deconfined criticality: su(2) dejavu · deconfined criticality: su(2) dejavu nikolay prokof’ev...
TRANSCRIPT
![Page 1: Deconfined criticality: SU(2) Dejavu · Deconfined criticality: SU(2) Dejavu Nikolay Prokof’ev (UMASS, Amherst) Anatoly Kuklov (CSI, CUNY) SF VBS Boris Svistunov (UMASS, Amherst)](https://reader030.vdocuments.site/reader030/viewer/2022040610/5ece27b6f6bb9c0f49301960/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
Deconfined criticality: SU(2) Dejavu
Nikolay Prokof’ev (UMASS, Amherst)
Anatoly Kuklov (CSI, CUNY)
SF VBSBoris Svistunov (UMASS, Amherst)
Matthias Troyer (ETH)models
m
SF-VBS
+ simulations
PRL 101, 050405 (2008)
models
Munehisa Matsumoto (UC Davis)
, ( )Annals of Physics 321, 1601 (2006)Prog. Theor. Phys. Jap. 160 (2005)PRL 93, 230402 (2004)
= I-order transition
“Quantum critical phenomena” Totonto, September 25-27, 2008
![Page 2: Deconfined criticality: SU(2) Dejavu · Deconfined criticality: SU(2) Dejavu Nikolay Prokof’ev (UMASS, Amherst) Anatoly Kuklov (CSI, CUNY) SF VBS Boris Svistunov (UMASS, Amherst)](https://reader030.vdocuments.site/reader030/viewer/2022040610/5ece27b6f6bb9c0f49301960/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
Why Dejavu?
(1) (1)U U× (2)SU
Contributing authors Many of the same authorsContributing authors
Simulations of specific models
Many of the same authors
Same type of models
claims of new criticality claims of new criticality
Problems with scaling for systems
claims of new criticality
Method of solution: flowgrams generic I-order
Dejavu
![Page 3: Deconfined criticality: SU(2) Dejavu · Deconfined criticality: SU(2) Dejavu Nikolay Prokof’ev (UMASS, Amherst) Anatoly Kuklov (CSI, CUNY) SF VBS Boris Svistunov (UMASS, Amherst)](https://reader030.vdocuments.site/reader030/viewer/2022040610/5ece27b6f6bb9c0f49301960/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
Solid = insulator with broken translational symmetry (integer filling excluded)
Checkerboard solid (anti-ferromagnet)
Valence-bond solids (VBS) ( g )
Columnar VBS Plaquette VBS
Density-order Current (or bond) orderDensity order
i jn n
Current (or bond) order
2 2i jJ J
![Page 4: Deconfined criticality: SU(2) Dejavu · Deconfined criticality: SU(2) Dejavu Nikolay Prokof’ev (UMASS, Amherst) Anatoly Kuklov (CSI, CUNY) SF VBS Boris Svistunov (UMASS, Amherst)](https://reader030.vdocuments.site/reader030/viewer/2022040610/5ece27b6f6bb9c0f49301960/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
Superfluid and Solid orders and transitions:
Ψ M ,x yB B ,x yD D …
order parameters:
”Naïve” Ginzburg-Landau(expansion from the generic quantum disordered phase)
order parameter
?
g gg SF SFirst-order
SF SSFS
SupersolidSF S
Quantum First-order Supersolid disordered
![Page 5: Deconfined criticality: SU(2) Dejavu · Deconfined criticality: SU(2) Dejavu Nikolay Prokof’ev (UMASS, Amherst) Anatoly Kuklov (CSI, CUNY) SF VBS Boris Svistunov (UMASS, Amherst)](https://reader030.vdocuments.site/reader030/viewer/2022040610/5ece27b6f6bb9c0f49301960/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
1 2 3 4 5( , , , , ...)S S S S S S= - multi-component order parameter;the symmetry of S is ALWAYSbroken in the ground state
Ψ M ,x yB Bbroken in the ground state
0S ≠
O(3)-case: Heisenberg point = exact O(3)-symmetry
EM
S -sphere
E
θπ
M
θ2
Generic case; I-order SF-S transition
Ψ E
θ2πM−
![Page 6: Deconfined criticality: SU(2) Dejavu · Deconfined criticality: SU(2) Dejavu Nikolay Prokof’ev (UMASS, Amherst) Anatoly Kuklov (CSI, CUNY) SF VBS Boris Svistunov (UMASS, Amherst)](https://reader030.vdocuments.site/reader030/viewer/2022040610/5ece27b6f6bb9c0f49301960/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
SF and VBS orders are deeply related … May be even self-dual at the critical point!
