copper toxicity - nebula.wsimg.com
TRANSCRIPT
0
1
COPPER TOXICITY
DISCOVER HOW THIS EPIDEMIC
MINERAL IMBALANCE MAY BE ROBBING YOU
OF ENERGY, EMOTION, LIFE, & OPTIMAL HEALTH
(BASED ON THE WEBSITE WWW.COPPERTOXIC.COM)
RICK D. FISCHER
2
Copyright © 2017 Rick D. Fischer
All rights reserved. No part of this book (or website www.coppertoxic.com) may be
reproduced, copied, or resold in any form other than for “fair use” as brief quotations embodied
in articles and reviews – without the prior written permission of the author.
This book is an E-book version of the information provided at www.coppertoxic.com, the author
of which is the same as this E-book.
This E-book is available by donation or purchase ONLY. This E-book may not be resold or
redistributed. If you believe you have received an unauthorized copy of this E-book, kindly
contact [email protected], or make a donation to support the time and effort that has
gone into this research and, more importantly, the cause.
Medical Disclaimer: The author of this book is not a doctor. The information contained herein is
based on first-hand experience, hundreds of case studies, the author's own extensive training in
HTMA, working as a practitioner with those affected, and decades of research into mineral
balancing and copper toxicity by leading doctors and other professionals. HOWEVER, this
information is presented solely for informational purposes to help people better understand the
potential health implications of excess copper. It is not intended to provide medical advice, it is
not intended to diagnose any condition, and it does not replace the advice of your physician or
other health care provider, provided they understand both the physical and psychological
effects of copper toxicity and the detox process. The author assumes no responsibility for any
possible consequences from any treatment, procedure, dietary modification or action which
results from reading, following, or interpreting the information contained herein, or from the
failure to first consult with a licenced medical professional specializing in copper toxicity. The
reader is therefore encouraged to speak with a medical specialist trained in copper toxicity
and detoxing before starting any new therapeutic technique, diet, supplementation program,
or detoxing protocol.
3
“When medical science comes to understand the implications of a copper imbalance, it may be referred to as the scourge of the late 20th century. It is one of the
most commonly encountered imbalances that we find on tissue mineral tests today. Many of the most prevalent metabolic dysfunctions of our time are related in some way to a copper imbalance. Copper toxicity is a much
overlooked contributor to many health problems; including anorexia, fatigue, premenstrual syndrome, depression, anxiety, migraine headaches, allergies, childhood hyperactivity and learning disorders.”
~ Dr. Paul Eck and Dr. Lawrence Wilson
4
“It's unthinkable that so many people are suffering, physically, emotionally, or
energetically, by a condition that has been known and written about for over 4
decades, but which conventional medicine still has so very little understanding
of, or in some cases even refuses to recognize. The research and compilation of
information on www.coppertoxic.com, and on which this book is based, is
dedicated to a forever beautiful woman and her dream of helping women and
girls with nutritional knowledge, health, and personal growth. It is dedicated to
every woman, man, and child, struggling, knowingly or unknowingly, with
copper toxicity; and to those who's loved ones may be affected.
I hope through this research we as a community can offer greater support,
guidance and understanding to those experiencing copper toxicity and its
symptoms; providing people in general and women in particular with vital
nutritional knowledge that can unlock a door to the rediscovery
of their highest and healthiest potential, while also reducing the risk
of associated symptoms in our children and future generations.” ~ Rick Fischer
Acknowledgments
Beyond the author's own experience, training in advanced HTMA, hundreds of case studies,
and working with clients, much of the information provided here is based on the life work
of several pioneering doctors and experts in this field. A few of these individuals who have given
us so much knowledge and deserve recognition include:
Dr. Carl Pfeiffer, PhD., MD (physician, biochemist, specializing in orthomolecular psychiatry
focusing on schizophrenia, author of Mental and Elemental Nutrients...)
Dr. Eck (widely considered the authority on the science of balancing body chemistry through
hair tissue mineral analysis and founder of Analytical Research Labs)
Dr. Watts, PhD (Dr. Ecks past partner at ARL, and founder of Trace Elements Inc (one of the two
top hair testing labs in the U.S.), as well as its Director of Research)
Dr. Hans Selye Ph.D., MD (pioneering endocrinologist, Nobel prize nominee, acknowledged as
the "Father" in the field of stress research)
Dr. Rick Malter, PhD (licensed nutrition counselor, licensed psychologist, leader in the field of
copper toxicity and HTMA for the past 40 years, author of "Shrinking the Judge")
Dr. Lawrence Wilson, MD (a student of Dr. Eck who, for over 30 years, has focused on nutritional
balancing science and copper toxicity research).
Dr. Ann Louise Gittleman (pioneering leader in the field of nutrition, columnist, functional and
integrative medicine advocate, and author of "Why Am I Always So Tired")
Dr. Weston Price (considered the "Isaac Newton of Nutrition, medical researcher, and author of
"Nutrition and Physical Degeneration")
...and many others, not mentioned here, who have devoted their work to bringing greater
awareness and understanding to copper toxicity and mineral imbalances in general.
5
SPECIAL OFFER from www.HTMATEST.com
This offer is not valid if you received this book as a bonus as part of an HTMA package
6
TABLE OF CONTENTS
What is Copper Toxicity…………………………………………………………. 7 Terminology …………………………………………………………… 8 Copper Toxicity vs Deficiency ………………………………………. 9 Most Common Symptoms ……………………………………………. 10
Chart: The Flow & Effects of Copper Accumulation ……………………… 11 Copper's Effect on Adrenal Function and Energy ………………………… 12
Adrenal Burnout and Relationships ………………………………….. 14 Evidencing Adrenal Burnout on an HTMA …………………………. 16 A Word of Caution When Taking Adrenal Support … ……………. 17
Copper's Connection with Estrogen / Hormones and Birth Control ….. 18
Estrogen Dominance ………………………………………………….. 22
How Diet Affects Copper ……………………………………………………… 24 Copper Sulfate on Our Crops ………………………………………….. 29 Organic vs Inorganic Copper ………………………………………….. 29 Drinking Water (Copper Piping) ……………………………………….. 30
Impact on Emotions, Relationships, and Mental Health .…………………. 31
Why Copper is Called the 'Emotional Mineral' …………………… 31 The Calcium Shell ……………………………………………………….. 33 The Cortisol - Oxytocin - Serotonin - GABA Connection ……….. 35 The Damaging Toll on Relationships ………………………………... 38 The Emotional Impact of Detox ……………………………………… 39 A Silent Link to Alzheimer’s ……………………………………………… 42
Testing ………………………………………………………………………………. 44 Blood and Urine Testing ………………………………………………….. 44
Hair Tissue Mineral Analysis …………………………………………….. 48 The Slow Metabolizer vs Fast Metabolizer …………………………. 53
Detox and Healing…………………………………………………………………. 55
How Long Should One Expect Copper Toxicity Detox to Take ….. 55 More Words of Caution Before Taking Zinc and Adrenal Support… 56 Beneficial Nutritional Considerations …………………………………. 60 Additional Considerations That May Assist Detox ………………….. 65 What to Expect and Look Out For During Detox ……………………. 69 How Emotional Programming Can Block Correction ………………. 74 The Gift of Healing …………………………………………………………. 75
Why Copper Toxicity is So Poorly Understood ………………………………….. 77
References …………………………………………………………………………….. 83 About The Author ……………………………………………………………………. 84
7
WHAT IS COPPER TOXICITY?
Copper Toxicity is a build up of stored bio-unavailable
copper in the body that at high levels affects many of the
most common physical and mental conditions we're seeing
today. Copper is an essential mineral in the human body
and in bio-available form plays many important roles.
However at high unbound levels, a simultaneous
toxicity/deficiency condition is created. Copper becomes
toxic when it accumulates in the body's tissues in excessive
amounts (Pfeiffer, 1975; 1987), while also becoming more
and more bio-unavailable which then impairs and in many
cases reverses its beneficial attributes. A high level of
unbound copper becomes a powerful reactive toxin to
both the body and mind, leading to a number of symptoms
including brain fog, chronic fatigue and adrenal burnout,
hypothyroid, depression, panic attacks, and at later stages
is linked to the numbing of emotions, paranoia,
hallucinations, Alzheimer's, schizophrenia, even cancer.
Copper toxicity is a major factor in many of today's most
prevalent conditions, and should at least be an essential
route of investigation for any of the above mentioned
symptoms.
Rates of copper toxicity have been steadily increasing over
the past half century due to increasing exposure to various
estrogens, certain birth control methods, high copper diets,
stress, copper piping, and many other environmental,
dietary, and lifestyle factors. Copper toxicity goes vastly
unrecognized however due to an over-reliance on using
blood to measure copper status, along with the myriad of
articles being written that blindly promote the idea of
copper deficiency without making the key connection
that most copper deficiency (and associated symptoms) is
the result of excess copper exposure. In essence, the higher
the degree of copper accumulation, the higher the degree
of bioavailable deficiency. There is also a widespread
denial of copper toxicity (perhaps the most far reaching yet
“Virtually all MDs, including psychiatrists, still have not heard
of this health problem. They practice medicine and psychiatry
with an incredible lack of awareness that such a serious
health problem even exists. They claim to be practicing “evidence
based medicine”, yet they are practicing without the most
basic evidence – real laboratory data showing the presence of
excess (toxic) copper that has a profound effect on both the
physical and mental health of the vast majority of their
patients. Ever since Carl Pfeiffer, MD, PhD first wrote about the
devastating health effects of copper toxicity in 1975, it has been a challenge for him and
others among us to get the message out to the public and
health professionals. Until medical doctors and other
“health” care practitioners begin to study the mind/body’s
mineral system especially as it is reflected in HTMAs, the medical
/ mineral disconnect will remain. Without HTMA data,
medical doctors will not recognize the epidemic nature of
the copper toxicity problem.” ~ Dr. Rick Malter, Ph.D.
8
misunderstood health epidemic of our time) which only
further suppresses those affected from finding real answers.
TERMINOLOGY
Copper toxicity may sometimes be referred to as
hypercupremia, though it is a misleading term since
hypercupremia literally translates to mean 'high copper
concentration in the blood' even though blood levels are
almost entirely irrelevant in assessing copper toxicity.
Symptoms of copper toxicity can very much exist even when
blood levels are normal or low. Another erroneously used term
being used recently, copper dysregulation, while it eludes to
the body's inability to regulate copper due to low
ceruloplasmin, is a narrow-minded view that fails to address
the bigger picture of why we have this epidemic in the first
place, not to mention completely ignoring copper’s proven
toxic attributes at high levels. Copper toxicity, as research has
shown since the 1970s, is far more than just a dysregulation
issue that can be ‘fixed’ by regulating ceruloplasmin. Our
modern epidemic of copper toxicity is largely the result of
ever increasing exposure to copper with each new
generation over the past half century, a concept of
paramount importance that is trivialized by using the
term ‘dysregulation’. Copper toxicity, in the context of this
site, differs somewhat from Pyroluria (a genetic condition in
which the individual produces excess kryptopyrrole which in
turn causes B6 and zinc deficiency). Copper toxicity, though
sharing some similarities with Wilson's Disease, is different in
that the latter is an inherited & rare genetic disorder which,
like copper toxicity, causes copper to collect in the liver, brain
and other body tissues, but has a more dire prognosis than
copper toxicity, and for which a different treatment
approach is required.
“High cellular copper levels, along with related sulfur
deficiencies, can be considered to be one of the most
prominent causes of many physical and mental health
problems" [1]
“One of the most common and important imbalances that we
see in clinical practice with trace minerals is excess copper
and deficient zinc.” ~Chris Kesser
9
COPPER TOXICITY vs DEFICIENCY Before discussing excess copper symptoms, the relationship
between excess copper and deficient available copper
needs to be understood. Many people who are copper
toxic, after searching online, discover they have symptoms
that resemble copper deficiency. They will also likely come
across the slew of online articles out there that ad nauseam
promote the idea of copper deficiency and associated
symptoms - yet very few of those authors understand
that most copper deficiency in the West is actually caused by
copper toxicity! And that distinction makes a world of
difference - the difference between leading the public to
believe that more copper consumption will do them well,
instead of helping people understand that too much copper
exposure is at the root of many of their health symptoms. True
dietary copper deficiency in the West is rare. Though a
minority of the population do have a true deficiency, the
majority of people have a deficiency of bioavailable copper
stemming from excess exposure / accumulation. Excess
copper acts as an excitotoxin, and as the copper level builds
up, the adrenals eventually weaken from over stimulation. This
in turn leads to an eventual decline in the liver's production of
ceruloplasmin (a protein which binds to copper to make it
bioavailable); and without adequate ceruloplasmin to bind
to the copper, excess copper then gets stored in a bio-
unavailable form in soft tissue - creating a deficiency
condition. In other words, the more copper the body
accumulates (toxicity), the more likely the eventual
deficiency of bioavailable (usable) copper. Dr. Malter, Ph.D,
one of the leading researchers in this field for over 40 years,
uses the great analogy of copper toxicity being akin to being
stranded in the middle of the ocean and dying of thirst. There
is lots of water all around, but none of it is in a form that can
be used to drink. As a result, the copper toxic patient's
symptoms may simultaneously reflect that of both copper
deficiency and toxicity. (Again though in a small percentage
of the population, a true copper deficiency does exist).
"If there is excess copper in the body, then a wide array of
psychological and physiological symptoms and conditions can
also develop like Tourette’s, schizophrenia, bipolar, mania,
autism, asperger’s, anemia, hair loss and much more. Extremely high copper levels can result in
a psychotic break." ~ Cynthia Perkins, M.Ed
10
MOST COMMON SYMPTOMS fatigue and exhaustion, adrenal depletion
hypothyroid
emotional numbing / apathy /
despondence
concentration and memory problems
racing mind (feeling wired but tired)
nausea
panic attacks
depression
hair loss and/or whitening of hair
brain fog / spaciness
high anxiety
irritability
ruminating negative thoughts
personality change
loss of sex drive
OCD and Relationship OCD (ROCD)
withdrawal / isolation
chocolate cravings
allergies and mold sensitivity
lowered immunity
The diagram on the following page is adapted from the more detailed version
available at www.coppertoxic.com, and shows the flow and effects of copper
accumulation.
insomnia
increased PMS
constipation
anemia
(manic) mood swings
despair, hopelessness
suicidal thoughts
joint aches and pains
depersonalization
candida / yeast infections
hypoglycaemia
headaches
reduced metabolism
confusion, disorientation,
paranoia
decreased self awareness
ADD
pseudo bi-polar disorder
schizophrenia / disperception of
self or others
11
Figure 1: The Flow & Effects of Copper Accumulation
12
COPPER'S AFFECT ON THE ADRENALS AND ENERGY Though copper assists with energy production, this is only
one side of the energy coin. As copper builds up, it has a
stimulating effect on the adrenals, giving one a sense of
increased energy. However, as the person takes on more
and more, this 'wears down' adrenal function over time, and
eventually fatigue and exhaustion can set it. Eventually this
can potentially lead to full blown adrenal burnout. Initially,
aldosterone increased which enhanced brain activity and
led to the 'racing mind' symptom, common as copper
begins to accumulate. The person might take on new
projects and load their plate with tasks. However in doing so
they are only further adding to their own stress and further
wearing themselves out. The accumulation of excess
copper presents a continual source of internal stress, which
takes a further toll on the adrenals. Under stress (from any
source), the body loses both zinc and magnesium (calming
minerals), while boosting sodium and intensifying the
individual's short fuse reactions to stressors. In turn, with zinc
spiralling lower, copper accumulates further. Eventually the
body is no longer able to respond to the stress. If the body is
unable to properly eliminate the copper, and so long as the
exposure to copper continues, it will eventually lead to
exhaustion / adrenal burnout, along with a crash in sodium
and aldosterone. At this point the person has little energy
left to do anything. The more exhausted the adrenals
become, the less the liver is able to produce ceruloplasmin
needed to make copper bioavailable, and so
biounavailable copper then accumulates faster and faster
in the liver (primarily) and brain (secondary).
Stress from any cause contributes to copper imbalance.
Stress depletes the adrenal glands and lowers the zinc level
in the body. Whenever zinc becomes deficient, copper
tends to accumulate.
“Burnout causes emotional and physical devastation that
cripple’s the person’s personality and human potential ... The person whose life has been
gutted by stress-damage usually does not know what hit him –
and usually has no idea what is really wrong with him... When
you go into burnout, unless you pull out of it and realize what
actually happened to you - you can go into a state of
disillusionment that can last the rest of your life."
~Dr. Eck
13
Full adrenal burnout is a significant game changer that can
have life long affects on the patient. The obvious symptom is
an overwhelming sense of debilitating fatigue, often with a
period of complete and utter exhaustion. Resentment,
withdrawal, dizziness, loss of libido, slurred speech,
depression, insomnia, frustration, lost interest in relationships,
moodiness, poor concentration, and irritability are all
common symptoms.
Beyond the obvious symptoms above, the point of adrenal
burnout will cause a significant worsening of the copper
toxicity condition, due to ceruloplasmin production
decline. Ceruloplasmin is a glycoprotein produced in the
liver, and it is responsible for the transport of 95% of the copper
in the blood plasma. As the adrenals speed up initially,
ceruloplasmin (Cp) production is usually fine, as the adrenal
activity assists with Cp production. However, upon burnout,
this all changes, and the previously adequate Cp levels now
dwindle and become deficient. Without ceruloplasmin to
bind to copper, copper is essentially bio-unavailable in the
body, regardless of how much excess copper is being stored.
This post-burnout Cp insufficiency means that stored bio-
unavailable copper now begins building up even faster,
adding an even greater burden to the liver and adrenals, and
in turn exacerbating the aforementioned symptoms of
burnout. Energy also takes a further hit. Without adequate Cp,
copper is incapable of completing the electron transport in
the mitochondria (where our energy is produced). In the
exhaustion stage, copper is not being used nor eliminated,
and it further stores in the tissues. Under stress or sudden
increases in adrenal activity, copper leaks out or 'dumps' from
storage, and this can heighten PMS type symptoms, insomnia,
headaches, joint pains, skin rashes, anxiety, panic attacks,
paranoia, and depression, among other problems.
"In the fall of that year I went
into total breakdown…Gittleman talks about adrenal burnout in
zinc deficiency as a total exhaustion of the adrenal
capacity to respond to stress. Deep burnout produces a
bone-shuddering, unrelenting fatigue that is beyond anything I would have imagined… Burnout
was only part of what was going on. There were also waves of a
kind of feverish delirium that made it very hard to focus on my
surroundings or communicate with others… I remained in a
free-floating kind of fugue state for years. It is part of the
disorientation of the condition that I don’t know now exactly
when I came out of it...there is such a high level of confusion,
distractibility and anxiety in certain people today that they frequently cannot focus on the
information that could help them. Such observations lead me
to look into the area of zinc deficiency and adrenal burnout
in their situations." ~ Laurie Warner, MA, CNC
14
ADRENAL BURNOUT AND RELATIONSHIPS The lack of energy resulting from adrenal exhaustion / burnout
can have a profound effect on relationships as well. When
exhaustion, depression, and anxiety take over, it's impossible to
be the spouse you want to be for your partner, and shame and
doubts creep in. Often, the patient is not even aware of what
their feelings really are. The lack of energy reduces awareness
to the true extent of the problem. In fact, at this stage many of
the symptoms associated with copper toxicity are the same as
those common with adrenal burnout, and the issue is just as
much about the burnout as it is with the copper. If copper
toxicity is accompanied by adrenal exhaustion/ burnout, the
previously mentioned symptoms can be further amplified. It is
highly improbable for a person who has experienced adrenal
burnout, especially when copper toxicity is also at play, for
emotional thinking to be rational in the period following
burnout. The following conversation is taken from an interview
with biochemist, HTMA and Nutritional Balancing pioneer and
world's foremost expert on trace mineral relationships, the late
Dr. Paul Eck, as can be found in the 1985 book 'Energy: How it
Affects Your Emotions, Your Level of Achievement, and Your
Entire Well-Being' by Chatsworth and Eck:
Dr. Eck: Exactly! When a person undergoes a severe stress, or a series of minor stresses, the body’s reservoirs of zinc become severely depleted. The end-result is an ever-increasing build-up of copper in the tissues. Excessive tissue copper leads to a depression of both adrenal and thyroid activity. It is at this point that burnout ensues. Recovery from burnout occurs only when excessive tissue copper has been eliminated and tissue zinc reserves fully restored. Partial recovery from burnout occurs when tissue copper levels are diminished. Full recovery occurs only when excess tissue copper has been completely eliminated. Although a person may indeed have tremendous amounts of excess copper stored in his tissues, it may not immediately appear on a tissue mineral analysis until the body releases this copper from storage reservoirs. HV: I have noticed that people in burnout retire into their own world. Now they may be just as talkative as before, but somehow they are more distant. The person’s spontaneity seems to be gone, they seem to be more artificial. It seems as though there is always an aura of repressed anger about them – as though they are ticked off and you don’t know why. You wonder if it’s at you or if it’s at everything. You never know. You can’t even talk to them about it
"Copper toxicity reduces the ability to cope normally with
stress and the inability to respond adequately can provoke
many fearful emotions, including anxiety and panic."
