curbing methane to weaken rules white house set · 11/09/2018  · camera and open up about in ads....

1
VOL. CLXVII . . . No. 58,082 © 2018 The New York Times Company NEW YORK, TUESDAY, SEPTEMBER 11, 2018 U(D54G1D)y+@!/!?!#!: WASHINGTON — The Trump administration, taking its third major step this year to roll back federal efforts to fight climate change, is preparing to make it significantly easier for energy companies to release methane into the atmosphere. Methane, which is among the most powerful greenhouse gases, routinely leaks from oil and gas wells, and energy companies have long said that the rules requiring them to test for emissions are costly and burdensome. The Environmental Protection Agency, perhaps as soon as this week, plans to make public a pro- posal to weaken an Obama-era re- quirement that companies moni- tor and repair methane leaks, ac- cording to documents reviewed by The New York Times. In a re- lated move, the Interior Depart- ment is also expected in coming days to release its final version of a draft rule, proposed in February, that essentially repeals a restric- tion on the intentional venting and “flaring,” or burning, of methane from drilling operations. The new rules follow two roll- backs this year of regulations that, taken together, represent the foundation of the United States’ effort to rein in global warming. In July, the E.P.A. proposed weak- ening a rule on carbon dioxide pol- lution from vehicle tailpipes. And in August, the agency proposed replacing a rule on carbon dioxide pollution from coal-fired power plants with a weaker one that would allow far more global- warming emissions to flow un- checked from the nation’s smoke- stacks. “They’re taking them down, one by one,” said Janet McCabe, the E.P.A.’s top climate and clean- air regulator in the Obama admin- istration. Officials from the E.P.A., the In- terior Department and the White House did not respond to emails and telephone calls seeking com- ment. Industry groups praised the ex- pected changes. “It’s a neat pair” of proposals on methane, said Kathleen Sgamma, president of the Western Energy Alliance, an association of independent oil and gas companies that is based in Denver. The Obama-era E.P.A. WHITE HOUSE SET TO WEAKEN RULES CURBING METHANE INDUSTRY HAILS CHANGE Looser Monitoring and Repair Schedules for Oil and Gas Wells By CORAL DAVENPORT Continued on Page A13 WASHINGTON — The Trump administration is considering sanctions against Chinese senior officials and companies to punish Beijing’s detention of hundreds of thousands of ethnic Uighurs and other minority Muslims in large internment camps, according to current and former American offi- cials. The economic penalties would be one of the first times the Trump administration has taken action against China because of human rights violations. United States of- ficials are also seeking to limit American sales of surveillance technology that Chinese security agencies and companies are using to monitor Uighurs throughout northwest China. Discussions to rebuke China for its treatment of its minority Mus- lims have been underway for months among officials at the White House and the Treasury and State Departments. But they gained urgency two weeks ago, af- ter members of Congress asked Secretary of State Mike Pompeo and Treasury Secretary Steven Mnuchin to impose sanctions on seven Chinese officials. Until now, President Trump has largely resisted punishing China for its human rights record, or even accusing it of widespread vi- olations. If approved, the penal- ties would fuel an already bitter standoff with Beijing over trade and pressure on North Korea’s nu- clear program. Last month, a United Nations panel confronted Chinese diplo- mats in Geneva over the deten- tions. The camps for Chinese Mus- lims have been the target of grow- ing international criticism and in- vestigative reports, including by The New York Times. Human rights advocates and le- gal scholars say the mass deten- tions in the northwest region of Xinjiang are the worst collective human rights abuse in China in decades. Since taking power in 2012, President Xi Jinping has steered China on a hard authori- tarian course, which includes in- creased repression of large ethnic groups in western China, notably the Uighurs and Tibetans. On Sunday, Human Rights Watch released a detailed report U.S. May Act Against China For Detentions Economic Punishment for Anti-Islam Camps By EDWARD WONG Continued on Page A6 ATLANTA As Hurricane Florence gained muscle over the Atlantic Ocean on Monday and sped toward the shores of North and South Carolina, government officials in both states were taking few chances, exhorting more than a million residents and tourists in coastal areas to grab their essen- tials, jump into their cars and head inland as part of a great coastal emptying. The National Hurricane Center warned that the storm, which jumped to Category 4 strength on Monday with 140 mile-an-hour winds, could pummel the shore with life-threatening storm surges and soak a wide area with rains so heavy that freshwater flooding would become a major threat. It is expected to make landfall Thurs- day night near the North Carolina- South Carolina border. In Myrtle Beach, S.C., Tneah Brown was listening to the warn- ings. At work on Monday after- noon, she weighed the many com- plications that would soon flow from the order issued by Gov. Henry McMaster of South Car- olina, calling on people in eight counties nearest the shore to get out. Storm Closes In As One Million Flee Carolinas By RICHARD FAUSSET Hurricane Florence, seen from the International Space Station, was building strength on Monday as it headed for the East Coast. NASA, VIA ASSOCIATED PRESS Continued on Page A11 These are not the stories that candidates usually turn to the camera and open up about in ads. One talked about her father’s vi- olent temper and how she once watched him throw her mother through a plate glass door. An- other recalled watching his broth- ers struggle to find steady work because of their criminal records. A third spoke of suffering a decade of sexual abuse as a child. The wave of female, minority and outsider candidates that is breaking