current statistical methods for mortality (failure … · tape of the presentation can be obtained...
TRANSCRIPT
CURRENT STATISTICAL METHODS FOR MORTALITY
(FAILURE TIME) DATA
TEACHING SESSION
JOHN D. KALBFLEISCH
University of Waterloo Waterloo, Ontario
N2L 3Gl
The following pages contain copies of the overhead transparencies used in Dr. Kalbfleisch's presentations. An audio tape of the presentation can be obtained at nominal cost from the conference organizers, Harry H. Panjer and Frank G. Reynolds .. University of Waterloo.
-327-
Cu~t~6111T S'-.Ansntl'(. 11~11+c>DS
FO/t Hdii..TIIU1Y (FI+I~fiU TIH~) bATA·
p.,, ~·sc. ~ I. E STI/'1 A T.4 '"~"' 01' DISTAl ~,: T 1;.,,~ !
T AAIIl l-. -Re ~~~e,vc;e~:
I< A&.ISFc.eiStll ., P~•N Tit~ (,•,.> T~ ~+al#h'cJ A,..t.,sls
of hn .. ,, -,-,·"'~ D"ta, Wif•y
J.AW~ ss C "' tl J S +-.1-; J ,.,.<•l 11 «At Is -. 11 e t~ o i. s (o .,.. J,.,•lt HM/1\t ~fa. J w; w '1
C'oll~b.£. lt-.~1.) l(~~.,~~si~ Hodtlra ~ L..iffl T(l.lole ~ c w 1 tt.. ~i r-t,. ss ; P\) ~ ~ ~ s a ~ , , ~ .. , "'o
-328-
C.tfi~N A
P••A. " . . i:.o ,.,. s ,,., ,, ' ,,, lfO ,,,
.z. 0' a. of .Ill .114. &.1.0 l&~ ~\0 Z.''f &¥-. I.C.S" 3o¥ ~.!\t:
~""' i'.' Ill'& ,,., ''1 ,,, &IS" &\"L 1.1'- 231
~'S1 aJl &Sl zs, z.vo z,, l.lo .Z. IO J.,, ,,, Ill ;lO'J 3'1'1-
R t Gr H'T t.fftl SoR lNG- - V E It y ~oltf~tllfl
H47?IOI)S l'tosr lfCUNI¥o•lf.'1"~ TillS.
-329-
!I
-I :
! -
,I 'ol '
. -f-i-.e fTo,..., olia.., l\OS~ ~ +o d.tt~.'t"-.
f;"'e, f.-o"" a{i"c:J""~is +o 4d•i1~i~
A'e. pr··~ ~ro.py 0• Jto 1~:1'' Ct ttl +., f -t oer.fo,""•,.ce sha.+M.s.
-330-
A u6c..e.cAn o ~.·"~ l~srs. -lOll IO,Cf+
I~" 'f • .1. l-1-1., 3 '+ Cf Cf, 'l.flfl.., 3 1-10
'11'-o) s-1ttC., 3x. S''+CII+
llf.or~ ~o'~ 1'5'1'4, 11'1'1, 1¥'10
S'Y- IC.Io•
'fol, '406, ~o&+, s-o'+, S""O'+, S' .. ~zl+
A sse.ssMoeJ~tt of re.lo.ti o"ship be.twe~"'
teW\per4+tAre. ~"'d. ti~e to fc..;(u((.
E )l +r Apo \Q.H ~ ~ 1"3 C) ·c i' sta1\ct O.fd...
op UQ.+i~~ +e"" pe.fa.1u~~.
Poss/J,;!iJ.y 1l,f +i~e Vaf'yi"~ cotta.~lA+t. s.
ilt): -1-e"' pe~A+~Art u+ fr'~Jtt. t
re lo. te fQ.; l~re V'"tA tt. +o C.ufft11 t · a~ d..
P·'w ,· O'-l \ v" lw 1 s of i-t tL
-331-
F AII.IJ~~ "'"''I 4~ ANY (JAI~ Ill" Sllll~ltlff.
'0•~~£/l.IAJT rY~4S.
T= -H~e +o fa~ l·e&f(.
- ;r = +'1,. e • ~ ft~.:.w... rc.
e..,. Hoel (,,1-1..). H,·c.e. ~;1/~n 3oo tCLctS o~ rfl..d...c'fAkr·I'YI
ef followe.~ for C:..ClVMce~ i't'c.,de"'(e.
Tit ru. (u; lute -1-yJH. s.
i) iw ti (.{f,.(e. (ttic.t' xo~is) of t~y•ic. I y Mpho•·
ii) " , ,,
i'e ti tli\l~.t~ Ct H
S"rto }II\~
How do w~ ~nsfruc.t C.o1ult~tt&ct J-tt~dt.ls ?
How dot..s fv'e«+ wtt"'t (or o~..- ~ ',) o. fftc.:t
fa; ft.tt.e (fA. fe "t o-f o"• +y pe. ?
-332-
Jl .. " ,. " "
-we.ay be. lrtffrest~d i)\ fe(att""~ (AtL
of ~H- Qtk s +o {f.,.) po lf~Ah·~ lei« Is.
or fo reee"t his+o-ry d f 4tto.ttcs.
reffA.,.~ ({.teA' de"t raf<t +o C:.t·:)·> 46f. ~ sex~
pre~;ous o.ec.i de"t "'•''Sto"f, c.r,.
~ fAJt t m·t tl.. orl~ wlick ~ Jt te-d i-o ~ i 1-w<A filMS
lt'lc e. Tke s e .
Ce .. sor-ln'
T;,..e. VQ.~'I;,., cotta.~iCttfs.
11 ~ l+ipl.e r~A/Iu.~~ T'f pt s.
H•th'p·l<t. Fa,·lu.~e l/mts.
-333-
II ill I
I
Suf"Vivor Func:.+\cf")\. ( Re.l&a.bi li~y F~)\ch'<M)
:Def't\ S l-l-) = P" t T~ t J
StU
SCo)=t , SCca)=o , nc»\. i~c.te«si"~
SU.) ·
-334-
. ~
:~ : : ._,
• : l
: . ' ' . : ' . ' ' ' .
