�\¾¿�¯´µ7>����

(1¸���:�gNûæ6��x[:l#q�X\�d´â7«^@îSª6�(y

��9Ì: 2020���6�(y�7>:Ñ��6�2X

&'�½�� 1995 �ÍÎÏ6bp� Ïîe�G#/6b¸®e�´Ð ¬¸b´

´µî�e6©^X2002�6,¦¦§ÙDEIY���d­úb´>,a�â7�(e�

°búù@CB¥>�Me@ë,¦¨B�âM´>G26\¾�#_,a´Ñ�%Ñì

-6��èXõ��b,¦ 2012�l66Ç+´´>DE�Y��Y����_�(G�

�PQGÇ¿u�9I���2���RSJK45�B�ÁÑî�X,¦¦§Ùô<¸

Ö<Ù¶�Û�ÒA:úÑ���PQâ7:kÆ¿u�9#/��(�´µ3�¬�î

6´µtô¤È«ÁÑ+üX�¥�DE�+�#/\�6�(ÚNÌ~L��¡Þ��

�9:£¤Âm��ì�¦,±7½�{T�33ù6()�������º3�nÄ

Ç��]�6TD�C�^ì:fg:b��¨©e6#}X

2gwx�Ç+´Ð:S>¦M��bú,÷(e¹`ò2´@¸ÑBÏ�D�¯u

öF¹®�G×Iá�I66º©6ÕöÌ[Ë̳ï�ºª��®ú,´�3(��ØX

õ�gN���b²ª»¼e6��>�()�̹äÚ�lÎÑõ­1@�,¦¦§Ù

Ï�+­�By�(6�ÚÌbSW"½e���Úb­gõ@�Ï"eKÄXÇ+´�c

V¸�[6N¾¬�6v½gx��:ì/=ëì01÷Ì�F6¨©ÌNH>��<>È

�<>$w��½�<EG>�<E�/<*�X��<��÷�<¨Õ9��íç<Ã�

{;F���¬°JÅG.:àHQ�à���^|�%�:T^¥�JX

û��ÇÙ���µrb�î�¦e=b�G¯IBÌè�næç�(b8�e¨b�

6I�e�Ú�kÏ¥��b§6I§eÙ�nvÑýþ�]]��ì¤Fb¿�e67

>X{¡��ªxÑ�¯ÐG()�,��:x%#/´µ"c6Ëa³TA��«��

n«?��JK6uD� ¤X

Page 130: Department of Political Science College of Social Sciencentupoli.s3.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/finalP9532… · Department of Political Science College of Social Science

125

____<<<<t�::[t�::[t�::[t�::[----

0/¸ 20�x��6J���2�â��t�,¦s1¯¦Ó�����Ï=�»

Ð3áñ6î¯X¡úßa3b��PQ¯un­úúÔ�?()�#/Ï=�úÔ��

#¦6J�Ï=e�û�0/b,���(-VPQe³��ÚJÏ=6J�PQ�{ù

GC��}·�­â�þ6ò*X

��������(�±�6`÷A(�±�6`÷A(�±�6`÷A(�±�6`÷A

,¦6b�(�ÚeDxôW�¹bgNéÈeÀstrategic ambiguityÁ�Ú�¡Ìãf

?v()PQ^x@Taiwan Relations Act�TRABX158v()PQ^xC�,¦�(�ÚéÈ

õÌè6�ØXØy®í,�(�Úlñò6�îÙ�Nb()�Úe�b()RSeXP

?b()�ÚeÙ��,¦bí£e@acknowledgeB���()63ù�9­¥Ù²�Ï�

,¦�Ç¡¥¦>��%îÇð�,¦­:�M��Ç�,¦üì�Çð��¶·6��

¥¦Ì��6�û¹^ì(�6´µºº�­����:()±ã��6���RS��

õ(),¦����6�X¸?b()RSeÙ��>?v()PQ^xn�3�Tô

¬¹6b§ l�e�ú­Ì���N¶��û�v()PQ^xúY�()ÏRS���

Ì,¦6ñ#P5@grave concernsB�,¦n H§ è¸R9()ª�â7Ú�´µ"

ciÏ%|§ Xû�Ã)v()PQ^x�,¦�?Ì�§ ()63ùÌ­G�6�¡

ÄéÈè6RS���`ò�®úâ76�(´µ2���i�()��Ú2�i�G,

¦H�gNè01{T´µî��MX

���ª�b�î�¦�ÚeúÌ,¦�#/�()J�6fg�n HÇð()¶·

6��1���,��7�6v-îgL`Dx�159:b-­Îpe�160?:b-#εe

158 1978� 12& 15'�,¦\]Ê÷ÔONb% 1979� 1& 1'õ�,¦���¦n�L^���6���,d�¦23¥7PQn�í��i9ù����,¦�@8���BÏ¥7PQn%OI�íXÙ,¦

¹Ûp�b()�½e6PQ�³7�Ê÷?�� 12& 30'7�î�Ø[�ÂÃèî�AP�6^øÉÃ���Ã��î�Ø[Ïq>�kÆ�()ÛpPQX1979��,r�-�3�­:�`6i=��Å� 3& 28'³ 29'tð�"�Ê÷\]? 4& 10'r�7�v()PQ^x@Taiwan Relations ActB�n~Â%1979� 1& 1'�qX^hd 18¶�¹,¦¦Ø^yv()PQ^xl�#6Ã{��?¶l6bÚNéÈe@masterful ambiguitiesB���,¦\]ºðÚ6iÛ�â�û�1�®´õÃxpÄX159 �$ 89X160 bp� Ïîe_�¿�Ê\]¹3R}��nµE()���\]��4x6����¦&y0��á

Page 131: Department of Political Science College of Social Sciencentupoli.s3.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/finalP9532… · Department of Political Science College of Social Science

126

6$%���161,¦�b�î�¦e63ù�u¡$+JpË�õ�,¦6b�î�¦e

�ÚC�cÞv-îgL`Dx�b-­Îpe�b-#εe¨Øy6"%��¯~î6b(

��ÚeúC�>éÈpDB�X

­"�,¦�#/�b�î�¦e68ò��cÑ­þÚ��+?É�,¦î�Ùò

¬�t6|=�Iâ�t,¦�b�î�¦�Úeä���àá¶*�ë 2002� 2&�d

�tv�î�¦¨©�()¶·xUVS_�¿�Ê\](tG�,¦{îb�î�¦�

ÚeÑ 20��9���iÎp�����í¹����b¥7��eÇð���õ�#

/6b�î�¦¨©e�b]�eX,�úÎp()�ÄÑv�6�^�b�î�¦eä�

8X162

¿��,¦�(�RSgN6ñò`ß�(�?����î�î7½�Ûp���qX

�,¦õ|��#/7½Qû¯¹©õÏì²���êRS6()>j�¿sy�()7

½Qf?I�¶<6 Å���,`¦Ó³BÑ�#/Ú¤q6�WgNñòè¨Xõ�

�PLè6û.(�?N,¦�ãä��Ññ#6RS��¡Þ��F¹úgm@_

¾Wn�6:ì�ÑÂ^¤Ñ0òÛp�������6±���Û�¯¦Ó�X

cccc������´µ>1�¦§RS6�qA��´µ>1�¦§RS6�qA��´µ>1�¦§RS6�qA��´µ>1�¦§RS6�qA

{,¦�(���6�î7½õ|�Ì{T�Ä���´µ�6b�q�Úe���ª

��(´B�,'Rr���¸>2��gN®ú��±ã��Ù�bg�Ȩ̈k�]e

¨�163�aÆ#/6,a�n�´µÝ i�3b��b�Ç+´´>�2����ª©

�� 1995 � 8 &r�~Òbãä¡ÞLF:}e@APECBi�1�794¯[?p79�O,X4x��¿�ÊJ�raN,¦­Îpb�î�¦e�b���(e�­Îpb()�3e�­Îpb()r��¦Ó

¹`�6¦ö�eXõ_ 1998� 7& 1'�¿�Êá¶#/i�X�u����,¦\]¡¢`*Ô�¯b6-­e@(N-­ÎpB�ÚX161 � 1999� 7& 21'��ÍÎÏ6b�¦=e�t_�¿�Ê\] �b-îεe6Ñ^��ÅÌbí£�î�¦e�b<g����e�b��Çð��eX162 2000� 5& 24'�,¦�(l:<µ`�³´���|�#ë@Shorenstein forumBt�Nb�����6�}�î���,¦­:9�^ì��eX163 ,¦6Ȩ̈k�]�ú{ÌCÌ[ËÌ@Anti-Ballistic MissileB�]��¹bS¦Ȩ̈ke@Nation Missile Defense, NMDB�]�bg�Ȩ̈ke@Theater Missile Defense, TMDB�]XNMDÌ1�§ ,¦��6RSyTMD 6`ò\6©Ì§ ,¦��¥6m´��N¦�Ý<ñò¨�¯Ä1`ò{Ì�?©%�3,000`��äg�Ì[ËÌ@Theater Ballistic MissileB6ñòXTMDÆk�Ä66´µ���>���[6�K�]�³�Ý 6ËÌ ¯¬�ÃX��K�]��`òG1,¦6´µgNg¯ ½@Militarly Strategic Tactical Relay, MILSTARB¬�Ã6 ½�K¡È�]�³e) ½�K¬g«¤¬�Ã6i<ص

Page 132: Department of Political Science College of Social Sciencentupoli.s3.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/finalP9532… · Department of Political Science College of Social Science

127

�´µ7845�ü�,��´µPQ6øaX

,¦�ª6ÚNëäN@�B��(´B�ªN,¦ H()§ è¸R��Ûp��

´>�qX¿É¸ 20��,¦�(6ñ#´B½½Ì�#/�(¸>"c¥Ç���â7

÷���´>¾ñ�qÏöXë 1992� 9& 2'�,¦ÔOB( Fh16gAQûÇ+´�

­u%@<H3 SUh27³MIGh31�gA�1997�()<HÈÉCªËÌ©Ì�b(�

ËÌTAeÏ()X@cB,'Rr��N,�'�¦¶<�x(Ñ�NPQ��úg<¶�

,'�NÎò��ãä��6��¥�IÁѶ�ãÕ��d°�>6^&X$Ùúg

E9m�9,�'ÐpÆÉ�#/�ãä��6�Õ���÷ÅÌ(���6��®¤X

¸�,�'¹û�¦ö6½��b,'Rr��e�>"��ê6r�'��µ8¹lÖ�

Û�ãä�êÏ���RSX$Ùb,'Rr��e�tª�Ì,�'Ï=6²��8&l

}��^ø¶£�¤«�³(�}·�9�v�Vµ�^x���(�6R���BÑX

�6()X164? 2005��,�'�¦¥7¦§�©ÃQ�®�,¦¦&yÒ��¦§Ù¶

ð�]�'�¥Ú�6KÊ�§ ä¶Ã#K]Ĩö?�ÉÊÕî,'RS¦m:}n

�tgLøG�£����bü�(�½�eâMd�gN\¾�½¾��!"���

�Çð¶·X165�¹,¦���,¦³7�x�(�RS��JuôwM,¦�N¦6´

µRÍÏ���()õ|�âs¹�ÄRS§ 6��X

@-B¸>2��gN®úN1996� 3&�#/��()ÕîJur�¸\]±A�

¬��(6´µ¸>­®6ì��?�@î3Ì[ËÌ�©X,¦©? 3 & 8 'ÔO�3

�]Xõ�~�6 TMD¸R�]�®�/f�@land-basedBȨ̈k�]��f�@sea-basedBȨ̈k�]�³��Ȩ̈k@passive defenseB�]X164v�Vµ�^x®�3'��:¸>2�iF�C�6v¸>2�µ�^x�vRSrs:}3{^µ8hx

