cook, kevin - mt judicial branch · 2019-07-08 · 1 cook, kevin from: menzies, lois sent: sunday,...

1

Cook, Kevin

From: Menzies, LoisSent: Monday, June 3, 2019 4:13 PMTo: Cook, KevinSubject: Public Comment -- Phelan

From: Allison Pennell <[email protected]> Sent: Friday, May 24, 2019 11:59 AM To: [email protected] Subject: Ryan Phelan Letter of Support To Whom It May Concern, I am writing in support of Ryan A Phelan to be appointed as judge in the Missoula district county. I have known Ryan for over three years, and have had the pleasure of nannying her children. As an employer, Ryan was incredibly supportive of my college career and made sure that my education came first. As a person, she is compassionate, honest, and fair, qualities that I believe every judge should embody. Ryan would make an excellent judge, especially as she is involved in the Missoula community. I am very proud to endorse her for Missoula district judge. ‐Allison Pennell

1

Cook, Kevin

From: Menzies, LoisSent: Thursday, June 6, 2019 9:25 PMTo: Cook, KevinSubject: Public Comment -- Phelan

_______________________________________ From: Catherine Brookes Pennell <[email protected]> Sent: Monday, June 3, 2019 2:17 PM To: [email protected] Subject: Ryan Phelan To whom it may concern, I worked for the Phelan family as a nanny for several years during my undergrad. To say that Ryan is a diligent, compassionate, and caring person is an understatement. Every day I saw her at her job and it played a large part in my decision to change my political science degree option from international relations to public law. She is truly a dedicated public servant. Many people in her position are involved in the community simply to “boost” a resume; not Ryan. She loves the community of Missoula. Her family is not limited to her wonderful husband and kids, but reaches out to all members of the community. She is an inspiring woman with integrity, and she will do great things as the next District Judge. I know Ryan Phelan and I support her! Sincerely, Brookes Pennell

2

Cook, Kevin


________________________________________ From: Helen Kelly <[email protected]> Sent: Tuesday, June 4, 2019 7:11 PM To: [email protected] Subject: District Court judge appointment ‐ Ryan Alane Phelan I am writing to express my support of Ryan Phelan’s application for appointment as District Court judge to replace Karen Townsend. I have known Ryan since she was a young girl and I have always been impressed with her intelligence, work ethic and sense of public service. She was an outstanding student and has brought that striving for excellence to her profession as a family practice lawyer. This is an area of law which requires compassion and an ability to listen andI Ryan certainly possesses those qualities. Her goal is always to seek the best outcome for all parties and to help people move on with their lives. I also know Ryan as an amazing wife and mother. In spite of a heavy workload, she is always able to be there for her children and is involved in all their activities. Ryan is also involved in her community. She serves on the board of MCT and volunteers with BASH. In closing, I would like to say that Ryan’s dedication to her profession, her sense of fairness and justice, her strong work ethic and her even temperament would make her an excellent choice for District Court judge. Helen Kelly 4313 Barbara Lane Missoula, MT 59803 Sent from my iPad

3

Cook, Kevin


From: Mark and Ruthie Mizner‐Welch <[email protected]> Sent: Tuesday, June 4, 2019 1:21 PM To: [email protected] Subject: Missoula District Court Judge Nominee Ryan Phelan Dear Ms. Mezies, It has been my family’s pleasure to know Ryan Phelan of P. Mars Scott law firm in Missoula, MT for several years. She has managed our litigation expertly and represented us fairly in District Court. Her kind, thoughtful, informed approach has blessed us greatly. We are able to recommend her for the position of District Judge without reservation. Ryan is a qualified attorney with wide legal experience whose temperament lends itself very well to overseeing a court. We believe she possesses wide community support and would be easily elected when the term expires. Sincerely, Ruth E. Mizner‐Welch 186 Renzim Court Seeley Lake, MT 59868 406‐677‐2520 Sent from Mail for Windows 10

1

Cook, Kevin

From: Menzies, LoisSent: Sunday, June 9, 2019 5:29 PMTo: Cook, KevinSubject: Public Comment -- Phelan

From: Ashley J. Weaver <[email protected]> Sent: Friday, June 7, 2019 9:38 AM To: [email protected] Subject: Support for Judicial Candidate Ryan Phelan Good morning! My name is Ashley Weaver and I am an attorney in Missoula, Montana. I know Ryan Phelan and I confidently support her candidacy for District Judge. I know her to be fair, level headed, and focused on justice. In a profession where integrity and compassion matter, I can imagine no other candidate has more than Ryan. Thank you! Ashley Weaver, Esq. Christian Samson 310 W. Spruce Street Missoula, MT 59802 (406)532‐1228

2

Cook, Kevin

From: Menzies, LoisSent: Sunday, June 9, 2019 5:28 PMTo: Cook, KevinSubject: Public Comment -- Phelan

From: Diane Sova <[email protected]> Sent: Sunday, June 9, 2019 2:14 PM To: [email protected] Subject: I have hired Ryan Phelan to represent me in two different cases 1 as a divorce lawyer and 1 for grandparent visitation she was a very professional lawyer and was always very accurate at what she did. I would highly recommend Ryan for the position.

1

Cook, Kevin

From: Menzies, LoisSent: Saturday, June 15, 2019 8:38 PMTo: Cook, KevinSubject: Public Comment -- Phelan

From: Andrew Larson <[email protected]> Sent: Friday, June 14, 2019 12:17 PM To: '[email protected]' Subject: Ryan Phelan ‐ support for candidacy To whom it may concern, I am writing in support for Ryan in her bid to become a District Court Judge. I have known Ryan personally for about 10 years. She is a great person who generally cares for others. She is extremely bright, thorough and committed to her trade. I have not worked with her professionally but have had customers and other attorney’s who speak highly of her and her work. I think her background and demeanor would be a great fit for the position. Thank you for your time. Sincerely, Andrew Larson | Vice President Commercial Lending 1704 Dearborn Missoula, MT 59801 | [email protected] P: 406.327.1021 | F: 406.329.1992

This email message is for the sole use of the intended recipient(s) and may contain confidential and privileged information. Any unauthorized review, use, disclosure or distribution is prohibited. If you are not the intended recipient, please contact the sender by reply email and delete the original message.

2

Cook, Kevin


From: Stephanie Graybeal <[email protected]> Sent: Friday, June 14, 2019 11:10 AM To: [email protected] Subject: Ryan Alane Phelan for District Court Judge I'm writing this to express our support for Ryan Alane Phelan to replace Judge Karen Townsend as District Court Judge in Missoula Ryan helped our family so much. When we were hoping for my husband to shoot my daughter but were misinformed that even though her biological father had relinquished all rights that we couldn't go through with an adoption, Ryan assured us we could. She walked us through the process and supported us and we will forever cherish the help she gave. Ryan would be an absolutely incredible District Court Judge and she 100% has the support of me and all of our family! I know she's got so much support but I wanted to write and express that support!

Thank you! Stephanie Graybeal

Get Outlook for Android

3

Cook, Kevin


From: BRYANT HIGGS <[email protected]> Sent: Friday, June 14, 2019 8:58 AM To: [email protected] Subject: Ryan Phelan's experience and application To Whom It May Concern; I have know Ryan for over 13 years, and her husband for 30+ years. Ryan's experience, judgement, temperament, empathy, and demeanor in personal, as well as professional, situations has always impressed me. Her compassion for the situations people deal with on a daily basis is beyond reproach and something I greatly admire about her, wishing I had more of those traits and qualities. My family has spent time with her and her family on numerous occasions, as friends, and our personal relationship led to my wife and I hiring Ryan for our personal legal matters regarding our wills and estate planning. I have also requested her professional expertise in personal situations, which has revealed her professionalism even more clearly. I also know that she has spent a majority of her life in the communities of Missoula and Mineral counties. She grew up and attended elementary and high school in Missoula, earned her B.S. at Montana State University‐Bozeman, completed her J.D. at the University of Montana‐Missoula, and has recreated, worked, and been involved in the surrounding areas. Her career has required her to travel extensively across western and central Montana as an attorney for her law firm, which has allowed her to gain unique experience and expertise in the lives and communities of the residents across our state. I can think of no better candidate for the position of District Court Judge in the 4th Judicial District on Montana. The citizens and communities served by her in this capacity would be proud to have her as their District Court Judge. Sincerely, Bryant Higgs

4

Cook, Kevin


From: Cory Thompson <[email protected]> Sent: Thursday, June 13, 2019 8:34 AM To: [email protected] Subject: 4th district judge for missoula Dear Judicial Nomination Committee: I am writing in support of Ryan Alane Phelan’s candidacy for the 4th District Judge for Missoula and MIneral Counties. I feel that her experience and dedication to the fair application of our judicial precedents will make her a tremendous District Judge. Thank you sincerely, Cory Thompson Owner of Corys Valley Market Seeley Lake, MT

TO: Judicial Nomination Commission Members

FROM: Lois Menzies

DATE: June 10, 2019

SUBJECT: Public Comment

The following is a transcription of a telephone message received on June 10, 2019:

This is Stan Rasmussen calling in support of Ryan Alane Phelan for the 4th Judicial District judge. I think she would be an excellent person for that position. I’ve known her ever since she was a little girl all the way up to high school when she was a member of the debate team at Loyola and did such a phenomenal job there and all the way through college and her law school years and her 20 years of practice as an attorney here in Missoula. She has extensive experience in family law that I think would be very, very appropriate for the 4th Judicial District judge. You could not go wrong in appointing her to that position. I thoroughly support her in every way. Thank you for your consideration.