;
h . . ' ! ' L.. : •• ,; ! :: ._
•. ' ' ;
T d.c' Stf'e t~ .
j
T (A~so~uTeLV) CoNTINuoos.
fl-f> = - ;t Slt>
: /,'W\ prtTE- [t-,t-tAt)} /4t ~t-'>o+
HA!AitD FuNCTION (i"St4Mttuuovs fcdLuft red~, force. o t: ~art c..t1+1)
Att): /t'IK pr ~T'f[t-,t--t•t)IT~t}/4t' ~t-')o+
~Ct) • fC-tl/Slf)
= -:t: t., (SH·l)
.--/Sit.)= expt- s: ..\Mdu.1 [ ~;"ct Slo)= f
T 1\~~t\ ~ lf) ChAt"tAc+e,i!tS t'ke
~i~tt>e'bk+io~ of T.
[f'tt) = ..\ lt) $1-t) .1
-335-
(J) ~~~tr6s 5EIJtJ~Ifl'1114-t- IJVr~APtt.erAnoAI
/,me d tf''l- ~1/a-'''4.:1-u . l.i /c1 t/ J. o oi. euxsfyuth·~
PtA'h'~l //kti/Aood-
i t+~t
r"hrpte.ftAI·iOY\ of 'l't'~kt t~~orilt".
-336-
J. IFf_ IS A SEQVeWCE.
OF BE.f<.I/OUI.Ll -rtriALS
/ ,
~-
-337-
I I
I
I 1,1
I I
I
I~ I I
I D1scR£T£
~-{+ J SI-t p .fc't\
d.c's coMfi)\uiHts Clt x,.c:x-&<~1< ·•··
Pro BASI&. trY
f{%i):
FuAJC.TtON:
pr iT= x; ~
HA '!A It b FcJNC.iiOAI ~
. J ~ t l. . -· I J
)j: pi 1 T:XjiT~xjf ~ flxj)/Sl"j)
*
-338-
( b.so, ~.)
l a.., b .. )
r ~, ~~)
<lt risk.
N. N'" H-s
--
deaths
D. 1)" 111
0
0
,.,.,~
(wi"" Gltawal ")
c., c~
c. ..
The Cotfe ~po)\t;ll~~ esti·)llttAt~ Df t~e.
SCA.t'Vi vor fc.t11\~MOOII\ ··~
.f.t:A ,'r ... fiS ... C "-' ~0~'1' ~, S
ht 1t t f' t. u.;"" ... ~ s 0
-339-
!He KAPLAN ltcJCI( ( PRotJtJt:r L1111r) E s ,,HAT~
Clttsortd sample frowt ~(t): pt{T~t1.
Fa,.lufl ft'wtiS ar1 t,<t.,<··· <l:ec
d& ired,.v/duttls fail at -t;
Ctttso,-td. riW\IS
"".i irtdiv,·rJ.v.Als .
ate t!l1tSoft.d '~
[t . .., t·) At J ... ~~ ••
t. , ... ,f. ,J ' " ,.,. • rl
-t, "' ~J. I
ct, d~ d'S \......._ ___ . ____ --. -~ ""• ""·
L~t J1j = d . .. lM • -+ ·- - -t J J d" + "'k
- # a.t -r•'s k ~t t.-o - J
E sfi wrate dis cn~te hQ-!CIV'd com pone~+s 14 " ~~ , ... • , ~ k A e t 1 , ••• , -1:~
" A. -J -
I< (A pi QJt ... M~itf' e sfi Mate
# ffA.i , .. ", # A+ .-,·, lc
. ·~
14 -T.I" ( r!J ) F l t ) : t1 I - - v
; I tj < t "'.J"
-340-
E JA,I'Lt: CAil~INtl "•*6SIS. ... "' f· rl· ,. (1-);) F'lfj·+a) J ~ I /'fa. I :II AO/al ·ft& tr' I zo lf/ao ·tar (z · f{& II i-~ ) ,,, I ,,
11/1, -tr~
/(il I II I':J/tl . ,. :zo$' ,,
If' /If. • ?$"9
Zl& l '~ IJ /tr' .,r, ZlS ' 13 f/11 ·VfS" Uf lVO
2"
~ 0 I-""!'-___ _
a.: - Trf.tl+""~"'t -- -=- ~."fro' -------. --
.z. - -- --341-
I,
I I '
I I' 11
(:
,,
il I
CP.:ttA~ISIW ()~ 714JcJ PtJfttie A17CM!,£.:
( *"SN~~ $•-,6fM Q~IC,./tliJfC (rtJII"'
-/-MJO /''JHUAfiVMS Wl'fk sw.,.llifiO~ ~S S,t•> ..._, $~(~).
W.e c.~~l.. fo fist 'flte It' p ~f"1sir S,t,.J : S~t*l , o< f < ~.
{o' ~AIIllk TEST (H~~t~re' HIIEAJS!eL Tesr)
-MAAIT~( (I'''' :tNt. l - P~ ro "#. 'f -rD (~=Jl.) 1"~SS ~
)A +• or' IJ.Jt i la.l·i _.,.:
- p•o I 'SQIIAJIII' a.~ I~ t-t, < ta < · •· <f:*
ht. rAe d/sfi n<t fQ,· luff. -ft'mt s
t, t" . . . .. tic
d, « ... dtc # ~~··u .. , ttC . •.r
•t ~ ....
.. ltf ,.,,. -n, .,.'1. ..,~
•+ t-;-o
.
View st\CA~"f-c'•Uy ta'Md ffsf ..\,(f): A~f+> ( e, CAa.lr'f-7 0 f fa.ilo.rt raffs)
-342-
Ltt d,",j {1f,i.) h~ +he # of foc'lutts At ~·
('II at r•'s k a f tj -o ) i~ S•wcplt. i ~ ,·~,, c
s .. .,..,,~ F4ilutts Sunl~•fl At- /(isk
I J,i '11 ',j - d 'J' 7f'J·
~ ol .. j ,. ... j - da.i ,,;
et· 1fJ -dj n· J 'J
(J,.~~~ fl.~ 'If.« /I lty,.tA1sis (A,l-1):,\-.l+) ).
