communications daily 9/29

8/3/2019 Communications Daily 9/29

1/19

Copyright 2011 by Warren Communications News, Inc. Reproduction or r etr ansmission in any form, wit hout writ ten permission, is a violation of Federal Statut e (17 USC101 et seq.).

FREE PRESS CHALLENGES FCCnet neutrality order in court, sayingit's too weak. MAP files similarchallenges on behalf of grassrootsgroups. (P. 1)

OUTGOING FTC COMMISSIONERKovacic talks privacy, Google, apps,and regulatory globalization, in exitinterview. (P. 2)

SPECTRUM LEGISLATION TOPSCTIAs agenda, Largent says.CTIA also focused on USF, getting1755 MHz band reallocated forbroadband. (P. 4)

COMCAST ENTERS TOWER SECTOR

as it finds new use for old broadcastreceive and microwave sites. (P. 8)

RURAL MERGER MANIA feared inUSF proceeding. (P. 9)

RELIGION AND NEWS COMMONAL-

ITIES discussed by Waldman, whosays both grappled with technology.NHMC still wants hate-speech FCCinquiry. (P. 11)

HOUSE PRIVACY BILL to deal withpractices of government as well asbusiness, Blackburn says. Officialsshould 'lead by example.' (P. 12)

VERIZON SEEKING TAX EXEMP-

TION in New Jersey, citing decreasein landline customers. (P. 13)

THURSDAY, SEPTEMBER 29, 2011

Fr ee Pr ess, MAP, File Fir st Challenges

t o FCC Net Neut r alit y Or der

Free Press sought judicial review of the FCCs December2010 net neutrality order in the U.S. Court of Appeals for the FirstCircuit in Boston. Free Press is based in Boston. Meanwhile, theMountain Area Information Network, based in Asheville, N.C.,also challenged the order in 4th Circuit in Richmond, and the Me-dia Mobilizing Project filed a challenge in the 3rd Circuit in Phila-delphia. Both are represented by the Media Access Project.

Free Press challenged the FCCs decision to "adopt one setof rules for broadband access via mobile platforms and a differentset of rules for broadband access via fixed platform," according toits Wednesday petition for review. Doing so violates the Commu-nications Act and is "arbitrary and capricious, an abuse of discre-tion, or otherwise contrary to law," it said.

Free Press Policy Director Matt Wood said the groups goalis to strengthen the rules. "Our challenge will show that there isno evidence in the record to justify this arbitrary distinction be-tween wired and wireless Internet access," Wood said. "The dis-parity that the FCC's rules create is unjust and unjustified. And it'sespecially problematic because of the increasing popularity ofwireless, along with its increasing importance for younger demo-graphics and diverse populations who rely on mobile devices astheir primary means for getting online."

The other two challenges raise similar questions about theorder and the distinction it draws between wireless and wirelinebroadband. Verizon and MetroPCS are expected to file appeals inthe Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit. The result is questionsabout where the challenge will ultimately be heard. Net neutralityopponents hope it's the D.C. Circuit, which they believe will bemore skeptical of the FCCs reasoning in the order and more likelyto overturn it.

VOL. 31, NO. 189

TODAYS NEWS


2/19

COMMUNICATIONS DAILY2 THURSDAY, SEPTEMBER 29, 2011

"There is a considerably better than a 50-50 chance that all of the net neutrality rules will bethrown out on the basis the Commission lacks authority to regulate Internet services in the way it did,"said Free State Foundation President Randolph May, a net neutrality critic. "In any event, in light of thedifferences between wireless and wireline networks, the odds that Free Press will succeed in arguing theFCC acted arbitrarily in treating wireless more flexibly are close to zero."

CTIA Vice President Chris Guttman-McCabe questioned the logic of the Free Press challenge. "Idon't know what Free Press is reading, but as the FCC noted during the proceeding, wireless is different,"he said. "There is ample evidence on the record that proves this."

Relations between the White House and the FCC have become strained over the net neutralityrules, a former FCC official told us. President Barack Obama and his team are frustrated that the net neu-trality order was too watered down, the official said. The matter has disappeared from his campaign'stalking points. Howard Buskirk

Google Inquir y War r anted

FTC St r uggling t o Under st and Rapid Technological Changes,

Says Out going Commissioner Kovacic

The FTC needs to commit more resources to understand rapidly evolving technologies, despite thetrend of heightened fiscal scrutiny, said former Commissioner Bill Kovacic in an exit interview Wednes-day. His term, a Republican slot, ended Sept. 25 after five years on the commission, including a year aschairman from March 2008 to March 2009. Kovacic returns to his former job as a law professor at theGeorge Washington University Law School in Washington.

The biggest change Kovacic saw during his term was the increased speed at which new technologi-cal phenomena begin, he said. The rate of change in technologies is occurring "faster today than ever,"and is placing "extreme pressure on policy making institutions" like the FTC, he said. "The greatest chal-lenge for the commission is to understand what is taking place. And secondly it must appreciate both thehazards and benefits associated with these changes and to take those tips to create a base of knowledge formaking judgments about the policy response going ahead."

The commission is still working to wrap its head around emerging technologies like Apple andAndroid's mobile application stores, Kovacic said. "These are extraordinarily complex phenomenaand they are changing quickly, so the commission is spending more resources on understanding itfirst," he said. "It requires a base of technical knowledge and a deep understanding of the relevantcommercial practices and their significance. That is a key investment of the agency's resources." TheFTC recently settled with the makers of two apps that promised to treat acne using colored lights onmobile devices (CD Sept 9 p12).

But the tight fiscal environment facing nearly all federal agencies could constrain the FTC's invest-ment in new resources, Kovacic said. "One hopes Congress will understand that you can't get first-ratepolicy results on the cheap," he said. "If you want broadband-quality policy outcomes you can't do it withdialup-quality institutions."


3/19

THURSDAY, SEPTEMBER 29, 2011 COMMUNICATIONS DAILY3


4/19


Kovacic said one of his biggest regrets is that he won't be around to contribute to the agency's con-versation in the online privacy debate. Just this month the FTC suggested more than two dozen changesto the rules for the Children's Online Privacy Protection Act (COPPA). The proposed changes would im-pose new requirements on operators of websites that cater to children under the age of 13.

