clarisonic itc complaint

8/9/2019 Clarisonic ITC Complaint

1/85

P A U L

H A S T I N G S

1(202)551-1763

[email protected]

April 30, 2015

BY HAND DELIVERY

The Honorable

Lisa R.

Barton

Secretary

United States International Trade Commission

500

E

Street,

SW

Washington, DC 20436

CBI

IS P-^^

DOCKET

NUMBER

Office of th e

Secretary

Int'l Trade Commission

29172.00208

Re :

CERTAIN ELECTRIC SKIN

THEREFOR, AND KITS

(ITC Inv. No. 337-TA- )

CARE

DEVICES,

BRUSHES

AND

CHARGERS

CONTAINING

SAME

Dear Secretary Barton:

Enclosed for

filing

on behalf of Pacific

documents in supportof Complainant's request

pursuant to the provisions ofSection 337 of

Bioscience Laboratories, Inc. ( Complainant ) are the following

that the

Commission

commence an

investigation

Tariff Act of 1930,

as amended: J

he '

1. One original (unbound) and eight

2. One copy, on CD, of the Non

Confidential

Exhibit, to

th e

3.

One

copy, on CD, of the

materials submitted (Rules 201

(8)

copies of

the verified

Complaint

(Rulp

210.8(a)(1)(i));

Confidential

Exhibits,

including

public

versio'ns

of

the

Compaint

(Rule 210.8(a)(1)(i));

j

Confidential

Exhibit

tothe Complaint, segregated

from

other

and210.8(a)(1)(ii)); {

(c)

4.

One

physical sample of each

accused

product, as identified in the

Complaint;

5. Eighteen (18) additional paper

co;

pies

both non-confident ia l and

(Rules 210.8(a)(1)(iii) and 210.11

6. Five (5) additional paper copies

Embassies

of

Canada, China,

and

210.11(a)(1));

Certified copies

of

U.S. Patent Nbs

patent ) and D523.809 ( theD'809

the Complaint

as Exhibits 1-3 (R^ile

8. Certified copies ofthe assignments

copies

of the

assignments

are

210.12(a)(9)(H));

of the Complaint and accompanyingExhibits, on CDs,

confidential,

oneeach

for

service

upon

the

proposed Respondents

(a)(1));

J

if the non-confidential Complaint for service upon the

Isifael, Korea, and the

United

Kingdom

(Rules 210.8(a)(i)(iv)

. 7,320,691

( the

'691

patent ),

7,386,906 ( the '906

patent ). Legible copies ofthe patents are included with

210.12(a)(9)(i)); {

related to the '691, '906

and

D'809 patents. Legible

included with the Complaint as Exhibits4A-6 (Rule

Paul

Hastings

LLP I 875 15th

Street,

N.W. I Washington, DC 20005

t:

+1.202.551.1700

I www.paulhastings.com


2/85

P A U L

H A S T I N G S

The

Honorable Lisa R. Barton

April 30, 2015

Page

2

9. Acertified copy and three

(3)

additional

copies,

on CDs, ofthe

prosecution

histories ofthe

'691, '906 and D'809 patents along with any applicable reexamination

prosecution

histories.

Legible

copies

ofthe

prosecution histories

are

included with

the

Complaint

as

Appendices

A

B, D and F (Rule 210.12(c)(1));

10. Four (4)

copies, on

CD, ofeach technical reference mentioned

in

the

prosecution

of the '691,

'906 and

D'809. Legible copies

ofthe references are included with

the

Complaint as

Appendices C, E and G (Rule 210.12(c)(2));

11. A letter and certification concerning the confidentiality of Confidential

Exhibit

37 and

containing a request forconfidential treatmentof such document (Rules201 6(b) and

210.5(d)); and

12. Astatement ofpublic interest (Rule210.8(b)).

Thank you for your attention to this matter. Please contact me at the number

above

if you have any

questions.

If

Iam

not available, you

may

contact

Timothy

Cremen

at (202)

551-1838.

RMM:mrp

Enclosures

LEGALJJS E# 114713329.1

wigiv'wgn&aatgss

•?


3/85

P A U L

H A S T I N G S

1(202)551-1763

[email protected]

April 30,

2015

BY HAND DELIVERY

The Honorable Lisa R.

Barton

Secretary

United

States International

Trade

Commissioi)

500 E Street, SW

Washington, DC 20436

29172.00208

Re:

CERTAIN ELECTRIC SKIN

THEREFOR, AND KITS

(ITC Inv. No. 337-TA- )

CARE DEVICES,

BRUSHES

AND CHARGERS

CONTAINING

SAME

Dear Secretary

Barton:

I am

counsel

for Pacif ic

Bioscience

C.F.R. § 201.6, Complainant requests

Tariff Act, as amended, and attached to

Laboratores, Inc. (hereinafter Complainant ). In accordancewith 19

confidential treatment of Exhibit 37, filed under Section 337 of the

Complainant's

complaint. j

Confidential treatment is sought for Exhibit 37

relating to Complainant's proprietary and con

plantand equipment, laborand capital, and '

and U.S. Design Patent No. D523.809 inthe

because

it

contains

confidential

business

information

idential commercial information, including investment in

the exploitation ofU.S. Patent Nos. 7,320,691,

7,386,906

United

States.

|

in

The information

described

above qualifies

as

201.6(a)(1) in that:

1. It is not available to

the

public;

2. Unauthorized disclosure of such

position ofComplainant; and

confidential business information pursuant to Rule

information could

cause

substantial harm to the competitive

3. The disclosure of

this

information

necessary to perform its statutory

could impair the Commission's

ability

to

obtain information

functions.

Paul Hastings

LLP

I 875 15th Street,

N.W.

I Washington, DC20005

t:+1.202.551.1700 I

www.paulhast ings.com

*T^sraa*Wf)VKsS ''i&' 4>,u-*35lt

-W

^gM;m«M^Vfi'W 'v-»*'-'lJW''^ti*^''^w'''J''''T''i ': 'r


4/85

P A U L

H A S T I N G S

The Honorable

Lisa

R.

Barton

April 30, 2015

Page 2

Thank

you for your attention to this

matter.

Please do not hesitate

to

contact

me if

there are any

questions pertaining to this submission.

RMM:mrp

Enclosures

LEGAL_US_E # 114713462.1

^i-SPjSAgSZZfg&WFlfigsrT

Respectfully submitted,

Robert M. Masters

of

PAUL

HASTINGS

LLP

875 15th Street, NW

Washington, DC

20005

Attorney for Complainant Pacific Bioscience

Laboratories, Inc.


5/85

UNITED

STATES

INTERNATIONAL

TRADE

COMMISSION

WASHINGTON, D.C.

In the

Matter of:

CERTAIN ELECTRIC

SKIN CARE

DEVICES,

BRUSHES AND CHARGERS

THEREFOR,

AND

KITS

CONTAINING

SAME

Inv. No. 337-TA-

p t t r t Tr TNTEREST STATEMENT

Complainant Pacific Bioscience

Public Interest Statement concurrently

19 C.F.R. § 210.8(b).

First and foremost, the public i

rights by excluding infringing imports.

Escutcheons, andComponents Thereof,

LEXIS 494, at *18 (June 19, 2000). As

designed anddeveloped technology

andkits containing the same( Clarisonic

underthe mark Clarisonic. PBL obtained

trade dress, among other rights, to protecjt

the Clarisonic systemresulting in

intellectual property rights, including U

trade dress.

PBL

seeks, inter alia, a

g<

articles, anda ceaseanddesistorder

The

requested

relief, therefore, furthers

robustintellectual property regime.

Laboratories, Inc. ( PBL ) respectful }

submits this

wii;h

a Complaint

having

the above-caption,

pursuant

to

I:iv

se t

directed

.

n u m e r o u s

eneral

interest

favors the

protection

ofU.S.

intellectual property

(Pertain Two-Handle

Centerset Faucets

and

No.

337-TA-422, USITC Pub. 33b,

2000

ITC

I

s

forth

more fully in

the

Complaint, PBL created,

to skin

care

devices,

brushes and (chargers therefor,

f

I

' '

I

system ),

and

manufactures

and

sells such

technology

intellectual property rights in the fam ofpatents and

this technology. Respondents

have unlawfully

copied

and

ongoing

infringements of several ofPBL's

S.

Patent

Nos.

7,320,691, 7,386,906,

and

D523,809;

and

exclusion

order against

importations

of infringing

prohibiting

Respondents

from

importing

or selling the same.

;he public's

interest

in encouraging innovation

via

a

TTnrirwaj-uwM>^|ij.iM^wj^tMww«Wir;i; k%M^w


6/85

The public's

strong interest in protecting intellectual

property

is not outweighed

by

any

countervailing considerations. See Certain Battery-Powered Ride-On Toy Vehicles and

Components

Thereof,

Inv.

No. 337-TA-314,

Comm'n

Op. at 11 (Apr.

9,

1991) (stating that

exclusionary relief should only be denied when the adverse effect on the public interest would

be greater than

the interest in

protecting

the patent

holder ).

As discussed

below,

the

issuance

of

the requested

relief

would not

have

an adverse

effect

on public health

and

welfare, competitive

conditions in

the

United States economy, the

production of

like

or

directly competitive articles in

the United States, or United States consumers.

1) Explain how the articlespotentially subject to the orders areused in the United

States.

The infringing articles

in

this

matter

are hand-held electric skin

care

devices, generally

used

for the

cleansing

offacial skin and/or treatment of

acne, along

with brushes or brushheads,

and chargers

for

those

devices.