Stan Rasmussen 610 Highland Park Drive Missoula, MT 59803

1

Cook, Kevin


________________________________________ From: Kara Grau <[email protected]> Sent: Monday, June 17, 2019 9:59 AM To: [email protected] Subject: Judicial Nomination letter of support Judicial Nomination Committee, I am writing in support of Ryan Phelan’s application for a position as judge. I know Ryan on a personal basis, rather than professional, but I would like to offer my support and encourage the committee to nominate her as a judge. I believe that she will be excellent as a judge, and would absolutely vote for her in the future. She is kind, fair, level‐headed and intelligent. While I don’t have an in depth knowledge of the legal system, I have confidence that Ryan would be excellent in the position. Thank you for your time, Kara Grau

MORALES LAW OFFICE, PC JULIO K. MORALES, Esq. (MT – retired on Senior Status) 422 W. Spruce • P.O. Box 9311 • Missoula, Montana 59807

406/728-6005 • [email protected] June 18, 2019

Montana Supreme Court Judicial Nomination Commission P. O. Box 203005 Helena, MT 59620-3005 Re: Comment on behalf of District Judge Candidate Phelan Dear Sirs: It is my distinct pleasure to hereby recommend Ryan Alane Phelan for the position of Missoula County District Judge. I have known Ryan and her extended family, Harrington as well as Harkin, for years. I have watched as this delightful and most proper young lady flourished and developed into an excellent attorney. I also have the highest opinion of her both as a highly skilled, ethical and experienced lawyer, and as a person of the highest integrity, dedicated to family and community. Occasionally our legal careers crossed paths, as hers skyrocketed and mine waned into retirement. She never failed to impress me with her dedication, yet ever courteous, as she fought for justice as the true goal. This I believe sets her apart: her ability to quickly grasp the facts, apply relevant legal principles, and arrive at a prompt, fair, equitable and just resolution for all. The people of Montana will be well served by Ryan Alane Phelan as District Judge. Most sincerely, Julio K. Morales, Esq. - Senior Status MORALES LAW OFFICE, PC JKM: hs

1

Cook, Kevin

From: Menzies, LoisSent: Tuesday, June 18, 2019 8:04 PMTo: Cook, KevinSubject: Public Comment -- Phelan

From: Gary Smith <[email protected]> Sent: Tuesday, June 18, 2019 9:52 AM To: [email protected] Subject: Ryan Phelan I highly recommend & support Ryan Phelan for District Court Judge. I have know her for her whole life & I think she is intelligent, compassionate, & hard working. I will also vote for her on a re‐election ballot. Sincerely, Gary “Scooter” Smith 406‐370‐4999

June18,2019JudicialNominationCommissionc/oLoisMenziesOfficeoftheCourtAdministratorP.O.Box203005Helena,MT59620-3005DearJudicialNominationCommission,IamwritinginsupportofRyanPhelanforDistrictCourtJudgeinthe4thJudicialDistrict.ImetRyanandherhusbandTerryover4yearsagothroughamutualfriendandourchildrennowallattendthesameschool.OurfamilieshaveinteractedboththroughschoolfunctionsandsociallyattheRanchClub,andmostrecently,oursonsplayedbasketballtogetherthispastwinter.IhavenotworkedwithRyanprofessionallybutwehavehadmanydiscussionsaboutlaw,includingtheimportanceofjuryserviceandhowjurorsareselectedinMissoula.Ibelieveherrecentdualroles-bothasaprivatepracticeattorneyandActingJusticeofthePeace–makeheranidealcandidate.IhavespentenoughtimearoundRyantoknowthesheisanextremelycompetentandtrustworthyperson.Shehandlesdifficultsituations-parenting,coaching,andI’msureinthecourtroomaswell–inameasuredandresponsiblemanner.IbelieveRyanwouldservethe4thJudicialDistrictwithfairnessandshewouldabsolutelyreceivemyvote.Sincerely,DeniseA.Birkholz

Judicial Nomination Commission

Attn: Lois Menzies

Office of Court Administrator

PO Box 203005

Helena, MT 59620-3005

Dear Judicial Nomination Commission,

My name is Christine Oschell and I am writing to you to support Ryan Phelan for District Court Judge in Missoula, Montana. I have known Ryan for five years and have interacted with her in diverse situations from school functions for our children to discussing law relevant to my job as a river manager for Montana Fish, Wildllife, and Parks. Ryan has an even, fair temperament and has a breadth of experience and knowledge in law. Ryan gets along with all types of people and is well liked in the communities where we interact together. This speaks to Ryan’s ability to be elected which in my opinion is very favorable.

In closing, Ryan is deserving and worthy of the position as District Court Judge and I would vote for her. Thank you for your time.

Sincerely,

Christine Oschell PhD

(406) 370-0898

June 18, 2019 Dear Judicial Nomination Commision, I am writing to you in support of Ryan Phelan who is seeking appointment to the soon vacant District Court Judge replacing Karen Townsend. As a lifelong resident of Missoula, I am familiar with all the judges and have been to court with my classes and have served on Jury Duty. Based on what I have seen and know, Ryan would be a very capable Judge. I have known Ryan for over twenty years and I know she would be an excellent choice to fill the open District Court Judge. In addition I know many others in Missoula who also support Ryan. Thank you, Wesley Appelt

1

Cook, Kevin

From: Menzies, LoisSent: Friday, June 21, 2019 1:51 PMTo: Cook, KevinSubject: Public Comment -- Phelan

From: Amanda Milburn <[email protected]> Sent: Friday, June 21, 2019 12:54 PM To: [email protected] Subject: Phelan for 4th District Court To the Judicial Nomination Commission: I am writing in support of selecting Ryan Phelan as Judge Townsend's 4th District Court judge replacement. I have known Ryan in both personal and professional settings. She consistently conducts herself in a conscientious, straight‐forward manner. Her breadth of experience and commitment to doing a job well is evident in her office as well as with her family, friends, and engagement with the community through volunteering. Ryan has both high moral character and strong work ethic. I believe her family law experience would be extremely valuable in this role. Ryan is an excellent choice and I will definitely vote for her if given the chance in future elections. Sincerely, Amanda Milburn Missoula, MT 206.300.7945

2

Cook, Kevin


From: Kenneth Lousen <[email protected]> Sent: Thursday, June 20, 2019 10:26 PM To: [email protected] Subject: RE: APPOINTMENT TO FILL JUDGE KAREN TOWNSEND'S VACANCY June 20, 2019 To: Judicial Nomination Commission This letter is in reference to Ryan A. Phelan. I understand that Ryan is a candidate for the office of District Court Judge, to replace retiring Judge Karen Townsend. Ryan has practiced family law for nearly two decades now and I believe she is a superbly qualified, and highly experienced lawyer particularly in family law. Ryan certainly meets the qualifications to be a District Court judge. I believe that with her deep ties to Missoula, she would be a strong candidate for election in both Missoula and Mineral counties. A large portion of her legal work has been dealing with family law over the past 18 years. I also believe that Ryan has demonstrated a good deal of judicial temperament that is very suitable for that of a District Court judge. Her family has deep roots in the Missoula area community, and I believe she would command great respect and support within this community for this position in Missoula District Court. I urge you to give Ryan your highest consideration. Sincerely, Kenneth Lousen If you have any questions for me, I can be contacted as follows: Kenneth Lousen 2425 Skyline Drive Missoula, MT 59802 406‐543‐8189

3

Cook, Kevin


From: Vickie Mikelsons <[email protected]> Sent: Thursday, June 20, 2019 10:26 PM To: [email protected] Subject: Ryan Alane Phelan for District Court Judge TO: The Judicial Nomination Commission Please consider this message as my endorsement of Ryan Alane Phelan for the post that Judge Karen Townsend is vacating in August. I know Ryan as a person of great integrity, professionalism, and sound temperament. Ryan conducts herself with confidence, poise, and thoughtful judgment. Given the opportunity, I will absolutely vote for her in November. Ryan has been a practicing attorney for nearly two decades. She has done this while balancing her work life with raising her children to be successful in life and respectful of others. My daughter, Megan Williams, did an internship in the office of Mars Scott while she was going to law school. During that time, Ryan mentored Megan and was a great role model for Megan. If you are looking for someone who is thoughtful, fair, and calm under pressure, Ryan is an excellent choice. I hope you will interview her and decide for yourselves that she is fully capable of handling this important position. Sincerely, Vickie Mikelsons 410 Brooks St Missoula, MT 59801

4

Cook, Kevin


From: JC Done <[email protected]> Sent: Thursday, June 20, 2019 2:14 PM To: [email protected] Subject: Ryan A Phelan Letter of Recommendation Dear Ms. Mendez, We would like to recommend Ryan A Phelan for the position of District Court Judge for the Montana Fourth Judicial District, Missoula and Mineral Counties. Having met her and knowing her family, we feel she would be a very fair judge and would dispense the law in a just manner. Sincerely, Jim and Coleen Done 406‐210‐5635

5

Cook, Kevin


From: Alissa Grimm <[email protected]> Sent: Thursday, June 20, 2019 1:11 PM To: [email protected] Subject: Ryan Phelan To Whom It May Concern: I’ve known Ryan Phelan since Kindergarten and I support her candidacy. Sincerely, Alissa Grimm, CPA

Alissa A. Grimm, CPA

JCCS

[email protected]

2620 Connery Way / Missoula, MT 59808 Office: (406) 549-4148 / Fax: (406) 549-3003 / Direct: (406) 542-8136 www.jccscpa.com

DISCLAIMER: The information in this message is confidential and may be legally privileged. It is intended solely for the addressee. Access to this message by anyone else is unauthorized. If you are not the intended recipient, any disclosure, copying, distribution or any action taken or omitted to be taken in reliance on it, is prohibited and may be unlawful. When addressed to our clients any opinions or advice contained in this email are subject to the terms and conditions expressed in the governing Junkermier, Clark, Campanella, Stevens P.C. client engagement letter. Please immediately contact the sender if you have received this message in error.

Patrick A. Quinn 2675 Palmer St. Ste C

Missoula MT 59808 406-329=5460

June 21, 2019 Judicial Nomination Commission c/o Lois Menzies Office of Court Administrator P.O. Box 203005 Helena, MT 59620 Sent via e-mail [email protected]

Dear Commissioners, I am writing in support of Ryan Phelan regarding her application for appointment to the Montana Fourth Judicial District. Ms. Phelan has been opposing counsel on many of my cases. Frequently these cases are complicated with issues of fact and law that have not been addressed in Montana. While Ms. Phelan is a fierce advocate, she remains cool headed and professional at all times. Her ability to analyze issues from every angle will serve the citizens of the Fourth Judicial District and the State of Montana well. There are very few attorneys I work with who can critically evaluate an issue, a case, or a statues as well as Ms. Phelan. Ms. Phelan has my enthusiastic support for appointment without reservation. She will be a great addition to the Fourth District Court. Sincerely, Patrick Quinn

mailto:[email protected]

1

Cook, Kevin


From: Julie Maloney [mailto:[email protected]] Sent: Friday, June 21, 2019 11:09 AM To: [email protected] Subject: Ryan Alane Phelan

To Whom It May Concern, I would like to submit my support for Ryan’s application to be a District Court Judge. I’ve known Ryan for a long time and know her dedication to our community. It is important that we have a judge who is experienced in family law, and in private practice, on the bench. With 40% of the cases filed in the 4th Judicial District Court being family law cases, and many more share the same elements as a family law case are items which Ryan has spent her professional career addressing. She has a wide variety of experience, from family law to serving as a mediator and guardian ad litem, to serving as the Substitute Justice of the Peace. Ryan’s passion is helping people to understand the impact their action have, and how they can better fit within our community, for the betterment of themselves, and the community. What better person to have on the bench than Ryan? If you’d like to visit with me more in regard to Ryan and her abilities to fulfil the role of the District Court Judge, please feel free to reach out to me. I can be reached directly at 406.542.4848 or on my cell at 406.531.4004. Thank you for your consideration of Ryan Phelan. Warmly, Julie

Julie Maloney Sales Coordinator, Morrison-Maierle Systems

406.542.4855 main | 406.542.4848 direct | 406.531.4004 mobile 1055 Mount Ave, Missoula, MT 59801

We know that referrals are one of the highest compliments a business can receive. If you know of someone who might benefit from our IT services, please let us know. Thank you!

