conservation advisory group - enfield advisory group/20130402/agenda...dr chris jephcott said that...

1

CONSERVATION ADVISORY GROUP Tuesday 2nd April 2013 at 7 PM Contact: Heloise Brown Venue: Conference Room Conservation Officer Civic Centre, Silver Street Direct dial: 020 8379 4019 Enfield, EN1 3XA Extension: 4019 Email: [email protected] Council website: www.enfield.gov.uk

MEMBERS Councillors: Cole, Ibrahim , Laban, Pearce and Robinson Co-opted: Mr D. Stacey - Bush Hill Park Conservation Area Study Group

Mr T Dey - Federation of Enfield Residents and Allied Associations Mr P. Fisk - Forty Hill and Bulls Cross Study Group

Ms H Walton - Edmonton Study Group Dr C. Jephcott – The Enfield Society

Mrs C. Carter - Enfield Town Conservation Area Study Group Mrs A Bishop-Laggatt - Federation of Enfield Residents and Allied Associations

Mrs I Stone - Southgate District Civic Trust Mr D Alexander - Trent Park Conservation Committee Mr A Newman – Clay Hill Study Group Dr D Gandhi – Southgate Green Study Group Mr P Hutchinson – Grange Park Conservation Area Study Group Mr T Hanrahan – Meadway Conservation Area Study Group Mr C Younger – Lakes Estate Conservation Study Group

Director of Environment

2

AGENDA – PART 1

1. APOLOGIES FOR ABSENCE (if any) 2. DECLARATION OF INTERESTS Members to identify any personal or prejudicial interests relevant to any items on the agenda. Please see attached guidance. ATTACHMENT A 3. MINUTES

To confirm the Minutes of the meeting that took place on 6th March 2013. ATTACHMENT B

4. LOCAL PLAN AND HERITAGE AND DESIGN PROJECTS UPDATE 5. PLANNING APPLICATIONS AND LISTED BUILDING APPLICATIONS FOR

DISCUSSION ATTACHMENT C

6. CHAIRMAN’S FEEDBACK FROM PLANNING COMMITTEE To receive for information feedback from the CAG Vice Chairman from Planning

Committee of 26th March 2013. 7. CONSERVATION OFFICER’S FEEDBACK ABOUT LAST MONTH’S CASES

8. CONSERVATION AREAS, LISTED BUILDING APPLICATIONS AND

APPEALS–DETERMINED ATTACHMENT D 9. OPEN SESSION To enable members of the Conservation Advisory Group to bring up urgent matters not covered elsewhere on the agenda 10. CALENDAR OF MEETINGS To receive for information, the calendar of meetings for the Municipal Year 2012 ATTACHMENT E 11. EXCLUSION OF THE PUBLIC AND PRESS TO CONSIDER PASSING A RESOLUTION UNDER SECTION 100A(4) OF LOCAL GOVERNMENT ACT 1972 EXCLUDING THE PRESS AND PUBLIC FROM THE MEETING FOR THE ITEMS OF BUSINESS MOVED TO PART 2 OF THE AGENDA ON THE GROUNDS THAT THEY INVOLVE THE LIKELY DISCLOSURE OF EXEMPT INFORMATION AS WILL BE DEFINED IN THOSE PARAGRAPHS OF PART 1 OF THE SCHEDULE 12A TO THE ACT, AT THE MEETING. (There are currently no items in Part 2 of the Agenda unless any items are transferred

from Part 1).

3

What matters are being discussed at the meeting?

Do any relate to my interests whether already registered or not?

Pers

ona

l in

tere

st

You can participate in the meeting and vote

Pre

judic

ial in

tere

st

YES

NO

NO

NO

YES

YES

YES

You may have a personal interest

Note: If in any doubt about a potential interest, members are asked to seek advice from Democratic Services in advance of the meeting.

NO

YES

You may have a prejudicial interest

A DECLARING INTERESTS FLOWCHART - QUESTIONS TO ASK YOURSELF

Declare your personal interest in the matter. You can remain in meeting, speak and vote unless the interest is also prejudicial; or If your interest arises solely from your membership of, or position of control or management on any other public body or body to which you were nominated by the authority e.g. Governing Body, ALMO, you only need declare your personal interest if and when you speak on the matter, again providing it is not prejudicial.

Does the matter affect your financial interests or relate to a licensing, planning or other regulatory matter; and Would a member of the public (knowing the relevant facts) reasonably think that your personal interest was so significant that it would prejudice your judgement of public interest?

Do the public have speaking rights at the meeting?

You should declare the interest but can remain in the meeting to speak. Once you have finished speaking (or the meeting decides you have finished - if earlier) you must withdraw from the meeting by leaving the room.

You should declare the interest and withdraw from the meeting by leaving the room. You cannot speak or vote on the matter and must not seek to improperly influence the decision.

Is a particular matter close to me? Does it affect:

• me or my partner;

• my relatives or their partners;

• my friends or close associates;

• either me, my family or close associates:

• job and business;

• employers, firms you or they are a partner of and companies you or they are a Director of

• or them to any position;

• corporate bodies in which you or they have a shareholding of more than £25,000 (nominal value);

• my entries in the register of interests more than it would affect the majority of people in the ward affected by the decision, or in the authority’s area or constituency?

4

B

Minutes of the Conservation Advisory Group Meeting 5

th February 2013

MEMBERS Councillors: Cole, Ibrahim, Laban, Pearce and Robinson Co-opted: Mr D. Stacey - Bush Hill Park Conservation Area Study Group

Mr T. Dey - Federation of Enfield Residents and Allied Associations Mr P. Fisk - Forty Hill and Bulls Cross Study Group

Mr A. Rodrigo - Edmonton Study Group Dr Jephcott– The Enfield Society

Mrs C. Carter - Enfield Town Conservation Area Study Group Mrs A. Bishop-Laggatt - Federation of Enfield Residents and Allied Associations

Mrs I. Stone - Southgate District Civic Trust Mr T. Hillman - Trent Park Conservation Committee Mr A. Newman – Clay Hill Study Group Dr D. Gandhi – Southgate Green Study Group Mr C. Johnson – Grange Park Conservation Area Study Group Mr M. Slatter – Meadway Conservation Area Study Group

Mr C. Younger – Lakes Estate Conservation Study Group Officers: Heloise Brown (Conservation Officer), Paul Walker (Assistant Director Policy

and Regeneration), Christine White (Heritage Officer), Italics denote absence

5

AGENDA – PART 1 1. APOLOGIES FOR ABSENCE

Councillor Ibrahim, Councillor Pearce, Donald Alexander, Paul Hutchinson, Tom Hanrahan. 2. DECLARATION OF INTERESTS None. 3. MINUTES

The minutes of the previous meeting were signed as a true record.