(l~Q( ,.iYftl\ Cj : {tJi 1 'tffj 1 rl,j)
1 -tit•
f'O Ptll•i I t'l·1 f c ". 0 f d ',j c,; ( / , ) ( 71,j ( "naj ) / ?tj
P ri'J '-.i : tA,j 1 «i·d; I Ca.i)
Tit~ c.o"t spo~~tfJ,' ,, ( t:ntdl ff'nctA. I ) Jrrt""'- ~ VOt'i dl Mte Q'~
l.; : E (d.,j I CJ· ) c 11•j dj/'1tj
Vtj : nn ( d.,j /CJ· J = 11,j Ytt.; dj ltt,j-d;) "i'L<rtj·r)'
Ltt "J = d,j - e,j
-343-
II
n . f lot t'a~t sha.Hsfic is lc
v: ~. V.j = 0, -E. , ..
ap,.,o.,.,·l'l1Clt•l7 ')1ot'm41l/ wt'~ h1e~ o ""oC. v• ,,. 01ett. e s h' 'W\Q. t•d to,
k
V = ~ v,i ~·'
( c 0"' , .. r,· St 'r'\ 0 f V" I rv wr"14 Nlo,') +tt,lts ~o'lldt s tk +~$1".
!Le.Ju.: i) 0, = obs'rJ #. tr6 dea1"'s ~ sa.w.ple 1
f., :. ( ~ UW\ 0 f C.o~rJ.,' "'jp_._ fi'J) eYpfC t~ rJ.
# of d.•o.tl-.s ,·"' S4Mttplf 1.
ii) Tk• +~sf- expf oik t'J..~ se,C(4~d·,.Q. I
'hq 1-c.trt of 11..« fc..;(C4.rc. -f.t't-Kf M~ck ..... ·s,.,.
it-t) T"c teJ+ is D.f#J-t,·c,.bl~ ho 11t +o ~t"oet.p~fL c::l«.t'Q. O.,.CI( to "eal\1-ti'\WOWS ,, ~CltCA·
-344-
(-t.Aif~Le:
Dis ~rt fe ( ~ro"'ptd) fC4.&lwf( fiw.e do. ta.. Ce"s•"'"~ Ot~ • ._ct .,f iMftrvals.
r,· .. , +o ,., turr e "''e. a~+er hu"h'•l Cfo dt1Af -1-rtftf "'t11t period..
0•3*1'1· 3·C. "'os. , ...... 9-ll•••·
Ratt c:i,, c to a .... : • d,,~ n. .,, ... J ,.,, : (.f' J'1,'": S'f n,, • Cfo "·~. l~
Hrt. 'tlta4. ct •• : S" d'" ... f d-a, 'C' Dlw= 'f 'h .... ':1-0 "'"" c c. 't ""·': 'f~ ,.,., ": 11
•
>t'&.
(~
.20
Yilw St?,•'""tialfy - ~-~ it4hrvel ,·, a Stpth"aft -/tr,·Q I
~·) . 2."' Gi i td''C!r ,._I Sa _,,. ~.~, '-'"· a.trls
c ~
B .--<- $'"/
s s-'1 "'t. • J,. /00 \ ,, c.
~"': a, ... - e, .. = i- ~-vf = · rs-11,~,: 3·'1'*
sfliMt it~ttllc.afiA 'tho.k 1fT~ .,. Ra.tA .. , tlte. pre.I-«~•Oie fl.. , .. ,.y.
-345-
fy..Q'*ple: u,. t"•"pc.ll. «atA. Cc..,.,cMo~~c.ri\,
''f' I: ,..5~ /'f/ ,Ill# Ill, /fOJ I'll.~ ...
~~ ,,.z: ,.,., '" ,IU, ttl, .2ot; U&, 13',·-
1 s .... c P'f' c.• -. .. f'&
J, ,., . at -t. = I tl J
"'f,j :I r d.j ': 2.
""i • 'a rJ .. j = 0
\
~·· rt'sJr s ... ,.,. '"'v '
;). '~ '~ % 0 II ,,
2. 3S"
/a ~aft• I,..,. • - ' I 1 • (..,. -'• .,.. r'J , "'J
ea "~'I ~~- t eo,. p tA. .,.,"''"" s (o '~" e. fA cA nc.,. 'I fie t«. +;.,..,.
I,.. flu's Cti$ e tr .--v = ,. 11
v a D, - £I > () •) $. ,.,.,,~ ' It (A s S'olff feN hw pc~rt r • Jt p era' '"u. D;l fff-t,.u 1 fA 'c Xtt f SiC)";f,·t~.
-346~
- llU•w !•a.,tf·l{t'cafi~ o-f .. ,,.,~.:• ASSeCA'wf•4 ""''H.. v-uiu~r s"•fJ"tA/JS itt.dt'ctaff~ ., IL~ds of f·
Co"!s/rJ,, sl•pltsf c.se first. fa ~I $&'Mplt. iMc:ia'CUO -r. .4: f
Tlu
.fo, so,. e u " It, tJW)I&, fJ a ('Q 111 t ", j5 fMII fA.
r;J .. ~ hi ka ~'I ,.,.. sp~ tA'ft"4d 11eca""d Ao t+ J.
TJ.Ms .A lfioJ = J. t~ J A If; t):: Ao If) e ~
. It " .,, s •
-347-
(!-aO) (.fat)
E /he,. tJ f tl..e co.,•~··a. ft i~ +o oc.t)tutll-ipl,·catl ~t 1'1 D"' +N lttAJ_.,d.
A tf; ,J = e f5 = ~If; D)
re (a f,· \It tls k
( i~dfp.+ of ... i""t.).
GF~t~rML ! = (~.~ ••• , ~.) ~~"" ~ -4 (01#0Nt•6kt '.
II ,·~ A tl ; ! ) : e- • t:.. ~1-f;gJ
tl ss• ciot~d _ '-'fl. h. l = ~ * --343-
f'Rolc.~: 1. TEsn ,.A. NOIJ~' AD4~ "~~ v.