��ì% ���³7>6v% �^µ8hx¨ 3�^øXÃ)b�Vµ�^e¬C�6_�Î3�����q'�% ��uIá¦öÂ^�òÑq��x%�¥6"c�¯¬Òí6�8(¹'�RSgN6

µr��~Xõ% 1999�'�¦:�"b�Vµ�^eéÈ�()�µâMb�Vѵe6`aÏ_�2005� 2& 19'?��Õî6,'RS¦mPQ:�,�'d��tøG�r�()�µs¹�¦RS6d�gN\¾X165 1997� 9& 23'�,�'�¦¥¶�¦§J¶��¢�¡"d/b,'Rr§ LFY÷��e6µ8*��¯�l6�p�6Ìb�V��e6cÞ`aÌ�®í()�µXõ� 2005� 2&�t6,�'bc�cel}ò���úJu ³(�¶·�(ÌÑ()�µ6���Ì,�'Rr6P�µ�ÏØ��s¹

��#/ÏbC�Ò¦Ó^e6&�X¬¹,�'bc�celm�Qv3? 1960�,'Rr¶�µ¿Ïö�S�]¹bRS¦m:}eX>'�¥Ú�§ ¶Ã��áQ�³,¦m'#G�,´ä�\�[;Ã6n

A:�X�"½6:���Õoãä���tøa½��(ùbc�ce6/=`·X

Page 133: Department of Political Science College of Social Sciencentupoli.s3.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/finalP9532… · Department of Political Science College of Social Science

128

��¯g°�?()±��êXY�n? 3& 11'%Õ�)��²�³��¯g°��½

()�¸�ê��#�6¸>��gN®ú6F1�ÕÖ(�����X@nB±ã��Ù

�bg�Ȩ̈k�]eN1998 � 8 &�,¦ �s��'��á��()¨¦��d�

G�bg�Ȩ̈k�]e6`a��F¹#/,´�»-�ê²>]�6�q45X@qB

,¦��d´µ78N�,¦��dÔOóDb23è6gN��PQeÏ_�I�*2

®�b23�JÂ~e�bÃQ�<Jáe�b23��´µRS£mA�e¨�´µ78Ú

P6B�LFµfX¯F1¹Nð>�´PQ6�2�l�A;633�GÇ+´67>

�� !G¤��G±IjX

----����(�ºº6اA(�ºº6اA(�ºº6اA(�ºº6اA

bا¥7e@preventive diplomacyBù¸ 20 ��,¦� <��TAi6`ò�

k�õ¯�bK�2345eø4PgX¬¹6bا¥7e�Ìð>IV�áV@´µB

786÷�RÍ��ó��<Ç�23K^�ÕÖIj�³ó�ºº6â7è��õ[:

���m@:�Ü��7���l}6\6Xle�¯>?Ìú�´µ©ª�6uö¡*

¬®wõx�õ_���ô�¥7ÃF1ÚP>?�F^�nì¤����¥7�ª6q

��1�ا��ºº6â7X|µâ���� 1999 �6b�¦=e³ 2002 �6b�V

�¦=e6h.�0/,¦Ìëì01bا¥7ex0ùg|å�6â7èX

1999� 7& 9'�ÍÎÏò�3b�¦=e�,¦���(l: ¶a¢£? 7& 13

'¤�ÍÎÏ��ªØ�b�¦=eÌ�¡9�¶^³¿®�Ú�²q¦&3áuñ,

,¦6b�î�¦�Úe³ñÖ�����n%��« :()l­Ô�6b6-­eX7

& 18 '�¿�ÊJÝ!"Â~D�O,raNb,¦6��î�¦�Ú�­®e�20 '�

¦&yXOÒ÷ÔO�Å�Q�½���(��îª�ªC��3ÇX166õ_@21'B�

¿�Ê\]�tb-îεe��%\]�ó�®�¦§Ù¶�¦&3�|�¨��Å�­

�î�Ô�,¦ïg(�|Ý������Çð6�¢3ù�=²ï���6¸>2�ú

�Ѭ[�X>?,��Mí¹�uµÝQ>()`�fõ�Ü� 9 &�´�gL¦\&

PQ:/=��,¦M:hi�,¦ôt»`�6�|C��¡Ì 1993�()���Mg

166 >¦R:ãäµ&¡ `^ͱë@Kenneth LieberthalB�ãäÖy/�[@Stanley RothB.���,¦�(l:`�³´�@William CohenB.(�C�l�X

Page 134: Department of Political Science College of Social Sciencentupoli.s3.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/finalP9532… · Department of Political Science College of Social Science

129

L¦î��x�,¦X�u­1b«]eõ1bC�ext[3ùX¯�b�¦=eµ*

�¬­()���qnR}��Ï�"¹GÇX

2002� 8& 3'6b�V�¦=eè�_�,¦6bا¥7eF¹BÑ 3î÷¯N

X��FÌ�i��#/�()��ÖñA"�9�6HIXp� á¶_�¿�Ê��

�6b7½e�Ú�G()Ì��õ��õb�¦=e6CÌXõlOï��e<D()

â�6���6õ��6>�¯¹b��ÚNeÏ01XûÏ��u6bا¥7eF¹

Ç�FËT3"�6Ö�XXc�¯�k¹´µ��n1�,¦�í:�?#/�üBb´

µ®úeÌ­Û6�°¥¦��×Û6b��raeÓ78��+�X�()¤Ù���

r()6RS­�"c¥�°ò�r¯����­`�fÍ�ú{Ìb­�SU~e��7

�r½�­���XX-���'³:����6ª��¬Ñ6ñ��øû��`*6ù

L�ë�)â*[r�6È��úrû3��b%�pÌe6÷=X

õ�,¦¬Ñ��(���6bا¥7eF¹��lñò6{Ìb­Îp(�e6

Ô�Xi� 1972�²0�á¶#/i(��b­Îp()�3eX¸ 1995�bp� Ïîe

_�¿�ʹ��(�½��ö? 8 &4x�O,�rab­Îp(�eX1998 � 7 &�

¿�Ê?á¶#/i����`*Ô�b­Îp(�eX2002 ��Ñ��Ç�b�e6â

D_�¦§Ù¸Ù¶.ÑÛÍÂÆ 3 ut[,¦b­Îp(�e63ù�10 & 25 'I>

lOïD�O, ³b,¦­Îp()�3e��¹,¦$x�b­Îp(�e}·�l�

©^�l`*úl·ñ6��X�Ùb­�e@­Îp(�Bú�b­¸e@��Çð(�

¶·BÚ-ÚÃ��Ã,¦�(��Ú��¶¨î6bU~e�ú̯bا¥7e6��

lñò6¨©XõÇÙ6��m�=xÍ��ÕÖ(�½����ª�¸ 20�x,¦6bØ

§¥7eF¹Î¸ÑÌÃÄ6X

nnnn��������1�6 HA����1�6 HA����1�6 HA����1�6 HA

,¦ñÖ���î���j�`a(���¶·��ÇðÌ,¦�(��Ú6εX

û���B�F¹��,¦ ����îbXc�[e���bK�2345e�b�%l}e

¨2}�9,¦káu ³b­F��e@mediatorB63ù�úfu^b Hó�Ae

@facilitatorB�bÖÔAe@animatorBX

Page 135: Department of Political Science College of Social Sciencentupoli.s3.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/finalP9532… · Department of Political Science College of Social Science

130

õ�v()PQ^x�úâ�Í�,¦�()¶·�%|<à6î¯�Å{ÌNb()

¶·�>��%îÇð�,¦­:�^ì(�ÚP¶·6Çð��j�»Ð�l�A�eX

¡î�Úúñí�t�,b�e-î`D�X¡�­JØ�Ú�$¡'^\]­³��ñ

,�,¦�()¶·6Çð­Ø33ùXÜ>�bÏÉ������ª�,¦6î¯â

¯®ö¹b����1�6 HAeX

õ�,¦(�¬»Ð6î¯Ï¥��,���(-VPQ��|µÉ���Ï=6J

�³èÅÏØ�¥Ù()û.�â�H:ëäÏ�+X

�#/�,¦PQ�ª�h�ÔÑe�6�m;èÏ���.ë�����²¶·�

¡¢�SR²>��Ï7C�´µ¹Ñi�@í,¦�(³#/�X-¾W¦Ó6´BB

¨y9Ì�,¦XàY\]�^_�ÅÆ,`±6*]�f�{1b7½e6���O#

/y?���¦�SxSá6¦ö}·�ÑLF6÷=�¥ò�.ëN1�®´��êR

S�C�g|¨�GH�APQ\�ÞtÚ�rªÏã�Xf?,��\����}·�

ê�n«B�6ºº���I�ú�f����uPQ�.ë,¦$ÑÙ���u�#/

©õ�,¦6fg�9��{1b��©õe6¦è=b�167×�¯tjkn­�fg,

¦ì²��¹\¾X��� ���,¦¤vÑæçì��¿®#/ÏC��õÌ�bS

ªè7½e���¿¿Ö¯Ø®y�lOï`�_<Ú��XàYúf��¦öùL{T

9#/ª�6º^XÜ�«�¥��6�¹ä�¸<,��IV�Ê6PQâôpÆØ<X

���PQ��Y������@íÍÎÏ�\]³,�±@�i<Bl#6 Å�

?��PQ6¿uX��7�6 15�l}�1�d�@í ECFAB�Øy/³¢d�ÉÁz

��÷0��0������RS��^JÖ�Z�LF��°�d�¨Xn��PQw

x�2¬Ô�6ÒÓ���ªx%¦Ø���ª©x%��X�¦Ø,ë6�F³TUÏ

ä���6J�°ydô��bv(e6¾Ï��õúâ�2Xõ���6î�xÍ�`

²}·6[õwð�í�6C����ÐGH��Ï=Ô�Ú6­��èX

167 2003�>��d�»±�¸�¶�¥§ ��b��©õe�2gN6�îf�>?Nb©õe�b��e�¯���Ì���õ©õÓÌ�r6\6X¥0{T�¶[E��Ìòã���26[E�­"cÅ��c

ÌòÑ7>r %=¦Ó­�]�X�¦6©õ9¥Ù¾x6ÌA¬�õ­Ì"cyÌÛptÜ�õ­Ì¿

®tÜyÌq��õ­Ì/0X

Page 136: Department of Political Science College of Social Sciencentupoli.s3.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/finalP9532… · Department of Political Science College of Social Science

131

�()�,¦PQÙ���AÏ=DxÔÑø46���¡¢�´µ�£¤�Ý P

Q�9Ú�?,��³��PQ�¸<(�,Ï=6b,Ð�Oµ*e³,¦�'³#/

6C�ä��?()Ѭ%���û��PQ¿u�,¦�(�Ïp�>©â+ýõ|�

°âs¹Ì(,PQ6�¤X

\m�b�h� Î%�Î-­d�í�9ÐâN¹�Å�%�#l��%��t"

