combined pharmacotherapies and behavioral interventions for alcohol dependence (the combine study):...
TRANSCRIPT
Combined Pharmacotherapies and Behavioral Interventions for Alcohol Dependence
(The COMBINE Study): A Randomized Controlled Trial
Overview of Within Treatment Primary Outcomes
Raymond F. Anton, MD
for
The COMBINE Study Research Group
JAMA Vol. 295,17. 2003-2017, 2006 (May 3rd)
Treatment Group Combinations(1383 Randomized participants)
Medical Management (n=607)
Placebo Acamprosate Placebo 153 152 Naltrexone 154 148
Medical Management + CBI (n=619)
Placebo Acamprosate No Pills Placebo 156 151 Naltrexone 155 157 No Pills 157
Primary Outcome Measures
• Percent Days Abstinent during treatment period
• Time to relapse (number relapsed) to heavy drinking– Males: 5 drinks / day; Females: 4 drinks / day
Secondary Outcome Measures
Global Clinical Outcome Craving – OCDS
Other Drinking MeasuresBiological Markers (%CDT, GGT)
Participant Adherence / Retention
Medication Adherence
(%)
Treatment Withdrawals
*(%)
Drop out or Lost to follow-up
(%)
Placebo 80.1 22.2 1.3
Acam 77.7 28.9 2.6
Nal 80.1 24.0 1.9
Acam+Nal 75.9 23.0 2.0
Placebo+CBI 79.2 13.5 3.2
Acam+CBI 79.2 16.6 0.7
Nal+CBI 77.5 14.8 2.6
Acam+Nal+CBI 75.1 20.4 3.2
CBI, No Pills 27.4 2.5
*MM vs. CBI, p=0.05
Completion of Drinking Assessments
% Complete
Placebo 94.1
Acam 95.4
Nal 92.2
Acam+Nal 95.3
Placebo+CBI 94.2
Acam+CBI 95.4
Nal+CBI 95.5
Acam+Nal+CBI 92.4
CBI, No pills 94.9
Reasons for Treatment Withdrawal
Adverse
Event (%)
Serious Adverse
Event (%)
Taking Disallowed Medication
(%)
Clinical Deterioration
(drinking) (%)
Placebo 1.3 0.7 0.7 0.7
Acam 3.3 2.0 0.0 2.6
Nal 3.9 1.3 0.0 0.0
Acam+Nal 2.7 0.7 0.7 0.0
Placebo+CBI 0.6 1.3 0.0 1.3
Acam+CBI 0.0 2.0 0.7 2.0
Nal+CBI 4.0 0.7 1.3 1.3
Acam+Nal+CBI 4.6 1.3 0.0 1.3
Adverse Events (SAFTEE Interview)
Placebo
(n=309)
Acamprosate
(n=303)
Naltrexone
(n=309)
Acamprosate + Naltrexone
(n=305)
Event % % % % P
Nausea 21 24 34 42*** <0.001
Vomiting 9 9 15* 18 ** <0.001
Diarrhea 35 65 *** 31 * 56 *** <0.001
Decreased Appetite
13 19 21 25 *** 0.002
Somnolence 24 31** 37*** 31 * 0.003
AST or ALT
5 times upper limit normal
0 0 2 * 2 * 0.02
Withdrawals due to adverse events
1 3 4 4 * 0.09
* Nominal p-values for placebo vs. active drug comparisons: *p<0.05, **p<0.01, ***p<0.001
Results
PDA during Treatment (16 weeks)
Acamprosate Main Effect
Placebo (n=616)
Acamprosate (n=605)
P
Adj. mean (s.d.)* 77.6 (25.32) 78.4 (25.31) 0.61
Naltrexone Main Effect
Placebo (n=610)
Naltrexone (n=611)
P
Adj. mean (s.d.) 77.2 (25.42) 78.8 (25.46) 0.25
CBI Main Effect
No CBI (n=609)
CBI (n=614)
P
Adj. mean (s.d.) 77.8 (25.36) 78.2 (25.52) 0.82
*Least-squares means (standard deviation) adjusting for clinical center, and baseline PDA, fitting all main effects and two- and three-factor interactions.