2 . E 5 'r l#ftlf. .,,. AI iJ F 1!, All t:J II #lflt ~ II""
~e4A f7't~4 lfllJLs.
}/o ,.e a, .. ;,. tA1. )t(of/e I
!A AI#; ! ) -= ~o if. J e - .. -
Tke's ;, G. ,...,ffSs··~ )ff•flf I for 'H..L
f~i ICArt. ~-.foe. a.f -1-iwce. -t'
Pos+,.,taffs no ditfd- ff.(Ah'l?fr/t.ip h~~c,.J·~~
T: HWtt +o fQ,t'/u'f. a .. tt I'. -
-349-
£ STIMf.DoN OJ' f!.
]) a to.:
( t,. , J: ~ ~··)
-~:. - +•"". +· fr.;t .. ~t -' <f.· - ~ •• ·ttA r-l. ' -
0 Cbtso~-ttl..
p,, h ',,. : e s .w,.. oJ-tt 11
Tk r' '- a.,. Jt.,.,. eJ.. e ' '· MAr' i'htt( L .. Ice I a,o oJ. :1. Pod·;,..( L;Jc,t,"J..ood ,a..
$ . Ps, t.ul o H .. • iwt "~ Li Jc t t,· A • ,..«.
A 11 4re l~ essf.#aiY'a.l D~"~''"'"t.
#of-l: Sl-a,._dard O.S.,IIfJ-hlt'c. '''kffs fo,.. ~~tAJtlltflttAWV 1,./ttlilttJo/J eshiH~'I'KJ ti• 1t1f a.J-;t7 wi~ Qrb/-lr~tl''f ~ol•) ;,. tlA. 11teJ(f.
-350-
'
l
~~te- tottlirutiltj, if il +"t c:lA.tfA - Ot'' ~c ft w..,.
+o ~ wrr'fe A S t~ W ,.,_,."- f
Lt f tkt ObSftvft! fC4: ~~~~. .,. ...... s ~,,_.
'4,J • feu,·· · , ~6J J
0 C ~(IJ ~ 'f-{J.I < • •. < t-·J·
I" ,. d.tli M '(pi ~ let R l+) be .,..~._,_ se.t of
i#-twtS a fris It ( i~- ltot ~~~Su~t.d 4Md Af"
... ,·s~ of fa.:t~re ) at ~-o .
!{i) t'S 'th.t. COI/'~r/Q.ff. \/QckO~ of tkc, il~ +ko.t .fCA.t ·~ o.t t ,, , .
M et4tJd ;"volvts
i +t"' ~+ frM'I~
w/u't" tAr~ ~
t"r'slc t.t+ -f(i,.
C!cl,.. ~u~ rill' t~ -l . o I 1-~ r -(u
ta.f t-c,, wi fL.. !• , .If I( l t,..1 )
l .r~LfMf s 0 f t'"-t. ifttM s At
-351-
'II
iii II jl
111 fAttnA' t.11C4, 1~M1• ( ~· r1~s) ~·~.;
i I I
C.,.sidtr .l S••p~ P"obltwt. /1-,st-
~o(~)
~.if)
-1-o.,. S4 ~ttplt 0
for $11Mplt, I r ~.(f.}= ~.(+) ~ .. d' -t(t) < ~(\) < . . . < ir~t)
~~t r(c'J -o ' ,,. •rt ~f ,,·sic I (J + I!Jiw'~4 D"~ fn.t'fs.
I I .fa.,'lu'l a.t ~.·, C.:. Sl f~c.;fA,e ~ t.l~t. fv,~ A AX2. .,...,~
fAil let • S I I M ,,. -I 11 u•
s~o--~o~----~-·~,~·--;-~~~o~·-· ",·
--?to,· ~ott,.~) tlf,,1 .,. f11; A,lf-,,1)J.f,,.
1
ef-
/((tt •. ,) ""',.,·sic set ~ lohtlt, t1'l if.t111s a.'f- ,;,k ~tf 'i(;jO
~;,.;t.,t., ~ il <iJ ,·, ~ S•~t~plf 0
p~t IOf,,,.ts(~lf,:,), fo.it.ute Qlt oft.·, "• ..1. (5 J "•'- ... "•• e -352-
-ESE-
• b"W,•..toslll) )I'~ ~ Sl(ti.'.J»Jto~ vo ~wo.'I".•AtSt.,l YJJ."• .1 T1 t1 " ( v).., '¥ t, r/1-o r poo 'I.? ., 11 .'I
Jt:l r~'J.~Jtltutl '-'JOI ch.,l,s r; J J~Jnf')) "1+ ~ 1.AIJIIMOY'"'""•YS "''•1 Sl'~ ~I_ ·-,swJS
Jli,S»t W! YJOO'f,IJI~.'J ~ .foOl& S! (cJ), :jjON
(""'~' ~·, v~'~ ~ 7 ··~ ---====31!~-JL •(.."') ~
·v•n• ~ v J0 p.-,-Y-. ,,-,-~-· 7 frl.~ d
yW. \l,"l~f/0 ~ 1~,/ltlf ,1 J,d#,-:"J, lll!flfiOJ
C'·'-1111<~1
9"./fa 3 t .,J~ ~
-:' '·'~ ~., '"~s.u-o \otofiJ+ e"f-l-
"(~'4oJ~ ':' Slit!)! Jot ~~~fi/.'Wf!l 0 ~ I 2 ~.,. P•tJ
II I II
I
r;,,.,,.., e•sc.: { 7•~ -t::.)
~~, ••• ,. ~J TAelMrf +r··~ 1.
'!ciJ ~ · ..... , ~CIIJ COft#tsr. C.rttr,-_ ~~ 'tcfors
~.f t!e~IC~lo.,.C VIeJo, of ~ ~ t'"'-fllt~lduJ -
~ t ttlJ'
p~1;f'"' (lJ -itl,"ls/fil+ci1),oML ,·~~- -lw'ls u of(;,~ ).lft;, ; ~(1'1) = ~
E >. tt tr'J ; o~-.t ) ..ll:~lf-,.,) ...