#� i�-V½�óÑ�~6â7èXû���,��tjkPQÞtrªÜ¹ä��

()õ|�lÎ6º^Ì­â²Â^ì���wx�pÆ����PQ6�i�¤fç>

�,PQX

Page 137: Department of Political Science College of Social Sciencentupoli.s3.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/finalP9532… · Department of Political Science College of Social Science

132

2>2>2>2>6666--------��é}�a��é}�a��é}�a��é}�a----

;;;;<<<<����HHHH�TU�VW�TU�VW�TU�VW�TU�VWJJJJ¬KUB��� ��¬KUB��� ��¬KUB��� ��¬KUB��� ��----

�ª¡/="�lebK�2345e6>?Ì�´µ©ª�6uö¡*¬®wH

x6����ô�¥7Ã?ÌF1ÚP>?�F^�nì¤���¥7q���§ù��

ºº6ÁDXÜbK�2345e®�3���6��l}�b´µJKA�e¨�îÙ

��õ�=³bK�2345e�1?(���Ï}·i�Ðí¯l#sâ�?b`²¶

·eNb�¦ö�:×Ã��Ì��î��u�����î¦Ó�6µueXû��b�î�¦e

c8wG�HÇ���ØÙ����Úè%��³,¦��Ï()¨Ü¹ä��A�Mé

pq�É6(^X�£¤Ù�����É��9Ì�$Ùt(�¶·�úgi<±��

ú �»6i÷ßà­��nbK�2345e�bÕÖººe�b23K�e�bì¤��e

6jkè>?�F^Ð�ѯrs���â������JK62; H�î's�DX

¯B�6F¹â�ÌN

XXXX����jkjkjkjkbbbbÕÖººÕÖººÕÖººÕÖººeeee@@@@Conflict AvoidanceBNBNBNBN

JÝÌ���^ì45ó�:��ÑÖ?����JK��?�`Þ�"¸úâ�Ì

��ª6ó�:�6î�XëY��r�@î6b¥7!"e�Ú�wxÇ+´6¸Ñ�

Ù�­?BÑì-6��è�OÎ(��ª6Ì[ËÌ�]¨X

¯uÌO\�6zÇ�u���r�6úî�ë4¯[6b��6-�e�Y���

�_ñ#b[cd�e�{Ìr�6�DX

°Ñ�½¾èj©6²¼nrpù�ÏC��[����:6�<�­�<:_�Â

~¨�Hñò�&'% 1995 �bp� Ïîe_�:lm�ù�1999 �b�¦=e_�

:r��³gh�±¸ 2008� 5&_ÓjkC��[�{ÌÁª6h.�Ì�HTU6Ü

¹�­9«Ö?I�JK�°Ñ÷�ºº6â7X��jk�|µüò&u�@îÕÖº

º��¤6�Ú@í��è6|=B(â��¹�Mä�jk6JKA�ã�fgX

XcjkXcjkXcjkXcjkbbbb23K�23K�23K�23K�eeee@@@@Confidence-buildingBNBNBNBN

�jk6\6�@îF^]���jk­���\¾�­úÌ�ÕÖº�6ºº�

Page 138: Department of Political Science College of Social Sciencentupoli.s3.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/finalP9532… · Department of Political Science College of Social Science

133

TA�õò��«2;��6K^�K��ܯ�2Ú�÷jXJÝ��*2'slm}

·�â�¬ÑÚP45�l}�8�Ý_ù��ëb´µJKA�e���l}¨���´

µ�¡Þ¨è©ª6�ju�¨X¯u��@�0òI#6Ø�¥Ù��Îp�å

èJ��®íX-¦�¦ö�¨Ï¶·�¼r³Î3¨X

û��{(��ªõ|���6 CBMs���l}678¨�°�?�`ÞØX=³

� �0{�îtÆ��0/�+�ì¹ÑaX�b³�(���% 90�ôõ�/Æ�

t#÷2;b´µJKA�e6�ø�9¸¹ù���ØÙÐÙúú�û�bè%ÚJ

+�e�büýþ�)�­��äxe6��XC÷ì��Ï̯��,¦6û.iPLX

,¦Ì­Ì�6AÃ���b´µJKA�eÌFïg()�#/Ï=��$U6b´µ

JKA�eÌt�|µÍ:,¦���|�ÌÈ����b´µJKA�e�9,¦�r6

3ùÌ�$Ì¡�()()i#�Ì¥¦s16X

�:,¦6û.��£í¹,¦6ãägNO½�l<(6ÌÛp��?u��6Ü

��ïg���õ­»�ïg()­ò(��9Ìú­ïg�#/]��Îp��¡Þ�

2�9Ì´µRS�Ã�,¦�¡Ul�L,¦6gN�X¬��,¦­ïg��b´

µJKA�eãHä²XaêY��� 2008�AÕ�ö¡t���A_ò23����J

K�78��l}�23b´µJKA�e�9{æ�_�Cõt�iA°­Ã­@Â^_

¤ÙB�ÚP}·SÙúïäxXÌ�ß_Ñ,¦û%�6­>ÌuÍx�X168

X-jkX-jkX-jkX-jkbbbbì¤ì¤ì¤ì¤��������eeee@@@@Strengthening the PeaceBNBNBNBN

�ô6�÷7>�sKÌ���%�lñò6�1X��lm��÷���i@i*

2@ÎXZ¦¡ ×�¶Õ ö �Nb3Iì�T:G�¸~dÇ��RÐ�¬°¸ªë

Å.¸!ì¯á:� ��¸QR�?�É�JX�jlm0ûi�f�9lmúÑ�Kd

��XJÝ�òÑ%�y¯u�Ûp¡î%�pÆÔ�yX-�òÑl�X¯\6�,#

168 2009 � 4& 22'�YZ[?\]��,¦�ÒA;b¦ögNGC��e@CSISBsÈÂ~��ÑP()PQ^G/:6�?�����H,¦��kÆ�î()PQ^X�°Ñ���23b´µJKA�e\

�¹i°i�()ïg�#/#Ý <¡Þ}·XYZ[nt��,¦kÆ���(´B��,(PQ�H

ñòX5& 9'YZ[�²�6�\vgLiDx!ái?G��b´µJKA�et�Nb¡î}·äs���³()�,¦PQ�|µ`ò6´ÑÌx%?,¦�û�|µ�Hõ·eXYZ[ÂÆ6����8��´

µJKA�6/=wiÓ�=�XiGÇ���YZ[6t�â�Í��\�,¦°Áѹ��l��b´

µJKA�e*CDX

Page 139: Department of Political Science College of Social Sciencentupoli.s3.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/finalP9532… · Department of Political Science College of Social Science

134

n ¤)Ô6LF��nþâ7v×­7¬p6æç�2X

====<<<<����HHHHXYZ[LXYZ[LXYZ[LXYZ[LJJJJ��������������������������������----

b~L<=e�6b6Ä7`8e`òÌ���6��~����6~LXõb,}e

@spill-over effectB�bÄ7ghe�b��Z6()e¹¯ï�>?Xb,}eÌÄ7L

F¬°�6m��9¯Ñâ7ÉÑ��­�6�D�2�û���Z�û�ÙòØ6ð

Ú�¯F�Ú�êÙò°�()Xb,}etÆÌ�î%ð"%�õb­Ì�î%���e

6"%�üÑèr�A�"%�<H�i�Ó:f�pÆ���G¯­³���Xb6Ä

7`8e��î`ò>?Ìb���ôe���@Ernst HaasBí¹NH2²¡Ã:7 ì�

�ðÙ��)FêëÔ#:�ê78¯¸¡Ã:�eJ}�Õ±��:¸�»ì� G�

:�Õ!�Z)�JÅ-

¡KÉ����6$��?NX��ᩪ6Ä7LFÑ�?I�PQ6�2XXc�

��ë�üÌÃ�bLFe�n­yd°�b,}e6%�q��°Ì0òÑú�6���

>ÓâîXX-���Z�Ã���»Ðqñòî¯�ë�Zf��rª6�D�½

¾�nf�`���Çð¶·�©b,}eÜ:D,a6�D�2y9Ìë�ZµúÌ

qñ?ÄÇ�¡6��Å$~L©Ñâ7b}&e�Ìb��eXXn���^ì ¯Ä

7è6LF�:}�:���ë�òì��s1ÍÎÌ­5uö6XXq���J�i�

�fA|}èÜ��I�l0ò <6µ&���¹fgxÝb ¬d��e�nGH¨

�6Ä7LFC���¤XX��������d;6�m;ØÙ���Çð�õ­7

����³��6A;èLFX

ðq�bb6Ä7`8e6É�³���6$���£·�>�0/����JKu

D6�DX���âÝ�¡Þ©uLFC��2�©u6��LF�ëN%>¢d�¨¡

Þ©u6l��?C«23��b´µJKA�e�b��l�e¨X9b6Ä7`8e¤

í¹bÄ7}�en­:±²ÖÃb��}�e�¯lñò6Ìb��6��eX

�()r�b¾W �#:e@WHAB}·��#/�?()r�b¾W �#:e

µ�68«�b���e¨Ãt�Nb�?()r�¦ö���6¶·��­×Ã��î

�¦�³����(�6� ä�â�!"��&ulmF�L�L<6RÍeX()r�

Page 140: Department of Political Science College of Social Sciencentupoli.s3.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/finalP9532… · Department of Political Science College of Social Science

135

b¾W �#:e6<g�û��åè6J�°�A:�¡�ôt��PQ�6�2�I

Ñ���JK6ª«X¡(Ìb6Ä7`8e¬ì�b��e6`�î¯ð�3Ì�óD

~L6PLX

%Y\]�^�x�áu´bb�E¥7e�Ú� ��b[cd�efg���#

/�Ç!"�ÕÖºd³ÚJÜb¡£��&u�Ìè6��r�¦ö���õdvI

�� ()¥7���î�EXnïgð>¡¢½x�£¤786SªrH¤�º»��

¼½X����b��¡ÞLF_;l}eC`��¡ÞLFµ��opb�()¹`�

��,Ñ�e6¨©��b�¨�}¾�J�e� ä�î�¡{Ì���b�j��e

THLF6õ�@���j��Ï��:�t 5h3B�B�ttëäN

#-��b¡ÞLF_;l}e7�6�í�SR¤6É��>?��±²-�âG

±¡^_pO6Ô1�ó�0iÃ���#/¦¡6(mâó� 0Ã��[ú½Ñi=

6qX�Ö���°��é@Ð���±�éB�� ���7|>#ÑÎ X()�

ªÎ3ïgð>b#-�ejk��è�¨6lm¨A�G�¿u��PQ7Ñrª6Ö

¥�Iïg!"��-�³¡¢PQrH¤��õ�ìI�¡¢LF��<[:`��

�Q��Õ³Z�¨Sª6rH½xX?A���b¡ÞLF_;l}e@ECFABѯP

L�8�¯���()%>¤�SR¤6�ÚmL��#/78 ECFA 7ì¤�rs(

)�#/6�ù�úÑÖ?()SR�ù67|#�XECFA ³Xcub��:e_��

±²b-�e��³¯ß_¬ôt6u��8��Ï=6m¢��ùó�6AÒXª��

ê~L­³ ¤�()¥¦Iæç�Ý���b�j��e6¡ÞªD�ì¤��6J�

�JKX

��� 2001�O� 2002�eÝ_�Mb¾W¢d�e@WTOB�­ú�è%6¡Þ

9:�2°� ­()�õ%ú¹��PQ6��«�2n¾x6¨AX>?��PQ6

÷�è���Ï=6ñ#µ*�â7�����PQ°�()���Ï=6LF�¾Ñ�

��8X��Ý_�MWTO�«=�#/°Ì�()xÑ��Ì�*}���¡ÞS½6

ñ#µ*X�M¾¢�����¾xàá6¶·����0òRs�µ8ÚP^ø^C�

�~ÚP�Ú¶.�ú0òÚJlm/=�³ WTO 6¶·�å¯�Ïõx6ÌÖî�r

Page 141: Department of Political Science College of Social Sciencentupoli.s3.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/finalP9532… · Department of Political Science College of Social Science

