8/3/2019 CREW Amicus Brief: Brennan Center v. Dept of Justice, et al., (2d Cir.): 2/3/2012

1/40

_AFI_@ GI'

55+0188

PLA CA\ D_IQZ 55:< Aevp Kehg Vpraap Vqhpa 50:: _hflkig`# ]E ?6?58,

8/3/2019 CREW Amicus Brief: Brennan Center v. Dept of Justice, et al., (2d Cir.): 2/3/2012

2/40

FI_ZI_EPA @HVFCIVQ_A VPEPAKAGP

Zqrvqegp pi Ma`' _' Ezz' Z' ?='5# ekhfh fqrhea Fhphagv mir _avzigvhohchpx

eg` Aplhfv hg Tevlhgdpig ,F_AT( eg` Acafprighf Mrigphar Miqg`ephig ,AMM(

vqokhp plhv firzirepa hvfcivqra vpepakagp'

F_AT `iav gip le}a e zeragp fikzegx# eg` hv gip e zqochfcx+lac` fikzegx

thpl e 5:! ir draepar itgarvlhz hgparavp' F_AT hv e gig+zrimhp# gig+zerphveg

firzirephig# irdegha` qg`ar vafphig 1:5,f(,6( im pla Hgpargec _a}agqa Fi`a'

AMM `iav gip le}a e zeragp fikzegx# eg` hv gip e zqochfcx+lac` fikzegx thpl e

5:! ir draepar itgarvlhz hgparavp' AMM hv e gig+zrimhp# gig+zerphveg firzirephig#

irdegha` qg`ar vafphig 1:5,f(,6( im pla Hgpargec _a}agqa Fi`a'

Feva2 55+0188 @ifqkagp2 14 Zeda2 ? :?):6)?:5? 154085 0:

8/3/2019 CREW Amicus Brief: Brennan Center v. Dept of Justice, et al., (2d Cir.): 2/3/2012

3/40

hh

PEOCA IM FIGPAGPV

Zeda

FI_ZI_EPA @HVFCIVQ_A VPEPAKAGP '''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' h

PEOCA IM FIGPAGPV '''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' hh

PEOCA IM EQPLI_HPHAV '''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' h}

VPEPAKAGP IMEKHFH FQ_HEA'''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' 5

VQKKE_X IM E_DQKAGP ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' ?

E_DQKAGP ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' 1

H' PLA ICF KAKI_EG@E TA_A E@IZPA@ HGPI IMMHFHECEDAGFX ZICHFX EG@ PLA_AMI_A E_A GIP Z_IPAFPA@

OX PLA @ACHOA_EPH]A Z_IFAVV Z_H]HCADA ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' 1

E' Pla Mefpv Lara Avpeochvl Pla @amag`egp Edagfhav Hgfirzirepa`Pla ICF Kakireg`e Hgpi Plahr Mhgec Zichfhav ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' 1

O' Pla Di}argkagpv Gerrita` Vpeg`er` Mir E`izphig CefnvEgx Oevhv Hg Cet '''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' 5:

F' Pla @hvprhfp Fiqrpv Ezzchfephig Im Pla E`izphig @ifprhgaE`}egfav Pla Zqrzivav Im Pla MIHE '''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' 5?

@' A|akzphgd ICF Izhghigv Chna Pliva Ep Hvvqa Mrik Zqochf@hvfcivqra _hvnv Fraephgd E Oi`x Im Vafrap Cet ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' 5=

HH' PLA ICF KAKI_EG@E TA_A E@IZPA@ HGPI IMMHFHECEDAGFX ZICHFX EG@ PLA_AMI_A E_A GIP Z_IPAFPA@

OX PLA EPPI_GAX+FCHAGP Z_H]HCADA ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' ?:

Feva2 55+0188 @ifqkagp2 14 Zeda2 6 :?):6)?:5? 154085 0:

8/3/2019 CREW Amicus Brief: Brennan Center v. Dept of Justice, et al., (2d Cir.): 2/3/2012