- exp ( !(1·, ~) -
Proclc.cc.k o~t.r /.1144. f
&..( ~): k
T •••
-1511,-
"',· ~ P l T: ~(.·., 1 :f.: 2 1 r, tt•• J
,.\;(!,) :P~ T:. i-(,'J I !,JT>,t(il \
.. >.; e ! t\
/.(- ~.·t t 11 - ),· =
t • e .,.. ! 4. J• t31NII~'I L ''.J.·· ,,.,,
l ).,·
'9 ·~· Nt.Dtl.. •·,
""·' t, = E )t. I' tt .. ,.,., )
Alt;J)' E ~.·£1-l otf .. t-,~··>
~ tf; r J.tt
~f&t.A'~iiS Ito-H. tJ.iSCtf/of •
eo to\ ,.,. ""'" 0 Col s '11M vtl f /~ •
-355-
JA rJ4 : -t6.
'
-t,, t tc., , · · · · , 't'car'\
c:,(,
-.
--
, ct, ~ .. - • c("
Slf of i .. Cw't I
e -ltl• 4
I, e-4' I! leR.r,ttrol
t:J. i 14-4 .. ct t"-i(u~4 okiMI S
"""'H ,.u,;+.·,, .
-fai ti "' of ~'til.
~·.tt ~\ t',;,) is ~ S&.-,. cf aU ,4sc.r;. ~ f d; ;U:...s. · el..~s~~ .fv•,.,., 11\.:& ~••" s-..t"
tN ik.GIA.t '~"(~c.A ""~' -356-
A,,. .. ~,lllltTitJN :
C H•AI·~ "we Tl10~ T' (lt.~,-,_,A t.4'16"" 1'" 'rO -· w tr,.,
.. ._ "~~"' t+ooa .
-357-
j 1,,.,
. " ,,,
f1 . . "
I
I
'
I
0
. • . I
1 C~o"f)
/(JVV)
CCM+" +o li~(,'l.o44.
e~ / {t'f-l.:ttt. ~) , 1 ~ , .. ~ 1.0 t ~ l . . 1/ (If+ til f$) 'I.
e~/(j'S+ tlefa) ~,../ ( 13 + ,,. t~)
e '"I(!"+ tle ~)tf . . • • .
2. fl"'t.u.u•'1 -fo uie ~'fl.. .fG.:lut< +i""'- a.,.pnJt...
5ittCL Q(( fltd. nwtS O(C«r At COJW..cQ~
.f \f"'f\ c.u ' s .
-358-
L~ ,.,,., .• , lr'ltll/keofl *" of ("' -fo,. Co.rc.c'tto-
9'"Lsr·s do.t"fA.
-359-
I
1
j ~' 'S 1'fllf}. ftfr'c. f< IS II. f+s:
7"A~ Po.(lr'al lilcll/l.e•~ ls 'lot A.
/ilcef/J.ood i~ UJ114I sus~.
It lt1.1 s blllt S4.o'4)~ ~lt.owf t/~t', 'f/,..~ Cc.oc.ttl( (
D. sy•,+o ,.,., pr•pll'f7't ~ Jaold.
A i, · /{ A is 'flat "'._.. · u p~ ff • ( I,' lt1 flIt od J.. t: -r ' 1M ""-
~SI-f'Wtafe~ 'fA!rt U"dt~ rtlt:tflfltl'/ ,.,ile(
j r'' ~,.,,. '} tnuJt'li, s :
A ·· J /s u,,·~C(l $oft.c+IM to
d ~ '? 1-l(J). 0
~
id ~C.:. QJ'I'-P hl1it_lt, Jtorwt~tlly d/sm"ht.f/ftd
Wt'H.. lefl~ {i ~ CAtiU't'~ c.t.. ')t!(a../t',',_
fi sl-1,. ~ 1 fJ. •-,
z-'(t)
~-silfir ( ttfl'l, A of.. SfJ.}
A-...d~~t!l ..... G-ill (tqSt. 1 A,._.o{. ~~.)
-360-
E11fH~t6: ~14AtllfiOGIAI~$1S DAT'/4
A
~ c -.s'" Itt>: - ~ ~L(~')I : f,J.Jl-
ara~ -tl ~=f.
cu?• c .r. ~,. ~
a ~ •·1' c.,'C'') = <-.. ~ "·. 04,
9s?c. c. r. 1 s 'e-'· "', e·O") : ( ~~~) "-' • '2.1 , '. (h
J.t'lt ef,.ltoof/ ~~ h'o
/J J 1../0) z c.o"'..,"'' x(~,J rro:(S-:o -lloj t Lttl> J -:. 2·8'=' r
9f7o c.r. ~ t~: .. l~ ~c~?, s~,f¥}= (-t.z."I-J . 11 )
R.a.o /Jco'l.. T~.· -· #o .·fS:O fAt->: tf, ?(,1 • Itd)= ,..$'(,0
co~'f' puk' .fto""' .fit~t r~ep ;~ Ntw+o"' RD.pl..I.~)
l-Uo)"' l:la)·• = s.oo
AI·~. t(lo) = 0- E i' t'~ l U3 ra.t ~ sMit$,'u -361-
~)· ... . ~~Lf~)/~e ~~to
: iJ t fir;~ - "'' .,..-· X !• I z •=' IHU+y,•1) J
Wkt' & 11\ : # of t,llc ;,. (( l f,,.,)
s,.·J' ~ obs'rJ sw Wt 0 f l' -for fC&ilc.rrl s a.:~ t,,.J.
S'IIIH;I~ ,,,b/1,.,._ !/ = ( !,; .J ••• , .,, ) !,;.· :.~
0
1 Iff... Sa 'I ,.· j t4 s.,..,, .. ,,,, s-~; +··· +~ c ol,s'.t ~ f.,.,·t,.u\ Ufo) : o-E
... llttl .¥ .,
0 : -"(If I.~ 14 f.lt! fj M ltC.A)-; (M :
froM Co)t (ilcf.lr'"-ood t.ISe ! lo) -;.,., vo lvt s apf1ro 14 1or ft't S.