136

U�a×��K¨6�ý&�6¢d¦¡¶·X¡Kî�µP¦,¡Þ6ت�^ì£m

+üÑ,=�îõÍÎî��3^A;6r���j�EFXû���M¾¢���jk

��«�Ì�î6¨A�õ¡úÌ6Ä7`8¬÷Åì�6b,}eq�X

{~L<=�66Ä7`8xÍ����{b��ètexz{`²|}�dvI��

ÕÖLM¼½X���M WTO ³ ECFA 678�ÖG���¡Þ©ª�ÑI��«6�

2���¡¢ÃÔ�¤IÁø4X�M WTO ³()r�b¾W �#:e���jk�

���jÌ�î66¨A�¯�÷Åì�b��e{�6`�î¯X��JK6uD��

2�àáiÛú0�1¦ö�¨ùLxÖï\6Ï[ÃX

9�<=�õ|�b6Ä7`8e�� 9��̦Ó�¦Ó6PQ�Òíq�î`²

¦Ó=â�ðq78�å¯Ì¡Þ78x[:���6~LXÜ�<=����â�ðq

¡Þ©ª�678xb,}e:¯F©ª�9u&�ÐÔÑ+J6¶·�ë`²³��¶

·�¡�Ì�<=¬w�6X�u&�õ|�SR¤iô6xS�¾W¡ÞÉD�ê~L

³SR~L6�D��XÚÜ?¾W¡Þ6~L���­7%¥?�Á�Ï��å¯Ì�

b��¡ÞLF_;l}e6}·��û¹��6°�Ì�?��äM6�é�����

J�Xë�¡Þ�7~L�°�!'q��¡{Ì��6�fXå¯�?#/õ|��

�Ú���§�¹\¾��¦ö=úâ()�¦Ó�8r�¦ö�y�´µ��Ðw�

�+=¸>�(y�¡Þ��©{îb8�e�ÚX¡GH()�ÔÑ����2;JK

­�X��$Ù*2²¼�78�C��9n­��*$3Sªè6����j�lmX

(G��*2Sªè6���lm�¡ú­��q�����¥7�´µ¨}·�â�ë

¡Þ�9:³£¤78}·�ß�<�B�m�XIì¹()ØÙów<HÉ~6d��

^ìºÙ²ª6«Ó��:×ÃØÙÉK�±6ºº�c�9:­RX¡K�¥¦�jk�

%�C«ÉÃ�9�56õ��¥¦Ý�bLFe�2;I�6��JK*2X

Ãb6Ä7`8e6É��Ä1�uD����JK���ì�NuD"%�0ò�

��ô@���ZB6���Ó:��b,}eq�Xû��YZ[\]�b�î�

¦eF¹��fà�169���I�6JK�Ù_Ñ����j�lmX9���j�lm

169 Ã(#���aã�Öi6�8�b�î�¦e�®� 3 î�cNX��b�î�¦e�Y 1912�Ã3�

Page 142: Department of Political Science College of Social Sciencentupoli.s3.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/finalP9532… · Department of Political Science College of Social Science

137

"%���Ì�¨@I�{?�¨���^ì��­���j�¥��"c��²�¯`

aB�*+@­Ø3m=�^ì}·]â�B6X#/�4¯[6b��6-�e:��

�6b�n�e¯¹��ü6��"%��b�n�e����IÌ�í����6tÜ�

³�¦#/�()���î�¦6=b��Xl_�Ø+��7Û23JK�Éfà���

ntt¯l#6u��¤Ç���C«�¡Þ�Ä7LF,}¸��©ª�óÌ���,

wx�+ÏîX

0000 5µµµµ3 åÓåÓåÓåÓ<<<<�Ó� �Ó� �Ó� �Ó� ����T�T�T�T�

åÓ� åÓ� åÓ� åÓ� �Ó� �Ó� �Ó� �Ó�

� ¿R�·� ����� � _9� þN�·9�X� ¯ç9¿R�m� @ÀM£�E

� {Óß� ¯çÉÊ� r<�<{Mð� ��9"��r� ��9��� ��ê� !P9��

����#Reginald J. Harrison, Europe in Question: Theory of Regional International Integration(London: George Allen & Unwin,1974), p.197

____<<<<����HHHH�UB[L�UB[L�UB[L�UB[LJJJJ^�������^�������^�������^�������----

b9:2;`8eëAÃ÷@Alexander WendtB?¯qFv¦ö��69:<=x�

Sª´b3�6<=�> C�`86<è`8��`86C'`8X�G��ÑGb2

;`8e6òzN��¦ÓÌ��6`òî¹A�«��Ü�̦Ó×Ã6yc�¦ö�

�6m;��lñò6ÌbdÑ£�e�(É?6�K�ÌÚJ`�è6�õ��Ø>16

�Ky-�9:PQ;2bí���e�õutí���mL6ÚF`òÑ 3ÄN�"

`²u�6Юy�"���6LFy�"¦öm>®b�=6í�e¹bõ�6í�eX

b2;`8eí¹�lÎ6��­Ìx%�²ä6ì��@�ú­Ì£%�³Ã�

�¤õx69:¨�C`�õÌx%è`�ÚJÏ=6bJKe�bõ�í�e�ë�¡Ä

bJKe�bõ�í�e7Û�Ã�{:�è¦Ï=×{�Ä� 6d����°��­

6��,¦�¯`²³?~î�¦�9\�Ï�²�©ú³?(�·�Z�YXXc�% 1949�õ�¦ ?wi�ÒÏÜ��­7¿s>�î��u����µ��6µuXX-����d�LF23%>,`]

Ä6�¦X

Page 143: Department of Political Science College of Social Sciencentupoli.s3.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/finalP9532… · Department of Political Science College of Social Science

138

�g|�kÇð��|Ý6d��bRSd��eú{23õxXû��Ã÷ÑNHW�ì

Nì�]:Ó#��U��¸�`��b�m辸Ò�°B�¼å×�ª¸���Ä

Å|}{�ñò %>J��Ç |%�����John Locke���:�k�Immanuel Kant�

��:�ÏJÅ«���¯���Å6Y���LM��¼½Ãû�¡ú{IÇt�b2;

`8e�1?GC��}·6��¬�X

Ü�£÷Öi6´ò�â��t�b9:2;`8eí¹bBÑd1É?6õ�í�e

â��¦Ó=23b��K^e�|µ(��É�5M�0/ ¤��JKÏ[X

bí�eQ¡¢6W��Yû9:î¹�6%|��è�îè�Ì9:î¹��Å?

¯�9:î¹�6C�èXbí�eW���õ¡¢��6�í:`÷î¹�6î¹X

î¹kâ�¿®m;���¬�bí�e¶·Ì��PQ��î¸Pñò6>?XI�Ù

UW�%¡Ì��6:���GH��F¹:�x�í%=�xC�%=6���:

�����í�%¡��A6:���k�q|µ��6W�õ�ì�ë�õèà1

Ì�î#¶·�û�0òº�p®�GI�ÑI#6d��üÇ:�����ìK^��

LF���%¡�Ü�%¡��î66¡¢����W�X9Ì���Ï=°ªS�î

¶·�I�6:�£?$��£?¡Ä¡¢���5�A�m;úÌJÚ;26X()�

ªí¹%=Ìb��,¦e�ôtq®�#/�¥�ò�()�Ø6S�¦X#/�ªúí

¹%=ôtq#/�()�Ø6S�¦X_x()Ñb��,¦�()e�b�()6��

,¦e6Ñ^�Ì�î�#/�¨6��u��(��>IÌÑ()�#/Á�$PQ�

()Ì�î`²�36¦ÓX¡Ä¡¢6%|í��¥Ùí�6 �ÌI���6PL¬

�X

õ��ª()6á�,�m�xÍ�90�ô�x���,¦6¦Óí��u�t3p

®X{��í�õ|�#�¦í�ÞtäóÁ��� 1990 �ô6 20}S��äó¸ 2008

�6 12}S����,¦�()í�©Þt���ö6Á��� 1994 �6 48.3}��

: 2008�6 63.5}�()¦í�úÞtöÁ��1994�ú 11.1}�2008�[: 23.1}�

�#�¦í�Á�Þt�Ü�¶6GÇ�ÛX�¡¢í��ª��¦�í��UÞtäó

Á��� 1992�6 26.2}äó¸ 2007�6 15.4}��¦�úÌ()�6¡¢í�©ÌÛ

Page 144: Department of Political Science College of Social Sciencentupoli.s3.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/finalP9532… · Department of Political Science College of Social Science

139

p���()�í�©ÞtöÁ��� 1992�6 17.3}��: 2007�6 63}X()�

,6��í��¡¢í�Ñ3GÇ6¿®�9`ò̦Óí�ÁÚ�ç6ܶ�ÛptÜ

6�=E~ÐÙÌ`ò6>1X�¡U6É�xÍ�()6¦Óí�Þtp®�9`�6

í�nÁÑ#_�6®¤X­"��Á�xÍ�(),��uÞt�#�¦@x@þ6Á

���#/õ|�{Ì�b�î�¦e@x@þ����­³ì�b�î�¦¨©e6�

i�µu����PQ�26¼½ú{ô¡îbme¬@Û�Å{ÌN()�,í�°�

p®�9#/�½6í�nÁÑp®�¡Äí£� 6ؽ×Ã��PQ«^#_¿u6

¼½X

,��Ñd�6¼|�£¤���¨!�³�<fg6���,��¡{Ì�îÉ?