The FTC's proposed revisions to COPPA are "appropriate" to ensure that minors "know whatthey are getting into online," Kovacic said. "A greater level of precaution taking is important for chil-dren." The proposed revisions "respond to a deep social preference to ensure that minors do not get inover their heads in a form of communication whose implications may not be entirely apparent tothem," he said. "I regret that I won't be here as the further elaboration of the commission's statementon privacy takes place."

The agency's antitrust inquiry into Google's business practices is warranted, Kovacic said, but thatdoesn't necessarily mean the FTC will bring action against the company. "I believe that it is responsiblefor the agency to take a closer look, but where that leads is an entirely different question," he said.Kovacic said he's particularly concerned about the way Google integrates the service offerings of other

firms into its own search listings and products. "The assessment will evaluate whether some of the com-plaints that were made about access discrimination are well founded," Kovacic said. Last week, YelpCEO Jeremy Stoppelman said Google incorporated Yelp content into Google Local without permission(WID Sept 22 p1). "Those results are worth exploring, but initiating an inquiry does not necessarily meanprosecuting the company," Kovacic said.

Another change the outgoing commissioner observed is the increased globalization of the policy-making arena. There is a "growing awareness that the solutions have an increasingly international dimen-sion" and the solutions to many of today's policy questions "require a broad range of interaction with pol-icy makers at home and abroad," he said.

Kovacic hopes his successor will be able to work cooperatively with international regulatoryagencies on policies that require a more global approach. "There is a lot of room for improvement instrengthening the cooperative framework related to the international and state governments," he said.Kovacic's successor should also "emphasize the importance of making capital investments in improvingcapability in the regulatory framework," he said. "The quality of the institution should be decisive ingood results and we should not short change the investment of these policies." In July, President BarackObama nominated Maureen Ohlhausen, a partner at the Washington law firm of Wilkinson Barker, toreplace Kovacic (CD July 21 p7). She previously spent 11 years at the FTC, where she was the directorof the Office of Policy Planning until 2008. Her nomination is awaiting approval from the Senate,which hasn't scheduled a hearing. Bryce Baschuk

USF Being Wat ched

Lar gent Opt imist ic Congr ess Will Approve Spect r um Legislat ion This Year

CTIAs top priority is getting Congress to pass spectrum legislation, and the association thinks itsnot a question of if, but when a bill will be approved, CTIA President Steve Largent said during a pressconference Wednesday. CTIA officials also said Universal Service Fund reform remains a significant is-


5/19



6/19


sue for wireless carriers, with the FCC poised to take up an order at its Oct. 27 meeting. Largent said he'sconfident the 1755-1780 MHz band will be reallocated for wireless broadband.

All Im going to say is that at this point in time: CTIAs number one, two and three highest pri-orities are getting more spectrum, Largent said. We are focused like a laser beam on getting more spec-trum. The U.S. will lose its leadership position in the world if carriers dont get another 500 MHz in 10

years." Timing is a big concern and CTIA hopes broadcast spectrum will be auctioned within two years,Largent said.

CTIA isnt sure which version of spectrum legislation will pass, but is very confident a bill willmove before Congress leaves in December, Largent said, suggesting it could be folded into the work ofthe Joint Select Committee on Deficit Reduction. Largent is not confident the super committee will pro-duce a product that reduces the deficit by $1.5 trillion, but I am totally confident that theyll have some-thing in there on spectrum, because were helping the process."

The super committee process is new, so its unclear what will happen, said CTIA Vice President

Jot Carpenter. Even if spectrum is included, theres no guarantee it will pass since there are many otherissues involved, Carpenter said. Its still possible spectrum legislation will be passed through regular or-der, he said. Weve told [Congress] we dont care much what the process is, as long as at the end of theprocess, theres additional spectrum coming to market, he said.

The House Communications Subcommittee plans a markup on spectrum legislation next week (CDSept 28 p13). Chairman Greg Walden, R-Ore., wants to move a bill to give options to Commerce Com-mittee Chairman Fred Upton, R-Mich., and the super committee, Carpenter said. If the super committeedoesnt take it up, then the House still has the option to move the bill through regular order, he said. TheGOP and Democratic staffs have meetings regularly and are working very hard to reach consensus, Car-penter said. Based on talks Carpenter has had with both sides, he estimated the parties are in about 80 to

85 percent agreement. There may be a few issues at the end where the staff cant figure out how to get inagreement, and thats where you get the members in the room and you try and work it out, Carpentersaid. If they cant get agreement, then you take votes.

CTIA likes most of President Barack Obamas American Jobs Act, but opposes spectrum fees,Carpenter said. Fees collect revenue for the government later, but reduce the amount of money companiespay for auctions up front, he said. Carpenter hopes a new tax on wireless would be a non-starter butCTIA is taking it seriously, he said. Theres a little more meat on the bones in this particular proposalthan there has been in the past, he said. CTIA officials are particularly concerned about a proposal to im-pose fees retroactively.

Carriers would bid less for spectrum licensees if they know theyd have to pay additional fees onthe backend, Largent said. It doesnt make sense. Largent also said one incentive auction probablywont be enough to tee up all the spectrum the industry needs. Either youre going to hold an auctionand its going to be so late and our industry is going to so desperately need the spectrum that youre sortof defeating yourself anyway, he said. Or youll hold it so early and have so much spectrum availablethat you drive the price." He said the best solution would be to hold two or three auctions over 10 years.

CTIA Vice President Chris Guttman-McCabe said he's not concerned about Congress imposingtoo-specific of rules for auction design as part of legislation. The 700 [MHz auction] as a whole is an


7/19


example of how not to hold an auction, he said. The D-block didnt get auctioned. The C-block hadtwo bidders but only one that truly wanted to win the license. ... Then you had the A and the B blocks andthe A block had interference concerns." Largent said weve seen the FCC play games with auctions andweve seen what the results are.

Public safety officials have pointed to the wireless industrys network woes following the Virginia

earthquake as evidence that they need to control the 700 MHz D-block. Largent said its technically im-possible for wireless networks to serve a spike in demand like was felt during the earthquake. Networkssaw a 400 to 600 percent demand spike after the earthquake, he said. The truth is, we would never beable to build enough lanes on the highway, regardless of how much spectrum we have, to handle a 400 to600 percent increase of traffic on a given moment, Largent said. That spike in demand could never bemet with all the spectrum in the world, he said. It did highlight the fact that we need more spectrum.