[•,lr'lr tsf.t' *M'C. V i" volvl s ~e..o -.,.J-Fo}(.
Cf. o.,,·sf c ()(,·.,~ cJ ly -Fro""'- pufial. li~tikovd
Wl/1... d.lSCftft lot) r'Jh'c ht•J~ I.
CQ 1t 6 ~ s 1t. ow ,... tit~
ytp>' It!)-' {!t9J $ tt{J) '_v-• ~l.!J -362-
~': l<fA~IIofslcy 7to'C.
fa : Q,~
:: 1 etlf f.yl'e '!$' ~ ic, +''"t"'t"t.
sa .. , ... .,, "'· , .. ,~~ ~ ...... u .,, . ,.,,t Atlt litO, "'· I A':Jt..
'. +tjt o • s+&.\dcwd.
~lot; !.l 0 -~ ~o(~)e-·
A
X' (L,'Jcff,'l.oo~ >HAH•) Vtuio< ~
ol, -.o 31 3S·O I'
~1 -.oo1'C. . t.\
-is - ·&fOt~
~ C.tltl\po~C. ~(s, ;" •ff4l ,, ..• "It" .,,.~,
~c. -·.Z.'tt a.. 0 ':J
~,= 100
t' e. , - .,, tf( t'l·~ lc
'1f':' oz., = r o " lS'O)(-.oSl) ..,
..n.= e : ·'Z.?.
~ tJtA/d sp•dry sal,,,,.,.,.$ ~tJ.~'Itfc •tel- • .,,.,.,~. ,
u.ei~~- '''tie. will.l"' wlu'c,/.. ~ ~t's /c. c.
"J'\ t. Q~~~t 7 CKMsh.J- • -363-
~e~r~l ap_p~••ci.J ,.. T tJ. Jc e ~.'= {!_ a,., d.. se.,. ~Q ( ,.,~
E s .,.,.wt4+t s
Ilk +r,.tot.tl.
.f. ~~ oh-1-tLt'l't. f,.o""' "tltt's .eSf.t'lflftlt.#S ~f
Sot f.~ S (f-; ~ )': pr ~ T>..-t j 'I]: e- o ~ Ql"') olw f
=1 So(~)} ~,o(! ,1.)
-364-
L.tf [40 =0~ II,) 1 [h,,h.) , · ·· · • [~ .. ,Ia~~) h~ ,_ p•h'lr'fhl tJ f r"'e it\+•"'"' (o,a..l.
f./oft ff..J '. r~ ( r~ [b,.,,t..:) IT~ '•-• ,I} • ewp(- ~~·•"><~,. e ~~ }
ftl l~,S) = !-;. , i.=t,&., ...• lc..
~~·~/dt r< to,._, ) i~ttfo
,(), :
~,·
,;t.
I,.lw ((L(
[h;.,, b,·)
=
=
sa.t of
S't t of
SeT of
3 t!nt't-po" e" t s ir~.d. i llc'dkA I~
i ~~td blt'rJ "" f r
i k(;o( i vt'd~~t-_ (s
Forwt a lt'lcett"lcod~ ~o estima fe. f,:
ftA/Ii~~t' ~ [6.-..,J A,)
$ftt#'llt'vl~ 8,. ce,.~.,~d ~ Ib.·., .b,-)
J
1K; .,.It d rtliAJtlf h
a~ ,L• X~·
L = 71 tJ..."''c"•"' 1T (t- "-~,.tl:~~J) 7f {t- ,~,.llt~1 \ ../f.~· u-, .J&..A T• " ' )
• r\,;c' .f ttA,'
~ • s ,.,. '"tit('• f,. u.;~e 5 1'1(~;-,,.,., ''~ liA.~,fl. -365-
£xr6111SION$:
(j) 7ii'I.C V~~tyuvfz Co11AK.1AT£,..
@ c~~~nN(, RtSKt {H"'""~ F/IILII~'-: r.,.,.,4'S)
Q) M.,,,.,~~.t F1411.V~4 /,~~'·
UH4 -· VAitftA/_6_ CtJfll41t119 'rl s _:
Atl t~l 'fl\a eotlit,. ••1-trl-..1 Ilk ,..,.d.s +o
1-1-• e,,. Sf i"' w '-lcL ~ c ctttt.t 1'14 fo# s vo ''I
W liJ... .,.,.,. L •
~ l f > c t!V11cM' t~J'e trA be e t). + fi M e ~
-~If) = I ! ~~) : 0 .: 4 " t }
~It; tl+J) c liwt p~ 1TE- [+;4.,~1-) }lttJ, T''f- j /t.~
.cl~o•
~U)~ I
-: Ao(of) e.- ""'
wJ..ftc d«-p ...,11""-el~ is o)\ +lu c.t.trr-t,.,A:- I
VAliA t ! (+) Olol-0
Plllt11AL /..1~4' lt-/UUI> J!.XTENbS /HI'-flfAI~A 12.t-l".
pt~(1J 6fM'(s / Rtt-~.·1), tA-I~;,IA,, fAk ft,., f
= e lft«.~ t+,.·,) 15
z e. ~, lft,,~) ;t
.l~~U·t • .~)
-366-
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
T s f-IM4 ~o fa/lurt
T= fyp1 of .f~ .. ilurc Tst,'l,-·, ~
f•ltt fc +• co,.art'o+l s ! -= l 't', • ••• ~ ~ .. )
or ··c:~cJD6 "
NDfl t1wJ' -fAA +o+te t h(A -..rfl. ir. ... ,t lt-; !) : ].; ~. l~i ,_)
.j:l .I -
IS A S4r;iu£Nt.e 01'- Ht/L7Jifi()HIIft. -tAC. S .,
-367-
TJ.ru -~-etru of ~·tu~~
j :. , i lltU' df ;rc.e. •f .,..~., 1• ic. I 'I flll4 plu lftC A-
J:t ,. ,.
ft.f,·c~ I".., Cl (( S'a.,co-.~
j:'J dutt1.. hy ~ fhlr (..AUSf. S.