6õL��Ì�î�<d���£¤d���Ìí�6°�X���?��,��­Ì¶

·�9t�()ØÙÑK�rm>ì�()�6,�è�ë�1b2;`8e6É�� 

�3b(),�e�í¹2;�6b(),�eÌ�Ä��,��®í¬Ñ�()�f�¹

()�6��n%ò�Åb��,�e�b£¤,�e�í¹ì�b()�#/�£�Äe

Ì�¨a,6#­Ü¨�� G±���,�6í��põì�b(),�eXÜ��#/

�()���ì���,�6í�X�i����,�6í�úÑÖ?ÜÇ()6���

Ò��³�¤()��62;Xí�0ò;2�;26�^Ï�{Ì�ìC�X¬���

ì��678���#-6d��å¯Ìd�É?�ÑÖ?JK6 ¤X

()¦Óí�6�"�6âDb#�¦e:t�6âDb()`�èe�-á6û.×

Ã3í�6p®X)Ù¡Kû.×Ã3p®��U6m;¿®ú7Ûp®\�(),-6

í��ë�()`���Ì>?���(ì§�Ú6&��Å$��d�÷�ë�7Û¿

®���ú{Ñâ7¿®(),�`86�2è8Xñ��?���ª¥¦I¨Ãí£(

)`8,�6ãD���Ir�6�^�|T(),-6Îp�Ó7�ïg?()�,X

���õ|�òÇ*¡îbme��Ù{Ìò� ¿®()�,í�p®6Á���Á

�pDÁ]Xì§6�ÚÇÙ[­:��Ø<6q��"�§p��ú«^¡p()¦Ó

í�6p®Á����6ì§�Ú�#/ØÙd�6qËâ�[:q���(),-6^

<(�â�[:q��¶·Ì���ò6Ì�$Ì#/,-qËd��2�()Ìúù(

Page 145: Department of Political Science College of Social Sciencentupoli.s3.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/finalP9532… · Department of Political Science College of Social Science

140

),-Îp^<(�Ì°Ì|T(),-²���ãD]LÌë���AÒ6b̸>Ç

ðe�Å$�\�6´µu>�uÐâ[:®ú^<(�6q�X9Ì�ë���AÒ6Ì

%=PÅ6b��]�e�Å$����ËH�~�(�Ú����3^ó���6:��

G±®ú��ìåèJ��ë��Ó7Ûª�b,�Dße¡î��PQ�r6j·X

õ�b£¤e�ª�£¤(9:dÑ£��B�6£¤���ëC`�C©����

¬"������^ø�¨!¨��Ì>dÑ£�2;�Ã6XdÑ£�Ì9:ÃQ�9

:ùà��"J�°�6d�É?�Ì9:ÃQd�BÑ6<Ç�<gX£¤­úÌî¹

Aî¹6¨û�õ%2;3î¹AXû��£¤)Ñû�F1�úÑ2;F1X

t�ÑÙ�É�`a()£¤Ìá�6��¦£¤üÌ()£¤6�Ù�y�`a(

)£¤��¦£¤­��()Ì�£¤��¦Ì#/£¤y�`a­í��¦£¤�õ

ç>½�í�()£¤y��¦£¤Ì�_6�¥¦��bÝÞe�bQO�=eX�µ­

úÑ¡U6<=�õ%tt�uD�y®��î(¼Öë�ÖÝS�ì�()$�n�

¦$�wM¾W��#> #()£ë¨¨X>?¡U6b��¦¤e6ÁD�n­�?

��PQ6���2Xû��� ¤��6��JK�å¯òì�£¤6d����Iá

£¤�6d���ì1¸�XÛë��ì��£¤678�í��å¯ÌÖ×678�â

�$��¼£¨ëÝÖ"�ùG��6 !�;2�°�ô6d�$����í�Xõ�

������ú0ò<¤ ��I�&uXë#/ò23Äì�,`�£G6�¦�()

ò23�î%>�,`�]Ä6�¦Ñàá6ÚÈÏ �#ÓòÍ:d����Ô�X�

ì7½Ì<¤I� ��HÚJ<Ç6fg�û¹I�67½Ì�îJÚë¨6"%��

õ�ûK¶·��Ãd�6��������Ãd���m;69:�<d��Xë�

��?á�¦��³ßÈ�`²��Ã6�î�?|µ�¦�6��6ÛÜd�X+_

��,-Ï=69:�<d��7kÆ,#�2�Z����ß�,Ï=LF`a6,

#¨��:���JK6ª«ÑæçrD6�8X

�£mLÚP<=�(���JK6 ¤¶·6Çð �3�Äì�b"%e6�^X

"%üÌ�Ä�k�"%6~C$Ù­¥Ù÷�m�6°��9"%Ì÷Dm�ÏÚX¿

���2;`86É���1?��JK6 ¤��Ñäâ6�íN

Page 146: Department of Political Science College of Social Sciencentupoli.s3.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/finalP9532… · Department of Political Science College of Social Science

141

X����PQ6�22? 1949�¦,±��x(�d°±�²2�?���n%B

q()�µÚJ�»X�Ò6m;Ì()�#/�î5�A�¯m;J�õ�ÃÏ�)Ì

I�;23¡ÄPQ�Å$�ú{ò�I�¹`�d�x¤Ç¡ÄC�X

Xc�¦ÓRS)­ÌÛÉ6�ú­Ì`É6�õÌ`�è6�RSÌ�ÄPQ�t

u`8¬<Ç6²>­"Ì9:2;õÃ�¦ÓÌ��:"c��?%|��¦Ï=Ì�

233õ�í�Xû������JK6 ¤���2;`8ñÁ��bí�e��¥òF

¹Xû��Ú�?tu`8�6%>`86b²>e�b�e¨ï�>?�2;`86

ï�>?Ìbí�eX|µ�â23�î®íb���,d�¦e�b��,¦eõk­Ì

cA666¦Ó6í��/8�{Ìb�î�¦e6í��í�#Ó�Ìb�¦�eX

X-��µ��� <��¶·i��±¿N32;��6bñ�í�eF¹�Ú

6ï�X�()�¦,±�,�±����@6B%>`8�¬ì�6b,`e�b%>e

º¹#/�Ú6`ßXõ�¦#/16Ìtu`8�!16b`²e�b,�`8eÉ�

x'sX� 1987�|¦*+��01�x���6¡¢£¤78pq�9Ú�?����

=6J���ÁÑ23bRSd��e6A��úÁѪ«bñ�í�e6�Úä�tt

�i«�uö�:�wGX{��23¶u6��PQõ|­��Ü�ð>î¹�Ï=

2;dÑ6£��£¤�°�ÚJK^66>?��ÕÖ��Ï=6RS÷�X

ë�ò23b?u���e�­â7úÌÃ�ì²��²ä6ì��@�ú­úÌ£?

��Ã��¤õx69:¨�C`X�r6¦ö��üÑ23�¦Ó%ø�%f�JK

�õ�í�6fg�Ó7Û[ÃX�XN�,¦¹.�XN�,¦ÌbÈ �6��e��

�ÑqÚ�6��èí��XNÃQ¦=IÑq£¤�����¹XÕ�6d�í��¹

b1à�6��eXõ�����|µ¥¦�2�®�£¤��������,�6í��

¹bN��6��e���ÓÑâ7ã�?u��X

Page 147: Department of Political Science College of Social Sciencentupoli.s3.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/finalP9532… · Department of Political Science College of Social Science

142

2M42M42M42M4--------��������----

¡>�£�bèY[6=b�|µâ��t�����JKt�Ð ?eójk�F

6uD� ¤ÑO������,d�m>�u1ÚN�Ö>��¤ÇØ�¥Ù6èÄs

â�()û.X�£ÚK�üò�µ��­³ ¤��JK�{7ÛáS(����26

fg�����PQpÆ���×�S��¦�Xû��b ¤����JKe��d�2

;(����2ؽ�G¯­?Ñ�®�¬p6â7��Ìwx��d�[>6\¾X¹

[Ã�\¾�³�¼=£0Cb����JKe¬H�\më_X

�����b�b�b�b�î�¦�î�¦�î�¦�î�¦eeee6666�D�ÚN�D�ÚN�D�ÚN�D�ÚN

�£*yG8(t[Nb�²�tu��tu����E��Ì��(�������,

ª�� ×����6��PQ�¡�îñò¢·¬�Ñ6í£��í�¤Ì¥¦§p6

¨©eXÙõ��b�î�¦e6ï�}·��I��btue6áñ�­�N#/�ªì

��¦ö9:�íb��e6tuy()�ª©�b��eÑ­�68ò�í¹¦Ó­�

�����,6®Iõ��`²�ò}ñ���3���6tuX

#/6b��¨©e$Ù¡'u6Ìè�~µ8�9ï29­fª�b��,¦`²

Ô�e6µu��Ä=b� 2008� 5&Ï�6 ·���93()ûK����ç#6E

E÷=�×Ã()�µ�uô¾:TUVWX170õ(G¦,±�H3 2008 �³ 2012 �\

]#A�9Ì(),-�?b�¦�í�enÁÑ���Îp()�36ï@x@á�¡

ÑG3��b­f�²���,¦e=b¬×Ã6Áª()>1Ïì#X��ë�­7³

iµrdì� �6=b�,�±?þÑ�16A:��µüò­�EF�b()­Ì�î

¦ÓÌ"$Ìe�b()Ì­Ì��6����@ú�÷�BÌe¨}·���6���í

�{:kÆôâÒX

û������b��e6�����ij�ÑqÇðÏ÷���ëì��Ô���

ñs��GCí¹âB��u�äâ 4î�ªN

@�BáSn ¤b[cd�e6e��d�C�b(�e�ÕÖØbXGb[cd�e

170 � QY 1995�96�b(�ËÌTAe³ 1999�b�¦=e¨ 2uñ#TAX

Page 148: Department of Political Science College of Social Sciencentupoli.s3.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/finalP9532… · Department of Political Science College of Social Science

143

^ø¤�<H()����^ø�6rsX

@cB()�ª%���b��¶^e���­�b(�eX()ò����¡Þ�£

¤�Öרê�êØ�r�ub��¶^eØc�b]�e���l����

µ&ÍÎ�b`¦^e¥Xo�³��}·����`²`a6Øy­Hù

b`¦e}·X

@-BI��3b��5_e�ï�Ìb������eXY��áut���b,�

��e�b£¤��e³b����e¨�QÁD?b������e=bX�

£í¹b��5_eÛb��¨©eI¹Ìè�IB®yè�âÁèX<=�

b��5_ec�3b��¶^e³b��,¦¶^eX

@nB#/­â�¨b�¦e�¼²XJKÌòBI�6b�@eÚO�#/�ªò

�í�) �b��6-�e�©­òbO�õu­¸e�)Ùb#/�()

���î�¦e�©�¦ö�{ò¡�>î�`� ×���Ìb�¨6�¦ô

t²e6�ÆX¦£�()'<�6b�¦í�e�Ù�Q�û?#/¶<�

¦ö9:��¨3b�¦e6�¼²¬�Xòñ62;���b�¦e�b�¦

�e�b��,�e6bñ�í�e�bõ�í�e�©#/�ªò?á�m>�n

%ü�uöî�ÓîX�=�B��t?�£6¹=)6b9:2;`8e�a

ã�Öi6b���te³8¦ Öi6b¦ÓR�<=eÏ�X

1994�*2���6b�î�¦e�(�6b()`�èe�M=b�ð�171I��

ÌiÓ�()LM����6Øb�¡Þ�2ã×­�y#/ÁÑH:()�,6í��

��í�²ªËÒX���(���í� ��Ä8���â�I�6=bIJX¯uö

F^©ÌNJÝ�{ÌI��b[cd�e6fgä�²�btueܹX�?��xÑ

Ìb�î�¦e��?(�õ|Ìb¶���eX���õ|�²�(�¹�îb¶�±�

`�e�ü̲�µu6tÜõ�9Ìâ�QOÜÎ(�6����Û6EEy�(�õ

|�²�b�î�¦e�üÌ}ñ%=6¶^õ�9Ìâ�ÕÖkÆØb�â76"6g

TX��ÍÈ8«�¯u�ÁÑ8«X�î���â�²�6btue�ÓÑâ7H:I�

171 ��? 1994�Ϩ>Q�û?ÍÎÏ�\]²��Ynäo!áiÑNb()¥¦Ì()�6�¡Ìf�6É?e�÷ÅÄÇ()`�èX��ûb[cd�e¬;26��JK*2²�fg���PQ��®¤X

