climate intervention report release presentation

8/9/2019 Climate Intervention Report Release Presentation

1/18

BOARD ON ATMOSPHERICSCIENCES AND CLIMATE


CLIMATE INTERVENTION

!"#$%" !$'() *!"#$% +, -".//0 120"."3,

4$5) 657/8, 6"9%0 :%;./8


2/18


%?7> 5@ $="7?%7?$.%A";/ "#/ ".. "#5(70 (>B

– C#//7=5(>/ ?">/> "#/%7$#/">%7?

– 4/" ./9/. %> #%>%7?

–

D$/ >=//;> "70 ?."$%/#> "#/A/.37?

– C.52". ;/AE/#";(#/> "#/%7$#/">%7?

•

F.%A";/ $="7?/ %AE"$;>E/5E./, /$5>8>;/A>, "70;=/ /$575A8

G2>/#9/0 F="7?/ %7 4(#@"$/ :/AE/#";(#/

& ' ! ! (

* + , -


3/18


HBOARD ON ATMOSPHERICSCIENCES AND CLIMATE

•

I/0($%7??#//7=5(>/ ?">/A%>>%57> – J!%3?"357K

• 10"E37? ;5 ;=/%AE"$;> 5@$.%A";/ $="7?/ –

J10"E;"357K

• F.%A";/D7;/#9/7357LLL

POSSIBLE CLIMATE RESPONSE OPTIONS


4/18


MBOARD ON ATMOSPHERICSCIENCES AND CLIMATE

COMMITTEE ON GEOENGINEERING CLIMATE:

TECHNICAL EVALUATION AND DISCUSSION OF IMPACTS

6GN, '141, 'G11, OP4P %7;/..%?/7$/ $5AA(7%;8, "70 '"357".1$"0/A8 5@ 4$%/7$/> >(EE5#;/0 ;=%> >;(08

!"#$%'( '**"**+"%, 5@ ;Q5 $.">>/> 5@ $.%A";/ %7;/#9/7357;/$=75.5?%/>

–

I/A59%7? $"#257 0%5R%0/ @#5A ;=/ ";A5>E=/#/ – I/0($%7? >(7.%?=; "2>5#2/0 28 N"#;= %7 5#0/# ;5 $55. E."7/;S> >(#@"$/

• -="; %> $(##/7;.8 T75Q7 – 4$%/7$/ U #%>T> "70 $57>/V(/7$/>

– W%"2%.%;8 @5# %AE./A/7;"357

• D0/73@8 @(;(#/ #/>/"#$= 7//0/0

• F5AA/7; ?/7/#"..8 57 E5;/73". >5$%/;"., ./?"., "70 /;=%$".$57>%0/#"357>


5/18


XBOARD ON ATMOSPHERICSCIENCES AND CLIMATE

COMMITTEE ON GEOENGINEERING CLIMATE:

TECHNICAL EVALUATION AND DISCUSSION OF IMPACTS

-'.#&' /0 -#123 45$'&.6 4$%/7$/ Y 1114

7'(""8 9:8'(';

O7%9/#>%;8 5@ F5.5#"05, Z5(.0/#

/"% 5'(8"&.'

F"#7/?%/ D7>3;(357 @5# 4$%/7$/

=%"?

-550> [5./ G$/"75?#"E=%$ D7>3;(357@'2( A0 B'(C=D*C&

I(;?/#>, :=/ 4;";/ O7%9/#>%;8 5@ '/Q \/#>/8

%;8 5@ !"#8."70

F'+"* G0 B("+&%H

F5.28 F5../?/

%;8

F=?#" J0 @"%%".

O7%9/#>%;8 5@ !%$=%?"7

G'?+=%8 !0 @&".."$2+:".,

O7%9/#>%;8 5@ F=%$"?5

@$&(&K F0 G'*#$

^"$%_$ '5#;=Q/>; '"357". `"25#";5#8L?%% -0 G2**"((

4$#%EE> D7>3;(357 5@ G$/"75?#"E=8

F=$% !0 %;8 5@ GT."=5A"

>'E&8 70 !&,("?