Largent has more confidence in our networks than maybe public safety does, he said. Commercialnetworks are pretty darn good, and when they do go down theyre able to come back very, very quickly,he said. But public safety has its own needs and wishes, and I wish them well on their quest to get the D-

block, he said. CTIA members differ on whether the D-block should be auctioned or reallocated to publicsafety, so the association is not taking a position, Guttman-McCabe said. But there is consensus amongmembers that public safety needs money to build the network, he said. CTIA hopes disagreement over theD-block doesnt hold up spectrum legislation since there's much more spectrum at stake, he said.

Asked about broadcaster concerns about voluntary incentive auctions, Guttman-McCabe saidCTIA wants broadcasters to be comfortable, because we want broadcasters to participate in the auctions.This shouldnt have to be a life-and-death battle because thats not whats being contemplated." Broad-cast spectrum is important, but its only 120 MHz of the 500 MHz sought by carriers, he said.

CTIA officials also took questions on a few non-Hill issues. USF reform is a very big issue,

Guttman-McCabe said. We believe that here is a vehicle out there that can help get us to a solution onintercarrier comp and USF and what weve suggested are a few changes to it, the key one being a signifi-cantly larger Mobility Fund, he said. We think that that fits exactly in line with the other policy issuesin front of the commission greater deployment, greater adoption of wireless broadband." Guttman-McCabe noted comments by Commissioner Michael Copps that he was able to use his wireless devicewhile on a trip on the Yangtze River in China. Were not going to get broadband service on our Yangtzerivers if the size of the Mobility Fund is $300 million, he said. He said he hopes the FCC will be able tovote out an order in October.

When I signed on with CTIA in August 2003, intercarrier comp and USF was one of the issuesthat I inherited then, and were just now coming to a point where I think something is going to happen,Largent said.

Largent also said he's really optimistic that the NTIA and FCC will conclude that the 1755-1780MHz band should be reallocated for wireless broadband. My hope is that as the auctions come along thatthat would be the first spectrum to be auctioned, he said. Several of the spectrum bills, including the jobsbill, advocate that the band be reallocated.

Guttman-McCabe questioned the conclusions in a Citigroup report released this week that foundthere's no spectrum shortage in the U.S. (CD Sept 27 p10). The study was based on 2010 numbers, he


8/19


noted. They suggest in the study that theres no AWS being used, which isnt factually correct, he said.The paper is based on, as far as we can see, no 700 MHz being used even though Verizon has deployedtheir C-block to a whole bunch of markets." Guttman-McCabe said he was surprised when he saw the re-port: I dont want to have to go on the attack against Citigroup. Im sure these guys had every intentionof getting it right. ... I just dont agree with their analysis."

Meanwhile, CTIA expects the House will soon pass the Wireless Tax Fairness Act by Rep. ZoeLofgren, D-Calif., Carpenter said. The bill (HR-1002), which has wide bipartisan support in the House,would impose a five-year moratorium on new state and local discriminatory taxes on wireless. Meanwhilein the Senate, Sen. Ron Wyden, D-Ore., Olympia Snowe, R-Maine, and John Thune, R-S.D., have asked(CD Sept 28 p13) for a Finance Committee hearing on the Senate companion, S-543. "If we can get the[Lofgren] bill through the House this fall [and] get a hearing scheduled in the Senate, I think well be in anice position with a fairly long runway in front of us next year in the Senate to finally get this done. With-out a moratorium, state and local governments will continue to look at wireless as a potential revenuesource," said CTIA Vice President Jamie Hastings. Adam Bender, Howard Buskirk

800 Towers

Comcast s Ventur e Capit al Wing Sets Up Wir eless Tower Operat or

Comcast is getting into the wireless tower business through a company just set up by its venturecapital arm, Comcast Ventures. CTI Towers said it will take the 800 towers Comcast already owns andtry to lease them to wireless companies. For now, CTI Towers holdings overlap entirely with Comcastsservice area, but the company is looking to expand its footprint either through acquisitions or developingnew tower sites, said CEO Anthony Peduto.

As fiber connections have replaced microwave links as a means of delivering TV programming tocable headends, Comcast has been left with under-used tower sites around its service area, Peduto said.Comcasts many cable system acquisitions has left it with multiple towers in some markets. In Washing-ton, D.C., for instance, it has three sites within the Beltway one in Northwest D.C., another in CapitolHeights, Md., and a third in Arlington, Va. according to data from CTI Towers website.

Plus, the towers are in prime locations, said Peduto. By virtue of coming in through the cable sys-tems, a lot of these towers are in strategic locations, such as some residential neighborhoods and high pro-file commercial areas." Some local regulatory hurdles remain to be cleared because the towers werentbuilt for commercial wireless use, he said. But local governments are generally willing to allow the shift

because it may mean eliminating the need for building a new tower in their jurisdiction, he said.

Demand for tower space is high and is forecast to increase, said Clayton Funk, a managing directorfor Media Venture Partners who brokers transactions involving wireless towers. Bringing in a tower-industry veteran and running the CTI Towers as a separate unit within Comcast is a smart business movefor the company, he said. Instead of being viewed as a nuisance or non-core asset, it can be viewed as aseparate revenue center."

Its easy to see why Comcast would get into the tower sector, said Clayton Moran, an analyst forBenchmark Capital who follows the tower industry. The tower industry in the U.S. is growing at about 9


9/19


percent year over year in terms of revenue, and we think it will be in high single-digit growth for severalyears to come."

Its very profitable growth, as the tower business largely fixed cost business, meaning incrementalrevenue can drop directly to the bottom line, said Jonathan Schildkraut, an analyst with Evercore Partners.An independent operator can break even with a single tenant on the site, but the next tenant, maybe 90cents of the incremental dollar falls down the bottom line." Most leases are long term, providing steady,recurring revenue, he said. Its a great business and its unsurprising to me that Comcast Ventures wouldlook at this and take advantage of the assets Comcast had and make them more productive.

Dont look for clues about Comcasts wireless ambitions in this move, Moran said. Its being runwithin their venture group and its obviously not part of their operating business, so theyre not assumingsynergies with their other business lines, he said. I wouldnt read this as indicating anything about theirwireless strategy."