1

Cook, Kevin


From: Patrick Montgomery <[email protected]> Sent: Monday, June 24, 2019 11:21 AM To: [email protected] Subject: District Court Judge appointment I live in Missoula and have been practicing in health care for nearly 40 years. During this tenure I have known Ryan Phelan and hold her in the highest regards both personally and professionally. Her professional reputation is top notch and I know she is compassionate and thoughtful in her practice of law. I highly recommend her appointment to this honorable position. Sincerely, Patrick R, Montgomery

2

Cook, Kevin


From: Mountain Flying LLC <[email protected]> Sent: Sunday, June 23, 2019 10:37 PM To: [email protected] Subject: Support Ryan Alane Phelan for District Court Judge Dear Sir or Madam, I support Ryan Alane Phelan for District Court Judge. Thank you for your time and consideration. Sincerely, Lori Imeson

3

Cook, Kevin


________________________________________ From: Rod Henning <[email protected]> Sent: Sunday, June 23, 2019 9:16 AM To: [email protected] Subject: District Court Judge, Missoula and Mineral Counties To: Judicial Nomination Committee I am pleased to write in support of Ryan Alane Phelan’s candidacy for District Court Judge for the Montana Fourth Judicial District, Missoula and Mineral Counties. I know Ryan to be a loving mother and wife, a serious and responsible citizen and a woman with genuine respect and concern for all people. Her extensive legal experience; reputation for fair minded, knowledgeable and well prepared approach to legal representation; family, civic and social activities in the community make me believe that Ryan would be a great asset to Missoula and Mineral Counties by serving as District Court Judge. Ms. Phelan would certainly have my vote for any public office she ran for and I hope she receives the Committee’ support for this Judgeship. Sincerely, Rod A Henning Sent from my iPad

4

Cook, Kevin


From: sari hettick <[email protected]> Sent: Saturday, June 22, 2019 5:52 PM To: [email protected] Subject: District Court Judge applicant support Hello, My name is Sari Hettick, I am writing in support of Ryan Alane Phelan in her application to be a District Court Judge. Her experience in family law would be a great addition. Thank you, Sari Hettick

5

Cook, Kevin


From: Robin Troy <[email protected]> Sent: Saturday, June 22, 2019 5:16 PM To: [email protected] Subject: Letter of Support for Ryan Phelan for District Court Judge (Missoula and Mineral Counties) 22 June 2019

Dear Judicial Nomination Commission:

I am writing on behalf of attorney Ryan Phelan, to recommend her very highly to replace Judge Karen Townsend as District Court Judge for Missoula and Mineral Counties. Ryan has represented me for the past five years,navigating my family-law issues heroically. I can honestly say that the work Ryan has done on my behalf haschanged my life, and my children’s. Her professionalism, humanity, expertise and impeccable attention to detailhave secured a happy, healthy, safe future for my family. It is hard to find the words to capture the value of whatRyan has done for us, but my experience with her gives me supreme confidence in her qualifications to be DistrictCourt Judge. I recommend her to you without hesitation.

At P. Mars Scott, Ryan has worked with a team of lawyers, paralegals and a family counselor on my case. In myyears with Ryan, I have witnessed not just her extreme competence as an attorney, but also her natural ability towork with others, and to lead a team. She very obviously has the respect of her colleagues, and together her teamhas an easy camaraderie that always puts me at ease. Ryan has the enviable ability to be a tough, no-nonsense lawyer who doesn’t miss a trick, while also bringing a relatable humanity to her work. With Ryan, you have nodoubt that she is paying attention to the specifics of your life, and your case, meticulously. I never had the sense that she was too busy. I never felt lumped into any “category” of cases—I always knew that she was consideringthe specifics of my life with care and experience. I’m repeating myself now intentionally: Ryan’s blend ofprofessionalism and humanity is remarkable.

I have also been with Ryan in the court room, and I can attest to her crisp, focused, thorough presentation beforemultiple judges. Ryan appears unflappable even in contentious situations. She also has a keen sense of what toexpect from a given hearing, and is always agile, succinct and respectful. Again, I always felt at ease because Iknew that Ryan was ready, and I could see that she is well-respected by her legal community.

I have said to Ryan that the thing about practicing family law is that she is catching most of us clients in some ofthe lousiest moments of our lives—not exactly seeing the best of any of us. And yet, she is always steady,evenhanded, and ready to smile. I’ve never seen her ruffled. I’ve managed to have lighthearted conversation withRyan even on the hardest days. To me, this is a sign that Ryan truly loves her work—that she is unfazed by adversity, and that she can see through a person’s messiest moments to forge a fair, clear path for him or her. Ithink Ryan’s character is absolutely suited to the work she would face as District Court Judge, and I can see herthriving in this position.

6

I feel lucky to call Missoula home. We live in a pretty magical community. I believe Ryan would represent thiscommunity with integrity and grace, and I think we would all be lucky to have her working for our community inthis capacity.

Thank you for your time with my letter.

Sincerely,

Robin Troy

7

Cook, Kevin


From: Marcia Booth <[email protected]> Sent: Saturday, June 22, 2019 10:12 AM To: [email protected] Subject: suport for Ryan Alana Phelm Montana Judicial Nomination Commission Ryan is an excellent choice for District Judge. As an attorney she is bringing expert knowledge to the position. She is smart, compassionate and fair. Great qualifies for District Judge. Marcia Booth

8

Cook, Kevin


From: Robert Tobin <[email protected]> Sent: Friday, June 21, 2019 6:07 PM To: [email protected] Subject: Ryan Phelan for district court judge I am a friend of Ryan’s and have known her for several years. I do not work with her personably, but she is an outstanding person of judgement and character. Her work ethic is impeccable and impressive. I have no doubt that she would be a perfect and welcoming choice for the judicial district court judge position. I will vote for her. Daylene Tobin Sent from Mail for Windows 10

1

Cook, Kevin


________________________________________ From: [email protected] <[email protected]> Sent: Tuesday, June 25, 2019 12:02 PM To: [email protected] Subject: Phelan nomination I am writing to recommend Ryan Alane Phelan for the position of District Court Judge. I have known Ryan's family for over fifty years. She has a strong work ethic and has experience in family law, estates, business and property matters. She has also served as judge pro tem and is familiar with the workings of court . She is dedicated and principled and has excellent qualifications. We would be well served in having Ryan Phelan as a Judicial District Judge. Thank you. Kathleen B.Cunniff P.O. Box 1561 746 S Placid Lake Road Seeley Lake, MT. 59868 Sent from my iPhone

1

Cook, Kevin


From: [email protected] <[email protected]> Sent: Tuesday, June 25, 2019 8:29 AM To: '[email protected]' Subject: Letter of recommendation for Ryan Phelan for District Judge To the Judicial Nominating Committee: I am recommending Ryan Phelan as district court judge to replace Judge Karen Townsend. I have known Ryan's family for more than fifty years. She comes from a group of hard working, reputable Montanans, and certainly exemplifies these same traits. As a practicing family lawyer she is familiar with estate work, business matters and property disputes. She has provided litigants help in navigating the difficulties of judicial review. I know Ryan has the background necessary to handle the duties of district judge for Missoula and Mineral counties. Thank you. Jeff Cunniff 746 South Placid Lake Road Seeley Lake, MT 59868

2

Cook, Kevin


________________________________________ From: David Jasnicki <[email protected]> Sent: Monday, June 24, 2019 11:51 PM To: [email protected] Subject: Judicial Nominations I would like to support Ryan Alane Phelan to be considered for the position of District Court Judge. My knowledge of her character stems mostly from knowing her father, Steve Harrington, for the last 14 years. Steve was a single Dad and the pride and love he has for his daughter and grandchildren is very evident. What I am trying to express is the importance of family values is something Steve has passed on to his daughter. I have met Ryan on several occasions and as first impressions go you can see the obvious family harmony between the parents and their children. I believe Ryan would be an excellent choice as someone who can truly relate and empathize with family matters. Regards, David Jasnicki Sent from my iPhone

3

Cook, Kevin


________________________________________ From: Chad Carman <[email protected]> Sent: Monday, June 24, 2019 9:36 PM To: [email protected] Subject: Ryan Phelan ‐ District Court judge My name is Chad Carman and I am a voter in Missoula County. Ryan Phelan has my support for the appointment of District Court Judge. Thank you! Chad Carman

4

Cook, Kevin


From: Megan Mikelsons <[email protected]> Sent: Monday, June 24, 2019 9:31 PM To: [email protected] Subject: Fourth Judicial District Court Judgeship ‐ Ryan A. Phelan

Dear Judicial Nomination Committee,

It has come to my attention that Ryan A. Phelan has submitted her application for a District Court Judgeship position

within the Fourth Judicial District in Missoula county. Please consider this email as my full recommendation of Ryan for

that position; I can think of no one more qualified to replace Judge Karen Townsend upon retirement.

I have known Ryan for over twenty years in both a personal and professional capacity. Ryan's family is a Missoula family,

like my own, and our younger brothers grew up together. Ryan also served as my supervisor at the P. Mars Scott Law

Offices, P.C. where I interned during my first year of law school. In later years, while a close member of my family went

through a contentious divorce, Ryan was kind enough to offer guidance in a non-professional capacity; she made the

situation infinitely more manageable through her cool calm, empathy and intellect.

