come and play come and play have your have your say say
TRANSCRIPT
Come and play
Have your say
Have your say
Come and play
Come and play
Have your say
Come and playHave your say
Come and play
Have your say
Come and play
Have your say
Have YourHave YourCome and Play...Come and Play... www.sheffkids.me.uk
SaySay . a o sc o l. . b ut h o. a o sc o l. . b ut h o
Feedback ReportFeedback ReportSeptember 2005
Have Your say…about school______________________________________________________________
Children’s Voices Project0114 273 5233
Contents
Introduction 2
Executive summary 3Enjoying and achieving 3
Staying safe 4
Being healthy 4
Making a positive contribution 5
Economic well-being 5
Phase 1: Consultation events 6
What did we do? 6Monitoring information 7
What did children tell us? 11Play in school 11
Health in school 17
Bullying in school 22
Behaviour at school 25
Learning at school 29
Children’s voices in school 31
After-school and holiday provision 35
Phase 2: Questionnaires 36
What did we do? 36
What did children tell us? 37Talking about…you and your home 37
Talking about…school 43
Talking about…feeling safe 49
Talking about…bullying 51
Talking about…after-school activities 54
Talking about…moving to secondary school 55
Talking about…your feelings 57
Phase 3: Focus groups 60
What did we do? 60
What did children tell us? 61Arbourthorne Primary School 61
Springfield Primary School 65
Have Your Say…about school______________________________________________________________
Children’s Voices Project0114 273 5233
2
Introduction
Children are at the heart of many services throughout Sheffield. Theirinvolvement in the planning, delivery and evaluation of services affecting themis critical for ensuring a service is efficient and based on actual need.
Article 12 of the United Nations’ Convention on the Rights of the Child states that, “Children and young people have a right to express an opinion and to have that opinion taken into account in any matter affecting them”. This statement has been supported at a local level through the work of theChildren’s Society and Children’s Funds.
The Children’s Voices Project, funded by Sheffield Children’s Fund, is firmly committed to this principle and is leading on children’s participation in Sheffield.
For more information on matters relating to this report or for support andadvice in involving children in your setting please contact:
Clare HumberstoneChildren’s Voices Project ManagerSheffield Children’s Fund PlusFloor 3, Palatine Chambers22 Pinstone StreetSheffieldS1 2HN
Tel: 0114 273 5233Email: [email protected]
Have Your Say…about school______________________________________________________________
Children’s Voices Project0114 273 5233
3
Executive summary
During April, May and June 2005 Sheffield pupils aged 5-13 years were askedtheir views on issues related to education and schools. The results of theconsultation were to feed into the ‘Engagement with Learning’ consultation. The consultation process was undertaken in 3 phases: Phase 1: 3 days of consultation activities involving 350 children Phase 2: questionnaires circulated to Year 5 pupils involving 6 schools
and 268 pupils Phase 3: focus group work involving 2 schools and 14 pupils
A summary of the key findings from the children’s responses is presented below:
Enjoying and achieving
Academic achievement Three-quarters of the children who responded are happy at school One-third enjoy most lessons; less than one-fifth do not enjoy any
lessons at school During holidays, friends and school work are the things that children
miss most Children feel they achieve “very well” in games and art, “OK” in maths
and literacy but “could do better” in science Fun, more interesting and interactive lessons would help children learn
more effectively Other children’s bad behaviour stops learning; these children should be
sent to work in another room More time and more adults would help children achieve better in maths,
literacy and science Children get on best with their friends, learning mentors and teachers at
school Bad behaviour is thought to be mainly because of children showing off,
ADHD or children being bullied themselves The most common punishment for badly behaved children is being sent
to the head teacher; they should be made to miss playtimes or excluded Good behaviour should be rewarded rather than bad behaviour
punished; rewards should include stickers and certificates Children like to feel proud of their school
Play at school The best things about play at school are being with friends and
playtimes; the worst things are people hurting you, fighting and bullying Most children prefer playing outside at school than playing inside The most popular activities when playing outside are team games and
sitting chatting to friends The most popular activities when playing inside are playing with
Have Your Say…about school______________________________________________________________
Children’s Voices Project0114 273 5233
4
computers and on apparatus Children like having things to do or equipment to play on at playtimes; it
helps to reduce fighting and bullying Most children think they have a lot of time to play but would like even
more time, more football and no bullying Half of children were happy with the after-school clubs they attend at
school; the most popular activity is sports clubs 4% of children said there were no after-school clubs at their school During the school holiday children would like schools to provide trips,
swimming, play schemes and sports clubs
Staying safe Almost all children who responded said they had either been victims of
bullying or knew someone who had been bullied Bullying takes place most commonly close to home or in the playground
at school Most children would talk to a teacher if they were being bullied at school Bullying is most commonly dealt with by the head teacher who often
talks to the bully’s parents Almost half of children had been teased within the past four weeks Most children have places outside where they can play safely Most children are allowed out more often when going out with friends or
adults than on their own Safety from other people and traffic issues are the main factors affecting
whether children play out or not Children generally feel safe when playing outside in their area, except
when they are alone Less traffic, more police and being safe from teenagers would improve
safety for children; 18% would not change anything about safety in theirarea
Being healthy
Emotional well-being Being loved is the best thing about living in a family Most children would not change anything about their family. Of those
who would change something, “shouting and arguing” was the mostcommon response
Most children feel most comfortable talking to a friend or a teacher abouta problem at school
Most children said they feel happy most of the time
Have Your Say…about school______________________________________________________________
Children’s Voices Project0114 273 5233
5
Physical well-being Children are aware that they should eat healthy food and stated a desire
for better education for them and their parents about healthy eating Children feel they could be helped to be healthier through healthier
meals at school, more time for PE and longer playtimes The most common breakfast foods are cereal and juice; 10% of children
who responded said they did not eat anything before going to school Children recognise the health benefits of drinking plenty water; water is
readily available at school, primarily through taps in classrooms andwater fountains
More than half the children who responded walked to and from school A school nurse is seen as someone who can be trusted for a confidential
conversation at school Children would also like access to a school nurse outside of the school
day, for example at after-school clubs or home
Making a positive contribution Most schools have a school council Class reps are a common method of children making their views known
within school; school reps also report back to pupils about school councilmeeting discussions
Suggestion boxes are an effective way of collating children’s views within school
Less than half of the children who responded feel part of what happenswithin their school; 20% feel that nothing happens as a result of schoolcouncil discussion
Three-quarters of children feel that they are not consulted on issues inschool that are important to them, such as bullying
Almost half of the children who responded feel that adults do not listen tothem when they tell them something
Jobs around school are viewed as a good way of being involved inschool life and allow children to feel proud of their school
Economic well-being More than half of the children who responded are looking forward to
going to secondary school The best things about going to secondary school are trips and exciting
things to do The worst things about going to secondary school are the fear that work
might be too hard
Have Your Say…about school______________________________________________________________
Children’s Voices Project0114 273 5233
6
Phase 1: Consultation events
What did we do?
