consensus on recording of gas permeable contact lens...

21
Consensus on Recording of Gas Permeable Contact Lens Fit James S Wolffsohn 1 Eef van der Worp 2 John de Brabander 3 and the GP Consensus Group 1 Ophthalmic Research Group, Life and Health Sciences, Aston University, United Kingdom BSc MBA PhD FAAO FBCLA 2 University of Maastricht, Netherlands BSc PhD FAAO FBCLA 3 University of Maastricht, Netherlands MSc PhD FAAO

Upload: others

Post on 04-Jun-2020

5 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Consensus on Recording of Gas Permeable Contact Lens Fiteprints.aston.ac.uk/19272/1/Consensus_on_recording_of... · 2017-02-07 · Abstract Purpose: To develop a new schematic scheme

ConsensusonRecordingofGasPermeableContactLensFit

JamesSWolffsohn1EefvanderWorp2 JohndeBrabander3

andtheGPConsensusGroup

1Ophthalmic Research Group, Life and Health Sciences, Aston University, United Kingdom

BScMBAPhDFAAOFBCLA

2UniversityofMaastricht,NetherlandsBScPhDFAAOFBCLA

3UniversityofMaastricht,NetherlandsMScPhDFAAO

Page 2: Consensus on Recording of Gas Permeable Contact Lens Fiteprints.aston.ac.uk/19272/1/Consensus_on_recording_of... · 2017-02-07 · Abstract Purpose: To develop a new schematic scheme

Abstract

Purpose: Todevelopanewschematicschemeforefficientlyrecordingthekey

parametersofgaspermeablecontactlens(GP)fitsbasedoncurrentconsensus.

Methods: Over100establishedGPfittersandeducatorsmettodiscusstheparameters

proposedineducationalmaterialforevaluatingGPfitandconcludedonthekey

parametersthatshouldberecorded.Theaccuracyandvariabilityofevaluatingthe

fluoresceinpatternofGPfitwasdeterminedbyhaving35experiencedcontactlens

practitionersfromacrosstheworld,grading5imagesofarangeoffitsandthetopographer

simulationofthesamefitsinrandomorderusingtheproposedscheme.Theaccuracyof

thegradingwascomparedtoobjectiveimageanalysisofthefluoresceinintensityofthe

sameimages.

Results: ThekeyinformationtorecordtoadequatelydescribethefitofanGPwas

agreedas:themanufacturer,brandandlensparameters;settlingtime;comfortona5point

scale;centration;movementonblinkona±2scale;andthePrimaryFluoresceinPatternin

thecentral,mid‐peripheralandedgeregionsofthelensaveragedalongthehorizontaland

verticallensaxes,ona±2scale.Onaverage50‐60%ofpractitionersselectedthemedian

gradewhensubjectivelyratingfluoresceinintensityandthiswascorrelatedtoobjective

quantification(r=0.602,p<0.001).Objectivegradingsuggestinghorizontalmedian

fluoresceinintensitywasgenerallysymmetrical,aswastheverticalmeridian,butthiswas

notthecaseforsubjectivegrading.Simulatedfluoresceinpatternsweresubjectivelyand

objectivelygradedasbeinglessintensethanrealphotographs(p<0.01).

Conclusion: GPfitrecordingcanbestandardisedandsimplifiedtoenhanceGPpractice.

Keywords: rigidgaspermeablecontactlenses(RGP);fittingcharacteristics;lens

evaluation;recordkeeping;fluoresceinpatternobservation

Page 3: Consensus on Recording of Gas Permeable Contact Lens Fiteprints.aston.ac.uk/19272/1/Consensus_on_recording_of... · 2017-02-07 · Abstract Purpose: To develop a new schematic scheme

Introduction

Accuraterecordkeepingwhenfittingcontactlensesisessentialformedico‐legalprotection

aswellastoallowinformedrefittingdecisionstobemadeinthefuture.Thisisparticularly

importantiffollow‐upcareisundertakenbyadifferenteyecarepractitioner.Whilesoft

lensesfitevaluationhasbeenanalysedobjectively,andasimplifiedbutcomprehensive

schematicforrecordingthefindingshasbeendeveloped,1nosuchresearchhasbeen

publishedongaspermeablecontactlenses(GPs).

