computational building physics using comsol€¦ · computational building physics using comsol...

48
Computational Building Physics using COMSOL Research, Education & Practice dr.ir. Jos van Schijndel

Upload: others

Post on 17-Jun-2020

16 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Computational Building Physics using COMSOL€¦ · Computational Building Physics using COMSOL Research, Education & Practice dr.ir. Jos van Schijndel . 10-11-2011 . PAGE 1

Computational Building Physics

using COMSOL

Research, Education & Practice

dr.ir. Jos van Schijndel

Page 2: Computational Building Physics using COMSOL€¦ · Computational Building Physics using COMSOL Research, Education & Practice dr.ir. Jos van Schijndel . 10-11-2011 . PAGE 1

PAGE 1 10-11-2011

User since 1998(?)

Page 3: Computational Building Physics using COMSOL€¦ · Computational Building Physics using COMSOL Research, Education & Practice dr.ir. Jos van Schijndel . 10-11-2011 . PAGE 1

PAGE 2 10-11-2011

Contents

• 1.Introduction • Complexity and scale levels

• My computational laboratory

• 2.Combined heat, moisture, air, stress models for (building) constructions

• 3.From Material [~mm] to EU [~Mm] scale level

• 4.Conclusions

Page 4: Computational Building Physics using COMSOL€¦ · Computational Building Physics using COMSOL Research, Education & Practice dr.ir. Jos van Schijndel . 10-11-2011 . PAGE 1

PAGE 3 10-11-2011

• What is a ‘Complex system’?

• Where are Complex systems in the built environment?

1. Introduction Complexity and Scale levels

Page 5: Computational Building Physics using COMSOL€¦ · Computational Building Physics using COMSOL Research, Education & Practice dr.ir. Jos van Schijndel . 10-11-2011 . PAGE 1

PAGE 4 10-11-2011

• The whole is greater than the sum of the individual parts

Introduction Complexity and Scale levels

Page 6: Computational Building Physics using COMSOL€¦ · Computational Building Physics using COMSOL Research, Education & Practice dr.ir. Jos van Schijndel . 10-11-2011 . PAGE 1

PAGE 5 10-11-2011

• Butterfly effect: Small parameter variations may produce large variations in the long term behavior of the system.

Introduction Complexity and Scale levels

Page 7: Computational Building Physics using COMSOL€¦ · Computational Building Physics using COMSOL Research, Education & Practice dr.ir. Jos van Schijndel . 10-11-2011 . PAGE 1

PAGE 6 10-11-2011

• Where are the dynamic complex systems at the built environment ?

Everywhere and on several scales

Introduction Complexity and Scale levels

Page 8: Computational Building Physics using COMSOL€¦ · Computational Building Physics using COMSOL Research, Education & Practice dr.ir. Jos van Schijndel . 10-11-2011 . PAGE 1

PAGE 7 10-11-2011

Material ~ mm Present dynamic complex systems: Material Physics •Durability

Introduction Complexity and Scale levels

Page 9: Computational Building Physics using COMSOL€¦ · Computational Building Physics using COMSOL Research, Education & Practice dr.ir. Jos van Schijndel . 10-11-2011 . PAGE 1

PAGE 8 10-11-2011

Building ~ 10 m Present dynamic complex systems: Building Physics •Indoor climate •Building systems

Introduction Complexity and Scale levels

Page 10: Computational Building Physics using COMSOL€¦ · Computational Building Physics using COMSOL Research, Education & Practice dr.ir. Jos van Schijndel . 10-11-2011 . PAGE 1

PAGE 9 10-11-2011

Urban Area ~ km Present dynamic complex systems: Urban Physics •Urban Climate •Urban district systems

Introduction Complexity and Scale levels

Page 11: Computational Building Physics using COMSOL€¦ · Computational Building Physics using COMSOL Research, Education & Practice dr.ir. Jos van Schijndel . 10-11-2011 . PAGE 1

PAGE 10 10-11-2011

EU ~ 1 Mm Present dynamic complex systems: Global climate Physics • (Future) Climate • Mapping

Introduction Complexity and Scale levels

Page 12: Computational Building Physics using COMSOL€¦ · Computational Building Physics using COMSOL Research, Education & Practice dr.ir. Jos van Schijndel . 10-11-2011 . PAGE 1

PAGE 11 10-11-2011

Multi Buildings ‘HAMBase’