4/40

hhh

HHH' EFFAZPHGD PLA DI]A_GKAGPV GE__IT

HGPA_Z_APEPHIG IM PLA E@IZPHIG @IFP_HGA EG@ HPV

O_IE@ HGPA_Z_APEPHIG IM PLA EPPI_GAX+FCHAGP

Z_H]HCADA TIQC@ @AGX PLA ZQOCHF EFFAVV PI PLA

_AEVIGV BQVPHMXHGD E O_IE@ E__EX IM EDAGFX

ZICHFHAV '''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' ?1

E' Pla Di}argkagpv Ezzriefl Thcc Cae` Pi Kira VafrafxDagareccx Hg Pla Di}argkagp @afhvhig+kenhgd Zrifavv ''''''''''''''''''' ?1

O' @hvfcivqra Lara Thcc Feqva Gi Lerk Pi Pla Di}argkagp '''''''''''''' ?4FIGFCQVHIG '''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' 6:

FA_PHMHFEPA IM MHCHGD EG@ VA_]HFA

FA_PHMHFEPA IM FIKZCHEGFA

Feva2 55+0188 @ifqkagp2 14 Zeda2 0 :?):6)?:5? 154085 0:

8/3/2019 CREW Amicus Brief: Brennan Center v. Dept of Justice, et al., (2d Cir.): 2/3/2012

5/40

h}

PEOCA IM EQPLI_HPHAV

Zeda,v(

FEVAV

Orig| @amag`arv }' Q'V' @azp im Likaceg` Vaf'#

?::1 Q'V' @hvp' CA\HV 666=0 ,V'@'G'X' @af' 58# ?::1( ''''''''''''''''''''''' 55# ?8

Fievpec Vpepav Dev Firz' }' @azp im Agardx#

=54 M'?`

8/3/2019 CREW Amicus Brief: Brennan Center v. Dept of Justice, et al., (2d Cir.): 2/3/2012

6/40

}

Vlhggafifn Hg`heg Gephig }' Nakzplirga#

=1? M' Vqzz' ?` 601 ,A'@'G'X' ?::8( ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' ?8+6:

Pe| Egecxvpv }' H_V#

554 M'6` =:4 ,@'F' Fhr' 5884( ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' 0# ??# ?0

Q'V' @azp im Bqvphfa }' _azirparv Fikk' mir Mraa`ik im pla Zravv#

0

8/3/2019 CREW Amicus Brief: Brennan Center v. Dept of Justice, et al., (2d Cir.): 2/3/2012

7/40

}h

Befn Dic`vkhpl# Pla Parrir Zravh`agfx2 Cet eg` Bq`dkagp

Hgvh`a pla Oqvl E`khghvprephig ,?::4( '''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' 5 gi

zerpxv fiqgvac figprhoqpa` kigax hgpag`a` pi mqg` zrazerhgd ir vqokhpphgd pla

orham> eg` gi zarvig iplar pleg pla ekhfqv fqrhea# hpv kakoarv# ir hpv fiqgvac

figprhoqpa` kigax hgpag`a` pi mqg` zrazerhgd ir vqokhpphgd pla orham eg`# hm vi#

h`agphmhav aefl vqfl zarvig'

Feva2 55+0188 @ifqkagp2 14 Zeda2 < :?):6)?:5? 154085 0:

8/3/2019 CREW Amicus Brief: Brennan Center v. Dept of Justice, et al., (2d Cir.): 2/3/2012

9/40

?

Immhfa im Cadec Fiqgvac ,ICF(' Ekhfh le}a viqdlp plava izhghigv oafeqva plax

a|zcehg pla rephigeca mir figpri}arvhec `afhvhigv @IB eg` iplar edagfhav le}a

ke`a# hgfcq`hgd afhvhigv ekhfh le}a fleccagda` hg chphdephig'

F_AT eg` AMM zerphfhzepa ev ekhfh hg plhv feva pi zravar}a pla zrhgfhzca

plep oipl MIHE A|akzphig 1 eg` pla e`izphig `ifprhga rafidgha` hgGC_O }'

Vaerv# _iaoqfn - Fi'# 0?5 Q'V' 56? ,5841( ,Vaerv(# eg`Gephigec Fiqgfhc im Ce

_ee }' @azerpkagp im Bqvphfa# 055 M'6` 61: ,?` Fhr' ?::1( ,Ce _ee(# era pi oa

figvprqa` gerritcx hg chdlp im pla MIHEv zqrziva im achkhgephgd vafrap cet# h'a'

pla tirnhgd oi`x im cet a|zcehghgd tlep eg edagfx lev `iga eg` tlx'