Page 149: Department of Political Science College of Social Sciencentupoli.s3.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/finalP9532… · Department of Political Science College of Social Science

144

�,Îp�õÃ{����JK6PLÖ>X

cccc����,#,#,#,#9:9:9:9:����£¤678J�£¤678J�£¤678J�£¤678J�

bJKe¥¦�f?b�Çe�@7 M�Ç�@723JK�õ�ÇòB78J�X

û���S��6J�78�Ì6uD� ¤����JK6¥>EFXõ9:�£¤7

8���,-qË�����JK�8ñ#X¸�x���,=9:78äå�2�n­

³TH6º»X9Ï�>?��9:¶<�B����3¨û.6()�è�78¤�:

Ù�J�X¹,2tÑÃ���pÆÉäâ�Dm>N

@�B��,=78Ø1N

�£�ª6Y[b³�,-½x���,=78�>)`ò��X�q78­³

M����,½xØ1Çq ¬X�t� 3î�ª�JÝÌ'1��y1987�O()*

+01_���78�2©ª�½x�u�78�\]#_��X)#/¦Óz�½6]

�¡¢Ç��1988 ��(),-�M#/��¹ 43 � 7,700 �u�2011 ��©[ 526 �

2,000�u�23�Ï='1�¶ 12�X1990��()£à#/{,x(01�78_�)

()ï,�6]��1990��#/,-.( 7,524�u�õ¸ 2011���¸ 172� 7,293

�u@x(ÉÁz�¹ 128 � 6,000 ·�u�9:³!�78L�¹ 31 �·�uB�'1

�¶:� 200 �@#/,-% 2002 �*2x(ÉÁz�BX�ÄâD�pÆPp½¾�G

íâ8�­â¬ÏÁ�X172¯uÌØc­³�2y���Q½x>le(),-.#/

016�D78�C�,2¸#/Kn³1�.(01�0æ�çÇ�{û��{¨ID

78X78Øc>1�TD69:J�Åí¸ë¯�yÖ�£��,"�Ý �Ö×��

ר!�78¨X#/�,x(ÉÁz�ú>b����e*+¸b%>îe�G¯I7�

(),-¸!�6²¼X�ß6rÉ�Ð� ¬¸ë¯G/� ¯Y÷�LFGC¨!�

¤� ©uJ��78`�ú>��,-,2¸�±���,�ôt³,=9�¨X�q

���Q½x­³45�I����6�Ç�¥I���Xl_Ì©^#_ �y��½

xleúb?�ß,-�_xC�,2:!ÓëA�,=A;³`�ÙòÁÂ��"¸�

±�©³ÃQúçç�,=¡¢JáXõ�b6Ä7`8e6É����¡�ëèWZ

172 ]�')Qr�/P:`O¡¢X

Page 150: Department of Political Science College of Social Sciencentupoli.s3.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/finalP9532… · Department of Political Science College of Social Science

145

678�?����PQ6�ÊrÌPLÖ>Ï�X

@cB�裤78�êN

��#ë¦P��GCQÓ±KÖiöB�2}�I�Ã3b��£¤=Âe�d�ç

Ö��6Ô¤�2X�í¹���¡" 60�6Bé�I��,���É��������

��ª��°�3Ú�#6 !X()ÓÓ��¤iÝ��±��Ñiì6`,��y#

/�,©Ì`­Ë�­Ë�­�±�Xòù*��Ï=6£¤ !�­úò��I�yÖ�

£¤�ª678�õ%ò��lëÖ׺õ�½¾ê±�r���F��n1�í�%=

6£¤*]�Ó7ù*I�6£¤ !X

û��|µí£3£¤78Ì ¤��JK6}·��l/é�l�è�l[�<O

6�Z�ê�¯Þt�Øyá�¤�½x«¤¨÷��úÌ�ìI�JK6`òû.X

¯Ãqútt� 3î�ª�X�ÌCé­³,#X)/P:]��% 1992�¸ 2010�ù�

¯dÖ��,=6£Ö78��C�«��²�¸ 3,000 *ydÖ��!ÓëAJ¸��

�ëGC�²�¸ 1,000*y�Ö��GC�J¸��GC�ï�h*:" 1,100*y173X

cÌ�êC��^X¸ 20�x���£¤78�le6£ë�¯�ê�C�,2¸Ö×

Ý � ��×�6ý�*�,=�¯�yÖ¨"�£¤°�¨èî�ª���pqÕP

èÄö�6ë¯G/�LFGC�Ð�2z�±',�78³yÖ�^ɤ���78�

�åÄáUXX-Ì��£¤78D7 �2X��£¤78'Ápq�Þt�á�[�

S��6���nD ©u�!�¤�D�2X��6ý78>�Q7½ÁD?LF�g

L{áX���×W��23LFA�X��Ê��Ö×���£¤78'Á�«X��

�§u6fg��wx��I��« ¤��Ö×�6ý�£¤°�78LF�nlm7

8��£¤Ö×78l}�kÆ�2�åÄ3��£Ö78ØcX

���ªú�G�:b¦�í�e¥Ù°Ìòë�£¤6ÎÏX¸�x#/�£¤�

�ø*]��£¤6 ¤�¡Ì�*ε�X�?�U��£¤6Òã�TÑ�ÑÖ?

wx����É�6?�LX�¥�b,`e�b%>e�±Ì()�2;b6¦�í�e

�6�îñò1[X��â��tÑ6��¿À�kÆ�����9:@*+�()b6

173 ]�')Qr�/P:`O¡¢X

Page 151: Department of Political Science College of Social Sciencentupoli.s3.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/finalP9532… · Department of Political Science College of Social Science

146

¦�2;e60ò{@¹G�����ï�}·�6 �ú{@lX

----����~L¡¢�2_;~L¡¢�2_;~L¡¢�2_;~L¡¢�2_;

Y��"� 4 �áx�Û���PQ��ìÑÃq�å¯Ì�#/7� ECFA�¹(

)¡ÞpM�Ð��¹��ñ#Ã{XECFAÙ�bi�¨�e? 2011���õu5�174

%�@2012B�õ#/��i� 539�°��:" 9Ã�P6X)#/�P]��2011�

1¸ 11&�#/%()�O\�¹ 1,141.6s,��Û� 1��<�¶ 8.66}y���i�

#/9M()i�¨�`��O�¹ 182.77s,��GÖP6� 1.14s,�X()� ECFA

<H6��û�ô]¹b��U�eXh�"���x�ECFAi��\�u#_ö�

9Ûõ¯�¦Ó�#/�ù6ön­÷ÅÇq�()°��#/6�¨~­�CG�Û

­���'�X�,Xû��ëì,# ECFA 6`a�q�ÇÙÚ��5Xå¯ëì�

ªý�GIá/¡x(�úÌ¥¦m>6�DXõ 2012�#A_Y��3(ò��ª ECFA

_Ælm6È��n?�,#/¡x(¦¡6�\�­ÍÎv¦¡�\>rªt⿹

Áªtâ��Ú*+6�D��«Ö���¡¢45½xX

�q��¡Þ6��«�2�()�#/Ï=67LPQ>Ã�#/í��é�#

1�°6Ð��é�p®¹()v6*��#/�°F×6�±~LX(>()*�ÉÃ

6°��ïp:#/�°��Ã�¶É~6H�î� H)ófkÎ6°�X����é

_;��#/̾W6é��()©ì¤G�éFXt�Ì()�#/�°v×~L�ä

�«©Ì�2 ¯CØ"¸*v#����6�'��SR#�7|X�£ÚK�üò�

q&u6�����Ô��u��1��¼|�£¤Ú�³�<�{¨#��B�p¤¹

¡Þ#��7|>��²¡Þ~L�2*åèJ����g�d��2X�ø46¡¢P

Q,}¸��6��JKX

¯u FTAâ7÷�#¡Þ�H�l¡Þ�6m��9�M WTO_�¯�­â8X,

¦�Ñ#ë�ËÖiï�8@Ezra F.VogelB{í¹NH��³Î¯ç�c�ECFA��¸ì

174 bi�¨�e@i<�e¨�B�(�78%>¢dl�i�I�Ýâ�*+�%=Ñ�6P6�\� �

b ióP6e6�\¨�X�ß� FTAIVÖP66l����îñò6¨©{Ìb10�ØC�ÜÎI�P6eX¬¹bC�ÜÎe��'{Ìjkè6�k�îXëI�OÎP66<=�¹(i�3��5��7��10�¨Xõbi<�e¨�e6�\�{Ì�?b(i*+eö6°��m�X

Page 152: Department of Political Science College of Social Sciencentupoli.s3.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/finalP9532… · Department of Political Science College of Social Science

147

�ïPkLEÎ��¯ç�×¾$&��>¸¦�í�êJÚ��W�âÚ@}b¸ÇJ

¡¢¯çÉÊ:�Ý9� JX175û���l¡Þ�õ|�lÎ6��Ìbd��e�!

"bA�e³b��e6��r�%=��l#X{<=�õ|@b9:2;`8e6É

�B�(Ì�bRSd��exì¤bñ�í�eX

nnnn����Û�Û�Û�Û�lmA�lmA�lmA�lmA�6Ñq6Ñq6Ñq6Ñq0F0F0F0F

¹ÖñA 1995 �ûbp� Ïîe�:lm�³�1999 �b�¦=e ��:r�

gh�[�ù6;B�¥¦l�Û��f��l�:6C�l�A���õ��wxI�

r�lm�[���:��óDÃ�r�X¯ò��?N

@�BI��3{b��Ô�e6A��n��6Ù��îTA�<�m>��¤Ç

Ï[X

@cB�bi�eõ­bi²e6����îbXcW[e@Second Track DiplomacyB

���176nò���K±r���ì¤IVPQX.ë�\�ãä���bg

NRS�ªe`ò6Xc�[=Â@ªB®�ÑN,´ä��[ÙbãäR

SGC��e¬ÕP6��=Â�ðñ¦ögNGC¬@London International

Institute for Strategic Studies�IISSB`P6bãÕRS:}e���W\b¦ö

gNGC��e@Center for Strategic and International Studies�CSISBÕî6bã

ä�í=Âe@Asia Pacific Roundtable�APRB��³¯�è�èU6éF:D³

G/:X��â!"¡K¦öùê:_6A:�[Ã{÷�}·786\6X

���ÆëA¤âÕPG/:�ð>ë¯78�����JK23�î0/�

!"õ'/�¡*�+6�����d�m/ëì��()I�23JK6

¶·Xn⺹�¦cè�LFèA�6e«·�X

@-B�WTOé�¹´������¨r�¦ö9:A:�n�¦öùL�î��X

@nB���33èÄ}·=Â��<è�pÆè�ÕP�êØ6ë¯G/:�9M

ëA!Ó����ô�"¸Ã�ôt¨áî�ø�786�[³����7�

175 vgLDx�2012� 6& 15'�X n*X176 ¬¹bXcW[eY6ÌÃ��¥6C��[�®�ëA����^ÃQ���¡¢¬r�6:�X

Page 153: Department of Political Science College of Social Sciencentupoli.s3.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/finalP9532… · Department of Political Science College of Social Science

