AXYZ CAMaster Diversified Machine  EZrouter FreedomMachine Tool Forest Scientific Haas MultiCam Precix ShopBot ShopSabre Techno

$20K ‐ $40K  4'x8' CNC Router Comparison 29‐Apr‐2010

MAKE MAKEAXYZ CAMaster Diversified Machine Systems

EZrouter Freedom Machine Tool Forest Scientific Haas MultiCam Precix ShopBot ShopSabre Techno

4008 Cobra CR408 Trimstar Scorpion F35‐4‐8‐7 HSIPRO4896 SR100 1000    1‐103 INDUSTRIALplus PRSa4896 4896 LC4896

MAKE

MODEL

MAKE

MODEL

X 60 50 50 49 52 52 50 51 50 60 48 X

Y 96 98 98 98 100 100 100 98 102 98 96 Y

Zc 12 12 12 12 8 8.5 8 4.5 12 13 12 11 Zc

CAP

CAP

Zc 12 12 12 12 8 8.5 8 4.5 12 13 12 11 Zc

Zt 11 11 9? 7 9 6.25 6 9? 8 9 9 Zt

X ~100 + gantry ext           54 62 87 71 60 – 72 79 60 74 X

Y ~102 +control box       122 122 140 155 120 108 125 Y

SZE

SZE

2200 2800 2612 2800 1500

AXYZ  A2MC WINCNC Fagor 8035 MACH3  Fagor 8035 Centroid HaasCNC MultiCam Precix ShopBot WINCNC Techno

TEKNIK CL Servo AC servo Servo AC CL servo DC CL servo AC servo stepper/loop AC CL servo Servo

THK Hi i Hi i fil d R th R th li BWC Hi i THK ( Y) liil /b i

WT

controller

motors

WT

controller

motors

il /b iTHK Hiwin  NSK? Hiwin 25mm profile profiled Rexroth Rexroth ‐ linear BWC ‐ vee Hiwin THK (onY) ‐ linear

R&P R&P ballscrew R&P ballscrew R & P R&P R&P R&P ballscrew ballscrew

ballscrew ballscrew ballscrew ballscrew ballscrew ballscrew ballscrew R&P ballscrew ballscrew

650”/min 1500”/min 800"/min 1000"/min 450”/min 1000”/min 600”/min 1200"/min 200”/min

rails/bearings

X‐Y

Z

max feed rate

rails/bearings

X‐Y

Z

max feed rate650 /min 1500 /min 800 /min 1000 /min 450 /min 1000 /min 600 /min 1200 /min 200 /min

1000"/min 1800”/min 800"/min 2000"/min 600”/min 1500”/min 1200"/min 250”/min

.002” .001” 0.001 0.003 .002” 0.001 0.001

handheld handheldinclusions

max feed rate

travel rate

repeatability

max feed rate

travel rate

repeatability

inclusions

43020 20995 31400 15700 20400 39999 35995 34900 23000 18790 21390 21785

inc 1500 ? 1995 NA NA NA NA 1500 inc inc 1600

w/ t‐slots       inc inc 3/8‐16 inserts 1500 phenolic   1535 phenolic          inc 6995 inc inc diy inc 2500

8 5 h 3950 11 5 h 4500 11 5 h 4650 11 5 HP i 15 h ? i 10 h 3200 16 5 h 6495 20 h 6800 8 5h 6495

BASE $

Z EXT

VAC BED

VAC PUMP

BASE $

Z EXT

VAC BED

VAC PUMP8.5 hp   3950 11.5 hp   4500 5hp       inc 11.5 hp   4650 5hp, 70ACFM  4500 11.5 HP             inc 15 hp?    inc 10 hp     3200 16.5 hp    6495 20  hp   6800 8.5hp   6495

2.2KW/3hp       inc 3.0KW/4hp       Inc 8hp       inc 3.0KW/4hp   2698 8hp ATC  3410 3.7KW/5hp        inc 6.6KW/8.9hp    inc 3.0KW/4hp     inc 3.7KW/5hp         inc  3.0KW/4hp    2895 3.0KW/4hp     inc 2.2KW/3hp   3400

875 1000 1000 1500 1800 950 800

i 1095 i iPC

VAC PUMP

SPINDLE

FREIGHT

VAC PUMP

SPINDLE

FREIGHT

PCinc 1095 inc inc

2 days training    inc 1400 ? 3days   3500 1000 ? 1500 1 day inc,   1300/day  inc

~15% edu    ‐9395 10% edu    ‐2700

5hp/5pos HSD 8995 5hp/6pos HSD 9030 5hp/6pos HSD 10000 10 position 7095 5hp 10000 5hp 14995 5hp/5pos HSD 10300ATC

PC

INSTALL

DISCOUNT

PC

INSTALL

DISCOUNT

ATC5hp/5pos HSD   8995 5hp/6pos HSD 9030 5hp/6pos HSD 10000 10 position   7095 5hp   10000 5hp  14995 5hp/5pos HSD 10300

4th axis, 12"x 96"? 4995 pendant 1080 4th axis    1795 4th axis       5995 4th axis, 6"    1795

X3     3500 dust hood   285 5th axis    5595   sd mt 24" 4th  6000  

tool ht sensor   400 alum table    3495

ATC

OPTIONS

ATC

OPTIONS

the information contained within this comparison is not guaranteed to be accurate,  it is compiled from published information and recent quotations from manufacturers/reps at a single point in time.