O.I. Motrunich and A. Vishwanath, Phys. Rev. 70, 075104 (2004).T. Senthil, A. Vishwanath, L. Balents, S. Sachdev, and M.P.A. Fisher, Science, 303, 1490 (2004):
Deconfined criticality, does not fit the standard Landau-Ginsburg-Wilson paradigm.
SF VBS
gDeconfined spinons
= vortices in the VBS order x yB iB+
DCP action:
( )22 2( ) ( ) ( )22 22 2 2 22
1 21,2
aa
S d rd iA z s z u z v z z Aµ µ µνβ ν βτ κ ε=
= ∂ − + + + + ∂∑∫
![Page 7: Deconfined criticality: SU(2) Dejavu · Deconfined criticality: SU(2) Dejavu Nikolay Prokof’ev (UMASS, Amherst) Anatoly Kuklov (CSI, CUNY) SF VBS Boris Svistunov (UMASS, Amherst)](https://reader030.vdocuments.site/reader030/viewer/2022040610/5ece27b6f6bb9c0f49301960/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
Ordered SF state for matter fields = (duality mapping) “quantum disordered” for vortex fields
Do LG expansion for vortex fields!
L. Balents, L. Batosch, A. Burkov, S.Sachdev, K. Sengupta, PRB 71, 144508 and 144509 (2005).
Filling factor 1/2 dual magnetic flux/plaquette 1/2 two species of vortexes+ gauge field coupling
at the SF-VBS critical point
DCP action
( )22 2
∫ ( ) ( ) ( )22 22 2 2 22
1 21,2
aa
S d rd iA s u v Aψ µ µ µνβ ν βτ ψ ψ ψ ψ ψ κ ε=
= ∂ − + + + + ∂∑∫2 2 2| | | | | |ψ ψ ψ= +2 1 2| | | | | |ψ ψ ψ= +2[ 1/ ] ( ) g e g L gLκ = = → = Run-away flow to strong coupling
![Page 8: Deconfined criticality: SU(2) Dejavu · Deconfined criticality: SU(2) Dejavu Nikolay Prokof’ev (UMASS, Amherst) Anatoly Kuklov (CSI, CUNY) SF VBS Boris Svistunov (UMASS, Amherst)](https://reader030.vdocuments.site/reader030/viewer/2022040610/5ece27b6f6bb9c0f49301960/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
DCP action:
( )22 22 2 2 2
0v =SU(2)
( ) ( ) ( )22 22 2 2 2
1 21,2
ai a
S iA s u v Aψ µ µ µνβ ν βψ ψ ψ ψ ψ κ ε=
= ∂ − + + + + ∂∑ ∑
( ) ( ) ( )21 2
,cos cosXY
rS J A A Aµ µ µ µ
µ
ϕ ϕ κ ⎡ ⎤= − ∆ − + ∆ − + ∇×⎣ ⎦∑ ∑
( ) ( )1
2 2 2 21 2
1,2 with | | | | 1aCP
i aS iA Aµ µ µνβ ν βψ κ ε ψ ψ
=
= ∂ − + ∂ + =∑ ∑
( ) ( )[ ( )] ( ') ( ) ( ) ( ') ( ')S U F j r g Q r r j r j r j r j r = + − + ⋅ +∑ ∑ ( ) ( )1 2 1 2',
[ ( )] ( ) ( ) ( ) ( ) ( )J ar rr
S U F j r g Q r r j r j r j r j rµ µ µ µ µµ
= + + +∑ ∑
1 2( ) i ( / ) ( ) /∑1 2( ) sin ( /2) ( ) 1/Q q q Q r rµµ
− = → ∑ ∼
![Page 9: Deconfined criticality: SU(2) Dejavu · Deconfined criticality: SU(2) Dejavu Nikolay Prokof’ev (UMASS, Amherst) Anatoly Kuklov (CSI, CUNY) SF VBS Boris Svistunov (UMASS, Amherst)](https://reader030.vdocuments.site/reader030/viewer/2022040610/5ece27b6f6bb9c0f49301960/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
Mappings: “High-T” expansion (expansion in kinetic energy)
( )'24 2 *
''
. . [ ]rriAr r r r
r rrS U t e c c Aψ µ ψ ψ ψ κ< >
< >
= − − + + ∇×∑ ∑ ∑
( ) ( )b b
S
n m
Z DAD e
t t
ψ
∞ ∞
= ∫∫
( )* *' '
0 0'
( ) ( )( ) ( )! !