In April 2005, the Children’s Voices Project invited primary aged children from across Sheffield to attend one of three ‘Have Your Say…about school’ events. The events were held in Sheffield city centre, Sharrow and Norfolk Park from6th–8th April 2005. Fun activities, including circus skills and break dancingworkshops, badge making, biscuit decorating and an obstacle course wereprovided along with a number of consultation activities. Consultationtechniques were specifically designed to be fun and engaging and to best suitthe area being consulted on. The children were free to choose whichactivities they took part in.
The table below shows the issue consulted and the technique used:
Consultation issue Consultation techniquePlay Picture votingSchool nurses and health Questionnaire and treasure huntBehaviourLearningBullying
Big Brother diary room
Children’s voices QuestionnaireAfter school and holiday provision Post-it notes
On arrival, the children were asked to register their details in an ‘activity booklet’ to accompany the day’s events. The children kept this booklet with them during the day. After completing a minimum of four fun activities andfour consultation activities, the children handed in their booklet in return for agoody bag. The completed booklets contained information about the child,including name, gender, age, date of birth, school attended and ethnicity.This allowed us to collate valuable monitoring information about the childrenwho attended.
From the monitoring information we received we know that half of the childrenattending were female and half were male. The average age of the childrenattending was 8 and a half years old. The children came from 43 differentschools across Sheffield and live in 30 different areas across the city. Two-thirds of the children attending were white British. Of the remaining children,the highest number of attendees were from Pakistani, dual heritage, Somaliand Caribbean ethnic backgrounds.
The findings, including monitoring information collated at the events, arepresented below:
Have Your Say…about school______________________________________________________________
Children’s Voices Project0114 273 5233
7
Monitoring information
Are you a boy or a girl?
How old are you?
What word best describes you?
47.5
52.5Boy
Girl
1
97
13
18
13
17
22
0
5
10
15
20
25
4 year
s
5 year
s
6 year
s
7 year
s
8 year
s
9 year
s
10ye
ars
11ye
ars
Age of child
%o
fch
ildre
n
67
10 95 5
2 1 10
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
Whit
e
Pakist
ani
Multipl
e herita
ge
Somali
Caribb
ean
Libya
n
Yemen
i
Indian
%o
fch
ildre
n
What area do you live in?
0.5
2.5
10.5
21 1
3.5
0.5 0.5 0.5
11.5
1 1
5.5
1
2.5
8
18
2.5
4
2.5
6
2 22.5
0.5
15
0.5 0.5
0
2
4
6
8
10
12
14
16
18
20
Abbey
dale
Batemoo
r
Beauc
hief
Bradw
ay
Broom
hall
Cross
pool
Darna
ll
Eccles
all
Encliff
e
FirthPar
k
Frech
eville
Gleadle
ss
Gleadle
ssVall
ey
Green
Hill
Herdin
gs
Highfie
lds
Hillsbo
roug
h
Jord
antho
rpe
Lowed
ges
Lowfie
ld
Manor
Nether
Edge
Norfol
k Park
Norton
Pageh
all
Parso
n Cross
Pitsmoo
r
Sharro
w
Shireg
reen
Woo
dsea
ts
%o
fch
ildre
n
Have Y
our Say…
about school_________________________________________________________________
Children’s V
oices Project
80114
2735233
What is your school called?
Children’s V
oices Project
90114
2735233
Have Y
our Say…
about school_________________________________________________________________
10.5
2
1
4
2
1 1 1
4
3
0.5 0.5
3
2
13
10
4
10.5
3 3
2
0.5 0.51
4
0.5
2
6
7
2
1 1 10.5
1 1
4
1
2
1
0
2
4
6
8
10
12
14A
bbey
dale
Acr
esH
ill
Arb
ourt
horn
eJ
Bal
lifie
ld
Ban
kwoo
d
Birl
ey
Byr
onW
ood
Cha
rnoc
kH
all
Eas
tHill
Gle
adle
ss
Gre
enhi
ll
Har
tley
Bro
ok
Huc
klow
Hun
ter's
Bar
J
Long
ley
Low
edge
s
Low
erM
eado
w
Low
field
Lydg
ate
J
Man
orLo
dge
Nor
folk
Nor
ton
Fre
e
Par
kH
ill
Par
son
Cro
ss
Pip
wor
thN
I
Pip
wor
thJ
Por
ter
Cro
ft
Pye
Ban
k
Sac
red
Hea
rt
Sha
rrow
NI
Sha
rrow
J
Sir
Har
old
Jack
son
StJ
ohn
Fis
her
StM
ary'
sC
E
StO
swal
d's
StP
atric
k's
StT
here
sa's
StT
hom
asof
Can
terb
ury
Val
ley
Par
k
Wal
kley
Whi
tew
ays
Woo
dtho
rpe
%o
fch
ildre
n
What school do you go to?
Key0-4 children
5-9 children
10-14 children
15-19 children
20-24 children
Have Your Say...about school
10
Have Your Say…about school______________________________________________________________
Children’s Voices Project0114 273 5233
11
What did children tell us?