Ryan absolutely satisfies each requirement set forth on the list which illustrates how the judicial candidates will be

assessed...to include meeting the minimum district court judge qualifications, electability in Missoula and Mineral counties,

depth and breath of legal experience, temperament and significant community support.

As an Equity Partner at her law firm, an Arbitrator on the FINRA Dispute Resolution Panel, and with years of successful

trial work under her belt, Ryan has proven dedication to her work and professional life, and is a highly regarded, reputable

family law practitioner. Further, as an active volunteer for programs such as MISMO Gymnastics, the Ranch Club and the

Missoula Children's Theater, Ryan's outreach throughout the Missoula community in a non-attorney capacity has also

been significant; she has created a competent, stable and empathetic reputation for herself. As a community member

who has worked with Ryan in both a non-professional and professional setting, I can personally attest to the fact that

Ryan demonstrates sound judgment and calm reasoning.

To conclude, as a Missoula voter, an attorney, and someone who has known Ryan personally for years, I absolutely offer

my full recommendation of Ryan A. Phelan for the District Court Judgeship. She has my vote.

Thank you for time and consideration.

Sincerely,

Megan C. Williams

5

Cook, Kevin


From: Katie Lyon <[email protected]> Sent: Monday, June 24, 2019 8:44 PM To: [email protected] Subject: Support Ryan Phelam I support the appointment Ryan Phelam for distric court judge. I live in Missoula and would vote her hands down. Katie Cusker ‐‐

Katie Lyon

6

Cook, Kevin


________________________________________ From: Madison McCarthy <[email protected]> Sent: Monday, June 24, 2019 8:44 PM To: [email protected] Subject: Support Ryan Phelan Hello, My name is Madison McCarthy. I am a registered voter in Missoula County. I support Ryan Phelan in the run for district court judge. She is a voter in Missoula County, she is active in her community, and she cares about our city. She is a great candidate for the job. Thanks, Madison

7

Cook, Kevin


________________________________________ From: Morgan McCarthy <[email protected]> Sent: Monday, June 24, 2019 8:42 PM To: [email protected] Subject: Support Ryan Phelam I support Ryan Phaelam for district court judge. I am a voter in Missoula Montana. She has my vote! Morgan McCarthy

8

Cook, Kevin


________________________________________ From: Jamie <[email protected]> Sent: Monday, June 24, 2019 7:49 PM To: [email protected] Subject: Support Ryan Phelan To Whom It May Concern: I support Ryan Phelan for District Court Judge. I am a long‐time Missoula Resident. Jamie Daniel Sent from my iPhone

TO: Judicial Nomination Commissionc/o Lois MenziesOffice of the Court AdministratorPO box 203005Helena, MT59620-3005

FROM: Mary and Max Oelschlaeger3019 Rustler Dr.Missoula, MT 59808

We have reviewed the materials detailing the education, legal experienceand other qualifications of Ryan Alane Phelan (found at:https://courts.mt.gov/Portals/189/supreme/boards/jud_nomination/4th/apps/phelan.pdf). Ms. Phelan has submitted her name in application to replaceJudge Karen Townsend upon the latter’s retirement.

Ms. Phelan is a fellow resident in our Ranch Club neighborhood, located onthe west side of Missoula, MT. We have known her for several years (sinceour retirement as university professors), primarily through club relatedactivities. Our interactions with her have been casual and recreational ratherthan formal, legal and/or commercial. On occasion we have discussedpolitical and economic issues affecting Montanans and American citizensgenerally. Our viewpoints are largely congruent.

We believe Ms. Phelan deserves serious consideration for appointment forseveral reasons, some obvious, and some perhaps not so obvious. Based onher credentials, she is unquestionably qualified in a complete professionalsense. Based on our her interactions with us and other members of ourcommunity, we are confident that she has an ideal judicial temperament.We’re also confident, given the demonstrated electoral preferences ofMontana County citizens, that she is electable.

Less obvious are two other facts. Given that approximately forty percent ofthe District Court caseload involves family law, and given Ms. Phelan’s legalpractice (including her work in court, with other attorneys, and with involvedfamilies), we believe that she would be a valuable addition to the FourthDistrict Court. We also believe that she is a member of a cohort that willbring a fresh generational perspective to the court.

Respectfully submitted,Mary Oelschlaeger, Ph.D.Max Oelschlaeger, Ph.D.

Cindy Miller, Ph.d. 129 W. Kent Ave., Missoula, mt 59801 406-542-7365

June 26, 2019

Judicial Nomination Committee C/O Lois Menzies Office of the Court Administrator P.O. Box 203005 Helena, MT 59620-3005 [email protected] RE: Recommendation for Ryan Alane Phelan for 4th Judicial District Court Judge Dear Commission: I am writing this letter to support the application and nomination of Ryan Alane Phelan for 4th Judicial District Court Judge. As a therapist, evaluator and expert witness, I have had the opportunity to work with Ms. Phelan on many occasions and have always been very impressed with her ability to balance representing her client with understanding the best interest of the child. She is very adept at communicating with clients, other attorneys and professionals in the community in a personable yet professional manner. In my many years of working as a psychologist in Missoula I have never heard anyone speak disparagingly about Ms. Phelan. She enjoys an excellent reputation community-wide.

I also had the opportunity to work on a committee with Ms. Phelan and other attorneys to edit the 4th Judicial District Guidelines. She naturally took on a leadership role while collaborating extremely well with others on the committee. I was struck by her ability to quickly grasp others’ ideas, consolidate them, and craft them into concise language, as she voluntarily served as our scribe.

In summary, I whole-heartedly support Ryan Phelan for a position as a 4th Judicial District Court Judge.

Sincerely,

Cindy Miller, Ph.D. Clinical Psychologist

1

Cook, Kevin

From: Menzies, LoisSent: Wednesday, June 26, 2019 3:27 PMTo: Cook, KevinSubject: Public Comment -- Phelan

From: Melissa Lentz <[email protected]> Sent: Wednesday, June 26, 2019 1:18 PM To: [email protected] Subject: Public Comment ‐‐ Phelan To whom it may concern, I am writing this letter to support the application and nomination of Ryan Phelan as District Court Judge for Missoula County. I have had the privilege of working with Ryan for several years. In addition to working with Ryan professionally, I also gained a friendship with her. Ryan is a genuine, kind, and caring person with a great passion for the law. Ryan has supported the Missoula community in a multitude of ways, whether that be by volunteering her time or supporting community efforts financially. Serving her community has been the upmost of importance to her. Ryan would bring strong legal expertise to this position, more importantly, she has strong motivation and work ethic. Her passion for serving would bring enthusiasm and dedication to this position. Ryan’s command of the law and language makes her a confident and formidable presence in court. One of her other strengths is being a realistic advocate for her clients, working to find the best, most feasible solution to their cases. Ryan’s sense of fairness and her ability to analyze and problem solve means she can find best fit solutions to complex problems while upholding the integrity of the law. With Ryan’s experience in family law as well as her work as a substitute Justice of the Peace for Missoula Justice Court, I believe Ryan would make an exceptional Judge for this community. I would, without a doubt, vote for Ryan Phelan as the next Fourth Judicial District Court Judge. Sincerely, Melissa Lentz

2

Cook, Kevin


From: Candace Gama <[email protected]>

Sent: Tuesday, June 25, 2019 9:33 PM

To: [email protected]

Subject: Ryan Phelan

Dear Judicial Nomination Commission, I am writing in support of Ryan Alane Phelan, Esq. for appointment as a district court judge. I first met Ryan 14 years ago at St Francis Xavier church in Missoula. I have had the pleasure of knowing her very well both personally and professionally. I have had the opportunity to witness her over all of these years in many different situations. She always handles difficult professional situations with grace and poise. She has many times been my technology tutor, because of her willingness to help others. Ryan is absolutely brilliant, knowledgeable about everything from current events, to social activities going on in our community. She is known and respected throughout the community for her work in family law, but she has also helped my family with real property issues, and estate planning. This is why I know her legal skill set is so versatile. Ryan is very active in our community from her work with MCT to helping her children’s friends in their athletic endeavours. Many evenings when I reach out to Ryan she is attending a board meeting or community event. Her willingness to serve her community and engage with people from a variety of backgrounds, has won her many supporters, and makes me confident that she is very electable in the 4th judicial district. Ryan is unflappably ethical, always making sure she stays above the fray of emotions her clients are feeling, yet is always empathetic to them. In selecting a replacement for Judge Karen Townsend I urge the Commission and the Governor to consider appointing someone with a not only a strong and diverse legal background, as well as a solid history of engagement with the community, but also an impeccable reputation. I strongly believe that Ryan Phelan is all of these things, and more.

Candace Gama DDS

‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐ This message, and any attachments to it, may contain information that is privileged, confidential, and exempt from disclosure under applicable law. If the reader of this message is not the intended recipient, you are notified that any use, dissemination, distribution, copying, or communication of this message is strictly prohibited. If you have received this message in error, please notify the sender immediately by return e‐mail and delete the message and any attachments. Thank you.

