dade county beach erosion control and hurricane protection ... protection/da… · overview....

1
U.S. ARMY CORPS OF ENGINEERS, JACKSONVILLE DISTRICT For Additional Information, Contact: Jason Harrah, Project Manager | [email protected] DADE COUNTY BEACH EROSION CONTROL & HURRICANE PROTECTION PROJECT IDENTIFICATION OF ALTERNATIVE SAND SOURCES FOR THE REMAINING PERIOD OF FEDERAL PARTICIPATION 1 2 3 4 5 6 ST. LUCIE MARTIN PALM BEACH BROWARD MIAMI-DADE PROJECT AREA ST. LUCIE COUNTY OFFSHORE SOURCE 120 miles from project area ~4,600,000 cubic yards Dade County beach quality material MARTIN COUNTY OFFSHORE SOURCE 80 miles from project area ~600,000 cubic yards Dade County beach quality material ORTONA & WITHERSPOON SAND MINES 120 miles from project area Adequate quantities of Dade beach quality material LUMMUS PARK ACCRETION AREA ~50,000 cubic yards accretes annually ACI SAND MINES 35 miles from project area Adequate quantities of Dade beach quality material BAKER’S HAULOVER EBB SHOAL ~30,000 cubic yards accretes annually NOT TO SCALE N LEGEND: # Potential SAND Study Sources Dade County BEC-HPP Sand Source Alternatives 7 OVERVIEW Federal beach nourishment projects are authorized for generally 50-year periods. The Dade County Beach Erosion Control/Hurricane Protection Project (BEC- HPP) is over halfway through its authorized period of participation and its traditional sand sources have been substantially depleted at this time. Collaborative, proactive efforts over the past 20+ years at the federal, state, local and private sector levels have sought beach compatible material for the project while ensuring that the needs of all regional beaches have been considered. Recent efforts indicate there is in excess of 100,000,000 cubic yards of beach quality material available for the non-federal and federally- authorized beaches of southeast Florida through 2062. Dade County beach renourishment needs through its period of participation is estimated to be approximately 3,625,620 cubic yards. PROJECT BACKGROUND Dade BEC - HPP 1970s Pre - nourishment Dade BEC - HPP Post - Nourishment HAULOVER BEACH PARK BAL HARBOR SURFSIDE KEY BISCAYNE SUNNY ISLES MIAMI BEACH BISCAYNE BAY BOUNDARY OF PREVIOUSLY USED BORROW SOURCE BAKERS HAULOVER INLET Broward County Miami-Dade County N GOVERNMENT CUT SUNNY ISLES: 2.5 miles OF Sunny Isles Beach Authorized: 1986 Initial Construction: 1988 Remaining Period of Federal Participation: 2015-2038 DADE COUNTY BEC-HPP REMAINING PERIOD OF FEDERAL PARTICIPATION Sand Needs (cy) Sand Availability (cy) Excess (cy) County 50-Year Volume Need 50-Year Volume Need + 55% Contingency 2012 Total Volume Available Per County Volume + Contingency/ Confidence Volume after Needs met St. Lucie 18,017,487 27,927,105 175,847,874 106,149,618 78,222,514 Martin 22,111,000 34,272,050 107,593,227 56,160,331 21,888,281 Palm Beach 2 45,577,000 70,644,350 191,951,814 117,728,007 47,083,657 Broward 3 11,650,000 18,057,500 - - -18,057,500 Miami-Dade 3 14,968,300 23,200,865 - - -23,200,865 TOTAL 112,323,787 174,101,870 475,392,915 280,037,956 105,936,086 100,000,000 SAND SOURCE INVESTIGATIONS DADE COUNTY BEC-HPP PROJECTED FUTURE RENOURISHMENT NEEDS DATE SEGMENT CUBIC YARDS SUNNY ISLES 2016 Sunny Isles 547,330 2026 Sunny Isles 500,000 2036 Sunny Isles 100,000 1,147,330 Main Segment 2016 Hot Spots 556,730 2017 Surfside 560,460 2019 Haulover 90,000 2019 Bal Harbor 330,000 2019 Non-Hot Spots 606,100 2021 Hot Spots 200,000 2022 Surfside 