Unlikesoftlenseswhichlargelyconformtothecontouroftheocularsurface,GPfitcanbe

evaluatedbythepatternoffluoresceinunderthelens.Evaluationofthelensfitwith

fluoresceinhasbeenusedeversincerigidlensescameontothemarketinthe1950s.Ithas

beenproventobeveryusefulinclinicalpracticetoidentifywherethelenscomeson

contactwiththecornealsurface(termed‘touch’),althoughthehumaneyeisonlyableto

detectfluoresceinlayerswithathicknessofatleast20μm.2,3Thisresultsintearlayers

thinnerthan20μmappeardark.Forthisreasonforinstance,itisdifficulttofit

orthokeratologylensesrelyingonfluoresceinpatternsalone.4

SuboptimallensfithasbeenproventobeofinfluenceoncomfortofGPlenswear.Ina

studyattheUniversityofMaastrichtitwasfoundthatcomfortimprovedoveraperiodof

threemonthsintheoptimallensfitgroup,butnotinthesub‐optimallensfitgroup.The

differenceafterthreemonthsbetweenthesetwogroupswas2ona10pointscale;a

statisticallyandmostprobablyclinicallysignificantdifference.5

Oneofthefewcomplicationsthatistypicalfor,andexclusivelyseenin,GPlenswearis3‐

Page 4: Consensus on Recording of Gas Permeable Contact Lens Fiteprints.aston.ac.uk/19272/1/Consensus_on_recording_of... · 2017-02-07 · Abstract Purpose: To develop a new schematic scheme

and9‐o’clockstaining.Theprevalenceof3‐and9‐o’clockstainingisreportedtobeupto

80%,ofwhich10‐15%isestimatedtobeofclinicalsignificance.Inareviewpaper,fiveout

ofthetotalofeleventreatmentoptionstodecreaseorremedy3‐and9‐o’clockstaining

identifiedintheacademicliteraturewererelatedtolensparameters,threetolens

performance.6Henceimprovinglensfit,byfollowingtheshapeofthecorneamoreclosely,

couldremedytheconditionof3‐and9‐o’clockstaining.7

Cornealtopographycouldbebeneficialinthisprocess,butfluoresceinevaluationiscrucial

inthefinaljudgmentofthelensfit.Inaddition,suboptimalGPlensfitleadstocorneal

warpage.8‐10 The mean recovery time for corneal warpage in GP lens wearers (as assessed by a

topography change less than 0.5 D) is 8.8 ± 6.8 weeks.12 The resting position of the lens on the

cornea seems to play an important role; the topography of warped corneas is usually

characterised by a relative flattening of the cornea underlying the GP contact lens in its resting

position. Lenses that ride high, for example, produce flattening superiorly and result in a

relatively steeper contour inferiorly.11

Aswellasthefluoresceinpattern,otheraspectsofGPfithavealsobeenproposedtobe

importanttooptimisedfittingsuchascentrationandcoverage,lidattachmentandsurface

wettability.13‐16However,thereislittleevidenceintheacademicliteratureastowhichof

theseparametersindependentlycontributetocomfortable,healthyGPlenswear.Unlike

softlenses,17,18therearenostudiesmodellinghowlensdesign,materialandanterioreye

parametersinfluencelensmovement.

Page 5: Consensus on Recording of Gas Permeable Contact Lens Fiteprints.aston.ac.uk/19272/1/Consensus_on_recording_of... · 2017-02-07 · Abstract Purpose: To develop a new schematic scheme

AnaddedlevelofcomplexityresultsfromthedynamicnatureofanGPfit,withthe

movementonblinktypicallyanorderofmagnitudelargerthanthatofasoftcontactlens.

Movementofalensiscriticaltoprovidesufficientoxygenexchangeoverthecorneal

surfaceaswellastoremovetrappeddebris,inflammatorycells,andothertearcomponents

thatwouldotherwiseaccumulateunderthelens.19Thetearlayerbetweenthecontactlens

andcorneaalsoreducethefrictionbetweenthesurfaces,avoidingsignificantmechanical

interaction.Whilesoftlenseswithlimitedmobilityhavebeenshowntohaveamore

negativeimpactonocularphysiologythanwellfittingsoftlenses,20thisisnotwell

researchedforGPs.ThisisprobablybecausetearexchangebeneathanGPistypically15‐

16%comparedto1‐2%forsoftlenses,19,21althoughtearmixingwithdifferingamountsof

lensmovementdoesnotseemtohavebeenexamined.