cultural barriers and toppling incumbents in the Demo- cratic Party is also sweeping aside a longstanding norm in cam- paigns: That the public image of politicians — especially women — should be upbeat, uncontroversial and utterly conventional. For many of these Democrats who were running against better- financed rivals, the breakthrough moment came after they got per- sonal in relatively low-cost videos that went viral, reaching millions of people. Using documentary- style storytelling, which can last for several minutes, candidates have found a successful alterna- tive to the traditional model of raising huge sums of money that get spent on expensive, 30-second television commercials. The videos are chiefly intended as ads, but they also served a fund-raising purpose. For a frac- tion of the cost, these videos can help to spread a candidate’s story in a way that is easily shareable and can inspire donations. Jahana Hayes, a Connecticut educator and first-time candidate who won a primary for Congress last month, produced a video for less than $20,000 that brought in $300,000 in donations. In it, she described the difficult circum- stances of her upbringing — being raised by her grandmother while her mother battled addiction and then getting pregnant at 17. In the housing project where Baring a Bit of Your Soul to Connect With Voters By JEREMY W. PETERS and SAPNA MAHESHWARI Continued on Page A14 Candidates Turning to Low-Budget Videos to Get Noticed SUKIONIAI, Lithuania — For the tiny village of Sukioniai in western Lithuania, the exploits of General Storm, a local anti-Com- munist hero executed by the Sovi- et secret police in 1947, have long been a source of pride. The village school is named after him, and his struggles against the Soviet Un- ion are also honored with a memo- rial carved from stone next to the farm where he was born. All along, though, there have been persistent whispers that General Storm, whose real name was Jonas Noreika, also helped the Nazis kill Jews. But these were largely discounted as the work of ill-willed outsiders serving a well- orchestrated campaign by Mos- cow to tar its foes as fascists. Blaming Russian propaganda, however, has suddenly become a lot more difficult thanks to Mr. Noreika’s own granddaughter, Sil- via Foti, a Lithuanian-American from Chicago who has spent years researching a biography of her revered relative and went public in July with her shocking conclu- sion: Her grandfather was a fierce anti-Semite and Nazi collaborator. Her unequivocal verdict — an- A Lithuanian Hero, or a Nazi Ally? Maybe Both By ANDREW HIGGINS A monument for Jonas Noreika. He signed documents ordering the seizure of Jewish property. BRENDAN HOFFMAN FOR THE NEW YORK TIMES Continued on Page A8 Descendant’s Research Exposes Complicity President Trump’s national se- curity adviser, John R. Bolton, strayed from his boss with skepti- cism for North Korea. Page A6. Strident Tone From Bolton Most mammals rely on ancient genes to produce teeth and tusks. But some elephants in Africa show how nature is able to alter the code. PAGE D1 SCIENCE TIMES D1-6 How Tusks Became Liabilities A Guatemalan mother, back with her two children after 51 days of forced separation, is seeking asylum. PAGE A10 NATIONAL A10-14 Making a New Life in Oregon An anti-graft commission is investigat- ing President Jimmy Morales, who is aggressively fighting back. PAGE A4 INTERNATIONAL A4-9 A Crisis in Guatemala The Education Department said pro- posed rules would decrease the number of investigations in schools. PAGE A12 Reducing Campus Rape Cases “Climate change is the defining issue of our time, and we are at a defining mo- ment,” the U.N. leader said. PAGE A6 An Alarm on Global Warming After Sam Darnold threw an early inter- ception, the Jets regrouped to rout De- troit, 48-17, and open with a road victory for the first time since 2009. PAGE B8 SPORTSTUESDAY B8-13, 16 Jets Win in Rookie’s Debut A brother-and-sister rabbi team held their usual unusual Rosh Hashana service, with a gospel choir singing songs in Hebrew. PAGE A15 NEW YORK A15-17, 20 Preaching Less Oy, More Joy Leslie Moonves took CBS from the depths to the top of television. Then his career came crashing down. PAGE B1 BUSINESS DAY B1-7 The Rise and Fall of Mr. TV A decade after Lehman Brothers implod- ed, the crisis still sets the political tone, Andrew Ross Sorkin writes. PAGE B1 Crash Echoes, 10 Years Later In the new series “The First” on Hulu, the years ahead are not quite the dysto- pian nightmare that seems to be in vogue now with other shows. PAGE C1 ARTS C1-8 A Not-So-Dark Future Martina Navratilova PAGE A19 EDITORIAL, OP-ED A18-19 As students have returned to school, they have been greeted by teachers who, more likely than not, are white women. That means many students will be continuing to see teachers who are a different gender than they are, and a differ- ent skin color. Does it matter? Yes, according to a significant body of research: Students, especially nonwhite stu- dents, tend to benefit from having teachers who look like them. The homogeneity of teachers is probably one of the contributors, the research suggests, to the stub- born gender and race gaps in stu- dent achievement: Over all, girls outperform boys, and white stu- dents outperform those who are black and Hispanic. Yet the teacher work force is be- coming more female: 77 percent of teachers in public and private elementary and high schools are women, up from 71 percent three decades ago. The teaching force has grown more racially diverse in that period, but it is still 80 per- cent white, down from 87 percent. There are many things that con- tribute to children’s academic achievement, including teachers’ experience and training; school funding and zoning; and families’ incomes and home environment. And teachers have long been pre- The teaching pool is still 77 percent female and 80 percent white. REED SAXON/ASSOCIATED PRESS Continued on Page A11 Students Thrive When Teachers Are Like Them By CLAIRE CAIN MILLER Late Edition Today, cloudy, humid, warmer, showers or thunderstorms, high 81. Tonight, showers or thunderstorms, low 71. Tomorrow, thunderstorms, high 80. Weather map, Page B16. $3.00

