consulting sources – citation systems ethical issues: plagiarism

13
Research Methodology Consulting Sources – Citation Systems Ethical Issues: Plagiarism

Upload: percival-parker

Post on 12-Jan-2016

219 views

Category:

Documents


1 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Consulting Sources – Citation Systems Ethical Issues: Plagiarism

Research MethodologyConsulting Sources – Citation Systems

Ethical Issues: Plagiarism

Page 2: Consulting Sources – Citation Systems Ethical Issues: Plagiarism

Reasons for Consulting SourcesProves awareness of major views on your topicProvides support for your own viewsProves that you are able to carry out research at academic

level

Page 3: Consulting Sources – Citation Systems Ethical Issues: Plagiarism

Academic SourcesTypes of sources:

Primary – texts, documents to be analysedSecondary - literature on your topic or theory

Types of secondary sources according to manner of publication and length:Articles in scholarly journalsArticles in edited volumesMonographs

NOT academic sources:- Encyclopedias, dictionaries- Sources with unknown author (except for government and other official

publications)- GCSE resource books

Page 4: Consulting Sources – Citation Systems Ethical Issues: Plagiarism

Tools to Map Up Literature to be ConsultedLibrary catalogues

College library catalogueODR catalogue

DatabasesFreeRequire subscription – accessible from the college

Bibliography of already consulted sources

Page 5: Consulting Sources – Citation Systems Ethical Issues: Plagiarism

To Read or not to Read?Factors in choosing really important secondary sources

AuthorInfluence Time of publication

Ways to decideCheck bibliographySkim introduction, search for thesis statementsCheck reviews

Compromise – selective reading

Page 6: Consulting Sources – Citation Systems Ethical Issues: Plagiarism

I Know I’ve Read it Somewhere…Methods for highlighting important information in

sourcesUnderlining or highlighting (your own books or

photocopies)Note-cards

Bibligraphical notes Content notes

Note-taking (handwritten or digitalised)

Page 7: Consulting Sources – Citation Systems Ethical Issues: Plagiarism

Sample Note-Card 1

Page 8: Consulting Sources – Citation Systems Ethical Issues: Plagiarism

Sample Note-Card 2

Page 9: Consulting Sources – Citation Systems Ethical Issues: Plagiarism

Types of QuotationDirect – word-by-word quotation – quotation marks

Short: less than 50 words or 5 linesLong

Indirect – no quotation marks, or quotation marks for certain phrasesParaphraseSummary

CLEARCUT REFERENCE TO THE SOURCE IS AN ABSOLUTE MUST IN BOTH CASESS

Page 10: Consulting Sources – Citation Systems Ethical Issues: Plagiarism

To Quote or not to Quote?When to quote?Source gives supportDisagreement with source – prove that the source is

wrong

When not to quote?Source only repeats well-known informationDisagreement with source without proving it wrongLack of understandingInability to paraphrase or summarise

Page 11: Consulting Sources – Citation Systems Ethical Issues: Plagiarism

How to Quote?Formatting handbooks in academia – to be used as

manualsMLAChicagoAPAEtc.

Page 12: Consulting Sources – Citation Systems Ethical Issues: Plagiarism

PlagiarismDefinition: using other peoples words and/or ideas

without clearly indicating their source (stealing).How to avoid it?

Careful note-taking (quotation marks for copied words, exact bibliographical notes)

Careful following of the rules outlined in an academic handbook

Page 13: Consulting Sources – Citation Systems Ethical Issues: Plagiarism

Works Consulted2011. évi CCIV. törvény a nemzeti felsőoktatásról. Magyar Közlöny

165 (2011): 41181-247.

Babbie, Earl. A társadalomtudományi kutatás gyakorlata. Trans. Kende Gábor and Szaitz Mariann. 5th edition. Budapest: Balassi, 2000.

Eco, Umberto. Hogyan írjunk szakdolgozatot? Trans. Klukon Beatrix. Budapest: Gondolat, 1992.

Gőcze István. A tudományelmélet és kutatásmódszertan alapjai. Budapest: ZMNE, 2010.

Gyurgyák János. Szerkesztők és szerzők kézikönyve. Budapest: Osiris, 2003.

Majoros Pál. A kutatásmódszertan alapjai. Budapest: Perfekt, 2010.