4. LOCAL PLAN AND HERITAGE AND DESIGN PROJECTS UPDATE Broomfield House – Paul Walker updated the Group on his meeting with the HLF to discuss the failure of Council’s bid for funding. The application had been recommended for approval by the case officer which had then gone to the National Committee and been one of 6 out of a total of 10 to not be successful. There were understandable concerns raised about the condition of the building and the potential increase of anticipated costs. The HLF recommended addressing further the link between restoring the house and its grounds in any future application as well as the possibility of putting offices upstairs. Paul Walker concluded that the main problem was that the HLF don’t have enough money for the many deserving projects.

5. PLANNING APPLICATIONS AND LISTED BUILDING APPLICATIONS FOR DISCUSSION

P12-02785PLA, P13-00320ADV and P12-02786HER WHITE LODGE MEDICAL PRACTICE, 68 SILVER STREET, ENFIELD, EN1 3EW The Group had seen the proposals at the pre-app stage. They have been modified since then to reflect their comments. The restoration of the railings was welcomed and most of the works were considered in keeping. The Enfield Conservation Area Study Group had raised concerns about the amount of signage proposed and the toughened safety glass balustrade, both of which were being amended. The extension of the car park without planning permission was raised as were a couple of points about changes that had been made internally.

• Support the principle. P13-00041PLA TRENT PARK GOLF CLUB, TRENT PARK GOLF CLUB, BRAMLEY ROAD, LONDON, HERTFORDSHIRE, N14 4UW The proposal for a larger shop constructed under the lawn outside the club house was considered acceptable. No real changes will be visible once the work is fully completed.

• Support. P13-00262PRI, EDMONTON GREEN RAILWAY STATION, CHURCH STREET, LONDON, N9 9DX Following the consultation from the architects, a prior approval application had been submitted. There were numerous concerns about the appearance of the scheme and there was some discussion about how it could be improved. Mr Rodrigo asked about the requirement for conservation area consent in relation to the brick wall that runs along side the station buildings on Church Street and that the Council should address the possibility of the shaft being positioned at the other end of the station. It was agreed that if the Group had known that one of the considerations the Council had to address as part of the application was whether the scheme caused injury to the amenity of the area. It was considered that the proposed view would cause injury and should did not therefore constitute permitted development.

• Object

6

P13-00290PLA, 28 GREENWAY, LONDON, N14 6NN The proposal is for a part single part two-storey rear extension. The proposal is a re-submission of a scheme which previously proposed a first floor side extension. The group felt the first floor rear extension still affected the gap between the properties unacceptably.

• Object – proposal is excessive.

P12-02961PLA 65 ULLESWATER ROAD, LONDON, N14 7BN The proposal is for rooflights on the front slope and converting the hipped roof to a gable end. The Group felt that the pattern of hips and gable ends was important to preserve, even though further up the road the pattern had been compromised by some changes, there is nevertheless a run of original roof forms. The resultant unbalanced pair would be visually unsatisfactory. The rooflights clearly contravene the conservation area appraisal and are unacceptable.

• Object.

P13-00328PLA 31-33 Silver Street, Enfield, EN1 3EF The unity of the three buildings 31-35 (odd) was noted. The design of the shopfronts was not considered sufficiently sympathetic to be granted consent. The shopfront guide (SPD) should be followed. G. Matthews had a nice pair of timber doors and these should be kept or replicated.

• Object

9. CHAIRMAN’S FEEDBACK FROM PLANNING COMMITTEE Dennis Stacey noted that the Forty Hall Farm applications for the rebuilding of two shelters had

been to Planning Committee but these were not contentious. 10. CONSERVATION OFFICER’S FEEDBACK ABOUT LAST MONTH’S CASES

Heloise Brown updated the Group on the following applications that had been considered by CAG: P13-00017PLA College Farm, 515 Hertford Road, Enfield – CAG’s views had been reported to the case officer and the application would be going to Committee. Dr Jephcott said the Enfield Society had been to visit the building and were considering writing to the Chief Executive. P13-00079PLA 1A, Lichfield Road – The case officer has requested that the applicants remove the front door to prevent the public space becoming too much like a front garden. P13-00070PLA and P12-00071HER Forty Hall Farm, Forty Hill – There is due to be a meeting about the location of one of the CCTV cameras. P13-03088PLA and P12-02766HER – The applications are uncontroversial and have been approved.

11. CONSERVATION AREAS, LISTED BUILDING APPLICATIONS AND APPEALS–DETERMINED No comment. 12. OPEN SESSION

Tony Dey asked why TP/11/1831 - Public House, Turkey Street had not been brought to CAG. Andrew Newman asked when CAG would be consulted on the plans to demolish and redevelop the flats at the bottom of Forty Hill. The Spurs applications were also raised. Dennis Stacey asked if Andrew Newman could highlight any future applications he felt ought to come to CAG. Dr Chris Jephcott said that CAG ought to thank Aled for having attended CAG meeting. It was agreed Dennis Stacey should write him a letter. Anne Bishop-Laggatt asked what was happening with the building opposite the Dugdale Centre which is being converted to a hotel as little seems to have happened for a long time. Tony Hillman said there had been no news on the former Middlesex University site at Trent Park. Asitha Rodrigo said that the car wash on Lion Road was still operating and was still displaying signs.

7

Dennis Stacey mentioned that the enforcement system was not currently working for the group and

he was working trying to sort it our. Colin Younger mentioned there were many outstanding cases in the Lakes Estate, not to mention the on-going saga of 110-112 Aldermans Hill.

Caroline Carter said that both the old and new street lights on The Town were coming on at the

moment which presumably was not the intention.