~ Theresa Vernon, L.Ac.
"The unfortunate consequence of all this fatigue-induced
irritability can often be negatively felt in our
relationships with those closest to us... Many women have
missed out on important milestones in their loved ones’
lives due to debilitating fatigue that has left them unable to participate in even the most
basic daily tasks...We feel too tired to keep up with the
demands of life, so we feel overwhelmed. Feelings of
overwhelm often result in losing sight of the bigger picture and
difficulty seeing workable solutions to the problem at
hand. Overwhelm spirals into feelings of guilt, frustration,
disappointment, and, eventually, anger, resentment, and
depression." ~ Michelle L. Brown, CTNC
15
because they will not talk about it. They will even deny that it is true. Dr. Eck: This is true. People in burnout will withdraw. They hesitate to communicate; you have to be so careful what you say to them, and often they won’t cooperate or want to work with anyone. They act as if they want to do everything on their own without anyone’s help. If you try to get too close to them they push you away. Even though they need your help, they may act as if they don’t, and even act as if they resent your ‘interfering’ with them. HV:The person might think that their relationship with their partner isn’t satisfying and that they need a different person. Dr. Eck: This is true. It is very easy to blame everybody else when you are in a state of adrenal exhaustion. One of the first insidious signs of burnout – even before chronic fatigue – is that all of a sudden the person is not as sexually aroused as he used to be. He doesn’t think about it as often and he doesn’t participate in it as often. What we are saying applies even more to women than it does to men. HV: The person is no longer the same person that he was before. He becomes unapproachable. Dr. Eck: It shouldn’t come as a surprise that burnout breaks up so many marriages. People in burnout have trouble making emotional commitments to others. They are too sunken into themselves. They can’t even take care of themselves. What do they have to give to others? They don’t have enough energy to make a deep commitment to almost anyone or anybody. Often the person has no real idea of what has gone wrong with their life... They may become functional to a point where they return to work and enjoy things more. However , the devastating effects of a severe burnout are usually permanent. Even without experiencing full adrenal burnout, adrenal fatigue
presents its fair share of symptoms. In her book 'The Everything
Guide to Adrenal Fatigue', Dr. Maggie Luther lists the following
symptoms of adrenal gland dysfunction as:
difficulty getting up in the morning
strong salt cravings or strong sugar cravings (usually one
or the other, not both)
daytime fatigue that is not relieved by any amount of
sleep
lowered or no libido
difficulty handling stress, decreased productivity
increased emotional symptoms including anxiety,
irritability, depression
trouble recovering from illnesses, chronic infections
16
lightheadness when standing quickly, ongoing ringing in the ears
worsening of symptoms if meals are skipped
lack of focus, "brain fog", memory loss
exhaustion in the morning, crashes in the early
afternoon, energy bursts after dinner at night
Energetically, just as the person's physical energy decreases,
or changes, so does their 'vibrational energy', or
frequency. This can also affect relationships because the
ability to connect energetically to the person they once knew
diminishes. As Dr. Lawrence Wilson states, "Relationships often
suffer when one person in the relationship goes into adrenal
exhaustion".
EVIDENCING ADRENAL BURNOUT ON AN HTMA
As copper rises, it has antagonistic and synergistic effects on
various minerals as explained visually on page 11. One
mineral that excess copper depletes is potassium. On an
HTMA (Hair Tissue Mineral Analysis) we can clearly see the
effect copper has on the adrenals by assessing the
corresponding levels of potassium (and sodium). Low sodium
and potassium is a clear indicator
of adrenal burnout/exhaustion.
When we see such low potassium
we know that not only is there
insufficient adrenal function, but
that as a result there will also likely
be insufficient ceruloplasmin
production. Along with the low
sodium and potassium
(exhausted adrenals) there is the
possibility that copper won't show
up as high in the hair (or in blood
either for that matter), simply
because that excess copper is
tightly stored in tissues with
insufficient energy to release it.
Figure 2: HTMA Profile showing adrenal exhaustion, yet still
with clear evidence of copper toxicity showing.
17
A WORD OF CAUTION WHEN TAKING ADRENAL SUPPORT Adrenal support will be required to help release excess stored
copper as well as raise ceruloplasmin. HOWEVER, this
requires the patient (and practitioner) to be aware of two
possible and very important consequences.
Adrenal support can give a person a relatively quick sense
of restored energy, enough to make the person think they
have recovered. Any such quick improvement is merely a
false sense of improvement, as to properly restore adrenal
function takes at minimum 6 months to a year or more,
including giving the body sufficient rest and following proper
healing protocol. For those who are suffering from severe
adrenal burnout, the process can take two years or more.
The danger is that adrenal support can lead a person to quit
their program too early, believing themselves to be fine, even
though they have merely just begun the process. Don't be
fooled - feeling better quickly does not mean your adrenals
are rejuvenated.
Adrenal support will mobilize stored copper. Attempted too
quickly (or strongly), and without sufficient detox pathways,
this bio-unavailable copper will simply be stirred up, possibly
aggravating symptoms further, and getting redeposited in
other locations, including the brain. This underscores the dire
importance that any copper detox using adrenal support
must be done very gently and cautiously. The supervising
practitioner also needs to inform the patient of these possible
detox reactions while not misleading the patient into thinking
they are fine after just a few weeks. It also underscores in a
general sense, when investigating how to heal adrenal
fatigue, the importance of understanding one's mineral
status and the role imbalance plays in contributing to the
fatigue.
18
COPPER'S CONNECTION WITH ESTROGEN / HORMONES AND BIRTH CONTROL For some women, the copper IUD experience is without any
significant symptoms, and most OB/GYN's insist there is no
possible connection with the IUD or that an increase in copper
levels or psychological changes can occur. The copper IUD is
promoted as a safe option because it's "non-hormonal".
However, copper IUD risks are not being fully disclosed to
patients, and the product is certainly not as innocuous as those
promoting it make it sound. As far back as 1975, Dr. Carl
Pfeiffer in his book Mental and Elemental Nutrients made the
connection between the increasing prevalence of copper
'toxicity' and use of the pill and IUD. After copper IUD insertion,
both blood tests and hair tissue mineral tests will likely show an
increase in copper levels. These studies (46, 47, 48) support that
evidence, while hundreds of thousands of HTMA profiles
(including the sample profile shown in the TESTING section)
verify this connection. Of course, some blood elevation in of
itself does not necessarily lead to problems (initially), as for
many women their diet contains enough zinc to balance the
increase in copper, while their detox systems are strong enough
(for a while) to maintain proper regulation. That said, it will not
take much searching online to find forums filled with thousands
of women who's lives and health have been utterly ruined after
having their IUD put in (several cases and stories are included
at www.coppertoxic.com), and numerous class action law suits
have been filed as a result (that alone should be a clue as to
the dangers). Copper builds up slowly in the body. For many
women symptoms first begin appearing 2 or 6 months after
insertion, for others though the time period may be much
longer, years to decades before they notice anything, or
connect the dots. Side effects of copper IUD as copper
accumulates usually begin with increasing brain fog and
fatigue, often paired with a racing mind. Eventually, once the
liver is overloaded, copper will then start accumulating in the
brain, and severe shifts in personality can occur as a result of
increasing bio-unavailable copper and calcium and changes
"Birth control pills and copper IUDs - these two birth control
methods definitely affect copper metabolism in the body. While some women can handle them,
others experience depression, anxiety, personality shifts and
many horrible side effects from them, either acute or chronic.
This aspect of [birth control] has probably caused more
disasters in women’s health than any other."
~Dr. Lawrence Wilson
"TMA studies frequently reveal elevated tissue copper in
women taking oral contraceptive agents which has
been confirmed by others, as well in women with copper
intrauterine devices." [2]
"The continued use of oral contraceptives has been, and
will continue to be, an important factor in influencing
copper homeostasis in women."
~ Karl E. Mason, PhD, [3] (Note: this warning was given to
us back 1979!)
"In a fair number of these women [on the Pill]...problems
are often stated by other members of the family who have
observed a total change of personality.”
~Dr. Philip Ball testifying on the side effects of birth control
at the Nelson Pill Hearings, 1970
19
in neurotransmitter production. The period 2 to 5 months post-
insertion is a common time for many when metabolism begins
slowing and energy, behaviour, and reactions begin
changing, especially with increasing depression and
irritability. For some people, the simple decision to use
a copper IUD can change their entire life trajectory, destroying
important relationships, and beginning a cascade of health
issues that can take many years to rectify.
The copper problem has significantly worsened in the years
since the birth control pill was introduced. Since that time,
more and more females have become copper toxic (and we
see this with the evidence provided through HTMA data). The
mother's excess then gets transferred in utero via the placenta
to the fetus during pregnancy, leading to elevated levels in
the male population as well. Young girls entering adolescence
are especially at risk since their own estrogen build-up will
further increase the vulnerability to the problem - this is why it's
so important to acknowledge this issue and proactively test
female children early. The birth control pill affects copper by
way of estrogen. Anything that raises estrogen (as the pill
does) increases copper retention, and in turn, many of the
direct psychological effects of copper (especially depression
and anxiety). In fact, the 'science researchers' seem to finally
be catching up to this connection with a study published in
2016 (something the pioneers of HTMA and copper toxicity
research have already known about for 40 years, trying for
decades to get the medical community and public to listen).
This study [6, 7], the largest of its kind with over a million women
tracked over 13 years, showed the direct link between
hormonal contraceptive use and significantly increased rates
of depression. Most people however just think of the Pill's
connection to estrogen, without making the copper
connection. When the copper connection is made,
considering excess copper's direct link to increased rates of
depression and copper's effect on raising tissue calcium and
lowering magnesium (which in turn increases the risk of blood
clots [39]), questions raised by cases examined in articles such
"One of the effects of Xenoestrogens is to reduce the excretion rate of copper from the body. All estrogens cause
copper accumulation, xenoestrogens look like
estrogens to our biochemistry and hence also cause copper
retention. These patients have very high copper levels."
~Dr. Igor Tabrizian
"Excess copper can cause dramatic imbalances in two key
neurotransmitters, and may lead to depression or
behavioural/learning issues. For example, 68% of all ADHD
kids have a tendency for very high levels of copper. Excess
copper can cause inattention, anxiety, and hyperactivity.
Copper is especially problematic for women because estrogen
and copper are proportionately related. If you're high in
estrogen, you'll be high in copper."
~William J. Walsh, PhD
"When copper accumulates in the brain, this is the racing
mind, the paranoia, the anxiety, the fears, the phobias, tired but
wired...when you see women with their PMS, it's the copper
accumulating in the brain causing a lot of the depression,
anxiety, paranoia" ~ Dr. Robert Selig
20
as this one would certainly find clearer answers, and those
researching why youth mental health cases are exploding in
schools (example) might stop scratching their heads. How
many more have to suffer before this nutrient connection is
made!?
The estrogenic effect of the oral contraceptive pill, combined
with the fact that the synthetic progesterone does not have a
true progesterone effect, means that minerals such as
magnesium, zinc, and B6 diminish while copper rises [8]. On
that note, consider the unstable (negative) emotions
associated with pregnancy, or post-partum, or with
PMS. During pregnancy, estrogen rises, increasing copper
retention. The serum copper level almost doubles during
pregnancy! After giving birth, if the mother is not able to
detox her copper load (either through natural and healthy
liver and bile functioning) or through breast-feeding, much of
her elevated copper level remains stored in her body, a
contributing factor to depression / PPD, and anxiety. In fact,
women with a history of PPD have significantly higher serum
levels of copper[9]. (It would be interesting to see how even
more prevalent this connection would surely be if proper HTMA
testing had been done for that study). Many of the emotional
symptoms of PMS are also copper induced as estrogen rises
during the cycle. Estrogen rises up until ovulation at which
point progesterone takes over as the dominant hormone and
helps bring down estrogen (and copper). But when the
woman is estrogen dominant (low progesterone) or already
copper toxic, the cycle build up of estrogen leads to a further
increase of copper along with its correlated emotional
symptoms. Studies have clearly shown that zinc deficiency
resulting from increased copper occurs during the luteal
phase - when PMS symptoms occur.[10] Copper increases
sodium which aggravates PMS symptoms, while lowering zinc
and vitamin B6 - two nutrients which help reduce PMS
symptoms and are both also essential for serotonin production
(our happy hormone).
"Blood clots and blockage of blood vessels are one of the most serious side effects of
taking oral contraceptives and can cause death or serious
disability." ~Merck (package insert for
Desogen tablets) [49]
"It has been shown that women with a history of postpartum
depression (PPD) exhibited significantly higher Cu level
than those without PPD history." [29]
"I will not treat a woman more than once, if at all, if she is using
an IUD because it’s a certainty that it’s causing some, if not all of, her problems. I haven’t seen
an exception yet." ~Dr. Stephen Gangemi, DC,
DIBAK, DCBCN
21
The majority of women on the pill have negative side effects
[11], but because this all-important mineral connection is so
rarely discussed (even denied!) in medical circles and by
prescribing physicians, women often don't associate their
symptoms with the pill, or even more so with the ‘non-
hormonal’ IUD. Nor are they being given fully informed
consent when they are prescribed the pill or the IUD -
something (informed consent) every woman surely deserves to
have! This book is not meant in any way to discourage the use
of birth control, but rather help women understand the effect it
can have on their mineral balances so that they can
proactively take steps to maintain a healthy balance and
body.
"Women recently have been encouraged to substantially increase their dietary intake of calcium in hopes of preventing osteoporosis in their old
age. TMA data strongly suggest that most women today are slow oxidizers. Adding significant amounts of calcium to their dietary intake
will very likely exacerbate tendencies toward hypothyroidism and adrenal insufficiency (characteristics of slow oxidizers). Increasing calcium intake
will further slow the rate of metabolism of these women and allow for greater accumulation of toxic metals in the body. Increasing calcium
intake in a slow oxidizer will especially allow for increased accumulations of excess copper. This phenomenon will be intensified by the use of the
birth control pill or by estrogen replacement therapy during and after menopause (Mehta & Eikum, 1989). The accumulation of
excess copper will lead to greater storage in the liver and in the brain. The excess copper accumulation will further slow the rate of
metabolism with both psychological and physical problems manifesting more frequently (Malter, 1985). This process may be
leading to a major iatrogenic health disaster."[5]
"Another troubling discovery we have made during our research is that women are often unable to identify the side effects they
are experiencing from hormonal birth control, because
they are not fully informed. Around 60% of
women go off the Pill in the first six months due to unwanted side effects. Sometimes these
medications are tolerated well, but many times the side effects
are insidious, like depression, anxiety, lack of libido, or
headaches that can too easily be ascribed to just being a
'teenager' or a 'moody female'. Many women will begin taking an antidepressant without ever
realizing that their symptoms were brought on by their birth
control." [4]
22
ESTROGEN DOMINANCE
Estrogen dominance is a major issue which really throws off our
mineral balance and leads to increased copper
retention. The following are some of the more common
symptoms of estrogen dominance:
*cramping *bloating
*bleeding and clotting *mood swings
*Fibroids *memory loss
*Endometriosis *weight gain
*PCOS *brain fog
*Fibrocystic breasts *hair loss
*breast tenderness *insomnia
*increased irritability *fatigue
*osteoporsis *PMS
*hypothyroid *headaches
*slow metabolism *hypoglycemia
Note the similarity between those symptoms and
the symptoms of copper toxicity. While oral contraceptive use
is one contributing factor to estrogen dominance, largely
adding to the problem is the increasing prevalence of
xenoestrogens in our environment and lifestyle. Xenoestrogens
are manmade chemicals that mimic estrogen in the body.
Pesticides are our biggest source of xenoestrogens, both from
crops and produce as well as eating meat from animals which
previously consumed those crops. Growth hormones given to
much of the (non-organic) livestock and poultry we eat is
another source. PCB's, PVC's and plastic food and drink
containers also give chemicals which mimic estrogen in the
body. Even stress contributes to excess estrogen, while
estrogen in turn mimics the shock phase of the stress reaction.
Dr. Hans Selye, MD (the ‘father of stress research’) explained
how estrogen causes the pituitary to secrete hormones which
impair the ovaries from producing progesterone while at the
same time stimulating cortisol production. For women as they
enter their late-thirties, progesterone levels begin to decline
more quickly than estrogen, further contributing to estrogen
"One of the effects of Xenoestrogens is to reduce the excretion rate of copper from the body. All estrogens cause
copper accumulation, xenoestrogens look like
estrogens to our biochemistry and hence also cause copper
retention. These patients have very high copper levels."
~Dr. Igor Tabrizian
"The Estrogens in [birth control pills] do have Estrogenic effects,
but the progesterone (being synthetic) tends not to have true
progesterone effect. Another version of Estrogen dominance.
This explains why zinc and magnesium fall and why copper
rises while on the OCP (oral contraceptive pill)." [8]
23
dominance in women. In fact, between the ages of 35 to 50,
while estrogen drops about 35%, progesterone drops by up to
75% [44], leading to more and more to estrogen dominance as
menopause approaches. A zinc deficiency then allows copper
to accumulate further, especially with the presence of
estrogens and xenoestrogens which impair the body’s ability to
excrete the excess copper. Once again, the more estrogen
(regardless of source), in men or women, the higher the rate of
copper retention in the body. We've already seen through
scientific studies of wildlife how frogs and fish are switching
gender due to this rise in estrogens. Women are becoming
more and more estrogen dominant, especially in the Western
world, and some experts link this increase of estrogen to the rise
in rates of breast cancer, infertility, autoimmune diseases,
etc. This most definitely further impacts the number of people
who currently and who in the future will be diagnosed as
copper toxic.
"Excess copper can cause
dramatic imbalances in two key neurotransmitters, and may
lead to depression or behavioural/learning issues.
For example, 68% of all ADHD kids have a tendency for very
high levels of copper. Excess copper can cause inattention,
anxiety, and hyperactivity. Copper is especially problematic
for women because estrogen and copper are proportionately
related. If you're high in estrogen, you'll be high in
copper." ~William J. Walsh, PhD
24
HOW DIET AFFECTS COPPER This section discusses the effects of copper toxicity on the gut
and digestion, as well as how a plant based diet contributes to
copper toxicity. This discussion should not be taken in any way
to knock the virtues of veganism / vegetarianism, as copper's
affect on gut health affects everyone, regardless of dietary
preference. The information here is presented with evidence
from a nutritional / mineral perspective, further backed up by
HTMA data, to inform, educate, and serve. Remember
that, even diet aside, excess copper can build up for everyone
from drinking water through copper piping (discussed later in
this section), as well as from glyphosate sprayed on crops
(which tends to chelate zinc), fungicides such as copper
sulphates also used on crops (as also discussed further below,
and which contain oxidized copper that cannot be used by
the mitochondria and is toxic to the body), congenitally, birth
control methods, and a number of other sources. Diet,
however, is a key contributor that needs to be acknowledged
as part of a complete discussion. For the vegan reader, this
section is not to dissuade from the plant based diet, but rather is
offered as a source of further empowerment for the individual
by providing a greater understanding of the biochemical
effects of minerals, while encouraging proactive action through
proper testing and added supplementation.