135,000 2,478,290 TOTAL 3,625,620 2011 – 2013 SOUTHEAST FLORIDA SEDIMENT ASSESSMENT & NEEDS DETERMINATION STUDY 2015 DADE COUNTY BEC-HPP LIMITED REEVALUATION REPORT AND ENVIRONMENTAL ASSESSMENT The results of the study indicated that the Southeast region of Florida has excess sand of 100,000,000 cubic yards beyond its 50-year need. ANTICIPATED UPCOMING CONSTRUCTION SCHEDULE RESULTS Renourishment scenario where all 7 sources will potentially be used Offshore sources will be used for large renourishments Upland sources/truck haul will be used for small renourishments Two Miami-Dade sources (Baker’s Haulover and Lummus Park accretional areas) will be used when sand is available Beach renourishment has been providing essential economic, environmental and recreational benefits to coastal communities in southeast Florida since the 1970s. Renourished beaches and dunes serve as a vital buffer between coastal infrastructure and the destructive forces of ocean waves and surge during storm events. MAIN SEGMENT: 9.3 miles from Government Cut to Baker’s Haulover & 1.2 miles of Haulover Beach Park Authorized: 1968 Initial Construction: 1975 Remaining Period of Federal Participation: 2015-2025 The regional investigation, known as the “SAND Study” involved extensive coordination and collaboration between the Florida Department of Environmental Protection (FDEP), the five southeast Florida counties, the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, and the Bureau of Ocean Energy Management (BOEM) to determine regional sand needs through 2062: Each county determined their own 50-year sand need for federal & non-federal projects. All needs assessments were peer reviewed. Geological investigations identified sand sources meeting FDEP criteria (contingencies were applied to reach a final volume available) FDEP funded an independent technical review of the study. These studies evaluated sand sources that would meet specific Dade BEC-HPP sand criteria and needs that would be both cost effective and environmentally sound. PREFERRED USE OF SAND SOURCES EXISTING DADE ACCRETION SOURCES UPLAND SOURCES OFFSHORE SOURCES (Federal Waters) MAP REFERENCE 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 SOURCE BAKER’S HAULOVER EBB SHOAL LUMMUS PARK (SOUTH BEACH) ORTONA WITHERSPOON ACI MARTIN COUNTY ST. LUCIE COUNTY VOLUME (cubic yards) 30,000 Annually (no less than 10 years between events) 50,000 Annually (no less than 5 years between events) adequate adequate adequate 600,000 4,600,000 DISTANCE FROM PROJECT SITE 4.5 miles south of northern project limit Southern 1.5 miles of project 120 miles 120 miles 35 miles 80 miles 120 miles TRANSPORT Dredge & pipeline Dredge & pipeline Truck haul Truck haul Truck haul Dredge & pipeline Dredge & pipeline 2: All Palm Beach County categories have an additional 25% contingency removed talus content applied in the “Volume Contingency/Confidence” column. 3: Further investigation, project constructions & environmental constraints reduced volumes for Broward and Miami-Dade counties to0 cubic yards. Project 50-year volumes assume placement of scheduled full-sized projects until the end of 2062. Sand sources in the table include known borrow areas in state and federal waters. Renewable sources such as sand dredged from ebb shoals are incorporated by reducing needs. MILESTONE DATE Design Complete February 2016 Contract Advertised March-April 2016 Miami Beach Renourishment Awarded May 2016 NOT TO SCALE