^/77 4;";/ O7%9/#>%;8

F"%%&M". 7&(#=N

4;"7@5#0 O7%9/#>%;8

• :=/ F5AA%)// =/.0 @5(# A//37?> "70 %7;/#"$;/0 Q%;= 05a/7> 5@ >$%/73>;>

• I/E5#;> Q/#/ #/9%/Q/0 28 bc 5(;>%0/ /RE/#;>


6/18


cBOARD ON ATMOSPHERICSCIENCES AND CLIMATE

THERE IS NO SUBSTITUTE

FOR MITIGATION AND ADAPTATION

G"#=++"%8';=% OP

JQ=.,* ,= '88."** #(&+'," #$'%H" *$=2(8 #=%;%2" ,=

M=#2* +=*, $"'E&(? =%

•

+&;H';%H H.""%$=2*" H'* "+&**&=%*• &% #=+:&%';=% D&,$ '8'K;%H ,= ,$" &+K'#,* =M

#(&+'," #$'%H"

:"#'2*" ,$"*" 'KK.='#$"*• 8= %=, K."*"%, K==.(? 8"R%"8 '%8 K==.(? S2'%;R"8

.&*C* '%8

• '." ', ' H."',". *,'," =M ,"#$%=(=H'( ."'8&%"**


7/18


d

CARBON DIOXIDE REMOVAL AND

RELIABLE SEQUESTRATION

N7="7$%7? 7";(#". $"#257 >%7T>

• F="7?/> %7 ."70 (>/ A"7"?/A/7; – I/@5#/>;"357 Y "e5#/>;"357

– 1?#%$(.;(#". E#"$3$/>

• 1$$/./#";/0 Q/";=/#%7? – F=/A%$". #/"$357> ;5 @5#A $"#257";/

5# >%.%$";/ A%7/#".>

•

G$/"7 %#57 @/#3.%a"357 – 100%7? %#57 ;5 ;=/ 5$/"7 ;5 255>; ;=/

?#5Q;= 5@ E=8;5E."7T;57


8/18


f

CARBON DIOXIDE REMOVAL AND

RELIABLE SEQUESTRATION

G;=/# ;/$=75.5?%/>

• 6%#/$; 1%# F"E;(#/ "70

4/V(/>;#"357 *61F4+ – F=/A%$". >$#(22%7? E#5$/>>/>

• Z%5/7/#?8 Q%;= F"#257 F"E;(#/

"70 4/V(/>;#"357 *ZNFF4+ – O>/ E."7;> *2%5A">>+ ;5 E#50($/

/7/#?8

–

F"E;(#/ $"#257 0%5R%0/ @#5A

E5Q/# E."7; "70 >/V(/>;/#

(70/#?#5(70


9/18


g

CARBON DIOXIDE REMOVAL READY FOR

INCREASED RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT

G"#=++"%8';=% TP

!$" 5=++&3"" ."#=++"%8* ."*"'.#$ '%8 8"E"(=K+"%,

&%E"*,+"%, ,=

•

&+K.=E" +",$=8* =M #'.:=% 8&=N&8" ."+=E'( '%8 8&*K=*'(

', *#'("* ,$', +'3".

&% K'.;#2('. ,=

•

+&%&+&U" "%".H? '%8 +',".&'(* #=%*2+K;=%• &8"%;M? '%8 S2'%;M? .&*C*

• (=D". #=*,*V '%8

• 8"E"(=K ."(&':(" *"S2"*,.';=% '%8 +=%&,=.&%H


10/18


bhBOARD ON ATMOSPHERICSCIENCES AND CLIMATE

ALBEDO MODIFICATION

1.2/05 A50%_$"357 $5(.0#/0($/ "A5(7; 5@ >(7.%?=;

"2>5#2/0 28 N"#;= %7 5#0/# ;5

$55. E."7/;S> >(#@"$/ V(%$T.8

•

:=/ #/E5#; $57>%0/#/0 ;Q5

>;#";/?%/>B

– 4;#";5>E=/#%$ "/#5>5.>

–

!"#%7/ $.5(0 2#%?=;/7%7?

./012345 $6 7"2 8%484%94: 4; $:

6?:0$>"7 7"#7 $6 %2@2


11/18


bb

N79%#57A/7;". #%>T> i 25;= T75Q7 "70 E55#.8 T75Q7

– 6/$#/">/> %7 >;#";5>E=/#%$ 5a57/

– F="7?/> %7 ;=/ "A5(7; "70 E")/#7> 5@ E#/$%E%;"357

– '5 #/0($357 5@ #55; $"(>/ 5@ $.%A";/ $="7?/ *?#//7=5(>/ ?">/>+

– ^55#.8 (70/#>;550 #/?%57". 9"#%"2%.%;8

– ^5;/73". #%>T 5@ A%../77%". 0/E/70/7$/

4%?7%_$"7; E5;/73". @5# (7"73$%E";/0, (7A"7"?/"2./, "70#/?#/)"2./ $57>/V(/7$/>

–

D7$.(0%7? E5.%3$"., >5$%"., ./?"., /$575A%$, "70 /;=%$". 0%A/7>%57>

G"#=++"%8';=% WP 9(:"8= +=8&R#';=% ', *#'("* *2X#&"%,

,= '(,". #(&+'," *$=2(8 %=, :" 8"K(=?"8 ', ,$&* ;+"