3

Cook, Kevin


________________________________________ From: Jack Chambers <[email protected]> Sent: Tuesday, June 25, 2019 2:39 PM To: [email protected] Subject: Letter of Support for Ryan Phelan for District Court Judge Judicial Nomination Commission: My wife and I are writing a letter of support for Ryan Phelan in her application to be appointed a District Court Judge. We were next door neighbors of Ryan and her young family for well over a decade. We couldn’t have asked for better neighbors. Watching as they grew their family by two children was inspiring as Ryan and her husband Terry juggled work and family. We know this is not a job reference but you can tell a lot about a person over a neighbors’ fence. What we do know is that Ryan is a very responsible, dependable and honest. You can also tell a lot about a person by observing how they raise their children. Ryan is very calm, consistent and fair in her role as a parent. Before our retirement, my wife and I both dealt with the court system. My wife as a DDP case manager and my self as a CEO of a large nonprofit serving adults with disabilities. We both agree that Ryan’s personal characteristics would be an attribute to the District Court Bench. She listens, she is fair and she honest. Please feel free to contact us with further questions. Again we wholeheartedly recommend Ryan Plelan for your consideration. Thank you for your time. Sincerely, Jack and Bonnie Chambers 3208 Paul Lane Missoula, MT 59803 (406)207‐6065 Sent from my iPad

4

Cook, Kevin


From: Robert Farrington <[email protected]> Sent: Tuesday, June 25, 2019 2:36 PM To: [email protected] Subject: Letter of support (Ryan Phelan) To: Judicial Nomination Commission, I am writing this letter to you in support of Mrs. Ryan Phelan to be considered for the position of District Court Judge. I have known Mrs. Phelan since 2004 and since the day we met, she has been focused on the law and how best to serve it. Mrs. Phelan is a dedicated attorney and an excellent mother. She has a strong family and is well rooted in Missoula. I can not speak to whether Mrs. Phelan meets the minimum qualifications but I believe she is highly electable in the Missoula and Mineral counties, has the depth of legal experience to serve well in this capacity, has the judicial temperament necessary and with her family being spread through Missoula county she will receive strong community support. I was fortunate enough to receive legal guidance from Mrs. Phelan regarding trademark issues for my Montana based business which helped me avoid legal expense. After my experience with Mrs. Phelan in a professional capacity, I have no hesitation in supporting her for the position of District Court Judge. Kind regards, Robert Farrington President & CEO. The StrapSmith Inc. 406‐212‐1026

5

Cook, Kevin


From: Brenda Allington <[email protected]> Sent: Tuesday, June 25, 2019 2:08 PM To: [email protected] Subject: Recommendation for Ryan Alane Phelan Dear Members of the Judicial Nomination Commission: At a time when our country is marred by a lack of civility, accountability, integrity, and honorability, it would be refreshing to see an experienced, capable, ethical attorney appointed to the Missoula District Court. For that reason, I am writing to endorse Ryan Phelan's pursuit of that position. Having a principled, hardworking woman, who has proven herself as an attorney in handling challenging cases without losing her perspective of humanity, would be an asset to all involved in the work of justice. It is time that politics, gender discrimination, and the "who you know system" of appointing less qualified individuals be subjugated to the past‐‐ never again to be resurrected. Ms. Phelan has my unequivocal support, as well as my hope that she can once again shine light on Lady Justice and the values she represents. I believe she can once again be the beacon of our judicial system with individuals such as Ms. Phelan to lead the way. Thank you for your kind consideration. Brenda M. (DeGrazio) Allington 326 Bullrun Road Florence, MT 59833 (406)‐546‐4769

6

Cook, Kevin


From: Kelly Bigelow <[email protected]> Sent: Wednesday, June 26, 2019 2:24 PM To: [email protected] Subject: Letter in support of Ryan Phelan for District Court Judge

CAUTION:Thisemailmessagemaycontainanunsafeattachment. WescanemailattachmentsformalicioussoftwaretoprotectyourcomputerandtheState'snetwork.Ifwedeterminethatanattachmentisunsafe,thenweblockitandyouwillonlyseeanattachmentcalled'UnsupportedFileTypesAlert.txt'.Ifwecannotscananattachment,thenweprovidethiswarningthattheattachmentmaybeunsafeandadviseyoutoverifythesenderbeforeopeningtheattachment.Ifyoudon'tseeafileattachedtothismessage,itdoesn'tmeanthatweblockedit,someemailsignaturescontainimagefilesthatwecannotscan.PleasecontactyouragencyITstaffformoreinformation.

Dear Judicial Nomination Commission, I am writing in support of Ryan Phelan for District Court Judge of the 4th Judicial Court, and that you strongly consider her for this position. Ryan’s qualifications for this position are exemplary of any judge currently sitting on the 4th Judicial Court. Moreover, with more that 40% of the cases in the 4th Judicial Court being cases dealing with family law, Ryan’s extensive years of family law practice give her an even more level view of the law. The seat which is left open come August of this year is that of Karen Townsend. Having been a casualty of divorce myself, Karen was my judge. Not that my case was any more hard than others, I found that Judge Townsend always was fair, balanced, and sided on what the law is, in a reasonable and professional manner. With this high level of power, Ryan Phelan is balanced, fair, and reasonable. Her current record as a justice of the peace should also be heavily weighted in her run for this position in my opinion. Although I have not seen any of these cases being tried personally, I know you will find fairness and balance in her judgement. I have personally known Ryan for over five years as our daughters have been school friends since kindergarten at St. Joseph’s school in Missoula. Having known her personally, and even worked for her firm professionally, she has always exuded professionalism at the highest level to myself and the colleagues I have brought to work with her and her firm. Ryan strives for excellence in herself, her colleagues, supports them, her family and friends, volunteers in our community and is an outstanding civic servant to our city. So I am asking that you please strongly consider Ryan Phelan for the 4th Judicial Court. Sincerely, Kelly Bigelow Brand Edge Marketing Group Brand/Creative Marketing Strategist 406.258.0258 P 406.396.4121 C

7

Confidentiality Notice: This email and its attachments (if any) contain confidential information of the sender. The information is intended only for the use by the direct addressees of the original sender of this email. If you are not an intended recipient of the original sender (or responsible for delivering the message to such person), you are hereby notified that any review, disclosure, copying, distribution or the taking of any action in reliance of the contents of and attachments to this email is strictly prohibited. If you have received this email in error, please immediately notify the sender at the address shown herein and permanently delete any copies of this email (digital or paper) in your possession.

1

Cook, Kevin

From: Menzies, LoisSent: Thursday, June 27, 2019 8:24 AMTo: Cook, KevinSubject: Public Comment -- Phelan

From: Russell Holman <[email protected]> Sent: Thursday, June 27, 2019 6:08 AM To: [email protected] Subject: District Court Candidate Appointment – Ryan Phelan To Whom It May Concern, I am writing this letter in support of the appointment of Ryan Phelan for the position of District Court Judge in the 4th Judicial District. She is an exceptional candidate for this position due to her unique experience as both a private practice attorney focused primarily on family law (but not exclusively) and as a trained arbitrator. I believe her rich experiences regarding family law is exactly why she is a great candidate. However, even if it is not a family law case, many cases including mental health issues and business valuations share similar components where a family law background along with arbitration training are instrumental in finding the most lawful outcome.

Ryan is a champion for accountability and serving the truth. Her passion for helping individuals find their way through tough situations while understanding the impact and how their actions affect themselves, their friends, family and community is what drives her the most. The betterment of the community motivates her to search for the truth while also being efficient, compassionate, responsive, and effective.

We have known Ryan for 13 years and her husband for 35 years. Ryan is a devoted family woman who loves her family deeply. She and Terry have created a safe and comfortable home for their two children where their goals are to raise kind, conscientious, motivated, empathetic children who love life and want to serve their community. I believe Ryan will bring the same devotion, intelligence, and desire to do good to the District Court.

I hold Ryan Phelan in the highest of regards and highly recommend her as a candidate for the position of District Court Judge. Her experience and dedication will serve her community and the position very well.

Sincerely,

Russell L. Holman

32 Tiger Gulch

Clancy, MT 59634

406‐439‐1264

2

Cook, Kevin


________________________________________ From: Zak Mercer <[email protected]> Sent: Thursday, June 27, 2019 6:06 AM To: [email protected] Subject: Ryan Phelan for district court judge, 4th district If nominated, I will support & give my vote to Ryan Phelan for District Court Judge. Thanks, Zak Mercer 11875 Obrien Ck Rd Missoula, MT 59804

3

Cook, Kevin


From: Natalie Marx <[email protected]> Sent: Thursday, June 27, 2019 2:36 AM To: [email protected] Subject: Ryan A. Phelen Letter of Recommendation Dear Ms. Menzies, Please accept this email as a recommendation for Ryan A. Phelan, an applicant for selection to the position of District Court Judge for the Montana Fourth Judicial District, Missoula and Mineral Counties. I am a family friend and have know Ryan since she was a small child. As a long term member of this community I realize the importance of this position to families in these communities, depend on an experienced, ethical, hard-working judge Ryan's experience over the past 18 years in family law would lend itself to her success in this position, Her experience as judge pro tem for Justice of the peace Marie Anderson also supports her knowledge of the court system. Based on these experiences, she would be both fair and equal in applying the law to both sides. If Ryan is chosen to complete Judge Townsends term, I will support her in the upcoming election in November 2020. Thank you for considering Ryan Phelan. If you have any questions, feel free to contact me at [email protected] or 406 360-6399. Sincerely, Natalie Marx

4

Cook, Kevin


From: Michael McGill <[email protected]> Sent: Wednesday, June 26, 2019 4:27 PM To: [email protected] Subject: Support for Ryan Phelan Judicial Nomination Commission, I am Michael McGill, Executive Director of MCT Inc. (Missoula Children’s Theatre) and I would like to voice my support for Ryan Phelan for judge. Ryan serves on our board of directors giving of her time to the betterment of our non‐profit and our community. I like the fact that she has been practicing family law and would be a valuable resource to the court. I would vote for Ms. Phelan if on the ballot. Sincerely, Michael McGill 1760 Mullan Trail Missoula, MT 59808

5

Cook, Kevin


From: Dave Rieker <[email protected]> Sent: Wednesday, June 26, 2019 9:19 AM To: [email protected] Subject: The nomination of Ryan Alane Phelan for the fulfillment of Karen Townsend’ s term My name is David Rieker , I am a life long resident of Missoula. Educated and Work as labor and Business to Retirement. I am writing in support of Ryan as a person raised with Montana Values of Integrity, Independence, Confidence and Respect. A hard working individual that has chosen to stay in Montana and contribute to the betterment of our community. I respect , and am proud to witness her growth and contributions to our community and believe she has the support of a large spectrum of our community, She Will Get my support and vote ! Thank you for consideration David Rieker 3945 Trails End Rd Msla,Mt 59803

Kathleen Kaiser 122 Tahoe Drive Missoula, MT.59803 June 26, 2019 Judicial Nomination Commission c/o Lois Menzies Office of Court Administrator P.O. Box 203005 Helena, MT. 59620-3005 Re: Ryan A. Phelan Letter of Recommendation Montana District Court Applicant Dear Ms. Menzies, I am writing to offer a recommendation for the selection of Ryan A. Phelan to the position of District Court Judge for the Montana Fourth district Missoula and Mineral Counties. I am a graduate of the University of Montana with B.A. and M.A. in Elementary Education. I was an educator in the Deer Lodge School system for three years and the Clinton Elementary school system for thirty-two years. I am a Missoula resident who votes in every election and I am very aware of local and national issues. I have known Ryan since she was a young girl. My Mom was a nanny to Ryan and her brother John. Ryan and John became my Mom’s second family. Ryan is a very accomplished attorney in family law. She has practiced family law for eighteen years in Missoula, MT. In addition to family law Ryan’s practice also includes estates, real property and business matters. Through her private practice Ryan has developed skills that will aid her in making difficult decisions that one has to make as a judge. I fully support Ryan A. Phelan as an appointment for District Court Judge and look forward to voting to elect her to the position in 2020. Thank you for considering Ryan A. Phelan. Please feel free to contact me at [email protected]. or 406-251-3704 for additional information. Sincerely, Kathleen Kaiser

mailto:[email protected]