13. CALENDAR OF MEETINGS Noted.

8

C

PLANNING AND LISTED BUILDING APPLICATIONS FOR DISCUSSION P13-00435PLA, LAND SOUTH SIDE OF WHITEWEBBS LANE, INCORPORATING ROLENMILL SPORTS GROUND AND LAND REAR OF MIDDELTON HOUSE, BULLS CROSS, ENFIELD, EN2 9HA Case Officer: Sean Newton Description: Proposed extension to ecological area and associated re-contouring of the site known as the 'Western Field'. Site and Surroundings: The site is to the south of Whitewebbs Lane and on the western end of the Spurs Training Ground. The site is within the Forty Hill Conservation Area. Impact on the Heritage Assets: The ecological management plan (EMP) that was granted permission as part of the original applications denoted the creation of a woodland habitat strip along the northern edge of the Western Field and the remainder of the site was to be given over to green waste recycling. The proposal is now to extend the ecological area (from 0.9ha to 1.16) and re-contour the site by increasing the visual screening from the footpath along the southern boundary of the site. The site is in the Forty Hill Conservation Area To consider: The impact of the changes on the Conservation Area.

9

Site plan

10

Proposed site plan

Proposed plan showing bunds P13-00247PLA and P13-00246PLA, 5-12, ST ONGE PARADE AND GENOTIN ROAD, 8, SOUTHBURY ROAD, ENFIELD, EN1 1YU Case Officer: Sean Newton

11

Description: Conversion of 5 self contained flats at first and second floors into 10 self contained flats (comprising 9 x 1-bed and 1 x 2-bed) involving a first and second floor rear extension and enlargement of commercial unit (no. 6) at ground floor rear. and Conversion of 5 self contained flats at first and second floors into 13 self contained flats (comprising 9 x 1-bed and 4 x 2-bed) involving a first and second floor rear extension, construction of third floor within a mansard roof with roof terraces at rear and enlargement of commercial unit (no.6) at ground floor rear. Site and Surroundings: The site is on the western edge of the Enfield Town Conservation Area. It is an attractive three-storey parade on a busy junction opposite the station. Impact on the Heritage Assets: One of the most important visual changes proposed is the roof extension to the block which is a part of application P13-00246. This new mansard will have an impact on the building’s appearance and the conservation area. To Consider: The effect of the external changes on the character of the conservation area.

Site Plan

12

Proposed elevations P13-00468PLA, 33, BOURNE AVENUE, LONDON, N14 6PA Case Officer: Misbah Uddin Description: Demolition of garage and erection of a part single, part 2-storey side extension with integral garage, part single part 2-storey rear extension, first floor front dormer and extension to roof with a side and rear dormer. Site and Surroundings: The site is on the east side of Bourne Avenue close to the junction with the Meadway. It is a detached property and one of an originally matching pair. The house is within the Meadway Conservation Area.

13

Impact on Heritage Assets: The house is proposed to be extended in a way that will substantially alter its appearance. To Consider: The impact of the extensions on the character of the building and the conservation area.

Site location plan

14

Front elevation as existing (with neighbour to the left)

Elevations as existing

15

Proposed elevation (with neighbour)

Proposed elevations

16

P13-00329PLA, 27 Church Street, Enfield, EN2 6AJ Case Officer: Kate Perry Description: Change of use of land at side to mixed use for a mobile catering van for the sale of hot and cold food and the sale of fruit, vegetables and flowers. Site and Surroundings: The site is on the main thoroughfare through Enfield Town and on the corner of Little Park Gardens. It is next door to the Post Office and within its historic curtilage and within the Enfield Town Conservation Area. Impact on Heritage Assets: There is an extant permission for a mobile catering van on the site but the owner wants to expand to sell fruit, vegetables and flowers. The new stalls will be visible from the street. To Consider: The impact on the appearance of the conservation area.

Site Layout

17

Proposed site layout P13-00730PRE 22-68 Forty Hill, Enfield, EN2 9EG Case Officer: Andrew Jarrett Description: Proposed residential development for 9 units (and the demolition of the existing block on the site). Site and Surroundings: The site is at the south end of Forty Hill, on the west side. The existing ‘L’-shaped block of flats is set back slightly from the road. The flats are within the Forty Hill Conservation Area and on what was part of Gough Park.

18

Impact on Heritage Assets: The new houses will be a conspicuous change to this part of the conservation area. To Consider: The principle of the layout and form of the new development.

Site visit

Aerial view of the site

19

Proposed sketch of the development P13-00664ADV, 1, SILVER STREET, ENFIELD, EN1 3EF Case Officer: Kate Perry Description: Installation of internally illuminated signs comprising 2 x fascia signs, 3 x hanging signs, 2 x wall mounted signs and 2 x non- illuminated wall mounted signs and 3 window Vinyl's to entrance. Site and Surroundings: The site is on the junction of Silver Street, The Town and Southbury Road. The building is an Edwardian bank with its entrance on the corner. Impact on Heritage Asset: This is a handsome building in its original use. Any signage should be subservient and respectful. To Consider: Whether the signage preserves and enhances the character of the building and the conservation area.

21

As Existing Images

As Proposed Images P13-00697ADV, GARAGE, COCKFOSTERS ROAD, BARNET, EN4 0DZ Case Officer: Rajvinder Kaur Description: Installation of 10 x signs comprising of internally illuminated signs 2 x wall mounted signs, 3 x signs to canopy,1 x vinyl fascia,1x non illuminated wall mounted poster sign to north west elevation, 1x internally illuminated freestanding gantry sign and 1 x wall mounted sign to south west elevation and 1 x non-illuminated floor mounted sign to east elevation. Site and Surroundings: The site is on the west side of Cockfosters Road bordering Trent Park and north of the listed Cockfosters Station building. The station is within the Trent Park Conservation Area. Impact on the Heritage Asset: The petrol station has been unused for a while and the proposed signage is associated with it being brought back into use and refurbished. To Consider: Whether the amount of signage is appropriate.

22

Site Plan

24

D

LONDON BOROUGH OF ENFIELD

List of Decisions in respect of Conservation Areas FROM: 28/02/13 TO: 28/03/13

Conservation Area: Enfield Town Conservation Area

Application No.:P13-00077PLA

Decision: GRANTED WITH CONDITIONS Decision date: 20-Mar-2013 Level: Delegated Applicant’s Name: William Hill Organisation Ltd Location: 8, SOUTHBURY ROAD, ENFIELD, EN1 1YT

Proposal: New shop front and installation of 2 internal condenser units, 2 x satellite dishes and 1 x antennae to rear of main roof.