ALBEDO MODIFICATION POSES

SIGNIFICANT RISKS


12/18


b<

ALBEDO MODIFICATION RESEARCH

I/>/"#$= 7//0/0 ;5 0/;/#A%7/ %@ ".2/05 A50%_$"357 $5(.0 2/ 9%"2./$.%A";/ #/>E57>/

– D@ ;=/#/ Q/#/ " $.%A";/ /A/#?/7$8

– F5(.0 %; 2/ T/8 E"#; 5@ " E5#j5.%5 5@ #/>E57>/>L

Z/)/# (70/#>;"70%7? 5@ $57>/V(/7$/> 7//0/0 %@ ;=/#/ Q/#/ "7 "$357 28 "

(7%.";/#". Y (7$55#0%7";/0 "$;5#

G"#=++"%8';=% YP

!$" 5=++&3"" ."#=++"%8* '% '(:"8= +=8&R#';=%

."*"'.#$ K.=H.'+ :" 8"E"(=K"8 '%8 &+K("+"%,"8 ,$',"+K$'*&U"* +2(;K(" :"%"R, ."*"'.#$ ,$', M2.,$".*

• :'* 2%8".*,'%8&%H =M ,$" #(&+'," *?*,"+

• '%8 &,* $2+'% 8&+"%*&=%*


13/18


bH

F(##/7; 52>/#9"357".

$"E"2%.%3/> ."$T >(k$%/7;

$"E"$%;8 ;5 0/;/$; "70

A57%;5# /79%#57A/7;".

/e/$;> 5@ ".2/05

A50%_$"357 0/E.58A/7;

G"#=++"%8';=% ZP !$" 5=++&3"" ."#=++"%8* ,$', ,$"

[%&,"8


14/18


bM

GOVERNANCE CONSIDERATIONS

1.2/05 A50%_$"357 #/>/"#$= %>75; >E/$%_$"..8 "00#/>>/0 28 "78@/0/#". ."Q> 5# #/?(."357>

'//0 @5# ;#"7>E"#/7; "70

%7$.(>%9/ $579/#>"357>C5". 5@ ?59/#7"7$/ >=5(.0 2/ ;5A"R%A%a/ 2/7/_;> 5@ #/>/"#$=Q=%./ A%7%A%a%7? #%>T>

!5#/ ;="7 l(>; >$%/7$/ %795.9/0 %7 0/$%>%57> 57 #/>/"#$="70 0/E.58A/7;• C59/#7"7$/

• N;=%$". m ./?". $57>%0/#"357>


15/18


bX

GOVERNANCE CONSIDERATIONS

G"#=++"%8';=% \P

!$" 5=++&3"" ."#=++"%8* ,$" &%&;';=% =M ' *".&=2*

8"(&:".';E" K.=#"** ,= "N'+&%"P

4'6

D$', ,?K"* =M ."*"'.#$ H=E".%'%#"V :"?=%8 ,$=*" ,$','(."'8? "N&*,V +'? :" %""8"8 M=. '(:"8= +=8&R#';=%

."*"'.#$V '%8

4:6

,$" ,?K"* =M ."*"'.#$ ,$', D=2(8 ."S2&." *2#$ H=E".%'%#"VK=,"%;'((? :'*"8 =% ,$" +'H%&,28" =M ,$"&. "NK"#,"8

&+K'#, =% .'8&';E" M=.#&%HV ,$"&. K=,"%;'( M=. 8",.&+"%,'(

8&."#, '%8 &%8&."#, "Q"#,*V '%8 =,$". #=%*&8".';=%*


16/18


bc

CONCLUSIONS

•

:=/ $="../7?/> 5@ $.%A";/ $="7?/ #/V(%#/ " E5#j5.%5 5@"$357> Q%;= 9"#8%7? 0/?#//> 5@ #%>T "70 /k$"$8

• :=/#/ %> 75 >(2>3;(;/ @5# A%3?"357 "70 "0"E;"357

•

F"#257 0%5R%0/ #/A59". >;#";/?%/> 5e/# E5;/73". ;50/$#/">/ $"#257 0%5R%0/ $57$/7;#"357> %7 ;=/ ";A5>E=/#/

• 1.2/05 A50%_$"357 >;#";/?%/> $(##/7;.8 .%A%;/0 28

(7@"A%.%"# "70 (7V("73_"2./ #%>T> "70 ?59/#7"7$/ %>>(/>

• 178 %7;/#9/7357 %7 N"#;=S> $.%A";/ >=5(.0 2/ %7@5#A/0 28

" @"# A5#/ >(2>;"739/ 2508 5@ >$%/73_$ #/>/"#$= ;="7 %>

"9"%."2./ "; E#/>/7;