PDA during Treatment (continued)
Acamprosate x Naltrexone Interaction
Placebo Acamprosate Placebo
(n=307) Naltrexone
(n=309) Placebo (n=303)
Naltrexone (n=302)
P
Adj. mean (s.d.) 77.0 (25.82) 78.2 (25.31) 77.3 (25.37) 79.5 (25.37) 0.74
Acamprosate x CBI Interaction
No CBI CBI Placebo
(n=307) Acamprosate
(n=300) Placebo (n=309)
Acamprosate (n=305)
P
Adj. mean (s.d.) 77.3 (25.41) 77.9 (24.90) 78.4 (25.84) 78.4 (25.50) 0.84
Naltrexone x CBI Interaction
No CBI CBI Placebo
(n=305) Naltrexone
(n=302) Placebo (n=305)
Naltrexone (n=309)
P
Adj. mean (s.d.) 75.1 (25.46) 80.6 (25.37) 79.2 (25.32) 77.1 (25.49) 0.009
PDA Effect Size at Week 16
Relapse to Heavy Drinking During Treatment (16 weeks)
Acamprosate Main Effect
Placebo (n=618)
Acamprosate (n=608)
P
Percent 70.1 69.6 0.23
Naltrexone Main Effect
Placebo (n=612)
Naltrexone (n=614)
P
Percent 71.4 68.2 0.02
CBI Main Effect
No CBI (n=607)
CBI (n=619)
P
Percent 69.7 70.0 0.16
Relapse to Heavy Drinking by Week 16 (continued)
Acamprosate x Naltrexone Interaction
Placebo Acamprosate Placebo
(n=309) Naltrexone
(n=309) Placebo (n=303)
Naltrexone (n=305)
P
Percent 73.4 67.0 69.6 69.5 0.40
Acamprosate x CBI Interaction
No CBI CBI Placebo
(n=307) Acamprosate
(n=300) Placebo (n=311)
Acamprosate (n=308)
P
Percent 71.3 68.0 68.8 71.1 0.66
Naltrexone x CBI Interaction
No CBI CBI Placebo
(n=305) Naltrexone
(n=302) Placebo (n=307)
Naltrexone (n=312)
P
Percent 73.1 66.2 69.7 70.2 0.15
Relapse to Heavy Drinking, Naltrexone Effect
Relapse to Heavy Drinking, Naltrexone x CBI Interaction
Relapse to Heavy Drinking at Week 16
Relapse to Drinking (first drink), Acamprosate Effect
Acamprosate Secondary Outcomes Effect Size
Naltrexone Secondary Outcomes Effect Size
CBI Secondary Outcomes Effect Size
Secondary Outcomes Naltrexone x CBI
Composite Clinical Outcome* during Last 8 Weeks of Treatment
Naltrexone by CBI interaction, p=0.02
*No more than 2 daysheavy drinking over eight weeks and no more than 11 (women) or 14 (men) drinks per week and no alcohol problems
% Good Clinical Outcomes (16w)
58.2
73.7
60.8
78.4
71.3
74.4 74.473.5
60.6
56
58
60
62
64
66
68
70
72
74
76
78
80
Placebo N A
N+A
CBI+P
CBI+N
CBI+A
CBI+N+A
CBI
CBI X Naltrexone interaction: p = .02
Odds Ratios for Good Clinical OutcomeNaltrexone Comparisons
Odds Ratios for Good Clinical OutcomeOdds ratios for Good Clinical Outcome Acamprosate Comparisons
Summary
• There was marked improvement in all groups• Acamprosate showed no greater efficacy than placebo• In the context of medical management both naltrexone and
CBI were more efficacious than placebo• There was no increase in efficacy by combining acamprosate
with naltrexone or by adding either medication to CBI
Implications
• Alcohol dependent patients may benefit from being treated by a health care professional who adopts medical management and utilizes either naltrexone and/or refers to a specialized alcohol counselor using CBI-like techniques.
• This broadens options for treatment for those not previously being treated.
Limitations
• Select sample of outpatient alcoholics – generalizability to others needs to be done with caution
• Doses used were higher than those in the NDA for FDA approval
• MM delivered in the context of substance abuse facilities not in “primary care settings”
• Potential of assessment effects adding to overall response
• Only a few subjects were in need of medical alcohol detoxification - ? Implications for acamprosate
• Therapists were trained and monitored - ? Implications for CBI in clinical settings
Future Data
• Evaluating predictors of treatment response including genetic markers of response
• Evaluation of the Economic Impact of the Treatments over an extended period of time-Cost Effectiveness Study
• Evaluating what components of the therapies accounted for greater response including compliance and adherence
• Data presented in this presentation were collected as part of the multisite COMBINE trial sponsored by:
National Institute on Alcohol Abuse and Alcoholism
• Acamprosate, naltrexone and their matching placebos were kindly donated by Lipha Pharmaceuticals.
• Data and Safety Monitoring was conducted by: R Hingson ScD C Meinert PhDR Kadden PhD R Saitz MD MPHM McCaul PhD Gerard Connors PhD
• A full listing of the staff of the COMBINE Study can be found at http://www.cscc.unc.edu/combine/.
Acknowledgements