cyst nematodes in equatorial and hot tropical regionsfrom: cyst nemat'qdes edited by f....
TRANSCRIPT
From: CYST NEMAT'QDES Edited by F. Lamberti and C, E. Tayfor (Plenum Publishing Corporation, 1986)
CYST NEMATODES I N EQUATORIAL AND HOT TROPICAL REGIONS
Michel Luc I Musiehm n a t i o n a l d ' H i s t o i r e n a t u r e l l e Labora to i re des Vers, 61 rue de Buffon, 75005 P a r i s France
INTRODUCTION
In the p re sen t communication, t h e term "cys t nematodes i n e q u a t o r i a l and t r o p i c a l reg ionsf t i s used in s t ead of t h e usua l " t r o p i c a l c y s t nematodes" f o r two reasons :
- i n add i t ion to those spec ie s of c y s t nematodes t h a t are c l o s e l y assoc ia ted wi th h o t t r o p i c a l crops and a r e a s , t h e r e are o t h e r s t h a t a r e common i n temperate a r e a s which may a l s o be occas iona l ly found i n t he t r o p i c s ;
- t h e topographical meaning of " i n t e r t r o p i c a l " encompasses some mountainous a r e a s , namely i n Cent ra l and South America, where c l ima te , vege ta t ion and crops are q u i t e similar to those of temperate r eg ions : t hese a r e the "cold t ropics" .
This paper dea l s on ly ,wi th t h e "hot t rop ic s" , and the t e r m " t rop ic s" and f%ropica l f l r e f e r here only t o these c l i m a t i c regions.
Regarding the earliest r eco rds of %"teroderart i n e q u a t o r i a l and t r o p i c a l a r e a s , i t must be kep t i n mind t h a t p r i o r t o Chitwood's (1949) r e s u r r e c t i o n of t h e anc ien t gener ic name MeZoidogyne Goeldi, 1877, t h e genus Hetmodera contained both c y s t forming spec ies of Heteroderidae ( o r Heterodera sensu l a t o ) and var ious r o o t knot spec ies under the name Heterodera marioni (Cornu). i n t he t rop ic s were given wi thout morphological d e t a i l o r d e s c r i p t i o n of symptoms on the h o s t p l a n t , i t i s n o t poss ib l e to determine whether t he spec ies i n ques t ion were MeZoidogyne o r cyst-forming spec ies .
A s most of t h e e a r l y records of "HeterOdt?ra"
Also, t he re a r e numerous records of IlHeterodera-like juven i l e s " i n t h e l i t e r a t u r e concerning t r o p i c a l crops bu t such juveni les may belong t o spec ies of non-cyst forming Heteroderinae genera which a l s o occur i n the t rop ic s . For example, i n the Ivory Coast Heterodera-like juven i l e s were f r equen t ly found i n some a reas of primary o r anc ien t f o r e s t s bu t ex tens ive inves t iga t ion f a i l e d t o f ind c y s t s . Eventually it w a s discovered t h a t these juven i l e s belonged t o a non-cyst forming spec ies of Heteroderinae p r e s e n t on some t r e e s and t h a t they represented a new genus and spec ie s , sub- sequently described under the name of HyZonema ivorense by Luc e t a l . (1978). Therefore records only of TTHe$eroderatl j ____- - -- - _ _ __ --
Q O 10025052
356 M. LUC
The f i r s t r e p o r t of a c y s t nematode a t t ack ing a t r o p i c a l crop i n a t r o p i c a l a r e a concerns sugar cane i n the Hawaiian I s lands (Muir and Henderson, 1926). because the au thors s t a t e d "It is only r e c e n t l y t h a t the two spec ie s * [of ItHeterodera"] have both been recognised i n Hawaiian Islandsll. A d e s c r i p t i o n i s given of t he damage symptoms caused t o t h e h o s t p l a n t by the "two spec ies" and the d i s t i n c t i o n between Heterodera and MeZoidogyne i s c l e a r l y s t a t e d . Concerning Heterodera they say " In sugar cane t h i s nemaode does n d t show a preference f o r t he t i p of r o o t s bu t a t t a c k s them a t any po in t ; ... i t does no t produce a g a l l on the root". c i t e d .
It i s c l e a r t h a t t he re was no confusion with MeZoidogyne
The "brown c y s t stagell is a l s o
Muir and Swezey (1926) a l s o recorded IlHeterodera schachtiill on pine- app le , i n t he Hawaiian I s l ands , bu t here t h e t e x t i s no t a s c l e a r and doubts remain. These two records a r e c i t e d aga in i n a l a t e r paper by Henderson (1926).
The r e p o r t 6f a c y s t nematode on sugar cane was no t considered s e r i o u s l y by subsequent au thors because of the p reva i l i ng thought t h a t c y s t nematodes were t o be found only i n temperate a reas . For example, i n t he compilation by Goodey (19561, t h i s record i s c i t e d as 1IHet. schacht i i = ? Mel. sp . l t .
This ItHeterodera" has n o t been r epor t ed again in Hawaiian sugar cane p l a n t a t i o n s and thus the spec ie s , and perhaps the genus, remain unknown. However, I consider t h a t it probably was n o t H . sehacht ic , as sugar cane has been shown t o be a non-host f o r t h i s spec ie s (Skarbilovich and Kurramov, 1473).
Th i r ty f i v e years l a t e r , Luc (1961) repor ted two t r o p i c a l Heterodera s p e c i e s , one p a r a s i t i s i n g swamp r i c e i n t h e Ivory Coast and the o t h e r sugar cane i n the Congo. They were described as H . oryzae Luc & Berdon - Br izue la , 1961 and H . sacehari Luc & Merny, 1963 and t h i s c l e a r l y e s t ab l i shed t h a t c y s t nematodes could occur i n the t rop ic s . Subsequently s e v e r a l o the r spec ies have been described from t r o p i c a l crops and weeds. Never the less , it appears t h a t t h e cyst-forming nematodes a r e not as common nor as numerous, and probably n o t a s economically important, i n t h e t r o p i c s as they are i n temperate a reas .
GENUS HETERODERA Schmidt, 1871
Heterodera oryzae Luc & Berdon-Brizuela, 1961
H . oryzae w a s repor ted from swamp rice f i e l d s a t Bokakouamekro i n the c e n t r a l p a r t of the Ivory Coast (Luc and Berdon-Brizuela, 1981). This s p e c i e s , of t he schacht i i group, i s cha rac t e r i s ed mainly by the presence of a voluminous egg-mass, a t t ached t o t h e c y s t , which o f t e n conta ins more eggs than the c y s t i t s e l f . The o r i g i n a l d e s c r i p t i o n has been supplemented by Luc and Taylor (1977).
*Prior to t he beginning of 1928, only two spec ies of IIHeterodera~l were recognised: H . sdkacht i i Schmidt ( the cyst-forming spec ie s ) and H . marioni (Cornu) ( t h e r o o t knot spec ie s ) . A t h i r d spec ie s , H . javanieu Treub, 1885, a l s o e x i s t e d bu t a s it was described from an exo t i c h o s t p l a n t ( sugar cane) and from a t r o p i c a l country (Indonesia) l i t t l e a t t e n t i o n w a s given to it a t t h a t t i m e .
,. . . r
CYST NEMATODES IN EQUATORIAL AND HOT TROPICAL REGIONS 357
The r o l e of t he egg-mass i n r e l a t i o n t o population dynamics has been s tudied (Merny, 1966; Merny, 1972a, Reversa t , 1975d). Juveni les i n the egg- mass ha tch immediately without need of a s t imu la t ion by r o o t exudates and t h i s enables two o r t h ree genera t ions t o develop on the same r i c e p l a n t (Merny, 1972a). This ready ha tch ing of egg-masses f a c i l i t a t e s t h e c u l t u r e of the nematode, even under monoxenic condi t ions (Reversat , 1975a). Thus H. oryzae has been used t o examine var ious aspec ts of the biology of Heterodera such as ovigenesis and reproduct ion , which does no t d i f f e r from other amphimictic spec ies of t h e genus (Netscher, 1969); h i s topa thology of a t tacked roo t s (Berdon-Brizuela and Merny, 1964); f a c t o r s in f luenc ing the sex r a t i o and sex determination (Cadet e t a l . , 1975; Cadet and Merny, 1978a); gene t ic f a c t o r s r e l a t e d t o the length of j uven i l e s (Netscher and Pernes , 1971) ; production of a r t i f i c i a l mutants (Cadet, 1976) ; f a c t o r s in f luenc ing pene t r a t ion by the juven i l e s (Reversat and Merny, 1973; Cadet and Merny, 1976; Merny and Cadet, 1978); chemical composition of j uven i l e s (Reversa t , 1977a); oxygen uptake by j u v e n i l e s (Reversat , 1975c; 1977b) and t h e i r su rv iva l (Reversat , 19801, p a r t i c u l a r l y i n anaerobic condi t ions (Reversat , 197513).