The vegetarian diet, and even more so the vegan diet, puts
one at significantly higher risk of having elevated levels of
copper. How 'toxic' the copper accumulation becomes on
your body depends on how long you've been following a plant
based diet, the strength of your detox pathways, stressors in
your life, and if other sources of copper (such as the birth
control pill or IUD) are also contributing. Everyone reacts
differently, and elevated copper levels do not necessarily
translate into symptoms, initially. However, almost across the
board, through HTMA data looking at the tissue level of copper,
we see the copper toxic pattern as typical in the long-term
vegan/vegetarian person.
"We have observed through
TMA studies that vegetarians appear to have a greater
tendency to retain copper than non-vegetarians."
~Trace Elements Inc
"Once digestive vigor has been reduced and copper buildup
has affected liver function, foods high in copper, or those that
interfere with zinc, can be troublesome. Gittleman states
that vegans, who often combine plant protein sources to
increase protein intake, can be especially susceptible to
copper toxicity." [12]
"Ironically, animal meat is the main food high in zinc which
could correct the excess copper. But a person like me,
who stayed away from red meat for the past 10 years and leaned
into a vegetarian diet, tends to accumulate more and more
copper unbalanced by zinc. Then, to make us extra
crazy, our body begins to crave high copper foods, so we eat
more of them. I was inhaling avocado, nuts, beans, chocolate,
sugar and tea every day. Growing just a tad more
coppery, zippy and fatigued as I munched along, oblivious."
~Diane Stallings RN, Nutritionist
25
Zinc is required to keep copper in check; without enough zinc
copper will accumulate. The best zinc sources in terms of
absorption are found in meats. Without this zinc, excess copper
builds up in tissues which then interferes particularly with the liver
and digestion, among other systems as well. A vicious cycle is
then created, because as liver / bile function and digestive
processes decline, meat protein becomes less tolerable,
solidifying the belief that one feels better eating plant foods.
Zinc is also very important for metallothionein (MT) synthesis.
One of MTs vital roles is to bind to copper for enhancement of
utilization or for removal and excretion. Without adequately
absorbed dietary zinc, MT synthesis is impaired, further allowing
copper (along with other toxins and metals) to build up. [15]
Phytates, common in plant foods, further compound the
problem by interfering with zinc absorption. The copper zinc
ratio in plant foods is already high to begin with, and the
phytates (and oxalates) just make it worse. Without adequate
zinc, the individual lacks the ability to retain potassium.
Adequate potassium is necessary for hydrochloric acid
secretion in the stomach - a deficiency of which will develop a
distaste for animal protein. No matter how much potassium the
individual eats through vegetables and fruit, it is not being
retained. This lack of available potassium is a common cause
behind many vegetarian complaints including apathy,
underweight, digestive issues, and depression. The answer is not
to simply eat more potassium, but rather help the body make it
usable by strengthening the adrenals and metabolism.
Otherwise, the vegetarian will continue to crave stimulants such
as chocolate (high in sugar, copper, and oxalic acid) or
running/jogging which temporarily whips up the adrenal glands
making the person feel temporarily 'more alive'...all the while
depleting their energy reserves further and allowing copper to
rise. These are just some of the dangers of veganism (and to a
slightly lesser extent vegetarianism) that are often over-looked
but should at least be understood.
"Disruption of the copper-zinc
ratio is an overlooked contributor to intractable
fatigue that follows excessive reliance on a plant-based diet.
The result is toxic accumulation of copper in tissues and critical
depletion of zinc through excretion. This condition usually
goes unrecognized because copper levels in the blood can
remain normal. Also, most doctors are unprepared to meet
with extreme zinc deficiency and its baffling effects on many
systems of the body. Hair mineral analysis, competently
used, is the tool which can unravel the complexities of this
growing problem. In particular, it is becoming clear that plant-
based diets, and lighter diets generally, cause serious
nutrient imbalances and long-term damage to digestion and
cellular metabolism that are not easily corrected." [12]
26
Two additional problems the vegan/vegetarian faces is
potential sulfur deficiency and taurine deficiency, both of which
then make proper detoxing even more difficult. Sulfur is found in
certain vegetables (i.e.: garlic, onions, beans) as well as in
meats. It is most abundant however and in a more usable form
in meat. This creates a serious problem for many vegetarians
and vegans as sulfur is essential for liver detoxification and
removing heavy metals. Without enough meat-based sulfur
sources in the diet, vegetarians will be even more prone to the
build-up of heavy metals (and copper), as well as experience a
much harder time chelating those metals. The case with
Taurine is similar, especially as Taurine is also sulfur-
containing. Taurine is a meat-sourced amino acid not found in
plant foods which is critical for the production of bile. Bile is the
primary means through which the body eliminates excess
copper. Taurine (and sulfur) deficiency means bile production is
impaired, hindering the natural detox process and further
allowing copper (and other toxins) to build up.
Of course much of this imbalance won't show up in a blood test.
Unless there is a current and direct exposure to copper (such as
an IUD), most vegetarians / vegans have too low a metabolic
rate for the elevated copper to show up high in a blood test. At
times, when metabolism is low and the body is exhausted, it
won't show up in a hair test either (though other indirect
indicators can be used in the HTMA to determine the copper
status).
However, a quick search through online forums will turn up a
large percentage of vegetarians/vegans (and ex-
vegetarians/vegans) sharing stories of their battles with copper
toxicity, many of them eventually realizing their health was more
important than their principles, however virtuous. Many too,
about 50%, drop out of the vegan diet due to declining health
[12], though this mineral connection to the cause of their health
decline is rarely made. Though veganism is thought to be
healthy, unlike vegetarianism it has no historical basis and is
founded on ideology, not on human physiology. Vegetarianism
"Restoring and maintaining liver detoxification is one of the most important aspects
of healing. Sulfur, mainly in the form of sulfur-containing amino acids - mainly taurine, methionine and cysteine - are
absolutely needed for the detoxification pathways in
the liver. We find that most vegetarians…cannot remove toxic metals as well because
they are low in the sulfur-containing amino acids."
~ Dr. Lawrence Wilson
"The great majority of vegetarians suffer from long-
term copper toxicity. This is true even if all tests indicate
a low copper level. The vegetarian’s metabolic rate is
too low to cause a proper elimination of copper. Not
enough copper may be released on a regular basis to
show up in a blood test or even in a hair analysis test. Of course, sometimes the copper
level in the hair will be high, but it doesn’t have to be. In
some of the worst cases I have seen, the copper is tightly-bound in tissue
storage sites. It may take three years on a nutritional correction program before
the person will even start releasing his excess copper”
~ Dr. Paul Eck
27
on the other hand does have a much longer history, and can
be considered slightly more healthy. However when the
underlying mineral patterns are analyzed, we quickly see that
both diets are deplete in key nutrients. DHA for example,
essential for good health, energy, and neurological function, is
non-existent in the vegan diet. As Mara J Kahn points out in her
deeply researched book 'Vegan Betrayal: Love, Lies, and
Hunger in a Plants-Only World', "DHA is really a problem with
vegans … In fact, two of the founders of veganism, as they
became older, suffered from Parkinson’s disease. They had
their DHA tested and it was zero." B12 deficiency is a huge
problem among vegans, as is the lack of retinol. Animal source
retinol is essential for the liver and the production of
ceruloplasmin - the key protein that binds to copper to make it
bioavailable. Many vegetarians and vegans who have been
diagnosed as copper toxic have returned to a meat diet, as
taking that step becomes almost essential in order to properly
heal and re-balance minerals.
Copper toxic individuals very often will also have gut concerns,
including candida and yeast, low HCl, poor nutrient
absorption, gluten sensitivity, even leaky gut. One of copper's
roles is that of an anti-fungal, and when in balance, helps to
control fungi and yeast / candida in the gut. However, with
toxic levels of copper, much of this copper is in a bio-
unavailable form stored in tissues, and is not serving its role in
controlling the candida / yeast, or other parasites. This, along
with the anaerobic GI environment that's created, allows
candida, fungi, yeast, parasites and bacteria to flourish.
Meanwhile, as mentioned above, copper toxicity (by way of
lowering zinc) also reduces hydrochloric acid production.
When hydrochloric acid (HCl) is low, the healthy gut flora are
weakened (and zinc is lowered further - a vicious cycle). HCl
helps kill off pathogens and is required for the absorption of
nutrients such as calcium, iron, and various vitamins. Reduced
digestive enzyme production occurs and the intestine
becomes overly alkaline, giving a nice home to pathogenic
bacteria. Copper toxicity leads to low HCl by way of slowing
"There is a predisposition in this country to kinds of virtuous
extremes, and I lived this life myself. I was a vegan, I was a
vegetarian, I was non-fat, I was low-fat, I was anorexic, in short
I thought that if animal foods would kill you and fats would
kill you, the less the better and zero must be ideal. This is
obviously nonsensical thinking. It's black its white. It's rigid.
It's extreme. And it's not virtuous...
Little by little I started to eat these foods (traditional - meat,
poultry, raw milk, etc) again and in time came back to being
a moderate omnivore, a conscientious carnivore, a
traditional foods person, and restored my health along the
way.... ... I was...gloomy and irritable, I was depressed in the
winter, in short I was a sickly person with a big personality
and I had no idea that my virtuous diets were making me sick until little by little I added
traditional foods back." ~Nina Planck (Food Writer)
28
metabolism and reducing sodium and potassium levels, two
minerals which are required in the production of HCl. The
destruction of gut function and the collapse of one's
metabolism are hallmarks of copper toxicity.
Long term copper-induced zinc deficiency will increase the
permeability of the gut lining, contributing to leaky gut and
food intolerances. "Research has shown that both
metallothionein and zinc play powerful roles in preventing and
restoring the damage in the gut barrier. Damage to the
intestinal barrier can lead to serious conditions, such as leaky
gut, colitis and Crohn's Disease."[15]. We already know that
copper lowers zinc, and zinc is important for metallothionein
synthesis. For the vegan / vegetarian, they do require extra zinc
supplementation. However, it alone may not be enough. This is
because, when the body is under stress or suffering from
adrenal weakness, the zinc level can drop further even when
supplementing - allowing copper to accumulate further. A
whole body / endocrine system approach is required to
understand which supplements (and in what amounts) are
optimal.
It's becoming increasingly difficult for people to get unbiased
and scientifically founded facts on nutritional choices,
especially when some of the most widely referenced 'nutrition
facts' websites are run by vegan organizations with a clear bias
toward pushing the plant-based diet. To be clear, the author
here is not suggesting any one diet over another, but rather is
an advocate for people having informed choice and receiving
full disclosure. The goal here is to support vegans and
vegetarians by providing awareness into potential pitfalls so
that those pitfalls can be avoided down the road. With
awareness, intelligent supplementation, and some flexibility, the
risk of copper toxicity can be reduced.
"It is tragic that Americans who have been inspired to adopt healthier diets have been so
harmfully misled by the anti-animal foods dogma, often
against their better instincts. I myself was led into this trap in
the mid 1970s, and have only found my way out of it in the
last few years. Although I found the Weston A. Price Foundation material when it first appeared,
and benefited from many of its suggestions, I was unable to
consistently expand my diet, or even tolerate any fat, until I
learned to recognize and apply the lessons of the copper-zinc
imbalance. In fact, this imbalance could very well have
killed me. ~Laurie Warner, MA, CNC
29
ADDITIONAL SOURCES OF COPPER INGESTION
1. COPPER SULFATE ON OUR CROPS Copper sulfate is a fungicide which is used against bacterial and
fungal diseases on a wide variety of fruit, vegetable, nut and field
crops. (It’s also added in some pools, hot tubs, and municipal
drinking water supplies to control yeast, bacterial or algae growth).
Focusing here on crops, copper sulfate, though numerous studies
show it is toxic to humans and the environment, is approved as a
pesticide under the USDA National Organic Program [31]. While the
official pesticide information website on copper sulfate tries to paint
it as being harmless (suggesting that ‘excess copper is excreted
and not often stored in the body)’, this site [32], though somewhat
dated, offers a somewhat more telling perspective. Since copper
sulfate is derived from ‘natural sources’, it's allowed to be used on
organic produce, even if it’s no less harmful than synthetic
pesticides. In fact, the Committee on European Communities noted
in their recommendations to Parliament in 1999 that copper sulfate
was even more dangerous than the synthetic alternative. Some
wineries in France (and other countries) have even stopped
growing organic wine because of copper in the soil. Even though
much of the spray is usually washed off the produce, it then ends
up going into the soil, affecting the next batch of crops. “Typically,
each spray with a copper-based fungicide results in an application of 1 to 4 lb.
of copper per acre (raising the topsoil concentration from 0.5 to 2 ppm), and
often several copper sprays are made per season. Thus, under a heavy copper
spray program, toxic topsoil levels could be reached in a matter of decades.”
[33] In other words, even those of us who try to live healthy and
clean by eating organic fruits and vegetables may be at risk of
toxic copper accumulation from even just this one source alone,
especially in places where soil levels are not properly monitored.
2. ORGANIC VS INORGANIC COPPER It's one thing to ingest copper through diet, it's another to be
exposed to copper through copper sulfates and other sources.
Food source copper is organic copper, bound to organic protein
30
molecules, and not exhibiting as severe side effects as inorganic
copper. This does not invalidate the above discussion of the vegan
diet contributing to copper overload. Even though the copper is of a
healthy organic kind, the lack of taurine and/or high quality
absorbable zinc contributes to the accumulation of copper, which
then eventually takes a toll on the adrenals and liver and eventually,
due to lowered Cp, lowers the bioavailability of the copper. Also, due
to the vegan's higher crop consumption, they are generally more
prone to inorganic copper sulfate exposure as discussed above.
Inorganic copper (the kind found in drinking water, most copper-
containing supplement pills, or the copper IUD) is not bound to
anything. Unlike organic copper, inorganic copper largely bypasses
the liver and enters the free copper pool of the blood directly. This
copper is potentially toxic because it can penetrate the blood/brain
barrier [34].
3. DRINKING WATER (COPPER PIPES) With no proteins to bind to in water, the drinking water flowing through
copper piping in homes leaches copper off from the pipes. This
copper then combines with sulfates, carbonates and phosphates to
form copper sulfate, copper carbonate, or copper phosphate. This
inorganic copper is at its highest level during the first run of the tap in
the morning. If your home has copper piping (aged piping being the
worst), it would be wise to test your water, and also to run the water for
a minute before using the water for your morning drink or coffee
maker. Not doing so could be exposing you to high levels of inorganic
copper. The use of copper piping in homes of developed countries,
along with increasing use of The Pill, both gaining mainstream and
widespread use in the 1950s/1960s, are perhaps the two biggest
causes of the copper epidemic that has been increasing over this past
century. Just how dangerous is this increased inorganic copper? Well,
in addition to everything else explained throughout this book, the
information provided in the Alzheimer's section of this book may be of
particular interest.
31
THE IMPACT ON EMOTIONS, RELATIONSHIPS, and MENTAL HEALTH
"Copper toxicity often leads to the destruction of relationships.
Sometimes they don't realize it because their feelings are numbed so
much by the buildup of excess calcium and copper, they're not even
aware that their feelings are numbed, deadened, and cut off, and
they're basically operating at a cognitive level and not a feeling
level, and yet cognitively they can convince themselves that they're
thinking their way through their emotional life. And that's simply not
the way it works, psychologically. I would venture to say that divorce
courts are loaded with people who's relationships were destroyed by
copper toxicity. Because the role of copper toxicity impacting the
emotions, thought processes and behaviors is not understood, it leads
to a lot of animosity and anger and resentment, and revenge - a lot
of flare ups of the Judge psychologically - that ultimately winds up
destroying the relationship." ~ Dr. Rick Malter, Ph.D.
The accumulation of copper to high bio-unavailable levels
contributes to adrenal burnout, the numbing Calcium Shell
effect, estrogen/PMS symptoms, destruction of hippocampus
cells affecting memory and emotion, depletion of NGF,
changes to key neurotransmitters, and an increased sodium to
potassium ratio – all of which can play havoc on relationships.
WHY COPPER IS CALLED THE 'EMOTIONAL MINERAL' Copper, at a healthy level, helps in the release of endorphins
that contribute to normal feelings of love and
euphoria. Ancient cultures made this connection, and
manufacturers today of certain copper products use these
concepts as a benefit in their marketing, including calling
copper a 'love mineral'. What they fail to recognize is that the
human population today is far more prone to copper toxicity
than it was thousands of years ago, and when copper
accumulates too much in the body, the reversal of 'love' is
created. The higher that the bio-unavailable copper level
becomes, especially when compounded with adrenal
exhaustion, the more that feelings of love are diminished and
numbed... at the same time that the risk for depression,
"Copper toxicity has been observed in association
with major psychological problems including
hyperactivity, depression, attention deficit disorder,
memory problems, anxiety and panic attacks,
violence, and emotional deadness.
~J.Casper, L.Ac
"Anyone who becomes highly copper toxic will begin to
experience a deadening of his/her feelings."
~’The Strands of Health', by Dr. Rick Malter, PhD
32
irritability, and even violence increase. Excess copper indeed
affects the emotions, but not in a warm, loving way that could
easily be misinterpreted by the connotation of 'emotional
mineral'.
The dichotomic emotional effect of copper is perfectly
summarized in the book 'Energy: How it affects your emotions,
your level of achievement, and your entire well-being' , an
excerpt from which discussing the destructive role that copper
and adrenal burnout play on relationships, is provided on page
14.
While it's true that copper increases the 'emotional states' of
humans, this should not be confused with feelings of love and
positivity. Emotions also include depression, anxiety, fear, anger,
resentment, etc. Science shows that high levels of bio-
unavailable copper trigger those negative emotional states
(fear, anger, irritability, etc), while at the same time deadening
positive feelings of love.
Though copper mostly accumulates in the liver initially, once the
liver is overburdened, copper then gets stored in secondary
storage locations, including the brain. Copper stimulates the
diencephalon or old 'emotional' brain (the part of the brain
based on quick emotional decisions such as anger/fight and
avoidance/flight). Zinc on the other hand is needed for the new
brain (cortex) - the brain associated with the “higher emotions”
such as reasoning, compassion and love. As zinc drops and
copper rises, these higher emotions are weakened and the
person tends to revert to using the old brain - triggering a wide
array of negative emotions and behaviours. Copper toxicity
causes "excessive emotions of many types such as anger, rage,
frustration and others"[16] Additionally, copper is largely
deposited in the limbic brain which contains the hippocampus
(affecting memories and emotions) - the cells of which have
been shown to die when deprived of zinc. Copper is also a
key factor in PMS symptoms. We already know estrogen's
intimate connection to copper as we talked about in the
"Mental diseases and symptoms linked to high inorganic copper
levels are low-histamine schizophrenia, postpartum
psychosis, depression, senility, autism and hyperactivity.
Paranoia and hallucinations are prevalent in younger
schizophrenics and depression in older ones." [50]
"An adequate copper level is what gives a woman her
'warmth'. Copper is involved with the production of estrogens
- the female hormone. Women who lack 'AVAILABLE' copper
tend to be cold and sometimes either secretly or openly hostile
to men." ~ Chatsworth & Eck
33
Estrogen section. As estrogen rises during the premenstrual
cycle (or during pregnancy), copper rises. Not only does
this lead to copper induced zinc deficiency during the
luteal phase (when PMS symptoms occur), but it also in turn
increases sodium. This increase of sodium increases the
Na/K stress ratio, and the individual becomes more prone
to short fuse reactions to even the slightest
stressor. Meanwhile, calming nutrients which can ease PMS
symptoms such as zinc, magnesium, and B6 are, not
coincidentally, reduced as copper increases. Copper
toxicity and magnesium deficiency (the former contributing
to the latter) are the two biggest contributors to depression
and anxiety.
With the drop in the zinc level as copper increases, so too
drops the level of NGF (nerve growth factor). Elevated NGF
plays an important role in early stage romantic love (first 1-6
months of a relationship) [3]. Copper toxicity occurring to a
partner during this early relationship phase can really play
havoc as heightening copper lowers zinc and in turn NGF,
suffocating those feelings of love. Added to this, high
copper also leads to a state known as the 'calcium
shell'. This rise in the tissue level of calcium is a defence
mechanism against increasing and overwhelming stress
which aims to reduce the adrenal response but in doing so
blocks feelings and awareness, potentially leaving
one emotionally numb.