Upload: others

Post on 28-May-2020

1 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Dade County Beach Erosion Control and Hurricane Protection ... Protection/Da… · OVERVIEW. Federal beach nourishment projects are authorized for generally 50-year periods. The Dade

U.S. ARMY CORPS OF ENGINEERS, JACKSONVILLE DISTRICT

For Additional Information, Contact: Jason Harrah, Project Manager | [email protected]

DADE COUNTY BEACH EROSION CONTROL & HURRICANE PROTECTION PROJECTIDENTIFICATION OF ALTERNATIVE SAND SOURCES FOR THE REMAINING PERIOD OF FEDERAL PARTICIPATION

12

3 4

5

6

ST. LUCIE

MARTIN

PALM BEACH

BROWARD

MIAMI-DADE

PROJECTAREA

ST. LUCIE COUNTYOFFSHORE SOURCE 120 miles from

project area ~4,600,000 cubic yards

Dade County beach quality material

MARTIN COUNTY OFFSHORE SOURCE 80 miles from

project area ~600,000 cubic

yards Dade County beach quality material

ORTONA & WITHERSPOONSAND MINES 120 miles

from project area Adequate quantities

of Dade beach quality material

LUMMUS PARK ACCRETION AREA~50,000 cubic yards

accretes annually

ACI SAND MINES 35 miles from project area Adequate quantities of Dade

beach quality material

BAKER’S HAULOVER EBB SHOAL ~30,000 cubic yards

accretes annually

NOT TO SCALE

NLEGEND:

#Potential SAND Study Sources

Dade County BEC-HPP Sand Source Alternatives

7

OVERVIEW

Federal beach nourishment projects areauthorized for generally 50-year periods.The Dade County Beach ErosionControl/Hurricane Protection Project (BEC-HPP) is over halfway through its authorizedperiod of participation and its traditionalsand sources have been substantiallydepleted at this time. Collaborative,proactive efforts over the past 20+ years atthe federal, state, local and private sectorlevels have sought beach compatiblematerial for the project while ensuring thatthe needs of all regional beaches havebeen considered. Recent efforts indicatethere is in excess of 100,000,000 cubicyards of beach quality material availablefor the non-federal and federally-authorized beaches of southeast Floridathrough 2062.Dade County beach renourishment needsthrough its period of participation isestimated to be approximately 3,625,620cubic yards.

PROJECT BACKGROUND

Dade BEC-HPP1970s Pre-nourishment

Dade BEC-HPPPost-Nourishment

HAULOVER BEACH PARK

BAL HARBORSURFSIDE

KEY BISCAYNE

SUNNY ISLES

MIAMI BEACH

BISCAYNEBAY

BOUN

DARY O

F PREVIOUSLY USED BO

RROW

SOURC

E

BAKERS HAULOVER INLET

Broward CountyMiami-Dade County

N

GOVERNMENT CUT

SUNNY ISLES: 2.5 miles OF Sunny Isles Beach Authorized: 1986 Initial Construction: 1988 Remaining Period of Federal Participation: 2015-2038

DADE COUNTY BEC-HPP REMAINING PERIOD OF FEDERAL PARTICIPATION

Sand Needs (cy) Sand Availability (cy) Excess (cy)

County

50-Year Volume Need

50-Year Volume Need +

55% Contingency

2012 Total Volume Available

Per County

Volume + Contingency/ Confidence

Volume after Needs met

St. Lucie 18,017,487 27,927,105 175,847,874 106,149,618 78,222,514Martin 22,111,000 34,272,050 107,593,227 56,160,331 21,888,281Palm Beach 2 45,577,000 70,644,350 191,951,814 117,728,007 47,083,657Broward 3 11,650,000 18,057,500 - - -18,057,500Miami-Dade 3 14,968,300 23,200,865 - - -23,200,865