148

GC����H�d��ÊÑ��Ú�¹��2|XÃ�ë�­ó`P�{P

¯,=P<�1dÖ6���¾P<X� 2009�6b�����eG/:¹.�177¯úÕP 1Æ_{w?ÆP�­=¯¨û¹ì��3(M�Ú��83A��

�<P<��Ú�>�ð>�ÊÚC�78X

@qBA�623�H÷j�9Â=ïÚ�ydHáXb���j�eúÌ23JK6

î¹ys�è6ï�}·â�¿¿��9­7�ù��¤â�%�*2�õX

��â��H��Hü¿�9­7�ù�­7�ù78J�6���A�X

@�BbK�2345e�bÕÖººe�b23K�e�bì¤��e6jkè>?�0

FBÑrs���â������JKA�62; H�î's�DXÚPA

�âopbÝ¡_�e�bÝd_je�bÝ¥_üe³bà���e¨¨©��

f�*2C«ü��ª«JK�²Æ?�î±²���lmy9­â¿N�x

Õbï�}·e�I��³i{bï�}·eÙ�õ'/8�23=b�n¹Í

Îsâع~�X

qqqq����²æJK²æJK²æJK²æJK

��6ÚJK^Ìwx(���6fg�õK^6fg�?b�@e�23JKÌ�î

b��e�bC«æ²e6"%X��ì����JK6"%��I��òÑI#6l��

ÚJ3Ç�®yè�6�����5mûn�6�îhè6º�µ*�³<è6C���

����I��9M��I#÷=6�i�ú93%=I#6÷=X|µ��ëì23�

��n²æ��JK�ÇÙÌ�����26ò&X�£í¹N

JK6X�«�C�!GNJK6f�¨©ÌNb÷â�E�|ÎÜ��â�E�|-

Ü��9­ò9[|��6Ü�e@good news, bad news , no supprise!BXJK{Ìò7Û*

[r�6È��­�¡îÈ�ÌΰÌ-��q­�n­7Çð¶·�õ9MHI6È�

I��C��6#?X

177 b�����ë¯G/:e? 2009� 11& 13'¸ 14'�(�¾|#ñòG*�>��^�ä�£¤fZ:`P6X¡Ì��!ÓëA���PQ�26jk6�ùñò678�����X���:A�q�

�Ô�6���`P�� #6bFó�*��v6��ôe6<?��î M60/�d�à 26� 50¶d�X

Page 154: Department of Political Science College of Social Sciencentupoli.s3.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/finalP9532… · Department of Political Science College of Social Science

149

JKXc«�23]¨�d�r�@î"%��õÇð¶·NJKÌBbì[e²æ

�x6�­Ì�î�Ú�F^��ÌO\�6Ñ^{7236XÑ�î�H U�9ïÌ

Z6­�6[<â��1¯�Nb÷ÚK|�u�±:|õ÷yë�|ÁÑõ÷�÷{kÆ

ÚKä�eX�£���JK#}6$%�â��t�Ï����"¸(�,Ï=JK6o

-(�?äá6ösupprise÷X

�£�����JK6ev�fg�oÇ:pA6à��+�â��t�� 1995h2008

�;�Ï=�{Ìû¹��øøb|î­�e�b��ªç±'�ðÚe�bî���±��

¤�:S¦Ó~��eµ*­³�º�Ïä�õ����JK»��(�RSgùTU

VW6�¹X

õÒ$�6¡*Ö��wx���J���I�0ò­³0ª�ÚJú�n­³æ²

¡*X|µ�à�����uD���C«»Çj·6'EX$ÙÇð��¶·°ÑO?

êá¶*6b�pe�9úòpÆæç�v׶*Xë�¬b6����Æ�ëA�!ÓÝ

�믩ªÝá�0ª�&u/=���ëìm@��:�Ü�6èÄâ7whX�£<

OÑIáë¯0/���7�6���÷=�¡¥�ÑÖ?ª×ÊË���d��C«²

æJKX

���������jwx�jwx�jwx�jwx 2hhhh4�6A¬<�6A¬<�6A¬<�6A¬<

�GCí¹�wx6 2h4���ò�u�jbA:Ïúe�æç����JKXû¹�

�#/õ|�JÝÌ,¦�ãä���#/�ÃaÆ6O½����n=ÇtÃq�ë,�

'��³,�'�è6mN@´ÐB³?�S�á�6pp�N�ß�ÃÄ�©b-�q

�eÌ[Ę̈y¯uÌY\]Â^Ä�����pÆü��9 2016�\]#A�¦,±

7�kÆ@�ÌÐ̶�yÜ#/�òæç|Twx6 2h4�Xõ�()�ª�#/�÷

��Æ_õ�Ñ��6�~<�õÞØ�¡k<=ØúvÑñ#6AÕ�¬�â��®�

á?­â��®�yÜY����ji=���{()6¦ö÷=¶·¨�îá�¤6�

�lmX�¥��òí�GCbJ­�í�J­�íe6���hyhªÉà ECFA _Æ

lm�ÖÃb��%>¢d�ei'ut��i��33(m¦¡÷�¨º»èKÄ45y

s�78b��£¤785_l}e�b��Ö×785_l}e¨��¡¢�9:�£¤

Page 155: Department of Political Science College of Social Sciencentupoli.s3.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/finalP9532… · Department of Political Science College of Social Science

150

¨,�}·�n��¹fgv×IÎ6JKò*��iú¹wx����«6�â76�

�}·�¦ö÷=�´µJK¨Ýîã�§u�­â¬p6fgX

��JK6 ¤$Ù­7xÕs�6��}·�9X��`Ûɶ*wûí6¶*

ä�¢Ù�î���j�Ì7�¬¹6��l}Xwx 4 ��$ÙY\]«Â^­>�

9Цs1äâê�6¾hfgN

@�B��\�����Ìz{|}�Î�I�7Ûrstu�J­�í�n ¤J

K�������©��¼³`²�s���}·�LM¼½��j»Ò�

õ()Hx­d6���2ËaX

@cB,�'¨¦f?%¡¦Ó�$Ù���¡¢78rªÍO@Î�¡¢78}

�:��´µRSq�B�9���6���´µ��lm^ìÑãDÖ]6¿

®tÜÐÙ��Pp�nBÑÚ�Ï()>X

@-B()ØÙÉK����³��}·�ÐÙ¾ñ�3�jÑd��7õâ|X

@nB��¡¢78q�SRZ��ü�Xý+èº�Ïä��?�ß9:#-õ

|�È��������2�¯�î�þ¡¬H�¶�Ì��~äó��¸�

Ä !ùl¨P5}·�ówÇt�æç�Çq6qX

@qBá'(),-üò(:�����j�{%Ùg(:b�î�¦e�b��]�e�

b�¦��e¨¨©�\¾�úGH(),-�?�î���jwë¡¢,�

}·6lmÎp��X

@�BY\]�7AÂ^i�?tG����l}�j�b`¦�"e¹� ��`

¦�()�"ò�Ï�³��J��Ïs��wx��7���l}��?�

j��­â7^&Xû��³iµrÚP=b³�D��Ö%Û�ÈX

��êßfg�Ì0òY��������>�Ú���uäxXõ#/ú�»Ðæ

çè6î¯��¦ö�����¡¢LF�lÖ()º»tÜ�|T,���ÖÃ��J

K6 ¤�¹wx6åèJ�ãäfgX�b6Ä7`8e��÷Åì��÷A���

Z6()>yû����îgN3�Óõ|�ò3�C��Gi=�|Ñ�y�÷�,6

@�AI��æç�T�òÑF¹�Gwx�|Ñ�X

Page 156: Department of Political Science College of Social Sciencentupoli.s3.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/finalP9532… · Department of Political Science College of Social Science

151

QQQQ�b�b�b�b�1£GÑý|�1£GÑý|�1£GÑý|�1£GÑý|eeee����bbbb|1£GÑý÷|1£GÑý÷|1£GÑý÷|1£GÑý÷eeee

�FÓ���öÑNb�1£GÑý|e�178|µúâ�C'Nb|1£GÑý÷e�|

x()÷�|µÑK�{â�¿®#/X9{()ØÙõ|��b`²}·e�MÌ��

6�í¹��lm�Kb`²e{É3�®�àá����³`ò�±�ØXû�¡��

�JK6�2Ìçñò6®�X

,¦�Ñ#ëï�8Öií¹NH��:)[¸º�>��ì�£ÄwÅ��&Nåh

 ¡¢©ùE�:����:[$¸�ày�ÞÝVw,&�0:)[¸·ý,¯°¸

£¤&�JI¥�:�`¸ª«X:ë@FϦ¸F�â,F|Í���ë¼Å��)[

��e&§(�^¨<�9��¸�>©ì¢=)g<�¸��Zà��c©ªJX179

û��()¥¦ÑIáIì6%KX|µ��6��r�[#/��]��B�¬Ñ

x"()6#/,-�í�()rû3Iá6�¦£¤��()�,6����Í:3Ñ

±�@­|Ý�_B�[��@E­#�B�����@È?Ö�B6÷è�G�µ�Ç3

��,�úâ�+�£G6`,9:X()�,�ÑK��ÚÊçÖ#/ãHI*+�I

,ÎX§�b�î�¦e­úÌ���6¨©�IÌ�IJ�6Â^�§pb�î�¦e

­úÌ|µ�$�ÁÂ�IÌ�S��¦�ÁÂX

;;;;������6��6��6��66-VPQ6-VPQ6-VPQ6-VPQNbNbNbNb()()()()eeee����bbbb#/#/#/#/eeee����bbbb#/#/#/#/ 13s�,s�,s�,s�,eeee

�,���(-VPQÏ¥�()�#/�#/ 13s�,6-îPQI¹ñòX#/

\�6��¡Þu>�¦ö=]#?()�û��()ë��b`²e�b��e�fg#

/n�r�6ÚNXõ��v��Ï|÷D�������Ï|��æç6��ª�b�

î�¦e�()Ó7�jagN6���X

bí�eÌ�î ©6���ë�#/,-í¹()¡ß�3b��,�e�b�

î�¦e�Å$��{ùb�=PQe�b:|PQeX�¡ÄPQä�13s�,B�­

â7ù,`()�#/�²7�i6�N�ÆX�|Ï�ë�()�b��,�e�b�

î�¦e63ùâ�¹#/�,¬²��()6,`���*+9:�`,��ÓÑA:

178 �¦iD� 2006� 1& 26'��Î���ã��9���Ý�6`*K�¯·¹Nb�1£GxÑý|h9���Ý�6`*Ke�Øy`ò̹bÔ��3e�øX179 �$ 175X

Page 157: Department of Political Science College of Social Sciencentupoli.s3.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/finalP9532… · Department of Political Science College of Social Science