Auser operates such a device by activating amotorized

brushhead on the device, such

that

the brushhead moves and

when

placed

incontact with the

user's skineffects the facial skincleansing. The motionof the brushhead is intended to

cleanse

skin by

loosening the

adhesion ofsebaceous plugs inthe skin's

pores,

thereby

resolving

a root

cause

ofacne. The

brushhead

is also

effective

at cleansing

the

skin

and

removing any impurities

such as makeup.

Each

device is

battery-powered

and

is

sold with

a

complimentary charger that

plugs into a standard electrical outlet.

2)

Identify

any public health, safety, or

welfare concerns

intheUnited States relating

to

the requested remedial

orders.

The issuance of the requested relief will have

no

adverse impact upon the health, safety

or welfare

concerns

in

the

United

States.

To

the

contrary, itwill benefit public health,

safety,

or

welfare

by

removing

lesser-quality, knock-offproducts from the

marketplace.

PBL has devoted

significant sums ofits

annual revenues

to research

and development,

including

university-based

~^^ggg3gJWJffift}^a?Sfe'&*' = J) ^,V'K''M, 'Wl^'^.'^ililgll ,^j,y.»vut'iBi''


7/85

clinical studies, to ensurethat its Clarisonic

brushheads, andchargers are assafeand

while copying proprietary elements ofPB.

construction and design. On information

little

resources

onresearch anddevelopment

informed and believes that these accused

acne andcleansing skinthanthe proprietary

would,

therefore, further thepublic's interest

marketplace.

In addition, as discussed in more

from the United States marketplace, PBL

through its existing line ofClarisonic

market share ofits proprietary skin-cleanjsin

expanding

the

resources

that

PBL

could

effectiveproducts. In this manner,

furthers

the public interests of health,

In any event, the public willnot

health or welfare need. See Sponsion,

Cir.

2011) (noting that

theCommission

[w]ould

deprive

the public

of

products

The infringing products relate to the

each of which is a non-life-threatening

type

ofa

health issue

that outweighs

the

line of electricskin care devices, brushes and

effective as possible. Many

of

the accused products—

L's patents and trade dress—are ofinferior

and

belief,

Respondents

have

spent comparatively

of

safe

and

effective devices. Thujs, PBL is

t

Itroducts

are

less

effective

and/or

lessjsafe at treating

- -

Clarisonic

line ofproducts. The requested relief

I

in

having proven

effective and safe products inthe

Retail

below, should the

accused

products

be

excluded

can meet the demandfor electric skincaredevices

.

Moreover,

if PBLwereto enjoy its

rightful

i

[

g

systems,

revenues would

increase, thereby

devote

to

further research and development more

i

gthe public's interest in encouraging innovation

also

• . . I

and

welfare.

products

affirmin

safety

be

any important

eprived

ofproducts necessary for

•

v.

Int'l

Trade

Comm'n,

629 F.3d 1331,1360 (Fed.

las only denied an exclusion

order

when the order

necessary for

some

important health

or welfare need ).

' ' i

i.

cleansing ofskin and in

some cases

a treatment for

acne,

aW

largely cosmetic skin condition and which is not

the

[

public's interest in protecting intellectual

property

and

Inc.

•^yp^^s^^WTTTW^WP^^^^^


8/85

encouraging innovation. Moreover, as discussed in more detail below, the requested

relief will

not

deprive

the

public oftreatment options,

at least

because (i)

PBL

anticipates

that it can meet

the demand

for any

excluded

products; and

(ii) consumers have a

variety

of

commercial

alternatives for the treatment

of

acne. . ,

3) Identify like

ordirectly competitive

articles that

complainant,

its licensees, or third

parties

make

which

could

replace

the subject

articles

if they

were

to be

excluded.

The infringing articles constitute

unlawful

copies ofPBL's proprietary Clarisonic line of

hand-held

electric skin care

devices. Thus, the Clarisonic line ofproducts can replace the

subject

infringing

articles if

they were

tobe

excluded, raising

no

public interest concerns. See

Certain

Lens-Fitted

Film

Packages

( LFFPs ), Inv.

No.

337-TA-406, Comm'n Op., 1999 ITC LEXIS

202 at

*39-40

(June 28, 1999)(finding no

public

interest concerns

when

there

was

no

evidence

that the demand for the products

at-issue could

not be supplied by the

complainant,

and

reasoning that

[t]he fact

that

some

retailers and consumers may have to pay ahigher price for

the [products] does

not

justify a

determination

that the public interest inprotecting intellectual

property rights is in any way outweighed ).

In

addition,

the public has avariety ofalternatives

when

itcomes to

facial

cleansing and

treating

acne. These alternatives include, for

example,

manual cleansing with soap,

topical

creams and ointments, and orally-administered medications.

The

presence ofan adequate supply

ofsubstitute

products,

while not necessarily as

convenient

or

effective

as the Clarisonic

system,

is sufficient to override anypublic interestconcerns.

4)

Indicate

whether

the complainant, its

licensees,

and/or third

parties have the

capacity to replace the volume of articles subject to the requested remedialorders in

a commercially

reasonable

time in

the United States.

PBL

has the capacity to replace the volume ofinfringing articles subject to

the

requested

remedial orders

in

a commercially reasonable time in the United States.

PBL

developed the


9/85

market

for

the technology-at issue, and ha^

demand. PBL's manufacturing facility in

components

of the

Clarisonic system

in

PBL

believes that

with

current

replace the volume of

articles

subject to

5) State how

the

requested remedial

As

discussed above,

the

issuance

desist order in this investigation will not

be

replaced

byPBL's

Clarisonic

line

o

effective. In addition, a variety of

treatacne, suchasmanual cleansing with

administered medications. The issuance

encouraging innovation,

which

could

the resources andthe motivation to

keep

up

with

Redmond, WA has the

equipment required to produce

volume.

r e s o u r c e s

the

in a commercially reasonable time, it can

requested remedial orders.

orders

would impact

consumers.

o|f

the requested general exclusion order

and cease and

j

adversely impact consumers. Any excluded

articles

can

,

which

are

thoroughly tested

tobe

safe and

products

are available

for facial cleansing and to

soap, topical creams

and

ointments, and orally-

of

the requested

relief

furthers the public's interest

in

result in newer, better products for consumers.

f products,

' alternative

gwnfflff^TO^^^^ f^'Sft Mr™ '^ n -


10/85

Dated: April 30, 2015

^wmtrnmrnw?***

Respectfully submitted,

Attorneysfor Complainant

Pacific Bioscience Laboratories,

Inc.

Rober t M . Mast er s

Timothy P.

Cremen

PAUL HASTINGS LLP

875 15th St

NW

Washington, D.C. 20005

Tel: (202)551-1700

Fax:

(202)551-1705

[email protected]

[email protected]

Robert L.

Sherman

Natalie G.

Furman

PAUL HASTINGS

LLP

75

East 55t h Street

New York, NY

10022

Tel: (212)318-6000

Fax: (212)318-6847

[email protected]

[email protected]


11/85

UNITED STATES

INTERNATIONAL

TRADE

COMMISS ION

WASHINGTON,

D.C.

In th e

Matter

of:

CERTAIN ELECTRIC

S KIN C ARE

DEVICES, BRUSHES AND CHARGERS

THEREFOR,

AND

KITS

CONTAINING

S AME

Inv . N o . 337-

COMPLAINT

OF THE TARIFF

UNDER SECT ION

337

ACT OF 1930,

AS

AMENDED

Complainant:

PACIFIC

BIOSCIENCE

LABORATORIES,

INC.

17275 N E 67th Cour t

Redmond, WA 98052

(425)

285-1711

Counsel for Complainant:

Rober t M. Masters

Timothy P. Cremen

PAUL

HASTINGS

LLP

87 5

15th

St

NW

Washington,D.C. 20005

Tel:

(202)

551-1700

Fax: (202) 551-1705

[email protected]

[email protected]

Robert

L.

Sherman

Natalie

G.

Furman

PAUL

HASTINGS

LLP

75

East

55th Street

New

York, NY 10022

Tel: (212)318-6000

Fax: (212) 319-4090

[email protected]

[email protected]

Proposed Respondents:

OUR

FAMILYJEWELS, INC.

d/b/a Epipiir Skincare

10226

S.

Dransfeldt

Road

Parker,

CO

80134

ACCORD MEDIA, LLC

d/b/a Truth in Aging

241 West 36th Street, Apt. 16

New York, NY 10018

XNOVT

ELECTRONIC CO., LTD.

Room

915, GuanLiDa Mansion;

Qianjin 1st Road •

Zone

30 Bao'An; Shenzhen, China

MICHAEL TODD TRUE ORGANICS LP

648 SW

Port St. Lucie

Blvd.

j

Port

St.

Lucie,

FL 34953-1947 {

MTTO LLC

648 SW Port St. Lucie Blvd.

Port

St. Lucie,

FL

34953-1947

SHANGHAI

ANZIKANG

ELECTRIC

CO,

LTD .

168 JiXinRoad,

Building

3,Room 401

MinhangDistrict,Shanghai, China

NUTRA-LUXE M.D, LLC

j

6835 International Center

Blvdl

Unit

5

Fort Myers, FL 33912 i

SPIS'-w^W

way-iM'W%

vWU^'fii'/'''M ifl V

mK?5-^ajf^••^j«=w^-

k

i -w


12/85

v bm^@m&wv&

BEAUTYTECH, INC.

1430S.DixieHwy, Ste.321

Coral Gables, FL 33146-3175

ANEX CORPORATION

C-304 Seoul Hightech Venture Center,

647-26

Deungchon-dong,

Gangseo-ku, Seoul,

157-030,

Korea

RN VENTURES LTD.

Francis House, 10 Francis Street

London

SW1P

IDE, United Kingdom

KOREAN BEAUTY

CO,

LTD.