Upload: others

Post on 05-Oct-2020

1 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: CURBING METHANE TO WEAKEN RULES WHITE HOUSE SET · 11/09/2018  · camera and open up about in ads. One talked about her father s vi-olent temper and how she once watched him throw

VOL. CLXVII . . . No. 58,082 © 2018 The New York Times Company NEW YORK, TUESDAY, SEPTEMBER 11, 2018

C M Y K Nxxx,2018-09-11,A,001,Bs-4C,E2

U(D54G1D)y+@!/!?!#!:

WASHINGTON — The Trumpadministration, taking its thirdmajor step this year to roll backfederal efforts to fight climatechange, is preparing to make itsignificantly easier for energycompanies to release methaneinto the atmosphere.

Methane, which is among themost powerful greenhouse gases,routinely leaks from oil and gaswells, and energy companies havelong said that the rules requiringthem to test for emissions arecostly and burdensome.

The Environmental ProtectionAgency, perhaps as soon as thisweek, plans to make public a pro-posal to weaken an Obama-era re-quirement that companies moni-tor and repair methane leaks, ac-cording to documents reviewedby The New York Times. In a re-lated move, the Interior Depart-ment is also expected in comingdays to release its final version ofa draft rule, proposed in February,that essentially repeals a restric-tion on the intentional venting and“flaring,” or burning, of methanefrom drilling operations.

The new rules follow two roll-backs this year of regulations that,taken together, represent thefoundation of the United States’effort to rein in global warming. InJuly, the E.P.A. proposed weak-ening a rule on carbon dioxide pol-lution from vehicle tailpipes. Andin August, the agency proposedreplacing a rule on carbon dioxidepollution from coal-fired powerplants with a weaker one thatwould allow far more global-warming emissions to flow un-checked from the nation’s smoke-stacks.

“They’re taking them down,one by one,” said Janet McCabe,the E.P.A.’s top climate and clean-air regulator in the Obama admin-istration.

Officials from the E.P.A., the In-terior Department and the WhiteHouse did not respond to emailsand telephone calls seeking com-ment.

Industry groups praised the ex-pected changes. “It’s a neat pair”of proposals on methane, saidKathleen Sgamma, president ofthe Western Energy Alliance, anassociation of independent oil andgas companies that is based inDenver. The Obama-era E.P.A.

WHITE HOUSE SETTO WEAKEN RULESCURBING METHANE

INDUSTRY HAILS CHANGE

Looser Monitoring andRepair Schedules for

Oil and Gas Wells

By CORAL DAVENPORT

Continued on Page A13

WASHINGTON — The Trumpadministration is consideringsanctions against Chinese seniorofficials and companies to punishBeijing’s detention of hundreds ofthousands of ethnic Uighurs andother minority Muslims in largeinternment camps, according tocurrent and former American offi-cials.