THE CALCIUM SHELL One of the symptoms of copper toxicity that can result at
higher levels is a calcium shell. Physically, the calcium shell is
excess soft tissue calcium that forms a 'shell' around the
outside of the cell, slowing down nutrients from entering
and exiting. The psychological effects are just as important
to understand. In most cases, a very high level of calcium
"Excess copper in the system
can cause paranoia." ~Gabriel Cousens M.D., M.D.(H.), N.D.(h.c.), D.D.
"The present data indicate that serum copper is a 'trait
marker' (remains constant regardless of successful treatment) of unipolar
depression.” ~[1]
"...as a person's stress level increases and intensifies, s/he is more likely to develop a calcium
shell, especially if s/he is in a constant highly stressful
situation," [ie: demanding job, intense academic pressure...]
"This is because, under stress, a person tends to lose magnesium
and zinc from their cells and tissues. As magnesium is lost from cell and tissue storage,
more soft tissue calcification is likely to occur and the Cal/Mg
ratio will increase. These mineral changes lead to
increased muscle tension, more unstable blood sugar levels,
diminished awareness of one's feelings, and lower energy
levels. Depression and anxiety may also increase in frequency
and intensity. Since zinc antagonizes copper, a drop in
zinc allows copper and calcium to increase even more."
~'The Strands of Health', by Dr. Rick Malter, Ph.D
34
on an HTMA is a result of copper imbalance. The stress caused by rising bio-
unavailable copper in the body allows calcium to rise as a form of defence
against the stress. A calcium level above 165mg% is indicative of the calcium
shell pattern. It creates a numbing, deadening effect along with apathy,
withdrawal, rigidity, and being somewhat out of touch with reality. The calcium
shell dulls the emotional response, while also slowing the previously racing mind
down, giving the individual a sense of normalcy, though in reality it is not at all a
sign of healthy improvement.
The following offers a great background and is taken from clinical psychologist
Dr. Rick Malter's article in The Journal of Orthomolecular Medicine Volume 9,
Number 2, 1994: "The Slow Oxidizer has elevated tissue levels of calcium and magnesium. A person's sense of awareness may be affected by tissue levels of calcium and magnesium. The higher levels of calcium and magnesium in the Slow Oxidizer tend to be associated with emotional blocking and deadening of feelings. The excess calcium and magnesium provide a natural barrier between outside stimuli and the inner emotions. The high levels of calcium and magnesium tend to provide a protective shell at the cost of emotional blocking and deadening of feelings. This allows a person to more easily cope with stress or abusive situations because awareness is blocked and feelings are deadened. A high tissue level of calcium tends to block natural cellular functioning, especially that involved in energy production. Lowered cellular energy production tends to be associated with emotional blocking, numbing of feelings, depression, low self-esteem, pessimism, and feelings of inferiority. The more need there is for emotional blocking and deadening of feelings, the more the TMA calcium will tend to exceed magnesium. As the Ca/ Mg ratio increases, blood sugar problems will increase along with neuromuscular problems such as spasms. In alcoholic or other dysfunctional families, there seems to be a strong tendency for a child to develop a calcium "shell" as a natural self-protective mechanism which helps to constantly deaden feelings of vulnerability and anxiety. In chronically unpredictable and threatening situations, these feelings would become intolerable without the aid of the calcium shell. However, this calcium shell can become a chronic entrenched mineral pattern affecting glucose metabolism and neuromuscular functions. By adversely affecting glucose metabolism, the high Ca/Mg ratio also tends to predispose the individual to a higher risk of alcoholism or other addictions. Thus, TMA profiles allow us to observe and explain how psychological stress within a dysfunctional family can affect critical mineral patterns which then increase the person's risk to repeat the addictive and dysfunctional behavior. Over an extended period of time from childhood to adolescence, a high Ca/Mg ratio may become chronic and entrenched. Psychologically, a chronic high Ca/Mg ratio tends to be associated with denial or covering up a problem with which the individual cannot or will not deal. [18]
35
Along with the high Ca/Mg ratio as mentioned in the quote
above, comes an associated high level of sugar in the blood.
This then affects neurons in the brain and further suffocates
emotional awareness. At extreme Ca/Mg ratios > 20:1,
emotions and deeply buried problems can become so
suppressed that the individual finds himself in a state of
continuous false euphoria.
Another key concept is the inherent psychological tendency of
the slow metabolizer. The slow metabolizer's mineral pattern is
easily evidenced on an HTMA profile, generally showing high
copper and calcium, with reduced sodium and potassium. The
more extreme this pattern, the more the tendency for
introversion, depression, despair, and lowered emotional
expression [19]. These personality 'symptoms' can of course
also have a profound impact on relationships.
THE CORTISOL - OXYTOCIN - DOPAMINE -
SEROTONIN - GABA CONNECTION
A high copper level induces stress, anxiety, and fears. When a
stressor happens that brings up some past emotional pain,
cortisol is triggered to help us do whatever is necessary to avoid
that pain again. With proper rationalizing, we are able to tell
which current 'dangers' are real, and which aren't (most aren't -
our current fear is almost always a reflection of some past
programming projected on to some future event that hasn't
even happened). Under normal conditions, oxytocin steps in to
regulate these bad feelings while the (neo)cortex part of our
brain rationalizes that the triggered fear or anxiety is not
real...and we get back to life as normal without over-
reacting. This isn't the case however when copper levels
become high (or during detox) - fears from the past may be
brought to the surface, and the neocortex is weakened and
the brain's ability to determine if the fear is real or not is
compromised. The natural response may then be to run
"Sequentially, you get higher and higher and higher levels of
copper concentration, which now will affect brain capacity,
processing, and thinking and make anxiety and depression worse. This is what we see in
post-partum depression and in post-partum psychosis. Many
times, you hear the stories about women who have shot their husbands and drowned
their children, et cetera. If you notice, most of these women have had multiple children,
usually three to four, sometimes even five, before these events have occurred. These women
were copper-toxic females who could not get rid of copper, it
affected their brain functioning, their nerve-conduction and in
actuality caused a huge electrical short-circuiting of
mental processes. We’d be amazed at the knowledge of
how many individuals who are in prison systems are there
really because of a poor detoxification process involving
copper." ~Dr. Albert Mensah
36
away from whatever or whoever even innocently triggered that
past emotional pain.
As copper builds up higher and higher, the adrenals get
weaker and cortisol production then slows. When cortisol
production is low, especially near adrenal burnout, you are
'constantly going into hypoglycemia, which can result in
depression, irritability, mood swings, poor concentration, poor
memory, dizziness, fatigue, sleepiness and many more
unpleasant effects.'(51) Also keep in mind that as the body
approaches adrenal burnout while facing hypoglycemia, it
increases adrenalin in an attempt to correct the
hypoglycemia. Adrenalin is an anxiety and panic hormone,
and the reactions of anxiety and panic can amplify then when
copper is mobilized and enters the bloodstream (ie: through
detox). Subsequently, when adrenal function is jump-started
through an aggressive detox protocol, cortisol production once
again rises. In addition to the diminished feelings of romantic
'love' and compassion brought on by the calcium shell and
neocortex, the newly heightened cortisol level kills memories
and emotions even further, all of which can profoundly lead to
relationship issues and emotional changes.
Oxytocin, known as the 'love hormone' or 'cuddle hormone' is
important for behaviours including sexual arousal, recognition,
trust, and bonding. As stress goes up (internally caused by rising
copper (and other toxins), along with weakening of the
adrenals and increasing amounts of bio-unavailable copper,
our bodies in time become more and more oxytocin deficient.
In other words, as copper toxicity builds up and the adrenals
become exhausted, oxytocin levels generally drop, and the
sexual arousal, recognition, trust and bonding that once existed
between partners can become diminished. Symptoms of
oxytocin deficiency can include generalized depression,
heightened anxiety, social isolation, mistrust, resistance to
intimacy affection and relationships, phobias, panic attacks,
and sleep difficulties to name a few. Meanwhile, other
neurotransmitters also come into play…
"The main hormone that mediates stress response is
cortisol which is directly toxic to nerve cells in the part of the
brain (the hippocampus) that mediates memory and emotion -
it kills them." ~ Dr. Andrew Weil
"Copper also affects neurotransmitter production.
It actually pushes the conversion of dopamine, that
lovely, warm, fuzzy feeling neurotransmitter into that
excited neurotransmitter, norepinephrine. So, all that
norepinephrine cause the heart to race, it can cause anxiety, it can later cause
depression and it can later cause adrenal fatigue."
~Dr. Albert Mensah
37
Serotonin is a calming neurotransmitter and helps control
anxiety. Serotonin receptors seem to be directly involved in the
normal function of hippocampus in mood regulation and
memory formation. Serotinin also influences sexual desire and
some social behaviour. The problem is that copper oxidizes
serotonin and therefore stops it from doing its job. Furthermore,
if serotonin is under-methylated, serotonin becomes inactive
and further depression ensues. Zinc, B6 and Vitamin C are all
essential for serotonin production, yet all three of these nutrients
are reduced in the presence of excess copper. Consider the link
between depression and low zinc:
'A meta-analysis published in December 2013 in Biological
Psychiatry analyzed 17 studies and found that depressed people tended
to have about 14 percent less zinc in their blood than most people do on
average, and the deficiency was greater among those with more severe
depression.' [43]
GABA (Gamma Amino Butyric Acid) is one of the body’s most
inhibitory neurotransmitters, helping to maintain calm and
relaxation - balancing against glutamate (the body’s main
excitatory neurotransmitter). Excess copper, by way of slowing
the thyroid and impairing cellular energy production, inhibits the
conversion of glutamate into glutamine and GABA, resulting in
high glutamate levels. This in turn contributes to copper's excito-
toxicity effect along with symptoms such as impaired speech,
high irritability, anxiety, aggressiveness, GI inflammation, and
neuronal destruction. It should be noted that depression has
long been associated with deficiencies in serotonin, dopamine,
and GABA [52] ...all of which are impaired by excess copper.
[Consider this information (and copper's link to estrogen and the
Pill) in the staggering increase in the rates of depression and use
of anti-depressants. Anti-depressant usage has increased 65%
between 1999 - 2014 [42], with twice as many women on the
medication as men. And not surprisingly, the biggest benefit to
the medication is the placebo effect. Anti-depressants further
throw off the body's delicate mineral balance, and certainly do
nothing to teach about, address, or rectify the copper
connection.]
"It is well understood that neurotransmitters play a role in
psychiatric conditions... when copper is elevated, dopamine
levels decrease and norepinephrine levels rise.
Having these neurotransmitters out of balance can result in a
whole range of problems including anxiety, panic,
paranoid schizophrenia, bipolar disorder, depression, ADHD, and
autism." ~Courtney Snyder, MD,
Psychiatrist
38
THE DAMAGING TOLL ON RELATIONSHIPS
Even independent of each other, copper toxicity and adrenal
burnout both individually can lead at more advanced stages
to withdrawal, apathy, irritability, anxiety, memory problems,
and depression. When both are experienced together, the
results are amplified, and it can be devastating on
relationships. The highly copper toxic individual shuts down
emotionally (compounded by the calcium shell, and especially
even more so if adrenal burnout occurs). Often, the patient is
not even aware of what their feelings really are. The lack of
energy reduces awareness to the true extent of the
problem. In fact, many of the symptoms of copper toxicity at
this stage are the same as those commonly seen with adrenal
burnout, and the issue is just as much about the burnout as it is
with the copper. If both are present, the symptoms can be
amplified. It is highly improbable for a person who has
experienced adrenal burnout, especially when copper toxicity
is also at play, to be acting as one's true self emotionally in the
period following burnout. Too many factors are acting
together to make a person shut down. This short discussion from
the 1985 "Energy" book provides an excellent starting point in
understanding the relationship withdrawal commonly occurs
during adrenal burnout. The effects of copper and the
calcium shell then add to this withdrawal.
Sexually the person is not only mentally, but also biologically
forced to withdraw when burnout occurs - the body is trying to
preserve its energy and so the sex hormones, being not as
critical, are put on the back burner. It can seem to the patient
that they no longer desire their partner, not understanding that
this feeling is simply a survival mechanism and not their true
self. The closer and more intense the relationship, and the more
intense the copper-induced burnout, the more intense the
opposing negative withdrawal reaction often is toward that
person. Relationship OCD and paranoia
become common. Many of the stories and cases presented
on www.coppertoxic.com underscore this change in
“A tired person is fearful, and an exhausted couple is more prone
to doubt each other. One partner wonders ‘Will she (or
he) always love me as I am?’ and the other is thinking the
same. As the fatigue settles in, the joy goes out of being
together. You get so tired, you don't want to be touched and
you don't enjoy touching — much less lovemaking. You can
get so on edge that just the turning of the pages of the daily
newspaper or the squeaking of a chair can irritate you. You are
so tired you can't enjoy anymore the little kindnesses you used to do for each other. You get too exhausted to even
do them, and when totally exhausted, to even care.
Apathy replaces joy, and life becomes boring. People start
wondering if they really are meant for each other. They
wonder what happened to the original feelings that got them
together. Fatigue and exhaustion can do all of this and
more. It can help destroy a marriage that should have
lasted forever." ~ Colin and Loren Chatsworth,
“Since copper raises the hair and tissue calcium level,
women, in particular, with very high copper levels or hidden
copper on their hair analyses, often lose interest in sex. Their
energy declines and the body can become a bit “numb”
because excessive tissue calcium tends to render the nervous
system less sensitive.” ~Dr. Lawrence Wilson
39
personality and damage to relationships. Forums across the
internet are also filled with stories of how the Pill and IUD have
devastated relationships. Is it not a tragedy that a product
such as the Pill or IUD, designed to bring people closer
together, is effectively contributing to tearing those same
people apart!
Unless this connection is properly understood, a person can
very easily misinterpret their increasing sexual and emotional
withdrawal from their partner as a relationship issue, rather than
a consequence created by adrenal burnout and the emotional
cataract created by heightened copper and calcium.
THE EMOTIONAL IMPACT OF DETOX
Not only can relationships be challenged due to rising fatigue
and the calcium shell as copper accumulates, but the process
of detoxing can be equally damaging to a partnership. It is
known, with any kind of detox, that symptoms get worse before
they improve. Copper detoxing is no different. However, the
negative impact of a copper detox can be greatly diminished
when:
The detox is done slowly and gently over months / years
HTMA is used to monitor progress and stress response
Counsel is given to the individual beforehand educating
the patient on the potential psychological reactions that
may occur.
When these steps are not taken, the outcome may not be a
positive one. The untrained practitioner will typically attempt to
detox copper by boosting the adrenals and administering zinc.
However, giving EITHER too much zinc or too much adrenal
support too quickly (ESPECIALLY in a person with adrenal
exhaustion) will worsen the detox effect and psychological
reactions. With adrenal exhaustion, the body is too weak to
process the toxins being released through such support, and
“In Phase C of Adrenal Exhaustion, the body can
become extraordinarily sensitive to stressors. Mundane activities may act as triggers in this phase while they normally
do not behave as triggers in early stages of Adrenal
Fatigue… The first symptoms to show up usually represent the organ system to be turned off
first as it is not required for basic survival. Reproduction is considered a luxury and not a vital function when survival is
at stake. Libido as a result is lowered. Sex drive becomes non-
existence. “ ~ Dr. Michael Lam, M.D., M.P.H.,
A.B.A.A.M.,
"Copper is one of those bad boys when it is leaving your
system....if it’s coming out too quickly. You can indeed control the rate at which elements like
copper are removed from the system through detoxification.
And that’s extremely important, because believe me, you don’t
want somebody or a family member calling you saying,
“What did you do to my wife? She is not the same person
and…” I’ve had that happen before. So we have to be very
careful." ~Dr. Albert Mensah
"Remember this one final thought: Emotions change
minerals and minerals change emotions. Your emotional life is reflected in your minerals, just
like moonlight is reflected on the surface of a lake. It also
works in reverse. Your mineral balance will be reflected in your
emotional life, and in your ability to give love."
~Dr. Paul Eck
40
without adequate detox pathways being opened first, the
mobilized copper gets redistributed in the body, often raising
the load in the brain and amplifying psychological
reactions. This is addressed further in the Healing section, as
well as exemplified in the 1995 article shown on the following
page. Remember again that copper mobilization into the
blood stream of a burnt out individual can exacerbate anxiety
and panic reactions. Also too, copper antagonists such as zinc
and manganese (as well as stress) can cause copper to come
out of storage which can then cause symptoms such as
anxiety, OCD, mood swings, and much more. In terms of
relationships, it's important to understand the powerful negative
role that an improperly advised detox can play on a person,
and on a relationship.
During the process of detoxing (and as toxins are released from
the liver), old fears, traumas, and relationship hurts may
surface. These can be projected onto the current relationship -
at the same time that negative emotions are amplified, the re-
stimulated adrenals increase the Na/K stress ratio and in turn
reactions to the slightest stressor, the rationalizing neocortex is
weakened, anxieties rise, and feelings of romantic love are
erased by the numbing 'emotional cataract' effect of the
calcium shell. A need to ‘get away’ can take over the mind.
The article on the following page was written back in 1995 by
Registered Dietician Renee Nataro who, through hTMA research,
quickly came to understand the characteristics of copper toxic
individuals. The characteristics she describes are common when
copper is mobilized ('dumped') too quickly causing the Na/K stress
ratio to rise, as well as the pseudo-inversion of Na/K that reflects
the intracellular loss of potassium that can also occur during an
intense copper dump.
“Can a HTMA save a marriage? Yes, it can. When it exposes the
ravages of copper toxicity, stress overwhelm and rampant
magnesium loss, you better believe it can save a marriage.
When minerals are being brought back into balance,
when NMDA receptor hyperactivity is being quelled,
when the amygdala is no longer on rapid fire ready to pounce at the slightest provocation, when the blood sugar roller coaster is levelling out, a person can begin
to express their virtues instead of their vices. A person can
regain their composure as well as their dignity instead of
remaining a wrecking ball. Anything which interferes with the mineral system of the body also interferes with its psycho-
spiritual system.” ~Abdul Saad, BSc (Hons),
MPsych (Clin)
Many people who have been out of balance for years have been
unable to express their negative emotions, such as resentments,
fears, anxieties, angers, and hatred. They have stored all of their emotional hostilities and
anger in their tissues in the same way that money is stored
in a bank. When some people start to improve, many of their
hidden repressions and hostilities can come pouring
out. This could possibly strain a loving relationship. The best
thing to so when this happens to a close loved one is to just let it
pass and sit out the storm." ~Eck & Chatsworth (1985
'Energy')
41
42
A SILENT LINK TO ALZHEIMER'S As of 2017, the Alzheimer's Association website continues to
state "At this time, there is no treatment to cure, delay or stop
the progression of Alzheimer's disease". While there may be no
'cure', there is certainly enough evidence to suggest that
progression can be delayed - if medical research chooses to
look at the contribution copper plays in this epidemic, and if
the public becomes educated on daily lifestyle influences that
are affecting their copper levels. Unfortunately, just as with the
Pill or IUD, discussion of copper is almost all but ignored, in this
case as evidenced by not one single mention of copper in this
otherwise excellently written and comprehensive 84 page
report on A.D....even though we know the following:
We know that copper antagonizes zinc, and we know that zinc
deprivation causes cell death in the hippocampus, where
memories are recorded. “In Alzheimer's disease, the hippocampus is
one of the first regions of the brain to be affected, leading to the confusion
and loss of memory so commonly seen in the early stages of the disease.”
~Dr. Ananya Mandal. At the same time, excess copper causes
neuronal toxicity while zinc deficiency causes neuronal
damage [35]. Alzheimer’s is characterized by degeneration
and/or trauma of neuronal structures [36].
Dr. Rashid Dean, PhD, a research professor in the University of
Rochester Medical Center (URMC) Department of
Neurosurgery, has shown in his study that “over time, copper’s
cumulative effect is to impair the systems by which amyloid beta is
removed from the brain. Amyloid beta is a main component of the
amyloid plaques found in the brains of Alzheimer’s patients” [37].
