contradiction

17
Contradiction A statement is a contradiction iff it cannot be T.

Upload: nibal

Post on 05-Feb-2016

38 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

DESCRIPTION

Contradiction. A statement is a contradiction iff it cannot be T. Contradiction. A statement is a contradiction iff it cannot be T . So its truth table has all F s on the output column. Contradiction. A statement is a contradiction iff it cannot be T . - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Contradiction

Contradiction

A statement is a contradiction iff

it cannot be T.

Page 2: Contradiction

Contradiction

A statement is a contradiction iff

it cannot be T.

So its truth table has all Fson the output column.

Page 3: Contradiction

Contradiction

A statement is a contradiction iff

it cannot be T.

So its truth table has all Fson the output column.

Sample: A Standard Contradiction: P&-P

Page 4: Contradiction

Contradiction

A statement is a contradiction iff

it cannot be T.

So its truth table has all Fson the output column.

Sample: A Standard Contradiction: P&-P

P P & -PT F FF F T *

Page 5: Contradiction

Contradiction

A statement is a contradiction iff

it cannot be T.

So its truth table has all Fson the output column.

Sample: A Standard Contradiction: P&-P

Standard Contradictions are not the only ones.

-(P>P) -(Pv-P) P<>-P

Page 6: Contradiction

Contradiction

A statement is a contradiction iff

it cannot be T.

So its truth table has all Fson the output column.

-(P>P) -(Pv-P) P<>-P

Contradictions are Bad News: They must be false.

Page 7: Contradiction

Contradiction

A statement is a contradiction iff

it cannot be T.

So its truth table has all Fson the output column.

-(P>P) -(Pv-P) P<>-P

Contradictions are Bad News: They must be false.

They carry no information.

Page 8: Contradiction

Contradiction

A statement is a contradiction iff

it cannot be T.

So its truth table has all Fson the output column.

-(P>P) -(Pv-P) P<>-P

Contradictions are Bad News: They must be false.

They carry no information.Lousy Weather Report: it is raining and not raining.

Page 9: Contradiction

Contradiction

-A is a contradiction iff

A is a logical truth.

A -AT FT FT FT F

Page 10: Contradiction

Contradiction

-A is a contradiction iff

A is a logical truth.

So these must be contradictions: -(P>P) -(Pv-P) P<>-P

A -AT FT FT FT F

Page 11: Contradiction

ContradictionTo show a statement A is a contradiction ... with a table: The output row for A has all Fs.

P -(P>P)T F TF F T *

P -(P v -P)T F T FF F T T *

Page 12: Contradiction

ContradictionTo show a statement A is a contradiction ... with a table: The output row for A has all Fs.

with a proof: Prove -A.Here is a proof that -P&P is a contradiction.

P -(P>P)T F TF F T *

P -(P v -P)T F T FF F T T *

-(-P&P) GOAL

Page 13: Contradiction

ContradictionTo show a statement A is a contradiction ... with a table: The output row for A has all Fs.

with a proof: Prove -A.Here is a proof that -P&P is a contradiction.

P -(P>P)T F TF F T *

P -(P v -P)T F T FF F T T *

1) -P&P PA

?&-? -(-P&P) 1-? -I

Page 14: Contradiction

ContradictionTo show a statement A is a contradiction ... with a table: The output row for A has all Fs.

with a proof: Prove -A.Here is a proof that -P&P is a contradiction.

P -(P>P)T F TF F T *

P -(P v -P)T F T FF F T T *

1) -P&P PA2) P 1 &O3) -P 1 &O4) P&-P 2,3 &I5) -(-P&P) 1-4 -I

Page 15: Contradiction

ContradictionTo show a statement A is a contradiction ... with a table: The output row for A has all Fs.

with a proof: Prove -A.

with a tree: The tree for A closes.

P -(P>P)T F TF F T *

P -(P v -P)T F T FF F T T *

Page 16: Contradiction

ContradictionTo show a statement A is a contradiction ... with a table: The output row for A has all Fs.

with a proof: Prove -A.

with a tree: The tree for A closes.

P -(P>P)T F TF F T *

P -(P v -P)T F T FF F T T *

Here is a tree that shows that -P&P is a contradiction.-P&P

-PP*

Page 17: Contradiction

ContradictionTo show a statement A is a contradiction ... with a table: The output row for A has all Fs.

with a proof: Prove -A.

with a tree: The tree for A closes.

For more click here