MatLab

Multi Details PDE

Comsol

Multi Systems & Control ODE

SimuLink

Introduction My computational laboratory

Page 13: Computational Building Physics using COMSOL€¦ · Computational Building Physics using COMSOL Research, Education & Practice dr.ir. Jos van Schijndel . 10-11-2011 . PAGE 1

PAGE 12 10-11-2011

Tools Buildings modeling physics: HAMBase scientific software: MatLab

Anne Frank House

Simulation and validation

Page 14: Computational Building Physics using COMSOL€¦ · Computational Building Physics using COMSOL Research, Education & Practice dr.ir. Jos van Schijndel . 10-11-2011 . PAGE 1

PAGE 13 10-11-2011

Tools Detail modeling physics: PDEs scientific software: Comsol

3D Moisture

Hunting Logde St. Hubertus

Page 15: Computational Building Physics using COMSOL€¦ · Computational Building Physics using COMSOL Research, Education & Practice dr.ir. Jos van Schijndel . 10-11-2011 . PAGE 1

PAGE 14 10-11-2011

Tools Systems&Control modeling physics: ODEs scientific software: SimuLink

Dutch Maritime Museum

Building systems failure modeling

Page 16: Computational Building Physics using COMSOL€¦ · Computational Building Physics using COMSOL Research, Education & Practice dr.ir. Jos van Schijndel . 10-11-2011 . PAGE 1

PAGE 15 10-11-2011

http://archbps1.campus.tue.nl/bpswiki/index.php/Hamlab

Introduction My computational laboratory

Page 17: Computational Building Physics using COMSOL€¦ · Computational Building Physics using COMSOL Research, Education & Practice dr.ir. Jos van Schijndel . 10-11-2011 . PAGE 1

PAGE 16 10-11-2011

Computational Building Physics Research Matrix

Topic

Scale

Heat

Moisture

Air

Stress

~ mm

~ m

~ km

~ Mm

Page 18: Computational Building Physics using COMSOL€¦ · Computational Building Physics using COMSOL Research, Education & Practice dr.ir. Jos van Schijndel . 10-11-2011 . PAGE 1

PAGE 17 10-11-2011

Computational Building Physics Heat

Topic

Scale

Heat

Moisture

Air

Stress

~ mm

~ m

~ km

~ Mm

Page 19: Computational Building Physics using COMSOL€¦ · Computational Building Physics using COMSOL Research, Education & Practice dr.ir. Jos van Schijndel . 10-11-2011 . PAGE 1

PAGE 18 10-11-2011

Application 1: Heat 3D

Page 20: Computational Building Physics using COMSOL€¦ · Computational Building Physics using COMSOL Research, Education & Practice dr.ir. Jos van Schijndel . 10-11-2011 . PAGE 1

PAGE 19 10-11-2011

Computational Building Physics Heat+Moisture

Topic

Scale

Heat

Moisture

Air

Stress

~ mm

~ m

~ km

~ Mm

Page 21: Computational Building Physics using COMSOL€¦ · Computational Building Physics using COMSOL Research, Education & Practice dr.ir. Jos van Schijndel . 10-11-2011 . PAGE 1

PAGE 20 10-11-2011

Application 2: Heat and moisture transport PDEs

)(

)(

2221

1211

LPcKTKt

LPcC

LPcKTKt

TC

LPc

T

,

,

,

)log(

21

22

12

11

10

T

PsatK

RT

MPsat

LPc

Pc

LPc

PcKK

LPc

Pc

Pc

wC

RT

MPsat

LPc

PclK

K

cC

PcLPc

p

a

wp

LPc

a

wplv

T

• Potential T, LPc

• PDE coefficients formulation

• Material properties

• function of T, LPc

Page 22: Computational Building Physics using COMSOL€¦ · Computational Building Physics using COMSOL Research, Education & Practice dr.ir. Jos van Schijndel . 10-11-2011 . PAGE 1

PAGE 21 10-11-2011

Calculating PDE coefficients using material properties, method 1/2

)(

)(

2221

1211

LPcKTKt

LPcC

LPcKTKt

TC

LPc

T

• PDE coefficients lookup

tables calculated in MatLab

using:

• heat conduction

coefficients

• specific heat

• density

• liquid permeability

• moisture retention curve

• vapour permeability

Page 23: Computational Building Physics using COMSOL€¦ · Computational Building Physics using COMSOL Research, Education & Practice dr.ir. Jos van Schijndel . 10-11-2011 . PAGE 1