Case Officer:Ms K. Perry 0208 8379 3853 Ward: Town


Application No.:P13-00204LDC

Decision: GRANTED Decision date: 14-Mar-2013 Level: Delegated Applicant’s Name: Mr Laurent Melka Location: 6, LITTLE PARK GARDENS, ENFIELD, MIDDLESEX, EN2 6PQ

Proposal: Ancillary use of property by the residential occupier for business purposes in connection with internet mini cab service.

Case Officer:Mr A. Jarratt 0208 8379 3842 Ward: Town Conservation Area: Grange Park Conservation Area

Application No.:TPO/11/0096

Decision: WITHDRAWN Decision date: 05-Mar-2013 Level: Delegated Applicant’s Name: Mr Andrade Location: 119, THE CHINE, LONDON, N21 2EG

Proposal: Works to Oak tree covered by LBE Order No. 255 (1998) - lift lower branches to a height of 4m, prune branches overhanging outbuildings to give clearance of 2m, crown clean and deadwood.

Case Officer:Mr S. Downing 0208 8379 3845 Ward: Grange Conservation Area: Enfield Town Conservation Area

Application No.:P13-00076ADV

Decision: GRANTED WITH CONDITIONS Decision date: 20-Mar-2013 Level: Delegated Applicant’s Name: William Hill Organisation Ltd Location: 8, SOUTHBURY ROAD, ENFIELD, EN1 1YT

Proposal: Installation of externally illuminated fascia and projecting sign.

Case Officer:Ms K. Perry 0208 8379 3853 Ward: Town

25



Decision: WITHDRAWN Decision date: 05-Mar-2013 Level: Delegated Applicant’s Name: Andrea kemp Location: 89, CECIL ROAD, ENFIELD, EN2 6TL

Proposal: Work to 1 Lime tree covered by LBE Order 223- Reduce by 25% and re-pollard to previous points.

Case Officer:Mr S. Downing 0208 8379 3845 Ward: Grange Conservation Area: Grange Park Conservation Area


Decision: WITHDRAWN Decision date: 04-Mar-2013 Level: Applicant’s Name: Mrs Motala Location: 114, OLD PARK RIDINGS, LONDON, N21 2EP

Proposal: Works to trees in The Grange Park Conservation Area - 1 x Horse Chestnut - Reduce by 2m

Case Officer:Mr S. Downing 0208 8379 3845 Ward: Grange Conservation Area: Enfield Lock Conservation Area.


Decision: GRANTED WITH CONDITIONS Decision date: 20-Mar-2013 Level: Delegated Applicant’s Name: Raymond Goss Location: 4, HERON MEAD, ENFIELD, EN3 6FD

Proposal: Erection of summer house to side of dwelling.

Case Officer:Ms K. Perry 0208 8379 3853 Ward: Enfield Lock Conservation Area: Southgate Green Conservation Area.


Decision: WITHDRAWN Decision date: 05-Mar-2013 Level: Delegated Applicant’s Name: Mr & Mrs Geoff Burns Location: 19, THE GREEN, LONDON, N14 7AB

Proposal: Works to 1 Ash tree at front covered by LBE Order No. 1, 1967 - reduce and shape crown by 30-40%, cut back to side branch/bud and remove dead and diseased wood; together with reduction of Laurel at front and rear by 50% and reduce Holly at rear by 50%.

Case Officer:Mr S. Downing 0208 8379 3845 Ward: Southgate Green Conservation Area: Southgate Green Conservation Area.


Decision: GRANTED WITH CONDITIONS Decision date: 14-Mar-2013 Level: Delegated Applicant’s Name: Ms Sheeley Steinhart

26

Location: 9, ARNOS GROVE, LONDON, N14 7AD

Proposal: Demolition of garage and erection of a single storey side and rear extension.

Case Officer:Mr P. Higginbottom 0208 8379 3927 Ward: Southgate Green Conservation Area: Winchmore Hill Green Conservation Area.

Application No.:P13-00193TRE

Decision: GRANTED Decision date: 04-Mar-2013 Level: Delegated Applicant’s Name: London Diocesan Fund Location: ST PAULS VICARAGE, CHURCH HILL, LONDON, N21 1JA

Proposal: Works to trees in the Winchmore Hill Green Conservation Area: 1 x Ash to fell and grind out stump, 3 x Holly trees reduce height by 3m, reduce spread to balance and crown lift to 2.5m, 1 x Oak tree remove all deadwood, reduce crown by 20% where required to balance, 1 x Oak/Horse Chestnut to be felled, 1 x Pear and 2 x False Acacia trees crown reduce by 20%, crown thin by 15%removing epicormic to crown break and remove deadwood, 1 x Holly reduce height by 3m to balance and prune any unruly spread to balance and 1 x Yew reduce crown overhanging pavement and road by 25% and crown lift to 2.5m.

Case Officer:Mr S. Downing 0208 8379 3845 Ward: Winchmore Hill Conservation Area: Grange Park Conservation Area

Application No.:P13-00255DEP

Decision: APPROVED Decision date: 19-Mar-2013 Level: Delegated Applicant’s Name: Mr Mike De'ath Location: 9, THE CHINE, LONDON, N21 2EA

Proposal: Details submitted to P12-02662PLA for the grill to the proposed lightwell pursuant to condition 2 for the increase depth of existing basement and formation of a lightwell to front

Case Officer:Ms R. Kaur 0208 8379 6441 Ward: Grange Conservation Area: Enfield Town Conservation Area


Decision: GRANTED WITH CONDITIONS Decision date: 20-Mar-2013 Level: Delegated Applicant’s Name: Charles Bloom Location: 37, CHURCH STREET, ENFIELD, EN2 6AJ

Proposal: Variation of condition 3 of P12-02006PLA to allow extension of opening hours as follows: 0800-2200 Monday to Saturday and 0900-2200 hours on Sundays.

Case Officer:Misbah Uddin 0208 8379 3849 Ward: Town Conservation Area: Southgate Green Conservation Area.


Decision: WITHDRAWN Decision date: 05-Mar-2013

27

Level: Delegated Applicant’s Name: Amina Tareen Location: 4, CANNON HILL, LONDON, N14 7HG

Proposal: Deadwood Lime tree covered by LBE Order No. 1.

Case Officer:Mr S. Downing 0208 8379 3845 Ward: Southgate Green Conservation Area: Bush Hill Park Conservation Area.


