8/8/2019 Concise rendering of GXS antitrust behaviors in Loren Data Corp Complaint

1/3

Yueefry ka Motwkrj Oaaoits lm tbo ^rosomt Ifso +

Ckrom fs f ^orilovod Tbroft tk HRY

Tbo ckmh vorslkm wltb ^rofe`co fmd Blstkrlifc Ikmtoxt ls km ID umdor, tbo ?>% Ykcutlkm!

"m tbo #rosomt ifso k$ D" motwkr&s, tbo #cflmtl$$ ls $lhbtlmh f `fttco kvor motwkr& o$$oits ox#ckltod `' tbo

do$omdfmt uslmh twk s'morhlstli $krios( )* Tbo `u'lmh k$ su`sirl`or #k#ucftlkms vlf #rlvfto skvorolhm

o+ult' covorfhlmh, fmd * ox#ckltlmh do$lilomilos lm tbo iurromt -./ rkutlmh s'stoe stftus +uk!

6Y dkos mkt mood f mueorlifc fdvfmtfho lm su`sirl`or eotrlis, fctbkuhb lt bfs fttflmod tbls! 6Y, `'

vlrtuo k$ tbo wolhbt k$ lts su`sirl`ors `' t'#o fmd mue`ors, bfs fi+ulrod f mueorlifc fmd t'#o su#orlkrlt',

fmd, `' lts kwm fdelsslkm, ls kvor 0>% k$ tbo efr&ot!

6Y ox#cklts lts motwkr& o$$oits `' fhhrosslvoc' dom'lmh lmtorikmmoitlkms lm fm lmdustr' omvlrkmeomt

homorfcc' su##krtlmh f blstkr' k$ ikccohlfc lmtorikmmoitlkms! Tbo' bfvo dkmo tbls socoitlvoc', stfrtlmh wltb

9krom Dftf Ikr#, fmd #rosomtc' fro ox#fmdlmh tbls #kcli' ikmtrfit `' ikmtrfit, dom'lmh lmtorikmmoitlkms

#frtmor `' #frtmor, iclomt `' iclomt! Yu##krtlmh oxbl`lts fro fttfibod!

Tbo D4 bfs ikvorod motwkr& o$$oits vor' tbkrkuhbc' lm f cfmdefr& #f#or, fvflcf`co lm tbo oxbl`lts!

.ctbkuhb fcc tocoikes fmd "mtormot sorvlio #rkvldors fro efstors k$ tbolr rkutlmh `krdors, #oors doslrlmh

ktbor eotbkds k$ trfmslt bfvo homorfcc' bfvo bfd roikurso vlf f s'stoe k$ blorfriblifc rkutlmh su##krtlvo

k$ toe#krfc trfmslt fhrooeomts! Tbo ck`fc s'stoe k$ D" /otwkr&s, -./s, um$krtumftoc' dkos mkt bfvo

suib f iomtrfcl1od dlroitkr' s'stoe, mkr f blorfriblifc rkutlmh fribltoituro! fib -./ eust ef&o ox#clilt

lmtorikmmoitlkms tk ktbor -./s, fmd suib fm fhhrosslvo stfmio k$ $kroickslmh lmtorikmmoitlkms bfs

`oikeo fm o$$oitlvo eofms k$ iroftlmh f do $fitk ekmk#kc'! vom l$ tbo 6Y su`sirl`or #k#ucftlkm wfs

8ust sbkrt k$ ?>%, suib f #k#ucftlkm ls wolhbtod lm $fvkr k$ cfrhor trfdlmh #frtmors fmd ef8kr rotflc

fiikumts!

Yuib ck#sldod wolhbtlmh `' t'#os ls vlrtufcc' le#kssl`co tk ikm$rkmt lm f lmtorikmmoitlkm dls#uto, fs tbo

sefccor su##clors fmd trfdlmh #frtmors fro wbkcc' do#omdomt km rofiblmh tboso u#strofe su##c' ibflmdostlmftlkms, fmd efm' fro `kumd 2lm kmo wf' kr fmktbor vlf k`clhftlkms tk trfdlmh #frtmorsbl#s* tk tbo

6Y "D #kkc! Tbo sefccor #frtmors, k$tom soo&lmh D" ikeeumliftlkms vlf suib lmdo#omdomt D" Ifrrlors

fs tbo #cflmtl$$, roc'l km suib ikeeumliftlkms $kr tbolr vor' oxlstomio!

Yuib ls tbo iurromt ifso k$ 6Y ox#ckltlmh lts motwkr& o$$oits tk tbo dotrleomt k$ tbo #cflmtl$$, fmd tk tbo

$urtbor dotrleomt k$ tbo ikeeumlt' k$ fcc trfdlmh #frtmors, fs suib dlsirlelmftkr' fitlkms fs

lmtorikmmoitlkm ro$usfc iurtflcs tbo rlhbts k$ trfdlmh #frtmors tk ibkkso fm D" motwkr& `fsod km tbo #uro,

efr&ot drlvom eorlts k$ toibmkckh', $ltmoss, $ofturos, fmd #rlio! "m sueefr', tbo 6Y #rfitlios k$

lmtorikmmoitlkm fr`ltrfho vlf tbo ox#ckltftlkm k$ motwkr& o$$oits ls doslhmod tk sbf#o tbo efr&ot vlf tbo

iurtflceomt k$ ike#otltlkm!

Tbo ^oriolvod 9krom Tbroft tk 6Y

"m >>, tbo -./ lmdustr' bfd mk ikmio#t k$ bkstod f##cliftlkm fmd bfd bfrdc' ifuhbt km tk tbo stfto k$

tbo frt lm soiuro "mtormot Ikeeumliftlkms! Tkdd kucd fmd 9krom Dftf Ikr#, bkwovor, bfd ikeeomiod

tbolr fiiocorftod f##rkfib tk iroftlmh f s'stoe k$ fdvfmiod lmtorikmmoitlkm efmfhoeomt, dlroitkr'

sorvlios, fmd roekto #rkhrfelmh eotbkds!

8/8/2019 Concise rendering of GXS antitrust behaviors in Loren Data Corp Complaint

2/3

Tbo $kroslhbt oxbl`ltod `' 9krom Dftf Ikr# $kumd $fvkr wltb f mow `rood k$ oikeeorio sorvlio

#rkvldors! Tboso #rkvldors tkk& tbo $umitlkms k$ ossomtlfc >, sfw fm omorhotli fmd vlslkmfr' omtro#romour,

8/8/2019 Concise rendering of GXS antitrust behaviors in Loren Data Corp Complaint

3/3

lm tbo $kre k$ Tkdd kucd, omvlslkmod tbo wkrst wltb f ekst cleltod #urvlow k$ wbft tk ox#oit

$rke suib fm fhlco fmd lmmkvftlvo omtor#rlso, fmd $kroicksod km 9krom Dftf Ikr# tbo rlhbt tk

/ftlvo "mtorikmmoitlkm!

4. Nofmwblco, ike$krtf`co wltb tbo dovlc lt &mkws, 6Y hrfmts mkm7sottcoeomt lmtorikmmoitlkm tk lts

frib rlvfc, "