Amyloid beta is a small protein clipped off a larger one by the
beta secretase enzyme. The Proceedings of the National
Academy of Sciences journal concluded in 2013 that “Copper
appears to be one of the main environmental factors that trigger the onset
and enhance the progression of Alzheimer’s disease by preventing the
clearance and accelerating the accumulation of toxic proteins in the
brain.” [37]
"A large body of clinicopathological, circumstantial, and
epidemiological evidence suggests that the dysregulation of copper is intimately involved
in the pathogenesis of Alzheimer’s disease.” [41]
43
It could be argued that the rise in the prevalence of
Alzheimer’s rates, which really is a 20th century phenomenon,
loosely corresponds with the rise in rates of copper toxicity. Dr
George J. Brewer, MD, offers the following, I would suggest
accurate, comment: “Scientists these days like to talk about the
complexity of AD. They formulate drugs or agents designed to lessen the
amyloid-beta burden in the brain or to attack biochemical aspects of the
neurofibrillary tangles. [I have] long suggested there is a simpler line of
attack: prevent AD by eliminating ingestion of inorganic copper. This
concept, however, has yet to enter the conversation of the scientific
community…It is our belief that the leaching of copper from copper
plumbing into the drinking water is a major causal factor in the AD
epidemic.” [38] To further corroborate this, Sparks and Schreurs,
in a published 2003 study [39, 40], found that the addition of
only 0.12 parts per million of copper to the drinking water of
rabbits greatly enhanced the AD-type pathological changes
in the brain, along with marked decrease in performance of
previously learned tasks. They also later found that copper in
drinking water at even 1/10 the U.S. EPA limit destroyed the
blood-brain barrier receptors (LRP receptors) responsible for
clearing amyloid beta from the brain, resulting in the hallmark
accumulation of amyloid plaques. “It is clear that copper (II) is
extremely toxic. It is as toxic to the brain as lead, but in a
different way. Lead acts quickly to cause damage, including
brain damage. Copper (II) acts over many years to cause
cognition loss."[45]
Alzheimer’s Disease, just as with depression, schizophrenia,
anxiety and other emotional and mental health issues, could
be much better understood if we started looking at the
connection they share with mineral imbalances, specifically
copper. Of course there can be other causes to these
conditions as well, this fact being acknowledged. However,
given the very clear connection that copper toxicity plays in all
these conditions, it seems ludicrous how quickly damaging
pharmaceuticals are prescribed without even giving
consideration that a simple mineral imbalance may be the
cause.
"The web of evidence tying ingestion of inorganic copper as
a causal factor in AD is strong, and includes AD animal model
data where trace amounts of inorganic copper in the drinking
water markedly worsened AD, human studies where ingestion
of copper supplements, along with a high fat diet, is associated with a marked loss of cognition,
human studies showing a markedly higher mortality in
elderly women ingesting copper supplements, as well as other data. It is likely that a high fat diet works in conjunction with
ingestion of inorganic copper to increase the risk of AD."
~Dr. George J Brewer, MD
44
TESTING In this unit we discuss testing for copper toxicity. A large reason
why copper toxicity (and mineral imbalances in general)
remains so misunderstood is due to the over-reliance on blood
testing across most of the allopathic medical community (and
even on the holistic side as well). Below we'll address, first, the
wrong (yet most common) approach to testing, followed by
what should be considered a much more accurate method.
To begin this discussion, one fundamental key point must be
addressed and understood: Excess copper gets stored in the
cells and tissues, NOT the blood!
BLOOD AND URINE TESTING Blood is merely a transport system; it is not where minerals get
stored.
Imagine a highway leading through a busy town. On an
overhead bridge is a camera. If the camera takes a snapshot
of the highway at a busy time, is that proof that the town itself is
crowded? Not necessarily. What if all those cars are simply
passing through town and never stopping? Likewise, if the
camera takes a snapshot of the traffic and the highway is
empty, does that mean the town is empty? Of course not! The
snapshot could be taken at night when the crowded town is
sleeping, or there could be construction on the highway which
has closed the access road. In both scenarios, the snapshot of
highway traffic is a very poor indicator of what is truly
happening in the town. Blood is similar. It carries the various
metals / toxins / minerals / nutrients either to where they're
needed, or it will take them to be excreted. However, along the
way, and especially if the body's detox pathways are not
perfectly efficient, some of those minerals and metals and
toxins get stored in the cells and tissues.
"The transport system of the
blood absolutely does NOT provide a reliable correlation of
tissue mineral levels at the cellular level."
~Rachel Neumann
"Excess of copper does not necessarily show up in the
blood. In an evaluation of 30 patients with normal serum and
urine levels but unusually high hair copper levels the following
symptoms were present: apprehension, poor
concentration, severe depression, insomnia,
irritability, memory lack and profound mental fatigue, in
addition also somatic (bodily) problems."
~http://www.health-science-spirit.com/mentaldisease.html
45
Let's take lead for example. If a person were to have a
significant acute exposure to lead, and he were to be tested
for lead within a week of exposure, likely his blood test would
show a high level of lead, and doctors would catch it. Now
let's say the blood test instead was done two months after his
lead exposure. Do you think the blood test will still show a high
level of lead? While it's possible some small elevation may
appear, more likely than not the blood serum will show
normal, in other words - the lead is gone. Is it really
though? Has is magically all disappeared? Of course not! This
is because, not only is blood merely a transport system, it is
also homeostatic. The blood must return to a tight nutrient
range in order to protect the body; if it didn't we would
die. With too much of a mineral or metal the blood will
attempt to remove it, either through excretion, or by storing it
away in tissue. And so, 30 to 40 days after that acute lead
exposure, the serum can appear completely normal even
though toxic levels of lead have been deposited and stored
away in tissues of the liver, bones, hair, teeth, etc.
Another very obvious example would be with potassium. Let's
say you were to eat a bag of bananas the morning of your
blood test. Likely your blood serum would show high
potassium. However that's just a snapshot in time, when in
reality your cellular potassium may be dangerously low. We
can see the caution here in how looking at a blood test to
determine mineral needs can be dangerous - based on the
blood test the practitioner would say avoid potassium as your
level is too high, while the person wise enough to look at the
tissue level (through HTMA as we'll discuss later) will clearly see
the body's true deficiency of, and requirement for, potassium.
The same warning is true for the body's two most important
minerals, calcium and magnesium. Severe osteoporosis can
develop without significant calcium changes appearing in
the blood. Meanwhile the magnesium level can be affected
by something as simple as how long or tight the tourniquet is
applied - magnesium will rise due to tissue hypoxia. Not only
46
that, but the body will rob the cells, tissues, and bones of
magnesium in order to maintain a 'healthy' blood level of
magnesium. What this means is that the blood status of
magnesium can appear completely healthy even when the
cells are completely starved of magnesium. Similarly, when the
blood level of calcium drops to low, calcium is robbed from the
bone to boost the blood level – the blood level still appears fine
even though deficiency is happening in the bone. It is insanity
that doctors continue to rely on the blood level of these
nutrients, especially when you add to the fact that less than 1%
of the body's magnesium is even in the blood to begin with!
In terms of copper - blood's homeostatic nature will ensure that
excess copper is quickly removed from the blood, but this
doesn't mean it magically disappears from the body. If a
patient is being exposed to an immediate source of copper,
such as a copper IUD, chances are the blood may show an
elevated level. But once that IUD is removed (or the
immediate source of exposure taken away), the blood will
naturally return to normal, even though loads of toxic bio-
unavailable copper is now stored in the body's tissues. In fact,
we might even see the blood serum level of copper being low
in a copper toxic person. If copper has accumulated and is
tightly stored in the tissues, and adrenal function is too weak to
mobilize that stored copper, it's not going to show up in the
blood!
With this background, why on earth are so many practitioners
still so reliant on the mineral level that shows up in the blood,
without ever stopping to examine the tissue level? As a direct
result of such practice, misdiagnosis runs rampant. Not only is it
ignorant and irresponsible, but also dangerous, and as long as
people continue to focus on serum blood results, the mass
confusion surrounding this epidemic will only continue. There
are so-called 'experts' online who are so focused on blood test
results, and their trusting audience then spends a fortune in
time and money getting all the suggested blood panel lab tests
- serum this, plasma that - only to discover even more confusion
47
as they try to interpret the results, once again ignoring that
copper excess is stored in tissue, not blood. Blood is certainly
invaluable for many markers of disease and health conditions,
but NOT when it comes to measuring mineral status! At best, if
the timing is right, a blood test may catch copper toxicity, but
certainly far more often than not it will miss it. Copper toxic
individuals very often receive blood tests results that show
'normal' and are falsely diagnosed as 'healthy'. As Dr. Eck points
out, "If you have high levels of a certain mineral, like copper,
held tightly in storage, why on earth would you expect the
copper to show up in the blood - unless it is being released?!"
Copper needs to be bound to a transporter protein (either
ceruloplasmin or metallothionein), otherwise it becomes bio-
unavailable, does not enter the cell where it needs to be, and
instead gets accumulated in a bio-unavailable form in the
body's tissues. The problem again with the standard blood serum
testing procedure is that it ignores not only the accumulated
bio-unavailable copper stored in the tissues, it also ignores
the copper content within the cells. The following quote is by Dr.
Carolyn Dean, MD, ND speaking about the inadequacy of
serum tests. While in the quote she is referring to magnesium, the
same is very much true for copper: "A serum test for magnesium
is actually worse than ineffective, because a test result that is
within normal limits lends a false sense of security about the
status of the mineral in the body. It also explains why doctors
don't recognize magnesium deficiency; they assume serum
magnesium levels are an accurate measure of all the
magnesium in the body."
A urine test on the other hand shows what the body is excreting.
When the body is excreting copper, then elevated copper
levels will show on a urine test. If the urinalysis is performed during
this time of excretion, it will catch the copper toxicity problem,
and it can also be useful for showing how much copper (or any
mineral/metal) is being excreted. But once again, what is being
excreted is very different from what is being STORED. The stored
copper is NOT being excreted, rather it is tightly stored in various
48
organs and soft tissue of the body, particular the liver and the
brain, yet won't show up in a urine test. Even urine challenge
testing usually only reaches superficial areas of toxicities and
can miss much of the tightly stored copper. Not only that, but
chelation can also stir up and redeposit toxins in vital organs,
while also being excessively hard on the kidneys (since this
method forces toxins out through the kidneys rather than
through the bile).
HAIR TISSUE MINERAL ANALYSIS The central issue of copper toxicity is stored copper in the cells
and tissues. If we want to know the stored tissue level, blood tests
and urine tests certainly aren't the answer (though they may in
some cases be useful as a secondary source of information if
you suspect copper toxicity or are on a detoxing program). Of
course one could do a liver biopsy which would provide
excellent evidence of tissue levels, however being both
expensive and invasive it is not a viable or realistic option for
most. Hair, however, being a form of soft tissue, provides a
great window into what is happening inside the body at the
tissue level.
As copper passes through the blood, either to be utilized,
excreted, or stored, it gets picked up in the hair follicle. An inch
or so of hair taken closest to the scalp provides approximately a
three-month window into the mineral and metal status of the
body. As such, it is not prone to the hour to hour fluctuations that
affect the blood reading. More importantly, the hair reflects the
tissue level, which is what we want to know in terms of our
minerals status. Another major advantage that Hair Tissue
Mineral Analysis offers is data on the key ratios between mineral
pairs as determined through the exhaustive research in the
1970s and 80s by Dr Eck and Dr Watts, the pioneers of the
Science of Nutritional Balancing. When it comes to rebalancing
minerals, or assessing mineral status, looking at any one mineral
level in isolation explains very little. Take magnesium, for
"[HTMA] may be the most
important health test that
exists… Only when you and your
doctor know for sure your
mineral status and important
ratios can you adapt your diet,
minerals and supplements to
work toward proper balance."
~Dr. Robert Thompson, MD
49
example. If the hair chart shows high magnesium, is it really
high? Not necessarily, as stress depletes magnesium and most
people are magnesium deficient. However, if we look at the
ratio between sodium and potassium, known as the stress ratio,
and we see a high Na/K ratio, we know that the individual is
under a lot of stress, and that the high magnesium level is
representing an intracellular loss of magnesium which shows up
high in the hair but indicates magnesium deficiency. This is just
one example of the importance of looking at the bigger
picture, and not just one mineral level in isolation. The same
can be said for assessing the copper status. A copper toxic
individual can have either high (overt) copper showing up in
the hair, or he may have low (hidden / latent) copper.
Therefore, we MUST look at what is happening with the other
mineral levels and ratios in order to determine copper
status...and the correction of copper. For example, when
copper appears low in the HTMA, we can look at other key
indicators such as a high calcium, low potassium, a Ca/K ratio
over 10, low molybdenum (<.003), low Na/K, and a number of
other levels and ratios to understand what may be happening
with copper. This underscores the importance of the HTMA
practitioner understanding these various markers, otherwise they
could easily look at the low copper level and suggest the client
needs to consume more, when in fact doing so would only
compound the problem.
Though this may all sound very complex (and it is…especially
when copper is ‘hidden’ on the HTMA as it commonly is), the
trained HTMA practitioner is able to deduce a goldmine of
information from an HTMA profile, including:
adrenal strength
thyroid function
other mineral deficiencies and toxicities
heavy metal toxicities
inflammation
various reasons for fatigue
mental health issues (including markers for depression,
anxiety, ADD, and a host of others)
.
“Without HTMA data, medical doctors will not recognize the
epidemic nature of the copper toxicity problem.”
~ Dr. Rick Malter, Ph.D.
"Excess copper has a distinctive effect on the HTMA mineral
pattern and on the overall mineral system. A high soft
tissue calcium level, a low potassium level and a very high
Ca/K ratio are the major mineral effects of an elevated
copper level. The thyroid slows, diminishing energy production, often producing depression and ADD types of symptoms. When even more copper builds up in
the brain, schizoid and psychotic reactions may
also manifest. " ~Dr. Rick Malter, Ph.D
50
liver and kidney impairment
blood sugar imbalances
metabolic rate
and, most importantly, a safe and full nutritional
approach to correcting the copper toxicity
issue. Correcting copper toxicity is nowhere near as
simple as simply taking more zinc (rather, doing so can
actually make things worse!).
Unfortunately, most allopathic doctors tend to negate HTMA, as
the nutritional approach to healing health conditions at the
source is overshadowed by the pharmaceutical approach to
simply bury symptoms. Most doctors are not adequately trained
in nutrition, let alone the intricacies of how mineral imbalances
affect physical and mental health. They are obsessed with
measuring the blood level of minerals, without stopping to
question what the cellular level is - the level that actually
matters! Many broader thinking practitioners are now adopting
HTMA as they learn the importance of it. While this is certainly a
step in the right direction, it also necessitates a warning. At
present, any doctor is able to open an account at a testing lab
and request a test. This presents a problem if that practitioner
attempts to diagnose or prescribe based on the charts, without
adequate training. This does happen frequently though, and
the unsuspecting patient sees poor results. The doctor (and
patient) then dismiss HTMA because it 'failed'. However this is not
the fault of the test, but rather a lack of dedication on the part
of the practitioner to verse himself in this essential testing
tool. HTMA charts appear deceptively simple, yet are infinitely
complex. No amount of medical training qualifies an individual
to be able to quickly assess an HTMA chart, without having
been trained in HTMA as well. Please ensure that the HTMA
practitioner you are working with has indeed been trained in
HTMA and is experienced in dealing with copper toxicity.
Copper toxicity is among one of the most misunderstood
conditions in the world today, largely due to the resistance of
many in the medical field to adopt HTMA into their toolbox. The
.
.
51
very fact that blood testing is still done so prolifically as the
primary determinant of toxicity - with almost no mention of HTMA
- goes to show a most basic lack of understanding behind
copper toxicity on the part of practitioners. As long as blood
remains the primary go-to screening tool for mineral imbalance,
the true extent of copper toxicity will never be
recognized. Sadly, HTMA has a history of vicious smear
campaigns directed against it, aimed at suppressing this most
important of screening tools, and as a result has cost people
dearly who could have otherwise benefited from proper testing.
In 1985 and again in 2001, JAMA published two studies which on
the surface seemed to dismiss the accuracy and reliability of
HTMA, and these results were widely publicized, and to this day
are still being widely referenced as justification for not using
HTMA. The tragic irony is that the hard data from the studies in
fact validated the excellent accuracy of HTMA, as well as
copper toxicity in the samples, however neither the author nor
the editors were able to recognize it as they themselves did not
understand how to use HTMA or what to look for. The studies,
when using the data from approved labs, in fact validated the
very opposite of what the authors claimed. However, to arrive at
the finding that HTMA was not reliable, the authors of the studies,
in one case used a mere 2 person sample size, in another
used an illegally operating lab to obtain skewed results, and in
both cases violated almost all proper sampling and testing
protocol and were run by people untrained in HTMA. In fact, the
doctor behind the first study, who continues to run a number of
websites nicely disguised to mislead the public and attack the
consumer's right to informed choice, has been shown to have
almost zero credibility, and in fact a California Appeals Court
declared him to be "biased and unworthy of credibility”.
However, given his title as a ‘doctor’, those that don’t take the
time to research further fall victim to his writings. The authors of
the aforementioned studies (and the media) also largely ignored
the thousands of peer-reviewed references [20] that support
HTMA, or the fact that HTMA is used routinely by various heads of
government and world class athletes who have access to the
very best medical care. Those who dismiss HTMA are doing so
.
.
.
52
based on their own lack of understanding, reluctance to learn, or
ulterior motive. Dismissing HTMA as pseudo-science shows
complete ignorance on the person making such a claim, and
begs the question 'what is their agenda?'. Though human hair
has been accepted as an effective tissue for biological
monitoring of toxic heavy metals by the US Environmental
Protection Agency and is being used for this purpose throughout
the world, when it comes to copper toxicity suddenly this fact
becomes ignored.
When correcting any condition through nutrition, or when taking
supplements, we must recognize that nutrients do not operate
independently from other nutrients. Having a clear picture, as
presented through HTMA, is essential prior to supplementation,
and makes supplementation and corrective guidance much
more practical, meaningful, manageable and
safer. Understanding one's various mineral levels should be an
essential first step to any dietary, weight loss, or health restoration
program. Hair Tissue Mineral Analysis, tested through either ARL or
TEI labs (labs that do NOT pre-wash the hair samples), and
assessed by a practitioner trained in understanding mineral
ratios, is the best approach. Other labs that wash the hair sample
(which most other labs do) are not recommended here as the
washing procedure throws off several key levels and ratios.
HTMA provides essential indicators that, when properly
interpreted, can show the presence of a hidden copper toxicity
problem, and provides the evidence-based information
necessary to properly detox copper while balancing other
mineral levels at the same time - a necessary part of the process.
Any other approach to treating copper toxicity without this
'bigger picture' of other various minerals is really taking a blind
approach to treatment, and dangerously exposes the patient to
other mineral levels being thrown off in the process which in turn
can greatly exacerbate the psychological and physical
changes that occur in the patient. This underscores the
importance of frequent monitoring of mineral levels throughout
the detoxification process, something that can only be
accurately achieved via HTMA.
"The HTMA is the window into our physiology, our psychology,
and revealing our pathology." ~Dr. Robert Selig
53
THE SLOW METABOLIZER VS FAST
METABOLIZER (OXIDIZER)
Oxidation types (metabolic types) are based upon the work of
Dr. George Watson, Ph.D, who was able to detect distinct
patterns and differences between what he termed slow
oxidizers and fast oxidizers (a similar concept to slow
metabolizers and fast metabolizers). These patterns are easily
identifiable through an HTMA profile, and also show a clear
connection with the three stages of stress (Dr. Hans Selye). For
simplicity sake, there are two main metabolic types, slow and
fast. The fast metabolizer, with an overactive thyroid and
adrenals, is releasing energy too quickly, running himself out of
fuel. The slow metabolizer is releasing energy too slowly –
basically he doesn’t have enough. The slow metabolizer will
typically have elevated levels of calcium, magnesium and
copper (with low sodium and potassium), while inversely the fast
metabolizer will have elevated sodium and potassium (with
lower calcium, magnesium and copper). Infinite combinations
result of course within these two broad descriptions. What's
important to understand however is that almost all copper toxic
individuals represent as slow metabolizers. Copper not only
leads to a slowing of metabolism, but the slowing metabolism in
turn spirals the copper accumulation higher as the copper is not
being used as quickly as it would be in a Fast type. Simply put,
copper accumulates as metabolism slows down. Sluggish
adrenals and thyroid will allow copper to build up. As
mentioned though, copper is also a major reason why these
glands slow down, so it's a vicious cycle. Traits of slow
metabolizers often include fatigue, depression, apathy, low
blood sugar, adrenal insufficiency, and hypothyroid. These traits
are clearly explainable through the various mineral ratios
presented on the HTMA profile. The more extreme the slow
metabolizer pattern is, the more apparent symptoms such as
depression, despair, withdrawal, and apathy / emotional
numbness become.