Therefore,toassessalltheseparameterstakesasignificantamountoftime.Time

pressuresofclinicalpracticeandalackofconsensusastothekeyparametersthatneedto

beoptimisedtoachieveanappropriateGPfitresultsinvariedandsometimesminimal

documentationofGPfitcharacteristics.Notationssuchas“good”or“adequate”canbe

highlysubjectiveandoflimiteduseinfuturepatientaftercare.Thisisespeciallythecasein

largepracticeswithmultipleeyecarespecialists,orwhencommunicatingwithcolleagues

orlensmanufacturer/consultants.Therefore,therelativeimportanceofcontactlensfit

characteristicsshouldbedecidedupontodevelopatimeefficient,butsufficientlydetailed,

descriptionoflensperformanceforrecordinginclinicalpractice.

ThisstudyaimedtogainconsensusfromGPpractitionersacrosstheworldastothekey

parametersthatshouldbeobservedandrecordedandcharacterizedtocharacterize

Page 6: Consensus on Recording of Gas Permeable Contact Lens Fiteprints.aston.ac.uk/19272/1/Consensus_on_recording_of... · 2017-02-07 · Abstract Purpose: To develop a new schematic scheme

cornealGPcontactlensfit.Inaddition,practitioner’sabilitytosubjectivelyscale

fluoresceinpatternswasassessedagainstobjectiveimageanalysis.Thisallowedfora

simplifiedmethodofrecordingtheGPlensfitoftrialedlensesinclinicalpracticetobe

devised.

Page 7: Consensus on Recording of Gas Permeable Contact Lens Fiteprints.aston.ac.uk/19272/1/Consensus_on_recording_of... · 2017-02-07 · Abstract Purpose: To develop a new schematic scheme

Method

Over one hundred established GP fitters and educators met to discuss the parameters

proposed in educational material for evaluating GP fit and concluded on the key

parameters that should be recorded. These focus groups were held in 2011‐13 at the

British Contact Lens Association Conference, Netherlands Contact Lens Conference and

British Committee of Contact Lens Educators (BUCCLE). In addition, members of the

International Association of Contact Lens Educators (IACLE) and the Association of

Optometric Contact Lens Educators (AOCLE) were contacted for their opinions and

comment.

Thefocusgroupswerefacilitatedbytheauthorstodiscussallelementsthatcontributeto

theGPfitdecisionmakingprocessandtodebateoverthoseelementsthatarecriticaltothe

decisiontomodifylensparameters.Itwasemphasisedthatwhilemakingclinicaldecisions

cannotbeprescriptiveonalimitedrangeoffindingsandtheGPfittedshouldbebasedon

clinical interpretation and experience, the recording of the key parameters could be

standardisedandterminologyemotiveofclinicaldecisions,suchas“excessive”,werehence

avoided. Observation should also be totally independent of clinical consequences, as

somethingisn’tnecessarily‘worse’becauseadifferenttreatmentplanisrequired.

TheaccuracyandvariabilityofevaluatingthefluoresceinpatternofcentraltheGPfitusing

the scheme proposed and agreed on by the consensus groups was determined by 35

experienced GP practitioners from around the world using five photographic images

capturedthroughayellowfilterchosentorepresentarangeofsteep‐to‐flatandspherical‐

to‐toricfitsandthefivetopographersimulationsofthesamefitswiththeMedmontE300

Page 8: Consensus on Recording of Gas Permeable Contact Lens Fiteprints.aston.ac.uk/19272/1/Consensus_on_recording_of... · 2017-02-07 · Abstract Purpose: To develop a new schematic scheme

corneal topographyer (Medmont Ltd, Melbourne, Australia). These were presented in

randomorderandthepractitionerswerenotawarethatthetopographersimulationswere

pairedwithphotographsof lens fits toavoidbias in theirgrading.Thegradedregionsof

thephotographsandsimulationswereobjectivelyanalysedusingbespokeLabviewVision

software (National Instruments, Austin, Texas, USA) using the 256 point 8 bit) intensity

scale for green light for comparisonwith the average practitioner grading. Concordance

was assessed between practitioners as to the percentage selecting themedian grade for

each corneal zone. The average grade was correlated to the image analysis objectively

measured green intensity across all zones and meridians using Spearman’s rank

correlation.