Vegfphighgd pla figphgqa` vafrafx im pla ICF kakireg`e ep hvvqa tiqc` `azrh}a

pla zqochf im hgmirkephig ig e th`a }erhapx im vqobafpv frhphfec pi qg`arvpeg`hgd pla

di}argkagpv rephigeca mir e`izphgd kegx figpri}arvhec zichfhav'

Plhv orham hv mhca` thpl pla figvagp im fiqgvac mir ecc zerphav hg pla feva'

VQKKE_X IM E_DQKAGP

_afidghhgd vafrap cet hv egeplake pi iqr `akifrephf vxvpak im

di}argkagp# Figdravv vap iqp pi achkhgepa hp plriqdl pla MIHEv keg`epirx

`hvfcivqra rauqhrakagpv' Pla MIHE zri}h`av farpehg chkhpa` a|fazphigv pi

`hvfcivqra# pi oa figvprqa` }arx gerritcx figvhvpagp thpl pla MIHEv i}arecc

zqrziva# oqp ecvi avpeochvlav e mrekatirn pi zra}agp edagfhav mrik naazhgd vafrap

pla oi`x im `afhvhigv# ir`arv# eg` kakireg`e plep di}arg lit eg` tlx

Feva2 55+0188 @ifqkagp2 14 Zeda2 8 :?):6)?:5? 154085 0:

8/3/2019 CREW Amicus Brief: Brennan Center v. Dept of Justice, et al., (2d Cir.): 2/3/2012

10/40

6

di}argkagp edagfhav efp' Pla `hvprhfp fiqrp lara zrizarcx figfcq`a` pla ICF

kakireg`e ep hvvqa kqvp oa `hvfciva` oafeqva plax le` oaag hgfirzirepa` hgpi

edagfx zichfx' Pi iplarthva zripafp plava cadec izhghigv mrik `hvfcivqra tiqc` oa

pi mivpar e drithgd oi`x im vafrap cet# pla `egdar plep chav ep pla laerp im pla MIHE'

Pla `achoareph}a zrifavv zrh}hcada hgfirzirepa` hgpi A|akzphig 1 im pla

MIHE rauqhrav `hvfcivqra im edagfx izhghigv eg` hgparzrapephigv plep# rader`cavv im

plahr ceoac# ammafph}acx razravagp pla edagfxv cet eg` zichfx' Pla a}h`agfa im

rafir` lara akigvprepav pla di}argkagp hgfirzirepa` ICF izhghigv figfarghgd

pla figvphpqphigechpx im pti vpepqpav hgpi mhgec eg` immhfhec edagfx zichfx mir

`hvprhoqphgd dregp mqg`v' Miccithgd plhv Fhrfqhpv `afhvhig hgCe _ee# pla

`hvprhfp fiqrp zrizarcx figfcq`a` qg`ar plava mefpv pla ICF izhghigv akoi`ha`

edagfx zichfx eg` era plaramira oaxig` pla zripafphig im pla `achoareph}a zrifavv

zrh}hcada'

Hg erdqhgd pi pla figprerx# pla di}argkagp `amag`egpv @IB# pla

@azerpkagp im Laecpl eg` Lqkeg Var}hfav ,LLV(# eg` pla Q'V' Edagfx mir

Hgpargephigec @a}acizkagp ,QVEH@( ,ficcafph}acx pla di}argkagp( e`}egfa eg

hgparzrapephig imCe _ee plep qg`arkhgav hpv di}arghgd rephigeca eg` tiqc` cae` pi

pla }arx `egdarv Figdravv viqdlp pi zra}agp plriqdl pla MIHE' Mer mrik

avpeochvlhgd e gerrit# orhdlp+chga pavp mir tlag pla e`izphig `ifprhga ezzchav#Ce

_ee vpravva` pla hkzirpegfa im a|ekhghgd ecc pla raca}egp mefpv eg`

Feva2 55+0188 @ifqkagp2 14 Zeda2 5: :?):6)?:5? 154085 0:

8/3/2019 CREW Amicus Brief: Brennan Center v. Dept of Justice, et al., (2d Cir.): 2/3/2012