"With slow oxidizers, one gets biounavailable copper
problems. Here one has a combination of too much free copper floating around, but a
deficiency of available or bound copper. This may be due to
adrenal exhaustion causing impairment of ceruloplasmin
synthesis in the liver, and perhaps deficiencies of other
copper transport proteins such as metallothionein."
~Dr. Wilson, M.D
54
Understanding one's metabolizer type (and the key ratios shown
on the HTMA) is paramount to creating a healthy recovery
protocol and nutritional program. Although specifics will vary
person to person, slow metabolizers often need more potassium,
zinc, vitamin A and Vitamin C, while avoiding calcium, copper,
and Vitamin D.
Figure 3: The above shows copper toxicity in a slow metabolic pattern on an HTMA. Not all
patterns will be this obvious as sometimes the copper toxicity issue is hidden with a low
copper reading. However here we can see without any question the extreme level of copper,
combined with exhausted adrenals and sluggish thyroid as indicated by the low Na and K
readings and K in relation to Ca. This patient's primary symptoms included depression,
anxiety, brain fog, racing mind, allergies, and substantial fatigue /low energy, all which can be
seen with this pattern. Up until this test the patient had a 2 year history on a copper IUD
preceded by 12 years on the birth control pill.
55
DETOX & HEALING
Depending on the extent of accumulation and the body's
natural ability to detox, the detoxing of excess copper is often a
complex, long term endeavour. It most often involves the
integration of numerous approaches, including removal of the
source of excess exposure, specific nutritional support, and
even some element of emotional healing and growth. For some
it can seem like an endless process, and not all are wiling to
make the journey, resisting and denying the physical and
psychological work involved. However for those who commit
to their healing, the eventual 'detox' of copper is often
described as a gift offering a heightened sense of self-
awareness and appreciation, along with improved energy and
health. Though the specific healing protocol will vary from
person to person determined by their individual mineral pattern
as shown on their HTMA, there are certain generalities that can
be explained here. This site is not meant to diagnose, nor is it
meant to 'cure'. The hope is that the information compiled here
will give you guidance in your healing journey, but the
importance of working with HTMA and a practitioner well-
versed in copper toxicity cannot be understated.
HOW LONG SHOULD ONE EXPECT COPPER
TOXICITY DETOX TO TAKE?
Depending on severity, it should be expected to take
anywhere from 6 months to several years to correct a copper
imbalance [21] ... and this assumes the patient is undergoing a
properly constructed and monitored nutritional balancing
program. Removing excess tissue copper is required, which in
turn requires sufficient adrenal strength and bile production,
and all of this requires a long term commitment.
Typically, vegetarians/vegans and those on raw food diets take
the longest to recover, not only because the copper has been
"Correcting a copper imbalance
can NOT be done
in 2 weeks or even 2 months."
~Dr. Lawrence Wilson
"In the case of copper, a mineral
almost all burnout victims
accumulate, this by itself can
take three or more years to
eliminate. Sometimes we have
had people on a nutritional
correction program for up to
two years before any of the
stored copper starts releasing."
~Dr. Paul Eck
56
building up in the body over a long period of time, but also
due to their reduced adrenal and metabolic function,
paired with possible resistance in adding meat back into the
diet. Vegetarians will have further difficulty in adequately
detoxing copper due to their lack of Taurine, an amino acid
not found in plant foods yet which is critical for bile
production. Even for the meat eater, the balancing of
minerals takes many months, and commitment to the
program is necessary. The greater the adrenal
weakness/burnout, the longer the process will take. Adrenal
restoration can take 9-15 months for a fast oxidizer and 15-
36 months for a slow oxidizer [Eck], and this needs to take
place before copper can be properly
regulated. Attempting to detox too quickly can result in
serious reactions both physically & mentally. Note: if
symptoms were exacerbated by a copper IUD, removal can
often lead to a very quick return to 'feeling better'
(increased energy, improved libido, less brain fog, etc),
though this is not a reflection of having detoxed or 'healed'.
WORDS OF CAUTION BEFORE TAKING THE
'TYPICALLY RECOMMENDED' ZINC AND
ADRENAL SUPPORT
As the heavily copper toxic individual will most always
present with adrenal exhaustion, the most common
approach is to immediately target the adrenals to restore
the person's energy. Zinc is also very commonly
recommended as it is the most well known copper
antagonist (getting depleted as copper goes too
high). Though there is some merit to such an approach, it
can also be a very dangerous approach. When copper is
mobilized too quickly through adrenal support and other
copper antagonists such as zinc without first ensuring an
efficient biliary tract system and sufficient bile production,
the mobilized copper simply gets stirred around and
"Insomnia, increased fears and
paranoia are common during
the detox as the dumping of
copper causes copper to enter
the blood stream which causes a
sodium potassium inversion...If
you're not prepared for the
copper dump, you'll have
unbearable insomnia, anxiety,
panic attacks..."
~Dr. Robert Selig
57
redeposited, resulting in potentially undesirable
psychological, emotional, and/or physical reactions. In fact,
giving zinc to the copper toxic individual is initially rarely
recommended, and at amounts greater than 20mg-25mg
can often make things much worse, bringing on both
physical and psychological effects of a copper dump.
As copper is mobilized from storage sites and enters the
blood, adrenalin secretion is increased. Adrenalin is an
anxiety and panic hormone, and this is one reason why
during copper dumping (when blood copper is elevated),
these psychological reactions can amplify.
Too strong and quick an adrenal boost can also bring on
serious copper dump symptoms. Often the patient will stop
the program, either because the symptoms of copper
dumping initially are too intense, or because, paradoxically,
they actually begin feeling better due to their increased
energy and believe they've healed. Adrenals react quickly
to support, and energy can return rather soon, giving a false
sense of improvement. This is where one must understand
that this quick return in energy does NOT represent a proper
restoration of adrenal function. Stopping the detox process
at this point is like giving up on a weight loss program as soon
as you lose the first pound. For women in full burnout,
recovery can be expected to take one to two years on
stringent adrenal therapy.
An important to understand danger with offering adrenal
support formulas without monitoring mineral levels through
HTMA, is that the adrenal support will increase one's sodium
level. As sodium increases, the sodium to potassium
ratio increases. Considering that copper dumping further
depletes potassium, this will really increase the Na/K stress
ratio and in turn the stress response - leading a person to
more extreme reactions and a shorter fuse than would be
normal, and rash decisions / over-reactions could result. It
can be very difficult to get through to a person in this state.
"Copper is one of those bad boys
when it is leaving your
system....if it’s coming out too
quickly. You can indeed control
the rate at which elements like
copper are removed from the
system through detoxification.
And that’s extremely important,
because believe me, you don’t
want somebody or a family
member calling you saying,
“What did you do to my wife?
She is not the same person
and…” I’ve had that happen
before. So we have to
be very careful."
~Dr. Albert Mensah
"I have talked to so many people who say, “Well, I read that zinc was good, and I did
this and that.” And I said, “You know what you did? You
actually activated detoxification mechanisms
that now cause your depression to get worse."
~Dr. Albert Mensah
58
Once again, the patient should always be made fully aware of
what negative psychological symptoms may appear once
detox begins so that extreme over-reactions and potentially
damaging decisions can be avoided during this time. Not
doing so is certainly not in the best interest of the patient, and
could be considered gross negligence.
The aforementioned is also true for doing exercise while
detoxing copper. Anything what whips up the adrenals, which
exercise does, will result in potentially similar physical and
psychological reactions of a copper dump as explained
above. If any of these circumstances are occurring without
adequate liver and bile functioning, copper gets stirred up and
largely redeposited, often in secondary locations including the
brain. This can really impact one's awareness and perception,
especially in combination with the calcium shell, adrenal
support (which can increase one's sense of short term energy),
and a lifting of brain fog (which is often the result of copper
accumulation in the liver, but which can be 'improved' as
copper gets mobilized and redeposited elsewhere).
Adding too much zinc too quickly into a detox program can
aggravate mental symptoms in a very inconspicuous way. First,
it's important to understand that zinc has been shown to have
an antidepressant effect[22]. Thus, as copper accumulates
and the Cu/Zn ratio becomes more and more imbalanced, the
tendency for depression increases - a very common trait of the
copper toxic individual. Then, if too much zinc is added into
the detox program, due to it's antidepressant effect, it can
make the person feel better, like a weight has been lifted.
However, under the surface, that zinc has also mobilized
copper, and this in turn can amplify on the one hand
depression and other negative effects of detoxing, but on the
other hand it can increase the calcium shell effect as a
protective mechanism, further shutting a person down and
decreasing their awareness of what has happened. Through
this tinted lens of the calcium shell, zinc's antidepressant effect,
and the energy boost given by adrenal support, the individual
" Many symptoms can occur when excess copper is
eliminated from the tissues. One may experience headaches,
usually of the migraine type. Extreme fatigue, acne, skin
eruptions on the head, chest and thighs, free floating anxiety
feelings, spaciness, fears and disorientation may occur. Changes in the menstrual
period are common, including irregular periods, cramps and
symptoms of premenstrual tension. Men may experience
testicular pain. The elimination of copper can also cause joint
pains. Nausea, digestive disturbances, anorexia and
discomfort in the area of the liver may also occur during
copper elimination." ~Analytical Research Labs Inc
59
may feel better and decide that their healing is done.
Unfortunately, the zinc has done very little to actually lower the
copper level, especially considering that zinc's antagonist
effect on copper is only at the intestinal level [1]. In other
words, consuming zinc with a high copper diet is helpful to
prevent a copper build up, but once that copper has
accumulated and become stored in tissues, zinc will have a
very weak effect on lowering copper - rather it will just stir
things up, especially if there is inadequate bile to help
eliminate the copper.
This underscores the importance of supporting the liver and
ensuring adequate bile production before any copper
antagonists (such as zinc) or adrenals stimulants are given. If
the liver is weak / congested, then there is likely low bile flow.
Bile is necessary to excrete the excess copper. This is why
working on the liver and bile is so important. However, a
caution is needed here too. With the 'cleansing' of the liver can
also come the release of a lot of negative emotions. In
Traditional Chinese Medicine, long ago buried negative
emotions are stored in the liver, and these can be released
along with the toxins during a detox. Being mindful of these
consequences beforehand can be helpful to reduce the
psychological reactions that may otherwise appear.
Herein is the challenge with detoxing copper - anytime you
begin a detox, you whip up the bad stuff. This underscores why
the detox must be approached slowly and cautiously.
60
BENEFICIAL NUTRITIONAL CONSIDERATIONS
While this section (and book) should not be used to treat or
diagnose any condition, the following provides some
generalities that may be considered when working to detox
and heal.
1. Identify where the source of copper toxicity is coming
from and as best as possible, remove the source. While
this may not be entirely possible, certain sources are
obvious and can be adjusted. If a copper IUD is
causing the toxicity, remove it. If it's the birth control
pill, look into what other options might be available. If
your home has copper piping, avoid drinking the tap
water. If your diet is plant-based, it will serve your health
to consider, even in small gradual amounts,
incorporating some organic meat back into the diet.
Without first removing the underlying key source of
exposure, it will be very difficult to ever properly heal
and recover.
2. Have an HTMA test performed and properly analyzed.
This will provide the evidence-based guidance
necessary for establishing a nutritional balancing
healing protocol. How much adrenal support, thyroid
support, zinc, potassium, calcium, etc your body needs
can be seen through HTMA data. If your doctor
cautions you against using HTMA in favor of blood
testing, that in itself means they do not adequately
understand the complexities of copper toxicity nor how
to properly treat it.
3. Adjust mineral and vitamin supplementation
accordingly, through an HTMA-based supplement
program. While the HTMA practitioner can offer you
more specifics, some general considerations are:
a. The copper must be made more bioavailable
"The correct approach consists of
making copper (or calcium) more
bioavailable by supplementing the
proper co-factors, with the best
choice being those whose levels are
lowest ratio-wise to copper - and as
mentioned above - may include
Vitamin C, chromium, sulfur (MSM),
molybdenum, nickel, or (rarely)
zinc. The avoidance of foods high in
copper is important as well. This will
take care of the medical conditions a
practitioner was originally
consulted for, and at the same time
prevents the potential development
of new medical problems elsewhere
related to excessive copper intake.
Chromium has to be considered first
when trying to normalize copper,
since it is its associated trace
element. Following a close second is
Sulfur, usually supplemented in the
form of MSM, whose main action in
addition to helping restore cartilage
formation is the lowering of
copper!" [1]
61
through supplementing the proper co-factors and raising
ceruloplasmin (if appropriate)
b. Copper elimination channels must be open and bile must be
flowing. This is a great hindrance for the vegan/vegetarian due to
their lack of meat-sourced Taurine. Taurine supplementation will be
essential in this case, as are other supplements that can support
bile production.
c. Adrenal support and zinc, while both can be beneficial, must be
used with extreme care as too much can cause undesirable
physical and psychological reactions as already discussed. In
fact, zinc is rarely used to detox copper. It should be considered
more of a preventative for future copper accumulation. If zinc is
supplemented for copper toxicity, it must be introduced slowly,
beginning with no more than 10mg to 25mg. Likewise, while
adrenal glandular and adaptogenic herbs can be great for mildly
weak adrenals, once a person has gone into burnout these
supplements become over-stimulating and in fact should be
avoided, or used very cautiously. Though they can help restore
energy at first, they can lead to increased irritability and anxiety, an
increased calcium shell, and, in the long term, even worsening
fatigue.
d. The liver must be supported. Only once adrenal function and
adequate DHEA production is restored can the liver then produce
adequate ceruloplasmin necessary to bind to copper to make it
bioavailable. Just as importantly, liver support is also required to
help make sufficient bile which in turn is necessary in order to get rid
of excess copper. Improving overall mineral balance will in turn
assist the health of the liver and adrenals, alongside the production
of ceruloplasmin.
e. Digestive support (which most copper toxic slow metabolizers
need) is also required. As digestive function improves so too will the
efficacy of nutrient intake.
62
f. Look at your magnesium level. Copper toxicity
depletes magnesium, and deficiency causes a
myriad of symptoms (including clouded thinking,
irritability, depression, anxiety, panic attacks,
hallucinations, and personality changes). It also
further adds a toll on the adrenals. So while
magnesium is important, just like with zinc or
calcium, adding in too much of it can worsen
symptoms [24].
g. It cannot be overstated that taking too much of
any copper antagonizer or boosting adrenals
too quickly can lead to significant detox
reactions including severe PMS type symptoms,
emotional withdrawal, flu-like symptoms, or the
many others that are mentioned in the section
below. Detox must be approached gently.
h. Vitamin C, Sulfur (MSM), and Chromium should
be considered a first line of defence against
normalizing copper, followed by the minerals
manganese, molybdenum, iron, keeping in mind
that these must be given as suggested through
HTMA data and should be given gradually.
i. Whole Vitamin C is different from the typical
'ascorbic acid' version of Vitamin C typically sold
in stores. The former is the whole molecule, while
ascorbic acid is just one part of it. While both
are beneficial in terms of lowering copper and
helping to chelate it from the liver and the brain,
Whole Food C (which contains Tyrosinase as well
as copper ions which the liver needs to produce
ceruloplasmin) helps to raise ceruloplasmin
levels, while synthetic ascorbic acid unbinds
copper from ceruloplasmin. The adrenal glands
also require large amounts of Vitamin C, and as
copper stresses the adrenals more, the greater
the need for Vitamin C in order to help eliminate
the excess copper. Stress depletes Vitamin C
“Over 30 years ago, Hoffer and Osmond discovered that Vitamin C
was helpful in the treatment of certain, not all, schizophrenics. We
know today, from hair analysis research, that the type of
schizophrenia that responds favorably to massive doses of
vitamin C, is what we refer to as copper-induced schizophrenia. It is
the accumulation of excessive amounts of copper in the brain,
which is responsible for this particular type of schizophrenic
behavior. Vitamin C causes copper to be chelated and removed from
liver and brain reservoirs." ~ The Eck Institute of Applied
Nutrition and Bioenergetics, Ltd
63
from the tissues, especially from those of the adrenal cortex.
j. Other beneficial minerals and vitamins not already mentioned,
depending on one's HTMA, may include Potassium, Phosphorus,
Vitamin A (retinol form rather than beta-carotene). The following
antagonistic (to copper) nutrients may also be advised: Vitamins
B1, B2, B6, folic acid, inositol, and choline.
k. In cases where the patient shows a high calcium level or low
potassium (as is common with copper toxicity / slow metabolizers),
oral Vitamin D supplementation should be avoided as it will make
the negative side effects even more pronounced by further raising
calcium and depleting potassium (further slowing the thyroid,
lowering energy, lowering emotions, and increasing depression). It
will also raise the sodium potassium ratio (which threatens the stress
response, and lowers (calming) magnesium.
l. Calcium is also usually best avoided as it will further increase the
calcium shell and further slow metabolism. Though it can help
alleviate symptoms, it is doing so by numbing the person's
awareness and feelings.
4. General diet: It's widely accepted that vegetarian/vegan diets
exacerbate copper toxicity, and vegans/vegetarians should strongly
consider slowly reincorporating animal meat back into the diet (despite
the strong resistance to this that will naturally be felt by many with copper
toxicity). It will be almost impossible to properly detox otherwise. This is not
meant to promote meat - the modern Western meat based diet is far
from healthy and plant based diets have great health benefits, certainly
short term. However, if you are hoping to fully recover from copper
toxicity, despite personal objections to eating meat, it is of paramount
importance to add at least some meat back into the diet. This does not
need to be a lifelong commitment. Certainly though it can help speed up
and make more effective the period of detox, and could be the make or
break decision determining a proper recovery - physically and
psychologically. Organically raised grass fed meat is recommended.
Organic or not though, foods that have high enough zinc levels to
counterbalance the high copper should be increased, these being red
meat (best source) such as beef, lamb, and venison, chicken, eggs and
pumpkin seeds. Likewise, high copper containing foods should be
reduced or eliminated - these being notably shellfish, nuts and seeds
(except for pumpkin seeds), soybeans (tofu, tempeh, miso, etc.),
64
legumes, wheat germ (though also high in zinc, remember
that the phytic acid greatly impairs the utilization of that
zinc), coconut, avocado, chocolate, coffee, and leafy
greens. To help recover and detox, these foods should be
limited. Finally, a note regarding cod liver oil and
desiccated beef liver, two items sometimes misguidingly
suggested by practitioners. Cod liver oil does provide a
great source of retinol, but it also is high in Vitamin D,
which in turn lowers potassium. If the patient's potassium is
low, this should be avoided. Beef liver contains a high
amount of copper, and for the copper toxic person, even
½ mg of copper can have adverse effects.
5. Sulfur rich foods (such as eggs, garlic, onions) are
highly important to help with detoxing toxins in general.
6. Other foods and herbs that can generally help the liver
and the detoxing process include: Fermented foods,
Turmeric, Pomegranates as well as Brassicaceaes
Vegetables, Milk Thistle (very important for liver detoxing),
Stinging Nettle (nettle infusions), Flax, Dandelion Root Tea,
Kombucha Tea, and Diatomaceous Earth (both of which
bind to and help remove heavy metals from the body),
Castor Oil packs, and St. John's Wort. The latter, St. John's
Wort, also is effective with decreasing serum estrogen
(high levels of which as you'll recall are a major cause of
copper retention).
7. Remember that it is not just about correcting the copper
level. Your recovery will also be determined by the
balancing of other key minerals and ratios. Those minerals
that are deficient in relation to others will need to be
increased through diet and supplementation, while other
minerals in excess may need to be reduced. Keep in
mind there is no one-size-fits-all recommendation that can
be given here - again the detox and nutritional plan is a
highly personalized plan that must be properly assessed
and monitored. Without HTMA results to use as a guide,
any supplement or detox program becomes nothing
more than blind guesswork.