Page 9: Consensus on Recording of Gas Permeable Contact Lens Fiteprints.aston.ac.uk/19272/1/Consensus_on_recording_of... · 2017-02-07 · Abstract Purpose: To develop a new schematic scheme

Results

Itwasagreedintheworkshopthatthefollowingshouldberecordedwhenfittingor

checkinganGPcontactlensfit:

Lensspecificationsincludingthelensdesignandmanufacturer,basecurvesand

associateddiametersandlenspower(aswellascentrethickness,edgeliftdesign,

material,colourandanyspecialrequestssuchasprism,truncationor

lenticularizationifnotpreviouslyrecordedinthenotes)Evenifthepatientwas

previouslyfittedinthepractice,itisoftennotclearwhichlensthepatientis

wearingifitisnotrecordedalongwiththelensfitevaluation.

Thesettlingtimeinminutes,whichshouldbesufficientforinitialadaptationtohave

occurred,anyinducedtearingtohavesubsidedandthelenstobecomfortable.The

consensuswasthat20minutesshouldmeetthesecriteriainmostcases.Ifthisisnot

thecase,thelensfitrecordedwillnotberepresentativeofthetruefit,andifthelens

doesnotfullysettle,thenitisunlikelythelenswouldbeprescribed.

Comfortona0(poor)to4(perfect)scale.The5pointrangewasdeterminedtobe

sufficienttodifferentiatebetweencomfortstates,withoutscalegradesbeing

redundant.Thismatchesfamiliargradingscaleincrements,althoughinreverseas

askingapatientaboutanydiscomforthasthepotentialtonegativelyinfluencethe

patientsreflectiononthelensfittingexperience.

Whitediffuselighttoevaluate:

o Centration‐asthelensismobile,theamountofdecentrationwillchange

withtimeaftereachblink,sotomakeclinicaldecisions,centrationwouldbe

notedas‘L’toindicatetheGPiscrossingthelimbusor‘P’whentheoptic

Page 10: Consensus on Recording of Gas Permeable Contact Lens Fiteprints.aston.ac.uk/19272/1/Consensus_on_recording_of... · 2017-02-07 · Abstract Purpose: To develop a new schematic scheme

zoneencroachesacrossthepupilindimlight(mesopicconditions),together

withthedirection;otherwisea‘C’couldindicateadequatecentration.

Coveragewasfelttobelargelycoveredbycentrationindicators,withan‘X’

denotingthediameterisinsufficientfortheopticzonetoencompassthe

pupilthroughouttheinter‐blinkperiod.

o Movement–theamountofmovementonblinkshouldberecordedona‐2to

+2scale:

+2: >2mmmovement

+1 1.6to2.0mmmovement

0 1.0to1.5mmmovement

‐1 0.5to0.9mmmovement

‐2 <0.5mmmovement

Fluoresceinassessment–sodiumfluoresceinshouldbeappliedusingafluoretwithexcess

salineremoved22ideallytothetemporalsuperiorconjunctivatomaximiselongevityonthe

ocularsurfaceandtheGPlensevaluatedwhencentred,afterafewblinks.Ayellowfilter

shouldbeusedinfrontoftheobservationsystemtooptimallyviewthefluorescein

fluorescence.22Whilesomepractitionersliketoevaluatethelensinitsrestingposition

afterablinkaswell,thelensparametersaretraditionallychosentoconformwiththe

centralcorneaandifthelensistoofardecentredfromthecentralcornea,itsparameters

shouldbealteredtoimprovecentration.HencethefluoresceinpatternwhentheGPis

centred(whichcaninvolvelidmanipulationbythepractitioner)shouldberecorded.The

‘PrimaryFluoresceinPattern’shouldbegradedinthetwoprincipalmeridians,recording

thecentral(theinner50%oftheradiusexcepttheverycentrewherethetwomeridians

cross),midperipheral(theouter50%oftheradiusexceptforthefinaledgecurve)and

Page 11: Consensus on Recording of Gas Permeable Contact Lens Fiteprints.aston.ac.uk/19272/1/Consensus_on_recording_of... · 2017-02-07 · Abstract Purpose: To develop a new schematic scheme

edgezone(thefinaledgecurve)fluoresceinintensity(Figure1).IfthePrimaryFluorescein

Patternshowsclearobliqueastigmatism,thefluoresceinintensityshouldbegradedalong

thesemeridiansandanotemadeoftheobliqueangleunderwhichthegradingis

conducted.