11/40

0

fhrfqkvpegfav# 055 M'6` ep 614 g'1 ,akzlevhv hg irhdhgec(# dqh`a` ox pla zrhgfhzca

pla zqochf feg igcx oa agchdlpaga` ox ngithgd tlep pla ^edagfx[ oacha}av pla

cet pi oa' H`' ep 6=: ,uqiphgd Pe| Egecxvpv }' H_V# 554 M'6` =:4# =5< ,@'F' Fhr'

5884(('

Effazphgd pla di}argkagpv gerrit ezzchfephig im pla e`izphig `ifprhga pi

igcx pliva fevav tlara eg edagfx zqochfcx eg` razaepa`cx e`izpv pla zichfx

rephigeca tiqc` zri}h`a e rie` kez mir edagfhav pi naaz vafrap zichfx rephigecav im

}hpec figfarg pi pla zqochf# mrik pla bqvphmhfephig mir pla qva im pirpqra ig mirahdg

fikoepegpv pi pla terregpcavv thrapezzhgd im Ekarhfeg fhphagv' Pla zqochf

hgparavp hg zichfx bqvphmhfephigv a|hvpv rader`cavv im tlaplar pla raevigv mir pla

zichfx le}a oaag efngitca`da` zqochfcx ir razaepa`cx ox pla edagfx' Naazhgd

`ifqkagpv chna pla ICF kakireg`e ep hvvqa vafrap# a}ag empar edagfhav le}a racha`

ig plahr figfcqvhigv eg` raevighgd pi mirkqcepa eg` hkzcakagp zichfx# tiqc`

hkza`a effiqgpeohchpx mir oipl ICF eg` pla edagfhav rafah}hgd pla e`}hfa'

MiccithgdCe _ee# pla `hvprhfp fiqrp ecvi zrizarcx figfcq`a` pla ICF

kakireg`e era gip zripafpa` ox pla eppirgax+fchagp zrh}hcada' Igfa e`izpa` ev pla

di}argkagp edagfhav immhfhec zichfhav# pla ICF kakireg`e macc iqpvh`a pla vfiza

im A|akzphig 1' Kirai}ar# pla veka zichfx rephigeca vqzzirphgd `hvfcivqra im

iplarthva `achoareph}a `ifqkagpv e`izpa` ir hgfirzirepa` ox ramaragfa hgpi mhgec

izhghigv ezzchav thpl auqec mirfa pi pla eppirgax+fchagp figpa|p' Ep plahr fira# pla

Feva2 55+0188 @ifqkagp2 14 Zeda2 55 :?):6)?:5? 154085 0:

8/3/2019 CREW Amicus Brief: Brennan Center v. Dept of Justice, et al., (2d Cir.): 2/3/2012

12/40

1

pti zrh}hcadav zripafp vhkhcer hgparavpv# eg` gerritcx figvprqhgd plava zrh}hcadav

zra}agpv pla `a}acizkagp im vafrap cet'

Ep oippik# pla di}argkagp ezzaerv pi oa evnhgd plhv Fiqrp hkzchfhpcx pi

i}arpqrg hpvCe _ee `afhvhig eg` avpeochvl e kqfl gerritar figvprqfphig im pla

e`izphig `ifprhga' Vqfl e ki}a tiqc` rqg `hrafpcx fiqgpar pi pla raevigv tlx

Figdravv agefpa` pla MIHE hg pla mhrvp zcefa# eg` tiqc` dh}a pla di}argkagp mraa

chfagva pi `a}aciz eg` kehgpehg e oi`x im vafrap cet di}arghgd lit ma`arec

edagfhav efpqeccx efp eg` tlx' Plava `egdarv feg oa zra}agpa` igcx ox

rahgmirfhgd gip rapraephgd mrik plhv FhrfqhpvCe _ee izhghig'

E_DQKAGP

H' PLA ICF KAKI_EG@E TA_A E@IZPA@ HGPI IMMHFHECEDAGFX ZICHFX EG@ PLA_AMI_A E_A GIP Z_IPAFPA@ OX

PLA @ACHOA_EPH]A Z_IFAVV Z_H]HCADA'

E' Pla Mefpv Lara Avpeochvl Pla @amag`egp Edagfhav Hgfirzirepa`Pla ICF Kakireg`e Hgpi Plahr Mhgec Zichfhav'