b bb b b br
b
Ab
b
n mn m iA n mS S
r r r r rn mr b rr b b
t tDA d e e en m
ψ ψ ψ ψ ψ∞ ∞
−
= ==< >
− −= ∑ ∑∏ ∏∫∫ ∫
' , with ' , with{ } { }
e (xp{ ( ' { }) } ) J
b b b bb b b b
Sr r
n m rr n mj n m loops j n m l p
b
oo
g Q eW j= − ∈ = − ∈
− − = =∑ ∑ r r j js
∑
loop configurationsof oriented currents (DCP)1 2r r r = +j j j
![Page 10: Deconfined criticality: SU(2) Dejavu · Deconfined criticality: SU(2) Dejavu Nikolay Prokof’ev (UMASS, Amherst) Anatoly Kuklov (CSI, CUNY) SF VBS Boris Svistunov (UMASS, Amherst)](https://reader030.vdocuments.site/reader030/viewer/2022040610/5ece27b6f6bb9c0f49301960/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
INSULATOR (NORMAL) SUPERFLUID
Winding numbers = MC “blessing”2 2 2 /dTL W W L−Λ
(Pollock, Ceperley ’87)
Superfluid stiffness: 2 2 2 /ds TL W W LΛ = →
j-current through any cross-section
Probe system properties at the largest scales; ideal for studies of critical phenomena
![Page 11: Deconfined criticality: SU(2) Dejavu · Deconfined criticality: SU(2) Dejavu Nikolay Prokof’ev (UMASS, Amherst) Anatoly Kuklov (CSI, CUNY) SF VBS Boris Svistunov (UMASS, Amherst)](https://reader030.vdocuments.site/reader030/viewer/2022040610/5ece27b6f6bb9c0f49301960/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
Continuous critical point:the entire disctibution
is universalI-order SF-S transition:( )P W
( )P Wis universal
( )P W
2 1W ∼≈
2
SFW L∼
W1 2W1 20
Since 0( )
(0)W
P W
P≠ =
∑ in 0 I
SFi
∞ 0( )
#(0)
WP W
P≠ =
∑Transition point Def:
(0)P 0 Iin (0)P
Quantity to study at I order∞Quantity to study at the transition point:
2 ( )W f L = →c
I-order continuous onst
∞(scale invariance)
![Page 12: Deconfined criticality: SU(2) Dejavu · Deconfined criticality: SU(2) Dejavu Nikolay Prokof’ev (UMASS, Amherst) Anatoly Kuklov (CSI, CUNY) SF VBS Boris Svistunov (UMASS, Amherst)](https://reader030.vdocuments.site/reader030/viewer/2022040610/5ece27b6f6bb9c0f49301960/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
Phase diagram of the U(1)xU(1) DCP action
( ') ( ')gQ r r V r rδ− → −short-range version
g ~ 0.5 - weak I-order
small g maps to g > 0.5
RG flow: ( )effg L gL∝
![Page 13: Deconfined criticality: SU(2) Dejavu · Deconfined criticality: SU(2) Dejavu Nikolay Prokof’ev (UMASS, Amherst) Anatoly Kuklov (CSI, CUNY) SF VBS Boris Svistunov (UMASS, Amherst)](https://reader030.vdocuments.site/reader030/viewer/2022040610/5ece27b6f6bb9c0f49301960/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
Flowgrams of . What to expect across the tricitical point.2W
L
2 2W I-orderdivergence
TP criticality
criticalitybelow TP
Lshort-range CP1
![Page 14: Deconfined criticality: SU(2) Dejavu · Deconfined criticality: SU(2) Dejavu Nikolay Prokof’ev (UMASS, Amherst) Anatoly Kuklov (CSI, CUNY) SF VBS Boris Svistunov (UMASS, Amherst)](https://reader030.vdocuments.site/reader030/viewer/2022040610/5ece27b6f6bb9c0f49301960/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
Flowgrams of for the run-away flow to strong coupling and I-order.2W
L
2 ( )P S2W
S
( )P SSFI
I-orderdivergence
Slarge g
criticalitycriticalityat g=e =02
L
![Page 15: Deconfined criticality: SU(2) Dejavu · Deconfined criticality: SU(2) Dejavu Nikolay Prokof’ev (UMASS, Amherst) Anatoly Kuklov (CSI, CUNY) SF VBS Boris Svistunov (UMASS, Amherst)](https://reader030.vdocuments.site/reader030/viewer/2022040610/5ece27b6f6bb9c0f49301960/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
Flowgram collapse! 2W
2 2
criticality
2W 2W
l ( )L
criticalityat g=e =02
( )P Sln( )L
S
( )P SSFI
Different g are identical on