T,·,..e - .._,a s~trtd . d..-.ys. ·~ = +iJttAf +-e fa,"/fltf. Of' (f"SOf'fll'
=I Cf•,"ft.4ff.) 0 (tfi'IO~t,C)
~,
-;jC: : +,,.f. Df fA."fwff.
PIZDIUHS
1. flow d• C.NAf'i~tt f r"f. faftt fc rak. ~
fGlilwre by "'ut'uvs +ypts ?
2. Ar~ tJ..t. feu'lwlt +'fflS i~~tft,~t/(l(fttl? '' i11tfJl p~,.rJ lnt" 1't's)cr
3. W"A+ is t~e ... fftc.t t)T (f.Motl/1"' o ... ~ Dr ~~~trtAI ~14u.SU tJf ·ftu'lftlrt?
a is of+t" t!ta tit~ THE pr•h/~,._ tJf t~tMpt fl,_'J tt's~'.
-368-
f~olt.IRI (tOMT10~
,. £s""' Afl~ ., lt.UAIIMISII'I% JU'~N cftiA~,If~c • ANO FltiL VU ~,._~. -
- ... , . f fft e.# of 9f'"" fr.t' ~ "·" ;r·ot~t tell~ J er )"'
c/~~ f"fA.tQ. bJ (f~ictA.{UW~. Cf.l.( S._f.(C)W.t1.
- ... _,. CIJ!#.t' rt,r.i'J C..,.(Jtlp Die.htl-tc Prf~J''""~".
~. I~t ftr ,.,f•lr'rNJitt"pl 6e lw t•,.. I( llft~u.A- -f.w'IA.tr.t
fyf'&S "If o ... a~~'.l ;,.,;~;e'u~l ~~ c,f v•vsu.~tly J..,·,: ,,·~~ ~f fr;,'f.tit'l of CH'.I -1-·yf' , ;'i 3~.,
t ~,., .• s r·-.,.·" .- ~ ~1 ~c1 c.~ t· ~·5 /.. t hw) ~is.Jr e; t· ' _I ? U fo ~ c. 'I, ' t; f e 11' ( ~1. ( , +·J r { ~
~ 1$ o 1t & 11 (). r r• w ;-, ~ sl"! ,.,;t D. ,., ill't i A v f' • f Acuf ~. Le ut ew.t'A-
At.u1c ~,14 ff vtrsu~ ltosf- liiJtas~.
~~ Ut't't Itt /.1. ~~ tltW'A·
~ D~p l~t/u't' Ct!,e.rorlltj •
.3. E sfl tt~~lllr'fl" tJ f -1./lur~ ra~s .fo, r~Ma,,l,..k., .,,.s il SoMe '?l''s ~rc r.t~MOtlf.d.
t:oN·~': 11~· A. ~ 1'¥'('/<ro~
~ ~J f,;,/. hnu""'' /1/;f':~-[)
-369-
I'/ 0 TA- ., • /tJ ~--··---
"" ' l'o fa/ It• 1 ~v·d : _...__.,. _____ _ ).{f; !) : ~ .l,; lt; ! )
J"''
Sut~iv•r ftl.tt cHG~t: . -- ===a fo
Flt;!l: pr1T~tl!1 ~ ewp 1- {, ~(Mif)tt.l
S'cd~~s,'~ £~cfr~~.:£~ .. -i~.--~~~ t,,~ r
~·(tj !) : J; ... ,.t1Tf[+,ttAt), T:j I! J /4t:
~ "Jlt; !) Ftt;!,)
~UWtk(et.fl~!._ I!!t.tP#~e_4: ·- ~!!~.__ _.~_:'fl.... +Jp4. :
Ij { t ; l ) : pr t T ~ t 1 7 •j / ! }
: ft f. l"i !) otAA. 0 J
P~e.CA~o ~~~vivor Fk"'c..h'f/t'\. .fo~ i"""- .,.'~'f«-...__ ~--- _..._. - --· ~- •--- ·-- ._ - ......__....._ ___ ~-------- . .-. s-------- ---- -I .. .
~·l+;!) : t•p i- fo-t ).i lu; !) .C.~A 1. No G. : ~· { t; ! ) hAS Ito P'oll•ht'//sh',
; .,._ ~~,,.,fA f?'tJll\ t'Jo\. ''"t ,A. I
) I~ .,. ' I .
-370-
p.C\, ..... _ ... _. ._. ,_ ...... ,_ ..... ~ ..... ~-- ....... , J
~--~--~~-----------------..~ Setb fJIHSi~ (or i~ttlrlt~ec e) -MA~~tcJr'I'JI\ fw iH.. -1-yp£.
£.et'a~os"' HtJSit.fler (tt~So) 'Mo,e.l IASt'~~t' ~·(f.) Aoou(
)-/lt; !)= fltM pttTt(+,+fat)\a1 7cj,.T'\+}14t. ·-371-
1?. £ (,11-eSSitMI ff •1>4 t ~ :
p .41fA>HEIZ1l.: - f'.••l 'fA' .t.,. ~;lt; '!.) 11: ).j Pi Q; t) 1 e- t:"
[#i!l_f~A~: fN•,.rHntaf J..,.n/S J.;tf;!) ~ A!/fJ e l!j 1 .. '~····,""
J)a+.: SIA./1}-I.U kJ fc..tl~d'IS of Jr.,('~ • J
~f ~,.~._,,,ft .f-iwt~S -t;, ~ .... ~ 1:;/C_/ (7'lo fr'ts)
Path'.J L; Ice.~ 'Jto o tl. pdift...\j& ~~ ...,pt j ~;lut._ ~t~:J({ltji)-1-o"t ~pt. j
. +cc.;t..Lttt. 4.t fj,' \
>.j l.fj;; 1;.:)
Peol'ueT Ofl )l'l Fltt'I"D~S. 7'TJ.f +M.fOI« IS $N1& A{. &£FoA~ fi/1T'It# ALe IJur .,.,.1'~ T I'~I,UU.\ TA-lC~ It~ ''"'soil£~.