Play in school
Where do you like playing most in school?
playing inside23%
playing outside77%
Have Your Say…about school______________________________________________________________
Children’s Voices Project0114 273 5233
12
When you’re playing outside at school, what do you like doingmost?
running and chasing games team games12% 45%
games to play on my own traditional games9% 5%
quiet games sitting chatting to my friends5% 24%
Have Your Say…about school______________________________________________________________
Children’s Voices Project0114 273 5233
13
Where is your favourite place to play outside at school?
hard playground all-weather pitch13% 19%
grass playing field wood play area17% 18%
play equipment natural things to play26% 7%
Have Your Say…about school______________________________________________________________
Children’s Voices Project0114 273 5233
14
When you’re playing inside at school, what do you like doing most?
home corner board games6% 4%
computers apparatus38% 26%
movement indoor games14% 5%
dressing up7%
Have Your Say…about school______________________________________________________________
Children’s Voices Project0114 273 5233
15
How often do you play at school?
What is the best thing about play at school?
%Playing with friends 36Football 27PE 8Skipping 6Playing games 6Basketball 4The playground 4Swings 2Computers 2Tiggy 1Playing inside 1The equipment 1Wet / muddy playing field 1Art 1
25
10
12
1
LotsSometimesNot muchNever
Have Your Say…about school______________________________________________________________
Children’s Voices Project0114 273 5233
16
What is the worst thing about play at school?
%People hurting you / fighting 20Bullying 16Falling over / hurting yourself 13Arguments 9Teachers shouting at you 8Not enough equipment 5Rain 4Nothing 3Swearing 2When it’s cold 2Breaking your legs 2Dangerous bits of play area 2Games 2Being lonely 2Skipping 1No dressing up 1Boys 1Cricket 1Playtimes not long enough 1Being scared 1Football 1PE 1Kiss catch 1Indoor games 1
If you could change one thing about play at school, whatwould it be?
%More time to play 27More football 15No bullying 13Football pitch and nets 9No football 6Being able to go on the grass 5No fighting 5More things to play on 5Girls to play football 5Safer yard 4Adventure playground 4No swearing 2
What would help you be healthier at school?
61
18
85 5
1 1 0.5 0.50
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
Healthiermeals; more
fruit andvegetables
More PEtime
Longerplaytimes
Water inclassrooms
Free milk Having aschool nurse
Lessonsoutside
Lessonsabout being
healthy
Fresh air
%o
fch
ildre
n
Health
insch
oo
l
Have Y
our Say…
about school_____________________________________________________________
Children’s V
oices Project
170114
2735233
What does a school nurse do?
43
18 18
5 4.53 3
2 1.5 1 1
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
45
50
Look afteryou if youare sick
Checks tomake sureI'm healthy
Look afteryou if youfall over
Eye tests Checksheight and
weight
Checks yourteeth
Giveinjections
Check myears
Teaches usabout drugs
Give youhearing test
Don't know
%o
fch
ildre
n
Have Y
our Say…
about school_____________________________________________________________
Children’s V
oices Project
180114
2735233
What else could a school nurse do?
20
11 1110
9
6 65.5
5 5
2 21 1 1 1 1
0.5 0.5 0.5 0.5 0.5
0
5
10
15
20
25
Mak
em
ebe
tter
Giv
em
epl
aste
rsw
hen
Ifa
llov
er
Tea
chm
eho
wto
behe
alth
ier
Tal
kto
me
whe
nI'm
upse
t
Be
nice
/kin
d
Be
arou
ndm
ore
ofte
n
Tea
chpa
rent
sho
wto
keep
you
heal
thy
Giv
em
em
edec
ine
List
ento
you
Che
ckfo
rni
ts
Che
ckm
yhe
arin
g
Tal
kto
usab
outg
row
ing
up
Giv
eyo
uin
ject
ions
Che
ckou
rey
es
Che
ckm
yte
eth
Hel
pm
eco
ntro
lmy
tem
per
Tak
eyo
uto
hosp
ital
Tea
chyo
usa
fety
rule
s
Not
beto
oro
ugh
Not
too
man
yta
blet
s
Tea
chus
first
aid
Giv
eyo
ua
bow
land
clea
nup
ifyo
uar
esi
ck
%o
fch
ildre
n
Have Y
our Say…
about school_____________________________________________________________
Children’s V
oicesP
roject19
0114273
5233
If you had a personal problem, would you talk to a school nurse about it?
27
10
63
YesNoMaybe
Have Y
our Say…
about school_____________________________________________________________
Children’s V
oices Project
200114
2735233
Where else would you like to talk to your school nurse?