1

Cook, Kevin


From: josie tomich <[email protected]> Sent: Thursday, June 27, 2019 9:26 PM To: [email protected] Subject: Ryan Alane Phelan for district court judge for the 4th Judicial District To whom it may concern: I am writing in support of the appointment of Ryan Alane Phelan as the next District Court Judge for the Fourth Judicial District Court, Missoula County. Ryan exceeds the qualifications for appointment, including being electable in Missoula County, having the depth and breadth of legal experience, having the appropriate judicial temperament and having support in the community. I have witnessed these qualities in person for more than a decade. I first met Ryan in August of 2004 when I was hired as the receptionist for P. Mars Scott Law Offices where Ryan was an attorney with the firm. A year later, I was promoted to a paralegal; the position I retained for the next 9 years. At one point, I was even Ryan's paralegal. I have worked closely with Ryan on a variety of family law matters, including simple, collaborative divorces, parties with parenting issues, clients with sensitive needs, and cases that have been appealed to the Montana Supreme Court. We have worked long hours together, including evenings and weekends, with and without our respective children present, to prepare for cases and meet with clients. During this time, Ryan has always been extremely professional and portrayed a depth of legal knowledge and acumen. One occasion, in particular, comes time mind. I had filled in for doing the mail and running errands. When I finally got back to the office long after 5 o'clock, I overheard Ryan on the phone with a client. The client was in crisis about a parenting issue. While I finished my duties, Ryan remained on the phone with the client providing legal advice, professionalism, and a case-specific legal plan of action. When Ryan finished the call, the client was satisfied with her representation and never knew that Ryan had to rearrange her plans for the evening. Ryan has always been considerate and acted appropriately to everyone, no matter the position of the person, from runner to receptionist to senior attorney to colleagues in the community, as well as clients. She treats everyone fairly and kindly. I have witnessed this first hand during many client and colleague meetings, as well as at settlement conferences and court hearings, where Ryan either acted as second chair or took the lead or handled it directly herself. Settlement conferences require a lot of time and concentration before with preparation of settlement statements, during, and after preparing for entry of decree or trial. Not only that, they are stressful for clients. Ryan handled the stress of settlement conferences with aplomb. While at one particular settlement conference, the client was emotionally triggered by his spouse requesting certain personal

2

property that she knew he wanted. The client became upset and Ryan calmly asked the settlement master for time to discuss the offer with her client. After the settlement master left the room, Ryan discussed the legal and emotional pros and cons of the offer, various outcomes, and the client's ultimate goals. In the end, a settlement was reached to the client's satisfaction. This is just one of many professional interactions with Ryan, but we have also interacted on a friendly basis. When I first met Ryan, she had just started dating her now husband. I was at her wedding, subsequent baby showers, and personal parties. While I left the firm to move out of state almost 5 years ago, we have continued to grow our friendship. Through all of these personal changes in life, Ryan has continued to grow and develop and handle what life has given her with grace and professionalism. Ryan has also kept on track with her professional development. Ryan has a thirst for knowledge and developing her skills in all aspects of the legal field. She has spent many hours obtaining her CLEs and preparing for presentations that she is attending or presenting herself. She is also willing to share her knowledge, as well as being receptive to new ideas and differing opinions. There are too many qualities that Ryan possesses to be expounded in a simple letter of support. Ryan meets all of the minimum requirements for a district court judge, but, most importantly, Ryan exceeds these requirements. That is Ryan Alane Phelan. Ryan will excel at anything she sets her mind to. Ryan may not be the only candidate for this position, but Ryan is the most qualified and will be the best District Court Judge for the Fourth Judicial District Court, Missoula County. If you should have any questions or would like any further information, please do not hesitate to contact me via email or by telephone at (406) 880-3449. Sincerely, Josie L. Tomich

3

Cook, Kevin


From: John Schulte <[email protected]> Sent: Thursday, June 27, 2019 5:24 PM To: [email protected] Subject: Ryan Phelan's application to be appointed fourth Judicial district Judge Attention: Lois Menzies Dear Judicial Nominating Commission: I am writing on behalf of Ryan Phelan. She has applied for the Fourth Judicial District Court judicial position that is open as a result of the retirement of Judge Karen Townsend. I have worked with Ryan for many years, mostly serving as a settlement master on her family law cases. I have always found her to be prepared and she presents a case in a position so that settlement may occur. She understands her clients and their needs. She is respectful of opposing counsel while being an excellent advocate for her clients. I believe that Ryan would make an excellent district court judge. Her ethics are above reproach. She has the right demeanor and good instincts. She is inherently fair minded. Her experience in family law would be a great asset to the Fourth Judicial District Court bench. Please send Ryan’s name to Governor Bullock so he may consider her as his next appointment to the Montana judiciary. Thank you for your consideration. Sincerely, John C. Schulte SCHULTE LAW FIRM P.C. 2425 Mullan Road Missoula, MT 59808 (406) 721-6655 (406) 543-5023 (fax) [email protected]

4

Cook, Kevin


From: Paul Heihn <[email protected]> Sent: Thursday, June 27, 2019 11:10 AM To: [email protected] Subject: Missoula County District Court Judge I am writing to you today to support Ryan Phelan for Missoula District Court Judge. I have worked with Ryan for more than 10 years. I have worked with many attorneys in both business and volunteer capacities. Ryan stands out amongst them with her professional and compassionate methods in dealing with the many cases we have worked on together. She has consistently worked to find the best solution that resolves issues to the best possible outcome for all parties, yet she can be strong in making decisions when required. In my volunteer capacities as a Court Appointed Special Advocate, I have appeared before many district court judges many times and have had sufficient interactions with the current holders of this position to have an understanding of the type of person it takes to be a District Court Judge. I believe that Ryan is the correct choice for Missoula District Court Judge. Paul Heihn President

The linked image cannot be displayed. The file may have been moved, renamed, or deleted. Verify that the link points to the correct file and location.

PO Box 2898 Missoula, MT 59808 406‐541‐3993 844‐541‐3993 406‐541‐3991 (fax) [email protected] www.nwcollectors.com

5

Cook, Kevin


From: george deaton <[email protected]> Sent: Thursday, June 27, 2019 9:43 PM To: [email protected] Subject: Email Recommendation (for Ryan to fulfill current term of retiring Judge Karen Townsend, and subsequent election) Judicial Nomination Commission c/o Lois Menzies Office of the Court Administrator P.O. Box 203005 Helena, MT 59620‐3005 Dear Members of Judicial Nomination Commission: This email is being sent in connection with our support of Ryan Alane Phelan, as she seeks to become nominated to fulfill the current term of District Court Judge Karen Townsend, whom we understand will soon be retiring. My husband, George, and I have known Ryan for many years, in more of a personal relationship, as we have had seats next to Ryan and her husband at Washington Grizzly Stadium for many years of cheering on the Grizzly football team. We have watched as they began bringing their children with them, initially as a baby and then toddler, to see their children grow older, and become involved in gymnastics or other sports. Ryan has always exhibited a calm demeanor, and genuine love and care for her husband and children, when we have seen them at those football games. Additionally, although I retired about a year and a half ago as a probate paralegal employed with the firm of Boone Karlberg, P.C. (employed there for just over 39 years at the time of my retirement), I was aware of Ryan being involved with attorneys in our firm in connection with family practice matters. I did not ever work directly with Ryan, but I was aware of the respect that she was regarded with by attorneys in our firm, in connection with the family practice matters she was working on with them. My husband, George, and I both feel Ryan Phelan would be an excellent choice to serve the remaining term of retiring Judge Karen Townsend, and we would vote for her in a subsequent election should she desire to run for the District Judge position (which we understand she would be interested in doing). We believe that her experience in her law practice, her work with family practice matters and other areas of law, prior experience of serving as judge pro tem (for Justice of the Peace Marie Anderson) and knowledge of Court procedures and statutory law of the State of Montana, together with her calm demeanor, would all serve her well in that position.

6

If you have any further questions, please don’t hesitate to call us at (406) 721‐1417, or send inquiry by email to: [email protected]. Thank you for considering Ryan Alane Phelan for this very important position. Sincerely, Sherry & George Deaton 2105 Nut Hatch Drive Missoula, MT 59808 (406) 721‐1417

7

Cook, Kevin


________________________________________ From: Connie Keogh <[email protected]> Sent: Thursday, June 27, 2019 10:14 PM To: [email protected] Subject: Ryan Phelan Appointment Judicial Nomination Commission, As a legislator representing HD 91 in Missoula, it has been my pleasure to work with Ryan Phelan on Family Law legislation. Ryan is thorough with her preparations and articluate in her presentation. Ryan is a concerned practioner of the law and very dedicated to improving Montana State Law to better support families and individuals through their legal issues. Through our legislative work, I was impressed with how knowlegable Ryan is about the court system and recognized the value she would bring to this appointment. I believe Ryan's background, temperment and experience make her well suited to serve as a District Court Judge. Thank you! Rep. Connie Keogh House District 91 Rattlesnake Valley, Downtown, and University area of Missoula 406‐298‐0985 [email protected] P.O. Box 7542 Missoula, MT 59807 https://gcc01.safelinks.protection.outlook.com/?url=http%3A%2F%2Fconniekeoghforhd91.com&data=02%7C01%7Cmtsupremecourt%40mt.gov%7Cf1ae43bc4d8549d67ff908d6fb7f209e%7C07a94c98f30f4abbbd7ed63f8720dc02%7C0%7C1%7C636972920759935224&sdata=AhaDJb5LF17xKOxAId%2Fswg431MApLHz8y0N4LwbaNYM%3D&reserved=0 Legislators are publicly elected officials. Legislator emails sent or received involving legislative business may be subject to the Right to Know provisions of the Montana Constitution and may be considered a "public record" pursuant to Montana law. As such, email, sent or received, its sender and receiver, and the email contents, may be subject to public disclosure, except as otherwise provided by Montana law.