10F, PluszoneBldg700

Deungchon-Dong,

Gangseo-Gu

Seoul,

Korea

H2PRO BEAUTYLIFE, INC.

1043 SegoviaCir.

Placentia, CA 92870-7137

SERIOUS SKIN CARE, INC.

112 N.Curry St.

Carson

City,

NV 89703-4934

HOME

SKINOVATIONS

INC.

lOOLeekCrescent Unit 15

Richmond

Hill,

ON

L4B

3E6,

Canada

HOME SKINOVATIONS LTD.

Tavor Building, ShaarYokneam

Yokneam, 20692, Israel

WENZHOU

AI

ER

ELECTRICAL

TECHNOLOGY

CO,

LTD

d/b/a

CNAIER

1#,

XiaSong

Road, WanQuan

Town, PingYang,

Zhejiang, China

COREANA COSMETICS CO, LTD.

204-1

Jeongchon-ri,

Seonggeo-eup,

Seobuk-gu

Cheonan-si, Chungcheongnam-do, Korea

FLAGEOLI CLASSIC LIMITED

7310 Smoke Ranch Road

Las Vegas,NV 89128


13/85

TABLE OF CONTENTS

I .

II .

INTRODUCT ION .

TH E PARTIES .

A. The Complainant PBL

B. Proposed Respondents

1. Our FamilyJewels.

2. Accord Media

3.

Xnovi

4. MTTO LP and

MTtO

LLC .

5. Anzikang

6. NutraLuxe

7.

Beauty

Tech, Inc.

d/fb/a

5th

Avenue

Buzz.

8. ANEXCorp

9.

RN Ventures Ltd..

10. Korean Beauty

11.

H2P ro

12 . Serious Skin

Care.

13. Fkgeoli

14 . Home Skinovations.

15.

CNAIER

16.

Coreana

III.

THE

TECHNOLOGY

AND

PRODUCTS

A. Description of theTechnology

B. Background Information

1. Conventional

2. The

Innovative

on

.

Treatment

IV . THE PATENTS-IN-SUIT..

A.

B.

C.

The '691

Patent

1. Identification

o f

the

2. Non-Technical Desc

3. Foreign Counterparts

The ' 9 06 Patent

1. Identification of

th i

2. Non-Technical

Descr:


T h e D '8 0 9 P ate nt

1. Identification of

th e

2. Non-Technical DescriptL


Page

.7

.7

,7

...9

10

11

13

14

15

.16

.17

.1 7

.1 8

.19

.2 0

.2 1

.2 2

AT ISSUE 1 23

i

at

Issue '

23

the Products and

Processes at Issue ...J. 23

of Acne

> 24

Claiisonic System . 24

27

,28

Patent and PBL's Interest Therein 28

ription ofthePatented Invention t

29

29

30

Patentand

Ownership

byPBL

}...

30

iption of the Patented Invention

[. 31

P (

31

J 32

Patent

and Ownership by PBL J 32

on of

the

Patented

Invention I. 33

33

.-5^-*™^-—jT^t^jTTSETB^r^ rr-^PT^rT^^^^^^r^^T^^^Tp^^^^n

teff̂ ^ZW'^~' $J


14/85

TABLE

OF CONTENTS

(continued)

Page

V. THE TRADE DRESS 33

VI.

LICENSES

: ...; _ 38

VII. UNLAWFUL AND UNFAIR

ACTS

OF RESPONDENTS 39

A.

Infringement ofthe

'691

Patent

39

B.

Infringement

of the '906 Patent 42

C. Infringement

of

the D'809

Patent

44

D. Trade Dress Infringement

45

VIII. SPECIFIC INSTANCES OF SALE

AND

IMPORTATION

47

EX

RELATED

LITIGATION

50

A.

NutraLuxe Litigation (Western

District ofWashington)

50

B. Litigation inChina 59

C. Litigation inGreat Britain 53

D. Contemporaneous Litigation

in the

Western District of

Washington

53

X .

HARMONIZED TARIFF

SCHEDULE

53

XI.

DOMESTIC

INDUSTRY

53

A. Technical Prong

54

B.

Economic

Prong—Significant Investment

in

Plant,

Equipment, Labor,

and

Capital _

rr

C.

Economic Prong—Substantial Investment

in the Exploitation

of

PBL's

Patented

Technologies .

56

D. Injury

to

Domestic Industry

5g

XII. GENERAL EXCLUSION

ORDER

60

XIII.

RELIEF

:

61

-11-

-w~m,. „„»-„ ,. .„, -»», ,- .. .. ,, .„ „. , .. „ .. ., ,_„. ,„ .„ ,, ,, ..

-^,.„, ,_-...,.,„„.,—^ww«>njBWI >Wi^»WlWMIIlllMIMWW»Ml*Mi«


15/85

Exh ib i t No .

4A

4B

5A

5B

7A

7B

7C

7D

7E

7F

7G

7H

71

7J

DOCUMENTARY EXHIBITS

Description

Certified

copy

of

U.S.

Patent

No.

7,320,691

( the

'691

patent

Certified

copy

of

U.S.

Patent

No. 7,386,906

( the '906 patent )

Certified

copy of

U.S.

Patent

No. D523,809 ( the D'809 patent )

j

Certified copy of the ass.

inventors

to Pacific

ignment

papers for U.S.

Patent

No. 7,320,691 from

the

Laboratories, Inc. ( PBL ) |

ioscience

Certified copy of

the

assignment for U.S. Patent No. 7,320,691

from PBL to

L'Oreal S.A.

Certified copy of the

assignment

for

U.S. Patent No. 7,386,906 from

the

inventors

to P BL

Certified copy of

the

assignment for

U.S.

Patent No. 7,386,906 from PBL

to

L'Oreal

S.A.

nment for U.S. Patent No. D523,809 from the inventors

Certifiedcopyof the assigi

to P BL

Declaration of

Lilac Muller

in Supportof Complaint

Photographs,

Receipt, ^nd Physical

Exhibit

from Purchase of

Our Family

Jewels'Episonic

Photographs,

Receipt, Jmd

Physical Exhibit from Purchase ofAccord

Media's

UltraClear

Photographs, Receipt, ^nd Physical

Exhibit

from

Purchase ofXnovi's

Lemonsonic

Photographs, Receipt,

jmd Physical

Exhibit

from

Purchase

of

MTTO's

Soniclear


md

Physical Exhibit

from

Purchase

of

Anzikang's Dione


NutraSonic 4-Speed

and Physical

Exhibit

from Purchase

ofNutraLuxe's

Photographs,Receipt,

NutraSonic Travel


Buzz's

NuSonic



and Physical

Exhibit

from Purchase

of

NutraLuxe's

and

Physical Exhibit from Purchase of5th

Avenue

and Physical Exhibit

from Purchase

ofANEX's Mimian

and Physical Exhibit

from

Purchase ofRN Ventures'

- l i i -

e*rmrwexa*m*s'>*>r-r*™r™r*>*™*TV

^W ' ^ ^ ggWg tWTW^

»«ei»- •*»--•- •


16/85

Exhib i t No .

7K

7L

7M

7N

7 0

7P

8A

8B

8C

8D

9A

9B

9C

9D

9E

10A

10B

11A

Description

Magnitone Pulsar

Photographs, Receipt, and Physical Exhibit from Purchase ofKorean

Beauty

Photographs,

Receipt, and

Physical

Exhibit

from

Purchase ofH2Pro's Eve

Photographs,

Receipt, and Physical Exhibit from Purchase ofCoreana's 4D

Mot ion .


and Physical

Exhibit

from Purchase of Serious

Skin

Care's / Flageoli's Beauty Buzz

Photographs, Receipt, and Physical Exhibit from

Purchase

of

Home

Skinovations'

Silk'n

Sonic

Photographs,

Receipt,

and Physical Exhibit from Purchase of

CNAIER

Printout

of the

Episonic

Word

Mark

from

the

Trademark Electronic

Search

System (TESS) available at

http://tmsearch.uspto.gov/

(last

accessed

Jan.

13,

2015)

Prmtoutfromhltp://www.epipurskincare.com/products/episonic-facial-cleansing-

system.html

(last

accessed Jan. 9, 2015)

Printout from http://www.amazon.com/Episonic-Facial-Cleansing-Brush-

System/dp/BOOFWZRCGS/ (last

accessed July

16, 2014)

Printout from http://centralops.net/co/DomainDossier.aspx

for

epipurskincare.com (last

accessed Mar.

12,

2015)

Printout

from

https://www.tmthinaging.com/terms

(last

accessed

Dec.

2, 2014)

Printout from http://www.truthinaging.com/review/ultra-renew-clear-our-new-

power-cleansing-brush (last accessed Jan.

9,

2015)

'

Printout from

http://www.truthinaging.com/ultra-clear-replacement-brush-heads

(last

accessed

Jan. 9,2015)

Printout from http://www.amazon.com/Ultra-Clear-Facial-Cleansing-

System/dp/B00DMHKG2K/

(last

accessed

July 16, 2014)

Printout from https://www.ttutlimaging.com/about (last accessed

Mar.

13,

2015)

Printout

from http://www.amazon.com/Lemon-Sonic-Cleansing-Svstem-

White/dp/B00DCMDYK6

(last accessed

Dec.

2, 2014)

Printout from http://www.amazon.com/Lemon-Sonic-Cleansing-System-

Replacement/dp/B00I505TPI/ (last

accessed

Dec. 2, 2014)

Printout from http://www.michaeltoddusa.com/somclear-antirnicrobial-deansme-

system/soniclear.html (last

accessed Jan.