33
21
13
9
6 6 64
1 1
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35H
ome
Doc
tors
Afte
rsc
hool
club
Som
ewhe
repr
ivat
e
Pla
ygro
und
Libr
ary
You
thcl
ub
Hos
pita
l
On
the
stre
et
Som
ewhe
rein
holid
ays
%o
fch
ildre
n
Have Y
our Say…
about school_____________________________________________________________
Children’s V
oices Project
210114
2735233
Have Your Say…about school______________________________________________________________
Children’s Voices Project0114 273 5233
22
Bullying in school
What do you think bullying is?Response % CommentsNasty 50 It hurts your feeling and it’s really, really bad
People teasing you for no reason all the timeCalling names 29 Calling you names and always picking on you every
single dayPhysical attacks 21
Do you know someone who has been bullied?Response %Me 60Friend 17Someone at school 12Sibling 5No-one 4I bullied someone 2
Where did it happen?Response %School 81Playground 66On way home from school 19Classroom 12School field 22
What time of day did it happen?Response % CommentsPlaytime 48Lunchtime 25 Mostly dinner times when they have more time
to walk about the playground and stuff, whenthere’s nothing else for them to do
After school 10During lesson time 10All day 7
Who would you talk to if you or a friend were being bullied?Why would you talk to this person?Response % CommentsMy teacher 41 He said at the beginning of the year ‘come and
talk to me if you’re being bullied’ so it showshecares and I know I can trust him
Head teacher 26 Because I know he can do somethingHe sorts everything outCos I know he will sort it
Have Your Say…about school______________________________________________________________
Children’s Voices Project0114 273 5233
23
Mum or Dad 14 I’d rather talk to my mum because my mum always listens to me not like the teachers…if I tried to tell them they’d probably tell me to stop talking. It’s rubbish
Learning mentor 7 She’s more understanding, she does a friendship group
Another teacher 3 I get on with him better than my teacherDinner lady 3 She’s always there when it’s happening and can
stop it straight awaySchool council 3 Then they can tell a teacherFriend 1.5 He makes me feel comfortable, calms me down
and makes me laughNo-one 1.5 I talked to my teacher but she didn’t listen, she
said just leave itOther comments:They should get a person who isn’t from school to come in so more people would talk to them about stuff like bullying…if it was someone who was from school like a teacher they’d say they haven’t got enough time
Do you know if your school has a bullying policyResponse %Yes 80No 13Don’t know 7
Does your school ask the pupils about how the school shoulddeal with bullies?Response % CommentsNo 75Yes 25 The school council talk about it
Yes we get asked through the school councilWe made this poster about bullying to go on the walls
How does your school deal with bullying?Response % CommentsMiss playtimes 23Temporary exclusion 17 It works cos they get scared that they might
be kicked out altogether so it makes themstop
See head teacher 13 They talk to them and find out why they’re bullying peopleOur head teacher gets everyone into thehall and talks to us all about bullying andwhy you shouldn’t do it
Permanent exclusion 10Talk to teacher / learningmentor
10
After school detention 10
Have Your Say…about school______________________________________________________________
Children’s Voices Project0114 273 5233
24
Bully form (for the victim) 7 It [bully form] tells you what to do if you’re being bullied
Do nothing 7 Loads of people get bullied at our schooland we have a bullying policy but theteachers never carry it out so they knowthey can get away with it
Internal exclusion (go andwork in another room)
3
How do you think your school should deal with bullies?Response % CommentsWarnings system 27Permanent exclusion 19 Ask them why they’re bullying and then
send them to another schoolI’d expel them permanently so theywouldn’t be able to bully me
Call their parents 15 Write a letter to parents and they would becross and punish them at home too
Miss playtimes 15Temporary exclusion 12Involve police 8 The school should ask a policeman to talk
to themif it’s really seriousTalk to them 4 Talk to them and find out why. Is it
someone you don’t like and if it is then why do you play with them, why don’t you just stay away from themTalk to them and punish everyone if thebully won’t own up
Have Your Say…about school______________________________________________________________
Children’s Voices Project0114 273 5233
25
Behaviour at school
Why do you think children behave badly at school?Response % CommentsAttention seeking / showingoff
33 Sometimes they want to be cool. Theythink they’re right good but they’re not
ADHD 14Being bullied themselves 14Problems at home 9They know they can getaway with it
5
Bad grades 5Learning problem 5They can’t get their own way
5
Showing off in front ofsupply teachers
5
Don’t know 5
What happens in your school when children behave badly?Response % CommentsSent to head teacher’s office
22 If you’re naughty you have to sit on the naughty chair outside the head teacher’s office and he comes out and talks to youand if you do it again he writes a letter toyour parents and after that he just keepson writing letters and letters and lettersHe gives them chances cos he’s a nice head teacher
Lose playtime or lunch time 17 A 10 minute detention at dinner time…but they think it’s not a lot so it doesn’t stop themYou have to sit next to the window andwork and listen to everyone outsideplaying
Isolation / sent to work inanother room
16 Bad people get new things, a niceclassroom and fun things to do likecolouring. It’s not fairThe rainbow room is nicer than ourclassroom, it’s got all nice new stuff in it and I don’t see why naughty people should be allowed to go there, you shouldbe able to got here if you’ve been good cos it’s a treat. If you’re good you should be able to go in there and do colouringlike for golden time but not as apunishment just on your own
Detention 13
Have Your Say…about school______________________________________________________________
Children’s Voices Project0114 273 5233
26
Warning systems leading toother punishment
8 We have yellow and red cards…you get a yellow card every time you’re naughty and if you get 3 then you get a red cardand that means you miss playtimes for aweek. If you get 3 red cards you’re expelled
Told off by teacher 8Miss fun lessons 8 If they swear at a dinner lady they’re not
allowed to go swimmingTime off golden time 8
How do you think children in school should be punished forbad behaviour?Response % CommentsExclusion 36 Then they won’t be able to misbehave
because some people are really badLose playtime or lunchtime 27Sent to head teacher 13Given warnings 9After school detention 9Cane 4 Shouting doesn’t do any good cos they
just take the mick out of them, theyshould really punish them like with caning
Do you think teachers react to bad behaviour in the same wayas parents? What is the difference?Response % CommentsNo 87 Teachers can’t ground you and can’t smack you
Your mam would be nasty and ground you but teachersdon’t do anything cos they know they’d get done like your mam will smack you but teachers can’t do it and kids know it and that’s why they behave badly at school more than at homeAt school they just say that’s your warning’ and carryonbut my mum she’ll just smack me and send me to bed…my mum is the worst punishmentBecause my mum would hit me and teachers can’t…I would be more bad at school than for my mumTeachers don’t hit you because sometimes you get smacked by your mum don’t you but teachers can’t so they just send you to isolation…people would be better if teachers could hit themTeachers start shouting and bawling and parents justsmack youThey’re different punishments…parents’ is worseTeachers don’t slap youParents don’t give you warnings, they shout at you,ground you and tell you to go to bed