PAGE 22 10-11-2011

)(

)(

2221

1211

LPcKTKt

LPcC

LPcKTKt

TC

LPc

T

Calculating PDE coefficients

using material properties, result 2/2

Page 24: Computational Building Physics using COMSOL€¦ · Computational Building Physics using COMSOL Research, Education & Practice dr.ir. Jos van Schijndel . 10-11-2011 . PAGE 1

PAGE 23 10-11-2011

Verification HAMSTAD Benchmark no 1

)(

)()(

ppg

pplTThq

i

ilvii

0

)(

g

TThq ee

Page 25: Computational Building Physics using COMSOL€¦ · Computational Building Physics using COMSOL Research, Education & Practice dr.ir. Jos van Schijndel . 10-11-2011 . PAGE 1

PAGE 24 10-11-2011

Verification Heat & Moisture

Page 26: Computational Building Physics using COMSOL€¦ · Computational Building Physics using COMSOL Research, Education & Practice dr.ir. Jos van Schijndel . 10-11-2011 . PAGE 1

PAGE 25 10-11-2011

Verification Moisture

LPc based model RH based model

Thanks to: Natalie Williams Portal (visit today, 4:00-5:30, Silchersaal)

Page 27: Computational Building Physics using COMSOL€¦ · Computational Building Physics using COMSOL Research, Education & Practice dr.ir. Jos van Schijndel . 10-11-2011 . PAGE 1

PAGE 26 10-11-2011

Computational Building Physics Heat+Moisture+Air

Topic

Scale

Heat

Moisture

Air

Stress

~ mm

~ m

~ km

~ Mm

Page 28: Computational Building Physics using COMSOL€¦ · Computational Building Physics using COMSOL Research, Education & Practice dr.ir. Jos van Schijndel . 10-11-2011 . PAGE 1

PAGE 27 10-11-2011

Application 3 HAM modeling Influence of micro air movement

Inside

Outside

a b

Page 29: Computational Building Physics using COMSOL€¦ · Computational Building Physics using COMSOL Research, Education & Practice dr.ir. Jos van Schijndel . 10-11-2011 . PAGE 1

PAGE 28 10-11-2011

HAM modeling Physics

0)(:

;0)(:

0)(:

vvv

pp

ppDt

pMoisture

PKPKt

PAir

TCTt

TCHeat

u

u

u

0)(:);()(::

0:;::

0)(:);()(::

inf

0

inf

vvvv pDInsulationpppDFlux

PKInsulationPPPressure

TInsulationTThTFlux

nnMoisture

nAir

nnHeat

PDEs

Boundary values

Page 30: Computational Building Physics using COMSOL€¦ · Computational Building Physics using COMSOL Research, Education & Practice dr.ir. Jos van Schijndel . 10-11-2011 . PAGE 1

PAGE 29 10-11-2011

HAM modeling Simulation of Relative Humidity

Air velocity

= 0

Air velocity

+10 μm /s Air velocity

-10 μm /s

Page 31: Computational Building Physics using COMSOL€¦ · Computational Building Physics using COMSOL Research, Education & Practice dr.ir. Jos van Schijndel . 10-11-2011 . PAGE 1

PAGE 30 10-11-2011

HAM modeling Influence of micro air movement

a b

Summary

A (so far immeasurable) low air movement of order 10-5 m/s seems to have significant impact on the RH

Page 32: Computational Building Physics using COMSOL€¦ · Computational Building Physics using COMSOL Research, Education & Practice dr.ir. Jos van Schijndel . 10-11-2011 . PAGE 1

PAGE 31 10-11-2011

Computational Building Physics Heat+Moisture+Air+Stress

Topic

Scale

Heat

Moisture

Air

Stress

~ mm

~ m

~ km

~ Mm

Page 33: Computational Building Physics using COMSOL€¦ · Computational Building Physics using COMSOL Research, Education & Practice dr.ir. Jos van Schijndel . 10-11-2011 . PAGE 1

PAGE 32 10-11-2011 Thanks to: Zara Huijbregts (visit today, 4:00-5:30, Silchersaal)

Application 4 HAMS modeling Including stress and strain

Page 34: Computational Building Physics using COMSOL€¦ · Computational Building Physics using COMSOL Research, Education & Practice dr.ir. Jos van Schijndel . 10-11-2011 . PAGE 1

PAGE 33 10-11-2011 Thanks to: Zara Huijbregts (visit today, 4:00-5:30, Silchersaal)

Application 4 HAMS modeling Including stress and strain

Page 35: Computational Building Physics using COMSOL€¦ · Computational Building Physics using COMSOL Research, Education & Practice dr.ir. Jos van Schijndel . 10-11-2011 . PAGE 1