9,

2015)

- I V -

?^^5, '9^'3®£&'r S33*Kra '^^

vmw&st&w ' 9G&pa$ir?m>*

^•jtBIS^^B


17/85

Exh ib i t N o .

11B

11C

11D

12

13A

13B

13C

13D

14A

14B

14C

15A

15B

15C

15D

15E

16A

16B

Description

fmazon.com/Soniclear-Anti-microbial-Skin-Cleansing-

/'dast

accessed Jan. 9, 2015)

{

Printout from http://www.

System/dp/BOOMNNGRL

Printout

from

http://searcrj.sunbiz.org/

for

MTTO

LLC

(last

accessed

Mar. 13,

2015)

Printout from http://searcLsunbiz.org/

for

MichaelTodd True Organics LP

(last

accessed Mar. 13,2015)

c|enter/anzikang-electric-facial-body-brus;h-spa-deaning-

;ift-packing-pink/ (last accessed Dec.

2,12014)

Printout from http://acne.

system-electric-waterproof-:



Cleansing/dp/B002RZKFAQ/

nutrasonic.com/contact-us/ (lastaccessed Dec. 2, 2014)

amazon.com/Nutra-Sonic-1020-Professional-

dast accessed Dec. 2, 2014) [

amazon.com/Nutra-Sonic-0046-Compahion-

G6/ (last accessed Dec.2,2014)


Professional/dp/B004UO

•TV'

Printout from http://search.sunbiz.org/ for Nutra-Luxe M.D,LLC (last

accessed Mar. 13,2015)


accessed Nov. 27, 2014)

5thavenuebuzz.com/shop/devices/test]hgv.html

(last


Avenue/dp/B00J7U9ZVE

amazon.com/SONIC-CLEANSING-SYSTEM-5th-

(last accessed Nov. 27,

2014) |

Printout

from

http://searcji.sunbiz.org/

for

Beautytech,

Inc.

(last

accessed

Mar.

13, 2015)

;clariancy.com/pdf/mimian/mimian_catalog.pdf

(last

rintout from http://www

accessed Dec. 2, 2014)

.amazon.com/Mimian-Beauty-Portable-Cleanser-

dast accessed Nov. 27, 2014) ;

Printout fromhttp://www

Facial/dp/B00JSQ5ZG6/

Printout from http://anexcorp.com/ (last accessed Apr. 24, 2015)

j

Printout

from http://anex^orp.com/eng/02_sub/02_sub.html (last

accessed

Apr.

24,2015)

Printout from http://anexcorp.com/jap/ (last accessed Apr. 27,

2015)

Printout

from https://magbitone.co.uk/shop/magnitone-pulsar/ (last accessed

Nov. 27,2014)

;.lookfantastic.com/magnitone-pulsar-daily-skin-

exfoliation-brush-for-face-and-body/10858382.html(last


cleansing-toning-and

accessed Nov. 27, 2014)

g}T7-'-g»'WF*'.l't»>frft • ' '**-> »»*

ff

-*^ ' ~n »-.*•


18/85

Exhib i t

N o .

16C

16D

17A

17B

18A

18B

18C

19A

19B

19C

19D

19E

19F

20A

20B

20C

20D

Description

Manual from

https://magnitone.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2014/10/

MagnitonePulsarMP009Manual.pdf

(last accessed

Mar. 13, 2015)

Printout

from

https://www.magnitone.co.uk/terms-and-conditions/

(last

accessed

Mar. 13, 2015)

Printout from http://www.amazon.com/Korean-Beauty-Cleansing-Foundation-

Batteries/dp/B00HMHI3AS

(last accessed

Nov.

27, 2014)

Pr in tou t f rom

ht1p://omniko.gobizkorea.com/catalog/mc/down.jsp?f£e_path=/att/cat/omniko

/&file_nm=korean+beauty+4d+motion+cleanser.pdf

(last accessed

Mar. 13, 2015)

Printout from http://www.amazon.com/Micro-Sonic-Care-Brush-

Motion/dp/B00FAX7KXM/ (last accessed

Nov.

27,

2014)

Printout

from

http://h2probeauty]ife.com/05/?page_id=196

(last accessed

Mar.

13, 2015)

Printout from

http://h2probeautyHfe.com/5th/subpages/00aboutus/aboutus.html

(last

accessed

Mar. 13,2015)

Printout from http://www.amazon.com/Sefious-Skincare-Sonic-Clean-

System/dp/B00B91S40W7 (last

accessed

Nov. 27, 2014)

Printout

from

http://www.seriousskincare.com/product_p/150571.htm

(last

accessed Nov. 27,2014)

Printout from

http://www.seriousskincare.com/product_p/

bbnormalbrushhead2.htm

(last

accessed

Nov.

25,

2014)

Printout

from

http://wvvAv.seriousskincare.com/prdduct_p/175898.hm'i (last

accessedNov. 25,2014)

Printout

from

http://nvsos.gov/sosentitysearch/CorpDetails.aspx?lx8nvq=

)J01tjaSh0oiEKVRSRMqEA%253d%253d&nt7=0

(last

accessed Mar. 13, 2015)

Printout

from http://www.bbb.org/losangelessiliconvalley/business-reviews /not-

elsewhere-classified/serious-skin-care-in-los-angeles-ca-100027036

Oast accessed

Mar. 13, 2015)

Printout

from

https://www.silkn.com/contacts/ (last accessed Dec. 2. 2014)

Printout from https://www.silkn.com/somc-clean-prus/ (last accessed Nov

27

2014)

Printout

from

http://www.amazon.com/Silkn-SonicCleanPlus-Cleansmg-Sensitive-

Silicone/dp/B00O84208Y/ (last accessed Nov. 27, 2014)

Printout from https://www.silkn.com/about/

(last accessed

Mar.

13,

2015)

- V I -

- '^ f f^Wg^l^^i l l^WSBH

^^wj^^sts^Bis^^^ssswse^


19/85

Exh ib i t N o .

20E

21A

21B

21C

21D

22A

22B

23A

23B

23C

24

25

26

27

27A

27B

27C

27D

27E

27F

27G

27H

Description

Printout from

http://centralops.net/co/DomainDossier.aspx

for www.silkn.com

(last

accessed

Mar.

16,2015)

.amazon.com/Cnaier-Electric-Waterproof-Cleansing-

dast accessedJan. 9, 2015)


Massager/dp/B00NDW20t4/


beauty-mstrument/1990793J77

2014)

,dhgate.com/product/ultrasonic-deansing-instrument-

.html#sl-18-l

13711470265 (last

accessed Nov.29,

Printout

from

http://www.chinaaier.com/en/

(last accessed Mar. 13, 2015)

Printout from htto://centealops.net/co/DomainDossier.aspx for j

www.chinaaier.com (last fccessed Mar. 16,2015)

amazon.com/Coreana-Senite-Motion-C

(last accessed

Nov. 27,

2014)


Korean/dp/B00H4HGR0Y

eanser-

coreana.com/eng/main/main.asp

(last accessed

Mar,

rintout from http://www.

13,2015)

Printout from http:

4808:vt8qa9.2.2 for The

//tmsealrch.uspto.gov/bin/showfield?f-doc&sfate-

Bsauty Buzz (last accessed Mar.

13,

2015)

.gov/sosentitysearch/CorpSearch.aspx

(last accessed

rintout from http://nvsos

Mar. 13, 2015)

Printout from http://nvso6

8NLTQnMaYsXahC9WBpQ'

.gov/sosentitysearch/CorpDetails.aspx?lx8nvq-Mkg

•%253d%253d&nt7=0# (last accessed Mar. 13, 2015)

Photographs

and Physical

Exhibit ofPBL's

Clarisonic

Plus

Photographs

and Physical

Exhibit

of

PBL's

Clarisonic

Pro

Photographs and Physical

Exhibit of

PBL's Clarisonic Aria (Mia 3)

Claim Charts

in Support

of:Complaint

Claim

Chart

Showing

Infringement

by

Episonic

ofthe

'691 Patent

Claim

Chart

Showing Iafringement by

UltraClear ofthe

'691 Patent

Claim Chart Showing

Infringement

byLemonsonic of the '691 patent

Claim

Chart

Showing

Infringement

bySonidear ofthe

'691

Patent

Claim

Chart

Showing

Infringement

byDioneof the

'691

Patent

Claim Chart Showing Infringement by NutraSonic 4-Speed

of

the '691 Patent

Claim Chart Showing Infringement

by

NutraSonic Travel

of

thfe '691 Patent


by

NuSonic

of

the '691

Patent

-vli-

^Z&zzs T - ^w ^T p ^n s s ^ ^ r ^PT i ^ ^ ^


20/85

Exhib i t

N o .

27 1

27J

27K

27L

27M

27N

2 7 0

27P

27Q

27R

27S

27T

27U

27V

27W

27X

27Y

27Z

27AA

27BB

27CC

2 7DD

27EE

27FF

27GG

28A

28B

«* Jnf

Description

Claim Chart Showing

Infringement by

Mimian

of the

'691

Patent

Claim

Chart

Showing

Infringement

byMagnitone

Pulsar

ofthe

'691 Patent


by

Korean Beauty of

the '691

Patent

Claim

ChartShowing Infringement byEveof the'691 Patent

Claim Chart Showing Infringement by

Beauty

Buzz ofthe '691 Patent

Claim

Chart

Showing

Infringement by

Silk'n Sonic

of the

'691

Patent

Claim

Chart Showing Infringement

by

CNAIER

of the

'691 Patent

Claim Chart Showing Infringement byCoreana 4DMotion of the '691 Patent

Claim

Chart

Showing Infringement by

Episonic

of the '906 Patent

Claim ChartShowing Infringement byUltraclear of the

'906

Patent

Claim

Chart

Showing Infringement by

Lemonsonic

of the

'906

Patent

Claim Chart Showing Infringement byDioneof the

'906

Patent

Claim ChartShowing Infringement byMimian of the '906Patent

Claim


by

Coreana

4D

Motion

of the

'906 Patent

Claim

Chart

Showing Infringement byEpisonic of the

D'809

Patent

Claim Chart Showing

Infringement by

UltraClear

of the

D'809

Patent

Claim

Chart

Showing

Infringement byDioneof the

D'809

Patent

Claim

Chart

Showing

Infringement by NutraSonic 4-Speed of the

D'809

Patent

Claim ChartShowing Infringement byNuSonic of theD'809 Patent

Claim Chart

Showing

Infringement

byMagnitone Pulsar oftheD'809

Patent

Claim Chart

Showing

Infringement by

Beauty Buzz ofthe

D'809 Patent

Domestic industry claim chartfor

U.S.