Have Your Say…about school______________________________________________________________
Children’s Voices Project0114 273 5233
27
Yes 13 They both calm the person downThey both just shout at youThey stop you playing out at playtime like parents stopyou playing out on a night
Do you think that children should be rewarded for goodbehaviour?Response % CommentsYes 95 There’s a lot of people who just get on with it in their
lessons and no-one ever says anything to themThey don’t notice when you’re doing something well even when you’re really trying your hardest when you’re not very good, they never see how hard you’re trying
Sometimes 5 If you did it all the time it wouldn’t be a treat
No 0
How should children be rewarded for good behaviour? Whathappens in your school?Response % CommentsStickers 36Certificates 24Presentations in assembly 14Free dinners 9Star chart and prize 9Golden points 4 Golden points…names go in a pot and
it’s drawn on a Friday and 3 people get a prize like a pen or a pencil orsomething
House points 4Other comments:We get credits…little slips of paper and if you get 50 you get a prize, a sticker book or somethingAt our school naughty people get rewarded, they get to have their lunch beforeanyone else, it’s wrong
Do you think it is more important to punish bad behaviour orreward good behaviour? Why?Response % CommentsReward good behaviour 74 I think bad kids should just be ignored and
left to what they’re doing and then they’ll get fed up of it and then praise all goodbehaviour and they’ll get jealous of all theattention and just stop it because they’re only naughty cos they’re attention seeking anywaySo there’s less bad behaviour and people get good marks in their SATs
Have Your Say…about school______________________________________________________________
Children’s Voices Project0114 273 5233
28
They don’t have rewards at secondary school and they have worse behaviourIf you look out for people being good andteachers concentrate on it then kids willthink about being good more than beingbadThe bad ones will keep being bad so youshould concentrate on the good onesBecause people can carry on being bad butyou have to try hard to be goodNormally people don’t get treats all the time so if they’re good they should get somethingIt’s good if you’re good cos you get stickersIt will make all the naughty people behaveproperly
Punish bad behaviour 26 You don’t have to learn a lesson if you’re good but you’ve got to learn a lesson if you’re badIf you don’t do something about it, it’s just going to carry on and get worseThey’ll just carry on
Have Your Say…about school______________________________________________________________
Children’s Voices Project0114 273 5233
29
Learning at school
What helps you learn well at school?Responses % CommentsFun lessons 42 Fun lessons where you don’t just sit down
and copy stuff like in science doing tests onthings
Better teachers 26Good books / equipment 16Sitting next to friends 5 I know that if I don’t get something I ask my
friends and they’ll help me get it rightAdults helping 5Learning centre 5
What stops you from learning?Responses % CommentsPeople messing about,talking, distracting me
72 If people talk tome I can’t do my work
Bad behaviour 14 If someone is messing about the teacherhas to stop teaching and that stops youfrom getting your educationPeople messing about and making theteacher stop to sort them out
Bullying 14 It stops me from concentrating on my work
What would help you learn better?Responses % CommentsNaughty children moved toanother room
38 People distracting me in class, if they gotmoved to a different class…and then they could have extra support and learningmentors to help then and then we could geton with our work tooThey could go and do the same work as usbut they’d have extra time to do it and have it explained and extra people to help themNaughty children sent to another room orsent home and punished more
Extra adults in class to help 21 Give you extra support…cos the teacher can’t really talk to each individual child if they’ve got a big class…and they could see the people causing the problems better
Better teachers 16 A teacher who pushes you to the limit tohelp you do your work and help you learnand to be in a class where there’s good people who get on with their workHave experts who know more about whatyou’re learning to help you so they’d make it sound more interesting and then it wouldseem easier and more fun
Have Your Say…about school______________________________________________________________
Children’s Voices Project0114 273 5233
30
Sitting at single desks 12 If you sat at single desks you’d be close enough to ask your friend for help if you gotstuck but not close enough to sit chattingwhen you should be workingStop people from being naughty and if theychat then move them…so I could sit on myown so no-one could disturb me
No talking rule in class 8 If they talk then make them stand up andstop it
More books and betterequipment
4 So you don’t have to share books cos if you have to share with someone who messesabout you can’t do your work properlyBetter stuff to use to help you when you’re working
Working in a room on myown
1
Other comments:Sit in different seats…so girls should sit next to boys”
What do you think schools should do to help children atschool?CommentsStop giving us sugary foods…it’s down to us to choose but they could give us more things to choose from that we like…like at Safeway they have salad bowls they could do more stuff like thatGet support teachers in like for someone who’s dyslexic to help them readand write and sit next to them…who’s there all the timeGive out more prizes for good children
Have Your Say…about school______________________________________________________________
Children’s Voices Project0114 273 5233
31
Children’s voices in school
Does your school have a school council?
Do you have a class rep?
91
9
Yes
No
80
20
Yes
No
Have Your Say…about school______________________________________________________________
Children’s Voices Project0114 273 5233
32
How can you make your voice heard to the class rep or school council?
How do you find out about what your school council talks about?
What sort of things have been talked about by your school council?
Issue %New equipment 11Don’t know 10Playtime 10Toilets 8Football nets / pitch 7Playground 6Bullying / fighting 5New school being built 5
3229
21
9
52 1 1
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
The
yas
km
e
We
doit
inci
rcle
time
Ital
kto
them
atpl
aytim
e
We
have
asu
gges
tions
box
The
yne
ver
ask
me
Ask
incl
ass
Cla
ssco
unci
l
I don’t
both
er
%o
fch
ildre
n
42
24
18
9
3 2 1 10
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
45
Cla
ssre
pte
llsus
Sch
ool
new
slet
ter
Ass
embl
ies
Not
ice
boar
ds
Don
'tkn
ow
Tea
cher
s
Ask
them
Pla
ytim
e
%o
fch
ildre
n
Have Your Say…about school______________________________________________________________
Children’s Voices Project0114 273 5233
33
Dining room 4School dinners 4Behaviour 4More computers 3Uniform 3More trees 3Wheelchair ramps 2School bus 2Safety 2Football boots 2Fund raising 1Sports day 1Carpet on corridors 1New books 1After school clubs 1Changing the school logo 1New doors 1Water fountain 1Bins outside 1Golden time 1Bike shed 1Newsletter 1Swimming pool 1Skateboarding 1
What has changed in your school because of what your school councilhas talked about?
Issue %Nothing 20Playground 14Sports hall / equipment 12Toilets 8Playtime 6New games 6Hitting and bullying 6School gates 4Uniform 4Dining room 3Classroom 3School dinners 2Climbing frame 2Flower bed / garden 2Tuck shop 2Wheelchair access 2School bell 2Teachers’ attitudes to children 1
Have Your Say…about school______________________________________________________________
Children’s Voices Project0114 273 5233
34
Fresh fruit 1Planted trees 1More computers 1New books 1Tables 1Security door 1Outside door 1Bike shed 1
Do you think your school listens to what you have to say?
