dale wen reality behind chinas miracle
TRANSCRIPT
8/2/2019 Dale Wen Reality Behind Chinas Miracle
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/dale-wen-reality-behind-chinas-miracle 1/33
The Reality Behind China’s Miracleand the Ongoing Debates
Dale Jiajun Wen
International Forum on GlobalizataionSeptember, 2007 Washington D.C.
8/2/2019 Dale Wen Reality Behind Chinas Miracle
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/dale-wen-reality-behind-chinas-miracle 2/33
The Rising China in the Media
The way to middleclass life style—The
China my universityclassmates areexperiencing.
8/2/2019 Dale Wen Reality Behind Chinas Miracle
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/dale-wen-reality-behind-chinas-miracle 3/33
The Hinterland China
A village school.It was founded in
late 60s. Nowthe villagershave to beg aUS foundation tocover the
renovation cost.
Thousands of rural schools with similar history.Thousands of rural schools already closed down.
8/2/2019 Dale Wen Reality Behind Chinas Miracle
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/dale-wen-reality-behind-chinas-miracle 4/33
Which One is More Real?
• Number of mass incidents (protests,demonstrations, or even clashes withpolice involving more than 100 people)
1993 2003 2004 2005
10,000 54,000 74,000 87,000
8/2/2019 Dale Wen Reality Behind Chinas Miracle
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/dale-wen-reality-behind-chinas-miracle 5/33
Growing Inequality• Ratio of urban versus rural per capita income
early 1980s 1.8:1
2003 3.23:1
• Income distribution
Top 10% Bottom 10%
Early 1980s <20% (of totalincome)
1995 33.7% 1.87%
2005 45% 1.4%
8/2/2019 Dale Wen Reality Behind Chinas Miracle
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/dale-wen-reality-behind-chinas-miracle 6/33
Poverty
• Cheered by World Bank and Chinesegovernment: 300 million people were liftedout of poverty since 1978. Yet, is this
monetary measure of poverty accurate?• The number of rural people living in extreme
poverty increased from 28.2 million in 2002 to29 million in 2003.
• From 2000 to 2002, 42 percent of ruralhouseholds experienced decreased income inabsolute terms.
8/2/2019 Dale Wen Reality Behind Chinas Miracle
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/dale-wen-reality-behind-chinas-miracle 7/33
Health CareNeoliberal reform in health care
• From 1980 to 2003, health care costsskyrocketed 15 fold.
• Government and collective contributiondeclined from 78.8% to 44.5%.
• Percentage of people covered bygovernment/collective health care
Urban Rural
1978 Almost 100% ~90%
2003 ~50% <10%
8/2/2019 Dale Wen Reality Behind Chinas Miracle
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/dale-wen-reality-behind-chinas-miracle 8/33
Health Care Collapse in Rural Areas
• Number of rural health care professionals:
Rural Doctors Rural Nurses
1975 1.5 million 3.28 million
2001 1 million 270,000
A 60 year old barefoot doctor. He has
served the villagers for more than 30years, while his total income from hismedical practice is 30~40$ per month. Who will serve the villageonce he retires?
8/2/2019 Dale Wen Reality Behind Chinas Miracle
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/dale-wen-reality-behind-chinas-miracle 9/33
Health Care (Summary)
• Average Life Expectancy
– In WHO’s 1978 Alma Ata Conference Health For All by theYear 2000 , China’s primary health care system was featured
as a model for the world. – In a 2000 World Health report, China ranked 188 out of 191
countries in terms of fairness in financial contribution tohealth and 144 out of 191 countries in overall performanceof the health care sector.
1949 1978 2005 2005
(urban)
2005
(rural)
~35 67 70 78 66
8/2/2019 Dale Wen Reality Behind Chinas Miracle
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/dale-wen-reality-behind-chinas-miracle 10/33
Education• Education costs have skyrocketed in the last
20 years while the share of governmentfinancing has dropped significantly. Even for
primary and secondary education, non-government sources pay 44 percent of thecost (1999 data),
• A four-year college degree costs an estimated
40,000 yuan, more than 13 times average per capita rural income.