Figure1: Fluoresceinpicturewithoverlaidcentral,mid‐peripheralandedgezones,

gradedforfluoresceinintensityona+2to‐2scalealongtheprincipal

meridians(imagecourtesyofRonBeerten,Procornea,TheNetherlands).

Fluoresceinintensitygradingconcordancewasassessedbetweenpractitionersastothe

percentageselectingthemediangradeforeachcornealzone(i.e.theonechosenmost

commonlybythegraders).Fortheinnerringconcordancewas60±11%whichwas

Page 12: Consensus on Recording of Gas Permeable Contact Lens Fiteprints.aston.ac.uk/19272/1/Consensus_on_recording_of... · 2017-02-07 · Abstract Purpose: To develop a new schematic scheme

significantlygreaterthanthemid‐peripheralgrading(48±10%;p=0.036),butnot

significantlydifferentcomparedtotheedgezone(53±10%;p=0.248;Figure2).The

averagegradewascorrelatedtotheimageanalysisobjectivelymeasuredgreenintensity

acrossallzonesandmeridiansusingSpearman’srankcorrelation.Therewasastrong

correlationbetweentheaveragesubjectivegradingandobjectivequantificationof

fluoresceinintensity(r=0.602,p<0.001).

Figure2: Concordance(eyecarepractitionersselectingthemediangrade)inthe

central,mid‐peripheralandedgelenszonesforbothrealphotographsand

simulatedimagesoffluoresceinpatterns.Errorbars=1S.D.n=35

practitionersand5averagesoffluoresceinpatternintensitygradingona+2

to‐2scalealongtheprincipalmeridians.

Page 13: Consensus on Recording of Gas Permeable Contact Lens Fiteprints.aston.ac.uk/19272/1/Consensus_on_recording_of... · 2017-02-07 · Abstract Purpose: To develop a new schematic scheme

Thesubjectivegradingwasnotsymmetricalbetweensuperiorandinferiororbetween

nasalandtemporalfortheinner(F=70.318,p<0.001;F=28.533,P<0.001)ormid

peripheral(F=22.831,p<0.001;F=14.969,P<0.001)fluoresceinintensitygradingzones

(respectively).Howeveredgefluoresceinintensitygradingwassymmetricalbetween

superiorandinferior(F=3.477,p=0.071),althoughnotbetweennasalandtemporal(F=

36.869,P<0.001)zones.Hencethefluoresceinintensitygradesinthesteeperandflatter

meridiansgenerallydifferedoneithersideofthelenscentre.Conversely,objectivegrading

wasnotsignificantlydifferentbetweensuperiorandinferior(F=1.256,p=0.292)or

betweennasalandtemporal(F=0.833,p=0.385)positions.

Simulatedfluoresceinpatternsweresubjectivelygradedsignificantlydifferentlytoreal

photographs(averagegrade‐0.3±1.3vs0.2±1.2;F=47.069,p<0.001),andtherewasan

interactionwithgradingzone(inner‐0.1±1.3vs0.6±1.0;mid‐peripheral‐0.2±1.2vs0.2

±1.2;edge‐0.5±1.5vs‐0.3±1.3;F=5.950,p=0.003)andpositionontheGP(superior0.5

±1.1vs0.4±1.1;temporal‐0.8±1.2vs‐0.1±1.3;inferior0.1±1.3vs0.5±1.1;nasal‐0.8±

1.2vs‐0.2±1.2;F=27.178,p<0.001)respectively.Thecorrelationbetweentheobjective

quantificationoftherealandsimulatedfluoresceinpatternswasalsoonlymoderate(r=

0.256,p=0.048),withthe‘brightness’oftherealphotographsbeinggreater(40.2±

17.2%)thanthesimulatedimages(30.4±24.7%;t‐testp=0.008).