65
ADDITIONAL CONSIDERATIONS THAT MAY ASSIST DETOX
Here are some additional things to look at to enhance the healing/detox
process:
1. Work to improve ceruloplasmin (Cp) production (with a word of
caution). Ceruloplasmin (Cp) has been mentioned above as the key
protein that binds to copper to make it bioavailable. The lower the Cp
level, the faster copper will accumulate in the liver and the brain as
insufficient carrier protein exists to bind the copper. With adrenal exertion
and as copper increases, Cp levels typically rise. However, as with most of
the other actions of copper, things reverse post-burnout. At this point the
liver is too weak to allow for adequate production of Cp and so, with
declining Cp, copper will then begin accumulating even
faster. However, while adequate Cp is a necessary factor, there is
danger in protocols out there that teach people to focus on raising their
serum Cp levels; using their rising serum Cp level as a measure of progress.
Consider that Cp will also rise together with estrogen (especially
supplemental forms), as well as during pregnancy, lactation, and ...
during inflammation! If you then add more copper as some protocols
suggest (or Vitamin D for that matter) to an already copper toxic person
with low potassium and slow metabolism, you're only further tanking their
potassium level while increasing their Na/K stress ratio, and quite possibly
raising Cp as a result of increased inflammation. Rather than spend time
and money on blood tests that measure Cp, equally or more important is
re-regulating the overall mineral pattern together with reducing physical
exertion and stress. The adrenals will then strengthen, Cp production
occurs, and negative side effects both physical and psychological can
be minimized. Some simple steps to naturally improve Cp levels include:
a. (if you are a slow metabolizer) eliminate Vitamin D which destroys
liver retinol needed for Cp
b. avoid excess calcium and ascorbic acid. Respectively, these
nutrients in excess impair the absorption of Mg and Fe, as well as
the bond between Cu and Cp.
66
c. take cod liver oil and whole food vitamin C which,
respectively, increase retinol and bioavailable
copper
d. increase dietary fat while limiting carbs (fat is
needed for proper copper absorption)
e. add Taurine which helps copper metabolism in the
liver
2. Reduce Stress. Find which areas or events in your life are
causing you stress, and reduce or eliminate them. Taking
on new projects, workloads, or hard exercise (heavy
weights, intense cardio, crossfit, etc) all increase stress
and can bring out many of the negative symptoms as the
stress stimulates copper being dumped from storage.
Other stimulants such as drugs, caffeine, sugar,
glutamates) can have a similar affect and should be
avoided. On the surface, that stress may even give
energy in the short-term, but in the long run it will make
the adrenals even more exhausted. Stressful events of any
kind cause the adrenals to weaken further, making it even
harder for the body to excrete excess copper while
further impairing the utilization of copper. During stress,
stored copper can sporadically 'leak out' from tissue
storage reservoirs, leading to increased anxiety,
depression, PMS symptoms, mood swings, insomnia, joint
pains, acne, and a host of other issues. To avoid negative
detox reactions, it's important to find ways to relax and be
at peace during the process.
3. Sweating / saunas offer a gentler and safer approach
with a less severe effect than enemas. Infrared sauna
therapy is in fact excellent for detoxing copper as well as
other heavy metals and toxins. It also creates
a parasympathetic effect which further helps with bile
secretion, allowing toxins to be excreted.
4. Meditate or do Tai Chi
5. EFT (Emotional Freedom Technique)
6. Breathwork. Breathwork can be one of the most powerful
anti-anxiety and stress relieving tools you can use. One
very successful method is the "4/7/8 Breath". To do this,
67
begin by fully and powerfully exhaling through the mouth.
Then inhale fully through to the nose to a count of 4. Hold
for 7 seconds. Then release and exhale through the mouth
forcefully for 8 seconds. Repeat this for 4 breath cycles.
Then stop. Do not go longer. Do this twice a day,
consistently each day, for at least 6 to 8 weeks.
Butekyo Breathing can be another useful technique.
7. Get adequate rest (and avoid excessive exercise for the
reasons discussed above)
8. Epsom Salt Baths or Magnesium Chloride Baths (these can
help enhance your magnesium absorption without the
laxative effects as this way it bypasses the gut
9. Coffee enemas are excellent for removing toxins and
especially stimulating bile flow. Just be cautious as you
can't control which minerals it will deplete. In other words,
if you use it to reduce high levels of copper, it can deplete
other minerals in the process. For this reason I do not
suggest coffee enemas when all the minerals are low to
begin with. Otherwise, as long as your mineral levels are
being monitored and adjusted, coffee enemas are
very beneficial for detoxing.
10. Be objectively aware of recent behaviours. Did you make
a drastic decision or did your life take a turn around the
time you began to detox? Decisions which could be seen
as hurtful or have dragged you in a more closed-off
direction are often not your true, higher self, but rather are
influenced by copper, negative energies, and triggers. Try
as best you can to focus on positive, higher conscious
behaviours such as forgiveness, love, kindness,
compassion, openness. Believe in the real you, which is
always positive towards yourself and others.
68
11. Seek support and guidance from those who understand
copper toxicity and the detox roller coaster. Copper
toxicity is very poorly understood. Though people and
practitioners will offer you their advice, they rarely have
true understanding of the extent of changes that copper
can cause in an individual. Make sure the actions you
take are based on advice from those who've taken the
time to really understand this condition.
12. Psycho-therapy, recommended to help reduce the
destructive effects of the superego (also known as the
Judge (Malter, 2001) which copper gives rise to, and
emotional support, are both very beneficial. In fact,
psychotherapy and counselling are highly
recommended to help the individual cope with the rush
of awareness and emotions that may return as the
calcium shell dissolves.
13. Read & Research. In addition to a number of additional
resources in the reference section on coppertoxic.com,
Ann Louise Gittleman's book 'Why Am I Always So Tired'
offers a dietary program that can assist in remedying
copper overload.
14. Investigate your methylation. Methylation, a process that
in most simple terms turns on systems within the body, is
an extremely complex topic with many variants. It plays
a role in many emotional or psychological or brain
development disorders and, in the context of toxic levels
of copper and other minerals and metals, converts these
toxins into water-soluble compounds which can then be
more easily eliminated. It is therefore a key component of
being able to properly detox. As copper rises, zinc
decreases. Inadequate zinc inhibits the methylation
process, which blocks proper detoxification.
69
WHAT TO EXPECT AND LOOK OUT FOR DURING
DETOX
As one eliminates copper through detox (even one properly
monitored), patients will often experience the effects of copper
"dumping". The dumping is simply the elimination of copper.
Though many people have elevated copper, not all will
experience the following detoxing effects. These effects apply
more so to individuals who have accumulated a significant
copper level. For those people, often the copper detox
symptoms are frightening and very uncomfortable, and if the
patient is unaware of what is happening they may stop
treatment as it is too unbearable. Conversely, patients may also
stop copper toxicity treatment if they feel they have improved
by a sudden increase in adrenal strength / energy. By
understanding that copper dumping and the associated
symptoms are part of the detoxification process, patients (and
their partners) are better able to endure what they are
experiencing. Dumping usually occurs in cycles, and life can feel
like quite a roller coaster for some time. Detoxing is NOT a quick
process, and can usually take 6 months to a year or more,
with many up and down cycles, until the health of the mind and
body are restored. Women generally have a rougher and
harder time detoxing than men, due to their higher estrogen
levels and monthly cycles.
It should be noted that aerobic exercise, stimulant drugs, and
increases in stress while detoxing can further exacerbate
symptoms of copper elimination. These activities increase
metabolic rate and cellular energy production which in turn can
trigger copper dumps from cellular storage. Exercise, by
stimulating the sympathetic nervous system, also reduces bile
secretion, causing copper to get stirred up but blocking its
elimination [25]. The detox process usually brings to the surface
some of the worst symptoms of toxicity, both physical and
psychological. The importance of proper monitoring and
support throughout the detox process cannot be over-
.
70
stated. As noted, not everyone will experience severe copper
elimination symptoms - it depends on the extent of the copper
accumulation and the aggressiveness of the detox
approach. In addition to the symptoms pointed out in the
quote by Dr. Casper to the right, other symptoms of mobilization
and detox can include flu-like symptoms, decreased libido,
acne, spaciness, disorientation, digestive problems, nausea, joint
pains, and emotional detachment especially when
accompanied by the calcium shell.
The stimulating effect of exercise is so powerful that it can
actually allow an adrenal burned out person to feel fit and
healthy, even as key mineral reserves are being dangerously
depleted. The following excerpt is from the 1981 Healthview
Newsletter Issue 27-29 in discussion with Dr. Paul Eck:
"When you are fatigued, and cannot, or will not, do anything
about it, the body often dulls your sensitivity. It reduces your
awareness so you can continue to function. Often the person
has no idea of the trouble he is in until you pull him out of it. This is
frequently true of heavy exercisers. One reason for this is that
exercise can give people a sense of physical and mental
euphoria which is not warranted by their physical condition.
Vigorous exercise can cause a release of narcotic-like
substances from the brain and pituitary gland. This is why runners
say they get a "natural high." ...The person is getting an exalted
and exaggerated sense of well-being that is frequently NOT
supported by a solid mineral base. What concerns us about
heavy exercise is that it is so stimulating. It has the ability to
prevent people from feeling bad when they should feel bad. It
has the ability to block out awareness of an underlying fatigue."
"The mobilization and removal
of excess copper can cause
psychological and physical
symptoms, including; PMS,
fatigue and exhaustion,
allergies, brain fog, headaches
and migraines, mood swings,
cry easily or for no reason, cold
hands and/or feet, depression,
dry skin, chocolate cravings,
feeling out of control, paranoia,
despair and hopelessness,
arthritis and calcium spurs,
constipation, tachycardia or
bradycardia, poor
concentration or memory, short
attention span, spaced out,
eating disorders (anorexia,
bulimia, overeating), anxiety,
panic attacks, yeast infections
(candida), aching or cramping
muscles, hypoglycemia,
insomnia, mind racing,
obsessive thoughts, cysts,
mononucleosis, low blood
pressure, hypothyroid."
~ Julie Casper, L.Ac .
71
As a result, a return to exercise too quick and too hard in a
copper toxic burned out individual can further support a false
sense of improved wellness and cause them to abandon further
treatment. The exercise, just like adrenal stimulants, also raises
sodium over potassium, increasing the stress response, further
losing magnesium, further increasing the calcium shell, and
further complicating the process of counseling the individual.
As one begins to detox, it's not uncommon for the copper level
on the Hair TMA to show up at an even higher level than before -
this is simply the copper being mobilized. The copper released
from storage into the blood as a result of detox is now free,
unbound copper. Without adequate ceruloplasmin or minerals
such as molybdenum to bind to the copper, the mental
symptoms will worsen. This can also affect the ratios with other
minerals (such as magnesium and calcium), and lead one
further into a calcium shell. This is why changes in perception
and personality are not uncommon during the detox phase. The
calcium shell also helps slow down the previously racing mind
while also numbing the patient to what is happening around
them, both of which lead to a false sense of improvement. In
effect, though some symptoms have "improved", other
symptoms (psychological) are less obvious to the patient and
can get worse. This is why detox must be done in a slow, gentle,
and monitored way. Relationship struggles / break-ups are
common during this time (online forums are filled with these
cases, and this is discussed more in the Relationships section). It
is so important to keep this in mind if you feel your relationship
heading down the same path. Remember that you are not
yourself during this time. As copper stimulates the old brain and
weakens the neocortex, selected parts of reality and the
perception of certain people and beliefs can get distorted,
compounded by the rise in calcium which creates an 'emotional
cataract'. Over time, as copper is eventually eliminated, the
calcium shell (which previously had numbed the emotions and
blocked awareness of what was happening), begins to break
apart. This breaking of the shell may be experienced suddenly,
or in some cases gradually, with little sparks of old awareness,
"One of the key things you first
have to understand is who you
are biochemically and how
the wrong detox mechanism
can affect you psychologically
and psychiatrically."
~Dr. Albert Mensah
“When the shell breaks up, it is
often described in the person's
own words as a wall or a plate
glass coming down or
disintegrating. Or, it may be
experienced like a dam
breaking and a flood of blocked
feelings rushes in an
overwhelms the person."
~The Strands of Health,
Dr. Rick Malter, Ph.D
72
memories and feelings slowly peaking through as the shell
disintegrates.
Another thing that can happen during detox is something
known as "retracing". Retracing stems from a subconscious
association of memories with biochemical patterns, similar to
how hearing a certain song brings back memories of that time.
The following is an excerpt taken from an article [26] written by
Analytical Research Labs:
"The first factor that can cause emotional reactions is the
association of memories with mineral patterns. It is well known
that thoughts and memories may be triggered by such things as
odors, music, or specific locations that remind the person of
something from the past. What is less well known is that
memories can also be associated with specific biochemical
patterns. As we rebuild and rebalance the body chemistry a
person may pass through a mineral pattern of 20 years ago.
Suddenly, thoughts or feelings from that time can flood into
consciousness. The change in body chemistry unlocks, releasing
feelings that were dormant or subconscious. To suddenly
experience these feelings can be frightening inasmuch as they
can occur out of the blue, when one thought they had finished
with or forgotten a particular situation or emotion."
It's imperative that the overseeing practitioner helps the patient
understand the long-term commitment required for copper
detox. When the patient quits detox too soon (either because
they 'feel better' or in some cases due to the unpleasant effects
of copper dumping), the liver may have lightened its copper
load and adrenal function may have improved, but the work
has not yet been done to detox the stored copper that in the
latter stages accumulated in the brain. The person can wind up
being left in a pseudo-reality state psychologically as a result
with selectively altered perception and diminished awareness
of what's happened. Though the patient feels better and a
blood test shows "normal", there could still be large amounts of
bio-unavailable copper in the brain. Furthermore, other mineral
73
levels will likely also still be out of whack, causing a wide range
of psychological effects. All of this can only be properly
determined through HTMA, and this underscores the
importance of being monitored constantly via HTMA
throughout the often lengthy detox process, as well as the
importance of working with a practitioner that, beyond just
treating the obvious physical symptoms, understands the strong
psychological connection copper has to the brain and
thoughts. Without such proper guidance or HTMA testing, the
patient can easily believe they are fine and determine they no
longer need treatment.
There are a number of additional resources on the web which
explain in more detail what one can expect, including
http://www.arltma.com/Articles/CopperElimDoc.htm, and the
numerous links at www.coppertoxic.com/references.html. The
book "The Strands of Health" by Dr. Rick Malter Ph.D offers not
only one of the most comprehensive descriptions of Hair TMA
testing, but should also be mandatory reading for all who are
navigating their way through copper detox, both patients and
practitioners alike, in order to understand the importance of
precise mineral balancing and the consequences of not doing
so properly.
Lastly, like with any detox, it's imperative that you be aware of
how it will affect your emotions and spiritual energy. Excess
copper's close linkage to the emotions and feelings of
depression, anxiety, and paranoia are troublesome enough. On
top of this though, understand that lower energies are being
released (and surface) during this detox time. If one is not
careful, these too can play havoc with one's life path and
relationships.
“Lower emotions such as
resentment, grief, sadness, and
anger will surface to be
released during the cleansing
process…A big mistake is to feel
these feelings, then start
attaching a mental story to
them, creating a “drama” and
becoming upset about the
emotions, or projecting the
cause of them onto others in
your life, or taking some
unnecessary action.”
~Niki Gratix
74
HOW EMOTIONAL PROGRAMMING CAN
BLOCK CORRECTION
As copper rises, so too does sodium, while conversely
potassium levels decrease. The ratio between sodium
(Na) and potassium (K) is known as the 'stress ratio'. As the
Na/K ratio is allowed to rise, the intensity of stress rises, and
one's ability to handle stress becomes less. The slightest
irritation can cause intense agitation, and the person may
act out in a reflex over-reaction that bypasses higher
cortical intellect function. Balancing this ratio is essential to
correcting a copper toxicity issue. The challenge is
that emotional issues from childhood may block the
correction of this ratio and even over-ride the effect of
supplementation because the issues are imprinted in the
brain and nervous system at a subcortical cell and tissue
level. (Some resources that may help in this regard are
offered at
http://www.integrativehealthcoaching.ca/emotional-
healing.html). Further compounding this challenge is that
by this stage the calcium level has also risen to form a
"shell" effect that numbs the emotions and selectively
blocks the person's awareness of their behaviour and
reactions. If the calcium shell is an ingrained pattern since
childhood as a protective mechanism, it may be very
difficult to resolve this pattern through mineral balancing
alone.
Indeed, beyond the HTMA and correcting nutritional
imbalance, a big part of healing is spiritual in nature -
identifying beliefs and possible childhood traumas that
have not only led to the current condition, but are also
blocking further healing. Protective mechanisms may
have been learned in childhood in times when expressions
of love were met with pain, and those self-preservation
adaptations are now getting in the way of self care and
self love as adults. Counseling to overcome fear and
"A high tissue level of calcium tends to
block natural cellular functioning [and]
tends to be associated with emotional
blocking, numbing of feelings,
depression, low self-esteem, pessimism,
and feelings of inferiority. The more
need there is for emotional blocking and
deadening of feelings, the more the TMA
calcium will tend to exceed magnesium.
…In alcoholic or other dysfunctional
families, there seems to be a strong
tendency for a child to develop a
calcium "shell" as a natural self-
protective mechanism which helps to
constantly deaden feelings of
vulnerability and anxiety. …This calcium
shell can become a chronic entrenched
mineral pattern. …Psychologically, a
chronic high Ca/Mg ratio tends to be
associated with denial or covering up a
problem with which the individual
cannot or will not deal." [5]
"A great deal of energy is expended to
hold on to resentments, frustrations,
anger, guilt, rage, shame, and fears.
Whatever energy may be built up by
taking vitamins and minerals may
continue to be drained and wasted in
holding on to emotional conflicts and
feelings that are not adequately dealt
with.... Mineral patterns may remain out
of balance because there is an internal
psychological resistance to change. Until
the person works through and resolves
the emotionally conflicts, mentally, he or
she will be blocked in changing their
related adverse mineral pattern....When
the emotional conflict is finally resolved,
a tremendous amount of energy is freed
up and a significant mineral pattern
change may then take place."
~Dr. Rick Malter Ph.D (Excerpt from
"The Strands of Health")
75
anxiety, healing one's emotional history of abuse or trauma, and
helping the person move into a renewed state of self-love can
be most helpful.
THE GIFT OF HEALING
Copper toxicity perfectly demonstrates the intimate connection
between mind and body, between biology and psychology,
each influencing the other. Beyond the physical symptoms,
we've also seen how excess copper plays a powerful role on
emotional/mental health. It can also play a role in our spiritual
growth. Excess bio-unavailable copper gets largely stored in our
tissues, which also is where an energetic memory of our fears get
stored. As copper gets stirred up and mobilized through detox,
so too can old belief systems from our parents and childhood,
along with traumatic memories and fears. If we're not careful,
we then approach the continuation of healing as if we're driving
a car and deciding which way to turn based on what we see in
the rear view mirror. We need to be mindful of this
influence. We can also consider the view of Traditional Chinese
Medicine which says that anger gets stored primarily in the
liver. Many experts regard depression as a form of repressed
anger. As one cleanses the liver through detox, these long-
buried negative emotions of anger, fears, or traumas which we
don't want to look at may come to the surface together with the
toxic load. Awareness of this possibility can hold a key to
continuing the journey, or giving up.
This is an opportunity therefore to examine how past hurts and
beliefs may be affecting one's current behaviour, and to let
them go so they no longer control and sabotage our lives. Did
you inherit non-supportive beliefs from your parents? Are you
now acting in a similar way or pattern as one or both your
parents? Is there a trauma to deal with? As for fear, it is the
greatest enemy that stops us in our evolution in life. Sometimes
the greater our spiritual evolutionary 'reward' (awakening), the
greater the fear that one must conquer first...and in the context
"Individuals with an abuse
history, or a history of trauma,
also form neural units that do
not serve them for health,
wellbeing, and a peaceful
life. This is one reason why
individuals have a difficult time
correcting their mineral
balance without healing their
emotional history, and/or
spiritual levels. We are much
more than a body."