The spec ies i s known only from some swamp a reas i n the Ivory Coast (Merny, 19701, and i n Senegal where it p a r a s i t i s e s banana t r e e s (Taylor , 1978). Reports of H . oryzae from Japan (Hashioka, 1964; Shimizu, 1971, 1972, 1973; Nishizawa e t a l . , 1972) r e f e r t o a d i f f e r e n t spec ie s , descr ibed by Ohshima (1974) as H . e lachis ta . However, t he two spec ies appear t o be c lose ly r e l a t e d and t h e i r r e l a t i o n s h i p s r equ i r e f u r t h e r study.
I n add i t ion t o r i c e and banana, few o the r p l a n t s have been shown t o be hos ts . Maize and Mariscus wnbellatus a r e suscep t ib l e (Merny and Cadet, 1978) whereas sugar cane, Sorghum uuZgare, Pennisetwn typhoides and Panicum maximum a r e n o t , and l a rge d i f f e rences between var ious r i c e c u l t i v a r s have been observed (Merny and Cadet, 1978). could expla in the l imi ted d i s t r i b u t i o n of t h e spec ies . I t is a l s o l imi t ed i n flooded r i c e f i e l d s by competit ion with H. sacchari; experiments wi th juven i l e s marked with 35 have shown t h a t H. oryzae i s much l e s s aggress ive than H. sacchari (Reversat and Bois , 1982).
This r e l a t i v e l y narrow h o s t range
s
Heterodera sacchari Luc & Merny, 1963
H. sacchari, of the schacht i i group, w a s o r ig ina sugar cane ' in the Niari Val ley , Congo (Luc and Merny, subseqúently been repor ted from t h e Ivory Coast where been found i n flooded r i c e f i e l d s i n the nor thern and
l y described from 1963). I t has it has f r equen t ly c e n t r a l reg ions
and wi ld g ra s ses (Merny, 19701, i n Niger ia on sugar cane ( J e r a t h , 1968 (Odih i r in , 19751, i n flooded r i c e f i e l d s of Casamance Province, Senegal and i n Gambia (Fortuner and Merny, 1973) and on sugar cane i n Burkina Faso (Cadet and Merny, 1978b). The spec ie s is a l s o repor ted t o have been found on Saccharum spontaneum i n Ind ia (Swarup e t a l . , 1964).
I n addi t ion t o sugar cane and r i c e , var ious wild Graminaceae a r e considered a s hos t s by Odih i r in (1975): PaspaZum eonjugatum, Axonopus compressus, Mariscus umbellatus, Cynodon dactylon, Eleusine indica and Brachiaria brizantha. Odihi r in (1975) considers t h a t H. sacchmi i s indigenous i n Niger ia and w h i l s t I agree I a l s o th ink t h a t t h e a rea of d i s t r i b u t i o n is probably wider than ind ica ted by present r epor t s .
The morphology of H. sacchari has been described and t h e o r i g i n a l desc r ip t ion was supplemented by Luc (1974). The major d i agnos t i c charac te r of the spec ies i s a very dark , s t rong ly developed underbridge
358 M. LUC
of the female c y s t which has f inge r - l i ke p ro jec t ions . The apparent ly non- func t iona l male has been descr ibed by Netscher e t al . (1969). (1969) has shown t h a t H . sacchari i s a t r i p l o i d par thenogenet ic spec ies .
Netscher
The hatching of juveni les from c y s t s i s similar i n sugar cane r o o t d i f f u s a t e and tap water (GarabKdian and Hague, 1984) but Riversa t (1981) has found potassium permangate t o be u s e f u l as a hatching agent. Aldicarb, oxamyl and carbofuran prevent hatching from c y s t s but t h i s e f f e c t i s decreased by the addi t ion of sugar cane r o o t d i f f u s a t e (Garabedian and Hague, 1984). 8
J e r a t h (1968) observed t h a t i n fe s t ed sugar cane p l a n t s a r e s tun ted and t h i n , and secondary roo t s a r e less abundant than hea l thy p lan ts . In sugar cane p l a n t a t i o n s , c y s t s of H. sacchari may be t ranspor ted by the water i n i r r i g a t i o n cana ls f o r a t l e a s t 5 to 8 km (Odih i r in , 1977).
i
On r i c e , experiments show (Babatola , 1983a) t h a t i n fe s t ed p l a n t s a r e c h l o r o t i c and t h e i r growth r e t a rded , r o o t s are nec ro t i c and blackened, t i l l e r numbers a r e reduced and the g r a i n y i e ld i s lower. H. sacchari a t t a c k s both swamp and upland r i c e b u t the l a t te r appears more suscep t ib l e to damage (Babatola , 198313). Rice c u l t i v a r s r e a c t very d i f f e r e n t l y . t o in fe s t a - t i o n by the nematode (Babatola , 1983b).
I n western areas of Af r i ca , H. sacchari may c o n s t i t u t e a danger f o r sugar cane, and both upland and swamp r ice . F o l i a r app l i ca t ions of oxamyl have been shown experimental ly t o prevent invasion of young sugar cane p l a n t s (Garabedian and Hague, 1982) but f i e l d tr ials have no t been reported.
H. cyperi Golden, Rau & Cobb, 1963
H. cyperi was f i r s t found i n f e s t i n g Cyperms escuZentus a t Sanford, F l o r i d a , USA, and w a s descr ibed by Golden e t a l . (1963). known and i t s d i s t r i b u t i o n w a s thought t o be l imi ted to two coun t r i e s i n F lo r ida and one i n Gèorgia (Mulvey and Golden, 1983). Recently, however, Kumar (1980) recorded it on Cynodon dactyZon and Bambusa sp. i n a cof fee e s t a t e , i n Karnataka, India . Eroshenko and Kazachenko (1972) considere'd it t o be a spec ies inquirenda, but t he re does not seem s u f f i c i e n t reason f o r t h i s .
No o the r hos t was
Heterodera mothi Khan & Husain, 1965
H. mothi; found on Cypems rotundus, w a s t he f i r s t c y s t nematode Cysts of t h i s spec ie s , descr ibed from India (Khan and Husain, 1965).
which is of the goettingiana group, a r e cha rac t e r i s ed by the th inness of t h e i r c u t i c l e , the prominence of the a n a l a r e a , and the . s l ende rness of the vu lva l br idge. b r idge i s r a r e l y present . An egg-sac has been observed (Khan and J a i r a j p u r i , 1975).
Mulvey (1972) emphasised the f a c t t h a t the under-
Sharma and Swarup (1984) s t a t e t h a t t h i s spec ies reproduces only on the type h o s t whereas o ther records a r e from Chrysanthemum carinatum and Hibiscus syria'cus i n India (Yaqoob and Khan, 1969); Cyperus escuZentus, GZyCine m u , GOSSypiUm hirsutum, i n Georgia, USA (Minton e t a l . , 1973); i n s o i l from sugar-beet f i e l d s i n I r an (Tala t sch ian and Achyani, 1976); sugar cane (Maqbool, 1981) and onion ,(Maqbool e t a l . , 1983) i n Pakis tan ; and c y s t s i n s o i l a t V i t i Levu, F i j i I s l ands (Kirby e t a l . , 1978).
',
CYST NEMATODES IN EQUATORIAL AND HOT TROPICAL REGIONS 359
Sharma and Swarup (1984) gave information on the morphometrics and l i f e cyc le of H . mothi but nothing i s known about i t s pathogenici ty .
H . indocyperi Husain & Khan fi Khan e t a l . , 1964 ( c i t e d by Hesl ing, 1978) i s considered by Hesling t o be a nomen nudum and a synonym of H . mothi.
Heterodera cajani Koshy, 1967 (= H . V igni Edward & Misra, 1968)
This spec ie s , of the schacht i i group, was f i r s t reported under the name of H . t r i f o z i i i n a pigeon-pea f i e l d of t he I A R I a t New Delhi , Ind ia (Swarup e t a l . , 1964). It w a s descr ibed l a t e r as H. cajani by Koshy (1967). H . v i g n i descr ibed from r o o t s of Vigna unguicuzata by Edward and Misra (1968) has been recognised (Kalha and Edward, 1979) as a jun io r synonym of H . cajani.