TOTAL 112,323,787 174,101,870 475,392,915 280,037,956 105,936,086100,000,000

SAND SOURCE INVESTIGATIONS

DADE COUNTY BEC-HPP PROJECTED FUTURE RENOURISHMENT NEEDS

DATE SEGMENT CUBIC YARDSSUNNY ISLES

2016 Sunny Isles 547,330

2026 Sunny Isles 500,000

2036 Sunny Isles 100,000

1,147,330Main Segment

2016 Hot Spots 556,7302017 Surfside 560,4602019 Haulover 90,0002019 Bal Harbor 330,0002019 Non-Hot Spots 606,1002021 Hot Spots 200,0002022 Surfside 135,000

2,478,290

TOTAL 3,625,620

2011 – 2013 SOUTHEAST FLORIDA SEDIMENT ASSESSMENT & NEEDS DETERMINATION STUDY

2015 DADE COUNTY BEC-HPP LIMITED REEVALUATION REPORT AND ENVIRONMENTAL ASSESSMENT

The results of the study indicated that the Southeast region of Florida has excess sand of 100,000,000 cubic yards beyond its 50-year need.

ANTICIPATED UPCOMING CONSTRUCTION SCHEDULE

RESULTS

Renourishment scenario where all 7 sources will potentially be used Offshore sources will be used for large renourishments Upland sources/truck haul will be used for small renourishments Two Miami-Dade sources (Baker’s Haulover and Lummus Park accretional areas) will be used

when sand is available

Beach renourishment has beenproviding essential economic,environmental and recreationalbenefits to coastal communitiesin southeast Florida since the1970s. Renourished beaches anddunes serve as a vital bufferbetween coastal infrastructureand the destructive forces ofocean waves and surge duringstorm events.

MAIN SEGMENT: 9.3 miles from Government Cut to Baker’s Haulover & 1.2 miles of Haulover Beach Park Authorized: 1968 Initial Construction: 1975 Remaining Period of Federal Participation: 2015-2025

The regional investigation, known as the “SAND Study” involved extensive coordination andcollaboration between the Florida Department of Environmental Protection (FDEP), the fivesoutheast Florida counties, the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, and the Bureau of OceanEnergy Management (BOEM) to determine regional sand needs through 2062: Each county determined their own 50-year sand need for federal & non-federal projects. All needs assessments were peer reviewed. Geological investigations identified sand sources meeting FDEP criteria

(contingencies were applied to reach a final volume available) FDEP funded an independent technical review of the study.

These studies evaluated sand sources that would meet specific Dade BEC-HPP sand criteriaand needs that would be both cost effective and environmentally sound.

PREFERRED USE OF SAND SOURCES

EXISTING DADEACCRETION SOURCES

UPLANDSOURCES

OFFSHORESOURCES

(Federal Waters)MAP

REFERENCE 1 2 3 4 5 6 7

SOURCE

BAKER’SHAULOVER

EBBSHOAL

LUMMUSPARK

(SOUTH BEACH)ORTONA WITHERSPOON ACI MARTIN

COUNTY

ST.LUCIE

COUNTY

VOLUME(cubic yards)

30,000Annually

(no less than 10 years between

events)

50,000Annually

(no less than 5 years between

events)

adequate adequate adequate 600,000 4,600,000

DISTANCEFROM PROJECT

SITE

4.5 milessouth of

northern projectlimit

Southern 1.5 milesof project 120 miles 120 miles 35 miles 80 miles 120 miles

TRANSPORT Dredge &pipeline Dredge & pipeline Truck haul Truck haul Truck

haulDredge &pipeline

Dredge & pipeline

2: All Palm Beach County categories have an additional 25% contingency removed talus content applied in the “Volume Contingency/Confidence” column.3: Further investigation, project constructions & environmental constraints reduced volumes for Broward and Miami-Dade counties to0 cubic yards.Project 50-year volumes assume placement of scheduled full-sized projects until the end of 2062.Sand sources in the table include known borrow areas in state and federal waters. Renewable sources such as sand dredged from ebb shoals are incorporated by reducing needs.

MILESTONE DATEDesign Complete February 2016

Contract Advertised March-April 2016

Miami Beach Renourishment Awarded May 2016

NOT TO SCALE