Page 14: Consensus on Recording of Gas Permeable Contact Lens Fiteprints.aston.ac.uk/19272/1/Consensus_on_recording_of... · 2017-02-07 · Abstract Purpose: To develop a new schematic scheme

Discussion

ThisstudysetouttoestablishaconsensusontherecordingofGPlensfit.Whilegradingis

sometimesdirectlyrelatedtomanagement,recordingofGPfittingcharacteristicsshouldbe

informativetothemanagementprocessbasedonclinicaljudgmentusingalltheavailable

information,ratherthandictateit.Basedonclinicalandanecdotalfeedback,consensuswas

reachedontheidealsettlingtimebeing20minutes;theratingofdiscomfortona5point

scale,whichhaspreviouslybeenshowntosufficientlydifferentiatebetweencomfortstates,

withoutscalegradesbeingredundant1;whitediffuselightevaluationofcentrationand

coverage,withrecordinglinkedtoissuesthatwouldaffectclinicalmanagementsuchas

crossingthelimbusortheopticzoneisencroachingacrossthepupil;andmovementon

blinkwhichiscriticaltohealthyocularphysiology.19,21

FluoresceinassessmentwasconcludedtobebestevaluatedwiththeGPlenscentred,using

lidmanipulationifnecessary,usinga±2gradingsysteminthefourprincipalmeridians,

recordingthecentral,midperipheralandedgezonefluoresceinintensity.This‘Primary

FluoresceinPattern’evaluationwasutilisedbythirty‐fiveexperiencedpractitionerson

bothrealandtopographersimulatedfluoresceinimages.Concordancebetween

practitionerswasmoderate,withapproximately50‐60%agreeingonthesamegrade,

althoughitwasslightlyworseforthemid‐peripheralzone.Thismaybeduetodifficulties

injudgingthemostappropriatepositiontogradethefluoresceinintensityforthiszone.

Thezoneswerearbitrarilychosentobeapproximately5mmand8mmindiameter,buta

graticuleintheslitlampeye‐pieceortheimagingsoftwaredepictingthesezonesshould

assistthepractitionerinenhancingtheirgrading.Thecorrelationwithobjectiveanalysisof

Page 15: Consensus on Recording of Gas Permeable Contact Lens Fiteprints.aston.ac.uk/19272/1/Consensus_on_recording_of... · 2017-02-07 · Abstract Purpose: To develop a new schematic scheme

fluoresceinintensitywasalsomoderate,withsubjectivegradingaccountingfor36%ofthe

variance.

Whileobjectivemeasurementoffluoresceinintensitywassymmetricalintheverticaland

horizontalmeridians;however,thiswasnotgenerallythecaseforsubjectivegrading.The

intensityofthefluoresceinwasconsistentlygradedasgreaterinthesuperiorposition

comparedtothenasal,andgreaterinthetemporalpositioncomparedtothenasal,foreach

ofthezones.Thiswouldsuggestthatthelackofsymmetricalsubjectivefluoresceinpattern

gradingmaybeduetooff‐axisclinicalpositioningoftheslit‐lampilluminationsystem

ratherthandifferencesinfit.Henceitwouldseemappropriatetoaveragethegradingalong

theverticalmedian(soonegradeforedgefluoresceinintensityastheaverageatthetop

andbottomofthelens,onegradeformid‐peripheralfluoresceinintensityandonegrade

forcentrallensfluoresceinintensity)andalongthehorizontalmeridiantohalvethe

numberoffluoresceinintensitygradestorecord.

Interestingly,simulatedfluoresceinpatternsweresubjectivelygradedassignificantlyless

intensethanactualphotographsineachzoneandthiswasconfirmedobjectively.In

addition,thecorrelationbetweentheobjectivequantificationoftherealandsimulated

fluoresceinpatternswassignificant,butonlyjust.Hencethiswouldsuggestthat

topographersimulationimagescouldbemademoreintensetomorecloselydepictclinical

imageswhenanGPoftheseparametersisfittedtotheeye.

Hence,fromthisresearchthesuggestedschematicforrecordingGPfitisdemonstratedin

Figure3examples.WhilemorecouldberecordedregardingGPlensfitparticularlywhen

Page 16: Consensus on Recording of Gas Permeable Contact Lens Fiteprints.aston.ac.uk/19272/1/Consensus_on_recording_of... · 2017-02-07 · Abstract Purpose: To develop a new schematic scheme

fittingirregularcorneas,thisstandardisedschematicformatisquicktonotateandshould

besufficientformostdecisionmaking,providingasubstantialbenefitovercurrent

practice.