H. cajani is the most widespread cyst-forming nematode i n India and has been reported i n the s t a t e s of Andhra Pradesh, Bihar , Delhi , Haryana, Rajasthan. Tamil Nadu and Uttar Pradesh (Sharma and Swarup, 1984). The . . spec ie s has a l s o been repor ted on cowpea i n Egypt (Aboul-Eid and Ghorab, 1974).
i'
On the bas i s of f i e l d observa t ions and experiments by var ious au thors (Koshy, 1967; Koshy and Swarup, 1972; B h a t t i and Gupta, 1973; Janarthanan, 1972; Verma and Yadav, 1975; Gaur and Sing, 1977) the following h o s t p l a n t s have been e s t ab l i shed : Cajanus cajan, Cicer arietinwn, Cyamopsis te t ra- gonoloba, DoZichos bifZorus, D. ZabZab, GZycine max, PhaseoZus atro- purpureus, P. aureus, P. caZcaratus, P. Zathyroides, P. Zunatus, P. mungo, P. vulgar is , P i s w n sativwn, Sesamwn indicum, S. orientaze, V i v i a narabenesis cv. sa t iva , Vigna s inens is and Zea mays. t he l as t spec ie s , a l l these h o s t p l a n t s belong t o Leguminosae o r Pedal iaceae. Koshy and Swarup (1972) e s t ab l i shed t h a t 82 crop and weed spec ie s were non-hosts including Cyamopsis tetragonoloba, GZycine max, Phaseozus CaZcaratus, P i swn sativwn cv. Ear ly Wisconsin and seve ra l V i c i a spec ie s . Koshy e t a l . (1971) and Sharma and Swarup (1984). The biology of H . cajani i s s i m i l a r t o o the r Heterodera spec ies . Host r eac t ions have been descr ibed by Aboul-Eid and Ghorab (1974) and the l i f e cyc le by Koshy and Swarup (1971a.l. More than nine generat ions per year have been repor ted (Koshy and Swarup, 1971b). The hatching of j uven i l e s from cys t s and egg-masses i s opt imal a t 29°C; r o o t leacha tes of Cajanus cajan and DoZichos ZabZab have a p o s i t i v e e f f e c t ; hatching of j uven i l e s from egg-masses a t 20 days i s 100 pe r cen t i n c o n t r a s t t o only 16 per cen t from brown c y s t s (Koshy and Swarup, 1971d). The presence of egg-masses, and the rap id hatching of j u v e n i l e s , expla ins the high number of genera t ions observed. I t has a l s o been observed t h a t H. cajani may a t t a c k the a e r i a l p a r t s of young seedl ings of pigeon-pea (Koshy and Swarup, 1971e).
With the exception. of
The o r ig ina1 ,desc r ip t ion of the spec ies has been supplemented by
Although the re i s no p rec i se da t a on the damage t o crop p l an t s caused by H. cajani , it must be considered a dangerous spec ies . Its presence i n Egypt shows t h a t it could become es t ab l i shed i n t r o p i c a l , sub t rop ica l and even Mediterranean count r ies .
Heterodera graminis Stynes, 1971
H . graminis w a s descr ibed from r o o t s of Cynodon daetyzon on a bowling green a t New Castle, New South Wales, A u s t r a l i a (Stynes, 1971). spec ie s has r ecen t ly been recorded on undetermined spec ies of grasses on
The
360 M. LUC
a gol f course a t Delh i , Rajasthan, Ind ia (Sharma and Swarup, 1984) and has been found i n s o i l a t Vanua Levu, F i j i I s lands (Kirby e t a l . 1978) and on Cynodon dactylon i n a sugar cane p l an ta t ion i n Trinidad (Stone, i n l i t t . ) .
H . graminis is of t he goe t t inghna group, and appears t o be c lose ly r e l a t e d t o H . cyperi.
In po t experiments H . graminis reproduced on Setaria i t a l i c a , Secale cereale and maize (Sharma and Swarup, 1984). Nothing i s known about i t s pa thogenic i ty but h o s t p l an t s w e r e descr ibed as yellowish and s tun ted (Kirby e t a l . , 1978; Sharma and Swarup, 1984). Data on t h e l i f e c y c l e a r e given by Sharma and Swarup (1984).
i Heterodera zeae Koshy, Swarup & S e t h i , 1971
This spec ies of t h e schacht i i group w a s described from specimens found i n a s soc ia t ion wi th maize a t Chapl i , Rajasthan, Ind ia (Koshy e t a l . , 1971). Surveys showed t h a t H . zeae i s widely d i s t r i b u t e d throughout India and i n t h e following s t a t e s : Andhra Pradesh, Bihar , Delh i , Gujara t , Madhya Pradesh, Punjab, Rajasthan, Uttar Pradesh (Koshy and Swarup, 1 9 7 1 ~ ) and Karnataka (Narayanaswamy, e t a l . , 1982). Subsequently i t was recorded i n Pakis tan (Maqbool, 1981), i n Egypt (Ote i f a , unpublished r e p o r t , 19781, and i n the USA (Sa rdane l l i e t a l . , 1981). H . zeae i s considered t o be one of t he most economically important nematodes a t t ack ing c e r e a l s i n Ind ia (Sharma and Swarup, 1984).
In add i t ion t o the o r i g i n a l desc r ip t ion , d a t a on morphology and morphometries have been repor ted from Indian populations by Sharma and Swarup (1984) and f o r American popula t ions by Golden and Mulvey (1983). Hutzel1 (1984) has r e c e n t l y descr ibed t h e m a l e . provide some information on the biology of t he spec ies b u t t he re has been no published information on pa thogenic i ty . Hosts recorded f o r H. zeae inc lude seve ra l c u l t i v a r s of Zea mays, (Misra e t a l . , 19771, Echinochloa cozona, Panicum spp., Setaria italics and Tri t icum aestivum. (Sr ivas tava and Swarup, 1975; Sharma and Swarup, 1984) t h e following p l a n t s have been found suscep t ib l e t o H . zeae: Oryza sa t iva; Secale cereale , Sorghum vulgare, Zea mexicana, Avena sa t ivaand Hordeum vulgare. vulgare w a s , however, considered r e s i s t a n t by Sr ivas tava and Swarup (1975) a s were Paspaluni spp. and Pennisetuni typhoidem. Maqbool (1981) r epor t ed non-graminaceous c rops (gram, c i t r u s , pea r , g a r l i c ) a s h o s t s , bu t it i s n o t c l e a r i f c y s t s were found on t h e r o o t s of these p l an t s o r i n the surround- ing s o i l .
Sharma and Swarup (1984)
Experimentally
Sorghum
Heterodera gaembiensis Merny & Netscher, 1976
Heterodera gambiensis, belonging t o the schacht i i group, has been repor ted on Sorghum vulgare and Pennisetum typhoideum i n var ious loca t ions i n Gambia, West Af r i ca (Merny and Netscher, 1976). Su rp r i s ing ly , i n the b
Senegalese reg ions surrounding Gambia, ex tens ive surveys f a i l e d t o l o c a t e t h i s spec ies . It has , however, r e c e n t l y been recorded on Eleusine caracana i n Karnataka, Ind ia (Narayaswamy e t a l . , 1982). There i s no information on the biology, hos t range o r pa thogenic i ty of the spec ies .
Heterodera oryzicoza Rao &,Jayaprakash , 1978
This spec ies of t he schacht i i group is known only from upland r i c e i n Kerala S t a t e , Ind ia (Ra0 and Jayaprakash, 1978). Although it has been observed t o pene t r a t e t he r o o t s of s eve ra l graminaceous p l a n t s , according
CYST NEMATODES IN EQUATORIAL AND HOT TROPICAL REGIONS 36 1
t o Sharma and Swarup (1984) cys t s are produced only on r i c e , mainly on the c u l t i v a r s J aya , Ratna and T (N)-l.
H . oryzieoZa causes s tun t ing and ch lo ros i s of leaves (Rao and Jayaprakash, 1977) and f i e l d experiments i nd ica t e y i e ld lo s ses of 21-42 per cent (Usha and Kurien, 1981).
Morphologically H . oryzicola i s very c lose t o H . oryzae, from which i t d i f f e r s mainly i n var ious measurements of t he s t y l e t and sp icu le s , and length of t he hya l ine terminal p a r t of t a i l of t he second s t age juven i l e (Bao and Jayaprakash, 1978). Sharma and Swarup (1984) provide add i t iona l morphometric d a t a and information on the l i f e cyc le .