79
15
6
YesNoSometimes
Have Your Say…about school______________________________________________________________
Children’s Voices Project0114 273 5233
35
After-school and holiday provision
What do you miss about school in the school holidays?
What would you want school to provide for you during the holidays?
47
20 18
11
4
05
101520253035404550
Friends Schoolwork
Nothing Playing /playtime
Teachers
%o
fch
ildre
n
28
22 22
16
42 2 2 2
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
Trip
s
Sw
imm
ing
Pla
ysch
emes
Spo
rts
club
s
Foo
tbal
ltr
aini
ng&
mat
ches
Sho
win
gvi
deos
like
atth
epi
ctur
es
Com
pute
rcl
ub
Coo
king
club
Chu
rch
club
%o
fch
ildre
n
Have Your Say…about schools______________________________________________________________
Children’s Voices Project0114 273 5233
36
Phase 2: Questionnaires
What did we do?
During the summer term, 2005, a number of schools across Sheffield wereapproached about being involved in a survey process involving Year 5 pupils.Six schools agreed to take part in the survey and the questionnaires werecompleted during June 2005. The following schools took part in the process:
School Number of pupilsAbbey Lane Primary School 58Arbourthorne Primary School 42Ballifield Primary School 49Monteney Primary School 43Nook Lane Junior School 54Springfield Primary School 22Total pupils 268
The pupils were asked to answer multiple choice questions on the followingissues:
You and your home School Feeling safe Bullying After-school activities Moving to secondary school Your feelings
The pupils’ responses provided the following results:
Have Your Say…about schools______________________________________________________________
Children’s Voices Project0114 273 5233
37
What did children tell us?
Talking about…you and your home
I am a…
The word that best describes me is
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
Whi
teB
ritis
h
Mul
tiple
herit
age
Som
ali
Yem
eni
Pak
ista
ni
Whi
teIr
ish
Chi
nese
Am
eric
an
Car
ibbe
an
Japa
nese
Afr
ican
back
grou
nd
Whi
teE
urop
ean
Oth
er
%o
fch
ildre
n
52%48% boy
girl
Have Your Say…about schools______________________________________________________________
Children’s Voices Project0114 273 5233
38
Who looks after you most of the time?
Other responses:Mum and mummy
How many people live in your home other than you?
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
45
mum and dadtogether
mostly mum mum and dadshared
mostly dad grandparents foster parents brother /sister
child minder
%o
fch
ildre
n
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
45
none one two three four five six seven eight nine ten eleven
number of people
%o
fch
ildre
n
Have Your Say…about schools______________________________________________________________
Children’s Voices Project0114 273 5233
39
What are the best things about living in your family?
Other responses:Celebrating birthdaysBeing a happy familyGetting taken to footballPlaying with cousinsPlaying on consoleMy pets
What would you change about your family?
Other responsesMum and dad together againTo have a brother and sisterSee Dad morePlay more football
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
being lookedafter
being loved being treated going out withfamily
brothers andsisters
talking withfamily
%o
fch
ildre
n
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
told off andpunished
go out moretogether
Mum and Dadthere more
not getting onwith siblings
shouting andarguing
nothing
%o
fch
ildre
n
Have Your Say…about schools______________________________________________________________
Children’s Voices Project0114 273 5233
40
How many bedrooms are there in your house?
Do you have any places in or near your home where you can go to bealone?
Do you have any places in or near your home where you can go to doreading and writing quietly?
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
2 bedrooms 3 bedrooms 4 bedrooms 5 bedrooms 6 bedrooms 7 bedrooms 8 bedrooms
%o
fch
ildre
n
68%
32%
yesno
60%
40%
yes
no
Have Your Say…about schools______________________________________________________________
Children’s Voices Project0114 273 5233
41
Do you have any places in or near your home where you can playoutside safely?
How much do you like the house where you live?
What are the best things about your home?
Other responses:GardenPetsFootballMum and DadFridge
83%
17%
yes
no
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
a lot quite a lot a bit not much
%o
fch
ildre
n
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
my room toys &games
friendsnearby
TV andvideo
nice placeto live
computer neighbours
%o
fch
ildre
n
Have Your Say…about schools______________________________________________________________
Children’s Voices Project0114 273 5233
42
What things would you like to change about your home?
What did you eat or drink before coming to school today?
Other responses:PancakesPizzaYoghurt
Where do you get water to drink at school?
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
cleaner andtidier
bigger house biggergarden
bigger / ownroom
warmer nothing
%o
fch
ildre
n
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
brea
kfas
tba
rs
cere
al
choc
olat
e/
swee
ts
cook
edbr
eakf
ast
cris
ps
tea
/cof
fee
wat
er
milk
frui
t
juic
e
porr
ige
toas
t/br
ead
noth
ing
%o
fch
ildre
n
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
class waterbottles
own drinkingbottles
tap inclassroom
water fountain can't get any
%o
fch
ildre
n
Have Your Say…about schools______________________________________________________________
Children’s Voices Project0114 273 5233
43
How did you get to school today?
Other responses:TramTaxi
Talking about…school
How many lessons do you enjoy at school?
How often do your parents or carers ask you about your school day?
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
walked car bike bus
%o
fch
ildre
n
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
all most half less thanhalf
hardly any none
%o
fch
ildre
n
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
all the time sometimes hardly ever never
%o
fch
ildre
n
Have Your Say…about schools______________________________________________________________
Children’s Voices Project0114 273 5233
44
Are you happy at school?
How well do you get on with people at school?
What are the best things about your school?
05
1015202530354045
very happy quite happy not veryhappy
not at allhappy
not sure
%o
fch
ildre
n
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
100
teachers headteacher
lunchtimesupervisor
classroomassistant
learningmentor
schoolnurse
friends otherpupils
%o
fch
ildre
n
very wellquite wellnot very well
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
favouritesubjects
playtimes schoolclubs
seeingfriends
sports andPE
teachers
%o
fch
ildre
n
Have Your Say…about schools______________________________________________________________
Children’s Voices Project0114 273 5233
45
If you needed to talk to someone at school, who would it be?
What things would you like to change about your school?