Decision: WITHDRAWN Decision date: 05-Mar-2013 Level: Delegated Applicant’s Name: Mrs Zoe Goldblum Location: 57, WELLINGTON ROAD, ENFIELD, EN1 2PG

Proposal: Works to trees covered by Tree Preservation Order LBE No 342 (2010) - 1 x Conifer - Reduce by 30% and crown lift to 2.8m and 1 x Yew - Reduce by 30%

Case Officer:Mr S. Downing 0208 8379 3845 Ward: Bush Hill Park Conservation Area: Enfield Town Conservation Area

Application No.:P13-00205NMA

Decision: AGREED Decision date: 06-Mar-2013 Level: Delegated Applicant’s Name: Adam Pelled Location: 33, ESSEX ROAD, ENFIELD, EN2 6UA

Proposal: Non material amendment to allow an additional rooflight to ground floor rear extension approved under ref: P12-02110PLA.

Case Officer:Mr R. Singleton 0208 8379 3837 Ward: Grange Conservation Area: Southgate Green Conservation Area.

adj. Southgate Green Conservation Area Application No.:P13-00207TRE

Decision: GRANTED Decision date: 28-Mar-2013 Level: Delegated Applicant’s Name: Edna Ede Location: GLEAMS, 9, CANNON HILL, LONDON, N14 7DJ

Proposal: Work to 1 Cherry tree in Southgate Green Conservation Area - Reduce by 50%.

Case Officer:Mr S. Downing 0208 8379 3845 Ward: Southgate Green Conservation Area: Winchmore Hill Green Conservation Area.


Decision: GRANTED WITH CONDITIONS Decision date: 28-Mar-2013 Level: Delegated Applicant’s Name: P Patel, Dentist & Osteopath on the Hill Location: 4, WADES HILL, LONDON, N21 1BG

Proposal: Installation of 1 x non illuminated fascia sign, 1 x sign to side gate and 1 x non illuminated projecting sign.

Case Officer:Mrs J. Rebairo 0208 8379 3822 Ward: Winchmore Hill Conservation Area: Southgate Green Conservation Area.


28

Decision: GRANTED WITH CONDITIONS Decision date: 21-Mar-2013 Level: Delegated Applicant’s Name: TRAGUS LTD Location: 45-46, CANNON HILL, LONDON, N14 6LH

Proposal: Replacement of 2 x externally-illuminated fascia signs and 1 x hanging sign (RETROSPECTIVE).

Case Officer:Mrs J. Rebairo 0208 8379 3822 Ward: Southgate Green Conservation Area: Meadway Conservation Area


Decision: GRANTED WITH CONDITIONS Decision date: 12-Mar-2013 Level: Delegated Applicant’s Name: Mr Barrett Location: 19, THE RIDGEWAY, LONDON, N14 6NX

Proposal: Erection of chimney stack to roof at side.

Case Officer:Ms H. Brown 0208 8379 4019 Ward: Southgate Green Conservation Area: Enfield Lock Conservation Area.


Decision: REFUSED Decision date: 13-Mar-2013 Level: Delegated Applicant’s Name: Will Bridges, National Grid Location: BRIMSDOWN SUBSTATION, MOLLISON AVENUE, ENFIELD, EN3 7NR

Proposal: Change of use of land east of site from open space/scrubland to operational land involving the relocation of footpath and part boundary line and erection of new boundary fencing (2.4m high steel palisade fence with 4m high electric fence to rear).

Case Officer:Mr R. Singleton 0208 8379 3837 Ward: Enfield Highway Enfield Lock Conservation Area: Hadley Wood Conservation Area.


Decision: GRANTED WITH CONDITIONS Decision date: 20-Mar-2013 Level: Delegated Applicant’s Name: M BROWN Location: 8, ALDERWOOD MEWS, BARNET, EN4 0ED

Proposal: Single storey rear extension, involving rooms in roof with dormers to front and rear.

Case Officer:Mr A. Jarratt 0208 8379 3842 Ward: Cockfosters Conservation Area: Grange Park Conservation Area


Decision: GRANTED WITH CONDITIONS Decision date: 26-Mar-2013 Level: Delegated Applicant’s Name: John Georgiades Location: 40, OLD PARK RIDINGS, LONDON, N21 2ES

Proposal: Erection of single storey rear extension to existing side garage, construction of rear steps and including replacement of roof to pitch roof over and doors to front, renewal of hard standing and walls to front.

29

Case Officer:Mr A. Jarratt 0208 8379 3842 Ward: Grange Conservation Area: The Lakes Conservation Area

Application No.:TCA/10/0076

Decision: GRANTED Decision date: 04-Mar-2013 Level: Delegated Applicant’s Name: Miss N Broady Location: 68A, FOX LANE, LONDON, N13 4AR

Proposal: Work to trees in the Lakes Estate Conservation Area- 1 x Sycamore, 1 x Birch and 1 x conifer - Fell.

Case Officer:Mr S. Downing 0208 8379 3845 Ward: Winchmore Hill Conservation Area: Winchmore Hill Green Conservation Area.


Decision: GRANTED Decision date: 04-Mar-2013 Level: Delegated Applicant’s Name: Christine Holder Location: 45, CHURCH HILL, LONDON, N21 1LE

Proposal: Work to trees in winchmore hill conservation area:- 1 x Sycamore and 1x Laurel- reduce by 30%; 1 x Lilac- Remove 1 limb and 1 Conifer- reduce by 5 %.

Case Officer:Mr S. Downing 0208 8379 3845 Ward: Winchmore Hill Conservation Area: Southgate Circus Conservation Area

Application No.:P13-00132PRI

Decision: REFUSED Decision date: 08-Mar-2013 Level: Delegated Applicant’s Name: Harlequin Group Location: SITE:- PUBLIC FOOTPATH ADJACENT TO, 2, CHASE SIDE, LONDON, N14 6JT

Proposal: Installation of a BT Cabinet.

Case Officer:Mr N. Catherall 0208 8379 3833 Ward: Southgate Conservation Area: Bush Hill Park Conservation Area.


Decision: GRANTED Decision date: 04-Mar-2013 Level: Delegated Applicant’s Name: Simon Whorwood, Haywards Mowing Location: 15A, QUEEN ANNES GARDENS, ENFIELD, EN1 2JW

Proposal: Fell 3 x Elwoods Conifer trees at front.