Heterodera deZvii J a i r a j p u r i , Khan, Se t ty & Govindu, 1979
This s p e c i e s , belonging t o the goettingiana group, w a s descr ibed from I1ragiv1 (Eleusine coracana) i n Bangalore, Karnataka, Ind ia ( J a i r a j p u r i , 1979). var ious EchinochZoa spec ie s , Sorghum vulgare, maize, p e a r l m i l l e t , f i nge r m i l l e t , Setar ia i t a z i c a , wheat and Pan?hm miliaceum.
Other hos t s repor ted by Krishna Prasad e t a l . (1980) include
H . dezv i i i s c lose t o H . eyperi , H . mothi and H . graminis, but d i f f e r s mainly i n the s t r u c t u r e of the underbridge which shows a subci rcu lar mass a t tached t o i ts c e n t r e ; t h i s is absent i n the o the r spec ies . No informa- t i o n is a v a i l a b l e on the biology and the pa thogenic i ty of t h i s spec ies . It i s not known ou t s ide the type loca t ion , and at tempts t o f ind it again a t t h i s s i t e have been unsuccessful (Sharma and Swarup, 1984).
Heterodera sorghi J a i n , S e t h i , Swarup & Sr ivas t ava , 1982
This spec ie s , of the schacht i i group, has been found on Sorghum vulgar@ a t Raispur , Utah Pradesh, Ind ia ( J a i n e t a l . , 1982); it has a l s o been recorded, without i nd ica t ion of h o s t , a t Hayatpur, Haryana S ta te (Dhawan e t a l . , 1983). I n pot experiments H . sorghi reproduced on EchinocZoa colona, Eleusine caracana, Se tar ia i ta ' l i ea , Paspazwn scrobiculatum. and Swarup, 1984).
Zea mays, Cypems rotundus and Ponnisetwn typhoides (Sharma
H . sorghi is cha rac t e r i s ed by a very t h i c k , prominent and dark brown underbridge. Sharma and Swarup (1984) bu t nothing i s known about i t s pathogenici ty .
Data on morphometrics and l i f e cyc le have been provided by
Heterodera r a s k i i Basnet & Jayaprakash, 1984
H. r a s k i i w a s r e c e n t l y descr ibed from Hyderabad, Ind ia , on CypeWS bulbosus Vab., which i s p re sen t ly the only known h o s t (Basnet and Jayaprakash, 1984). It is i n the goettingiana group and considered t o be c lose t o H . cyper i Golden e t a l . , 1962. Cysts are very elongated, somewhat resembling those of Doliehodera Mulvey & Ebsary, 1980. Nothing i s known about pa thogenic i ty o r hos t -pa ras i t e r e l a t ionsh ips .
Other Heterodera spec ies
Heterodera schacht i i Schmidt, 1871: This t y p i c a l l y temperate spec ies has been recorded itl Western Tropical Afr ica i n two loca t ions c lose t o each o ther . In Senegal , H . schacht i i -was found i n a s m a l l vegetable garden i n the cen t r e of Dakar, where it caused damage t o bee t s and cabbage (Luc and Netscher, 1974); ex tens ive surveys i n the surrounding area were negat ive.
362 M. LUC
It w a s recorded l a t e r i n Banjul , Gambia, a l so on bee ts (Bridge and Manser, 1980). with rooted p l a n t s and i s n o t considered to pres-ent a danger t o crops i n Senegal and Gambia.
In both cases , H . schachtii w a s probably introduced from Europe
Heterodera graminophiZa Golden & Birch f i e ld , 1972: Although found by Golden and B i rch f i e ld (1972) ou t s ide of a s t r i c t l y t r o p i c a l area (Louis iana. USA), H . graminophiza i s c i t e d here as B i rch f i e ld - ( l973) s t a t e d t h a t the spec ies "may not be n a t i v e t o the USA s ince the hos t p l a n t , EchinochZoa cozona and o ther c l o s e l y r e l a t e d forms, a r e cu l t i va t ed i n t r o p i c a l A s i a and Afr ica f o r food". H . graminophiza w a s s a id by B i rch f i e ld (1973) t o be a typ ica l of the genus because of t h e absence of g i a n t c e l l s a t the feeding po in t wi th in the hos t roo t : the females feed i n tlie pe r i cyc le and phloem t i s s u e s of the h o s t ; no g a l l i n g of r o o t t i s s u e s and no f o l i a g e symptoms occurred. B i rch f i e ld (1973) considered it an example of a well-balanced hos t -pa ras i t e system, poss ib ly ind ica t ive of a very o ld p a r a s i t e r e l a t ionsh ip .
'
Other hos t s a r e r i c e and SOPghwn hatepense.
H. graminophiza belongs t o the goettingiana group, and is c lose t o H . cyperi and H . graminis.
Heterodera avenae Wollenweber, 1924: This i s a cosmopolitan spec ies present i n some w a r m p a r t s of t he world. It has been a s soc ia t ed with severe d iseases i n Ind ia known as llmolyatl. Many Indian pub l i ca t ions r e f e r t o H . avenue but it occurs only on temperate c e r e a l s such as bar ley and wheat. On the con t r a ry , t r o p i c a l c e r e a l s such as EchinochZoa coZona, Sorghum vuzgare, EZeusine coracana, Oryza sa t iva , Setaria italica, Zea mays a r e non-hosts ( G i l l and Swarup, 1971; Sharma and Swarup, 1984). Thus s t r i c t l y H . avenue does n o t qua l i fy as a t r o p i c a l c y s t nematode.
Heterodera chaubattia Gupta & Edward, 1973: This spec ie s was found i n the s o i l of an orchard. a t Chaubat t ia . Uttah Pradesh. Ind ia (Guota and . L
Edward, 1973). This is the only r e p o r t and Sharma and Swarup (1984) f a i l e d t o red iscover the nematode. a t the type l o c a l i t y . Moreover types are apparent ly n o t a v a i l a b l e f o r study and thus taking i n t o account the . discrepancies and lack of information i n the o r i g i n a l d e s c r i p t i o n , Sharma and Swarup (1984) considered H . chaubattia to be a spec ies inquirenda.
GENUS CACTODERA K r a l l 6 K r a l l , 1979
Cactodera cacti ( F i l i p j . & Sch. Stekh. , 1941) K r a l l & K r a l l , 1979
This spec ies w a s repor ted on Echinopsis spp. i n Mysore, Ind ia (Kumar, 1964); the nematode could have been introduced with the h o s t p l a n t , which i s an ornamental.
Cactodera amaranthi (Stoyanov, 1972) Krall & Kral l , 1969
This spec ies w a s descr ibed by Stoyanov (1972) as Heterodera amaranthi from roo t s of Amaranthus v ir idis growing i n experimental f i e l d s a t Sant iago de las Vegas, near Hayana, Cuba. Heavy i n f e s t a t i o n of the hos t w a s repor ted . It w a s found e a r l i e r i n F lor ida by G. J. Rau (unpublished r e p o r t , 1957). Golden and Raski (1978) who a l s o s tudied the d i f f e r e n t s t a g e s of the nematode.
Details of t h i s and subsequent f ind ing a r e given by
Hosts a r e l imi ted t o spec ies of Amaranthus (A. v i r id i s , A. spinosus, A. r e t r o f z e x u s ) . The d i s t r i b u t i o n includes Cuba, Mexico, and the USA
CYST NEMATODES IN EQUATORIAL AND HOT TROPICAL REGIONS 363
(F lo r ida , Colorado, I l l i n o i s , Kansas, Missouri , Tennessee) according t o Mulvey and Golden (1983). However, Reis (1982) r epor t ed a c y s t forming spec ies "c lose ly resembling" G. maranth i and heavi ly p a r a s i t i s i n g Amaran thus putulus i n a c i t r u s orchard near Maputo, Mozambique. Thus, t h e d i s t r i b u t i o n of t h i s spec ies may be r a t h e r wide.
GENUS GLOBODERA Skarb i lovich , 1959
4 (Stone, 1973) Behrens, 1975
The pota to c y s t nematodes have been repor ted i n t r o p i c a l coun t r i e s bu t only on r a r e occasions. The f i r s t r e p o r t i s t h a t of Tiago (1956) i n Mozambique; bu t a t t h a t t i m e t h e r e p o r t w a s considered ques t ionable . Ind ia , G. rostochiensis and/or G. pazzida a r e considered t o be se r ious p e s t s of po ta toes i n t h e N i l g i r i s reg ion , which i s a h i l l y p a r t of Madras S t a t e and does n o t have a t r o p i c a l c l imate (Seshadri and Sivakumar, 1962; Prasad and Chawla, 1965; Logisvaran and Menon, 1969). (1983) r e p o r t t he presence of both spec ies i n T a m i l Nadu S t a t e , t h e southernmost s ta te of Ind ia and t r o p i c a l . G. rostochiensis had a l s o been recorded i n South A f r i c a , where i t s d i s t r i b u t i o n appears t o be r e s t r i c t e d t o t h e Transvaal (Kleynhans, personal communication).