PatentNo. 7,320,691

Domestic industry

claim

chart

for

U.S.

PatentNo. 7,386,906

Domestic industry

claim

chart

for

U.S.

PatentNo.

D523,809

Claim


by

CNAIER

of

the'906

Patent

Technology Agreement between L'Oreal

and

L'Oreal USA,

Inc., dated

January 1, 2012

Amendment Agreement,

effective

February 15, 2012

-V111-

g y,Hi.JWHJ B ,M' •-^ ^aJi', tfLM^ggB^

HW

W ^^ - ' A - S - T iw ^ ^ a ^ ^


21/85

Exh ib i t

N o .

29

30

31

32

33

34

35

36

37

Description

Clarisonic Technology Agreement between

L'Oreal

and PBL, dajted

February

15, 2012 '

Case No. 2:10-cv-00230

Dkt. No. 1 - Complaint.

, Dkt. No. 65 - Amended Complaint

ase No.

2:10-cv-00230

Case No. 2:10-cv-00230

Dkt. No. 98 - Order

on

Claim Construction

Case No. 2:10-cv-00230,Dkt. No. 228—Jury's Verdict Form

Case No. 2:10-cv-0023Q:

Modifythe Stipulated

, Dkt. No. 257—OrderGrantingJoint Motionto

Permanent Injunction f

Civil

Complaints

filed

in China

Claim

Form

filed

in

the

Intellectual

Property

Enterprise

Court

J

Declaration of Robert Hennessy in Support of Complaint

- I X -


22/85

'l^^'SM^min^mv^

APPEND ICES

As

required

by

19 C.F.R. §210.12(c), a certified copy ofeach of the prosecution histories of the

patents-at-issue, including the references cited

therein, is

submitted

in

the

following appendices.

Appendix No.

App.

A

App.

B

App.

C

App.

D

App.

E

App.

F

App.

G

l***ne%&&*SZggm8&eXmWr

Description

Certified copyof the

file

historyof

U.S.

PatentNo. 7,320,691

Certifiedcopyof the file histories of the reexaminations of U.S.Patent No.

7,320,691

Eachdocument of recordin the file history and

reexaminations

of the '691

patent

Certified

copy

of the file history of U.S. PatentNo.

7,386,906

Eachdocument of record inthe

'906

patent

file

history

Certified

copy

of the file history of U.S. PatentNo.D523,809

Each document of

record

in the D'809 patent

file

history

-x -

WFWR^TS-^^^^1

i^y m^w^i


23/85

I. INTRODUCT ION

1. ComplainantPacific

violation of Section

337 of th e TariffAct of

respectfully requests that the United States

investigation andgrant reliefto remedy the

importation into theUnited States, and/or

owner,importer or consigneeof certain

and kitscontainingsame, that infringePBL

described

below.

2. L'Oreal S.A, together with L

cosmetics and beauty company and,has built

knownbrands in the personal careand

Lancome, Maybelline, Garnier,Kiehl's, Skin

amongothers. In 2011, L'Oreal acquired

portfolio.

3. Since the early2000s,PBL

soldin the United

States

(andworldwide) its

Clarisonic System ), whichis a lineof

skin

devices,brushes and related accessories, the

treatment solutions. Examples of

Clarisonic

^^FS^^^^S^^^^BS^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^

;

Bioscience

Laboratories,Inc. ( PBL ) files this Complaintfor

1930,as amended, 19

U.S.C.

§ 1337 ( Section337 ) and

Ihternational Trade Commission ( ITC ) institute an

•unlawful importationinto theUnitedStates, the

sale

for

salewithin the United States after importation, by the

s

1

ic skin care devices, brushes and chargers therefor,

United States patents

and

trade dress

id the

manner

d ie

electric

. related

,'Oreal USA, Inc., ( L'Oreal ) is the world's largest

an unrivaledportfolio of someof the world's best

i

fields,

including

without

limitation, Lpreal Paris,

I

Ceuticals,La Roche-Posay, Matrix and Yves St.Laurent,

f.

further adding value and

prestige

to fhe

L'Oreal

BL

has

designed,

developed,

manufactured,

marketed,

and

innovativeClarisonicSonicSkinCleansing System(the

i

care products

that include a

number

of sonic

cleansing

I

Clarisonic Opal®

Sonic Infusion System, and

targeted

products arepictured

below:

v^ ^>^B£'2I* [ ̂ &$' S^ ^ ^i'i

LJ'Hpil'

W^i

i r y ^ ^ g ^ r ' H l n r ^ ^ y*


24/85

0

o

4. The Clarisonic

System

was developed by PBL over

many

years and at great expense

and effort, and

represents abreakthrough in technology consisting of

devices and

methods

for

treatment

of

early stage

acne and for the

effective cleansing

of

skin. Those devices and

methods

employ

motion

and forces

at

sonic frequencies to cleanse,

soften

and

smooth

skin. They alleviate

clogged pores

and

remove debris from the

skin more

gently

and

effectivdy

than other

alternatives,

such

as

manual

cleansing.

The innovations

embodied

in the

Clarisonic System have been recognized

in

the United States (and worldwide), and

are

protected

by

numerous United

States and foreign

intellectual

property

rights, including rights deriving

from patents, trademarks

and trade

dress.

5. As described in more

detail below,

PBLhas investedconsiderable resources in the

development ofadomestic industry with respect to the

Clarisonic System.

PBL is headquartered

in

Redmond,

WA

and designs,

develops,

manufactures, markets,

and

sells the Clarisonic

System

from

that

location.

6.

Prior

to

the introduction

ofthe

Clarisonic

System,

there were

no sonic facial

cleansing

devices on

the market.

Indeed, before development ofthe

Clarisonic

System, no market

existed for sonic skin care devices. PBL expended considerable resources to create

the

sonic skin

care market and to educate the public regarding

facial

cleansing,

as

well as tomarket and sell

its

sonic

facial

cleansing

devices.

7. Since

its introduction, the Clarisonic System

has

become widely

acclaimed by

professionals

and consumers, and has

garnered

many media awards from sources such

as

•ss> * *r^ âjtg^'jgr^gyf*- v^s^ss^Mâajygî^saa^=ai?g-s>'

v- ,.>-•

„-«,.,-.,

jfî^mêasmi^-p -'


25/85

authoritative magazines in the beauty i

Winfrey Show, Best

ofSephora in 2007

and

2010. The success

of

the Clarisonic System

those

accused herein.

8. The proposed respondents i

(ii)

Accord Media,

LLC;

(iii) Xnovi Electronic

MTTO LLC;

(v)

Shanghai Anzikang Electric

Tech, Inc.; (viii)

ANEX

Corporation; (ix)

H2PRO

Beautylife,

Inc.;

(xii)

Serious Skin

Skinovations Ltd.;

(xiv)

WenzhouAi Er

CoreanaCosmetics

Co,

Ltd.; and (xvi) Flag

Respondents ).

9. The accused productsare im

therefor, and kitscontainingsame,and s

cleansing

system byOur

Family

Jewels,

Inc.

facial

cleansing system byAccord

Media,

a sonic skincleansing system byXnovi

product ); (iv) anantimicrobial sonic cleans

MTTO LLC under

the

name soniclear (

Shanghai Anzikang

Electric

Co, Ltd. undei

cleansing system

by

Nutra-Luxe

M.D,

LLC

( NutraSonic 4-Speed

product );

(vii) a fac

name nutra sonic (companion2-speed) (

byBeauty Tech,

Inc. d/b/a

5thAvenue

industijy,

Oprah's Favorite

Things

in2007 on

the

Oprah

i

2008, andQVCCustomer Choice in

2008,

2009 and

iias spurred a

large

number ofknock-off

products

-

m

this investigation are: (i)

Our

Family Jewels, Inc.;

I

i

Co,

Ltd.;

(iv)

Michael

ToddTrue

Organics

LPand

i

Co, Ltd.;

(vi)

Nutra-Luxe M.D,

LLC; (vii)

Beauty

•RN

Ventures Ltd.;

(x)

Korean

Beauty

Co,Ltd.; (xi)

,

Inc.;

(xiii)

Home

Skinovations

Inc.andHome

ideal

Technology

Co, Ltdd/b/a CNAIER; (xv)

koli

Classic

Limited (collectively

'Troposed

Care.

:

Elec

ported

electric

skin care devices,

brushes and

chargers

pecjifically indude,

but

are

not

limited to: (i)| a

facial

1

under the

name

episonic ( Episonic product );

(ii)

a

(

LtC under the nameultraclear ( UltraClear product ); (iii)

i

Electronic Co,

Ltd.

underthe

name Lemon; ( Lemonsonic

i

ing system by

Michael Todd True

Organics

LP and

Scjniclear product ); (v)

an

ultrasonic beauty instrument by

the

name

Dione ( Dione product );

(vi)

a facial

under the namenutra sonic (professional 4-speed)

j

al deansing

system by Nutra-Luxe

M.Di, LLC under

the

NutraSonic

Travel

product ); (viii) a skin jcleansing system

Buzz under the nameNuSonic

( NuSonic

product ); (ix) a

^ r jn ;

wsw* u ^?