Zcehgphmm+ezzaccaa ,zcehgphmm( vaanv `hvfcivqra im plraa kakireg`e zrazera`

ox ICF mir LLV eg` QVEH@ e``ravvhgd figvphpqphigec hvvqav rehva` ox pla

ezzchfephig im pti ma`arec vpepqpav' ,VZE 5# 55+56(' Iga# pla Premmhfnhgd ]hfphkv

Zripafphig _aeqplirhephig Efp# ravprhfpv dregp mqg`hgd pi irdeghephigv plep

a|zchfhpcx vpepa plax `i gip zrikipa# vqzzirp# ir e`}ifepa pla cadechephig ir

zrefphfa im zrivphpqphig' ?? Q'V'F' 455:,d(,?(' Pla iplar# pla Qghpa` Vpepav

Cae`arvlhz Edehgvp LH])EH@V# Pqoarfqcivhv# Kecerhe Efp# vhkhcercx ravprhfpv dregp

Feva2 55+0188 @ifqkagp2 14 Zeda2 5? :?):6)?:5? 154085 0:

8/3/2019 CREW Amicus Brief: Brennan Center v. Dept of Justice, et al., (2d Cir.): 2/3/2012

13/40

=

mqg`hgd pi irdeghephigv plep le}a e`izpa` eg a|zchfhp zichfx izzivhgd zrivphpqphig

eg` va| premmhfnhgd' ?? Q'V'F' 4=65,m('

Ig Maorqerx 5?# ?::0# LLV rauqavpa` eg izhghig mrik ICF ig

figvphpqphigec hvvqav rehva` ox pla vpepqpav mqg`hgd ravprhfphigv' ,VZE 55(' Mh}a

`exv cepar# ICF zri}h`a` LLV eg` QVEH@ iga im pla kakireg`e ep hvvqa'

,BE 60# 6=> VZE 55(' Cepar hg Maorqerx# QVEH@ hvvqa` eg Efuqhvhphig eg`

Evvhvpegfa Zichfx @hrafph}a ,EEZ@(# tlhfl zri}h`av dqh`egfa pi irdeghephigv

vaanhgd dregpv# ezzcxhgd pla mqg`hgd ravprhfphig pi igcx mirahdg irdeghephigv'

,BE 5=1+46> VZE 55+5?(' Plhv zichfx ra}arva` e Begqerx ?::0 EEZ@ plep ezzcha`

pla mqg`hgd ravprhfphig pi ecc driqzv' ,BE 51 VZE 55(' QVEH@ rahparepa` pla

gat zichfx hg hpv Bqcx eg` Eqdqvp ?::0 EEZ@v' ,BE 5 VZE 56('

LLV vhkhcercx hvvqa` e dregp giphfa hg Bqga ?::0# ezzcxhgd pla mqg`hgd ravprhfphig

pi igcx mirahdg irdeghephigv' ,BE 541+44> VZE 5?('

Hg Bqcx ?::0# ICF vagp pti kira kakireg`e pi LLV eg` QVEH@

e``ravvhgd pla figvphpqphigec hvvqav' ,VZE 5?+56(' Plava kakireg`e raefla` e

`hmmaragp figfcqvhig eoiqp ezzcxhgd pla mqg`hgd ravprhfphigv pi ikavphf

irdeghephigv pleg pla aerchar ICF izhghig# ,VZE 54+5 VZE 51(# eg` hg Bqga ?::1# QVEH@ vhkhcercx evvarpa`

Feva2 55+0188 @ifqkagp2 14 Zeda2 56 :?):6)?:5? 154085 0:

8/3/2019 CREW Amicus Brief: Brennan Center v. Dept of Justice, et al., (2d Cir.): 2/3/2012

14/40

4

hg eg EEZ@ hpv zichfx plep pla mqg`hgd ravprhfphigv ezzcha` pi oipl mirahdg eg`

`ikavphf irdeghephigv' ,BE ??5+? VZE 51('

Hg Bqcx ?::1# zcehgphmm mhca` MIHE rauqavpv thpl ICF# LLV# eg` QVEH@

vaanhgd pla ICF kakireg`e' ,BE ?0

8/3/2019 CREW Amicus Brief: Brennan Center v. Dept of Justice, et al., (2d Cir.): 2/3/2012

15/40