In
Sharma and Swarup
Apparently, G. rostochiensis and G. pazzida are n o t adapted t o the t r o p i c s ; they may su rv ive i n some loca t ions ( a s does H. schachtii) bu t they do n o t pose as severe a t h r e a t t o pota to crops i n h o t t r o p i c a l a r eas as do var ious root-knot nematode spec ies .
GENUS AFENESTRATA Baldwin & B e l l , 1985
Afmestrata africana (Luc, Germani & Netscher, 1973) Baldwin & B e l l , 1985)
A. africana w a s descr ibed by Luc e t a l . (1973) as t h e second spec ie s of Sarisodera Wouts & Sher, 1971, as the two spec ies apparent ly shared seve ra l important cha rac t e r s inc luding t h e presence of c y s t s devoid of f e n e s t r a and a p e c u l i a r vu lva l cone formed by t h e hypertrophied and very pro tuberant vu lva l l i p s . hydrophiza Wouts & Sher , 1971, by Baldwin and B e l l (1985) l ed these au thors t o cons ider t h a t t h e females do n o t transform i n t o c y s t s ; consequently, they e rec t ed the genus A f e n e s t r a t a (without c y s t s ) .
Restudy of t he type spec ie s , Sarisodera
(with c y s t s ) , d i s t i n c t from Sarisodera
Morphology, caryology (n = 9 , as i n many Heteroderinae) and h i s to logy of t h e syncytium produced by A. africana are wel l documented (Luc e t a l . , 1973; Taylor and Luc, 1979; Baldwin and B e l l , 1985). The only repor ted h o s t i s Guinea g r a s s Panicum m a x i m w n , and the only l o c a t i o n i s the type l o c a l i t y - Experimental F i e l d s , ORSTOM Centre, Adiopodoume near Abidjan, Ivory Coast. However, A. africana came from Kenya, East Af r i ca and the loca t ion i n the Experimental F i e l d s where the nematode w a s found had been p lan ted wi th rooted seedl ings of Guinea g ras s obtained by p l a n t breeders during an expedi t ion i n Kenya.
Because of t h i s no f u r t h e r i nves t iga t ions of A. africana have been .undertaken and the o r i g i n a l f i e l d w a s t r e a t e d wi th a nemat ic ide , then p lan ted wi th a non-graminaceous crop. t r a n s f e r r e d t o a greenhouse a t the Nematology Laboratory, ORSTOM Cent re , t o be used only f o r taxonomic o r anatomical s tud ie s .
A population of A. ajcricana was
364 M. LUC
CONCLUSION
This paper somewhat resembles a catalogue and it i s d i f f i c u l t t o s epa ra t e i n t o sec t ions . Nevertheless , t h e following t e n t a t i v e c o l l e c t i v e conclusions can be made:
- with a few except ions , among the genera of cyst-forming Heteroderinae found i n temperate c l ima tes , only spec ies pe r t a in ing t o the genus Heterodera have been repor ted i n the ho t t r o p i c a l c l imates ;
- the twelve Heterodera spec ies considered he re in as t rop ' ical belong t o only two groups of the genus: the schacht i i group foryzae, sacehari, cajani , zeae, gamgiensis, oryzicola and SOPghi), and the goettingiana group (cyper i , mothi, graminis, deZvii and r a s k i i ) ;
- a l l these spec ies with the except ion of H . mothi and H . cajani show a c l e a r h o s t p reference f o r graminaceous p l a n t s ; s e v e r a l of them have been descr ibed from, o r experimental ly r a i sed on, r i c e b u t it must be kept i n mind t h a t r i c e i s the most c u l t i v a t e d c e r e a l i n the t r o p i c s , and con- sequent ly the most f requent ly sampled;
- these spec ie s , with a few except ions , have been repor ted only i n West Afr ica and i n Ind ia but t h i s could n o t be considered conclusive i n r e l a t i o n t o geographical d i s t r i b u t i o n because the re a r e no negat ive r epor t s from o the r t r o p i c a l p a r t s of t he world;
- cur ren t ly , on ly the genus Afenestrata can be considered as s t r i c t l y t r o p i c a l ;
- with the l imi t ed information on t h e biology of these spec ie s , i t can be s t a t e d t h a t t h e optimal temperature f o r hatching i s r a t h e r high, and there a r e seve ra l generat ions per year , t h i s being co r re l a t ed i n seve ra l spec ies with the presence of a voluminous egg-mass a t tached t o the c y s t ;
- as f a r as p resen t research observat ions permi t , i t may be assumed t h a t only H . ca jani , H . oryzicola, H . zeae and t o some e x t e n t H. sacchari a r e dangerous spec ie s ;
- c y s t forming Heteroderinae appear less important i n t r o p i c a l c l imates than i n temperate a reas but research on the group should no t be neglected because of t h e i r presence on var ious important c rops , p a r t i c u l a r l y ce rea l s .
REFERENCES
Aboul-Eid, H.Z. and Ghorab, A . I . , 1974, Pa thologica l e f f e c t s of Heterodera cajani on cow pea, P1. D i s . Reptr., 58:1130.
Babatola, J . O . , 1983a, Pathogenici ty of Heterodera sacchari on r i c e , Nematol. medi t . , 11:21.
Babatola, J . O . , 1983b, Rice c u l t i v a r s and Heterodera sacehari, Nematol. medi t . , 11:103.
CYST NEMATODES IN EQUATORIAL AND HOT TROPICAL REGIONS 365
Baldwin, J . G . and B e l l , A.H., 1985, Cactodera eremica n.sp., Afenestrata africana (Luc e t a l . , 1974) n.gen., n-comb., and an emended d iagnos is of Sarisodera Wouts and Sher , 1971 (Heteroderidae) , J. Nematol., 1 7 : 18 7.
Basnet, C.P. and Jayaprakash, A., 1984, Heterodera r a s k i i n.sp. (Heteroderidae: Tylenchina) , a c y s t nematode on grass from Hyderabad, Indian J . Nematol., 16:213.
Berdon-Brizuela, R. and Merny, G . , 1984, Biologie d'Heterodera oryzae Luc & Berdon-Brizuela, 1961. I. Cycle du p a r a s i t e e t r eac t ions h is to logiques de l ' h ô t e , Revue Pathol . veg. Entom. ag r i c . Fr . , 43:43.
B h a t t i , D.S. and Gupta, D.C., 1973, Guar, an add i t iona l h o s t of Heterodera cajani, Indian J . Nematol., 3:160.
B i rch f i e ld , W . , 1973, Pathogenesis and hos t p a r a s i t e r e l a t i o n s of t h e c y s t nematode Heterodera graminophiza on g ras ses , Phytopathology, 63:38.
Bridge, J. and Manser, P.D., 1980, The bee t c y s t nematode i n t r o p i c a l Afr ica , P l . D i s . , 64:1036.
Cadet, P . , 1977, Obtention de mutants morphologiques chez l e nématode Heterodera oryyzae p a r a s i t e du r i z , Cah. ORSTOM Se'r. B io l . , 11 (1976): 143.
Cadet P. and Merny, G . , 1977, Methode d f é t u d e de l a pëné t r a t ion e t du développement des deux sexes chez l e s Heterodera (Nematoda: Tylenchida) , Cah. ORSTOM Se'r. Biol . , 11 (1976): 151.
Cadet P. and Merny, G . , 1978a, Inf luence of some f a c t o r s on sex - ra t io i n Heterodera oryzae and H . sacehari (Nematode: Heteroder idae) , Revue Nématol., 1:143.
Cadet, P. and Merny, G . , 1978b, Premiers e s s a i s de t ra i tements chimiques cont re l e s nématodes p a r a s i t e s de l a canne a sucre en Haute Vol ta , Revue Nématol., 1 3 3 .
Cadet P . , Reversat , G. and Merny, G., 1975, Facteurs a f f e c t a n t l e déterminisme du sexe chez Heterodera oryzae (Nematode: Tylenchoidea), Cah. ORSTOM S é r . Bio l . , 10:207.
Chitwood, B.G., 1949, Root-knot nematodes. P a r t 1. A r e v i s i o n of t he MeZoidogyne Goeldi , 1887, Proc. helminth. Soc. Wash., 16:90.
