civil engineering applications of tire shreds · • insulation to improve performance of heat...

25
CIVIL ENGINEERING APPLICATIONS OF TIRE DERIVED AGGREGATE Dana N. Humphrey, Ph.D., P.E. Professor of Civil Engineering University of Maine 2017 Colorado Waste Tire Conference June 21, 2017

Upload: others

Post on 23-Mar-2020

7 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Civil Engineering Applications of Tire Shreds · • Insulation to improve performance of heat pumps • Drainage layers for landfills • Gas collection layers and trenches for landfills

CIVIL ENGINEERING APPLICATIONS OF TIRE DERIVED AGGREGATE

Dana N. Humphrey, Ph.D., P.E.Professor of Civil Engineering

University of Maine

2017 Colorado WasteTire ConferenceJune 21, 2017

Page 2: Civil Engineering Applications of Tire Shreds · • Insulation to improve performance of heat pumps • Drainage layers for landfills • Gas collection layers and trenches for landfills

Tire Derived Aggregate – TDA

Page 3: Civil Engineering Applications of Tire Shreds · • Insulation to improve performance of heat pumps • Drainage layers for landfills • Gas collection layers and trenches for landfills

Why use TDA?• TDA has properties that civil engineers

need• Lightweight (1/3 soil)• Low earth pressure (1/2 soil)• Good thermal insulation (8 times better)• Good drainage (10 time better)• Compressible• Vibration damping

Page 4: Civil Engineering Applications of Tire Shreds · • Insulation to improve performance of heat pumps • Drainage layers for landfills • Gas collection layers and trenches for landfills

Why use TDA?• TDA is often cheapest alternative if you

need their unique properties

Page 5: Civil Engineering Applications of Tire Shreds · • Insulation to improve performance of heat pumps • Drainage layers for landfills • Gas collection layers and trenches for landfills

Why use TDA?• Can use lots of tires!!!

–75 tires per C.YD. of tire shred fill–400,000 tires for bridge

abutment, Topsham, Maine–1.2 million tires for highway

embankment, Portland, Maine–1 million tires for leachate

collection system in Delaware

Page 6: Civil Engineering Applications of Tire Shreds · • Insulation to improve performance of heat pumps • Drainage layers for landfills • Gas collection layers and trenches for landfills

Where can TDA be used?• Landslide stabilization• Lightweight embankment fill• Lightweight backfill for walls• Lightweight fill over culverts• Free draining backfill for “French Drains”• Stormwater infiltration basins• Vibration damping beneath rail lines• Backfill for residential foundations (drainage & insulation)• Insulation to limit frost penetration beneath roads• Insulation to improve performance of heat pumps• Drainage layers for landfills• Gas collection layers and trenches for landfills

Photo: Courtesy of Kennec, Inc.

Page 7: Civil Engineering Applications of Tire Shreds · • Insulation to improve performance of heat pumps • Drainage layers for landfills • Gas collection layers and trenches for landfills

Geysers road slide repair

Page 8: Civil Engineering Applications of Tire Shreds · • Insulation to improve performance of heat pumps • Drainage layers for landfills • Gas collection layers and trenches for landfills

Geysers road slide repair

Page 9: Civil Engineering Applications of Tire Shreds · • Insulation to improve performance of heat pumps • Drainage layers for landfills • Gas collection layers and trenches for landfills

Geysers road slide repair

Page 10: Civil Engineering Applications of Tire Shreds · • Insulation to improve performance of heat pumps • Drainage layers for landfills • Gas collection layers and trenches for landfills

Geysers road slide repair

Page 11: Civil Engineering Applications of Tire Shreds · • Insulation to improve performance of heat pumps • Drainage layers for landfills • Gas collection layers and trenches for landfills

North Abutment of Merrymeeting Bridge

el. 9.4 mClay

el. 5.2 m

el. 8.2 m

Type B Tire Shreds

NativeSoil

Type ATire Shreds

229 mm BituminousConcrete Pavement

AggregateSubbase

el. 11.3 m

el. 10.1 mel. 10.7 m

Station 53+35.4

CommonBorrow Granular

Borrow

AggregateSubbase

Geotextile

Piles

Station53+72.0

@ Center LineStation53+50.6

Concrete Approach Slab

4.2 m TDA

1.9 m soil cover

Page 12: Civil Engineering Applications of Tire Shreds · • Insulation to improve performance of heat pumps • Drainage layers for landfills • Gas collection layers and trenches for landfills

Initial Placement of TDA

Page 13: Civil Engineering Applications of Tire Shreds · • Insulation to improve performance of heat pumps • Drainage layers for landfills • Gas collection layers and trenches for landfills

Placement with Dump Truck

Page 14: Civil Engineering Applications of Tire Shreds · • Insulation to improve performance of heat pumps • Drainage layers for landfills • Gas collection layers and trenches for landfills

Compaction with 10-ton Roller

Page 15: Civil Engineering Applications of Tire Shreds · • Insulation to improve performance of heat pumps • Drainage layers for landfills • Gas collection layers and trenches for landfills

Goal of Presentation!

Page 16: Civil Engineering Applications of Tire Shreds · • Insulation to improve performance of heat pumps • Drainage layers for landfills • Gas collection layers and trenches for landfills

Place Soil Cover

Page 17: Civil Engineering Applications of Tire Shreds · • Insulation to improve performance of heat pumps • Drainage layers for landfills • Gas collection layers and trenches for landfills

Cost Comparison

Material Unit wt. Cost $/lb of weight credit

TDA 57 pcf $25/c.y. 0.37 Extruded

polystyrene 2 pcf $80/c.y. 0.66

Expanded shale 75 pcf $80/c.y. 1.60

Page 18: Civil Engineering Applications of Tire Shreds · • Insulation to improve performance of heat pumps • Drainage layers for landfills • Gas collection layers and trenches for landfills

Highway Edge DrainWitter Farm Road

Typical Cross Section

Page 19: Civil Engineering Applications of Tire Shreds · • Insulation to improve performance of heat pumps • Drainage layers for landfills • Gas collection layers and trenches for landfills

Place Edge Drain

Page 20: Civil Engineering Applications of Tire Shreds · • Insulation to improve performance of heat pumps • Drainage layers for landfills • Gas collection layers and trenches for landfills

TDA use in landfills

Donovan, et al., 1996

Page 21: Civil Engineering Applications of Tire Shreds · • Insulation to improve performance of heat pumps • Drainage layers for landfills • Gas collection layers and trenches for landfills

CASE HISOTRY - ChaquitaLandfill, Los Angeles County, CA

Gas Collection Trenches

• 3-ft x 3-ft trenches excavated into existing waste; perforated pipe placed in center

• TDA covered with geotextile

Page 23: Civil Engineering Applications of Tire Shreds · • Insulation to improve performance of heat pumps • Drainage layers for landfills • Gas collection layers and trenches for landfills

Chaquita Landfill

Photo: CalRecycle

Page 24: Civil Engineering Applications of Tire Shreds · • Insulation to improve performance of heat pumps • Drainage layers for landfills • Gas collection layers and trenches for landfills

Conclusions• TDA has properties that engineers need• TDA can be cost effective• Civil engineering applications an

important use for scrap tires– Multiple highway and landfill applications

• Specifications and guidelines available• Negligible environmental effects

Page 25: Civil Engineering Applications of Tire Shreds · • Insulation to improve performance of heat pumps • Drainage layers for landfills • Gas collection layers and trenches for landfills

QUESTIONS?