1

Cook, Kevin

From: Menzies, LoisSent: Friday, June 28, 2019 11:29 AMTo: Cook, KevinSubject: Public Comment -- Phelan

From: Martin Beebe <[email protected]> Sent: Friday, June 28, 2019 10:37 AM To: [email protected] Subject: Recommended District Court Judge replacement for Judge Karen Tounsend To whom it may concern: Having known Ryan Phelan (Fairbanks) since she was a girl in Missoula, MT, I have been impressed with the accomplishments that she has made in school, relationships, life in general. I think Ryan's friendly, engaging personality is the reason for her support in the community and with all her friends. Ryan's almost 20 years of practicing family law gives her a close relationship with clients in their personal problems and a need to provide the most correct solution to their particular problems, a character trait, that I would want in a District Court Judge. If Ryan were candidate for Judge in our local elections, I would vote for her without reservation. Martin Beebe Registered voter in Missoula, MT. (Retired Carpenter at the University of Montana)

2

Cook, Kevin


From: Melisse Myers <[email protected]> Sent: Friday, June 28, 2019 9:44 AM To: [email protected] Subject: Ryan Phelan for District Court Judge To whom it may concern, I am writing to show my support for Ryan Phelan for District Court Judge in Missoula. I have personally known Ryan and her family for over 16 years. She is very professional in her nature and very well balanced in her life in all aspects. Ryan has a strong work ethic and takes pride in all that she does. She would make a wonderful judge and I hope you will consider her for the position. Thank You, Melisse Myers Parts Manager Anvil Attachments, Inc. Anvil Attachments, Inc. 261 Highway 19 Slaughter, LA 70777

3

Cook, Kevin


From: Karen <[email protected]> Sent: Thursday, June 27, 2019 10:49 PM To: [email protected] Subject: Letter of public comment in support of Ryan Phelan June 27, 2019 To the Montana Judicial Nomination Committee: Please consider this letter of support for Ryan Phelan as a candidate for District Court judge. Ryan and her family moved into my neighborhood a few years ago, and I am very happy to have gotten to know her through golfing together in the Ranch Club Monday ladies league and through other neighborhood activities. She is a dependable friend and pleasure to be around. Ryan has the perfect combination of appropriate work experience, legal knowledge, community involvement and youthful enthusiasm to be an exceptional judge. Her sense of fairness, level‐headed temperament and emotional intelligence are evident not only in her professional life but also are present when disciplining her children, playing golf with all types of interesting personalities and reacting with friends and neighbors. I admire her desire to serve the community through her work with the Missoula Children’s Theater and her work with the Gymnastics Booster club. As voters in the 4th Judicial District, my husband and I would definitely support Ryan in future elections, knowing she is highly qualified to excel in the position of District Court judge. Thank you for the opportunity to comment on this appointment. Karen Shelly Montana Urban Forestry Inventory Coordinator and Good Neighbor Authority Botanist Forestry Assistance Bureau Montana Department of Natural Resources and Conservation 8718 Mashie Lane Missoula, Montana 59808 406‐550‐1221

1

Cook, Kevin


From: LINDA LENNOX <[email protected]> Sent: Friday, June 28, 2019 3:51 PM To: [email protected] Subject: Judicial Nomination Commission RE: Ryan Alane Phelan: I have known Ryan Phelan for many years. I have been on the MCT, Inc. Board of Directors for over 30 years and I was so pleased when Ryan joined the board in 2015. Ryan is the chair of the Personnel Committee. She has the ability to maintain confidentiality which is very important. She has an even temperament and has proved to be very good at resolving issues with the Company. Ryan is very community minded and keeps informed of community events and projects. Ryan has a background as a private practice attorney, she has expertise in family law and is familiar with the inner workings of the court. These are just a few of her qualities. I would like to recommend Ryan Alane Phelan for appointment as District Court Judge in the 4th Judicial District (Missoula and Mineral counties) when Judge Karen Townsend retires in August of this year. Sincerely yours, Linda M. Lennox 537 Woodford Street Missoula, MT 59801‐4040

2

Cook, Kevin


From: Malori Strang <[email protected]> Sent: Friday, June 28, 2019 3:49 PM To: [email protected] Subject: Support letter for Ryan A. Phelan To Whom It May Concern: I am writing to support Ryan Phelan’s application for District Court Judge. I grew up in Superior, which is in Mineral County, where my parents continue to reside. I have worked as a paralegal in the Missoula legal community for nine years, and had the opportunity to work with Ryan at P. Mars Scott Law Offices for 2 of those years. I have also worked cases on the opposing side from Ryan. Ryan continues to stand out as someone whose dedication to their practice is unmatched. Ryan does not do things half-heartedly. Her insight and depth of understanding on issues of law continually impresses me. As a young attorney with ample experience, Ryan is a perfect candidate for the Fourth Judicial District. Her enthusiasm is refreshing. Since submitting her application, Ryan has made a point to speak with colleagues who practice in all areas of the law and discuss concerns that members of the community may have.

I feel lucky to have had Ryan as a mentor and have no doubt that she could make a positive impact if chosen for the position. I know that this position will require the person appointed to run for election in 2020, and also in 2022. Ryan has a strong support network in and around Missoula, and also in Mineral County. I believe she has the energy and support to be successful in an election. As a member of the community, and a voter, I would certainly support Ryan in a bid for reelection. Sincerely, Malori Metzger

3

Cook, Kevin


From: Casey L Erickson <[email protected]> Sent: Friday, June 28, 2019 3:41 PM To: [email protected] Subject: Ryan Phelan for 4th Judicial District Judge Good Afternoon, My name is Casey Erickson and I am a registered voter in Missoula, MT. I am writing to let you know of my support for the appointment of Ryan Phelan as 4th Judicial District Judge. I have known Ryan and her family for several years and believe that she has the temperament, compassion, and experience required to serve our community wisely. I will also vote for Ryan to serve in this position in the next election. Thank you for your time. Casey L Erickson 520 Ford St Missoula, MT 59801 406-241-8017

1

Cook, Kevin


From: dennis cromwell <[email protected]> Sent: Saturday, June 29, 2019 4:19 PM To: MT Supreme Court, Subject: Lois Menzies/ Tracy Rhodes judgeship I am writing to give Tracy labin Rhodes a refference to be a judge she represented me in two cases one was a DN Case and one was a Dr case she worked pro Bono on the Dr case she fought hard and expressed to the district Court judge that his version of the law was wrong and she was right she appealed both cases and in a en banc decision reversed both cases in my favor she is ethical smart very aware of the laws compassionate even tempered woman she would make a very good judge pleae give her the opportunity to show you the people of the 4th district will thank you Sincerely, Dennis Cromwell

2

Cook, Kevin


________________________________________ From: Courtney Kellum <[email protected]> Sent: Saturday, June 29, 2019 4:10 PM To: [email protected] Subject: Ryan Phelan Hello, I am writing to advocate for Ryan Phelan for District Court Judge. I met Ryan in college and know she is an outstanding woman and lawyer. I believe she would be an excellent and fair judge. Thank you Courtney Kellum

3

Cook, Kevin


From: Kelsey Booth <[email protected]> Sent: Saturday, June 29, 2019 2:27 PM To: [email protected] Subject: Ryan Phelan ‐ District Court Judge I have known Ryan for many years and I feel she would be a wonderful fit for the district court judge. Kelsey Booth

Get Outlook for Android The information transmitted is intended only for the person or entity to which it is addressed and may contain confidential and/or privileged material. Any review, retransmission, dissemination or other use of, or taking of any action in reliance upon this information by persons or entities other than the intended recipient is prohibited. If you received this in error, please contact the sender and delete the material from any computer.

4

Cook, Kevin


From: Deborah Place <[email protected]> Sent: Saturday, June 29, 2019 2:19 PM To: [email protected] Subject: Ryan Alane Phelan for District Court Judge in Missoula I have known Ryan and her family for thirty years, she is an excellent candidate for the District Court Judge in Missoula. Respectfully, Deborah W. Place 303 683 0769

5

Cook, Kevin


From: Carl Maehl <[email protected]> Sent: Saturday, June 29, 2019 10:39 AM To: '[email protected]' Subject: Letter of Recommendation for Ryan Phelan

CAUTION:Thisemailmessagemaycontainanunsafeattachment. WescanemailattachmentsformalicioussoftwaretoprotectyourcomputerandtheState'snetwork.Ifwedeterminethatanattachmentisunsafe,thenweblockitandyouwillonlyseeanattachmentcalled'UnsupportedFileTypesAlert.txt'.Ifwecannotscananattachment,thenweprovidethiswarningthattheattachmentmaybeunsafeandadviseyoutoverifythesenderbeforeopeningtheattachment.Ifyoudon'tseeafileattachedtothismessage,itdoesn'tmeanthatweblockedit,someemailsignaturescontainimagefilesthatwecannotscan.PleasecontactyouragencyITstaffformoreinformation.

To whom it may concern, I am writing to show my support for Ryan Phelan’s candidacy for District Court Judge in the 4th Judicial District. I have personally known Ryan and her family for over 15 years. Ryan is well respected within the community and very involved with many local organizations. Her depth of experience in family law and in private practice makes her an excellent candidate for this position. I highly recommend Ryan for appointment. Thanks, Carl Maehl 5635 Prospect Drive Missoula, MT 59808 (406) 829‐3859 Carl J. Maehl, PE, LEED AP Associate o 406.728.9522 | m 406.214.6301

TO: Judicial Nomination Commission Members

FROM: Lois Menzies

DATE: June 29, 2019

SUBJECT: Public Comment -- Phelan

On June 28, 2019, Carolyn Overman from Missoula called to recommend Ryan Phelan for the

district court position. She said that she has known Ms. Phelan for three years, and they serve

together on the Missoula Children’s Theater board. Ms. Overman noted that Ms. Phelan has

been invaluable as a board member. She listens attentively and gives great thought before

speaking. Her comments are clear and concise, and you always know where she stands. Ms.

Ryan is always willing to participate as part of the theater community and the Missoula

community at large. Moreover, her background in family law would make her a valuable

addition to the court.

June 29, 2019

Judicial Nomination Commission, c/o Lois Menzies Office of Court Administrator [email protected] via email only

RE: Ryan Phelan Application to the Fourth Judicial District Judgeship Vacancy

Greetings,

Ms. Ryan Phelan asked me to write her a letter in support of her application to the

judicial vacancy of the Montana Fourth Judicial District, Missoula and Mineral Counties.