~Rachel Neumann
"The main thing that is
preventing you from waking up,
the main thing that is
preventing you from finding the
joy, and the main thing that is
preventing you from living your
life here now, fully, is your
fear. So you could be doing
everything you want to be
doing, but if you do not address
the fear, you're not going to
wake up…. We all want to stop
judgement, the negative
emotions, culturally it's not
acceptable to say what I feel, to
show that I'm insecure, that I'm
angry, that I'm not happy, all
these things stay repressed in
our body. Where do these
repressions go? They stay in
your tissues. Every single
experience you've had in your
life starting from your birth, the
memory of your birth, the
trauma, or even if it's the
experience of fear, it's in your
tissues."
~Mada Eliza Dalian
76
of this topic, copper toxicity may be the catalyst that calls one
to that challenge of growth. Forgiveness, of yourself and others,
becomes the next step. In this light, a quote from the book 'A
Course in Miracles' is well suited: "The world we see merely
reflects our own internal frame of reference...Projection makes
perception. We look inside first, decide the world we want to
see and then project that world outside, making it the truth as
we see it. We make it true by our interpretations of what it is we
are seeing...We have distorted the world by our twisted
defences, and are therefore seeing what is not there. As we
learn to recognize our perceptual errors, we also learn to look
past them or 'forgive'... Forgiveness means no longer living in the
fearful past...Forgiveness is the most powerful healer of all... "
It can be helpful to take a step back and question your
reaction to people as well as nutritional guidance offered
during your detoxing process. If you've closed off a part of your
life or an approach to healing during this time, that could be a
clue to where the biggest hurt or fear exists, and thus the most
important, albeit hardest, area to examine. Not to be confused
with the way things may appear to be normal while under the
influence of the calcium shell or other imbalances, those who
put in the effort to truly heal themselves physically and mentally
(arduous and long as the process often is), invariably refer to
copper toxicity as the catalyst to their greatest spiritual growth
and self-awakening.
77
WHY COPPER TOXICITY IS SO POORLY UNDERSTOOD
Most doctors remain unfamiliar with copper toxicity or show little interest in it
because treatment is based on nutrition, not pharmaceuticals; the latter
approach provides profits, the former does not, nor is nutrition adequately
taught in medical school. Furthermore, when it comes to assessing copper
status, almost all doctors and researchers rely on blood test results (and studies
based on blood testing). This ignores one of the most fundamental aspects of
copper toxicity - excess copper does not get stored in the blood! Blood levels
have almost no correlation to stored tissue levels! Articles strewn across the
Internet promoting the one-sided benefits of copper only further muddy the
waters of understanding. Only through properly interpreted HTMA testing (Hair
Tissue Mineral Analysis) can the public ever truly come to understand the
prevalence of copper toxicity, how it’s impacting their health, and how to
properly approach the complex rebalancing of minerals in the body “Until
medical doctors and other “health” care practitioners begin to study the
mind/body’s mineral system especially as it is reflected in HTMAs, the medical /
mineral disconnect will remain. Without HTMA data, medical doctors will not
recognize the epidemic nature of the copper toxicity problem." ~Dr. Malter,
Ph.D.
The rest of this section explains, in significant detail, the various causes and
effects of copper toxicity. Hopefully this work will shed light and clarity on a
topic which affects so many, yet on which so much false information has been
relayed by practitioners or continues to be written about online. The Internet
today is flooded with articles that:
dismiss altogether the concept of copper "toxicity", instead suggesting
that most of the population needs to consume more (when in fact the
standard diet of the Western world sufficiently supplies the recommended
daily intake for all age groups), and failing to educate the reader that
most copper deficiency in the West is a result of excess copper exposure
(as explained on the Symptoms page of this site).
deny (or fail to mention) that birth control methods like the pill or copper
IUD could lead to the presenting symptoms,
espouse only the 'benefits' of copper (such as being healthy or stimulating
for the brain, energy, thyroid...), leading the reader to believe we all need
78
to consume more - despite excess copper over time leading to mental
illness, adrenal burnout, slowing of the thyroid, and much much more...
promote the Ayurvedic benefits of drinking from copper vessels. Though
such practice served a sterile-water-storage benefit in ancient days
(since copper does in fact provide antimicrobial properties), what fails to
be mentioned is that our biochemistry today (mineral profile) is very
different than it was thousands, or even hundreds, of years ago). We
know today that copper being leached from copper piping in homes is
harmful and are moving away from such practice; certainly not toward
it!
promote their copper-containing products (using copper as a selling
feature) using such phrases as 'copper toxicity is rare', 'excess copper is
excreted', or in the case of excess, copper can be 'removed by chelating
agents or by the consumption of high levels of zinc'. Ignorant advice that
is wrong, wrong, and downright dangerous!
portray copper to be a 'love mineral' without expanding on the fact
that excess copper is a major cause of emotional shutdown, depression
and broken relationships,
promote blood testing as the standard way to determine copper status
(despite the fundamental fact as mentioned that excess copper gets
stored in tissue and NOT the blood, meaning that blood provides almost
NO reliable correlation to the tissue mineral level at the cellular level),
base arguments on studies which use blood (which of course most studies
do and therefore are very misleading), or on the two widely publicized
studies from 1985 and 2001 on HTMA that intentionally aimed to dismiss
the benefits of HTMA through faulty testing and manipulation of results),
refute the benefits or accuracy of HTMA testing - despite thousands of
peer reviewed references supporting HTMA and it being the single most
important test to determine copper toxicity and provide the guidance
necessary for intelligent evidence-based nutritional rebalancing. [Given
the efforts that have gone into suppressing HTMA, could it be that this
simple non-invasive 'alternative' test threatens the profits of big-pharma
since money is made off drugs and disease rather than health and holistic
self care?]
Without mentioning site names (their promotion is not deserved) it is important
for people to understand the caution necessary when researching this topic. By
79
far the majority of websites and blog articles out there written about copper are
presenting blatantly false or misleading information. A few examples:
A popular medical website widely used for diagnosis of various conditions
makes no mention of HTMA but instead promotes urine and blood testing
as the best ways of diagnosing copper toxicity (the reasons why such
advice is dangerously flawed are addressed on the Testing page of this
site). The same medical website also makes the incorrect claim that
constant fatigue has a weak or unproven link to copper toxicity. Again,
this is a reflection of a complete lack of understanding behind how
excess copper directly affects and weakens the adrenals, leading to
fatigue.
One of the world's leading providers of online medical health information
states the primary cause of copper toxicity to be the consumption of illicit
drugs or prescription, over-the-counter, alternative medications or drug
overdoses. They fail entirely to make any mention of the MUCH more
prevalent and important causes of copper toxicity, nor do they make any
mention in their discussion of the key symptoms of fatigue, adrenal issues,
or influences on mood and mental health. Quite frankly, their explanation
of copper toxicity is misleading at best and void of any substance or truth
on the topic whatsoever. How can the public ever be properly informed
when such mainstream medical sites purport such astonishingly false
information?!
A doctor-authored 'science based' site promotes copper as the
protective, anti-aging, love mineral. The site suggests people do not need
to worry about copper excess because the body does a fantastic job
regulating levels, citing "with amazement" how numerous studies show
that copper "magically" disappears out of the blood. It completely fails to
make mention of where this excess copper goes (ie: into tissue and
accumulating in the body)!! Furthermore, copper toxicity can have a
powerful impact on the emotions - though not always good. Whereas
the article hypes copper as the mineral of love, the fact (which the article
misrepresents) is that copper at high levels can eradicate feelings of love
and cause depression. In fact, we know, anyone who becomes highly
copper toxic will experience a deadening of their emotions! Misleadingly,
the article goes on to imply that copper is great for mental health,
completely ignoring the EXTREMELY significant negative psychological
symptoms that present with high levels of copper stored in the brain
80
(including Alzheimer's, schizophrenia, ADD, depression, anxiety, the list
goes on!) The article then goes on further to make such false claims
as "the only dietary source of copper that a person should worry about is
in contaminated water" (implying that diet plays no role in copper toxicity
and adjusting one’s diet therefore would not make any difference!), and
that "copper provides preventative benefits for ALL conditions except
one (Wilson's Disease)". The amount of blatantly false information in this
one article alone is astonishing, yet tragically people read and trust this
kind of literature because it’s authored by a doctor, and as a result the
public continues to be dangerously misled.
A national public service information site from the U.S. that claims to offer
"objective science based" information, states "The human body adjusts its
internal environment to maintain copper equilibrium" and that copper
rarely gets stored in the body. Hundreds of thousands of HTMA profiles
very clearly disprove that! Once again though, people believe such
falsehoods because it comes from a so-called 'trusted' source.
Sexual health and official birth control option websites make little to zero
mention of the ‘copper connection’ to the common symptoms of copper
toxicity that arise from the birth control Pill and copper IUD. Young women
go to these sites (and to their doctor’s) expecting reliable information, yet
without receiving full disclosure to symptoms, their physical and mental
health is being put at risk. Women so often realize something is wrong but
they simply can't get their doctors to listen, and information (or lack
thereof) being relayed from sexual health officials sure doesn’t help the
matter.
a copper-based health product, in their sleek marketing, uses misleading
attribution from a random selected article that claims copper to be a
new 'gold standard in saving lives', without disclosing copper's negative
effects, and attributing the quote as coming from one of North America's
leading healthcare research and publishing services.
Another one of the ‘world’s leading online independent health platforms
with over half a million members and millions of visitors each month offers
a discussion group for women complaining of negative symptoms that
started after inserting their IUD. These women are looking for answers,
trying to understand what’s causing their symptoms. Yet, when copper
toxicity was brought up and a link provided where people could learn
more, publication was denied by the site administrators. To this day,
people continue to post, seeking answers, but the public is effectively
81
blocked from receiving this information. The same is true for one of
Facebook’s largest health ‘advocacy’ groups - mention of copper
toxicity has been quickly attacked and dismissed by the administrators,
and people continue to be led astray by dangerous protocols that ignore
consideration of copper toxicity.
Countless more websites (including one of the world's top 10 most visited
natural health websites) talk about all the benefits of copper (it helps
increase energy, is good for healthy brain function, assists emotional
health, supports healthy metabolism, helps thyroid activity...) ... and lead
the public to believe most of us are deficient in copper and therefore
should be increasing our intake! They do not understand that most
deficiency is caused by a toxicity issue, NOT by a lack of copper in the
diet. Second, the benefits mentioned are only true at a normal, healthy
level of copper. As copper builds up and becomes bio-unavailable in
large quantities, those aforementioned benefits REVERSE!!! Copper
increases energy? At a basic level, yes...but too much copper leads to
adrenal exhaustion! Healthy brain function? It's a marker in over half of
schizophrenics, and a key factor leading to Alzheimer's! Emotional
health? Too much copper leads to the numbing of emotions and
damaged relationships, as well as being a leading cause of depression
and anxiety. Supports metabolism? It leads to a slowing of metabolism!
Helps thyroid activity? Copper raises calcium and lowers potassium,
leading directly to a slowing of thyroid activity! And again we see even
more websites claiming that the body is able to self-regulate the level of
copper. Anyone who studies the interrelationship of minerals and uses
the hard evidence provided by HTMA testing knows how absurd such
claims are.
Tragically, the Internet and social media has become a breeding ground of
erroneous information, much of it influenced by a small number of individuals
(including doctors) who have the power and a platform to convince large
trusting audiences, and this is the unfortunate environment the public is left to
navigate through. It's becoming increasingly difficult for people to know what
to believe, especially when some of these so-called 'experts' flat-out deny the
concept of 'copper toxicity'. Not only does such ongoing ignorance deny what
so many have painfully struggled through, it also suppresses greater awareness
of the condition and the chance to address the sources of exposure. How
many more people have to painfully lose their health or a loved one because
82
of ignorance surrounding copper toxicity, or their practitioner not understanding
that the blood copper level is a fluctuating and highly unreliable marker, or not
understanding the effect birth control pills, copper IUDs, copper sulfates,
estrogens, copper piping and high copper diets have on people, physically
and psychologically. How many more stories do we have to hear of young
women being prescribed anti-depressants, without even an investigation into
her copper level and associated mineral imbalances? To deny copper toxicity
is to deny an individual's right to possibly finding the one answer that could save
their life or transform their health. Too many lives have already been hurt or
destroyed as a result of medical ignorance, and the health of our future
generations, especially our young women, is most at risk. Those of us in the
health care and holistic healing communities have a duty and owe it to the
people we serve to promote proper understanding of this epidemic. It's time we
move into a new paradigm of health, recognizing the interconnection between
our environment, food choices, and minerals levels, and how those interrelated
minerals influence, and indeed control, our health, even our personality. The
science, research, and hard evidence has existed for over 40 years; it's time we
recognize the toxic nature of copper on the body resulting not from mere
internal 'dysregulation' but from the large number of sources from which we are
receiving over-exposure (copper sulfates, copper IUDs, copper piping,
xenoestrogens as examples). Leaving outdated medical and nutritional beliefs
behind, let's open ourselves to knowledge which can truly serve the greater
good of people. When women receive fully informed consent to birth control,
when nutritionists understand the essentiality of program design based on a
client's individual mineral profile and not fad dietary beliefs, and when the
medical system allows for greater conversation on the role mineral imbalance
plays in disease, what are the possibilities for our world in terms of reducing
illness, increasing human energy, and saving relationships and lives?
The research on this site is the summation of 40+ years of research specific to
mineral balances and copper toxicity. There is no longer a lack of research, or
evidence. The evidence is clear and factual, especially through HTMA data.
The hope is that through this website and furthering the life's work of pioneers in
this field including Drs Eck, Watts, Pfeiffer, Malter, Wilson, and others, the tide will
eventually be turned in favor of awareness and proper understanding for the
benefit and healing of all those affected.
83
References [1] http://www.acu-cell.com/crcu.html [2] http://www.traceelements.com/Docs/The%20Nutritional%20Relationships%20of%20Copper.pdf [3] Karl E. Mason: A Conspectus of Research on Copper Metabolism and Requirements of Man, The Journal of Nutrition. Volume 109, Number 11, Nov 1979, pp 1979-2066 [4] http://groknation.com/women/birth-control/ [5] http://www.orthomolecular.org/library/jom/1994/articles/1994-v09n02-p079.shtml [6] http://archpsyc.jamanetwork.com/article.aspx?articleid=2552796 [7] http://www.msn.com/en-ca/health/wellness/contraceptives-may-increase-the-risk-of-depression/ar-BBx2gWW?li=AAggFp5 [8] http://www.alternativementalhealth.com/396/ [9] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/17317521 [10] http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/8034078 [11] http://www.cdc.gov/nchs/data/nhsr/nhsr062.pdf [12] http://www.westonaprice.org/modern-diseases/copper-zinc-imbalance-unrecognized-consequence-of-plant-based-diets-and-a-contributor-to-chronic-fatigue/ [13] http://www.traceelements.com/Docs/The%20Nutritional%20Relationships%20of%20Copper.pdf [14] http://articles.mercola.com/sites/articles/archive/2016/09/25/veganism.aspx [15] https://metabolichealing.com/metallothionein-forgotten-antioxidant-missing-puzzle-piece-for-alzheimers-leaky-gut/ [16] www.healingaia.com/blog-resources/nutritional-balancing/common-imbalances/depression/ [17] https://pdfs.semanticscholar.org/8d8b/ee2d0767f2b91f7f004227cd6dda01327e7d.pdf [18] http://www.orthomolecular.org/library/jom/1994/articles/1994-v09n02-p079.shtml [19] http://www.tvernonlac.com/copper-toxicity.html [20] http://nutritionalbalancing.org/center/htma/science/articles/htma-references.php [21] http://www.arltma.com/Articles/CopperToxDoc.htm [22] https://www.spectracell.com/media/uploaded/2/0e2017253_277abstract2006nutrrevzinc-theantidepressantpdf-.pdf [23] http://www.acu-cell.com/crcu.html [24] http://www.arltma.com/Articles/CopperElimDoc.htm [25] https://books.google.ca/books?id=1kGcFOKCUzkC&pg=PA517&dq#v=onepage&q&f=false [26] http://www.arltma.com/Articles/RetracingDoc.htm [27] https://www.hormonesmatter.com/depression-mood-disorders-trivialized-side-effects-birth-control/ [28] http://www.drgangemi.com/health-articles/hormone-health/iud-pain-problems/ [29] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5090008/ [30]https://www.researchgate.net/publication/12499522_Is_serum_Cu_a_trait_marker_of_unipolar_depression_A_preliminary_clinical_study [31] https://geneticliteracyproject.org/2016/05/09/popular-organic-pesticide-copper-sulfate-compare-synthetic-ones-like-glyphosate/ [32] http://pmep.cce.cornell.edu/profiles/extoxnet/carbaryl-dicrotophos/copper-sulfate-ext.html [33] http://articles.extension.org/pages/18351/organic-management-of-late-blight-of-potato-and-tomato-with-copper-products [34] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/20150596 [35] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/22438177 [36] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/17296833 [37] https://www.urmc.rochester.edu/news/story/3916/copper-identified-as-culprit-in-alzheimers-disease.aspx [38] http://www.townsendletter.com/Oct2013/copper1013.html [39] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC196927/ [40] http://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/10937404.2010.499732?src=recsys [41] http://pubs.acs.org/doi/abs/10.1021/bi3006169 [42] http://articles.mercola.com/sites/articles/archive/2017/08/31/antidepressant-use-continues-
rise.aspx?utm_source=dnl&utm_medium=email&utm_content=art1&utm_campaign=20170831Z1_C&et_cid=DM159355
[43] https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/metals-and-mental-health/
[44] https://www.energeticnutrition.com/blog/2013/02/progesterone-almost-forgotten-hormone/
[45] https://www.mitosynergy.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/11/AnalysisOfTheNeedForACopper-
1SupplementPill_11_04_16.pdf
[46] http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0378427409015264
[47] http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/16022851
[48] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/12343060/
[49] https://www.merck.com/product/usa/pi_circulars/d/desogen/desogen_ppi.pdf
[50] http://www.health-science-spirit.com/mentaldisease.html
(51) http://www.westonaprice.org/health-topics/metals-and-the-mind/
[52] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2248201/
84
ABOUT THE AUTHOR
Rick Fischer is a Certified Health Coach, advanced H.T.M.A. Practitioner, nutritional
educator, author and speaker. His life was profoundly impacted by copper toxicity -
witnessing how it affected his beloved fiancée and subsequently losing her to the
psychological effects of a post-adrenal burnout copper detox administered under the
guidance of a physician who, like so many, relied on blood testing and failed to
understand the powerful psychological effects of adrenal burnout and the mobilization
of excess copper. He vowed not to allow this heartbreaking loss not serve a greater
purpose. He has since devoted his life to furthering the research in this field, and
bringing increased support, awareness and understanding to the copper toxicity
epidemic which silently affects so many, and yet is so widely misdiagnosed or
mistreated. The more he researched, the more he began hearing similar stories from
others who also had their lives, health, or relationships devastated as a result of adrenal
burnout, copper toxicity, and/or the subsequent detoxing process when incorrectly
administered. Given that much of this research has been around for over 40 years, it’s
shocking that lives are still being affected today because of medical ignorance and
even denial surrounding copper toxicity or the benefits of tissue mineral testing
(hTMA). Rick is a passionate advocate for advancing awakened nutritional awareness,
providing informed consent for women on birth control, helping those affected by
copper toxicity, and improving education in the role mineral imbalances play in
physical and mental health, energy, and relationships. Delving far deeper than the
content contained herein, Rick is currently also co-authoring a ground-breaking and
heavily researched book on copper toxicity, due out around 2020.
Rick’s work can be found at:
www.CopperToxic.com
(Copper Toxicity’s most comprehensive online resource, and the basis for this e-book)
www.TheHealingWorkbook.com
(Interactive guidebook for healing and life transformation)
www.HTMATEST.com
(All about Hair Tissue Mineral Analysis)
www.IntegrativeHealthCoaching.ca
(Portal site for Rick’s consulting practice)
www.MineralMastery.com
(Online nutrition education focused on minerals)