§- v i i

•^^^BTsr^Ti^^^^^^s^

Ki1*? ^*^ ^


26/85

beauty sonic

skin

care deanser by ANEX Corporation under the name mimian ( Mimian product );

(x)

a

daily

skin

cleansing and toning brush by RN Ventures Ltd.

under

the name Magnitone Pulsar

( Magnitone Pulsar product ); (xi) afacial cleansing

system

by Korean

Beauty

Co, Ltd.

under

the

name

KOREANBEAUTY 4D MOTION ( Korean

Beauty

product ); (xii) afacial

cleansing

system

by H2PRO Beautylife, Inc. under the

name

EVE Micro

Sonic

Care ( Eve

product );

(xiii)

an

ultrasonic

cleansing system by Serious Skin

Care,

Inc.

/ FlageoH Classic Limited under the name the

beauty

buzz

( Beauty

Buzz

product );

(xiv)

a

facial

cleansing system

by

Home Skinovations Inc. and

Home

Skinovations Ltd. under

the name Silk'n

SonicCleanPlus

( Silk'n Sonic

product );

(xv)

a

facial

cleansing system

by

Wenzhou

Ai

Er

Electrical

Technology

Co,

Ltd

d/b/a

CNAIER under

the

name CNAIER AE-603 ( CNAIER product ); and (xvi) a facial deansing

system

by Coreana

Cosmetics

Co,

Ltd. under the name Coreana 4D

Motion

Cleanser ( Coreana 4D Motion

product )

(collectively

Accused

Products ).

10.

As addressed

herein,

Proposed

Respondents are

engaged inunlawful

and unfair

acts

ofcompetition

in violation

of

19

U.S.C. §

1337(a)(1)(B) by selling within the United States after

importation,

selling

for

importation

and/or

importing

certain

dectric

skin

care devices,

brushes

and

chargers

therefor,

and kits containing

same,

that infringe claims

of

one or more of the

following

United

States Letters Patent: (i) U.S. Patent No. 7,320,691 ( the

'691

patent );

(ii) U.S.

Patent No.

7,386,906

( the '906

patent );

and

(iii) U.S.

Design

Patent

No.

D523,809 ( the

D'809 patent ).

Collectively, these

patents

are referred

to

herein

as the Asserted Patents.

11.

An industry exists in the United

States

relating to the

artides protected

by

the

'691,

'906,

and

D'809 Patents, as

required

by 19 U.S.C. §

1337(a)(2)

and (3).

12.

In

addition,

certain

Proposed Respondents'

actions are unlawful

under

the unfair

methods

of

competition provision

of 19 U.S.C. §

1337(a)(1)(A)

because each of their

products

infringes PBL's distinctive trade dress (the Clarisonic Trade

Dress ).

-4-

v^^•^^^j^^mfv -

•^ww-* , .„-[==%;.c =.^j..t^,,^Jgiej^^ iWj(,

S^py^iyi^Li^y^iyiy^^^^.j^,


27/85

13. Those certain Proposed Respondents' violations of19

U.S.C.

§

1337(a)(1)(A)

have

substantiallyinjured or threaten to cause

industry in the United States,within the

14. The following table

infringed intellectual property.1

Proposed

Respondent

Our

Family

Jewels

Accord

Media

Xnov i

MTTO

Anzikang

Nut raLuxe

Nut raLuxe

Beauty

Tech d/b/a

5 t h Avenue

Buzz

Accused '

Produc t

Episonic

UltraClear

Lemonsonic

Soniclear

Dione

NutraSonic

4-Speed

NutraSonic

Travel

NuSonic

: m e a n i n

summarizes

Exh ib i t

7A

7B

7G

7D

7E

7F

7G

7H

Exhib i t

27

A,Q;

w

B,R:

X

C, 3

D

E,T.

Y

F ,Z

G

H.AA

7,320,691

Claims 1, 4-6,

12-16, 22, 31,

33,39-41,42,

44-46, 49, 51-

52

Claims 1, 4-6,

12-16,22,31,

33, 39-41, 42,

44-46, 49, 51-

52

Claims 1, 4-6,

12-16, 22,

31,

33, 39-41,42,

44-46, 49, 51-

52

Claims 31, 33

39-41

Claims 1, 4-6,

12-16,22,31,

33, 39-41, 42,'

44.46, 49, 51

52

•

Claims 31, 3

39-41

Claims 31,

3

39-41

Claims 31,

3

39-41

7,386,906'

C la im s 1 -

2, 4-5, 7-

15

Claims 1-

2, 4-5, 7-

15

Claims

2, 4-5,

15

Claims 1-

2, 4-5, 7-

4 C

- - I?

**.... -.?.-•.-„/:••

-_

substantial injury to, and/or destruction of,PBL's related

ing of 19U.S.C. § 1337(a)(1)(A)®.

the Proposed Respondents, infringing

products,

and

D523,809

V

.Trade

Dress '

/

/

'iSn-' t v

1In the table,Exhibit 7 ( Ex. 7 ) refers to

refers to photographs of the respective

the

Declaration of

Lilac

Muller and

th e

Exhibit letter

infringing product.

ThatDeclaration is discussed below.

identified patents infringed by each respective product

Asserted Patents and, in three instances, trade dress.

Exhibit 27 refers to claim charts showing

of th e identified

claims

of one

or

more of

the

d i e .

-5 -

^VWWWF^W?%~'^'*,'®°~*™** • YV- ^yMW^^Vy-^ * '~ ' ^ 5^* - -^ -^

.^T£V.. .^Vl.^ -^^ -j,-,.-

-^y.


28/85

Proposed

Respondent

A N E X

RN

Ventures

Korean

Beauty

H2P r o

Serious Skin

Care /

Flageoli

Home

Skinovations

CNAIER

Coreana

Accused;;

Product

Mimia

Magnitone

Pulsa r

Korean

Beauty

Eve

BeautyBuzz

Silk'n

Sonic

CNAIER

Coreana 4D

Mot i on

Exhibit?

71

7J

7K

7L

7N

70

7P

7M

Exh ib i t

Z':--27

••• •'.

I ,U

J,BB

K

L

M,CC

N

0 ,GG

P ,V

7,320,691

. Claims 1, 4-6,

12-16,22,31,

33,

39-41,42,

44-46, 49, 51-

52

Claims 31, 33,

39-41

7,386,906

Claims

2>4-5>7-

t . 'g^kfrx^.

D523,809

:

Trade

Dress

•.:, w.3-..

: -Si.- — • :

, SSC. . , u In i

.a

Claims 31, 33, &X .S^llf?'

jV

^-•-'

' '

• ^sS--^ •- • •

39-41 fcc* ;:sjg3fcM .*.-£%;>:: 'x £j£-:'

:j i

Claim;

39

s 31,33,

&:&SjjjB&t*-.\: v:^- - v^ / :.q

j-41

l-..:V

gJg*g;-r--« -

^«LL.V: \ : f

-.*_.• . •«

Claims 31,

33,

felS^IJ?

39-41 *' '

^ : j - *

iS

**-' :

J*Sl

:.>./iiSS;,:-..;'1la

Claims

39 -

31,

33, tJr.Tfei

^f^sCy^

£

^ . ^ ^X

Claims 1, 4-6

12-16, 22, 31,

33, 39-41, 42,

44-46, 49, 51-

52

Claims 1, 4-6,

12-16, 22, 31,

33, 39-41,42,

44-46,49, 51-

52

5^2ifc___l

';i___^___^

Claims 1- ^^S^m^'h'p^:^

2,4-57-9

h:j^ '^i£^pfes*??

Pk.'- .. . .?.iKs. .»>-» -.-Ji S~-- -*

=

'.Vi;.-.=

-. j-V'.'h1™

- ,v^ Vcfjv?; -^r.-?,

•-

••-

~'^

.r

it . :.

.-, - • 'J^V' -*-

••...--jj

14

15. PBL is the exclusive

United

States licensee

ofall substantial rights, including the right

to bring suit ofprotectable patent rights (including the Asserted Patents)

as

described

herein.

PBL

also is the owner

ofcertain

trade dress

rights,

asserted herein. In view

ofthe

widespread

infringement by elusive foreign entities,

Complainant

seeks a

permanent

general exclusion order to

prohibit

anyone from

importing, entering

and

selling

within the

United States

electric skin care

devices,

brushes

and

chargers

therefor, and

kits

containing

same

that infringe

these

patents

and

trade

dress.

Complainant also seeks permanent cease and desist orders to halt the marketing, sales and

distribution of

infringing

products in the

United

States by

each and

every

one

of

the Proposed

Respondents.

' kNtSTSP^^S^HT^^P

4m/k st&tw

»*»™ mmmm


29/85

II .

TH E PART IE S

A.

The Complainant PBL

16. PBL (PacificBioscience Lab

incorporated inJanuary

2001,

with its

Redmond, WA. PBL is in the business o

marketing, advertising, offering to

sell

and

the Clarisonic System.

17. In 2004, PBL introduced the

known as the Clarisonic Classic), the first

creating a newmarket for sonic fadal

remains enormously successful. In 2010,

Companies.

18.

In

December 2011, L'Oreal

B. Proposed Respondents

1.