Other responses:Shorter daysMore playtimeBetter behaviourClimbing frame
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
45
friend headteacher
learningmentor
lunchtimesupervisor
no-one schoolnurse
teacher parents
%o
fch
ildre
n
0
5
10
15
20
25
bette
rm
eals
bigg
erpl
aygr
ound
less
borin
gsu
bjec
ts
dinn
erla
dies
mor
efu
n
mor
ehe
lpw
hen
you
don'
tun
ders
tand
mor
eto
doat
play
time
teac
hers
shou
ting
less
pupi
lslis
tene
dto
mor
e noth
ing
%o
fch
ildre
n
Have Your Say…about schools______________________________________________________________
Children’s Voices Project0114 273 5233
46
What helps you learn at school?
Other responses:Fun lessonsSitting at tables you choosePeace and quietInteractive whiteboardFriendsHelpers
How well do you think you doin…
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
computersin class
goodequipment
learningmentors
teachers tidyclassroom
%o
fch
ildre
n
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
maths literacy science games art
%o
fch
ildre
n
Could do betterOKVery well
Have Your Say…about schools______________________________________________________________
Children’s Voices Project0114 273 5233
47
What might help you more in…?
Do you have a school council?
Do you think your class council rep is good at telling the school councilwhat you think?
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
maths literacy science games art
%o
fch
ildre
n
Adults
Equipment
More time
Older pupilshelping
Something else
96%
4%
yes
no
82%
18%
yes
no
Have Your Say…about schools______________________________________________________________
Children’s Voices Project0114 273 5233
48
Do things happen in your school because of what your school counciltalk about?
If you don’t have a school council, how can you tell people what you think?
If you have them in your school, do you think the following are a goodidea or not?
80%
20%
yes
no
62%
25%
13%
suggestion box
notice board
newsletters
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
playgroundfriends
office duties lunchtime jobs showing visitorsround
%o
fch
ildre
n
Good idea
Not good idea
Don't know
Have Your Say…about schools______________________________________________________________
Children’s Voices Project0114 273 5233
49
Do you feel part of what happens in school?
Talking about…feeling safe
Are you allowed to play outside in the streets, parks or play areas?
49%
17%
34%
yes
no
don't know
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
Whenever I want Sometimes Never
%o
fch
ildre
n with parent /carer
with friends
on my own
Have Your Say…about schools______________________________________________________________
Children’s Voices Project0114 273 5233
50
If you don’t play outside much, why not?
Other responses:Rather play on PS2 / XboxNothing to play onRather readRather watch TVGroundedCan’t be bothered
Do you feel safe when…
35%
40%
25%danger of traffic
don't feel safebecause of otherpeople
parents / carerswon't let me
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
on way toschool
at school on way homefrom school
going out afterdark
going outduring the day
%o
fch
ildre
n
Yes
Sometimes
No
Have Your Say…about schools______________________________________________________________
Children’s Voices Project0114 273 5233
51
What things would you like to change about safety in your area?
Other responses:Suspicious behaviour by hooded peopleNo burglarsSafe from dogsNo motorbikesLess bulliesNo drunk peopleMore speed bumps
Talking about…bullying
Have any of these things happened to you more than once in the last 4weeks?
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
less traffic more roadcrossings
policearound more
safe fromolder
teenagers
safe fromother people
nothing
%o
fch
ildre
n
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
asked formoney
ganged upon
teased ormade fun of
threatenedfor noreason
called nastynames
had thingstaken
pushed or hitfor noreason
%o
fch
ildre
n
Have Your Say…about schools______________________________________________________________
Children’s Voices Project0114 273 5233
52
Where did this happen?
Who would you talk to at school if you were being bullied?
Other responses:School nurse
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
45
at or nearhome
during lessontime
classroom atplaytime
schoolcorridor or
toilets
outside atplaytime
park or playarea
on way to orfrom school
%o
fch
ildre
n
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
classroomassistant
headteacher
learningmentor
lunchtimesupervisor
teacher friend family no-one
%o
fch
ildre
n
Have Your Say…about schools______________________________________________________________
Children’s Voices Project0114 273 5233
53
What happens in your school if someone is being bullied?
Other responses:Miss playtimeMiss golden timeTeacher in charge of talking to bullies deals with itBully told off by teacherBully is namedBully told not to do it again
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
bully isexpelled
head sendsletter home
head talks tobully's parents
nothing don't know
%o
fch
lidre
n
Have Your Say…about schools______________________________________________________________
Children’s Voices Project0114 273 5233
54
Talking about…after-school activities
What after schools clubs do you go to?
Other responses:Street danceChessGymnasticsHomeworkGardening
SpanishHockeyCricketBowlsSambaLunch club
How good are after school clubs you go to?
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
art drama football music /singing
afterschoolclub
recorder sportclub
no clubsat school
%o
fch
ildre
n
55%34%
11%
very good
OK
not verygood
Have Your Say…about schools______________________________________________________________
Children’s Voices Project0114 273 5233
55
Do you think there should be more after school clubs?
What other clubs would you like?
Art Gymnastics BasketballTennis Football AthleticsCricket Rugby DramaDance Chess RoundersClimbing Sports GolfIce hockey Choir singing Fashion/ beautyHomework Gardening HistorySwimming Languages CyclingGaming Computer / PS2 / Xbox HockeyCooking Badminton TrampolineScience Conflict resolution SnookerMaths Netball Table tennis
Talking about…moving to secondary school
Are you looking forward to secondary school?
59%
41%
yes
no
60%
40%
yes
no
Have Your Say…about schools______________________________________________________________
Children’s Voices Project0114 273 5233
56
What are you most looking forward to about going to secondary school?
Other responses:Seeing my brother / family membersSweet shopsGoing home / out for dinnerVending machinesGetting nearer to the job I wantBetter school mealsOther clubsHaving my own thingsSwimming poolSeeing old friendsDissecting
What are you least looking forward to about going to secondary school?