S
glength scales ( ) 1L gξ≥ >>criticality
at g=e =02criticalityat g=e =02
ln( / ( ))L gξln( / ( ))L gξ
![Page 16: Deconfined criticality: SU(2) Dejavu · Deconfined criticality: SU(2) Dejavu Nikolay Prokof’ev (UMASS, Amherst) Anatoly Kuklov (CSI, CUNY) SF VBS Boris Svistunov (UMASS, Amherst)](https://reader030.vdocuments.site/reader030/viewer/2022040610/5ece27b6f6bb9c0f49301960/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
(1) (1) caseU U×
2.1
2.2
2.3
1.7
1.8
1.9
2.0
0.58
1.3
1.4
1.5
1.6
<W2 >
0.5 I-order proved
0 9
1.0
1.1
1.2
1.3
g=0.125 0.25
0.375
-0.5 0.0 0.5 1.0 1.5 2.0 2.5 3.0 3.5
0.9
ln [(g+g2)L]
![Page 17: Deconfined criticality: SU(2) Dejavu · Deconfined criticality: SU(2) Dejavu Nikolay Prokof’ev (UMASS, Amherst) Anatoly Kuklov (CSI, CUNY) SF VBS Boris Svistunov (UMASS, Amherst)](https://reader030.vdocuments.site/reader030/viewer/2022040610/5ece27b6f6bb9c0f49301960/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
Proof of first-order transition at g=0.58
Probability distributions at the critical point for g=0.58
Scaling of peak positions with system size L
![Page 18: Deconfined criticality: SU(2) Dejavu · Deconfined criticality: SU(2) Dejavu Nikolay Prokof’ev (UMASS, Amherst) Anatoly Kuklov (CSI, CUNY) SF VBS Boris Svistunov (UMASS, Amherst)](https://reader030.vdocuments.site/reader030/viewer/2022040610/5ece27b6f6bb9c0f49301960/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
‘07
(2) caseSU
07
‘07
‘07
![Page 19: Deconfined criticality: SU(2) Dejavu · Deconfined criticality: SU(2) Dejavu Nikolay Prokof’ev (UMASS, Amherst) Anatoly Kuklov (CSI, CUNY) SF VBS Boris Svistunov (UMASS, Amherst)](https://reader030.vdocuments.site/reader030/viewer/2022040610/5ece27b6f6bb9c0f49301960/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
1(2) case, - modelSU CP
![Page 20: Deconfined criticality: SU(2) Dejavu · Deconfined criticality: SU(2) Dejavu Nikolay Prokof’ev (UMASS, Amherst) Anatoly Kuklov (CSI, CUNY) SF VBS Boris Svistunov (UMASS, Amherst)](https://reader030.vdocuments.site/reader030/viewer/2022040610/5ece27b6f6bb9c0f49301960/html5/thumbnails/20.jpg)
“Smoking gun” of the first-order transition
![Page 21: Deconfined criticality: SU(2) Dejavu · Deconfined criticality: SU(2) Dejavu Nikolay Prokof’ev (UMASS, Amherst) Anatoly Kuklov (CSI, CUNY) SF VBS Boris Svistunov (UMASS, Amherst)](https://reader030.vdocuments.site/reader030/viewer/2022040610/5ece27b6f6bb9c0f49301960/html5/thumbnails/21.jpg)
(2) caseSU
![Page 22: Deconfined criticality: SU(2) Dejavu · Deconfined criticality: SU(2) Dejavu Nikolay Prokof’ev (UMASS, Amherst) Anatoly Kuklov (CSI, CUNY) SF VBS Boris Svistunov (UMASS, Amherst)](https://reader030.vdocuments.site/reader030/viewer/2022040610/5ece27b6f6bb9c0f49301960/html5/thumbnails/22.jpg)
O.I. Motrunich and A. Vishwanath ‘08
![Page 23: Deconfined criticality: SU(2) Dejavu · Deconfined criticality: SU(2) Dejavu Nikolay Prokof’ev (UMASS, Amherst) Anatoly Kuklov (CSI, CUNY) SF VBS Boris Svistunov (UMASS, Amherst)](https://reader030.vdocuments.site/reader030/viewer/2022040610/5ece27b6f6bb9c0f49301960/html5/thumbnails/23.jpg)
Conclusions:
1. So far, all 2+1 dim. models of the SF-S transitions observe either I-order, or problems with scaling
in agreement with both (!!)
GWL using 1 2 3 4 5( , , , , ...) 0S S S S S S= ≠
Ψ CBS ,x yB B g SFS
DCP action = a continuous theory of weak I-order scenario
U
SF S
U
2. Strong renormalized pairing of vortices on large scales may be the mechanism ti d fi d iti lit f h ipreventing deconfined criticality from happening