The economic penalties wouldbe one of the first times the Trumpadministration has taken actionagainst China because of humanrights violations. United States of-ficials are also seeking to limitAmerican sales of surveillancetechnology that Chinese securityagencies and companies are usingto monitor Uighurs throughoutnorthwest China.

Discussions to rebuke China forits treatment of its minority Mus-lims have been underway formonths among officials at theWhite House and the Treasuryand State Departments. But theygained urgency two weeks ago, af-ter members of Congress askedSecretary of State Mike Pompeoand Treasury Secretary StevenMnuchin to impose sanctions onseven Chinese officials.

Until now, President Trump haslargely resisted punishing Chinafor its human rights record, oreven accusing it of widespread vi-olations. If approved, the penal-ties would fuel an already bitterstandoff with Beijing over tradeand pressure on North Korea’s nu-clear program.

Last month, a United Nationspanel confronted Chinese diplo-mats in Geneva over the deten-tions. The camps for Chinese Mus-lims have been the target of grow-ing international criticism and in-vestigative reports, including byThe New York Times.

Human rights advocates and le-gal scholars say the mass deten-tions in the northwest region ofXinjiang are the worst collectivehuman rights abuse in China indecades. Since taking power in2012, President Xi Jinping hassteered China on a hard authori-tarian course, which includes in-creased repression of large ethnicgroups in western China, notablythe Uighurs and Tibetans.

On Sunday, Human RightsWatch released a detailed report

U.S. May ActAgainst ChinaFor Detentions

Economic Punishmentfor Anti-Islam Camps

By EDWARD WONG

Continued on Page A6

ATLANTA — As HurricaneFlorence gained muscle over theAtlantic Ocean on Monday andsped toward the shores of Northand South Carolina, governmentofficials in both states were takingfew chances, exhorting more thana million residents and tourists incoastal areas to grab their essen-tials, jump into their cars and headinland as part of a great coastalemptying.

The National Hurricane Centerwarned that the storm, whichjumped to Category 4 strength onMonday with 140 mile-an-hourwinds, could pummel the shorewith life-threatening storm surgesand soak a wide area with rains soheavy that freshwater floodingwould become a major threat. It isexpected to make landfall Thurs-day night near the North Carolina-South Carolina border.

In Myrtle Beach, S.C., TneahBrown was listening to the warn-ings. At work on Monday after-noon, she weighed the many com-plications that would soon flowfrom the order issued by Gov.Henry McMaster of South Car-olina, calling on people in eightcounties nearest the shore to getout.

Storm Closes InAs One MillionFlee Carolinas

By RICHARD FAUSSET

Hurricane Florence, seen from the International Space Station, was building strength on Monday as it headed for the East Coast.NASA, VIA ASSOCIATED PRESS

Continued on Page A11

These are not the stories thatcandidates usually turn to thecamera and open up about in ads.

One talked about her father’s vi-olent temper and how she oncewatched him throw her motherthrough a plate glass door. An-other recalled watching his broth-ers struggle to find steady workbecause of their criminal records.A third spoke of suffering a decadeof sexual abuse as a child.

The wave of female, minorityand outsider candidates that isbreaking cultural barriers andtoppling incumbents in the Demo-cratic Party is also sweeping asidea longstanding norm in cam-paigns: That the public image of

politicians — especially women —should be upbeat, uncontroversialand utterly conventional.

For many of these Democratswho were running against better-financed rivals, the breakthroughmoment came after they got per-sonal in relatively low-cost videosthat went viral, reaching millionsof people. Using documentary-style storytelling, which can lastfor several minutes, candidateshave found a successful alterna-tive to the traditional model of

raising huge sums of money thatget spent on expensive, 30-secondtelevision commercials.

The videos are chiefly intendedas ads, but they also served afund-raising purpose. For a frac-tion of the cost, these videos canhelp to spread a candidate’s storyin a way that is easily shareableand can inspire donations.

Jahana Hayes, a Connecticuteducator and first-time candidatewho won a primary for Congresslast month, produced a video forless than $20,000 that brought in$300,000 in donations. In it, shedescribed the difficult circum-stances of her upbringing — beingraised by her grandmother whileher mother battled addiction andthen getting pregnant at 17.

In the housing project where

Baring a Bit of Your Soul to Connect With VotersBy JEREMY W. PETERS

and SAPNA MAHESHWARI

Continued on Page A14

Candidates Turning toLow-Budget Videos

to Get Noticed

SUKIONIAI, Lithuania — Forthe tiny village of Sukioniai inwestern Lithuania, the exploits ofGeneral Storm, a local anti-Com-munist hero executed by the Sovi-et secret police in 1947, have longbeen a source of pride. The villageschool is named after him, and hisstruggles against the Soviet Un-ion are also honored with a memo-rial carved from stone next to thefarm where he was born.