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
being bullied getting lost more tests teachersshouting
work might betoo hard
%o
fch
ildre
n
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
learning newthings
making newfriends
new teachers more excitingthings to do
school trips
%o
fch
ildre
n
Have Your Say…about schools______________________________________________________________
Children’s Voices Project0114 273 5233
57
Other responses:Getting detentionInjectionsHaving to bring my own thingsMore homeworkCarrying my bag all the time
Talking about…your feelings
How happy do you feel most of the time?
When you have something to say in front of teachers, do you feelworried or scared?
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
very happy quite happy not sure not veryhappy
very unhappy
%o
fch
ildre
n
29%
37%
34%yes
no
don'tknow
Have Your Say…about schools______________________________________________________________
Children’s Voices Project0114 273 5233
58
Do other pupils in school fall out with you a lot?
Do you feel lonely at school?
Do you think the other children often say nasty things about you?
24%
53%
23%
yes
no
don'tknow
20%
61%
19%
yesnodon't know
27%
33%
40%yes
no
don't know
Have Your Say…about schools______________________________________________________________
Children’s Voices Project0114 273 5233
59
When you want to tell an adult something do you usually feel shy?
Do you think adults listen to you when you when you tell themsomething?
38%
45%
17%
yes
no
don't know
38%
45%
17%
yes
no
don't know
Have Your Say…about schools______________________________________________________________
Children’s Voices Project0114 273 5233
60
Phase 3: Focus Groups
What did we do?
Two small groups of Year 5 pupils, including seven children fromArbourthorne Primary School and seven from Springfield Primary School,were invited to take part in focus group sessions to look at issues around theirschool.
The children were given digital cameras and dictaphones to record thingsaround their school that were important to them. The children were asked tothink about what helped and hindered them in their learning and anything elsethat they considered important to their learning and school life.
The photographs and accompanying comments are recorded below:
Have Your Say…about schools______________________________________________________________
Children’s Voices Project0114 273 5233
61
What did children tell us?
Arbourthorne Primary School
My classroom is my favourite placeto go in school. It’s where my friends are.
Our classroom is a really good placeto learn.
Our teachers are really good andhelp us learn.
These boards make lessons moreinteresting. We should have one inevery classroom.
I think I learn best in here. It’s different to being in the classroom, itmakes it more interesting. I wish wecould be in here more often.
It’s my favourite place to learn in school.
We can get books from here andread them. There’s lots of books so we have lots to choose from.
People can write or do tests in quietin the library. It’s a nice quiet place to do your work.
Have Your Say…about schools______________________________________________________________
Children’s Voices Project0114 273 5233
62
We’re doing Macbeth for our school play. It’s fun to do something different from just sat in theclassroom. These people makereally good costumes.
We really enjoy doing different work.
We have cooking lessons in here.It’s a lot better to learn about things when you can do them instead ofreading about them in a boring book.
It’s nice to see what other classes are doing.
It’s relaxing to have bits of garden inthe school. It helps you learn betterwhen you’re relaxed.
Have Your Say…about schools______________________________________________________________
Children’s Voices Project0114 273 5233
63
It brings nature into school and wecan learn about it and see it insteadof looking at it in books.
The nursery children play here.There lots of little toys for them toplay with. They’re safe to play here and they don’t get knocked over by bigger children running about.
The infants is the best place to learn,you do loads of really fun stuff.
Our playground is my favourite placein school cos I can play with myfriends and have fun.
I love our new playground, there’s loads more to do at playtime anddinner time so people don’t cause as much trouble as before.
We can play cricket at playtimes. It’s fun and everyone can learn how toplay.
Have Your Say…about schools______________________________________________________________
Children’s Voices Project0114 273 5233
64
The playground is where we havefun and games.
It helps you have a better day whenyou get back in the classroom.
The best thing about playtime ishaving time to talk to my friends soit’s a good idea to have somewhere where we can sit quietly if we don’t want to run around all the time.
These benches look really nice.
There should be more bins roundschool to stop people throwing litteron the floor. It makes school looknicer and makes me like coming toschool.
We get fruit delivered to our classes.It’s good for us to be healthy.
Have Your Say…about schools______________________________________________________________
Children’s Voices Project0114 273 5233
65
This is outside where you go whenyou’re sick. People can enjoy looking at it when they’re poorly and it might make them feel better.
Springfield Primary School
I think this looks really good, it makesme proud of my school.
Children from other schools come tosee our Victorian classroom. Itmakes us really proud of our school.
When we get visitors to school itmakes people behave better.
Have Your Say…about schools______________________________________________________________
Children’s Voices Project0114 273 5233
66
This map shows where our schoolwas and where children lived inVictorian times. It’s really interesting to learn about it.
Even maths is more fun in theVictorian classroom.
These animals are in our Victorianclassroom. You can go and seethem really close up and touch them.
In our computer room we can learnhow to use a computer and akeyboard. It’s a good place to go for lessons.
Have Your Say…about schools______________________________________________________________
Children’s Voices Project0114 273 5233
67
These maps help you learn whereplaces are in the world. They’re really bright and colourful.
This is a fun place for youngerchildren to learn.
This is our community room. It’s for adults to come and use but wesometimes have lessons in it too, likemusic lessons. It’s a nice, big room and I like coming in here for lessons.
The climbing frame is fun. I likewatching people play on it. It’s good to get some fresh air and meet yourfriends after working hard all morninginside.
If you don’t want to play football or basketball you can climb. Peopleused to get bored of playing thesame games before the climbingframe was there.
Have Your Say…about schools______________________________________________________________
Children’s Voices Project0114 273 5233
68
This is our school football team. Meand my friends are on the picturetogether. It makes me feel reallyproud when I see it on the wall inschool
In the nursery playground the littlechildren can learn to play get alongwith each other and be safe. It’s good for them to see the light of day.
This is the equipment in our PEcupboard. We learn how to use allthe different equipment and get toplay with it.
This is our head teacher’s office. She tells us what’s right and wrong.
Our head teacher is someone youcan talk to if you’re upset or if someone’s bullying you.
Have Your Say…about schools______________________________________________________________
Children’s Voices Project0114 273 5233
69
This is the dining room where we eatat lunchtime. We learn what weshould eat and how to eat.
Our school helps us learn abouthealthy eating.
It’s good for parents to be able to find out about what we’re doing and about trips and stuff.