Our

Family

Jewels

19. On information

and

belief,

Skincare, ( Our FamilyJewels ),is a co

with its principal placeof business at 10226

20.

On

information

and

belief,

electric skin care devices, brushes and char

products. See Exhibits 8A-8C.

The

packag:

epipurskincare.com. See Exhibit

7A2.

websiteas Our Family Jewels. See Exhibit

the owner of the Episonic trademark. S

oratories, Inc.) is a Washingtoncorporation

principal-place of business at 17275 NE 67th Court,

f researching,

designing, developing,

manufacturing,

:lling technically advanced skin care products, including

e .

Clarisonic System and began selling the

Clarisonic

(now

|

skin care device available on the market, thereby

j

g

devices.

The

Clarisonic System has been and

was named one of Inc. 500's Fastest Growing Private

sonic

.

deans

in;

PBL

acquiredPBL.

Respondent Our Family

Jewels, Inc.,

d/ti/a

Epipiir

organized

and

existing under

the

laws

of

Oregon

S.

Dransfeldt

Road, Parker,

CO

80134.

Our

Family Jewels

manufactures,

markets,

and

sells

i

ers therefor, and kits containingsameas the Episonic

I

ng for the Episonic product directs

consumers

to

domain

dossier fo r that website

lists

t ie owner of the

$D. Additionally, Our

Family Jewels

Inc. is

listed

as

i.

Exhibit 8A.

rporation

The

-7 -

r-it-v^vgn r̂-r^ti'wwsvv


30/85

21. On

information and

belief,

the

Episonic products are manufactured inChina and are

imported into and

sold

in the United States. For example, components

of

tiie

Episonic products

bear

the label Made

inChina.

See Paragraph

7 and

Exhibit 7A2

to the

Declaration

of

Lilac Muller

inSupport ofComplaint

( Muller

Deck ), attached

hereto as Exhibit

7.

22. On

information

and belief,

the Episonic

products are available and sold in

the

United States

through

Our

Family

Jewels' website,

htttp://www.epipurskmcare.com/products/episomc-fadal-cleansmg-system.html,

and

at

least

through

Amazon.com,

http://www.amazon.com/Episonic-Facial-Cleansing-Brush-

System/dp/BOOFWZRCGS/.

See

Exhibits 8B-8C.

23.

Accordingly,

Our

Family

Jewels

is

responsible for importing into

the United States,

selling for importation into the United States, and/or selling within the United States after

importation

the

Episonic

products.

24. As set forth

below

in Paragraphs 169,187, 196, and 203-206, Our

Family

Jewels'

Episonic

products infringe

the

'691 Patent,

the

'906 patent,

the D'809

patent, and the Clarisonic

Trade

Dress.

2. Accord

Media

25.

On information and belief,

Respondent

Accord Media,

LLC,

d/b/a Truth

in

Aging,

( Accord Media )

is

alimited liability company organized and existing under

the

laws ofNew York

with its principal

place,

ofbusiness

at

241

West 36th

Street, Apt.

16,

New York, NY

10018.

26.

On information

and belief, Accord Media manufactures, markets, and sells electric

skin

care devices, brushes and chargers

therefor,

and

kits containing same

as

the UltraClear

products.

See

Exhibits 9A-9B.

The

packaging

for the UltraClear products explains

that

it

is made

by

Truth

in

Aging.

SeeExhibit 7B2. The Terms

ofUse page

of the Truth in Aging website

lists

Accord

Media, LLC as

the

actual company. See

Exhibit 9A.

Additionally, the AboutTruth in

' J • - ' •* * ̂ *S9^^^ i^™*™^^^


31/85


32/85

Electronic Co, Ltd.

having

an

address

of Rm

915 Guanlida Mansion (Nonle Plaza), [QJianjin

the

IRoad 30Area of BaoAnShenzhen, China.

See

Exhibit

7C2.

33. On information

and belief,

the

Lemonsonic

products

are manufactured

in

China

and

are imported

into

and

sold

in

the

United States; For example,

components

of

the

Lemonsonic

product bear the label Made in China. SeeMuller Decl. (Exhibit

7),

paragraph 14 and

Exhibit

7C2.

34. Oninformation and

belief,

the

Lemonsonic

products are available and

sold

in

the

United States,

at

least

throughAmazon.com,

http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B00DCMDYK6/and

http://www.amazon.com/Lemon-

Sonic-Cleansing-System-Replacement/dp/B00I505TPI/.

^Exhibits

10A-10B.

35.

Accordingly, Xnovi

is responsible for

importing into the

United

States, selling

for

importation into

the

United States, and/or selling

within

the United States after importation the

Lemonsonic products.

36. As set

forth

below in Paragraphs 171 and

189,

Xnovi's Lemonsonic products

infringe the

'691

Patent

and the '906

patent.

4. MTTO LP and

MTTO

LLC

37. On

information and belief, Respondent Michael

Todd

True Organics LP ( MTTO

LP )

is

a

limited

partnership

organized

and existing under the laws ofDelaware with its principal

place

of

business

at648 SW

Port

St.

Lucie Blvd., Port

St.

Lucie,

FL

34953-1947.

38.

On information and belief, Respondent MTTO LLC

is,

a

limited

liability company

organized

and existing-under

the

laws of

Delaware

with

its principal place

of

business

at

648

SW

Port

St.

Lucie Blvd., Port St. Lude, FL 34953-1947. On information and belief, MTTO LLC is a

general partner ofMTTO LP.

-10-

^/ sssgaa^w^M^^ „ . | ..... u... .u ji

^ ™

~ J

-T—p- aT-j.j^..M-= u —

-j.WL»^»WJ1.U.MIIMJIIII

I l ll l.ll | j | . I. I ..in HI .CTIMI BUIJJJIIIIII1MIIIIIU1ILH III


33/85

39.

On information and

belief,

manufacture, market and sell electric skin

containing sameas the Soniclear products,

products refers to MichaelTodd true org;

consumers of the Soniclear products to mi

of the FloridaDepartment of StateDivision

with

address in

Port

St. Lucie,

FL

34953,

the Soniclear products aremanufacturedin

States. For example,components of the

Muller Ded. (Exhibit 7), paragraph18and

40.

On information and

belief,

MTTO's ownwebsite,http://www.:

system/soniclear.html, and at leastthrough

Anti-microbial-Skin-Cleansing-System,

41. As set forth belowin

Paragra1]

Patent .

MTTOLPandMTTO

LLC (collectively, f'MTTO )

t

devices, brushes and chargers

therefor*,

and kits

Exhibit 11A. The packagelabeling for the Soniclear

Port S fLucie, FL 34953 USA

and

directs

rmcHaeltoddtmeorganics.com. See Exhibit 7D2. A search

of Corporations

yields

two entities relatedto MTTO

i

,

J>


34/85

43. On information and belief, Anzikangmanufactures,markets, and sells electric skin

care

devices, brushes and

chargers

therefor, and kits containing same as the Dione products.

See

Muller Deck

(Exhibit 7), Exhibits 7E1-7E2.

Themanual fortheDioneproduct lists, in

Chinese:

See

Exhibit

7E2.

A

translation

of

this

Msting

as

assisted

by

Google Translate

(http://translate.google.com):

ShanghaiAnzi Kang Electric

Co,

Ltd.

Produc t ion Address :

Ningbo

Ninghai Sanmen

Bay Economic Development Zone

Sales Address :

Shanghai Minhang

Qu,Ji

Xin Road,

No.

168 Building

3,

Room 401

44. Based on thepackage labeling, theDione product is

manufactured

in China and is

imported

into and

sold

in the United

States. For

example, the

packaging

for

the

Dione product

bears a multitude of Chinese characters and a Sales and Production Address in China. See Muller

Deck (Exhibit 7),paragraph 22 andExhibit 7E2.

45.

On information and

belief,

theDioneproductis

available

and

sold

in the

United

States at least through the internet,

http://acne.center/anzikang-electric-facial-body-brush-spa-

cleaning-system-electric-waterproof-gift-packing-pink/,

and

through

Amazon.com.

See

Exhibit

12;

Muller Deck (Exhibit 7),Exhibit 7E1.

46. As set forth below inParagraphs

173, 190,

198 and 203-206, theDione product

infringes the

'691 Patent,

the '906 patent the

D'809 patent, and

theClarisonic Trade Dress. -

-12-

^^^^^^•pb^^^afei ĝsgFtft^w^ w

•••«

•«gw?ge^ gea»^wg~^'v

^T^B'gywiSgww^1^^


35/85

6. Nu t raLuxe

47.

On information and

bekef,

limited kability company organized and

business

at

6835

International Center Blvd.

48. On informat ion and belief,

care devices, brushes and chargers therefor,

products

and the

NutraSonic

Travel prod

NutraSonic

4-Speed product and

NutraSonib

Nutra

Luxe

MD.

See

Exhibits

7F2 and

the NutraSonic Travelproduct further lists

Unit5,FortMyers, FL

33912. See

Exhibit

Division of Corporations yields the details

FL 33912, USA. SeeExhibit 13D.

49.

On information and bekef,

4-Speed product

and

NutraSonic

Travel

and sold in the United States. For example.^

Made in China. See MullerDeck (Exhibit

50.

On information and bekef,

available and sold in the United States at le;

http: /

/www.

amazon.

com/Nutra-Sonic

http: /

/www.

amazon.com/Nutra-Sonic-

http://www.amazon.com/Nutra-Sonio

Exhibi ts 13B-13C.

Res

pondent

Nutra-Luxe M.D,

LLC ( NutraLuxe )

is a

g

under

the laws ofFlorida with its

principal place

of

tyoit 5,FortMyers, FL33912.

aLuxe manufactures, markets, and sells electric skin

t

andkits containing same as the NutraSonic 4-Speed

:

See Exhibits 13A-13C.