Dhawan, S .C. , Kaushal, K.K. and Sr ivas tava , A.N., 1983, Record of occurrence of Heterodera sorghi from Haryana S t a t e , I n d i a , Indian J. Nematol., U:241.
Edward, J .C . and Misra, S.L., 1968, Heterodera v ign i n.sp. and second s tage la rvae of Heterodera spec ies i n U t t a r Pradesh, I n d i a , Allahabad Fmr . , 42 : 155.
Eroshenko, A.S. and Kazachenko, I .P . , 1972, [Key t o the spec ie s of Heterodera Schmidt, 18711, Bio1.-Pochvenn. I n s t . , Dal 'nevost . Nauchnyi Tsentr AN SSSR, 11:205.
366' M. LUC
For tuner , R. and Merny, G., 1973, Les nématodes p a r a s i t e s des r ac ines ~.
assoc ié s au r i z en Basse-Casamance (Senegal) e t en Gambie, Cah. ORSTOM Ser. Biol . . 21:3.
Garabedian, S. and Hague, N.G.M., 1982, comparison of methods of appl ica- t i o n of oxamyl f o r con t ro l of Heterodera sacchari on sugar cane p l a n t s , Nematropica, 12:39.
Garabedian S. and Hague, N.G.M., 1984, The a f f e c t of weekly exposure t o non-vola t i le nematicides and sugar cane r o o t d i f f u s a t e .on the hatching of Heterodera sacehari, Revue Nematol., 7:95.
Gaur, H.S. and Singh, I., 1977, Pigeon-pea c y s t nematode, Heterodera ca jan i , assoc ia t ed with the mung crop i n the Punjab S ta te , J. R e s . Punjab agr i c . Univ. , 14 : 509.
G i l l , J.S. and Swarup, G., 1971, On the h o s t range of the c e r e a l c y s t nematode, Heterodera avenae Woll. 1924, t h e causa l organism of !!Molya!l .d i sease of wheat and bar ley i n .Rajasthan, Indian J. Nematol., 1:63.
Golden, A.M. and B i rch f i e ld , W . , 1978, Heterodera graminophiZa n.sp., (Nematoda: Heteroderidae) from g ras s with a key to c lose ly r e l a t e d spec ie s , J. Nematol., 4:147.
Golden, A.M. and Mulvey, R.H., 1983, Redescr ipt ion of Heterodera zeae, the corn c y s t nematode, with SEM observa t ions , J. Nematol., 15:60.
Golden, A.M. and Raski , D . J . , 1972, Heterodera thorne i , n.sp., (Nematoda: Heteroderidae) .and a review of r e l a t e d spec ie s , J. Nematol., 9:93.
Golden, A.M., Rau, G . J . and Cobb, G.S,. 1962, Heterodera cyperz Heteroderidae) a new spec ies of cyst-forming nematode, Proc. helminth. Soc. Wash., 29:168.
Goodey, T. , 1956, The nematodes p a r a s i t e s of p l a n t s catalogued under t h e i r hos ts . Rev. J , B . Goodey and M.T. Frankl in . Farnham Royal, England, Commonw. agr i c . Bur. , l40pp.
Gupta, P. and Edward, J.C., 1973, A new record of a cys t forming nematode (Heterodera chaubattia n.sp.) from the h i l l s of Uttar Pradesh, Curr. Sc i . , 42:618.
Hashioka, Y . , 1964, Nematode d i seases o f . r i c e i n the world, Riso, 13:139.
Henderson, G., 1926, Remarks on the genera of spear-bearing nematodes found i n H a w a i i , with a t ab le f o r t h e i r i d e n t i f i c a t i o n , H a w a i . P l an t . Rec., 30:454. -
Hesl ing, J.J., 1978, Cyst nematodes: morphology and i d e n t i f i c a t i o n of Heterodera, GZobodera and Punctodera, & "Plant Nematology!!, J.F. Southey ed., HMSO.
Hu tze l l , P.A., 1984, Descr ipt ion of males of Heterodera zeae, J. Nematol., 16:83.
J a i n , K., S e t h i , C.L., Swarup, G. and S r ivas t ava , A.N., 1982, Heterodera sorghi sp.n., a new c y s t forming nematode p a r a s i t i z i n g sorghum, Revue Nematol., 5 : 20 1.
CYST NEMATODES IN EQUATORIAL AND HOT TROPICAL REGIONS 367
J a i r a j p u r i , M.S., Khan, W.U., S e t t y , K.G.H. and Govindu, H.C., 1979, Heterodera dezv i i n.sp. (Nematoda: Heteroderidae) . a p a r a s i t e of r a g i (EZeusine coraeana) i n Bangalore, Ind ia , Revue Nematol., 2:3.
Janarthanan, R. , 1972, Occurrence of t he pigeon-pea c y s t nematode i n T a m i l Nadu, Indian J . Nematol., 2:215.
J e r a t h , M.L., 1968, Heterodera sacehari, a c y s t nematode p e s t of sugar * cane new t o Nige r i a , P1. D i s . Reptr . , 52:237.
Kalha, C.S. and Edward, J . C . , 1979, Heterodera v i g n i Edward & Misra, 1968, a synonym of H . cajani Koshy, 1967, Allahabad Fmr., 50:143.
Khan, A.D. and Husain, S . I . , 1965, Heterodera mothi n.sp. (Tylenchida: Heteroderidae) p a r a s i t i z i n g Cyperus rotundus L. i n Al igarh , U.P., Ind ia , Nematologica, 11: 167.
Khan, U.V. and J a i r a j p u r i , M.S., 1975, A r e p o r t on the occurrence of an egg sac i n Heterodera mothi (Nematoda: Tylenchida) , Curr. Sc i . , 44:590.
Kirby, M.F., Kirby, M.E., S idd iq i , M.R. and Loff , P.A.A., 1978, P l a n t p a r a s i t i c nematodes from F i j i : nematode d i s t r i b u t i o n s and h o s t assoc ia t ions . UNDP/FAO Survey ag r i c . Pes t s 6 D i s . S. P a f i c i c Reg. - Coord. Comittee Meet., 28 Feb.-2 March, 1978. Rep. mimeogr. 1 2 pp.
Koshy, P.K., 1967, A new spec ies of Heterodera from I n d i a , Indian Phytopath 20 : 272.
Koshy, P.K. and Swarup, G. , 1971a, Inves t iga t ions on the l i f e h i s t o r y of the pigeon-pea c y s t nematode, Heterodera ca jan i , Indian J. Nematol., 1:44.
Koshy, P.K. and Swarup, G . , 1971b, On the number of genera t ions of Heterodera cajani t he pigeon-pea c y s t nematode i n a year , Indian J . Nematol., 1: 88.
Koshy, P.K. and Swarup, G . , 1971c, D i s t r ibu t ion of Heterodera avenue, H . cajani , H . zeae and Anguina t r i t i c i i n Ind ia , Indian J. Nematol., 1: 106.
Kishy, P.K. and Swarup, G . , 1971d, Fac tors a f f e c t i n g emergence of l a rvae from c y s t s of Heterodera cajani Koshy, 1967, Ind ian J. Nematol., 1:209.
Koshy, P.K. and Swarup, G . , 1971e, S u s c e p t i b i l i t y of aerial p a r t s of pigeon- .I pea seedl ings t o Heterodera cajani l a rvae , Indian J. Nematol, 1:245.
Koshy, P.K. and Swarup, G., 1972, S u s c e p t i b i l i t y of p l a n t s t o pigeon-pea d cys t nematode, Indian J . Nematol., 2 : 1.
Koshy, P.K., Swarup, G. and S e t h i , C . I . , 1971, Fur ther no tes on the pigeon- pea c y s t nematode Heterodera eajan;i, Nematologica, 16:477.
Kra l l , E.L. and K r a l l , Kh. A. , 1979, [The r ev i s ion of p l a n t nematodes of the family Heteroderidae (Nematoda, ty lenchida) by using a com- pa ra t ive ecologica l method of s tudying t h e i r phylogeny], & "Pr in ts ipy i metodyi zucheniya uzaimootnoshenii mezhdu p a r a z i t i - cheskimi nematodami irasteniyamil!, Tar tu , USSR (1978, publ. 1979).
368 M. LUC
Krishna Prasad, K.S., Krishnappa, K. , S e t t y , K.G.H., Reddy, B.M.R. and Reddy, H.R.C., 1980, Suscep t ib i l i t y of some c e r e a l s t o r a g i c y s t nematode Heterodera d e z v i i , Gurr . R e s . , 9 : 114.