152

�÷=2t¯()>�#/�,úÓf�¯F¹ò��d�²¿À6��XF��Ñ�

()6,`*+�9:á��£¤�9:`8¥¦�b�î�¦e¡î5_��Ó7ÛÑ

q�°�>1X

��á������&�pÔ�ÑPê�=Ú Ï[i�öÑNH«¬� Z��Rá

«r�¸Z�áR���Rá�¸���©¸�áR��¸­��©Å���¸Ã��m

­��¸ÃG�JÅÜ��â70ò�Ç�üÑ#A�ìAÓÑ8«6�4�8«�ìAõ

|Ì��,����AïÌ�Ä@AX�<01?��PQ��|µ<O#/­9ÑbÖ

Ae6����u�Iò�¤Ã¹b!+(),�6Dße�b�Ç()�I60�e6b�

Ae�ë�Ó7µ;Ä�X()ú¥¦ò�b§p�î�¦e6tbä�2t6÷��rD

�26%KX��ë��7Ûñ#%K�JK%Ùâ�Ð:PÃX

h���6��JK¶·ç¯í,jÇ�9Ñ?AÐ��ob$����½e6

���ÍÎ�j�m>�� ¤�²æ����JK6ÚFX¯e�¨û{�?FÌÛ�

(����26¥ò¶*yú{ÌÑ�2;��JK�Ì|µ[Ãb��d�e¡î\¾

­â�þ6éBX¡îéB�â�çÖ|µbÁ�e�G���,��LF�*v�?�¦

�6¾�yâ�çÖ|µbÕ6e�ÖÎ(�b"6gTeÏùXë�¸Pñò6éB�|

µ�ÙHii�� �-G��ð�&GF?þrp�lRÜ�°

Page 158: Department of Political Science College of Social Sciencentupoli.s3.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/finalP9532… · Department of Political Science College of Social Science

153

rs£c;;;;<<<<&�&�&�&�Í�Í�Í�Í�----

UK Heo�Shale A. HorwitzL��2008�vãÕººx�(�N¦§Ù�����X�ÓZ�Ò�£��1996�v��PQ6C���Ex�^_N^_�£#ë^_ãäGC¬X��Ã�2005�v7½�Ö®x�(�Nqá S`�X���`��1995�v¦ö^x�(�Nqá S`�X�J[�^Ê�`��1887�v�d�jÚNx�(�Ng¡�*9X®y��Ó��`��2011�v|»�6��PQ<=x�(�Nqá S`�XºÃ���1998�v�,PQ6�2®¤³¯Á�x���N���,�*9XÓ±K�1994�vb�¦¶·e�XÕì²gNRSPQx�(�Nqá S`�XÓ6��1995�v~L<=���PQÏGCx�(�Nqá S�*XÓ���1995�v�¦6�Ò�]�x�(�N?��*9XØã>�1995�v��ëx�(�N-,S½XÍÎÝ�1995�vúg_�d��±��6¥7�Úx�(�Nr�S½X�¾Å�1994�v¦ö����êRSlmNXãRS��Ï0/x�(�Nqá S`�XG{r�1996�vI�ÌIiÌx�(�N�å�*9X��Ê@Samuel P. HuntingtonBq���,��1997�v£Gºº�¾W±�6ñ2x�(�Ng¡�*9X y��1998�v��PQÔ��d������x�(�Nqá S`�X����1996v¦ö��6<=�uöx�(�N$Z£¤`�X�iå��1995�v¦öPQ<=÷âx�(�Nqá S`�X�L��1996vû®-=,�PQ�úgm@(ä)x�(�N¦§Ù����½X=G>�Ó2�`��2005�v��PQ�K�2345x�(�N�3 S`�X=G>�������ÙLq�1994�vXÕ�ê�6=x�(�Nqá S`�X=G>`��1998�v�¾�¦ÓRSgNx�(�N}��*9X��Ш�1993�v�µ��6��ghWZ:�_6��6��x�(�N¬­=Â�*9X��^��µ78fZ:78,-��2008�v��*+78 20�¦öë¯G/::}uäx�(�N��^��µ78fZ:X

aã��1998�v��`²=x�(�N��£¤µ�`�Xaã��2011�v]L�Nx�(�N��£¤µ�`�Xaã��Ò¦¹�1999�v,¦6�¦�ÚhaÆ�7½�gN��x�(�N��£¤µ�`�Xaã�`��2010�v������0ªx�(�N��£¤µ�`�Xaã�`��2011�v���t���ètx�(�N��£¤µ�`�Xà·��1997�v��GC�^�]�x�(�Nqá S`�XM�W`��2008�v¸c ���PQ6�2�®´x�(�N��^��µ78fZ:X%¶?�1999�v�dëì�jx�(�NiZ�*9X�Ý �1998�vgNGCMòx�(�N}��*9Xñ�e��1998�v±ãgN>= 1996h1997x�(�N¦§Ù´&½X>?@�>3@`��1999�vGC�^�=£�Fx�(�NmA£¤`�XVµ,�!£�L��1985�v�¥7�x�(�Nr�S½X�á��1993�v,¦¥7�TA <x�(�N�G3X,¬X�á�`��2002�v�,PQGC!·N1998h2000x�(�Nqá S`�XûS�¨�1994�v,®�6ãä���PQx�(�N�ì�*9X¢�"`��2006�v¾W6ؽ���PQN����262gx�(�N<�#ë¦öGCë3�iZ�*9X

�õ�1992�v=��dPQrH¤x�(�N-,S½X

Page 159: Department of Political Science College of Social Sciencentupoli.s3.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/finalP9532… · Department of Political Science College of Social Science

154

�õ�2003�vTUVWh��¦=:�V�¦x�(�N`äþ��*9`��õ��R¦`��2006�vb�î�¦�è%tbed�6�ux�(�N¦Ó�ÚGCfZ:��ì�1993�v(�RS�¦§ÚNx�(�N�ì�*9X�#J�1992�v��é���dGCx�(�N?Ù£¤�*`�X

hhh�1996�'�d�L¦78�ì´µ�êK^l�Ï�}(�vd±¶·GCx�XccäXq<�� 1h3X

hhh�1997�'��´µ78�?6º»(�v(G���ô0ªI&�x�Xq<�� 120-126Xhhh�1998�'�d�?�áã�êb23K^45e63ù(�v��gNë�x�>���� 115h144Xhhh�1998�'(���bK�2345eý}(�v¦§,-x�X -äX c<�� 3h12Xhhh�1999�'K�2345�()�µ��PQ(�vgN�¦öGCx�X�äX�<�� 9h10�12h

13Xhhh�2000�'K�2345���PQ(�vgN�¦öGCx�XcäX�<�� 135h145X�Ù`�1995�'�d´µtô¤ãäRSA�(�v�¦#/GCx�X-;äXQ<�� 6h20XÓ6��1996�'��´µtô¤J�PQÏGC(�v<=��Úx�>���� 82h106XÍG�2000�'��K�23456uD�Ãq(�vgN�¦öGCx�XcäX�<�� 56h63X�$�1998�'úg_,¦��d6´µPQ(�v¦öPQëDx�X -<�� 13-17XG{r�1995�'�l%#6PLì�N#/�ÚÏgN's(�v<=��Úx�&���� 84h91X�£%�2000�'�d�K�234563ù³F^(�vgN�¦öGCx�XcäX�<�� 120h121�128

h129X�r8�1998�'XÕ³ãäK�xRS2345ÏGC(�v<=��Úx�X cäX-<�� 75�80h85�

88h90X �Ù�1996�'��m�b9ù:�Ü�l�e�b��l�eÏGC(�v¦Ó]�PQ:P¯GC��x�

� 25h30X y��1996�'���÷�:_âîèÏ0/(�v<=��Úx�>���� 27h44Xa�Ú�1994�'�K�23¹`÷6��PQ(�v¦ÚIw�x�X�-[<�� 16Xaã��2009�'=�µ��23JK(�v�¦�=&�x�\X�n-<Xa�×�1996�'��,¦��Ö���PQ6@��m>(�v<=��Úx�>���� 2h13Xa�,�Í���2000�'bK�2345e6&'�2g(�vgN�¦öGCx�XcäX�<�� 68h70X-#��1997�'_úgi<±l¦Ó�±áã�ê23K�RS45Ïú'(�v±áã��x�XcäX�

<�� 82h101X'S.�1999�'K�2345�()�µ��PQ(�vgN�¦öGCx�X�äX�<�� 90h91X�¦Ù�1997�'23K�456Ð�³|¦6$�(�v¦§,-x�X c<XQä�� 58h67X�?G�yz��1999�'K�2345�ãäRS(�v¶·�GCx�X-;äX�<�� 1h21X(£��2003�'��´µK�234562;N<=�uö(�v¦§�Ú�=x�XnäX�<�� 18-63X6���1998�'��d6bC�=eÍN�����6b23ègN��PQe(�v<=��Úx�X cä

X�<�� 1h11X8¥��1995�'_úgi<±áã��±�(�v±Ó��ëDx�Xn<�� 130h131XûÉü�2003�'��K�2345ý}(�vþàfZ:��x�XnäX�<�� 65h91Xó0 )}0�Û �1999�'=RS���23K^45�gN6F1(�v�¦�=x�X -<�� 20X §�1996�'�µ��´µ786âîè(�v¦Ó�ÚI��xXX�nn<�� 8h9X��ì�2004�'��´µJKA�6o�u—ÁÑJ�{ÁÑJK�ÁÑJK{ÁÑRS(�v6¾��

Æ=Âx�Xc�<X

----

====<<<<6666��������----

Alford, Jonathan, 1981.“The Usefulness and Limitations of CBMs.” in William Epstein and Bernard T. Feld eds.

Page 160: Department of Political Science College of Social Sciencentupoli.s3.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/07/finalP9532… · Department of Political Science College of Social Science

155

New Directions in Disarmament(New York: Praeger Publishers, pp. 134.

Allen, Kenneth W., 1999/4/8-9.“Confidence-Building Measures and People’s Liberation Army,”in the PRC’s Reforms at Twenty: Retrospect and Prospects, An international conference(Sun Yat-sen Graduated Institute of Social Science and Humanities, National Chengchi University.

Drifte, Reinhard, 1983.“Diplomacy,” in J. M. W. Chapman, Reinhard Drifte, and I. T. M. Gow, Japan’s Quest for Comprehensive Security: Defence, Diplomacy, Dependence.London: Printer, pp.81-143.

Holst, John Jorgen., 1983/1-2.”Confidence building measures: a conceptual framework,” Survival, Vol. 25, No. 1, p1.

Keddell Jr, Joseph P., 1993. ”The Politics of Defense in Japan: Managing Internal and External Pressures. ”NY: M. E. Sharp.

Krepon, Michael et. Al., 1998. ”A Handbook of Confidence-Building Measure for Regional Security, 3rd Edi-tion.”Washington D. C.: The Stimson Center.

Krepon, Michael, 1993.”Study on Defensive Security Concept and Politics.”New York: United Nations.

Lynn-Jones, Sean M., 1988. “A Quiet Success for Arms Control: Preventing Incidents at Sea.” quoted in Steven E. Miller. and Stephen Van Evera eds., Naval Strategy and National Security. Princeton, N. J.: Princeton Uni-versity Press,, pp. 359.

Mulgan , Aurelia George, 1997.“The U.S.-Japan Security Relationship in a New Era,” in Denny Roy(ed.), The New Security Agenda in the Asia-Pacific Region. London: Macmillan.

Nagashima, Akihisa, 2001.“Collective Self-Defense and the Japan-U.S. Alliance,” Japan Echo, Vol.28, Issue5, pp.32

Pederson, M. Susan, and Stanley Weeks, 1995.“A Survey of Confidence and Security Building Measures.” in Ralph A. Cossa ed…Asia Pacific Confidence and Security Measures. Washington D.C.: The Center for Stra-tegic and International Studies, pp.82.

Shimbunsha, Asagumo, 2001.”Defense Handbook 2001.”Tokyo: Asagumo Shimbunsha. Welfield, John, 1988. An Empire in Eclipse: Japan in the Postwar American Alliance System, London: Athlone.