17/18

BOARD ON ATMOSPHERICSCIENCES AND CLIMATEBOARD ON ATMOSPHERICSCIENCES AND CLIMATE

4E57>5#>

F5AA%)//

I/9%/Q/#>

'IF 4;"e

'(A/#5(> $5../"?(/>$57>(.;/0 0(#%7? >;(08

^./">/ 9%>%; '+".'*#(&+',"#$="*0=.H ;5 _70B

• F5AE./;/ #/E5#;> "9"%."2./ @5# @#// ^6] 05Q7.5"0

• I/E5#; %7 Z#%/@ *MUE"?/ ."8 >(AA"#8+

• ^#/>> #/./">/

•

D7@5#A"357 "25(; (E$5A%7? /9/7;>, >($= "> Q/2%7"# ]/2 .%0/> "70 "#$=%9/0 E(2.%$ #/./">/ Q/2$">;

\5%7 ;=/ $579/#>"357 B nF.%A";/D7;/#9/7357

ACKNOWLEDGMENTS


18/18


bfBOARD ON ATMOSPHERICSCIENCES AND CLIMATE

5'.:=% >&=N&8" G"+=E'( K.=K=*'(*] 9(:"8= -=8&R#';=% K.=K=*'(*]

] '88."** ,$" #'2*" =M $2+'%^&%82#"8 #(&+',"

#$'%H" 4$&H$ ',+=*K$". AIA

#=%#"%,.';=%*60

o05 75; "00#/>> $"(>/ 5@ =(A"7U%70($/0

$.%A";/ $="7?/ *=%?= ";A5>E=/#%$ C[C

$57$/7;#"357>+P

]8= %=, &%,.=82#" %=E"( H(=:'( .&*C*0 o %7;#50($/ 759/. ?.52". #%>T>P

]'." #2.."%,(? "NK"%*&E" 4=. #=+K'.':(" ,=

,$" #=*, =M "+&**&=% ."82#;=%60

o"#/ %7/RE/7>%9/ ;5 0/E.58 *#/."39/ ;5 $5>; 5@

/A%>>%57> #/0($357+P

]+'? K.=82#" =%(? +=8"*, #(&+'," "Q"#,*

D&,$&% 8"#'8"*0

o$"7 E#50($/ >(2>;"73". $.%A";/ /e/$;> Q%;=%7

8/"#>P

].'&*" M"D". '%8 ("** 8&X#2(, &**2"* D&,$

."*K"#, ,= H(=:'( H=E".%'%#"0

o#"%>/ 0%k$(.; %>>(/> Q%;= #/>E/$; ;5 ?.52".

?59/#7"7$/P

]D&(( :" _28H"8 ('.H"(? =% S2"*;=%* ."(',"8 ,=

#=*,0

oQ%.. 2/ l(0?/0 ."#?/.8 57 V(/>357> #/.";/0 ;5

#%>TP

]+'? :" &+K("+"%,"8 &%#."+"%,'((? D&,$

(&+&,"8 "Q"#,* '* *=#&",? :"#=+"* +=."

*".&=2* ':=2, ."82#&%H AIA #=%#"%,.';=%* =.

*(=D&%H ,$"&. H.=D,$0

o$5(.0 2/ %AE./A/7;/0 >(00/7.8, Q%;= ."#?/U

>$"./ %AE"$;> 2/@5#/ /75(?= #/>/"#$= %>

"9"%."2./ ;5 (70/#>;"70 ;=/%# #%>T> #/."39/ ;5

%7"$357P

]."S2&." #==K".';=% :? +'_=. #'.:=%

"+&3".* ,= $'E" ' *&H%&R#'%, "Q"#,0 o$5(.0 2/ 057/ (7%.";/#"..8P

]M=. (&C"(? M2,2." "+&**&=%* *#"%'.&=*V ':.2K,

,".+&%';=% D=2(8 $'E" (&+&,"8 #=%*"S2"%#"*

o@5# .%T/.8 @(;(#/ /A%>>%57> >$/7"#%5>, "2#(E;

;/#A%7"357 Q5(.0 E#50($/ >%?7%_$"7;

$57>/V(/7$/>

'+".'*#(&+',"#$="*0=.H `5(&+',"a%,".E"%;=%

climate intervention report release presentation

Documents