Kumar, A.C., 1964, A note on the occurrence of Heterodera cacti from Mysore, Curr. Sc i . , 33:534.
Kumar, A.C., 1980, S tudies on nematodes i n cof fee s o i l s of south India . 4. Occurrence of Heterodera cyperi, J. Coffee R e s . , 10:77.
Logiswaran, G. and Menon, P.P.V., 1969, Prel iminary observa t ions on the spread of t he golden nematode (Heterodera rostochiensis Woll.) of pota toes i n the N i l i g i r i s , Madras S ta te , A l l I nd ia Nematol Symp. New Delhi:7.
Luc, M., 1961, Nématodes du genre Heterodera p a r a s i t e s de cu l tu re s t rop ica l e s en Afr ique, C . r . Seanc. Acad. Agric. Fr . , 47:940.
Luc, M . , 1974, Heterodera sacchari, C.I .H. Descr ipt . P1 . paras . Nematodes, S e t 4 , N o . 48.
Luc, M. and Berdon-Brizuela, R. , 1961, Heterodera oryzae n.sp. (Nematoda: Tylenchoidae) p a r a s i t e du r i z en Côte d ' I v o i r e , Nematologica, 6:272.
Luc, M. and Merny, G . , 1963, Heterodera sacchari n.sp. (Nematoda: Tylenchoidea) p a r a s i t e de l a canne a sucre au Congo-Brazzaville, Nematologica, 9 :3 I,
Luc, M. and Netscher , C., 1974, Presence of the sugar-beet nematode a t Dakar, FAO P1. P ro tec t . Bul l . , 22:24.
Luc M. and Taylor , D.P., 1977, Heterodera oryzae, C.I .H. Descr ipt . P1. Daras. Nematodes. S e t 7 . No. 91.
Luc M . , Germani, G. and Netscher, C., 1973, Descr ipt ion of Sarisodera . africana n.sp. and observat ions on the r e l a t i o n s h i p s between the genera Sarisodera Wouts Sher , 1971 and Heterodera A. Schmidt 1871 (Nematoda: Tylenchida) , Cah. ORSTOM. S é r . Bio l . , 21:35.
Luc, M . , Taylor , D.P. and Cadet, P . , 1978, Descr ipt ion of a new t r o p i c a l Heteroderidae, HyZonema ivorense n.gen., n.sp., and a new out look on the family Heteroderidae (Nematoda: Tylenchida), Revue NeÍnatol., 1:73.
Maqbool, M.A., 1981, Occurrence of root-knot and c y s t nematodes i n Pakis tan , Nematol. medit., 9:211. x
Maqbool, M.A., Hashmi, S. and Begum, Z. , 1983, Onion a new h o s t of Heterodera mothi from Pakis tan , Nematol. medit., 11:213.
12
Merny, G . , 1966, Biologie d'Heterodera oryzae Luc & Bredon, 1961. II. R Ö l e des masses d'oeu\fs dans la dynamique des populat ions e t l a conservat ion de l ' e spece , Annls Epiphyt., 17:445.
Merny, G. , 1970, L e s nématodes des r i z i è r e s inondées de Côte d ' Ivo i r e . I. Les especes observées , Cah. ORSTOM S k . Biol . , 11:3.
CYST NEMATODES IN EQUATORIAL AND HOT TROPICAL REGIONS 369
Merny, G . , 1972a, Les nématodes phytoparas i tes des r i z i è r e s inondges de Côte d ' I v o i r e . III. Etudes sur l a dynamique des populat ions de deux endoparas i tes : HirschmannieZZa spinicaudata e t Heterodera oryzae, Cah. ORSTOM Sér. Biol . , 16:31.
Merny, G . , 1972b, Les nématodes phytoparas i tes des r i z i è r e s inondées de Côte d ' I v o i r e . l ' i n t e n s i t é de l ' i n f e s t a t i o n des r ac ines par l e s nématodes endo- p a r a s i t e s en fonc t ion de l ' inoculum, Cah. ORSTOM Sér.Biol., 16:129.
I V . Essai d ' i n t e r p r é t a t i o n mathematique de
Merny, G. and Cadet, P . , 1978, Penet ra t ion of j uven i l e s and development of a d u l t s of Heterodera oryzae on d i f f e r e n t p l a n t s , Revue Nématol., 1:251.
Merny, G. and Netscher , C . , 1976, Heterodera gambiensis n.sp. (Nematoda: Tylenchida) p a r a s i t e du m i l e t du sorgho en Gambie, Cah. ORSTOM Sér . Biol . , 11: 209. -
Minton, N.A., Tucker, E.T. and Golden, A.M., 1973, Occurrence of Heterodera moth i , a c y s t nematode i n the United S t a t e s , P1. D i s . Reptr . , 57:946.
Misra, S.M., Edward, J.C. and Gupta, P . , 1977, S tudies on the occurrence of whitelbrown c y s t s of Heterodera zeae i n a year i n po t c u l t u r e and on emergence of la rvae from these c y s t s , Allahabad Fmr. , 48: 115.
Muir, F. and Henderson, G . , 1926, Nematodes i n connection with sugar cane r o o t r o t i n the Hawaiian I s l ands , H a w a i i P l an t . Rec., 30:233.
Muir, F. and Swezey, O.H., 1926, Entomology: Nematodes, Rep. H a w a i i Sug. EXD. Stn.. 1926:25.
Mulvey, R.H., 1972, I d e n t i f i c a t i o n of Heterodera c y s t s by terminal and cone top s t r u c t u r e s , Can. J. Zool., - 50:1277.
Mulvey, R.H. and Golden, A.M., 1983, An i l l u s t r a t e d key t o the cyst-forming genera and spec ies of Heteroderidae i n the Western Hemisphere with spec ie s morphometrics and d i s t r i b u t i o n , J. Nematc . , 15: 1.
Narayanaswamy, B.C., Gowda, D.N. and S e t t y , K.G.H., 1982, Heterodera gambiensis (Nematoda: Heteroderidae) , a new c y s t forming nematode on f i n g e r m i l l e t from Karnataka, Ind ia , J . S o i l Boi l . Ecol., 2:90.
Netscher , C . , 1969, L'ovogenèse e t l a reproduct ion chez Heterodera oryzae e t H . sacchari (Nematoda: Heteroderidae) , Nematologica, 15:lO.
Netscher , C . and Pernes, J., 1971, Etude concernant l ' i n f l u e n c e de l a c o n s t i t u t i o n génét ique su r l a longueur des l a rves d'Heterodera oryzae, Nematologica, 17:336.
Netscher , C . , Luc, M. and Merny, G. , 1964, Descr ip t ion du mâle d'Heterodera sacchari Luc & Merny , 1963 ) Nematologica, 15 : 156.
Nishizawa, T . , Shimizu, K. and Nagashima, T . , 1972, [Chemical and c u l t u r a l c o n t r o l of the r i c e cys t nematode, Heterodera oryzae Luc & Berdon- Br i zue la , and hatching response of the l a rvae t o some r o o t e x t r a c t s ] , Jap. J. Nematol., 2:27.
370 M. LUC
Odihi r in , R.A., 1975, Occurrence of Heterodera c y s t s nematode (Nematoda: Heteroderidae) on wild grasses i n Southern Niger ia , OCC. Publ ic . Nigerian Soc. P1. P r o t e c t . , 1':24.
Odih i r in , B.A., 1977, I r r i g a t i o n water as a means f o r the disseminat ion of t he sugar cane c y s t nematode Heterodera sacchari a t Baci ta Sugar E s t a t e , Oec. Publ. Nigerian Soc. P1. P ro tec t . , 2:58. '
Ohshima, Y., 1974, Heterodera elachista n.sp., an upland r i c e c y s t nematode from Japan, Jap. J. Nematol., 4:51. Y
Prasad, S.K. and Chawla, M.L., 1965, The pota to r o o t eelworm Heterodera rostochiensis, on t h e Indian Agr i cu l tu ra l Research I n s t i t u t e , Indian J. Entomol., 23: 127.
t
Rao, Y.S. and Hayaprakash, A., 1977, Leaf ch lo ros i s due t o i n f e s t a t i o n by a new cys t nematode, I n t . Rice Res. Newsl., 2:5.
Rao, Y.S. and Jayaprakash, A. , 1978, Heterodera oryzicoZa n.sp. (Nematoda: Heteroderidae a c y s t nematode on r i c e (Oryza sativa L.) from Kerala S t a t e , Ind ia , Nematologica, 23:341.