A) Manufacturer,Brand,7.80/9.8+3.50

Settlingtime:20mins

Comfort:4

Centration:C

Movementonblink:‐1

PFP;CMEV:+20‐1H:+20‐1

Figure3A:Exampleofhowtorecordawellcentred,steeplens(fluoresceingrading

medianof35experts)

B) Manufacturer,Brand,8.20/9.8‐2.50

Settlingtime:20mins

Comfort:2

Centration:Ltemporally

Movementonblink:+1

PFP;CMEV100⁰:+1+2+2H10⁰:‐1‐2+1

Figure3B:Exampleofhowtorecordaslightlyobliquetoriclensfit,whichismobile

andcrossesthelimbus(fluoresceingradingmedianof35experts)

Page 17: Consensus on Recording of Gas Permeable Contact Lens Fiteprints.aston.ac.uk/19272/1/Consensus_on_recording_of... · 2017-02-07 · Abstract Purpose: To develop a new schematic scheme

C) Manufacturer,Brand,8.10/9.8‐1.50

Settlingtime:20mins

Comfort:3

Centration:C

Movementonblink:0

PFP;CMEV:000H:00‐1

Figure3C:Exampleofhowtorecordalargelyalignedlenswithlittleedgelift

(fluoresceingradingmedianof35experts)

ConflictsofInterest:

None

Acknowledgement:

WearegratefultoPatrickCaroline,FAAO,FCLSA,FIOSandRandyKojima,FAAO,FSLS,

FIOSofPacificUniversityCollegeofOptometryfortheirprovisionoftheimagesthatwere

gradedinthisstudyandtotheGPLensInstitute(www.GPLI.info)fortheirsupport.

GPConsensusGroup:

LensArnham;EddyBakker;IdeBangma,PACBeks;EdwardBennett;JBliekendaal;Wim

Borst;KBrindha;HvanBruggen;NBuijs;ZaheerCassim;CatharineChisholm;Arnold

Cochrane;RobertConway;CarolineChristie;JyotiDave;MDeWinter;RDorst;CMAvan

Duijn;HEek;DeanDunning;DonaldEgan;RezavanEtten;ITEvenhuis;IanForrest;Daniel

Fuller;LDGertzen;JJvanGerven;SDvanGerven‐Stoppelenburg; JoseMGonzález‐Méijome;

PSGroen‐Vegt;AGroet;TonyHarknett;KathleenHelsen;ElienJanssen;AKamst;NJKerst;

Page 18: Consensus on Recording of Gas Permeable Contact Lens Fiteprints.aston.ac.uk/19272/1/Consensus_on_recording_of... · 2017-02-07 · Abstract Purpose: To develop a new schematic scheme

WalterKochen;KoenKoers;SAKolbe;PeterSKollbaum;WKram;RondeLau,Wolfgang

Laubenbacher;NManessa;AndrewMcLeod,GrahamMouat;VicenteS.MartínMontañez;

MyrianTMayorga;NiravMehta;LeonMeijboom;CristianMertz;MMohr‐Bakker;JA

Mohunlol;MoniqueMommen;JudithMorris;MarianNagtzaam,ShehzadNaroo;Katherine

Oliver;DieuwkevanOoik;GOosthuizen,JvanOverbeek;MSPreeji;MSas‐Meertens;Jayne

Schofield;PTASchreven;StefanSchwarz;HelmerSchweizer;CASikking‐vanReenen;E

Sissing;AlanTomlinson;MarcoTovaglia;GCFEVanschoenwinkel;CésarVilla‐Collar;S

Verdonk;JVerdoodt;SandraWoldringh,MarisaTesónYudego.

Page 19: Consensus on Recording of Gas Permeable Contact Lens Fiteprints.aston.ac.uk/19272/1/Consensus_on_recording_of... · 2017-02-07 · Abstract Purpose: To develop a new schematic scheme

References

1 Wolffsohn JS, Hunt OA, Basra AK. Simplified recording of soft contact lens fit. Contact

Lens Ant Eye 2009;32:37-42.