Case Officer:Mr S. Downing 0208 8379 3845 Ward: Bush Hill Park Conservation Area: Grange Park Conservation Area


Decision: GRANTED Decision date: 04-Mar-2013 Level: Delegated Applicant’s Name: Kay Taylor, Marsishal Thompson Group Location: 3, THE GRANGEWAY, LONDON, N21 2HB

Proposal: Removal of a Hazel and Atlas Cedar tree in The Grange Park Conservation Area

30

Case Officer:Mr S. Downing 0208 8379 3845 Ward: Grange Conservation Area: Forty Hill Conservation Area.

adj. Forty Hill Conservation Area. Application No.:P13-00078PLA

Decision: GRANTED WITH CONDITIONS Decision date: 14-Mar-2013 Level: Delegated Applicant’s Name: Mr David Mills, A. J. Mills Location: CLOCKHOUSE NURSERY, FORTY HILL, ENFIELD, EN2 9EU

Proposal: Renewal of unimplemented permission granted under ref: TP/08/1616 for the erection of replacement single storey building for use as a sales, display and checkout area.

Case Officer:Mrs S.L. Davidson 0208 8379 3841 Ward: Chase Conservation Area: Grange Park Conservation Area


Decision: GRANTED WITH CONDITIONS Decision date: 20-Mar-2013 Level: Delegated Applicant’s Name: Mr & Mrs Kent Location: 16, OLD PARK RIDINGS, LONDON, N21 2EU

Proposal: Part single, part 2-storey rear extension.

Case Officer:Mr R. Singleton 0208 8379 3837 Ward: Grange Conservation Area: Southgate Green Conservation Area.


Decision: GRANTED Decision date: 04-Mar-2013 Level: Delegated Applicant’s Name: Headteacher Location: ST MONICAS PRIMARY SCHOOL, CANNON ROAD, LONDON, N14 7HE

Proposal: Work to trees in Southgate Green Conservation Area- 2 x Sycamore- fell; 2 x Pear - fell; 3 x Sycamore - reduce overhang to main crown and thin by 20%.

Case Officer:Mr S. Downing 0208 8379 3845 Ward: Southgate Green Conservation Area: Highlands Conservation Area.


Decision: GRANTED Decision date: 04-Mar-2013 Level: Delegated Applicant’s Name: Sheila Bowden, Ian Gibbs Estate Agents Location: BLACKWELL CLOSE, ENFIELD, N21 1UL

Proposal: Works to trees in Highlands Conservation Area - 1 x Oak - lift clear of lawn; 1 x Oak - thin by 20% and trim back by 15%; 1 x Oak - remove vertical branch over road; 1 x lime- lift low branches to 3m and deadwood; 1 x Horse Chestnut - fell; 4 x Planes - reduce lateral branches overhanging by 20%; 1 x Oak - thin bough.

Case Officer:Mr S. Downing 0208 8379 3845 Ward: Southgate Conservation Area: Highlands Conservation Area.


31

Decision: GRANTED Decision date: 04-Mar-2013 Level: Delegated Applicant’s Name: Sheila Bowden, Ian Gibbs Estate Agents Location: BLACKWELL CLOSE, ENFIELD, N21 1UL

Proposal: Works to trees in Highlands Conservation Area - Fell 1 x Ash and deadwood 12 x Oaks, 3 x Horse Chestnut, 1 x Pink Chestnut and 2 x Sycamore.

Case Officer:Mr S. Downing 0208 8379 3845 Ward: Southgate Conservation Area: Southgate Green Conservation Area.


Decision: GRANTED Decision date: 28-Mar-2013 Level: Delegated Applicant’s Name: Mr Shaun Rigg (Trustee) Location: THE WALKER CRICKET GROUND, 175, WATERFALL ROAD, LONDON, N14 7JZ

Proposal: Work to trees covered by LBE Order No 230:- Group of trees (G8)- Pollard evergreen by 3m and reduce crown Oak (T12) by 10%.

Case Officer:Mr S. Downing 0208 8379 3845 Ward: Southgate Conservation Area: Hadley Wood Conservation Area.


Decision: WITHDRAWN Decision date: 05-Mar-2013 Level: Delegated Applicant’s Name: Mrs Jane Exall Location: 33, LANCASTER AVENUE, BARNET, EN4 0EP

Proposal: Works to trees covered by Tree Preservation Order No 87 (1979) - 2 x Lime - Fell, 2 x Sycamore - 1 x Fell and 1 x Reduce by 30%, 1 x Maple - Fell.

Case Officer:Mr S. Downing 0208 8379 3845 Ward: Cockfosters Conservation Area: Hadley Wood Conservation Area.


Decision: GRANTED Decision date: 04-Mar-2013 Level: Delegated Applicant’s Name: Christopher Marino Location: 3, DOUGLAS CLOSE, BARNET, EN4 0AQ

Proposal: Remove a conifer tree in a Conservation Area.

Case Officer:Mr S. Downing 0208 8379 3845 Ward: Cockfosters Conservation Area: Bush Hill Park Conservation Area.


Decision: GRANTED Decision date: 04-Mar-2013 Level: Delegated Applicant’s Name: Simon Whorwood, Haywards Mowing Location: ROYAL COURT, 17, QUEEN ANNES GARDENS, ENFIELD, EN1 2JE

Proposal: Works to 1 x lime, 1 x yew and 1 x sycamore at front comprising reduction in height by one third and balance remaining crowns.

Case Officer:Mr S. Downing 0208 8379 3845

32

Ward: Bush Hill Park Conservation Area: Meadway Conservation Area


Decision: GRANTED WITH CONDITIONS Decision date: 21-Mar-2013 Level: Delegated Applicant’s Name: Susan Wilkie Location: 49, MEADWAY, LONDON, N14 6NJ

Proposal: Replacement of original bay window facing street with wooden window of same specification except double glazed panes of glass.

Case Officer:Ms H. Brown 0208 8379 4019 Ward: Southgate Conservation Area: Forty Hill Conservation Area.


Decision: WITHDRAWN Decision date: 04-Mar-2013 Level: Delegated Applicant’s Name: Marishal Thompson Group Location: LONGBOURN, FORTY HILL, ENFIELD, EN2 9EU

Proposal: Work to trees in Forty Hill Conservation Area:- 1 x Yew and 1 x Beech- Fell.