All along, though, there havebeen persistent whispers thatGeneral Storm, whose real namewas Jonas Noreika, also helpedthe Nazis kill Jews. But these werelargely discounted as the work ofill-willed outsiders serving a well-orchestrated campaign by Mos-

cow to tar its foes as fascists.Blaming Russian propaganda,

however, has suddenly become alot more difficult thanks to Mr.Noreika’s own granddaughter, Sil-via Foti, a Lithuanian-Americanfrom Chicago who has spent yearsresearching a biography of herrevered relative and went publicin July with her shocking conclu-sion: Her grandfather was a fierceanti-Semite and Nazi collaborator.

Her unequivocal verdict — an-

A Lithuanian Hero, or a Nazi Ally? Maybe BothBy ANDREW HIGGINS

A monument for Jonas Noreika. He signed documents ordering the seizure of Jewish property.BRENDAN HOFFMAN FOR THE NEW YORK TIMES

Continued on Page A8

Descendant’s ResearchExposes Complicity

President Trump’s national se-curity adviser, John R. Bolton,strayed from his boss with skepti-cism for North Korea. Page A6.

Strident Tone From Bolton

Most mammals rely on ancient genes toproduce teeth and tusks. But someelephants in Africa show how nature isable to alter the code. PAGE D1

SCIENCE TIMES D1-6

How Tusks Became LiabilitiesA Guatemalan mother, back with hertwo children after 51 days of forcedseparation, is seeking asylum. PAGE A10

NATIONAL A10-14

Making a New Life in OregonAn anti-graft commission is investigat-ing President Jimmy Morales, who isaggressively fighting back. PAGE A4

INTERNATIONAL A4-9

A Crisis in Guatemala

The Education Department said pro-posed rules would decrease the numberof investigations in schools. PAGE A12

Reducing Campus Rape Cases“Climate change is the defining issue ofour time, and we are at a defining mo-ment,” the U.N. leader said. PAGE A6

An Alarm on Global Warming

After Sam Darnold threw an early inter-ception, the Jets regrouped to rout De-troit, 48-17, and open with a road victoryfor the first time since 2009. PAGE B8

SPORTSTUESDAY B8-13, 16

Jets Win in Rookie’s DebutA brother-and-sister rabbi team heldtheir usual unusual Rosh Hashanaservice, with a gospel choir singingsongs in Hebrew. PAGE A15

NEW YORK A15-17, 20

Preaching Less Oy, More Joy

Leslie Moonves took CBS from thedepths to the top of television. Then hiscareer came crashing down. PAGE B1

BUSINESS DAY B1-7

The Rise and Fall of Mr. TV

A decade after Lehman Brothers implod-ed, the crisis still sets the political tone,Andrew Ross Sorkin writes. PAGE B1

Crash Echoes, 10 Years Later

In the new series “The First” on Hulu,the years ahead are not quite the dysto-pian nightmare that seems to be invogue now with other shows. PAGE C1

ARTS C1-8

A Not-So-Dark Future

Martina Navratilova PAGE A19

EDITORIAL, OP-ED A18-19

As students have returned toschool, they have been greeted byteachers who, more likely thannot, are white women. That meansmany students will be continuingto see teachers who are a differentgender than they are, and a differ-ent skin color.

Does it matter? Yes, accordingto a significant body of research:Students, especially nonwhite stu-dents, tend to benefit from havingteachers who look like them.

The homogeneity of teachers isprobably one of the contributors,the research suggests, to the stub-born gender and race gaps in stu-dent achievement: Over all, girlsoutperform boys, and white stu-dents outperform those who areblack and Hispanic.

Yet the teacher work force is be-

coming more female: 77 percentof teachers in public and privateelementary and high schools arewomen, up from 71 percent threedecades ago. The teaching forcehas grown more racially diversein that period, but it is still 80 per-cent white, down from 87 percent.

There are many things that con-tribute to children’s academicachievement, including teachers’experience and training; schoolfunding and zoning; and families’incomes and home environment.And teachers have long been pre-

The teaching pool is still 77 percent female and 80 percent white.REED SAXON/ASSOCIATED PRESS

Continued on Page A11

Students ThriveWhen TeachersAre Like Them

By CLAIRE CAIN MILLER

Late EditionToday, cloudy, humid, warmer,showers or thunderstorms, high 81.Tonight, showers or thunderstorms,low 71. Tomorrow, thunderstorms,high 80. Weather map, Page B16.

$3.00