CTI Towers could make an attractive acquisition target for some of the larger tower operators, both

stock analysts said. Theres been a pretty healthy consolidation trend for many years, Moran said. Andthe number of tower operators with 500 or more sites is limited, he said. That potentially creates a scar-city value as these bigger companies desire to continue to grow." Josh Wein

'Part and Parcel'

Rural Telcos Wor r y t hat USF Reform Point s t o Consolidat ion

Rural telcos and state regulators worry the pending universal service and intercarrier compensation

regime reforms will result in consolidation in their sector. Earlier this week, ex-FCC commissioner Har-old Furchtgott-Roth accused the agency of pushing rural telcos toward consolidation in the Universal Ser-vice Fund rulemaking notice (CD Sept 26 p13).

The "dynamic" rural market may inevitably result in mergers or acquisitions, but rural carri-ers are still worried that the FCC will push them into consolidation, said NTCA Policy Director JoshSeidemann. I think the FCC certainly indicated their view that there could be benefits to consoli-dation, he said. This is an aspect of the industry, however, that should be left to market forces andthe market forces will determine what works best for a particular carrier or for particular carriers."Parts of the rulemaking notice ask about whether companies ought to share switching support, Sei-demann said. Some rural telecom officials read that as an indication that their operations ought to

be merged, he said.

There have been other indications that reform points toward M&A. After listening to an Iowaregulator talk at an FCC workshop on the pending reforms about the difficulties in regulating the 140-some telcos in her state, AT&T Vice President Bob Quinn asked aloud whether we really need so manysmall telcos in Iowa. FCC staffers have made similar statements in ex parte meetings, a rural telecom of-ficial told us. Blair Levin made clear in a number of public speeches that he thinks the entire rate-of-return regime should be rethought (CD Jan 25 p9). Levin led the team that wrote the National BroadbandPlan, from which many of the pending USF reform proposals have come.


10/19


Rural consolidation is already underway, Vermont regulator John Burke told us. Shoreham, aVermont telco, is about to be acquired by Otelco, a wireline provider that works in Maine, Massachusettsand New Hampshire, he said. He said he would expect M&A to increase if the incumbent-backed ABCplan is adopted by the FCC. The cost models in the plan simply make it too hard for small, rural carriersto operate, Burke said. That would be a disaster for rural economies, Federal/State USF Joint BoardChairman James Cawley said. Small, independent telcos are part and parcel of the business and social

fabric of rural communities."

Anxiety over a shrinking market has become a new angle in the USF battle but its not clear thatconsolidation is a direct consequence of pending reforms, MF Global analyst Paul Gallant said.Financial buyers of rural telcos raise certain issues for regulators, but one rural telco buying anothershouldn't have much effect on consumers, he said. So I don't think rural consolidation is per se good orbad from a public policy perspective. If consolidation follows from the pending reforms, its probably anunintended consequence, Gallant said: The commission's goal is expanding broadband by rationalizinga fairly irrational system of subsidies. One consequence might be some rural consolidation, but I doubtthat's what's driving the commission."

In the meantime, rural telcos ought to be looking at each other to see if they can maximize effi-ciencies with or without M&A, John Staurulakis Inc. Senior Vice President Steve Meltzer said. Ourposition is that the FCC should not force these companies to consolidate, said the consultant to small andmid-size telcos. However, there are certain services where they can gain economies of scale." Compa-nies can theoretically pool resources for help desks, engineering and billing to cut costs, Meltzer said.

Meanwhile, a group of Missouri rural telcos released a study Wednesday claiming that USF

is central to the states rural economy. Without USF support, economic output would drop by

By using our e-mail delivery service, you understand and agree that we may use tracking software to ensure accurate electronic delivery and copyright compliance.This software forwards to us certain technical data and newsletter usage information from any computer that opens this e-mail. We do not share this informationwith anyone outside the company, nor do we use it for any commercial purpose. For more information about our data collection practices, please see our PrivacyPolicy at www.warren-news.com/privacypolicy.htm.

(ISSN 0277-0679)PUBLISHED BY WARREN COMMUNICATIONS NEWS, INC.

WASHINGTON HEADQUARTERS

Albert WarrenEditor & Publisher 1961-2006

Paul Warren . . . . . . . . . . . Chairman and PublisherDaniel Warren . . . . . . . . . . .President and EditorMichael Feazel . . . . . . . . . . . Executive EditorHoward Buskirk . . . . . . . . . . . . . Senior EditorDinesh Kumar . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Senior EditorJonathan Make . . . . . . . . . . . . Senior EditorAdam Bender. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .Associate EditorBill Myers . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ..Associate EditorYu-Ting Wang . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Assistant EditorTim Warren . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Assistant EditorKamala Lane . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Assistant EditorBryce Baschuk . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Assistant Editor

Louis Trager. . . . . . . . . . . . .Consulting News EditorJosh Wein. . . . . . . . . .West Coast CorrespondentDugie Standeford . . . . . . . . . European CorrespondentScott Billquist. . . . . . . . . . . . .Geneva CorrespondentGreg Piper . . . . . . . . . . . . . Seattle Correspondent

Television & Cable Factbook

Michael Taliaferro . . . Managing Editor & Asst. Pub.Gaye Nail . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Assoc. Managing EditorKari Danner . . . . . .Sr. Editor & Editorial SupervisorColleen Crosby . . . . Sr. Editor & Editorial SupervisorBob Dwyer . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .Sr. Research EditorMarla Shepard . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .Senior Editor

NEW YORK BUREAU276 Fifth Ave., Suite 1002, N.Y., N.Y. 10001

Phone: 212-686-5410Fax: 212-889-5097

Paul Gluckman . . . . . . . . . Bureau ChiefMark Seavy . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Senior EditorJeff Berman . . . . . . . . . . . . . Senior EditorRebecca Day . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . Senior EditorRazia Mahadeo . . . . . . . . . . . Editorial Asst.Barry Fox . . . . . . . . . . . . . Contributing Editor

Michael Feazel . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Managing EditorHoward Buskirk . . . . . . . . . . . . . Associate Managing EditorJonathan Make . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Assistant Managing Editor

Warren Communications News, Inc. is publisher of CommunicationsDaily, Warrens Washington Internet Daily, Consumer Electronics Daily,Green Electronics Daily, Washington Telecom Newswire, Telecom A.M.,

Television & Cable Factbook, Cable & Station Coverage Atlas, PublicBroadcasting Report, Satellite Week and other special publications.

Send news materials to: [email protected]

Copyright 2011 by Warren Communications News, Inc.Reproduction in any form, without written permission, is prohibited.