8/2/2019 Dale Wen Reality Behind Chinas Miracle
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/dale-wen-reality-behind-chinas-miracle 11/33
Liquidation of Human Resource
• Between 1949 and 1980, adult illiteracydecreased from >80% to 33%.
• The number of adult illiterate populationhas increased from 87 million to 116million between 2000 and 2005.
8/2/2019 Dale Wen Reality Behind Chinas Miracle
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/dale-wen-reality-behind-chinas-miracle 12/33
Education as a Form of
Colonization• In the last quarter century, most educational materials
and media imply that
– The only way to a better life is to industrialize, tourbanize.
– Everything urban is progressive and desirable,while everything rural is backwards anddespicable.
– Peasants’ traditional attachment to the land is astupid sentiment, and should be replaced byupward mobility at all cost.
8/2/2019 Dale Wen Reality Behind Chinas Miracle
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/dale-wen-reality-behind-chinas-miracle 13/33
Ideal Preparation for Sweatshops
• Words from a female migrant worker and asurvivor of catastrophic factory fire
“ There is no possibility to be humanback in the village”.
8/2/2019 Dale Wen Reality Behind Chinas Miracle
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/dale-wen-reality-behind-chinas-miracle 14/33
Declining Rural Investment
• Government expenditure on agriculture, as apercentage of total national expenditure
• The share of infrastructure investment in therural sector decreased from 10.6 percent in1979 to 2.8 percent in 1992 and 1.7 percentin 1994.
1976-1980 1981-1985 1985-1990
10.5% 5.5% 3.3%
1979 1992 1994
10.6% 2.8% 1.7%
8/2/2019 Dale Wen Reality Behind Chinas Miracle
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/dale-wen-reality-behind-chinas-miracle 15/33
Left:The empty highway financed by World Bank.
Right: The village road built thirtyyears ago.
8/2/2019 Dale Wen Reality Behind Chinas Miracle
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/dale-wen-reality-behind-chinas-miracle 16/33
Left:The empty highway financed by World Bank.
Right: The village road built thirtyyears ago.
8/2/2019 Dale Wen Reality Behind Chinas Miracle
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/dale-wen-reality-behind-chinas-miracle 17/33
De-development of Rural Infrastructure
Photos by Joshua
An irrigation canal in early 1970s. The same irrigation canal in 1990s.
8/2/2019 Dale Wen Reality Behind Chinas Miracle
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/dale-wen-reality-behind-chinas-miracle 18/33
Funding for Rural Exodus
• More than 280 billion Yuan investmentin Beijing for 2008 Olympics.
• The annual government spending onrural health care is only 9.25 billionYuan(1998 data), less than 3.5% of the
Olympics expenditure.
8/2/2019 Dale Wen Reality Behind Chinas Miracle
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/dale-wen-reality-behind-chinas-miracle 19/33
Employment and Jobs• China is NOT stealing jobs from the world. On
the contrary, it is losing more manufacturing jobs than any other country due to the globalre-structuring. – From 1995 to 2002 manufacturing jobs decreased
15 percent from 98 million to 83 million.
– During the same period, manufacturing jobsdecreased by 22 million globally; thus China’s job
loss of 15 million contributed to two-thirds of theglobal shrinkage.
8/2/2019 Dale Wen Reality Behind Chinas Miracle
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/dale-wen-reality-behind-chinas-miracle 20/33
Labor Conditions
• Industrial accidents result in 40,000severed fingers in Pearl River Delta per
year.• Who are responsible?
Foreign-funded
enterprises
Domestic private
enterprises
State/collective
enterprises
26.0% 53.9% 5.4%
From a 2003 survey in Pearl River Delta
8/2/2019 Dale Wen Reality Behind Chinas Miracle
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/dale-wen-reality-behind-chinas-miracle 21/33
Declining Labor Income
• The average salary of factory workersat Pearl River delta only increased by
$8.20 nominally between 1992 and2004, and decreased by 30% in realpurchase power.