Case Officer:Mr S. Downing 0208 8379 3845 Ward: Chase Conservation Area: Southgate Green Conservation Area.


Decision: WITHDRAWN Decision date: 05-Mar-2013 Level: Delegated Applicant’s Name: Freedom Group of Companies, Stowland Division Location: ELECTRICITY SUB STATION, YORK COURT, 138, ALDERMANS HILL, LONDON, N13 4QG

Proposal: Works to tree covered by Tree Preservation Order LBE No 1 (1966) 1 x Ash - Fell



Decision: GRANTED Decision date: 04-Mar-2013 Level: Delegated Applicant’s Name: Mrs Deacock Location: Cherry Cottage, The Green, London, N14 6EN

Proposal: Reduce and shape 1 Oak by 30% and thin by 10%.

Case Officer:Mr S. Downing 0208 8379 3845 Ward: Southgate Green Conservation Area: Winchmore Hill Green Conservation Area.

Application No.:P13-00603PRE

Decision: Pre-application advice given Decision date: 11-Mar-2013 Level: Delegated Applicant’s Name: Sinead McCaghy Location: Land bewteen St Pauls Church & 56 Church Hill Road, (rear of) 22, BRANSCOMBE GARDENS, LONDON, N21 3BN

Proposal: Erection of a new dwelling.

Case Officer:Mr C. Ahmet 0208 8379 3926 Ward: Winchmore Hill

33

Conservation Area: Trent Park Conservation Area.

Application No.:P13-00695DEP

Decision: APPROVED Decision date: 15-Mar-2013 Level: Delegated Applicant’s Name: Mr Ben Davies, Adventure Forest Ltd, t/a Go Ape Location: TRENT PARK, COCKFOSTERS ROAD, BARNET, EN4 0PS

Proposal: Details submitted to ref P12-02013PLA for Archaeological Watching Brief (condition 10) for a High wire adventure course and associated equipment (in part constructed), shelter and training area (constructed) at Church Wood to the south and south east of Trent Park cafe and car park, together with construction of a proposed reception cabin.

Case Officer:Ms K. Perry 0208 8379 3853 Ward: Cockfosters Conservation Area: Hadley Wood Conservation Area.

Application No.:P13-00595PRI

Decision: WITHDRAWN Decision date: 13-Mar-2013 Level: Delegated Applicant’s Name: Harlequin Group Location: SITE:- Public footpath outside 33, CRESCENT WEST, opposite 18 CRESECENT WEST, BARNET, EN4 0EJ

Proposal: Installation of BT cabinet.

Case Officer:Ms R. Kaur 0208 8379 6441 Ward: Cockfosters Conservation Area: Southgate Green Conservation Area.


Decision: GRANTED Decision date: 28-Mar-2013 Level: Delegated Applicant’s Name: Mr Simon O'Shea, SOS Gardens Location: PUBLIC HOUSE, 22, THE GREEN, LONDON, N14 6EN

Proposal: Work to trees covered by Southgate Green Conservation Area- 1 x Willow tree crown reduce by 3m and 3 x Conifer trees crown lift to 3m and remove dead, dying and dangerous branches.



Decision: GRANTED WITH CONDITIONS Decision date: 28-Mar-2013 Level: Delegated Applicant’s Name: London Tree Surgeons Location: 25, LULWORTH COURT, 13, CANNON HILL, LONDON, N14 7DJ

Proposal: 1 x Horse Chestnut tree covered by TPO order No:93- remove the entire upper limb, this 20% of the entire canopy.

Case Officer:Mr S. Downing 0208 8379 3845 Ward: Southgate Green Conservation Area: Highlands Conservation Area.

34


Decision: GRANTED Decision date: 28-Mar-2013 Level: Delegated Applicant’s Name: simon chard, pinnacle-psg Location: 16, BANTING DRIVE, LONDON, N21 1SL

Proposal: Works to a Sycamore tree in the Highlands Conservation Area - fell and poison.

Case Officer:Mr S. Downing 0208 8379 3845 Ward: Southgate Conservation Area: Highlands Conservation Area.


Decision: GRANTED Decision date: 28-Mar-2013 Level: Delegated Applicant’s Name: simon chard, pinnacle-psg Location: 15, BANTING DRIVE, LONDON, N21 1SL

Proposal: Works to a Chestnut and large Ash tree in the Highlands Conservation Area - fell and poison.

Case Officer:Mr S. Downing 0208 8379 3845 Ward: Southgate Conservation Area: Enfield Town Conservation Area

Application No.:P13-00363LDC

Decision: REFUSED Decision date: 20-Mar-2013 Level: Delegated Applicant’s Name: Monica Smith Location: 91, HOLLY WALK, ENFIELD, EN2 6QB

Proposal: Single storey rear extension.

Case Officer:Mr R. Singleton 0208 8379 3837 Ward: Town Conservation Area: Bush Hill Park Conservation Area.


Decision: GRANTED WITH CONDITIONS Decision date: 28-Mar-2013 Level: Delegated Applicant’s Name: Mrs Jane Heatley Location: 10, WOODLEA LODGE, 72, WELLINGTON ROAD, ENFIELD, EN1 2NW

Proposal: Works to 1 beech tree covered by Order No(128) 1981 - Reduce & shape crown by 20%, thin by 15% and remove deadwood.

Case Officer:Mr S. Downing 0208 8379 3845 Ward: Bush Hill Park

35

Appeals in respect of conservation areas. FROM: 28/02/13 TO: 28/03/12

There were no appeal decisions in conservation areas.

Decisions in Respect of Listed Buildings FROM: 28/02/13 TO: 28/03/12

Application No.:P13-00193TRE LocallyListed Building

Decision: GRANTED Decision date: 04-Mar-2013 Applicant’s Name: London Diocesan Fund Level: Delegated Location: ST PAULS VICARAGE, CHURCH HILL, LONDON, N21 1JA

Proposal: Works to trees in the Winchmore Hill Green Conservation Area: 1 x Ash to fell and grind out stump, 3 x Holly trees reduce height by 3m, reduce spread to balance and crown lift to 2.5m, 1 x Oak tree remove all deadwood, reduce crown by 20% where required to balance, 1 x Oak/Horse Chestnut to be felled, 1 x Pear and 2 x False Acacia trees crown reduce by 20%, crown thin by 15%removing epicormic to crown break and remove deadwood, 1 x Holly reduce height by 3m to balance and prune any unruly spread to balance and 1 x Yew reduce crown overhanging pavement and road by 25% and crown lift to 2.5m.