EDITORIAL & BUSINESS HEADQUARTERS

2115 Ward Court, N.W., Washington, DC 20037Phone: 202-872-9200 Fax: 202-318-8984

www.warren-news.comE-mail: [email protected] Dir. of Advertising: Richard NordinPhone: 703-819-7976

Fax: 202-478-5135

Business

Brig Easley. . . . . . . . . . . . Exec. VP-ControllerDeborah Jacobs. . . . . . . Information Systems ManagerGregory Jones . . . . . . . . . Database/Network ManagerGina Storr . ..Director of Sales & Marketing SupportAnnette Munroe . . . . Asst. Dir., Sales & Mktg SupportSusan Seiler . . . . . . . .Content Compliance SpecialistKatrina McCray.. Sr. Sales & Mktg. Support SpecialistGreg Robinson . . Sales & Marketing Support AssistantLoraine Taylor . . .Sales & Marketing Support Assistant

SalesWilliam R. Benton . . . . . . . .. . . . . Sales DirectorAgnes Mannarelli . . . . . . National Accounts ManagerJim Sharp . . . . . . . . . . .Account ManagerBrooke Mowry . . . . . . . . . . .Account ManagerNorlie Lin. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .Account Manager


11/19


$604 million over five years, 3,500 jobs would be lost either directly or indirectly, wages would

decline by more than $162 million and federal tax revenues would fall by $36.4 million, the study

claimed. Bill Myers, Yu-Ting Wang

Copps Seeks Diver sit y

Religion and News Media Shar e Commonalit ies, Waldman Says

Religion and news media have more in common than it may appear at first glance, the author of the

FCC's report on the future of the industry said as he prepares to leave the agency next week (CD Sept 27

p4). Steve Waldman said the news industry and religious leadership have both grappled with how to stay

abreast of technological trends and make sure those trends don't undermine some of their reason for exis-

tence. Both have at times wondered "how they won't be overrun by technology," he said in a Wednesday

lecture on ethics in telecom.

The Internet boom of the 1990s and early part of last decade offers some hope for long-time insti-

tutions seeking to remain relevant, Waldman suggested. EToys, which some thought would become the

top website for buying kids' presents, went bust, he noted. But toysrus.com, owned by the brick and mor-

tar retailer, is now the online leader, Waldman said in the annual Everett Parker Ethics in Telecom Lec-

ture. The United Church of Christ helped organize it and was among the sponsors.

"If you embrace technology, use it as an exciting way to get your message out, rather than sticking

your head in the sand, you will thrive," Waldman said. That "would have been very good advice" for "TV

news managers" to have heard. Journalists and religious authorities "both care, in some sense, about the

good news," he said. "There are more similarities there than might be first apparent, and I don't mean that

only news and the holy scripture tell stories about floods," he said. "They both attempt to get at something

they call the truth, they both try to do so in profoundly different ways" and "they both attempt to get at the

question 'why is the world this way?'"

At the same event, FCC Commissioner Michael Copps pressed his case for more diversity in me-

dia, while the head of the National Hispanic Media Coalition again sought an FCC inquiry into hate

speech. Both men accepted awards, along with Joe Waz, who retired this year as senior vice president of

Comcast. Commitments to diversity and selling cheap Internet access to the poor that Comcast made to

buy control of NBCUniversal are bearing fruit and will continue to, Waz said.

"We're taking them on," NHMC President Alex Nogales said of media that perpetuate what hecalled hate speech he didn't define the term in markets including Los Angeles. "Hate speech is not

good for anyone, it's not good for people who are the recipients, or the people who are doing it," he said.

Hate crimes have risen in L.A. and in Washington, which he said "is not an accident" and comes after

more hate speech.

"We still have so many miles to go to build the media that America requires," said Copps.There's "too little substance and too much fluff" now, he added. Consumers should "work for and in-

sist upon a media environment that informs us with real news and information" and reflects "the diver-


12/19


sity of this land," he said. Copps speaks Monday in Phoenix about the report Waldman finished in

June that was done under the auspices of FCC Chairman Julius Genachowski, who also will talk about

its recommendations.

If Waldman had to send out a summary on Twitter of his 478-page report (http://xrl.us/bmesmp), itwould be: "There is tremendous innovation in the modern media landscape, but there are very consequen-tial gaps," he said. "Technology has reduced the cost of gathering, producing and distributing news"while a "search engine-driven Internet has just made it much easier to find stuff out," he said. Newer localnews websites, some started by former traditional journalists, "have the skill, but not the scale" needed,Waldman said. He stumped for the report's recommendation of disclosure by broadcasters of how they'reserving their communities, including by disclosing news sharing and other arrangements with stations inthe same market. "I don't mean coverage that is locally relevant" should be disclosed in lieu of only localinformation, he said, "because that is a loophole that you can drive a truck through. But I mean newsabout their community, as that is commonly understood." Jonathan Make

'Lead by Example'

House Commer ce Pr ivacy Bill t o Deal Wit h Gover nment

Dat a Pr act ices, Says Blackburn

SANTA CLARA, Calif. The government's handling of personal information will be the subjectof a House Commerce Committee privacy bill, which also will have provisions on business practices, Rep.Marsha Blackburn, R-Tenn., told us Wednesday. She didn't elaborate, including about when the measurewill be introduced, and a committee spokeswoman didn't get back to us right away. Blackburn is a mem-ber of the Communications Subcommittee.

Speaking at a forum of the Congressional Internet Caucus Advisory Committee and Santa ClaraUniversity's High Tech Law Institute, Blackburn had said the government's collection, protection, use andretention of data has been a major subject of worries expressed at privacy roundtables she has held."Citizens are very concerned" about the amount and kinds of information the government collects andholds, Blackburn said. But she added, "I can't tell you exactly what the processes to move forward are go-ing to be." People want the opportunity "to protect their virtual 'you,'" and "government has a different setof rules than anybody else," Blackburn said. The "government must lead by example on privacy protec-tion," she said.

On the Hill, "bipartisan opposition to the imposition of the net neutrality rules" by the FCC "hashad an impact" on the progress of spectrum legislation, Blackburn said. The "lesson in the failed D-blockauction" is not to "weigh these auctions down with a lot of conditions and mandates," which are"counterproductive" to business aims, she said. It's "vitally important" to "get this spectrum out in themarketplace," she said.

