cs 2010

24
:: Christa B. Teston, Rowan University | 19 March 2010 :: [ From Artifact to Action ] The Role of Medical Images in Cancer Care Deliberations

Upload: christa-teston

Post on 27-May-2015

351 views

Category:

Documents


2 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Cs 2010

:: Christa B. Teston, Rowan University | 19 March 2010 ::

[ From Artifact to Action ] The Role of Medical Images in Cancer Care

Deliberations

Page 2: Cs 2010

[ Q’s ]How is risk

communicated?

How is evidence displayed?

How are decisions made?

Page 3: Cs 2010

[ Tufte (1992) :: Cholera ]

Page 4: Cs 2010

[ Tufte (1992) :: Challenger ]

Page 5: Cs 2010

[ Sauer (2003) :: Coal Mining ]

Page 6: Cs 2010

[ Herndl, Fennel, Miller (1991) :: Nuclear Power ]

Page 7: Cs 2010

[ site ]multidisciplinary medical workplace

Tumor Board meeting

Page 8: Cs 2010

[ methods ]Glaser & Strauss (1967)

Grounded Theory

Observational Heuristics

Page 9: Cs 2010

[ Q ]How is medical decision-making shaped by visual renderings of disease?

Page 10: Cs 2010

[ Fig. 1 ]

Page 11: Cs 2010

[ example ]1 tumor board deliberative

trace

Page 12: Cs 2010

5 10 15 20 25 30

Past Personal

Experience

Typical Practice

Standard of Care

Studies & Statistics

Path. & Rad.

Information

Background

Information

Passage of Time (minutes)

Kin

ds

of

Refe

ren

ces

? ?

Page 13: Cs 2010

“Seeing those images will

change minds.”:: Dr. Thomas | TB participant, oncologist ::

Page 14: Cs 2010
Page 15: Cs 2010
Page 16: Cs 2010
Page 17: Cs 2010
Page 18: Cs 2010
Page 19: Cs 2010
Page 20: Cs 2010
Page 21: Cs 2010

[ Fig. 2 ]

Page 22: Cs 2010
Page 23: Cs 2010

[ medical images ]materially rendered,

argumentatively deployed,

facilitate future action

Page 24: Cs 2010

[ visual rhetoric ]more than mere illustration,

epistemic in an ontological sense---

(Enos & Lauer, 1992; Scott, 1967; McNely & Teston, 2010)