Case Officer:Mr S. Downing 0208 8379 3845 Application No.:TPO/11/0088 Grade II

Decision: WITHDRAWN Decision date: 05-Mar-2013 Applicant’s Name: Amina Tareen Level: Delegated Location: 4, CANNON HILL, LONDON, N14 7HG

Proposal: Deadwood Lime tree covered by LBE Order No. 1.

Case Officer:Mr S. Downing 0208 8379 3845 Application No.:P13-00376TRE Grade II

Decision: GRANTED Decision date: 28-Mar-2013 Applicant’s Name: Mr Simon O'Shea, SOS Gardens

Level: Delegated

Location: PUBLIC HOUSE, 22, THE GREEN, LONDON, N14 6EN

Proposal: Work to trees covered by Southgate Green Conservation Area- 1 x Willow tree crown reduce by 3m and 3 x Conifer trees crown lift to 3m and remove dead, dying and dangerous branches.

Case Officer:Mr S. Downing 0208 8379 3845 Application No.:P12-02324PRE Grade II

Decision: Pre-application advice given Decision date: 14-Mar-2013

36

Applicant’s Name: Darren Carroll, Tibbalds Planning and Urban Design

Level: Delegated

Location: MIDDLESEX UNIVERSITY, QUEENSWAY, ENFIELD, EN3 4SA

Proposal: Proposed redevelopment of site for residential led mixed use development.

Case Officer:Mrs S.L. Davidson 0208 8379 3841 Application No.:P12-02677PLA Grade II

Decision: GRANTED WITH CONDITIONS Decision date: 05-Mar-2013 Applicant’s Name: London Borough of Enfield

Level: Planning Committee

Location: Former Middlesex university Campus, No's 188-230 (even) (excluding No.228), Ponders End High Street and Ponders End Library and associated parking area, College Court, Enfield EN3.

Proposal: Demolition of existing buildings on site (excluding the Broadbent Building, Gymnasium, Caretakers Cottage, multi storey car park to the Queensway frontage and 198 High Street) and the redevelopment of the site to provide a mix of residential (Class C3), business (Class B1), retail (Classes A1-A4) and community uses (Class D1), hard and soft landscaping and open space, new connection (vehicle and pedestrian) to High Street via College Court, retention and alteration of existing accesses to Queensway, car and cycle parking (including alterations to car parking arrangements within College Court) and all necessary supporting works and facilities, including an energy centre; the retention, refurbishment and extension of the listed Broadbent building, retention and refurbishment of the associated caretakers cottage and gymnasium to provide up to 43 residential units, 2,141sq.m (GIA) of commercial/live work floor space (Class B1) and 427sqm (GIA) of community use (OUTLINE with some matters reserved - Access).

Case Officer:Mrs S.L. Davidson 0208 8379 3841 Application No.:P13-00267TRE Grade II

Decision: GRANTED WITH CONDITIONS Decision date: 28-Mar-2013 Applicant’s Name: Mr Simon Belofsky, IDA Nurseries Ltd

Level: Delegated

Location: HYMUS HOUSE, BROWNING ROAD, ENFIELD, EN2 0EF

Proposal: Works to oak tree covered by TPO No. (339) 201, 8 x Lime trees to be pruned 30% 3x Ribineas need pruning ,1 x yew tree, 30% 1 x Hawthorn needs pruning, 30% 1 x large Ash tree needs pruning 30%.

Case Officer:Mr S. Downing 0208 8379 3845 Application No.:P13-00078PLA Local Interest, Listed Building Links (walls

etc) Decision: GRANTED WITH CONDITIONS Decision date: 14-Mar-2013 Applicant’s Name: Mr David Mills, A. J. Mills Level: Delegated Location: CLOCKHOUSE NURSERY, FORTY HILL, ENFIELD, EN2 9EU

Proposal: Renewal of unimplemented permission granted under ref: TP/08/1616 for the erection of replacement single storey building for use as a sales, display and checkout

37

area. Case Officer:Mrs S.L. Davidson 0208 8379 3841 Application No.:TCA/10/0079 Grade II

Decision: WITHDRAWN Decision date: 04-Mar-2013 Applicant’s Name: Marishal Thompson Group

Level: Delegated

Location: LONGBOURN, FORTY HILL, ENFIELD, EN2 9EU

Proposal: Work to trees in Forty Hill Conservation Area:- 1 x Yew and 1 x Beech- Fell.

Case Officer:Mr S. Downing 0208 8379 3845 Application No.:P13-00324TRE Grade II

Decision: GRANTED Decision date: 04-Mar-2013 Applicant’s Name: Mr Andrew Turvey Level: Delegated Location: MYDDELTON HOUSE, BULLS CROSS, ENFIELD, EN2 9HG

Proposal: Work to Acer tree covered by TPO order no:2 (1958) - fell

Case Officer:Mr S. Downing 0208 8379 3845 Application No.:P12-02682PLA Grade II*

Decision: WITHDRAWN PRE-REGISTRATION

Decision date: 04-Mar-2013

Applicant’s Name: Fikret Akgundogdu Level: Delegated Location: 151, Bramley Road, Enfield, N14 4UT

Proposal: Installation of canopy to shopfront.

Case Officer:Ms T. Pettit 0208 8379 3827

Appeals in respect of listed buildings. FROM: 28/02/13 TO: 28/03/12

There were no appeal decisions in respect to listed buildings.

38

E

CONSERVATION ADVISORY GROUP

MEETING DATES FOR THE 2012/2013 MUNICIPAL YEAR

6/6/12 Room 6 11/7/12 Room 2 7/8/12 Conf Room 4/9/12 Conf Room 2/10/12 Conf Room 6/11/12 Conf Room 28/11/12 Conf Room 8/1/13 Room 1 5/2/13 Room 2 6/3/13 Room 1 2/4/13 Conf Room 30/4/13 Room 1 The start time of the meeting is 7.00pm although the room is booked from 5.30pm for setting up of the plans etc. Everyone will be informed of any changes in the date or venue as soon as they occur.

conservation advisory group - enfield advisory group/20130402/agenda...dr chris jephcott said that...

Documents