Asked about the administration's legal challenge to the T-Mobile sale, Blackburn said, "I'm goingto pretty much leave that alone. ... We'll see what DOJ has to say." But she added, "Let's think long-termabout the health of the industry and the health of jobs growth." The policy shouldn't "stifle the ability ofinnovators to innovate and bring applications" to users, Blackburn said. Louis Trager


13/19


Cour t Case Pending

Ver izon Seeking New Jer sey Tax Exempt ion

Due to a decrease in landline customers, Verizon is telling 68 municipalities in New Jersey that its

no longer required to file tangible telephone property tax returns. Municipalities like Hopewell Boroughin Mercer County disagreed, bringing the telco to state tax court.

Based on New Jersey law (Title 54, section 4-1), in municipalities where Verizon no longer pro-vides landline to 51 percent of a local exchange, the company isnt required to file the property tax re-turns, a Verizon spokesman said. For tax year 2011, Verizon didnt pay personal property tax in 37 mu-nicipalities that met the threshold, and identified 31 additional municipalities for 2012, he said. Verizonestimates savings of about $7.8 million for the 2012 tax year, he said. None of Verizons competitors inNew Jersey are subject to the tax, he noted. Verizon is still submitting property tax returns for about 475other municipalities across the state and continues to pay the personal property tax in the municipalitieswhere the assessor has placed an assessment on the tax roll, he said.

Hopewell Borough has appealed Verizons decision in the Tax Court of New Jersey (casepending). The New Jersey League of Municipalities is also opposing Verizons position, said Ex-ecutive Director Bill Dressel. The league maintains that the statute specifically provides that thosetelecom carriers formerly subject to the New Jersey Franchise and Gross Receipts Tax Act will con-tinue to be taxed, and contains no provision for an annual test to determine whether the tax contin-ues to apply, he said.

Consumers have more communications service options now, the Verizon spokesman said regard-ing declining landlines. New and evolving technologies enable various service providers, many of which

arent traditional telephone companies, he said. Verizon is seeking tax exemption on a case-by-case basis,said a spokesman with the state Treasury Department. The agency doesnt have any comments becauseits a tax collected at the local level, he said. Yu-Ting Wang

Comm Daily Notebook

Any intercarrier compensation regime reforms should clearly address the rights of CLECs, TimeWarner Cable and Cox Enterprises executives said in meetings with FCC staff last week, according to anex parte notice released Wednesday (http://xrl.us/bmesj3). Meeting with FCC Chairman Julius Gena-chowskis aide Zac Katz and Wireline Bureau staff, including Bureau Chief Sharon Gillett, the cable ex-ecutives said todays ICC regime is increasingly plagued by resource-draining disputes regarding com-petitors' rights to terminating access charges. In order to accomplish genuine reform, the commissionshould define terminating access in a functionally neutral manner that includes either the termination ofcalls directly to retail customers or the delivery of traffic to facilities-based interconnected VoIP providersthat in turn transmit calls to retail customers, Time Warner and Cox said. As other cable executives havedone, Time Warner and Cox executives urged the commission to reject the ABC Plans call for deregu-lating tandem transit services, the ex parte notice said. We explained that such services are governed bySection 251(c) of the Act as a form of interconnection, as several state commissions and courts have held,and there are often no competitive alternatives to relying on an incumbent LECs facilities to transmit traf-


14/19


fic to rural LECs via indirect interconnection arrangements, the ex parte notice said. The two cable com-panies would support measures, however, that subject VoIP traffic to interstate access rates during the re-form transition, if the Commission can develop a reliable means of identifying such traffic, the ex partesaid. By the same token, we explained that our willingness to compromise on the treatment of so-calledVoIP traffic has a significant impact on the revenues of companies like TWC and Cox and any failure todeliver clear, certain and enforceable rules would undermine the rationale for that compromise, the ex

parte said.

NCTA CEO Michael Powell said he's calling the "bluff" of CEA CEO Gary Shapiro for sayingthe administration is the most anti-business of his lifetime (CD Sept 27 p8) while seeking AllVidrules. "While he is vehemently condemning some 200-plus new regulations that would cost industryhundreds of millions of dollars if implemented, Gary and CEA are leading an effort to push the FCCto adopt new regulations that would impose substantial costs on cable and other video providers,"Powell wrote on NCTA's blog Wednesday (http://xrl.us/bmerxc). Shapiro addressed the criticism, in aresponse on Powell's blog post that noted it's been 15 years since the Telecom Act required cable in-teroperability with third-party CE devices. The AllVid rules for all pay-TV companies to connect to

consumer electronics without CableCARDs "would have the very government bureaucrats that he sodisdains set technical standards on a marketplace that is exploding with innovation," Powell said ofShapiro. The proceeding, hanging over cable like Damocles' sword, "if implemented as Gary andCEA would like," would "force video providers (job-producing business owners) to break up their ser-vices in a manner that would strip away valuable (and popular) content and allow competitors to pickand choose which pieces they want," Powell wrote. "He should be true to his principles and walkaway, and the FCC should shut down the proceeding and let the market continue working." Shapiroacknowledged that "in a perfect world cable would not have to be mandated to give consumers achoice," in his response. "As long as consumers have only one cable provider, giving consumers anoption to get boxes at retail is pro-competition" since "few consumers" can "cancel one broadband ca-ble service and replace it with another," Shapiro wrote. "Cable is a physical monopoly, like utility

services, and even the strictest of conservatives accept some regulation of natural physical monopo-lies." If retailers like Best Buy could sell "cable boxes and even cable services, more people wouldsubscribe to cable," he said: "Worked well for DBS, phones and tablets."

Capit ol Hil l

Rep. Jo Ann Emerson, R-Mo., urged the FCC to move forward with its overhaul of the Univer-sal Service Fund and intercarrier compensation. In a letter dated Tuesday to FCC Chairman JuliusGenachowski, Emerson cited a serious problem with broadband connectivity in rural America." Em-

erson chairs the House Appropriations subcommittee that oversees the FCC. The Commission needsto continue with reform of these two programs in a manner that is aimed at meeting the objective ofaccelerating broadband deployment to rural areas and doing so in a fiscally responsible way bycarefully targeting support and keeping the high-cost Universal Service Fund within its currentbudget, Emerson said. In a separate letter to Genachowski dated Sept. 23, the congressional delega-tion from Idaho applauded the FCC and the industrys overhaul efforts. We are encouraged by therecent discussions with Idaho stakeholders, said Sens. Mike Crapo and James Risch and Reps. MikeSimpson and Raul Labrador, all Republicans from the state. You have already received a careful re-view process and feedback that gives you and the FCC an opportunity to reform and update the USFand its core mission mandate and goals."