8/2/2019 Dale Wen Reality Behind Chinas Miracle
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/dale-wen-reality-behind-chinas-miracle 22/33
The Families Behind “Made in China”
20 million left-behind children
grow up withoutparentalpresence.
8/2/2019 Dale Wen Reality Behind Chinas Miracle
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/dale-wen-reality-behind-chinas-miracle 23/33
Environment
• Becoming the world waste dump
– Seven of the ten most polluted cities in China.
– Pollution claims 750,000 lives prematurely per year.
– About 60 percent of the water in China’s sevenmajor river systems is classified as beingunsuitable for human contact. mental pollution inexport zones.
– Ground water table under North China plain isdropping 5 feet per year.
8/2/2019 Dale Wen Reality Behind Chinas Miracle
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/dale-wen-reality-behind-chinas-miracle 24/33
8/2/2019 Dale Wen Reality Behind Chinas Miracle
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/dale-wen-reality-behind-chinas-miracle 25/33
8/2/2019 Dale Wen Reality Behind Chinas Miracle
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/dale-wen-reality-behind-chinas-miracle 26/33
The river runs black or red?
8/2/2019 Dale Wen Reality Behind Chinas Miracle
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/dale-wen-reality-behind-chinas-miracle 27/33
The signs say, “No pollution. We need to survive.”
8/2/2019 Dale Wen Reality Behind Chinas Miracle
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/dale-wen-reality-behind-chinas-miracle 28/33
Foreign Economy Growing on China’s Soil
• Tax rate for foreign MNCs: 11%
• Foreign funded enterprises account for 60%
of China’s export.• China only as the cheap resource base, labor
supplier and waste dump.
China is the kitchen, while US and Europe isthe dinning room.
8/2/2019 Dale Wen Reality Behind Chinas Miracle
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/dale-wen-reality-behind-chinas-miracle 29/33
Trickling Up of the Problems
• Water crisis at Harbin city in December,2005, at Wuxi City in June 2007.
• Employment rate for new collegegraduates has dropped to <50%.
• Middle class is increasingly complaining
about run-away health care andhousing price.
8/2/2019 Dale Wen Reality Behind Chinas Miracle
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/dale-wen-reality-behind-chinas-miracle 30/33
Growing Dissents• Actual quotes from the Internet
– Their GDP is growing, while our livelihood is declining.
– Please take away the TVs, washing machines, refrigerators or whatever consumer goods, give us back theaffordable health care, education and
housing we used to have.
8/2/2019 Dale Wen Reality Behind Chinas Miracle
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/dale-wen-reality-behind-chinas-miracle 31/33
Recent Changes by the
Government• Increased media coverage of the plights
of peasants and workers.
• Increased investment for rural areas,especially in health and education.
• Several environmental initiatives.
• News slogans like “harmonioussociety”, “scientific development”instead of “Development is the absoluteneed”.
8/2/2019 Dale Wen Reality Behind Chinas Miracle
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/dale-wen-reality-behind-chinas-miracle 32/33
Ongoing Debate and
Possibility of Alternatives?• Rural reconstruction movement
• Emerging environmental movement
• Emergence of new left, resurgence of old left
• What are the real meaning of new
government slogans like “socialistcontryside”, “harmonious society”,“scientific development”?
8/2/2019 Dale Wen Reality Behind Chinas Miracle
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/dale-wen-reality-behind-chinas-miracle 33/33
Some Recent Good News
• IFG’s book “Alternative to EconomicGlobalization: A Better World is Possible” is just
published in Chinese. It would not be possible two
years ago.• National halt on “oil to liquid” and “food to
biofuel” projects.
• From the official government report of the 17th Party Congress meeting: Harmony between man and nature is one important
aspect of harmonious society.