2 Carney LG. Luminance of fluorescein solutions. Am J Optom Arch Am Acad Optom

1972;49:200-4.

3 Guillon M, Sammons W. Contact lens design. In: Ruben M, Guillon M, ed. Contact Lens

Practice. London: Chapman & Hall, 1994:87-112.

4 Mountford J, Cho P, Chui WS. Is fluorescein pattern analysis a valid method of assessing

the accuracy of reverse geometry lenses for orthokeratology? Clin Exp Optom

2005;88:33-8.

5 Van der Worp E, De Brabander J, Lubberman B, Marin G, Hendrikse F. Optimising RGP

lens fitting in normal eyes using 3D topographic data. Contact Lens Ant eye 2002;25:95-

9.

6 Van der Worp E, De Brabander J, Swarbrick H, Nuijts R, Hendrikse F. Corneal

desiccation in rigid contact lens wear: 3- and 9-o'clock Staining – a review. Optom Vis

Sci 2003;80:280-290.

7 Van der Worp E. Corneal desiccation in rigid contact lens wear: Time to deal with 3- and

9-o'clock Staining. PhD thesis, University of Maastricht (the Netherlands), Nov 2008.

8 Maeda N, Klyce SD, Hamano H. Alteration of corneal asphericity in rigid gas permeable

contact lens induced warpage. CLAO J 1994;20:27-31.

9 Ruiz-Montenegro J, Mafra CH, Wilson SE, Jumper JM, Klyce SD, Mendelson EN.

Corneal topographic alterations in normal contact lens wearers. Ophthalmology

1993;100:128-34.

Page 20: Consensus on Recording of Gas Permeable Contact Lens Fiteprints.aston.ac.uk/19272/1/Consensus_on_recording_of... · 2017-02-07 · Abstract Purpose: To develop a new schematic scheme

10 Wilson SE, Lin DT, Klyce SD, Reidy JJ, Insler MS. Topographic changes in contact lens-

induced corneal warpage. Ophthalmology 1990;97:734-44.

11 Wilson SE, Lin DT, Klyce SD, Reidy JJ, Insler MS. Rigid contact lens decentration: a

risk factor for corneal warpage. CLAO J 1990;16:177-82.

12 Wang X, McCulley JP, Bowman RW, Cavanagh HD. Time to resolution of contact lens-

induced corneal warpage prior to refractive surgery. CLAO J 2002;28:169-71.

13 Phillips A. Rigid gas permeable and hard corneal lens fitting. In: Phillips A, Stone J, ed.

Contact Lenses. London: Butterworth, 1989:333-81.

14 Ruben M, Guillon M. Contact Lens Practice. London: Chapman & Hall, 1994.

15 Bennett E, Egan D. Rigid gas permeable lens problem solving. J Am Optom Assoc

1986;57:504-11.

16 Dougal J. Abrasions secondary to contact lens wear. In: Tomlinson A, ed. Complications

in Contact Lens Wear. St. Louis: Mosby, 1992:123-56.

17 Martin DK, Holden BA. Forces developed beneath hydrogel contact lenses due to

squeeze pressure. Phys Med Biol 1986;30;635-49.

18 Bibby MM, Tomlinson A. A model to explain the effect of soft lens design specifications

on movement. Am J Optom Physiol Opt 1983;60:287-91.

19 McNamara NA, Polse KA, Brand RJ, Graham AD, Chan JS, McKenney CD. Tear mixing

under a soft lens: effects on lens diameter. Am J Ophthalmol 1999;127:659-65.

20 Young G, Coleman S. Poorly fitting soft lenses affect ocular integrity. CLAO J

2001;27:68-74.

21 Kok JHC, Boets EPM, van Best JA, Kijlstra A. Fluorophotometric assessment of tear

turnover under rigid contact lenses. Cornea 1992;11:515–7.

Page 21: Consensus on Recording of Gas Permeable Contact Lens Fiteprints.aston.ac.uk/19272/1/Consensus_on_recording_of... · 2017-02-07 · Abstract Purpose: To develop a new schematic scheme

22 Peterson RC, Wolffsohn JS, Fowler CW. Optimization of Anterior Eye Fluorescein

Viewing. Am J Ophthalmol 2006;142:572-5.