15/19


The co-chairmen of the House Privacy Caucus asked the FTC to investigate what they allege to beFacebooks practice of tracking users after they log out. Such an investigation should fall within theFTCs mandate with respect to protecting Americans from unfair and deceptive acts or practices, Reps.Joe Barton, R-Texas, and Ed Markey, D-Mass., said in a letter to FTC Chairman Jon Leibowitz. WhileFacebook claims that it stopped this practice, we remain concerned about the privacy implications forFacebooks 800 million subscribers. Facebook should "consider this problem a top priority and should

allocate the resources necessary to safeguard consumers in an expedited fashion, they said. There was nosecurity or privacy breach, a Facebook spokesman said in an email. "Facebook did not store or use anyinformation it should not have." Three of the cookies used to personalize content and secure users' experi-ence "inadvertently included unique identifiers when the user had logged out of Facebook," he said. Thesocial network site didn't store the identifiers for logged out users, he said: "We could not have used thisinformation for tracking or any other purpose."

Wir eline

Rate-of-return carriers would receive more than $13 billion in Universal Service Fund cash overthe next six years under the ABC plan, executives from the incumbent companies behind the plan said lastweek in a meeting with FCC staff. USF support for rate-of-return areas would start at $2 billion in 2012and reach $2.3 billion in 2017, executives said, according to an ex parte notice posted Wednesday todocket 10-90. The program would generate $161 million in budget surplus over the next five years, theexecutives said in their presentation (http://xrl.us/bmesfk). Under the ABC plan, the legacy high costUniversal Service Fund would spend a little more than $2 billion over four years, starting with $821 mil-lion in 2012 before dropping to zero in 2016, the ABC executives said. The Connect America Fundwould start by spending $440 million in 2012 and reach more than $2.2 billion by 2017, the executivessaid. The executives were from AT&T, Frontier, USTelecom, Verizon, Windstream and CenturyLink.

Wir eless

The Rural Cellular Association offered a compromise on the size of a proposed Mobility Fundas the FCC moves forward on Universal Service Fund overhaul. A $300 million fund as proposed inthe ABC Plan, or even a $500 million fund, "would dramatically undervalue the ability of wirelessproviders to deliver broadband service to high-cost, rural communities," RCA said in a letter to thecommission (http://xrl.us/bmercx). In the past, the group advocated a $1.5 billion annual fund, theletter noted. "RCA could support a $800 million Mobility Fund, approximately one-fourth of what thewireless industry contributes, if the FCC also allocates a sufficient amount for annual operating ex-

penses and if the largest wireless carriers and rural local exchange carriers are prohibited from partici-pating in the Mobility Fund."

Google sought to protect confidential information it has filed with the government in the AT&T/T-Mobile case, in a filing to U.S. District Court in Washington, D.C. Google submitted information tothe Justice Department as it investigated the deal under a protective order. "As it stands, the ProtectiveOrder fails to require the parties always to provide advance notice to Google of potential disclosure ofits confidential information on the public record, in open court or to experts retained by the parties," thecompany said. "Google therefore wishes to seek limited additional relief to ensure such advance noticeis always given."


16/19


PTC-220 LLC, the alliance owned by the major rail carriers to develop positive train control tech-

nology in the 220 MHz band, is testing the technology at the Transportation Technology Center near

Pueblo, Colo., said an FCC filing (http://xrl.us/bmerfb). "Though this testing does not give us the final

word on our spectrum needs, it does help us understand the radio's real capabilities so that we can do our

communications network engineering more precisely," the filing said. The alliance invited key FCC offi-

cials to attend testing Oct. 11-13 in Pueblo at the end of its second month-long test.

Internet

Only one in five businesses handling payment-card data is "fully compliant" with payment

card industry (PCI) security rules, Verizon said in a report (http://xrl.us/bmer2m) released Wednes-

day. The results are based on more than 100 such reviews by its assessors last year and Verizon's

investigations into data breaches, covering the U.S., Europe and Asia. The compliance situation has

"neither worsened nor improved" in the past year, the telco said, with "overconfidence, complacency

and the need to focus on other compliance and security issues" among the reasons for noncompli-

ance. Breached organizations are more likely not to be PCI-compliant and to suffer from identity

theft and fraud, Verizon said. The report said organizations struggled to meet requirements to pro-tect stored cardholder data, track and monitor access, regularly test systems and processes, and

maintain security policies. Despite the availability of the "prioritized approach" guidance from the

PCI Security Standards Council since 2009, organizations largely rely on older standards and are

"ignoring security threats with the highest risk and potential for the largest negative impact," Veri-

zon said. It recommended organizations holding payment card data make compliance into "an eve-

ryday, ongoing process" by undertaking "daily log review, weekly file-integrity monitoring, quar-

terly vulnerability scanning and annual penetration testing," through a "champion" within their or-

ganizations who can oversee such compliance. Verizon also suggested that Level 1 and 2 mer-

chants, who process the most cardholder transactions, hire an "objective third party" to validate thescope of its self-validation assessments or perform the testing itself. The company told organiza-

tions that are having trouble with existing PCI standards to "quickly get ready" for the more-

stringent 2.0 standards, which were approved a year ago but haven't taken effect.

Internet ad revenue increased 23 percent to $14.9 billion in the first half of 2011, according to re-

search from the Interactive Advertising Bureau and Pricewaterhouse Coopers. The growth rate more

than doubled year-over-year, as last years first-half ad revenues of $12.1 billion had represented an 11.3

percent increase over 2009, IAB said. Banner ads, rich media, digital video and other display-related ad-vertising reached more than $5.5 billion in the first six months of 2011, up from nearly $4.4 billion, IAB

said: Digital video increased 42 percent over a year ago, "and moved close to the $1 billion mark with$891 million in half year 2011 revenue. Fueling online ad growth is the ability of advertisers to corre-

late performance and results with the dollars they are investing, IAB said.

St at e Telecom Act ivit ies

United Private Networks (UPN) will partner with Iowa Communications Network (ICN) to helpbuild a BTOP-funded state-wide fiber network in Iowa, the companies said. UPN will connect 65 Iowa


17/19


communities to expand access to over 170 end-user facilities located throughout the state. The projectwill increase the ICN Network to a 10 Gbps backbone that will reach all 99 counties in Iowa. The projectwill also offer one Gbps of Ethernet connectivity to education facilities, hospitals, libraries, public safety,workforce development and other anchor institutions.