The package

labeHng

forthe

I

Travel product

state

thatthe

products

are offered by

. The bottom-of the back

of

the package labeling for

In address

of

6835 International Center Boulevard,

7G2.

A search of theFlorida Department ofState

for Nutra-Luxe M.D, LLC with address in Fort Myers,

at least the brushheads and chargersfor the NutraSonic

TF3W^E3*H$ ¥r*


36/85

51. As set forth below in

Paragraphs 174

and

199, NutraSonic

4-Speed products

infringe

the

'691

Patent

and

theD'809 patent.

52. As

set forth below in

Paragraph 175,

NutraSonic Travel products

infringe the '691

Patent .

7. Beauty

Tech,

Inc.

d/b/a

5th Avenue Buzz

53.

On information

and

bekef, Respondent Beauty Tech,

Inc.

d/b/a 5th Avenue

Buzz

( 5th

Avenue

Buzz ) is a

corporation organized

and

existing under the

laws of

Florida with its

principal place ofbusiness at

1430

S. Dixie

Hwy,

Ste. 321, Coral Gables, FL 33146-3175. On

information

and

belief,

5th Avenue

Buzz also

has

a

place

of

business at

20241

NE

16th

Place,

Miami,

FL

33179.

54.

On information and

bekef,

5th Avenue

Buzz manufactures, markets, and

sells

electric skin care

devices,

brushes and chargers therefor, and

kits

containing

same as

the NuSonic

products. See Exhibit 14A. The

base

ofthe charging station

Hsts

Bauty [sic] Tech, Inc. USA.

www.beautytec.com. See Exhibit 7H2. The bottom

of

the website for 5th Avenue

Buzz

also

identifies

Beautytech, Inc.

as

the copyright

owner.

See

Exhibit

14A.

The Florida

Department

of

State Division ofCorporations Hsts 1430 SDixie Hwy Ste 321, Coral Gables, FL 33146 as the

address for Beautytech,

Inc.

See Exhibit14C.

55.

• Qn information and bekef,

the

NuSonic products are manufactured in

China

and are

imported

into and sold in the United States. For example, components of

the

NuSonic

products

bear the labd Made in

China.

SeeMuller

Deck (Exhibit 7), paragraph 34

and Exhibit

7H2.

56. On information and bekef, the NuSonic products are

available

and

sold

in

the

United

States at least

through the

5th

Avenue

Buzz website,

htto://www.5thavenuebuzz.com/shop/devices/test-hgv.html, and through Amazon.com,

-14-

&®^^%m*tyu™%%-®


37/85

http://www.amazon.com/SONIC-CLEAN^ING-SYSTEM-5th-Avenue/dp/B00J7p9ZVE. J«

Exhibi ts 14A-14B.

57.

As

set

forth

below

in

Paragraphs

176 and 200, the

NuSonic

products :

'691 Patent and the D'809 patent.

8.

ANEX

Corp.

58.

On information and

bekef,

corporation organized and existing underthe

304SeoulHightechVenture Center, 647-26

On

information

and

bekef,

ANEX

also has

345

Seokcheon-ro, Ojeong-gu, BucheonCi

59. On information and bekef,

devices, brushes and chargers therefor, and

Exhibits 15A, 15D. The ANEX website (in

Park, 345 Seokcheon-ro, Ojeong-gu,

The

ANEX

website (inJapanese) ksts an

Deungchon-dong, Gangseo-ku,

Seoul, 157-1

Mimian products ksts Anex Corporation

647-26 Deungchon-dong, Gangseo-ku,

60. Based on packagelabekng,

importedinto and soldin the United

States,

th e

label

Made in Korea. See

Muller

Decl

61.

On information and

bekef,

States at leastthroughAmazon.com, http:/

Facial/dp/B00JSQ5ZG6/.

See

Exhibit

15E:

w^ T w™ ^ s ^ r w™ r ™ T T f f ^

• fww w

£J:

infringe the

RespondentANEXCorporation

( ANEX )

is a

i

laws of Koreawith its principal place of business at C-

Deungchon-dong, Gangseo-ku, Seoul,

1(57-030,

Korea,

place

of

business

at #304-705 Bucheon Techno

Park,

Gyenggi-do 421-741,Korea.

ANEX manufactures, markets, and seks dectric skin care

I

Irits

containing sameas the

Mimian

products.

See

Engksh) ksts

an

address

of#304-705 Bucheon Techno

City,

Gyenggi-do

421-741,

Korea. See

Exhibit

15C.

address

of

C-304

Seoul

Hightech Venture

Center, 647-26

I,

Korea.

i>£

Exhibit 15E. A brochure for the

with address at C-304 SeoulHightech Venture Center,

157-030, Korea.

^Exhibit

15Aat 16.

Mimian products are manufactured

iti

Korea and are

{

For example, components of theMimian products bear

I

(Exhibit 7),paragraph 38andExhibit712.

,Bucheon

-030.

Seoul,

tie.

the Mimian products are available and so

d in t h e Un i ted

/www.amazon.com/Mimian-Beauty-Portable-Cleanser

-15-

-gOTr®^1—H^TT^n^T^^sr^T •r'sr'wr

B.»P i/

' / jB i ' ^ p^wp

-

•^-•aaw'i

«£y •^'t-ijf'T^*


38/85

62. As set forth

below inParagraphs 177 and 191,

the Mimian

products infringe the '691

Patent and the '906patent.

9. RN Vent ur es L td .

63.

On information

and bekef,

Respondent

RN

Ventures

Ltd. ( RN

Ventures ) is a

corporation organized and

existing under

the

laws ofUnited Kingdom

with its prindpal place

of

business atFrancis House, 10 Francis Street,

London

SW1P IDE, United Kingdom.

64. On information and bekef, RN

Ventures

manufactures, markets, and seks electric

skin

care

devices, brushes and chargers

therefor,

and kits

containing same

as

the

Magnitone Pulsar

products.

See

MuUer

Deck

(Exhibit

7),

Exhibit

7J2.

On the

base

of

the

charging

station,

RN

Ventures Ltd London SW11 is

printed.

See Exhibit

7J2.

Additionauy, the brochure for the

Magnitone Pulsar

products states that

Magnitone is

a

trading brand

name

owned

by: RN

Ventures

Ltd. London, SW11. See Exhibit

16C

at 10. TheMagnitone terms

and

conditions

website

ksts

Francis House, 10 Francis St, London SW1PIDE as the address for R N Ventures Ltd. See

Exhibi t

16D.

65.

On

information

and bekef, the Magnitone Pulsar

products

are

manufactured

in

China,

distributed from United'Kingdom, and are

imported

intoand sold in the United States. For

example, components

of the

Magnitone

Pulsar

products

bear

the

label Made

in

China. See Muller

Deck (Exhibit 7), paragraph 42 and

Exhibit

7J2. '

66.

On

information

and bekef,

the Magnitone Pulsar

products are available and sold in

the

United States

at

least through

the

Magnitone website,

https://magnitone.co.uk/shop/magnitone-pulsar/, and

other

websites, such

as

http://www.lookfantastic.com/magmtone-pulsar-daky-skin-cleansing-toning-and-exfokation-brush-

for-face-and-body/10858382.html.

^Exhibits

16A-16B.

-16-

»->W«»W»»-v»»w, -*»~»^»'^^-*^« »« «-^^


39/85

67. As set forth belowin Paragraphs 178 and 201, the Magnitone'Pulsar products

infringe the '691 Patent and the D'809 patent,

10. Korean

Beauty

68.

On information and

bekef,

is a corporation organizedand existing under

at 10 F, Pluszone Bldg700,Deungchon

69. On information and

bekef,

skin care devices, brushes and chargers

products.

See

Exhibits 17Aand 7K2. The

Exhibi t

7K2.

A b rochu re for

the Korean

andproduct

image,

ksts the company and

Bldg700,Deungchon-Dong, Gangseo-Gu,

70. On

information and

bekef,

and are importedinto and soldin the United

Beautyproducts bear the labd Madein

Exhibit 7K2.

71.

On information and

bekef,

United States at least through Amazon.com,

Foundation-Batteries/dp/B00HMHI3AS.

72. As set forth below in Parage

Paten t .

Respondent Korean BeautyCo, Ltd. ( KoreanBeauty

the laws of Korea with its principal place

of

business

g, Gangseo-Gu, Seoul, Korea.

I^^^~qZF> 8^^


40/85

1043

Segovia

Or,

Placentia, CA

92870. On information and bekef, H2Pro

has

a place ofbusiness

also at 4319 Regency Drive, Glenview, IL 60025.

74. On information and bekef,H2Pro manufactures,markets, and sekselectric skincare

devices,

brushes and ;chargers therefor, and kits

containing same

as the Eve

products.

See

Exhibits 18A

and

7L2. The

packaging

for the

Eve

products

states

the product

is

distributed by

H2Pro

and

ksts

a

website

of

www.h2probeautykfe.com. See Exhibit 7L2. The H2Pro

Beauty

Life

website ksts

an

address

of 1043 Segovia Or,

Placentia,

CA 92870.

See

Exhibit

18B.

On a

different About us

page,

the H2Pro

Beauty Life

website ksts

a

different address,

namely, 4319

Regency Drive, Glenview, IL 60025.

See

Exhibit 18C.

75.

On information andbekef, theEve

products

are

manufactured

in

Korea,

andare

imported

into

and sold

in the United

States. For example,

components of

the

Eve products

bear

the

label

Made

in

Korea. See Muker Deck (Exhibit

7),

paragraph 50 and Exhibit 7

clarisonic itc complaint

Documents