R e i s , L.G.L., 1982, P l a n t p a r a s i t i c nematodes assoc ia ted with C i t rus i n Mozambique, Agronomia l u s i t . , 41:213.
Reversat , G . , 1975a, Elevage monoxenique du nematode Heterodera oryzae sur l e r i z , Ann. Sool. Ecol. anim., 7:81.
Reversat , G . , 1975b, Etude p ré l imina i r e de l a su rv ie en anaérobiose des juvéni les du nématode Heterodera oryzae (Tylenchida Heteroderidae) , C.R. Acad. Sc. P a r i s , 280 sér. D:2865.
Reversat , G . , 1975c, Méthodes pour l a mesure de l a consommation d'oxygène des nématodes par l a technique du ludion, Cah. ORSTOM Se'r. Bio l . , u): 169.
Reversat , G . , 1975d, Inf luence d'une i n h i b i t i o n p réa l ab le par l a press ion osmotique su r l ' d c l o s i o n des masses d 'oeufs du nématode Heterodera oryzae, Cah. ORSTOM Ser . Bio l . , 10: 189.
Reversat , G . , 1977a, Etude de l a composition biochimique g loba le des juvéni les des nematodes MeZoidogyne javanica e t Heterodera oryzae, Cah. ORSTOM Sér. Bio l . , '11 (1976) : 225.
Reversat , G., 1977b, Inf luence of ex te rna l f a c t o r s o n 4 t h e rate of oxygen x. uptake by second-stage juven i l e s of Heterodera oryzae, Nematologica, 23:369.
Reversat , G . , 1981, Potassium permanganate as a hatching agent f o r Heter- #
odera sacchuri, Revue Nematol., 4:174.
Reversat , G. and Bois, J.F., 1982, Marquage par l e 35 d'Heterodera oryzae S e t dfH&erodera sacchari e t app l i ca t ion a l ' é t u d e de l a compéti t ion pour l ' i n f e s t a t i o n de l a plante-hôte , Bull. OEPP., 12:371.
Reversat , G. and Merny, G. , 1973, Inf luence de quelques f a c t e u r s sur l a péné t r a t ion du nematode Heterodera oryzae dans l e s r ac ines du r i z , Cah. ORSTOM Ser. Bio l . , 21 : 111.
,
CYST NEMATODES IN EQUATORIAL AND HOT TROPICAL REGIONS 37 1
Sardane l l i , S., Krusberg, L.R. and Golden, A.M., 1981, Corn c y s t nematode, Heterodera zeae, i n the United S t a t e s , P1 . D i s . , 65:622.
Seshadr i , A.R. and Sivakumar, C.V. , 1962, The golden nematode of po ta toes (Heterodera rostochiensis Woll., 19231, - a t h r e a t t o pota to c u l t i v a - t i o n i n the Madras S t a t e , Madras. ag r i c . J . , 49:281.
Sharma, S.B. and Swarup, G . , 1983, I d e n t i f i c a t i o n scheme f o r Heterodera spec ies i n Ind ia , Indian J. Nematol. , 13: 171.
Sharma, S.B. and Swarup, G . , 1984, Cyst forming nematodes of Ind ia , New Delhi , Ind ia Cosmo Publ ica t ion .
Shimizu, K . , 1971, [ Inf luence of t h e r i c e c y s t nematode on the f i e l d of paddy r i c e ] , 15th Ann. Meet. Jap . Soc. appl . Entom. Zool., FÛchu, Tokyo, Apr. 7-9 1971, 32.
Shimizu, K., 1972, [Relat ionship between growth and y i e ld of paddy r i c e and the time inocula t ion with the r i c e c y s t nematode], 16th Änn.-Meet. Jap. Soc. appl . Entom. Zool., Shizuoka, Apr. 6-8 1972, 114.
Shimizu, K. , 1973, [ Inf luence of d i f f e r e n t sowing times of r i c e on seasonal f l uc tua t ions of the r i c e c y s t nematode], 17th Ann. Meet. Jap. Soc. appl . Entom. Zool., Nagano, Apr.3-5 1973, l30.
Skarb i lovich , T.S. and Kurramov, Sh. Kh.,' 1973, [Nematode in fec t ions i n sugar cane and soy bean], Byull. Vsesoyuzn. I n s t . gel lmint . K . I . Skryabina, 11: 80.
Sr ivas tava , A.N. and Swarup, G . , 1975, Prel iminary s tud ie s on some graminaceous p l an t s f o r t h e i r s u s c e p t i b i l i t y t o the maize c y s t nematode, H . zeae Koshy e t a l . , Indian J. Nematol., 5:257.
Stoyanov, D. , 1972, Heterodera amaranthi n.sp. (Tylenchida: Heteroderidae) ; un nemátodo formador de q u i s t e s en Cuba, Poeyana, 97: 1.
Stynes, B.A., 1971, Heterodera graminis n.sp. a c y s t nematode from g ras s i n Aus t r a l i a , Nematologica, 17:213.
Swarup, G . , Prasad, S.K. and Raski , D . J . , 1964, Some Heterodera spec ies from India , P1. D i s . Reptr . , 48:236.
Ta la t sch ian , P . and Achyani, A., 1976, Heterodera-Arten i n Ziickeruben - Feldern verschiedener Anbaugebiete des I r a n , Z. angew. Zool., 63:497.
Taylor , D.P., 1978, P a r a s i t i s m of banana by Heterodera oryzae, Revue Nematol., 1: 165.
Taylor , D.P. and Luc, M. , 1979, Observations on Sarisodera africana (Nematoda: Heteroderidae) : Redescr ipt ion of a n t e r i o r end of females and occurrence of j uven i l e s wi th abe r ran t t a i l s , Revue Nématol., 2 , : l l l .
Tiago, J .S. , 1956, Un grave inimigo da c u l t u r a de b a t a t a , Gazet ta Agric. Moqamb, 8:334.
Usha, K. and Kurien, K . J . , 1981, Cyst nematode, Heterodera OryzicoZa, on r i c e i n Kerala. I. Estimation of loss i n r i c e due t o H . oryzicoza i n f e s t a t i o n i n f i e l d condi t ions , Indian J. Nematol., 11:106 [Abstr.].
372 M. LUC
V e r m a , A . C . and Yadav, B.S., 1975, Occurrence of Heterodera cajani i n Rajasthan and s u s c e p t i b i l i t y t o c e r t a i n sesame v a r i e t i e s , Indian J . Nematol., 5:235.
Wouts, W.M. and Sher, S.A., 1971, The genera of the subfamily Heteroderinae (Nematoda: Tylenchoidea) with a desc r ip t ion of two new genera, J. Nematol., 3:129.
Yaqoob, M. and Khan, A.M., 1969, Seasonal f l u c t u a t i o n i n the populat ion of Heterodera mothi, A l l India Nematol. Symp. 1969, 20.
i I
DISCUSSION I Noel s t a t e d t h a t , according t o d a t a of D r W. Hadisoeganda, H. gZycines
i i s p i e sen t i n Indonesia as a r e o the r spec ies of the genus and he asked i n what wqy.HH. glycines i s r e l a t e d t o H . cajani. Golden responded t h a t a l though the two spec ies a r e c lose ly r e l a t e d they are d i s t i n c t , l a rge ly on the b a s i s of s t r u c t u r e of the cys t w a l l . Stone s t a t e d t h a t populat ions of H. oryzicolQ h e i s s tudying with D r A . K. Koshy a r e very c l o s e , i f no t i d e n t i c a l , t o H. oryzae; they a t t a c k both r i c e and banana-trees , as does H . oryzae. Stone a l s o s t a t e d t h a t H. chaubattia i s probably a junior synonym of GZobodera mali .
B IChir reported t h a t c y s t nematodes a r e not economically important i n Tunis ia , as compared with MeZoidogyne or Pratylenchus, r e f l e c t i n g the genera l s i t u a t i o n i n the t r o p i c s , b u t GZobodera spec ies can be a problem when potatoes a r e grown continuously. This l ed to a d iscuss ion about t h e e f f e c t of temperature on the behaviour of po ta to c y s t nematodes from which it w a s concluded t h a t , based on observa t ions i n var ious coun t r i e s e.g. N e w Zealand, Tunis ia , Pakis tan , they become inac t ive when s o i l temperatures exceed 30°C but they may never the less c o n s t i t u t e a problem i n cooler seasons.
Edongali s t a t e d t h a t the H. trifolii reported i n Libya does no t a t t a c k subterranean clover and i n response t o a quest ion by Luc he s a i d t h a t H. Zatipons has no t y e t been recorded i n Libya, whereas i t i s present i n Tunis i a.