Br oadcast

NAB and NPR continue seeking changes to an FCC plan to cut a backlog of FM translator

requests and then let low-power radio applicants seek outlets, in replies to a rulemaking on imple-

menting part of the Local Community Radio Act. NAB opposed some low-power FM backers' re-

quests (CD Sept 8 p12) for the agency to change the way it decides whether there would be enoughLPFM frequencies available in a market after translators are awarded. The concerns about the size

of the market grid come as there are inherent tensions between LPFM and translators, the associa-

tion said (http://xrl.us/bmesht). "There may be no perfect solution to the problem of accommodat-

ing both" types of requests "in markets where FM frequencies and locations are in short supply," it

said in docket 99-25 (http://xrl.us/bmesfv). "There is certainly no approach that will please all inter-

ested parties. The Commission should reject calls to adopt a conclusive preference for one service

over another or to manipulate its proposal to favor one service over the other." Making the changes

to the rulemaking the NPR seeks will better "comport" with Section 5 of the act, the public radio

programmer said (http://xrl.us/bmeshv). "It is clear, therefore, that further modification of the Com-

mission's market-by-market approach is warranted" to deal with leftover applications from a 2003

FM translator filing window, NPR said. "The Commission should not dismiss pending FM transla-

tor applications that, if granted, would not obstruct future LPFM opportunities." There's

"widespread support" demonstrated in the initial comments "for the expansion of LPFM to urban

areas," Prometheus Radio Project said. "We urge the Commission to use the utmost caution in pre-

serving LPFM opportunities, reiterating the need for a freeze on translator application modificationsand prohibitions on translator speculation and AM rebroadcast." NAB disagreed. The commission

should let AM stations use any FM translator from the auction seven years ago, it said: "No parties

refuted NABs explanation that eliminating the date restriction on AM stations use of FM transla-

tors will not reduce potential opportunities for future LPFM stations."

The proposed community of license change of WHRO-TV Hampton, Va., to channels in Norfolk,

Va./ Elizabeth City, N.C., fully complies with all pertinent FCC rules and policies, Hampton Roads Edu-

cational Telecommunications Association said. The comments are in docket 11-139 (http://xrl.us/

bmer9v). HRETAs proposal to change its community of license is mutually exclusive with its existing

authorization at Hampton-Norfolk, it said. WHRO-TVs programming will not change, except to theextent needed to serve the needs of Elizabeth City. The proposed allotment at Elizabeth City will give

the community its first TV station, HRETA said.

Sinclair Broadcast Group is using Digital Alert Systems DASDEC-II digital EAS/CAP encoding

systems at its TV stations, Digital Alert Systems said. Even though the deadline for CAP compliance has

been pushed out, both single station and large station groups such as Sinclair are completing their deploy-

ment of our DASDEC-II systems, said Bill Robertson, who manages business development for Digital

Alert Systems.


18/19


Cable

Another cable operator wants an FCC waiver of an encryption ban for channels on the basic pro-gramming tier. Mikrotec wants an exemption for its system in southeastern Kentucky, southwestern WestVirginia and southwestern Virginia which would include future expansion there. The waiver should take

effect for each node that goes all digital, and the system is converting to digital, the company said in a pe-tition for special relief to the Media Bureau. It cited theft of unencrypted cable service and high costs tosend technicians to homes to activate subscriptions and deactivate them. RCN made similar arguments ina waiver request this summer that's pending and expected to be eventually approved by the bureau (CDAug 17 p4). "Mikrotec experiences extraordinarily high levels of signal theft," with 6.8 percent of homesin an audit of most of the system getting video without paying, the company said: "If Mikrotec can scram-ble the basic tier," it can remotely "change the mix of services received by subscribers," almost instantlyand "without the time and cost of a truck roll."

Comcast took aim at Bloombergs recent pleadings in its FCC complaint regarding Comcastscompliance with the neighborhooding conditions of its NBCUniversal takeover approval. In a surreply

filed with the commission this week, the cable operator criticized Bloomberg for including seven new ex-pert declarations and raising several new legal arguments in its reply to Comcast's opposition. That infor-mation should have all been in its initial complaint, Comcast said. Bloombergs reliance on such proce-dural gamesmanship underscores and confirms the fundamental lack of merit in its complaint, Comcastsaid. Moreover, much of the new material contradicts Bloombergs earlier assertions, Comcast said. Andit contradicts the language of the condition the FCC adopted when it approved the deal, Comcast said.Bloomberg offers an entirely new and misguided approach to defining a news neighborhood in the re-ply, Comcast said. For the first time, Bloomberg has asserted that ratings, advertising, branding and otherfactors should affect the definition of a neighborhood, rather than relying on the numerical test set out inthe condition, Comcast said. Under their new test, a grouping of only two or three channels may con-stitute a neighborhood even if many more similarly themed channels may be found elsewhere, Com-

cast said. This absurd result cannot be reconciled with the language of the condition and results in a dra-matic and unforeseen expansion of the conditions scope."

HSN Inc.s board approved a plan to buy back up to 10 million shares of its stock and pay a regularquarterly dividend of 12.5 cents per share, the company said.

Mass Media Notes

"In the hope of getting the stalled retransmission consent rulemaking moving," Mediacom said it's

considering asking multichannel video programming distributors and broadcasters to commission a panelto render a "disinterested opinion" on the FCC's retrans authority. They'd hire "respected and independentlaw professors or retired federal judges," Senior Vice President Joseph Young wrote Dave Grimaldi, chiefof staff to Commissioner Mignon Clyburn. The Tuesday letter is in docket 10-71 (http://xrl.us/bmerxx)."Frankly, in our view, the case publicly made by the Commission's staff for concluding that the Commis-sion lacks authority would earn a failing grade in most law schools," Young wrote. "What is even moresurprising is the Commission's resignation to its claimed powerlessness, even as it professes to regret theharm to consumers that it acknowledges is caused by the existing regime," he said. "The contrast is strik-ing between the Commission's passivity when it comes to retransmission consent and the expansive read-ing of statutory provisions and legislative history in other contexts for example, the Commission's rule-


19/19

communications daily 9/29

Documents