I am a certified Child Welfare Law Specialist (NACC) in private practice since 2015. My

firm specializes in foster parent representation, civil rights litigation, personal injury, and crime

victim representation. Formerly, I served as a substitute municipal court judge in Missoula City

Court 2015-2016, ran for Missoula County Justice of the Peace in 2014, and practiced as a

Deputy County Attorney from 2004-2015 after graduating from Montana Law.

Ms. Phelan possesses the qualifications Montana seeks in its judges. I have practiced

opposite Ms. Phelan professionally and known her as my next-door neighbor. She has an

incredible depth of knowledge in over 40% of all cases Montana’s judges see: family law. She

understands dispute resolution and working in the best interests of Montana’s children. She

possesses the balanced demeanor of judicial temperament required to resolve Montana cases.

Her experiences as a substitute Justice of the Peace have given her a solid foundation in

criminal matters. Her experience in dissolution cases has given her a solid foundation in

complex civil litigation. And her background in advance of being a family law practitioner gives

Montana attorneys confidence to expect she will be successful sitting in judgment of the disputes

citizens bring to Court.

The commission would do well to forward her name to Governor Bullock for

appointment to the judicial vacancy of the Montana Fourth Judicial District

Page ! of !1 2

Respectfully submitted,

___________________________________ Matthew B. Lowy Lowy Law, PLLC

cc: Ryan Phelan

Page ! of !2 2

1

Cook, Kevin

From: Menzies, LoisSent: Monday, July 1, 2019 1:13 PMTo: Cook, KevinSubject: Public Comment -- Phelan

From: [email protected] <[email protected]> Sent: Sunday, June 30, 2019 11:21 PM To: [email protected] Subject: Judicial Nomination for Ryan Phelan Jun 29, 2019 To Whom It May Concern: I am writing this letter in support of the candidacy of Ryan Phelan, as she has submitted her application for Judicial Nomination to serve as District Court Judge in the 4th Judicial District. In particular, I would like to expound on the reasons why I feel the Court, as well as the Missoula and Mineral County communities, would benefit from the service of Ms Phelan in the capacity of district court judge. I have known Ms Phelan for approximately 12 years, having first met her when she and her husband, and my then fiancée and I, were participating in pre-nuptial courses at Saint Francis Xavier Catholic Church. She and her family have since become close family friends, and as such I feel qualified to state the qualities that make Ryan an excellent candidate. To begin with, I feel very comfortable commenting on Ryan's commitment to whatever endeavor she is challenged with. I know her to be one who pursues excellence in everything she applies herself to, whether it be her work, or to the responsibilities towards her family. "Diligence" is certainly a word I would use to describe her; she approaches her responsibilities with carefulness and with persistence. I feel it is her nature to not only complete a given task, but to complete it to the very best of her abilities. Ryan is also very committed to her community of Missoula. She was raised here, and as such understands what is meaningful to Missoulians. Despite her work responsibilities, she donates much of her spare time and energy to various community programs. Her daughter is involved in competitive gymnastics with my daughter at Mismo Gymnastics in Missoula, and I have seen how much time she volunteers there, not only for her daughter's benefit but for the benefit of the entire program. I know, too, that she is involved in the Missoula Children's Theater, as well as our church parish, Saint Francis Xavier Catholic Church. I truly feel that it is out of a desire to take part in community-building that Ryan chooses to dedicate so much of her spare time and energy into these programs. Lastly, in terms of Ryan's character and temperament, I know her to be intelligent, logical, compassionate, and level-headed. She always strikes me as composed, even in challenging circumstances. She always appears to be in control, regardless of what things may be taking place around her. In short, I feel Ryan has all of the qualities that make her ideally suited to serve as a District Court Judge. Her intelligence, diligence, commitment to community, and temperament all will serve her well in the capacity of District Court Judge. I therefore support without reservations her candidacy for election, and will hope that in this position Ryan can continue to serve her community well. Sincerely, Armando A. Gama, DDS Oral and Maxillofacial Surgeon Missoula, MT

2

Cook, Kevin


________________________________________ From: Jennifer Alexander <[email protected]> Sent: Sunday, June 30, 2019 11:18 AM To: [email protected] Subject: Support for Ryan Phelan Hello, My name is Jennifer Alexander. I am a resident of Missoula. I have known Mrs. Phelan since 1992. We were best friends in High School and she has done some professional work for my daughter and I. She is of high moral character and is very knowledgeable. When she worked on my parenting plan she had the needs of my daughter uppermost in her mind. I feel she would make the best District Court Judge because she does have a love of the law and doing the right thing. She is very involved in the community genuinely cares about the community. I support Ryan Phelan for District Court Judge! Thank you, Jennifer Alexander 406‐239‐3209 [email protected] 205 W Kent Missoula MT 59801

3

Cook, Kevin


From: Curt Hammill <[email protected]> Sent: Sunday, June 30, 2019 4:57 PM To: [email protected] Subject: Ryan Phelan for 4th Judicial District Court I think Ryan Phelan would be an excellent choice for the appointment to the 4th Judicial District Court judge. Regards, Curt Hammill

4

Cook, Kevin


From: Char Peppenger <[email protected]> Sent: Sunday, June 30, 2019 4:55 PM To: [email protected] Subject: Letter for Ryan Phelan as District Court judge Judicial Nomination Committee C/O Lois Menzies Office of the Court Administrator P.O. Box 203005 Helena, MT 59620‐3005 [email protected] RE: Recommendation for Ryan Alane Phelan for 4th Judicial District Court Judge Dear Commission: I am writing this letter to support the application and nomination of Ryan Alane Phelan for 4th Judicial District Court Judge. I am a Licensed Clinical Social Worker working as a psychotherapist with a private counseling practice in Missoula. As such, I have had a number of occasions, over the years, to work with Ryan in her legal practice. She has been very helpful to my understanding of the Courts, and the law, as they relate to my work with children and families. I have also been impressed by her understanding of when and how mental health evaluations and treatment may be beneficial to clients involved in the litigation process. Ryan has a knowledge of, and sensitivity to, mental health issues and treats those struggling with such things with dignity and respect. I believe these are important traits for a District Court Judge and I support her appointment.

Char Peppenger, LCSW

2935 Stockyard Rd, Suite K-4 Missoula, MT 59808 406-370-3839

6

Cook, Kevin


From: Alicia Jones <[email protected]> Sent: Sunday, June 30, 2019 2:33 PM To: [email protected] Subject: Support for Ryan Alane Phelan Dear Judicial Nomination Commission, This email is to provide my recommendation and support for Ryan Alane Phelan to be a candidate of the ballot for a Missoula Judgeship position. I have known Ryan for approximately 4 years. We met sitting in the gym, as both our girls practised gymnastics. Through conversations, I came to know Ryan and learned that she was a lawyer. I was surprised to learn this, as she does not come across as better or smarter than the person she is talking to and is willing to offer both personal and professional advice to those who are struggling. Ryan has worked beside me during fundraisers and helping to host our gym's gymnastics meet. She can take direction while offering her support and opinions without coming across as better than you. Any time Ryan is offering her support, it is almost as if I can see her brain processing. She seems to think through the situation without being biased and offers opinions, advice, and recommendations that make sense and are easy to follow. As I struggle to write this email with the eloquence and detail that I would like to convey, it all comes down to one thing... I 100% support Ryan on her quest for a judgeship position and I would vote for her. I can imagine that she has received her fair share of letters, calls, and emails recommending her for this opportunity and I look forward to seeing her name on the ballot! Best Regards, Alicia Jones 2425 Fleet St Missoula, MT 59808 406‐880‐8006

7

Cook, Kevin


________________________________________ From: Cynthia Stern <[email protected]> Sent: Sunday, June 30, 2019 2:14 PM To: [email protected] Subject: Ryan Phelan I support the nomination of Ryan Phelan for District Court Judge. I am an active voter in Missoula County. Cynthia Stern 30 Willowbrook Missoula, MT 59802 Sent from my iPad

8

Cook, Kevin


From: Steve Shelly <[email protected]> Sent: Sunday, June 30, 2019 1:06 PM To: [email protected] Subject: Letter of public comment in support of Ryan Phelan June 30, 2019 To the Montana Judicial Nomination Committee: I am writing in full support of Ryan Alane Phelan as a candidate for District Court judge in the 4th Judicial District. I have known Ryan for several years, as a friend and neighbor, and have come to appreciate her as a valued member of our neighborhood and the Missoula community. Ryan possesses many personal and professional attributes that make her an outstanding candidate for this judicial appointment. On a personal level, it has been a pleasure getting to know Ryan and her family. She is an excellent parent who has a very calm, consistent demeanor when interacting with her children and those of others. She is a very kind friend who is always willing to listen to the experiences of others. Ryan is also very active in supporting our community in valued ways, including her work on the Board of Directors for the Missoula Children's Theatre. These characteristics, which reflect her strong commitment to help others, would serve her extremely well as a judge. Ryan has many professional experiences that make her an outstanding candidate as well. Of particular note is her long‐term depth of legal experience in family law, which would be extremely valuable in the 4th Judicial District where about 40% of the caseload is family law. She also served as a judge pro tem for the Missoula County Justice Court for a period of five years since 2014. In addition, she has an extensive background in teaching family law, and serves on two committees for the Montana State Bar Child and Family Law Section. Her 18 years of experience in private law practice, combined with this judicial background, make Ryan an exemplary candidate. Both my wife and I would definitely vote for Ryan in future elections, and feel she is highly electable in Missoula and Mineral counties. Her appointment as District Court judge would be excellent for our community and the state of Montana. Thank you for the opportunity to comment on this appointment. J. Stephen Shelly

9

Regional Botanist U.S. Forest Service, Northern Region Missoula, Montana Home address: 8718 Mashie Lane Missoula, Montana 59808 406‐550‐2555

6/30/2019

To Whom it May Concern:

I am writing this letter of recommendation for Ryan Phelan.

I have known Ryan for the last 12 years in both a personal and professional setting. Ryan exemplifies integrity, tact, kindness and grace.

In a professional setting Ryan is fair, candid and honest. I found her advice helpful and insightful. She has a strong understanding of the law, and has a fair mind and provides excellent counsel.

In a personal setting, she is delightful and has a wonderful sense of humor and in my judgement is an excellent parent, that is willing to go the extra mile for her family and friends.

In my opinion, she would be an excellent judge.

I highly recommend Ryan for this position.

Please contact me with any questions.

Best Regards,

Mark Wells Vice President of Busines Development Glo European Windows

cook, kevin - mt judicial branch · 2019-07-08 · 1 cook, kevin from: menzies, lois sent: sunday,...

Documents