-372-
tU~D,f,?ell /-lALII NIC.I-
is ./. 01 ~~ /'I_ (, 8 ..,,.., tY•c. •
'!A. )..i I+; ~) = >-ojl+> ~ ~ ~~l,t, s.
j•• T~~ L..y,..ek4~~ .- x c i. r· = • o I'Z. ' -· • .'leu·
~t-1' .so
J~t ~-~~s. tA C2 c -c .. 1 fR
Uo e,,.t/,_,Cil fJ-1- a,. eff~lk of fJeK'" .w~c. e...t~,"AJ,,.c.J:-6" T~ut ,..,.·, t.yM!-ItO~fiL rrJ•s. ..
- MfAN/c~d. o(~C+'#tUtl t::ltJe -#o 9u:' ff-t~ e~lfOHIIfW' -to.,. j~'L~ 'S r-t.lAA't'ie n\*~ e·fn.c ~-t'L ..
~ -~~ c ).1.1'
·37 3·
Cf~t-,siUA.( Ap/*'••'-'· /:1.14 I fl1l.c. l>e '-' fl•'tl ~
A.. A. -T •• T, , .•. , T...., c:o'"' p'fkrA.C ( lAt'l"t) ""'ilc..rc
l +i~• s. 01-Stn c. "" ~
T' ~ ,.,.,;" ( T., .•.. , T....,)
7 = t j I T; ~ TJ6 • 1c • ,j ... ,,.. 1 T"• '"&.L ,,...,,. lllu4 ,. eJ -fu Mc.h·~ is
,., t!... ., ,,· • ~ ~.,.~,·~ •,. ,; "' "'o,. • f -r; ~
&jt:tj;J)= G.lo~···,o,t:; .. o, .. 1 o)
. = ft' i TJ ~t-,.l:, t} TA• eo,rt~p174.d.t'"1 "'-~ ~rd is cr;.ll~d "f~
"c.t ka~ A~d
.......
. ·~ .,, hj t+r= - 1~ t, ~lt) = titw\pt~~•lt,t.,.t)l~~tJt
-374-
f$0 .,. 7"1/~lf.~ It; A 1'-...~,~~ ! J -~.':.~"'"'"•l~·~.;r'·· ··~--·
TA• IllAtA loti, ~·, 1.i , t: ) aroL s" ff.t·c./IJ"
+o ltJl~t1/fy ~MI'f ~.. ~1! .. " s~~Jffc. "-. '-4N~I
F.C'"·· -~-
)j tt;!) = LJ.,., P" 1 Tl [t,'f.,4t),7aj J!, T~t }/4f.~ 4~~0
GLt;, ... ~t~) ~~ 8..jlt;) ·i:.,J ... ,...,.. Qf"C.
t\Ot i 4~+e"fiCAit'f - fkr~tr ASSfA1t4fJ~~S ttftd~t/ •
•• ~,_.,..,:JI:t.. ' '": . -·- -~ .:.•.·.t"!: ..... - ___ __.... ... ·.:..~ ... - ..... ~ ... --~ ... -- ·.-•. ..., .... - ----.1>·1'-•'-·· 'I<' -~".P.
\ r,. ""~'T"~11$
, llo: 6 (f,, •.. ,t'-') s 1r Q_; (t-;) is "'ftofl-,
I CAtt.+f i +o.i.\.c. wi~~+ fkrt~ r AUfUMJO.fiOl\. ----
-375-
it\; ~N 51"147'/SrtCAt. G.v~STION t ~ilfAT IS TH~ H6l!HI4A11l~ ot: lt~nt~ti,AL ?
C !ttss/c-. I Arero,..~
1Hulfiple eltt't"' ~If t Q l t,.J ... ~ ~~)
Afltr ,t,..ol/a/ of all bat il--k Ca11Jt
Q. .i l f-; ) : G.l 0) .. "0, t-j .. 0~ .. "0} -: pt{ ~- ~ t J A~s t.f .,,. h ·,..! of i "'de pl tt.ti.t "l<-'- o.,. of
PfA ('(A )II\ ~ ty,·(. }4lf ddt. IS ~ •
~., ,.ot- loL t~swU.
@ !Xt,.,fJ .,4 f ~="> Ha,fi ~tall ltJ.fi~ ? No f''·o, v• h'r/ /"'J Ht:t ~ll.."' M ( t f?-'1)
@) .,/. SU41/y o"swe~ f-o ~ ete~h'~Jt S flf Ce.c.cA s~
~t-~1 (fjUt'f~ splei•li l~d 'l9f otlt Is .,~..~
Q((.(J UMt l.r -fltf ~ec.Aa..tcs "" t~e. .fK,' (", (
~'!P'-' a,..d tN. 'W1t.'fkorJ. df 'ftntova.l.
-376-
TAt sfa fisk't~l ~etltl)(/s ou.tli~ttd o..ho tit.
eo"~ e .,. ; t 1l t I y ~ e ttl,.,/ l t fo txo bIt ,., s ;,. voJvi.._, -wr u.l fi pfe fo.ilu.rl fi-.1. s.
n i•~i~·· tltAals t:Ut fo llowetJ. ;.,. fu fc'tt~tf.S of aft Aclc ~·r~ f'l.u,~f.d.. WJt,t- +o ~tlat~ r~tf~ of qtfac.~ ~ +o (,.,.) rl)tlwn·,.., ltft/s. Let ~lf) be. a .,.tQSul'e
of ;~I) 1/uh'oM a f +;,.e. -t
).It: llt>) - ra+e at Cll)f4..c'"- eflf.ltf" OUIAr Af -h'IM t ~it"" CIAII~I!Vt /tltt-f flf
~ lfj ~If)): Ao (f) e ~/t) "
ftott. 9~eT•ffy, 1'1110fiCfS C4fK (A/low /or d.EpiNtdt«U
of ffAf-f. o" ft•?JtAt~tcy trl pN.tli•tAS a71icJs., (ft.
T-t'w..e Si~~tu /o.';f41ttAc.li,.c.fc.
-377-