PAGE 34 10-11-2011

Application 4 HAMS modeling Including stress and strain

Thanks to: Zara Huijbregts (visit today, 4:00-5:30, Silchersaal)

Page 36: Computational Building Physics using COMSOL€¦ · Computational Building Physics using COMSOL Research, Education & Practice dr.ir. Jos van Schijndel . 10-11-2011 . PAGE 1

PAGE 35 10-11-2011 Thanks to: Zara Huijbregts (visit today, 4:00-5:30, Silchersaal)

Application 4 HAMS modeling Including stress and strain

Page 37: Computational Building Physics using COMSOL€¦ · Computational Building Physics using COMSOL Research, Education & Practice dr.ir. Jos van Schijndel . 10-11-2011 . PAGE 1

PAGE 36 10-11-2011

Computational Building Physics Heat, including Building Scale

Topic

Scale

Heat

Moisture

Air

Stress

~ mm

~ m

~ km

~ Mm

Page 38: Computational Building Physics using COMSOL€¦ · Computational Building Physics using COMSOL Research, Education & Practice dr.ir. Jos van Schijndel . 10-11-2011 . PAGE 1

PAGE 37 10-11-2011

Application 5 Heat, including Building Scale

Page 39: Computational Building Physics using COMSOL€¦ · Computational Building Physics using COMSOL Research, Education & Practice dr.ir. Jos van Schijndel . 10-11-2011 . PAGE 1

PAGE 38 10-11-2011

Computational Building Physics Heat, including Urban Scale

Topic

Scale

Heat

Moisture

Air

Stress

~ mm

~ m

~ km

~ Mm

Page 40: Computational Building Physics using COMSOL€¦ · Computational Building Physics using COMSOL Research, Education & Practice dr.ir. Jos van Schijndel . 10-11-2011 . PAGE 1

PAGE 39 10-11-2011

Application 6 Wind & driving rain at Urban Scale

Page 41: Computational Building Physics using COMSOL€¦ · Computational Building Physics using COMSOL Research, Education & Practice dr.ir. Jos van Schijndel . 10-11-2011 . PAGE 1

PAGE 40 10-11-2011

• ..

Thanks to: David van Reenen

Application 7 Ground energy at Urban Scale

Page 42: Computational Building Physics using COMSOL€¦ · Computational Building Physics using COMSOL Research, Education & Practice dr.ir. Jos van Schijndel . 10-11-2011 . PAGE 1

PAGE 41 10-11-2011 Thanks to: David van Reenen

Application 7 Ground energy at Urban Scale

Page 43: Computational Building Physics using COMSOL€¦ · Computational Building Physics using COMSOL Research, Education & Practice dr.ir. Jos van Schijndel . 10-11-2011 . PAGE 1

PAGE 42 10-11-2011 Thanks to: David van Reenen

Application 7 Ground energy at Urban Scale

Page 44: Computational Building Physics using COMSOL€¦ · Computational Building Physics using COMSOL Research, Education & Practice dr.ir. Jos van Schijndel . 10-11-2011 . PAGE 1

PAGE 43 10-11-2011

Computational Building Physics Heat, including EU Scale

Topic

Scale

Heat

Moisture

Air

Stress

~ mm

~ m

~ km

~ Mm

Page 45: Computational Building Physics using COMSOL€¦ · Computational Building Physics using COMSOL Research, Education & Practice dr.ir. Jos van Schijndel . 10-11-2011 . PAGE 1

PAGE 44 10-11-2011

• Weather Stations

• Used as boundary

values for the external

climate

Application 8 Incorporate EU Scale

Page 46: Computational Building Physics using COMSOL€¦ · Computational Building Physics using COMSOL Research, Education & Practice dr.ir. Jos van Schijndel . 10-11-2011 . PAGE 1

PAGE 45 10-11-2011

• Subject building

constructions to

external climates

• Map performances

Application 8 Incorporate EU Scale

Page 47: Computational Building Physics using COMSOL€¦ · Computational Building Physics using COMSOL Research, Education & Practice dr.ir. Jos van Schijndel . 10-11-2011 . PAGE 1

PAGE 46 10-11-2011

Conclusion

• COMSOL is a state-of-art Multiphysics modeling tool for doing research in the area of building physics

• High performance on

• 1,2 & 3D capabilities

• Grid & solvers techniques

• Visualization

• Flexibility due to PDE abstraction level

• Also an excellent tool for education

• Our models are available at http://sts.bwk.tue.nl/hamlab/